@@MaRkYWaHoO- So, any other Chiefs fans a bit nervous? I trust Mahomes and Reid, but I am a bit concerned with our receives corps. Can Mahomes make it work again? I mean, Mahomes can only do so much, we are so shallow at WR I am not sure Mahomes can make up for it. Skyy Moore will really have to step up, a lot will he riding on him.
@@ElectronFieldPulse look at what the Chiefs and Mahomes did in the playoffs against the Bengals when it mattered most! James Rice Moore Watson Toney MVS…is enough when Travis is out there…🤩
Dak being ahead of Kirk Cousins never makes sense. Kirk's biggest criticism is lack of playoff success, well guess who also has a lack of playoff success despite having generally a better roster on paper? And Kirk outperforms Dak in the regular season like every damn year.
They need more tiers. Mahomes is the only one in tier 1. 3 should begin with Hurts. Edit: Obviously, I spoke too soon. They just mentioned his own tier.
“If Goff does it again, I think he comes into tier 2” but yet Cousins has been 4 years passing rating of 95+, 2 years of 100+, 4k yards last like 8 years with 30 touchdowns….but yet y’all said he’s not tier 2…but if Goff does it just the 2nd time in like 7 years he’s tier 2??? Wtf😭😭😭
Life long chiefs fan here, y'all need to stop putting Herbert on a damn pedestal. Dude has accomplished nothing, and to have him ahead of Hurts is laughable. JS
you can’t judge everything after 1 year, aaron was probably the best qb in 2020 and 2021, and t law had a good last half of the season, but we need to see it againz
it seems pretty ludicrous to put justin herbert in tier 1 considering he hasn't won anything. that meltdown against the jags was pretty ugly. that's a pretty big "but".
He has had the most injured team since being in the league. He also has had coaching/ organization problems!!! He has broken every record for first 3 years. Put him on any well run team and he's winning a SB!! That's a fact!!! That's coming from a Patriots fan
@louisloother301 so your saying he's not teir 1 cause teir 1 is for elite qbs who win in spite of who's on the roster. Mahomes lost maybe the best wr in the league and won the super bowl. Herbert gets more excuses than tds
Allen IS the Bills offense, more than any other QB for their team. Any disappointment has got to be with the lack of talent on the O line and receivers after Diggs. I don't know what more they can expect from him. He has no help. Edit: spelling
Josh Allen produces numbers and wins behind a horrendous O-line, one reliable pass catcher, a first year coordinator, McDermott as a coach and he is the Bills run game. Everybody was all about him last year and his numbers were almost identical this year, quit trying to throw shade on the dude.
Noah Gray is nwxt up for the Chiefs. mahomes is following the Brady gameplan. Interchangable wise receivers with a constant elite tight end. Also, has to make sure to have a white shifty wide receiver. KC defense about to shock alot of people this year. They played 7 rookies last year with significant snaps. They are only going to get better
I think skyy Moore can excel in that shifty slot reciever role. I have high hopes for rashee Rice being a legit outside alpha type of reciever and if kadarius can stay healthy as an x factor type of weapon we should have a really solid receiving core
I dont understand the herbert love. Year one as starter mahomes won mvp and year 3 superbowl. Year one starting for lamar he won an mvp. Year 2 for burrow he lead his team to the superbowl. Herbert has accomplished nothing to be put on a list with these guys
@@AB-sm4sf theyve been lower half not lowest of low. And a few teams above them made the playoffs as well. I looked it up. If herbert is how hes talked about then he should be able to overcome. Prime example last year against the jags, no qb I named lets that lead go. I get it hes young, but accomplish something first before your name gets thrown at the top
@@AB-sm4sf in the nfl there are no games you should win only the games you do win. If youre gonna tell me someone is that guy then if you have to win high scoring games then you gotta do it. Ive been having the same argument with lamar for years that he hasnt had the same offense as other qbs and lamar is my guy, but in the end its about winning
So much of how people evaluate QBs is what their expectations were coming into the league. It's really stupid after a few years of being in the league, but first impressions are really a huge factor. Herbert surpassed expectations (so did mahomes) and that's why they're looked at so highly.
@@nicholassitter6400 herbert has just about avg success for a qb picked in the first round. Tier one SHOULD mean you have accomplished something so far in your career, like won an mvp or 2 or even reached or won a superbowl. Saying herbert has exceeded expectation along with the guy who has reached 5 conference champs, been to 3 superbowls and won 2 mvps is asinine. He cant even compare yet to the guys in his class who have been to superbowls or even won an mvp. Hes not there yet
What is that supposed to mean? Chiefs and Eagles met in the SB once so now they're rivals? If anything you have more of a bias against the Jets since unlike the Eagles, they play in your conference. You're also shook because you know they're a real threat. 49ers vs Jets SB future, bet the farm
@@Nonchalant1994😂🤣😂🤣 Rodgers? You mean the guy that before the #1 wr in the NFL Adams showed up he only had mediocre seasons? 😂😂😂😂😂 Rodgers looked like garbage without the best wr in the NFL. He isn't anything special.
@@CalebJohnston He used to be. Doesn't belong in tier 1 so idk what this NFL analyst is smoking with putting him there. But even if he's no longer a top 5 or even top 10 QB at this stage of his career, the Jets are primed for a big season this year, and that's coming from a Dolphins fan
@@Nonchalant1994 I don't care who you're a fan of. Being a casual is being a casual. Rodgers has never once in his career faced the kind of adversity he's about to face. Dude is 19-31 against top 10 defenses.
Dude it's so annoying how everyone pretends Mahomes does everything himself without "receivers" as if he doest have the GOAT Offensive coach and GOAT receiving TE and a consistently top 5 O-line his entire career. I promise you Joe Burrow would trade Higgins and Boyd for a good O-line, forget about Kelce AND Reid on top of that
The fact that Mahomes had the year he had last season with the most mediocre receiving corps of any playoff team is astounding. Yes i know he had Kelce, but he’s a 34 year old tight end. He doesn’t have the same effect on defenses the way Jamar Chase or Stefon Diggs does. After Kelce all Mahomes had was Juju and MVS who were cast offs from other teams, Skyy Moore a rookie who kept making mistakes and a 7th round rookie runningback. To lead the league in TD’s and yards without an actual number 1 receiver is really impressive.
Pure delusion, 2nd best oline best te in league 2 number 1 wr’s the second best recieving rb with above average rb , mahomes prolly had the second best offensive unit if not best in whole league in fact mahomes worst offense his whole career was more talented than allens best unit his whole career.
Greatest receiving TE of all time... he doesnt have the same effect on defenses like Diggs or Chase? Are you crazy? OC is Andy Reid with a top 3 O-line in the league. Not Mahomes' fault, but lets not act like he has no help.
Mahomes is the best QB in the league, and he excelled last year without that game breaker WR, but he still relies on the support of a great OL and a dude named Chris Jones. I mention the latter because if something goes haywire with him, you will find out how hard it is to win games when you can't stop the run. Not that Jones is only good at that. Outside of Patrick he may be your team MVP. I'm a big believer in giving the QB what he needs to succeed, but sometimes we undervalue his most valued OL and run stoppers. If you can't stop the run, Mahomes will be pacing the sideline a lot more than you want.
Justin herbert doesn't have a "but" .... but jalen has. Literally jalen hurts is the most under valued QB right now. Ma man had one of the best Superbowl perfomances ever and still gets put on tier 2. While herbert is a 500 QB and gets put on tier 1, you really can't make this stuff up
To his point about mahomes not having any help like the other “legacy “ QBs Mahomes has Andy Reid. Everyone needs help, you don’t do it ALL on your OWN. If he’s in Jacksonville or Houston he’s still gonna be great and have incredible stats but he doesn’t have any rings. Brett and Andy Reid help a lot.
Bro, Andy Reid was Fired from his previous team for having time management issues and an inability to win the big game. After that he was either talked about as not able to live up to his potential or continuously derided for being "one and done" in the playoffs (he had 1 playoff win for the Chiefs before the qb wearing 15 came into the picture). His career was on a mediocre if not downward trajectory before Mahomes.
@@alaskau9175 Andy has always been one of the best offensive minds in football. He got to 3 or 4 nfc championships with Philly and a super bowl and lost to the dynasty of the patriots. Look at his career record, he’s always been a good coach. Sure no one else was beating Bill or Tomlin consistently (maybe Harbaugh) when they had their HOF QB’s in their prime. Now it’s flipped. To sit here and presented like he’s not a good coach and mahomes isn’t lucky to have (their lucky to have each other) is ludicrous. Just like Bill and Brady, and bill wash and montana, Tomlin and Big Ben. You are a 🤡.
Herd always tries to push mediocre QBs. Until Herbert wins a playoff game he is tier 2. Goff will always be tier 3 because he never delivers at critical moments of a game.
If trevor and hurts are in tier 2 because of the "buts", then you gotta pass equal judgement on your guys in tier 1. Rodgers is great, but he's 39 and has regressed without davante. Allen is great, but his elite playoff QB play was nonexistent last year Herbert is great, but he still has a lot to prove and struggles in the playoffs.
Regular season stats don't mean a thing. To be a top tier QB you have to produce at crucial moments in a game. When you are 7 points down late in the 4th quarter do you make the critical throw. And you must produce in the playoffs. Rodgers is a tier one talent but should be in Tier 2 because he chokes at critical moments and in the playoffs. Herbert is tier 2. Hurts is tier 1 because he produced all season and in the SB.
Herbert & Dak are the same qb's! Decent; but can't win the big 1! Josh Allen is great; but, once again, a turnover machine! All 3 qb's are going to have trouble winning a SB! Cousins is close to the same! Great season QB; but, can't get deep in the playoffs! 🤞🤏🤔
I like how they say lamar jackson gets hurt all the time but nothing about joe burrow 😂 and how tf can you put herbert in the same tier as mahomes… tier 1 is mahomes and maybe rodgers(but hes getting older) tier 2 is burrow, lamar, allen, maybe hurts (only said maybe bc it was one year but he did make it to the superbowl) and the rest on this list are tier 3.. idgaf if you can throw really well.. none of the others have done a dam thing.. like seriously man. it’s too much disrespect going on for the qbs that have actually done something
Why do we pretend like tier one is that large. Tier one is Mahomes and maybe burrow, but how people can pretend like Herbert, and Rodgers are in the same tier as the best player we’ve ever seen at the position is beyond me. Mahomes is in the same tier as people Herbert , who wasn’t very good last year, and has never won anything, and Rodgers who tremendously regressed from the years before. Istg some people just evaluate qbs based on their arm strength
Championships have less to do with Qb than you think. It's a team sport where 52 other guys have to do their jobs, excluding coaches. You can be an elite QB without winning a ring. Nobody denies that Dan Marino was an elite QB. It is about the arm talent and the smarts for these Rankings, as no one would say Purdy is an elite QB had the 49'ers won the super bowl. Also who did Rodgers have at pass catcher last year? No one great or elite like Burrow, Mahomes, Allen, or Herbert. Keep in mind when Rodgers had Adams, he won multiple MVPs and was a touchdown away from a super bowl the year Tampa won. Would you actually put Herbert and Rodgers in the same tier as Dak, Trevor, Cousins, Watson, and Stafford? I wouldn't. And I would certainly put them above Lamar and Hurts.
@@theechoproject899 the issue is that people assume Mahomes has this god-like supporting cast and that just isn’t true. Let’s start from the receiving core: So yea obviously Travis Kelce is the best TE in the NFL, but Mahomes WRs as they stand are probably the worst in the nfl. So while Kelce is great his overall pass catcher room is far from being elite. Second, while his interior O-line is great, he had easily the worst tackle duo in football, which led to him dealing with an insane amount of pressures, but since he evaded more sacks than Herbert, Rodgers, and Burrow people assume his Line is great. And lastly, his defense has just never been that great, which is unfortunate bc the early 2010s chiefs defenses were amazing. I didn’t even mention that Mahomes has never had an elite run game(thanks for passing on Johnathan Taylor Veach) So how does a team like the eagles lose to a team with an overall weaker receiving core, offensive line, and weaker defense lose a qb on one leg. The answer is simple, because the true greats win superbowls. So I’d like to stop pretending that all the other “tier one” qbs are in much more adverse circumstances bc that’s not actually true. Just remember, there was a reason the “experts” thought the chiefs were gonna be a wildcard team this year. Also on a side note Jalen Hurts is def better than Herbert and probably Rodgers
@@AB-sm4sf Conversely when your defense forces the other QB to throw 4 interceptions and you’re up 27 points well if you’re an elite QB I’d expect you not to lose that lead no matter bad your defense plays in the second half.
@@AB-sm4sf Mahomes also became the first QB THIS CENTURY to win MVP, the SB & SBMVP in the same season. Mahomes broke Drew Brees' record for Most Total Offensive Yards in a Single Season with 5,608 including 6 Receiving Yards he passed to HIMSELF. 2022 ESPY Award for Best NFL Player 2022 ESPY Award for Best Male Athlete 2022 ESPY Award for Best Team Number 1 Netflix Docu-series 11-3 Post Season 4,084 Passing Yards 35 Passing TD'S 7 INT'S Oh & he has even better Regular Season stats, FYI.
The lunacy of Herbert, Rodgers and Allen being teir 1 over Hurts. Herbert has 0 playoff victories and is teir 1? Rodgers had 1 great playoff run 30 years ago and hes teir 1? Josh Allen is shoved down our throats as the next goat every year and hes done nothing.
Geno behind Stafford, Watson and Cousins is the biggest disrespect. Two of them didn’t even play most of last year AND Geno took us to the playoffs when NOBODY thought we would be relevant.
Geno is 10-11 as the Seahawks’ starter. He went 9-8 in an injury-depleted year for the NFCw, and lost to the 49ers three times. He didn’t light it up like Seahawks fans think he did, and the Seahawks were a 4-13 team last year at best. Their record said 9-8, but they weren’t a 9-8 team.
Mahomes is in a tier of his own. Herbert may have a lot of talent, but he doesn't belong in tier 1 until he actually wins something... Like a playoff game where they get out to a big lead.
Stats dont Lie. Herb played through injury, and took his team to the playoffs. His defense lost that game. But go ahead and keep talking like a casual.
Love the snide comment about DJ. He could have left it alone. He could have just been interview over but according to the experts DJ & Goff aren’t that far apart. He can’t even give him credit for that.
because he, like many people, including so called experts do not take into account(enough) how rotten the ol and receivers have been for jones during his four years in the league. goff has had cooper kupp and amon ra st. brown to throw to, jones has never had anyone even close to receivers like that. i'd love to see goff play behind a bottom 5 pass blocking line like jones has
To have Herbert in tier 1 and Hurts and Jackson in tiers 2 is absurd. Unlike Herbert, those guys have won playoff games…everybody is judging Herbert on what he COULD be instead of what he IS…
100% SPEAKING FACTS! Sports media bozos don't know any more than you and I do, they just have researchers doing all their homework 24/7. If this was MY job, I would come with opinions that had some bases and based on facts.
Did you watch the video? This is a player evaluation and not a team evaluation. The team had the 28th best defense for the past 2 years but went 19W-15L with Herbert as QB. All other teams with defense that bad were around 50W and 90+ Ls. Wins and Losses are a team stat. For some strange reason they get tied to the QB. They should be tied to the team and to the coach. If you are a football fan then you know there are games when your QB was on fire and lost because the defense didn't come through or a RB fumbles at a bad time or a kicker misses an easy FG. The Chargers have been Kings of losing games in the strangest ways and a lot of those come without Herbert's involvement. I wouldn't put him ahead of Hurts but he is definitely one of the best 6 QBs in the league. I think 1 and 2 are set and 3-6 can go in any order.
acting like Hurts didnt go against a terrible giants team and a qb less niners lmao. Hurts needs to prove it a second year to get any respect imo. AFC is way tougher than NFC lol
@@semi6544 and sometimes they are his fault. Like when he couldn’t complete a pass in a playoff game to avoid losing a 27 point lead. Is that the defense’s fault? Sure. But great ones overcome. I like Herbert. I think he’s going to be a great QB. But Tier one is for guys with no holes in their games. His hole is that he sometimes doesn’t have it in prime time. Regardless of schedule, Hurts proved in the superbowl that the lights are never too bright for him. He made plays when he had to. Herbert, while somehow having an defense wit defensive stars all over it, often doesn’t. I’m not saying he’s not a top six QB. Honestly, I’d take Rodgers out and put him in Tier 2.
Brady wasn’t the best QB talent, but he’s arguably the greatest QB because of his achievements. Championships and other accomplishments measure greatness, talent tells us who is best. So you have it backwards to a degree. Think about the inputs: Best: talent/ability and skills Greatness: Talent/ability and skills used to produce outstanding performances, win titles, set records, and achieve personal and/or team accolades. Greatness is partially an output of talent and skills. Mahomes has talent and skills, but we will have to wait on calling him the GOAT, because he isn’t even close right now, especially after the stain that is SB55 on his resume. He has to own that. He was pure dogsh!t that night, and a respectable QB would have at least tried to RUN a TD. He didn’t play well for most of SB54, either. The great ones are always at their best when the lights are the absolute brightest. Mahomes is like this 👋🏾 for me. Idc what anyone says. His game is pretty, but he isn’t carrying anything or anyone.
I need to add that the Chiefs should have lost SB57 and would have if not for Jalen Hurts’s fumble. The Chiefs shouldn’t have been playing in that SB anyway. The fix was in. The NFL has made Mahomes the face of the league, and that’s the reason he will always get the favorable calls, be given excuses in the media, have his fake injuries promoted, and get the benefit of the doubt when he isn’t good. They have DECIDED that Mahomes will always be front and center until it can’t be justified, and it p!sses me off because Russ got stepped over in the equation. He was supposed to be that dude. Russ, Luck, RG3, Cam, and (believe it or not) Kaepernick were the Mahomes-Burrow-Allen-Herbert-Jackson of the previous group. Watson should be right up there with Mahomes too but ruined himself and his career because he couldn’t control his urges, but I digress… The NFL is rigged! For example, the no-call in the 2018-19 NFC Championship game that deprived Sean Payton of an opportunity to play in that year’s SB was no accident, and neither was the lousy officiating in the 2022-23 AFC Championship. Roger Goodell and the other commissioners are like PT Barnum: they’ll always put on the best SHOW, even if it requires them to do underhanded sh!t like rig games. They’re robber barons.
@DeCurtaRican I know Brady isn't the most physically gifted, arguably that's Rodgers or Elway or old school with Otto Graham. Lamar being arguably a rich man's mike vick but not winning in the playoffs ruins his case as the most physically gifted. For a long time people have said Rodgers is the best but if you can't do it when there's the most pressure to perform you can't be the best that's why Peyton and Rodgers have a hard argument to make in my opinion.
@DeCurtaRican sorry why shouldn't they have been in the super bowl? Bengals blew the that game they should have been in the super bowl Sure if Asante Samuel caught the interception in the 4th quarter the pats wouldn't have lost thar obe or if they called holding on the oline or in the grasp on the tyree catch the pats would have won
@@DeCurtaRican Don't forget the Pats vs Chiefs champ game on 4th down when Brady was handed a free set of downs instead of game over for a "roughing the passer call" that clearly showed Chris Jones hand just barley brushed Brady's shoulder and ended up costing the Chiefs going to the SB. Brady has at least 3 or 4 SB rings that he shouldn't have even been to the SB. Jalen Hurt's did fumble and the Eagles got a lucky break on that other turnover for 6 that was called incomplete when at least 50% of the time that was a fumble too. Can play the what-if game all day and try to blame refs every time but players will tell you the game is a lot more than 1 or 2 missed or bad calls that fans will always cry about.
Pure Passing Situations...this is the phrase that the vast majority of fans and even some front office folks don't understand. People want to turn the pocket passing discussion into one about race, offensive philosophy, and trends when in actuality it is just a pure objective scientific fact. With finite space and time on the field the most efficient delivery of the ball is going to be in the pocket and on time. This separates the flashes from the consistently good and the consistently good from the greats. This is what makes an offense almost impossible to defend. This is why certain QBs who get so much hype never last, because people overlook the most important ability and just focus on stats.
how is Justin Herbert a tier 1 Quarterback???? he never made it to the postseason. Colin rationality is just flawed or wrong. I would have argued for Lamar Jackson or Matthew Stafford than Herbert
right? he said it at the beginning. a tier 2 qb is basically a tier 1 qb that comes with a but. we love everything about justin herbert, BUT he hasn't wona playoff game.
Subscribe to The Carton Show now: sprtspod.fox/SubscribeCartonShow
Mahomes is about to make Justyn Ross a STAR this year
If healthy yes
He’s gonna use Sky Moore a lot imo
I hope so. I have been excited to see them play since last year
@@MaRkYWaHoO- So, any other Chiefs fans a bit nervous? I trust Mahomes and Reid, but I am a bit concerned with our receives corps. Can Mahomes make it work again? I mean, Mahomes can only do so much, we are so shallow at WR I am not sure Mahomes can make up for it. Skyy Moore will really have to step up, a lot will he riding on him.
@@ElectronFieldPulse look at what the Chiefs and Mahomes did in the playoffs against the Bengals when it mattered most! James Rice Moore Watson Toney MVS…is enough when Travis is out there…🤩
Goff should be tier 2 easily , Dak and Watson should be tier 3
Kirk tier 3 as well
Watson is not tier 3 this year you ll see
@@juniorluma9129hopefully 💪🏿🤦🏿♂️
@@juniorluma9129Tier 4 😂
@@jbelevateee i think kirk is right where he should be, the very last one in tier 2 hes the gatekeeper for tier 2.
Well deserved, Patrick Mahomes the best QB in the NFL today 💯
Dak being ahead of Kirk Cousins never makes sense. Kirk's biggest criticism is lack of playoff success, well guess who also has a lack of playoff success despite having generally a better roster on paper? And Kirk outperforms Dak in the regular season like every damn year.
yeah idk, cause he’s a cowboy, generally they are overrated
They need more tiers. Mahomes is the only one in tier 1. 3 should begin with Hurts.
Edit: Obviously, I spoke too soon. They just mentioned his own tier.
Tier 1:Mahomes
Tier 2:Allen
Tier 3: Everyone else
@@axe2grind244 As much as I love Allen, I would have him and Burrow as Tier 2.
@@axe2grind244Allen is not tier 2 by himself 😂
He said I love but for every tier 2 QB outside of Watson and that's very funny lol
“If Goff does it again, I think he comes into tier 2” but yet Cousins has been 4 years passing rating of 95+, 2 years of 100+, 4k yards last like 8 years with 30 touchdowns….but yet y’all said he’s not tier 2…but if Goff does it just the 2nd time in like 7 years he’s tier 2??? Wtf😭😭😭
Gonna look real awkward when Cousins has 55k yards and 325 touchdowns for his career💀
@@CrabtreeCodyand 2 playoff wins lol…
Cousins is 34, Goff is 28. the young guy will get the benefit of the doubt because there is still upside.
@@theechoproject899Stats are stats.
@@julienforletta7896You mean one.
The NFC needs Caleb Williams!
Life long chiefs fan here, y'all need to stop putting Herbert on a damn pedestal. Dude has accomplished nothing, and to have him ahead of Hurts is laughable. JS
So you watched the video and didnt hear anything they said lol. Try again sweetheart.
Same with Trash Lamar Jackson.
- Ravens fan
-Football Fan
Funny because Herbert always gives your cheatin chiefs a run for their money every time they play eachother
His biggest accomplishment was blowing a 27 point playoff lead
@@themoviefan9990 you mean the chargers
... or are you one of those skip bayless emmanuel acho disciples 🤔
Mahomes is in his own tier. I have a feeling after this yr Trevor Lawrence joins tier 1, and Aaron Rodgers joins tier 2
you can’t judge everything after 1 year, aaron was probably the best qb in 2020 and 2021, and t law had a good last half of the season, but we need to see it againz
it seems pretty ludicrous to put justin herbert in tier 1 considering he hasn't won anything. that meltdown against the jags was pretty ugly. that's a pretty big "but".
He has had the most injured team since being in the league. He also has had coaching/ organization problems!!! He has broken every record for first 3 years. Put him on any well run team and he's winning a SB!! That's a fact!!! That's coming from a Patriots fan
@louisloother301 so your saying he's not teir 1 cause teir 1 is for elite qbs who win in spite of who's on the roster. Mahomes lost maybe the best wr in the league and won the super bowl. Herbert gets more excuses than tds
Allen IS the Bills offense, more than any other QB for their team. Any disappointment has got to be with the lack of talent on the O line and receivers after Diggs. I don't know what more they can expect from him. He has no help.
Edit: spelling
O line was upgraded this year and we added 5 more weapons. No more excuses.
Josh Allen produces numbers and wins behind a horrendous O-line, one reliable pass catcher, a first year coordinator, McDermott as a coach and he is the Bills run game. Everybody was all about him last year and his numbers were almost identical this year, quit trying to throw shade on the dude.
You Josh Allen fans are so sensitive.
Regular season wins
Hurts goes 16-2 as a starter including a super bowl loss and is tier 2? Herbert hasn't even won a playoff game lol
Not sure if I'd put Rogers in Tier 1. He struggled pretty bad last season. Under pressure I'd take quite a few over Rogers.
I think he is going to be tier 2 after this yr, he didn't play well last yr, we will see if the change of scenery helps him.
Plus outside of the one Superbowl run, Rodgers has a been a choke artist in the playoffs.
Noah Gray is nwxt up for the Chiefs. mahomes is following the Brady gameplan. Interchangable wise receivers with a constant elite tight end. Also, has to make sure to have a white shifty wide receiver. KC defense about to shock alot of people this year. They played 7 rookies last year with significant snaps. They are only going to get better
I think skyy Moore can excel in that shifty slot reciever role. I have high hopes for rashee Rice being a legit outside alpha type of reciever and if kadarius can stay healthy as an x factor type of weapon we should have a really solid receiving core
@@allengodfrey2488 I agree. If KT can't stay healthy I just hope he is good by the time the playoffs roll around. He is a difference maker
I dont understand the herbert love. Year one as starter mahomes won mvp and year 3 superbowl. Year one starting for lamar he won an mvp. Year 2 for burrow he lead his team to the superbowl. Herbert has accomplished nothing to be put on a list with these guys
@@AB-sm4sf theyve been lower half not lowest of low. And a few teams above them made the playoffs as well. I looked it up. If herbert is how hes talked about then he should be able to overcome. Prime example last year against the jags, no qb I named lets that lead go. I get it hes young, but accomplish something first before your name gets thrown at the top
@@AB-sm4sf in the nfl there are no games you should win only the games you do win. If youre gonna tell me someone is that guy then if you have to win high scoring games then you gotta do it. Ive been having the same argument with lamar for years that he hasnt had the same offense as other qbs and lamar is my guy, but in the end its about winning
Uh, in year 1 as a starter Mahomes won MVP & OPOY. Year 2, he went to & won the SB & SBMVP.
In year 3, he went back to the SB.
So much of how people evaluate QBs is what their expectations were coming into the league. It's really stupid after a few years of being in the league, but first impressions are really a huge factor. Herbert surpassed expectations (so did mahomes) and that's why they're looked at so highly.
@@nicholassitter6400 herbert has just about avg success for a qb picked in the first round. Tier one SHOULD mean you have accomplished something so far in your career, like won an mvp or 2 or even reached or won a superbowl. Saying herbert has exceeded expectation along with the guy who has reached 5 conference champs, been to 3 superbowls and won 2 mvps is asinine. He cant even compare yet to the guys in his class who have been to superbowls or even won an mvp. Hes not there yet
'Mahomes tops NFL quarterbacks tiers'
Wow I'm shocked 😅
I'm a Chiefs fan and even I would switch Rodgers and Hurts around on the tiers...come on now.
What is that supposed to mean? Chiefs and Eagles met in the SB once so now they're rivals? If anything you have more of a bias against the Jets since unlike the Eagles, they play in your conference. You're also shook because you know they're a real threat. 49ers vs Jets SB future, bet the farm
@@Nonchalant1994😂🤣😂🤣 Rodgers? You mean the guy that before the #1 wr in the NFL Adams showed up he only had mediocre seasons? 😂😂😂😂😂
Rodgers looked like garbage without the best wr in the NFL. He isn't anything special.
@@CalebJohnston He used to be. Doesn't belong in tier 1 so idk what this NFL analyst is smoking with putting him there. But even if he's no longer a top 5 or even top 10 QB at this stage of his career, the Jets are primed for a big season this year, and that's coming from a Dolphins fan
@@Nonchalant1994 I don't care who you're a fan of. Being a casual is being a casual. Rodgers has never once in his career faced the kind of adversity he's about to face.
Dude is 19-31 against top 10 defenses.
I didn't realize tier 1 QBs blew 27 point leads in the playoffs
So the bengals dragging their nuts all over Allen’s face we just sweep under the rug? Lmao delusional
Sheeeeeeesh I’m so happy Uncle Colin is back💯💯
5:25 that part
Pat is in a class by himself
Remember Jared Goff’s blown pass in the Super Bowl?- Tier 3
Allen is absolutely in tier 1. Every bit as good as PM. Except Allen’s ceiling is higher!
One of the worst takes I’ve seen in a long while
Dude it's so annoying how everyone pretends Mahomes does everything himself without "receivers" as if he doest have the GOAT Offensive coach and GOAT receiving TE and a consistently top 5 O-line his entire career. I promise you Joe Burrow would trade Higgins and Boyd for a good O-line, forget about Kelce AND Reid on top of that
The fact that Mahomes had the year he had last season with the most mediocre receiving corps of any playoff team is astounding. Yes i know he had Kelce, but he’s a 34 year old tight end. He doesn’t have the same effect on defenses the way Jamar Chase or Stefon Diggs does. After Kelce all Mahomes had was Juju and MVS who were cast offs from other teams, Skyy Moore a rookie who kept making mistakes and a 7th round rookie runningback. To lead the league in TD’s and yards without an actual number 1 receiver is really impressive.
for the record the giants recieving core was way worse than the chiefs (Wr 1 came off a different teams practice squad mid season)
Yea and? Of course Mahommes is great. Think everyone agrees with that
Pure delusion, 2nd best oline best te in league 2 number 1 wr’s the second best recieving rb with above average rb , mahomes prolly had the second best offensive unit if not best in whole league in fact mahomes worst offense his whole career was more talented than allens best unit his whole career.
Greatest receiving TE of all time... he doesnt have the same effect on defenses like Diggs or Chase? Are you crazy? OC is Andy Reid with a top 3 O-line in the league. Not Mahomes' fault, but lets not act like he has no help.
Mahomes is the best QB in the league, and he excelled last year without that game breaker WR, but he still relies on the support of a great OL and a dude named Chris Jones. I mention the latter because if something goes haywire with him, you will find out how hard it is to win games when you can't stop the run. Not that Jones is only good at that. Outside of Patrick he may be your team MVP. I'm a big believer in giving the QB what he needs to succeed, but sometimes we undervalue his most valued OL and run stoppers. If you can't stop the run, Mahomes will be pacing the sideline a lot more than you want.
Geno was top 5 in most qb categories last year. Definitely not a good list when it comes to tier 2
How is Herbert in tier 1 when this dude can never finish!
Exactly I don't get it either, he's done nothing but wet the bed when it matters most.
I didnt know Herbert plays defense too, 🤦🏼♂️🤦🏼♂️
@@jdizzlle6197 I didn't know Herbert didn't realize there's 4 quarters to football.
@@AB-sm4sf He has the most and had the most last year
Justin herbert doesn't have a "but" .... but jalen has.
Literally jalen hurts is the most under valued QB right now.
Ma man had one of the best Superbowl perfomances ever and still gets put on tier 2. While herbert is a 500 QB and gets put on tier 1, you really can't make this stuff up
@@AB-sm4sf I can give you that "but" argument, but justin herbert being tier 1 doesn't make any sense in my mind when he is a 500 QB
@@AB-sm4sf I didn't say that
I said that I can agree with you on your "but" point
But for me herbert is not tier 1 is JH is tier 2
he's like a legend
To his point about mahomes not having any help like the other “legacy “ QBs Mahomes has Andy Reid. Everyone needs help, you don’t do it ALL on your OWN. If he’s in Jacksonville or Houston he’s still gonna be great and have incredible stats but he doesn’t have any rings. Brett and Andy Reid help a lot.
And the best TE in NFL history.
@@NewYorkRaven gronk isnt on the chiefs
In Jacksonville, Peterson would likely go deep in the playoffs every year with mahomes. He did learn from reid….
Bro, Andy Reid was Fired from his previous team for having time management issues and an inability to win the big game. After that he was either talked about as not able to live up to his potential or continuously derided for being "one and done" in the playoffs (he had 1 playoff win for the Chiefs before the qb wearing 15 came into the picture). His career was on a mediocre if not downward trajectory before Mahomes.
@@alaskau9175 Andy has always been one of the best offensive minds in football. He got to 3 or 4 nfc championships with Philly and a super bowl and lost to the dynasty of the patriots. Look at his career record, he’s always been a good coach. Sure no one else was beating Bill or Tomlin consistently (maybe Harbaugh) when they had their HOF QB’s in their prime. Now it’s flipped. To sit here and presented like he’s not a good coach and mahomes isn’t lucky to have (their lucky to have each other) is ludicrous. Just like Bill and Brady, and bill wash and montana, Tomlin and Big Ben. You are a 🤡.
Josh Allen is amazing but he sometimes costs his teams games. He is not a tier 1 QB.
Flacco is elite
How is Herbert Tier 1 but never won anything substantial?
Why are people still on Herbert so hard. Yeah he's good, but he's a .500 QB, he doesn't carry his team, he folds constantly
Herd always tries to push mediocre QBs. Until Herbert wins a playoff game he is tier 2. Goff will always be tier 3 because he never delivers at critical moments of a game.
If trevor and hurts are in tier 2 because of the "buts", then you gotta pass equal judgement on your guys in tier 1.
Rodgers is great, but he's 39 and has regressed without davante.
Allen is great, but his elite playoff QB play was nonexistent last year
Herbert is great, but he still has a lot to prove and struggles in the playoffs.
Herbert's but is his team, injuries, and coach NOT HIM
Whats has herbert done besides get the better deal!
Solid top 5
Regular season stats don't mean a thing. To be a top tier QB you have to produce at crucial moments in a game. When you are 7 points down late in the 4th quarter do you make the critical throw. And you must produce in the playoffs. Rodgers is a tier one talent but should be in Tier 2 because he chokes at critical moments and in the playoffs. Herbert is tier 2. Hurts is tier 1 because he produced all season and in the SB.
How is Justin Herbert tier one??
Have you ever watched him play😂
Yes, and I watched him lose big games. I thought winning was apart of the metric.
Right. Guy hasn’t even won a division.
Herbert & Dak are the same qb's! Decent; but can't win the big 1! Josh Allen is great; but, once again, a turnover machine! All 3 qb's are going to have trouble winning a SB! Cousins is close to the same! Great season QB; but, can't get deep in the playoffs! 🤞🤏🤔
@@tommychapo7252 I agree with that.
I like how they say lamar jackson gets hurt all the time but nothing about joe burrow 😂
and how tf can you put herbert in the same tier as mahomes…
tier 1 is mahomes and maybe rodgers(but hes getting older)
tier 2 is burrow, lamar, allen, maybe hurts (only said maybe bc it was one year but he did make it to the superbowl)
and the rest on this list are tier 3.. idgaf if you can throw really well.. none of the others have done a dam thing.. like seriously man. it’s too much disrespect going on for the qbs that have actually done something
Disagree with your opinion
@@joeyb.205 ok.. whats your opinion
Can we get Arod a jets logo?
Why do we pretend like tier one is that large. Tier one is Mahomes and maybe burrow, but how people can pretend like Herbert, and Rodgers are in the same tier as the best player we’ve ever seen at the position is beyond me. Mahomes is in the same tier as people Herbert , who wasn’t very good last year, and has never won anything, and Rodgers who tremendously regressed from the years before. Istg some people just evaluate qbs based on their arm strength
thank you
Championships have less to do with Qb than you think. It's a team sport where 52 other guys have to do their jobs, excluding coaches. You can be an elite QB without winning a ring. Nobody denies that Dan Marino was an elite QB. It is about the arm talent and the smarts for these Rankings, as no one would say Purdy is an elite QB had the 49'ers won the super bowl. Also who did Rodgers have at pass catcher last year? No one great or elite like Burrow, Mahomes, Allen, or Herbert. Keep in mind when Rodgers had Adams, he won multiple MVPs and was a touchdown away from a super bowl the year Tampa won.
Would you actually put Herbert and Rodgers in the same tier as Dak, Trevor, Cousins, Watson, and Stafford? I wouldn't. And I would certainly put them above Lamar and Hurts.
@@theechoproject899 the issue is that people assume Mahomes has this god-like supporting cast and that just isn’t true. Let’s start from the receiving core: So yea obviously Travis Kelce is the best TE in the NFL, but Mahomes WRs as they stand are probably the worst in the nfl. So while Kelce is great his overall pass catcher room is far from being elite. Second, while his interior O-line is great, he had easily the worst tackle duo in football, which led to him dealing with an insane amount of pressures, but since he evaded more sacks than Herbert, Rodgers, and Burrow people assume his Line is great. And lastly, his defense has just never been that great, which is unfortunate bc the early 2010s chiefs defenses were amazing. I didn’t even mention that Mahomes has never had an elite run game(thanks for passing on Johnathan Taylor Veach) So how does a team like the eagles lose to a team with an overall weaker receiving core, offensive line, and weaker defense lose a qb on one leg. The answer is simple, because the true greats win superbowls. So I’d like to stop pretending that all the other “tier one” qbs are in much more adverse circumstances bc that’s not actually true. Just remember, there was a reason the “experts” thought the chiefs were gonna be a wildcard team this year. Also on a side note Jalen Hurts is def better than Herbert and probably Rodgers
@@konradbecker3670 facts on the hurts line at the end😌
Mahoney arguably isn’t the best player we’ve seen at the position, and he certainly hasn’t done enough to be called the greatest.
Tier 1 can “ put the team on their back in pure passing situations “ Lawrence literally did that go beat Herbert
even after throwing 4 turnovers in the 1st half lol.
Switch Lamar and herb the list is perfect
Herbert needs to be in tier 2. Love his arm, but can he win
Hurts played better than hurbert.
Did the Editor of colin forget about aaron in the first slide or what that from last year
Rogers listed as a packer on the first graphic lol
How does Justin Herbert not have a “but” after losing a playoff game up 27 points
THANK YOU!!!
@@AB-sm4sf but they didn’t and he only scored 3 points in the 2nd half
@@AB-sm4sf Conversely when your defense forces the other QB to throw 4 interceptions and you’re up 27 points well if you’re an elite QB I’d expect you not to lose that lead no matter bad your defense plays in the second half.
@@AB-sm4sf
Mahomes also became the first QB THIS CENTURY to win MVP, the SB & SBMVP in the same season.
Mahomes broke Drew Brees' record for Most Total Offensive Yards in a Single Season with 5,608 including 6 Receiving Yards he passed to HIMSELF.
2022 ESPY Award for Best NFL Player
2022 ESPY Award for Best Male Athlete
2022 ESPY Award for Best Team
Number 1 Netflix Docu-series
11-3 Post Season
4,084 Passing Yards
35 Passing TD'S
7 INT'S
Oh & he has even better Regular Season stats, FYI.
@@rellfacts279 exactly idk why he gets a pass when he’s supposedly an “elite” Qb
The lunacy of Herbert, Rodgers and Allen being teir 1 over Hurts. Herbert has 0 playoff victories and is teir 1? Rodgers had 1 great playoff run 30 years ago and hes teir 1? Josh Allen is shoved down our throats as the next goat every year and hes done nothing.
Dak at 9 is a disgrace in front of goff and Daniel Jones we all know dak belongs in tier 3
Hurts in Tier 2 is wilddd
“This is not only about talent”
“Team on your back in the greatest moment”
*Puts Herbert in tier 1 *
Thats jokes
Not even a funny joke
Hurts is in tier 1. Herbert shouldn’t be, his “but” is he hasn’t won at all in post season.
The excuses roll out for Herbert bro
Remember Colin predicting Derek Carr beeing a Hall of famer just a year agp
what has herbert done in the nfl so far?
Goff’s biggest issue is his deep ball.
Geno behind Stafford, Watson and Cousins is the biggest disrespect. Two of them didn’t even play most of last year AND Geno took us to the playoffs when NOBODY thought we would be relevant.
Geno is 10-11 as the Seahawks’ starter. He went 9-8 in an injury-depleted year for the NFCw, and lost to the 49ers three times.
He didn’t light it up like Seahawks fans think he did, and the Seahawks were a 4-13 team last year at best.
Their record said 9-8, but they weren’t a 9-8 team.
The Goff disrespect is unreal.
Dak and Kirk Cousins are tier three QBs.
Were you comparing Allen to Allen? I’m confused? Or did you mean to compare Allen to burrow and maholmes?
Mahomes is in a tier of his own. Herbert may have a lot of talent, but he doesn't belong in tier 1 until he actually wins something... Like a playoff game where they get out to a big lead.
Stats dont Lie. Herb played through injury, and took his team to the playoffs. His defense lost that game. But go ahead and keep talking like a casual.
Aaron rodgers over jalen hurts is crazy
?? Huh, why? Jalen Hurts is better than a back to back MVP the past 3 years??
Fine with rodgers but how’s Herbert ever ranked over Lamar I don’t get
Rodgers still listed in GB ??????????????
Love the snide comment about DJ. He could have left it alone. He could have just been interview over but according to the experts DJ & Goff aren’t that far apart. He can’t even give him credit for that.
because he, like many people, including so called experts do not take into account(enough) how rotten the ol and receivers have been for jones during his four years in the league. goff has had cooper kupp and amon ra st. brown to throw to, jones has never had anyone even close to receivers like that. i'd love to see goff play behind a bottom 5 pass blocking line like jones has
If Tier 2 has "buts", then Herbert absolutely should be in Tier 2.
How do u have Justin in the Tier #1 group of QB's when he never got out the 1st round playoffs.
I think Mahomes is Tier 1 and Burrow, Allen and Hurts and in Tier 2.
Herbert should be Tier 2 and Hurts should be tier 1
To have Herbert in tier 1 and Hurts and Jackson in tiers 2 is absurd. Unlike Herbert, those guys have won playoff games…everybody is judging Herbert on what he COULD be instead of what he IS…
100% SPEAKING FACTS! Sports media bozos don't know any more than you and I do, they just have researchers doing all their homework 24/7. If this was MY job, I would come with opinions that had some bases and based on facts.
Did you watch the video? This is a player evaluation and not a team evaluation. The team had the 28th best defense for the past 2 years but went 19W-15L with Herbert as QB. All other teams with defense that bad were around 50W and 90+ Ls.
Wins and Losses are a team stat. For some strange reason they get tied to the QB. They should be tied to the team and to the coach.
If you are a football fan then you know there are games when your QB was on fire and lost because the defense didn't come through or a RB fumbles at a bad time or a kicker misses an easy FG.
The Chargers have been Kings of losing games in the strangest ways and a lot of those come without Herbert's involvement.
I wouldn't put him ahead of Hurts but he is definitely one of the best 6 QBs in the league.
I think 1 and 2 are set and 3-6 can go in any order.
acting like Hurts didnt go against a terrible giants team and a qb less niners lmao. Hurts needs to prove it a second year to get any respect imo. AFC is way tougher than NFC lol
Dude complained and didn’t watch the video or didn’t pay attention.
@@semi6544 and sometimes they are his fault. Like when he couldn’t complete a pass in a playoff game to avoid losing a 27 point lead. Is that the defense’s fault? Sure. But great ones overcome. I like Herbert. I think he’s going to be a great QB. But Tier one is for guys with no holes in their games. His hole is that he sometimes doesn’t have it in prime time. Regardless of schedule, Hurts proved in the superbowl that the lights are never too bright for him. He made plays when he had to. Herbert, while somehow having an defense wit defensive stars all over it, often doesn’t. I’m not saying he’s not a top six QB. Honestly, I’d take Rodgers out and put him in Tier 2.
Inb4 lawreence has a better year than herbert, allen and possibly burrow as well.
Mahomes 🎉🎉🎉
What herbt has done to be in tier one
Mahomes will go down as the most physically gifted qbs. We will see if he gets the championships to become the best
Brady wasn’t the best QB talent, but he’s arguably the greatest QB because of his achievements.
Championships and other accomplishments measure greatness, talent tells us who is best. So you have it backwards to a degree.
Think about the inputs:
Best: talent/ability and skills
Greatness: Talent/ability and skills used to produce outstanding performances, win titles, set records, and achieve personal and/or team accolades.
Greatness is partially an output of talent and skills.
Mahomes has talent and skills, but we will have to wait on calling him the GOAT, because he isn’t even close right now, especially after the stain that is SB55 on his resume.
He has to own that. He was pure dogsh!t that night, and a respectable QB would have at least tried to RUN a TD.
He didn’t play well for most of SB54, either.
The great ones are always at their best when the lights are the absolute brightest. Mahomes is like this 👋🏾 for me. Idc what anyone says.
His game is pretty, but he isn’t carrying anything or anyone.
I need to add that the Chiefs should have lost SB57 and would have if not for Jalen Hurts’s fumble. The Chiefs shouldn’t have been playing in that SB anyway.
The fix was in. The NFL has made Mahomes the face of the league, and that’s the reason he will always get the favorable calls, be given excuses in the media, have his fake injuries promoted, and get the benefit of the doubt when he isn’t good.
They have DECIDED that Mahomes will always be front and center until it can’t be justified, and it p!sses me off because Russ got stepped over in the equation. He was supposed to be that dude. Russ, Luck, RG3, Cam, and (believe it or not) Kaepernick were the Mahomes-Burrow-Allen-Herbert-Jackson of the previous group.
Watson should be right up there with Mahomes too but ruined himself and his career because he couldn’t control his urges, but I digress…
The NFL is rigged! For example, the no-call in the 2018-19 NFC Championship game that deprived Sean Payton of an opportunity to play in that year’s SB was no accident, and neither was the lousy officiating in the 2022-23 AFC Championship.
Roger Goodell and the other commissioners are like PT Barnum: they’ll always put on the best SHOW, even if it requires them to do underhanded sh!t like rig games.
They’re robber barons.
@DeCurtaRican I know Brady isn't the most physically gifted, arguably that's Rodgers or Elway or old school with Otto Graham. Lamar being arguably a rich man's mike vick but not winning in the playoffs ruins his case as the most physically gifted. For a long time people have said Rodgers is the best but if you can't do it when there's the most pressure to perform you can't be the best that's why Peyton and Rodgers have a hard argument to make in my opinion.
@DeCurtaRican sorry why shouldn't they have been in the super bowl? Bengals blew the that game they should have been in the super bowl
Sure if Asante Samuel caught the interception in the 4th quarter the pats wouldn't have lost thar obe or if they called holding on the oline or in the grasp on the tyree catch the pats would have won
@@DeCurtaRican Don't forget the Pats vs Chiefs champ game on 4th down when Brady was handed a free set of downs instead of game over for a "roughing the passer call" that clearly showed Chris Jones hand just barley brushed Brady's shoulder and ended up costing the Chiefs going to the SB. Brady has at least 3 or 4 SB rings that he shouldn't have even been to the SB. Jalen Hurt's did fumble and the Eagles got a lucky break on that other turnover for 6 that was called incomplete when at least 50% of the time that was a fumble too. Can play the what-if game all day and try to blame refs every time but players will tell you the game is a lot more than 1 or 2 missed or bad calls that fans will always cry about.
Allen and Mahomes are in their own leagues and there has never been a point where they weren’t.
Nah Allen is literally not in his own league. He leads the league in turnovers over the last 3 years 😂
YET, HE'S ALWAYS SPOKEN AS IF HERBERT HAS WON SOMETHING🤡💩
Ask sarkisian if he’s gonna yell at anymore random tv employees!
Having Josh Allen and Justin Herbert over Jalen is wild.
Goff is super underrated. As is Daniel Jones
Jones n Goff aren't. They are just guys bud
12 QBs. 9 in AFC.
Herbert in tier 1 🤨
Pure Passing Situations...this is the phrase that the vast majority of fans and even some front office folks don't understand. People want to turn the pocket passing discussion into one about race, offensive philosophy, and trends when in actuality it is just a pure objective scientific fact. With finite space and time on the field the most efficient delivery of the ball is going to be in the pocket and on time. This separates the flashes from the consistently good and the consistently good from the greats. This is what makes an offense almost impossible to defend. This is why certain QBs who get so much hype never last, because people overlook the most important ability and just focus on stats.
Josh Allen and Aaron Rodgers are not tier 1 QBs, and Cousins and Prescott aren't tier 2......
Rodgers still plays for GB? FS1 slacks it man.
TLaw will be tier one next year
Herbert 27-0 PLAYOFF GAME YEP TOP 5/😂
Mahomes is 1 Burrow is 2 rank everyone else however you want
Lamar Jackson hold the Baltimore Ravens down y'all will put some respect my QB one day
He gave a reason why. He said tier 1 QBs are able to put the team on their back throwing the ball down the field.
@@ncpdew4599 whatever child please stay NFL racist
@@ncpdew4599 Lamar Jackson been passing the ball Louisville
@@larrymoore6855 I agree with you, was just restating what he said
Dude can't stay healthy.
Jalen Hurts was a MVP candidate last year and he's in tier 2?
Why is Herbert in tier 1? Seriously?
Tier 1 is just one person. Mahomes.
Herbert and Hurts should change position... Hurts has done way more than Herbert in playoffs.
Lamar has had the worst wr core out of all the franchise guys
But u will never hear them make any excuses for him like they do for Herby and others
I'd put Hurts in Tier 1 and boot Herbert and Rodgers out of Tier 1.
how is Justin Herbert a tier 1 Quarterback???? he never made it to the postseason. Colin rationality is just flawed or wrong. I would have argued for Lamar Jackson or Matthew Stafford than Herbert
right? he said it at the beginning. a tier 2 qb is basically a tier 1 qb that comes with a but. we love everything about justin herbert, BUT he hasn't wona playoff game.
Jalen Hurts who outplayed mahomes in the Superbowl is behind a 40 year old Aaron Rodgers.
How did Hurts outplay Mahomes?!? That 6 pick Hurts threw?