Remakes should be left for games that are over 10 years old, didnt live up to the potential they had due to tech limitations and/or didn't have enough time to genuinely finish Or some combo of the first and the latter 2. (Subject to change)
@kevingame3198 out of genuine curiosity, what's a 30+ year old game you played that people would find worth remastering? That would sell well enough to warrant it, of course
Day of Defeat getting a remake less than three years after release was pretty bad. There's no reason to remake a game that isn't old enough to get into most kindergartens.
the updated graphics for Horizon would've been nice as a patch or something but to buy the game all over again just doesn't inspire joy. granted i've bought Skyrim for like 3 different systems but that's a whole other story
Don’t forget about Taito’s reimagining of “Space Invaders”. Their poorly received 2002 attempt at modernizing the franchise with their installment “Space Raiders” (or as it’s known outside of N. America) “Space Invaders: Invasion Day”…😂
Screaming "ark survival ascended" as loud as I can at my screen. Punching the air. Jumping and pulling my hair out. To announce a sequel with vin diesel with more lore and plot development only to put on hiatus to focus on a remake nobody asked for which would cause the servers to shut down for the current player forcing them to buy the new game and all the dlc all over again! Chewing on my phone. Rocking back and forth. Crying.
3:53 Is it just me or does the original look better? If you're going to remake XIII don't change the art style. Is it really that hard to improve the character models with this art style? How the hell could you mess up a remake this bad if you have the original game to work with? You're not making a brand new game. 5:43 How did Bomberman survive that? 5:51 Just because everything was going dark and gritty doesn't mean you should do it to Bomberman. Forced Edginess XD.
No mention of The Last of Us which (not counting the sequel) had 2.5 remakes within a decade... NONE of which (barring the .5 being for optimization on PS5 specifically) having any changes worth note?
I have three different versions of Skyrim and have yet to finish the game. I enjoy the exploring but lose all interest when I get a couple hours into the main storyline. Can’t wait for the 32nd remake.
Secret of Mana remake sounds excellent for 1 reason. Companion AI improvements. I am old enough to have played the original and the AI for companion pathing it would have improved if they were the three blind mice.
I love on the loose. Yeah it doesn't have the dual stick controls, but if im being honest that was never the reason i wanted to play the game. I wanted to play the game because the levels and apes were great. Thats just me though
If its easily available i.e. a ps4 game thats fully able to play fine on ps5 for example its unnecessary.. The last of us 1 and 2.. Horizon zero dawn/forbidden west Until dawn Skyrim Persona 3 reload. Just to name a few . I will never turn down a chance to bash atlus for being greedy. 4 games right off releasing multiple versions with different content that is NOT available as even paid dlc/expansion in this day and age is unforgivable. 2 versions of persona 3 released the remake wasnt even all inclusive Persona 4/persona 4 golden again no upgrade path 5 5 royal yet again greed Smt5 and smt5v on switch.. Why not give a bone to people who support your products early on?
Still bagging on the horizon zero dawn remake, yet it’s clear whoever wrote this list never actually played the remaster, cause if they did they would have actually discovered they did a whole lot more than just some mo-cap upgrades, they add realistic weather effects to the characters so when it cold they get windburn on there faces, as well increasing the NPC population in all cities and outlying areas, increased number of machines wondering the wilds, among other things.
I’m glad they didn’t bring up TLOU1 for once, because that’s just become low hanging fruit. The original can look outright bad at times. And it’s a minor hill to die on, but adding the PS5 haptics, especially for the safecracking mechanic, almost made it worth it on its own.
as PResumed , you missed a remake that is WRAPed in sh!t , so lets goto the ER (editing room) THE game is about a RAPPER ... don't remember his name ..... maybe you will remember it (?)
@@Legend0famyth Screws up lore and just adds things that shouldn't be possible to know, horrible voice acting and acting in general which is far inferior to the original, worse animations with Necromorphs moving laughable stupidly or Isaac holding his tools like a toy and the sound effects being as weak as one, story is more convoluted and adds plot points we didn't need like Mercer making the Hunter from Harris being willing instead of the harrowing audio log we find before it's introduction in the original, Mercer is made to be a complete moron giving evil villain monologues and even has a lapse in his faith despite being a super sane nutcase in the original who lets himself turn.... Worse cutscenes and then existing more than the original anyways is pointless and one of the most meh jumpscare endings ever... The original does everything far better, only things the remake does better is texture quality, asteroid sections and inventory layout... Even the Twinkle Twinkle trailer was an inferior copy
How about top ten videos what culture fans didn’t ask for, THIS ONE! And every other top ten video you do, why can’t you just go back to discussing the newest games and gaming news together ! There’s plenty to talk about, why haven’t you spoken about dragon age ? I have loved your channel over the years but it will die if it just becomes top ten videos over and over again. Sorry.
@ they really don’t, they do the occasional video, then there will be like 10 videos in a row that are all top ten, then they tease me with another interesting video game update with Scott and Josh and then straight back to boring top ten again.
I swear, do they even know the difference between a sequel and a remake? Clearly they don't. Also, pretending you have to re buy horizon when you don't is even worse. You can't call it just a quick also of paint, even if it didn't need a remaster. And active like a PS5 patch is a "remaster" ? Really?
Back then it was awesome plus the controllers back then worked better for the controls in game. It's so clumsy in newer consoles lol but yeah 007 rocked once upon a time. Definitely didn't age too well.😅
Honorable Mention: The Last of Us, parts 1 AND 2.
Remakes should be left for games that are over 10 years old, didnt live up to the potential they had due to tech limitations and/or didn't have enough time to genuinely finish
Or some combo of the first and the latter 2. (Subject to change)
Far cry 4
Gta 4
Remakes should only be that way older from 20 to 30 years ago
@kevingame3198 out of genuine curiosity, what's a 30+ year old game you played that people would find worth remastering? That would sell well enough to warrant it, of course
@roonkolos 1991 sonic the hedgehog doom 1993 goldeneye 64
Blizzard: "This isn't broken. Any way we can fix it until it is?"
Day of Defeat getting a remake less than three years after release was pretty bad. There's no reason to remake a game that isn't old enough to get into most kindergartens.
I don't think any game beyond the PS3/Xbox 360 generation needs a remaster
the updated graphics for Horizon would've been nice as a patch or something but to buy the game all over again just doesn't inspire joy. granted i've bought Skyrim for like 3 different systems but that's a whole other story
Also doesn’t help they jacked up the price of the original release from the $20 it had been before
Not trying to defend them or anything, but wasn't the upgrade just $5. I think it was fairly reasonable then
@@arjunghose02 $10. And still too much. It's another entirely unnecessary remake of a game that is still easily accessible and looks/plays fine.
@@Rhinox-89 10 dollar upgrade. Stop the lies
@@steveperry2321 It was the equivalent of $5 in my country adjusted for other charges
Don’t forget about Taito’s reimagining of “Space Invaders”.
Their poorly received 2002 attempt at modernizing the franchise with their installment “Space Raiders” (or as it’s known outside of N. America) “Space Invaders: Invasion Day”…😂
Hes got a point on some of these
Last I remember, Bomberman Act Zero isn’t a remake. It’s a reBOOT. That is two completely different things.
Could you provide the title or a brief description of the video so I can tailor the comment to fit its content?
I would love an Alpha Protocol remake rn
yes I did ask for an until dawn remake and no it does not have those thing you claim it has
Screaming "ark survival ascended" as loud as I can at my screen. Punching the air. Jumping and pulling my hair out. To announce a sequel with vin diesel with more lore and plot development only to put on hiatus to focus on a remake nobody asked for which would cause the servers to shut down for the current player forcing them to buy the new game and all the dlc all over again! Chewing on my phone. Rocking back and forth. Crying.
A Team Buddies remake or remaster would be great. Had soo much fun playing it on the PS1.
3:53 Is it just me or does the original look better?
If you're going to remake XIII don't change the art style. Is it really that hard to improve the character models with this art style? How the hell could you mess up a remake this bad if you have the original game to work with? You're not making a brand new game.
5:43 How did Bomberman survive that? 5:51 Just because everything was going dark and gritty doesn't mean you should do it to Bomberman. Forced Edginess XD.
No mention of The Last of Us which (not counting the sequel) had 2.5 remakes within a decade... NONE of which (barring the .5 being for optimization on PS5 specifically) having any changes worth note?
They should just remaster the og bomber man for us old people lol I mean just having them rereleased would be amazing I loved those games.
The Last of Us remakes should be here.
I have three different versions of Skyrim and have yet to finish the game. I enjoy the exploring but lose all interest when I get a couple hours into the main storyline. Can’t wait for the 32nd remake.
The last of us has been remade twice now in like 12 years
Horizon zero dawn was the most wholesome asked for this and clearly meant for money grubbing
Reforged is a heinous crime.
Doing a first time playthrough of Secret of Mana, funny coincidence its for RetroAchivements though!
Secret of Mana remake sounds excellent for 1 reason. Companion AI improvements. I am old enough to have played the original and the AI for companion pathing it would have improved if they were the three blind mice.
On the loose was my first ape escape and I remember the camera being horrible
I’m baffled COD doesn’t fall into the remake category. It’s been the same game every release but somehow bleeps getting more expensive.
It’s a crime they omitted Bionic Commando. The twist alone kept me far away😅
i just want GTA IV for the ps5. that’s it. that’s all 😔
so do I
Make new games. Are we out of ideas? It’s why there’s no reason to buy new consoles.
Hasn't there been more than 10 tho?
I played Secret of Mana and Secret of Mana remake, the companion AI in the remake is actually worse.
I love on the loose. Yeah it doesn't have the dual stick controls, but if im being honest that was never the reason i wanted to play the game. I wanted to play the game because the levels and apes were great. Thats just me though
If its easily available i.e. a ps4 game thats fully able to play fine on ps5 for example its unnecessary..
The last of us 1 and 2..
Horizon zero dawn/forbidden west
Until dawn
Skyrim
Persona 3 reload.
Just to name a few .
I will never turn down a chance to bash atlus for being greedy. 4 games right off releasing multiple versions with different content that is NOT available as even paid dlc/expansion in this day and age is unforgivable.
2 versions of persona 3 released the remake wasnt even all inclusive
Persona 4/persona 4 golden again no upgrade path
5 5 royal yet again greed
Smt5 and smt5v on switch..
Why not give a bone to people who support your products early on?
No space Invaders on ps2?
They always make the new models of women ugly, the thumbnail is just 1 example
The game may not have needed remakes, but this video definitely does. 👎🙉
Somebody needed attention today huh?
@@mixedcompany3225 apparently so, as they are indeed very mixed in both mind & company, replying nonsensically to criticism.
@ as you reply nonsensically…
I have to disagre with entry #5
I’m loving the Zero Dawn remake. Looks and runs fantastic on the PS5 Pro.
same here
I will and always defend Last of Us Part 1 and Last of Us Part 2 Remastered
You said it yourself.... Gritty "REBOOT" lol bomberman zero isn't a remake lol 😂 how people still doesn't know the difference lol 😆
I know the difference between a remake and a reboot. A reboot means that they are rebooting something, while a remake means they are remaking it.
nope
There is a distinct difference between remakes and reboots, therefore Bomberman Act Zero should not be in thia video
Still bagging on the horizon zero dawn remake, yet it’s clear whoever wrote this list never actually played the remaster, cause if they did they would have actually discovered they did a whole lot more than just some mo-cap upgrades, they add realistic weather effects to the characters so when it cold they get windburn on there faces, as well increasing the NPC population in all cities and outlying areas, increased number of machines wondering the wilds, among other things.
Nobody asked for any remakes, just good games.
TLOU2 was the most stupid remake.
Didn’t resident evil fans want a remake of 2?
That was a remaster for Last of Us 2, the first one had a very pointless remake
Tlou 2 not a remake. And they should not have called it remastered, directors cut would have suited it fine
What an abrupt ending. The whole video goes 50 mph and then... have a wonderful day.
I have never heard anyone call Ape Escape generic.
I’m glad they didn’t bring up TLOU1 for once, because that’s just become low hanging fruit. The original can look outright bad at times. And it’s a minor hill to die on, but adding the PS5 haptics, especially for the safecracking mechanic, almost made it worth it on its own.
as PResumed , you missed a remake that is WRAPed in sh!t , so lets goto the ER (editing room)
THE game is about a RAPPER ... don't remember his name ..... maybe you will remember it (?)
Well they got made, So SOMEONE asked now didn't they !!!
I will still stand up on stage of the world any day and list off every reason why the Dead Space remake is bad...
We're all waiting to hear your reasons.
Carry on.
@@Legend0famyth Screws up lore and just adds things that shouldn't be possible to know, horrible voice acting and acting in general which is far inferior to the original, worse animations with Necromorphs moving laughable stupidly or Isaac holding his tools like a toy and the sound effects being as weak as one, story is more convoluted and adds plot points we didn't need like Mercer making the Hunter from Harris being willing instead of the harrowing audio log we find before it's introduction in the original, Mercer is made to be a complete moron giving evil villain monologues and even has a lapse in his faith despite being a super sane nutcase in the original who lets himself turn.... Worse cutscenes and then existing more than the original anyways is pointless and one of the most meh jumpscare endings ever... The original does everything far better, only things the remake does better is texture quality, asteroid sections and inventory layout... Even the Twinkle Twinkle trailer was an inferior copy
no dead space remake is not bad its good
@@zenderman4913 as a standalone game it's good, as a remake it's uncreative and an abomination
@@Lubble- no its not
I hate that they keep forcing us to buy these remakes and remasters!!!!
Forcing you didn’t know that are taking your money and making you buy them.
@akiralight51986 sarcasm my guy
How about top ten videos what culture fans didn’t ask for, THIS ONE! And every other top ten video you do, why can’t you just go back to discussing the newest games and gaming news together ! There’s plenty to talk about, why haven’t you spoken about dragon age ? I have loved your channel over the years but it will die if it just becomes top ten videos over and over again. Sorry.
They still do that. Quite a bit
@ they really don’t, they do the occasional video, then there will be like 10 videos in a row that are all top ten, then they tease me with another interesting video game update with Scott and Josh and then straight back to boring top ten again.
The Secret of Mana remake is such a waste. I'm just thankful Chrono Trigger didn't get that treatment.
What is with the pattern of WhatCulture video titles that presume my personal thoughts? Immediately insulting.
Psy even sounds sad when she says Horizon. Lol terrible remake.
Hi there she-dude
I'm glad I didn't get a console this gen, unless Steller doesn't release for PC. no reason to get a PS5
I swear, do they even know the difference between a sequel and a remake?
Clearly they don't.
Also, pretending you have to re buy horizon when you don't is even worse. You can't call it just a quick also of paint, even if it didn't need a remaster. And active like a PS5 patch is a "remaster" ? Really?
Golden Eye For Nintendo 64 Was Overrated and Dumb I'm more of a Fighting Game guy myself
Back then it was awesome plus the controllers back then worked better for the controls in game. It's so clumsy in newer consoles lol but yeah 007 rocked once upon a time. Definitely didn't age too well.😅
In it's time for a Nintendo fps it was great but compared to most ps1 fps games that used 2 sticks..
You're dumb.