Which Controller is BEST for the Nintendo Switch?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 июл 2024
  • When it comes to the Nintendo Switch, you are going to need to pick up a controller but which is BEST? Should you get a 1st Party Controller, a 3rd Party Controller, or a Licensed By Nintendo 3rd Party Controller? Let's find out.
    #nintendo #powera #8bitdo #nintendoswitch
    The Controllers
    8bitdo Pro 2: amzn.to/34BCq8h
    PowerA Nano Enhanced Controller: amzn.to/3JvOJBO
    Nintendo Switch Pro Controller: shop-links.co/cfYaK7N3Yyl
    FOLLOW ME
    Instagram: / julienmelnick
    Twitter: / julienmelnick
    Facebook: / julienmelnick
    Chapters like in a Book
    Which Controller is right for the Nintendo Switch: 00:00
    The Controllers we are using TODAY: 01:47
    Super Mario World Test: 05:55
    Mariokart 8 Deluxe Test: 10:15
    The Unexpected RESULTS: 14:40
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 107

  • @julienmelnick
    @julienmelnick  2 года назад +6

    What is your favorite controller for the Nintendo Switch? Share why!

    • @ThatGuy001
      @ThatGuy001 2 года назад

      So, i actually have the official switch pro controller, the Pro plus, and the pro 2. All of them are amazing, but if i have to choose, i'm gonna have to go with pro plus or pro 2 just because you can connect not only to the switch, but other devices as well
      Edit: one more thing that i love about pro plus or pro 2 is the d-pad. The official pro controller d-pad is not precise enough for me.

    • @taqiiskandar5083
      @taqiiskandar5083 2 года назад +1

      Gulikit Kingkong 2 Pro. It has all the features that the switch pro controller has (Including Gyro, Wake switch up from sleep, and NFC). Eventhough there is no HD rumble, the rumble feels okay, and you can adjust the rumble up to 4 levels, including no rumble at all. It has APG (macro-like function) and turbo features (limited to abxy, r and zr buttons) which I don't really use, but it's there. There is also a feature where you can swap abxy button (not physical change, but the a and b + x and y function can be swapped), which you can use if you're used to xbox layout for switch. You can also use it if you're used to switch layout on pc, since the controller detected as xbox controller on pc. You can adjust both the sticks and triggers sensitivity, for instant the triggers can be changed from analog to digital on pc. And also, the features that I interested the most, Motion-sense aiming for FPS games on pc. Basically you can use gyro aiming on a game that doesn't even have gyro support. The way it work is that the gyro movement would be detected as right stick movement on the game.
      Enough for the features, the feels of this controller is really good. It similar to xbox one controller, with a lot more features! (except for the headphone jack, ofc, because it's advertised as switch third-party controller). Overall, I really like this controller.

  • @slimofbonar1978
    @slimofbonar1978 2 года назад +22

    3rd party can't be worse that the drift issues on the original joycons

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад +7

      That wasn't a latency issue though. That was a connectivity issue and has been long since resolved. That wasn't drift either. It was a communication problem due to interference

    • @slimofbonar1978
      @slimofbonar1978 2 года назад +2

      @@julienmelnick my sons were drifting, ordered the parts online and fixed them myself, tbf they could be made better

    • @Dannyssb
      @Dannyssb Год назад +1

      No each controller gets drift go look at reviews i rather trust from the manufacturer these 3rd parties are so bad each one skills just be 30$ it’s still going to get drift issues

  • @BrianLera
    @BrianLera Год назад +1

    Clean intro man! Thanks for making this. Literally been trying to figure this out.

  • @nonsense1140
    @nonsense1140 Год назад +2

    This video was fantastic! Exactly what I needed to make my decision, thank you so much.

  • @JeremyPeeples
    @JeremyPeeples 2 года назад +18

    Controlling a 2D platformer with an analog stick will always be a bit wonky - it's best to use the d-pad for those

  • @ATDStudios
    @ATDStudios 2 года назад +14

    The 8bitdo Pro 2 is easily my favorite controller right now. I use it on my Switch and PC since it's easy to swap back and forth. I had no latency issues after the latest firmware update. I even bought the wired Xbox-licensed version to use on my Series X.

  • @themailman3331
    @themailman3331 2 года назад +10

    I use the Pro controller. It’s the first one I bought, so I’ve been sticking with it, it’s awesome. I was lucky enough to grab the Super Nintendo controller for the Switch, made by Nintendo, so I use that for retro stuff. Also, SMW is a f*cking gem.

  • @jamesconors88
    @jamesconors88 Год назад +2

    Love this content dude , great voice and love the honesty , you remind me of the RUclipsr WULLF DEN don’t worry about only doing Nintendo stuff wullf built a career on it & you can too keep it up :)

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  Год назад +3

      thanks man. I really appreciate teh support

  • @iyeetsecurity922
    @iyeetsecurity922 2 года назад +2

    Can't say I've got a definite favorite. I change up which one I use just for the fun of it. I use the pro controller, PowerA wireless GameCube controller, and a PS5 Dualsense controller.

  • @simongorelik92
    @simongorelik92 2 года назад +1

    dude loved watching this!!! the 8bitdo i have used for several months on my switch and ive never had any lag ever acually itsvery accurate for my and i prefer over the pro contoller

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад +1

      I wish my experience was the same...

  • @mrlyles2002able
    @mrlyles2002able 2 года назад +2

    I really appreciate your honest response, because the 8bitdo was my favorite also. I have tried the Gulikit King Kong Pro 2 and it's a very expressive controller.

  • @Marko-ij4vy
    @Marko-ij4vy 2 года назад +2

    I have all of these controllers + binbok joycons. Pro controller is my main controller for 3d games while 8bitdo 2 pro is my main controller for 2d games, fighting games,sidescrollers, retro games. Basically any games where I use D-pad. Power A mini is great for traveling because its small and portable but still feels almost like a regular sized controller. And binbok joycons are for handheld use, they feel similiar to hori split pad pro but can still be used wirelessly and therefore its another extra controller for local multiplayer. So that way I have 4 "regular" controllers and 4 joycons which I can easily take to friends house during a party and we can play 8 player smash and hopefully 8 player mario strikers once it comes out!

  • @kennymichaelalanya7134
    @kennymichaelalanya7134 Год назад

    Man those are great shoes. I just ordered 8bitdo pro 2. I heard more positive messages about it than other controllers

  • @Psmgamer
    @Psmgamer 2 года назад +2

    I use Rival Labs Gaming's Contender Wireless Contender for Switch/PC it has motion controls and NFC, Adjustable Vibration feedback, Turbo function and wireless Bluetooth technology. Only downside is the battery life which is 8 to 10 hours. I definitely want to get a 8 BitDo Pro 2 when it goes on sale as I heard it's an awesome controller. Awesome review on third party controllers.

    • @Josuh
      @Josuh Год назад

      did you get one?

    • @Psmgamer
      @Psmgamer Год назад

      @@Josuh
      Probably get one for Christmas

  • @heyheyspaceman
    @heyheyspaceman 2 года назад +1

    I love my 8bitdo pro but haven't dug into the app yet. I'd dig a video on the controller more. cheers

  • @brosettastone7520
    @brosettastone7520 2 года назад +4

    Pro all day. Best controller I’ve ever held by far. But I have smaller hands and I can see how people with larger hands can find it a bit cramped feeling especially after coming from something like an Xbox controller. Which by the way, the 360 controller was the best fit for my smaller hands compared to any new Xbox controller. But man sweaty hands and 360 controllers was so annoying haha

  • @ducethe2nd246
    @ducethe2nd246 2 года назад +2

    I wish Panda was able to get their GameCube switch controller up and running. I would’ve gotten that for sure since it had a smash bros focus

  • @briguy_fieri1689
    @briguy_fieri1689 2 года назад +1

    I’m not a switch user as I’m steady Xbox, but i actually love the transition of content on the channel. It keeps things fresh as it’s not particular topics beat to the ground. I don’t even have a switch and I watched the whole video because.. hey cool im seeing something unknown to me.

  • @Josuh
    @Josuh Год назад

    That intro has its charm to it

  • @ctnative203
    @ctnative203 2 года назад +3

    fresh kicks ! have to be from a certain era to understand.

  • @stephno13
    @stephno13 8 месяцев назад

    The pumps though 🤣🔥

  • @neilritchiecaguioa8593
    @neilritchiecaguioa8593 10 месяцев назад +1

    8bitdo pro 2 I used it on my Android Tablet it works fine,And I also have sn30 pro+ it felts the same.i am planing on purchasing 8bitdo Arcade Stick for my fighting Games

  • @dacbiet
    @dacbiet 2 года назад +7

    I wish Nintendo made a nano version of the pro controller. With HD rumble, long ass battery life, and amiibo support. I love the Nintendo pro controller but I want something smaller to put in my sling bag.

  • @cocozimme
    @cocozimme 2 года назад +1

    I have the Splatoon pro controller that my son mainly uses and I have the 8bitdo pro 2 I use for PC and switch.

  • @Plymouthmusicschool
    @Plymouthmusicschool Год назад

    Sweet….Just picked up a pair of the nano controllers at an Amazon bin store bundled together in used condition for 9 bucks!

  • @TiVo2Go
    @TiVo2Go 2 года назад +1

    *I wanna get the Nano but no rumble and with my luck, they release a rumble version the day after I buy the current one.*

  • @Kimmievdw
    @Kimmievdw 6 месяцев назад +1

    Nice and honest review since you really wanted the 8bitdo to do better, you still pointed out it was not performance wise. But it seems like it is comfort wise. Mostly playing pokemon games so the latency doesn’t really matter for me. Looking into this one or the powerA enhanced controller but really loving the 8bitdo retro style and symmetrical sticks.. i’m also someone who plays games on PlayStation so really loving this design it’s like a mix between gameboy and playstation. So being 2024 you still recommend the 8bitdo pro 2 controller?😊

  • @danielemmerich8782
    @danielemmerich8782 2 года назад +7

    Can you review the new controller GuliKit King Kong 2 PRO that I just find and curious before to get it? It claims to have hall sense magnetic joystick with no drift ever,mechanical letter buttons, amiibo,console wakeup,rumble and many other powerful features.

    • @iyeetsecurity922
      @iyeetsecurity922 2 года назад

      It's really quite nice. But if you've already got a working pro controller for your Switch, I wouldn't get it unless you really want it. It feels the same as the pro controller and Xbox controller and aside from the "driftless" sticks, it plays the same.

  • @Mindstormer
    @Mindstormer 2 года назад +3

    I've noticed the latency on the 8bitdo pro 2 I think it has something to do with syncing with multiple devices. There are times when I try and play on my computer and the delays are up to 3 seconds. I want to say it's due to multiple syncs, but I think another part was an update they did a while back. When I first got the controller I don't think I had any lag. So I find it interesting.
    Ps. I still love the controller but I think a patch might be in order.

    • @ac3e19
      @ac3e19 2 года назад

      Has it already been fixed?

    • @Mindstormer
      @Mindstormer 2 года назад +1

      @@ac3e19 yup!

    • @ac3e19
      @ac3e19 2 года назад

      @@Mindstormer do you recommend it? I really wanna use it on my mac and switch

    • @Mindstormer
      @Mindstormer 2 года назад

      @@ac3e19 i havent used it on mac before but its really nice on switch. So yeah it’s definitely worth the money.

    • @ac3e19
      @ac3e19 2 года назад

      @@Mindstormer that’s good to hear! And it doesnt disconnect from switch anymore right?

  • @TheNyapism
    @TheNyapism 2 года назад +2

    The 8bitdo adapter helped reduce the latency by a lot

  • @kennangelopujante4036
    @kennangelopujante4036 2 года назад

    im enjoying my 8bitdo pro 2 😍😍😍 but planning to buy Xenoblade pro con soon

  • @nicholasspeer9337
    @nicholasspeer9337 2 года назад

    I have a pro controller a couple power a controllers one red Mario from Amazon and two Mario 3 one's from Walmart but my favorite had got me to go back to handheld is the hori split pad pro

  • @RC-73
    @RC-73 Год назад

    Love those shoes. I used to have some!!!!

  • @july172
    @july172 2 года назад +1

    All i could say is the first company to make Amiibo supported and back paddles will get rich quick.

  • @mightandbelightnr2290
    @mightandbelightnr2290 Год назад +1

    Put the switch "not in the back" of the tv and try agian and see if u get better resolt!

  • @dawsoncjames
    @dawsoncjames Год назад +1

    Great format for a video! Very interesting discovery.
    I'd love to know:
    A) has a firmware update fixed the 8bitdo pro 2 lag?
    B) Would an 8bitdo dongle improve the lag.
    C) did you have more than one controller atatched to the switch, as there's a rumour the pro2 doesn't like sharing a console with other devices, and slows down in protest.

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  Год назад +2

      a) yes
      b) absolutely for controllers that support 2.4
      c) No

    • @dawsoncjames
      @dawsoncjames Год назад

      @@julienmelnick awesome, thank you! So the 8bitdo now keeps up completely with the pro controller?

    • @TheTrueXaver
      @TheTrueXaver 6 месяцев назад

      @@dawsoncjamesi assume it's basically the same. i have a pro+ (which came before) and i can play anything perfectly on it. i don't notice much lag and even speedrun a precision platformer with it

  • @outer22
    @outer22 Год назад

    The Nano is a great controller and is reactive. I too have latency on the 8bitdo which is a problem when u need accuracy…

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  Год назад

      They have seemed to fix it with newer production models

  • @timhaas6021
    @timhaas6021 10 месяцев назад

    Pro 2, I own two, one wired and one Bluetooth.

  • @ashtoric
    @ashtoric 2 года назад +1

    my 8bitdo Sn30 Pro+ controller is dying on me. It’s not registering the face buttons a lot of the time now, meaning I’m missing major inputs in things like QTEs and it’s getting really frustrating. is its successor any better?

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад

      I like mine. it still works great but needs to be updated OFTEN.

  • @ronaldcastaneda681
    @ronaldcastaneda681 2 года назад +2

    Can't you program the 8Bitdo to be more sensitive on the control buttons and sticks? So that they can have better reaction time?

  • @mongoose7171
    @mongoose7171 2 года назад +4

    Had you updated the 8bitdo pro 2? There was a patch which was meant to help with the latency apparently (patch 1.05 mentions it). Trying to decide between this or the extra money for the official Nintendo Pro. The potential latency of the 8bitdo is putting me off, but I would like the back paddles (and cheaper cost).

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад +6

      I recently updated it and the controller is GREAT

    • @mongoose7171
      @mongoose7171 2 года назад +3

      @@julienmelnick Thanks for the reply. So just to clarify. Have you updated the controller since doing the video? And the update improved the latency issue? Great video by the way. Covered the differences really well and thoroughly.

  • @guybrushtwood
    @guybrushtwood Год назад

    You never actually mentioned the latency of the power-A Nano controller. Just kept saying it felt good.
    Did it have more latency than the normal pro controller?

  • @paulblack9931
    @paulblack9931 2 года назад +3

    Great demonstration with all three controllers. My favorite is clearly the Pro Controller. My question is can Nintendo get the remapping available when playing N64 games on the expansion pack? I still can’t the get N64 controller (sold out) and I prefer the Pro Controller

    • @timhaas6021
      @timhaas6021 10 месяцев назад +1

      Needs back buttons.

    • @paulblack9931
      @paulblack9931 10 месяцев назад

      @@timhaas6021 is the 8bitdo Pro 2 a better option with back buttons included?

  • @birdmansenpai7508
    @birdmansenpai7508 2 года назад +1

    I just stick with the 1st party controllers because to me some of the 3rd party controllers don’t have HD Rumble.

  • @kamm3021
    @kamm3021 2 года назад

    One word: 👑 8bitdo 👑

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад

      I love mine. I just want it to be less laggy

  • @illdee04
    @illdee04 2 года назад

    Asymmetrical are best... symetrical sometimes is annoying for me.

  • @K3ntucky123
    @K3ntucky123 Год назад

    I regret buying the pro+ for the splatoon 3, the gyro lag is so unbearable.

  • @jakesmith5278
    @jakesmith5278 2 года назад +2

    8bitdo pro 2 all the way. Would never ever use the thumb stick for Mario World. That is just stupid and weir. The dpad is unmatched on the Pro 2. As for Mario Kart, you didn't adjust the thumb stick property if you want quick turn.

  • @bluestripe8
    @bluestripe8 2 года назад

    Got a knock off switch pro controller… best $30 spent, had all the same features (including gyros and nfc)

  • @Megaboyd
    @Megaboyd 2 года назад +1

    Super Mario World FTW!

    • @Megaboyd
      @Megaboyd 2 года назад

      This game is still amazing.

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад

      This game gets played top to bottom quarterly

  • @maindave1
    @maindave1 2 года назад

    Bought two pro controllers $40 each when toys r us shut down yay me

  • @ShadowCthulhu
    @ShadowCthulhu Год назад +1

    I would pick the 8bit since the analog is symmetrical, I am not a fan of the off-set thumb-sticks

  • @nothoake
    @nothoake 2 года назад

    how do people play without vibration? i don’t get it

  • @CasualtiesOfGaming
    @CasualtiesOfGaming 2 года назад

    8bitdo knocks all other 3rd party controllers out of the water. If the sticks were spaced a bit more like a ps controller it'd be even better.for retro gaming they can't be beat, mind you both mine are wired. I only use them on my laptop so there was no reason to get wireless. Latency is a non issue for me. I have a ln sn30 and an sn30 pro 2. Maybe give the corded ones a try. Not sure if the work with the switch

  • @GianniTamai
    @GianniTamai 2 года назад +1

    Is it a gshock?

  • @gb1838
    @gb1838 Год назад

    the 8bitdo is your favorite controller and you use sticks for 2d games? wtf

  • @ReviloKralc
    @ReviloKralc Год назад

    101 comments lol

  • @tommy6742
    @tommy6742 Год назад

    Every controller is better than the 1st party Switch Pro controller with that garbage ass d-pad. I replaced my official 1st party Switch Pro controller with 8bitdo's SN30 Pro and the newly release Lite 2 controller. I will never buy another Nintendo controller until they can make one with a hall effect sensor joysticks with proper d-pad and abxy buttons that have tact switches.

  • @tamodolo
    @tamodolo 2 года назад +1

    Expected with pro2 controller. The reason you're missing time with it is because the input delay of this controller is REALLY bad. It's astounishing 33ms!!! This is the single worst controller I ever used.
    Start to measure this in your reviews. There are tools to do that with easy on PC as input delay is calculated by 1000ms/polling rate (in Hz). The good polling rate over USB is 3.6ms (or 280Hz). For BT you can actually be faster. DS4 updates at 500Hz or ~1.5 ms (compare this to that crap 8bitdo makes that have 33 ms).
    Why do that? The polling rate adds to your setup input lag. Games that requires dextery will turn impossible to play with high input delay times. This way you will have an actual number to inform your audience what is actually good besides the build quality of the controller.
    As reference, the too high threshhold is 10ms.

  • @tayloraustin4016
    @tayloraustin4016 2 года назад +2

    No one cares about you putting your shoes on. They literally have nothing to do with this video except you want to show them off. Why not just make a shoe video? Good job rainbow warrior.

    • @julienmelnick
      @julienmelnick  2 года назад +11

      Hope you find content that serves you better man. Those shoes meant a lot and to the community that I am trying to build they understand why. It’s a shame that you chose to be hurtful rather than just pass on without saying anything. Please try not to do this to others as they might not be secure enough in themselves to handle it.

    • @tayloraustin4016
      @tayloraustin4016 2 года назад

      @@julienmelnick please stop telling me not to do something I have a God given right to do. This is America, not China. It’s not Russia and it’s not any other nation that doesn’t allow it’s citizens to speak freely. Have a nice day, commie.

    • @KT1459
      @KT1459 2 года назад +7

      @@tayloraustin4016 who pissed in your cereal? Yikes

    • @tayloraustin4016
      @tayloraustin4016 2 года назад

      @@KT1459 you did, bro. Now, you eat the bowl of soggy oats you pissed in.

    • @KT1459
      @KT1459 2 года назад +4

      @@tayloraustin4016 lmao