Col staffenburg was a great soilders sacrifices his life but failed but will remember in history as a great soilders not a failure.against Hitler nothing was easy but we pay respect to staffenburg not to Hitler.
Yes, But they expected to come to an arrangement with the Western Allies, but continue the war against the Soviet Union, which ironically was what Stalin was worried would happen, and was always suspicious of the Western Allies negotiating a separate peace with Germany.
May they Rest In Peace. They met an easier death than other conspirators who were hanged with piano wire. This was filmed and Hitler had his Jolie’s watching their slow death.
Perversely, they were "lucky" to meet a relatively easy death. Fromm's intentions were purely those of personal self-preservation - the five men he court-martialed could identify that he had been aware, if not exactly a supporter, of the Attentat, hence following its failure had to be eliminated quickly. Had they lived, they would have been tortured without mercy and then faced the grisly and prolonged death. May they rest in peace.
Even if the plot had succeeded ,the West were not interested in a ceasefire ,. The plotters assumed that they would join England and the US and fight the Russians but the West was committed to a joint war with Stalin as an ally. A new democratic government in Germany would only have complicated things. Unconditional surrender was easier to handle.
True, unconditional surrender would still have been demanded. Maybe the new rulers would have complied to this which would have saved millions of lives. On the other side a new stab in the back theory would have been born. Rightwing Germans could have claimed that the war would have been won if it hadn’t been for those ‘traitors’ just like 1918.
If only they could have seen into the future at the prosperous condition of 21st century Germany with it's 4th largest economy, Tolerance towards all groups, divers ethnic groups, freedom of speech, religion, right to peacefully assemble and protest
It is because you are on the allies side you see them as heroes ... but the fact is that i despise them … a human nature always hates and resents betrayals and traitors .
Everyone is talking about the heroism of these people. However, one point is missed. These people were active officers of Hitler's army, and served in it for a long time. And they decided on a conspiracy only after it was already obvious by 1944 that the Red Army of the Soviet Union would defeat Hitler's Germany 100%. Up to this point, they didn't do something conspiracy. Conclusion - before the Battle of Stalingrad and the Battle of Kursk, they were satisfied with everything. The murder of millions of civilians, persecution on a national basis... And when the inevitable reckoning loomed on the horizon - "oh, we need to save Germany, Hitler turns out to be bad!"
Very brave men. Many others where executed after them including Stauffenburg's brother who had a terrible death.-They half hung him 9 times and each time they brought him round and did it all over again.
@ Zaptics A project ?! What on.? Most sadistic execution methods?! What's next ? How to skin a human being alive ? Very educational. The FBI needs a word with your teacher .
@Blahblobify You might well be right. In total honesty, I do not know for sure. During the early years of the war however, even less people in Germany knew about what Hitler and the Nazis were about then in later years. Perhaps a good man like Stauffenberg could never have dreamed that the Nazi regime would be what it turned out to be. I give him credit to him for acting in a very brave way to end the Nazi regime.Because of his courage, I give him the benefit of the doubt.
@Joe I liked it overall. Pretty much stuck with the facts but far too many exchanges of " meaningful / suspicious " looks and reaction shots . Fairly plodding direction .?
@@2msvalkyrie529 Kenneth branagh and Tom Wilkinson and the other general guy are like my favorite actors is probably why I didn't mind the not speaking in German accent. And it's not like they spoke cockney or rough northern working class slang. It was believable to me. And like I said, I even didn't mind Tom cruise doing his American accent. It's not like he did it with a southern accent or exxagerrate american embarrassing one. No offense though. And I'm not offended by people that missed the movie entirely because of cast. Liam neeson in schindler's list definitely didn't do his native Irish accent but it also wasn't German like Christoph waltz speaks.
Well, this whole plot is overrated. The plotters didn't want or intended to end the war on all fronts, they intended to continue on Eastern Front where most of the the action as far as the number of people involved. Soviets would never stop given the amount of damage Germans inflicted on them. British would never forget London bombings. US would never invested so much to say, ok let's go home folks. So the plotters never accepted the responsibility of being a part of why Germany was where it was: in deep shit. So, that coup had no meaning in what happened to Germany in May of 1945.
The coup had a meaning in the sense that there were human beings within Germany who opposed the Nazi regime, its policies and the atrocities that came with it. Incidentally, I wouldn't generalise when it comes to their motivations - there was considerable disparity between them in terms of what brought them to the Widerstand and their plans for post-nazi Germany had the Attentat succeeded.
Many of the people involved in the coup were initially enthusiastic about Hitler's successes, but turned on him later due to the atrocities of the regime. General Treskow, for instance, was horrified by the order to kill captured Red Army commissars, and sought to avoid it. Beck turned against Hitler after the invasion of Czechoslovakia. Perhaps they should have recognized the wrong of the Nazi movement, but that is hindsight, and opposing the Nazis required rare courage.
Khihu ktorú napísal Hitler není až taká ťažká ani nemusíte čítať 1000 krát aby ste mohli pochopiť v jedne výklade vete že Khihu môj boj napísal proti samotnému svtoritovi napríklad to vidieť v praxi v ako Farári predávali obete stanoví
Al parecer la historia no lo ha dicho todo sobre los alemanes ,sin embargo no todos los alemanes eran malos ,pudieron corregir los errores del pasado ,pero aún así son responsables de todo lo que hicieron en la S,G,M😤
He does not if i'm asked. One picture from the sideview doesn't tell nothing. I've seen frontview pictures about the both and they do not look the same.
General Fredrich Olbritch is my great uncle. I've got some time off work and am trying to find any footage of Uncle Friedrich since he was stripped of all his medals and personal belongings. If anyone knows of any I'd be very grateful. My Uncle Chuck looks exactly like Fredrich.
Thankyou that's very kind of you. Friedrich was my Uncle Chucks fathers brother. I only just learned about this at our last family Christmas. If you ever look up a photo of Charles Olbritch of N.Y. /NYC my Uncle Chuck looks EXACTLY like Fredrich! I think of all the bickering fights Uncle Chuck and I've had all over NYC/England and Africa and have to laugh. Thanks SO much for answering.
Gideon Horowitz Thankyou again. I found some film of him in the footage of the victory parade thru Warsaw. I could spot him straight away as the family resemblance is so strong. All of us Olbritchs are Very tall and there he was towering over Hitler in his eye glasses. Thankyou again again for the thoughtful kind words. Finding out family history is so
Who are the traitors you're talking about? The rabid nazis who ultimately led Germany to its grisly, tragic, ruinous end or the ones who tried to avert the inevitable for their country, minimise the bloodshed, many more deaths and misery for their countrymen and others involved in the conflict and paid the ultimate price for the failure???
Mr. Stauffenberg, who gave his life for world peace, is a man I admire
When they were losing .
Col staffenburg was a great soilders sacrifices his life but failed but will remember in history as a great soilders not a failure.against Hitler nothing was easy but we pay respect to staffenburg not to Hitler.
เขาต้องตรวจให้แน่ใจ
Heroes....
These guys are legends and legends never die
True heroism...
Fullest respect to those man..."principles before personal interests"
Such thinking is scarcity these days...
Yes, But they expected to come to an arrangement with the Western Allies, but continue the war against the Soviet Union, which ironically was what Stalin was worried would happen, and was always suspicious of the Western Allies negotiating a separate peace with Germany.
May they Rest In Peace. They met an easier death than other conspirators who were hanged with piano wire. This was filmed and Hitler had his Jolie’s watching their slow death.
Perversely, they were "lucky" to meet a relatively easy death. Fromm's intentions were purely those of personal self-preservation - the five men he court-martialed could identify that he had been aware, if not exactly a supporter, of the Attentat, hence following its failure had to be eliminated quickly. Had they lived, they would have been tortured without mercy and then faced the grisly and prolonged death. May they rest in peace.
It wasn’t piano wire but rather a thin hemp rope. It was filmed but Hitler didn’t watch it according to Goebbels.
@@tinaswan1734 fromm went two days later to collect the reward from himmler i thik but he was arrested
Who's here to remember them? 🥺
مٌوَسِيَقًُه
Even if the plot had succeeded ,the West were not interested in a ceasefire ,. The plotters assumed that they would join England and the US and fight the Russians but the West was committed to a joint war with Stalin as an ally. A new democratic government in Germany would only have complicated things. Unconditional surrender was easier to handle.
True, unconditional surrender would still have been demanded. Maybe the new rulers would have complied to this which would have saved millions of lives. On the other side a new stab in the back theory would have been born. Rightwing Germans could have claimed that the war would have been won if it hadn’t been for those ‘traitors’ just like 1918.
Without hitler and the Nazi hierarchy germany would have collapsed within weeks !
May the four heroes rest in peace.
Thanks for posting this.
Shoot the traitor.
If only they could have seen into the future at the prosperous condition of 21st century Germany with it's 4th largest economy, Tolerance towards all groups, divers ethnic groups, freedom of speech, religion, right to peacefully assemble and protest
stauffenberg was hardly a hero, he was a traitor and a nazi
They're just as guilty of treason as the founding fathers of America were when they wrote up and signed the declaration of Independence
It is because you are on the allies side you see them as heroes ... but the fact is that i despise them … a human nature always hates and resents betrayals and traitors .
Everyone is talking about the heroism of these people.
However, one point is missed.
These people were active officers of Hitler's army, and served in it for a long time.
And they decided on a conspiracy only after it was already obvious by 1944 that the Red Army of the Soviet Union would defeat Hitler's Germany 100%.
Up to this point, they didn't do something conspiracy.
Conclusion - before the Battle of Stalingrad and the Battle of Kursk, they were satisfied with everything. The murder of millions of civilians, persecution on a national basis...
And when the inevitable reckoning loomed on the horizon - "oh, we need to save Germany, Hitler turns out to be bad!"
Good point. Just like many things about the WW2; mostly blemished or even outright made up.
Four brave men.
4traitor
@@habandajop5617 U nazis little piece of Sh*t
@@habandajop5617 shut up!! u nazis lost in ur own homeland u wanna get beat up again?
Fromm got what was coming to him in the end.
In The Ending Its So Sad It Broke My Heart 😞😞
Yup. He was involved in it up to neck. He got lucky though. He was shot, rather than hanged
fromm the carrerist pig
The ending music and scene just breaks your heart
So Sad Very Sad 😭😭😭
german heroes of the ww2..
The Democratic Heroes Of World War ll
LONG LIVE SACRED GERMANY!
THANK YOU !
(3:38 - 3:41) Proof that Joseph Gordon-Levitt is a time traveler 😅. The third guy from the left.
Very brave men. Many others where executed after them including Stauffenburg's brother who had a terrible death.-They half hung him 9 times and each time they brought him round and did it all over again.
brecans where did you get that info I’m doing a project for school
Zaptics From a book.
@ Zaptics
A project ?! What on.?
Most sadistic execution methods?!
What's next ? How to skin a human being alive ?
Very educational. The FBI needs a
word with your teacher .
@Blahblobify You might well be right. In total honesty, I do not know for sure. During the early years of the war however, even less people in Germany knew about what Hitler and the Nazis were about then in later years. Perhaps a good man like Stauffenberg could never have dreamed that the Nazi regime would be what it turned out to be. I give him credit to him for acting in a very brave way to end the Nazi regime.Because of his courage, I give him the benefit of the doubt.
HEROES, May they rest in the hands of GOD.☝️☝️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I think the movie valkyrie is underrated, personally.
@ Andre
Yes....the film was very badly cast. Too many English theatre
based actors . Great for certain
parts but not quite right for here .
@@2msvalkyrie529 I weirdly didn't mind the cast that didn't do German accents.
@Joe
I liked it overall. Pretty much stuck
with the facts but far too many
exchanges of " meaningful / suspicious " looks and reaction
shots . Fairly plodding direction .?
@@2msvalkyrie529 must've been why it got no nominations for awards. Maybe I like it because I like ww2 history.
@@2msvalkyrie529 Kenneth branagh and Tom Wilkinson and the other general guy are like my favorite actors is probably why I didn't mind the not speaking in German accent. And it's not like they spoke cockney or rough northern working class slang. It was believable to me. And like I said, I even didn't mind Tom cruise doing his American accent. It's not like he did it with a southern accent or exxagerrate american embarrassing one. No offense though. And I'm not offended by people that missed the movie entirely because of cast.
Liam neeson in schindler's list definitely didn't do his native Irish accent but it also wasn't German like Christoph waltz speaks.
May you rest in Heaven!
@TurnerEckhardt i think he was no fanatic nazi... he was just a soldier fighting for his country... not all soldiers and generals were real nazis...
Well, this whole plot is overrated. The plotters didn't want or intended to end the war on all fronts, they intended to continue on Eastern Front where most of the the action as far as the number of people involved. Soviets would never stop given the amount of damage Germans inflicted on them. British would never forget London bombings. US would never invested so much to say, ok let's go home folks. So the plotters never accepted the responsibility of being a part of why Germany was where it was: in deep shit. So, that coup had no meaning in what happened to Germany in May of 1945.
The coup had a meaning in the sense that there were human beings within Germany who opposed the Nazi regime, its policies and the atrocities that came with it. Incidentally, I wouldn't generalise when it comes to their motivations - there was considerable disparity between them in terms of what brought them to the Widerstand and their plans for post-nazi Germany had the Attentat succeeded.
Their trying “IS” the success......
Stafenburg and the rest were hero's.
Except Fromm who changed sides and betrayed they to save his own skin
Hero?? Before war begin why he Don't try kill Hitler?? After german will crush and lose the war he do it?? Hero my ass
God decided otherwise
Many of the people involved in the coup were initially enthusiastic about Hitler's successes, but turned on him later due to the atrocities of the regime. General Treskow, for instance, was horrified by the order to kill captured Red Army commissars, and sought to avoid it. Beck turned against Hitler after the invasion of Czechoslovakia. Perhaps they should have recognized the wrong of the Nazi movement, but that is hindsight, and opposing the Nazis required rare courage.
Document en français ! C’est possible ?
Good plan.Bad practice
Des hommes mort pour une juste cause !
Ill conceived poorly organized.not enough explosive used.
it would had been very easy if schtawffenberg had chosen the suicide bomber methode instead of fleeing the place quickly ...
@Ligeia D.Aurevilly I know i know it wasn't in Wermacht traditions , but it could have changed the History!
@Ligeia D.Aurevilly
I see a good strong aryan woman on your photo . I like it ❗is that you ?
@Ligeia D.Aurevilly
Beautiful shot 👍 Unfortunate that i can't enlarge it ...
Apart from Tom Cruise, all the others looks an exact match.😁
Little known fact. During this coup all the Germans decided to start speaking english, including Hitler
จะโชคพนาไมนิ่งได้ยังไง
ส่งงบประมาณไปเยอรมัน
ฮิตเลอร์มาตัดยางอยู่
German Patriots!
0:07 Post-war map of Poland 🤣
Terrible map
ไม่ดิ้นรนเขาเอาหมดที่ดิน
TOM CRUISE
Khihu ktorú napísal Hitler není až taká ťažká ani nemusíte čítať 1000 krát aby ste mohli pochopiť v jedne výklade vete že Khihu môj boj napísal proti samotnému svtoritovi napríklad to vidieť v praxi v ako Farári predávali obete stanoví
Otto got trolled by Goebbels and Hitler
4:42-5:13 made me cry (the music just got to me) :(
ตรวจสอบบริษัท
ถางไว้ได้หลายไร่
Didn't expect Jim Raynor to narrate this video)
Al parecer la historia no lo ha dicho todo sobre los alemanes ,sin embargo no todos los alemanes eran malos ,pudieron corregir los errores del pasado ,pero aún así son responsables de todo lo que hicieron en la S,G,M😤
Fromm thought he would escape. He dis not. The fool.
@TurnerEckhardt Oh that explains.
And it's On God's Will
Staffenberg tušil že prejde linou všetci boli v momente po výbuchu
My grandfather was part of the initial plot, but chickened out
Good movie
He does not if i'm asked. One picture from the sideview doesn't tell nothing. I've seen frontview pictures about the both and they do not look the same.
They're loyal to the Weimar Republic.
Kapitola sa zruší a skončí WW 2
Beginning Best map
Lets not forget Rommel too
General Fredrich Olbritch is my great uncle. I've got some time off work and am trying to find any footage of Uncle Friedrich since he was stripped of all his medals and personal belongings. If anyone knows of any I'd be very grateful. My Uncle Chuck looks exactly like Fredrich.
Thankyou that's very kind of you. Friedrich was my Uncle Chucks fathers brother. I only just learned about this at our last family Christmas. If you ever look up a photo of Charles Olbritch of N.Y. /NYC my Uncle Chuck looks EXACTLY like Fredrich! I think of all the bickering fights Uncle Chuck and I've had all over NYC/England and Africa and have to laugh. Thanks SO much for answering.
Gideon Horowitz Thankyou again. I found some film of him in the footage of the victory parade thru Warsaw. I could spot him straight away as the family resemblance is so strong. All of us Olbritchs are Very tall and there he was towering over Hitler in his eye glasses. Thankyou again again for the thoughtful kind words. Finding out family history is so
Pardon-its been so interesting. And again thankyou for your response and kindness.All the best to you
Those are family u bitch ass . We are one nation we are Kingmens
I SHOULD BE ASHAMED TO BE RELATED TO HIM HE COMMITTED TREASON, ,
Stop da movie 😍
Claus Von Staffenburg you had one job ..?!
Give him a break,… He only had one hand
he had more balls then ur whole family combined rude boy
@@ridgemercury take a joke son
@@pfcwar5150 lmao
jaypers,tom cruise really does look like him lol
Wow like the movie😱
Traitors and that’s what they get and and deserve 👍🏻
R.I.P
traidores
There is a special place in hell for traitors.
Tony Stewart These men were loyal to Germany, not Hitler.
Who are the traitors you're talking about? The rabid nazis who ultimately led Germany to its grisly, tragic, ruinous end or the ones who tried to avert the inevitable for their country, minimise the bloodshed, many more deaths and misery for their countrymen and others involved in the conflict and paid the ultimate price for the failure???