Shooting the .451 Whitworth civil war sniper rifle

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
  • Please support us at: / capandball
    This is something I promissed you long before: a review of the Whitworth rifle with hexagonal rifling. Thanks to a friend of mine I was able to testfire one of those old Parker Hale rifles. Well, here is the result. And of course some history...
    Magyar szöveg: kapszli.hu/a-wh...
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 1,2 тыс.

  • @ThisOldHat
    @ThisOldHat 8 лет назад +3052

    "They couldn't hit an elephant at this range." U.S. General Sedgwick famous last words.

    • @FredDude27
      @FredDude27 8 лет назад +161

      Poor Uncle John! :(
      Even Confederate General Robert E. Lee was said to have mourned his death.

    • @FredDude27
      @FredDude27 8 лет назад +53

      I dont think we'll ever know about Reynolds fate. Some peeps think it was a whitworth/rebel bullet, others think accidental friendly fire.
      Regardless the Union lost a good General on July 1st.

    • @FredDude27
      @FredDude27 8 лет назад +24

      As I understood it, the rifle used in his death was not made clear and even today it is still a matter of debate.
      During the war the Whitworth and other rifles were used for sharpshooting duties on both sides. I dont think an autopsy was performed regarding Reynolds so I do not know of any definitive facts about the weapon used.

    • @jkoeberlein1
      @jkoeberlein1 8 лет назад +58

      Thisold Hatte
      I though it was, "what are you ducking for, they couldn't hit an elephant at this dist,,,"

    • @FredDude27
      @FredDude27 7 лет назад +13

      John Koeberlein
      There are probably other variations of his last words out there. ^_^

  • @rickhooker4625
    @rickhooker4625 6 лет назад +1078

    No mention of General John Sedgwick, the Whithworth's most famous victim. He told his companions that they were all safe; the distance from the CS line was too great, nothing could shoot that far with accuracy. Those were his last words, as a Whitworth and a skilled marksman showed that he was wrong.

    • @haupper
      @haupper 5 лет назад +31

      That's according to Ben Powell of 12th South Carolina, the Whitworth's owner, after the war. Several of Sedgwick's men ventured out shortly after the general's death and killed a reb they believed to be the sharpshooter. Nobody knows for sure.

    • @philgiglio7922
      @philgiglio7922 4 года назад +21

      There was also a cannon that used the same idea.
      A 3inch ordnance rifle could put 3 shots into a sheet of newsprint at a thousand yards.
      At that range the front sight was 'larger' than the target.

    • @FIREBRAND38
      @FIREBRAND38 4 года назад +9

      No evidence that a Whitworth killed him.

    • @epictroll4714
      @epictroll4714 4 года назад +16

      @@FIREBRAND38 it is a whitworth because there is no way that a musket can kill someone from a long distance with good accuracy

    • @mrj4990
      @mrj4990 4 года назад +6

      Popped him right below the left eye

  • @davidca96
    @davidca96 9 лет назад +1585

    The Confederates were extremely lethal with these rifles, there are lots of stories about it including an officer claiming they couldn't hit his men at this distance, seconds later he was hit in the head and dropped dead. Thanks for the video.

    • @psikogeek
      @psikogeek 7 лет назад +194

      An unknown Confederate managed a sniper shot longer than any WWI or WWII shot from Ft Sumpter. It was 1390 yards. Likely a Whitworth.

    • @Auggies1956
      @Auggies1956 7 лет назад +57

      My gg grandfather and his brother were with the Army of Virginia and were "sharp shooters." Thanks for this information.

    • @ravenwing199
      @ravenwing199 7 лет назад +27

      1510Yrd .50-90 Sharps rifle.

    • @psikogeek
      @psikogeek 7 лет назад +31

      Ravenwing19 might be referring to the 1538 yard shot by Billy Dixon in 1874 witha .50-90 Sharps.

    • @slimjim7411
      @slimjim7411 6 лет назад +21

      No there is record of a Confederate sniper using a Whitworth rifle to kill a man at 1400 yards.

  • @grumpyoldfart7302
    @grumpyoldfart7302 8 лет назад +1684

    How long is the barrel on that thing? In Vietnam I killed an officer over 1000 yards away with my 45 ACP 1911 service pistol. I dropped it out of the helicopter door, and it hit the Captain, on the ground.

    • @creaturedanaaaaa
      @creaturedanaaaaa 7 лет назад +416

      lol 10/10 story

    • @ZalVIIzero
      @ZalVIIzero 7 лет назад +170

      Grumpy old fart Damn, you got me there.

    • @justsam0511
      @justsam0511 7 лет назад +89

      fucking hell i laugh out loud at work

    • @fullretardcustomguns837
      @fullretardcustomguns837 6 лет назад +13

      Lol.

    • @danielevans8910
      @danielevans8910 6 лет назад +106

      Grumpy old fart oh yeah? When I fought in Nam i killed five farmers just with my old M1 Carbine. Placed it at the foot of their hut doorway, made some noise outside, and when that all started walking out the tripped over the rifle and suffered skull/brain internal bleeding.

  • @perfectfan2006
    @perfectfan2006 6 лет назад +459

    most people today do not even know who whitworth was...he had his own measure system not metric and not standard back in the old days if you wanted to work on a bsa..triumph,,enfield,,motorcycle you had to have a set of whitworth tools to fit every nut and bolt on them british bikes.... thanks for the video he was a great inventor and engineer

    • @davidpage4005
      @davidpage4005 6 лет назад +36

      Still got my "Whitworth" spanners. 1/8" all the way up to 1" in 1/16" increments.

    • @kinkong1961
      @kinkong1961 5 лет назад +24

      David Page same here I was a truck mechanic even trucks in the seventies had whitworth nuts and bolts

    • @FoosaStomp
      @FoosaStomp 5 лет назад +12

      Reminds me of a truck I had with BPT fittings - so annoying but oh so very English. :-)

    • @jacqirius
      @jacqirius 4 года назад +15

      On one side i absolutely adore this rifle of his.
      On the other hand it's pretty damn stupid to reinvent a system that works perfectly fine.
      You wouldn't believe how annoying the whitworth threads can be when mixed up with metrics on a machine

    • @daddydoc1115
      @daddydoc1115 4 года назад +2

      Sounds like an asshole 😂

  • @tetroxo394
    @tetroxo394 7 лет назад +775

    I feel like this guy is trying to seduce me lol

    • @iwritechecksatthegrocerystore
      @iwritechecksatthegrocerystore 6 лет назад +33

      Jason Bartone what do you mean “trying”? Haha. 😂

    • @TheWizardboy5
      @TheWizardboy5 6 лет назад +14

      He's successful if he's trying

    • @redprovince6427
      @redprovince6427 6 лет назад +22

      If I were queer I'd be all over him.

    • @OTTO149x
      @OTTO149x 5 лет назад +21

      That's because he looks like fucking Randolf Scott, from the handsome-hero shaved-down mustache to the swashbuckling perfect hair. He should be swinging on a chandelier in his tights while holding a maiden-in-distress and sword-fighting three guys at the same time...

    • @simonpotter7534
      @simonpotter7534 5 лет назад +6

      Roll over and check who is bed with you tonight...you never know

  • @bluewater454
    @bluewater454 7 лет назад +542

    I cant imagine hitting a target a mile away without a scope. You could barely see the target.

    • @jamesharris9558
      @jamesharris9558 6 лет назад +70

      If I recall, the British army was able to get a 7" grouping at 2000 yards. 2 km away. Is more than a mile. Maybe 1.2, 1.3.... IN 1859! But the Enfield cost 20 pounds compared to the Whitfield, scope and 1000 rounds costing 1000 pounds.

    • @geofreak12345
      @geofreak12345 5 лет назад +7

      no its not CS GO

    • @jamesharris9558
      @jamesharris9558 5 лет назад +7

      @@SuqMadiq According to an internet conversion program 2000 yards is 1.136364 miles.

    • @bilibiliism
      @bilibiliism 4 года назад +25

      according to ian, this thing was indeed equiped with a scope

    • @REIDAE
      @REIDAE 4 года назад +41

      @@jamesharris9558 that would require those rifles themselves to shoot a third of an inch groups at 100 yards. Very few modern high end precision rifles can achieve that kind of accuracy. Couple that with only using ironsights and human error, i dont believe that story at all.

  • @TheGunrunn3r
    @TheGunrunn3r 9 лет назад +582

    The Whitworth was ahead of it's time, but like others similarly "out of time" they suffered one critical shortcoming. The thing just cost too damn much. Same as the Ferguson Rifle and Girandoni. Too much buck for the bang.

    • @RandyLeftHandy
      @RandyLeftHandy 9 лет назад +15

      +TheGunrunn3r Cheap and in mass usually rules the day.

    • @TheGunrunn3r
      @TheGunrunn3r 9 лет назад +14

      RandyLeftHandy And still does. One-on-one, the WWII German panzers outclassed any Allied armor. We just rolled 35 Shermans off the line for every one PzKpfv V (Panther) of Germany. (off the topic slightly... They caught this old dude in Germany who had a Panther (yes, a tank!!!) stashed in his basement. www.newser.com/story/209357/wwii-tank-was-stashed-in-78-year-olds-cellar.html )
      I guess we figured that with enough ants you can kill an elephant.
      I do have a theory, though. It runs something like this: Back in the days of gotta-fire-volleys-with-muskets to hit anything, if they were using Whitworths (or even used more Baker rifles), there might have been a slight reluctance among the rank-and-file to stand nice and straight in neat shoulder-to-shoulder lines. Even in the face of muskets it hardly seems the smart thing to do, now does it?

    • @RandyLeftHandy
      @RandyLeftHandy 9 лет назад +8

      Yes, but I read a lot about the Generals of old, and audacity and creativity on the battlefield are pretty rare occurrences. They were reluctant to try anything new, especially when the risks were high. That's why Hannibal's name still rings out today.

    • @TheGunrunn3r
      @TheGunrunn3r 9 лет назад +5

      RandyLeftHandy Very good point. Mr. Barca was rather annoying to the Romans whose ideas of strategy rarely coincided with that of their nemesis. Another fellow that is perhaps less well known, but was as unorthodox and daring was old Colonel Paul von Lettow-Vorbeck. The only commander in WW1 never to suffer a defeat, despite being outnumbered by at least 5 times his own strength at any given time. It is historically cruel that this man is not better known.

    • @jamesstevens213
      @jamesstevens213 8 лет назад +3

      Scipio out thought and out fought Mr. Barca at the Battle of Zama. Blaring trumpets startle elephants it seems.

  • @RyanAlexanderBloom
    @RyanAlexanderBloom 6 лет назад +112

    The funny thing about these old rifles is that they have "effective ranges" out to where you literally cannot see the target through the iron sights. I mean, maybe in clear weather, with the target wearing something shiny you could get lucky at a mile away. But its not the problem of the rifle bore or round, its just seeing the person you're shooting without magnification. They'd just be a little dot.

    • @Ravnulv
      @Ravnulv 5 лет назад +10

      I believe the whitworth was delivered to the union with x4 magnification :)

    • @FIREBRAND38
      @FIREBRAND38 4 года назад +3

      Ryan Alexander Boom That's horsecrap

    • @FIREBRAND38
      @FIREBRAND38 4 года назад +3

      @@Ravnulv Confederacy not Union

    • @RyanAlexanderBloom
      @RyanAlexanderBloom 4 года назад +2

      @@FIREBRAND38 what is? That the rifle will actually shoot that far or that you could effectively see your human sized target in dark clothing to aim at over 1500-2000 yards away with iron sights?

    • @RyanAlexanderBloom
      @RyanAlexanderBloom 4 года назад +3

      John Simpson I’ll add that the longest confirmed kill of the entire civil war was 1390yds, so the gun was effective out to at least that range but nobody seemed to be able to hit anything farther out than that in 4 years of shooting at each other.

  • @Saved_Sinner0085
    @Saved_Sinner0085 7 лет назад +269

    Forgotten Weapons did a pair of videos on this rifle recently, it shoots ~3 MOA which is phenomenal for an over 150 year old muzzle loading rifle.

    • @anonfilly7335
      @anonfilly7335 5 лет назад +17

      Kuuryo He said one minute of angle at 500 yards.

    • @beelz5932
      @beelz5932 5 лет назад +2

      @Kuuryo it's probably because of corrosion to the rifling from the blackpowder

    • @REIDAE
      @REIDAE 4 года назад +5

      @@anonfilly7335 i call bullshit on that

    • @FIREBRAND38
      @FIREBRAND38 4 года назад +2

      @Kuuryo Watch the correction video he made.

    • @alexm566
      @alexm566 3 года назад +2

      @@beelz5932 corrosion shouldn't be a problem if the rifle gets frequently cleaned

  • @britishmuzzleloaders
    @britishmuzzleloaders 10 лет назад +336

    Nice job. Again, the perfect mix of history and shooting. I did a very similar clip with a PH Volunteer Rifle... Some of the same pictures too! They are, of course, of the same generation. Well done.

    • @capandball
      @capandball  10 лет назад +14

      I shoot a PH Volunteer as well. I have the rifle for more than 10 years now. I love it. 60 grains of 3Fg Swiss + the Lyman Volunteer bullet sized to .451 will put the bullets hole in hole at 100m.

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders 10 лет назад +4

      ***** Do you have the 2 band or the three band version? Platinum nipple? I haven't tried any 3F powder in mine yet and typically use 2F. Must see what the finer powder does to the groups, for sure.. I use a bullet by Lee Shaver specifically designed for muzzleloaders which is 500 Gr. Your clips are so well polished with great lighting and clarity. They are a pleasure to watch. Thanks.

    • @capandball
      @capandball  10 лет назад +3

      britishmuzzleloaders
      Thanks!! I have the 2 band version. PH bore + Euroarms lock and stock. The lock is a piece of sh... unfortunately... No platinum lined nipple, but i decided to buy one this year, as the high pressure kills the normal steel nipples quickly. I saw Lee Shaver's bullets. They are excellent in my opinion. Do you shoot long range as well?

    • @britishmuzzleloaders
      @britishmuzzleloaders 10 лет назад +2

      ***** I have shot my Volunteer (and Enfields) out to 500yds.... Not in any competition, mind you. The small bore rifles are so powerful when you compare them to their full bore cousins. I have a similar sight setup to the one in this video, even with the same backsight. Fortunately mine is a full-on PH. The lock has a fly on the tumbler and the overall quality is excellent, as you'd expect from a British PH. Do you use a card-wad or anything under the bullet? What is your cleaning regimen during firing?

    • @capandball
      @capandball  10 лет назад +4

      britishmuzzleloaders
      I sae that on the rifles 3 sights were present, but never thoght the diopter was just for orthopic use. Thanks for the info! Great vid on the Volunteer. Makes me wanna take my rifle to the range. :)

  • @DoyleHargraves
    @DoyleHargraves 8 лет назад +164

    Sir, you just gave me more information about that rifle in 5 minutes than I have found after studying the American Civil War for 20+ years (amateur Civil War buff). The detail with which you speak about the history and functionality of all of these weapons is amazing.
    I'd say you deserve your own TV show, but that would be to ignore the fact that this internet fad and your current media outlet is much more effective.
    Thanks!

    • @mannyfox8089
      @mannyfox8089 3 года назад +5

      "internet fad" XD

    • @reyzephlyn105
      @reyzephlyn105 3 года назад +1

      Despite the title it took him forever to actually shoot the damn thing

    • @NoNo-fy3kr
      @NoNo-fy3kr 3 года назад +1

      Have you ever actually looked for the information? ............. LMAO Because there is plenty out there.. Just need to look.

    • @calonarang7378
      @calonarang7378 Год назад

      The schools today are shit.

  • @chrisjohnson4165
    @chrisjohnson4165 3 года назад +23

    Whitworth was a brilliant engineer. His most famous contribution was standardising the pitch and diameter of screw threads for maximum strength and interchangeability. Later they were adopted as UNC.

    • @datadavis
      @datadavis Год назад

      Whitworth and unc threads are completely different standards.

    • @chrisjohnson4165
      @chrisjohnson4165 Год назад

      @@datadavis Apart from half inch, they have the same pitch and diameters. The thread angles are slightly different, but they are mostly interchangeable. In any case, Whitworth was an outstanding engineer.

    • @datadavis
      @datadavis Год назад

      @@chrisjohnson4165 hex head sizes differ between unc and whitworth too, apart from the thread form

  • @gonagain
    @gonagain 10 лет назад +23

    I've been wanting to invite you to the annual Mathew Quigley Long Range Buffalo Rifle Match, held in Forsyth, Montana, USA every father's day weekend. I think you would absolutely love it. If you are interested, I'm willing to provide you with all the information.
    Rick Herzog

    • @lwarner3392
      @lwarner3392 3 года назад +1

      It's like Quigley just muzzle load. Same caliber.

  • @since1876
    @since1876 3 года назад +44

    Engineer: "Wait, the Queen will be firing the first shot?? Someone, quick, I need a stand built to make her hit a bullseye in one shot!!!"

    • @bernarddavis1050
      @bernarddavis1050 3 года назад +1

      You made the bullet hole first, of course.

    • @legbreaker2762
      @legbreaker2762 3 года назад +6

      The Queen was actually a pretty good shot in her own right.

    • @milosmilosevic5113
      @milosmilosevic5113 3 года назад

      Gde da kupim Remington 1858. Od ne rđajućeg čelika u SRBIJI.

    • @since1876
      @since1876 3 года назад

      @@milosmilosevic5113 I definitely understood that.

  • @Benji1836
    @Benji1836 10 лет назад +51

    Superb work Balázs. Perfect mix of the historical facts and practical experiences

  • @mag30th
    @mag30th 9 лет назад +160

    Parker Hale produces an outstanding reproduction but they have three serious design flaws in the manufacture of the breach.
    The recomended load for these rifles is a 560 projectile and a 90 grain powder charge. My P-H Whitworth had a catastrophic breach failure, this was not the result of abuse, but a common design flaw I see in many P-H Whitworths, including the one fired here in the video.
    The problem can be easily seen in slow motion video of the breach when the rifle is fired.
    The first issue is the nipple threading. The thread they use is a course thread, which is a poor choice for rifles designed for such heavy charges. All P-H Whitworth rifles fail to form a sufficient seal by simply tightening the nipple or using material applied to the threads. I found making a copper O-ring gasket was the only way to stop the gas blowby. The blowby is occurring on the rifle in this video as well. Evidence can be seen by the dark, almost wet looking, dark ring at the contact point where the nipple seat contacts the breach. When watching it fired in slow motion, and excessive amount of smoke can be seen coming from the nipple region, and the shooter generally has an uncomfortable feeling when the unexplainable hot gas strikes his face. Most the time you will actually see the shooter look directly at the breach the moment the rifles is fired, because of the hot puff of air. A thin copper gasket was the only solution I found in stopping this leakage.
    Secondly, the small access screw is not typically seen on rifles that fire such a heavy load. Some original Whitworths had it, but most were manufactured without it or had it removed because of pressure issues.
    But the dangerous flaw in these rifles is how P-H soldered the breech components.
    The breech plug is round and made from several pieces. there is an inner and an external part. These parts are not threaded and appear they should be silver soldered in the original whitworth design.
    But after mine blew up, I was shocked to learn mine was soldered with bronze.
    Repeated firing on a bronze solder will slowly etch out the bronze, forming an air cavity. Air cavities and black powder can create a rebound pressure effect that can exceed 100,000 PSI, and once the cavity is formed, the repeated firing will cause the cavity to enlarge and eventually blow the poor breech solder apart.
    I saw early signs of the breech failure but I failed to diagnose the problem correctly.
    The sign my rifle was giving prior to the failure was a small thin dark, wet-like line which appeared when where the barrel met the breech. I didn't realize that this was the result of gas escaping the bronze solder. Behind this small line, I also detected a extremely small, hardly detectable bulge in the bottom of the breech. This was only noticeable when the barrel was removed from the stock.
    My only advice to anyone who may be seeing these symptoms is to have the breech disassembled, and the bronze solder repaired and properly welded with stronger Silver Solder.

    • @NeuKrofta
      @NeuKrofta 7 лет назад +5

      this could be remedied by putting a flintlock action. From what I understand it was not uncommon to convert the new primer system to the old flintlock system in the 19th century.

    • @Snipeyou1
      @Snipeyou1 7 лет назад

      Mag30th so in other words ouch!?

    • @colinbell6461
      @colinbell6461 6 лет назад +5

      Thanks, i have this rifle, i will look out for the signs of a possible failure

    • @kylegilmore3810
      @kylegilmore3810 6 лет назад +5

      Besides the matter of authenticity, I'd rather have a small tig weld instead of a much weaker braze. Unless it would need to be easily removed, then silver would be a better option.
      Thanks for the information.

    • @jamesharris9558
      @jamesharris9558 6 лет назад +1

      Have you looked at the Pedersoli replica? www.davide-pedersoli.com/scheda-prodotto.asp/l_en/idpr_395/rifles-whitworth-rifle-whitworth-rifle.html

  • @ultimateninjaboi
    @ultimateninjaboi 8 лет назад +9

    Love me some Civil War guns. There were some pretty interesting ones, as well as some really ahead-of-their-time stuff like the Whitworth.
    Personal favorite Civil War era gun, for me, is still the LeMat revolver. Just an interesting concept.
    But the Whitworth is a beautiful gun. And as someone said in other comments, the big downside was the cost. At the time, anyway

  • @alanwhitworth659
    @alanwhitworth659 8 лет назад +10

    Well.. Joseph Whitworth also standardized the engineering measurements. Also linked to the Blockade runners in the American Civil war.. The Alabama traded his guns for Cotton. to supply the Lancashire Cotton Mills in work
    23,000 people died in the Rossindale area of Lancashire due to the blockade Hench the Alabama,supported by the Cotton traders in Liverpool
    All down to my ancestor
    .

  • @Ken-fh8iv
    @Ken-fh8iv 5 лет назад +36

    I can just picture that exchange ;-P
    Wife: "It cost HOW MUCH??"
    Hubby: Honey, I don't drink, hit you, & am loving to our kids & your mother. Leave my Whitworth alone."

  • @453421abcdefg12345
    @453421abcdefg12345 10 лет назад +8

    As always, an excellent video, you really enjoy all this don't you, it certainly beats working! The Whitworth bullet moulds are still made to order in UK.

  • @thingsofsuch
    @thingsofsuch 5 лет назад +7

    Nice rifle, interesting history, and damn expensive when it was first conceived and in production. Comparing the rifle to the revolver which was $17, versus the rifle which would fetch $1000 ... no wonder so few were around. Probably fairly impossible to find one these days, along with the specialty bullets, makes shooting this shooting a real piece of history. Thanks for showing this to us!

    • @harryshuman9637
      @harryshuman9637 2 года назад +1

      I think he made a mistake, that was probably $1000 in modern currency. According to Forgotten Weapons channel the rifle cost around $96, which is still x3 times of a typical high-tech rifle of those days.

  • @needsomehike
    @needsomehike 7 лет назад +11

    I fell off the chair when i heard my mother language during the video.....
    :)

    • @lyftedd7203
      @lyftedd7203 6 лет назад +1

      Hungarian is the coolest sounding language in my opinion

  • @utzius8003
    @utzius8003 3 года назад +5

    This is really amazing. I've been wondering for a long time if one could make a well functioning rifle with polygonal bullets. Great video!

  • @HarrysHouseChannel
    @HarrysHouseChannel 9 лет назад +9

    That is an amazing weapon for the era. I never suspected it to be that accurate

  • @mikelangelno
    @mikelangelno 3 года назад +5

    As a mining electrician in the 60/70s I used 'Whitworth' spanners but also had some AF spanners - not because we ever came across AF (American Flat - for Brits who don't know), threads in mining but so that, when, occasionally, I found some hexagon-headed bolt that my Whitworths didn't fit, an AF just might. This happened because during World War 2, to conserve steel - bolt heads had metal shaved off them. These we called 'bastard' sizes, and were still found on some older gear. Otherwise it was inserting a flat-bladed screwdriver blade in the gap - not ideal or most times very effective. The American civil war misnamed, I believe, as it was a war of secession, I've always found to be particularly heart-breaking but the story of Jack Hinson's murdered sons, especially so.

    • @MURDOCK1500
      @MURDOCK1500 2 года назад

      I am a Brit. And AF stands for Across Flats

    • @mikelangelno
      @mikelangelno 2 года назад

      @@MURDOCK1500 I got American Flat from an ex soldier/electrician who used to work on American cars and jeeps during the war but you are correct, thanks I remember this now.

  • @davo26101966
    @davo26101966 6 лет назад +5

    Thank you for this. I am a Whitworth from Melbourne Australia. A great man that did many things.

  • @legbreaker2762
    @legbreaker2762 3 года назад +10

    Sir Joseph Whitworth was my ancestor. There are still to this day a few excellent marksmen in the family. Sadly though no examples of the rifle. :(

  • @Player_Review
    @Player_Review 7 лет назад +6

    Whitworth definitely belongs in the Firearms Hall of Fame, if that exists. What an amazing feat of engineering. Even Browning who came up with so many great firearms and bullet caliburs would have to acknowledge how amazing this feat was, especially for it's age of production. Maybe this was the best black powder rifle ever made before muzzle loading blackpowder rifles would become obsolete except within certain hunting and firearms enthusiasts. I've gone hunting with a muzzle loader for deer and I would have loved to have one of these, but I agree that they aren't the most pretty (at least this version). Apparently some of the originals were very elegantly made for the wealthiest of wealthy patrons.
    Thanks for sharing this - It was suggested in the sidebar on Forgotten Weapons as Ian had an original on the channel today up for auction. He or Karl recommended your channel a year ago or so and I've been subbed ever since.

  • @RR-gw2uj
    @RR-gw2uj 5 лет назад +7

    The engineering prowess behind this rifle is astounding.
    Great, informative video, love it!

  • @siddharthm285
    @siddharthm285 9 лет назад +15

    Sharps Rifle Vs. Whitworth : Discuss

    • @capandball
      @capandball  9 лет назад +14

      Siddharth fgjhfh Depends on which Sharps and for waht purpose. For skirmish in the Civil War: 1859 Sharps for sure. For taking out a Union general from 600 yards: Whitworth.

    • @siddharthm285
      @siddharthm285 9 лет назад

      Well as for which Sharps, I was thinking long cartridge like .50-90 or .50-110, think Adobe Walls :)

    • @capandball
      @capandball  9 лет назад +1

      Siddharth fgjhfh I think they can be something like equal in accuracy, but the center fire self contained cartridge is far superior than the muzzleloading system.

    • @siddharthm285
      @siddharthm285 9 лет назад +2

      From what I understand from wikipedia (lol) they were effective "sniper" weapons too, being the preferred rifle of "2nd United States Sharpshooters". I think the Whitworthis beautifully engineered though

    • @capandball
      @capandball  9 лет назад +9

      Siddharth fgjhfh Wikipedia is not the best source for info... :) IN the civil war the sharps rifles used were breech loading percussion rifles, not metallic cartridge guns like the 1874 Sharps rifles. The civil war time guns fired a linen or paper cased cartridge including the bullet and powder. The rifles had to be primed separatly by placing a percussion cap on the niplle after closing the breech.

  • @tomsterism
    @tomsterism 10 лет назад +5

    As always, superb work! The Atlanta History Center here in Atlanta, Georgia (USA) possesses 2 original Whitworth rifles from the War Between the States, what we Southerner refer to as the Civil War. As there was little actually "civil" about it! They are not typically displayed, but are alelgedly in fine condition.

    • @bloodybones63
      @bloodybones63 Год назад

      Your phrasing is backwards. Southerners refer to it as 'The War Between the States.'

    • @tomsterism
      @tomsterism Год назад

      @@bloodybones63 I stand corrected. My only hope is you're no Yankee!

    • @bloodybones63
      @bloodybones63 Год назад +2

      @@tomsterism No, SC. 1st SC Confederate Regiment, Greggs

  • @timbow50
    @timbow50 3 года назад +3

    What an awesome weapon! Totally amazing beyond belief. Had to be the finest rifle for years. I would love to shoot this.

  • @arthurvandervelde
    @arthurvandervelde 3 года назад +3

    Great info. I had the experience of firing a Whitworth about 45 years ago. The most memorable part was the recoil. Firing in a standing position, it lifted my leading foot off the ground.

  • @natedorney7032
    @natedorney7032 5 лет назад +13

    Union Major General John F. Reynolds was felled on the first day's fight at gettysburg by a confederate sharpshooter. And let's not forget about another union corp commander at spotsylvania courthouse, Major General John Sedgwick in 1864 who chided his men when the rebel sharpshooters were making it rather hot for the yankees. No sooner than he had said his famous quip of "they couldn't hit an elephant at that distance" to a cowering soldier, he fell dead by a round from one of those rifles aimed in his direction.

    • @FIREBRAND38
      @FIREBRAND38 4 года назад

      No evidence a Whitworth did it

  • @vulcandawg7623
    @vulcandawg7623 5 лет назад +3

    Adjusted for inflation... this rifle would be a about $30,422... and some change.
    Its no wonder only the best sharpshooters got them...

    • @SwornHeresy
      @SwornHeresy 5 лет назад

      Wow it's absolutely incredible how expensive these were.

  • @buckotte1414
    @buckotte1414 8 лет назад +4

    There is a movie ...[somewhere]...that centers around a 'sniper' shot at very long distance. Its a civil war setting. Just one chance to 'kill the general'...as the shot would give away the presence of troops with the sniper. Also, a movie of a youth with a long range rifle, with scope, working vengence from unseen distances.

    • @nolocotendre5229
      @nolocotendre5229 3 года назад

      I recall the 'movie' re the shooting of the General; though I recall it to be a '50s TV program rather than a movie. The sniper remained in concealment for the longest while, waiting for the General to appear. Finally, knowing he was to return to his unit, he fired at his secondary target... just as the General emerged from his tent, to take the round.

  • @rlbadger1698
    @rlbadger1698 9 лет назад +5

    One has to wonder if a step back in time mite not lead to a super performance sniper rifle. Modern rifling scars the projectile and might effect it's performance. A higher spin rate may help. With modern CNC machining and advanced metallurgy we may be able to produce a 50.cal Whitworth type gun. Just a thought.

    • @Lightspit
      @Lightspit 9 лет назад

      +Rl Badger That is a very interesting idea!

    • @rlbadger1698
      @rlbadger1698 9 лет назад

      +Lightspit Well thank you

    • @williamshakespeare4013
      @williamshakespeare4013 8 лет назад

      +Rl Badger
      mite1
      mʌɪt/
      noun
      a minute arachnid which has four pairs of legs when adult, related to the ticks. Many kinds live in the soil and a number are parasitic on plants or animals.

    • @rlbadger1698
      @rlbadger1698 8 лет назад

      +William Shakespeare thank you corected

  • @dockmasterted
    @dockmasterted 7 лет назад +4

    I am so jealous of you getting to shoot that rifle my friend!

  • @51WCDodge
    @51WCDodge 3 года назад +2

    The original Witworth rifles, and the mechanism used by Queen Victoria are in the NRA musuem Bisley. Whitworth built the rifles originally to study ballistics. Four started wit seven foot long barrels and wer etrimmed till optmum performance was achived. In the process developing the mathmatics of small bore ballistics.

  • @jacknifedbl
    @jacknifedbl 10 лет назад +6

    that was an awesome vid!

  • @mountainbearoutdoors
    @mountainbearoutdoors 4 года назад +2

    I have a specially made bayonet for that rifle, it looks the same as most of the 1856 yataghan rifle bayonets of the day but this one has a circular mortise slot that was specific to the 1863 whitworth rifle, fairly hard to come by. my dad gave it to me when he was having a clear out, i asked him why he had it and he told me his mum let him buy one from the junk shop as a kid and he used it to play with and it was used as a fire poker!. its safely mounted on a wall now haha!

  • @claytonstewart8322
    @claytonstewart8322 8 лет назад +3

    THAT is a sniper rifle. Very good video, will be watching more

  • @EvilMerlin
    @EvilMerlin 10 лет назад +2

    Amazing history and fantastic shooting. I just ordered my very first 1861 Special today. I'm looking forward to it.

  • @JB-ym4up
    @JB-ym4up 8 лет назад +3

    You sir have an excellent channel. Have not seen a bad video yet, nor do I expect I will.

  • @louiscifer5438
    @louiscifer5438 6 лет назад +2

    In any case it is a very restrictive rifle, which requires cleaning every 5 shots, at the risk of jamming the ball. The bullet has the shape of the barrel, which makes it more difficult to extract a ball in case of blockage, it does not turn on itself in the barrel like a ball of round shape.
    I made an inertia tool specifically for the extraction of the bullet from this rifle.
    Personally I find it too expensive for its quality, even the paint of the barrel is too thin and scratches at the slightest touch, after 30 shots the sighting bar is gone by itself, the lacquer of the stick is very fragile too .. .
    It is less finished than a Hawken Missouri or a traditional Hawken Pédersoli, which are almost twice cheaper, less restrictive and more reliable.
    Moreover this rifle of "precision" does not even stecher ?! Yet existing at this time ...
    I draw a lot of black powder, I'm not unhappy to have bought this curiosity, but I wonder if I will not sell it again.
    The mold is very expensive and the one that Pedersoli sells makes bullets without a grease groove, the balls are smooth.
    This weapon is for me a curiosity in the history of arms, which pushed me to buy it.
    Personally, I shoot at 100/120 meters, with 60 grs, when all is well I'm still in a C50 target, without diopter, with the basic sighting devices, no better or worse than with my Hawken ...
    Excuse my bad English I do not speak it very well.

  • @normanrea4509
    @normanrea4509 9 лет назад +10

    I enjoy history and black powder weapons. You produce excellent videos on both counts.

  • @SuperWasweissichdenn
    @SuperWasweissichdenn 8 лет назад +1

    In 1862, the Kingdom of Saxony tested a new .45 caliber cavalry carbine whith a whitworth type barrel and a breech loading mechanism made by Malherbe et cie. from belgium. Onfortunately the commission dropped it due to a too weak locking mechanism in favour of the 62 caliber terry carbine.

  • @Boredout454
    @Boredout454 10 лет назад +9

    Ive read about this rifle before and never thought Id see one fired. Great job brother and keep it up man I love your videos. I bet youd have fun here in the US especially Texas, youd have a field day with all of our firearms!

  • @slantsix6344
    @slantsix6344 7 лет назад +1

    There were Confederate regiments of hand-picked Sharpshooters too. The Palmetto Sharpshooters out of South Carolina was one of these regiments. However, the South had so few men to begin with that they put their sharpshooters in with regular infantry regiments.

  • @treatb09
    @treatb09 8 лет назад +9

    100 meters, vs 500 is a massive change.

    • @thomasgibbons353
      @thomasgibbons353 3 года назад

      It is the length of the range on Parris Island.

  • @Valin9275
    @Valin9275 4 года назад +1

    How is it that every single "fact" you mention about the rifle is in complete contradiction with forgotten weapons and other historical firearms channels?

  • @mnpd3
    @mnpd3 5 лет назад +4

    Years ago I was in Knoxville driving somewhere when I saw a historical marker about some Union General killed by a sniper from a distant tower. The tower still stands, and using the car's odometer I drove the distance between the two points..... just under one mile. The clerks and mechanics from the large northern cities never could grasp the danger they were in at great distances from natural-born riflemen who'd been shooting since weaned.

  • @k.w.churchill4397
    @k.w.churchill4397 9 лет назад +18

    Your pulling your face off the rifle too quickly. Hold your face , right there, until the echoes die away....follow through is critical to fine shooting. Other than that. . Slow down...ease into it...Groups will shrink even tighter!! Love you vids!!..Your a smart guy, and a credit to gun collectors everywhere!

    • @SupaSwope
      @SupaSwope 7 лет назад +1

      I agree.

    • @MacCoalieCoalson
      @MacCoalieCoalson 7 лет назад +11

      K. W. Churchill It doesn't really matter, it's a muzzle loading rifle so you have to reposition yourself after every shot anyway.

    • @nicholasrucker1355
      @nicholasrucker1355 7 лет назад

      +Stale Meme that's what you tell yourself when you bite the pillow.

    • @daveybernard1056
      @daveybernard1056 7 лет назад +2

      You'll never be sorry you had good follow thru at the target range.

    • @daveybernard1056
      @daveybernard1056 7 лет назад +2

      follow thru is legit

  • @fastdraw30
    @fastdraw30 6 лет назад +2

    Those sights have always amazed me..the intricacy and mechanical engineering in them are way beyond the times ... fantastic rifle

  • @mbogucki1
    @mbogucki1 7 лет назад +16

    Can't you folks at least put metric conversions in the corner or something so the rest of the civilized world can understand? Thanks.

    • @Rob_Nasty
      @Rob_Nasty 7 лет назад +11

      mbogucki1 civilized? fucking please... U.S. LEADS the world in just about EVERY category.... from stupid shit like Silicon Valley (aka Apple, Droid, Drones, technology) even too our Culture.. Every country copys the U.S... Why do you think so many people choose to leave terible countries like Australia or UK. Cause your governments are run by CUCKS.

    • @mbogucki1
      @mbogucki1 7 лет назад +28

      So salty. Did I hurt your ego?
      I guess whatever makes you sleep at night buddy.

    • @capusvacans
      @capusvacans 7 лет назад +14

      If only you were nr 1 in education, then you wouldn't be spouting such nonsense.

    • @XtreeM_FaiL
      @XtreeM_FaiL 7 лет назад +1

      bulg7430 From which country?

    • @XtreeM_FaiL
      @XtreeM_FaiL 7 лет назад +7

      mbogucki1 That gun is older than metric or SI system, so conversion would be stupid.

  • @mrpirate3470
    @mrpirate3470 5 лет назад +2

    Amazing rifles thank you for posting this. Aside from the price issues the only main problem was they were very susceptible to fouling after a relatively low number of shots, far more so than a normal rifle/musket. This made them very unsuitable for general issue

  • @828enigma6
    @828enigma6 4 года назад +1

    If the Confederates had a thousand skilled snipers, each armed with a Whitworth, the American Civil War could easily have had a different outcome.

  • @Vo_d_kontra_o_norMAL
    @Vo_d_kontra_o_norMAL Год назад +1

    Hey tell me what you guess - is harder to a third world home gunsmith build a modern pointy bullet kind of sniper weapon or a oldschol exagonal bullet sniper rifle ?

  • @dutchschultz3076
    @dutchschultz3076 3 года назад +1

    Its nice to hear a foreigner talking about USA civil war, instead of another country, he also knows more about the us civil war than half of Americans.

  • @Manbunmen65
    @Manbunmen65 4 года назад +1

    What he didn't say is to hit a target at 1800 yards with the whitworth you aimed at 5 imaginary vertical full moons for hold over. 1000 yards was only 3.

  • @highvelocity6529
    @highvelocity6529 3 года назад +2

    One of the greatest and genius inventions in firearms history 👌

  • @jimsmith7445
    @jimsmith7445 8 лет назад +2

    Loved the video! I enjoyed knowing the information behind it ! Interested in seeing more videos... especially about sniping and the American civil war.

  • @MrCantStopTheRobot
    @MrCantStopTheRobot 7 лет назад +2

    An informative video, calmly and competently presented. Excellent work!

  • @leightodd7335
    @leightodd7335 10 лет назад +2

    Good job as usual! I really like your including history, shooting, and family. Thanks again and keep up the good work.

  • @Dephy
    @Dephy 5 лет назад +2

    It this Littlefingers Hungarian gun loving cousin?

  • @bobs3060
    @bobs3060 3 года назад +1

    The shooter looks like Richard Harrow from Boardwalk Empire

  • @southronjr1570
    @southronjr1570 7 лет назад +1

    You can solve the problem of the hammer recocking itself by swapping nipples, if that doesn't work you will need a heavier main spring, but am pretty sure that is your problem, I recomend ampco birilium nipples. These are what I use on all of my competition guns. This will also have the added affect of making chamber pressures more consistent, thus shrinking group size. I say this not as an armchair gunsmith, but as a 20+ year veteran gunsmith/competitor in the North-South Skirmish Assoc. (www.n-ssa.org)

  • @joachimsingh2929
    @joachimsingh2929 3 года назад +1

    Still haven't seen any proof of a 1000 yard shot being possible. And his grouping @ 100 yards was horrible if you multiply it with what it would be at 1000 yards. A similar grouping might be possible if it was fastned to a stand and used precision bullets with a weighed amount of powder. No way josê that he would be able to see his target as some people in the comments say "up to 2km" ehrm no... This is a black powder gun..

    • @CocoonClub360
      @CocoonClub360 3 года назад

      1000 yard = 914,4 Meter hit???! With these old school Rifles?

  • @cerberaodollam
    @cerberaodollam 3 года назад +2

    Holy damn it's weird to hear my accent from someone else.
    Also, now I want one of these.

  • @PistaZOV
    @PistaZOV 6 лет назад +1

    furcsa volt amikor egyszerre csak kimondtad a neved

  • @BeezerWashingbeard
    @BeezerWashingbeard 6 лет назад +1

    Nagyszerű videó! Mire van szüksége a lőfegyverek magyarországi tulajdonlásához és üzemeltetéséhez?

  • @arkanilmasawungrana3730
    @arkanilmasawungrana3730 4 года назад +1

    So Littlefinger plays guns right now.

  • @828enigma6
    @828enigma6 5 лет назад +1

    There is a book "Jack Hinson's One Man War", a factual story about a 60 year old man in Kentucky whose two early teen sons were murdered by Yankee troops. Although he had tried to stay neutral in the war, he went rogue. He commissioned a 50 caliber sniper rifle to be built, very similar to the Whitworth but without the hexagonal bore. He killed over 100 Yankees before the War ended. This without being a Confederate soldier or receiving any support from them. It's a very good book and I strongly suggest reading it.

  • @soopcan4980
    @soopcan4980 3 года назад

    No joke, the front sight looks EXACTLY like the air rifles we shoot for competition

  • @southronjr1570
    @southronjr1570 10 лет назад +1

    While you have a great gun and are very well informed I would like to suggest to you of a problem I noticed with your lock. It looks like you may be using #10 or #11 caps with a modified nipple on the rifle. It looks like you may need to replace the nipple because if there is enough pressure blowing your hammer back, the flash cone at the bottom of the nipple is too large and will send the cap fragging into the direction of your eyes. I recommend you replace the nipple with one that uses Musket size caps which is a much hotter cap and is what the rifle was designed to shoot with. S&S firearms out of New York has one that will fit your Parker-Hale. I believe the part number will be EN76.
    I have been shooting American Civil War muskets in competition since 1995 and have been building them since 1997. My father and I build and accurise these type of weapons for N-SSA competitions and between the two of us have over 60 years experience with them. We have seen the issue with the hammer being blown back dozens of times and a burned out nipple is the culprit 99% of the time. The other item that can cause it is a weak mainspring with a marginal nipple.
    If you would like to see what we do please go to www.n-ssa.org to see a demonstration and explanation of our sport. I am commander of the 24th GVI in the Carolina region and if you wish you can contact me through there or look on the bulletin board and speak with some who have more experience than I. Good luck and keep your powder dry.

  • @joeboden8898
    @joeboden8898 3 года назад +1

    Simply amazing that I randomly ran into your fascinating video after watching Jack Hinson the most
    Deadly Sniper of Civil war hashtag'
    I'm an Tennesseans and didn't know
    The History behind Jack Hinson and
    How it came about' Jack Hinson was neutral in the Civil war until his
    Two innocent young sons were executed by union Soldiers for Bush wacker and the heads cut cut off and left on Father's fence post"
    Mr. Hinson ordered a 50 cal hand custom made Rifle, from a Farmer
    Too one of the greatest Soutnern
    Sniper of his Era"

  • @davebarrowcliffe8539
    @davebarrowcliffe8539 6 лет назад +2

    I live in Manchester. Home of Whitworth. There is a main street named after him and an art gallery.

    • @kinkong1961
      @kinkong1961 5 лет назад

      that's probably why gardener engines kept on using whitworth nuts and bolts when most engine manufactures had gone to UNC or metric as they are based in Manchester as well

  • @kellypaws
    @kellypaws 6 лет назад +1

    Historical background shots of a beautiful old rifle, target shooting. It's got it all. What a great video. I'm furious at RUclips that they now penalise people like Cap and Ball, making great historical videos. This has nothing to do with gun violence, it's just a great video.

  • @Lucas-nh2mk
    @Lucas-nh2mk Год назад +1

    Beautifull rifle and test,whats speed bullet?

  • @ihateyankees3655
    @ihateyankees3655 5 лет назад +1

    The Confederate States bought a bunch of those rifles and used them to great effect to target union officers and artillery crews. One of them even made the list for longest recorded sniper kills.

  • @iduswelton9567
    @iduswelton9567 6 лет назад +1

    Very interesting vids and shooting of weapons from the past-my godfather was a collector of old weapons-from flintlocks to ww2 -my favorite was a 68cal halfstocks and the 7.92mm Mauser made in 1939

  • @SlickSixguns
    @SlickSixguns 5 лет назад +1

    Thanks for the video as always great story telling along with execution of action shots

  • @charliesebbage9401
    @charliesebbage9401 4 года назад +1

    Your hunglish is very good my friend, not many English speak Hungarian but trying to learn, stay safe

  • @troy9477
    @troy9477 7 лет назад +1

    Nice. I know a little bit about these from a few gunzine articles over the years. I had forgotten all about the hexagonal bullet design. Didn't know they were so expensive back then- that explains a lot. Thanks for the presentation.

  • @turbowolf302
    @turbowolf302 7 лет назад +2

    I feel I should put out there for any shooters of Whitworth rifles out there, that my great uncle, Robert T. Hayley Jr, makes custom cartridges for obsolescent calibers. He has no website, but if you google search his name, you will find his phone number there. He advertises in the likes of Shotgun News/Firearms News.

    • @Turtletanks
      @Turtletanks 7 лет назад

      Bee H. Hope he has luck finding customers. How’s his business doing?

    • @baronjphellingtonesq9636
      @baronjphellingtonesq9636 6 лет назад

      Bee H. Make him a cheap website for xmas.

  • @adrianlarkins7259
    @adrianlarkins7259 10 лет назад +1

    Very interesting. If the hexagonal bullet had so many advantages, as it surely did, why was it not produced in greater numbers for the army sharp shooters. Judging from what you said, the principal could even be useful today. I assume the cost of manufacture is the fly in the ointment.

    • @amperzand9162
      @amperzand9162 9 лет назад +1

      +Adrian Larkins The main method of making hexagonal barrels, as I understand it, was to make hexagonal tubes, then twist them with a very high level of precision, which is obviously slightly hard to accomplish in the 1860s.

  • @steelgila
    @steelgila 8 лет назад +1

    An hexagonal bullet! Who'd 'ave known! Thanks, what an amazing piece of firearms history I didn't know.

  • @rogerhudson9732
    @rogerhudson9732 6 лет назад +1

    I used to shoot at Hythe in the 1970s/80s, great place, great history.

  • @prasadsavara2845
    @prasadsavara2845 3 года назад +1

    Super.... from.andrapradesh

  • @mchamburgerslice2870
    @mchamburgerslice2870 5 лет назад +1

    It is amazing how good and surprisingly cool and old gun like this is, even though most old guns are cool, this gun has quite neat sights that seem to work rather well for the time period, making this a very cool old weapon, great video

  • @aaronhiggs
    @aaronhiggs 3 года назад +1

    My Great Great Great Grandfather Jesse Stanfield went to battle in the Civil War with a .451 whitworth. In his journal , when his dad sent him to war, he was given it as his father wanted his son to be equipped with the best rifle in the world at that time. Till his dying day he kept that rifle and at his funeral , they buried him with it. Great video!

    • @KingAnarchist
      @KingAnarchist Год назад +1

      Iiiiiinteresting….how many Jesse Stanfields could there have been in the Civil War? Not many I’d imagine. Now just the matter of tracking down his burial site and…well…a guy’s gotta make a buck 😅😅😅

  • @RandomAussie-dx9fj
    @RandomAussie-dx9fj Год назад +1

    Hexagons are bestagons

  • @SvenTviking
    @SvenTviking 7 лет назад +1

    He also invented the first standardised screw thread.

  • @leightodd7335
    @leightodd7335 7 лет назад +1

    My uncle has one of these. It was used in long range contest into the 1960's

  • @ConspicuousPeach
    @ConspicuousPeach 7 лет назад +2

    0:16-0:17 favorite part

  • @slinkerdeer
    @slinkerdeer 4 года назад

    Pause at 4:58, if you ignore the flinklock mechanism it looks like a WW2 era firearm. Such an advanced piece of weaponry for its time

  • @especialistascopus3776
    @especialistascopus3776 2 года назад +1

    Very Good my Friend

  • @DarthDimmadome
    @DarthDimmadome 4 года назад +1

    You are now pregnant

  • @dieudonne2514
    @dieudonne2514 10 лет назад +2

    It's a cool video, Thanks.