Judge Denies Camille Vasquez's Request to Use Video Depositions During Closing Arguments
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 май 2022
- Johnny Depp's lawyer Camille Vasquez requested the use of video depositions in closing arguments. Judge Azcarate denied the request, stating that only exhibits already entered into evidence can be used.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard #CamilleVasquez
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on RUclipsTV!
tv.ruclips.net/user/welcome?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK RUclips CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam 
Развлечения
Huge job for this judge. I feel that she has been unbiased, calm, and friendly. She is clearly respected by the lawyers on both sides.
Imagine what it's like when there's murder involved
I do feel that yesterday and especially today she has been more biased towards Amber's team and more stone faced towards Depps. Up until now I thought she did a great job at staying even.
@@NE-sd9hn Seems strategic to me, let Amber keep talking (lying) so she can literally shoot herself on the foot 😁
@@NE-sd9hn yea I felt that too..i think she's buying amber's whole victim act...i hope the jury sees how pathetic amber is...
Um a Judge clearly must be respected by all sides! It isn’t a option!
I wish she could use the video of Amber apologizing to Johnny for throwing the bottle at his finger. It's crazy the proof exists and can't be used..
I don’t think that is fair to Depps team. They should be able to listen to it considering AH is accusing him of DV which is why his career was lost. I thought that was the reason for the trial. Defamation because she called him a wife beater.
Why can't it be used?
what did I miss ? why can't it be used ?
Where was that can u tell pls? Which day?
@@zizisisi Because there are other people's voices in the audio, I believe, and apparently one of them has since passed... So, it'd fall under hearsay (?)
This job is so stressful. Even watching the judge go through those papers is anxiety inducing
even just sitting there listening to AH and not showing any emotion! that is extremely big self-control!
There's a reason why getting into law school is even harder than medical school
@@gabrielng3449 Not actually true and getting accepted into a veterinarian program is more difficult than either
People with this personality type LOVE to get into a huge pile of papers and split every hair possible.
@@gabrielng3449 ye okay😂
The judge has kept them on topic, not allowed the lawyers to take control and really held them in line in a very polite, professional way. You don't have to be a hateful brute to run a tight ship.
Your right are u referring to camille on how she has a tough cross examination?
I get the feeling she isn't happy this is public at this magnitude and it's in jury hands. Id bet a substantial amount she would be highly bias other wise, she feels very much like she's saving face to not show bias.
That is judging lol
she allowed heavily edited photos as evidence though.
the orignal one where johnny was holding a baby can be seen in twitter/instagram of the father but the one that was submitted has been edited.
@@midori4713 How else could the jury make a comparison between the doctored photos otherwise?
I genuinely wish that Johnny should win this case. It’s now a necessity.
Hope the jury will make the right decision.
Why? Genuinely asking, the trial has determined he was an abusive husband through reems of evidence.
Why do you want yet another violent, arrogant, powerful man to gain yet another victory?
Carly do you live on the same planet that we do?
Name one piece of evidence that proves Johnny depp was an abusive husband?
@@Whatishappenin 😂😂😂
@@Whatishappenin
that's your opinion
Even if he loses in some parts, he already succeded in what he wanted. The money wasn't that important to him anyway (all he needs to do to get insanely rich again is to sell his Bahama island - which he said he was thinking about because it reminds him of the awful time with AH). But I think she has to face a perjury penalty AND someone should keep an eye on AHs child. It's honestly upsetting to know that somebody like her got hold of a baby.
As a former paralegal.... I can tell you that every night they leave the courtroom, they are all still in their offices until way late in the night preparing for next day. Just these instructions alone will mean many many hours tonight pouring through exhibits and prep. Easy to think they leave the courtroom and go home for drinks etc... People have no idea how much work is involved behind the scenes each night.
Yes seems like a lot of prep work behind the scenes
I was thinking about that yesterday. Both sides were astonishingly prepared for the last-minute witnesses. Somebody took the time to look into the film that Mr. Knight, the trailer guy, made years ago, for example, and who was on the crew. That's just one example. Many all-nighters were done by many hard working people in the background, no doubt at all.
I think it's clear Elayne hasnt slept much 🥴 especially with those surprise rebuttal witnesses. Much respect to both teams
Not only this. Even a small event needs preparation and hard work. Every thing.
💯 shoutout to all real lawyers who fight for true justice ⚖️
This judge deserves an award for her service. She has shown incredible amounts of patience and impartial plight to this case. Well done
She even served in the marine corps
Shes amazing. Unlike that muppet who judged the Kyle Rittenhouse case.
Yes unlike this phony groupie lawyer with her fake voice
This judge has been incredible. Cool under pressure with the Whole World watching. Doesn’t ham it up and keeps things professional and by the book. Pleasant, nice, fair, unbiased, and competent in both her knowledge and application of the Law.
The way she responded to the objections on the last day, she did great but you could tell she was looking at the clock saying we're almost done.
If she had attorneys like F Lee Bailey, Johnny Cochran, and Shapiro it’s a different story
and she cracked some jokes too =D
Sucking taxes, smiling, talking to mental consultants called lawyers and law offenders that can't break up in two hours (what many years!?), and reading commentaries about which of judges' opinions can make it to the verdict through a streamline of the law's if-thens. A good job (it's not).
@@BeckGho What a shame... Camille wanted to show amber's deposition from 2016 .. her version of the "stairs" incident was different in her trial testimony now and also different to amber's sister. The whole "I remember, i remember ... Kate Moss pushed down the stairs by Johnny'' ~drama~ lie", when amber hit Johnny.
Wow ..what a Judge she has been. I’ve watch cases for many years and have never seen such sweet and fair judge as her.
for 10 years at least
@@Omnis.satanica.potestas_omnis no I don't want that
She has been fair and clear.
Amen
In that case, you definitely gotta watch the Halderson Trial.
Amber photoshops a picture of her "bruises", and when confronted with the orginal and altered photos, says they're same. She then sees two pictures of the same floor, and argues they might be different. This woman. If I were on the jury I'd ignore even confession from Johnny depp at this point and vote against her just for insulting my intelligence.
Admire your recognition of bias
And when she was caught with her lies she started accusing Johnny of being powerful man lol
i have seen the same comment before...one shouldn’t copy others comment. people should express their opinion in their own words specially in RUclips. if you have nothing to say, don’t say. None is forcing you to comment 😢
@@raishalionel3382 Noone is forcing you to comment
@@LFCEVO24 they changed the contrast and saturation. That's editing. She claims it was two different photos when it was the same photo except edited. Why are you attacking that dude? He's right. And the floor was the same too
The judge will finally have a piece of peace of mind once this is finally done. Her patience is commendable. 🍵
She is truly "Honor" - as were addressed as "Your Honor" !
I mean, this is literally her job, after this trial she'll move on to the next one
Why don't they end it sooner? I am sure they all clearly know who is lying. They should end the case and go back home
Another crazy cray cray nutjob will take Amber's place and the judge has to deal with it again...peace of mind as if it's the first and last for her ... We wish but not gonna happen ... The world needs a judge like her...
@@asdfffs yeah…but 2 months of this.
People can’t even imagine how difficult it is to remain impartial throughout a case like this
you don't have to be impartial to be professional.
Also, people can’t imagine how gruelling a weeks long trial is on the lawyers. Brutal and exhausting.
I can. I could never. My facial expressions would reveal it all!
You’ve written that under almost every video related to this trial lol
@@loserplanet Same xD
It’s ok Camille. You’ve done a good enough job where they aren’t needed.
Better safe than sorry!
The thing is, just the mention that even more testimony exists in favor of Depp, benefits his case even if those depositions are not allowed.
First trial?
I wonder what those contain
@@buffyking5880 depositions…basically recorded testimony before the trial.
We need to say a prayer, Johnny and his team have put their whole effort into this. It’s been for so long and the truth needs to be unveiled!!!
She thinks she's above the law? Camille who calls herself a lawyer needs to start realizing that there is a system of law and Johnny can not get around it.
A prayer for this nonsense? Lol
@@tal32 like what?
Yes, praying for Johnny and his team 🙏🙏🙏
The truth unveiled
This whole trial has been full of powerful, intelligent and highly skilled women. Bravo to them all, especially the judge.
Very true 👏👏
@King Brilliant Elaine, where is the button to the microphone?
@King Brilliant you are right, Amber is very powerful in taking high skilled poops on beds
Male feminists are weak
Minus the entirety of Heards team 😂
"Tell the world, Johnny"
He did and we listened. We believe him.
But did the Judge and jury listen?
How telling that she taunted him like that.
This sounds straight out of an inevitable movie trailer about this
I don't believe he never laid in a hand on her ever.He's a drug addict and alcoholic so how can he remember everything.They were toxic to each other.
Let’s hope they didn’t believe her
I'm 66 years old and I had been around all sorts of people. I have never seen anything like this woman not even close.
Wow
Consider yourself extremely lucky then? People like her are becoming more common everyday
I've got a sister who is similar, has similar traits, but she'd never have the nerve to be so arrogant about her lies.
@@amber619pop right? It's like everyone I come in contact with is exactly like this and it's scary.
Thank God, if you believe. I have been around several people like this, both are blood related.
Guys please stop only praising Camille, the whole team is doing a great job and if you became a fan of Camille, you should also become a fan of the man who has been exterminating all of Amber’s “experts”.
True. It's always a team work.
You can't tell people who to praise. People praising Camille are well aware that the other 8 lawyers are just as good, maybe more so.
Yes, not taking anything away for her, but that whole Team did a fantastic winning job!
I’m a Wayne fan, man is awesome
Yes, Wayne Dennison is brilliant. They all have different personalities but equally brilliant on their own and as a team
This judge is such a great model for future "TV courtrooms", because Judge Azcarate has taken great pains to ensure the publicity of the trial does not distract from the mechanics of justice. That "four walls" moment is just beautiful, a very solid and sound position to take, one that I think not every judge has been able to hold to.
This judge is so on it. Much respect for her knowledge and experience.
Hopefully the jury remembers her admitting 3x today she wrote the OP-Ed to attack Johnny
"Tell the world, Johnny, tell them, 'Johnny Depp, I, a man, I'm a victim too of domestic violence'. And see how many people believe or side with you" ......
She has literally asked for it.
🥗🐇🐢
Having served 18 years as a trial court judge, I can say that this judge is exemplary in her competent and even handed handling of this trial.
Who do you think is more abusive?
Thanks, for mentioning.. This is quite an “ event”………and interesting to the extreme..though normally I detest the “ legal maneuvering, Lawyers, etc”…I noticed the Judge, TEAM Depp, *& even Team HEARD ( A. Heard is a Problem) with some semblance of Representing “?”. Mr Chew, Ms Vasquez with the Assorted Court,Employees of State,Sherriff restored some of my Faith……..
The fact nobody has an opinion about the judge, can we acknowledge how difficult it is that is? People will always have an opinion about someone, and in this case we have millions of people watching.
Honestly i've seen a lot of opinions about the judge, and most of them characterize her as very professional and impartial. Which of course is a great thing.
Dunno where you have been looking but I have seen tons of comments and opinions on the judge. There us a ton on this very video.
“Nobody has an opinion about the judge”
Everyone in the comment section of any video the judge is in: the judge is so professional, patient, and impartial
I have an opinion on the judge. If anyone is the star of this trial it’s Judge Penney. She is incredibly impartial fair balanced professional and very patient
It looked like depp is gonna win but we never know how the jury sees things. Hopefully a bit of justice is done to him
The evidence supports Depp. But we'll see if Heards theatrics convinced the jury
I heard that a few of them were rolling their eyes during her testimony today.
You literally have to be from another planet to see it her way.
@@courtneyblue15 my eyes are sore from constantly rolling my eyes. Imagine how theirs are. I'm sure they were falling asleep at sum times. And I'd say they've got pretty friendly with each other now after 6 weeks together
@@courtneyblue15 tell me more about it Please , who said that , because if it's really the case then it's wonderful , atleast we know jury is with Johnny
It’s odd that 90% of JD’s witnesses seemed like good people and 90% of AH’s seemed like fly-by-night mechanics/hucksters
Well atleast 10% of her side were good. 😅
After the psychiatrist Spiegel, I started to believe that AH was in the mental hospital, after left there she changed her name. The whole witnesses on AH's side, they were her besties in the mental hospital. 😄 😄😄 😄
And one Lemony Snicket !
Birds of the feather as the old adage goes
You really live in an oblivious world, don't you? Sounds tempting but I rather stay in the real world
Shocked she asked such an obviously wrong thing. Two things, actually, with the televised depo. Maybe she’s not as good as we thought. That was rookie.
I started asking why on earth depositions wouldn’t be allowed, and then the judge explained in two sentences and it made complete sense. Thank god for this pro throughout.
Because it would be easy to manipulate videos and only show seconds and put it out of context. Remember how many hours it took with all the witness testuminonies? They all connect and counter argue each other in many ways. They only have 2 hours to sum it up. It is only the evidence that's most important, witness testimonies are up to jury to remember & cover, etc.
She explained how legal procedures work so yeah, U right
I hope jury sees what she is.. she shifts so fast from faking to cry without tears to aggressive rude defensive when Camile is crossing.. has a victim u badly can keep yourself together no matter what.. abusers take us everything she doesn't act like a victim. This is a mockery to real victims. If she wins is like giving power to abusers so victims are doomed
Yeah that’s it. And this is why I also hope that the jury will understand how important it is, and their responsibility to decide what is right to do in such trial. This is not a simple case of high profile gossip, it reveals a far more radical problem than it seems.
She's a different person every time she gets on the stand
Or...she's just incredibly brave, and alot more intelligent than so many of her dire acusers.
@@alexandriabaratta2085 well said. 👍💥💜
@@anjou6497 Whatever the jury decides, it's unlikely to sway many people away from their prejudices. I'll admit, I wasn't there. The evidence may have been cherry-picked and played up. I'm no longer sure whether it matters who "wins" - they're both now free of a horribly toxic relationship.
Camille killed it for this entire trial, I hope that she gets offers from an endless number of clients after this is over ❤
i hope there aren't any more clients that have suffered the way johnny did. he had his own problems, but that was brutal and he deserves justice.
I hope she gets a partnership. She's earned it.
Espero que Johnny vença e ela passe a se dedicar somente aos trâmites dele.
She's definitely on the way to starting her own firm.The passion she showed for her client will be well sought after.
As long as the client she defends is innocent… Imagine if Rottweiler brilliance in a lawyer had been on AHs payroll!
This judge is excellent. She is patient and fair with everyone.
Another joke
It looks like the lawyers are actually quite friendly with each other when their clients aren't around. It's nice to see.
They don't really care, they get paid anyway :-) ;-)
Jury should be able to deliver a quick deliberation. It's clear who's lying.
Let's hope
They have to go back through ALL of the evidence.
or they can just listen to the audio recordings of Amber's voice lol
We on the internet have evidence the jury doesn't. Rottenborn can't block us from seeing and hearing things.
thank god jury is not depp fanbase
This judge is absolutely brilliant. She is impartial and willing to allow more things than not. Careful the whole way to avoid a mistrial. A judge worthy of the national spotlight, but seems to be wary of her public presence.
You mean “wary”?
@@SP-qi8ur "weary-adjective; feeling or showing tiredness, especially as a result of excessive exertion or lack of sleep." "wary-adjective; feeling or showing caution about possible dangers or problems." I think in the way that Justin Poley phrased their sentence, they were using the correct term.
I LOVE HER
@@technote5124 actually, you just proved that the OP meant 'wary' lol. Wary was the intended word
@@SP-qi8ur haha I fixed it. Both work in describing her, but in this case I did mean wary. Thank you!
She didn't deny Camille anything, don't make it sound like something it wasn't. Judge clarified a question, of which Elaine also wanted to know. So messed up to misrepresent.
She DID deny Camille's request. The fact that you and the other loons who gave you likes, could not glean that...
Agree
“Do you have any objection to us playing…”
Judge says no they can’t play it, so yes that’s denying a request.
And what’s wrong with denying it? It’s her job to approve or deny. Don’t make something out of nothing
@@Mushroom_moon_stirfry it’s because they put these people on a pedestal so god forbid they are told no or are depicted as imperfect in any way
Interesting to be flies on the wall able to hear these kinds of conversations between the judge and lawyers. Also, this judge seems nice and down to earth. And fair.
You’ll be eating your words when she rules in favor of Heard and I’ll be here for it. Eating my popcorn. 🍿
@@NAConen bruh😂
I’ve really liked this judge the whole time. She’s been great at being unbiased and not turning this into a circus act. Or at least not adding to the current circus act lol
Already a circus act staring Johnny depp
@@lemmon-up4er you should star in a spelling bee contest
I can tell the judge is so over this trial...but she is very patient with them.
@@Uniqueheartnmind so true she wasn't fed up at start and I think she was on amber side but she did let the court room turn in to a circus
and it's still suspicious why Amber's team doesn't want the videos and witness testimony to be given to the jury.
I like how ambers team chimed in and tried to correct Camille like they’re actually smart 😂 even tho Elaine can’t do math and the guy objected himself
🤣🤣🤣👍
I'd like to see u as a lawyer in a high profile case with the world staring at you
@@TheLatina2000 shush
@@LFCEVO24 lol it wasn’t only two mistakes
😂😂😂
That was a ridiculous request
This judge is ear candy!
Everything she says is like pink clouds with a lot of sugar on top!
I've seen many hearings, trials etc in my life but this judge has during the last 3 weeks been the most amazing thing ever entered a court room.
Absolutely fantastic!
The best thing JD did is asking to televise this court proceedings, no matter what happens, JD wins and AH lost!!
That was a good idea so it at least gives the public the chance to hear his side of the story. Problem is, this is a defamation case and Depp wasn't able to prove that he lost his job at Disney because of Amber Heard.
@@remannhall9457 Wasnt it about the op-ed? which she basically admitted today
@@remannhall9457 it was about the op-Ed then amber heard goes and says she wrote it about Johnny on her last testimony 😂😂🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️ another slip up lol that the jury heard lmao
Abuser behavior and of course you remoras enable him
The best thing about the proceedings being televised is that we can see for ourselves how much the mainstream media lies and reports with bias and omission these type of cases. Mainstream media in Ireland mainly ignoring the case and when they do report they cherry-pick something they can find that looks favourable to AH.
They all seem so friendly after hours.
Almost like they’re all cool with eachother irl …but when trial is in session, it’s game on.
love to see it.The way it should be imo.
Lol IN REAL LIFE?? U think the court room isn't real?? How old are u? Just asking
@@charliechurch5004 bro 💀 calm down its a general expression. Obviously this court case is real smh
Have you ever had to do with attorneys and judges? They eat together, play golf together go to the same parties after a process is over.
@@charliechurch5004 I think what she was trying to say is that "in real life" refers to what goes on outside of the court, not that the court isn't real.
Herd should face charges for lying
This judge is an amazing woman. I never ever thought i would say that about any judge but there you have it.
I am a domestic violence survivor, it took me along time to be able to not say I'm sorry to everything, asking my parents if I could go somewhere besides to work( I was 27 at this time ), when someone got angry and raised their voice I would dropped my head , if a car that looked like the car my ex had I would have a panic attack, I moved from the state and when I would go back to that state I would constantly look over my shoulder. She is not the victim. She is way tooo calm , aggressive to be a victim. I know several other domestic violence survivors that acted ( not 100% same) like me or had similar symptoms. I speak out about it now and stand up for victims. It took me 15 years to be able to put this part of me away, I will never fully heal but I get stronger every day.
That kind of weak, apologetic personality is exactly what attracts abusers, as well as purse snatchers, etc. You need to learn self-esteem, assertiveness, and carry yourself with confidence so they stay away from you!
@@genxx2724 "You need to", some people don't have the luck to not be born into abusive families. You can hardly learn these thing there. Also personalities are different and not every person on this earth can walk around super confident. Some people are just born fine like vulnerable flowers and it should be ok.
I wish you the very best for your future. You are a brave person and I wish you can gain the strenght to keep on being brave in the future, to identify people that are bad easily and just throw them out of your life.
@@skarbuskreska But it’s not. Self-esteem class, assertiveness training, self-defense class. Perpetrators look for victims. They don’t bother women who walk purposefully, look people in the eye, and are aware of their surroundings.
@@genxx2724 I'm sorry but this sounds like victim blaming. Did you know there is evidence that narcissists look for victims who are not weak? Ones that the believe will reflect well on them? Unfortunately they take advantage of their EMPATHY, which is something they lack.
Bravo Camille Vasquez, Esq. She's so brilliant and worked so hard to demolish the absurd tissue of lies she was confronted with.
Camille didn’t do well today, sadly. AH adjusted from last time and came out looking bullied and just more of a victim.
This is what a real judge looks like. Not what you see on those "reality" tv shows. That's mockery to the law.
how sweet is this judge. i hav so much respect for her and her professionalism.
The judge is 1st class ......... with all the coverage getting slammed to defence or prosecution, its sometimes lost how good a job she has done with being tasked to oversee such a prolific case
Good luck to Johnny's legal team!
Her admittance that She write OP-ED because of JD is already a big factor in favor of JD...We knew already that she is lying from the very start...All her doings backfire against her...May the good Lord guide the jury in their decision ....
Yes that's what all of us are hoping...but this world is so twisted that's why we are so worried.
She has every right to tell her story and every right to tell her story publicly, calling him out by name and everything. Depp has to PROVE that it was because of Heard's op-ed article in WaPo that led to his dismissal from Disney. Depp has zero evidence of that and he has no chance of winning this case.
@@remannhall9457 AH just admitted on the stand that she wrote the oped abt Johnny. She implicated herself.
What I s op ed
@@wicomms “People who disagree with me are twisted.”
Lots of prayers for Johnny tonight.
I sincerely hope that the jury dismisses amber's counter claim, & awards Johnny his suit in full, based on the facts from honest witnesses whom never changed their stories, & that they don't fall for her awful tear-free "performance" this morning. She can crack & whine her voice, but just can't shed that honest, sincere tear. I feel sorry for the jury, & sincerely wish them patience, wisdom, and peace ❤❤
Me too, he deserves to win this whole in full…
Agree- to think she could be rewarded any further cash is nauseating
Is it up to they jury to dismiss the counter claim? I saw a video where the judge dismissed the request to dismiss the counter claim?
I may be wrong but isn't that incredibly rare in civil cases. It's my understanding that the jury often ends up somewhere in the middle and awards some damages but not usually the full amount
@@nataliesmommy303 I apologize. You're correct on that. Thank you for the reminder😊
I really like this judge - she is very clear, competent, and professional.
yh she has a lot of patient and seems really kind to everyone.
imagine being around her as her younger relatives: she is so calm and fair!
It's been a privilege to be able to watch her at work.
Now this is a model judge. Human, unbiased, fair, approachable, understanding, and all out professional.
I love how JD’s attorneys are respectful in following the court process and use their logic to keep track of the contexts.
So she claims Johnny Depp is a powerful man but won't acknowledge he got her the Aquaman role?
Very good point
Her entire testimony, narrative, excuses, all of it are teeming with contradictions.... Every gaslight, deflection, "I disagree" presents a (usually barely) plausible reality when you're looking at it, but expand your scope even slightly and the whole house of cards collapses into a rotten mess.
It's infected her legal team too - like they literally claim in the same breath that JD already had "the exact same marks" under his eyes before getting on the train, and then... doctored a photo on the train to add marks to his eyes. Like are you guys even listening to yourselves?
All they care about is sowing doubt (anyone who cares about truth) and providing cover (anyone who doesn't). Blegh.
If he were that powerful he wouldn’t have been dropped from projects.
This woman will never speak for me and others male/female victims.. she doesn't know or lived anything of what she claims. Her posture like superior being answering to Camile when she looked at the jury is so disgusting. I hope JD wins and she faces legal charges for lies under oath and providing fake evidence.
Said the same thing! This woman’s “dv” sounds like a freakin movie. Idk who truly believes makeup can cover every and anything 😩 it’s a slap in the face
She definitely doesn’t speak for me. You know it’s probably what makes me the most angry because real survivors and conquers get it. You just know when you know. ♥️
He lost the divorce. He lost the London suit n he will lose this. Disney testified nothing about the op-Ed or divorce had anything to do w him losing Jack Sparrow. He’s done
Yes, exactly!! We hope So too!!
@@patricia7606 Yep, im sure he doesn't remember half of what he did with all the drugs.
How friendly these lawyers are to eachother. Lovely
I hope this is taken as a compliment. The judge is a sweetheart! Totally in control, knows the law requirements and has shown the lawyers respect and received it in turn. And she has a delicious sense of humor as well. More like her, please.
I wouldn't use the word sweetheart to describe a judge. I would say she's kind, fair, understanding, compassionate.
All the best for Johnny! The WORLD IS WITH YOU! The true survival of all terrible abuses of AH!
Poor guy grew up being beat by his mom then by his wife.
The “world” is on the side of the abuser. What a sick bunch!
Camille reaction when Amber Heard lawyer start talking 😹😂😂
It's going to be one long night for the attorneys!
Camille should finish her closing with the recording where amber says " tell the world Johnny, tell them that I Johnny Depp am a victim of domestic violence" that's chilling.
That‘d be so powerful
I do like the judge. I think she has been very fair and impartial throughout the trial, while remaining calm and collected. I have seen other judges in trials....
Manifestating for Johnny Depp to WIN!!!
She's literally on tape admitting she assaulted him. How is she not under criminal investigation?
That's pretty much been already covered in the trial.
wait, so you can't take something someone said while testifying, and show it to the jury? how does that make any sense?
Isn’t it like asking extra time to finish a test? All the evidence has been submitted, so they can only use what they have rather than get new evidence based on witness testimonies. The justice system is a game, it’s all about strategy to win it..even if the wrong person wins unfortunately
even if he doesn’t win the case atleast he knows we are all with him
If I recall correctly, that's all he wanted. so now, for him, it actually doesn't matter if he wins the trial. The public has made their opinions already 😎 and he cleared his image
Yep Johnny has already won in the eyes of the public!! And we love him no Matter how the jury rules !!
If he doesn't win, she will be paid $100,000,000. of his money, It's completely vomit inducing.
Winning will be the cherry on top though. Personally i want him to win in court, because she can’t keep getting away with it!!!
@@FragranceView Not necessarily! If they find Amber not guilty, they have to make a decision separately on whether she wins the defamation counter suit. I think worst case scenario……no one gets any money!!!
Soo they aren’t allowed to use the transcripts/ or video of Amber stating she did indeed write the op-Ed about Johnny!? Hope the jury caught on to that at least
That's not really all that important. It's obvious that she wrote it about it. What's more important are the audio clips of her screaming at him and admitting to hitting him, and him denying doing anything to her.
They surely did. She testified in front of everyone.
They are allowed to point to that, there just not allowed to show the video of it. It’s all in the records regardless tho.
@@OceanHedgehog but this whole case was defamation based on the op-Ed she wrote though right?
@@OceanHedgehog that is important. The entire case was about her writing that
I love this judge. She is sooo pleasant, respectful and calm and and just totally cool human being.
It must be said: this is an excellent judge.
The judge didn't deny, she clarified the rule
Exactly.
@@jasdeepkaur3136 what ever!!!!
@@LeticiaRODRIGUEZ-lx8om you're right, mostly. I think Judge Penney has some discretion, but her preference is a reasonable one - i.e. evidence is evidence, testimony is testimony.
Evidence they can show freely. Testimony (whether on the stand, or from deposition) is witnessed, so not available to be "replayed". The judge stated her preference in a way that left a little wiggle room for someone to make a case otherwise.... but both sides chose not to, and simply agreed.
You're definitely right though that Camille was really clarifying - she was not making a request (or getting denied). The characterization in the title is misleading.
@@jasdeepkaur3136 She didn't rule videos can't be used as evidence, or anything like that. Either side can play ANY video (or audio or picture) they want that's been submitted as evidence during the trial.
What she said was that video depositions cannot be played during the closing arguments. That's because depositions are testimony, not evidence - that is, depo videos are played in court and treated as witness testimony (as if they are on the stand), meaning those videos are not submitted into the court as evidence.
And to really split hairs 😄 she didn't even rule "cannot" - she stated her preference to treat ALL testimony as experienced by the jury within "these 4 walls" (meaning they live it once.... and no external recording of any testimony passes through those walls again to re-live it a 2nd time), but clearly left open the door a smidgen for someone to give a reason against her preference if they felt it necessary.... and neither side did.
Bottom line: Camille asked for clarification, and the judge clarified. It was a "denial" only in the most rudimentary sense of the word. Camille then further confirmed with the judge her understanding of Judge Penney's (well-explained and reasonable) preference by making sure that also means that the courtroom livestream is off limits. So if you weren't sure before, that made it doubly clear that Camille's intent was clarification of the boundaries all along.
The jury better get this right.
The probably won't
Unfortunately not
@@LFCEVO24 you’ve lost grip of reality if that’s your take
I’m not holding my breath
@@LFCEVO24 The only situation she can win is in strip contest.
Camille did her job 👏🏾 and she did phenomenal! Now it’s all up to the jury…
Play a mix of that terrifying audio to remind the jury what he was dealing with.
I told my landlord I’m going to pledge my entirety rent, like all of it…. Now I’m homeless 😂😂
Tell him you use them synonymously 😂
Calm down. It's not that big a deal. Camille and Ben have got this.
I hope so, I will need need my meds if Amber win
true Johnny's team gon make Amber lose this case
@@Forever18or21 it is Americas judicial system…so I’m hoping Johnny wins but if Amber wins it will be a slap in the face to all those real domestic victims including Johnny.
But I’ll say this Amber heard career is over
Camille has got this Ben was good the other sucked
Yes our judicial system sucks I mean look at all the freeloaders coming here like from Mexico they don't have to ever ID numbers to get no social security card get whatever they want don't have to show proof of who they are let us know we're considers do I think people like that need to be jailed
Camille, was put right back in her place ...😂😂😂😂👍 good one from the Judge. 😂😂😂😂😂
So a witness is not evidence unless it's admitted to evidence 🤔 🙄
Even if JD loses the case, he has won back the respect of the world.
He Shure did. And AH is in the grutter. I hope they Will never let her crawl out.
He sure did!!
Not so, only his fans. Hey Pieter B, what’s a grutter ?
Never really lost it!!.
Innocent from the get go!!.
Never. Y’all are blind 🐑. Your voice will only go down as misguided noice in history. No legit media will ever be on JD’s side.
Camille and team you have done wonderfully so far and in my eyes Johnny has won.
I don’t think so. They are so rude and not doing their job professionally. I saw yesterday trail how mr was staring at Amber viciously when amber finished her testimony. I am not either fan of amber neither Jonny but the way they are calling her liar is beyond irrespecutful. Please don’t be like passive person go for someone who is your favorite actor
i Can't imagine how judge would've read the Big Phat docs submitted by Lawyers from both sides....
how would the jury remember all the testimonies and depositions if they are not allowed to look at the transcripts of this trial??
How can their video testimony not be in evidence if the transcripts can be re-read in the jury room
Because they can't give more weight to a video deposition over live testimony. And you can't rebroadcast live testimony during closing arguments as its just giving them an opportunity to testify twice. Which would just open up a huge can of worms as to what is allowed in closing arguments.
Yeah, it makes no sense
It’s because they consider evidence to be physical items or digital data, while testimony is what is revealed during the trial.
It’s alright. The jury are mostly taking notes and they will discuss on it as a whole plus evidences
Oh hi person that acts like they know more than the experts
i love how respectful the judge is when both sides are confirming the order of events for closing. she answered camile fairly and camile replied the same way :D im excited to see this case finally close, and i hope that the outcome is appropriate for both sides
Heard lawyers literally brightened and airbrushed the train photo. How's that not been brought up.
Should a lawyer not know this already?
The key to the verdict will be the instructions given to the jury. They may know she is lying and fabricating evidence but it all about what they are allowed to consider and the points they are allowed to render a verdict on. This is the most important part of the whole trial.
You got it!
And also which jury members are in the final group. Only 7 of 9, according to Law and Lumber
She admitted today she wrote the op ed...
I keep thinking about Casey Anthony, You never know
@@suga3774 which she also admitted to today. She stated she wrote it about him
Love the Judge, she is so calm and seems fair.
well, no, she isn't
Yes she is
she is not biased but she clearly doesn't like johnny
If I were on this jury and sat through everything we saw and heard in this court room, I wouldn't even have to deliberate. I'd just find for Johnny.
Judge Penny has a very refreshing smile. Like one those people who walks in a room and suddenly happy vibes all around
AH has the audacity to say she has never lied in court. Wasn’t her whole argument for defamation based on the fact that she did not write the op-ed about JD? We all know for certain now that it was about him because she lost it on examination by Camille and stated she DID write it about him. She then proceeded, inappropriately and rapidly, to list all the reasons she did it, talking over Camille the whole time. I really wish Camille would have kept peppering her with questions because the jury would have seen the TRUE/ENTIRE wrath this woman can unleash! If only Camille could stated that JD got her the part in Aquaman again, I think she would have come completely unglued. I am glad the whole world got a glimpse of the lying, cannot-recall, everyone-else-is-lying, extremely-poor-acting person that is the real AH. The deliberate plotting, planning and staging scenarios are pure evil.
Today she admitted she wrote the op with Johnny in mind. She basicly admitted it.
Exactly, she testified she didn’t write it, than today said she wrote it, and the truth once again comes out!
Richard Marks spoke about Amber's contract.
She has a contract of a serie of four movies for aquaman. All four movies together for 2 millions.
She earned 450 000 dollars for her acting in aquaman part one.
Amber is an option like many other young actors. So it is on her to show if she is good enough for her role to expand or to cut back.
Richard Marks hates this kind of contracts because it is very difficult to negotiate later about how big the part of the actor will be in the second or the third part and how much of a rise the money will be for the actor.
I listened to his testimony today on earphones.
Maybe it was from day 21.
@@jvd1983rmd I HEARD THAT!
@@jazzliam75 4:06:14 on the whole day stream
The judge has done a pretty good job, in my opinion, as far as I can tell. Are there any legal professionals out there who beg to differ?
I've seen lawyers on youtube criticize her for being too strict on hearsay. But the important thing is she's equally strict to both sides. She's fair.
It was lovely to see the lighthearted moments of the lawyers together with the judge!
It was lovely to see her more relaxed!
This judge is super awesome I have so much props for her, bless her for the long stressful trial I’m sure it was exhausting.
Well we know why AH’S team wanted it and the judge gave it then
Camille slayed it again. BRAVO! GG!!
🙌🐝🙌
I never see a judge so patient and fair to both sides and she was always very kind even she knew amber is a liar I wish others judge could take her behavior and spirit as example from her how to act in court. 👏👏👏congrats Judge
It is soooo satisfying to see the judge putting entitled Camille in her place