Best Cordless Multitool Head-to-Head
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 июн 2024
- Oscillating Multitool Shootout
ToolBoxBuzz Article: www.toolboxbuzz.com/head-to-h...
Performance Testing (Power/Speed) in Wood - Winner Milwaukee In this test, we used the jig to test each tool's cutting speed through 3/4 plywood. Three runs were performed for each tool and their times were averaged. Milwaukee came in first place with an average of just 4.18 seconds per cut. Milwaukee claims to have the fastest cutting saw and from what we saw in testing, their tool delivers on that promise. The second and third-place finishers were Ryobi with a 6.11 average cut time and Dewalt with a 6.11 cut time. Both these tools cut through the material exceptionally well. The rest of the rankings can be found in the following chart. Winner of Metal Cutting - Milwaukee The fastest cutting tool was again the Milwaukee at 17.06 seconds, followed by the Ryobi at 26.61 seconds and the Dewalt in third at 28.68 seconds. Perhaps the biggest surprise of the bunch was the Ryobi, dethroning all but one tool in the performance rankings. As the lowest cost option of the group, the Ryobi boasts some serious cutting prowess. Best Features - Winner FLEX It's never easy to compare tool features from different brands. The entire team used all of the tools in a variety of cutting configurations and tests to rate four separate features on these saws on a scale of one to five. [With 1 being the best] we looked at: 1. Blade Change 2. LED Light 3. Decoupling 4. Variable Speed The number one slot for features went to the newcomer, the FLEX Multitool with 8-points. FLEX had the best wraparound LED light coverage, excellent vibration decoupling and scored second in blade change and third in its variable speed adjustment. A close second place went to Milwaukee with 9-points. The Milwaukee has low cutting vibration, excellent LED, and variable speed with auto-setting. Third place was a three-way tie [10-points] with both FEIN tools and the Festool Multitool. These tools were extremely smooth cutting [low-vibe] and, along with the Bosch, sported the best style blade clamps and blade changing system. Ergonomics Winner - Fein 700 Our pro team members evaluated each tool under a simulated/real-world test setup. Materials cut included drywall, clapboard, plywood, pine trim, baseboard freehand, and a "splice" jig. We also used the tools to free-hand cut 16D common nails and drywall screws. In laymen’s terms, ergonomics is the interface between the user and the tool. How’s it feel when using it? For this ergonomic section, we considered the following factors, rating them 1 thru 5. [1 being best] • Grip • Vibration • Balance Regardless of how fast a multitool cuts, the less vibration it produces, the better. Some multitools employ some sort of decoupling system to reduce vibration. The FEIN 700 multitool scored tops in balance and came in at 2-points for vibration and balance. Second place was a tie between the FEIN 500 and the Festool - both scoring 2nd place in all three categories. Third place went to Milwaukee and was noted well balanced. Noise - Winner FEIN 500 OSHA allows 8 hours of exposure for up to 90 dB, for exposures 95dB and greater, the exposure limits drop dramatically. So clearly these saws all need hearing protection. We used a fixed Decibel Meter to measure these multi-tools in the following workshops tests and ranked them on that average score: 1. No-load 2. Metal cutting 3. Woodcutting The quietest saw was the FEIN 500 averaging at 106.5 decibels followed by the Metabo at 106.7 decibels and the FLEX at 106.8. Best Cordless Multitool Winner -Milwaukee The competition for the best cordless multitool went to Milwaukee M18 FUEL multitool, with 19-points. Milwaukee crushed its competitors in the controlled wood and metal testing rig. It scored well in the accuracy and features sections coming in 2nd place in both and taking third place in ergonomics. Second place went to the FLEX multitool, with 24-points, which surprised the team. The FLEX is a feature-rich tool and came in first in that section. Scoring second in accuracy and third in the decibel testing, the FLEX solidly secured its position as the second-best tool in the testing. It was also the fourth-fastest cutting tool in metal. Third place went to the Festool with 26-points. The Festool came in first for accuracy, second in ergonomics, and third in features rankings. Festool has the best blade clamp of the top three contenders and is a top-tier, easy-to-use, and intuitive saw.
Join this channel to get access to perks: / @concordcarpenter
#fein #flex #makita #boschtools #dewalt #ryobi #ridgidtool #milwaukeetools 
Хобби
*** UPDATE ***
Guys - several of you pointed out that we used the wrong model in our price comparison. I redid the video to reflect the correct model/cost. You guys are sharp - thanks for catching that so early! ROB
50 dollars or so did seem crazy.
@@orijimi I want to be accurate so it was worth removing and editing. Thanks! ROB
@@orijimi HD has the Milwaukee with battery and charger for $99
@@Dirtyharry70585 That’s the non fuel version. Not the tool they tested, and not worth buying because the m12 fuel is a better tool than the old edition m18.
I think the Ryobi price is wrong too. I think the one you tested was actually the PBLMT50B (One+ HP). But you reference the P343B. The one you tested is $99.
As usual, the best head to head evaluations around.
In terms of youtube reviews and tests, you most certainly are professionals.
Spectacular work
As always - best review with all the big brands included. You guys are one of the few channels where I watch ALL your reviews. Thanks
I've been looking forward to this. Love the comprehensive head to head tests, because it is something very few people have the opportunity to do.
Rob, you guys do a stellar job. So informative and helpful, you’re the best channel at what you do. Thanks!
Thank you so much for all the time and effort you put into these tests.
This video is THE BEST review that I have ever seen about a Multitool. It showed the best tools in the market, reason for scores and it was by far extremely well edited and narrated. Above and beyond work that was done here!
I saw the sneak peak the other day and couldn't wait for the real thing. Thanks for your hard work and dedication that's why I subscribed to this channel
Bravo Team! I've watched this twice already. Incredible work, efforts and Data! 👍👍👍
Forgone conclusion for me, already on the Milwaukee platform. It's a guilty pleasure to watch your test, keep up the good work 👍
Thanks for the work guys! Been very happy with my Milwaukee FUEL, love the power!
You guys are amazing. I’ve bought so many tools from your recommendations and test. Cheers 🍻
Thank you for doing what you do! I wish you guys wealth and happiness!
Thank you for all your effort making this video, appreciate it.
Milwaukee has come along way. They have never let me down. Very good tools. Thanks for the comparison test. It will does help people to make good decisions in buying future tools for there shops or diy jobs.
Thank you for your effort and showing what is best without the worry of losing advertisers.
I really don’t understand how anyone can actually dislike these videos
Excellent and thorough review. Thanks!!!
These are great. Always love these especially when you are in the market
Very good review, well spoken, well explained, good tests. Definitely helped me choose my future OMT 🔥👌🏻
Rob and Crew: Very precise testing, and ranking. Your work is definitely appreciated!
I love you in-depth and unbiased reviews. I watch all of these even if I don’t plan on buying the tool you are reviewing.
@@dahut3614 What are you seven?
Wow the amount of work behind this video its incredible mikwaukee multi tool is crazy
I love that you guys threw in the flex. As always I trust you to give me honest opinions from real pros.
Another absolutely excellent video guys!
Thank you so much for doing these videos. You guys are awesome.
Thanks from a newcomer into DIY! I appreciate that you did your work with these multi tools, so I didn’t have to!! Taking your advice and getting one of the top three.
Fantastic evaluations! Thorough and well designed tests. Also, Rob does a great job at speaking clearly and succinctly. I’ll definitely be watching other tool reviews from your site. 👍👍👍
Thank you! Please subscribe and click on that notification bell. It notifies you when we publish a video and helps our ranking
I agree John. Their testing and videos are head and shoulders above most others. My favorite ovverall.
Another great review! Always come here when I’m looking to buy a new tool
Thanks
Nice testing rig ! The best way to do the proper testing!
I have multiple Batteries for Ryobi and Milwaukee so its a no brainer. I will get the Milwaukee. A neighbor borrowed my corded Dewalt Multitool but not the bag and kit for it to cut away a door Jamb and denies ever seeing it among the tools borrowed. I love their family and will not complain too much but they will never be granted access to my shop. Ryobi is fine but I am a true Blue Milwaukee guy. Ryobi dollar for dollar is a great value,
Fantastic review, fellas.
Such a great vid! Thanks for the effort and expertise! Subscribed
This test is awesome.
I have the Dewalt XR and been pretty happy with it. It seems to have done well in most tests except vibration.
Great work, thank you!
Amazing comparation, thanks!
Thank you - you guys do a great job
Thanks for the edit/update Rob! I wish the fuel was that much I'd probably buy another for my small crew.
Awesome episode, guys! thanks for posting! :D
Love the Videos you make, keep them coming
Great work. Thanks for the info.
best reviews around, period!
Great comparision.
Ive been waiting for these type of videos 👍👍
had the dewalt for years and just switched to the new Milwaukee.
i miss the dewalt , that variable speed trigger makes it a scalpel. the Milwaukee is like a caffinated sawzall.
Thanks again for the videos!
Hey Rob I'm still waiting for a updated hammer drill and impact head to head whenever you guys can get to it. These Head to head videos are the reason I subscribed to this channel. I know it takes time and hard work but it's worth it and I can't wait to see it
Thanks for the I depth comparison. This might be the nail in the coffin for my Ridgid system. I’ve been thinking about stepping up to Milwaukee already. I have the previous generation of the Ridgid oscillating tool and while it’s great to have this tool for the batteries I have, it’s a nightmare. Bounces around, overheats, etc.
Awesome well done!
This is a really incredible video. I'm not a contractor. I'm a homeowner and I own zero tools (well not really, I have a full woodshop of antique hand tools--I have no powertools). I needed a multi-tool for a small job and I wanted the best option. I think one thing this comparison doesn't really consider is the tool brand eco-system. I was buying into a new system, buying my first ever battery and charger. Because of this, I decided on the DeWalt. I would have loved the Milwaukee, but looking at the cost, and the cost of their other tools, it seemed to make sense to go with DeWalt--all their tools are 10-50% less in cost, and also well regarded and sell well on used markets. I hope I made the right choice!
Nice to see flex in there. Thanx guys!
Wow awesome job. Looking to buy into a cordless system, this helps immensely.
thank you
Loved this. Thanks.
Awesome video, thank you so much
I watch you guys and VCG construction for my buying decisions. I got to give it up to yuns, you provide the most accurate, legitimate, what can these tools do testing. I'm sure many hours went into setting this review up. Great work.
Thx brother
Performance testing is great, i love these videos and they are helpful. I wish you could test quality and how long they last. A tool is an investment. Construction tools go through hell and a tool that last is important. I would buy one with less features and mid range performance if i know its gona last longer
I own the Milwaukee and it is a beast!
Thank you sr
I always love your reviews. Unfortunately I have been in the Ridgid Battery lineup for years. All no the best I have to many to change now. I do like the Milwaukee tools.
For me, the only tools in this test i would are the ones that can take starlock max. So feil, festool or makita(maybe flex also but i live i europe so...). The system has much better transmission of power and can take longer blades and it Will last alot longer. In the future this will become the standard like sds has become. With the longer blades you get more movement, from the oscilation and better cuttingspeed. I don't think this is pointed out or tested here.
But i must say, i love your h2h test and all the other stuf you do at Toolbox buzz.
Thanks for your hard work👍
Again guys another great test, I am vested in Makita so I was a little disappointed that it did, int do better which really speaks to how much competition there is in the cordless tool industry right now, I ve been using Makita since the 1970,s and the cordless drills since the early 1980,s and they have always "Paid for themselves" .
Since I have other Makita 18V max tools I would like to get Makita also. Any regrets? For general purpose renovations. Should I get a corded instead?
You can get a battery adapter so you can run a DeWalt or Milwaukee tool with Makita battery or vice versa. I run DeWalt but Makita has some very refined and very unique tools. So to make that jump I just buy the coffee maker and adapter hook my DeWalt battery and I am happy
I've had the corded Ridgid for years and use it almost daily....what the heck did we do before the multi tool. I know I swore alot more before the multi tool.
Thanks
It's remarkable how closely the final ranking for these tools matches Project Farm's rankings, even given how different the relative speeds are for some of the tools. The Ryobi was lower here than on PF but other than that it was almost spot on
Love this! You should do a collaboration with Project Farm-should make for an interesting head-to-head video.
Great video it's been 6 days since this was posted not a single dislike on the video you guys are unmatched when it comes to tool testing
Thanks Al
In-depth review as always. Won't be unhappy getting the new Milwaukee when my old one gives up.
Take a look at the new Milwaukee M12 Fuel Multi-Tool. I like it a lot. It’s very powerful,low vibration and light weight. I like it much more than the Dewalt XR Multi-Tool, which I gave to my son.
@@martylucas8557 agree, love my m12. think the blade change could be better, but it's a small complaint for me personally
Ryobi banging em out. I'm happy with my 12v milwaukee and 18v ryobi hp decision.
Holy shit, the milwaukee is loud asf in idle stance. Decibels are in logarithmic scale, 3dB higher means twice as loud and that hold true for every next 3dB step. From makita to Milwaukee that's a freaking massive difference!
Your information is good and useful
Loved this head-to-head! Thanks for doing another amazing job!
Dang, I could have used this tool 30 years ago. Glad I now have one.
Works as designed
Awesome job Rob…. I’ve got both the Dewalt and Milwaukee M12 fuel multi tools…..
I have the Milwaukee M18 and the Festool, 2 great devices. I find the Festool the most pleasant to work with.
hearing damage is cumulative your whole life long and can occur in just 30 seconds of exposure at 115 decibels. thanks for making this important metric part of your testing.
Still going strong with the reviews guys, great job and thanks. The only thing I would recommend you consider is maybe providing a recommendation/comment for which tool would be suit the main trades. But otherwise really enjoy your reviews.
I got the Flex and love it. The Dewalt variable speed trigger is nice till it starts glitching after a couple years
Own 3 tools on the bosch 18v system but won"t be getting the gop 28 , i"ll stick with my 40-30 corded , good vid :)
I like the dewalt xr but I’ve used the Milwaukee m12 and it seems the vibration was less
The advantage of starlock vs OIS (pins) is that you can run longer blades that woukd break the pins on OIS platform. I have the bosch which is better built than makita and totally solid. Only downside is the straight battery i.e. no kink up at end.
Awesome - thx!
TTI knows how to make a great multi tool. I have the m12 fuel and I can gaurantee it would've been top 3 in the cutting speed and vibration tests even as a 12v tool
Great review as always. I really appreciate how comprehensive and solid your testing is for these H2H. One thing I was disappointed wasn't mentioned was the very useful accessories available for the Festool OSC18. I have both it and the Milwaukee, and when it comes to precision work, especially for trim carpentry, I reach for it every time. Add the dust shroud, depth stop, and plunge guide, and it's on a whole other level compared to the others. Sure, it's not as fast and powerful like the Milwaukee, which I also have and use primary for demo and exterior work, but it is smooth, precise and easy on the hand.
No one touched Festool in accessories, not much of a contest there
@@ConcordCarpenter That's true. However, the fact that they exist and are significant accessories could have definitely added some points in favor of precision/usability categories. Granted, they are extras and add to the cost. Bit, it really does set the OSC18 on another level IMHO.
But again, overall a great review. Your data in these H2H often factor heavily into buying decisions for my little carpentry business and are incredible. Keep it up!
@@j.thewoodcraftninja3918 I just remembered my Flex has a depth stop that I should test out. I am not impressed with the Festool accuracy and think the Flex has out gun it. Milwaukee and accuracy does go hand in hand
Joshua, have you ever seen a Festool OMT outside a cabinet shop or trim carpenter's(who's invested elsewhere in Festool) tools? They're not marketed to the common man. I like the way that Rob and his team didn't give Festool extra points for an area that most people will never venture into.
Terrific video. Thanks for all of the great content. But I did notice you had the Milwaukee 2626-20 tool in your ‘Over-all best’ table. When I pull up that tool it shows the non-FUEL model. Did your test include the 2626-20 (non-FUEL) model or the 2636-20 which I believe is the FUEL model? Thanks again for putting out such terrific and helpful videos. A++
Rob, enjoyed the video wish you mentioned something about the blade length options.
I owned the DeWalt without the speed change, and used the new Milwaukee
My boss bought me a vecturo when he broke my DeWalt that was 7 years old.
The ability to use starlock max blades is huge, and makes these tools insanely more useful for troublesome hard to reach cuts in awkward spots.
I absolutely hated the blade change on the Milwaukee and preferred a 7 year old DeWalt to it in real life applications.
Still currently hate the location of the power switch on the festool and accidentally turn off while using regularly
My biggest gripe with the Dewalt is the crazy vibration and the fact that you have a trigger. If I am correct all the other tools are turned on and can be used in any position except the Dewalt because the trigger has to be held on while in operation.
The dewalt has 3 speed settings that can be locked on each speed so it has the best of both worlds dewalt for the win
Now I understand why it has been soooo hard to buy Imperial Blade iBoat360, you bought them out for this testing. (your forgiven), since you know, the quality found in every blade.
Excellent test with a wide range of Multi-tools and tests some very impressive.
I bought the DeWalt years ago and it's been great but I'm already to invested in the yellow to change now haha. I love tool comparisons so much competition out there.
No reason to change , dewalt makes the best tools for framing, construction, finish work. Milwaukee is for plumbing, hvac and mechanics allow dewalt 12v is catching up.
@@jncn1490 How is the 12V? I only have 20V, I heard good things but haven't pulled the trigger on any.
@@Gunfreak451 love my 12v gear. However with the new powerstack batteries not sure there is any point to 12v anymore.
You guys have amazing tool head to head reviews. I think it would be valuable if you guys kept a running total on your website of which manufacturers scored 1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc. in an attempt to find out which is the best overall tool brand to go with if you were looking to buy into a new battery platform from scratch.
Who owns only one battery platform? There are also battery adapters available in the aftermarket. Buy the "best" tool in the category that you are shopping.
@@pheloniousmunk I would imagine that a LOT of people only own one battery platform. I have an extremely well fitted shop, and I still have tools from only 2 companies, with 1 of the 2 companies being only a few tools that aren't offered by the main company.
@@Subsonic-cd2en Ironic that you're replying to my question of who owns only one battery platform by telling me that you have two. 🤣 You get it....but you're denying it.
Thank you for good testing and analysis. Very informative for armature first multitool buyer like me. Unfortunately, for me, I find this report 2 days after I placed an order to BOSCH, DIY 18V model. I will check your report next too I consider to buy. However, I am Japanese user and buying mostly from Japanese market.
FYI, some of the information on the Makita was for XMT03 but it looks like you tested the newer XMT04. The price chart in the video and some info on your website (e.g. 3.2 degrees vs 3.6 are also mixed up)
Great test, I just noted that Ryobi is not $49 bare tool. The P343B model you listed is an older brushed model.
Darn I own the newest Skil and a Kobalt that is a couple years old. Was so hoping they'd be on here. I think they'd compare well, especially the Skil. Another great video guys!
Honestly they don't compare
@@rickyperkins232 Well I was just being polite. They're actually more than comparable and are better than most, especially the Skil. I know the Skil is better than the DeWalt which ranked high. The Kobalt is on par with the DeWalt. The tool/battery for these are near half the price of the Milwaukee and DeWalt. So it was a mistake to not include these two really good, more economic tools.
Thank you. You guy's make my life easier. It not easy to make a choice when you already have multi brand platform 😅😅. Makita ,Dewalt and Milwaukee. Thanks again. Awesome video..
Thanks for the comments
If you want the absolute best tools for the job it is impossible to use only one brand. I am using Milwaukee, Flex and I use Ridgid wet dry vacuum and their 12" miter saw because it goes up to 70°
I'm in the same boat but also have Metabo/HPT in addition to the Makita, DeWalt, and Milwaukee. As always, these TBB HTH tests are very insightful and useful.
@@pheloniousmunk just picked up a DeWalt drywall gun kit. I tried a few other including Ridgid and Milwaukee and was surprised how comfortable and easy this gun felt in my hands so I just added yet another manufacturer. Lol.
@@rickyperkins232 it's a vicious affliction!
I luv the Milwaukee 12V fuel but converted one of our Metabo HPT over to the triangle detail sander and it absolutely shines and eats up wood
For $79 it outperforms some all of my other detail sander including our new 12V Milwaukee which is also nice but not as powerful in sanding
For anyone who has trouble with the Matabo HPT blade change, if you use open back blades there is a sweet spot with the pin where it can be lose enough to get the blades in and out without using the unlock collar and still have the blade be tight. It can be a pain to get the pin set in the right spot but once you do blade changes a quite fast. I opinion on the tool is that it is well made and a good value, but the more expensive offerings from other brands are better. I got mine on sale at Lowes with the 18v framing nailer for $300, I would not buy it on it's own.
I love the review(s).
Thanks for this bit of info - helpful!,,
Great video love your reviews! can I please get a link to wherever you’re buying that M18 multitool bare tool for $109.
no need to apologize for not being a professional testing company , which by the way i would wonder if there is a bias , you guys are just like us in the field everyday using the tool not testing the tool . Great comparison , i have the festool and dewalt . i think the festool has less vibration .