Against the Odds | Can Stuffy Doll Beat the Best Deck in Modern?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2025

Комментарии • 531

  • @CardmarketMagic
    @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +45

    🎎🐉 Decklists: bit.ly/3CCV7pg

  • @overtone55
    @overtone55 Год назад +911

    Hey, that Pariah card is pretty good. It pitches to Solitude

    • @lorisbach9905
      @lorisbach9905 Год назад +27

      I feel like people tend to forget that Pariah can target opponent's creature and acts as a removal spell and fog effect. It's not that bad on Regent for exemple.

    • @thehatebringer8005
      @thehatebringer8005 Год назад +23

      If playing against a deck that only has burn spells for removal the pariah cast onto your vindicator just wins the game because you can no longer take any damage ever and it all goes to your opponents face

    • @henryackerson7138
      @henryackerson7138 Год назад +7

      ​@@thehatebringer8005until they bring in bounce/dress down/ counter it to begin with

    • @lordhallibel3604
      @lordhallibel3604 Год назад +4

      @@henryackerson7138 cool story didnt ask

    • @ich3730
      @ich3730 Год назад +6

      @@henryackerson7138 "if playing against a deck that has only burn spells for removal..." Didnt know that dress down does burn damage?

  • @oliverhaberstock4958
    @oliverhaberstock4958 Год назад +497

    That Dress Down was absolutely brutal, great content team

    • @DarkAvenger1234
      @DarkAvenger1234 Год назад +3

      Absolutely crushing

    • @uriarte411
      @uriarte411 Год назад +6

      Those are format quitting moments right there.

    • @jeffe2267
      @jeffe2267 Год назад +9

      I love how Jamin was going to walk Crim through the hypothetical ideal line, but ended up just getting to show him instead of tell him.

    • @stillcantthinkofaname4800
      @stillcantthinkofaname4800 Год назад +1

      Real heart of the cards moment

    • @sethmasters2147
      @sethmasters2147 2 месяца назад

      That should have made blot not get exiled right?

  • @amboss6957
    @amboss6957 Год назад +431

    instant thumbs up for the shot of Crim being shoved toward a Jamin wearing a crown

  • @ThereIsAnExtension2UndoHandles
    @ThereIsAnExtension2UndoHandles Год назад +401

    That Thalia was almost as brutal as the old 'chalice on 1' that got Harry

    • @BraxtonMeyer
      @BraxtonMeyer Год назад +6

      Pretty sure it's spellt Hairy but yes.

  • @ThereIsAnExtension2UndoHandles
    @ThereIsAnExtension2UndoHandles Год назад +196

    Crimm played that Game 2 aiming for content, and content was what we got

  • @nathanpalmiter3260
    @nathanpalmiter3260 Год назад +89

    Having Crim pilot Seth's against the odds decks is pure genius. We're so used to Seth being super positive when things work out, but I love seeing Crim's reactions to just drawing some of the cards. He's so flabbergasted

  • @davidd.w.8681
    @davidd.w.8681 Год назад +101

    21:50 Crim "please don't have a counterspell" was so hilarious.

  • @chrispowell2480
    @chrispowell2480 Год назад +239

    Fun fact, on that second to last turn, Crim could have cast Thalia and still B.A. That way Jamin couldn't have countered or dressed down in response.

    • @Captain_Wasabi
      @Captain_Wasabi Год назад +19

      Yup, that was the line!

    • @ferificatienodig1025
      @ferificatienodig1025 Год назад +11

      he could have had unholy heat or bolt though, I saw the same line, but it might have been to risky.

    • @poiri
      @poiri Год назад +26

      @@ferificatienodig1025unholy heat would not have helped since delirium was not active, bolt was the only realistic out to that line.

    • @ferificatienodig1025
      @ferificatienodig1025 Год назад +14

      @@poiri oh wait, you're right, then it prolly was the better line since if he had the bolt Jamin would've won the next turn anyways.

    • @khurgar8120
      @khurgar8120 Год назад

      he could respond to thalia with dress down, if he had it.

  • @jeffshittles3664
    @jeffshittles3664 Год назад +87

    the two best magic websites working together. epic

  • @samglover2246
    @samglover2246 Год назад +82

    Crim just proved an important rule in Magic: make them have it. Yes, you should be smart, but if your choice is risk playing into what might be a counter or lose, always go for it.

    • @kieranharwood7186
      @kieranharwood7186 Год назад +14

      If you play ten threats and they have nine answers you just landed a threat. that's all you need sometimes.

  • @thecrazycapn
    @thecrazycapn Год назад +31

    Seeing the Against the Odds live against an opponent with reactions does add an extra dimension to it.

  • @jacktorborg9862
    @jacktorborg9862 Год назад +56

    The editing, little side commentary on these videos is out of this world good! Really sets it apart from other magic content channels. Also, of course love mtggoldfish and seth and crim, loving the collab.

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +11

      Thank you! It's worth all the hard work when hearing stuff like this :D

    • @danieldelaney1377
      @danieldelaney1377 Год назад

      @@CardmarketMagic yes whoever makes the little side bars with the information is a good example of german efficiency

  • @bryankopkin6869
    @bryankopkin6869 Год назад +39

    This was a great video! Love the Cardmarket x Goldfish crossover!

  • @lowciel
    @lowciel Год назад +137

    Can we talk about in game three when Jamin only has 2 open mana, crim draws the 5th land, and could drop the Thalia to deny the counter spell and then play the Blastphamous act?

    • @r4g1ngph03n1x
      @r4g1ngph03n1x Год назад +16

      Yep, came here for this too, but at least we got there in the end.

    • @emschmetty417
      @emschmetty417 Год назад +7

      I mean a spell pierce would have still worked, but yeah, the line was there

    • @lowciel
      @lowciel Год назад +24

      Spell pierce would have worked, but Crim hadn't seen one, and kept saying "you don't have spell pierce, you wouldn't have kept that in"

    • @Samantho87
      @Samantho87 Год назад +4

      I mean Jamin could have also bolted the reckoner in response to a blasphemous act and then the game would probably be lost for Crim.

    • @lowciel
      @lowciel Год назад +5

      I'm talking about 35:12 when Jamin bluffs the counter spell

  • @poiri
    @poiri Год назад +42

    36:25 best line from Crim here was probably playing Thalia so that Jamin was locked out of counterspell and only had spellpierce as a possible counterspell then playing the Blasphemous Act with the remaining 3 mana. The line is weak to Lightning bolt, but then again so is waiting.

    • @xano2663
      @xano2663 Год назад +1

      i will never be a control player... everything in me wanted crim to go for it. there are already 2 counterspells in the yard only 2 mana open.. just tax and JAM thats what i would have done but then again maybe i am not a good player xD

    • @andyony2
      @andyony2 Год назад

      I think, it wouldnt have make him weak to Lightning Bolt. Because even if Jamin Bolts something, Crim can cast Thalia.
      Also: Between Thalia entering the Battlefield and casting Act, Jamin wouldnt have get priority again. So he could have only Bolt something before Thalia enters. :)

    • @liamfoote7164
      @liamfoote7164 Год назад

      ​@@andyony2he had two mana up to bluff counterspell. He could have

    • @yaboy821
      @yaboy821 7 месяцев назад

      @@andyony2 if jamin had a bolt crimm would have been dead the next turn anyways

  • @SP-ik6cc
    @SP-ik6cc Год назад +9

    This was great - wouldve loved to see another short call with Seth after the games.

  • @Audentior_Ito
    @Audentior_Ito Год назад +23

    Two of the best MTG outfits out there! Hope to see more collabs

  • @smeatar
    @smeatar 10 месяцев назад +1

    I feel like the editing on this channel manages to get a perfect balance that other channels miss. Like, The Command Zone also does special effects and cutaways where players talk about the game but they go over the top and do it too frequently and it makes me dislike their videos. This channel uses it just the right amount, it really adds to the video without distracting from the video. Same with card descriptions, you have a good sense of which cards need describing and which ones are common enough that people know them. Admittedly I did have to pause to read Mishra's Bauble but that's probably because my experience is with commander and I've never seen it played there. Also I love how you show the triggers on the stack and have the little reminders about delirium and other important things to track, it's another thing that would be very easy to overdo but you do it just enough that it adds to the experience without distracting from it. My only complaint is that I hate the sound of cards being flicked and I've had to stop some videos because of it.

  • @zurreal8087
    @zurreal8087 Год назад +28

    You’ve gotta love Crim’s commitment to the content!

  • @overtone55
    @overtone55 Год назад +35

    Sweet decklist from Seth. Wacky as all hell but effective

  • @nickjoseph77
    @nickjoseph77 Год назад +3

    The thumbnail was amazing and this was a great way to have Seth be there and force Crim to play against the odds. Lol

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +2

      Thank you! I'm thrilled you enjoyed both it :D (and the thumbnail)

  • @Varler_
    @Varler_ Год назад +2

    That was so much fun! I'm always amazed at the production quality of your videos and at the kinds of amazing guests you guys manage to get on!

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +2

      We do put a lot of work in :) happy you liked it

  • @Jay-zt1pq
    @Jay-zt1pq Год назад +3

    My two favorite magic channels collaborating, couldn't be more excited!

  • @TinyLegs15243
    @TinyLegs15243 Год назад +3

    Really enjoying the crossover episodes. Always enjoy both cardmarket and MTGgoldfish content!

  • @thornthallid950
    @thornthallid950 Год назад

    I love the production on these videos. I've never seen paper magic videos that are so clear and easy to follow.

  • @edwardliddell501
    @edwardliddell501 Год назад

    I've been in love with this channel for awhile now. The gameplay videos, especially, are almost all straight fire.

  • @lukesveen5269
    @lukesveen5269 3 месяца назад +1

    As a stuffy doll player, I've found via fnm at my lgs, that Spiteful Sliver is better than Boros Reckoner, and I am now shaved to not even running Stuffy Doll in the mainboard. Phyrexian Vindicator has proven incredible. I strongly suggest adding 4 of both Deafening Clarion and Burn Down the House. I have never run Thalia or stepmom, I initially decided to build the deck with more mass damage instead. I strongly suggest running Cleansing Wildfire, I even run a playset in my mainboard, I notably replaced 4 plains with 4 Flagstones of Trokair, I also run the Boros indestructible lands, making Cleansing Wildfire a reliable RAMP piece that I can also use as a land hate piece if necessary.

  • @BoltTheEmolga
    @BoltTheEmolga 10 месяцев назад

    The Against the Odds videos are genuinely top 5 videos on this channel, would love to see this again if/whenever they come back

  • @EAD6031
    @EAD6031 Год назад +1

    While having an against the odds without hearing once "Ooooooponent" feels weird, it was a wonderful vid ! Thanks both Cardmarket and MtgGoldfish teams

  • @ReneAlbertoZuritaSanchez
    @ReneAlbertoZuritaSanchez Год назад +1

    Jamin has the best attitude and energy. His interaction with Crim was *cheff´s kiss*

  • @LucasMartins-gs6fd
    @LucasMartins-gs6fd Год назад

    You folks have the best advertising! A big big up for the clever deck price on the corner WITH the shipping included!

  • @gooob7548
    @gooob7548 Год назад +1

    Thank you for doing this collab. I’ve been missing Thoralf and Jamin since Arena Boye ended

  • @lvl85taurendk
    @lvl85taurendk Год назад

    Probably the best magic content out there atm for real for real!

  • @ConManAU
    @ConManAU Год назад

    This is why Against the Odds is so great - the deck that should get crushed instead gets to shine just a little. So wonderful seeing two all-star channels team up to bring this level of content.

  • @davec8385
    @davec8385 Год назад +1

    Loving these great videos week after week! I hope you guys have a great rest of your day :)

  • @DefinitelyNotReal627
    @DefinitelyNotReal627 11 месяцев назад +1

    Nah mad respect to Crim committing to the content play. It made for incredible content.

  • @tianruixiao9239
    @tianruixiao9239 Год назад +2

    Crim is always so entertaining to watch, this was great to get in while he was in Europe!

  • @Reverie42
    @Reverie42 Год назад +1

    I've built a version of this deck before. Another tech is Guilty Conscience, which goes infinite with either Stuffy or Vindicator. Toss in a couple boros charms and it can go infinite with Reckoner or Mogg Maniac as well.

  • @blaccoffee1
    @blaccoffee1 Год назад +1

    This is the crossover episode I never knew I wanted but definitely needed

  • @bencheevers6693
    @bencheevers6693 9 месяцев назад

    Love this series, saw another one, hope you guys keep doing this. Magic is pretty good but a meta or format where lots of eccentric decks could be competitive would be great, I like limited a lot but I feel like constructed is so one note but your giving me hope with this.

  • @phillipmeade7640
    @phillipmeade7640 Год назад

    You guys are my favorite MTG channel now. It’s official. Keep up the great work guys.

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад

      That's high praise! We'll make sure we live up to it :) thank you

  • @matteorebeschi6824
    @matteorebeschi6824 Год назад

    Great production (as always), fun theme and awesome guests... another banger!

  • @brothertobias
    @brothertobias Год назад +3

    Only THREE things are certain in life: DEATH, TAXES and THALIA, GUARDIAN OF THRABEN.
    That was a great video. I was thoroughly entertained.

  • @talamran7499
    @talamran7499 Год назад

    this is a crossover between my two favorite channels, couldn't ask for more

  • @Iceboxbeefboy
    @Iceboxbeefboy Год назад

    Best channel to watch paper magic every video is a gem

  • @honorableintent
    @honorableintent Год назад

    The subtitle "Probably better known as Saffron Olive" broke me. Good one, guys!

  • @Pandajannick
    @Pandajannick Год назад +1

    26:50 they didn't do the connive trigger, Crim was dead that same turn if they've done it

  • @colinoclock
    @colinoclock Год назад

    100% ❤ this video and collaboration!

  • @fish_in_distress
    @fish_in_distress Год назад

    This is so cool, it's like two crossovers in one with Crim playing an against the odds deck

  • @tiltedcube
    @tiltedcube Год назад +1

    I don't know why I found it so funny that Crim transferred his Arena commentation to his in person playing

  • @DatKyoda
    @DatKyoda Год назад

    I just built a stuffy doll style commander deck using Atla Pilani to flip them over when the eggs die, and have been ABSOLUTELY loving it. Glad to see the doll get some love 😄

  • @pathtracker4944
    @pathtracker4944 Год назад +1

    Thanks for putting so much love in every videi you make! That is to you, whoever is editing this video, but also to the whole team ! Putting so much energy into a magic game, doing those little breakdowns lf the situation and the thought processes...

  • @jacobarnoldmusic
    @jacobarnoldmusic Год назад +1

    There are really cool combo stuffy doll decks that used to be played around the time stuffy doll came out. I remember seeing some at my lgs back then. They are quite a bit different from this one though.

  • @WhammeWhamme
    @WhammeWhamme Год назад +2

    Please force Crim to play more Against The Odds decks. I enjoy his suffering. ;)

  • @digitalcardboard
    @digitalcardboard Год назад

    that moment when at the end of the video you close full screen to like the video... but you remember you always snap-like cardmarket videos and the video is already liked

  • @iclimbeverything2990
    @iclimbeverything2990 Год назад

    Blasphemous act line was amazing. Loving this channel

  • @MindstabThrull
    @MindstabThrull Год назад +1

    What about Chain Reaction in the side as well as additional Blasphemous Acts? Cast it sooner, might deal less damage but sometimes you just need to get Regent off the board :)

  • @zachariahhuey9876
    @zachariahhuey9876 Год назад

    I LOVE the status updates on the sides of the battle field!

  • @spliffi869
    @spliffi869 Год назад

    Oh sweet, nice to see Crim on here. Another great guest and match!

  • @TheKilskast
    @TheKilskast Год назад +2

    That second game was phenomenal, very fun video!

  • @allopeth
    @allopeth Год назад

    Wow two of my favourite MTG channels together!! please keep the collab going! :)

  • @DerickTheHeroV2
    @DerickTheHeroV2 Год назад

    I was screaming at my screen for Crimm to go all in so much in that third game. I am very grateful that he did. Every single turn with all the surveil and conniving I was like ughhhh you just have to go for it. 😵‍💫

  • @shrinkshrink
    @shrinkshrink Год назад

    I’m so glad to see Crim full send it for the content and the result turned out the way it did

  • @hugmonger
    @hugmonger 8 месяцев назад

    So funny enough this was my Return to Ravnica standard deck. Boros Reckoner + Blas Act "All American Bombs"... IM so happy to see it again

  • @underscorerx
    @underscorerx Год назад +3

    This was an insanely entertaining match

  • @moralessanchezoscarelias6412
    @moralessanchezoscarelias6412 Год назад

    Great video, awesome collaboration 🎉

  • @spicychinchin6597
    @spicychinchin6597 Год назад

    Dude the videos have been banger after banger. Can't wait to watch this match!

  • @andrewpowers3730
    @andrewpowers3730 Год назад

    You guys have the best gameplay videos! Always look forward to your videos

  • @magica3526
    @magica3526 Год назад +2

    at 36:22 couldn't he thalia into blasphemous act to stop counterspells? am i missing something?

  • @JEDWOLFF
    @JEDWOLFF Год назад

    I was so confused where there was against the odds yesterday. It all makes sense now

  • @cameton_youtube
    @cameton_youtube Год назад

    This was a really cool matchup! Good job to all involved

  • @OogaB0oga
    @OogaB0oga Год назад

    26:44 missed out on a Ledger Shredder trigger for potential lethal that turn :P Jamin didn't have a spell to pitch to Connive in hand, but could have ordered triggers to resolve the DRC surveil first, then keep on top anything that's not a land or mill a land for another shot at finding a nonland to loot away and grow the Shredder, for that final point of damage :) GGs!

  • @BenziTrain
    @BenziTrain Месяц назад

    At the 36:31 mark, should've play thalia. If it gets countered, hes tapped out and you can play BA. If he doesn't counter it, he won't have enough mana for counterspell and you can play BA (plus the thalia tax)!

  • @SmokeADig
    @SmokeADig Год назад +2

    Loving the Goldfish crossover episodes 👍👍👍

  • @purplelilypervincle4898
    @purplelilypervincle4898 Год назад

    This video enlighted my day! I was really sad, but as always you made me laugh 😊

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад

      I hope your day remains a little brighter :) keep it up and thank you for commenting

  • @allopeth
    @allopeth Год назад

    Really kudos to Crim for being brave and playing that Blasphemous act, however incorrect it was, it was so funny! :D :D

  • @TerminallyNerdy
    @TerminallyNerdy Год назад

    The combo I never knew I needed: MTG Goldfish, and Cardmarket.

  • @gaminggeckos4388
    @gaminggeckos4388 Год назад

    0:18 Spark Rupture seems REALLY weird to build around. Like, aside from WAR Huatli and Kiora, most planeswalkers don't have loyalty much higher than their CMC. And even with Hautli and Kiora, is a 3 cost vanilla 7/7 really worth going through those hoops? I think that'd be most interesting to see

  • @rubentigre9269
    @rubentigre9269 Год назад

    This channel is by far the best mtg channel ever existed

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +1

      That's so kind of you to say :D thank you! We do try our best

  • @godtiermtg
    @godtiermtg Год назад

    Love the Cardmarket MTGgoldfish crossovers!

  • @Nutshellbill
    @Nutshellbill Год назад

    I haven't seen punting for content that deliberate since the last time I watched Game Knights.

  • @CaptainStahlnippel
    @CaptainStahlnippel Год назад

    YES, stuffy doll is one of my all time favourite decks. I love this!

  • @theremy-levelup
    @theremy-levelup Год назад

    It took a awhile for my brain to process Against the Odd title not paired with MTGGoldfish logo 😅
    Great video and good game though!

  • @cole_CK
    @cole_CK Год назад

    Best storytelling in MTG content

  • @OGNoNameNobody
    @OGNoNameNobody Год назад +1

    Game 2 was a little sloppy;
    After *Dress Down* resolves, all the red cards on the Stack go to the Graveyard normally. Also, a *Ledger Shredder* trigger was missed, meaning lethal could have been a turn sooner.

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +1

      Haha, yes, we missed the Dress Down vs Sanctifier interaction in light of the craziness that just went down 😅
      -Jamin

  • @brettjuergens9785
    @brettjuergens9785 Год назад

    I love that stuffy deck. btw the cure for it, and indistructible decks, is Everlasting Torment.
    Card Name:
    Everlasting Torment
    Mana Cost: 2Black or Red
    Converted Mana Cost: 3
    Types: Enchantment
    Card Text:
    Players can't gain life.
    Damage can't be prevented.
    All damage is dealt as though its source had wither. (A source with wither deals damage to creatures in the form of -1/-1 counters.)
    Flavor Text:
    When night fell, the plane itself was scarred.
    Expansion:
    Commander 2016 (Rare) Commander 2016
    Rarity:
    Rare
    All Sets:
    Shadowmoor (Rare)
    Commander 2016 (Rare)
    Card Number:
    233
    Artist:
    Richard Kane Ferguson

  • @Psychonaut999
    @Psychonaut999 Год назад

    Awesome! Apart from Jamin missing so many Bauble Triggers. But good show!

  • @lego-man7694
    @lego-man7694 Год назад +1

    36:30 Thalia plus blasphemous act wins right?

  • @Wind_Ninja_Jubei
    @Wind_Ninja_Jubei Год назад

    Keep these coming. They are fun

  • @CTGStudios
    @CTGStudios Год назад

    Oof. Was rough to see that punt at 36:26
    Could have cast Thalia, upping creature count from 6 to 7. If he has the counter, he no longer has the mana to play it.
    Blasphemous Act goes from 3 mana to... 3 mana. Which still allows you to go for it.

  • @Era5erhead
    @Era5erhead Год назад

    Super fun crossover! Keep up the good work!

  • @marcumfleet502
    @marcumfleet502 Год назад

    More MTG Goldfish Colabs! This was awesome.

  • @Hexnano
    @Hexnano Год назад

    That dress down play was INSANE

  • @chesanceram4842
    @chesanceram4842 Год назад

    Awesome collaboration! Love it!

  • @thegreatmaximilian
    @thegreatmaximilian Год назад

    Love a good against the odds. Great collaboration.

  • @UNCLEBEN2021
    @UNCLEBEN2021 Год назад

    This is an awesome collaboration thank you so much for the great content

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад +1

      There is more with the MTG Goldfish friends to come :)

  • @mikegallo2143
    @mikegallo2143 Год назад

    Is Crim's shirt from "the critic" love that show

  • @DaveTheNoob
    @DaveTheNoob Год назад

    First time checking out the channel from the goldfish shout. Very well produced show! Deff hit the sub button!

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Год назад

      Thank you! 😃 we are reaching 100k subs so every one is greatly appreciated!

  • @TheWorstWurst
    @TheWorstWurst Год назад +1

    Really good content. Love the crossover