Murtaza Hussain & Yair Rosenberg - Israel-Palestine Paths to Peace | The Daily Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 май 2024
- The Intercept’s Murtaza Hussain and Yair Rosenberg of The Atlantic discuss with Jon Stewart how peace may be possible between Israel and Palestine, the United States’ involvement in the Middle East, and how the two journalists can have honest conversations even when they disagree. #DailyShow #JonStewart #MiddleEast
Subscribe to The Daily Show:
/ @thedailyshow
Follow The Daily Show:
Twitter: / thedailyshow
Facebook: / thedailyshow
Instagram: / thedailyshow
Stream full episodes of The Daily Show on Paramount+: www.paramountplus.com/?ftag=PP...
Follow Comedy Central:
Twitter: / comedycentral
Facebook: / comedycentral
Instagram: / comedycentral
Watch full episodes of The Daily Show: www.cc.com/shows/the-daily-show
About The Daily Show:
Jon Stewart and The Best F**king News Team host The Daily Show, an Emmy and Peabody Award-winning program analyzing the biggest stories in news, politics, and culture through a sharp, satirical lens. The Daily Show redefined the late night show category on TV and, with an audience of over 51M across social media platforms, has become a launching pad for some of the biggest stars in entertainment.
The Daily Show airs weeknights at 11/10c on Comedy Central. 
Приколы
These guys are serious heavy hitters in the political writing sphere. Jon is really the Godfather he can pick and choose pretty much anyone to be on with him with his limited schedule and he's going not for the celebrity haircuts like Maher, but for the people with the most articulate and relevant POV. Bravo, TDS!
that guy mustang has what I think I can safely call the polar opposite of a celebrity haircut.
The U.S. MUST start putting conditions on any "aid" sent to any country.
1st, there needs to be an accurate accounting for how our "aid" is used.
2nd (probably should be 1st), absolutely none of said "aid" can be used for war crimes.
How is that too much to ask?!
If Israel or Ukraine, or any other state the U.S. help shore up can't abide by those very simple requests then they don't deserve my tax dollars or any one elses!
Why America thinks it built Japan or Germany! Even worse American thinks it did them favor by bmbing them!
@@miandering_agreed! But i was using "haircut" as a way to profile media figures known for their look and not their intelligence, it's a common denigrating burn. All Fox News blonde's are "haircuts" for instance.
@@miandering_… Shame on you … you demean people, by denying them their identities … in your case calling him “mustang”, when you should know his name is “Murtaza”. Or are you a Russian TROLL?
While we applaud for Jon doing this interview and segment, let's also thank Comedy Central to let Jon use this platform to do what is right for the world.
He basically said Israel should not do a ceasefire until Hamas frees the hostages, which means they can keep murdering children and continuing their siege and genocide. Jon could have made a difference in the debate towards a ceasefire, instead we get this useless cutesy BS and he cries a bunch for his dog but only jokes about the conflict that’s brought 14k dead children.
Like he did on his Apple show, I hope he does this for trans people, especially since the death of Non Binary kid Nex.
PREACH!
This is one of the best things to ever happen in journalism.
All hail corporation. Corporation bring back Cool Old Guy = saviors!
Chill y'all, it's all jokes! Like, this comment!
...and the one I'm replying to🤣*clears throat"👉🏾😎👉🏾
This is true journalism. Not a debate with opposite extremest, which sell a lot more, but a debate with rational critical thinkers.
Yeh true journalism... making jokes about moving isreal to maine
The problem is politicians aren't rational critical thinkers
lol. this had nothing to do with journalism. it was shameful. what is this kumbaya in the midst of slaughter supposed to achieve?
People who get their information from TV are easily amused....this was garbage compared to podcasts. There was no real depth to this. It was all baseline.
Oh, poor Israelis. That joke was soooooo offensive. Grow up and acknowledge the fascist and racist state that the Zionist murderous regime has come to be.
It is so weird that I click a comedy link to find the first real peace summit between Muslims and Jews ever. Murtaza's logic is unbelievably reasonable; Yair provides a very logical counterweight as well. I was in Damascus watching an israeli airstrike unfold before my eyes as the sky turned sunset-orange at 9 pm on a winter night. I was shaking and in tears a few hours ago, and now after this conversation I'm like yeah, the METO thing could actually work. Thank you all for making me feel like this is not an impossible case again. Thank you; you have no idea how much more comfortable with being at a warzone this makes me feel. Appreciation.
What about 1993 between Arafat and Rabin?
Take care of yourself brother
It takes a community that doesn't take themselves so seriously...
This is actually a misconception. Muslims and Jews have no issue with each other, like propaganda has people believe. This is not a religious issue.
Money from marshall plan was NEVER spend on japan.
both germany and japan borrowed money form US government with interest to buy american products.
marshall plan was for allied nations in Europe NOT japan.
both Germany and japan paid back EVERY SINGLE penny they borrowed with interest.
"Doesn't it appear that no party is incentivized to fix this at the peril and detriment of the Palestinian people?" With but one sentence, Mr. Stewart pins the main issue preventing lasting peace to the wall. It's uncanny how different these discussions are when he's involved.
Jon is misinformed about Arab efforts to solve the problem! What can they do if imperialistic Superpowers like USA,UK, France, Russia don’t allow it. Superpowers are incontrol of Arab weapons , decisions and USA always threaten them with coups, wars, economic siege . On the other hand it gives the other side the green light for aggression on Palestinians!
Why America thinks it built Japan or Germany! Even worse American thinks it did them favor by bmbing them!
Twitter will be very upset by this very rational conversation because it excludes their favorite buzzword genocide.
@@nisahmed9121 I had no idea America consists of 1 uniform mindstate that can communicate its singular ideas to boot. Tell me more, does Florida and Colorado residents share snowboarding and surfing tips to each other, or how do you rationalize the wildly different election results & legislation of each?
@@nisahmed9121I think their referring to the Marshal plan..Due to the failure to stabilize post world war 1 economy in Germany and let the Brown shirt uprising
As a Westerner living in the Middle East, having any kind of emotionally stable conversation on this horrific subject, let alone adding in any light-hearted tone, is nigh on impossible. So kudos to the the legend that is JS, and Murtaza Hussain and Yair Rosenberg, for being able to do exactly that. Such an intelligent and mature discussion. An approach that the leaders of all the countries involved should take note of.
Really? You mean people reject that illegitimate criminal entity and you don’t like it! So you hide behind “they are too emotional”! “Light-hearted”
@@abdiheba4478 Thank you for being a display of what the three men in this video were describing as the problem preventing a peaceful solution.
Yeah a milquetoast shitlib discussion that solves nothing. LOL.
@@TheREALJosephTurner 💯
Apologising for genocide calmly is no different as to if they were screaming.
All of a sudden, I don't miss Trevor at all. Kudos to John, the network and his team to have the courage to shine light on a subject to what the world has turned its back on. Thank you!
I'm so happy this video and the other one is getting millions of views... It's the most sane thing I've seen about the conflict.
I survived a terror attack in 2016 in Tel Aviv. My dream of peace will never die. They will never make me just another hater. Salam brothers
All you did was admit that you only watch TV. This talk was barely even baseline talk and had no depth or real value to it. Go watch some podcasts like most people do now and hear some real information.
And Shalom to you, if everyone in the Levant were like you, we'd have flying cars by now !
Was it the one in Dizengoff or Sarona? happy you were one of the lucky ones and that it hasn't undermined your belief in peace. Shalom from Tel Aviv 🩵
How many times have you promoted non-linear radio here without elaborating on anything, Mr "@@thomasjones4570"?
Tell your fellow Israeli citizens who support Genocide and apartheid that they're criminally insane and to stop blocking the aid trucks from entering Gaza! And they wonder why they're so hated by the world!
Love this. Stewart still has it even 10 years later. Entertaining and educational. Those that call him out should get a reality check and realize that Stewart is telling the truth and sometimes the truth hurts.
Jon is misinformed about Arab efforts to solve the problem! What can they do if imperialistic Superpowers like USA,UK, France, Russia don’t allow it. Superpowers are incontrol of Arab weapons , decisions and USA always threaten them with coups, wars, economic siege . On the other hand it gives the other side the green light for aggression on Palestinians!
Why America thinks it built Japan or Germany! Even worse American thinks it did them favor by bmbing them!
@@nisahmed9121 Dude, how many times did you copy and paste that? You look more clueless every time!
@@Coolestmovies you can look away. No one is forcing you to read it!
He I think he’s better than he was 10 years ago. He’s aged like a fine wine.
It's nice to see a discussion where people are not yelling at each other on opposing views to discuss how to unite
Seriously this 3 person conversation was so refreshing in its respect for each other and well thought out and spoken dialogue. I kinda wish Jon was a little less joking during certain parts of this conversation but I both understand why he was and still respect how well overall this was conducted.
The "civility discussion" is so tired. We shouldn't pat ourselves on our backs for just being able to calmly discuss things. 29,000 Palestinians have died, including thousands of children. Entire families are being snuffed out. Hospitals are being attacked. Important cultural landmarks are being destroyed
Also, people killed by Hamas do not yell.
something piers morgan could never do😒
@@andrewign5806Whereas dead Palestinian children are notoriously garrulous. What a clever argument...
This is far better than the talking heads on major networks.
For-profit cable news is casually destroying us
I love this dialogue. As an Orthodox Jew who does a lot of Multi- Faith work, being open to listening to the stories of different people and give honor to their stories, and realize that we are all the products of those experiences will and does make a difference.
It's a huge shame that this conversation probably wouldn't reach those who need to hear it the most. This is journalism in its truest form.
Except a few lies like the two state statement 2min in
People actually expect this stuff will ever change 😂
The only people that can fix this are the Israelis and they are wholly unwilling to do it
@@squibbelsmcjohnsonSome of the current leaders in Israel are counting on people believing that this can never change.
It was a solid conversation, but (I know this is way too high of expectations) they didn't say anything that actually goes towards what should be done. The conclusion of "this is extremely hard" might be where we are stuck for decades or centuries. I think that is likely the case.
JS is genuinely passionate about finding a solution to this conflict, he’s using his short time on the DS very wisely by bringing 2 young journalists each from the opposite side but who share a 10 years friendship and clearly love and respect each other!! Very original and inspirational.
When occupation and settler-colonialism are called “a conflict”!
Jon is misinformed about Arab efforts to solve the problem! What can they do if imperialistic Superpowers like USA,UK, France, Russia don’t allow it. Superpowers are incontrol of Arab weapons , decisions and USA always threaten them with coups, wars, economic siege . On the other hand it gives the other side the green light for aggression on Palestinians!
Why America thinks it built Japan or Germany! Even worse American thinks it did them favor by bmbing them!
@@abdiheba4478writing from USA,Canada,Australia etc,just asking.Return hostages and return Karelia
@@nisahmed9121You need to re-read your history books .
Thank you so much for not treating your audience like we’re idiots.
It’s so frustrating to try to learn about what’s going on in Israel and Gaza because any discussion often devolves into a shouting match about who’s responsible for the worst atrocity. This conversation deserves respect and nuance, and you’ve accomplished that here.
Looking forward to seeing more!
but you are still treated like your an idiot....only in a calmer and nicer way...without all the shouting, so u dont realise ur being treated like an idiot,.. u would be an idiot to think they are actually saying anythinng when they are actually saying no-thing!
There is something so comedic about the fact that the best news you will get about the nuance of Israel Palestine foreign policy is from a tv channel called Comedy Central.
Its really sad and shocking that Comedy Central probably has a much more nuanced and actual debate about the conflict than the news network.
And has been the case for decades, actually - Mr "@@AnthonyJMurph".
Previously.. It used to be even worse.
The connundrum in being human in a faulty world, let's be elated to have Jon return
I am not sure what is the nuance, One group militarily took over another country via UN and western forces and wants to stay and dominate. It is better to See things for what they are rather than a romanticized version. There is no nuance.
@@jo7246 The fact that you are unable to even have a conversation speaks volumes about the current problems we are having with politics in todays society. Do I agree that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinians, without a doubt. Their constant expansions from the purloining of Palestinians. I could go on and on, Netanyahu is evil. BUT, when Hamas is calling for an Intifada by which they mean to eject EVERYONE not of Palestinian descent, the conversation does indeed become nuanced. A two state solution (one in which Palestinians have ACTUAL autonomy, self governance, and a sense of safety) is the ONLY reasonable solution, and achieving that requires heaps and bounds of nuance. To speak in such absolutes is a disservice to everyone, including yourself.
I do appreciate the clarity in these segments. To be honest, most discussions on the clash make me tune out. It's overload. This felt productive.
At the Berlin Film Festival, a documentary made by four activists, two Israeli and two Palestinians, just premiered. It's called No Other Land, hopefully it comes out soon.
@@samfilmkid Sounds interesting! Can't wait to check it out. Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ggregg2667 Hopefully it IS released and not censored.
Productive? They solved nothing
@@ahhmm5381 tf did you expect them to solve as American citizens? A rubix cube?
NOBODY is doing this kind of content....and I'm so grateful that Jon does. He has a few of the most notable professionals doing actual journalism for this discussion, and makes it real and makes it engaging...and makes it human. Just the best.
Sadly a lot of what pass as “journalists” these days are not interested in debating anything or in the truth. They want everyone to go along with their agenda or they’re antisemitic if they don’t. Comedians are doing journalism a lot better than actual so called Journalists.
There's a lot of YT channels with great journalism.
Pierse Morgan was trying
Jon Stewart is a dying breed among Democrat entertainers sadly. Why do you think none of the temporary hosts since Trevor Noah made the cut?
I really admire and respect Murtaza's reporting, but his barber should be in jail
Facts
Jail? I think not. It must be the chair for whoever did his line.
Honestly so fresh and honest to see a conversation about this topic without it descending into accusations and meanignless rhetoric. It's sad when the Daily Show holds more informative and thoughtful debates than most of the traditional media news
The incredible insight and humanity that Jon Stewart possesses is something to be cherished! Kudos to Murtaza Hussain and Yair Rosemberg for showing the world that there are no boundaries to friendship and goodwill. Also for showing that the only magic in great journalism is honesty and integrity.
5:22: Stewart: "Netanyahu, whenever he gets into trouble, suddenly there's a war".
Sheer, utter, unadulterated nonsense.
I saw no friendship and goodwill in the face and eyes of Murtaza Hussain. He has what I call "dead eyes" the eyes of someone whose thoughts revolve around highly controlled resentment.
@@sheilamacdougal4874 truth, not nonsense
@@globalcitizenn You agree with me that it is nonsense (to your credit), which is presumably why you didn't cite a single example.
@@sheilamacdougal4874if you expect someone to cite sources:
A) this is RUclips,
B) you could look at moderate journalists and read articles making a variety of claims, and see what the evidence supports, and
C) you didn't cite sources supporting your perspective either.
The second half of the interview was even more interesting...too bad it couldn't air on the broadcast, but very glad they uploaded it here.
Was hoping they would separate the second half to share.
Jon Stewart's approach to debate is admirable. He is more interested in spreading knowledge and getting constructive debate rather than indulge in sensationalist shouting matches which the majority of American political and news shows pursue.
Why is it, I always come away feeling better informed watching Jon then I do watching any of the networks, whether it's weeknight or Sunday Morning News programs.
THANK YOU. This was a million times better, more productive, more educational and inspirational than any of the loudmouth "debates" on Piers Morgan and the likes. Calm truthful guests... None of the baiting drama BS. Just thank you...
Not really. This was we should all get along and kind of ignored the indiscriminate slaughter which resulted in a current ongoing case at the ICJ where Israel is credibly accused of genocide.
@@lindaleeyou1234 so we shouldn't all get along? You're so enlightened, please tell us more about your hate for humanity please please please
@@lindaleeyou1234
Mmmm i remember 1200 people slautered in 1 day, and over 200 hostages taken. Throwing the word "genocide" around and assuming innocence is disingenuous.
@@raanajak471 Brain dead take.
@@lindaleeyou1234 This is kind of the point. Regardless of which side we hold more responsible the only *solution* is to actually all get along. It would be unfair to everyone involved and no one would be happy with it, but that's the only way. We've spent decades arguing over who is guiltier or worse or whatever. It had led to absolutely nothing but a sense of moral superiority on both sides. In fact it has led us to the current situation - a horrifying terrorist attack triggering a retaliatory (potential) genocide. And you can keep going back to keep seeing this pattern.
As unrealistic as "we should all get along" is, it's still more realistic to thinking that more of the same will lead to a different outcome.
I've "re-rung" my "bell" for The Daily Show RUclips channel. It's not just seeing Jon again. The whole show has become more than relevant again. Thank you. THANK YOU. 😎☮
It's Jon for me, 2 shows back an he was getting flak already
I've come back not just for JS but also because they finally got rid of that hack Trevor Noah
I re-subscribed right after watching the first episode of Jon being back.
After 7 years of Trevor Noah's humorless fumblings rendered the show utterly irrelevant, I agree.
They need to park the dump truck of money outside Jon’s residence and have him do the whole week instead of just Mondays.
Finally a discussion that left me with hope and admiration of all speakers instead of more frustration. This is the best thing that happened to me in a very long day.
One of the best discussions I’ve seen on any topic, regardless of the setting. Jon’s moderation was exemplary here. My two favorite quotes have to be these:
“We refuse to allow ourselves or our communities to be held hostage to a ruinous conflict thousands of miles away that we may never be able to resolve or fix. But we can have an impact about how we treat each other here.” - Yair Rosenberg
“I could accept any Palestinian’s view or any Israeli’s view when they’re so intimately involved in it. But I could never respect a bloodthirsty American.” - Murtaza Hussain
Hussain and Rosenberg, thank you both. You two are amazing and warm my heart.
Thanks Jon for this.
Brother man with the sparse bowl-cut needs a new barber or a lady who calls him out on whatever's going on up there.
Mind Begs the Question:
- If policies of Starvation,Death Camps,Ethnic Cleansing,etc are repeated
- Nazis ceased to exist
- Nazis continue to exist?
@@ChaosKingable bruh! They talk about something important and you were focused on his haircut? And it’s non of your business how he cuts his hair!
@@user-rn6cn5rp3y if he were Jo schmo - I agree none of my business. If you're a public figure speaking about a pretty important geopolitical issue - distracting from the issue at hand with a off-kilter look - I'd ditch it. If brother man came out wearing a thawb and ghutrah with a Shemagh, he'd be ballin, but this is just weird.
Beard's on point though !
@@ChaosKingable What if he didn’t have enough hair? Could be any reason! You have no rights to bully people based on their look!
It's great that these journalists are having open-air conversations about hot button issues without alarmist slants. Great work folks ✌️
@orpheuscreativeco9236 From the way Palestine has been treated it is far too kind to the Israeli side. How did the unfair gift of 50% of Palestine wind up being the Palestinians virtually wiped out?
It's not alarmist to raise the alarm on thousands of innocent people being slaughtered and starved, while the other side puts up bouncy castles to block humanitarian aid, and takes pictures of themselves on the bicycles of the children they are killing.
For the record, there was a second part to this comment (that RUclips wouldn't let me append for some reason) that stated that what's happening is straight up genocide and that the military industrial complex has no interest in peace for any nation.
@ng So true,
@@rvantong actually thats the definition of it.... if we cant talk we fail
We need more people like these two who listen to one another respectfully.
thank you for coming back john, what a refreshing conversation
This is one of my absolutely favorite episodes of the Daily Show so far. Powerful discussion, straight from the heart. We need more of this.
Sending you a mental fist-bump from Indiana in agreement.
Right?! Somewhat teared up when they mentioned they've been friends for a while and although they viewed the world from different lenses they knew each other was honest.
But why he is not objecting when people start talking about how half of these jews are from arab countries. Doesnt that make him liberal tucker carlson? Mizrahi jews didnt for israel. It was europeans. And they were running from european persecution not arab persecution
What is powerful about it?
They are daydreaming.
He should tell his country to stop meddling in the Middle East with their disgusting agenda and to stop supporting terrorists.
Thanks for having Murtaza Hussain on. He's completely correct. You're greatly *underestimating* the impact of the US. We not only fund Israel, but we veto any U.N. resolution that impacts them, and protect them against any significant consequences. If we pulled our support, it would change the dynamic dramatically.
I noticed how John quickly dismissed the notion of axing unconditional support of Israel by US. Pity.
How do you expect America to make any requests or demands about how Israel operates if it has no influence? Did Israel tell america how to fight the wars in Israel or Afghanistan? Can't have your cake and eat it too
Jon explained why he wouldn't consider axing unconditional support. If you want peace, that certainly won't do it, because the war is a two-way fight@@cv-cq9ry
Herzl (father of modern Zionism) had confided to his diary (1899) the idea of spiriting the Arab population away to make way for Jews:
"We must expropriate gently the private property on the estates assigned to us. We shall try to spirit the penniless population across the border by procuring employment for it in the transit countries, while denying it employment in our own country The property owners will come over to our side. Both the process of expropriation and the removal of the poor must be carried out discreetly and circumspectly."
-AIPAC controls the American congress to uphold Herzl's plan, so America is bought and sold.
-Corrupt Arab autocrats want Israeli technology to control their populations.
-Israel continues with illegal "settlements" (i.e. theft, ethnic cleansing, and apartheid).
-Palestinians and their non-state allies will continue to resist violently- inevitably.
-Gradual genocide will continue.
- Israeli, and Western countries will make big bucks from the arms and cyber-security industries.
-At some point there will be a terrible reckoning.
@@cv-cq9ryYeah, that was weird. It was there in the main segment too. The dumb thing is that previous US presidents did stop Israel with a phone call.
Jon is likely acting by reflex on the idea Israel is under existential threat. The state of Israel has no existential threats. Its social economic system does have an existential threat from itself. Economic and security exploitation is critical to Israel that without, can't maintain their standard level of living, especially if you are an illegal settler who under any functional peace plan must leave.
Finally, an interview with arab and israeli with no yelling, no interruption, no name calling, no emotional manipulation . I'd start to think at some point, that to hear a calm conversation with no fuss from both sides is simply impossible. Jon, applause for the mediation and guest choice🥰 Facts mentioned and questions asked are just a diffrent level, bravo💙
Man! The question of how they are able to be friendly with one another got me tearful. Thank you guys for being a compromising human. Hate is what destroys us. As evident by this war. 🙏 Thank you for sharing the extra part of the interview.
The reason that American foreign policy is often so cavalier is because the U.S. has almost never had to fight a war at home. I think that’s why Pearl Harbor and 9/11 enraged America so much, we aren’t used to attacks on the homeland. The U.S. is an ocean away from most of its adversaries, so an attack on American soil seems inconceivable.
American's, relative to others, have short memories/attention spans and generally don't hold grudges. Germany, Japan, Vietnam, so on and so forth, Americans move on. Note War of 1812 resulted in an invasion by England and the burning of DC. Yet here we are, buds with England. Also, Civil War, though much of that continues to impact the U.S.
Ideologically for citizens , yes. But it's naive to solely think that way. money is the other. They can afford to be reckless because reckless behavior and creates money for American capitalists and chaos elsewhere.
I don't think having a war here would change things. If anything it would help them be more reckless. 9/11 fueled cavalier foreign policy as opposed to reigning it in.
Wow.... It's amazing what hearing an actual conversation can do for your mental health. Thank you so much.
This is exactly how I felt while watching this healthy discourse… 😌
I've Never seen such brotherhood between two people with such opposing ideologies. So heartwarming! There is still hope!
Jon Stewart has always been a beacon for free speech and a common ground for opposite views. This is a great example of a constructive discussion between opposite views without falling on the easy trap of the insult, attack or sheer dismissal. Many thanks.
Twenty years ago, we lived in a world where we lamented the insanity that our political satirists were possessed of more sense and leadership ability than our politicians. And somehow things have only gotten worse in that regard. Thank you Jon Stewart for continuing to be an icon of stability and intelligence.
It goes back further than that. Will Rogers said it: "How crazy is it when politicians are a joke and comedians are taken seriously?"
And the great thing about being a comedian is that all you have to do is make an audience laugh and you think you've solved the problem.
He was not very intellectual in this conversation.
Nothing is new under the sun, dude.
Spare us the melodrama.
Indeed, Voltaire mocked people who tried to appear superior by being bored by everything over 250 years ago.@@ironspaghett
A very substantive discussion. This is what is dreadfully missing in the mainstream television messaging. Thank you to all involved.
I completely disagree that both Israelis and Palestinians are being hurt, as John stated. This is just another massive land grab, displacement, and slaughter. One side is doing it and the other side is being slaughtered. Our taxes are paying for genocide. Both sides aren't carrying that out, just one.
Such an encouraging and heartening conversation. Thank you for having these two men on and introducing them to us who didn't know about them. We need more people like them!
Hussain's haircut is a work of art
He’s repping Toronto with a fade. And middle age with the combover
You have to have conversations like this, calm and insightful. Yelling and inciting fear never gets anyone, anywhere.
When people are being genocided, it gets a little hard to stay “calm”. If you bothered listening to the yelling you’d get plenty of insight and if you absorbed the insight you’d be yelling too.
@@AriDrag Everyone believes that they have something to yell about but if everyone is yelling, nobody is heard.
Such a civilized discussion . People with different opinions, speaking and discussing their views without name calling and fighting, i haven't seen this in years
There is no civilized conversation if laws aren't mentioned. They didn't talk about international law once.
@@tyronevaldez-kruger5313 Trump has "changed the game" as he would say.
@@jasperzanovich2504 sorry to hear that. I knew about the division and Donald 🎺's insanity in the US but not that the situation is so serious.
@@Sehaj3 yes they did. Not more than once and not in depth, but it was the mentioned as the starting point to the Arab proposals in the first answer.
This episode exemplifies what top notch journalism should be like. Wonderful job Jon.
This is why I love Jon. I say things and get dumped on. He says the same things and somehow people understand. The past 4+ years I've felt completely unheard and two weeks in a row I've felt validated.
Ok. I cried and laughed. What a brilliant get together with the 3 so intelligent people. Thank you to all of you.
It was great to watch, and the ending joke on the NYC Subway was the icing on the cake.
Jon Stewart is still the best interviewer going around. And this was a fantastic interview covering many points of view on this conflict.
Jon has said many times he is terrible at interviewing people.
Makes you think just how bad journalists must be at it.
He was doing well, but he was cutting off Mr Hussain a bit too much before he'd finished his points.
@@gentleken7864 agreed. all I could think was how Trevor Noah wouldn't have cut him off like that.
Thank you Jon and crew! So refreshing to have actual productive conversations looking for solutions
Thank all the Gods involved here…Jon there are no words to explain the loss and sadness I felt when you left us. I thought “you’re nuts it was a comedy show get over it”….now you are back..with something like this….and I feel like I could maybe have hope in humanity again….so much power in such a little package you are❤❤.
Thanks Daily Show for sharing the 2nd part of the interview here on RUclips. Powerful. I'm tuning in from Australia, and look forward to a Tuesday afternoon when Jon's segments go hot over here our time.
same here in Germany! cheers!
In 2024 it feels rare to actually watch people on a stage have a real genuine conversation about something so hard. This was absolutely brilliant, and I love Jon Stewart endlessly for doing this. Really, this is what this country needed so badly. We forgot how to talk to each other over the last few years. I hope this show makes money, but thank you Comedy Central for doing this. It is so so needed right now.
The key in this debate is the fact that both yair and murtaza both recognized the right for the return to the Jews to their homeland AND the right of the Palestinians to have security, safety, and freedom. Whether that is two state or one state, doesn't matter, but every single debate about this issue needs to start there, period.
This: Murtaza Hussain and Yair Rosenberg. Is Golden
The king is back! I don’t watch the “news” I watch Jon Stewart! Thank you for coming back Sir.
so you dont watch the news?
I, and probably Jon Stewart as well, would encourage you to read the news. Jon Stewart is a comedian who comments on the news, but he won't give an unbiased report of the facts. Reading the news from accurate sources is the only way to get an accurate understanding of what's going on in the world.
5:22: Stewart: "Netanyahu, whenever he gets into trouble, suddenly there's a war".
Sheer, utter, unadulterated nonsense.
@@sheilamacdougal4874, this is very easy to counter by just providing a counterexample with a time he was in trouble and there wasn't a war.
Nice to see two individuals have a conversation about the Israeli-Palestinian situation without screaming at each other. Lessons can be learned from this.
John, I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE BACK!!
Praying for peace every day. It doesn't need to be this way. So many innocent lives lost on both sides for nothing.....
This is how we should have this conversation , we treat each other with respect deserved and understand the passion behind each other’s anger and frustrations
Absolutely. Who would've thought not yelling over each other & actually having meaningful, intelligent conversation instead of slewing talking points would actually go over well
I would add that the reason the UN can’t pass a ceasefire resolution is that our country keeps vetoing it, regardless of the majority vote.
It’s not our right to tell other countries how to defend themselves based on social pressures…. That’s social imperialism.
The UN draft proposal did not include protection or release of hostages, that’s why it was vetoed. Biden’s working on recognizing a Palestinian state to lead to a true cease-fire with real diplomatic pressure.
UN proposal did not protect hostages. Biden government is working on a better plan that includes recognizing a Palestinian state.
USA should stay out of it.
Bwahahahaha!
What, "@@Dr-386"?
The way you're defining “social Imperialism”..
Won't that translate to: Herzlstan always wants social Imperialist protection from the GS?
What Murtaza Hussain has to say about how to overcome being visceral are like golden rules which can't be repeated and followed enough. Well said!
It is nice to see people have a conversation calmly
the Marshall Plan reference is so true. I was just thinking abt how they tried that strategy everywhere
It brought me to tears when he mentioned the Golden Rule, thank you all so much!
It's a Hadith from Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him
@@TheHH77it’s a quote 600 years earlier from the Gospel of Matthew, to be super clear. Muhammad is simply quoting a man he believed was a prophet.
@@boomgospelit goes back even further to Leviticus, and then rephrased by Hillel the Elder, who predated Jesus by a century
the way you throw in the humour and keep it going. amazing .
I truly believe that most of us are reflected in this interview. We have differences and will not always agree with each other when pursuing truth and problem solving. Finding common ground, and I'm sure you'll find there is a lot, keeping open dialogue, having integrity, and at the end of the day, being kind.
This show was absolutely brilliant. The best peace plan I have ever heard. Nations, please do this. Help everyone with this plan.
A plan that is DOA and doesn't actually solve anything.
I'm an Aid Worker supporting affected families in Ukraine for the past two years. It's heartbreaking work, but as an American, with every person I meet, I offer hope we will not leave them in their hour of need. People still believe in what America stands for. Even if we don't believe it ourselves. ❤
Thank you so much for this.
@@monicabeaston4996 Thank you for saying that. 🙏
The US is a powerful country whose ideals (at least on paper) are still looked up to throughout the world. So, when you live in a place where those ideals are severely under attack, it is natural for people to hope the country with those ideals will help.
Trust me, that trust is at an all-time low. And I come from a country that was once helped by the US. Even my people are losing faith in this ideal because of what's happening to Palestine. USA lost credibility big time with their unconditional support for genocide.@@MrBrock314
I almost teared up on your comment! I'm an immigrant who came here 20 years ago now because I, like many other immigrants, had an American dream. Many people around the world look up to America as an ideal. Sadly in the last 20 years, I feel things have gotten so bad in a way that I've never seen it before. The division and chaos in our society is heartbreaking and disheartening. But you're right. We gotta cling on to that belief that made this country what it is and made us who we are. We can't give up! Gotta keep believing and keeping on.
Very refreshing conversation.
These are the conversations we SHOULD be having, ALL the time! I love that they’re friends and have been able to maintain that through all of this. Lead by example gentleman 👏🏻 🙌🏻💜💜💜💜
When Murtaza says keeping the golden rule in the forefront is key to these conflicts! ❤
And what would that be
@@benkei7530 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Rule
@benkei7530 Do unto others as you would have done to you. Ancient wisdom from before these cultures even existed.
@@patreekotime4578 That quote is generally from the Bible and it definitely doesn't predate Jews or Palestinians as they start about 20 books earlier in the Bible and chronologically about 1500 years earlier.
@@MrBrock314 the bible contains many borrowed stories, myths, and moral teachings and the golden rule is no exception. There are records of functionally similar sayings in Egypt and Sumer that pre-date David's rule of ancient Israel (potentially by a thousand years or more). The saying is so simple and fundamental, it probably vastly precedes even that (ancient China had its own version, as did the Tamils in India, and many other ancient civilizations). It's nothing to be ashamed of but it is indeed wisdom that probably pre-dates the Semitic peoples.
Emotionally intelligent men communicating: so refreshing and hopeful
What a breath of fresh air. These guys need to be heard everywhere
Thank you both of you. Peace and leadership moving forward needs to come from persons like you! 🙏🏻 🤍
Yes!!!! Two diasporas don't make a right! This is why we needed you back, Jon! This is it!
It's so nice that they're both real life friends.
Fascinating conversation! Enlightening, simultaneously discouraging and uplifting, thank~you all.
Christopher Hitchens commented that once established the Israeli state had the unfortunate side effect of irrevocable commitment to that state.
What a great conversation, this show has gotten so much better now that John has returned.
We missed you Jon.
Man, this is so much better than any other news source anywhere!
oh look, a nuanced, intelligent take on the situation. what a sadly refreshing change of pace.
Jon Stewart taught me what journalism is. As i was a journalism student.
Unbelievable how a comedy show does better journalism than the overwhelming majority of TV news journalists.
one of the best interviews on the whole topic this entire war
Someone tags Perce Morgane and shows him how a genuine conversation for peace looks like, not a the fights for views and trends that he’s being doing for the last months !!!
Thank you Jon for coming back 🙏🏻
I love that comment from the relative seeing the New York subway and saying now they understand.
If Jon Stewart came out of retirement to fight for peace in the Middle East and it somehow happens as a result, he be one of the greatest Americans to have ever lived.
More informative than any mainstream news
Except 2 min in is a blatant lie about Israel not being engaged in prior talks or propositions about a two state solution… so yes very informative🤣🤣
@@Thomas-mz9zq of course they engaged, what else would you call assassination of their own PM Rabin for negotiating a 2 state solution except for "engagement" 😂 rip bozo 🤡
You need to also watch independent media: Kim Iversen, Jimmy Dore, The Hill, Rising, The Duran and a lot more.
@@cv-cq9ryJimmy Dore and the Rising are contrarian grifters
6:33 - "It seems like nobody is actually being honest or genuine in the region about their aims." - Jon
This is 100% the problem.
Nah. The problem is 100% that Israel is occupying Palestine, is ethnically cleansing its population, and has full support of the western world.
In the midst of all these violence, this is so calming. This almost brought back my believe in humanity.
thank you comedy central and Jon Stewart for making modern political discourse appetizing again.
We really needed Jon Stewart back thank you
I think it’s insane that Israel’s illegal occupations are not mentioned at all. I think that is the main thing that needs to be rectified before peace can be had
Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005
@@dagda16 Ever heard of the westbank?
@@theflyingspaghettimonster6462
That may be true but I think their point was Israel has a very reasonable perspective on not pulling out. They did it in Gaza in 05 and look what happened. Whose to say that won't happen if they pull out in the West bank?
Your own insane lack of geo-political and historical knowledge is what is astounding
@@yehoshuabedziner2314
Sure, if Israel were to pull out from the west bank now, Hamas would probably take over. But it should hardly be surprising that the most radical faction gets support from a population living under an apartheid regime there. They had decades to build relations with those people, and show them that a peaceful coexistence is possible and in their best interest. Instead their actions (building settlements, ignoring violance from the settlers) entrench this believe that Israelis and Palestinians have to be enemies.
I don't argue that Israel should just pull out today, but they should start applying the same law on all the people living there. Not military law for one part and civil law for the other. Set up a citizens assembly to discuss the futue of the land, and broadcast it. It worked in Northern Ireland, so why not here?
Dear Jon, please continue with conversations like this. You sometimes become a talking head yourself and create more problems than solve them. This is you trying to actually solve something. You are blessed to have the platform to do so.
This was a refreshing and robust conversation. Thanks Jon !
Real discourse. How beautiful and refreshing.
That's how it is done! Thank you Jon for your fairness! You are the best!
Thank you for finding these two guys!!
conversations like this one are definitely on the correct path to achieve peace and prosperity to everyone