@@null8295 -- Whatever personal problems you have with Scat, Excrement or even Napoleón, we'll discuss in another forum. As you imply, we separate Wagner the Man from Wagner the Composer!
The listeners who think this symphony is too long are completely mistaken. With his striking melodic/harmonic formulae - extended by repetition of a few exotic progressions, Silvestrov produces pure Symphonic Form. You may not agree with the "content", the "sound material" is not the main poin of the piecet: it is the unfurling of a process - and very beautiful it is. Don't be taken in by your own limitations!
Surely, if someone finds something "too long", they find it too long; they can't be "mistaken". They just have a different idea of what "too long" means! Of course, you have to give this music time to make its effect, you have to 'go with it' rather than against it, but the question is: does the whole add up to more than the sum of its parts? Certainly parts of it sound like empty gestures (to my ears, anyway) - especially from around 3:30 - and I don't get a sense of direction, just drift, as in the 5th Symphony. Of the symphonies I've listened to so far, No. 7 is by far the most effective; it really takes you somewhere! Thanks for posting anyway; I'd much rather listen to new music than more Beethoven.
These are more than citations; Silvestrov literally has stolen from Liebermann Concerto for Jazz Band and Symphony Orchestra, Introduction, from 1954. Compare! Nevertheless highly interesting!
Apartir de este rumbo que tomo la musica de artistas como este la musica se arruino. Me pregunto sin Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven, albinoni que seria de la musica?? Probablemente lo que esta en este audio video, algo carente de espiritu sin alma y tan rudimentario que se parece a los ruidos que hacian nuestros ancestros de las cabernas una involucion de la musica
Fueron Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven y Albinoni quienes revolucionaron la música en sus respectivas épocas. Naturalmente hubo personas, como tú, que los criticaron fuertemente por sus ideas "exóticas" e "intrascendentes", por sus "ruidos". Te recomiendo que disfrutes y que aprendas de lo que nos depara el futuro.
En las cavernas (que no cabernas) se hacía la música más bella que era posible hacer. Igual hace Silvestrov, quien entendió que ya no vivimos en el siglo XVI.
@@pelodelperro gracias por tu corrección ortográfica, mi lengua madre no es el español (alemana) también quiero hacerte saber que prefiero quedarme en el pasado del renacimiento y tu goza de tu modernidad hasta el hartazgo
Beginning this course that took the music of artists like this, music is ruined. I wonder what would become of the music without Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven, albinoni?? Probably what it is in this video audio, something lacking of spirit soulless and so rudimentary that looks like noises that made our ancestors of the caverns, "An involution of music"
Видеоклипы
Composer this wonderful should be known by more people
I have heard the opposite of Silvestrov a man of great kindness. Mean spirited Trolls are at work here shame
Imperialistic Neo-nazis are in Putler's Russia which starts wars all over the region
Silvestrov only supports his people and his country
@Отборный научпоп - Лучший научно-популярный канал Mozart liked escrements and Beethoven supported Napoleon, should they be forgotten by everyone?
@@null8295 -- Whatever personal problems you have with Scat, Excrement or even Napoleón, we'll discuss in another forum. As you imply, we separate Wagner the Man from Wagner the Composer!
I don't care what anyone says, this is great art.
underrated and wonderful
I am a big fan of this man s musical world which he calls Meta music .His romanticism transcends our modern world
..no direction to go..like a hauting ghost in a colourful musical maze..
🇧🇷 ♥️
A stunning opening. Let's see!!
The listeners who think this symphony is too long are completely mistaken. With his striking melodic/harmonic formulae - extended by repetition of a few exotic progressions, Silvestrov produces pure Symphonic Form. You may not agree with the "content", the "sound material" is not the main poin of the piecet: it is the unfurling of a process - and very beautiful it is. Don't be taken in by your own limitations!
I agree (and have the same problem with Symphonies nos 5 and 6), but do try no. 7; it's something special!
Thanks for the tip.
Danke schön!!! Bamberg
thank you!!!
Cosmicism!
Surely, if someone finds something "too long", they find it too long; they can't be "mistaken". They just have a different idea of what "too long" means! Of course, you have to give this music time to make its effect, you have to 'go with it' rather than against it, but the question is: does the whole add up to more than the sum of its parts? Certainly parts of it sound like empty gestures (to my ears, anyway) - especially from around 3:30 - and I don't get a sense of direction, just drift, as in the 5th Symphony. Of the symphonies I've listened to so far, No. 7 is by far the most effective; it really takes you somewhere! Thanks for posting anyway; I'd much rather listen to new music than more Beethoven.
Unfortunately, TV has made everything "too long". Perhaps it isn't the piece that's too long, but your attention span may be too short.
@@stephenkutos6400tv? what about tv series?
I'd love to get the name of the painter for the artwork on this youtube posting.. It reminds me of Marc Chagall, but I don't think it's by him..
Я тоже хотела бы знать имя художника , и имя автора к картинке с вороном к симфонии 1
These are more than citations; Silvestrov literally has stolen from Liebermann Concerto for Jazz Band and Symphony Orchestra, Introduction, from 1954. Compare! Nevertheless highly interesting!
Wo bin ich? Wer bin ich??
чем эта симфония отличается от предыдущей мне кто-нибудь объяснит...?
Тем, что написаны другие ноты.
Apartir de este rumbo que tomo la musica de artistas como este la musica se arruino. Me pregunto sin Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven, albinoni que seria de la musica?? Probablemente lo que esta en este audio video, algo carente de espiritu sin alma y tan rudimentario que se parece a los ruidos que hacian nuestros ancestros de las cabernas una involucion de la musica
Fueron Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven y Albinoni quienes revolucionaron la música en sus respectivas épocas. Naturalmente hubo personas, como tú, que los criticaron fuertemente por sus ideas "exóticas" e "intrascendentes", por sus "ruidos". Te recomiendo que disfrutes y que aprendas de lo que nos depara el futuro.
Valea, tu sigue disfrutando este ruido (Silverstrov) yo me quedo con Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven, albinoni
¡Exacto! Gracias de antemano por eliminar tus comentarios.
En las cavernas (que no cabernas) se hacía la música más bella que era posible hacer. Igual hace Silvestrov, quien entendió que ya no vivimos en el siglo XVI.
@@pelodelperro gracias por tu corrección ortográfica, mi lengua madre no es el español (alemana) también quiero hacerte saber que prefiero quedarme en el pasado del renacimiento y tu goza de tu modernidad hasta el hartazgo
Beginning this course that took the music of artists like this, music is ruined. I wonder what would become of the music without Bach, Vivaldi, Chopin, Beethoven, albinoni?? Probably what it is in this video audio, something lacking of spirit soulless and so rudimentary that looks like noises that made our ancestors of the caverns, "An involution of music"
ok grandpa