Did Great Replacement Conspiracy Theory Lead to the Buffalo Attack?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 май 2022
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze the 2022 shooting in Buffalo and the “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
References:
www.washingtonpost.com/invest...
www.nytimes.com/2022/05/15/ny...
www.usatoday.com/story/news/n...
www.cnn.com/2022/05/15/us/pay...
Neumann, P. R. (2013). Options and Strategies for Countering Online Radicalization in the United States. Studies in Conflict & Terrorism, 36(6), 431-459. doi:10.1080/1057610x.2013.784568
"Did this racist conspiracy theory lead a racist to commit a terrorist attack on a black neighborhood?"
Yes. Next question.
Mmmm me too
Dr Grande said, if you think about it, "No." Some people are so blind to racism. You can say, "I'm racist, I read racist mass shooter manifestos in my spare time and target blacks." Tod is like, "wait is he actually raysist tho? I can't tell"
No. Next question
Exactly. The video could have been 30 seconds lol
@@mikedeleon5617 no, not it doesn’t. As I remember it white people owned black people and now they’re claiming that the very people their ancestors brought here are “going out of their way” to make whyte people go extinct. This is simply not true.
Alleged goes out the window when a person live streams their entire crime.
It's so crazy
He's pleaded not guilty. Good luck with that one. They have piles of evidence. I wonder if he'll go to trial just for the fame?
@Peter T i saw some of it
@Peter T I just saw the video, I found it in 10 seconds. You can see his face in the rearview mirror and hear his voice. So endliarcheats is right.
His reasoning for pleading not Guilty is because he believes that his actions were in the public interest and to solve a existential crisis but um yeah no the actions were not in the public interest and there is no existential crisis (well there is but that’s climate change and not some conspiracy against “the whites”) and also not how the law or logic works.
@Peter T that's quite ignorant peter there are several places with the shooting
For everyone upset or confused about the use of the word "allegedly":
It's just a legal term meaning guilt hasn't been determined via trial. That's all. We know he did it, duh, it's just legal jargon. Nobody thinks there's any doubt, that's not what the word is implying here.
WAUKASHA
Exactly
Facts
😒
No shit Sherlock!
I saw part of the video that guy made. Calling him 'troubled' is a misleading description. He knew what he was doing and was very methodical. He did it like it was all in a day's work for him. He is troubled in the same way a serial killer could be said to be troubled.
Sooo, you aren't diagnosing that lunatic, either!?!
Brilliant analysis Einstein.
@@Spiral.Dynamics i thought he was 18?
@@helianabanes4875 He's an adult though. Teenager makes it sound like he's underaged.
Talk about PRE-MEDITATED.
This happened about an hour from my house. Live streaming it so beyond fucked up. Didn’t know he cased the place so intensely before going through with the attack. Really upsetting.
That's probably because you have forgotten about the four punks, who abducted a mentally retarded white man, and spent the weekend livestreaming while they tortured him. Great people, outstanding content, amazingly enough, not a hate crime. Then we have the Waukesha incident, which this was retaliation for, again, not a hate crime. There's a whole lot wrong with how the facts in these cases are being reported. First on my list would be, people who have no first hand knowledge, like politicians and activist being interviewed, and people who were there, being ignored.
I'm in the area too! Made 2 vid about it
Prayers to all buffalonians
5 minutes from my job
Really fucked up. Like the Australia that went to New Zealand and killed 51 Muslims. We don't say his name here or New Zealand. I've honestly forgotten it, which is how it should be for 🤬 scum like this.
His "manifesto" was literally a copypaste of the Christchurch massacre killer....
Not in it's entirety
his "manifesto" reminds me of a vice journalist trying to larp. it also glows
@@gothmedli cope.
@@trishula-8037 lol
Wad he an eco-fascist? That one I haven't heard.
Is it me or do authorities make a habit of missing chances to stop these dangerous people early.
Dont be in the " is it me? " crowd
@@Kgio-2112 okay but I have remembered other times when authorities had a chance to act and didn’t
@@shelleydunkle7867 thank you and you would think in that knowledge, authorities would have thought to do better
They’re not allowed to do shit the same way most stores fire employees for getting license plates of thieves. It’s the way things are and we don’t have a president that’s interested in doing anything about it
@@theflyingegg3557 that’s sadly true but the FBI is not getting innocent of this. A report was made to the FBI concerning the parkland shooter and no one did anything.
The parents could be investigated to find out what kind of environment the shooter grew up in.
I understand he wrote "if you have children make sure you know what they are doing in their lives, and when they ask for guidance don't chide them for asking"... or something to that effect. My first thought was how did this kid have all this military equipment and the parents have no clue. Especially in light of his previous threats and unusual behavior. Parents are not solely to blame but they do have some responsibility if he was residing under their roof, and displayed such concerning behavior in the past. Red flags all around.
Who gives AF. What about those who lost their lives.
@@missmargmillionaire6421 He said this because more than likely the parents facilitated and possibly encouraged this behavior.
In his manifesto he claims his parents are not the cause of this and his parents share non of his communist views! Says that he has been into the communist ideology since 12 years old!
@@missmargmillionaire6421 The hope is that we can do better in identifying and treating and detaining these mentally ill people before they kill. That's just one piece of the puzzle, of course.
Another coward who decided to attack defenseless people in a normally safe space. No excuse for these demons
@@chuckrobinson599 I have said the same thing…. About you Chuck. Demons of a feather, flap leather wings together.
@@ChrisMillerCrazyHouse I don’t understand your answer to his question. Would you say the same thing about those other mass shootings? I would assume so, but then you didn’t say yes, and now I’m a little surprised
@@lostandfound5145 I will give you the same answer Becky. This is why you folks need to learn History and learn Emancipation happened in 1863. You two are not my slave master and I don’t have to answer or feel a certain way that YOU want me too.
Basically Chuck and Lost and Found believe in the same ridiculous idea of white genocide and condone the murder of innocent people while grocery shopping. They only get upset if a black person is committing mass murder and they wrongfully assume I am just as heartless as them and I am only upset because this is a white mass killer.
This was disgusting and should of been seen what was goin to happen. Also what about the black supremacist that ran elderly and kids and the Holliday parade? Or the other subway shooting? Funny how you only care about one murderer and not the others.
I'm usually in complete agreements with your takes, but I do think we need to take into account the inherent antisociality and hatefulness of some ideologies and conspiracy theories. Mass shootings are only possible if perpetrated by people with antisocial traits or tendencies, but they are likewise often (and definitely in this case) fueled by antisocial ideologies. Plenty of people are somewhere on the antisocial personality spectrum and do not feel the need to massacre large numbers of minorities in order to preserve one's racial dominance.
Thank you. Well said.
Mass shootings happen all the time. You’re only hearing about the politically helpful ones. You might want to look at the actual occurrences and statistics if you want to study what causes mass shootings and how to stop them.
They typically are a result of mental illness except in countries where other external factors make them pressure cookers for terrorism
He did take into account the Antisocial aspect of the shooter's personality, as well as the antisocial conspiracy theories- also he spoke to how the shooter had kept an online diary referencing torturing animals which suggests a lack of Empathy and Psychopathic traits, and that he was not only anti-social, but also had Psychopathic traits and possible mental Illness. I think he clearly implied that this and other people with these extreme behaviors are unique and rare, and he definitely did not say or imply everyone with some form of anti-social personality is Psychopathic or capable of such things. It is a fact that the profile for mass shooters, school shooters and otherwise- almost all have antisocial personalities and often high paranoia. I have 2 sons with Autism, my son who just turned 18 has high functioning Autism, and he has always had a form of anti-social personality, or been on that spectrum. He had found being extroverted and making friends a very difficult and anxiety filled process- often he just seemed not very interested when he was younger, and still he has just 1 or 2 close friends, but still spends a lot of time alone. However, he is the kindest, most understanding, extremely hardworking and responsible (bordering on OCD in these ways) person I've ever known. He is so loving to me and his 2 younger siblings, to Animals, etc. Just bc someone is or appears anti-social doesn't mean they have dark desires or are dangerous in any way- in fact in watching my son, he is MORE caring and thoughtful and loving bc he is a deep thinker, he spends much more time and energy thinking deeply and processing his own emotions and thinking about and trying to understand the behaviors and emotions of others, which leaves him more Empathic, warm, caring, and accepting of others, if you are lucky enough to be close to him. He could never hurt ANYONE. I thought Dr. Grande did a great job pointing out the Antisocial aspect of this shooter and others, without generalizing or stereotyping people on the spectrum of anti-social tendencies as a whole as dangerous or violent. The vast majority in fact are not, but there are extremist with other factors ADDED together with the Antisocial personality. I'm just curious what you didn't agree with or what you feel he didn't take into account, because I like to understand people and I'm just confused at what you disagree with in his assessment. Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts and opinions and contributing to the conversation! ✌️💖
Yeah, I kept to myself and didn't like going to school - I'm an otherwise normal human being!
@@dammar117 Of course you are, as I said above, my son is like this, has a very hard time in social situations, had always kept to himself, but is the kindest, warmest, best person I know! He works hard at his job and helps out in our family and is responsible, and is helpful and caring to his younger siblings and me. Having Antisocial personality or traits does NOT make you unhinged or mentally ill or dangerous in ANY WAY, it needs to be mixed with other traits like Psychopathy and delusions and Paranoia, rage, etc. Just being antisocial isn't an indication of who you are on the inside or how you truly feel about others or the world!It's just either a personality preference or stemming from anxiety or a mix of both, but says nothing about a person being dangerous or violent in any way! ✌️💖
I'm one quarter Indigenous. When I hear people who give credence to the great replacement theory. I can't help but think --oh you're afraid that one day your culture will be obsolete? 🤔
Its almost like some people don't want a multiracial society, only revenge based on a injustice they themselves did not have to carry in a past they never lived in. Im sure this insight into your thought process instills reassurance to the conspiratorial. In a country with a still large majority white populace, where all people are getting divided farther and farther into racial monoliths perspectives like these are only driving us farther towards something none of us want.
You’re a quarter of a person?
Got it.
There is not a specific "white culture" in the USA anyway.
@@novac1990 identity politics is the biggest force of division.
They are afraid that what they did to the indigenous people will be done to them
infuriates me that this kid was a walking billboard for what was to come. Did his parents know he had weapons? I know it is hard to stop this sort of thing, but how about TRY
His parents may like him the way he is I mean they raised him with their beliefs 🤔
He reports going to great lengths to keep them in the dark and hide his weapons. They didn’t figure out though that he dropped out of college a while ago to focus on this vile act.
@@ladymonacoofthebluepacific2571 You know nothing about his family, so all you're currently doing is spreading hate and misinformation. I doubt many parents, other than maybe less than 1% of radicals would every support their child doing something like this.
@@esteemedmortal5917 I guess more is coming out about him.
They gave him weapons but from what I've read, I don't think they realized how sick he really was.
As a teacher, I wonder every day: what can I do to help my students think clearly and critically in order to make productive choices regarding how they interact with the world and how they view themselves?
Therefore, you Ma’am are part of the solution, not the problem.
Help them understand that they aren't being persecuted, and that extremity only worsen their situation.
@@chuckrobinson599 oy ve. what a willfully ignorant comment.
Quantitative and qualitative research on humans throughout their lives would help tremendously. Unfortunately not everyone is willing to share personal information. I argue, limited freedom is the best option here.
Here in Sweden we teach "källkritik", meaning critical analysis of information. We are taught to ask who is behind information, what their motive might be, how to identify reliable sources etc. This helps in questioning propaganda and extremist views expressed on "alternative websites."
Regarding pro-social behaviour, I think we really have to push for mental health services to be easily accessible & of good quality. It's hard to reach a child in the depths of extremism and paranoia. Yet we see in the case of Kip Kinkel that mental health treatment helped tremendously, and had it continued, many lives could've been saved (RUclips channel "dreading." has a video on Kinkel which I recommend).
I mean, this kid wore a hazmat suit to class. Where are the parents?
Helping him bury the cat he tortured to death. 😠
I presume you are being sarcastic.
That sounds like something someone would do as a joke.
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim let’s use this to attack someone I don’t like ps the dad was a registered democrat
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim Wow lmellie you are really showing Putin
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim his father was a registered democrat I don’t know where you got that info about him running for mayor but your probably just making it up. And the highland park shooters dad ran a a democrat for mayor.
Pro tip: Camouflage clothes don't hide you in a supermarket.
New camouflage is a pattern that looks like a grocery store shelf 😭😭😭
How this attacker was taken alive is beyond belief. Unscratched, after all of that carnage.
@Euripides Feldman III ...and, protection from body armor.
@Euripides Feldman III if only it was that simple
@@sledzeppelin They took the New York subway shooter in without incident too. Every case is different. Should they have just opened up on him even though he surrendered? If so, should they do that with everyone?
@@sledzeppelin You are complaining because they did not use deadly force after he surrendered. That's how I got it. You act as if every law enforcement encounter fits the same mold when that couldn't be further from the truth. You have different officers, who have different training and policies, different suspects, different situations, different locations, different threats......ect.
Cops are human. They know they can be injured or killed by anyone at any time. 99 percent of them DO NOT want to be in a deadly force situations, because that means their life was in danger. In fact, situations that require deadly force often leads to law enforcement officers resigning. It's a tough job and it really shows a lack of empathy to armchair quarterback everything they do.
@@sledzeppelin How so? If you were trying imply something else, you sure didn't articulate it.
Lol "just allegations"!? The dude literally filmed himself doing the crime on his own Twitch account! The guy did it 100%, but I guess he's innocent until proven guilty so why not give him bail as well.
Silly and confused remarks.
There can be legal ramifications for making accusations when one hasn't been proven guilty in court
And McDonald's because he had a bad day! [cue eyeroll]
@@oseianderson4554 funny how when it’s a minority it’s a close case and the commenters never say allegedly.
@@lemur531 the victim or the perpetrator?
John Cleese said it perfectly in his soliloquy against extremism.
The tendency to look for enemies is a way to validate and justify already existing malignant feelings, sadly.
Love this quote!
Not all extremist fit this mold though some are just really hateful inferior scumbags and believe wholeheartedly what they're spewing.
Racial Essentialism and diversity dont mix.
explains western liberalism perfectly. looking for enemies (oil) in third world countries and blowing them up for not following liberalism.
Cleese is now accused of being a white nationalist.
Interesting that racism is not even mentioned in this analysis. Very telling.
I noticed several “very telling” remarks in this analysis. I thought I was about to hear “very fine people on both sides”.
I don't understand how the shooter is racist if his first victim was a woman whiter than him. At least I saw her very, very pale.
Or is it racism and misogyny?
Your investment in psychotherapeutic tradition keeps you blind to how truly systemic racism is.
Great replacement theory is more widespread than acknowledged. Growing up white, christian and as a girl with red hair, people encouraged me to try to make more redheads - because they're dying out, they'd say. Have a lot of kids to fill heaven and earth (because you know 'they're' having babies).
This video didn't feel like the condemnation it should've been.
@Bogda Nov Based
@Bogda Nov She didn't say anything about that at all. You're reaching because you actually want to be the whiny victim. Projection is a real behavior that's a red flag.
Another communist race traitor Satanist
I know that a lot of people got murdered during the George Floyd riots because of racial identity politics bullshit perpetuated by people like you
@Sarah Scott You're absolutely right. There's an increasingly frantic quality to similar propaganda that I've been hearing, directed both at my family and friends of other, different groups. We as a society are going backwards on so many serious issues, from race to women's rights to political polarization to religious extremism to guns to ignorance...I could go on, but it would take too long. And the laundry list is getting longer every day.
I broke up with my girlfriend the other day and started it with "Just a reminder I am not diagnosing anybody, only speculating on what can be happening in a situation like this" .... She did not like that.
Was that supposed to be funny or something?
@@HenriqueRJchiki I thought it was hilarious...mind you I'm just speculating about a situation like this.
@@HenriqueRJchiki It wasn't "supposed" to be funny.... it was funny af!
🥰
@@HenriqueRJchiki nigga take a joke damn lol
My heart hurts for the victims
Mine doesnt
@@cht2162 obviously he's in need of attention. These are the minds who think the world is flat and maps are printed out from Google maps. ✌️♥️🌵
Your heart hurts from eating too many pizza rolls.
@@annwethenorth you're the only one here dim enough to think the world is flat.
@@ChomoBidensMules I'm stealing that
He was RACIST point blank. This video was too light. Come on now!!!!
It saddens me that hatred and division seems to be increasing as time goes on instead of decreasing.
If only there was a solution, such as not continuing down the path of state imposed 'diversity'
@@NormalGuy-op8ft Agreed, and reversing the effects of Mass Immigration as well.
@@NormalGuy-op8ft If only you didn't kill, torture and stole the land from the Indians. If only you didn't enslave the black people. The country would not be so diverse. Lots of "if only". Your ancestors were immigrants.
Do you really still have to call it "allegations" when he livestreamed it to Twitch?
He might have to for legal reasons, even though it's obvious to everyone what happened.
@@weebunny I guess I get it but it absolutely baffles me that you can livestream yourself committing a crime from start to finish and people reporting on it still have to pretend there's a chance he didn't do it. It makes sense why he still deserves a trial but the rest of us shouldn't have to pretend to be stupid.
Yes because he has the right to due process and to defend himself. All US citizens do.
It sounds silly, when the idiot gave the court all the evidence they will need to convict him, if allowed in court. As you know, that's just a CYA to negate any liability for defamation. We wouldn't want to contaminate the jury pool, would we? 😆
@@doctormanganate5814 that's literally why people have to use the word allegedly. It's so funny you tell me to use common sense while not knowing that
That's the problem with kids tumbling down the rabbit hole of social media and politics. And being too young to understand nuance of a person's character while not taking the time to get to know other groups of people personally.
This has been openly spread on tv, no hole to go down needed.
@@tankthearc9875 The fox hole.
So you're saying that drag queen story hour is a good thing?
@@chuckrobinson599 you're part of the problem; people like you who do nothing but spread garbage and hatred to impressionable kids lead to people like this shooter.
@@chuckrobinson599 people reading to children? Oh the horror. The inhumanity.
Lock up these monsters dedicating their time to do something nice for the community.
All these shooters had received mental health assessments..but then nothing was ever done to help them. This Buffalo shooter was such a sick minded young man...I cant believe his parents didnt think anything was wrong with him. Thank you again on your analysis.
he is not sick, he is evil
@@andyisdead i mean, same thing if you think about
This clown should have been jailed for threats
I thought for a second I was going to hear an unbiased analysis of this horrific mass killing... i was wrong.
:(
I honestly wonder what you're definition of "unbiased" is.
Explain what was biased about it
@@noco7243 anyone who talks from a left wing viewpoint
Once again, maybe pushing for the legislation of federally funded mental healthcare in the richest country in the world could help a smidge. . .
Would it? Was he mentally ill?
Mental health is the latest weapon to be used against the people. It's not a new idea, look into the history of declaring intellectuals insane, because they went against the government.
I think this is the crux!
Reagan got rid of federally funded mental health facilities in such a way that it's probably never coming back 😪
@@sledzeppelin While a lot of people don't seek help, what you said isn't accurate. A lot of states lack mental health care accessibility. Also a lot of people can't even afford treatment. Look up the stats, it's not looking good, especially for the youth.
When people have huge paid platforms and promote theories that reliably lead to violence they should be held to account.
Like mainstream media?
This could be true. Who do you think promoted the theories that led to, say, the attacks by Frank Robert James or James Hodgekinson?
great replacement theory is real Nd doesn’t actually lead to violence inherently, it’s like saying by cnn calling out white supremacy and white racism, ur advocating violence against whites, it’s nonsense
@@eadweard. frank robert james followed Tucker Carlsson theories from Fox and james hodgekinson didn't follow any theories.
@@asdfasdf3989 citation needed
I wonder how Native Americans feel about the Great Replacement Theory. According to what I researched while in college it was estimated that before Europeans reached North America there were an estimated two million Natives living here. By 1900 there were less than 100,000 left alive. One just has to wonder.
So you are saying that the replacement conspiracy is true?
They were killed. That’s kind of different
Pretty sure Dr. Grande would say some reactionary centrist BS somehow both-sidesing the issues, blaming it on Indigenous people & their (few) allies at the time. They’ve only espoused this POV, just bc one of the genocidal murderers didn’t reference em means they have no complicity in it or obligation to denounce genocidal theories to reduce this possibility in the future. Fvcking pathetic stuff here. He cannot admit that he likes grudgingly voting for complicit actors. Truly a grotesque overview of this bullshit that’s a disservice to his viewers...
@@goldensoul6696 they mostly died from disease.
Disease played a huge role, and conquest did the rest. However, it's important to note that indigenous groups were massacring and committing ethnic cleansing against each other before Europeans arrived. History is a long tale of inhumanity.
I don't understand why it matters so much to some people. As a white person I dont care what color the world is I just want it to get better.
This is because you do not conflate someone's race with their beliefs or ideas. The fundamental belief that white nationalists and racists have is that black people, latino, asian or any combination thereof do not have the capacity to maintain or uphold "western" beliefs. Good on you for your outlook.
I still don't understand how skin color can matter when we're all going to end the same way.
@@dila4834 we're going to burn
Open borders matters. We life in a welfare state that requires people to pay into. You can't just open the borders and flood the country with millions of illegal migrants, it overwhelms our system. They aren't legally allowed to work. We can't afford to pay for their food stamps, welfare, public schools, health care, etc. The migrants jack up the rent and depress the wages. The only reason why white people even exist is they were in isolation and they naturally selected white skin. The ultra-lib anti-racist policies want white people to turn into a minority because they think that is a good thing because they say we're too racist to control our borders. It is anti-white racism. You should blame the Democrat politicians who have the borders open, not the people who believe the truth that the borders are open. Rapid demographic changes do matter.
One of the best parts of my day: a RUclips notification of a new Dr. Grande analysis video.
My heart was beating so hard as I watched the body cam footage from this monster. He was very accurate and fast making it even more frightening. Such a coward.
Unarmed people shopping! Yeah that's a fair target!
Sadly, it is not difficult to be accurate when you are shooting people 10 feet in front of you.
Coward indeed!
I saw the unedited video. Pure evil. I am not a big believer in the death penalty, but I would not give 2 hoots if this guy got the needle.
@@erdelegy I assure you the games aren't practice, a controller isn't remotely similar to a trigger. It's just extremely easy to hit a target when you don't care who or what you hit and the target is a car lengths away.
What a disturbing case...my heart goes out to all the families affected by this horrible crime. Excellent analysis, Dr. Grande! ❤️
Now if we only had Kyle Rittenhouse guarding that supermarket….
@@Timothee_Chalamet_CMBYN another punk
@@Timothee_Chalamet_CMBYN Glorifying another mass murder is your solution. No wonder this mass shooting are ocurring on a weekly basis.
This young man had extensive previous and ongoing contact with multiple FBI agents. What a strange pattern this is with the FBI and people who commit or attempt to commit extraordinarily heinous crimes.
I know my way of thinking can't always be right but it fails me how someone else's skin colour could bother me to the point of wanting to kill anyone. Doesn't someone has to have such low confidence to believe that? Loathe themselves even? Did he only get this much hate online or closer to home?
This was part of the maga agenda, preserve white privilege and blood line. they saw too many ppl mixing races these days. (i am bi racial)
Pure Evil. We are all the children of God regardless of race.
It's not only that the skin color is different, it's the constant narrative that those people are coming to take or ruin something for everyone else, this is the idea that Hitler pushed constantly trying to create what's called a narrative of aggrievement where all of society's ills are the fault of a certain group of people and only a racist leader with absolute power can save everyone so extreme lengths are needed to take care of this "problematic population". Watch the old documentary about fascism called "Don't Be A Sucker", it's a trick as old as time.
@Raf yep, blame on anything else but themselves. But to blame it on a virus? That's crazy.
That's because you're believing the lie about skin color. It's about cultural norms. How many whites do you know, that think prostitution is ok? Not in theory, but actual women that they know, who are actual prostitutes? I don't know any whites, who think what these women are doing is ok, but I've not met any blacks, who were the least bit troubled by it. I'm talking as far as one woman's husband. He knew what she was doing, and was fine with it, so long as he got part of the money. We're not talking about drugged out scum of the earth either, he was the manager of a gas station. They had two kids together. They were legally married. He didn't care that his WIFE, was out selling it, so long as he got paid.
It would be very wrong for anyone to try to assert that all or even most conservatives ascribe to this conspiracy theory, but also I haven't seen that at all. I think it is somewhat disingenuous to assert that this is a situation where two extreme sides of an issue are coming into conflict though.
There are a large amount of mainstream conservatives, politicians, and news media personalities that are actively promoting this dangerous thought process. I have seen people on both sides of the aisle that are asking for these specific individuals to be held accountable for the outcomes of their inflammatory language. Perhaps you are planning on doing a video specifically on Tucker Carlson and other politicians and media personalities that are actively spreading this conspiracy theory though.
As it stands, this video is less fair and balanced than it is portraying itself, because it leaves out this obvious and important distinction and misrepresents the issue that most people are attempting to address in my opinion.
This comment needs more upvotes. I couldn't put it any better. His take on Dems baselessly asserting that the Republican party supports the theory was completely off the mark and bordering on obfuscation.
Two presidents have said it was real, but you should ignore them, and get your information from RUclips, which bans the discussion of conspiracy theories. That's what smart people do m
@@chuckrobinson599 Thank you for the timely object lesson.
Only the leaders do? LOL Whatever. Every Christian Conservative I know is this way.
@@Darkwarlord1533 GOP doesn't support the theory. They just stay silent and support those candidates come election time. Totally different.
A fear of being replaced by another human in this short life is just plain dumb.
I'm sure the African American experience as a minority has been wonderful.. this is what this is about.
It's been happening we have the numbers, but it's tru that this doesn't help stop the replacement this is some crazy whyt boy snapping, he happened to find a target he felt he could justify attacking
I actually find it amazing the live stream was taken down within 2 minutes, that pretty damn good considering the size of the platform
Its still easy to find though
Both police and mental health professionals had a chance to evaluate him beforehand and failed to assess the danger he posed. How does that happen? /mindblown
half of the police force welcomes these theory's
Neither the police nor most mental health professionals have the insight or the training to adequately assess the risk, or even recognize that it exists in a specific individual.
@@auntymarushkafah Even without adequate training, has there not been enough examples by now? The average layperson can see the pattern, surely those with training can see it too.
Cops, municipal ones, are notoriously authoritarian and stupid. They lack not only training, but good judgement, at least all the 20-something fresh cops of Podunk that I've encountered. Same goes for non-PHD "therapists".
@@auntymarushkafah well when he writes it all down......
I think you’re drastically underplaying the role of hyper politicisation plays in these types of events. There’s a reason these types of events are vastly more common in the United States than anywhere else in the developed world. As an outsider looking in, news like this always frustrates as there are several very easy steps that could be taken to reduce these occurrences.
I think that gun accesibility plays the biggest role and I say this as someone that believes in gun rights.
Isolated, angry,crazy people are everywhere but its the access to guns that makes this stuff common here. It does happen in Europe and New Zealand etc but over there they have less guns.
The victims families should file a law suite against Tucker Carlson and Fox News for this..
@ Marlow Stanfield - I couldn't agree more. Anyone who has heard his vile talking points would understand that it's undeniable he should be held accountable.
Who do all the victims of black Chicago drug dealers sue? Multiples more than what this guy or people like him have done, a typical display of irrational liberal thought.
@@go4384 The victims in Chicago are in gangs or are in the drug game, what happens to them comes with the territory. The victims in Buffalo were normal people just grocery shopping. If you can't tell the difference then you are just stupid 🙄
When the murderer was in high school last year, he and his class was given an assignment from his economics teacher about what they wanted to do when they retired. The murderer stated he wanted to commit murderer/suicide. The school sent him for a psychological evaluation. He talked his way out of it saying it was a joke.
The week before he committed the murders, he attended school in a full hazmat suit ???
Also, sometime prior to the murders he had beaten a cat to death in his garage, decapitated it and asked his mother to assist in burying it.
I think we are dealing with a mentally ill person. He was clearly a walking time bomb. I don't think he deserves any recognition beyond that.
My heart goes out to all the victims. Sending prayers to my fellow Americans.
Thank you Dr. Grande.
You completely left out the fact that he went to a predominantly Black neighborhood with the specific intent of harming Black people. During the attack he apologized to a white man instead of shooting him (who turned out to be the store manager). Yes this is a failure of mental health systems within this country, but it is also a failure of our society to continue allowing racist conspiracy theories to be broadcast into millions of homes on a nightly basis and pretending they have any semblance of legitimacy.
I'm afraid I think he is in fact, a total sociopath. The DA today was backpedaling that he threatened his high school, he claimed this was an erroneous accusation, but still they were concerned enough to send him for a hospital psych eval. It also sounds like his parents knew he was highly troubled at best, and chose to just "wait and see."
He is a mentally ill, alright. Normal, sane people do not kill multiple strangers. Or anyone!
You have not acknowledge the racial aspect anywhere in your response you’re a prime example of a large part of American society.
@@nickdominic9103 The focus should not be race.
A mentally deranged man killed 10 innocent people in Buffalo.
In the winter a mentally deranged man used his car to run over and killed 5 people and i jured 40 in Wisconsin.
We have to come together as Americans, not divide by race religion or color. United We Stand.
Whenever I visit the US I get really nervous in crowds for exactly this reason.
You're more likely to be killed by a cop, and way more likely to be killed in a car wreck. The dirty little secret about mass shootings, is most of them are done by non whites, against non whites, and are usually gang related. There aren't any tourists attractions in gangland. You're not likely to wind up there.
I don’t blame you.
Kind: When I'm in crowds in Europe, I get nervous about keeping by wallet. shrug. Come to the US, don't use drugs, don't hang around with criminals and your chances of being shot are minimal.
so stay home. 🤣🤣🤣
Don’t be so dramatic
What's the fear? Does America treat minorities badly or something?
Ikr🤔? People are people we're all the same no matter the color of our skin 😊
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim me too, and it irritates me. I'm not quite sure why.
Not to take away from the topic at hand - but I really think a lot of these young men are picking ' low lying fruit' to be angry at in their own personal existential struggle as young-wanna-be-adults. They have a perceived failure in their life, and they pick a target to blame. I would imagine this guy had many problems leading up to this point, mainly rage.
Ur choice if words have you ever heard Nina simones song strange fruit?
I believe that tucker carlson has blood on his hands!
Interesting how the psychological health of certain people who commit heinous crimes is given immediate consideration while others who commit the same crimes are deemed to be evil by nature.
You can follow a conspiracy theory whilst also being evil by nature nobody said he isn’t, you’re putting words in others’ mouths.
Yes, let's talk about that special consideration and the so called "Summer of Love" and the 200 billion USD in damages?
I've been waiting for this!
I can’t stand how these people picks such soft targets. I live in Pittsburgh and the shooter walked into a synagogue his first victims were mentally disabled. They walk into churches and grocery stores why don’t you drive through Compton or go to the projects, then I’ll think that maybe you were brave. I started carrying a gun for a few years but I decided NOT TO , reading this makes me want to reconsider
Always. They never attack police stations, biker clubhouses, gang corners. See how brave for your cause you are and take on someone who can return fire. Always churches, or unsuspecting people shopping. Their causes just get lessoned by their actions.
He was in the hood, he had to go there to kill the black people.
You watch the video?
They want easy prey.... Cowards🤢
@@missesmew His 'cause' was groundless.
@@puketinmoarliek994 nah
My ❤️ goes out to these families -
I have my own thoughts on why this type of thing is happening, with some frequency
People, usually young male teens, have crazy thoughts and ideas, in a pre-internet society, these thoughts would almost always get shot down by your average human. It doesn’t really matter what the crazy thought is. It could be anything really. Now, these people with crazy ideas just find other people with the same crazy ideas and build their identities around said crazy idea. It grows and it grows until it occasionally results in a violent act
Some people, like some ‘news’ organizations, don’t believe a word of their own rhetoric. It is about money, political capital and influencing the unwashed masses. Then there are low life trolls who just like to stir up shit.
It's almost entirely politically motivated and by rightwingers so your interpretation is missing something.
I my be prejudiced but I don't think liberals feel as victimized and fearful of change maybe due to broader educational exposure? We fear what we don't know!
Family- clearly, you're of the age (as am I) to remember pre-internet days. I agree with you regarding that thought. Just look at some of the craziness on social media these days: Flat Earth, Blood over Intent, anti-vax, etc.
Too many people (and I've even seen a number of them my own age of 65) are being influenced by social media, and believing the most outlandish things. I also feel that many youngsters are using social media without any parental oversight.
@@rustyshackleford735 it’s not always rightwing people and it’s not always politically motivated. A good example would be the Vegas shooter or the congressional baseball game shooter. There was a black teen that tried to shoot up his school or the subway shooter in New York. This isn’t meant to downplay racial or rightwing violence, it’s just not exclusively rightwing. My point was that people with crazy ideas are more likely to be able to indulge their crazy ideas because of the internet
its horrific to me that these are all still 'allegations' right now. its literally all on video.
To be fair people just say that so they don't risk being sued
That's the way it should be. We all know he's guilty, but we have a process that must be followed and respected.
Why "horrific"? Does it really matter?
@@isaiahrowley9830 lol respect the process? that’s very unlikely. lol our criminal justice system is complete shit
@@alw_9911 How much have you studied our justice system? Do you know the key differences between our country and let's say Japan. What makes it shit? Do you have any ideas for a better system? What constitutes a good justice system? Have you ever seen a country that has done it correctly? I agree it's far from perfect, but I would love to hear how we could make it better.
I as a black person am baffled! Who are we replacing. I’m too busy trying to make ends meet.
its not really black people specifically. its non whites in general. Argentina is the only white country with more births over deaths(and that's if you consider Argentina white lmao). America, Britain, France, Germany, Australia, new Zealand and the list goes on. all these countries have white majority populations that have a low birthrate and high non white immigration. within 100 years most of these countries will have a white minority.
True. It's hard for anyone to replace themselves in today's world. The replacement theory believes that the newcomers will be having very large families, which is really not practical for anyone.
@@mylittlekittens it’s not a theory’s dummy.
The question is, why are there so many isolated people in society?
Social media
So many fucking red flags and he couldn't be stopped, sick.
Anti-vaccination proponents do not particularly have far-left characteristics.
The problem with discrediting conspiracy theories is that those idiots with absolutely no critical thinking ability come up with one theory after another. When you prove them wrong on one theory, they'll come up with another crazier one until you are totally exhausted arguing with these people and will eventually give up.
You've never proven anyone wrong, and why is your profile picture the flag for Biden's money laundromat?
That’s the m.o. of these self centered evil doers....to wear us down and exhaust us until we give up.
Some nutcases who believe in the replacement theory:
“The 1965 Immigration Reform Act promoted by President Kennedy, drafted by Attorney General Robert Kennedy, and pushed through the Senate by Ted Kennedy has resulted in a wave of immigration from the Third World that should shift the nation in a more liberal direction within a generation. It will go down as the Kennedy family’s greatest gift to the Democratic Party.” -Democratic consultant Patrick Reddy in 1998
“For all y’all rich folks, enjoy that champagne, or whatever fancy ass Scotch you drink. And for y’all a bit lower on the economic scale, enjoy your Pabst Blue Ribbon, or whatever shitty ass beer you favor…Because your time is limited…Because you’re on the endangered list. And unlike, say, the bald eagle or some exotic species of muskrat, you are not worth saving. In 40 years or so, maybe fewer, there won’t be any more white people around who actually remember that Leave It to Beaver …It’s OK. Because in about 40 years, half the country will be black or brown. And there is nothing you can do about it. The sound of your empire dying? Your nation, as you knew it, ending, permanently? Because I do, and the sound of its demise is beautiful.” -Tim Wise, "Open Letter to the White Right," 2010.
“Supporting real immigration reform that contains a pathway to citizenship for our nation’s 11 million undocumented immigrants is the only way to maintain electoral strength in the future.” -(leftwing think tank) Center for American Progress, 2013.
“Democrats underperformed in congressional races and state legislative contests. At the same time, the weeping and gnashing of teeth over these failures obscured a more permanent reality: Trumpism accelerated damage done by demographic changes and will harm Republicans for years. Demographics is destiny.” -Joe Scarborough, MSNBC Commentator.
WaPo’s Jennifer Rubin in response to claims that the proportion of whites in the American population was declining. “This is fabulous news. Now we need to prevent minority white rule.”
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim Women moment
It’s not a “theory” but fact. Whites are not as high a percentage as they were years ago. Whether it’s being done intentionally or not is somewhat immaterial, but common sense would indicate there is some intentionality when it comes to political interests and open borders. The author of this post apparently lacks the critical thinking to put these things together. And to think that whites becoming less a part of US politics and society isn’t a big deal that will cause massive shifts and changes, well, that makes you an idiot. Even more so if you think the changes will be for good…We’re already slipping into an inflationary depression that will lead to full on socialism and collapse. Whites will then flee to a new place, at least those with survival instincts.
Nazis: we are being replaced!!!
Meanwhile native Americans: 🙄
Wanna find me great swathes of land owned exclusively by white people? Where only they are allowed to live?
These mass shootings are terrifying. When I was a kid before Columbine nobody worried about this type of thing happening, now it can happen in any state, city, or small town. I wish I knew an answer that would be a quick easy solution. Clearly people in this country need easier access to mental health treatment, and I think we need to understand gun control is an issue we have to tackle
It's already against the law to murder. If someone doesn't obey that law, why do you think they won't access illegal guns? Consider the black market that will flourish if guns are made legally inaccessible.
I think there were guns before columbine.
Gun free zones 27 of 28 the last school shootings.
@@sharonwilfong503 We cannot perpetuate a firearms industry and regulatory systems where a teen with demonstrated violent tendencies can easily acquire combat-style weapons and kill innocent people en masse.
I think it’s too late with the vastness of the internet, social platforms, apps, smart phones, televisions, movies, communities lacking resources, families dynamics. etc etc. it’s no turning back.
A little too much "both sidesing" in this video. "Sometimes terrible attacks happen without there being a larger political reason." Sure, but the shooter's motives were explicitly political in this case. And he was explicitly motivated by a theory that is promoted by platforms on the right both large and small (Tucker Carlson, Infowars, Rebel News, Stephen Molyneux, etc.). So, these platforms definitely warrant some blame for engaging in stochastic terrorism.
Okay blm/antifa terrorist. Keep pushing your hatred and lack of independent thinking skills.
He lifted it as an excuse. He didn't write it.
Todd is so hit or miss. This video is 80% straw-manning bullshit, 10% outright lies and only 10% real unbiased factual information. Do better Grande.
Why shouldn't we talk about how racist replacement theory influenced this murder? Yes, he was crazy. But something can be both both crazy AND an overt political act.
I'm sure many Nazis were psychopaths, too. Should we not call the holocaust "racist" because Hitler was a narcissist? When psychopathy and ideology combine into literal murder, yeah, we should talk about it.
And you said it yourself, earlier in the video: this is NOT an isolated incident. How many of the mass shooters of the last 20 years have NOT been racists who listened to right wing radio or wrote on right wing reddit threads and incel message boards? 10 of them? That's still like 2% of the total.
There is a HUGE connection between alt-right talking points and physical violence and intimidation (and even if we omit racism, there's the sexism). And we all know it. Did we even need to SEE this guy's diary entries before being able to guess his race, sex, and M.O.? Shutting up about it is stupid, and reveals how weird and clingy you are with desperately clutching your "moderate" pearls.
The truth is, yes, conspiracy theorists often don't hurt people. But a significantly larger portion of RACIST conspiracy theorists do. Every other week, one of them is killing people in cold blood, with guns, in public. We shouldn't NOT analyze why that is.
(By the way, you weird centrist, "anti-vax" is not an "extreme left wing" position. The poster girl of the OG anti-vax movement was Jenny McCarthy. And the only time Trump was ever booed while on stage was at the one rally where he told his right-wing supporters to get the vaccine. And while yes, this is one of those rare conspiracies that afflicts those on the right AND left, at this point it is pretty much the purview of the right. if you've been to a state with a large population of right-leaning voters, you would know instantly that it's not the "extreme left" who is avoiding their vaccinations. Even those on the left who DID avoid the vax were basically middle-class wine moms, not bomb-chucking anarchists.)
Grande seems to lean to the right. An educated man who leans to the right and has white skin has no choice but to pretend white supremacists don't exist. The white men doth protest too much.
Exactly… had a feeling he was gonna try both sides this. Guess he doesn’t want to lose viewers
He’s just trying to stay non political as today the left hates and cancels anyone that shows political views they disagree with
Stop saying things like "we can replace them." Stop giving these people fodder
There is so much emotion in this post that it's quite funny. Racists are killing people every week? A LARGE portion of racist conspiracy theorists kill? Interesting. I do see a particular race committing murder at an alarming rate due to turf wars and other reasons. Racists though? Not so much.
This isn't to say right wing violence isn't a thing or a problem, it just isn't at the rate of concern that other things should be taking the place of.
I have to completely disagree in regards to your speculation on his mental state, and dismissing his beliefs as "conspiracies". Doing this mitigates the problem and unintentionally takes responsibility off the perpetrator. When you call his beliefs conspiracies, you are insinuating that he wasn't a rational person and thus incapable of rational thought. Before anyone says, "How could a rational person possibly commit such an atrocious act?" the answer is simple when you look at history. People commit acts like this all the time. Are they all clinically insane? I think chalking it up to mental health does a disservice and alleviates the perpetrator of responsibility. The fact is that more often than people would like to believe, some rationally thinking people see the world around them and the problems they deem important, and their solutions can be to commit acts that others find inexplicable. We have to look at acts like this as what they are; a person who's solution to something they see as a problem is extreme violence. They aren't mentally ill. They are normal people who end up resort to extreme violence. I think the reason many people like to chalk up these people as "crazy" or "insane" is because many people cannot fathom a person with the same mental capability as them, resorting to such actions. But the fact is many people fall to darkness like this, and saying they are irrational takes away from their crime. Irrational implies something is not logical or reasonable. I'm sure to him, and many other radicalized people, their actions are completely logical. And just because most people can't fathom someone like themself going down a path like this doesn't make it not logical. I know people are going to say I'm defending his actions and beliefs and that's fine. I know some people can't separate emotion from their analysis when reading certain things. I'm not defending his actions, I just think it does more harm than good when you explain his actions by saying he had a few screws loose, rather than accepting that he was a very bad man and people like that walk among us every day, and they are able to form rational beliefs just as easily as anyone else and sometimes these beliefs lead them to do very terrible things.
Exactly - criminals kill people, not thoughts.
Mental illness does not discriminate by race.
People blaming "Conspiracy Theories" when its a white person, and complete media silence when anyone else - are perpetrating the very politicization that they are the whole time espousing that they supposedly "oppose".
This was beautiful...these people aren't crazy. They are in control and their is legitimate anxieties to their particular fear.
We never resort to violence, but...
White people are being replaced, and if that insecurity is real to you, some will respond based on that reality...because it is real...
Whites are being replaced, it's fact...I hope we can see the facts and not gloss over it so we can actually come to solutions...murder is never valid, but his feelings on being replaced are real and we have to be honest about it..m
@@christopherhorn1161 thank you. I wasn't condoning or excusing his actions, but to defeat one's enemy, you must first understand him. And we'll never defeat hate if we pretend the people who feel it are on a lesser plane of competence than us. They are people who've identified their problems, done their research, and came to conclusions that are despicable. Not irrational lunatics.
@@Musclingus I'm with you...
I try my hardest to understand people, and do my hardest not to judge. Just see a perspective different than mine
🎯
Um, Tucker Carlson - who has the most popular show on the most popular Conservative network - regularly promotes the Great Replacement Theory, so I'm not sure how the Far Left is overreacting here. Versions of Replacement Theory are mainstream canon for American Conservatism.
I think blaming Tucker Carlson here makes more sense than blaming guns or violent video games. Believing in a dangerous theory is one thing, knowingly seeding hateful, violent thoughts to millions of gullible viewers is another entirely.
You fear Tucker, don't you? He speaks the truth, and that makes you tremble.
@@ramblinralph7609 are you kidding? Absolutely nobody in the world fears Tucker Carlson. Seriously. Who cares if your votes are replaced. It's literally racist to care about this
@@dadtronic Let me guess you're a white women
@@ramblinralph7609 Hahaha that's pretty funny. Your joking, right? No way you can be serious
@@ramblinralph7609 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Thank you for covering my hometown Dr Grande 🖤
Famous quote “why can’t we all get a long”
If only there were a legal and kind way to replace racist a holes with normal people. Would be a dream come true for most of us.
I was really hoping you would do a segment on this. TY Dr. Grande!
He wrote after torturing, and killing the cat, that he was expecting to feel bad, but he didn't
In science, not only must a hypothesis be "testable", it must also be "falsifiable." In other words, the possibility of evidence that refutes or contradicts a hypothesis may exist with emphasis on "may." A lot of the claims, hypotheses, and/or theories made by conspiracy theorists tend to lack this quality of falsifiability. When met with contradicting evidence, instead of accepting it, they ignore it and selectively choose and interpret only the information that supports what they believe, which is basically just confirmation bias. It's like thinking changing the batteries will always fix a flashlight, and if changing the batteries doesn't work, then there's always some excuse like the batteries are defective and the brand that manufactures them must have terrible quality control.
there is no contradicting evidence on the replacement. Check the population statistics.
@@kidgforce1 demographics shift as more people are born. it isnt the fault of minorites that white people choose to have less children. the theory is groundless and only someone with no grasp on reality would believe it.
Confirmation bias is exactly how ideology works. It's the methodology of Critical Theory, including Critical Race Theory. It posits a state of affairs on an a priori basis and it goes looking for phenomena that tend to confirm the bias. What doesn't confirm the bias might as well not exist. This is why the use of CRT in education is not likely to emphasize what is probably the most striking things about Europeans' involvement with slavery: the first is that they had to learn it from others, because slavery had disappeared in Europe after Roman times; the second is that they, of all people around the globe, abolished slavery. What's amazing is that people don't realize that all their browbeating about European slavery is based on a European moral aversion to the practice. They sure didn't get their moral censure of slavery from Africa or from Islam.
Dr Grande should get over his own political prejudice and open his eyes to the real and dangerous spreading of conspiracy theories amongst prominent right wing demagogues. Or does Dr Grande think that Tucker Carlson is not a noxious demagogue?
There isn’t a better more clear headed explanation available as good as this one .
I'm glad you covered this. Interesting.
It’s not a conspiracy theory when they outright tell you they’re doing it.
Than have some babies and become religious zealots that’ll boost your numbers in no time……. Oh but wait you don’t want solutions you just want to cry
And when was that?
WHO is telling people outright that they're trying to decrease the amount of White people in America? 🤔
@@cutienerdgirl You referring to Biden’s statement which is on video, or those who shall not be named? 🫣
Dude you’re the villain and everyone will gaslight you into thinking speaking out is futile until you lose it and do something crazy which will further villainize people like you. Get over it lol
I love this guy. We need more Dr. Grandes in this world. He always calls it straight -- no emotion, no partisanship, no bias. In a world that seeks to divide us and keep us divided, this doctor is the way forward. I will support him for as long as he remains level.
I absolutely agree! I wish politics has existed today existed for it’s true purpose: to manage the possible. Unfortunately, I would see used for is to divide people to gain power for the corrupt.
Everyone has biases. Including the white Doctor.
Neutrality bias is still biased. Saying something foolish in a calm tone isn't being clear headed.
He's unique brosky!!!
no bias? watch the video again...
Thank you for a great segment.
Another case that could've been prevented if the feds weren't lazy
Don't forget the Great Pumpkin Theory
Welp, he's joined the Tucker and Ritthenhouse gang, whatever you want to call it or however you want to analyze it. He's part of gang of crazies.
Can you do an assessment of the Chinese guy who killed 1 person at a Taiwanese church
The mainstream media is ignoring the Chinese mass murderer
Doesn't serve the narrative.
@@anthonyodonnell6105 and what narrative is that?
@@chocolatethunder192 It has various features, but the main one is that America is a fundamentally racist country and its ordinary majority white inhabitants are oppressive and express it habitually through contempt and violence. Hence, for example, why reporters and editors jumped on the Covington Catholic misrepresentations and the Jussie Smollett hoax, despite there being video evidence that belied the narrative interpretation in the first case, and despite the Smollett story being ludicrous on its face: people in MAGA hats on one of the coldest nights in recent history in Chicago, walking around in the middle of the night, in CHICAGO with a bottle of bleach and a "noose" which was a thin bit of chord that Smollett draped with theatrical absurdity around his neck for the police to see when they arrived at his apartment.
Doctor Grande, what is your opinion on Tucker Carlson's role in propagating this conspiracy theory?
Dr. Grande doesn’t want to offend half his viewers so he won’t. He’s a RUclipsr with a million followers, he’s not above profit motivation.
@@J.AlexanderTX yet he had no problem blaming the left for politicizing this. Not one mention of Tucker Carlson, who has done over 400 segments about that very topic on his show, though. 🤦🏻♀️
@@tat2mommie exactly
The access to deadly firearms for a person with mental health problems is also a factor.
He had a deadly automobile as well....
@@KB4QAA but didn’t run over and kill a bunch of people with it
@@KB4QAA ah...the apples and oranges comparison used so many times omes before. The the purpose of an automobile is transportation; the same cannot be said of a firearm
Genuine question: I am UK based. What is 'pan handling'? Does it just mean begging for money, like homeless folk often do (sitting on the floor with a small cardboard sign, and a bowl with a handful of small coins in it, etc), or does it mean something else/something more? Any clarifications would be greatly appreciated! Thanks.
Correct.. basically begging for loose change.
You're right. That's exactly what it means.
@@theboywithathorninhisside.4179 thanks for the reply. Um... where does the pan and handle come into things?
@@marydolan4857 thanks for the reply? Is it aggressive? Do they attempt to strike you with the pan or the handle, for example?
No! Most panhandlers are very peaceful and thankful for any donations.
He was basically quoting Tucker Carlson though…
Dr Grande this doesn't make sense. You were convinced the Christmas Parade was politically motivated but this was not?
You are becoming much less consistent doctor grande and your political ideals are leaking into your opinions.
Dr Grande, conservative media DOES promote these right wing extremist theories. Get your facts straight please. Seems like you are trying to downplay the influence of right-wing media on this particular incident. I've always respected your opinion on controversial cases and hope you do better next time something like this happens (and it will happen, it's America).
Right wing media had nothing to do with this particular incident... just fyi
@@chachacha2023 what makes you believe that? FYI, I'm not only talking about mainstream promoters of the replacement theory such as Fox News. Where do you think the shooter got his ideas from if not from right-wing media?
@@KelmutHool : Have you even bothered to read his manifesto before opening your mouth? The shooter was a radical leftist, doesnt like conservatives and doesnt even watch fox news.
@@chachacha2023 why did you delete your first reply to my question and then posted another one trying to antagonize me? Seems to me you are just a troll and not interested in any discussion.
Tucker Carlson has been talking about this almost daily for months. Fox. Figures. Smh.
You think the likes of Tucker Carleson aren't telling you mainstream GOP talking points?
This is some 'both sides are bad' nonsense.
Similar terrorist attack happened where I live. Guy tried a church first but couldn’t get in. So he went to a grocery store. Terrifying.
"great" work, always a breath of fresh air to hear a voice of reason and sanity 👍👍
I have never feared of being replaced in that fashion. So odd
If you cannot empathize with people concerned about cultural replacement then you’re not trying, and you ought to care and have empathy.
France and Sweden, for example, are having very serious and violent upheavals due to mass migration without enough time and effort put into cultural integration.
Do you want to live in a different country or culture? A third world one? Probably not, or you’d move there.
You probably wouldn’t like it if the third world suddenly took over your entire city and changed your home completely.
@@lostandfound5145 what's written on your ar 15 wasteoid?
If the sh00ter was smart he’d know that the numbers of IR dating have increased to the point that WW are now the fastest growing group of single mothers with biracial children and almost all biracial ppl end up with someone who is YT so by 2 generations the black is almost completely gone. It’s called racial cleansing. If anyone would be extinct it would be BLK PPL because most have an obsession with whiteness. So really he should have just waited and let eugenics do it’s magic 🤷🏾♀️
@@lostandfound5145 If the sh00ter was smart he’d know that the numbers of IR dating have increased to the point that WW are now the fastest growing group of single mothers with biracial children and almost all biracial ppl end up with someone who is YT so by 2 generations the black is almost completely gone. It’s called racial cleansing. If anyone would be extinct it would be BLK PPL because most have an obsession with whiteness and have a huge disdain for being BLK. So really he should have just waited and let eugenics do it’s magic 🤷🏾♀️
@@gombocdimensional9050 “everyone I don’t like is racist” 🙄
I rarely find myself in serious disagreement with you but I believe you've made something of an overreach here. Though I agree that the accused likely suffered from pathologies that significantly increased his propensity to carry out acts of violence, I think that the cultural availability of hateful conspiracy theories like "replacement" increased the likelihood that his antisocial characteristics would express themselves in an act of extreme violence. The fact that apologists for this theory enjoy highly visible, lofty posts in the hierarchy of our society provides an air of factual veracity to the theory. This can create a sense of urgency, even paranoia in an individual sensitive to the message. I don't believe that it is sociologically or criminologically controversial to say that the more prevalent and pervasive hateful messages are the greater the frequency of stochastic terrorism.
@YourRationalWorldisaCircleJerk Wow. I imagine that you honestly believe that you've presented a compelling counter argument. "I believe crazy things and I'm not killing people" is not a rebuttal to stochastic terrorism. I'm fairly certain that no commenter on this page, regardless of their position on the motivating factors in this crime neglected the assailants clear psychopathy. The question is whether or not this particular act of violence was shaped by his belief system.
@YourRationalWorldisaCircleJerk
The theory that statistically significant outcomes based on probablistic modeling of certain types of speech is not simply a vacuous, foundationless notion assigned the title "stochastic terrorism". If that's your claim, it's simply wrong.
It's also not an attempt to abridge free speech, or even hate speech. It's simply a statistical mechanism for making predictive models. It's basically a more rigorous, codified assertion that words have consequences.
As to the clear psychopathy of the assailant, it's not in doubt. The bone of contention is whether or not "replacement theory" was a contributing factor in his criminal act. Here I believe it's relatively clear. Psychopaths represent anywhere between two to four percent of the population. They clearly do not all carry out acts of mass violence. These are facts. It's entirely possible that the individual in this case was so profoundly pathological that acting out in a profoundly violent way was almost inevitable but the specific nature of the act, along with the victimology, the rubric under which he acted, was not an inevitable outcome of his pathology. He arrived at that through some other mechanism.
He didn't kill prostitutes or stock brokers or Vietnamese people. He selected an overarching narrative that guided his violence and made his identification with and selection of that narrative explicitly clear.
Regarding your assertion that interracial violence (I find it interesting that you specifically chose blacks victimizing whites. Was this editorial choice simply a case of "what aboutism" or something much darker... I guess only you know for sure) is always tinged with a component of racial animus, it seems unlikely as many crimes have clear motivations of enrichment, romantic passion, or personal revenge. I don't discount the notion that any particular interracial crime might have, at it's root some element of racial hostility but assert that some significant majority do is likely projection on your part.
Finally, your continued assertion that "great replacement theory" is viable explanation for the demographic shifts in the US is ludicrous. It's ignores all the well researched socioeconomic reasons for changing ethnicity and causally assigns them to a ridiculous conspiracy theory. Your belief that the post war phenomenon of "white flight" somehow buttresses or is exemplative "GRT" demonstrates a profound misunderstanding of the confluence of cultural, economic, political and technological conditions that motivated white exodus from urban centers.
In the end, we likely won't agree on the role that the "GRT" conspiracy theory played in animating the crime. That doesn't worry me much. People can differ on these points and as psychology, criminology and sociology gain sophistication and productive accuracy, we may we'll find clear and indisputable answers to questions of criminal motivation. What has truly disturbed me in our interaction is not that you believe that "GRT" played no role in the Buffalo shooter's criminal act, but what appears to be your desire to rescue "GRT" from any association with a violent act. "GRT" doesn't have explanatory or predictive power. These are the hallmarks of a good scientific theory. It's a paranoid screed that assigns sinister motive and dark agency to a fairly innocuous and we'll understood demographic phenomena. Nothing is being taken from "white people". You're not in danger from "dark people". Your access to employment, freedom of speech, assembly and religion aren't affected by "dark people". Insulating the nation from immigration from the global south will do far more economic and demographic (it keeps the population from rapidly graying) damage to our nation. In short, no one is replacing you in any meaningful way.
Thanks for you perspective Dr Grande👍
This is an amazing video. I can't tell you how excited I am to browse your content... knowledge in nimrod
Minus these extreme beliefs, just the mental health issues, I don't think he would have done the killing, like the other killers with the same sick beliefs.
All I'm saying is that it's really strange that he used every buzzword, website, and weapon the feds want to ban...
Preemptive hate as a response to speculated hate is indeed, as you put it, the greatest conspiracy theory of them all.
Thank you Dr. Love your channel 💖💖💖