Are the Europeans 1 Race? The Genetic Evidence
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 авг 2019
- What are the origins of the Europeans and do they really belong to a single "race"? Today we'll be looking at the genetic evidence behind the evolution of the indigenous people of Europe and how they've become the modern nations and phenotypes we see today.
Many of the reasons for the diverse phenotypes, genetics, languages and cultures of the modern European continent will be explored today, even stretching back thousands of years. Additionally, we'll be going over a brief overview of the European diaspora worldwide and how this has affected the definitions of the White or European race. Thanks for watching!
Masamap: / map_of_european_descen...
Sources:
www.researchgate.net/figure/P...
www.quantamagazine.org/how-ne...
anthromadness.blogspot.com/201...
dienekes.blogspot.com/2010/10/...
indo-european.eu/tag/neandert...
www.eupedia.com/europe/Haplog...
www.eupedia.com/genetics/yamn...
How European people divide Europa:
people who drink beer (central, north, British Isles)
people who drink wine (south, south west)
People who drink wodka/rakija (east)
@Steven PINEL don't take it too seriously, it's a joke :D
I'm from Austria and we drink all three of these things in similar quantities haha
If so, then division would be a bit different:
1. Southwest Europe - people who drink wine, as grape grows well within their lands;
2. Central Europe - people who drink beer, for hops are plentiful in their lands;
3. Northern Europe - people who drink strong spirits, for it is the most effective way of getting drunk;
and 4. Eastern Europe - people who drink whatever they have, be it vodka, beer, wine, rakija, rum, tequila, pure ethanol... For 'When you're drunk, you don't look around much, and it's easier to live this way - when no other way can be seen' ("Спьяну жизнь херово видно - даже легче жить"™ - Сектор Газа).
HiatoPS hahahha im albanian and we drink rakija too but we are from the south
The only division assertion that matters 😂
if you think about baltic and balkan you are right about wodka and rakija. But this is not whole east.
American locig: Spain isnt Caucasian, but Portugal and Italy is.
*Yeah it's big brain time*
(sarcasm warning) if Spain was white, it would imply that Latinos are partially white which would lower their status among colored people... you cant call latinos white, that is racist!... somehow.
edit: lol RUclips if full of really stupid people not getting sarcasm and irony
@@lamebubblesflysohigh The american classification is embarrasingly wrong..How can you say Spain is not white,what are you talking about, you are out of touch of reality...The Latinos you are talking about obviously have native american dna..But they propably have a percentage of white european dna, propably from the spanish colonization..
@@lamebubblesflysohigh hispanic can be totally white and mixed race and black but alot are white mediteranian
@@robertcuevas3602 I am not arguing about that, that's a different subject. We are saying that Spanish people are in the white/caucasian race..
@@zlinos139 but you say that us latino we're just native but i know spaniard are mediterranian
Wow. I’m impressed by how comprehensive this information is. Great job.
Portuguese family here, white as snow...
How's the sunburn doing?
Lol
i was just in Portugal and you see plain as day white Portuguese all the time. they look like a random White person you'd see in the U.S, but they're 100% Portuguese. blond hair, blue eyes, fair skin. the whole thing. so cool
@@bconni2
You were in Europe,what did you expect?
@@juannaym8488 los Europeos mediterráneos no se queman si no que broncean como los antiguos Griegos y Romanos
How to confuse americans: show them tanned Europeans
or white Mexicans
or non-tanned people from near east
It's not the first time I see Americans on quora asking if southern Europeans are considered white people... It's seems that lately white means blond with blue eyes.
@@bellycurious what does white mean in your opinion?
@@bayodebadu5834, a fair enough skin, I think. Not black or Asian. People found in Europe.
"Spain isnt white"
*laughs in pale skinned red headed aragonese genes*
Spain is white, they're Indo-European.
@Lynda Anthony Can you define “race obsession”? Who says Spaniards are Mexican? Compare a picture of a typical Spaniard and a typical Mexican and they look very different. Spaniards are 100% European and Mexicans are not, simple.
@@theoptimisticpessimist9335 this is the typical American college liberal WASP/Jew view towards me when they see me shill for white issues but learn my last name is Obregon
Lynda Anthony shut the fuck up
@Lynda Anthony “Not to a real white person” What does that even mean? According to who, and what is a “real white person”? You’re being vague and you’re not defining anything. A definition I accept is, a white person is a person with a certain percentage (I would say more than 75%) of dna of the historically native population of the European regions
If you consider that rape was one of most common spoils of war and Europe history of almost constant warfare my bet is that genetically we are all similar
In the preview, the “Russian” clearly has a non-Russian appearance. This is more likely some kind of Caucasian, in the sense of a resident of the Caucasus region: Chechen or Georgian, etc.
I noticed that often in Western films, etc., Russians are portrayed as black-haired, with hooked noses, etc., but this is not a typical appearance for Russians.
Russia is not a white country. They colonized way too much foreign land to claim any sense of whiteness.
@@teoleno4019russia is a white country. By your logic, the UK is not a white country because of their expansion and colonisation into foreign land?
Could you name a film in which Russians are depicted in that manner? I think most people know that Russians are mostly Slavs, and Slavs have a typical “white” appearance.
@@Alborzhakimi7010 recently, for example, I watched the TV series Expansion, and there the character Pyotr Korshunov has such a southern appearance. In the game Mass Effect, general Oleg Petrovsky. In the game Dishonored, Anton Sokolov. The first examples that came to mind.
Indeed, in some American films, Russians look like Arabs or Semites. For example, my favorite actor Omar Sharif plays in the movie "Doctor Zhivago". But he is an Arab by origin, and does not look like a Russian at all. It is true that in Hollywood films Russians were often portrayed by Russian-speaking Jews who left the USSR in the 70s of the 20th century. But Americans did not make a difference between those who speak Russian and Russians by nationality. Therefore, the immigrant Jews who portrayed Russians in Hollywood films looked very comical. Especially when they wore "Russian national shirts-kosovorotki" and hats with earflaps.
So according to the US, Sudanese are white and spaniards no... haha
This is Propaganda. Look at DNA studies that have already been published and you will see that Cro Magnon Man =Modern man, is geneticly isolated from all other types hominids on the planet that live today. European, Caucasian, White man, is geneticly different and has different ancestors from the other hominids on the planet. More recent genetic studies have shown ALL ancient Pharoahs in Egypt were of Caucasian ancestry, not black African.. Neanderthals NEVER..... Let me repeat that, Neanderthals NEVER mixed geneticly with Black African people or the Black Race. Never. That's why black people have ZERO percent Neanderthal DNA admixture.! 0%. OK. So, understand what that means...? Are you following me here? We are not all the same, we are all Sub Species of human! We have different sub species of Cats, Dogs, etc.... So it's very clear that we are not in any way different, in that aspect, from other living creatures here on earth with us. Our physical traits are determined by the DNA we get from our parents. The way we develop physically mentally and emotionally is determined by our DNA and the environment one grows up in. That includes the physical environment, the family environment, and upbringing of that individual interacting with the DNA to produce the outcome. This is called your genotype and your phenotype. So if you're still following me you can now understand why the physical traits may appear different but the underlying genetics are the same. It doesn't mean that the people of the caucus mountains today are the same people of the caucus mountains thousands of years ago. What you need to understand is the physical environment being so much different it will change the physical appearance of the individual as well. Certain physical traits will develop in place of others because the environment dictates and the genetics will alter themselves to survive in that environment the best they can. It is very simple. If a population of people are in the Sun a lot more, generation after generation after generation, the physical characteristics will change according to that environment. Just like if somebody lives in a very cold environment, they're always indoors, their body doesn't absorb direct sunlight because they are always covered up, they will in turn develop different physical characteristics and their genetics will adapt to help ensure survival. That's how it works. These are changes that take a long time to change the entire population but every one of us grows up and our genotype is interacting with our phenotype. If you took the time to read this I appreciate that and I hope you can do some more research for yourself and follow the truth. Everybody has unique characteristics and they can be celebrated and they can be loved. everybody needs to accept our differences, embrace our differences, and live with knowledge of truth, that's the only way that we can come together. Acting like everybody is the same and we should all think the same and act the same as just not logical and it's not reality. Thank you. I hope you are all Blessed. All Sub Species of people.
56% is a bit generous lmao
Hernan Marcos my mom had Celtic blood an has roots in northern Spain an she looks really white
Hernan Marcos Sudanese are black as they come lol
@@Allworldsk1 all pharoahs in ancient Egypt were not Caucasian and have nothing to do with Europeans. Ancient Egyptians were black African peoples much like Ethiopians or the Sudanese. European people come from modern humans that left Africa and mated with Neanderthals. The Egyptians share religious, linguistic, and a cultural history with the rest of Africa and not the middle East or Europe. In fact many aspects of their culture originate in other parts of Africa outside of Egypt.
I am Spanish. My daughter went to USA a couple of years ago and had to state her "race" in one form. She was absolutely puzzled by the question as she had never wondered which race she belongs to.
Your daughter is a White European. Don’t let anyone call her Hispanic. That term is essentially racist and it has no basis in fact; it’s a political term.
@@user-nv8pq7zr8q term Hispanic comes from the latin, from Hispania, which changed into España which means spain, so i guess that the term hispanic means someone with origins from spain
@@iZuqee Nice try. I have no idea how old you are, but if you’re over 65 you might wonder why the word was never used by your grandparents or even your parents. It’s essentially a made up term from the Nixon administration used to further divide people. In other words, it’s origin is essentially racist in that context.
@@user-nv8pq7zr8q definition of Hispanic: someone from Spain or Spanish-speaking countries, especially those countries in Latin America ... so ovbiosuly the term hispanic comes from Spain
calling someone hispanic or black isnt racist, cause its what you are, thinking that for being from that race hes gonna steal, or be poor , etc... is racist
Wow! Fascinating. And densely packed with data. I will have to watch this all over again and maybe another time after that. Well done!
Great video, thanks for sharing your detailed research.
It's slightly worrying how so many Americans are obsessed with races.
Yes, at the same time they don't study them at all.
So many of them have never traveled.There has also been a lot of political propaganda and their schools teach nothing of liberal arts and international studies nor any European History or geography...☹
@@emerdigiorgio3594 Its because they enslaved the descendants of the Olmecs who came over from Khemet (Egypt) and don’t want anyone to know about it.
@@marcusholbert2525 WHO enlaved.....?
It's also quite wrong to claim that "Caucasian" is synonymous with "European". The Aryans originally came from Asia, as even "Masaman" grudgingly admits, but he's somewhat inaccurate with his geography regarding the origin point. He asks if the Aryans could actually be referred to as "Europeans" even after admitting they are not originally from Europe. That Eurocentric bias is apparently difficult to let go of.
I guess it is good that we like to insult each other based on nationality in Europe rather than race xD It makes more sense
Yes, the US racial classification makes no sense
We are genetically closest to kurds and persians too
Right! 👍🤣🤣🤣
the privilege of not being a mutt
Imagine being french lmao
5:40 Is there any source that I can check? None of the sources that I've checked says Tatars and Chuvashs had spoken a Indo-European language.
Can you do a video on Celtic Nordic Germanic and ethnic groups of Europe , ?
"And I think it's a shame that race and ancestry became such a loaded and sensetive subject"
Amen to that
@Viktor NonHoUnCognome Your definition of progress is looking back?
@@Unlyricallyrics Not all changes are for the better.
It’s high time to do away with that; we are all different looking humans, only, ones behaviors determine his value to the human race. The rest is of value to doctors who are trying to find cures for genetic disorders. Period.
It's a loaded topic because everyone wants to be either "White" or some specific subgroup thereof; Spaniards want so badly to be "celtic" or in rare cases Germanic, when they are genetically basically arabs.
Most Spaniards and Portuguese people are a mix of Celts, Greeks, Romans, Visigoths, Suebis, Vandals, Alans, North Africans, Jews, Gypsies and believe it or not... Vikings, who
Invaded the Iberian southern region in the 11 century and fail at conquering it and got stranded, ending up there and mixing with the Arabic and north Africans that were living there during the age of the Muslim kingdoms of Andalusia in the midle ages. All those groups came to the Iberian peninsula in a period of some 4000 thousands years at different times by military Invasions and wars, and end up settling there, mixing with the whatever group was there before... That is why Spain and Portugal are so rich in culture, language and art, and why you have so many good-looking people in those countries. The languages that are spoken in the Iberian Peninsula so the modern Castilian that is spoken in Latin America today are mostly a mix of different languages from all those groups' trough out the centuries, specially Roman Latin, Goth and Arabic (with the exception of the Basque language that to these days no one know where it comes from but some scholars have found Sumerian words in it. In modern Latin America today, many Spaniards and Portuguese ended up mixing with the natives population and in some regions like Puerto Rico, Dominican Republic, Cuba, Colombia, Venezuela etc... with Black slaves...that's why we have today so many Mexicans, Latin and Central American people with native American facial and skin features in them, so African features and dark or reddish skin color tones as well... And the reason why so many White and Black US citizens who have mostly, a poor public education about the world so their own history as a nation, get so confuse trying to identify what race the Latin American people are when interacting with them, so why they get so confuse when encountering a Latin American, Spaniard or a Portuguese person that look like a German or an Irish looking European to them but speak Spanish or Portuguese .... that by the way, they are white...Knowledge is power. Thanks for sharing.
I guess if you speak spanish you turn magically into mexican.
si senor
And Mexicans can be white, too, as you know - but I got your point and I agree, it's idiotic lol
😂😂😂😂😂
White Hispanic actually
It's the dark complexion, wide flat noses, dark eyes, etc. that alarms certain White US folks.
Probably makes them wonder if their Greek/Italian pals & in laws are really Mexicans.
i live in south africa, my ancestry go back to Dutch, German, French and English people in my family ancestry, i regard myself as a south african and do not wish to return to Europe, i do find this video very interesting!
Take care man
@@JimmyJapanYes and so is much of Europe and the USA, i see it as a good thing, Western world always were against apartheid south africa, now they must live with all the blacks and muslims in there own countries, lol they can paint themselves black too for all i care, kiss them too ha ha ha ha ha ha
@@JimmyJapan No i am not running away, this stil the best place to live in. you must come visit, You wont want to leave!
Sorry for doings you grandfather's
@theovanstaden5766
People don't like the word "race," but they shut their mouths about the word "phenotype." It's curious.
“Phenotype” is backed my science and “race” is based theory and surface level feature like skin pigment & skull shapes.
I love how the United States considers Sudan to be white but not Spain
Nobody thinks that. There's just some confusion among census takers about what constitutes North Africa.
Dudu..how awesome the American that told you this lied to you.
@Crim Sin What?
@@LigaFantasma It was a joke, dude
And Central Asia but not South Asia.
South Asians looks much more close to European Mediterranids than Central Asians do.
Americans: im half white, half italian
Rest of the world: you're white 🤦♀️🤦♀️
E C southern Italians are mixed with North African and middle eastern.
@@user-mm2tk1jg5j I'm mostly Southern Italian and my DNA came up Italian 40%, Greek 12%, Sardinian 3%, and Malta 1% from that region.
Bruce Brewer i did it to 🤣im 50% albania 40% italian and 10% greek
ASAP world I am a southern Italian and I am DEFINITELY white, like wtf 😂 As well as the great majority of the southern (and northern as well) Italians... we might not be as pale as some Northern European people but we ARE white.
Oh my god, I wonder if you guys ever even saw an Italian...
ASAP world i have seen so called white Americans darker then southern Italians
According to my genetics I am 100% British Isles, since the time of the hunter gatherer, apart from 10% Swedish. I have zero Arabic, Indian or Asian. My whole family is exactly the same. My mother's and father's genetic coding has been in Northern European from the beginning.
Wow, that's awesome. I hope you make sure to keep it that way.
don't mix with southern Europeans, they are not Europeans.
@@Zeptus1488💀🤡
My understanding, the first, people who lived in Britain, they had Black skin😅 Does that mean you Black? No mixed - The first people, the Dravidians Albino children, moved to the island first😂😂..
yikes
Thank you Masaman for this thorough and well explained content on this topic. Your channel is a huge contribution to society. You are a great educator.
My race is mostly “white” (around 75%), and I look like it. In every job in the US I felt confused on what race I should select, and I realized it is more political than racial. The “white” option included “(non hispanic)”. I speak Spanish, therefore I cannot check on the white box. I am latina, and I know latinos that are 100% caucasian, but in the eyes of the US, they are not.
hahah... so obvious that you are American...latinos are not 100% caucasian!
Whole world: Spain is causasian
America: Spain is not causasian
@Iwwy Iw do u want to be conquered again?
@@sergiosanvicente817 I don’t think you can conquer much with Europe being taken over by others now
You:causasian
Whole world:caucasian
For USA Spain is not caucasian because the spaniards speak spanish.
@Iwwy Iw Pues claro que somos caucásicos, lo que quiero decir es que, según la lógica yanqui, si hablas español, no puedes ser caucásico. Y ya me explicarás que significa eso de "regardless", porque no me ha sonado bonito.
US census : SpAiN IsN'T WhItE, SuDaN iS.
Incredible how the US became dumb!
complain, Refers to Sudan Arabs. Not blacks.
US census: turns out all white people originated in Texas
ahahaha really. damn...
@@brazuka1371 Tv... Or Should we call it: "Brain Washing Machine" ?
Great video. I’d like to see more about Cro Magnon influence in European genetics.
Watch the video "Which country has the most blondies?"
The answer is Finland. Percentually Finland has got most blue eyes, blond hair and white complexion in the world.
Also finns are tall.
They are truly a beautiful variant of the European people.
Elvish freaks!
Not very tall..
@@niklassvensson860 Watch the statistics. The average height is the same as Norway,
Finland, Germany etc.
@@niklassvensson860the average Finnish man is 5’11. That is definitely tall considering the global male average of 5’8.
European diversity is also very interesting to me. Considering their diversity in hair colors and eye colors, same how Africans and Asians have different hair types, eye shapes and skin tones. Man Humans are interesting
It's very rare to see an African American person (if you are American) admire European diversity. Most of them say adversive shit about them due to their contempt.
@@dennisrheinhard5175 No. Its just jealousy.
@@corneliusdelasoto3955 ok
Dennis Rheinhard ha ha. I’m mature and self confident enough to admit you are right. But I will say that afr am do enjoy the culture of individual countries .. it’s just when you say “Europeans, caucasians or whites” we see red loo
@@Dcain2 I'm mostly Puerto Rican. Rheinhard is my mother's maiden name. My father's last name is Rivera. However, my mother is half African American and White.
I hate the assumption that diversity=non-european. Europeans are extremely diverse, even within European countries. Heck even within a family of European descent, you can have huge variations in eye and hair color, more variation than seen in the native populations of most CONTINENTS. We have all the diversity we need.
yes. My nation Finland for example has been found to be a diverse mix :-) Siberian, Fenno-Ugric and later Western European influx (Baltic and Germanic) . We def are more Asian than other Nordic ethnic groups and occasionally one can still see Asian features, as high cheek bones and slanted eyes... Nazis of course labeled us as 'Mongoloids', not Aryan enough.
They envy us, so they want to erase us. Mass migration is a form of warfare.
A tribe losing their territory from being flooded by foreigners is worse than any great military defeat. Because we can recover from the loss of life or resources, but we can't recover from the loss of blood.
I don't think the diversity in looks of Europeans is really the point here. People who argue with less European=more diverse literally don't understand the meaning of the word.
Example: If you have a group of three Europeans and replace one of them with an Indian and one with a Chinese person, it becomes more diverse. If you put a few Europeans in a Japanese movie it becomes more diverse. If you replace a completely European cast with 100% Bantus it's not any more diverse than before.
Phenotypically
I think whites are the most diverse
+euphoryuh The media says white genocide is a myth and conspiracy theory but in the same breath have headlines like "White Minority in 2045, Census Projects","Last Days of a White World", "New Hampshire is 94% White. How Do You Diversify an Entire State?" WHICH IS IT?
im from scandinavia and there are some who look more "asian" due to being mixed with these uralic genes, and some look more germanic. i always thought its kind of ironic when people seem to view scandinavian as the "most white"
Because if we look at ancient indian history, u will realise it is not a exaggeration and india truly was powerful and had influence on whole of europe. Please refer to videos of : Jeffrey Armstrong for more reference
@@LightLoveLaugh The claim that ancient India had a pervasive influence on the whole of Europe is not corroborated by widely accepted historical research. While there were interactions between India and Europe, they were limited in scale and often region-specific. India and Europe developed independently for much of their early histories, and any influence should be considered within specific historical contexts. Jeffrey Armstrong, mentioned in the claim, is not a widely recognized historian, so his views should be seen as perspectives rather than established historical facts. In summary, while there were exchanges, the idea of India having a widespread and continuous influence on all of Europe lacks robust historical evidence.
and which nation is the whitest if not northern Europeans?
were you talking about Sami people?
Where does a 'race' begin and where does it end? It's totally up to everyone themselve.
I'm Italian, it's crazy how in the USA, always there's this conversation about race.
Who cares.
The race, DNA, is everything; race creates civilization, not the other way around.
@Derick Willis What do you mean with ''black overlords''?
How's multiculturalism working out for Italy and the rest of Europe?
@TheAmarican hey my dearly american, what about you fkin care only about usa and not give a single shit about europe? it would be nice. europe is this shit nowadays because of usa
@C Klan the weird thing is you get racists, far right wing people, and far left people all getting worked up about race and making everything a racial issue so an SJW ends up sounding just as racist as some asshole from the KKK while most regular people are like "why should i care that some native american guy graduated college? hes just a regualr dude, not a poster child for your poltiical agenda"
"except Spain" I CHOKED ON MY SALAD
I mean the Iberian peninsula used to be inhabited by Afro-Asians before Indo-Europeans
@wisdom 777 we were conquered by the moors, so many spanish people are mixed white and north african/arab
cumoreo That's false, lol. North Africans (which is not the same as Arab) were expelled from the peninsula (múltiple times actually). So nowadays most people don't have non European blood. But it's true that some can have up to a 10%, but it's not common. That said, it's funny how everybody mention those North Africans (which again, are very different from Arabs) but no one mentions the jews, lol. Spain was also occupied by them. And same way, they were expelled the same exact year as the muslims. So most people don't have jew blood either. The majority of Spaniards are between a 95 and 100% European.
well my country even didnt count as human, probably we are transparent hahaha
@bishes be mad im spanish... i think i would know best. Its dumb to clump all white people together. Somehow indian and chinese people arent thd same but spanish and russian are? Sorry if i do not have good english.
Let’s be realistic here, it’s now become square to be White in Western culture. Now I hate how humans have divided us in to such broad racial categories myself, but it’s actually not so simple to distinguish most Europeans by their complexion & physical traits. I’ve met Nordic people that looked more like a stereotypical Mediterranean and I’ve known many Greeks or Sicilians that looked more like a stereotypical German. For example, both sides of my family are from Southern Italy, my complexion is somewhat fair, I had medium brown hair in my younger days & my eyes are blue. Now my best childhood friend is a 1st generation Czech American, and he had jet black hair, black eyes and tans very well. I’ve even met Swedes and Finns with darker complexion than myself, and I’m not exactly Albino pale. I’d love to live in a world with less racial/ethnic division, but realistically ancestral Europeans are too genetically similar to distinguish into separate racial categories; historically, it’s probably the least genetically diverse continent in the world. The vast diversity of very distinguishable groups of people in larger continents like Africa, Asia or the Americas, is why the mostly indistinguishable Europeans tend to fall under one racial category.
Europeans, Western Asians, North Africans and South Asians belong to a human group called the Western Eurasians, all of whom derive their genome from the Gravettians, from Sunghir, a group of humans who originated in the Middle East and spread to Europe ago. 30,000 years ago, the Nordics and the Arabs have sister Haplogroups I and J, they separated 30,000 years ago.
Sunghir genetic analysis ruclips.net/video/TNLOjJkdNwo/видео.htmlsi=n30XOa8hGiJkEquO
Modern Europeans arise from the mixture of three types of Western Eurasians, the Anatolians, the Western Hunter-Gatherers (ancient Europeans) and the Steppe Indo-Europeans (Yamnaya). The Anatolians had a strong genetic affinity towards the peoples of the Levant and Western Asia, and the Yamnaya had a genetic affinity towards South Asia and the Siberians.
History would tell you more about how different we see each others, to know them better, look at their past, and you shall see all of it
Census: US do you think Portugal, Italy and Greece are white?
US: Sure!! They are europeans
Census: And Spain is not European?
US: They speak spanish!!!
Census: But Spain is next to Portugal, and is in Eur...
US: OMFG They speak spanish!!!! NO WHITE
Exactly! Haha
Lmao 😂😂
Spanish from Spain are white in the Census. They also count Hispanic and Latino people as groups but they emphasize that Latino/Hispanic is not a "race" because there are many races there. I don't know why Massaman put his map the way he did.
From the Census: Hispanic origin can be viewed as the heritage, nationality, lineage, or country of birth of the person or the person’s parents or ancestors before arriving in the United States. People who identify as Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish may be any race. The 2020 Census asks about being Hispanic or Latino in addition to race. Hispanic and Latino is not one of the race categories. They as people to answer both questions: "Is Person 1 of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin?
NOTE: Please answer both Question 8 about Hispanic origin and Question 9 about race. For this census, Hispanic origins are not races. Hispanic origin can be viewed as the heritage, nationality, lineage, or country of birth of the person or the person’s parents or ancestors before arriving in the United States. People who identify as Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish may be any race."
Fr. Philip Kontos thank you for let us know that, personally I didn’t know it, i just saw the map.
Anyway for spaniards dont make sense that we are classified in the same “box” that latin american people for be Hispanic because today a Spaniard have much more in common with an Italian, a French or even a German than with any latin american person, apart of the language. So for us is a little bit annoying this classification.
@@PapaPhilip for US, latinos are "the others" Americans...
US: *says "race"*
Europe: We don't do that here
Wellshem only US does that lmfao
We may not say it, but it certainly happens.
because we have ethnic groups and the USA is more of a pan-European population, the EU has an intrest in making a more European identity and with that comes mixing with European ethnic groups.
so in a way the USA is ahead in that regard.
@@golagiswatchingyou2966 yeah sure, french black people are french. Not afro-french. Thats the big difference.
Are you willfully blind to headlines that don't suit how you wish things were or are you hungry for as much anti-american rhetoric as you can stomach? Europe, especially the UK, seems to be having a rise in such discussions, especially as your once almost entirely pasty continent becomes more and more colorful. I have heard or read numerous Europeans of non-native descent describe themselves as "Afro-French or Black British or Turkish German or British Indian," even if the native white population is too scared, politically correct or ideological to say it.The whole race conversation is an unfortunate part of being a multiracial country, especially one that has been multiracial from the start and which began in a much more unenlightened time like the US is and was. Plus, all those pasties didn't just spring up out of the ground on the North American continent, they had to come from somewhere else and bring their racial and ethnic ideas from the continent they came from... hint, that continent is west of Asia and north of Africa. I believe many if not most of the race "scientists" of the 17th to early 20th century were from Europe, especially England, France and Germany. Rudyard Kipling's "White Man's Burden" ring a bell? Or the race based slavery, social whitening, European-exclusive immigration policies and apartheid systems that ALL whites outside of Europe inherited from good ole Europa? I think your comment is confirming the stereotype of the stuffy, elitist, cosmopolitan, irrationally anti-American Eurotrash that I despair to see when I have otherwise decent conversations and debates with people from the old continent, whether indigenous or of immigrant descent. Try to wise up a bit with the rhetoric and anti-American fanaticism and be honest or do your research. Good day sir, just a bit of a clear up for any lurkers.
Race, ethnicity, nationality. We're Homo Sapien Sapiens, some of us were just changed a bit because the sun didn't come out much.
Good explanation of patterns of cultures. They were basically tribes that moved together. And if you listen to irish and Arab, it's very similar, languages totally different. Listen to early Chinese very close. Its scary. Just juxtapose the music. Not a disrespect to Irish music. Just a listener to all music.
Maybe americans think Spain in where? Next to Peru or something?
@Arpad Jones doesnt that make u a happy idiot? u didnt even check. the guy is wrong, the 2020 census has ppl from spain as white
@@robertgronewold3326 i know i know. I'm spanish but this paperwork thing that you have to fill in USA saying you are hispanic or subsaharian and stuff is sooo much weird
@@robertgronewold3326 so (i don't know if that thing with all hispanics is still on?) the "only white" were you know, white as snow anglosaxon people like WASP?, not white ethnically (if white could be seen as an ethic)
No it's near Portugal, And near France as Well, got invaded by the Moors as well. It's also called Hispania by its inhabitants, I'm American. Bye
They’re not great when it comes to geography 🤓😆
Well it's simple, in south Europe its sunny most of the year so many people get tanned. Here in greece I have seen many german tourists that are more tanned than me so the whole stereotype that greeks,Italians, Portuguese and Spaniards are not "white" is false.
Good for you! I am Italian and all my family are fair.We are proud of our ancient Greek temples and anfitheaters in Sicily.Great civilizations!
We are naturally more tanned, it’s called olive skinned. Of course there are still people paler and more tanned anywhere you go, it varies but on average Italians, we have different colour skin even in the cold.
@@johnywidgery6866 But still caucasians...
@@emerdigiorgio3594 I never said we aren’t Caucasian? Plus it’s a big generalisation. We all have our differences mentally and physically. I think the term was made by some desperate.
@@johnywidgery6866 I did not mean "you" said it.I was addressing some ignorant morons who believe that being "white" means looking like cadavers...I myself am a blond Italian,but we are all Italians!
Whats the music on the background?
Masam you are amazing. Thank you.
As a Portuguese, I laughed when the US Census defined Portugal as a "white country" but not Spain, cause like... DNA ascendency tests can't even tell us apart xD they don't define you as Portuguese/Spanish, they define it as Iberian and leave you to guess which one, which means we have a really close genetic code.
It makes even less sense that North African countries are back to being considered white when Spain wasn't, but I focused on Portugal cause we are literally that close on DNA xD Overall, I think we are all Caucasians, Spanish included xD
Edit: apparently everyone is ranting at me so let me clear this out: I didn't say portuguese weren't white. I meant that Spanish are hella white, just as much as the portuguese, and the fact that northern africa is considered white by americans when Spanish aren't is a joke. So there you have. I NEVER SAID PORTUGUESE ARE NOT WHITE.
I agree with that
@@flowershower6857 Mucho Ignoranzia!
@@flowershower6857 Sorry I do not read Portughese,but I agree with you! Too much lack of education and culture!👍
@@flowershower6857 I have always been considered white and never had special benefits! Happy New Year!🥀
@@flowershower6857 Yes,I am,but it should not matter! 💓🥀
I'm Serbian ..Slavic, white as a ghost .. my dear friends from Spain.. I'm shook.. there's people from Spain that are way more white than me and USA considers you not white..the fade of it all
That's because this video is wrong on this point. It's not what the census says at all.
коментаришем бзв srbjski brati I jas sum Serbian
@Valentina Valley
Anglo-Saxons are islanders. therefore, they are - Papuans.
whats really fun is when people use the phrase "Western" when their too afraid to say "white" or even just "western European" becasue it jsut creates a whole shit storm. so russians are white but not western but Spaniards are Hispanic but western but south americans arent white or western but portugese are western and maybe white but brazlians arent either but Argentinians arent white or western but iranians are arabic/middle eastern but not western and south africans are sometimes white but sometimes western while australians are white and western...
@@arthas640
the use of the concepts East/West originally meant the confrontation between the Catholic and Orthodox churches. now they are mainly referring to the eternal rivalry between the German and Slavic groups.
@10:40... That map looks like it's missing a few thousand islands.
Thank you for a well researched video.
I remember arguing with some of my friends, who tended to draw a line between "European" and "non-European" peoples at the political boundaries between the Christian world (both post-Roman and post-Byzantine) and the non-Christian world, which as a person with some levanite/middle-eastern heritage and a decent level of knowledge of the history of the eastern Mediterranean basin I found absolutely ridiculous; I personally find that Islander Greeks, Southern Italians, Lebanese, coastal Syrians, Cypriots, and even coastal Turks and Egyptians to have more in common both physically and culturally with one another than with their respective perceived "racial kin", and even many of their compatriots.
What jibd of scientific basis and study you have except your personal equation and willingness to the nature!
@@Saraswathiputra you're more than welcome to prove otherwise
Are you actually of Middle Eastern/Levantine background, or are you of European background, then took a DNA test that came back with like 10% Middle Eastern/Levantine results; and now consider yourself non-European? Because I can’t imagine an actual Middle Eastern or Mediterranean European person actually stating something like that. I won’t deny the Arabic or North African influence in Southern Italy or Greece, but like any other high traffic regions of the world, there’s bound to be hints of foreign influence from constant migration or invasion. Maybe I sort of agree with you, in terms of the Ottoman Empire’s influence in some Balkan countries; but saying that southern Italy is more like the Levant than it is Europe, tells me that the closest you’ve been to the Mediterranean is in a book or online. If you ever get to it, I wish you happy travels.😊
@@Whites0x4life "because I can't imagine an actual Middle Eastern or Mediterranean European person actually stating something like that".
Have you ever been to the region or had a conversation more meaningful than "no hummus with that kebab mate" with someone from said region? Perhaps you ought to.
And yes, I'm part Lebanese. As a matter of fact, I grew up there 😉
You forgot Albanian as well. Considering the ottomans influence, I’d says we’re culturally similar
Comments section:
1. *The whiteness of Spain*
2. *i swear my nation is whiter than your nation*
😂 Basically, a large percentage of human adults are a bunch of babies and have never matured...
@@libafried5840 Why? Spain is undebateably white.
@@libafried5840 Well, I do not think, and neither do most people, that there are any pure races (except maybe some African tribes).
Edit: I also think that discussing anything related to race on the internet is pointless, you won't convince anyone and you'll probably start a flame war at that. So I'd advise you to just save your sanity and not go around RUclips writing about races.
Chai Fried stfu
"Children of God.."
Grow up!
I'm spanish, blond, with blue-green eyes, all of my family is from Andalusia.
¡¡¡ARRIBA ESPAÑA!!!
Me toooo
My grandmother was born in southern Italy, and she had blonde hair, blue eyes, and fair skin.
I have darkblond hair and blue-green eyes ..... Hello from Republic of Kosovo 🇽🇰🇦🇱
@@beratmaliqi6158
Greetings from California. Hope all is well in Kosovo.
Of course race is real. It's utterly absurd to say that a Swede is the same race as an Australian Aboriginal. Whatever admixture of archaic people's Europeans are is secondary to the fact that modern Europeans are now one race. With exceptions of course in regional variations that can be debatable whether like for example Corsicans are Europeans.
Well technically that is incorrect, the Nordics or Northern Europeans could be considered different from the Mediterranean Race of Southern Europe. Saying that they are of the same race is like saying that a Mixed Mexican is of the same race as a Spaniard
@@eltecnico9541 Negative. But Northern Europeans and Southern Europeans have a common racial ancestor, the Proto-Indo-European. Race is not skin deep, it's blood deep. I.E. genetic.
@@alejandromacias7609 Only on the maternal side do they share genes in common but still not completely, only 18% of the current European male population is descended from the ancient hunter gatherers I.E.
@@alejandromacias7609 According to geneticists modern Europeans are made up of three different human groups, the ancient hunter gatherers of Europe IE, the Anatolian farmers who come from Turkey and the third and possibly the founder of the white race the Indo-Europeans Yamnaya proc from the Russian steppes , the Yamnaya Indo-Europeans brought the Indo-European Languages and the R1 Paternal Haplotypes replaced the original male population in addition to bringing part of their women, the Eastern and Northern Europeans have greater Yamnaya influence in relation to the South of Europe that has greater influence of the IE and Anatolian Farmers
@@alejandromacias7609 Of the most successful and most interesting groups without exaggeration is the Indo-European, they in turn are a mixture of Hunters from the Caucasus and an ANE (Ancient North Eurasian), the ANE descend from an ancestral population of the Middle East of Haplotype P that migrated and mixed with the ancient populations of East Asia, resulting in the Haplotypes Q and R, the R moved to the populations of Europe and South Asia (Iran, Pakistan, North India) and the Q in the Asians of the Altai and the Native Americans
This video should be played in every school
Can you do a video on Italians and their origins, including Sicilians and their diverse genetic background too.
Definitely soon!
Italians and Greeks are so similar
@@zeljkomikulicic4378 nah
@@zeljkomikulicic4378 nah
Portuguese people are also very similar to the italians and greeks, but in the north there is a lot of celtic/northern dna
Europe and the world: Hey America is like the main character of the world, let’s listen to him! America: OOGA BOOGA THERES THREE RACES OOOGAAA
You think there aren’t races? LOL!!!! Everyone point and laugh at this fucking idiot trying to be superior while being a complete fucking moron 😂
Aiden Frost OOGA BOOGA THERE’S 3 RACES
KimiDesu You can’t understand basic genetic science? Let me help you. Dolphins don’t give birth to elephants. That’s how it works. That’s all there is to it. I’m sorry ooga booga speak is all your people ever accomplished but there are actually three SUBSPECIES and several variants within those subspecies. You wouldn’t know that because you just believe any lie you’re told as long as it helps your pathetic inferiority complex.
Aiden Frost ooga oogaaa
duppy 00 Notice the lack of comeback or refutation here people. They mock me for being scientifically literate while they cling to pseudoscientific evolution denying bullshit from the last century.
Where are you sourcing this???
Apparently, the word "race" used to just mean "type", as in "What race of plant is that?" and then the concept typology eventually monopolised it. Also, are Lebanese people white? Where is the line drawn?
Greetings from Sardinia. I always appreciate your videos, they're thorough and leave politics aside for the sake of education and impartiality.
Heyyyyy I'm Greek but I do have 14% Sardinian DNA !
@@konangel7 Hi! Actually, I have 6,25% Greek blood, because my paternal great-great-grandomother (I don't even know if it is correct to say that), well, she was Greek, but I do not know from where.
@@alessandro_natali yup there is probably some kind of a link that connects all mediterranean islanders. I'm saying that because my paternal heritage is 100% cretan greek and I also know that others greeks form Crete have some percentage of Sardinian dna!
@@konangel7 Well, islanders probably share a more ancient genetic heritage due to the prolonged isolation. I also read that often Sardinian heritage just means that you have connections with the neolithic farmers whose DNA still lives in Sardinians. But I didn't take any test. I just know for a fact (Because my father told me) that his great-grandomother moved from Greek to Tuscany. Actually only my mother is fool-blooded Sardinian. My father is half Sicilian and half from Tuscany ( with a bit of Greek blood).
Greeks had a colony in Marseille 3000 years ago. Clearly somebody made a pit stop.
You always talk about fascinating stuff. Thank you
Averyyyy
You always post on interesting videos
For real, I see you everywhere.
Oye asere, los africanos del norte son mas blancos que nosotros... de pinga. Saludos de miami!
Weneedto Goback
Cuba = Africa de Norte
Dude, you're everywhere
Great video! You have gained a subscriber!
Odd, sometimes when I say that I'm from Croatia.. people say that I'm a Nazi or ask me if I'm Russian.
@Achaean That's sad
@Achaean Oh okay lol
Odd who did you speak to ? People that were influence by serbian smear propaganda ? Never ever by anyone I got N insult, only back home in corrupt media and by serbs that are filled by their own propaganda and dreams off great serbia. Yes people this croatia and rushia are the same....or were the same...maybe because evil communism was there, and language is slavic....
@@zb7293htjedoh napisati nesto....ali ne, reci cu samo jedno veliko FUJ
@@zb7293 htjedoh napisati nesto....ali ne, reci cu samo jedno veliko FUJ na tvoj koment, draga zrinka
Bruh I’ve been to Spain and they’re tanned but still white what is America saying?!
i think there much different nations and people who have different color. so need see who is origin from spain and not migrant.
@@Histra my father is Spanish, he was blond when he was younger, and he has pale skin and light eyes. Some of my great-grandperents were also blond on my father's side. So Spanish people (having been from here from maaany generations ago) can range from pale to really tan because of the different people who lived here (moors, Celts, Romans, etc), without even considering all the people who immigrated here recently.
@@anaisalvarez6017 we are all mixtures ..:)
Spain is whiter then america
Maybe people should stop speaking in terms of white/black 🤔?
It’s crazy how Europe has the best genetics overall
How so?
@@aurelianxcbd7799By unmatched intellect and creative abilities. Europeans basically created technology and EVERYTHING. They might as well be the most advanced species in the galaxy. Now other races can copy and develop stuff too, because the whites invented it.
@@aurelianxcbd7799 look at the world around us, whites gave us so much good
Yep, from ireland to russia, Europeans are badass warriors, writers, kings, scientists, and inventors.
I definitely believe caucasians were the original humans then evolved differently @@BananaSlug911
Who titled your video, my man? Not an race but a race. :)
... the US census doesn't count Spain as Caucasian???
Yes it does. Massaman is wrong on that map....and it's creating a crap-storm of comments dumping on the US, but that's not what the Census says.
That isn't the US census which has 6 categories. It is all the other demographic questionnaires that you have to fill out for jobs and schools based on affirmative action and anti discrimination policies in place since 1965. Hispanics are treated as a race, because so many people from central and south America identify that way and it is a chance for them to be counted as one group. So it includes Spain, if people want it to. Most people I know of spanish descent claim white
@@e.o.9094 probably because that it is how the population thinks, and as this is a democracy, that is what prevails. Oddly enough, you never hear someone of european descent call themself white american, but its rare to hear someone who isn't, not to describe themselves as black american or just black, or hispanic etc. In Hawaii, it's even worse, most of the locals can't talk about someone without describing their color/ethnicity/race.
A possible explanation for this, is that people who aren't white, are given preference over others for jobs, entry into school etc.
@@e.o.9094 I agree it is. And so do other people, but unfortunately we aren't the majority. In the US, there are plenty of white people who are poor, a lot are just average, and a very small percentage are insanely wealthy.
This is the big debate about identity politics, or ideology, being a detrimental to people seeing each other as just people, and therefor actually improving relationships. Our education system, spends most of its time focused on the wrongs committed in the past, and little or not time about how most people didn't commit those wrongs, and how that isn't happening today. (Out right racists still exist, but it's pretty equal between the groups now).
I am glad Columbia is doing well, I was there in the late 1980's during some troubled times, and is great to see how your country has improved for its people. Cheers.
@@e.o.9094 Sorry, I can't spell worth a hoot if spell check doesn't catch it:(
US : includes north africa ,central asia , and all of russia.
also US : excludes Spain
Me : confused screamimg
Including central asia is a big rofl.
It has nothing to do with race. The US needed a classification for people who it shared the continent with. The common denominator: Spanish speakers. So Spanish speakers, of all races have a different bracket for census related purposes. Every time you file a form it always clearly states that "Are you Hispanic (of any race) ?". It's not like the US doesn't consider Spain white, it kindly asks them to identify as Hispanic for purposes related to filing a form.
LMFAOOO 😭😭😭
I'm more confused about the fact that Sweden is considered white lol
@@dicecorporation have you drink too much?
Funny fact, us (caucasian people) don't mean europeans in Russia
The Spanish were literally the first white man, they had the first global empire. When American Indians spoke of the "white man" they were referring to Spanish conquistadors. Today Spaniards get conflated with South Americans whom many have significant indigenous mesoamerican admixture.
Portugal was the first global empire, spain was the second
@Lynda Anthony well the spanish are white and were white at the time so i dont know what u r trying to say
@Lynda Anthony My point was to show how much of construct white identity is, many dont consider Spanish white today when they were indeed considered to be the first "white" man because before they created the Spanish empire which was the first global empire there was no need to distinguish race by level of melanin. Whiteness today is a cult of phenotype, most Caucasians arent even socially considered white if they have too much of a tan complexion or the wrong last name despite being 100% Caucasian
American definition : lol u not white u arab
Row
This is correct.
Funny, cobsidering Spainard history in the Americas.
As a Finn, just talking about different "human races" makes me uncomfortable, because in Finnish we have only one word for both race and breed (rotu).It always makes me feel like we're talking about humans like they were specifically bred (by someone) to look different, like dogs and some other animals.
Its interesting that quite surely Finns do not have a specific word for race because historically racial intermixture in Finland was nearly non-existent. I am tslking about interracial mixture, not interethnic one. Its 2 different things.
Wolves have Different Fur colors, so do rabbits, cows and horses, is that an example of “race”?
@Devin Salmon There is no other periodic Table, so that’s impossible
@Szymon Lech Dzięcioł why is that a problem? aren't humans animals as well? or are we exempt from evolution?
I'm turkish, and same! we only have one word which means breed
9:28 in the “tropics” there in Colombia is actually up in the mountains it’s just like alpine Europe probably why its the most European in the tropics lots of Spanish and basques
this channel is great. why did you stop?
Italians, Greeks, Spaniards - Mediterraneans with a lot of history, divers in looks, hospitality, good food and culture. Europe at its finest!
More like North Africa imo
pretty late on lol
East Asia had the most vibrant for a far longer time
And Portugal too son
@Veronica Pascucci yeah girll...its a fact because....the coast of portugal doesent make part of mediterranian sea...but at the same timee the culture is the samee ;p you know we re souther european...and the mentality and the people...are to mutch similiar with spanish and italians....so youre probably italian right ;p?!
@Veronica Pascucci ahah yes i could understand girl😘🔥of course...so where the city you re from?! Naples, romee??
1:46 Spain not white but Portugal that shares 100% DNA with spaniards are?
Yes the " Politically" created race labeling in America is absurd.
The, Portuguese, Spanish, southern French,Italians,Greeks and Romanians are of the Latin- Roman Race.
It is not 100 % but in my country portugal there were more imigration than emagration so we are more white but that doesnt matter
@@MrKaido93 No such thing as Latin- Roman Race. And the portuguese dont share 100% DNA with spaniards, spaniards dont share 100% DNA with spaniards
@@vvhffc9447
We can agree to disagree.
Yes there is such a thing as
The Latin Roman Race.
Portuguse and Spanish do have allot of the same DNA and some differing DNA. Over all they are of the Latin Roman Race.
Spain is classified as "Hispanic race" in U.S. along with Latin Americans for some reason. There's no such thing as a Hispanic race.
Lol mellberg in the thumbnail caught me off guard.
If you spend time in Eastern Europe, your eyes learn to see the difference between ethnicities.
"AMERICA" was named after an Italian explorer,Amerigo Vespucci(1454-1513).
Well, they landed in south america first. And in US they claim of themselves as the True american because the other parts of americas are mostly colonized, don't have right to truly independent, means not real individually named in that place "America" because too dependent on Europeans. While their Traits are mostly Europeans. Cringe
Also if north and south america is divided by waters, they would call south america as just America, while the north is going to be named by the Brits sooner, in alternative.
"America" was a name given to the discovered continent and not to the United States of America that only existed a long time later, so America is a continent! long before it was a country! and not just the US.
@@ezequielbatista2309 it’s AMERICAS as in PLURAL(multiple) North and South America are two separate continents. It makes zero sense to identify them as one. They are different geographically and culturally.
@@srs6461 North and South America are the same continent not two. It makes zero sense to identify them to be one? Do you know what you are talking about? South Americans and North Americans are the same culturally, politically and historically. Northern Americans countries are not just US and Canada. Mexico and Colombia for example are not really different from each other. Also Latins Americans are in the Northern and Southern American subcontinents.
@@SK-mu6oj We are not the same no matter how much you try to make it that way.
an interesting thing to note is that all Europeans are somewhat genetically close to eachother relative to the various populations in Asia & Africa; for example, a Swede is much closer to a Spaniard than a Kenyan is to a Ghanaian. additionally, Celto-Germanic northwestern Europeans are all genetically more/less the same w/very minor variations (in fact, NW Euros like Brits/northern French/Germans/the Dutch incl. Belgians/the Irish/Scandinavians are more similar to eachother than Spaniards from different regions)
There are clusters and europeans are too different to africans
Africa is a enormously huge place.
People dont realize how huge it is as it does not look that big on a map.
I have heard that Africa is so big you could fit all of North America, All of Europe, All of South America (?) And most of China... all together, as one, in the continent of Africa.
That means there is more space for genetic drifting.
@@bevs9995 it’s true. It’s drawn small on a typical map, but it can fit multiple continents in it.
@@bevs9995 Area of the whole Americas 42.55 million sq.km Area of Africa 30.37 million sq.km
@@bevs9995 very true. i was baffled when i heard some americans think africa is smaller than the US
I am half Suomi, part Skandinaavinen/? myself and as to physical traits, I often find east asians take a quick liking to my 5yo daughter, some asking if she is part asian.
Wow I never realised that you have Iranian and black American, even though you said black American and African American? Correct me if I am wrong? Naaggaayaa and peace from Oromo sister :)
You say old steppe indo-europeans had middle eastern admixture but they did not. They had Neolithic European admixture which itself contained near eastern Mesolithic admixture.
Yes, thank you Tom. I'm pretty sure Masaman makes these "mistakes" on purpose. The term middle Eastern should not be used here at all because the group that it connotes had nothing to do with Steppe Indo-Europeans at all.
He also goes around deleting comments that might be too factual for his taste, not to mention his fascination with a "mixed" future for all people and calling anything non-European "diverse". It seems he's driven by certain agendas.
@A What is "CHG"?
❤️❤️❤️ Tom
Massaman does makes some strange assertions now and again. Like Ossetians being migrants from Persia. Although to be fair he did correct himself in a later video.
@A No. The human being's history starts in Africa. Whoever came out of anywhere descended from Africans. And Africans were all over the continent, not just Sub-Sahara. I'm not saying modern Africans. I'm saying ancient human Africans. It makes a lot of sense that they'd go north to Europe to what is today Portugal as the oldest fossil was found in what is today Morocco. There has to be Africa in the equation. Why assume an African person means any sub-Saharan African when using the term "Africa" or "African"? The problem with a lot of these migration scenarios is it has today's people going in particular directions based on "haplogroups." But they don't add up. The time of the next oldest skull after Morocco was present-day Ethiopia. But that doesn't mean that the ancient African just traveled east.
I have never heard any european pride themself on " hight levels of neandethal dna". What the heck are you talking about?
Speak for yourself surface-hugger. Me and my fellow 2-3% cavemen are very proud of who we are.
True all white people want to be black or asian nowadays
Yeah I've heard some people tickled by high levels of neanderthal dna.
@@gotemabk9024 You mean white kids in the US? I haven't seen that in Europe.
@@runningfromabear8354 yep, i live in the states. a lot of white people are ashamed of their skin color for some reason.
My part-Sami ass looking at how my ancestors were treated & referred to in official papers until pretty recently: well that depends who you ask I guess. And why are all three faces in that thumbnail so rectangular (and probably stuck on top of tall bodies)?
I would love to know more about the Uralic people. Anyone else agree?
Hell to the YEAH!
He did a video about em
/watch?v=UrOLla_Tqws
There ye go, friend
As a native Finn, yes!
@friendly Jew they are
pmsol3.files.wordpress.com/2011/02/averagefinnman.jpg
pmsol3.files.wordpress.com/2009/10/averagefinnishfemale.jpg
Spain not white hahaahaha, US logic.
@Meme 1416 I am a spaniard, of course white and spanish, that was a exchange student in US High School back in 1991 and they made me fill a form as a normal student in where I had to choose if I was "spanish" or "white", so been bouth I said I was "asian" :-)))
I think they get this nonsense about spanish enheritage by the english shame about Spain and the real History of the actual USA been profoundly spanish, something they hate to admit, but I have to admit that things are changing and US is starting to discover all the importance of their Spanish History, just as a reference: US Cowboys are just Andalusian horse riders speaking english, and that is just the beguining...
@Meme 1416 yes, I didnt care at all, but believe me, I was in World History class at that High School and it was completly english sided to the absolut ridiculus... Just see images of how they potrait the pilgrins vs. The conqyistadors... We appear like barbed male soldiers vs. Beautifull families having fun with the indians... And we all know how they ended...
Americans don’t know this they refuse to put it in the history
@Derek Smith you got that very wrong. Spain was never fully ocupied and was able to expell every single moor and jew, leaving no racial trace at all.
The moors didnt mix with Christians while the 700 years war.
The moors are not black, but had some black and northeuropean slaves.
Spain not only defeated the moors, olso defeated the ottomans and expanded christianity all over the world on the first global Empire.
@Derek Smith That is not true, starting in the first statement of that very sided and non scientiphic "article": Everybody knows they didnt conquer the all Spain... Do you know about Asturias?
All the rest in that "article" is fake. For your info, as I guess you are black, the moors are northafricans bereberes and had black slaves, in fact a very interesting episode of the Reconquista is when the King of Navarra charged directly to the tent of the caliph and broke into the chained black bodygards to win the battle of Las Navas de Tolosa and the Shield of Navarra since then has the chains of the black slaves that protected the moor tent.
Please dont claim that time as a black people good time since the christians didnt have slaves but the mors.
It's sad that race is such a politically loaded and sensitive subject, the discussion of ancestral continuums and genetic population clusters is a deeply interesting conversation that can help many feel a connection to their roots.
I'm not sure of the exact history, but the idea of "CAUCASIAN" probably goes back to the 19th century idea of a Aryan or Indoeuropean race who supposedly fanned out to populate Europe and parts of Asia. As in the Aryan-Dravidian ideas about the population of India.
Reminds me of an african american who actually got himself to Africa and sought to connect there. Asked a man where he looked like he came from (obviously curious where is Africa his ancestors might have come from, something sadly most never gets to know) and laughed when the actual African man said Brazil or Italy I think lol. He understood then how different they were
He still is wrong if he still calling himself African American but this is because slavery rob us of are true identity but i know whom we are.
@Héctor Santa Ana lmao not at all. I'm Nigerian and your answer is wrong. You do know native west Africans come in all shades, mostly dark brown, to dark skin, to light skin, and some even pale. During slavey, some AAs mixed with Europeans and some were raped. Their complexion doesn't really have much to do with it because the majority still have the same complexion range as us West Africans from dark skin to light skin to pale. Black americans mixed with other pure Africans and AAs after mixing with Europeans so their complexion wouldn't really be affected at all. It's more so their facial structures/features that have changed in many of them. Many have narrower noses, curlier hair, and lighter colored eyes (West Africans can have lighter eyes it's just not as predominant as it is in black americans).
@Héctor Santa Ana I don’t know if you have ever actually lived in Africa. Plenty of my relatives and myself have lighter skin than most African Americans.
In the last few generations there are black Africans who are born in Italy or get Italian citizenship.
If he is American, he is not African anymore. It doesn't make sense.
to anyone confused about spain not being considered white, they are considered white. its just that on american census papers, there are boxes for race (white, black, asian, etc.) and separates boxes for "hispanic" and "mixed". people from spanish speaking countries select their race or mix of races, as well as selecting "hispanic".
PS. yes, this does cause further confusion since spaniards, colombians and others get a special box but the portugues, brazilians and others dont.
Many Spaniards don’t wanna be white so they put Hispanic Latino. But its changing now. Many Hispanics are identifying as white by race
there shouldnt be honestly. Hispanic isn't a race. Hispanics can be white, black or mixed. Mixed is the only one that should be seperate.
@@CHPYXOhave ever been to Spain? I did. They are white
Penelope Cruz (a dark type of Spanish women) can't be mistaken with Beyonce: that's for sure 😂
@@Fake_account_001 And who is disagreeing? 😹😹. I know Spanish people are white. And was Beyonce really your yard stick for blackness? I mean she looks half white because..she's biracial.
When I read that the Spanish actor Antonio Bandera in America was considered an "actor of color" I was astonished.
Id love to learn about the baltics since their genetics are interesting. They were very isolated leading to not alot of genetic diversity for a long time.
I'm 2/3 polish particularly south-eastern and would love a video explaining the origins , common heritage's and differences between other peeps from that region!
kurwa
66%? Not sure how possible that is.
2/3 polish doesn't mean anything.
2/3 don't matter the 1/3 is more important. Is it of alien origin?
Ah, so there really is a third sex in Poland!
“Except Spain” lol 😂 deeaaaaddd 🤣🤣🤣 oh, the ignorance 🙈
Cocó Aedo You look Spanish
@@FrenchViking466 Yep she doesn't look white.
@Georgios Alencar Chardavellas It was a joke based on the video, are you alright?
According to the USA Spaniards aren't white Idk why
@Georgios Alencar Chardavellas I'm a blonde. Hazel eyes pale Salvadorean from Spanish andnItalian ancestry..I remember a darker, black haired, black eyes white american who was comfused was whiter than him.
Thank you for the vid. I allways learned that Europeans came from India, and that then migrated to Europe from there. Not the other way around.
Actually, do you know that proto caucasoid were dark skinned? The dravidian people of south asia is dark skinned with straight hair whose ancestors left Africa some 40 - 50k years ago. There's high chance these people moved to colder regions of central asia and evolved light skin.
European white peoples never come from India, is propaganda
A very interesting analysis. I guess I'm Yamnaya. As Popeye said: "I yam what I yam and that's all I yam." 😄
Just googled "Sudan People"
yeeeaah white boiiiii!
caucasian not mean white but is group of darker white or brown or black people to. European white is not caucasian white.
I searched them up and there blacker then most Africans Americans as a matter of fact you cant cant get any more blacker then them
The Arabs literally called the country “Sudan” because the people are black. The country name literally means “blacks.”
@@saydie6646 And they can have dark skin while being caucasoids.
@@saydie6646 yet they are considered semetic and are part of the Arabs league
Spain is in Europe so they don't count as European?
See maps of haplogoups and autosomal maps of Europe: Spain is genetically more "European" than Italy, Portugal, Greece and all of Eastern Europe.
Your a peein
No they don't count as your opinion
@john vento yes the arabs were 800 hundred years in Spain, but they did not mix. Also they were not in the whole Spain,.just until the middle of the peninsula. The people in the north, were european and.white. They won the war and killed almost all the population and kick out all that arabs. The people from the north were moving to the rest of the country. Spain has r1b dna mostly, wich means one.of the oldest european dna, Italy specially the south was really influenced by the northafricans, greeks, libia, turkey...and they mixed there. Italy have more african or arab or asian influence than another country in Europe...
@john vento muslims does not mix with catolics, and they were erradicated for that was a war, Spain was the head of the catolicism, since they discover america. You din not give any proof. The studies of cambridge and a hundred of univesitys say the opposite, and also say that is more frequent find some northafrican dna in the north than in the south, that is because the few survivors were redistribuited for the north to not reorganized again... Italy just is fairy skim in the north, the south has another tone and subgroup. But i dont want to argue with an idiot. The people out of the skills, as Casillas, Ricky Rubio, Fernando Llorente, Muniain and a long etc.. they are not originally spanish...in Canary Islands still there are spanish, descendants of the bereberes...
r1 a gene is native to india so i would say that the yamnaya ntg but indian which is backed by the fact that there is an historical migration from india after the battle of the five kings, and there has been negligible gene flow into india .
Proud to be of European ancestry! 💪🏼
I personally think in Europe no one cares what race you are , just know your nationality and that's it :DDD(I could be wrong tho)
We dont see ourselves as a white race. We see ourselves as germans, french, poles, italians, spaniards, aso. Everyone who isnt of your nationality, doesnt matter if hes black, white, asian, ... is considered a foureigner.
@@MMadesen ethnonationalism.
In Finland atleast it's been on the rise
We care more about culture than in race.
@@MMadesen Germans are fine as hell!
It's the same way in the Caribbean
Man the stereotypes😂😂 I’m blonde, I have blue eyes and I’m as white as a paper, and I’m from Spain. Many of us, I would say 50/100 has light hair and light eyes, and all of us are white but In summer we can get a tan because we live in a sunny country
👍🙂
Celtic Spain ?
Let's not exagerate, it's not 50/100, it's more like 20/100.
You're gorgeous omg
I think you forgot one important detail , the many centuries of Arabic rules over Iberian peninsula. More like majority of ppl living there are with mixed dark Arabic blood. White skin light hair/eyes are more like rare exceptions than normal for Spain and the region. I think like 80% are dark blood mixed with Arabian roots.. Same comes for Southern Italy/Sicily
i'd like to kow more about white south africans, the differences between the anglos and the boers and their numbers today
@Falk well the boers are descendants of dutch colonists