Randy Does Not Like Being Told No
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 сен 2024
- #JCSInspired #Interrogation
This Video Is For Educational Purposes. It is meant to show how police interact with criminals to try and get their confession.
In the JCS Inspired Interrogation, we take a look at the case of Randy Herman. After telling detectives that he cant remember what he did but he can remember the moments before and after, the detectives must figure out exactly what happened.
BECOME A MEMBER AND SHOW EVERYONE HOW YOU SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL BY RECEIVING A SPECIAL BADGE NEAR YOUR NAME IN THE COMMENT SECTION. LINK BELOW...
/ @redtreecrime
CHECK OUT OUR SECOND CHANNEL. WORKING ON OUR FIRST VIDEO
/ @redtreestories
WE NOW HAVE MERCHANDISE
my-store-c460c...
DONATIONS TO HELP SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL
cash.app/$RedT...
I hope you enjoy our take on this case. It has been referred to as "The Sleepwalker" case but strangely enough, Randy never once mentions sleepwalking as the cause of his crime. In fact, it was his mother, who he was very close with who claimed sleepwalking. I would love to hear your thoughts on this case, was it sleepwalking or could Randy not stand the thought of losing her?
He didn't want to be without her. It's the "if I can't have you no one will". Poor young girl she was headed off to start a new life. So sad 😕
I don't think his love for her was a secret. They move to a different state together to live in the same home, they pass their free time together and no girlfriends for years. No way she didn't knew he was in love. He the perfect example of the nice guy who get friendzone and use as a simp than dump.
@@WhiteHazee You sound like an expert in this area.
@@WhiteHazee Yeah, because the 'nice guy' always murders the girl he loves.
This is fascinating and frustrating but I really appreciate your work so that we could see it. Thank you!
I have a sneaking suspicion that he wasn't this whimpering, mumbling, pathetic mess of an overgrown toddler when he was heinously murdering that poor girl.
Good point. You're probably exactly right!
Exactly. He`s playing a game here.
@@fredajordan5704 maybe he even planned it in advance!
Ofc not, he was a raging drunk
He knows they record interrogations, so he's hoping this pity act will help his defense.
I'm sorry but he gets no empathy from me. Dude kills his roommate because she wasn't into him and then has the nerve to cry about it how disgusting.
I think he's crying because he killed her not because she's not into him. I'm not giving him sympathy just saying he was drunk as shit and killed his best friend. Of course he would be crying
@@jasonbeck1340 I don't think he deserves that. I think it's disgusting and if he really felt bad he would tell them what actually happened instead of running circles with the I can't remembers. He still feels entitled after ending the life of the person he claims to have loved. I wish this was back in the days when her family could return the favor and not be prosecuted. Taking a life deserves a life.
You'd also not give him empathy if he wasn't crying at all and says hes cold blooded. you can just say this person is unredeemable to you, which is an opinion you can have. But don't imply that if he didn't cry, you'd feel empathy then when your statement implies there's nothing the person could do after the fact to get empathy from you. I agree with your disgust with this person but I know it's just how I feel about this person given the short clip I'm seeing of this part of their life but I don't know enough to say they're an unredeemable monster which is where we can differ.
Doesn't get an ounce of sympathy from me either. His crocodile tears aren't following anybody.
He killed an innocent girl because she was moving, these kinds of suspects are so entitled that they believe only they should be able to be with the person they're into otherwise they kill them. It's pathetic and so sad for the victim.
@@mindhackz you said a fact
Crying about his own situation is way different than being remorseful
There was some remorse, albeit largely fake remorse cause he knows he'll spend the rest of his life in a cage!
He literally said "I'm the one that did it, I'm sorry" on the 911 call that he made. Seems pretty remorseful to me.
@@TurribleGamingClips sounds more like he knows he's caught so he's getting ahead of it.
@DrummerJacob so he knows he's caught because he called in on himself to catch himself and that's why he's remorseful??? Cause he caught himself?? You all literally sit back on your thrones and makes stupid opinions. This is why our justice system is so damn well broke.. it's all fun and games and no Redemption and nobody's remorseful crying or not Sorry or not,, until it's you or your family on The Chopping Block..
@@TurribleGamingClipsyou know ppl NEVER accept remorse from anyone 100% of suspects are not remorseful! I’m being a smart Ass b/c all these ppl commenting know EVERYTHING!If you opinion is different than theirs or majority its NEVER acceptable and I’m sure I’ll get backlash saying what a shitty person I am but we are all entitled to our opinion as long as it’s same as others🙄 it’s ridiculous!The whole saying she is alive knowing she is dead puts a card in the defenses hand b/c they canNOT knowingly and lawfully do that
She literally did absolutely nothing to deserve this and was in the presence of someone she's been around thousands of times, and that's terrifying.
I’ve watched way too many true crime videos now to know, when the party starts to get a little crazy, or even if you notice the SLIGHTEST thing off about anyone, get out of the situation ASAP.
@@maar8314 For sure. I'm blessed with the ability of being able to get bad vibes from certain people. But I'm sure there's evil ppl out there able to mask those bad vibes and manipulate even the most intuitive people.
@@martimcfly33 oh I totally agree! It’s a scary world.
Living together it was prob a bf/gf relationship but without the sexual or romantic part. He was happy living that way but not happy for her to leave him It’s the "if I can’t have you, nobody will" thing.
He had a history of trouble, arrests and drinking. Not someone you let move in with you.
Unfortunately this is a grown man that was probably not held accountable his entire life
The way he sat there and spoke in a baby voice was so hard to watch
I feel so very sorry for the young lady and her family
Your right I was thinking roughly the same thing. He kept asking about his mother, it makes me wonder if his mother never let him grow up into the man he should have been.
You’re 100% correct!! The fact his mother made a sleep walking excuse after the police told her that he MURDERED BROOKE is proof right there. No way my Mother would make any excuse for me if she got that call. She would be horrified and help the police with anything she could, even if it was against me. I was punished as a kid & learned life doesn’t always go your way. Poor Brooke & her family.
Facts. Fair warning out there to all the girls, guys you think are your friend might be on some super fuckin weirdo shit deep down
@@bonjovirocks24 same... If my mom was called by the police and told I had murdered a poor girl, she would tell the cops to throw me in the darkest hole they could find and throw away the key. As any upstanding parent should. You can be there for your children and support them in their lives, but if it ever came to them taking another life, there is nothing you can do for them. They made their bed, they will lie in it
@@jamesduncan6729 Exactly!!! You nailed it! I’m glad you were also raised right. It wasn’t always pleasant growing up but we knew the expectations and consequences. That’s what creates functional adults that have dealt with life not going your way, but moving forward without hurting others. ❤to your Mom!!
Take a drink everytime this detective says Randy 😂 and you too can black out.
😂
This is NOT love, it’s obsession. Love would NEVER allow you to hurt that person, no matter how much you don’t want them to go or they don’t return your feelings.
idk, there's diff types of love. lots of toxic types. lots of not toxic types.
Right. It’s an obsessive, “if I can’t have her, no one will”. And the alcohol didn’t help. He should’ve just got a puppy.
Unfortunately people today are not taught love and compassion but rather greed and ownership in relationships. Parents need to step up and teach their kids compassion, love, responsibility and integrity, otherwise they'll just learn crap from their friends and social media.
I don't believe in killing the person you love but love can cause killing as weird as it may sound.
@TikTok -Strange yup when you get so enraged you don't think about tomorrow or even an hour from that point but he had 0 reason to get to that point if they didn't even date lol he knew what their relationship was and was jealous of the dude I'd bet
He didn’t black out. He thought about doing this all that day. He needed the drinks to give him the right state of mind to do such a cowardly act.
It was the next day. He was sober by then.
he may of still been buzzed, he had 30 beers, ive been still drunk after a night of drinking a few times (usually after 2 bottles of wine or more)
You don't know that, so you shouldn't say that. But I guess that's difficult to understand when you're from a 3rd world country
@@tankl.jackson3481 He was drunk the night before. He was sober when he killed her.
Anybody that drinks 30 beers in a day is going to be legally drunk the next day still. I think he was trying to drink himself to death or to knock himself out long enough to not have to say goodbye to Brooke.
Wow when he said “what’s Brooke going to tell me?” His head popped up in shock that she might tell the truth! The look on his face said it all. Bless The detectives for the Incredible patience they showed.
Who's broke
@@2-pistolsya momma
AMEN to that. What a pathetic act he's putting on in that interview room.
Brooke
@@yaboyfrresh😂
I'm guessing that sobbing and croaking in a high-pitched voice worked with his mother, must have been a shock for him that it didn't work with the seemingly sympathetic interrogators
Haha
I doubt it's a strategy, he's just a puss. Tbf, still better than a cold-blooded murderer.
I was thinking the same thing.
Brings Out The Lion In Me I want to Tear Him Apart go to prison and get wats waiting for you
What a leap you made.
It's how he kept saying he was sorry over and over, but did nothing to try to help. The fact that he thinks he deserves a second chance is sickening when Brooke certainly didn't get one.
What he deserves is to ride the lightning
well said, very well said!
This 100%.
His “crying” is insufferable and all.
For some reason all killers are looking for a do over!
And that letter. He still cant take responsibility for his actions. He doesnt look built for jail so fair to say hes having a rough time.
I just found out my stalker who sent detailed rape threats to me and a picture of me outside my house, is my childhood friend, who was like my little brother. He would comfort me about it, offer to come over if I was scared, said he couldn't believe someone would do this right after my parents died and was sad they couldn't be there for me how they wanted to so said he was for them.
We have a case against him, as a result discovered he is doing this to about 30 women, none of us knew, most of us he was comforting, as well.
This doesn't just happen to people in true crime cases you hear about, it happens to you, to me.
Any one of us could've ended up like poor Brooke ❤
Everyone be cautious, have a safety plan even with those you trust.
Crickey! That's terrible! How did you find out? Geez
@@GormTheElder I had gone to the cops and found out my friend was getting similar messages at the exact same times and days as me so I knew it was the same person.
My friend didn't wanna go to the cops so I asked her to send me anything new (not the usual nasty texts, gifs, and voicemails we'd get) so I could give it to my detective or use as clues to find who it was.
He was also trying to help me "figure out who it was" and offering to come over the house if I was scared 😱 😨 since he wanted to "be there for me" since both my parents died the past couple years
So she sent me a voicemail she got from the stalker and I recognized his voice then almost threw up HAHAHA told the cops who said he's more likely to confess to me and that will bolster our case so I confronted him and he admitted it. 😅
Yea ok dr Seuss
Nice story. Nice lie
I'm honestly flattered people think this is a lie haha! Maybe after the case is closed I'll submit my story to some creepy story RUclipsr
Those investigators are very patient. I was frustrated just listening to him answer questions like my 3 year old.
literally S A M E
Yeah, they're focused on the fact that what they say, and can get him to say, in the interrogation might make the difference between first degree murder and some lesser charge by the time he gets out of shock and hides behind an attorney.
I'm sure they'd love nothing more than to tell them what they really think of him, but there'll be plenty of time for that.
Because his mam enabled him as a child to face no accountability when he put on this act. His a psychopath
right imagine telling the guy "no you're not a bad person at all!" after he just murdered someone
OMG!!!! Me too. I wanted to play bad cop so bad.
"I can't do this right now." Probably means, "I'm still dealing with what I've done, need some time for self pity. Also need to think up a way to explain this that does not make me look like a jealous murderer. Plus I need to talk to my mom, she might even be able to explain why this wasn't even my fault."
Good one, you’re exactly right, he’s a man baby that felt entitled somehow? If he doesn’t get at least 25-life there’s something really wrong with our justice system.
@@davidlawson7786 he was convicted in May of 2019 and received life imprisonment
^ This is such an astute way of putting it, nicely done Roboto
Yes, but it’s also very “Keeping up with the Kardashians” that idiotic spoiled diva talk.
@@jamesduncan6729 ty and thank goodness!
When a detective says, "you're not a bad person", you are a bad person.
100% of the time everytime lol
It’s part of the Reid Technique to gain trust and set the criminal at ease. It’s true that when they say those “nice” things, that the interviewee is the prime suspect. The more food and drinks they give a person is also a clue about being them being the prime suspect.
I give the interrogators so much credit. How they can hold themselves back, is beyond me. You guys are phenomenal!
Right! The crybaby voice is IRKING my shit 🙄🙄
I think they held back too much. Should have changed tactics, then they may have got something.
training - they have lots of training
Gaining their trust and being nice to them is part of the technique to getting information. They don't mind.
@@Erebus.666. yup
Good cop bad cop
Had one go in alone be all nice and then come in with 2nd detective and play hardball
The way he played the quiet pitiful victim the entire time made me fill with rage towards this piece of shit. He’s been able to escape accountability his entire life and somehow thinks he can escape this. So delusional.
I think he's genuinely remorseful and can't believe what he himself did. He knows he did it and he can't hide it. He knows his entire life is over. He thoroughly embarrassed himself in front of this girl and his method of handling it, in the state he was in, was to murder her. I don't think I've ever seen an interview with someone so full of regret since that other drunk college student with terrible anger issues beat his ex-girlfriend to death while blacked out.
If a video fills you with rage, please get professional help.
@@canileaveitblank1476 Incredible, some people still have emotions in this day and age, can you imagine
The democrats teach that to them in school, be the victim, cry like a good communist pos 😀
@@canileaveitblank1476 nah because this dude is a scumbag murderer who killed someone’s little girl and I hope he uses that voice with his boyfriend in prison
Imagine thinking your girlfriend is about to move in with you after months of waiting and the day before she was supposed fly out she was murdered by her roommate. Devastating.
Guy is probably super happy he dodged the bullet tbh. Any woman living with a "just friends" male roommate=IMMEDIATE yikes
@@dissraps your insecurity knows no bounds
@@dissraps dude come on really
Yeah waht a letdown
That’s my first thought, they were living long distance and now, the joy and excitement of finally being together. He probably had all kinds of plans for when she got there…omg just imagine 💔💔💔
I can't be this frustrated so early in the morning! I commend these detectives because in between the baby talk, "I don't know," " I can't do this right now," "does my mom know?" is aggrevating. Mom created an entitled man baby who is now out of control! Rest in peace to the young lady 💜
EXACTLY!!!! HIS FUCKING MOMMY CREATED THIS MONSTER. Coddling him his entire life-making sure “those whores” left her precious fat baby boy alone: none were good enough!!
I'm so sowwie Mr powice!
And he thinks that's enough. That he deserves a second chance because he's sowwie.
You're dead right, this is his mom's fault.
@xmisterpilgrimx He probably pulled the baby talk thing with his mum all his life so he's used to doing it when he's in trouble.
His Bud Lights are his baby pacifier and his caterwauling is his baby rattle, so he needs his mommy to rescue him. He’s just a homicidal toddler.
I just googled this guy. His father also had a drinking problem and murdered his girlfriend before taking his own life. Apple doesn't fall far the tree
😳😳😳😳
Neat
wow! that is crazy!
Holy shit! 😳. Thanx 4 the extra info. That’s freaking nuts
Bloody hell!! 😮😮😮
His mother is exactly the reason why he's like this. This dude is the poster child for 'nice guys' that turn out to be total creeps that are possessive over women that aren't interested in them for good reason. I'd bet the victim knew there was something off about him, but was friendly to him because she was a decent human being and felt sorry for him. I'd bet good money that they weren't actually friends, and he just deluded himself into believing they were far closer than they actually were, and that he had told her prior to the murder that he was in love with her and she made it clear she wasn't interested (again, for obviously good reasons), and he's just one of those crazy creeps that thinks that they're entitled to women returning their feelings just because they're a "nice guy" in their head (when in reality, they're the worst kind of people).
100%. That lie that he sleepwalked to granny's house when he was a child, cemented in this guy's mind that he can manipulate ANYONE. This cop is no dummy. His mother should be ashamed of herself for excusing his murder as "sleepwalking".
Wow. This was one of the most interesting interrogation that I've ever seen. The tactic of making him believe Brooke was still alive is both super cruel and brilliant.
It didn't work though . He KNEW she was dead that's why he completely ignored the brilliant tactic , it shut him down so ehhh idk just saying
I doubt there was any cruelty involved, the interrogator was not doing it to cause him pain, he was doing it because it was the practical thing to do. Very professional, and I agree it was brilliant, especially the way he posed the question, almost as if it was a hypothetical, since he had already told him he didn't know if she was still alive.
@@NondescriptMammal cruel as in to talk about the dead like they are still here not because of how he feels
I wish they would have pushed that more. I would have even said she was already talking, on top of, we are looking through phones and talking with friends already
@@Enochulate88 Okay, well maybe I am unclear about what the word cruel means.
Big props to those detectives, the sound of that guy whimpering would have caused me to lose it.
I know, right? The cop having to ask the same simple questions over and over again and the blubbering mess cant even give a simple answer. Ffs.
Right I appreciate the methods of this cop, he's doing everything in his power to get justice for Brooke.
They’re laughing inside at him. “F-ing murdering crybaby, grow a pair!”
sniveling murderers are very unlikable individuals
The biggest loser looking dude every ..he is embarrassing
Lol @ the cop that keeps having to get up and leave cuz he can't take Randy's sniveling 😆😆
This is heartbreaking. She was just beginning her life and it ended for what? I pray for her family and loved ones 😢
Ended for love
Love he’s not even going to get like what
But no death penalty. Just another freak we have to pay to feed clothe & keep in jail.
@@timtags not love, LUST.
that poor long distance boyfriend that was expecting to see her soon aswell. What a selfish prick i cant believe someone can just do this
It's baffling. You "love" someone SO much and don't want to lose them....so you kill them....losing them forever plus ruining your life and the lives of her family.
Good job.
It’s more of a “if I can’t have her no one will” mentality
exactly!!
@@michaeldebidart It's definitely that too.
It's definetly not a rational decision. The best explanation I could find for this sort of crime is that the killer is so emotionally attached to the victim or is so desperatly lonely they don't want to see them go so they literally don't let them go. Dahmer killing and eating his victims is usually used as an extreme example of that state of mind.
That is one sick sob
To everyone out there, never be afraid to trust your gut.
I had a male friend once who I only ever wanted a friendship with. He asked me out and I ensured him that I only wanted to be friends. When I began a new relationship, he would call consistently, become extremely protective and even insist that we should all go on a double date (to see what was going on in my relationship). I told him my concerns and gave him one more chance at friendship, though the red flags continued. My anxiety went through the roof for weeks.
It was incredibly difficult to do so, but I told him that we could no longer be friends, as he broke my trust. Despite losing a friend, the fact that I felt immense unease and concern about my safety when I was around him - this was enough justification. I felt a wave of relief.
Always listen to your instincts, even if you feel sorry for the person. You have to keep yourself safe.
ya, if you ever feel unsafe around someone who you deem as a friend, best not to be friends (maybe a distant acquaintance if thats manageable).
Don't friend zone guys that are into you. No self respecting man lets a woman put him in the friend zone. If a man is pathetic enough to be into a woman and keep pretending to be ok with just being friends after she turns him down then he's manipulative and pathetic and just trying to keep close to the woman hoping she'll eventually give him a shot. It's also cruel on the woman's part because she knows what he's after and is basically playing with his heart.
Imagine being really into a guy and that guy doesn't want to reciprocate those feelings but still wants to keep you around to have someone to talk to about the woman he's actually into.
@@thejohn6614 I didn’t ‘play with his heart’. I ended our friendship due to his ongoing feelings. That’s the only approach.
@@miap6844 ok. That's cool. The way you made it sound (or how I interpreted what you were saying) was that he came on to you and told you how he felt about you and you turned him down but kept him around in the friend zone for a good while. Shine on you crazy diamond.
@@thejohn6614 I don’t see how I am in the wrong here. I cut off the friendship. If I gave him one more chance of friendship, this was due to kindness and showing a friend respect and decency. There was no malicious or manipulative intent behind this, as you suggest.
I feel your reasoning stems from bias - either you dislike women, believe they’re all manipulative or you have been rejected by a female friend in the past. Switch the gender roles around and look from a different perspective, how would you feel about the situation then? Also, once again, people can give second chances and act out of empathy. This person was a very good friend, and cutting off the friendship immediately would have hurt him. Give me a break. There is no reason to insult me. I did the best I could at the time.
Dude talking like he's a child who ate a pack of cookies before dinner, after his parents said not to.
He is a lil punk
@@yaboyfrresh Give punks a break. He’s a jellyfish.
It's ok as a parent sticking up for your child, but trying to blame the murder on sleepwalking is ridiculous.
Especially because she fought back (and pretty well at that,) how can you sleep through a fight to the death
Or fine, blame it on sleepwalking. He can go sleepwalk in his cell for the rest of his life. Hopefully there’s no cellmate!
I agree with the theory of the creator: that this may have been how he got out of trouble with his mom when he misbehaved. “But mom…I was sleepwalking!” (like riding his bike to a friend’s house at night). That excuse doesn’t fly when you get stabby with your roommate, buddy.
I never would’ve believed it until I started sleep walking as an adult & apparently was trying to get out windows & our front door in the middle of the night & when my partner would try stop me I would yell & scream at him, I seriously didn’t ever remember any of it & would feel so awful. I made it outside on two occasions & he’d somehow talk me into going back inside. I have no idea why but I became a complete bitch & would full on scream abuse at him for no reason, our r/ship was really good. It eventually stopped, the only thing we can think is i was under more stress than usual at work & it was coming out during my sleep, strangely I’d always wake feeling really relieved, relaxed & good until I’d look at my partner & realised I’d had another episode. It was scary as esp knowing I had no control over it & how awful I treated my partner during them. I know I didn’t stab anyone but I do believe u can do things in your sleep & act things out exactly how they’d happen while awake & u not only have no control u don’t know who or why you’re directing so much anger towards a loved one. I was so scared I started trying to tie my arm to the bed post hoping it’d wake me if I tried to get up but to no avail, I’d just untie it like I was awake & start my tirade
@@honeybee1852there are story’s of people sleep driving to their relatives houses and ringing the doorbell in the middle of the night, but if they got into an accident, who’d be at fault
"You'd be halfway to Pennsylvania right now if you were a bad person"
As a Pennsylvanian i just need to know.. are we bad people here?? hahah
She was headed to New York I think that’s why he said that but I’m also from PA 😅
Well, it’s either going to be Pennsylvania or Mexico.
Poor girl, I bet he took her by surprise. Stabbing someone 25 times, someone who fights back... He knew what he was doing, he wanted destruction.
She trusted him, thought he was her friend, so of course he took her by surprise :(
@@urhunn7778 we pretend not to notice because men kill us when we say no. It’s not about attention from a POS like this guy. We are killed because men like this guy feel entitled. He killed her because she went to another man’s house that night and was moving out. Way to blame the victim.
The problem is the male behavior: stop being an incel and ask a woman to be with you. If she says no, move on. The female (or otherwise the desired party) is not responsible for coddling out a proposal from the pursuing party.
@@Matt-lp1xp Exactly. He was never upfront with his feelings, most likely he even knew he had no chance. She couldn't have given him much more of a sign than having a boyfriend that wasn't him. Disgusting incel behaviour
Your mom wanted destruction
Classic case of "if I can't have you, no one will"
May Brooke RIP ❤
After confessing his feelings he probably also felt embarrassment and shame, and that is also what contributes to men being violent.
He acts like he has been raised in house with no father ,men turns into spoiled children
@@gracie1312 - Sounds like you’re trying to justify and excuse what he did.
@@dantegood2195 Not really.
@@dantegood2195 Working out the reasoning or cause for something isn't necessarily justifying it, you twat
When a cop says you’re not a bad person, you’re a bad person
My patience and tolerance ran out within 5 minutes…. Kudos to the interviewers… big respect where it is due
Wow, you made it to 5 minutes?! 😅
Same here
I had to forward it to the very end..his pitiful baby voice! Ew!
Even if what he says is true (that he had a mental breakdown due to high stress), who’s to say that it wouldn’t happen again the next time he’s stressed out. We all regularly get stressed out for a variety of reasons, usually on a daily basis, but are able cope without crossing the line. However, someone who loses control like he did without provocation is a high-risk danger to society and cannot be given a chance to walk free.
So very true. Ppl. like him need to be kept away from society. Permanently.
Such a good point. Tbh, if I had a total dissociative fugue and KILLED someone when I didn’t know I did, I would be so horrified I would WANT to be locked in a mental hospital forever. Bc clearly if I was so messed up inside that evil was like just below the surface at all times, I’d be convinced I was wayyyyy too much of a danger to others.
@@Rae_777 That's why the real purpose of jail/prison is to rehab people into becoming functioning members of society. Unfortunately in the US we have a very "eye for an eye" way of dealing with justice. I'm sure with 10 years in prison along with the proper psychiatric and mental health treatment he would be normal and not at risk at all. Other countries function this way and have better outcomes in their societies.
@@gingerroot8802 the issue as you highlighted us that US prisons don’t often provide adequate mental health services, and often induce further traumas and PTSD in inmates, which cause their recidivism rates to increase.
@@gingerroot8802 Another reason they don't rehabilitate is the prison system in the US is a business and like all other businesses, they want repeat customers.
Imagine blacking out on a measly 30 Bud Lights lmfao
I guess the take away here is never underestimate the amount of violence that could be perpetrated by someone with a secret crush. Poor Brooke!
Rather;
Women; don’t be friends with beta boys and do definitely not share an apartment with them
@@pale_saint isn't a beta boy more passive aggressive?
alcohol first
@@truenokill yes until the breaking point when they lash out like here. He felt he was losing her and made probably a desperate attempt to convince her to stay and when she refused all that repressed emotion bursted out
@@pale_saint I get what u r saying. The beta boy that explodes after years of repression - yup just like him!
This is why I live alone no matter how much rent I have to pay 🤣🤣
yep
Right Mom always told me you never really know someone till you live with them and I've had situations where I had a male roommate and when we weren't living together everything was fine as soon as I moved in and made it clear what it was it became hell so I would never live with anyone again best decision Live alone
My neighbour lived alone in her house but wanted a little spending money so she rented one of her spare rooms. A young adult male moved in and before too long she wondered where her cat was so she went to the renter's room to ask him and she found him scuffing the cat mid-air ND slashing the cats throat with a knife. She screamed, startling the dude and went nuts on him, giving him a beat down right out of the house and then called 911. The cat barely survived and I told her that it could so easily have been her instead of the cat. As you said, it's better to pay high rent or mortgage and live alone than trust a stranger anymore.
Having roommates as an adult is garbage, unless you're dating. If I can't take my pants off around you, we can't live together.
“You seem like a level headed guy randy” translation: I’d like to establish premeditation
Jodi Arias couldn't remember shit either.
Omg his crying makes me sick this dude is gonna be someone's boy in prison 🤣 he will not survive in prison
They'll like his wimpering in there a lot. Ohhhh baby. 🤣
Fresh white meat on the menu in the joint ya'll
It's all an act.
He's bound to get shanked numerous times if he isn't in protective custody.
Well... at least he'll have a relationship... Well.. multiple XD
Mommy’s boy who has this mentality -
“If I can’t have her, no one will have her.”
That is a classic example of a sexual psychopath. They are the most dangerous type of person to be around.
30 Bud Light is roughly the equivalent of 3 real beers.
Or 50 coors lights.
Truth
I don’t how someone can drink that many beers without feeling full and bloated and not pissing like 67 times
He was probably drunker off water intoxication than the alcohol.
So you could only handle about 10?
Randy's mother did his laundry every Thursday, brought him meatloaf on Friday, brought his groceries on Saturday, and baked him cookies on Sunday.
C: “Randy, do you have a girlfriend right now?”
R: “…no.”
*SHOCKING*
A woman would have to be desperate to get romantic with a man-baby butterball like him. He is so weak.
Love when you put out a video on a case I've never heard of, just makes it all that much better!
Same. A lot of repeat cases on other channels with different stories. I prefer the unseen things like this
There's a documentary on Hulu that was just released about this case a few weeks ago
The soft spoken, pitiful, sniffling baby talk fills me with anger. And the detectives are responding to him as if they’re talking to a 3 year old. This is so hard to watch.
I feel the same way.
I couldn't cope with it, my 6yo doesn't even carry on like this anymore. Not surprised Brooke wasn't into him.
They baby them in the interrogation so they can destroy them in the court room
@@Cooter69 good ol’ “good cop bad judge” routine.
Straight up! I'd be like look bitch, you called us, you said a murder went down your ex roommate is trying to leave and she's stabbed and you're cut...bitch you were there she was there she almost dead and you not we already got the who where when we just need the fkin why! We know you did it 🤦♂️
I’m sure he thought he was coming out the friend zone, once he realized he wasn’t, he lost it. No sympathy from me.
Incredibly selfish. I hope the family finds some peace.
There will never be peace in that family. Not after this
Are yall just here ta sh*t on my comment, when all I'm doing is expressing my condolence. Trolls be trolls I guess.
@@katthefantastic yes
Wat??? No one in the History of the 🌎 has Anyone Ever Got Peace from hearing of their Murdered Family member NO ONE
@@katthefantastic oh poor YOU
>25 stab wounds
Blacked out my ass. I've yet to see someone that trashed fight a staircase let alone another human in that state.
I really want to thank you very much for the effort you put in to these interrogations, the commentary is awesome and the subtitles really help , cheers guys.
It's not charity,it's monetized,they get paid for putting out a good video
As a former alcoholic...there are random blackouts, as well as, moments of lucidity. This is not uncommon or unheard of. However, in this case...I'm not so sure. He's a whiny incel.
Completely agree….though I no longer drink, thank god, there are plenty of times where I have woken up to a general sense of shame and regret with hours of the preceding evening missing. And most assuredly not always in a linear way, but with picture flashes of memory from random points throughout the night…..I don’t know that this young man is telling the truth of his experience/actions, but what he is describing as his memory of it is completely plausible to me.
@@mostBurnt815 I tell people I am now allergic to alcohol. I break out in handcuffs. But honestly...I am so glad that is all behind me now. And I am thanking God as well. ; )
He mentions that it was during the hangover the next morning, so I'm thinking it's total BS about blacking out.
And you can never trust an incel
Not sure you understand what incel means. Any man who can come up with $120 and doesn't get a hooked is volcel
I don't buy the whole "just blacked out" thing. Stabbing someone to death isn't a mindless activity.
If he was on Xanax I would believe it, cause I use to take those things like crazy. Wake up the next day having to apologize for shit I have no memory of lol. But I've never black out with alcohol. I believe it's possible but you'd have to drink like crazy v
@@jasonbeck1340 I've blacked out from benzos before too but I never did anything so serious during it
@@jasonbeck1340 I took ambien once and woke up the next day to find a bowl with a bunch of fruit smushed in it and filled with water. I asked my bf wtf it was and he said, "oh, you don't remember that? you were trying to make juice last night". I never took it again lmaooo
@@mischr13 Hanky the Christmas Poo could learn a thing or two from you.
You’re right about him - he’s blatantly lying. However, there are actual documented cases of sleepwalking or blacked out murders - benzos are typically the cause
When the police say you're not a bad person, they really mean you are a bad person😊
100%
exactly
Also just a fun tidbit: these people lived within a 10 minute drive to Casey Anthony
something in the water
Do you know how to find her? I want to go bully her
"Not at all. I dont think your a bad person."..... yeah that's when you know you're done. Time to stop wimpering, dry your eyes, and kiss goodbye to your beautiful freedoms. 🤣
when I heard that I thought "well no, he is KIND of a bad person".
This is definitely a crime of passion. He was obsessed with her. I wonder if she sensed something “off” with him before this happened.
His mom probably coddled him too much as a kid. Possessive and riddled with separation anxiety.
If the ring camera across the street didn't catch their movements, his sleepy lies might have worked
Nah!!! No way he would've been able to wriggle out if this.
@@ek2137 Don’t be naive. Absolutes are the domain of limited cognition.
@@ek2137 not so sure...when they interviewed the jury, the video of her walking in the door right after he sent the last text, then him walking out the door.....cut his timeline and they did not believe it was enough time for him to fall into a deep sleep like he claimed. Without that video they could have said she was sitting in her car giving him time to justify falling into a deep sleep
Either that or he might have been convicted of second degree murder or manslaughter rather than first degree murder.
I give these detectives kudos for their patience with this over grown baby. I would not be able to handle his whiny voice and his baby acting, like a kid caught with his hand in the cookie jar.
The phone ringing as soon as the guy walks in and sits down is comedy gold.
Yes so unprofessional
Of course he remembers it. He remembers ALL of it. He wasn't sleepwalking. He's an incel mama's boy. Disgusting.
Incel! I hate that “new” word people use nowadays.
Oh I remember him. The cry-baby killer 😢 😆
Why does it look like there's a dark shadow standing behind him??😱😱
Because of the placement of the lights.. 😉
I dont know whats worse someone who feels nothing after murdering someone or someone who feels SORRY FOR THEMSELVES after doing it. smh
Lol
Oh Randy, were you thinking about being a bad person when you grabbed the knife and ended her🤡?? This makes me ill. Rip Brooke, sorry you never deserved This 💔😥🕊🕊🕊
What’s interesting is after watching this I looked into this young man, and he went to college for criminal justice and also was a corrections officer prior to all of this, he was standing in her closet naked the night before & she called a friend to pick her up because Randy was acting so weird. This poor sweet young girl lost her life because this man couldn’t handle rejection. Also I believe his father murdered someone also 🤔
It’s an excuse his mother gave him. No responsibility for his actions
His disgusting mom probably breastfed him until he was a teenager, then still babied his ugly ass with anything he did wrong... making excuses for him like he’s a toddler. Wtf?!? Parents need to teach responsibility & especially accountability for their actions. Poor Brooke had no idea what monster was awaiting her.
@@rosemarie9816 Bingo, his mom is a big time enabler
‘If I just keep saying I don’t know like a sulky toddler this will all go away’
He does deserve something and it sure isn't a 2nd chance!
A binkie and the electric chair
30+ beers is crazy
Really that’s truly crazy 😂
Lite American beer. Hardly 30 "real" beer its kinda like 8 cdn beers
I'd rather be locked in a room with a woman that hates me, than a man that likes me. Because my odds of survival are much, much, greater imo.
God his sobbing is ridiculously annoying
I can’t imagine how her friend Kyle felt after going to breakfast with her before she died. I’d feel so horrible … like I should’ve let her stay with me .. or I should’ve went with her…. Your mind would be full of what ifs 😩
And her family … oh my lord. Just so sad. He knows what he did . The “I don’t remember” shit is bull & the way she fought … he won’t forget that as long as he lives . That poor poor girl. & she thought this piece of shit was her FRIEND. There’s almost no such thing anymore! People will turn on you in a instant!
RIP beautiful . You deserved more than what you got
Of course! Kyle probably will have overwhelming guilt forever. I hope he can forgive himself as Kyle didn’t do anything wrong & didn’t know what a monster this piece of shit mommy’s boy was.
@@bonjovirocks24 you have no clue if he was mommies boy - LOVING hos mother doesn't make him a Mommies boy !
@@forpetessake3532 - That poster didn’t say it was. There’s a difference between loving your mother and being a weird ass mama’s boy
My dad always told me growing up I’m your only friend lol.
@@forpetessake3532 are you his mother lmao you’re in every comment defending the murderer and his mom 😂 go to Hell.
Lord I hate it when criminals baby talk and sniffle after committing a horrible act. It just shows how much they've been babied their whole lives.
The guy in Canada who raped and killed that little girl. He acted the same way as this guy in the interrogation room. It was so infuriating to watch.
So sad that Brooke knew something was wrong and acted on her instincts by staying at the friend's house but still ended tragically
I think she just thought he was going to try to make a pass at her while drunk. I doubt she thought he was actually dangerous.
You don’t kill a woman you are in love with.
Depends on how heavy the jealousy is and how weak the person experiencing it is.
@@kwakester no it fucking doesn't, you're a fucking weirdo.
Agreed. There’s a difference between loving someone and thinking you own someone.
Agreed, he was obsessed not in love
If you love someone, you care for them. Killing them is not caring for them. Possession and obsession is verry far from love. That is what creeps do.
This was frustrating to say the least all he was bothered about was if they had told his mum yet. What about her mum her family her friend . He thought his mum would get him out of this ,bet she did it a lot by the sounds of him turning in to a toddler . He should be ashamed of himself he killed her because she was moving forward with her life and maybe he wasn't going to be a part of her future who knows. It's still very sad . One thing for sure his mommy can't help him now. He's going to have to be a big boy from now on .
Obviously she was moving in with her longtime boyfriend. It was morning already .. she was scared she asked he friend to stay with her.. people your body and mind tells you something it's wrong it's because something will happen
I'm extremelly close to my mom and the thought of her getting a phone call from the police and learning I had just murdered someone mortifies me. I don't think I could live knowing I've caused her that ammount of pain and sorrow.
@@HassanZargari same brother, same. No shot am I under any circumstances even slightly worried I could do something like this. Takes a true sociopath or worse, and someone without conscience to do this
@@HassanZargari geez loosen the apron strings. That’s unattractive af. If you have a wife then move on. Be with her. She’s not your mom. Most women will never even date a momma’s boy 🤢
@@amazingsupergirl7125 What are you even talking about? Respecting your mother and not wanting to cause her pain is not being a mama's boy. Holy shit!!
Remember, it’s only a coincidence that he’s a ginger.
"You're not a bad person Randy" Ha ha such a nice police officer!
Oh. My. Does this sound eerily similar to my stalker, who is someone I have known from my childhood neighborhood. Apparently he decided never to have a meaningful relationship with anyone thinking that I, although happily and commitedly MARRIED for decades, would one day just up, leave my husband and go to him because that was meant to be. That thought process IS TERRIFYING to me, and there is NO law to protect me. I live in fear.
Please take good care everyone!
Theres one law that can, the 2nd amendment
@@Jcaeser187 Amen!
If you live in America it's your right to own a gun to protect yourself. 💯
So how do you know this is his thought process? Are you talking to him? Or did someone else tell you this?
Lol wishful thinking
It truly amazes me how HUMANS can snap tf out one minute, then turn around and play victim.
Just your typical Twitch/Reddit mod
You 'deserve a second chance'? Yeah...so did she.
The cops really irk me telling him “we know you’re not a bad guy” in the baby voice. Like he’s actually literally a bad guy.
It's part of the interrogation technique to get the suspect to feel comfortable and to ultimately confess
Amazing how they walk the line between being interrogative and using cognitive interview techniques. It's amazing to see a good detective at work
🎯
I still think bringing in another detective after this initial process with some more attitude and using the REID technique would have got him talking alot more
I thought these two were particularly crap actually "Randy, tell me, Randy, Randy, help me, Randy what happened? Randy?" arrrghh.
@@duchessofhazjack4878 exactly. If it frustrated YOU that much imagine being guilty and listening to it for hours. Locked in a tiny room. Knowing you're fucked.
@@duchessofhazjack4878 The purpose is to exhaust the suspect.
Poor lady, had a new life planned and was about to embark on it and this selfish man-child couldn't do the decent, normal thing and honestly wish her well.
So heart-breaking... People do such heinous things for ZERO reason at all. It's just beyond infuriating.
Saying it's for zero reason just makes you ignorant. Everything happens for a reason.
He was clearly jealous and interested in her and didn't want her to leave and was mad she had a guy waiting for him and was drunk and probably more reasons.
Far from zero.
@@DrummerJacob no sir, there is absolutely ZERO reason to ever take someone's life away. you sound like you're trying to justify murder and it is not a good look.
Wow your so dumb
@@aarra777 Jacob is making a philosophical statement and your trying to make it about morality when clearly your misunderstood
Thank you for covering this case. I’m asking people please do not watch the Hulu doc on this. The family of the victim was adamantly against it, so much information was twisted or incorrect to make Randy look like a victim of his own mind. True crime is a controversial topic, but when the family is specifically asking that a company does not do something, but they do it anyway, that’s too much for me. One example is in the doc they made it sound like the sister of the victim wanted to testify for him, when in fact she was subpoenaed and didn’t have a choice, they edited out the parts of her testimony that weren’t supportive of him. Kendal Rae interviewed the family, give her your time, not that doc.
Sleepwalkers don’t make all the steps he did, it’s embarrassing that film makers got fooled by this.
Edit: I wanted to add this doesn’t take away at all from Red Tree Crimes video. If anything Kendall Rae’s video is a good supplement to this to fill in some of the gaps of the story. I see no issue with interrogations being public. My problem is when a production company jumps on the innocent people jailed bandwagon (which we do have too many of), and tries to make a murderer a victim, and hurts the family in the process. There are so many other legit cases they should’ve spent their time on. I only hope the family has not received harassment as I’m sure because of that doc there’s people that believe he was sleepwalking.
Thanks for the info 👍 I won't watch it I totally agree with you
Thank you for this information!! I watched the documentary and had no clue about this
Never heard of it, but thanks, if I do stumble across I’ll know!
Thank you for giving me yet another reason not to have Hulu! That’s so disgusting!!!
@@heyitsjayy If you’ve watched it then Kendall Rae’s video will be such an eye opener for how things can be edited to look a certain way! It’s shocking when I come across things like that, but it’s also taught me a lot.
I recently blocked someone I’ve known for years because he would randomly get angry and pick fights over stuff like me not wanting to call or something. He said he liked me but then would spam my phone a million times and my Xbox and would say stuff that I don’t care to repeat. I never got bad vibes from him before he started doing that and seeing this is scary. Just thinking you could do that to someone you’re into romantically or just anyone at all is terrifying. I’m glad I don’t live near him anymore.
Randy’s controlling compulsion to enmesh himself into Brooke’s life eerily reminds me of the Lauren Giddings case. Much like here, Stephen McDaniel couldn’t bear the thought of losing his predatory grasp on Lauren’s life, so he killed her the night before she was to move away to be with her long distance boyfriend. Randy was the roommate and Stephen was her next door neighbor (or close enough to be able to see inside her apartment), both Randy and Stephen didn’t want to lose the out-of-touch-stalker’s ideal setup. Chock full of ✨deluded, incel, if-I-can’t-have-you-no-one-can✨ energy. RIP Lauren Giddings. RIP Brooke Preston.
Must agree with you there. This guy is sniveling and McDaniel seriously creeped me out. But both equal in their stalking - “psycholust” actions. I wish she hadn’t gone back to the house from her friend’s. I’ve just started watching but what a crybaby. Poor girl’s family has all of my sympathy.
Omg I thought of that too
Mcdaniel was a creeper for sure, this guy was way more involved in this woman's life.
It's funny that RUclips banned the word roas tie but not the word incel
Actually no it's not funny at all. Typical really.
@@AllofJudea RUclips employees took it personally
My therapist calls binge watching these “catastrophizing” lmao
Mine too 😭😭
Stop going to a therapist. Be strong and work your own problems out.
@@aliceflores812 last time I tried that, I ended up in a hospital lol so I try to accept the support that’s available to me.
Thank you for your advice, though. 💖
@@margotmcmanomanowitz5808 good luck 👍👍
@@aliceflores812 I really appreciate that 💖. Have a wonderful day!
The amount of times the cop said "Randy" makes me homicidal.
Heman, now 28, was sentenced to life behind bars. Last month, Herman filed a motion to try to get his conviction vacated. He wants a new trial and argues that his defense was wrong to claim that sleepwalking was a mental illness
This pathetic alcoholic and murderer wants a new trial? Just so he can get out, go get wasted, and kill more girls who don't reciprocate his lust. Yeah.. don't think so. He's probably just tired of being the victim, thanks to his prison "buddies." He's where he belongs.
That is NOT "In Love" .. That is unhealthily obsessed.
I love the way you hide the RTC symbol in the different scenes. Always so clever!
The sniveling and wimpering....I keep flashing to that scene in The Godfather, where Vito slaps Johnny Fontaine.
Billybadass until they're caught
"You're not a bad person at all. Just sign here so we can get you to prison!"
Can you imagine getting that drunk from just beer?! I sure can't!
As a sleepwalker myself, I find it hard to believe his story. I usually just go to sleep on my bed and wake up on the couch. Never once have I engaged in highly physical activities. But this is just based on my own experience.
I doubt his sleepwalking story. That being said different people act differently when sleepwalking. As a young kid I was camping with one of my friends and he apparently got up out of the tent and started running (my parents and his were still up around the fire, so they were able to catch him).
Edit: I have never sleepwalked walked, tho as someone who remembers my dreams I definitely understand how perception of 'reality' can be hilariously broken.
🎯
Yea booty bandits be doing crip walking all over his ass literally young lad exactly what he deserves she looked beutifull young lady looked like you had a lovely home I lost both parents to cancer when I was 7 mum in her late 30s me nanny was murdered me nephew trying to help a person who's bike got robbed the man stabbed him 2 times in the heart this happened 1 year ago last week and he was found not guilty this happened in 🇮🇪 a week later he's singing for Chelsea or celtic football team I've been through homes as a kid young prison never for violent things I've never committed a crime in 20 years my point is what I would have given to a life like yours and a friend like brook most of my school friend are dead or in prison why couldn't you be happy for her I love seen people doing great in life even though mines being fucked up but I've morals always respect your elders and never harm a female that's what me mam would say rip this young lady and God less her family and friends ❤️💯💯🇮🇪🙏
Read more on sleepwalking and don't be ignorant
@@mmaybee2353 bruh nobody is stabbing somebody dozens of times “sleepwalking.”…. Ignorant ass…