Does Progestogen Cause Breast Cancer? - 381 | Menopause Taylor
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- Alright, if, based on last week’s video, estrogen does not cause breast cancer, could it be that progestogen causes breast cancer? What do the studies on women taking progestogens alone tell us about the role of progestogens in causing breast cancer? In this video, I’ll help you discover the answer.
Download my Assessment of Estrogen, Progesterone, or Both as Risks or Causes of Breast Cancer chart here: menopausetaylo...
Visit my website: menopausetaylo...
Click here to print the worksheet: menopausetaylo...
Click here to find the outline notes: menopausetaylo...
Watch every Menopause Taylor episode from the beginning: • Watch the Menopause Ba...
Check out my book, Menopause: Your Management Your Way ... Now and for the Rest of Your Life: menopausetaylo...
Click to listen to my Radio Show: The State of Menopause in the World Today - www.iheart.com...
Connect with me on social media:
Facebook: / menopausetaylor
Twitter: / barbietaylormd
Instagram: / menopausetaylor
Pinterest: / drbarbarataylor
I just came here to say this woman saved my life . That’s all. I wish you dr Taylor have all the good in your life , I hope God see what you do and showers you with His blessings in life and beyond life .
You’ll never know how you saved my life bc it’s a long story . But believe me you’re a God sent to us women .
Makes me mad my suffering friends all believe the cancer stories, I've been on hormone pills, patches , back to pills for ten years I can't live normally without them I've tried 3 times.
I love them❣forever. Thanks Dr.
Yeah me too. I think untreated suffering midlife women are ruining the world. Their misery is transferred to the rest of us.
This education makes you want to save other women's lives.
A little late, but I'm here! I was kicked off a FB hysterectomy group when some women were duped by doctors and gaslit by another member that both progestins an testosterone were vital and necessary. I chimed in and said we have no uterus so no need for Baby Bears progestins. Too many women there relied on compounded. On woman was in her 30s and had everything removed and didn't want to take estradiol because she didn't want to get breast cancer. I told her she needs it to prevent the big three. I told her if it csused cancer you'd see teenage girls and lots of women under 50 who've got breast cancer....she was stubborb...oh well, her life...
Menopause is the most neglected topic on Earth. And most women have fear due to one distorted study 22 years ago that the media used to scare the public.
But fear is the most powerful emotion on Earth. People do not think in the midst of fear. They merely react to the fear.
@@MenopauseTaylor Good afternoon doctor? Where do you receive? I need to start hormone therapy for the first time in my life. Menopause began at age 40. And I'm scared to go to other doctors. I live in New York.
This is precisely the kind of thing for which I do one-on-one consultations. I cannot tailor things specifically to you in a comment box. It requires much more information than you can give me here, and you deserve much more information than I can give you here. No two women are alike, and addressing your situation requires tailoring all the facts specifically to YOU. I do them all via online video conferencing. You can schedule at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I look forward to meeting you and helping you.@@the555sun_ny
Thank you. I understood the who study showed a 100% increase in breast cancer because the rate of breast cancer without HRT was 8 out of 10,000 & the rate of breast cancer with HRT increased to 16 out of 10,000. But when they looked at the facts of the study the increase was only in the population of those who took the combined formula of estradiol+progestagin. There was no increase in the rate of breast cancer in the population on estrogen alone. I thought this equaled progestagin was the cause of breast cancer. I didn't realize that the fact of progestagin having never been analyzed alone meant there was no data at all.
Never accuse something of being the "cause" of a disease unless it meets all the criteria for a "causative agent." Progesterone alone does not meet all the criteria.
Thank you for sharing your knowledge, it has changed my life for the better and your scientific common sense is divine! The lack of research is a misjustice to all woman(and their families)
Many many thanks from New Zealand 🍀
Thank you so much for appreciating my efforts, my dear. I love delivering it to you.
Unrelated to this post but…I’ve been following you pretty much from your first video. Can’t help but share this with you as I can’t believe it myself!!! In Canada we are out of Estradot!!!! Out of stock since September and not expected to be back before middle of December. Meanwhile I was prescribed another company patch made in Canada and feel miserable. Apparently no other company here makes it other than these 2!!!! So I’m stuck!!!
This does happen. And it's inexcusable. Just imagine: If men lost all their testosterone, there would never be stock shortages.
Great dissection of Progestogens alone on whether they cause breast cancer.
Love, love this series.
Onward to the next video. We interrogated them alone and will now put them together in the same room. 💕💕 Wish you were here to enjoy my vegan thanksgiving.
You got it! Enjoy you Thanksgiving, my dear. I'm thankful for YOU.
🥲💕@@MenopauseTaylor
I love knowing this argument. I know I don't know all there is to know, but I appreciate so very much that you've prepared us to evaluate information and data for ourselves. It's sad, but true that many drs. say many goofy things, and I now know how much weight to give their opinions. I'll be giving thanks for you this Thanksgiving.
Happy Thanksgiving to you, Dr. T.!
You are so very kind, my dear. Thank YOU!
Happy Thanksgiving Dr Barbie ❤
And the same to you, my dear.
Im pregnant and taking progesterone i read on my leaflet that progesterone can cause or increase risk of breast cancer
Thank you so much for the worksheet. This information is invaluable!
You are so very welcome, my dear.
So at 59 I was on a estrogen progesterone cream thru a company called Winona for a year it worked great for about 6 8 months but then it just didn’t work well for me at all after about 11 months in so I stopped it and went to my doctor and he put me on the combi patch but I’m still having major hot flashes however it’s only been a week so I’m praying this works 🙏 I just want to feel good again with no body aches or hot flashes !
This is precisely the kind of thing for which I do one-on-one consultations. You definitely need one. I cannot tailor things specifically to you in a comment box. It requires much more information than you can give me here, and you deserve much more information than I can give you here. No two women are alike, and addressing your situation requires tailoring all the facts specifically to YOU. I do them all via online video conferencing. You can schedule at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I look forward to meeting you and helping you.
Thank you very much for your priceless education! ❤
I have one question: is there any significant difference between brand name Prometrium and just generic micronized progesteron? My insurance does not cover Prometrium at 100% and it's quite expensive compare to generic one.What women say about these two products to you? Is it safe to switch without any additional symptoms? Thank you!
Good question.
Funny, my leaflet in my mini pill (desogestrel) states that it increases the risk of breast cancer. I live in Germany.
All hormone products have that warning ... even the ones for which it is not true.
Gosh, that's scary. The information should be changed if there's no clear evidence@@MenopauseTaylor
I agree! I mean, what is so difficult about just telling the truth?@@ShazWag
Dr. Barb, can you please come in and use the DHEA in the perimenopause or menopausal era? Thank you.
This is precisely the kind of thing for which I do one-on-one consultations. You definitely need one. I cannot tailor things specifically to you in a comment box. It requires much more information than you can give me here, and you deserve much more information than I can give you here. No two women are alike, and addressing your situation requires tailoring all the facts specifically to YOU. I do them all via online video conferencing. You can schedule at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I look forward to meeting you and helping you.
Thank you for all you do!!!
You are ever so welcome, my dear. I love every minute of it.
Taylor, do you ever get concerned with taking estrogen and it going through the liver??? This is my concern with taking Birth control pills at the age of 52 to manage my menopause symptoms…love to hear your thoughts
This is something that you MUST tailor specifically to YOU. There is no way to answer this question generally for "a woman" or "all women."
You can schedule a consultation with me at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I do them all online.
Hello Menopause Taylor
Could you give a few reasons why the progesterone pill is making me drowsy even into the next day. Im only week 4 so all very new to me.
They never seem to answer this. It's an intolerance.
Why is dr Taylor always so shiney?
Because I apply Vaseline to my face. I don't wear makeup.
Thank you x💜
Thankyou so much.
You are so welcome!
Thank you 😊😊😊
You are so very welcome, my dear.
Hello dear! Do you have a video on cortisol? I'm in peri and was told through futch test I had high levels certain parts of day. My estrogen is post menopause at 44! I was prescribed vivelle dot 1mg through my gynecologist with 200mg progesterone. I've suffered enough with hot flashes and fatigue. Is cortisol really a problem like they say it is ? I watched your video speaking about the dutch and I wish I didn't waste my money on it. Everyone saying it's the "gold standard "
Nellie,
Most of the time, the people telling you that your cortisol is a problem are NOT endocrinologists. They are usually alternative or wellness providers who know absolutely noting about cortisol (except how to use it in order to make money).
If you want help determining what's really going on, just schedule a consultation with me at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I do them all online.
I would be interested to hear what you would think about Dr. Barbara Hoffman in California. She started a company called better Health Naturally, she sells “bio identical hormones “ and states she has studies and data on the use of synthetic hormones causing cancer. Could you please reach out to her and let us know? I would interested.
Nothing about this education derives from what "I think." It's all about what "you think," given an unbiased education.
My general principle is this: Any time you encounter anybody pushing or selling a product or a particular way of managing menopause ... run! That constitutes marketing, advertising, or propaganda. It is not education.
Is progesterone a form of testosterone? Or do we need to take both along with estrogen ?
No.
There are three sex hormones: Testosterone, Estrogen, and Progesterone. The three hormones are like The Three Bears in the fairy tale, Goldilocks and The Three Bears. You know how each bear had his or her own bed, chair, & bowl of porridge? Well, each hormone belongs to only one member of the family, just like each bed, chair, & bowl of porridge.
Testosterone is the male hormone. It belongs to Papa Bear. Estrogen is the female hormone. It belongs to Mama Bear. Progesterone is the hormone of pregnancy. It belongs to Baby Bear.
So, progesterone is NOT YOUR hormone. It's the baby's hormone. Pro -gester-one literally means "hormone in support of pregnancy.” (Pro = in support of, “gest” = gestation, or pregnancy, “one” = hormone)
The ONLY reason you produce progesterone or ever needed progesterone was to support a pregnancy.
While you have all three sex hormones in your body, the one that your body depends on more than anything is estrogen.
You really should schedule a consultation with me at MenopauseTaylor.ME and let me teach you everything BEFORE you approach any provide for HRT. I will arm you with what you need for success. I do them all online.
Great video! I am currently taking compounded progesterone. I’m taking It along with estrogen cream that is compounded as well. My dosage is 300mg of progesterone and my doctor thinks this is way too high but I have no side effects from it. I would like to lower the dosage but I know this cannot be done overnight. What are your thoughts???
This is precisely the kind of thing for which I do one-on-one consultations. You definitely need one. I cannot tailor things specifically to you in a comment box. It requires much more information than you can give me here, and you deserve much more information than I can give you here. No two women are alike, and addressing your situation requires tailoring all the facts specifically to YOU. I do them all via online video conferencing. You can schedule at MenopauseTaylor.ME. I look forward to meeting you and helping you.
I don’t know if this is too private of a question, but I was wondering, do you still still have your uterus Dr. Taylor?
I had endometriosis. My uterus, cervix, fallopian tubes, and ovaries were removed at age 34. I am now 64, and have been post-menopausal for 30 years.
Thanks for clarifying this. Would you know if there's a way of mitigating the drowsiness from taking progesterone? I take a bio-identical capsule every evening, but sometimes I need to stay up to focus on my studies.
I take it at night before bed.
I usually do that too, but at the moment I'm staying up until the wee small hours revising for exams so need to be alert@@vickizsecrets
Most women have the misconception that progesterone “helps you sleep.”
But the reality is not quite as advertised. Estrogen is actually the hormone that helps you sleep … like a baby, that is. Progesterone can help you sleep, but more like a zombie than a baby.
Here are the facts:
Insomnia is a symptom of estrogen deficiency. So if you take adequate estrogen, you will sleep deeply and continuously throughout the night and wake up perky and energetic in the morning.
But if you take progesterone, things will be a bit different. Instead of just getting a good night’s sleep, it will make it difficult for you to wake up in the morning, make you feel sluggish when you do get up, and leave you feeling like a zombie all day. You’ll feel like you could sleep standing up. And you’ll have a hard time being productive.
The reason women “hear” that they should take it at night is because the Alternative community claims that it helps you sleep. Progesterone gives you that all-day drugged, drowsy, you-could-sleep-while-standing-up feeling that is so characteristic of early pregnancy. With progesterone, you do not merely get a good night’s sleep. You get a sluggishness that lasts all day (which is good during pregnancy because it makes you lazy so that the baby gets more calories to grow). But now that you’re peri-or post-menopausal, you don’t want to be sluggish all day.
So, if you want to sleep like a baby at night, take estrogen. If you want to be sluggish like a zombie all day, take progesterone.
Hello Barbie
Are you implying I don’t have to take progesterone? I’m very confused. If you take estrogen then don’t you need take progesterone? Please explain this.. I’m on one pump of estrogen & 1 progesterone tablet as I can’t tolerate 2, I feel so tired.
I also still have a womb, that’s why was told I need to take progesterone..are you saying I don’t need to take?
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤