How To Define The Greatest Rapper Of All Time

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024

Комментарии • 2,3 тыс.

  • @willemdee
    @willemdee 7 лет назад +246

    These never ending debates over preference are always amusing cause someone will get mad at your top 5 cause it doesn't match their own lol

    • @alphaamigo9688
      @alphaamigo9688 7 лет назад +8

      willemdee ikr. People need to understand that you can't have twenty people in your top five.

    • @odg42
      @odg42 7 лет назад +10

      nobody 123 exactly man, top 5s are hard as fuck to make, I can't stand leaving out certain rappers but that's the challenge of it I guess
      Yet people still take it as a moment to try and" educate" you on the culture because you left out their favourite backpack rapper from arizona or some shit.
      People get fucking bloodthirsty over GOAT lists, that's why I only partake over comment sections, I dont wanna die for this shit 😂

    • @rickeybernard8156
      @rickeybernard8156 7 лет назад +1

      willemdee exactly

    • @rickeybernard8156
      @rickeybernard8156 7 лет назад

      SAMO KiiNG dude please. That best mc shit is opinion at best. At the most it's popular opinion. The reason people do that because they either conform or they are frustrated someone does not share the same opinion. It's like that "Made you look" remix. It's easily arguable that Luda and Kiss washed Nas on that track, but since it's Nas, popular opinion is Nas did better. You can't say someone is better without another being discredited.

    • @p.u.r.emusicgroup894
      @p.u.r.emusicgroup894 7 лет назад

      soundcloud.com/stew-art-pure/moon-walkin-prod-by-thovo

  • @slaughterbuku6614
    @slaughterbuku6614 7 лет назад +240

    Why everyone sleeps on Andre3000. Most creative . He's a real Artist .. great fashion sense. He's the best writer composter and rapper in my opinion. Outkast changed the south.. He started the fashion trends rappers now days . he's lyrically and musically gifted than most of the top 5. He's always consistent in delivery. wordsmith.

    • @didiermashaba8464
      @didiermashaba8464 7 лет назад +2

      Tramaine didn't he cross dress?

    • @MsJustcurious24
      @MsJustcurious24 7 лет назад +10

      Tramaine Andre is the true GOAT above all the things you mentioned he is also the best performer (when it comes to hip hop) till this day

    • @MB-yi4wu
      @MB-yi4wu 7 лет назад +3

      Tramaine when Andre 3000 puts out another solo album excluding that Love Below bullshit and it's hot then you have an argument

    • @danielmclaren170890
      @danielmclaren170890 7 лет назад +1

      does he even have a solo album?
      he dresses like I chick trying to be a guy or a guy trying to be a chick. that's fashion if you're trans

    • @kharis87
      @kharis87 7 лет назад

      Daniel McLaren I agree his fashion is straight up fruity. That bull shit agenda he has to play into. But as a lyricist he is great......however he needs a real solo album to validate how great he really is.

  • @maltherossel9348
    @maltherossel9348 7 лет назад +105

    Also, thank you, Justin, for showing up for Lupe Fiasco, THE most underrated and undervalued rapper ever no shit!

    • @hiphopdx
      @hiphopdx  7 лет назад +18

      Agreed!!

    • @EagleZtoTheGrave
      @EagleZtoTheGrave 7 лет назад +2

      Yes sir

    • @-Anonymous-.
      @-Anonymous-. 7 лет назад +5

      He never got the credit he deserved. 1 big reason is that Kanye overshadowed him. The lane Lupe was in during the 2000's Kanye was at the forefront, even though technically Lupe is a better skilled rapper. If the cool & food & liquor dropped today he would be more valued.

    • @maltherossel9348
      @maltherossel9348 7 лет назад +5

      If The Cool, Food & Liquor and Food & Liquor II were released by Kendrick today they would be hailed as some of the best albums ever.

    • @-Anonymous-.
      @-Anonymous-. 7 лет назад +3

      Malthe Rossel very true man. & kdot has a very similar cadence to Lupe when it comes to his approach on records with deeper/in depth meanings, & hidden messages.

  • @mattsak3338
    @mattsak3338 7 лет назад +98

    Black thought is mad underated

    • @stephen214
      @stephen214 4 года назад

      This comment is on EVERY debate video and gets LOADS of appreciation... just saying

    • @mattsak3338
      @mattsak3338 4 года назад +1

      2020Ave facts. He def gets respect. 15 year old me 3 years thought he has underrated bc he is underrated in younger demographics.

    • @stephen214
      @stephen214 4 года назад

      @Matt Sak fair mate

    • @zachyboi7293
      @zachyboi7293 3 года назад

      He's not consistent

  • @mystatamiaj
    @mystatamiaj 7 лет назад +93

    "I went to the hat store and bought a new hat" #fire

  • @KKillaMcneal
    @KKillaMcneal 7 лет назад +22

    Can we please stop sleeping on Big Boi?
    I think it is so disrespectful how people are quick to mention Andre, but Big Boi has had plenty of individual success with Sir Lucious Left Foot, I would say that album will go down as a classic. Its so slept on and the experimentation of Vicious Lies and Dangerous Truths that was not as good as Sir Lucious, but to see Big Boi step out of his comfort zone working with Phantogram.
    Big Boi is just not another rapper and I LOVE 3K, but please do not sleep on Big Boi.

  • @hondafan163
    @hondafan163 7 лет назад +160

    i love jude and justin together there should be more collabs with him

  • @billystutz55
    @billystutz55 7 лет назад +81

    "Ain't no best." - Nas

    • @saul_goodman3932
      @saul_goodman3932 4 года назад

      Nah there's a best

    • @hbkashhh3452
      @hbkashhh3452 4 года назад +10

      Nas is the best

    • @saul_goodman3932
      @saul_goodman3932 4 года назад

      @@hbkashhh3452 I disagree I think nas is overrated because of illmatic and ether

    • @shady8045
      @shady8045 4 года назад

      true but that doesn't mean there aren't various degrees of good and bad, i personally would characterize quality as whether it succeeds its artistic intention and how well those appeal to me (ie a feel good song that makes you feel good or a horror core song that makes you scared, or a political song that has good thoughtful messages ) how creativity it is and the influence those innovative decisions had on the medium as a whole, the difficulty of the craft (which is why i respect a lot of "lyrical miracle" rap despite it being a pretty saturated sub genre). 2 and 3 in particular are the most concerned with technically ability like rhyme and flow while for the most part all 3 is relevant to the lyrics themselves.
      for example Kendrick Lamar's best albums hits each criteria the hardest, exceptionally innovative with extremely unique flows and production (especially in TPAB), compelling in its message, and technically proficient, and those are considered some of the best albums of all time. same with a lot of the other "goats" like Nas and big, both succeeded at what they were trying to do in each song compellingly, wrote their songs in a difficult way that required wit, and innovated the genre. even some sound cloud rappers occasionally meet some of these marks and honestly good for them (granted plenty don't, looking at you lil Xan).

    • @saul_goodman3932
      @saul_goodman3932 3 года назад

      @Mathematics em,jay,mf doom,all of the wu tang, outkast, etc

  • @munozjonathan86
    @munozjonathan86 7 лет назад +7

    I love when Justin and Rude Jude have these convos.

  • @jeremybutler2103
    @jeremybutler2103 7 лет назад +155

    Mos Def always get left outta the GOAT conversations. He's mosdefinetly Top5. No doubt.

    • @ameensimmons4626
      @ameensimmons4626 7 лет назад +2

      Jeremy Butler these people don't know!!!!!!!

    • @Ghuttora7
      @Ghuttora7 7 лет назад

      Jeremy Butler Blackstar Respiration with Common is voted as one the best hiphop written tracks of all time.

    • @tonyschimmoeller4439
      @tonyschimmoeller4439 7 лет назад +11

      Love Mos but I'd say Black Thought and Pharoahe Monch deserve top 5 before Mos.

    • @MR_RAVEZ
      @MR_RAVEZ 7 лет назад +8

      How is Mos Def is Top 5? He's a dope Emcee but I wouldn't put him Top 5 or even Top 20

    • @ameensimmons4626
      @ameensimmons4626 7 лет назад

      his ability plus the impact of his music and all his music holds up and btw he killed every feature he was on .....

  • @YnSo33
    @YnSo33 7 лет назад +30

    Mixtape weezy Lil wayne was unmatched because of his constancy and quality output. Not to mention his cultural relevance, he's arguably one of the most influential to do it. So many different dope flows, def my top 10 all time. Sad that ppl downplay his career when he unarguably ran hip hop for 4 years...

  • @emmanueld.1816
    @emmanueld.1816 7 лет назад +21

    Lupe Fiasco. No other rappers are making concept albums like Tetsuo & Youth, intertwining social issues, spirituality, cartoons and video games seamlessly. You can put 'Mural' against any other rapper's best song. He makes conscious songs over trap beats. Not to mention the Michael Young History epic. He's great by any measure of a rapper, wordplay, flow, metaphors allusions, couplets etc...and DROGAS Wave is on the way. Just my two cents..thank you guys for making this video for the culture.

    • @momo-ht2oe
      @momo-ht2oe 7 лет назад +1

      Emmanuel D. Mural is in the top 3 of my favourite song. 1 The Great Gig In The Sky: Pink Floyd 2 March to the Sea: Twenty one pilots 3 Mural: Lupe Fiasco

  • @carterh3182
    @carterh3182 7 лет назад +328

    Does Jude really think in 10 years were gonna look back at TPAB and say "nah that albums stale now"? or even GKMC?

    • @melsotelo5109
      @melsotelo5109 7 лет назад +9

      Billy, From the Produce Section well from those albums he's probably only heard M.A.A.D city, poetic justice,alright,and king kunta. as he's said he hasn't actually listened to most of his catalog

    • @carterh3182
      @carterh3182 7 лет назад +2

      Mel Sotelo He said last video he listened to TPAB. But you're probably right about GKMC.

    • @jacobrobinson8310
      @jacobrobinson8310 7 лет назад +4

      Billy, From the Produce Section He never heard the albums in their entirety. So he wouldn't know.

    • @luistorres8005
      @luistorres8005 7 лет назад

      Billy, From the Produce Section that dude didn't even hear them, he also says he doesn't listen to hip hop anymore. This guy's opinion on this means shit.

    • @Beamboy555
      @Beamboy555 7 лет назад +1

      Billy, From the Produce Section yes. In the same way 2Pacolypse is stale. No comparing Pac to Kendrick because Pac is on another level but without a doubt Kendrick will bring out some better shit than gkmc. It's the same way as looking at eminems albums the Slim Shady LP is stale and not as good because of the MMLP. It goes for every rapper with a buzz don't think kendricks an exception because your basically saying he won't make anything better

  • @MugsyBrews
    @MugsyBrews 7 лет назад +2

    I love these dudes and really dig their banter/chemistry. Justin Hunte I appreciate what you doing, keep it up bruh

  • @killekillekille1
    @killekillekille1 7 лет назад +9

    My top 10: Pac, Biggie, Rakim, Big Pun, Eminem, Kanye, Jay Z, Kane, Nas and Wu-Tang

  • @MIkkoBaffo
    @MIkkoBaffo 7 лет назад +270

    I'd listen to this as a Spotify podcast. Thoughts?

    • @Ghost_Nava
      @Ghost_Nava 7 лет назад +1

      MIkkoBaffo Jude use to have a podcast but contractually with Siriusxm he can't do podcasts

    • @cordellboss
      @cordellboss 7 лет назад +3

      MIkkoBaffo since when does Spotify have Podcasts?

    • @drivmwempozv4445
      @drivmwempozv4445 7 лет назад

      MIkkoBaffo FUCKING AGREED

    • @MIkkoBaffo
      @MIkkoBaffo 7 лет назад +2

      Immortal Vegan In the UK if you pay 9.99 a month you have access to podcasts.

    • @MIkkoBaffo
      @MIkkoBaffo 7 лет назад +1

      EddyNaVa76 is that so? That's a shame

  • @PreparedDeath
    @PreparedDeath 7 лет назад +49

    There is a reason everyone gets compared to Pac. He seems to tick every box, other rappers do certain things better but he is too hard to ignore.

    • @gh0rochi363
      @gh0rochi363 6 лет назад +2

      PreparedDeath how does he tick all boxes? I like Pac but bars wise he's lacking. He says nothing amazing. Good beats but that's the producers and sound engineers. Not even the most original in flow nor subject matter. He s a good rapper. If He s your favorite dope but that doesn't make him the goat

    • @tupacshakur3745
      @tupacshakur3745 6 лет назад +5

      taaj howell Brenda's Got A Baby, California Love, To Live And Die In LA, Runnin, 2 Of Americaz Most Wanted, All Eyez On Me, Ambitionz Az A Ridah, Ghetto Gospel, Dear Mama, I Get Around, Keep Ya Head Up, Only God Can Judge Me, Hit Em Up, How Do U Want It, Hail Mary, Me Against The World, and hundreds and hundreds more. Yeah forget that he ain't talented

    • @Dubz9Ball
      @Dubz9Ball 6 лет назад

      taaj howell I agree

    • @jjocto
      @jjocto 6 лет назад

      Fuck tupac

    • @Anthonydu01630
      @Anthonydu01630 5 лет назад +2

      taaj howell i always find it funny when people says yes he has good beats but its the producer and sound engineers work ... Of course but who fucking choosed the beat man ??? Eminem whad the best producer in the world but most of his beats are wack, beats selection are one of the quality of a rapper. Drake, Lil wayne and kendrick are very good for that that's why their music almost always sound good to the ears, choosing a beat that will fit you well is a skill

  • @andreacusi
    @andreacusi 7 лет назад +40

    FINALLY SOMEONE MENTIONED ROYCE DA 59

    • @MFSGamePlay
      @MFSGamePlay 7 лет назад +1

      Andrea Cusanno right. too bad he doesn't want the success. well, to me he doesn't.

    • @jaycee598
      @jaycee598 6 лет назад

      Royce da Bomb

    • @tupacshakur3745
      @tupacshakur3745 6 лет назад +1

      Andrea Cusanno yeah seriously he is pretty fucking good

    • @bourkupine1281
      @bourkupine1281 6 лет назад

      Yeah, he's one of the only people who can do better than Eminem on a song

    • @stephen214
      @stephen214 4 года назад

      @Andrea Cusanno 3 years ago... You wait for his 2018 and 2020 releases!! 🔥🔥

  • @Belowone
    @Belowone 7 лет назад +114

    GOAT rappers people never mention: Big L.

    • @lultimmsrevolver
      @lultimmsrevolver 7 лет назад +6

      Doom Santana he died so young

    • @alphaamigo9688
      @alphaamigo9688 7 лет назад +12

      Doom Santana Big L could have definitely become the GOAT, or at least one of the GOATs, had he not died so young.

    • @wm_9640
      @wm_9640 7 лет назад +5

      Doom Santana doesn't have a catalog

    • @lulujones
      @lulujones 7 лет назад +18

      Big L - 2 classic albums, not in the conversation
      Biggie - 2 classic albums, in the conversation...okay

    • @Belowone
      @Belowone 7 лет назад

      Elrond Hubbard exactly!!

  • @zublack5609
    @zublack5609 7 лет назад +20

    Wassup hiphopdx I'd rather you debate with a dude that's not so bias to music he obviously doesn't listen to .. Kendrick Lamar is arguably one of the greatest period , I noticed he never said anything when you brought up Wayne .. how could you not recognize Wayne skills,, innovation, impact on hip-hop , even Scarface who he was dickriding so much said Wayne is one of the greatest of all time ... Use that quote in the next show ... please debate with someone more like yourself .Who's more objective and introspective

  • @sammyjaber1338
    @sammyjaber1338 7 лет назад +5

    Lupe fiasco's hip hop saved my life was a great 3rd party song... words I've never said was so socially great... but 2pac was so great and makes you feel something great every time.

  • @timjamesbitch4693
    @timjamesbitch4693 7 лет назад +6

    1. Eminem
    2. Biggie
    3. Pac
    4. Pun
    5. Weezy

  • @odg42
    @odg42 7 лет назад +30

    GOAT list for me:
    1. Pac
    2. Eminem
    3. Nas
    4. Biggie
    5. Kendrick Lamar
    6. André 3000
    7. DMX
    8. Jay Z
    9. GZA
    10. MF DOOM

    • @divinericks68
      @divinericks68 7 лет назад +1

      ODG I agree with this list

    • @clamp202
      @clamp202 5 лет назад

      bleachlover 2000 3 stacks the goat bro

    • @Anthonydu01630
      @Anthonydu01630 5 лет назад

      Loool, GZA, MF DOOM 😂 Nobody listen that shit man cmon ... You cant put underground rapper on a GOAT list, they dont have influence, they dont have cultural relevance .. If they are not famous is because they arent good, period. They can be amazing lyricist but rap is not only that but also flow, voices, delivery, charisma, energy, beat selection !!!

    • @Anthonydu01630
      @Anthonydu01630 5 лет назад

      Were is Wayne ? Were is Kanye ? Were is Drake ? Were is fucking snoop dogg ? Biggie had 2fucking album in his career how can you put him ahead of Jay-z when he has 14number 1album and 22grammy ??? When he has 3classic and 6others very good albums ???? And lil wayne is the most influencial, original, creative and productive rapper ever, like it or not its a fact so if he isnt in your top 10 you are biased.

    • @shady8045
      @shady8045 4 года назад

      here is mine
      1.kendrick
      2.biggie
      3. mf doom
      4. Jay z
      5. Black thought
      6. Rakim
      7. Eminem
      8.pac
      9. Andre
      10. Nas

  • @EyemJustMe
    @EyemJustMe 7 лет назад

    HipHopDX is a blessing to the hip hop community. They provoke great conversation.

  • @KtotheG
    @KtotheG 7 лет назад +15

    "Latest is greatest" is a cancerous mentality in hip hop. Smh. We're the only music genre where our "greatest" changes every 5 years. I can't stand that shit.

  • @charlienorthover1702
    @charlienorthover1702 5 лет назад +5

    THE TOP TEN HAS TO BE:
    1)2Pac (he had TOTAL control and mastery of the people)
    2)A Tribe Called Quest (a group but hip hop nevertheless)
    3)Scarface
    4)Biggie
    5)Rakim
    6)MF DOOM and all his other aliases
    7)Kendrick Lamar (this is because his lyrics are poetry in motion)
    8)Ice Cube (wrote a lot of albums, songs and is a fucking genius in general- also has the BEST dis track in the WORLD)
    9)Nas
    10)Aesop Rock (personal favorite of mine)
    THE BEST YOUNG RAPPER OF ALL TIME (not hip hop, but rap in general)
    DIZZEE RASCAL
    *drops mic*

  • @chickenfightaz
    @chickenfightaz 7 лет назад +31

    Pac, Kendrick, Jay-z, Lil Wayne, Nas

    • @kevinlos8231
      @kevinlos8231 7 лет назад +3

      Fernando Harris I'd have to give it up to this list

    • @alexsar4852
      @alexsar4852 7 лет назад +3

      Fernando Harris Lil Wayne GOAT!!

    • @saul_goodman3932
      @saul_goodman3932 4 года назад

      Lil wayne😭

    • @goat9283
      @goat9283 4 года назад

      Hater

    • @gkay8889
      @gkay8889 3 года назад

      Get Pac out and we straight

  • @meeksman2488
    @meeksman2488 7 лет назад +9

    "I can" on Gods son is one of the best rap songs of all time

  • @bigodetexas
    @bigodetexas 7 лет назад +125

    at 25 pac had the whole country ready for war. nobody in the history of rap made you feel the way pac did. pac is goat period

    • @ItsValWow
      @ItsValWow 5 лет назад +10

      Andre better

    • @joelclark2183
      @joelclark2183 5 лет назад +1

      Think that's debateable but okay.

    • @ItsValWow
      @ItsValWow 5 лет назад +2

      Joel Clark Andre is better than Pac imo

    • @joelclark2183
      @joelclark2183 5 лет назад +4

      @@ItsValWow No I do too I was just replying to the first guy. Andre better easily, Pacs influence was massive but he has a mediocre discog. All Eyez On Me is the most overrated Classic OAT

    • @ItsValWow
      @ItsValWow 5 лет назад +2

      Joel Clark FAX! Pac still a legend thi

  • @EddyKaSham
    @EddyKaSham 7 лет назад +8

    you know you're old when you refer to people as "cats"

  • @elibenGodson
    @elibenGodson 7 лет назад +8

    2pac. Andre 3k... two of the greatest if all times!

  • @Antifrustrated
    @Antifrustrated 7 лет назад +68

    At the end of the day, who is "THE GOAT" is all subjective, it really doesn't matter who is considered the greatest and who isn't

    • @thedondon911911
      @thedondon911911 7 лет назад +2

      Leo this is the most ignorant comment I've ever read about hip hop

    • @Antifrustrated
      @Antifrustrated 7 лет назад +13

      thedondon911911 Explain to me what was ignorant about what I said?

    • @giornogiovanna845
      @giornogiovanna845 7 лет назад +7

      thedondon911911 Yes...Do explain how what he said is ignorant....Cuz my G.O.A.T is Biggie

    • @tendo824
      @tendo824 7 лет назад

      Bernard Gilkes Mine is Biggie too...

    • @jovonj4010
      @jovonj4010 7 лет назад +1

      biggie is mine too. Then Nas...Then ghostface.

  • @ahjgetloud
    @ahjgetloud 7 лет назад +4

    Watching the end of this makes me think you should do a Breakdown piece about overshadowed greats, those that are collaborative and/or in groups. Big Boi is an example of a group and Royce is an example because of early AND recent collaboration with Eminem. The mention of Black Thought was also interesting.

  • @RockyBergen
    @RockyBergen 7 лет назад

    I am glad you are breaking this down and am happy to spend the hour with you doing it.

  • @hoop6822
    @hoop6822 Год назад +1

    That point about the old heads at the start is so good.
    People who are underrated in the GOAT convo, Lupe, DOOM, Andre, Big L, Big Pun, Kool G Rap, Chuck D, Black Thought, Canibus and Scarface.
    Obviously the more common ones, Nas, Big, Pac, Em, Rakim, Kendrick, Jay Z are very good too.

  • @sillypenta
    @sillypenta 7 лет назад +144

    I went to the hat store and got a new hat.

  • @elibenGodson
    @elibenGodson 7 лет назад +4

    "IS THERE A HEAVEN FOR A BALLER"?- Tu Pac (Only Fear of Death) one of the coolest phares ever in rap

  • @JimmiPynk
    @JimmiPynk 7 лет назад +9

    only half way through, but I have to agree with Jude. Without knowledge of the entirety of hip hop, you cannot​ even be in a conversation discussing the GOAT. Some criminally underrated emcees (not GOAT status) are AZ, Rah Digga, Phonte, and Left Eye, yes Left Eye, go back and listen to Left Eye flow and then listen to pop Nicki Minaj, or Natina from Blaque. If you can't make educated comparisons you have no business even casting a vote in who the GOAT is. Great show so far. Can't wait to watch the rest!

    • @DarkMajava
      @DarkMajava 6 лет назад

      Jimmi Pynk And now Gates is so damn close.

  • @upshawjohn94
    @upshawjohn94 7 лет назад +1

    I think both guys bring up great points.
    My ways of classifying someone a goat is from:
    1. Influence
    2. Critical Acclaim
    3. Consistent Prime
    4. Relevance
    5. Commercial Success

  • @MikeNmurdoc
    @MikeNmurdoc 7 лет назад

    These discussions are some of my favorite videos on youtube. Thanks Justin and Jude for being the two of the only cats around willing just see what the other one thinks about hip hop. RESPECK!

  • @darman210
    @darman210 7 лет назад +9

    Jay Z- for the success
    Eminem/Lil Wayne- for the worldplay
    Lupe- for the intelligence
    Tupac- enough said
    Twista/Biggie- for the flow
    Outcast/Bone/Wu Tang- best groups
    Kanye- great production

    • @radagastthebrown5025
      @radagastthebrown5025 7 лет назад +1

      Darkeith Lofton lil wayne ? who shit in ur brain? (freestyle for scale)

    • @alexsar4852
      @alexsar4852 7 лет назад +1

      Radagast The Brown lil Wayne The GOAT bitch!!

    • @djandreatkinson8671
      @djandreatkinson8671 5 лет назад

      Jay z is the goat

    • @ninadganore
      @ninadganore 5 лет назад

      @@radagastthebrown5025 wayne is the goat

    • @420speedweed
      @420speedweed 3 года назад

      eminem and wayne's wordplay arent anything special

  • @moose2066
    @moose2066 7 лет назад +45

    I think it's almost impossible to determine the best rapper of all time...u can't do it without discrediting other rappers, is it Pac??What about the other cats from the 90's illmatic, ready to die don't count?What about LL cool J,Slick Rick, KRS or Rakeem(80s rappers) who came way before Pac(or any other 90s rapper)
    What about Eminem,3k,MF or even Kendrick(99-10s rappers)
    HipHop changes and evolves. sounds different every decade.
    How do we determine this,skill or Discography?

    • @tropical9913
      @tropical9913 7 лет назад +4

      iMoose you simply can't crown a hip-hop artist as the greatest. impossible. it's not like pop or reggae, where you can easily say Michael Jackson & Bob Marley are the goats.

    • @UltimateDrDoom
      @UltimateDrDoom 7 лет назад

      Tropical99 Oh. I wasn't aware one specific genre isn't quantifiable where the rest are.

    • @moose2066
      @moose2066 7 лет назад +1

      Tropical99 yeah that's what I said

    • @thedondon911911
      @thedondon911911 7 лет назад

      iMoose it's about having common sense and not being biased

    • @K0sm1cKid
      @K0sm1cKid 7 лет назад +8

      Everyone is biased about music. It is purely bias. haha

  • @steelliving8785
    @steelliving8785 6 лет назад +3

    We are talking a time, when gangsta rap had emerged with the rise of N.W.A and Suge Knight’s Death Row. In a time when men were judged by what size gun they were carrying, Tupac was a man whom everyone respected despite his emotional bent of mind. He was the leader that Eminem could not be.

  • @heyitsvonage2768
    @heyitsvonage2768 7 лет назад

    at 23:28 I was like "ROLL THE FUCKING CLIP, JAMES!" hahahaha

  • @rcfresh4345
    @rcfresh4345 Год назад

    Dope channel..finally true hip hop heads from a perspective outside of NY ✊🏾 Keep it up 💯

  • @yinn9mm
    @yinn9mm 7 лет назад +8

    My Top 5: 1- Lil Wayne, 2- 2Pac, 3- J.Cole, 4- Eminem, 5- B.I.G.

  • @JimmiPynk
    @JimmiPynk 7 лет назад +43

    Eminem is like Jordan when he went to the Washington Wizards. too many lackluster performances done fucked his stats up and left it open for someone else to be considered the GOAT

    • @jordanrobinson8572
      @jordanrobinson8572 7 лет назад +1

      Jimmi Pynk 🤔🤔🤔 are you stupid or should I appreciate your wrong opinion. 🤔🤔🤔 joking thanks for telling us what you where thinking.

    • @JimmiPynk
      @JimmiPynk 7 лет назад +1

      learn to spell before you come for me darling, it's were not where.

    • @thclanavenger
      @thclanavenger 7 лет назад +3

      Jimmi Pynk he came back and claimed the title without claiming it but honestly redman is the shit

    • @KiddsWorldEntertainment
      @KiddsWorldEntertainment 7 лет назад +1

      Jordan Robinson " Wrong opinion" you just lost all credibility

    • @jordanrobinson8572
      @jordanrobinson8572 7 лет назад

      Controversial Radio I couldn't give two shit's.

  • @KtotheG
    @KtotheG 7 лет назад +3

    The Source pissed me off when they gave '93 'Til Infinity 3 1/2 mics. That shit was an instant classic in my eyes.

  • @Dcypha69
    @Dcypha69 7 лет назад

    this is better than everyday struggle , love how they let each other speak and acknowledge without interrupting

  • @enanvigil
    @enanvigil 7 лет назад

    I really look forward to these types of debates.you all respect each other and disagree... what a fucking concept now a days. Keep these coming. Respect

  • @jedmyth
    @jedmyth 7 лет назад +18

    Personal preference in no order
    Nas, HOV, 3 stacks, K Dot, Biggie, Tupac, and Wayne. Could say any of these on any given day

    • @jedmyth
      @jedmyth 7 лет назад +5

      NewNinetys Tha Carter 2, 3 and 4 not to mention any of his mixtapes. And this is from a guy who also had countless memorable features. Biggie had two of the best albums in rap at that time. As far as straight spitting no one did it better. I don't think he is the GOAT but the way he was able to impact society in such a short amount of time gives him more than a reason to be in the top 5

    • @desolatesouls3040
      @desolatesouls3040 7 лет назад

      What do you think about Big Pun?

    • @alexsar4852
      @alexsar4852 7 лет назад +1

      NewNinetys lol Wayne is The Greatest..

    • @4neumann
      @4neumann 5 лет назад

      @@desolatesouls3040 'scuse me for blunt but i been eating cunt since pimps was pushin pink caddies wit the fishtank pumps
      These kids dumb as fuck. Drake an entertainer, not a rapper. Wayne ain't close to top 20. Pac a poet, and no disrespect, but no top 5. Check the fucking Big ghost chronicles softest in the game for a good laugh.

    • @ninadganore
      @ninadganore 5 лет назад +1

      @@4neumann wayne the goat, Drake one if the goats

  • @ahjgetloud
    @ahjgetloud 7 лет назад +16

    Love the dynamic but you can't argue with a guy that "no longer listens to rap".

  • @Vuitton_The_Ruler_
    @Vuitton_The_Ruler_ 7 лет назад +20

    Rakim is the 'G.O.A.T.' PERIOD!

  • @TinyMontgomery204
    @TinyMontgomery204 6 лет назад +1

    Love these convos. Usually agree more with Justin but I appreciate Jude just as much. You two are really entertaining. One thing I'd ask Jude is if he really expects Kendrick's last 4 projects to not stand the test of time. For example, I can confidently say that To Pimp a Butterfly will go down as the greatest album of the 2010's, as well as one of the best of all time. It's changed music a mere three years after its release, and has inspired/influenced people outside of the hip hop community from David Bowie to Kasmani Washington. I really don't see us 20 years from now going "man, what were we thinking. That project wasn't that good".

  • @rocketk1442
    @rocketk1442 Год назад +1

    Got to look at the greats Melly Mell,Kurtis Blow, Run DMC, Rakim, Fat Boys,Kane, MC Lyte, Latifah, Krs1, Kane, Doug E Fresh, Slick Rick, Method Man, Red man, Ice Cube, NWA, Queen Latifah, Salt N Peppa, Moe Dee, DOC , etc
    LL is the Michael Jordan of rap he pulled from everyone. Built Def Jam, Jams still being played on radio to this day. Took it global inspired jay z, pac, eminem etc made rap sexxy appeared vulnerable. Had the biggest gold chains . He is the blue print . I could go on !

  • @KtotheG
    @KtotheG 7 лет назад +11

    Ice Cube was the first rapper to release albums in consecutive years.

    • @terrenceperkins5282
      @terrenceperkins5282 4 года назад

      &

    • @KtotheG
      @KtotheG 4 года назад

      @@terrenceperkins5282 I guess you didn't watch the video.

    • @420speedweed
      @420speedweed 3 года назад

      thats not even true though rakim and big daddy kane did that before cube

  • @WhyIDontHaveALife
    @WhyIDontHaveALife 7 лет назад +5

    "Drakes the most overrated rapper" You just earned a subscription and a like my friend.

  • @DoubleRRslimm
    @DoubleRRslimm 7 лет назад +58

    PAC is always #1

  • @s.m.pravin9738
    @s.m.pravin9738 3 года назад +2

    Lil Wayne has everything. Great bars, great commercial success, never had a bad verse, he created mumble rap, doesn’t hesitate to get out of his comfort zone and sound like today’s rappers and still spit fire. I don’t think anyone can match Wayne.

  • @TrapNerdMusic
    @TrapNerdMusic 7 лет назад

    This is the most influential discussion on Hip Hop and Rap that I have ever watched. Hands down.

  • @lukeg3983
    @lukeg3983 7 лет назад +3

    Dude said hes unfamiliar with all of Kendrick's work then not 2 mins later says, "you can't say whose the greatest and not know all his shit." I know they're not talking Kendrick specifically but its kinda funny thats what started this convo

  • @mystatamiaj
    @mystatamiaj 7 лет назад +5

    Pimp C also sang his ass off on them hooks too boi!!!

  • @HugoHakvoort
    @HugoHakvoort 7 лет назад +42

    There's no GOAT. It's almost impossible to have an actual GOAT.

    • @thedondon911911
      @thedondon911911 7 лет назад +1

      Hugo Hakvoort yes there is a goat, you're just too lazy to argue

    • @HugoHakvoort
      @HugoHakvoort 7 лет назад +8

      I don't think you could really have a GOAT, you never know, there may be some really, really underground rappers who are technically better than a Biggy or an Eminem. Lyrics wise, a suburban white kid will relate more with a rap about partying and smoking weed than a rap about shit going on in the hood and about the relation between for example black Americans and the police. So even lyrically you can't really say the one is better than the other. Hip hop doesn't even need to be political, it wasn't in the late 70s and early 80s atleast. Yeah, I think a track with some well thought political lyrics is better than one about fucking 'bitches' even though I can't really relate with it, but even that is pretty opinion based.
      For example, a lot of people label Eminem as the GOAT, but for me in my personal opinion he wouldn't stand a chance because I really just like people like Nas or Kendrick more in the overall picture, even when Eminem is amazing technically and lyrically.

    • @tupacshakur3745
      @tupacshakur3745 6 лет назад +7

      I agree more or less. Everyone has their own strengths, it's really hard to compare artists.

    • @Dubz9Ball
      @Dubz9Ball 6 лет назад +5

      Tupac Shakur it’s all opinion at the end of the day you jus have to state ur case for who u like. No right or wrong answer

    • @aaronkeenan2552
      @aaronkeenan2552 5 лет назад

      Lionel Messi

  • @hatemalmasry
    @hatemalmasry 7 лет назад +1

    Great conversation!

  • @Wonderbread91
    @Wonderbread91 7 лет назад

    I know top anything is subjective. But the reason why I love these type of discussions is because they drop some knowledge that maybe I would've never known about ( certain songs or artist) and there is nothing better than going back and listening to some of these awesome projects and automatically adding it to your playlist.

  • @MrSquaky
    @MrSquaky 7 лет назад +11

    2pac

  • @jc3raps191
    @jc3raps191 6 лет назад +4

    Top 10
    1.) Nas
    2.) 2pac
    3.) Eminem
    4.) Kendrick Lamar
    5.) Lil Wayne
    6.) Kanye
    7.) Biggie
    8.) Ice Cube
    9.) Jay Z
    10.) J Cole

  • @nb2685
    @nb2685 7 лет назад +6

    I generally base artists off of specific talents. There's no goat for me, just goats of certain categories. For example, Big Boi is my goat of flow, Andre 3000 for lyrical talent, Jay Z for class and relevance of culture, Eminem for rhyming, Nas for the perfect mix

    • @demetrelontos1359
      @demetrelontos1359 4 года назад +2

      Doesn’t saying nas has the perfect mix basically just mean he’s the best of them all

    • @lightVs.DarkBalance
      @lightVs.DarkBalance 3 года назад

      @@demetrelontos1359 It's true honestly Nas has a balance of everything that makes an Emcee. He's completely all around and pretty much always puts out quality work.

  • @unknownstigma892
    @unknownstigma892 7 лет назад +1

    thank you!! for shouting out Lupe another greats you forgot to mention is gangstarr and big L. Pun and his crazy lyrics

  • @goldtamadrummer
    @goldtamadrummer 7 лет назад

    I could listen to Justin's conversations all day

  • @TollFree999
    @TollFree999 7 лет назад +3

    De La Soul needs to digitize their catalogue, no one owns cd players anymore. They're missing out on a lot record sales.

  • @tonylopez9574
    @tonylopez9574 7 лет назад +10

    Whoever has a ghost writer
    They can't be the GOAT
    TALKING ABOUT DRAKE

    • @shauncameron8390
      @shauncameron8390 5 лет назад +1

      Yet you'll hypocritically claim Kanye as one.

    • @radiationbacon
      @radiationbacon 3 года назад

      @@shauncameron8390 & Kendrick! Drake's highkey a bum but tbf everyone's dips their toe in ghostwriters usually. It's like steroids in pro sports, dark secret that everyone's on

    • @lulanononwo6276
      @lulanononwo6276 3 года назад

      Thay goes for Kanye can't be in no conversation either

  • @PlayKeeps-il4fn
    @PlayKeeps-il4fn 7 лет назад +15

    Wayne had 80 features in one year and took over a solid 4 yrs who else can do dat 🤔🤔

    • @nitsujneal
      @nitsujneal 7 лет назад +6

      David E he da 🐐

    • @thehound3582
      @thehound3582 7 лет назад +2

      2Coo 2kJunky HHQHAAHHAHAHAHAHA

    • @kevinlos8231
      @kevinlos8231 7 лет назад +7

      David E wtf Wayne ruled for more than 4years

    • @disobayent
      @disobayent 6 лет назад +1

      93-96 Pac >
      No mixtape shit either..

    • @ninadganore
      @ninadganore 5 лет назад +1

      6-7 years at least

  • @bejitah
    @bejitah 7 лет назад +1

    Canibus, AZ, R.A. The Rugged Man, Locksmith, Elzhi. Extreme top tier lyricism. I'll also throw in Loaded Lux if we're talking sheer lyrical ability. And that's just to name a few.

  • @OmegaSunsLight
    @OmegaSunsLight 7 лет назад +1

    Articulation, wittiness, cadence, motivation, wordplay, record making, and creativity does "The G.O.A.T" make.

  • @TollFree999
    @TollFree999 7 лет назад +7

    Scarface is highly under appreciated.

  • @whyisleohere
    @whyisleohere 7 лет назад +4

    1. Eminem2. Nas3. PAC4. Biggie 5. Rakim6. Jay Z7. Kendrick8. Kanye west9. Dmx10. Dr dre

  • @djaga_one
    @djaga_one 7 лет назад +3

    Everyone has their favorite "time" of the day. there is NO greatest time of the day. You can't say blue, yellow or green is the best color. It's all intertwined and part of eachother and can't co-excist without eachother.

  • @OsofoGriot
    @OsofoGriot 7 лет назад

    That first caller hits it BANG on. "You are not the greatest if we can tell the story of Hip Hop without you"

  • @StayBlessed69
    @StayBlessed69 7 лет назад

    I thought I'd listen to this for a minute. Ended up watching the whole thing. GREAT points guys.

  • @bmore24t56
    @bmore24t56 7 лет назад +54

    pac had 5 albums at his death 3 out of 5 being classics and the other albums still had classic material I love pac

  • @OtherworldlyMedia
    @OtherworldlyMedia 7 лет назад +8

    I think this whole conversation would flow much better if Jude sat down a sec to listen to DAMN.

    • @nosrac3339
      @nosrac3339 7 лет назад +3

      dio-03 GKMC* kendricks best hip hop album

    • @lovelyla85
      @lovelyla85 7 лет назад

      dio-03 exactly !!!😔

    • @OtherworldlyMedia
      @OtherworldlyMedia 7 лет назад

      Opinions on which album is best, or if the album is good, are relative, but Jude in no moment has actually heard the effin album. All his arguments are moot, cause he's just imagining what the album may or may not sound like.

    • @henrymccallion1986
      @henrymccallion1986 7 лет назад +1

      DAMN is K-dots worst album

  • @TheWolvesDen
    @TheWolvesDen 7 лет назад +3

    Big Willie Style is a solid project still.

  • @matthewerra9662
    @matthewerra9662 2 года назад

    Off topic, I love how they can argue, so to speak, more so proving their point, but still have respect for another’s opinions and actually try to understand each other without having their emotions getting the best of them. Phenomenal, this is how to influence different perspective.

  • @ddotson4
    @ddotson4 7 лет назад

    This might be the best-discoursed hiphop conversation I've ever heard online. Yall taught me some shit even though I agree and disagree with you both on so many points.

  • @Lasheem
    @Lasheem 7 лет назад +49

    2Pac has to be the GOAT.

    • @anthonynegron788
      @anthonynegron788 6 лет назад +7

      If 2Pac isn't the Greatest rapper, he is the most influential rapper

    • @grinchoi1
      @grinchoi1 6 лет назад +1

      Yeah its Pac no doubt

    • @alexsar4852
      @alexsar4852 6 лет назад

      Jay Murthy PAC after Wayne!!!

    • @grinchoi1
      @grinchoi1 6 лет назад +4

      Wayne? Lol he cant walk in Pac's shoes. They dont have murals of Wayne in slums in Africa nor have Armies named after him. Wayne doesnt have close to the global impact that Pac does. Even just listening to them talk you dont hear nothing from Wayne. Pac transcends hip hop, was an actor, activist, poet, revolutionary etc

    • @alexsar4852
      @alexsar4852 6 лет назад

      Jay Murthy yea because Wayne is not dead you fucking stupid ass goddammm why you so average bro??!!

  • @matttraverso4592
    @matttraverso4592 7 лет назад +59

    my top 10, with a loose order, easy to switch around
    nas
    andre 3k
    jay-z
    pac
    scarface
    biggie
    rakim
    kendrick
    em
    MF DOOM
    if any of you think i'm missing anyone, tell me

    • @RickyMud
      @RickyMud 7 лет назад +6

      Matt Traverso Aesop

    • @meeksman2488
      @meeksman2488 7 лет назад +2

      I mostly agree

    • @rockster0192
      @rockster0192 7 лет назад +2

      DJ quik,

    • @Laurie12SlimShady
      @Laurie12SlimShady 7 лет назад +5

      big l, big pun, wu tang, redman all better than biggie and scarface imo but it's all preference

    • @jordanrobinson8572
      @jordanrobinson8572 7 лет назад +14

      Arsenal K he's tries to be corny on purpose he does it so people like you say shit like that.
      it's what makes his career 😂

  • @urbaezpablo
    @urbaezpablo 7 лет назад +21

    Pac
    Big
    Em
    Nas
    Rakim
    jay z
    50 cent
    Lil Wayne
    Big L
    Kendrick

  • @Ghost_Nava
    @Ghost_Nava 7 лет назад +2

    Great conversations overall

  • @josmoe674
    @josmoe674 2 года назад

    Impeccable interview🔥

  • @aadammohammed5878
    @aadammohammed5878 7 лет назад +20

    Beethoven is the greatest rapper of all time if you wanna talk about influences, cause rap came from rock and roll, rock and roll came from soul, soul came from r&b, etc. etc.
    My point is just because someone influenced someone does not take away from their credentials, cause Scarface had his influences, like slick Rick and ice cube, and he took those influences and reshaped them, their essence is still there, but innovation did take place, sane thing goes for Kendrick Lamar. They only thing Kendrick is missing is a legacy/ school of rappers to come holding him as their influence, other than that, commercial success, critical acclaim, lyricism, emotional connection, he's got it all and he's got more accolades than your favourite rapper, 4 certified classics (including DAMN obviously), 1 of 4 rap albums to get a certificate from havard (Illmatic, miseducation of Lauryn Hill and the low end theory) Best streaming album of all time (DAMN) and two of the highest ever album, not just hip hop, in all context of music on Metacritic. 7 Grammy's with two projects, most Grammy nominations for a rapper. Kendrick has it all

    • @Dank_Dank
      @Dank_Dank 7 лет назад +2

      He killed Justin Bieber on Epic Rap Battles Of History

    • @feresantar6803
      @feresantar6803 4 года назад

      if we're gonna talk about commercial success and numbers eminem is number one + the dude has an oscar and he did everything and a lot of styles through his whole career he began as a clown in hip hop and funny as fuck with insane lyrics and he managed to become one of the best lyricist to ever live and has insane rhyming skill and wordplays and he's still killing it ... he has it all . my point is just becuz kenrick is your favorite rapper doesn't mean he is the best . im not saying eminem is the best but each rapper has an influence and the difference is what makes it perfect . it would be boring if we all agree on one rapper you know ..

  • @bubabuba3848
    @bubabuba3848 7 лет назад +4

    MY TOP 6 with Jay z, Pac, Weez, Andre 300, Em, Drake

  • @vegancoastie9630
    @vegancoastie9630 7 лет назад +7

    Where is Lupe in the GOAT talk? These fools sleeping on Tetsuo and Youth but, Lu did say "Bumped into Doom the greatest rappers collide
    Everybody dead but AZ the greatest rapper survived
    I'm not the greatest rapper... the greatest rappers' a lie
    Got the same points as Lux the greatest rappers a tie,
    Chris said Common, Common said Kweli, Talib said I'm sure it's Mos Definitely"

  • @kyronmadethis2002
    @kyronmadethis2002 6 лет назад +2

    1. 2Pac
    2. Nas
    3. Eminem
    4. Jay-Z
    5.Lil Wayne
    6. Kanye West
    7. Andre 3000
    8. Rakim
    9. Kendrick Lamar
    10. Ice cube
    Top 10 in my opinion

  • @joshs5843
    @joshs5843 7 лет назад +1

    I think Kool Keith is extremely underrated. Sure, his discography is not all A+ material, but he also has like ~20 albums over FOUR decades. Always bringing interesting new concepts, the different personas, pioneered the horrorcore/sci-fi raps, not to mention being part of Ultramagnetic MCs. He can spit in several different styles, and is definitely not afraid to go completely left field which brings a lot of influence .

  • @SuperKnockyoudown
    @SuperKnockyoudown 7 лет назад +5

    Eminem is the goat, like seriously most records sold by almost double to any other rapper. Best lyricist by far he reads the dictionary for fun. Introduced many crazy new styles. Has been creating rap constantly since 88. All his music is catchy as fuck. He can freestyle better than anyone past or present maybe even future. He has the speed, he can rap faster than tech n9ne. His fluent words and fluent flow is unparralel and he was the first white boy who made it big and got accepted by another race into their territory. MGK Mac miller etc all can't rap for shit in my opinion compared to em they are nothing but dust. So there you have it in every category Eminem is untouched so stop saying he's not the goat just cuz of his skin color idiots. Andre 3000 in 2nd.

  • @yesp9248
    @yesp9248 7 лет назад +4

    If you didn't know Lil Wayne was the G.O.A.T, now ya do.

  • @detox2778
    @detox2778 7 лет назад +15

    Royce killed eminem on his own shit several times , Royce deserves a hat in the ring

    • @MFSGamePlay
      @MFSGamePlay 7 лет назад +1

      Alexander Eastwood yeah, bad meets evil was why I like him more.. he's very good.

    • @JohnDoe-tr1cx
      @JohnDoe-tr1cx 7 лет назад +5

      Royce will never escape Em's Shadow

    • @eminemfan2636
      @eminemfan2636 6 лет назад +3

      Hard for Royce cos he can’t get out of ems shadow

    • @parmar__12
      @parmar__12 6 лет назад

      Detox 2 it was always equal
      Perfectly balanced they both snapped

  • @thedondon911911
    @thedondon911911 7 лет назад

    Versatility, consistency, and impact are the biggest categories

  • @iluvdc202
    @iluvdc202 7 лет назад

    This was so good I watched it twice 💯 Justin, you said at the end of this marvelous piece of hip hop dialogue, that you were still unsure of "The Breakdown" topic for tomorrow, April 29. After the recent events and conversations in hip hop, highlighted by pieces such as this discussion, I feel it would only be right to give us your "Breakdown" for the Tupac The GOAT conversation you teased on the end of your "Tupac-alikes" piece. Just a request from a fan of your work. Peace and love, brother ✊🏾