It also has an excessive watermark. Would lead me to believe that the jerkiness is intentional and is meant to avoid his video getting taken down automatically for using protected content. Seems like a reasonable approach.
@@punchforpound2808 I'm not talking about legal culpability, I'm talking about the video being taken down by RUclips if their automated system detects copyright content in a video. Their automated system can't accurately detect if something is 'fair use' or not.
@@punchforpound2808 RUclips only exists because it got big enough to negotiate a balance between copyright holders and content creators. The system sucks, but the alternative is RUclips not existing at all.
%100 , look at terminator dark fates 4K quality compared to Terminator 2 , T2 is one of the greatest movies ever made with one of the worst 4K transfers
I love how he emphasizes that the list is only considering audio and picture quality then immediately jumps into some of the worst movies ever made haha
The Lord of the Rings trilogy really is exceptional. The picture is surprisingly crisp for an older title. Looks like it was filmed last year. And the atmos sound is very well done too.
The sound is spectacularly bad. It has one of the worst mixes I've heard in a very long, long time. Blaring music and muffled dialogue do not spectacular sound make. Nolan needs to get his head out of his ass regarding sound already and update to at least 7.1. 5.1 was good in 1999, but not anymore.
@@Neonmirrorblack I just ordered it even though I know I will need the bloody captioning on. What's with todays movie directors that hate clear dialogue
Such great words to describe all the movies. Shane you really do bring your A game each and every time out. You have become so polished in front of the camera. Honestly you should write a manual about how to develop a personality for the lens.
Well the odd thing about this video is that someone over age 15 could not watch or buy these movies. Odd how life turns. We not talking about a good movie, we talking about picture quality of crap or low quality stories. Your list is fine, but these are shit movies. There a good movies to watch. This video is fine. Thanks for sharing.
man after he revealed 1917 on No1 I was kinda shocked... coz I thought TENET was the best of the year... but than he mentioned TENET doesn't count because of not having DolbyAtmos...well done
My ear for sound is probably different from yours Shane. Maybe for picture quality as well. 1. The Invisible Man 2. Ford v Ferrari 3. The Hobbit trilogy 4. 300 5. 1917 6. Birds of Prey 7. Bloodshot 8. Joker 9. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story 10. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
@Jay tech addict Homekit Joker has more of a natural look than BOP. I like the use of color in "Birds of Prey" over "Joker". Plus BOP has better sound separation than Joker. Joker probably does best BOP in the sharpness category.
@Jay tech addict Homekit And why? Because of Chris Nolan allways against 3D Video + 3D Audio, i love 3D + 3D immersive audio, can't wait for AVATAR sequels
Your equipment is amazing, life is good! Wished we could all get dealer cost like you, that would divide the MSRP by 2! Agreed with you regarding Midway, Terminator, Bloodshot great audio and video but you missed Jaws, Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit and V for Vendetta
Ironically, long before I watched this video, I was telling friends and family that ‘1917’ was hands-down the most visually impressive movie I’ve ever watched in my living room. Thanks for this video - keep up the good work!
If someone gave me $100, I wouldn't sit through 1917 again. One of the worst movies of all time. I would rather watch Charlie Sheen in No Man's Land (1987) at 480P anytime! For me, it always starts with a movie star and a good story.
Shane...I know you said it have to be an atmos sound but Tenet should have been in the top three because even having a 5.1 it is so much superior to the call of the wild atmos which we have to turn up.
Excellent list. Based on what I got I would say 1917, Jojo Rabbit, Star Wars ROS, and Midway. For older movies that got 4k releases in 2020 I would say Requiem for a dream, Beetlejuice, Full Metal Jacket and 22 and I suppose 21 jump street
Shane can you tell us more about the 2k DI Vs 4K DI? Do we really need to pay attention to sites like real or fake 4K to get an indicator of video quality ?
I don't pay that much attention to those kind of sites anymore. Though a 2K DI does limit the pixel count, it doesn't prevent the use of HDR on the 4K transfer; IMO HDR is more important than the additional pixels. Besides, professional upscalers are usually higher quality than in consumer devices; redoing 2K CGI in 4K (as Peter Jackson did with much of the LOTR trilogy) is even better.
Dammit Shane, why you gotta be the Spoiler of 2020!?? LOL🤣🤣, Luv the rant on the other channel, your stance and answers where Awesome! I trust your opinions a lot as I do my due diligence too. Have a Merry Christmas Bro!!
Tenet had the best sound of any movie this year, dialog aside. An intense, nervy score that holds the tension from beginning to end. The base during the chopper scenes at the end was insane!
No. Had to turn subtitles on a quarter of the way through the movie and I just left them on. And even the bass was just over boosted, unbalanced mid bass.
@@Nscape-dl2js 2 years late. But yeah Nolan likes to mix the dialogue into the sound effects and stuff so the clarity is notoriously bad. BUT It is still an incredibly amazing sound experience
Hey Shane, ever consider doing a review of the Top Ten 4K music concerts for the year? Muse, Roger Waters, Metallica, and others made great contributions this year....with amazing audio and color fidelity. Might have to use AppleTV 4K for the source.
I already have Joker and 1917 in my collection in Steelbook, and I totally agree with their listing here! Only issue I have with 1917 is the fairly aggressive judder on my LG C9 OLED.
Catalog title. Besides there's some controversy as to the tweaks Peter Jackson made to the films, mainly by those who took his "I wanted to make LOTR look just like The Hobbit" comments a bit too literally (LOTR still isn't 3D @ 48 fps). He still did a great job updating LOTR's early-2000's 2K CGI for 4K; it could have been much, much worse.
Guess who’s back, it’s your boy...oh wait wrong channel! 🤣 Nice list Shane and very useful to have ratings out of 10 included for both audio and video. Stay safe and Merry Xmas. 🎄
I’m glad 1917 made it to No.1 however I’m surprised GEMINI MAN never made this list maybe the Soap Opera effect just didn’t go down well I know I was never a big fan of the 60fps version hence why I imported the 3D Blu-ray from Germany 🇩🇪, but I have to say great top 10 list Shane
@@colinbooth531 I ended up importing the Steelbook that included 4K, 3D & Blu-ray. There is a separate 3D Blu-ray & Blu-ray pack as well GERMANY 🇩🇪 is the only country in the world selling the 3D Version of GEMINI MAN
The worst DOLBY ATMOS mix has F vs F (saw in DOLBY CINEMA) not a single overhead effect in the whole movie what a waste of 3D immersive audio otherwise A1 sound design
I wonder who will buy the Joker and The Invisible Man in 4K...... It's not worth as the content is not worth to rewatch. And where's Pacific rim?? I expect it to be at least 2nd or 3rd!
If The Rise of Skywalker is in the top ten, it just goes to show how bad this year was even for UHDs. Tenet was just a bad film too, even though it looked spectacular and had some great action pieces. The audio is just a mess and the story is completely nonsensical. Watching it multiple times doesn't fix you "not getting it" either. The movie itself should be a factor here as well, not just the technical aspects. So in that respect, the LOTR trilogy and Total Recall should make the list.
Mr spare change I need ur help it’s an emergency so I just bought a Samsung active shutter 3D television for 350 dollars and when I put the batteries in it won’t stay connected what do I do?
I don't get this???? These are pointless videos unless the movies are good. Let e guess you are going to invite your friends to see a bad movie just because it has a clear picture and descent sound, really????
@@xboxgod7725 his list is specifically what he thinks are the best releases of the year, including packaging and extras. He doesn't just do what's the best looking movies like this. They are two different lists and comparing them is dumb
8:14 Dom's face getting blown off? You know how popular you are in real life when your celebrity name doesn't get mentioned but a character that you've played does.
I hadn’t realized how much film grain was in Rise of Skywalker until I turned it on recently. Great list, I want to check some of these out now that I’ve got an Atmos setup in my basement.
There is some strange jerkiness is 1917 video snippets.
It also has an excessive watermark. Would lead me to believe that the jerkiness is intentional and is meant to avoid his video getting taken down automatically for using protected content. Seems like a reasonable approach.
@@punchforpound2808 I'm not talking about legal culpability, I'm talking about the video being taken down by RUclips if their automated system detects copyright content in a video. Their automated system can't accurately detect if something is 'fair use' or not.
@@punchforpound2808 RUclips only exists because it got big enough to negotiate a balance between copyright holders and content creators. The system sucks, but the alternative is RUclips not existing at all.
It sucks that the best looking movies are the worst or just okay movies
It's sadly true. Mortal Engines 4k disc is a monster in PQ and AQ, but I really wish the movie matched the quality
Hey, Invisible Man is pretty good
1917 is Great and there are some others that are great but yeah for the most part I hear you fam
%100 , look at terminator dark fates 4K quality compared to Terminator 2 , T2 is one of the greatest movies ever made with one of the worst 4K transfers
@@DrRobertBischof Pretty good is an understatement. That film is one of my favourite films of all time.
I swear dude called Vin Diesel "Dom" here. Lol.
I realise we're looking at picture transfer and audio quality but goodness me there are some awful films in this list!
I love how he emphasizes that the list is only considering audio and picture quality then immediately jumps into some of the worst movies ever made haha
To bad there's no more top ten 3D blu rays.
Abraham Lincoln Vampire Hunter...just trust me
Perhaps it’s time for an “all time” list...
And The Lord of the rings? And Blade? Spartacus? Alfred Hitckock collection?
What version does he have because midway is in dts 5.1 master auido
The Lord of the Rings trilogy really is exceptional. The picture is surprisingly crisp for an older title. Looks like it was filmed last year. And the atmos sound is very well done too.
@@ermatthe The ignorance in your comment runs so deep that I don't know where to start.
Spartacus is a masterpiece in 4K
@@randmiller88 why?
This is Shane's list, these movies may not be the best but visually they're great! Great work! 🔥
Top gun? It was also awesome, I think my favorite 4K uhd disc of the year.
He hates film grain.
Tenet should be number 1 because its an amazing 4k presentation, the picture is awesome and the sound is Spectacular
For some reason he isn't counting movies that are only 6 channel
He said the only reason he demoted Tenet to honorable mention is its 5.1 non-Atmos mix, which is Christopher Nolan's creative preference.
The sound is spectacularly bad. It has one of the worst mixes I've heard in a very long, long time. Blaring music and muffled dialogue do not spectacular sound make. Nolan needs to get his head out of his ass regarding sound already and update to at least 7.1. 5.1 was good in 1999, but not anymore.
@@Neonmirrorblack I just ordered it even though I know I will need the bloody captioning on. What's with todays movie directors that hate clear dialogue
The dialogue was terrible
Such great words to describe all the movies. Shane you really do bring your A game each and every time out. You have become so polished in front of the camera. Honestly you should write a manual about how to develop a personality for the lens.
The sheer number of ads! Great list though.
glitches at 1917 :)
I sure hope he didn't watch 1917 like that with all those glitches!
@@onlyzach1 😂😂😂😂
Needed if Shane does not want to be hit with copyrights.
@@Icelandlover Yet the other movies?
Is 1917 a great movie? Because if it is, I may buy it in 4K
Hey just wondering why gemini man didn't make the list or at least honorable mentions.
That "Soap Opera" look is a gimmick.
I watched the first 10 minutes of this just to check it out quickly. Must be THE crispest film I've ever witnessed.
I think Gemini Man is the sharpest looking movie I have ever seen
@@88detour not a gimmick. Whether you like it or not, 60 FPS makes fast moving action look crisp, clear, and lifelike.
Didn't that come out last year or no?
What about jaws? It was amazing, brought the early 70s back to life.
I think he was rating only new releases, not catalog titles.
@@catfishhornet star wars was 2019, rt?
4k release was March 31st.
Inside joke... it was Jeff at films at home favorite movie...lol
@@catfishhornet ya but why not new to 4K releases, jaws can out around may 2020 as a restored 4K uhd title.
Well the odd thing about this video is that someone over age 15 could not watch or buy these movies. Odd how life turns. We not talking about a good movie, we talking about picture quality of crap or low quality stories. Your list is fine, but these are shit movies. There a good movies to watch. This video is fine. Thanks for sharing.
man after he revealed 1917 on No1 I was kinda shocked... coz I thought TENET was the best of the year... but than he mentioned TENET doesn't count because of not having DolbyAtmos...well done
My ear for sound is probably different from yours Shane. Maybe for picture quality as well.
1. The Invisible Man
2. Ford v Ferrari
3. The Hobbit trilogy
4. 300
5. 1917
6. Birds of Prey
7.
Bloodshot
8. Joker
9. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
10. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
@Jay tech addict Homekit Joker has more of a natural look than BOP. I like the use of color in "Birds of Prey" over "Joker". Plus BOP has better sound separation than Joker. Joker probably does best BOP in the sharpness category.
@Jay tech addict Homekit And why? Because of Chris Nolan allways against 3D Video + 3D Audio, i love 3D + 3D immersive audio, can't wait for AVATAR sequels
Your equipment is amazing, life is good! Wished we could all get dealer cost like you, that would divide the MSRP by 2!
Agreed with you regarding Midway, Terminator, Bloodshot great audio and video but you missed Jaws, Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit and V for Vendetta
How did the invisible man get a 9.4 for audio? That audio track was amazing
Ironically, long before I watched this video, I was telling friends and family that ‘1917’ was hands-down the most visually impressive movie I’ve ever watched in my living room. Thanks for this video - keep up the good work!
I can't buy a film because it looks good. I have to love the film. Good review though.
Agree
If someone gave me $100, I wouldn't sit through 1917 again. One of the worst movies of all time. I would rather watch Charlie Sheen in No Man's Land (1987) at 480P anytime! For me, it always starts with a movie star and a good story.
Shane...I know you said it have to be an atmos sound but Tenet should have been in the top three because even having a 5.1 it is so much superior to the call of the wild atmos which we have to turn up.
Excellent list. Based on what I got I would say 1917, Jojo Rabbit, Star Wars ROS, and Midway. For older movies that got 4k releases in 2020 I would say Requiem for a dream, Beetlejuice, Full Metal Jacket and 22 and I suppose 21 jump street
1917 is flawless,
Shane can you tell us more about the 2k DI Vs 4K DI? Do we really need to pay attention to sites like real or fake 4K to get an indicator of video quality ?
I don't pay that much attention to those kind of sites anymore. Though a 2K DI does limit the pixel count, it doesn't prevent the use of HDR on the 4K transfer; IMO HDR is more important than the additional pixels. Besides, professional upscalers are usually higher quality than in consumer devices; redoing 2K CGI in 4K (as Peter Jackson did with much of the LOTR trilogy) is even better.
Spectacular list my friend!
I tried 🍻
Great video. I actually own five of your choices.
In my opinion Dark Fate had the best audio mix of the year. Couch shaking bass and active atmos from the very first second all the way to the end.
Ford vs Ferrari sounded unreal, I keep coming back to it !
The worst DOLBY ATMOS mix has F vs F (saw in DOLBY CINEMA) not a single overhead effect in the whole movie so a waste of 3D immersive audio
Lol, didn't know 1917 was shot from an epileptic perspective... 🤣
Being new to 4K physical media (just bought the Panasonic UB9000) i really appreciate the review. Thanks so much!
You will love that player. It’s amazing
Too bad every movie on this list is crap except 1917 and the Invisible Man ;) But I get it, this is about the quality more than anything.
I watched Tenet this weekend and the Imax shots are amazing 👀, I'll pickup 300 which was one of my favorite Blu-ray when it came out
Hi Shane.
My taste mirrors yours. I'm fortunate to have all of them besides 'The New Mutants'. Happy holidays and enjoy!
Don't get new mutant. It sucks
Dammit Shane, why you gotta be the Spoiler of 2020!?? LOL🤣🤣, Luv the rant on the other channel, your stance and answers where Awesome! I trust your opinions a lot as I do my due diligence too. Have a Merry Christmas Bro!!
5 ads in a 13 minute video. Disgusting
But good content 👌
How could Tenet only be 5.1? A big budget, recent, fast action movie in 5.1 doesn't make sense to me.
Love 300 movie
Tenet had the best sound of any movie this year, dialog aside. An intense, nervy score that holds the tension from beginning to end. The base during the chopper scenes at the end was insane!
But Shane said 5.1 and 7.1 mixes weren't eligible. If they were, I think Tenet would've been in the Top Ten.
I think he said Tenet woulda been at or near the top if it wasn't 5.1. I understand 5.1 is Christopher Nolan's personal preference.
had the best sound ... "dialog aside" lol.. what ?
No.
Had to turn subtitles on a quarter of the way through the movie and I just left them on. And even the bass was just over boosted, unbalanced mid bass.
@@Nscape-dl2js 2 years late. But yeah Nolan likes to mix the dialogue into the sound effects and stuff so the clarity is notoriously bad. BUT It is still an incredibly amazing sound experience
Thanks for introducing "The Call of the Wild" as I never know of this and will watch. Others in your top ten list are great and sounding!
Just watched this last night. Stunning!!! Too bad they used so much CGI because otherwise this is as good as it gets.
Jaws
Back to the Future
300
V for Vendetta
Mad Max (1979)
Blade
Pitch Black
Top gun?
Think you missed some classics.
This was only for 2020 releases. 300 was his catalog honorable mention
It's time Nolan adapts Atmos mixing to his future movies.
Hey Shane, ever consider doing a review of the Top Ten 4K music concerts for the year? Muse, Roger Waters, Metallica, and others made great contributions this year....with amazing audio and color fidelity. Might have to use AppleTV 4K for the source.
Yes but those artists are only available for streaming on Amazon Prime in 4k Ultra not on any physical 4K Ultra discs as far as I can tell.
@@kingtrance6826 Metallica was physical, and I think the others were too but only in Blu-ray.
I agree with the list! Thanks Shane! Love what you are doing! I own most of the titles and I agree 1917 was the cleanest movie i saw on 4K all year!
I already have Joker and 1917 in my collection in Steelbook, and I totally agree with their listing here! Only issue I have with 1917 is the fairly aggressive judder on my LG C9 OLED.
the judder is absolutely horrendous and led to me returning my 77 CX
1917 is so boring
Kinda bullshit that movies with 5.1 or 7.1 won’t count. Till this day Interstellar has one of the best sound mixes i’ve ever heard
@Jay tech addict Homekit Tenet is good, but doesn’t come close to Interstellar
@Jay tech addict Homekit you should definitely see the 4k bluray. The sound and imax scenes are insane
Nice list .I have 9 of the 10 including the honorable mentions .
Sadly, most of those movies are horrible.
Very strange list. How about Vertigo?
I liked your list and explanation for each title.
I'm surprised LOTR wasn't mentioned.
Catalog title. Besides there's some controversy as to the tweaks Peter Jackson made to the films, mainly by those who took his "I wanted to make LOTR look just like The Hobbit" comments a bit too literally (LOTR still isn't 3D @ 48 fps). He still did a great job updating LOTR's early-2000's 2K CGI for 4K; it could have been much, much worse.
Guess who’s back, it’s your boy...oh wait wrong channel! 🤣
Nice list Shane and very useful to have ratings out of 10 included for both audio and video.
Stay safe and Merry Xmas. 🎄
No. You got the right channel 😎
A starwars le doy un 6 de calificación en imagen y audio.
Will there be a top 10 4k remastered movies list?
I really enjoyed your RUclips channel, very well done.
Jaws, full metal jacket?
Es una lista de todas las películas que fracasaron.
What about Requiem for a Dream? Is it a good transfer?
Was ok.
I’m glad 1917 made it to No.1 however I’m surprised GEMINI MAN never made this list maybe the Soap Opera effect just didn’t go down well I know I was never a big fan of the 60fps version hence why I imported the 3D Blu-ray from Germany 🇩🇪, but I have to say great top 10 list Shane
Does the 3D version have Atmos?
@@colinbooth531 it sure does 👍
@@hglmedia307 thanks. I have the 4K60 version but I might import the 3D version too, it's one of the very few 3D I don't own.
@@colinbooth531 I ended up importing the Steelbook that included 4K, 3D & Blu-ray.
There is a separate 3D Blu-ray & Blu-ray pack as well GERMANY 🇩🇪 is the only country in the world selling the 3D Version of GEMINI MAN
@@hglmedia307 lucky them!
10 of the best, but only 2 you’d actually want to own 😂
Totally agree with this whole list, start to finish!!
Lots of notes must of been taken there! Nice write up. Do the "bad" movies make it easier to review than the good ones?
shot in 8k but has a 2k di? wtf were they thinking?
Well done shane happy christmas
The worst DOLBY ATMOS mix has F vs F (saw in DOLBY CINEMA) not a single overhead effect in the whole movie what a waste of 3D immersive audio otherwise A1 sound design
Tenet sounded like ass. Obnoxious bass!
Crispy 2020
I wonder who will buy the Joker and The Invisible Man in 4K...... It's not worth as the content is not worth to rewatch. And where's Pacific rim?? I expect it to be at least 2nd or 3rd!
The Croods 2......is a demo worthy animation movie to showcase the power of HDR on your 4K telly. Check em out. It’s so colourful.
From 2019, I recommend *Alita Battle Angel* on 4K
You won't regret it, make sure you have surround sound 5.1 or higher.
65 inch screen or bigger.
Gemini Man n Ford vs Ferrari???
I'm glad you mentioned tenet but , also understand your criteria , that 5.1 sound was nice ,minus the dialog of course ,lol
If The Rise of Skywalker is in the top ten, it just goes to show how bad this year was even for UHDs. Tenet was just a bad film too, even though it looked spectacular and had some great action pieces. The audio is just a mess and the story is completely nonsensical. Watching it multiple times doesn't fix you "not getting it" either.
The movie itself should be a factor here as well, not just the technical aspects. So in that respect, the LOTR trilogy and Total Recall should make the list.
Mr spare change I need ur help it’s an emergency so I just bought a Samsung active shutter 3D television for 350 dollars and when I put the batteries in it won’t stay connected what do I do?
I love film grain.
Why'd you use the song from 1917 during the Midway review...
Lovely list but I think you slept on Doctor Sleep Shane. The audio IMO was phenomenal and its crispy as hell. Was this a 2019 release maybe.. ?
Awesome, Hope u be Ready next year for reviews, U gonna be Quite Busy.. Stay Safe, Be Safe!!!!
I don't get this???? These are pointless videos unless the movies are good. Let e guess you are going to invite your friends to see a bad movie just because it has a clear picture and descent sound, really????
Tenet sucked
Midway was 5
BUt WhAT aBoUT LoRD oF thE RiNgS?!
1917 was just mediocre 4k visual quality imo
Two Quarts Low Jeff at “Films at Home” had a Top 7 Blu-ray & 4k Combined List 😂🤣😅
Did multiple sets in the list & they shouldn't count as 'one' movie, like goddamn
@@xboxgod7725 his list is specifically what he thinks are the best releases of the year, including packaging and extras. He doesn't just do what's the best looking movies like this. They are two different lists and comparing them is dumb
Doms face getting blown off 🤔🤔
Damn straight 😎😎
If you were rating just for picture quality where would Mulan be on your list?
Why are Disney discs so quiet? Same goes for Marvel movies
Wheres Akira 4K bluray my guy???
Midway is in DTS master audio 5.1 the one I own and it is the 4K version ??
Missing here Top Gun or Hobbit movies, just to name a couple
Should have included catalog titles released in 4K uhd Blu-ray should have been included.
LOL 1917 Demo footage is just too funny
8:14 Dom's face getting blown off? You know how popular you are in real life when your celebrity name doesn't get mentioned but a character that you've played does.
Apostrophes don't make words plural.
I have to like a movie if it warrants an upgrade to 4K.
I hadn’t realized how much film grain was in Rise of Skywalker until I turned it on recently. Great list, I want to check some of these out now that I’ve got an Atmos setup in my basement.
Lord of the rings trilogy? The hobbit trilogy?