A few notable omissions: Judas priest- painkiller Mercyful fate - Melissa Celtic frost - morbid tales Sepultura - arise Bathory - under the sign of the black mark Death - leprosy Carcass - heartwork Napalm death - harmony corruption Accept - restless and wild Cannibal corpse - the bleeding Deicide - legion Entombed - left hand path Emperor - in the nightside eclipse Immortal - at the heart of winter Cradle of filth - dusk...and her embrace Nevermore - dreaming neon black Incantation - onward to golgotha Testament - the new order Kreator - pleasure to kill Sodom - persecution mania Satyricon - nemesis divina
I'm kinda surprised by how decent this list is. Big metal magazines usually manage to put the most god-awful stuff in their "best xyz" lists. Like Baby Metal and 9 generic nu metal bands being the top 10 metal bands of all time or something like that. As far as this list goes, I mostly agree. Though it does have a chronic lack of Blind Guardian to represent power metal.
These are the albums I own on CD of this list 1. Black Sabbath- Black Sabbath 2. Black Sabbath- Heaven and Hell 3. Iron Maiden- Iron Maiden 4. Metallica- Kill Em All 5. Metallica- Master of Puppets 6. Black Sabbath- Master of Reality 7. Metallica- Metallica 8. Iron Maiden- The Number of the Beast 9. Black Sabbath- Paranoid 10. Iron Maiden-Powerslave 11. Metallica- Ride the Lightning 12. Megadeth- Rust in Peace I want to get Dio's Holy Diver and Judas Priest's Screaming for Vengeance. (I enjoy clean vocals).
Emperor's Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk is my favorite album of all time, Blackwater Park and Images & Words are also in my top 10. Some albums, not on the list, that made a significant impact within the metal community: Symphony X - The Divine Wings of Tragedy, Agalloch - The Mantle, Trivium - Shogun, BTBAM - Colors, Porcupine Tree - In Absentia, Dissection - Storm of the Light's Bane, Haken - The Mountain, Overkill - Horrorscope, and Periphery - Periphery II.
I get what you mean with Paul Baloff’s voice, but man…Bonded by Blood is probably the best written thrash metal album outside of Metallica, Megadeth and Slayer’s best albums. Iconic song after iconic song.
I hadn't listened to Exodus at all so I just gave them a chance because of this comment. I'm at "a lesson in violence" right now and I think the album is excellent so far. Not loving the vocals but the song writing is on par with if not better than Metallica's early stuff
There are some major albums I'm surprised that were not on this list. Some obviously made it just because they were influential, rather than good. Albums that belong on this list: Alice in Chains - Dirt (S tier for sure) Slayer - South of Heaven (S tier) Slayer - Show No Mercy Tool - Aenima (S tier) Carcass - Heartwork (S tier) Bolt Thrower - Those Once Loyal (S tier) Coroner - pick any album Metalocalypse - Dethalbum 2 Enslaved - pick any album Dimmu Borgir - Death Cult Armaggedon Deep Purple - Machine Head
Dirt is one of my top 10 metal albums. But Deep Purple Machine Head is more rock so I would not include them on this list. Actually Fireball is my favorite Purple album. Ritchie Blackmore is my favorite guitarist of all time.
I was more mad at the loud wire list haha, felt like they just put the most popular albums from each band on and not actual thought. But I actually really like your list mostly because I too love prog more than anything
There is no way on Earth that Mayhem are one of the 50 best albums ever. The vocals are terrible and the production is worse than bad, not completely disrespecting the band I actually quite like Mayhem but for a top 50 album it has to be completely amazing, I think they were put here just because of the influence they had on black metal. It kind of feels like that's what they've based there choices on here. Also big fan of Anthrax bit I wouldn't say Amongst the living is good enough to break a top 50 either... maybe top 100
🙄 , production on black metal , especially early black metal.🤦♂️ Mayhem are the least of my fav black metal bands, but no one can deny the under ground influence of “ De Mysteriies……
Them/Conspiracy are like a double album to me. It is my favorite work by King Diamond and that includes Mercyful Fate. But I am so happy to see Mercyful Fate win. King is my number one metal vocalist. Also liked the placements of Mindcrime and Images and Words. Images and Words two biggest influences are Mindcrime and material from Rush. A couple of other things that are different with me are that I don’t like Ride The Lightning that much or Master of Puppets. If I like any Metallica album a lot it would be And Justice for All. Also I put Peace Sells above Rust In Peace but just by a hair for two reasons Devils Island and Good Mourning Black Friday. I can’t stand Pantera as I hate that tough guy image Phil puts on. Anyway great video and I look forward to every one of your videos.
Tier list for all 50 albums. Just my opinion S: Abigail, Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk, Don’t Break the Oath, Human, Keeper of the 7 Keys, Master of Puppets, Operation Mindcrime, Peace Sells, Rust in Peace, To Mega Therion, Times of Grace A: Blaze in the Northern Sky, Altars, Beneath the Remains, Heaven and Hell,Master of Reality, Screaming for Vengeance, Holy Diver, Kill em All, Korn, Lateralus, Leviathan, Powerslave, Wolverine Blues B: Ace of Spades, Black Sabbath, Paranoid, Blackwater Park, Bonded by Blood, Sad Wings of Destiny, Iron Maiden, Ride the Lightning, Rainbow Rising, Slaughter of the Soul, Vulgar Display of Power C: Among the Living, Bathory, Blizzard of Oz, Images and Words, Number of the Beast, Black Album, Toxicity, Seasons in the Abyss, Slipknot D: Balls to the Wall, British Steel, De Mysteriis Dom Satanas, Welcome to Hell, Reign in Blood, Tomb of the Mutilated
Powerslave and Number of the beast and Don’t break the oath should be the top 3 and everything comes after ..but I respect everyone’s opinion all these albums are killers and very important to the genre ..maybe I would discard Korn Slipknot and Mastodon but still I can’t deny how great these albums are ..and also I would switch wolverine blues with left hand path ..great video hails
Great ranking, but I don't understand some of Loudwire's picks. Like not criticising their choices, but to me Painkiller is the best Priest album, and way better than British Steel.
S: Human Powerslave Ride the Lightning Iron Maiden Slaughter of the Soul A: Rust in Piece (Bordering S) Peace Sells Kill em all Beneath the Remains Bathory Number of the Beast Master of Puppets Blaze in the Northern Sky Altars of Madness Paranoid Emperor (forget the name) B: Reign in Blood Master of Reality Black Sabbath Seasons in the Abyss Welcome to Hell L: Korn (don't remember the name, don't want to) Ace of Spades Vulgar Display of Power Whatever the fuck the Anthrax one is If I Speak I'm in Big Trouble: Blizzard of Oz Any Judas Priest Tomb of the Mutilated Holy Diver Heaven and Hell Don't Break the Oath No doubt missed a few, its hard to See em all whilst typing x
S Tier : Paranoid Black Sabbath Powerslave Iron Maiden Abigail Sad Wings of Destiny Number of the Beast Blizzard of Ozz Heaven and Hell Images and Words Beneath the Remains Holy Diver Master of Reality Master of Puppets Reign in Blood Rust in Piece Slaughter of the Soul Blackwater Park A Tier : Peace Sells Seasons in the Abyss Screaming for Vengeance Balls to the Wall Don't Break the Oath De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk Human B Tier: Ride the Lightning Kill Em All Rising Black Album British Steel Operation Mindcrime Keeper of the Seven Keys pt1 Altars of Madness A Blaze in the Northern Sky C Tier: Vulgar Display of Power Toxicity Welcome to Hell Wolverine Blues Tomb of the Mutilated Bonded by Blood Ace of Spades Bathory To Mega Therion D Tier: Among the Living Korn Lateralus Slipknot Leviathan F Tier: The Neurosis album has to go in F because i never really listen to them
You got me Questy , I usually watch the first 5 minutes then I skip at the end of the video. I usually try to not bitch too hard in the comments though :D
I am very much triggerd now. 😀 But not by you, by Loudwire. No Blind Guardian, Testament, Agalloch, Savatage, Amorphis, Enslaved, Insomnium, The Ocean or Saxon. No Heartwork, no Crimson, no Epicus Doomicus Metallicus, no Wildhoney... How dare you! Just kidding. I've seen much worse lists. The Rolling Stone 100 includes Evanescene, Melvins or Kyuss
@@markpalavosvrahotes5575 I couldn't really decide between The Mantle and Ashes against the grain. Also I see some other albums up there: Ghost Reveries, Winter's Gate, Autumn Eternal, Pelagial, Mirror Reaper and Brave New World
Putting System of a Down above Bonded By Blood? That might just be the most offensive thing I've ever heard. haha Bonded By Blood is in my top 3 greatest metal albums of all time. :) While System of a Down is as uninteresting as Eminem or Green Day or something. :D But taste is like buttholes, split and hairy. haha Cheers!
Always happy to offend 😉 haha funny you mention green day I saw them a couple of weeks ago and I’d see Eminem if I had the chance too. Gotta love hairy butthole tastes those are the best 👌
@@Questformetal In one of your videos you said that death and doom metal are you favorite genres so yea, explains but its fine, everyone has their own taste and that is great
@@1231213sdasd Well yeah black doom and death are my favourite genres so I’m a bit biased in that regard still love bands and albums in other genres though it’s all good
Well that depends on opinions. For me Ozzy was better for Black Sabbath but Dio has the edge for solo work. Dio is obviously way more talented and the Black Sabbath albums with Dio on them sound much more like Dio albums than traditional Black Sabbath.
The previous upload wasn't working so hopefully this one is for you guys? As always let me know your favourites down below and why my list is bad ;)
Will you ever do a video showing your battle jacket?
@@DanDavies12 Yeah once its redone
A few notable omissions:
Judas priest- painkiller
Mercyful fate - Melissa
Celtic frost - morbid tales
Sepultura - arise
Bathory - under the sign of the black mark
Death - leprosy
Carcass - heartwork
Napalm death - harmony corruption
Accept - restless and wild
Cannibal corpse - the bleeding
Deicide - legion
Entombed - left hand path
Emperor - in the nightside eclipse
Immortal - at the heart of winter
Cradle of filth - dusk...and her embrace
Nevermore - dreaming neon black
Incantation - onward to golgotha
Testament - the new order
Kreator - pleasure to kill
Sodom - persecution mania
Satyricon - nemesis divina
eh, for CC I’d rather have “Kill” or TOTM
The main album I am shocked wasn’t on this list is Heartwork
I'm pretty sure they had it as 3rd for the best death metal albums🫤. Loudwire have no consistency between their lists.
That makes no sense considering how much death metal made their top 50 of all time @@theyescapedtheweightofdarkness
I'm kinda surprised by how decent this list is. Big metal magazines usually manage to put the most god-awful stuff in their "best xyz" lists. Like Baby Metal and 9 generic nu metal bands being the top 10 metal bands of all time or something like that.
As far as this list goes, I mostly agree. Though it does have a chronic lack of Blind Guardian to represent power metal.
Yeah I think this list is one of their best was hard to order as they picked a lot of good albums
Thanks for mentioning Baby Metal. The biggest joke I've ever seen. I can't understand how metal fans can actually enjoy that silly garbage.
These are the albums I own on CD of this list
1. Black Sabbath- Black Sabbath
2. Black Sabbath- Heaven and Hell
3. Iron Maiden- Iron Maiden
4. Metallica- Kill Em All
5. Metallica- Master of Puppets
6. Black Sabbath- Master of Reality
7. Metallica- Metallica
8. Iron Maiden- The Number of the Beast
9. Black Sabbath- Paranoid
10. Iron Maiden-Powerslave
11. Metallica- Ride the Lightning
12. Megadeth- Rust in Peace
I want to get Dio's Holy Diver and Judas Priest's Screaming for Vengeance. (I enjoy clean vocals).
nice! the only ones i own are:
Iron Maiden - Powerslave
Mayhem - De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
Metallica - Master of Puppets
Korn's debut album is in s tier and Pantera vulgar display of power, for me personally. I do respect your list.
Emperor's Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk is my favorite album of all time, Blackwater Park and Images & Words are also in my top 10.
Some albums, not on the list, that made a significant impact within the metal community: Symphony X - The Divine Wings of Tragedy, Agalloch - The Mantle, Trivium - Shogun, BTBAM - Colors, Porcupine Tree - In Absentia, Dissection - Storm of the Light's Bane, Haken - The Mountain, Overkill - Horrorscope, and Periphery - Periphery II.
I get what you mean with Paul Baloff’s voice, but man…Bonded by Blood is probably the best written thrash metal album outside of Metallica, Megadeth and Slayer’s best albums. Iconic song after iconic song.
I hadn't listened to Exodus at all so I just gave them a chance because of this comment. I'm at "a lesson in violence" right now and I think the album is excellent so far. Not loving the vocals but the song writing is on par with if not better than Metallica's early stuff
There are some major albums I'm surprised that were not on this list. Some obviously made it just because they were influential, rather than good. Albums that belong on this list:
Alice in Chains - Dirt (S tier for sure)
Slayer - South of Heaven (S tier)
Slayer - Show No Mercy
Tool - Aenima (S tier)
Carcass - Heartwork (S tier)
Bolt Thrower - Those Once Loyal (S tier)
Coroner - pick any album
Metalocalypse - Dethalbum 2
Enslaved - pick any album
Dimmu Borgir - Death Cult Armaggedon
Deep Purple - Machine Head
Coroner is so good
Dirt is one of my top 10 metal albums. But Deep Purple Machine Head is more rock so I would not include them on this list. Actually Fireball is my favorite Purple album. Ritchie Blackmore is my favorite guitarist of all time.
Definitely do those ISIS and Neurosis album rankings. Will be interested to see what you think. Love them both 👍🏼
I was more mad at the loud wire list haha, felt like they just put the most popular albums from each band on and not actual thought. But I actually really like your list mostly because I too love prog more than anything
Awesome video, hard to argue with any of those rankings really.
There is no way on Earth that Mayhem are one of the 50 best albums ever. The vocals are terrible and the production is worse than bad, not completely disrespecting the band I actually quite like Mayhem but for a top 50 album it has to be completely amazing, I think they were put here just because of the influence they had on black metal. It kind of feels like that's what they've based there choices on here. Also big fan of Anthrax bit I wouldn't say Amongst the living is good enough to break a top 50 either... maybe top 100
🙄 , production on black metal , especially early black metal.🤦♂️
Mayhem are the least of my fav black metal bands, but no one can deny the under ground influence of “ De Mysteriies……
Most album rankings are filled with classics that are not actually that good and leave out some amazing albums
@@wafflemanofficial3130 Gotta sell those magazines, er, get those clicks. Fuckin' gross, eh?
Comparing any Mayem record with "Under the Sign of the Black Mark" for me is puzzling to say the least.
Reign in Blood, Master of Puppets & Abigail would have to be in S tier for me.
This is the quality content here
Them/Conspiracy are like a double album to me. It is my favorite work by King Diamond and that includes Mercyful Fate. But I am so happy to see Mercyful Fate win. King is my number one metal vocalist. Also liked the placements of Mindcrime and Images and Words. Images and Words two biggest influences are Mindcrime and material from Rush. A couple of other things that are different with me are that I don’t like Ride The Lightning that much or Master of Puppets. If I like any Metallica album a lot it would be And Justice for All. Also I put Peace Sells above Rust In Peace but just by a hair for two reasons Devils Island and Good Mourning Black Friday. I can’t stand Pantera as I hate that tough guy image Phil puts on.
Anyway great video and I look forward to every one of your videos.
Tier list for all 50 albums. Just my opinion
S: Abigail, Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk, Don’t Break the Oath, Human, Keeper of the 7 Keys, Master of Puppets, Operation Mindcrime, Peace Sells, Rust in Peace, To Mega Therion, Times of Grace
A: Blaze in the Northern Sky, Altars, Beneath the Remains, Heaven and Hell,Master of Reality, Screaming for Vengeance, Holy Diver, Kill em All, Korn, Lateralus, Leviathan, Powerslave, Wolverine Blues
B: Ace of Spades, Black Sabbath, Paranoid, Blackwater Park, Bonded by Blood, Sad Wings of Destiny, Iron Maiden, Ride the Lightning, Rainbow Rising, Slaughter of the Soul, Vulgar Display of Power
C: Among the Living, Bathory, Blizzard of Oz, Images and Words, Number of the Beast, Black Album, Toxicity, Seasons in the Abyss, Slipknot
D: Balls to the Wall, British Steel, De Mysteriis Dom Satanas, Welcome to Hell, Reign in Blood, Tomb of the Mutilated
Blackwater Park in B tier. Did you make a mistake? I thought that was your favorite album.
the only thing im gonna bitch and moan about is that C and F tier got the same colour that is upsetting not gonna lie mate
Very surprised you put Balls to the Wall and Bonded by Blood so low, but I agree with that Mercyful Fate ranking
Powerslave and Number of the beast and Don’t break the oath should be the top 3 and everything comes after ..but I respect everyone’s opinion all these albums are killers and very important to the genre ..maybe I would discard Korn Slipknot and Mastodon but still I can’t deny how great these albums are ..and also I would switch wolverine blues with left hand path ..great video hails
Great ranking, but I don't understand some of Loudwire's picks. Like not criticising their choices, but to me Painkiller is the best Priest album, and way better than British Steel.
I think Stained Class is my favorite. Have you heard that one?
I haven't heard all of these but I know Sad Wings of Destiny would go high for me. Third favourite Priest album after Painkiller and Turbo.
Turbo? I know it's not that bad but better than Sad Wings??? That's crazy dude
@@dornishraven1628 I like it around the same as Sad Wings tbh.
Toxicity C? bruh
Surprisingly decent list for a mainstream magazine but come on, no Painkiller ?
S:
Human
Powerslave
Ride the Lightning
Iron Maiden
Slaughter of the Soul
A:
Rust in Piece (Bordering S)
Peace Sells
Kill em all
Beneath the Remains
Bathory
Number of the Beast
Master of Puppets
Blaze in the Northern Sky
Altars of Madness
Paranoid
Emperor (forget the name)
B:
Reign in Blood
Master of Reality
Black Sabbath
Seasons in the Abyss
Welcome to Hell
L:
Korn (don't remember the name, don't want to)
Ace of Spades
Vulgar Display of Power
Whatever the fuck the Anthrax one is
If I Speak I'm in Big Trouble:
Blizzard of Oz
Any Judas Priest
Tomb of the Mutilated
Holy Diver
Heaven and Hell
Don't Break the Oath
No doubt missed a few, its hard to See em all whilst typing x
It's Part 1 from Helloween ;)
Wohooo though both would be on the same level anyway haha
@@Questformetal Yeah, you nailed it :D
Good job ranking Don't Break the Oath that high
Helloween is Keepers part 1.
Nice i own most of thos albums good list =)
S Tier :
Paranoid
Black Sabbath
Powerslave
Iron Maiden
Abigail
Sad Wings of Destiny
Number of the Beast
Blizzard of Ozz
Heaven and Hell
Images and Words
Beneath the Remains
Holy Diver
Master of Reality
Master of Puppets
Reign in Blood
Rust in Piece
Slaughter of the Soul
Blackwater Park
A Tier :
Peace Sells
Seasons in the Abyss
Screaming for Vengeance
Balls to the Wall
Don't Break the Oath
De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk
Human
B Tier:
Ride the Lightning
Kill Em All
Rising
Black Album
British Steel
Operation Mindcrime
Keeper of the Seven Keys pt1
Altars of Madness
A Blaze in the Northern Sky
C Tier:
Vulgar Display of Power
Toxicity
Welcome to Hell
Wolverine Blues
Tomb of the Mutilated
Bonded by Blood
Ace of Spades
Bathory
To Mega Therion
D Tier:
Among the Living
Korn
Lateralus
Slipknot
Leviathan
F Tier:
The Neurosis album has to go in F because i never really listen to them
yes yes dont break the oath , and lateralus my two fav. albums
You got me Questy , I usually watch the first 5 minutes then I skip at the end of the video. I usually try to not bitch too hard in the comments though :D
What's with people acting like and justice for all isn't a masterpiece. dude I think its Metallica's best album ! They obviously don't read lyrics.
Questy with the re-upload ⁉️
Lot of people had trouble watching the first one
@@Questformetal understandable
No fucking way they didn't include Painkiller
How do you cast the tier maker list live?
I am very much triggerd now. 😀
But not by you, by Loudwire.
No Blind Guardian, Testament, Agalloch, Savatage, Amorphis, Enslaved, Insomnium, The Ocean or Saxon.
No Heartwork, no Crimson, no Epicus Doomicus Metallicus, no Wildhoney...
How dare you!
Just kidding. I've seen much worse lists. The Rolling Stone 100 includes Evanescene, Melvins or Kyuss
The Mantle is my favorite album of the 21st century.
@@markpalavosvrahotes5575 I couldn't really decide between The Mantle and Ashes against the grain. Also I see some other albums up there: Ghost Reveries, Winter's Gate, Autumn Eternal, Pelagial, Mirror Reaper and Brave New World
@@simond1574 Ghost Reveries is also one of my favorites.
Kyuss is damn good.
Interesting
Name of the 6 album?
My top 10: (Favorite song on album)
Honorable mentions:
Infernal Power - Lucifuge (Black Battalions)
Shattered Existence - Xentrix (Crimes)
Exiled to the Surface - Traitor (66 Exeter Street)
Eternal Nightmare - Vio-Lence (Phobophobia)
Dealin' Death - Vulture (Gorgon)
10. In Search of Sanity - Onslaught (Shellshock)
9. Shadowland - Wolf (Seek the Silence)
8. Symbolic - Death (Without Judgement)
7. Mental Vortex - Coroner (Sirens)
6. Ride the Lightning - Metallica (Creeping Death)
5. Painkiller - Judas Priest (Painkiller)
4. Powerslave - Iron Maiden (Powerslave)
3. Transcendence - Crimson Glory (Where Dragon's Rule)
2. Never, Neverland - Annihilator (Fun Palace)
1. Rust in Peace - Megadeth (Hangar 18)
Decent list but i disagree with slaugher of the soul, should be a s.
**a very angry commentary bitching about "Slaughter Of The Soul" rated C**
How did you find this??
The Mantle?
Ashes Against the Grain better but either would’ve been nice
The Mantle is my favorite album of the 21st century.
Now burn my eyes or the blackening mate, you really prefer korn? Interesting
Slipknot self titled D? WRONGGGGG
Should be more Death Albums
Where did you find the tierlist?
Bonded by Blood deserves A !
Deserves probably. Do I like it though? Nah prefer rob dukes albums
@@Questformetal it deserves ss tier!
You still need your beard back
Quest for puberty
Questy the elitist butcher
Just get rid of s tier and have a through f. Nothing is better than a.
Putting System of a Down above Bonded By Blood? That might just be the most offensive thing I've ever heard. haha Bonded By Blood is in my top 3 greatest metal albums of all time. :) While System of a Down is as uninteresting as Eminem or Green Day or something. :D But taste is like buttholes, split and hairy. haha Cheers!
Always happy to offend 😉 haha funny you mention green day I saw them a couple of weeks ago and I’d see Eminem if I had the chance too. Gotta love hairy butthole tastes those are the best 👌
Iowa isn't on this list? Wtf?
Blizzard of Ozz at C??!???.....lol
Powerslave regin in blood number of the beast S tier. motorhead A tier 🇬🇧
I think every slipknot album is trash.
Killswitch Engage is so much better.
this dude really hates everyting that is not death or black metal-ish
Didn’t know iron maiden, mercyful fate , dream theater, tool or megadeth were black or death metal 🤪
@@Questformetal haha good one, i was talking in general, you tend to gravitate towards those kind of genres lets be honest
@@Questformetal In one of your videos you said that death and doom metal are you favorite genres so yea, explains but its fine, everyone has their own taste and that is great
@@1231213sdasd Well yeah black doom and death are my favourite genres so I’m a bit biased in that regard still love bands and albums in other genres though it’s all good
this list is stupid because wolverine blues
Bendiciones hermosa Celina que Dios te cuidep donde quiera que verwohntt.online encantan tus videos.
Wtf
Dio will never be better than Ozzy.
Well that depends on opinions. For me Ozzy was better for Black Sabbath but Dio has the edge for solo work. Dio is obviously way more talented and the Black Sabbath albums with Dio on them sound much more like Dio albums than traditional Black Sabbath.
Except he objectively is better as a singer and songwriter. You could say he fits better in to Sabbath but that's about it