Which Echo Show Should You Buy? || Echo Show 5 vs Echo Show 8 vs Echo Show 10
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
- Which Echo Show Should You Buy? || Echo Show 5 vs Echo Show 8 vs Echo Show 10
This video takes you through everything you need to know with the Echo Show 5, the Echo Show 8, and the Echo Show 10. The Echo Show 5 and 8 are 2nd generation devices, while the Echo Show 10 is the 3rd generation smart display from Amazon. By the end of this video you will for sure know which Echo Show is worth it, and which is the best Echo Show that you should buy.
We didn't talk about the new Echo Show 15, but stay tuned for a full review of that product as it comes out later this year. Until then, here are the 3 products from today's video:
Amazon Echo Show 5 - geni.us/EchoShow52021 (Amazon affiliate link)
Amazon Echo Show 8 - geni.us/EchoShow82021 (Amazon affiliate link)
Amazon Echo Show 10 - geni.us/EchoShow10 (Amazon affiliate link)
Need a stand? Follow those links and you'll see an option for the Amazon provided stand with the Echo Show you want (not the 10 obviously).
These are the main three displays that Amazon sells and I think most people will be wondering about the following 7 comparison indices that we tell you about. Here are our timecodes for today's video:
00:00 - Which is the best Echo Show?
0:42 - The best Echo Show Screen for Video
4:02 - The best Echo Show For Speakers and Music
8:51 - Speaker quality demo
9:34 - What are the physical differences?
13:59 - Are there differences in a smart home?
17:12 - How much will they cost you over time?
19:43 - Echo Show camera comparison
23:48 - Similarities you might not expect
Subscribe to Take The Frustration Out Of Automation: / @automateyourlife
Our Tutorials Channel will help you get more out of your smart home: / @techyourlife1
Join our Patreon Group to get direct access to me (and for even deeper content): / automateyourlife
Our recommended smart home products (Amazon affiliate link): geni.us/3KzREP
Get in touch with us through the About Page on RUclips, or at automatelife.net
Automate Your Life is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and other Amazon websites.
Thanks for watching, and Don't Hate, Automate.
Brian 
Наука
Buying an Echo Show?
Amazon Echo Show 5 - geni.us/EchoShow52021 (Amazon affiliate link)
Amazon Echo Show 8 - geni.us/EchoShow82021 (Amazon affiliate link)
Amazon Echo Show 10 - geni.us/EchoShow10 (Amazon affiliate link)
Need a review of the Echo Show 15 compared to these? ruclips.net/video/Dk-_KTUT0Sk/видео.html
This is hands down probably THE BEST review & comparison for any product I’ve researched!!!! Excellent work buddy👊💯
Awesome! Thank you!
I bought three Echo Show 5s (2nd gen) just to monitor my Ring doorbell... AND I LOVE THEM! The sound is surprisingly good when I set two of them up in stereo on my wooden office desk. I didn't realize how good the sound was and all the cool things Alexa can do. At this moment the Echo Show 5s are just $45 so it's a crazy good deal.
Oh I'm glad to hear this! Makes my day when someone else finds something that helps so much
So detailed and you even included power use. Thank you. So useful.
Thank you Andy and I'm glad it's so helpful. A lot of work went into this one!
This is the best review ever! Thank you!!!
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for a thorough review of the 3 sizes. I feel better prepared to purchase what each room needs.
Glad it was helpful! There is a new version of the Echo Show 5 just released, so you can check out our review of that here: ruclips.net/video/kR-rN27FyTg/видео.html
Man, you are my hero, amaziiiiing and super useful content, all my home automation is based on the knowledge you offered through ur channel 👏👏👏
Ohhh thank you for this! I was feeling like maybe people didn't want this kind of content today!
Excellent, detailed yet simple and relevant review - This helps me make my decision - Thank You!
😀👍
Great info and comparisons for Echo show's.👍
Glad you think so! Thank you as always Lany!
Thank you so much for sharing your review
It's my pleasure! Thanks for watching and commenting!
Great video! Definitely made my decision earlier. Thank you
Glad I could help!
Amazing video keep up the great work!! Do you think you can go over the new Nest Renew program and eco features!? I tried listening to the Verge article but it's harder to understand than someone explaining it.
Tell me about it! Ya, I'm going to give a Google Nest updates soon :)
@@AutomateYourLife thank you 🙏🏾
I have two of the Echo 5, 2nd Generation and both have the adjustable stand to raise them up. I also have a piece of cooking aluminum foil under the full length of the speakers. It makes a big difference on the sound.
Reflection at its best! Good stuff!
Excellent review and report on the technology of Echo and Alexa app. Thank you very much.
Thank you! Enjoy!
I have an Echo Show 10. Totally love it. One can even watch tv/movies with it.
The best review on the subject I ever seen
Oh wow! Thanks Eduardo!
Dude! Thorough review there. 👏🏽👍🏽
Glad you liked it!
@@AutomateYourLife I tested the 5 and 8 yesterday. One thing I would add is that the mic on the 8 hears me better, I was worried it would ignore my commands just like on the 5. But too early to confirm!
Watch with the 5 how your orient it. If there's a lot of reflection of sound back towards the mics, you will get that. I think my 5 actually hears me better than my 8, so might be something odd
@@AutomateYourLife thanks i will watch the orientation, mic is facing away from us nothing we can do about that. I have used the 8 for a few days now and the mic is hit and miss, i dont like being ignored! :D
21:38 The way the camera moved around, I thought there was a cockroach in the corner, then another on the other side, then realized it was the table leg's anchor points. Whew!
By the way, great video. I learned a lot. Thanks.
ahahhahaa! Cockroach!
Hey! Did you know that Amazon updated the windows Alexa app. Now you can make it into an echo show. I don’t know if it’s US only, but it might be cool to look into for you! You can turn an old laptop, or have your pc automatically go into show mode after a few minutes of inactivity
Yeah! Totally installed this one! Good tip though for others as they see this!
What’s echo show?
sounds very useful, thanks. I will look and see if theres one for an Old Android tablet.
@@ghinzani1 i think i lot of people turn those into dashboards for their smart home
A ton of great info! I just got my first echo shows, I purchased one of each for my apartment.
Is it possible or at least for a newbie to figure out how to make all the speakers automatically connect when playing music, but remain independent for everything else?
I think what you want is a Multi Room Music group, which you can create by hitting the + in devices. Then you refer to that in your command for music, which if you want to really keep things independent totally, you can put in a routine that pushes the command into it. This video will help you with routine tips and tricks!
ruclips.net/video/rLYRCej5v9I/видео.html
I found a echo show 8 at the pawn shop and was pretty hesitant on it. My girlfriend has a echo show 5 which was pretty cool. I only owned a echo dot and loved it for playing music but after seeing her show 5 I became intrigued in them. I initially wanted a echo studio just for speaker purpose in my downstairs kitchen area but now decide on a show. I must say the echo show 8 has been great so far for me seeing as how I got it for a great price from the pawn shop. No complaints from me
Oh, so you found Tech Pawn! ;)
I have all three devices and they are quite useful and entertaining.
I'll be grabbing an Echo 15 when they release.
Lots of people, including me, on that one!
Thank you very much, and as always, great video.
But there is still one thing that I cannot understand: Why I cannot get a full-screen clock on my Echo Show 8?
Best regards.
It's an odd choice by Amazon, because there was a time we could choose a number of clocks. I figure it's just something they're working on Daniel...but I can't answer that fully right now!
@@AutomateYourLife Thank you very much for your kind answer. So, lets wait. Best regards and keep you excellent work.
Great video! I was just wondering is there any real difference between the echo 10 and the echo 8 for the visually impaired / blind people. Like the show me feature. Which tells the person what they are holding..
There's really no difference other than the screen turning and the slightly bigger screen when it comes to visual features for blind/impairments
I'm looking for a budget echo show to use with the ring video doorbell. I didn't realize the Google hub I just grabbed for less than $50 at Lowe's wouldn't pair with it. We live in a bad neighborhood and there's been some thefts recently.
The echo show 5 or 8 work well for that
Tweeter ‘and the monkey man’, ha, great add in! Whaaa? 2 seconds later ‘haha’. Just tossed the song on my show 8 now.
Ahahahaha yesssssss
i remember you told me that the show 10 can be use as trigger for routine when it detects motion (given the light is adequate) and i saw that you have a routine setup that if no motion is detected screen will turn off. question is this, is that function regional? i can't find it anywhere in the Alexa app. thanks Brian
It should just be in the list of routines triggers for the smart home section. You'll find the Echo Show there. You know, it might make sense to change the region on your account if you're missing features like this.
thanks for this video
Our pleasure!
Thanks Brian. 👍🏻
Thank you Ron!
Lmao! The outro though - don't hate, automate - catchy indeed.
Yesssssssssssssss ;)
I am thinking about the 10 for my father-in-law who has dementia. I want to be able to video chat with him when needed, also so his Dr. At the VA can do video appointments. Is this a good choice for these uses?
In general yes. You'll want THIS video for sure though: ruclips.net/video/s1HbC-nuWAQ/видео.html
That video will help you get whatever you buy set up.
I want to get one for my mom. She is chair bound in a nursing home. I’m wondering about making video calls to her and from her ( she can’t pick up or dial a phone), also some security to watch the staff taking care of her.
Here you go. A full guide; ruclips.net/video/s1HbC-nuWAQ/видео.html
I have home wired non-smart speakers through my house. Back in the day you would need to have a receiver with zones. Is there a good way to setup an echo to a system like this? I know there are a lot of variables?
Not to a system with multiple zones that I've seen. You can check my channel for a method for Google speakers. It's basically through cast.
Was thinking about buying the 10. But want to know if it can work as a video intercom?
Yep, Drop in works great
I want to use Echo 8 for my Ring doorbell only. The 1st Gen 8 is on sale now for half the price of the 2nd Gen 8. Knowing my plan usage is it worth it to pay twice the price for Gen 2? ( and extra $60 more for Gen 2 )
oooooh, I think you're 2 years till the Echo Show 8 1st gen doesn't really work anymore. So that cost is up to you. Otherwise, not a ton of reasons. :)
3:20 - The "stripe" (letterbox) is because you are displaying a 2.39:1 aspect ratio movie on a 1.78:1 (16:9) display. The theatrical 2.39 aspect ratio is how the director intended the movie to be seen. Movies released in theaters are made to be 2.39, 1.85 and sometimes 2.0, but never 1.78. Correction: The Echo Show 8 display is actually 16:10, or 1.6:1.
So many specs. Thanks Paul!
Miss A! Love it!
Is echo show 5 2nd gen still good for basic sleeping music and studying music?
And responses such as "Whats the volume of ... etc"
Yep. No difference between it and others for that stuff. Quiet, weak speaker vs others.
The echo show 8 is perfect for me. I bought the echo show 8 - 1st gen about 3 years ago and it’s really good. Should I upgrade to the 2nd gen?
Hey Luke, it's really just the camera on the front that's been updated. A few new features. There's not much you're missing :)
I would go with the 8 because it’s not too big and and the larger one might as well be a tablet I’m here for research I’m looking into getting 3 two for bedrooms and one for living room I saw all 3 in target the larger one would be too big for my nightstand and the smaller one might as well be my iPhone 14 pro max turned to landscape mode I just want it for basic information like news, weather, setting alarms ask something without googling reaching for my phone while lying in bed at a glance I wouldn’t use it for streaming shows
I have a small Echo 5 in the Bedroom mainly for setting Alarms, and a Echo 8 in the Living Room for Music, News, Weather, etc. I've got it connected to my Cell Phone, for Face to Face calls with my wife.... But will it connect to my Garmin GPS to do Hands Free Calls?
That I can't tell you. It's going to pair with most bluetooth headphone sets and let you use the microphone on the device with the audio in the headset, but that's not a guarantee. Just try Bluetooth pairing those two and see what happens.
Thanks you for the video
Can you confirm that it’s not possible to connect a Show 8 to a Firestick as a speaker?
Correct. No Shows work this way any longer, though the Echo Show 15 is now basically becoming a Fire Stick.
@@AutomateYourLife Thanks for your speedy reply
@Automate Your Life can you give me a clue how I locate Amazon Echo and Amazon Echo 5th Generation in my home that is signed into my wifi network? I don't own neither
I'm planing to purchase two or three Echo Show devices for my home. How many Echo Show device (s) can you set up?
As many as your WiFi can handle! I would say you'll be just fine adding 2-3 new Echo Shows to your home. :)
Great info. Can I set up with my Amazon account?
Yep and you should!
I have a new Echo Show 8 2nd gen. I can start, skip or stop songs by asking Alexa but not by tapping the onscreen play pause next buttons. Any help would be appreciated.
That's odd. Not sure what's happening there and you should probably chat with Amazon support.
Is broadcasting possible only in bluetooth range? Can I do announcement with wifi connectivity from remote place under different wifi network?
Yes you can do broadcasting through WiFi and remotely :)
@@AutomateYourLife thanksfor sharing the information
For me, a 5 is too small and a 10 is too expensive. I have a fire tablet on show mode, but lots of features(like camera/doorbell view, and light grouping) are not available. Should I get the New Echo 8, or the Old Echo 8? I don’t plan to watch videos, just to play a little music, auto show doorbell(which I have soon to get), and control the lights without having to specify which light bulb name. I’d assume the Old 8 would work fine but I’m not sure
For what you're saying, the old Echo Show 8 will work just fine. However, I'd suggest that you wait for a good sale on the new 8 and buy that because of the newer processor and speed on the device.
@@AutomateYourLife thanks
Can you use the echo 10 as a navigation screen in an rv
No I don't think that's going to work. They don't really have a true navigation feature
I have a dot (bedroom) echo show 5 (lounge) & echo show 8. I use the 8 in my kitchen, mainly for music. I’ve been thinking of getting a new one, but I’m worried that the show 10 won’t be any better than the 8 !
Also there’s the echo studio. Which one do I choose ? Echo show 10 or echo studio…….help please
Both are fantastic speakers. You can't really make a wrong decision here. So that's good news!
I think it comes down to screen. Echo Show 10 has a rotating screen (which you probably won't use rotation long term on), and that's definitely a nice way to see news and information, plus to control your home or music by hand. The Echo Studio is really just a speaker, but a great one. It does pair with Fire TVs as a Home Theater speaker though (and you can even have 2 do that), so that's a great option there. You cannot do the Home Theater thing with Echo Shows.
As for going from Echo Show 8 to 10, I think the audio upgrade is there. The screen is there too. And I think it looks nicer. But that's a big jump in price...so worth it? You'll have to judge from this video!
@@AutomateYourLife thank you for replying. I think I’m probably going to go for the show 10, I think I’d miss a screen !
We wouldn’t use the studio for home theatre, we’ve got a full Teufel set up for that.
Thank you & your reviews are very thorough and helpful 👍🏻
I have the echo show 5.2 am looking at the echo show 8.2 because the echo show 8.2 can show 4 live view of my blink camera system vs echo show 5.2 only shows 1 camera at a time
Yeah that's a newer big difference
Does Amazon Echo Show come with premium sound smart and home hub like that Echo dot?
In the 8 and 10, you'll find the sound quality much better than an Echo Dot. The 10 is probably the most well-rounded speaker in the Echo lineup period, with only the Echo 4th Generation and the Echo Studio having sound quality that's near or better.
Can you use this for the blink cameras
Yep! They display blink cameras
I am considering the Echo Show 5 I have an alarm installed at the entrance to my property which sounds a tone when someone enters. I only need this device to show who is entering the property I don't want the echo screen to be on all the time. Can I set up either the 5 or the 8 to react to the alarm tone to show me who is entering the property?
Unfortunately there is far too much I don't know to answer this question. I don't know whether your alarm system is integratable with Amazon and I don't know if that can start an Amazon routine.
If that can start an Amazon routine then it is possible, but the speed of it coming up on the screen will be dependant on the camera you use and how that is interfaced with Alexa again
Which echo allows you to call for help? Say you fall, can you say Alexa call for help?
I don't believe there's a restriction as to which Echo or Echo Show allows you to do this. I believe the restriction is that you're in the USA. Not sure it's available anywhere else right now.
Can echo show be used to watch my Blink camera or does it only work with Ring?
Blink too, and many other camera makers
I haven’t seen a echo show 8. 2023 model yet I think I’ll wait for that one
I don't know that they're releasing one this year
😢
Can u adjust screen brightness ? I don’t want it shining in my face in the middle of the night when I roll over
You can, and there's now an option to shut off screens based on inactivity too
The Echo show 5 does everything i need it to do??
Ok!
The 10 and 8 can play the video from youtube automatically when i ask alexa to play music?
No you'd have to open YT and search from there, or you could ask for music through Amazon Music or Spotify
Can I input my photos and let it show on the echo show 5 as a wallpaper or slideshow
In general, yes. Before you go buying though, get the Amazon Photos app and upload your photos there that you want to. See if you hit a limit that you need Prime for. :)
Then there are settings for displaying that.
@@AutomateYourLife thank you for this information and it’s all I need to know I’ve just purchased the echo show 5 2nd gen version for just this reason cos it doesn’t have that light blurry look at night unlike the echo show 8 2nd gen version
Can it work like a security device when you are not around & record while you are away so you can view activity/sounds later? Or is it only able to do live view of motion & sounds?
You can run routines off of people being detected in a space. No recording occurs. The people detection is by no means perfect, so I wouldn't consider this a security device.
@@AutomateYourLife thank you so much!
Can you do this with the 15 now
I will eventually, but that's a BIG production. Honestly, the review of the 15 I did here will give you those comparisons you need after watching that. ruclips.net/video/Dk-_KTUT0Sk/видео.html
Just bought echo show 5 with the stand for 21.00 US dollars. 🎉
🙌🙌
I have all three, but I will pass on the Show 15.
👍
you are amazing :)
Oh thanks! I'm blushing ☺️
Nope. No way, no how will I ever be suckered into another show device until amazon gives us back control of the screen content. I no longer trust them and that's sad because I really wanted the new show 10.
They're getting there Dave. It's an evolution and the next step is the custom widgets...but we will have to see how it all unfolds
Degeneration on the echo show fives what is the best one?
Got the Show 8 2nd gen for 48$
Nice!
I don't know what Show Mode means
That's a mode that some tablets had. It made them look like echo shows
I have echo show only for time and other stuff but not videos or RUclips I watch RUclips on phone
:)
One thing I still don't know: Echo Show 10 is stereo or not?
There are two speakers in there, but to be honest, they're so close together it just doesn't matter. It's not "real" stereo so to speak.
@@AutomateYourLife thank you so much for the reply! Really: neither Amazon could answer me this question
3:23 They're called black bars.
I'll figure it all out someday
I dunno why I watch these lol I have smart displays and speakers in every room from Google samsung amazon and even apple although don't like apple lol
Watch mooooooore 😃😃😃
@@AutomateYourLife I will be 🤣🤣
I replaced a an echo dot with a show 5 for the bedside. Not happy at all with the microphone array, spend more of our time yelling at it, it’s deaf!
That's a little odd. It shouldn't be deaf. You may have a noise source like a fan or something blowing on it
Yes it is odd, it’s in the same location where my dot was. I could try a new location however I’m likely to upgrade to a larger one in the future. Love your videos, thanks for all the content!
Could just be orientation or an echo (like an actual sound echo not a device) causing it issues! Good luck!
A friend bought Echo 10 because she could not get it to work. I plugged it in and Echo is on the screen. Do I need to plug it into something else. Need instructions for setup.
We have a setup video for the echo show 10 on the channel! Just do a quick search!
It didn't make clear, I have to buy another speaker to be able to connect to my network?does it work as a hub for itself? Not seeing any interesting features to buy one, to be sincere I'm pretty disappointed.
The Echo Shows have to connect to a WiFi network. That's all they need.
Summary
Echo Show: crappy crappy tablet
Echo Show 5: crappy Tablet
Echo Show 8: crappy bigger Tablet
Just buy a Tablet...
Much better speaker though, and Alexa response on tablets has been traditionally much worse of an experience. So it's what you're looking for in a device.
>x😊😅
I know you get paid to advertise for them, but you should tell people they don't control all of the content that shows up on their screen.
I don't get paid to advertise for them. Please don't make assumptions.
I have the 10 and it's garbage.
None. Google is much better 😁
ahahhahaha! BAM!
Those chunky bezels look hideous and out-of-place in 2022.
So you're saying you're a fan
Handsome guy,,, You need a good Manicure
LOL