Brides and Brothels: The Rohingya Trade | 101 East | दुल्हन और वेश्यालय
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 мар 2018
- They have survived rape and the slaughter of their families. Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya girls and women fled Myanmar to escape a military crackdown.
In Bangladesh's refugee camps they thought they would be safe. But inside the tents that house almost a million Rohingya refugees, women and girls are being bought, sold and given away.
Girls are being forced into marriage because relatives can't afford to feed them, or are being lured to brothels with the promise of good jobs. We investigate the dangers still facing Rohingya women, and meet the people seeking to exploit them.
Follow 101 East here:
Facebook: / 101east
Twitter: / aj101east
Instagram: / aj101east
Homepage: aljazeera.com/programmes/101east
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
#AlJazeeraEnglish #101East #RohingyaRefugees 
Развлечения
When the father in law said we have no one to take care of us - did anyone else think what about your young healthy son - perfect person to look after his own parents. 🤔
what's the point when they can just get someone else's young daughter to do it, this is just horrible how these father's are setting their own daughters up for failure.
It is just too sad
It's consider as shame in some culture to make their son manage the house. Man are supposed to earn for the family and women on the other takes charges of the dusting and cleaning of the house and many more.
Anjali when they said take care means do housework not earn money for them
right! they give away daughters who would happily work at home and take care of their own parents and then complain no one is around to take care of them and buy a daughter in law?!! definition of insanity
"There's no benefit in keeping girls" my heart hurts 😢😢😢
I know, sometimes i feel like I’m not lucky but when i see these kind of videos I realize that I’m lucky I’m not in a situation like this. I feel sad for her.
These men are hypocrites! First they claim there is no sense in keeping girls but then they say they need someone to take care of them! Women do SO MUCH for the family unit including taking care of elders, raising the children, cooking, cleaning and keeping order in the house yet these men claim that they’re just useless baggage, how wrong they are! 😠
Any comments for the country Myanmar that killed raped n cleansed them
@@Coelacantha
If you really wanna blame someone, blame Myanmar government who destroyed their houses and made them Refugees to another country. Same what the israelis did with the palestinians.
Title of this video gives reply to all your questions. In rich countries daughters can earn bread for the parents because they can go out and they feel safe. In poor countries girls are not safe even in their own house, here you are are talking about refugees from another country.
If you really care for them then tell your government or foreign Ministers who always talks about bombing muslim countries for stooping oil tunkers and same time they visit dictators for negotiations.
To do something for ROHINGYAS, PALESTINIANS,
KASHMIR’S,
UGHYUR'S,
Let's not judge them they saw their daughters and wives raped and killed in Myanmar. They have big families, living under the poverty line as refugees are not easy. They are living in a country where they are not welcomed. If you are pushed to the wall under hunger, dangers and your daughters might get rapped getting older, what else choice they have? The basic need for protection, shelter, and food takes precedence over women rights.
Fatima: crying and hysterical and don't want to get married
Her relatives: quarreling and shouting about the bride's makeup
WHAT ON EARTH?!!!
This is how it is tbh
The biggest problem is using Islam to get rid of their daughter... Shame on this kind of thinking
Ini laorang rohenya beranak saja suda lamisikin kawin paksa macm binatang
Exactly..use islam when it fts ..horrific
So much cruelty in this world
The girl is so beautiful and the groom is so ugly
@@newfilmtrailer7733 no you are absolutely wrong.. you are filled with hate & abusive words.. Mohammed is a mercy & law giver...
this is depressing. it isn't easy to be a girl on this planet.
RR TT not on this planet but in this religion.
Religion is for men.
Men are not for religion.
Your pretty safe in the USA. Stop whining & get off the cross. We need the wood.
@@shawnshipstad739 depends on where you live. However, you are right. I would still feel safer here than being in some countries where Westerners are only liked because of the money the tourist industry provides.
nope. wherever you are in world, women are still unsafe
Watching the poor girl cried so hard and everyone is ignoring her plea is just so nerve wrecking. I wish she is doing alright now. 😢😢😢
rohingiyas should be given asylum IN OIL RICH MUSLIM countries
Its the muslim way......
Dominic Leite.... where & when budhist girl raped,,,, it's not the just u think.
thanks for your wishes now go focus on your problems
Melissa Suansing 😢😢 really disappointing story
The image of that burnt boy is what killed me the most. The shock and calmness, how could this happen to a child and yet, no one stops such horrific actions from taking place.
Her life isn´t about "to change". Her life is about to end.
If this father didn't get terrorized and kicked out of his own village, he wouldn't have taken this decision, I don't agree with him as in Islam woman should agree to the marriyand not be forced to one, But I get his concerns, he thinks it's a better life at least she'll have a solid roof on top of her rather than living in the camps why she could get kidnapped anytime to be forced to work in Adultery or even worse
@@mihar8bess So there is an excuse for selling your daughter to a man she doesn´t want, therefore she will be raped in marriage to avoid "adultery", which means rape?
@@martinaskupin9549 Place yourself with a mother whose girl has been kidnapped and raped then you might know the mindset of Fatima Parents' they are wrong at certain places but their intentions might not
@@Mominaspirant t
iamsadthiswillneuerstop
liz rahim
@@Mominaspirant
Mindset? Those parents are equally repulsive as the attackers for sending their daughters and children through forced marriage.
Wow this hurts so much. I complain about my life and the stupidest things but this is really happening to young girls. Be so fortunate for everything you have. 😣❤️
@Line snap I'm pretty sure it is be thankful for your blessings man
It breaks my heart to see her being sent off against her will. She's just a child... :'(
anything against the will is evil
Arlen Dones she was asked three times and she didn't say no. According to science they are not child. Should it matter if she is a child or adult? It should t because forced marriages is a son in Islam whether she is child or adult or older no woman can be forced into marriage.
If we keep saying child child then tomorrow they will let child grow into adult and then force her into marriage
I can understand who is running these camps and where is camp security?
@@struth4873 She said "yes" under duress, it's pretty obvious. She new that she would have to face horrible consequences if she said no.
No one has even bothered to find out if she’s ok. How sadistic
The father says he’s scared of the boys who may take her away and that would be “shameful for me.” Ahh so it’s about YOU and YOUR reputation.
Wtf he means that they will rape her
It is always about the men. I am discussed.
Social culture & stigma are very cruel in subcontinent, this father has no way against this disgusting system.He just wants or try to give her child a shelter,He is incapable of overcome this situation so he just wish that his child shoud not face rape,&rape trauma.
Dr.nadia tamanna no, this is an absolutely horrible and disgusting of a father who doesn’t care about his daughter getting raped, but instead about it embarrassing him.
@@michelleajordan8912
Their pa and ma and relatives are worse than trash for sending girls and children through forced marriage
This Father is misinterpreting Shari'ah .
No marriage is permitted without the permission of
Bride in Shari'ah
It's all there in your holy books dude..
True he is a coward,dayus.
Ever heard of the name SAFIYA, one of the wives of Muhammad? She lost her everything in Banu Qurayza massacre which is done by Muhammad & co.
She was taken by Muhammad as war-prisoner slave, later Muhammad married her. So, do you think, getting married with the murderer of your family can be a genuine CONSENSUAL thing??
Or do you think, Aisha has the sense of opinion regarding her marriage with Muhammad in the age of only SIX??
What is Shari'ah? Qur'an and the life of Muhammad.. isn’t it?
So, here, the true definition of SUNNAH is- to take the illegal advantage of your power in every possible way and to justify this using the name of GOD.
Do not put your moderated-humanitarian view here in the name of Shari'ah. Do not SUGARCOAT this barbaric medieval 'way of life'.
@@tariqulislam2687 It was genuinely consensual, and also Muhammad did not marry Aisha at 9 years old according to the context of the hadiths.
@@tariqulislam2687 Also, even if Muhammad married Aisha at 9, it was not a sexual relationship, it was for building relationships with other families. Muhammad only had 5 children from Khadijah, and one child from another woman. So don't sugarcoat the facts with lies
The one ray of hope in this video was the mom who bust down the door, to save her daughter.
Amen sister.
Bikin takut menusia tidakberfikir mau makan ap begitu banyak anak beranak saja tapi tiada pekerjaan yag tetap selangkaan kan saja mau ingat
Ada yag ji jadi palacur
Mimang orang rohenya jantan tukang pelogordi malasia juga diorangini bikin takut mimang pelogor
Polis pun tiada guna rasuah
"We're afraid of our brothers and fathers." - That says it all, what kind of men they are.
lts the rotten culture. Are the women kidnapping & trading the girls their brothers and fathers?
A. Xander nope..she said they are afraid of their fathers and brothers because of male domination..in most of Asian countries girls /women do not have any right to take decision for themselves..they have to follow their elders
So you'd deny that this forced marriage happens in the middle east as well?
Channy Walker according to their culture, afraid means respect. It's a family code that sons remain obedient to their parents. As a matter of fact, also think, what else her parents can do for her while she's not safe at their hand?
This is typical Asian family where children fears their parents and elders. Whether a boy or girl, they can't disagree with their parents and elder brothers decision.
5:18 i can't imagine the pain that little boy got😭😢
Religion, illiteracy, poverty, lack of respect for others is a deadly combination.
Yes, but it's the Myanmar who is destroying their life
Yes you are right
Well ssid, religion is prime reason
Not really, all of the things done against the Rohingya women is forbidden in islam tbh
@@redsenior7373
Not women, the girls and children should be our priority
As a mother, it hurt me deeply to my soul to hear that child/teen cry out to her mother asking why. I don't think I could ever do this to my baby.
NativeHoney81334 never !!! It hurts me even more because I have 3 girls
NativeHoney81334
I know that I would never do this to my child or any one no matter how poor we were ,it is just pure evil and brainwashing and disgusting in every way.
Yes true. Im so sad too.
What i get from this is Men as a whole.suck
..
@@storyteller6418 But it is the female relatives who ignored Fatima's plea for help. They are more concerned with the leftover makeup than Fatima's cries. It is also the female relatives who were dancing and celebrating this underage marriage. It is also women who kidnapped Jahara and tried to sell her into slavery.
Having seen this documentary featuring evil women and men, how did you come to the conclusion that "Men as a whole.suck"?
The ladies more worried about who gets the makeup sickening
Terrible!!!! how this people act, what kind of gritty mentality this humans have.
It makes my heart hurt so much when I think about this tremendous inequality. First they refuse to educate the girls and then they say they are useless 😭😭😭 The girls could have made world best doctors, attorneys, engineers, researchers, politicians but they are not even given a chance. Something gotta change
True and the thing is in islam,though on paper women might have been given respect,reality is different,women are not allowed to work some not allowed to be educated,and they don't let them work or study and tell the girls and women they are a burden
In this situations??
You think their men have it better? I wish the ignorant would just shut up!
Donate money instead of crying.
@@lotuseater3287 we do both
“Where are you going to send me, mum?” Ohh poor baby, my heart breaks for u😭
It's so hard 😥😥😥
😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😓😭😭😭😭
Those families will pay for this
They don't need a daughter in law, they need a slave. 😠
Azi Aira
Arabs are no different
@Adnan Khan
Agreed brother
Yes,they need a house maid,😭😭😭😭😭😭poor girl
@Adnan Khan For real it's so painful 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Poor sweet young girl. It's her culture
Nothing is crueler than we human. In this earth
True! And sad.
@Prince Vegeta
Islam has nothing to do with that
You mean third world Muslim societies.
Heart wrenching !!!!!!I am 28 years old and I am still not ready for marriage.... my heart ache for this girl who is just 15......
Excuse me! which country you belong?
Marry me i am ready
How’s the wall dear?
@@solanking1456😂
@@nagmaparveen5608 yes nagma are you interested?
Her father... wow I cannot express the pity I have for this poor girl and others who have the misfortune of calling things like him their parent. Not one time did anything he had to say was because he put his daughter first - it was all about him not being shamed, not having to provide for her etc.
I worry about my life, but then situations like these humble me and help me to remember that I am very fortunate. To think this is happening just half a world away is unbelievable. If I were that reporter, I don't know how I would manage to leave that place without stealing Fatima away. I'm so sorry.
Danicka Addams 😪😪yes I thought even like that oh my God we are lucky I will never complain about anything from now on I live in America thank God
Why do you think it is "unbelievable"? What will it take to convince you that muslim cultures do not consider women and girls as fully human? Their koran tells them that a woman has half the value of a man, and that her husband has the right to beat her and divorce her at will. He can have three other wives besides, and he is the owner of her children. Their ideology states that women are property to be used, abused and disposed of at will.
@@theinkbrain so does the bible, and in poorer countries like the Catholic Philippines, you can see how the same views of women are in play. All religion was created at a time when women were not thought of as mentally or physically capable. 🙍🏽
@@theinkbrain No, no, no and no. This is not correct information on islam. People in this video are not doing the right thing according to islam (and it is the followers fault not the religions), the person that is marrying has to want it and nobody (including the girl's brothers and father) can force her to marry somebody she doesnt want to. Even if they are starving as the dad said in the video it is not acceptable. It is the girls right to choose when and whom to marry. And about the sentences in quran where it says man can beat the women and marry up to 4 women, you need to make sure you research about those ayahs(a small section of the quran, a sentence basically) properly, because those ayahs are talking about spesipic stiuations that happen once in a millon. Its like a guide when you are stuck in a stiuation that makes you fill with anger that you feel like you will be able to kill somebody. You can look for it on youtube nouman ali khan explains it nicely but i am not an expert so i dont want to give false information.
And about the multiple wife ayah, it is adviced strongly to marry a single woman because it would be really hard for the husband to make justice for all his wives and that is what many people do in most of the islamic countries. But it is true that men are alloved to mary up to 4 women if they respect everyones rights and make sure there is justice among them. But its a huge responsibility for the man, its not like a wonderland where he can relax and be with whichever wife he wants to be, and beat whoever he wants to. So, before making statements that are making islam seem like something it isnt i would suggest you to research further and compare your findings to the western culture that you are admiring to because islam, if liven truely is something really beautiful and so much better than western culture that we are forced to accept. Hopefully you read this till the end cause it wasnt easy to right this long. :) Have a nice day.
This is why I want to adopt a child because they are not living a good life and they should be
Why even have children, when you'll ultimately give them away, because she is "one last mouth to feed"? WTF?
They had everything when they are having kids. After that Burmese military stole their land, makes them refugee.
it's not like they decide to have all those kids, they don't have access to contraceptions and pregnancy is unavoidable
@@x7yo7x thank god someone has a mind to use it. I was wondering why so many are asking these same questions but one really seems to realise or even mention CONTRACEPTION GOSH!
If this father didn't get terrorized and kicked out of his own village, he wouldn't have taken this decision, I don't agree with him as in Islam woman should agree to the marriyand not be forced to one, But I get his concerns, he thinks it's a better life at least she'll have a solid roof on top of her rather than living in the camps why she could get kidnapped anytime to be forced to work in Adultery or even worse
@Boi Nonsense
They have no choice, they are refugees.
It breaks my heart.
My father wasn't a perfect father, but he always protect his daughters, give the best education, and always try to provide anything we like...
Mom: Why are u so sad I will buy everything that u want
Daughter: Buy me freedom
@Ganga Din
What?
@Ganga Din
How is freedom blasphemy?
@Ganga Din
That's just a name lol
@Ganga Din
Your a lost plot seriously get lost
@Ganga Din
It is not. I'm muslim, and does my family force me to be a muslim? No. Do they punish me if I don't/forget to pray? No. Don't just judge people.
So, they get married to become a maid for the in laws. Depressing.
Bengalis also do that
What
The father was ashamed of probable shame while the father in law needed a maid to be taken care because of he was getting old. UN-imaginable.
Ursula. M no but because their villages and houses burned by Myanmar’s Buddhism government
Ursula. M
One as wife, another as maid
I have a 15 yrs old daughter and watching this just broke my heart
Unfathomable. I could never treat my daughter like that, I don't understand this cruelty. The bond between mother and daughter is the most powerful and amazing gift from God. 💔😢
So basically they are getting a servant to help around the house not a daughter inlaw....smh😑☹😕😡
+ Maggy Exactly!
If the wife is a servant the husband should be one too.
That's Bangladesh for you
exactly. were hope shes ok and GOD protect her always .
@현실 세계 do the husbands get beaten and raped everyday? are they prevented from leaving the house or speaking to their family? okay then.
Being a bangladeshi born and raised in the UK i seriously dont understand my own country Bangladesh anymore. Its beyond me this is happening. May Allah safeguard all the women and girls. They have fled their homes to find comfort and safety not to be sold by Bangladesh. How is Bangladesh even allowing this ?
Shakila Sharmin You do realize that this is normal Bangladeshi culture, not something due to their refugee status?
Your Allah approved Proffet Mohammed rape a 9 year old!
@@raclarke7379
You lie
When you practice 1400 year old rules u get 1400 year old results. Foolish religion really foolish to believe is Islam, pure evil creation.
@@celebmoments7060 Now thats what I call spin. It is definitely Islam thats causing this. Just take a look at the muslim world, all those countries. BTW, muslim isnt a race moron.
i live in a country that's official religion is Muslim. As a non Muslim, sometimes i wonder how they are proud of their laws and see no wrong in it. Though i have many friends that are Muslim, my state do not consider themselves as having an official religion, unlike the other states. So the Shariah Laws are not implemented. Everyday i am grateful because I feel safer in my home state.
I dont understand their motives to do what they do I just feel blessed that I dont have to do this to my daughter. The whole time listening to her cry before her wedding made me so sad. May God come soon to relieve your suffering
I can't stand this kind of mentality. You need a daughter-in-law to have her help you around the house?? ! I felt soooo sorry for Fatima 😢
Just seems like females are swappable commodities done under the guise of marriage. You get rid of one, to take on another later on as a in law.
Yup.. this is wrong teaching of their culture... supposed in islam.. most of workhouse must be done dominantly by male including cooking and babysitters
Mada don't say so sorry fatima condition will be okey because of you
Yes of course,,, but what about mtanmay army...
What about go out... And earn money
this is just sick! being a woman and a muslim myself to see this types of treatments towards to women makes me upset. and her father saying to keep a girl at home there is no benefits to it. what a heartless father. I believe a girl should be protected by her father. it just show you how little respect they have towards to women. I really feel sorry for Fatima sad sad sad
Jijo Osmam that's what struck me as well... no benefits in keeping girls. I'd live and beg on the streets but I will never give up any family member, not even my dog!
As the father said he would not have to feed her or buy clothes etc. I also had a Lebanese tell me this when he engaged his 13 yo daughter. He was educated and worked with me at what use to be the largest hospital in Saudi Arabia located in Riyadh. He showed me pics of her engagement. It also contained pics of her dolls and stuffed animals. I just looked at him and thought he's no father. If he truly loved her he would never marry her off like that. It's all about money.
Even in secure conditions, the ideology keeps life poor.
It's so strange. In my culture girls are thought to be special because its usually them who take care of their parents when they are elderly and I'm Muslim too.
There are no benefits. Females are a liability and cost money.
Disgusting. Those poor woman. My heart breaks.
I love my daughter so MUCH! I can't imagine doing this to her.😭💔 However, these people are living under such horrific conditions! Poor girls!😞 I hope and pray that the situation for Rohingya 's people change for the better.❤️🤲🏽
I feel Rohingya girls and children are our priority along with those in Bangladesh, Nepal, India, Lhotshampa, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Karakalpakstan
@@TheLatiosnlatias02 Yeah.🙂❤️☝🏽🧕🏼
@@TheLatiosnlatias02 dont bring india into this. indians dont send their daughters to unkown mens homes or brothels.
Western media is so silent about this smh
Akash Guha Thakurata and your point is?
@Akash Guha Thakurata not necessarily MUSLIM. It's ASIAN culture. Culture is different from religion. Culture can influence the way people practice their religion, yes, but it's not an 'Muslim' thing. I hate generalisation. -.-
@@fluorescentbubbles6498 Religion certainly influence culture too. Especially in undeveloped countries
Mads I believe that yes, there is influence with things such as creation of laws but everything else in religion is twisted to suit the government’s needs.
Ibn Battuta And what would they do?? Assassinate all the men? And then abolish the women from practising religion? Fine by me, but kinda unrealistic..
That poor child with the burns 😥 God be with them
God doesn't exist for them
@@rahatrezwan6006 it doesn't matter what religion or belief someone holds.
Our Creator exists. Period.
@@IllumiNauti 👍🏿
@@IllumiNauti atheist exists
It’s very much a man’s world. Poor little lamb, my heart aches for her. I have a 14 year old daughter and this is heartbreaking. I pray that they are kind to her and she has a happy life.
Fatima crying has just broken my heart 😥
These girls live such painful lives. My heart hurts. May Allah help them 😥
men have no hearts. All they care about is themselves, their own needs and desires. Such incredible misery it causes to innocent girls. A full time housekeeper for her much older husband and his parents, who she CLEARLY didn't want to marry? This is outrageous.
It's like an animal is being taken to a slaughterhouse :(
Yes that's exactly how they see and treat thier womens..
You three people in the replies are sick indeed, blaming Islam for this and that! I wonder though, if you had such bad energy why wasn't directed to those who killed and raped the Myanmar women and made them refugees in the first place?
@@minty289 Actually it is Islam ideology. Raping young women and kids, Chopping heads off of people. Is Islam ideology, Throwing acid on women faces is Islam ideology, oppression on women is Islam ideology.
“It’s unnecessary to keep girls” he said with a smile
I would like to see Muslim men have babies. The full 9 months then hours and hours of labour. Then raise the brat.
Sadly due to extreme poverty some people have little options. we don’t understand what it’s like for her and her family. Maybe that was the only option the parents had that would ensure their child’s safety.
Very heart touching, it's better not to be in this world when we realized how much issues do humans have to face
As an American woman I am ashamed to say I truly don't acknowledge the gift of freedom. While I do appreciate and love those in my life, many things I take for granted.
Seeing the lives of these tortured women makes me want to be a better person.
I sobbed with them throughout the film, leaving with a heavy heart.
Peace and safety be with them.
And yet here in America women are screaming that they are oppressed, it's embarrasing to witness.
Have you ever been condemned "Burman witch" she is also a female ,who is fully responsible for this condition..you Westerns are only dictate the present condition instead of reason......
Well said Marjorie. I think you speak for a lot of us.
The prophet told the marriage is not valid if the woman hasn't agreed, Such a menace seeing this :-
Can you indicate to me where in the Quran says so, Adil.
@@nazaharin Quran 4:19 “O ye who believe! Ye are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should ye treat them with harshness .....
@@minka992 But why are they doing what is against their believe/or the Quran ( I supposed Muslim should abide the teachings of the Quran). Are they Muslim ?
@@nazaharin To be fair a lot of religious groups (especially Christianity) goes against what their own prophet has said and holy books have contradictions in them. But none of the big religions are good for women if they are put i practice.
@@user-od8eq8bd1g i agreed .. sad at the same time.
The gift of Islam
I just hate how her own father thinks she's a burden to him😭
Islam doesn't regard girls as burden, but rather Allah says when he's the most happy with one's deed he blesses him with a daughter. Allah regards to daughter as "naimat", which means a "blessing"
THANK YOU👏🏾❤ these ppl disgust me....
Lol
That is true. Our Prophet, pbuh, tried to give women rights but cultural traditions are stronger.
Yet muhammad laid down with his own sons wife😂 and married a 6 yo girl. Its a ideology of.islam to marry and rape lil gals
how come no Islam practice what you're saying? Bull!
Her eyes are saying her soul is dying.. 😭😭😭😭
😭😭😭😭😭
I wish I could help her and the girls and children be free. No one should be a slave. I would bring them to my new apartment in Xinjiang where they would receive high quality education, be granted the means to stand on their feet. I am grateful to live there, despite the fact I'm a British Muslim.
Fatima's eyes shows all the pain...😢😢
It is a very informative documentary, congrats to all team members
This is so horrific, tragic... Why my country doesn't help these ppl. .. I'll never understand. I wish i could rescue that 15 yr old from the life she's living
Dr. K there are many Rohingiya in India too, they had too accept them because of silly UN laws. The Hindu nationalist government wants to kick them out they will be more than happy is you take them in your country.
Reporting from India.
Diego Sebastián Pérez, I don't think india is going to care about UN. We need to wait for Supreme court for the decision whether to keep rohingyas or not. Don't worry, india will deport them soon. Indian resources are limited, so it's impossible to keep them. central govt know that rohingyas are a threat to our national security too
Sae Nayn Shame on your government and you as well they are just like Indians too like you
Austin Orton then why don’t you keep them , we know that some Rohingya’s r threat to your country
It's not our problem . We have enough going on in the U.S. Than sticking Our noses where it doesn't belong
Why do *_women_* continue to subject their daughters to such suffering?
They were sold the same way, it is their way of life. They do not understand what they are doing to themselves. They have all the power but don't use it.
1hourOfLove because theyre passively pressured by what they consider the alpha male - their husbands.
The men are the bosses, their wives have no power to argue with them.
Those women are disgrace to send their daughters to such ill fate
1hourOfLove because there is no other way...
So sad, now i feel so blessed of having a happy simple life, good parents,
This is so depressing and archaic. I am acutely aware of how lucky I was to be born into my circumstances. Education is so important.
Why give them birth in the first place then? No Justice to their lives:(
@ikram Nizam father's fault
@ikram Nizam the same thing happened with bangladeshi hindus and minorities in muslim countries..i guess you are aware of this fact..
Its only easy in saying not in practical lyf...the reason behind this is the terrorist army of burma...who forced them to leave their homeland...poverty is the reason behind every evil...they are poor and being persecuted from their homeland....
Islamophobia...
If this father didn't get terrorized and kicked out of his own village, he wouldn't have taken this decision, I don't agree with him as in Islam woman should agree to the marriying and not be forced to one, But I get his concerns, he thinks it's a better life at least she'll have a solid roof on top of her rather being she kidnapped anytime to be forced to work in Adultery or even worse
I am blessed to be born where I was born, because to be born in these countries with little minded people...there is no words 😶
I just feel sad and hurt for the women and young girls
I feel like a stupid girl I treat my parents bad sometimes and now seeing this I respect them more
One question to you people's have you did something to safe this girl or even have you ever donate one single penny for this refugees but you commenting like a boss here and blaming his dad shame on you and your thinking.
Mentality towards women is a disgrace they get no say in who they want to marry its decided for them whether they want to go through with it or not that poor girl 😢
I'm glad living in Singapore 🇸🇬
Not women you should feel sad. It's for the girls and children
The thing is when you're on a pedestal it's easier to pass judgement and I also feel horrible for the girl ..it breaks my heart but at the same time I can't condemn her parents ..I condemn the circumstances that altered their lives which made them resort to this way of living .
Her parents are equally to blame for sending their daughter through this outrage
Al Zazeera your works are good and informative. I am learning to see the world from a different angle.
And do many of us think our lives are hard. I watch these things to keep my life in perspective.
Poor baby. Hearing her cry made me cry😞 is heart breaking listening to this and watching it.😭😭😭
Jayant Mohanlal how? Did they force themselves? There still needs to be awareness for help
If this father didn't get terrorized and kicked out of his own village, he wouldn't have taken this decision, I don't agree with him as in Islam woman should agree to the marriyand not be forced to one, But I get his concerns, he thinks it's a better life at least she'll have a solid roof on top of her rather than living in the camps why she could get kidnapped anytime to be forced to work in Adultery or even worse
@@mihar8bess didn't she die?
@@bro-ss2eu still not clear in the end, but whatever her destiny is for sure it wasn't good unfortunately
It's so painful 😭😭😭😭😭😭they sent her to work for them
2020
And this is still going on!!!
Heartbreaking!
Really how do u know
This is so heartbreaking. After watching this, it seems to me how fortunate i am..
dad can't keep off of his wife, complains about having too many mouths to feed, sells daughter.. alrighty then...
Ikr? Makes me wanna kick him in the ball.
@@Unknownplsyer yeah makes u hate men tbh
Seriously! Why is she being punished for him not being able to stop having children.
@@Unknownplsyer
Me, I would retrieve all girls and children and bring them to my new home in Xinjiang.
1st world problems: I'm not beautiful enough I'm not rich enough I'm not young enough I'm not thin enough I want to be better then the next person.. appreciate your life.
Wow you're statement is so true and tells nearly everything about us, our society believes and thinking... So I DON'T understand why your comment didn't get thousands of LIKES and or replies... Probably because the truth hurts too much
So true 😥😥😥😥
ThankGOD... we didn't went through this... and may GOD protect us all and them too
May God save this group of women and may God curse the bad people who caused it
O Allah I'm so sad that I keep complaining about life, however hard my life, I still have my freedom. I feel blessed for my life and pray for girls there.
The girls and children are in my prayers too
The Foxt islamophobia at its finest.
1.1400 yrs ago was different times,the legal age for marriage in the uk in the early 1900s was 12.Arounf the 1850s in the USA 7.
2.Dont know where "women hating" Islam gave women right when Christian popes and those guy were debating if women even had souls.Educate yourself on the rights women have in Islam.
3.What they're doing is strictly agains Islam, if she dose not wanna get married or she's being force or blackmailed then that marriage doesn't count.
EDUCATE YOIRSELF
@@dadashim52 yeah! They also forget tht they prophet married them if they were in a helpless situation widow,orphan and never had kids from them until those women were MUCH older!! And only had kid from khadija who was almost 30 something yrs older then him!
Allah is nothing more than a fictional character created by humans, try to solve your problems on your own with the help of your friend and family complaining to something that doesn't exist is useless.
@@monkeyman8834 🙏 thanks
It is never about the Girl always about having a slave and honour
Third world mentality. This is why we Indians were enslaved.
Well about the thord world mentality. Im from an americam third world country and we are far from whats happenig in those countries. Is not a third world mentalith but something that belongs to arabian or islam countries.
@@jammycorrea2136
You lie. Islam never endorses slavery.
I hope Fatima is okay 😢
Child marriage doesnt bring happiness,it only brings heartbreak
Ohh my god just burst in tears to see how helpless people are...how lucky i am.
I feel really depressed right now after watching Fatima been sent off /married at the young age of 15, I seriously cannot stop myself from crying along with her... like why would you want many children when you find them burdensome? at the least one can do as a parent, for not sending a child to school and providing them with the basic happiness of a child is to let them grow and get married to someone they love at least.. i cannot imagine marrying someone whom i've never met or seen in life.. my heart really hurts for her and other young girls like her.
I feel you.
Daughters have always been considered a burden,wherever. You go
The fact all these people hide behind their religion is disgusting , as a muslim myself I’m very sorry for fatima , however this ignorance is utterly disturbing, the fact that a marriage where one is forced is considered haram and not valid in islam and nobody among them seems to care about that as long as their cultural needs are met and a “burden” is lowered from his head , this statement itself contradicts the teachings of the religion they are preaching the girl about , a girl is considered a blessing and your way into heaven but he considers it a burden , oh god I’m so so sorry for the child
a horrible horrible situation... I hope the international court of justice sees this and establishes the fact that Myanmar's Military is culprit of Rohingya's genocide and the perpetrators(people who are ordering this) are put behind the bar with due respect to the rule of law.
Could you please tell me how to find Fatima. I am a mother and wife in Nz......and we should like to rescue her......if she wishes. And also sharif.
Pray you managed.. Imagine the rest😭
I think it'll be a hard task and a very risky job to go rescue her. However seeinv your comment, and your concern has made me respect you. All we can do is pray love ❤️
Maybe you can ask/contact the journalist by Google /other media. Its hard to help them, but at least you try the best..
Hi Monika, I was thinking and feeling the same thing. Im too here in NZ and we have quite a few homeless here. We have offered our home to share with many in need. Some take up the offer and some dont. I hope you have been successful. If not maybe we can we can help eachother help them. Blessings to you and yours and bless all of those suffering and bless these girls and families from this documentary.
Hi Monika,
You have the biggest heart. May God bless you and make it easy for you to fulfill your dreams and task to rescue these girls.
*The locked hut gave me chills!!* Seriously!! Wtf have they done to that 15 y/o GIRL, in just a couple of days??? That is frightening!!
N d most shocking thing is those team of journalists who witnessed d child marriag but taking no responsibility of a girl who disappeared, it's just a story fr thm nothing else,
Subscribe thr channel plez
@@bejoysaimon745 they cant do anything about it but report on the story. I can only imagine how difficult it was to witness, knowing the most you can do is remain calm and do your best to inform the rest of the world what's going on. For that, theyve done more good in this world than would have been done otherwise
@@minorcek
As a British Muslim, I feel:
Those families and all journalists deserve to be thrown in Saudi Arabia where it's stoning for them.
I wish I could save the Rohingya girls and children, build a Vocational education & training centre similar to that of Xinjiang and then, they will be lifted out of poverty thus starting a bright future for them.
Thanks a.j
There are the United Nations, the European Union, unicef, etc….what purpose do they really have when they hear the cry of a child from her soul?
Clearly her family deemed her a burden, yet the trauma of fleeing was her salvation.
These people are sick😠 where in Islam is written that a girl should be forcefully married???
They are illiterate and know nothing about Islamic rules.
It’s their culture...they do not follow Islam 😒
Poor baby. Ugh. This is breaking me. 😥😥😥 so. Her life isnt hers.
Abrar Akram
As much as I wish the Rohingya safe, I feel the girls like Fatima should be our priority.
I wish I could rescue her.
If we've built a town in Chad, Mauritania, Senegal, Western Sahara, maybe there we can find a way to give them their shelter there.
No where all lies and culture
I'm bengali in fact i'm muslim as well, however, I am so glad my family isn't ignorant and never forces on marriage. They said marry who you want as long as they respect you and treat you well, but not right now , finish your education and get a job, do everything you need. I plan on being a forensic science technician, and i am happy that i am supported. This makes me sad, this is the result of ignorance and no money.
I could never marry someone my family chooses, id kill myself.
Would your family spare your life, if you marry man of other religion
@@iamindianindian8286
Why poke your nose into his business?
starlighteuu women like you need to help protect other women who don’t have the choices you have.
Coz your family is not escaped from Myanmar, you still have your business, property, home, family, each and everything.
Whats wrong in marrying if your family chooses someone for you? Are you trying to say they will choose the wrong person for you? They wont want things to go well for you? Listen. Theres a difference between consensual agreement in marriage and a forced one...We were brought up in a Western country but still preferred to marry whom our parents agreed upon. Theres no shame in receiving the blessings of parents and family. You sound very much like a wanna be imaginative western brat, who is very stubborn and arrogant. Get better education.
I have four Daughters and from today henceforth I thank God in a special way ,NEVER to take things for granted. I identify with Fatima imagining she is mine and am pained beyond measure ,am overwhelmed with sadness .The sight of that burnt boy made my body shudder .The evil on this planet is unbearable
May Allah swt protect the women from such filth.... Aameen
Amin
Forced Marriages
Imam Ibn Taymiyyah
Fatwa from "Al-Masa'il ul-Mardiniyyah"
Translated by Abu `Abdullah Muhammad al-Jibali
May a father force his virgin daughter who attained puberty to marry?
That he may not. This is also the word of Abu Hanifah.
People have differed as tot he reason permitting the compulsion: whether it is virginity, the daughter being under-aged, or a combination of both. The closest opinion to the truth is her being under-aged, whereas no one can compel a grown-up virgin in marriage. Abu Hurayrah reported that the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) said:
"A non-virgin woman may not be married without her command, and a virgin may not be married without her permission; and enough permission for her is to remain silent (because of her natural shyness)." [Al-Bukhari, Muslim, and others]
Thus the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), prohibits forcing a virgin in marriage without her permission, whether it be her father or someone else. Furthermore, Ayshah said that she asked the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) "In the case of a young girl whose parents marry her, should her permission be sought or not?" He replied, "Yes, she must give her permission." She then said, "But a virgin will be shy, O Allah's Messenger." He answered:
"Her silence is [considered as] her permission." [Al-Bukhari, Muslim, and others]
This applies to the father as well as others. Furthermore, Islam does not give the father the right to use any of her wealth without her permission, how then could he be allowed to decide, without her permission, how her body (which is more important than her wealth) is to be used, specially when she disagrees to that and is mature to decide for herself?
Also, there is evidence and consensus in Islam to restrict an underage person's free control of his wealth or person. However, to make a virginity a reason for the restriction contradicts the Islamic basis.
As for the difference between the non-virgin and virgin in the hadith of the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), it is not a differentiation between compulsion and non-compulsion; the difference between the two cases is that (a) the former gives her instructions for the marriage whereas the latter gives permission, and that (b) the virgin's silence counts as a permission. The reason for this is that a virgin would be shy to discuss the matter of marriage, so she is not proposed to directly; rather, her walee (guardian) is approached, he takes her permission, and then she gives him the permission not the command to marry her.
And as for a non-virgin, she would not have the shyness of virginity anymore; thus she can discuss the matter of her marriage, she can be proposed to, and she gives the command to her wali to perform the marriage, and he must obey her.
Thus the wali is command-executor in the case of the non-virgin, and is permission-seeker in the case of the virgin. This is what the Prophet's words indicate. As for compelling her to marry despite her loathing to do so, this would contradict the fundamentals and reason. Allah did not permit a wali to force her to sell or rent her property without her permission. Neither did He permit him to force her to eat or drink or wear that which she does not wish. How would He then oblige her to accompany and copulate with a person whose company she hates - at the time when Allah has sent between the two spouses love and mercy? If such company happens despite her hatred and repulsion, where is the love and mercy?
Forced marriage is forbidden in Islam.
*O ye who believe! Ye are forbidden to inherit women against their will. Nor should ye treat them with harshness, that ye may Take away part of the dower ye have given them,-except where they have been guilty of open lewdness; on the contrary live with them on a footing of kindness and equity. If ye take a dislike to them it may be that ye dislike a thing, and Allah brings about through it a great deal of good.* [Sura Nisa: 19]
I am crying along with Fatima.. it is absolutely devastating for her and the other girls/women who go through this... but in her situation she lost her home, then her family which is all she had left. Just to be "one less mouth to feed." Disgusting. I hope she is okay, wherever she is. Sending prayers to her and girls like her.
Her family, Rohingya men, women should be sent to Saudi Arabia. The women gets stoned while men, including Fatima's father deserve to be beheaded. The Rohingya child brides and other kids deserve a better future.
Marriage is not the solution to poverty
Rose Mendiola - you’re right, but many south Asian communities do this. They give away their daughters to practically anyone who can ‘look after’ them. It’s disgusting, when families are going through hardship, it’s important to stick together, not force marriage daughters away. I hope these woman find the right person one day
Rose mendiola they don't have a choice are u stupidP
Get Shurikened - I think Rose is referring to the parents marrying off their kids. this vid. made it more than obvious Fatima didn't want to marry to escape poverty, but she was forced to, just like all the other young girls, and the father said it was one less mouth to feed and one less person to clothe. so 1reason theyre married off so young is for the girls family not to be in so much poverty,as the father said,1 less mouth to feed.
BARBARIC 😭 … Thank God for my parents and for letting me born in a country where womens have rights and freedom.
Why don't 58 Islamic countries of the world are not coming forward to save their brothers
Because All rulers are Coward...
😥😥😥
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
They are nothing
They are dead
may Allah give us mercy
Arranged marriage is something i can never understand...the girl is just a kid! shame on the parents who allowed it to happen.
That's a forced marriage. In an arranged marriage both the girl and boy still have a choice
Epi King my grandparents were arranged married and loved each other more than I ever knew was humanly possible. They both had a choice to say no to each other. In fact, the more older I grow the more I realize that who could possibly know more about me than my own parents and I could never marry someone my parents didn’t see fit for me
@@free2saywhatever proud to read your comment
many people aren't that mature
Nothing wrong with arranged marriage. The problem is when it's forced.
Theres a big difference between arranged marriage and forced. Stop being confused.
This is such a tragic piece on so many levels. As a Muslim, it's devastating to see people treating women and girls with such little respect and honor. I'm sure some of you think that's ironic, but know that that the way women are being treated here is not representative of what Islam teaches. This is pure culture...their external appearance looks "Islamic" while internally, what they are doing is typical of that region regardless of religion.
It's also disheartening to see that the father is making such a momentous decision for his daughter without any regard for her well being. He rationalizes that it is to alleviate the family's poor circumstances and to "protect" her from other men at the camp...but at no point does he seem to express legitimate concern for his daughter.
May Allah provide justice for those who are wronged.
Her father is dumb
Thats sad ,it is haraam in islam but it is also because of islam tjey suffer like this
@@nailanoorein2086wtf you smoke didn’t you watch the full documentary, because of the curse done by Myanmar 🇲🇲 military now these people displaced eventually become helpless and suffering from exploitations
I am so lucky to have been born in a family where a child is a child, where duties aren't allocated to gender and where all children get the same privilege to go to school.
Excellent reporting!
Why is there so much evil in this world...God have mercy
Asian Lives Matter I always wonder
Many people say if :;"GOD ;":is good,; Then why is there so much evil and bad things going on..But ":;GOD;:"says if the people would just follow my :;'"Commandments""':; Their wouldn't be so much evil & bad things in the world 🌎.
@RKA My friend one day you will have to give an account to the Lord" Hopefully you are saved in the name of Jesus by then😇 God bless you.
I have no words. I don’t know. I’m also struggling here in my country (financially) but no where near the suffering of these girls. God pls comeback soon. Your daughters are abused/raped/murdered.
I wonder why there is so much evil too.
Thank you so much Al Jazeera. Probably the best mainstream media outlet that covers super interesting and rarely looked into topics. Much appreciated.
No words to say😢
Heartbreaking for a young girls. 😭🤬🤬🤬