"Why did the New Republic keep making IMPERIAL STAR DESTROYERS?" ... too keep the Kuat Shipyards employed, cause the Kuat people aren't building stuff they don't design. ;^)
That and all the infrastructure is already in place, so while a new ship design might be better/cheaper by itself, the startup cost to tool up would be a huge additional investment compared to a tweaked ISD design.
@@Sivartius Also there is the wisdom from Arthur C Clarke's "Superiority". Don't fully commit to a new project until you ironed it's kinks out. Especially those that show only in large scale production&deployment. When those new designs show unexpected flaws you don't want to be caught with your proverbial pants down!
I could see it being a situation of “the ships where in a high stage of completion in the shipyard” with the later ships based on the ISD being modifications on the common and fairly cheap ISD hulls. Not to mention the manufacturing infrastructure was captured mostly intact on worlds like Kuat which would have an easier time producing ISDs instead of the various Moncalamari ships. R&D costs money,production machinery costs money,and the New Republic captured both at zero cost from the empire.
Moreover, the galaxy is probably drowning in warehouses full of spare/redundant ISD parts. That's one thing I really like about the Canon Starhawk - it's taking advantage of preexisting materials and labor.
The ISDs weren’t cheep at all, according to wookieepedia building just one ISD cost the annual economic output of several star systems. Also the ISDs need very large crews and where prone to mechanical problems.
I agree a fair number of ISD's the New Republic had were probably ones that had been captured more than halfway complete. When your pressed for warships finishing a half or three quarter built ship in a shipyard you just captured is far cheaper and quicker if you already have the parts available. If the fledgling New Republic had a serious shortage of in Legends it was a shortage of Capital Ships!
short answer: the rule of cool. long answer: they probably did that so that they could make their own later on, which they did. and also because they had people from the Imperial Remnant join their ranks, some of them even had Imperial Star Destroyers, they carried out the functions and purposes they were made for very well.
It is quite simple. Half of New Republic was the Empire. ISD if used properly was a good ship and New Republic inherited lot of infrastructure based around this class. Like scrapping all ISD's was dumb interpretation of New Canon (also not actually accurate also as there were implications that some ISD's wre still used).
@@TheRezro Theres a difference between retaining existing ISD's and continuing to build more instead of more efficient modernized ships, like the Nebula.
@@lenkagamine4145 First thing they address in the video was that they DIDN'T build new ships. Just memes are confused about continues use of this class by New Republic, what in limited scale do make sense.
@@papapalps2415 Well given your name its unsurprising you woudl claim that, but its not backed up by any actual sources. "It was designed to be able to defeat any one enemy Star Destroyer, two heavy cruisers, or an entire line of smaller Imperial support ships.[1] It mounted defenses strong enough to resist even some of the smaller Super Star Destroyers or analog warships." "The design also incorporated a system of lateral thrust vents to increase the ship's maneuverability, giving it far greater agility than most large capital ships." "In addition, the hull armor and shield systems of the Nebula outclassed most other ships in the galaxy, including the Republic." "Nebulas performed well in clashes with the extra-galactic warships once they finally did see combat. Even considering its age, the Nebula-class still represented the peak of modern, efficient Star Destroyer design during the Yuuzhan Vong War." "Although it was only 1,040 meters long (65% of the length of an Imperial-class Star Destroyer), the Nebula-class was built to be a match for an Imperial II." "(over 20% more power than the ISD-I)" On the contrary the ISD is not particularly focused on being a frontline brawler but is more of a very good garrison ship, owing to its sizable troop complement that enables it to launch planetary invasions as well as engaging in ship-to-ship combat. The Nebula is DEFINITELY stronger in ship-to-ship combat while having lower crew and maintenance requirements, as well as having much better firing arcs on its weapons and less vulnerabilities. Now regarding 'best capital ship brawlers of their size class', even that isnt correct. The Tector in terms of pure ship-to-ship combat is superior to an ISD, because it sacrifices the large ground forces and hangars for additional firepower. Obviously the ISD has more versatility, which is its main advantage; being much more versatile than a pure ship to ship brawler, given that it possesses large ground force contingents, fighters, etc.
Imagine spending _billions_ of dollars to purchase one of the most popular film franchises in history…and then half assing your big main trilogy. The laziness and incompetence of these people is just fucking incredible. What an absolute waste.
@@Gunnar001 this stuff happened BEFORE Disney took over I'm sure, this is legends lore. Not Disney cannon. They mentioned Anakin Solo which was around way before Disney took over. But yeah, Disney literally just took ISDs and put a gun on the bottom and called it a day. Not only was the super lazy it makes no damn sense form a lore point of view. Let's look at Darth Sidious's Eclipse. It was a huge damn ship was way bigger than the ISD because it needed that space to actually have a laser cannon that WASN'T AS EFFECTIVE as the Death Star cannon. It needed to be that big just to house a smaller version of it that couldn't blow up a planet but render in unhabitable. While apparently they can just take a normal ISD and slap a cannon on it and call it a day? That's BS.
@BlindingHornet yeah, that's fair, just wish these people, as in the words of BlindingHornet, "spending *billions* of dollars" would have a damn plan but didn't know what to do with the franchise and arguably ruining everything
@@zelithfang2365 First of using ISD by Republic actually did make sense, as IRL it wasn't uncommon when enemy equipment was used after the war. What didn't make sense was scrapping 25000 ISD's for ego reasons. If we want example of actual lazy it would be Xyston, where Jar Jar Abrams forget even about size of windows, rehashing model from Rogue One. Anyway it is actually Lucas Film what is responsible of Sequel fiasco as they were given free hand, except Disney forget that thy didn't make successful SW movie from the 80's and new management (hired by Lucas I remind) pick usual corporate BS with celebrate directors and ignoring the lore. Gladly Disney finally intervened and give creative control to Jon Favreau.
#AskEck Would you ever consider making a video talking about how you personally would have liked the Sequels to be made if you were in charge of story writing?
They didn't build them so much as used recycled Panthers that were laid on the sides of French streets and only used them in parades until they built a proper French tank. In fact they did a bunch of tests to see how they could improve the Panther and they found that it was so unreliable that you might as well built a new tank instead of fixing it. They mostly used American Chaffees and Sherman tanks in their own imperial attempts to keep a hold on their colonies cause those were far more reliable and better suited then the heavy tank that was two tons lighter than an IS 2 without the armour nor firepower to go with the weight.
@@michaelandreipalon359 yes, while tooling up and designing an alternative they had Panther formations in the French army, I would need to look up how many, but it was a decent number Edit: 2 regiments used them, the 6eme regiment de cuirassier, and the 503e RCC, both had about a squadron, and used them until spares ran out. It was a stop gap in case the Soviets decided to kick off.
@@michaelandreipalon359 given they still have one resistance captured Panther in working condition in a museum, not really, they had very practical views on using whatever you had to kill the other guy
I mean, even Booster Terrik's ramshackle casino ISD was putting in serious work against the Yuuzhan Vong. Say what we will about the Imperator's vulnerability to snubfighters, even decades later, that class was a capital-grade slugger par excellence.
Ask Eck: Can starships “throttle” their hyper drives to different speeds or were they just on/off? It always seemed weird to me that all the Alliance ships at Endor with their different drive ratings could jump together and emerge together.
They can. I remember reading a book from Mara's perspective that the hyperdrives of the ship she was in was going at beyond it's normal level. Also it makes sense from a strategic perspective to be able to coordinate long distance jumps to finish at the same time.
I think they can, I won't pinpoint a page but I believe in Thrawn's trilogy there were some orders from the great admiral that specified hyperspace speed when moving his flagship
My guess is, because they work just fine The ISD id a solid ship that fulfils a role on most fleet with pretty good shielding, good armour and very, very good firepower Plus its already established, spare parts and maintenance designed to care for it already exists It fits a role in the new republic pretty well, a main line warship that could hold its own against another of the same or bigger size. Its weakness against smaller ships could could also be covered with a few dedicated support ships of the republic or a few squadrons of X-wing independent of any carrier So yea thats what i think
the only big downside is its faster than most support ships, meaning any support fleet would either have to be unusually fast to keep up, or (what actually happend) the ISD 2 would just lumber along at half throttle or something.
@@AmdUlkoinen Bridge was actually well shielded and tower actually didn't have that many people inside holding mostly infrastructure. Also ISD did have second more secured bridge, but cocky Imperial commanders commonly didn't bother to move there during the combat. If used with anti-fighter escort in intended role as Assault Ship, then it was actually quite excellent (alongside Tactor used as Battleship). Problem was that Empire did send them unescorted to patrol systems, where they could easily fall in the ambush.
The problem isnt so much that the ship isnt good as much as its not super efficient. Large crew size and maintenance intensive, while not having great firing arcs on alot of its weapons. A modest redesign would improve its functionality and reduce its cost at the same time. Personally I think modifying all of the ISD's with new weapon placements (Copy the procursator optimally) and streamlined crew facilities would reduce their upkeep and improve functionality
I always assumed it was a case of there being just that many unfinished hulls and it was simpler and faster to finish them than to break them for parts and material for new ships.
Not to mention all of the production and maintenance facilities that would have to be retooled across the galaxy and the thousands of star destroyers scattered across the galaxy in various states of functionality. This isn't even getting into the fact that defected imperial command crews would have be trained to operate these vessels. For the fledgling new republic government it makes sense to leverage these and divert resources that would be wasted on setting up new military production infrastructure towards building new government institutions and programs.
Are you dumb? Starhawk was build as dedicated SSD killer (also it is ship from Legends). They didn't actually scrap most ISD's, especially as half of New Republic is the Empire. In fact famous Leia's ISD is specifically kept canon, even if they didn't yet confirm its faith.
@@TheRezro I think your insults are uncalled for. Starhawk is a ship from canon, built from ISD parts, and while it does have some benefits over an ISD if I remember correctly, calling it an SSD killer is ridiculous. Also your comment on scrapping most ISD's doesn't make sense, the majority of the ISD's were destroyed or escaped to the first order.
@@danielschwab4281 If you don't know what this debate is about, then don't justify future insults. Starhawk was originally mentioned in Expanded Universe. The reason why it did have this huge tractor beam in canon, was to push larger ships into planets gravity walls. That is literally the only reason why those ships were build. Most of New Republic was actually ex-Imperial and they equipment didn't magically disappear. It is just one of things we don't see off screen, like Death Star blowing up Rebellion Lucrehulk on the way to Yavin.
@@TheRezro 1. I know what your debate is about, I read EvilColeslaw's comment, and yours and I also watched the video. 2. I didn't justify future insults, I said that your insult (calling him dumb) was unneeded to make your counterpoint. 3. Starhawk being in legends has nothing to do with his statement about its inefficiency since he states he's referring to the canon. 4. If the entire point of the ship was to drag larger ships into planets then why did it need the engines of the SSD to be destroyed. 5. Even if it didn't need the engines destroyed, why did only one of the 3 Starhawks at Jakku make an effort to drag the SSD down? 6. If they were only built for SSD killing, then why were Starhawks present at battles where SSDs were not present? 7. If we don't see it offscreen, or in books, then how do we know it's a thing?
@@TheRezro Also its not from Legends. It was mentioned first in the Aftermath trilogy, which is technically EU but is Canon EU. If you're going to call someone dumb, which you never should, then get your facts straight. Any reference to a Starhawk in Legends is actually either a shuttle used around the time of the 2nd galactic civil War or two types of speeder bikes, the Starhawk and the Starhawk 2b. The ship is a Canon creation that is absolutely a cool idea that is entirely impractical. It makes no sense to waste time with the process when captured ISDs work fine. The only reason is to help PR, as the ISD is a symbol of oppression. However the legends rebellion and new Republic using it logistically makes sense, and is realistic as hell as discussion definitely took place over whether to scrap it or whatever but some bean counter, probably Borsk and his sect, decided it'd cost too much or weaken the navy for too long.
It would be like the German army denying Panthers during the Cold War era. Sure they replaced it with the Leopard, but the Panther is definitely better than throwing rocks.
Another factor could be that producing any kind of ship requires infrastructure to actually build them. A completely new design would need shipyards capable of their construction. E.g., wouldn't KDY need time and extra resources in order to re-design their production capabilities in order to transition to building other types of ships?
I actually have a book where a Dathomirean Witch actually snaps her fingers , and severs Luke Skywalkers brain and body connection he collapses to the floor ,and has to literally use all the force he can gather from the entire living jungle to save himself. He then starts to understand more about layering himself in the force. Putting up barriers to his emotions , and to his body. This is why more of the older Jedi seem to walk slower they are literally walking shields. Always prepared for anything.
Isn't that the scene where an actual rock says something like "here have my bit" and gives him a bit of Force strength. I remember reading it and going... 'yeah that might be taking it a bit too far with the Force being in everything'.
@@UnintentionalSubmarine yeah I thought so too but if you remember a lot of places where based upon more about ambience then actual life. So as to simplify good and bad.
@@chrissonofpear1384 Actually I view THE COURTSHIP OF PRINCESS LEIA to be the fourth book in the THRAWN TRILOGY. AND it wraps up everything nicely from the Thrawn trilogy. Actually my favorite book from my childhood.
On the "Could a force user use the force on someone's body parts" - Absolutely yes. There was a Star Wars comic depicting Darth Vader targeting an Jedi Alien's heart with Force Grip directly (I don't remember the specific comic unfortunately, but it's a good example) as a form of torture. As with all things with the Force, it requires stout and competent manipulation of the Force, something Darth Vader had in spades. You also see targeted Force manipulation used by Obi-Wan Kenobi against Anakin Skywaler/Darth Vader during their Mustafar duel in the movie novel. He momentarily disabled Anakin's robotic hand that caused Anakin to drop his Lightsaber (if you remember the scene where Anakin is without his lightsaber in the movie and charges at Obi-Wan, that's what happened even though the movie doesn't actually show the scene described in the book)
Superior firepower in the purest form. I just hope the Rebellion was smart enough to add in some anti star fighter guns. Other than that if it ain't broke don't fix it. The Imperials knew how to create a ship that could destroy any capital ship with ease
#askeck: I just noticed in RoTS when Vader is slaughtering the separatists on Mustafar, in one brief clip (1:35:07), he appears to be in pure agony. Is this a contradiction between the novelization (where he was thoroughly enjoying it) and movie, or is there an explanation for it?
@Admiral Wullf Yularen But the DS was smaller than a planet which some had shields over the entire planet and the DS probrobaly had enough room on board
@Admiral Wullf Yularen ok that makes more sense for the planetary one thank you and they were definitely waaaay too arrogant as palpatine let the DS2 be discovered before completion
@@chadholzman1819 Well, in Papatine's defense, the leakage of the DS 2's construction was part of his plan to catch and eliminate all the rebels at once (it's main force at least), that's why part of the Main Imperial fleet along with Vader's flagship, the Executor were also at Endor
I could see a situation where the republic took over shipyards where many star destroyers were being built/repaired...I think it would be cheaper to finish those than building new republic designs and scrapping the imps.
8:01 - Thanks for answering my question; that really made my day! I remember reading the Young Jedi Knights series when it was coming out, and yeah -- the wacky colours they'd come up with because of the scrounged crystals they used was awesome. Lowie's bronze blade _was_ particularly awesome.
#AskEck If blue alsers in Star Wars are better suited to taking out machinery, then why dud the Star Destroyers under The Empire switch from using Blue lasers to green? Until the Yu'Zhan Vong they didn't need to worry about biological spaceships!
My belief is that the 'new' Destroyers was retrofitted old Imperial Destroyers. Droid armies require at least factories which aren't highly mobile while being a target for the opposition.
We have multiple examples of using the force inside another person's body, one of which you actually covered. Gethzerion actually killed an entire army of Zsinj's stormtroopers by causing brain hemorrhages. In the KotOR games, the Wound line of darkside force powers literally starts with the base power being described as causing painful spasms in the target's lungs, before going up to the Choke and Kill powers.
Probably because he was worried Qiu-Gon could get more Jedi to think like him. The Jedi were corrupted politics and the dark side. They no longer were pure vessels for the force. Unable to fully carry out it's will. Qiu-Gon was thought to be a gray Jedi by a lot of people but others scoffed at the idea saying he isn't a gray Jedi for doing what he's doing, that the Jedi were supposed to be like Qiu-Gon and he was the only one sticking to what a Jedi should be. I'm guessing if others did follow Qiu-Gon they would have realize what's been going on a sense the plot of the dark side before the clones could have been brought into the picture. No clones, no order 66, the whole plan fails.
@@herbertphillips1383 Shit, **I** saw them "Taken" movies, I'd be scared of the guy too. Plagueis: "That dude's a F#%$ING JEDI NOW?!" **Quits Sith** "I just work at the Bank, f#%k THAT. Sheev, you're fired."
#askeck Why didn’t the rebels especially in the early years raid CIS outposts and get there own droid army, (not build just obtain) it wouldn’t limit them to much if they find some MTT’s ,a lucrehulk or any “Large” ship to transport them
I take it back, the HAET-221. Watched one of your vids on hidden ships in ROTS and realized that's what I was talking about. Just didn't recognize it cause in the hanger you see it from the front, and the best shot of it is in the rear.
I think the reason they used them was mostly as a deterrent, similar to the Tarkin Doctrine but with more peaceful intentions in mind. Just imagine how terrifying it would be for pirates and other outlaws to run into an ISD expecting to mow down a few TIEs, only for a squadron of black X-Wings and A-Wings to fly out of it instead.
With the question about using the Force inside someone’s body- It’s possible, but difficult. The Force and the various abilities that are possible through it rely largely on the ability of the mind to decide what it wants and believe that it’s possible. For the first part, you need to have a firm picture in your mind of what you want to do. This is one reason Jedi use hand motions while using powers like persuade or push - it helps them visualize the end result.the physical motion itself helps focus the mind, but isn’t intrinsically necessary. For the second part, you have to actually know what you’re doing is possible and rely on intense focus to prevent intrusive thoughts or doubt from interfering with the ability. For example, Yoda and Luke’s favorite exchange: “I don’t believe it!” “That is why you fail.” The Force can do basically do anything you believe it can, so long as that belief is strong enough to put aside doubts. So using the Force inside a body would likely require two things. The first is a reasonable knowledge of the anatomy in question, to help you visualize the target area and what you want to happen. The second is that you know for a fact that it’s possible to do what you want to do. Bardan Jusik (SPOILERS FOR REPUBLIC COMMANDO NOVELS) uses the Force to heal brain damage at one point. I don’t recall the phrasing, but it was involved.
If I'm remembering correctly there's the odd mention of the New Republic finishing Star Destroyers under construction when they took shipyards like Kuat. Kuat's legends page on wookiepedia actually specifically mentions that during the Yuuzhan Vong war that KDY produced many ships for the NR during the Vong war especially Star Destroyers. This could have been where I got confused about a throwaway line and it doesn't _specifically_ say the new SDs were Imperial class rather than Nebula for example. It would make sense to however to continue building ISDs from Imperial shipyards, they already have the assembly lines and processes for mass production of ISDs whereas for example the Mon Calamari Cruisers would have involved a significant retraining, retooling and reorganisation. As well, I seem to remember reading about the Nebula being much more expensive than an ISD? It could make sense to continue producing ISDs until the Nebula and the other ships of the New Ship Program were fully ready for scale production
In regards to using the Force to crush someone's internal organs, I wouldn't be surprised if Force-users had an innate resilience against such techniques.
Force users have innate resilience against milder Force techniques such as Mind Trick and basic telekinesis, but not something relatively advanced like Force Kill (the ability to destroy a victim's organs). It is the second most advanced version of Force Grip just behind Force Crush (crushing a victim's entire body outright), requiring a lot of skill to use. Force users need to actively resist powerful Force techniques (such as the one you brought up) using their own Force reserves; otherwise they will suffer the full effects of the ability.
In the Darth Bane trilogy, Darth Bane says that all Jedi and Sith are taught how to create a Force bubble to protect themselves from Force attacks, but with our it they don’t have any innate resilience against them unless they’re species does (an example being Huts)
If it becomes harder to manipulate things the further away they are (a pretty reasonable assumption), then the defender will always have an innate advantage - you're always much closer to your internal organs than your opponent. So there would have to be quite a difference in power in order for someone's attempt to move someone else's internal organs to be able to overwhelm the defender's attempts to counteract that movement.
About those possible New-Republic-built ISDs, I would guess that most of those were either refits of captured imperial ships, or partially built hulls sitting at various shipyards... however, I think New Republic actually built brand new ISD's simply for the reason that some shipyards were set up to build those, and some shipyards would rather build their old designs than to adjust their facilities for foreign-desgned ships simply due to prestige (with KDY being the prime suspect)... this is probably why you had new MC90 (Mon Calamari/Dac), Nebulas (REC... Rothana? Fondor? Corellia? Sullust?), Republics (RSD at Rendilli) and quite possibly a few ISD-IIs (KDY at Kuat), all within roughly the same capability...
If you’re talking about the Empire, the Venator didn’t fit into the Tarkin Doctrine, and if you’re talking about the New Republic then they just didn’t have the credits or the time they would need to totally retool their ship yards while they were pretty much constantly at war
@@dogloversrule8476 yeh we know, but I do think the empire could’ve made a combat venator, they used the acclamator II for example. But I see your point
#askeck I know Kyber Crystals were mainly used to power the Super Laser on the Death Star, but were there any other elements that also helped power and canon and also, do you believe the First Order used Kyber Crystals to power Starkiller Base?
i also think using the force to affect internal organs or workings of droids and ships is something completely possible but would require a deep understanding of the workings of the particular being or machine to be possible -- the force isn't magic, it requires focus and intention so while you could undo the insides of someone or something you would have to have the knowledge of *what* it is you're affecting be it an organ or component!
#askeck What was the need for the Nebulon B? i have seen EC-Henry's imperial nebulon B and it has got be wondering. I know many were used as medical frigates, but why not use a blockade runner or a small mon calamari cruiser?
My theory about why the Alliance not using droids was that it was a PR decision. The galaxy just went through a droid war and only the bad guys use droid armies.
What also might be considered is that there probably multiple Star Destroyers in mid-production. They might have been close to completion that it would have been cheaper to complete rather than scrapping.
I believe Bib Fortuna was supposed to only have 1 Lek. It is possible to use the Force to attack someone's biology. It's used by Luke throughout the Legendsverse, usually to disable his opponents. The Nightsisters use it significantly in the Courtship of Princess Leia, especially with breaking Han's teeth. It is also used on a micro scale to heal Mon Mothma in the Jedi Academy trilogy. But in all the major instances where such techniques were used, preplanning or extra focus and control were required, making them rather impractical during the heat of battle. Even during the Vong War, it's highly likely that major shipyards like Kuat had an abundance of ISD parts and hulls. It's much more practical and efficient to simply assemble the pieces with the latest improvements than to scrap the lot at a major cost. Additionally, the New Republic (as well as Trawn, and later Pellaeon) didn't field ISDs like Palpatine or Imperial Warlords. ISDs under the Republic were often part of a larger battlegroup with additional capital ships and support craft, allowing it to fulfill niche rolls in fleet formations, and extending its service life by decades.
I really thought the anakin solo was a brand new star destroyer. I always assumed it was simply because the new Republic needed ships badly and the infrastructure to build Imperial class star destroyers was already in place and efficient.
@@hayleyglyphs, I fear must clarify. Mara in the contemplation is very certain that Kyp lacks the ability to defend against a subtle attack, and that by the time he rallies to strike back in defense he would be too physically weak to win. Most Force powers, especially those involving the mind and will may be thwarted if their opponent has enough mind and will of their own. We see this addressed by Darth Bane when discussing essence transfer in that a person with enough will could defeat a Dark Lord who made the attempt, even if that person was not Force sensitive.
Simple, the shipyards were already set up to build Star Destroyers. It was cheaper to use them as is, rather than completely redesign everything for a new format of ship model.
There’s also the fact that the New Republic was constantly at war and didn’t have the funds for the R&D process of building an entirely new ship design when there was a perfectly good one already in existence. It also was much cheaper to just updated the systems on the ISDs than to make an entirely new ship.
Regarding the last askEck question: video game Star Wars Lethal Alliance's heroine Rianna Saren was a Twi'Lek with a prosthetic mechanical Lek. So this sort of injury is survivable.
#AskEck Why did Palpatine let Dooku take on apprentices like Asajj Ventress. Doesn’t this break the Rule of Two that the Sith had followed since Bane put it in place?
I found it ridiculous that the ROTS Cross Sections listed a Venator's capacity as 192 Jedi Interceptors, considering that a fleet may only have two Jedi on the flag ship on most occasions.
#AskEck: What would of happened if Operation Domino succeeded? Do you think the Galactic Civil War would've escalated into an open war like the Clone Wars between the Empire and an organized and formal Rebel government similar to the Separatists?
The New Republic made terrible decisions. First disarming in a very dangerous galaxy, then their lack of any kind of coherent fleet strategy. Then there’s the resistance bomber, the resistance transport, etc., both of which are garbage. They create a monster ship in the Starhawk and then choose Star Destroyers?
You're mixing up your canon and legends, this video is talking about legends. They dont choose star destroyers in canon. Incidentally the resistance transport is literally cobbled together from other ships so they presumably just didnt have any options, its not an actual class of ship. Its just a makeshift ugly.
I have maybe a better question, why did the Empire start making them in the first place? They had a full fleet of Republic ships from the Clone Wars and factories already tooled up for making more.
There was a Twi´lek with a severed Lekku as the hero of a game on the Nintendo Gameboy Advanced i think... However i think she was a half-blood, a human/twi´lek mix, IIRC...
#AskEck This may or may not be a shot in the dark, but here I go. What would be your input or views regarding written Star Wars fan projects. You have said a lot about and recommended many animated fan works and films, but what would you think of one were to write a string of full length Star Wars fan novels and not just some 1-3 page fanfiction with no research behind it?
I think Coran Horn's lightsaber was pretty cool. The ability to change its length and the double tap to turn off feature... It's going a long way back but I think the blade changed colour when it changed modes when he first found it.
i know that there was the Molevelance and the Devastation. i Em a big fan of these ships. But werent there 5 super weapon/ships made by the CIS? Cen yu tell my what are the ather 3 ships or what could the ather 3 ships be? And also Why dident the empire used the Devastation ? these are my question .
They shouldn't have because large ships were on there way out so more carrier based designs would have wrecked any future battles but everybody keeps building huge ships instead of being sensible. Biggest problem with star wars is how tactics and technology keeps reversing.
The power capacities outlined in the ICS are not "ridiculous." We're talking about ships that can power drives that cross the galaxy in a day and weapons that can vaporize asteroids in a single shot and slag planetary surfaces in hours. That requires a lot of power. Minimalism is what's ridiculous.
@@johnpatz8395 but I mean imagine, JUST IMAGINE if the New Republic in canon just went ham on it? Unlike Legends where the New Republic saw star destroyers as "tyrannical symbols of oppression", imagine if canon gave the New Republic the Resurgent-class star destroyer as its main capital ship alongside the Nebula-class star destroyer against the First Order? That would've been epic while the First Order used old Imperial designs from Legends but improved them and altered their fatal flaws
@@jonnnyren6245 Yeah, on the one hand I've always wanted to say they stories are unrealistic from a military POV, but then again this wasn't a military dictatorship coming into power, and instead the bureaucrats would have taken charge, which means most of those making the decision for the military would be clueless when it comes to what the military needs and the actually best course of action. So really the bad decisions aren't really surprising. Hell, we have long had politicians canceling needed military projects and procurement, not because the items weren't needed, but to score points politically, so why would that change, just because a society was more technologically advanced then we are now. To see true cluelessness, watch any video clips where politicians pushing for more and more gun control, where they talk about firearms, and even if you know very little about firearms, it will likely be very clear to you that they have no fucking clue what they are talking about. Hell most of them, and much of the American public, still think there's actually a loophole in sales at gun shows that allows dealers to sell firearms without any sort of checks or paperwork, which is basically false. Now a lot of them know this, but push the lie to advance their agenda, but most I'm sure are just truly that clueless.
Not shield bulbs, they are long rang scanners used for targeting hence the high height. Rotj executor lost its shield from the rebel fleet concentrating fire on its bridge, not the destruction of the bulb. Richard edlund even calls them long range radars when describing the scene in the movie. Makes sense why the ssd couldn’t shoot down the A wing if they are used for targeting. Assume they are shield simple because of a succession of scenes would be a casual fallacy.
Hmmm... Didn't the New Republic in the years after they took Coruscant from the Empire also had Kuat join them as well? Therefore, it would not surprise me that the Republic kind of inherited the Empire's Star Destroyer production contracts therefore Kuat Drive Yards would continue producing Star Destroyers for the Republic due to these contracts. That plus what Eck already mentioned in this video.
Well it depends on how many they made, if we are talking about a plenty amount of them then there are many reasons why I can say if asked. If only a few then there are also a few cool ideas, either way I don’t think it’ll be super satisfying
#AskEck: After the video has done on my idea for the Arquitens Light Cruiser to be a replacement for the ISD, at least one person noted that a vote against the idea was that ISD's were more complicated and better suited due to their larger size and higher fighter count. I have thought on this, and concluded that the single biggest weakness of the ISD is the use of TIE Fighters which lack Hyperdrives, as they are unable to patrol outer areas of their system and unable to further respond to nearby systems and sectors. My question to you, Eck, is thus: Why did the Empire consider its cheap and mass produced TIE Fighter series was suited to all of its starfighter role missions? This seems to me to be a major design oversight. On paper, the Empire could see that the TIE lacked a Hyperdrive. They put it in the field with no hyperdirve. Why then, did they seem to expect the same patrol rating and coverage from the TIE as if it did have a hyperdrive?
#askeck as a crossover FanFiction writer, I was wondering how viable Warp Drives would be in the Star Wars galaxy. They’re obviously far slower than hyperdrives, but would they make traversing places like the unknown regions easier?
@@papapalps2415 Because SW Hyperspace travel relies on transferring the ship into a different dimension, in which objects in realspace still have an impact. Warp tech, as I understand it, creates a time-space bubble around a ship, which pushes it through the warped space, thus vastly increasing speed. Since places like the Unknown Regions have anomalies specifically within hyperspace, but necessarily not in realspace, it isn't outside the realm of ideas to think that Warp Technology would be more effective in those areas.
By our current understanding of mass and psychics, the concussion missile could carry a 1kiloton swan nuclear fusion warhead, with an impact force of 250 ton of TNT. = 8d10x2 dmg. Base turbolasers do 5d10x5 dmg.
@@papapalps2415 Because I was just becoming a teenager at the start of the 1990's when the expand universe novels and WEG RPG were coming out. And to increase merchandise sales of toys and books, the early novels were written with the RPG states, so after you read a Star Wars novel, you can table top play out the plot story line action with your friends. Then go buy another Star Wars novel. WotC just carried over the damage weapon rating from WEG. And after 20 out of my 43 years of life, I think along RPG abstract numbers to represent RW nuclear fusion yields. As for a trolling remark, the Star Wars Y-wing concussion missile (size/ shape/ mass) listing could hold a fusion warhead as I listed above in my first post. and for nearly the pass thirty years has the listed damage of 8d10x2 dmg. Now as for Star Trek photon torpedo you can put a man in it's shell casing and that could hold the mass of a W80 fusion warhead with a setting of 5kilotons to 150kiloton of TNT. making 8d10x10 to 8d10x300. which will turn a ISD into a little burn star in the cold void of space. Further argument is can you time the kinetic impart of such said missile at the moment of fusion expansion for extra damage. And in RPG wargaming, it isn't so much about role playing or dice roll playing, but what little bit of extra damage to can protect yourself from and hammer out on the other team of players. Also in the X-wing " Rogue Squadron " series and the novel, " .. I, ..Jedi," there are written combat scenes where a fired traveling missile was hit by ion blasters/ cannons knocking out flight control, engine thrust, and disarming the warhead, but since the projectile was traveling at speed, it just function as an over size bullet or .. dumb bomb, that still took out the opposing fighter or ground fortified location.
Cause it's a quality ship design. Some downsides, sure, but still quality.
it looks strong but every time i saw it, it got defeated very quickly, mostly by smaller ships
Venator was better in my opinion
@@rudivomschauerberg6344 it didn't had plot armour.
Superior firepower in the purest form. I just hope the Rebellion was smart enough to add in some anti star fighter guns.
@@5mowFa11 did it at least had somekind of main battery or just the small lasers that never hit anything ?
"Why did the New Republic keep making IMPERIAL STAR DESTROYERS?" ... too keep the Kuat Shipyards employed, cause the Kuat people aren't building stuff they don't design. ;^)
"Okay, Republic, we'll join you, but you also have to take over our contracts with the Empire. First, 1000 ISDIIs... "^^
That and all the infrastructure is already in place, so while a new ship design might be better/cheaper by itself, the startup cost to tool up would be a huge additional investment compared to a tweaked ISD design.
@@ATRStormUnit the "^^" at the end was like saying "You have no choice, we still get money!"
No because even the republic can't hate them they are such fine ships
@@Sivartius Also there is the wisdom from Arthur C Clarke's "Superiority". Don't fully commit to a new project until you ironed it's kinks out. Especially those that show only in large scale production&deployment. When those new designs show unexpected flaws you don't want to be caught with your proverbial pants down!
I could see it being a situation of “the ships where in a high stage of completion in the shipyard” with the later ships based on the ISD being modifications on the common and fairly cheap ISD hulls. Not to mention the manufacturing infrastructure was captured mostly intact on worlds like Kuat which would have an easier time producing ISDs instead of the various Moncalamari ships.
R&D costs money,production machinery costs money,and the New Republic captured both at zero cost from the empire.
Probably took awhile to safely an comfortably switch to the other big battleships like Mon Cals and Starhawks as well
Moreover, the galaxy is probably drowning in warehouses full of spare/redundant ISD parts. That's one thing I really like about the Canon Starhawk - it's taking advantage of preexisting materials and labor.
I agree.
The ISDs weren’t cheep at all, according to wookieepedia building just one ISD cost the annual economic output of several star systems. Also the ISDs need very large crews and where prone to mechanical problems.
I agree a fair number of ISD's the New Republic had were probably ones that had been captured more than halfway complete. When your pressed for warships finishing a half or three quarter built ship in a shipyard you just captured is far cheaper and quicker if you already have the parts available. If the fledgling New Republic had a serious shortage of in Legends it was a shortage of Capital Ships!
short answer: the rule of cool.
long answer: they probably did that so that they could make their own later on, which they did. and also because they had people from the Imperial Remnant join their ranks, some of them even had Imperial Star Destroyers, they carried out the functions and purposes they were made for very well.
It is quite simple. Half of New Republic was the Empire. ISD if used properly was a good ship and New Republic inherited lot of infrastructure based around this class. Like scrapping all ISD's was dumb interpretation of New Canon (also not actually accurate also as there were implications that some ISD's wre still used).
Also consider that they would be very cheap to make compared to other capital ships of the era due to how many had already been produced.
@@TheRezro Theres a difference between retaining existing ISD's and continuing to build more instead of more efficient modernized ships, like the Nebula.
@@lenkagamine4145 First thing they address in the video was that they DIDN'T build new ships. Just memes are confused about continues use of this class by New Republic, what in limited scale do make sense.
@@papapalps2415 Well given your name its unsurprising you woudl claim that, but its not backed up by any actual sources.
"It was designed to be able to defeat any one enemy Star Destroyer, two heavy cruisers, or an entire line of smaller Imperial support ships.[1] It mounted defenses strong enough to resist even some of the smaller Super Star Destroyers or analog warships."
"The design also incorporated a system of lateral thrust vents to increase the ship's maneuverability, giving it far greater agility than most large capital ships."
"In addition, the hull armor and shield systems of the Nebula outclassed most other ships in the galaxy, including the Republic."
"Nebulas performed well in clashes with the extra-galactic warships once they finally did see combat. Even considering its age, the Nebula-class still represented the peak of modern, efficient Star Destroyer design during the Yuuzhan Vong War."
"Although it was only 1,040 meters long (65% of the length of an Imperial-class Star Destroyer), the Nebula-class was built to be a match for an Imperial II."
"(over 20% more power than the ISD-I)"
On the contrary the ISD is not particularly focused on being a frontline brawler but is more of a very good garrison ship, owing to its sizable troop complement that enables it to launch planetary invasions as well as engaging in ship-to-ship combat.
The Nebula is DEFINITELY stronger in ship-to-ship combat while having lower crew and maintenance requirements, as well as having much better firing arcs on its weapons and less vulnerabilities.
Now regarding 'best capital ship brawlers of their size class', even that isnt correct. The Tector in terms of pure ship-to-ship combat is superior to an ISD, because it sacrifices the large ground forces and hangars for additional firepower. Obviously the ISD has more versatility, which is its main advantage; being much more versatile than a pure ship to ship brawler, given that it possesses large ground force contingents, fighters, etc.
I find the writer's lack of imagination disturbing.
Imagine spending _billions_ of dollars to purchase one of the most popular film franchises in history…and then half assing your big main trilogy.
The laziness and incompetence of these people is just fucking incredible. What an absolute waste.
@@Gunnar001 this stuff happened BEFORE Disney took over I'm sure, this is legends lore. Not Disney cannon. They mentioned Anakin Solo which was around way before Disney took over.
But yeah, Disney literally just took ISDs and put a gun on the bottom and called it a day. Not only was the super lazy it makes no damn sense form a lore point of view. Let's look at Darth Sidious's Eclipse. It was a huge damn ship was way bigger than the ISD because it needed that space to actually have a laser cannon that WASN'T AS EFFECTIVE as the Death Star cannon. It needed to be that big just to house a smaller version of it that couldn't blow up a planet but render in unhabitable. While apparently they can just take a normal ISD and slap a cannon on it and call it a day? That's BS.
@BlindingHornet yeah, that's fair, just wish these people, as in the words of BlindingHornet, "spending *billions* of dollars" would have a damn plan but didn't know what to do with the franchise and arguably ruining everything
@@zelithfang2365 First of using ISD by Republic actually did make sense, as IRL it wasn't uncommon when enemy equipment was used after the war. What didn't make sense was scrapping 25000 ISD's for ego reasons. If we want example of actual lazy it would be Xyston, where Jar Jar Abrams forget even about size of windows, rehashing model from Rogue One. Anyway it is actually Lucas Film what is responsible of Sequel fiasco as they were given free hand, except Disney forget that thy didn't make successful SW movie from the 80's and new management (hired by Lucas I remind) pick usual corporate BS with celebrate directors and ignoring the lore. Gladly Disney finally intervened and give creative control to Jon Favreau.
lol
Would’ve liked to see the Nebula Class Star Defender in canon
@Matthew R. Mendez yes indeed
It is in canon - it's just not in Disney's Star Wars.
#AskEck Would you ever consider making a video talking about how you personally would have liked the Sequels to be made if you were in charge of story writing?
i was going to ask the same question!
Same reason the French built Panther tanks for a few years after Ww2, they worked, and you have warehouses of parts.
They didn't build them so much as used recycled Panthers that were laid on the sides of French streets and only used them in parades until they built a proper French tank. In fact they did a bunch of tests to see how they could improve the Panther and they found that it was so unreliable that you might as well built a new tank instead of fixing it. They mostly used American Chaffees and Sherman tanks in their own imperial attempts to keep a hold on their colonies cause those were far more reliable and better suited then the heavy tank that was two tons lighter than an IS 2 without the armour nor firepower to go with the weight.
@@coryfice1881 yup, exactly like the Star Destroyers, use them up because they are better than nothing and basically free
@@justicar5 It's only reasonable even if it's mostly for show.
@@michaelandreipalon359 yes, while tooling up and designing an alternative they had Panther formations in the French army, I would need to look up how many, but it was a decent number Edit: 2 regiments used them, the 6eme regiment de cuirassier, and the 503e RCC, both had about a squadron, and used them until spares ran out. It was a stop gap in case the Soviets decided to kick off.
@@michaelandreipalon359 given they still have one resistance captured Panther in working condition in a museum, not really, they had very practical views on using whatever you had to kill the other guy
I mean, even Booster Terrik's ramshackle casino ISD was putting in serious work against the Yuuzhan Vong. Say what we will about the Imperator's vulnerability to snubfighters, even decades later, that class was a capital-grade slugger par excellence.
Forgot Booster's most important part of his ISD red in colour and had gravity wells
Ask Eck: Can starships “throttle” their hyper drives to different speeds or were they just on/off? It always seemed weird to me that all the Alliance ships at Endor with their different drive ratings could jump together and emerge together.
They can. I remember reading a book from Mara's perspective that the hyperdrives of the ship she was in was going at beyond it's normal level. Also it makes sense from a strategic perspective to be able to coordinate long distance jumps to finish at the same time.
I think they can, I won't pinpoint a page but I believe in Thrawn's trilogy there were some orders from the great admiral that specified hyperspace speed when moving his flagship
Slave the hyperdrives together like in the Black Fleet Crises
My guess is, because they work just fine
The ISD id a solid ship that fulfils a role on most fleet with pretty good shielding, good armour and very, very good firepower
Plus its already established, spare parts and maintenance designed to care for it already exists
It fits a role in the new republic pretty well, a main line warship that could hold its own against another of the same or bigger size. Its weakness against smaller ships could could also be covered with a few dedicated support ships of the republic or a few squadrons of X-wing independent of any carrier
So yea thats what i think
All it needed is better point defence than TIEs and a re-desinged bridge.
the only big downside is its faster than most support ships, meaning any support fleet would either have to be unusually fast to keep up, or (what actually happend) the ISD 2 would just lumber along at half throttle or something.
@@AmdUlkoinen Bridge was actually well shielded and tower actually didn't have that many people inside holding mostly infrastructure. Also ISD did have second more secured bridge, but cocky Imperial commanders commonly didn't bother to move there during the combat. If used with anti-fighter escort in intended role as Assault Ship, then it was actually quite excellent (alongside Tactor used as Battleship). Problem was that Empire did send them unescorted to patrol systems, where they could easily fall in the ambush.
For safety's sake, I'd pepper the hull with some "modern" CWIS batteries. Those laser defence turrets they come with can't hit beans.
The problem isnt so much that the ship isnt good as much as its not super efficient. Large crew size and maintenance intensive, while not having great firing arcs on alot of its weapons. A modest redesign would improve its functionality and reduce its cost at the same time.
Personally I think modifying all of the ISD's with new weapon placements (Copy the procursator optimally) and streamlined crew facilities would reduce their upkeep and improve functionality
I always assumed it was a case of there being just that many unfinished hulls and it was simpler and faster to finish them than to break them for parts and material for new ships.
Not to mention all of the production and maintenance facilities that would have to be retooled across the galaxy and the thousands of star destroyers scattered across the galaxy in various states of functionality. This isn't even getting into the fact that defected imperial command crews would have be trained to operate these vessels. For the fledgling new republic government it makes sense to leverage these and divert resources that would be wasted on setting up new military production infrastructure towards building new government institutions and programs.
It's a good design. Specifically, 'the' Star Wars design.
Makes more sense than cutting a bunch of them up to build a brand new ship tbh. Starhawk in new canon is cool but seems impractical AF.
Are you dumb? Starhawk was build as dedicated SSD killer (also it is ship from Legends). They didn't actually scrap most ISD's, especially as half of New Republic is the Empire. In fact famous Leia's ISD is specifically kept canon, even if they didn't yet confirm its faith.
@@TheRezro I think your insults are uncalled for. Starhawk is a ship from canon, built from ISD parts, and while it does have some benefits over an ISD if I remember correctly, calling it an SSD killer is ridiculous. Also your comment on scrapping most ISD's doesn't make sense, the majority of the ISD's were destroyed or escaped to the first order.
@@danielschwab4281 If you don't know what this debate is about, then don't justify future insults. Starhawk was originally mentioned in Expanded Universe. The reason why it did have this huge tractor beam in canon, was to push larger ships into planets gravity walls. That is literally the only reason why those ships were build. Most of New Republic was actually ex-Imperial and they equipment didn't magically disappear. It is just one of things we don't see off screen, like Death Star blowing up Rebellion Lucrehulk on the way to Yavin.
@@TheRezro 1. I know what your debate is about, I read EvilColeslaw's comment, and yours and I also watched the video. 2. I didn't justify future insults, I said that your insult (calling him dumb) was unneeded to make your counterpoint. 3. Starhawk being in legends has nothing to do with his statement about its inefficiency since he states he's referring to the canon. 4. If the entire point of the ship was to drag larger ships into planets then why did it need the engines of the SSD to be destroyed. 5. Even if it didn't need the engines destroyed, why did only one of the 3 Starhawks at Jakku make an effort to drag the SSD down? 6. If they were only built for SSD killing, then why were Starhawks present at battles where SSDs were not present? 7. If we don't see it offscreen, or in books, then how do we know it's a thing?
@@TheRezro Also its not from Legends. It was mentioned first in the Aftermath trilogy, which is technically EU but is Canon EU. If you're going to call someone dumb, which you never should, then get your facts straight. Any reference to a Starhawk in Legends is actually either a shuttle used around the time of the 2nd galactic civil War or two types of speeder bikes, the Starhawk and the Starhawk 2b. The ship is a Canon creation that is absolutely a cool idea that is entirely impractical. It makes no sense to waste time with the process when captured ISDs work fine. The only reason is to help PR, as the ISD is a symbol of oppression. However the legends rebellion and new Republic using it logistically makes sense, and is realistic as hell as discussion definitely took place over whether to scrap it or whatever but some bean counter, probably Borsk and his sect, decided it'd cost too much or weaken the navy for too long.
There was also a legends game for NDS and PSP called Lethal Alliance which featured a Twi'lek with a prosthetic lekku.
Because there great capital ships.
It would be like the German army denying Panthers during the Cold War era. Sure they replaced it with the Leopard, but the Panther is definitely better than throwing rocks.
Another factor could be that producing any kind of ship requires infrastructure to actually build them. A completely new design would need shipyards capable of their construction. E.g., wouldn't KDY need time and extra resources in order to re-design their production capabilities in order to transition to building other types of ships?
I actually have a book where a Dathomirean Witch actually snaps her fingers , and severs Luke Skywalkers brain and body connection he collapses to the floor ,and has to literally use all the force he can gather from the entire living jungle to save himself. He then starts to understand more about layering himself in the force. Putting up barriers to his emotions , and to his body. This is why more of the older Jedi seem to walk slower they are literally walking shields. Always prepared for anything.
Isn't that the scene where an actual rock says something like "here have my bit" and gives him a bit of Force strength. I remember reading it and going... 'yeah that might be taking it a bit too far with the Force being in everything'.
@@UnintentionalSubmarine yeah I thought so too but if you remember a lot of places where based upon more about ambience then actual life. So as to simplify good and bad.
Luke, " I always wonder what it would have been like if the Emperor or Vader just wanted me dead, ... now I know, I think I'm dying now, not good."
The Courtship of Princess Leia, 1994, yes.
A curious, but underrated book.
@@chrissonofpear1384 Actually I view THE COURTSHIP OF PRINCESS LEIA to be the fourth book in the THRAWN TRILOGY. AND it wraps up everything nicely from the Thrawn trilogy. Actually my favorite book from my childhood.
On the "Could a force user use the force on someone's body parts" - Absolutely yes. There was a Star Wars comic depicting Darth Vader targeting an Jedi Alien's heart with Force Grip directly (I don't remember the specific comic unfortunately, but it's a good example) as a form of torture. As with all things with the Force, it requires stout and competent manipulation of the Force, something Darth Vader had in spades.
You also see targeted Force manipulation used by Obi-Wan Kenobi against Anakin Skywaler/Darth Vader during their Mustafar duel in the movie novel. He momentarily disabled Anakin's robotic hand that caused Anakin to drop his Lightsaber (if you remember the scene where Anakin is without his lightsaber in the movie and charges at Obi-Wan, that's what happened even though the movie doesn't actually show the scene described in the book)
If you can't replicate the firepower and design, then reuse it for a new purpose.
Superior firepower in the purest form. I just hope the Rebellion was smart enough to add in some anti star fighter guns. Other than that if it ain't broke don't fix it. The Imperials knew how to create a ship that could destroy any capital ship with ease
@@zelithfang2365 They probably did. Han Solo commanded one.
#askeck: I just noticed in RoTS when Vader is slaughtering the separatists on Mustafar, in one brief clip (1:35:07), he appears to be in pure agony. Is this a contradiction between the novelization (where he was thoroughly enjoying it) and movie, or is there an explanation for it?
#AskEck Why didn’t the Death Star have a planetary shield onboard because it is so big? Like put the Endor sheild generator on the Death Star itself?
@Admiral Wullf Yularen But the DS was smaller than a planet which some had shields over the entire planet and the DS probrobaly had enough room on board
@Admiral Wullf Yularen ok that makes more sense for the planetary one thank you and they were definitely waaaay too arrogant as palpatine let the DS2 be discovered before completion
@@chadholzman1819 Well, in Papatine's defense, the leakage of the DS 2's construction was part of his plan to catch and eliminate all the rebels at once (it's main force at least), that's why part of the Main Imperial fleet along with Vader's flagship, the Executor were also at Endor
I could see a situation where the republic took over shipyards where many star destroyers were being built/repaired...I think it would be cheaper to finish those than building new republic designs and scrapping the imps.
8:01 - Thanks for answering my question; that really made my day! I remember reading the Young Jedi Knights series when it was coming out, and yeah -- the wacky colours they'd come up with because of the scrounged crystals they used was awesome. Lowie's bronze blade _was_ particularly awesome.
#AskEck
If blue alsers in Star Wars are better suited to taking out machinery, then why dud the Star Destroyers under The Empire switch from using Blue lasers to green? Until the Yu'Zhan Vong they didn't need to worry about biological spaceships!
My belief is that the 'new' Destroyers was retrofitted old Imperial Destroyers. Droid armies require at least factories which aren't highly mobile while being a target for the opposition.
Ironically you could prob fit a droid factory in an ISD
We have multiple examples of using the force inside another person's body, one of which you actually covered. Gethzerion actually killed an entire army of Zsinj's stormtroopers by causing brain hemorrhages. In the KotOR games, the Wound line of darkside force powers literally starts with the base power being described as causing painful spasms in the target's lungs, before going up to the Choke and Kill powers.
Then in Kotor 2 you can become a Sith Lord and use Force Crush which is op
#askeck Why did Darth Plageus fear Qiu-gon?
Probably because he was worried Qiu-Gon could get more Jedi to think like him. The Jedi were corrupted politics and the dark side. They no longer were pure vessels for the force. Unable to fully carry out it's will. Qiu-Gon was thought to be a gray Jedi by a lot of people but others scoffed at the idea saying he isn't a gray Jedi for doing what he's doing, that the Jedi were supposed to be like Qiu-Gon and he was the only one sticking to what a Jedi should be. I'm guessing if others did follow Qiu-Gon they would have realize what's been going on a sense the plot of the dark side before the clones could have been brought into the picture. No clones, no order 66, the whole plan fails.
"cos he's played by Liam Neeson
@@andyb1653 damn good point
@@herbertphillips1383 Shit, **I** saw them "Taken" movies, I'd be scared of the guy too.
Plagueis: "That dude's a F#%$ING JEDI NOW?!" **Quits Sith** "I just work at the Bank, f#%k THAT. Sheev, you're fired."
@@andyb1653 good to know, I guess?
#askeck
Why didn’t the rebels especially in the early years raid CIS outposts and get there own droid army, (not build just obtain) it wouldn’t limit them to much if they find some MTT’s ,a lucrehulk or any “Large” ship to transport them
Good string capital ship, and the infrastructure is already in place for building and maintaining them I would imagine
Cuz numerous shipyards were already configured to manufacture these ships?
#askeck
In ROTS when Cody and Obi are talking, there's a ship in the Venator's hanger that kinda resembles a Battlestar, any clue what that is?
I take it back, the HAET-221. Watched one of your vids on hidden ships in ROTS and realized that's what I was talking about. Just didn't recognize it cause in the hanger you see it from the front, and the best shot of it is in the rear.
I think the reason they used them was mostly as a deterrent, similar to the Tarkin Doctrine but with more peaceful intentions in mind.
Just imagine how terrifying it would be for pirates and other outlaws to run into an ISD expecting to mow down a few TIEs, only for a squadron of black X-Wings and A-Wings to fly out of it instead.
With the question about using the Force inside someone’s body-
It’s possible, but difficult. The Force and the various abilities that are possible through it rely largely on the ability of the mind to decide what it wants and believe that it’s possible. For the first part, you need to have a firm picture in your mind of what you want to do. This is one reason Jedi use hand motions while using powers like persuade or push - it helps them visualize the end result.the physical motion itself helps focus the mind, but isn’t intrinsically necessary.
For the second part, you have to actually know what you’re doing is possible and rely on intense focus to prevent intrusive thoughts or doubt from interfering with the ability. For example, Yoda and Luke’s favorite exchange: “I don’t believe it!” “That is why you fail.” The Force can do basically do anything you believe it can, so long as that belief is strong enough to put aside doubts.
So using the Force inside a body would likely require two things. The first is a reasonable knowledge of the anatomy in question, to help you visualize the target area and what you want to happen. The second is that you know for a fact that it’s possible to do what you want to do.
Bardan Jusik (SPOILERS FOR REPUBLIC COMMANDO NOVELS) uses the Force to heal brain damage at one point. I don’t recall the phrasing, but it was involved.
I appreciate the video segmentation!
If I'm remembering correctly there's the odd mention of the New Republic finishing Star Destroyers under construction when they took shipyards like Kuat. Kuat's legends page on wookiepedia actually specifically mentions that during the Yuuzhan Vong war that KDY produced many ships for the NR during the Vong war especially Star Destroyers. This could have been where I got confused about a throwaway line and it doesn't _specifically_ say the new SDs were Imperial class rather than Nebula for example. It would make sense to however to continue building ISDs from Imperial shipyards, they already have the assembly lines and processes for mass production of ISDs whereas for example the Mon Calamari Cruisers would have involved a significant retraining, retooling and reorganisation.
As well, I seem to remember reading about the Nebula being much more expensive than an ISD? It could make sense to continue producing ISDs until the Nebula and the other ships of the New Ship Program were fully ready for scale production
In regards to using the Force to crush someone's internal organs, I wouldn't be surprised if Force-users had an innate resilience against such techniques.
Force users have innate resilience against milder Force techniques such as Mind Trick and basic telekinesis, but not something relatively advanced like Force Kill (the ability to destroy a victim's organs). It is the second most advanced version of Force Grip just behind Force Crush (crushing a victim's entire body outright), requiring a lot of skill to use. Force users need to actively resist powerful Force techniques (such as the one you brought up) using their own Force reserves; otherwise they will suffer the full effects of the ability.
In the Darth Bane trilogy, Darth Bane says that all Jedi and Sith are taught how to create a Force bubble to protect themselves from Force attacks, but with our it they don’t have any innate resilience against them unless they’re species does (an example being Huts)
If it becomes harder to manipulate things the further away they are (a pretty reasonable assumption), then the defender will always have an innate advantage - you're always much closer to your internal organs than your opponent. So there would have to be quite a difference in power in order for someone's attempt to move someone else's internal organs to be able to overwhelm the defender's attempts to counteract that movement.
Considering Mon Mothma is a pacifist in canon she’d be going insane that she had a warship named after her
Same with Anakin Solo Jacen's Flagship
@@aleccampbell7707 yes
I think you're thinking of Elegos A'kla, not Mon Mothma.
Ah, Young Jedi Knights will also be cannon to me.
About those possible New-Republic-built ISDs, I would guess that most of those were either refits of captured imperial ships, or partially built hulls sitting at various shipyards... however, I think New Republic actually built brand new ISD's simply for the reason that some shipyards were set up to build those, and some shipyards would rather build their old designs than to adjust their facilities for foreign-desgned ships simply due to prestige (with KDY being the prime suspect)... this is probably why you had new MC90 (Mon Calamari/Dac), Nebulas (REC... Rothana? Fondor? Corellia? Sullust?), Republics (RSD at Rendilli) and quite possibly a few ISD-IIs (KDY at Kuat), all within roughly the same capability...
Never seen such a big video with so few dislikes good job
#askeck Why haven't you done a video on the Vindicator-class Heavy Cruiser yet?
'cos it's just a miniature ISD, doesn't really have anything unique about it.
I could see them building ISDs for at least the short term as it takes a while to retool factories and shipyards and they still had battles to fight.
Wish they’d remake the Venator.
Same
If you’re talking about the Empire, the Venator didn’t fit into the Tarkin Doctrine, and if you’re talking about the New Republic then they just didn’t have the credits or the time they would need to totally retool their ship yards while they were pretty much constantly at war
@@dogloversrule8476 yeh we know, but I do think the empire could’ve made a combat venator, they used the acclamator II for example. But I see your point
Because their very affective warships it would actually be stupid not to use them.
I mean if you already have one, sure, why not use them. But if you are going to make one there are far better options.
@@VoicesOfNihil Like what?
@@papapalps2415 Huh?
@@SunSheepOfLight Mon Calamari cruisers, for example
@@papapalps2415 Mon Calamari cruisers, for example
I think the better question would be; why would the Sith fleet, or whatever the referred to themselves, stick with design but upsized?
@Alexander Pate With that level of cheapness, I'd even settle for an ISD photoshopped to look different.
@Alexander Pate How could I have forgotten?
#askeck I know Kyber Crystals were mainly used to power the Super Laser on the Death Star, but were there any other elements that also helped power and canon and also, do you believe the First Order used Kyber Crystals to power Starkiller Base?
i also think using the force to affect internal organs or workings of droids and ships is something completely possible but would require a deep understanding of the workings of the particular being or machine to be possible -- the force isn't magic, it requires focus and intention so while you could undo the insides of someone or something you would have to have the knowledge of *what* it is you're affecting be it an organ or component!
#askeck
What was the need for the Nebulon B? i have seen EC-Henry's imperial nebulon B and it has got be wondering. I know many were used as medical frigates, but why not use a blockade runner or a small mon calamari cruiser?
My theory about why the Alliance not using droids was that it was a PR decision. The galaxy just went through a droid war and only the bad guys use droid armies.
What also might be considered is that there probably multiple Star Destroyers in mid-production. They might have been close to completion that it would have been cheaper to complete rather than scrapping.
I believe Bib Fortuna was supposed to only have 1 Lek.
It is possible to use the Force to attack someone's biology. It's used by Luke throughout the Legendsverse, usually to disable his opponents. The Nightsisters use it significantly in the Courtship of Princess Leia, especially with breaking Han's teeth. It is also used on a micro scale to heal Mon Mothma in the Jedi Academy trilogy. But in all the major instances where such techniques were used, preplanning or extra focus and control were required, making them rather impractical during the heat of battle.
Even during the Vong War, it's highly likely that major shipyards like Kuat had an abundance of ISD parts and hulls. It's much more practical and efficient to simply assemble the pieces with the latest improvements than to scrap the lot at a major cost. Additionally, the New Republic (as well as Trawn, and later Pellaeon) didn't field ISDs like Palpatine or Imperial Warlords. ISDs under the Republic were often part of a larger battlegroup with additional capital ships and support craft, allowing it to fulfill niche rolls in fleet formations, and extending its service life by decades.
#BattleBreakdown
- Carrack light cruiser vs Arquitens light cruiser
- MC80 Home one Type vs MC80 Liberty Type
I really thought the anakin solo was a brand new star destroyer. I always assumed it was simply because the new Republic needed ships badly and the infrastructure to build Imperial class star destroyers was already in place and efficient.
Assuming I remember right, in the Darth Vader comics he used the force to crush a jedis heart when he was trying to get information from him
Mara Jade contemplates pinching Kyp Durron's jugular and giving him a stroke in one of the first five books of the New Jedi Order novels.
i would too
@@hayleyglyphs, I fear must clarify. Mara in the contemplation is very certain that Kyp lacks the ability to defend against a subtle attack, and that by the time he rallies to strike back in defense he would be too physically weak to win.
Most Force powers, especially those involving the mind and will may be thwarted if their opponent has enough mind and will of their own. We see this addressed by Darth Bane when discussing essence transfer in that a person with enough will could defeat a Dark Lord who made the attempt, even if that person was not Force sensitive.
Simple, the shipyards were already set up to build Star Destroyers. It was cheaper to use them as is, rather than completely redesign everything for a new format of ship model.
There’s also the fact that the New Republic was constantly at war and didn’t have the funds for the R&D process of building an entirely new ship design when there was a perfectly good one already in existence. It also was much cheaper to just updated the systems on the ISDs than to make an entirely new ship.
There was a video game for the DS that you played as a Twi'lek bounty hunter who had cybernetic lekku.
Regarding the last askEck question: video game Star Wars Lethal Alliance's heroine Rianna Saren was a Twi'Lek with a prosthetic mechanical Lek. So this sort of injury is survivable.
In Thrawns Revenge the only Imperial Star Destroyer I ever had in the New Republic is that Red one. That’s it
Errant Venture
@@greatskytrollantidrama4473 Yep. Other then that it’s them other Star Destroyers including the Venator ones if you add the Sub Mod in it
@@michaelandreipalon359 indeed
@MarkTheMeat no mark. You see there’s a sub mod you can use to Build venators for the New Republic if you get Kuat support influence maxed out.
@MarkTheMeat Yes. You need to have Thrawns Revenge to get the sub mod
On the "Can they crush organs" question: Yes they can. Vader used that as a torture method, squeezing someone`s heart, in one of the comics (Legends).
I think Jacen Solo also did something like this when he was interrogating Boba Fetts daughter in Legacy of the Force
@@dogloversrule8476 I think you are right, it`s been a while since I read that book but he crushed her brain or something.
#AskEck Why did Palpatine let Dooku take on apprentices like Asajj Ventress. Doesn’t this break the Rule of Two that the Sith had followed since Bane put it in place?
I found it ridiculous that the ROTS Cross Sections listed a Venator's capacity as 192 Jedi Interceptors, considering that a fleet may only have two Jedi on the flag ship on most occasions.
#askeck
Why did the B-Wings in the movies not use the four point laser that was seen in Star Wars rebels?
#AskEck: What would of happened if Operation Domino succeeded? Do you think the Galactic Civil War would've escalated into an open war like the Clone Wars between the Empire and an organized and formal Rebel government similar to the Separatists?
The New Republic made terrible decisions. First disarming in a very dangerous galaxy, then their lack of any kind of coherent fleet strategy. Then there’s the resistance bomber, the resistance transport, etc., both of which are garbage. They create a monster ship in the Starhawk and then choose Star Destroyers?
You're mixing up your canon and legends, this video is talking about legends. They dont choose star destroyers in canon.
Incidentally the resistance transport is literally cobbled together from other ships so they presumably just didnt have any options, its not an actual class of ship. Its just a makeshift ugly.
They demilitarised in Canon, but in the old EU they were constantly at war and Starhawks didn’t exist.
I can understand it by the ISD being T-72 and it's modification being something like PT-91(Modification of T-72 by Poland).
Video Idea: Commando Droids vs ODSTs(Star Wars vs Halo)
Tenel Ka's rancor tooth hilt was always one of my favorite lightsaber designs.
One of the NJO books implied that is was possible to pinch an artery shut, but it was used to troll a Jedi who was pretty awful with telekinesis.
The main character of star wars lethal alliance, Rianna Saren has a prosthetic lekku
I have maybe a better question, why did the Empire start making them in the first place? They had a full fleet of Republic ships from the Clone Wars and factories already tooled up for making more.
I recall there being one twilek character with a mechanical prosthetic lekku.
#askeck
Do all New Republic starfighters have hyperdrives?
#AskEck #AskEck How would your Starwars multirole Capital Ship be .Don't use existing ones please make your own: )
There was a Twi´lek with a severed Lekku as the hero of a game on the Nintendo Gameboy Advanced i think...
However i think she was a half-blood, a human/twi´lek mix, IIRC...
Because the parts are standard and common?
#AskEck This may or may not be a shot in the dark, but here I go. What would be your input or views regarding written Star Wars fan projects. You have said a lot about and recommended many animated fan works and films, but what would you think of one were to write a string of full length Star Wars fan novels and not just some 1-3 page fanfiction with no research behind it?
I think Coran Horn's lightsaber was pretty cool. The ability to change its length and the double tap to turn off feature... It's going a long way back but I think the blade changed colour when it changed modes when he first found it.
Not sure if you mentioned it, but already having the industry and machinery to make Isd’s has to help. Definitely would make production cheaper
i know that there was the Molevelance and the Devastation. i Em a big fan of these ships. But werent there 5 super weapon/ships made by the CIS? Cen yu tell my what are the ather 3 ships or what could the ather 3 ships be? And also Why dident the empire used the Devastation ? these are my question .
They shouldn't have because large ships were on there way out so more carrier based designs would have wrecked any future battles but everybody keeps building huge ships instead of being sensible.
Biggest problem with star wars is how tactics and technology keeps reversing.
The power capacities outlined in the ICS are not "ridiculous." We're talking about ships that can power drives that cross the galaxy in a day and weapons that can vaporize asteroids in a single shot and slag planetary surfaces in hours. That requires a lot of power. Minimalism is what's ridiculous.
Imagine if the New Republic got both the Resurgent-class and Nebula-class star destroyers in the sequel trilogy.
They did, but sadly they were all orbiting the capital when the planet was destroyed. 😂
@@johnpatz8395 so the Nebula-class star destroyer is confirmed canon then?
@@jonnnyren6245 no idea, it was a joke. 😀
@@johnpatz8395 but I mean imagine, JUST IMAGINE if the New Republic in canon just went ham on it? Unlike Legends where the New Republic saw star destroyers as "tyrannical symbols of oppression", imagine if canon gave the New Republic the Resurgent-class star destroyer as its main capital ship alongside the Nebula-class star destroyer against the First Order?
That would've been epic while the First Order used old Imperial designs from Legends but improved them and altered their fatal flaws
@@jonnnyren6245 Yeah, on the one hand I've always wanted to say they stories are unrealistic from a military POV, but then again this wasn't a military dictatorship coming into power, and instead the bureaucrats would have taken charge, which means most of those making the decision for the military would be clueless when it comes to what the military needs and the actually best course of action. So really the bad decisions aren't really surprising.
Hell, we have long had politicians canceling needed military projects and procurement, not because the items weren't needed, but to score points politically, so why would that change, just because a society was more technologically advanced then we are now.
To see true cluelessness, watch any video clips where politicians pushing for more and more gun control, where they talk about firearms, and even if you know very little about firearms, it will likely be very clear to you that they have no fucking clue what they are talking about.
Hell most of them, and much of the American public, still think there's actually a loophole in sales at gun shows that allows dealers to sell firearms without any sort of checks or paperwork, which is basically false. Now a lot of them know this, but push the lie to advance their agenda, but most I'm sure are just truly that clueless.
Not shield bulbs, they are long rang scanners used for targeting hence the high height. Rotj executor lost its shield from the rebel fleet concentrating fire on its bridge, not the destruction of the bulb. Richard edlund even calls them long range radars when describing the scene in the movie. Makes sense why the ssd couldn’t shoot down the A wing if they are used for targeting. Assume they are shield simple because of a succession of scenes would be a casual fallacy.
Hmmm... Didn't the New Republic in the years after they took Coruscant from the Empire also had Kuat join them as well? Therefore, it would not surprise me that the Republic kind of inherited the Empire's Star Destroyer production contracts therefore Kuat Drive Yards would continue producing Star Destroyers for the Republic due to these contracts. That plus what Eck already mentioned in this video.
Well it depends on how many they made, if we are talking about a plenty amount of them then there are many reasons why I can say if asked.
If only a few then there are also a few cool ideas, either way I don’t think it’ll be super satisfying
Well they inherited most if not all the infrastructure for building star destroyers from the empire. So it makes perfect sense.
Because they're badass.
#AskEck Will you ever do an analysis on anything from the Mobile Suit Gundam series?
I mean sure its a good ship but by the time first order came along, the classical star destroyer became obsolete.
#AskEck:
After the video has done on my idea for the Arquitens Light Cruiser to be a replacement for the ISD, at least one person noted that a vote against the idea was that ISD's were more complicated and better suited due to their larger size and higher fighter count. I have thought on this, and concluded that the single biggest weakness of the ISD is the use of TIE Fighters which lack Hyperdrives, as they are unable to patrol outer areas of their system and unable to further respond to nearby systems and sectors.
My question to you, Eck, is thus: Why did the Empire consider its cheap and mass produced TIE Fighter series was suited to all of its starfighter role missions? This seems to me to be a major design oversight. On paper, the Empire could see that the TIE lacked a Hyperdrive. They put it in the field with no hyperdirve. Why then, did they seem to expect the same patrol rating and coverage from the TIE as if it did have a hyperdrive?
Generation Films
#askeck What are you thoughts on if Thrawn appears in the Ashoka live series, would he hire Cad Bane to go after/eliminate her?
#AskEckhart: could you do a video on the rather unique ISD II, the Errant Venture?
When will you do more battle breakdowns?
#askeck as a crossover FanFiction writer, I was wondering how viable Warp Drives would be in the Star Wars galaxy. They’re obviously far slower than hyperdrives, but would they make traversing places like the unknown regions easier?
@@papapalps2415 Because SW Hyperspace travel relies on transferring the ship into a different dimension, in which objects in realspace still have an impact. Warp tech, as I understand it, creates a time-space bubble around a ship, which pushes it through the warped space, thus vastly increasing speed. Since places like the Unknown Regions have anomalies specifically within hyperspace, but necessarily not in realspace, it isn't outside the realm of ideas to think that Warp Technology would be more effective in those areas.
Kuat Drive Yards bad a lot of half built Star Destroyers and needed to sell them.
#askeck
How powerful do you think proton torpedos, concussion missiles etc actually are in comparison to turbolasers
By our current understanding of mass and psychics, the concussion missile could carry a 1kiloton swan nuclear fusion warhead, with an impact force of 250 ton of TNT. = 8d10x2 dmg.
Base turbolasers do 5d10x5 dmg.
@@papapalps2415 Because I was just becoming a teenager at the start of the 1990's when the expand universe novels and WEG RPG were coming out. And to increase merchandise sales of toys and books, the early novels were written with the RPG states, so after you read a Star Wars novel, you can table top play out the plot story line action with your friends. Then go buy another Star Wars novel.
WotC just carried over the damage weapon rating from WEG. And after 20 out of my 43 years of life, I think along RPG abstract numbers to represent RW nuclear fusion yields.
As for a trolling remark, the Star Wars Y-wing concussion missile (size/ shape/ mass) listing could hold a fusion warhead as I listed above in my first post. and for nearly the pass thirty years has the listed damage of 8d10x2 dmg.
Now as for Star Trek photon torpedo you can put a man in it's shell casing and that could hold the mass of a W80 fusion warhead with a setting of 5kilotons to 150kiloton of TNT. making 8d10x10 to 8d10x300. which will turn a ISD into a little burn star in the cold void of space.
Further argument is can you time the kinetic impart of such said missile at the moment of fusion expansion for extra damage. And in RPG wargaming, it isn't so much about role playing or dice roll playing, but what little bit of extra damage to can protect yourself from and hammer out on the other team of players.
Also in the X-wing " Rogue Squadron " series and the novel, " .. I, ..Jedi," there are written combat scenes where a fired traveling missile was hit by ion blasters/ cannons knocking out flight control, engine thrust, and disarming the warhead, but since the projectile was traveling at speed, it just function as an over size bullet or .. dumb bomb, that still took out the opposing fighter or ground fortified location.
#ASKECK what's your favorite Star Wars movie