Responding To Your HATE Comments
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- 🎵 My first song JUST DROPPED and I would appreciate it if you checked it out! 👉🏻 • H of The Stage - Will ...
----- Let's talk about THAT Dimash video. Here's the link if you don't know what I'm talking about: • Dimash FAKE Performanc...
Top 20 Biggest Lip Sync Fails Ever - • Top 20 Biggest Lip Syn...
🎶 Patreon: / hofthestage (early access, bonus content and more)
👕Check out my first ever MERCH DROP! h-of-the-stage...
🎤 Studio gear I use: thmn.to/thocf/... *
☕️Treat me to a Coffee: paypal.me/HofT....
✉️For business inquiries: hofthestage@gmail.com
Socials:
📲Instagram: / hofthestage .
▶️Subscribe: / hofthestage
💻Follow on FB: / hofthestage
🐦 / hofthestage
🎬My Movie/TV show reaction channel: www.youtube.co....
* Affiliate Links
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.
Non-profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Special thanks to my VIP Patreon: Blake Weber, Ismael G. Ramos, and Faisal.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
All Dears know that Dimash sometimes take a part in programs and shows where lipsync is prescribed according to the content of the show, or the studios are simply such that there are no opportunities for live performance and all singers use phonograms, this is not a discovery or a surprise.
The surprise was, however, that you focused on so-called proving what everyone already knows, instead of seeing the true nature of the song, where Dimash first used such a jazz funk style in a folk song.
I am one of those who watched the previous video to the end (I don’t know why). For all 14 minutes you repeated the same thing, although no one argued with you and you did not refute anyone. I don't doubt your competence. And what you said could well have been mentioned; your opinion as a specialist is of interest. But to whom, what and why were you trying to prove, if this is the format of a TV program. It wasn't a concert. And note that what we listened to was sung by Dimash in any case. It was VERY strange that you did not consider it necessary to say anything about the new interpretation, about the performance. It was clear that you were not interested in this at all. In the most interesting places, it was clear from your face that you weren’t even listening to them.
Да, сто раз "ДА"!
Merci
About HATERS and BULLIES
If you chose to pontificate on the dos and don’ts of a revered artist, you should be prepared for the heat. You think you can criticise Dimash relentlessly in one video for no good reason, but call commentators, who take objection to your views, HATERS, and pillory them? You should learn to distinguish between criticism and hate speech. Still, the title of your video (Lip-sync, Fake Performance) should have been a trigger warning.
The graph only shows that I, like others, have watched this song so many times since its release before we happened upon your negative reaction so that I didn’t need to verify again and again if he strained his neck or lip-synced authentically enough. We all noticed his calm and stylised performance and we all scrutinise his every utterance and move (obligatoire - Dimash, like Freddie Mercury, is an artist you want to watch perform, not just listen to). So, by the middle of the video, your gratuitous assault on Dimash got VERY annoying. For me there’s something incongruous about your criticism of a bona fide world class artist of the likes we haven’t seen before, despite his young age. And he got there without you…So the graph naturally declines in the second half since fans don’t like to listen to having their icon taken down - it’s not because I didn’t bother to listen to it. It’s a song of late that I adore and I’ve watched regularly, just not on your channel. So much for the premise of your 'analytical' graph.
You are also showing surprising naivité over Chinese regulations for artists performing on TV and in contests and, moreover, arrogance, to impute that Dimash should/could/would use his fame or popularity to bend Chinese rules. This reveals a big gap in your comprehension of the close bond between Dimash, China and those millions and millions of Dears who launched his world fame. He's much too respectful, humble and gracious to abuse that bond. What he certainly can’t do is edit an official CCTV release !!! Do you expect him to justify his every performance??? Should we expect him to provide a separate video in which he explains the exact context. Surely, he is not obliged to label his video releases and indicate if they’re autotuned, lip synced, studio etc. However he does it, he never disappoints. If you pay for a concert, you get live Dimash, full stop. To my imperfect knowledge, Dudarai was performed before a live audience on CCTV1, and regulations forbid lip syncing. In the video one can also catch glimpses of the rest of the orchestra and the audience. However, it is not my job to spoon feed relevant information to reactors. And expertise cannot be based on supposition because even if you reiterate your respect and love for Dimash, it is still peppered with your scathing criticism. I am sorry I triggered your defences and you felt you had to provide proof of your expertise.
But just because you're a vocal coach and happened upon a "studio" video of Dimash's - whose fault is that ? - certainly not a misleading stratagem by Dimash!!!
You could have simple decided not to 'analyse' because it wasn't in your line of expertise.
What really got me in your rant about Dimash’s “lip-synced travesty” were the stabs at his allegedly pushy ‘coercive’ management team, his tendency to overdo it and overstep the limits of his capacity, to spend his voice unnecessarily, and how you want to save him from an early demise due to his evolving performance practices (paraphrasing here). Are you angling for a consultancy position on his team? Just wondering. We are dealing here with the world’s most qualified, uncompromising, humble artist, who has skirted the global music industry to prevail among sharks and still spread his music and message … his way… not shackled by his team or industry dicta or driven by limitless ambition; just driven by his love for music and his special gift he wants to share with the world (and generously supported by his Dears). He also knows to whom he owes his loyalty and who truly loves him - his producers/parents, teachers and friends, not to forget China, which is why it’s one of his priority performance venues. It does not behoove any of us, reactors included, to tell him what to do or to
question his choices. What is evident is his integrity and his humility, as well as his boundless energy.
Generations of young and old fans/singers/musicians/coaches find inspiration in Dimash. He has already revolutionised voice training and shown what a human voice can do, and created a new musical genre. Do you really think he doesn’t know how to take care of himself and his voice?
Concerning Dudarai, Dimash's performance was flawless, not a word mal-synced or a beat missed, presenting two distinct styles to perfection with a novel jazzy composition that promises future revelations.
You have chosen to call me out publicly on the cover of your video. FYI, I’m not some frivolous, gung-ho dude or wide-eyed Dear lost in admiration, but a woman with a broad spectrum of long-term musical exposure and immersion who hails from the city of Mozart. Reactors should not preach from a bully pulpit enabled by and paid for in public subscriptions. Your expertise does not give you authority to bear down on the criticism of what you seemingly presume to be clueless commentators. 🙏
PS
Reactors serve their purpose - as entertainment. Most use artists for a first or secondary income stream - fair enough. But monetised fandom somehow cheapens it and invites disingenuousness. Some (of the many) excellent voice teachers edify Dimash’s sophisticated vocal techniques, though I have yet to find one who could improve upon them. Most just revel in seeing sophisticated music theory performed to perfection.
👏👏👏👏👏
Үлкен рақмет! Өте ризамын, мықты жауап, бергеніңізге, бәрін текшелеп, нақтылап, көздерін ашқызып. Осындай сум, куу сарапшыларға ауздарын жапқаныңызға мың алғыс! Өздерінің қолынан ештене келмеседе, ерекше жандарға тас лақтырып, аяқтарынан қағып, жолдарын кесетін ақымақ адамдар бар ғой.Аман болыңыз! 😮
Hallöchen nach Salzburg 😊! Wunderschöne Stadt, die ich im Oktober erst besucht habe. 🎉
Gut geschrieben und auf den Punkt gebracht , respektvoll mit viel Hintergrundwissen. Und das er einfach so einen Kommentar in sein Thumbnail setzte, fand ich persönlich am allerschlimmsten an dem ganzen Video.
Ich bin immer wieder erstaunt wie wenig Informationen bei den Kanalbetreibern wirklich ankommt. In letzter Zeit lesen die wenigsten ihre Kommentare und wie wenig sie sich zu Singern merken auf die sie regelmäßig neue Videos machen, obwohl sie sie anscheinend mögen! Man kann sich trotzdem informieren, ohne sich zu spoilern 😂.
Grüße aus dem Allgäu ❤
Hallo ins Allgäu.@@SoneaT Was ich in der ganzen Dimashgeschichte nicht leiden kann ist die Industrie die rund um ihn gesprossen ist. Ich weiß, daß Reaktionen einsteils zum verbreiten seines Könnens für ihn wichtig sind aber andererseits stehlen sie ihm in Wahrheit viele Likes während ihr Kanal astronomisch wächst. Sie müssen keine Arbeit leisten und werden von den Dears mit Informationen überschwemmt, die sie nicht einmal verifizieren, und often ist die Begeisterung nur von der Aussicht auf Subskriptionen beflügelt. Aber das ist meine persönliche Meinung. Sorry, I'm switching to English - Deutsch ist zu umstaendlich
Anyway, thanks for your comment. I was shocked when I saw my handle in big print. I'm even wondering if that's legal and will ask RUclips about their policy on such pilloring. Be that as it may, Dimash is a superstar. On your next visit to Salzburg, we'll have to meet 😊💗
.
❤👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Dimash'ı takdir ettiğini biliyoruz.Tepkimiz tüm şarkı boyunca hoşnutsuzluğunu tekrarlamanadır.Şarkının farklı aranjmanı hakkında bile tek söz söylemedin.Video boyunca o negatif hava bizi boğdı,Dimash da bunu hak etmedi.Tşkrler.
I was in a band in 1967 in New Zealand
we lip synched on tv even back then
El problema con el video anterior radica no es que Dimash pudiera o no haber estado haciendo play back (creo que se escribe así), sino en la insistencia en resaltarlo como si fuera un pecado mortal y, además, sin hacer la menor referencia a la canción, es decir, el menor análisis musical. Pudo haber realizado una crítica si así lo deseaba acerca de la calidad musical del tema... no lo hizo. En realidad usted habló sólo de usted, intentando demostrar reiterativamente su capacidad para advertir la sincronización o no entre el sonido y la imagen. Insistiendo en resaltar el posible playback como algo absolutamente negativo (repitió usted varias veces la palabra "odio"). Obvió usted que la voz de Dimash es inconfundible, su estilo también, que es lo que en definitiva debió analizar. Ese nomás creo fue el problema de su video.
Exacto, lo único que le interesó fue demostrar lo listo que es por detectar el playback, machacando con el tema durante 14 minutos. Y si alguien le critica es que es un fanático enfermizo de Dimash. Penoso.
@@Javier-id4lqEso es lo que yo he dicho,fuera de que Dimash cantara la canción en estudio no analizó la canción solo se fijó en si hacia playback,en fin…como si fuera algo del otro mundo …cantaba en estudio y es el,❤️así que no me importa las reglas de la televisión China ni las explicaciones porque yo se el motivo🤷🏻♀️
Por eso ya no sigo esta cuenta.
En muchos vídeos hay retraso en los movimientos. Talvez por la calidad del vídeo o porque no es de la fuente original. Pero yo no veo ningún problema el el lips sing. Si lo hizo bien hecho. El tiene que cuidar sus cuerdas vocales ya que son oro puro 🤗🤗🤗🤗
Exacto!…..
Уважаемый реакционер! Вот, вы очень близко к сердцу приняли, ответ-комментарии слушателей Димаша.Считая,что вы разоблачили его выступления,зная что возможно в силу каких то обстоятельств, может ему пришлось выступать в таком формате. Его никто не возвеличивает и не собираются поднять на олимп. Вы считаете, что вы правы, а те кто не принял вашу реакцию не правы? Вы, просто своей реакцией, дали повод для хейта, которые жаждут этого реванша. Его, с момента вступления на эту профессиональную сцену хейтят. Большинство людей обожают его творчество, его исполнение. И, многие профессионалы-музыканты,которые не на ютубе, дали свою оценку его вокала. Давайте будем вежливы и терпимы к творчеству исполнителей.
👏👏👏👍🏻
Мне кажется, фанам Димаша пора спросить себя, именно себя, почему блогеры, раньше хвалившие Димаша, начинают его критиковать? Почему обычные комментаторы перерождаются в хейтеров? Не знаете?
👍@@user-xz8bv5cw8d
@@user-xz8bv5cw8dочень хорошо сказано. Ещё странным кажется, что похоже в продвижении творчества Димаша в основном полагаюися на фанбазу, это промелькнуло в одном из интервью. Это кажется очень странным решением, если учесть, что фанаты действуют в большинстве своём некорректно, навязывая и внушая всем подряд даже ту информацию, которую сам Димаш не подтверждает, опровергает или уходит от ответа в интервью.
And again - not a word mentioned that this was a pre-recorded, post-produced and edited event tv program. Dimash was recorded the previous day, we saw that. What happened during the editing we don't know, but it wasn't great. If H knew that, then he did his previous video intentionally, just to diss Dimash. If he didn't, but read about it in our comments and prefers not to mention it, then again he does that intentionally, because every singer now and then participates in tv shows with a song or two. Sometimes it's just a jesture of good will. If H doesn't like these kind of performances, why comment on them, with titles in BIG RED LETTERS and false accusations. Some people are sued for this and there is a lot said in this tirade of a video that calls for it. In this video he showed his music diplomas but not his diploma of a shrink, yet he dared some very bold psychoanalyses, even said he was afraid for D's mental health! Well, what could I say, what could anyone say! I think H just crossed the line!
I did not bother to watch the clip but people forgot Dimash is an entertainer. You expect him to sing everything live for you for your you tube reactions. Ive been following Dimash for the last 4-5 years. Ive seen him grown up, improving, improvising and everything to do with his growth into international stardom. And what these "coaches" have been doing all these years? Still on you tube.
Lol that afraid of the truth? Stick your head in the sand
@@dishonestcomposerreacts what brought you here? No view at your youtube. Didnt i told you Dimash will go down in history having the best voice in our life time. Now double dumber for you. So sad, very sad.
A bit of perspective... When i see a live Dimash performance on RUclips, I've come to EXPECT to be dazzled . When he doesn't bring the ultimate, over the top, vocal gymnastics I've seen previously, my initial reaction is disappointment. As if he promised me something and didn't deliver. We are so thrilled that he has come into our lives, we start to take him for granted.
But who am I? and frankly HOW DARE I think he owes me (or any of us) ANYTHING. I need to remember that he is human, and the vocal spectacle that he delivers is surely the best he is able or allowed to given the circumstances. I can't imagine him ever "phoning it in" willingly. While we recognize that lip syncing is far beneath what we have come to expect from Dimash, we might consider how little we know of what's going on prior to ANY performance
So lets all step back take a deep breath and be kind to each other. And to Dimash.
Good point. Well said
Well said 👍
Perhaps there is a justification for the mocking reaction too? The thing is that even with the title of the video, you contributed to the propaganda that the haters carry. Whether you like it or not, this is true. Besides, your suspicions are unfounded, the fact that things didn't match doesn't mean that he didn't sing live. At least you should know that things are processed on television.even if that was lyp sync your reaction was disgusting. I'm not going to watch this video, especially since you don't even understand what the problem was in your previous video. It is a bit embarrassing for a professional of your level to evaluate Dimash. (By the way, I'm not just thinking this now, I used to think the same thing, as well as many others who are on RUclips as "vocal teachers". As for the basis for saying this, I myself have a bachelor's degree in musicology and completed the Bel Canto course, if you are very interested, I can send you my thesis, maybe you will learn something)
I used to love watching this reactor reacting to Dimash but now I stopped, the thing is why wasting his time reacting to Dimash when he just want to find something whether lip sync or not.
I recommend you to watch this video. Maybe you would understand a little at least. And he showed his diploma that he has a master in vocal coaching. This is his full time job at the University.
@@kriknut1but he can’t even sing 😂😅😂😅
@@kriknut1 ruclips.net/user/shortsQcxB0fLSd80
@@kriknut1 From his reactions, he doesn't really seem to be knowledgeable. For example, in the previous reaction, he repeated the words "fast part of the song" ten times, which is musically called presto. In addition, I don't know in which direction of education, but he clearly has no contact with bel cato, in fact there are very few professionals in the world who fundamentally know the classical bel canto with which the Italian classics sang at the age of 90 (it is a very healthy vocal technique). Therefore, what I wrote above is valid and not my delusion. I don't know his degree, but I know for a fact that to appreciate Dimash one needs to know both contemporary and classical techniques, not to mention his traditional techniques. I'm not going to explain much anymore, anyone with a little musical education will understand the professional level of this man. I think it will be interesting to name whose coach he was, it will be interesting to hear his student. As for his singing, I saw Olympico's cover before and his vocals have nothing to do with classical songs and vocals. Not even with the contemporary, he may have come up with some new vocal direction himself.
Right! This is my third installment, but youtube bloggers should learn some respect. To the person on whom they try to earn, and to his fandom, who help them reach their goal.
I saw the video of Dudarai on Di's channel like ten times! No desynchronization! None whatsoever! I thought that was just me doing some trick😁, H being a pro and me not so much. But I've been working in a TV station for more than twenty years and I know how these shows are done. Then we saw pictures of Di rehearsing or recording the previous day, most probably recording, he was in the same blue suit. I said to myself, right, this will be quite a complex tv show, they need pre-recordings, which it was. I saw the whole tv show, so I know it was. I tried to explain that to H, but it all went to deaf ears. All he wanted was hype, albeit negative. Not the first reactionist of this kind, won't be the last! H never got it that the Dears love Dimash for his integrity and his humanitarianism, for his wisdom and humility as much (if not more) as for his outworldly voice, and will always fight for him. H just tried to humiliate the wrong person, not that humilation should be ever accepted!
Love your informed contribution!
Dimash is simply the best!
Thank you for accusing me of loving Dimash too much
His point was made by another Dear: Love is blind. No one loves Dimash more than I do, but I agree.
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz This reactor is blinded by his anger and envy and he calls us... Haters!
@@Elam888 I love Dimash more than you.. If he asked for my opinion, especially if I was as qualified as H,, I would tell him the truth.. We are not blind-angry-envy-haters
Yes!….me too!…..🔥❤️🥰😍
I don't think it was your insistence on the fact that he was lipsyncing although the video and analysis was a bit superfluous, I think it was the word 'Fake' that upset his fans. Lipsyncing is not fake as he sings the song he is lipsyncing to, as you explained maybe due to tiredness or strain or the directors wishes, and is common, it was the implication unintentional maybe that somehow this is a flaw in Dimash. There are always those who are too ready to pull an artist apart looking for the most minute detail in order to disparage a performance. I don't believe this was your intention however you spent what I believe to be more time than necessary to establish this fact, bordering on unwarranted critique. You would probably have the same reaction from MJ fans saying the same thing or Freddie Mercury fans lol. I think the word fans is a giveaway as it means fanatics 😁 I do think some criticism of your reaction was reasonable though and you should take it in good grace as you would want your criticism of an artist to be taken too. UKDear 💜
You make good and diplomatic statements. I also think some Dears need to back off a bit. As Dimash is so great of an artist and a very kind and thoughtful person, his life speaks well for himself.
@@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o I agree. Nastiness from Dears is upsetting for Dimash.
@@kimwilson3863 If your best friend asks you how she looks in a new option outfit, do you love her enough to tell her the truth. Constructive criticism is a respectful response unless that WTF??!??? falls outta ya mouth first
🦋🦋🦋
@@ericdotd69 Not sure what your point is but I believe it was constructive criticism I gave. Being truthful is always the first thing you should be, kind but truthful. I did not disagree with truth being told just the way it was delivered. If I told my friend the truth repeatedly in a manner which made her feel overly criticised and bullied by my glee at her obvious error of judgement then the truth is being used as a weapon not a helpful opinion.🤔
Dimash is king of vocal
Well, I have to admit that I did not watch your previous video till the end, and commented anyway. Sorry for that. maybe it was unfair.
But you need to be fair too, what took me off and presumably many of us, was the word "FAKE" in the description. That description said it all for me. A pre-recorded performance in a TV show IS NOT a "fake" one, and using that word in relation to Dimash implies that he is a fraud. I found it offensive, to say the truth.
I did not understand also why you looked so surprised by the fact that it was pre-recorded. You have reviewed many of Dimash videos. Is this the first one you found? There are not a lot, but leaving aside the MVs, some 15% of the performances in his YT channel are pre-recorded, particularly many he did with Krutoi for Russian TV.
Don’t you understand what people write to you about?! It’s not about Dimash lip-syncing. And the fact that you turned out to be deaf and will not notice the great work that he did in recording this song. Singing it like no one has ever sung such an ancient song
If you're going to do reactions, you have to take what you get, right? We're watching you great to music we love. If we don't like your reaction, we're haters? Ummm, no.
I think the reason we fans of Dimash didn’t like your reaction is that you made a big fuss of him lip-syncing and also had it written in red, “Fake , Lip-synch” and made it a headline, was it really necessary, also just curious do you just react to live vocal singers? if the TV station wanted him to lip-synch surely it’s down to them.
I watched this video tonight, I was annoyed that you said, you was worried about Dimash’s mental health and that he could burn out… if you knew Dimash you would know that singing is in his blood. Maybe we should worry about your mental health, maybe your burning yourself out.
You used RUclips analytics as a defense? First off, I am beginning to question your claim of “vocal coach.” I am 82 years old and have been studying voice since age 20. In my humble opinion a vocal coach would not spend 14 minutes discussing only the mechanical production aspects of any music video. The vocal coaches I know would spend 14 minutes critiquing composition of the song, discussing the orchestrator’s arrangement, and/or reviewing the performing artists’s interpretation choices. I do agree that this video appears lip-synced and that Dimash looks unhappy, but his contractual obligations in China are not really the business of any outside reactor. Nor can his fans in the West in all practicality lodge complaints with a Chinese TV station. His song choice and execution are the only important issues for outsiders. I have enjoyed your past reactions, but your indefensible defending here has turned me away.
The best comment 🙌👏👏👏
Yes, agree. A turn-off for sure. :(
@@gracetrespeses2141 It is not the reactor's business to "turn-on." It is his business to react honestly.
I am so saddened and turned off by this reactor throwing Dimash under the bus with his teaser "lip sync" plastered in red.
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz not expecting him to turn me on lol 😂😆😂😆
Dimash got started into international fame in China...overnight...and is very thankful to his Chinese counterparts and fans for their very applauding response to a foreigner. And so he enjoys their company, and is not just keeping up appearances for the good of his career, but he is spreading the love.
I believe that that song Dudarau was at a concert in conjunction with the Panda Movie Awards concert and may have been part of that celebration. And so, he would have conformed to their practices where possible. Just prior to Dudarau, he was in an interview on stage where he also vocalised to an orchestra and concert pianist, in a very short but beautiful display of his frequencies.
It is normal in Russian cultural concerts to prerecord whole concerts, and so we sometimes see or suspect that this is what is going on. Apparently they do not like to have anything breakdown in their shows, and we have seen this even when Igor is involved at times.
So I suspect that this may also be the case at times in China.
We know that he can do everything that is required and more, and most of us just enjoy everything, as we watch them over and over with various reactors, and sometimes get a bit browned off as reactions spoil the atmosphere, and we do not mind the idiosynchracies.
No doubt, you have days or songs that affect you like that.
Personally, this was a first go at a full jazz type song and mixed into culture which he openly says to the Chinese audience, that he is trying to bring cultures together. As you know, he studied jazz amonst his qualifications, and we have seen little bits of aspects of it in some songs, to our great delight. So to have a longer song of it is a very pleasant experience for us all, and we aren't looking at it with your understanding and preferences. To most of us, it was super, and we want more....and the audience did not mind it either.
You cannot really bring these two attitudes together here anymore than you can demand your newborn to walk. Some things take time and have to be overlooked while being enjoyed...such is life.
Dimash is only at the beginning of a huge ongoing career and life experience that will leave this world in a better place when his time is up....in 500 years or so, or maybe 1000. Who knows how long we will live in our new 5th Dimensional world.
He is preparing us, tempering us, for what will be unknown experiences in terms of mankinds future development in every area of life and living. As soon as the corrupted governments are fully dispensed of, very soon now, we will enter into the unknown, and perhaps we will all have exceptional talents and abilities and super long lives, and dreams that actually come true.
In the meantime, we all have to raise our frequencies/vibrations to move into the new dimension, and leave stuff behind that does not fit with what is coming. It is a matter of choice whether you move up or stay in this 3 dimensional world and carry on around the mountain. But the two dimensions will not mix.
So keep on moving up...foster love...open minds...believe in dreams...everything positive..nothing is impossible!!
чем больше вы оправдывайтесь-тем хуже это выглядит,просто вы-не dear,не все вокальные тренеры достойны этого звания от Димаша!
Он не оправдывается а разжёвывает несведущим фанатам как устроена мызыкальная жизнь . Законы музыкальной индустрии едины для всех будь ты трижды Димаш . Нужно внимательно слушать что говорит автор а не поливать грязью давнего поклонника Димаша . А как Димаш поёт на живых концертах знает весь мир .
@@user-jhjkh пусть расжевывает на именах других исполнителей, хайпует дядька... насчёт давнего поклонника - от любви до ненависти один шаг
@@user-jhjkhнам не надо нечего разжёвывать, даже если мы несведущие мы любим творчество Димаша,его как личность и человека,а на пытаемся как он , якобы из лучших побуждений принизить впечатление от исполнения Димаша
@@user-jhjkhВам нужно внимательнее читать отзывы. Никто автора грязью не поливает. А разжёвывать поклонникам не нужно. Поклонники как оказалось лучше автора разбираются. Может это Вы "несведущий" в законах индустрии?
@@user-jhjkhс чего он взял, что все зрители такие уж несведущие? Он показал свое невежество, неуважение к зрителям, и не только к фанатам Димаша, к Димашу.
Dear trainer and censor, if you post your videos on RUclips, you should know that desynchronization occurs very often. Often, the same video is displayed completely differently by different responders and evaluators. Sometimes the synchronization is perfect and sometimes it is not. Desynchronization occurs when the video is frequently stopped and replayed, although it was perfect at first. I don't know if this is due to some defect on You Tube (?) or the incompetence of the reviewers themselves?
In any case, I only see desynchronization among the reviewers, if I display the video from the original link, there is no desynchronization. Regards.
Right! I saw the video on Di's channel like ten times! No desynchronization! None whatsoever! I thought that is just me doing some trick😁, H being a pro and me not so much. But I've been working in a TV station for more than twenty years and I know how these shows are done. Then we saw pictures of Di rehearsing or recording the previous day, most probably recording, he was in the same blue siut. I said to myself, right, this will be quite a complex tv show, they need pre-recordings, which it was. I saw the whole tv show, so I knew it was. I tried to explain that to H, but it all went to deaf ears. All he wanted was hype, albeit negative. Not the first reactionist, won't be the last! H never got it that the Dears love Dimash for his integrity and his humanitarianism, for his wisdom and humility, together with their love for his outworldly voice, and will always fight for him. H just tried to humiliate the wrong person, not that humilation should be ever accepted!
We didn’t question your credentials sir! We questioned you attitude and the way you referred to it as “ fake” which has a slight disrespectful sound to it! Also writing lip sync in red letters bannered on your intro in RUclips, was very unfriendly! And please do not come back here and try to explain that you were angry with the people who made darling Dimash do a lip sync, because that was NOT your original attitude sir!
Thank you for your efforts in your channel and best of luck! As you asked anyone who didn’t like your approach to a play back performance( which you are now trying to mellow down and say everybody does it!), to leave your channel, I am presently doing so and unsubscribing!
Simple y sencillamente Dimash puede hacer lips sing a la hora que le plasca. No veo cual sea el problema.
The reactor has a personal problem. That’s the problem.
El problema es que a este señor no le gusta que hagan playback y no acepta bajo ningún punto de vista que Dimash haya tenido que hacerlo aunque no tuviera seguramente opción o fuese un requerimiento del canal chino. O sea, pecado mortal de Dimash el haber aceptado hacerlo.
🤷♂️
OK. Tell me what is the real purpose of that reaction? Tell everyone it's playback? We know that. Get angry at tv shows? So why not to write to them directly or write directly to his management? You say you love him, but this reaction gives only damage to him. You are feeding his haters. You have no idea, how many haters Dimash has. Would you do that to people you really love? Let's say to your children? I really really do not understand the purpose of that reaction and especially the tittle. If it is not for clickbait and the views, that is for what? You could not to post this reaction, when you saw it is playback. But you choose to post. Why? Will this reaction change something in a good way in Dimash career? I do not think so.
And repeat I love him I am not in love with him ?!!!! What even that’s mean, and why you prised him as GOD ?!! What ?! if we are supporting one who really deserves our support that’s mean we are in love with him of course NoT, I agreed with each words you typed in your comment.
Well said!
I watch that TV program, because Dimash is one of the visitor there, is about culture thing, as Dimash present Kazakhstan, and he is musician, so they put him in singing, understand TV sometime is not set up for that live version there, and we have to thanks those TV program to let all Chinse viewer can see Dimash and enjoy his talent, music is the most wonderful thing in my life, I love Bob Dylan , I can listen to his music whole day long, the same I love Dimash music, I also can listen whole day long, we love their music, does not mean we in love with them in person, but I do like Dimash personality, he is a good human in today is rare found, so I do love him with that like I love my grand kids, respect your music degree, we can not make everybody happy, so I am careful in talking things, rather positive talk than negative. if one day, you are famous, you might also have situation like what you are talking now, but it is not very important, right? this is kazakh folk song, Dimash sings it in different way to present his ideal new version, and I love it, his old version also very good though.
I don’t think fans hate you for calling off Dimash lip sync. All of us know it’s not as simple as go on stage and sing these days, especially in big productions TV. However I do believe some of us piss off because of the word “FAKE” that you used. We recognise lip sync but we don’t tolerate fake. Those two are not interchangeable especially when it’s Dimash. Like how many years we have watched him? 4? Can we honestly say he is fake?
At NO time during this reaction did H say that Dimash is fake.. Chillax the visuals n the vocals are not quite right.. H is just in shock. Dimash is human How would you react to the One Sky Almaty live compared to the Yerevan performance.. ruclips.net/video/Zh4GjsXUnzM/видео.html
@@ericdotd69 It was written in the title of the video! Who wrote this ? Do you know the answer.
exactly! your comment should be pinned so that He can understand what was actually wrong in previous video.
It seems that at some point you implied that the instruments were not “plugged in”? I’m not an expert by any means, just want to say what I saw, you of course, don’t have to verify it if you don’t want to. The dombra has the light colored wire running from the front to the back, and the black box( don’t know what it’s called), with the antenna and green light, in the back of the instrument, in between the dombra and Dimash. (you can see it at 1:06 on Dimash’s original video). The keyboard, as I see, has a bunch of wires going down to the floor, into the power extender, that’s runs on the stage taped to the floor. That’s just my two cents.
Using the word “fake” in the title to your video is what was offensive. It wasn’t against your saying he lip synced. It was using the word “FAKE”. There are so many reactors that love to try to make Dimash into a “fake”
I always respected your reactions to Dimash
My concern is with the word “fake”. It seems extreme.
If performance is not real than it's fake.
@@JolaHiljaDo you really think TV shows should be real live performances to be accepted as "real"? That's funny. TV performances for big shows are rather presented as mv:s. No one expects them to be "live" at the first place. They are always recorded beforehand, possibly even sung live but with multiple takes (that seems to be a usual practice in China, while in Russia they use finished studio recordings). After shooting they take the best parts and put them together, cut and edit. That is the process. It's quite a lot of work, and the results vary. They can be good or bad. But. I would never call others' work "fake".
Yes!….agreed!…..bad reaction!…..
If there is smoke there is fire.
If there if FAKE there is FAKE.
SIMPLE
@@JolaHilja this is the entertainment industry. Movies and tv shows are fake. You are fake if you wear clothes to make yourself look a certain way. There’s so much makeup being used by the K-pop industry even off the stage that we don’t know how they really look like anymore. If people know anything about dimash, they should know about his goodness and sincerity as a human.
That's not faking. Every other artist does lip sync performances on TV Shows, almost all in Europe are. And many in the USA as well. And that's not about his management in Asia. That's about the TV stations! Russians are often not live as well. So maybe yes he does rest his voice too. But again such a reaction isn't enjoyable at all. And yeah I didn't watch till the end, bc my time is precious to me!
You are a professional and even more so you should be careful in your words! Because you make a video that is watched by people from many countries! You are grist to the mill of Dimash’s enemies and envious people. Dimash is forced to wade through thorns. It's harder for him than for many other artists
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👍🏼
Pretty sure he was being specific with his words. You need to grow up.
If you don't like lip-synced performances, and you are not willing to analyze them at all, why making a video of 14 minutes? You saw immediately that he lip synced, ok, so why didn't you just leave it there?, "ok, guys, he is lip syncing, see you in my next video". But you didn't do that, you went on ¡14 minutes! saying that Dimash is lip syncing, what's the point in that? It doesn't make sense at all. And please don't generalize about all the negative comments in such a rude and simplistic way, I don't even like several Dimash's performances and songs. A little of self criticism wouldn't be bad from your side.
Because I watched the whole song to see if he's going to lip sync the whole time. Very simple
@@HofTheStage of course, maybe he decides to sing live some seconds somewhere, after lip syncing the 70% of the song, it's something very common. I'm sure many thousands of subscribers would believe this very simple and very absurd and very silly explanation, in the same way as many thousands believe that Dimash always sings live. 😉
What kind of nonsense?🤬
@@HofTheStage
It' s not simple. Simple is just for you. The problem was the title and having spent the entire video saying and saying, the same thing. We are not stupid!
By the way I won't watch any more videos from you. I prefer real coches. Goodbye.
@@HofTheStage Wow. Sorry, that makes it even worse. Your "reaction video" was FAKE as it wasn't a reaction to the arrangement of the song or the vocals at all. See, that works both ways, doesn't it? 🤣
Just a thought - if you have nothing to say about the musical aspects then why continue making a reaction? You can just move on to another song. It's not interesting to hear somebody repeating the same thing we already know for 15 minutes.
And nobody expects those TV shows to be live.
And no, disagreeing with you doesn't equal hate, just a disagreement, just as calling hate your disagreeing with us won't be acceptable to you.
Well I thought that maybe he wasn't going to lip sync the whole thing and I would have something other to talk about.
@@HofTheStage I think we both know it's not a reasonable expectation.
@@HofTheStage nowhere was said it was live, instead of realizing it was you who thought it was, you decided to post the video by having FAKE on the screen. Bad choice!
"You can't handle the truth!!!"
You got me. I wasn't expecting that! ROFL.
As you see in the comments, the majority of the Dears left this ”honest” man’s channell...
What is your point? That you prefer reactors who pretend and just say what you want to hear “or else” ?
@@lolawants2008 I prefer reactors that are not doing reactions while being poised with anger and envy disguised in righteouness. Seeing only fakes and haters, that’s not a real professional vocal coach attitude. A vocal coach does something else.
@@Elam888 What a joke of a comment.
First of all, nowhere was said it was live. Neither on the title nor in the description of the video. It's YOU who assumed it was live. You noticed it wasn't written that it's live and you said that, during your video. After you realised it's not live, as YOU thought it was, you continued talking about not being live for the rest of your video. Apart from that, you decided to post this video by having FAKE as thumbnail. Bad choice. Secondly, you made it worse by showing your degrees so as to convince us you were right. I felt you're diminishing my intelligence and you're devaluing Dimash. Do you think that you or me or anybody knows what's the best for him better than himself? You know about his studies, his career and his experience. Do you think he doesn't know what he's doing? I trust and I support his decisions. So, please, don't say that being in shows is bad for him, he knows better. And why your title is "Responding to HATE comments"? Doing a public criticism you knew that you'll be criticized as well.
You have no intelligence
Вместо того, чтобы хотя бы частично исправить ситуацию с прошлым видео и принести извинения за своё враньё - хотя бы соврал что-нибудь правдоподобное. Этот блогер начал обесценивать зрителей и всех несогласных со своим навязанным фейковым мнением. Можно подумать, кто-то верит, что вокальный коуч может не знать, что тв программы записываются и режиссируются, тем более в Китае.
Ну денег заработал на хейте Димаша, зачем продолжать так со зрителями - за это тебе точно не заплатили.
Отписка, жалоба на содержание видео
I think the reason you rubbed people up the wrong way was because you spent the entire video slating the fact that Dimash was lip-syncing to a new song & nothing else. We all know that artists have to lip-sync sometimes (Dimash included). He NEVER stated in the title that it was a live performance & therefore mis-led no-one. We’ve all heard him sing live & know what Dimash is capable of. You came across with a very negative energy, aggressive & if for whatever reason the backing track failed, then that’s something HE & his team has to deal with - it’s not your problem & nothing for you to get so invested or angry about…that is why you are getting such ’hate comments’ as you put it. I’m pretty sure Dimash hates lip-syncing, but it’s part & parcel of the job. So going back to the point - It was NEVER stated as a live performance…you knew this & yet you chose to spend the whole 14 minutes slating it. You contradict yourself in this video by saying you wanted to analyse the ’live vocals’ which is nonsense because you already knew it was a lip-synced performance & yet you wonder why people reacted in a negative manner…come on now!
ruclips.net/user/shortsQcxB0fLSd80
Don’t forget the “fake” part…
Oh yes, I forgot that bit! 😂
Agreed!…….
Agradezco tu sinceridad, puedo estar de acuerdo en algunos puntos, y quizás en otros no, pero debe primar el respeto ante todo. AMO a Dimash porque precisamente lo que él siempre está tratando de transmitir tanto en sus canciones, como en entrevistas es el respeto, la tolerancia, el entender que podemos pensar distinto, sentir distinto, etc. Y yo como dear intento aplicar esos principios en mi vida. Paciencia ❤
Me encanta que estés de acuerdo en algunos aspectos y *en otros no* . De eso se trata en las opiniones.
Aunque Dimash no practicara y promoviera esos principios, todos los seres humanos tendríamos que aplicarlos y *mucho mejor le iría al mundo* .
Pero, en ningún caso debemos callar ante los actos que consideramos injustos, cueste lo que cueste, mientras se haga con el debido respeto a las personas, aunque la crítica tenga que ser *dura* en algunos casos.
Salud para usted
@@videospadron1950"Let him who is without sin be the first to throw a stone" John (7:53-8:12).
The word FAKE is not good.that's why Dimash fans can't admit it.Because he is not fake.his talent is true.and it's not a problem if he sings live or not.because we know him well.and how good he is.the problem is that some reactors are keep finding any flaws to criticize him.although others also doing that kind of thing.but you never reacted that way ,so what's the point?
ruclips.net/user/shortsQcxB0fLSd80
Se nota lo "HUMILDE" que eres. Algo que siempre le admiramos los QUERIDOS de nuestro principe Kazajo. A pesar de ser un privilegiado en todos los sentidos, entregado totalmente a la musica, haber estudiado desde los cinco años y teniendo un doctorado en música. Por eso lo amamos por ser quien es. Ojala que ese ejemplo que da Dimash sea copiado por la juventud que hoy en día tanto lo necesitan.
El no ha dicho que es humilde, por qué tendría que serlo? El solo está dando su opinión. Yo amo a Dimash pero tampoco me gusta verlo hacer doblaje. Si no te gusta el canal no lo veas. un abrazo Dear.
@@dra.karinashell5178If you don't like watching, don't watch! 😂😂😂
Gracias por su consejo, no volveré a ver ese canal. Y de HUMILDE lo dije con sarcasmo. Chao
Justamente, por el mensaje que Dimash quiere entregar al mundo, tengo la certeza de que a él no le gustaría tu comentario.
Dimash no es un príncipe kasajo. Es un tremendísimo y completísimo artista con un talento excepcional y que ha trabajado toda su vida para estar donde está y seguirá estando. Ama la paz y trata de promoverla en todo lo que hace. Los comentarios tóxicos de fanátic@s (porque no son verdader@s Dears) le hacen más daño a su imagen que cualquier otra cosa. Mi sueño es poder verlo en mi amado Chile. Espero que se cumpla algún día
No me gustan las dears que están siguiendo a Dimash como si fuera una religión, yo solo expreso mi opinion si a Dimash le gustaría o no, jamas lo sabras ni tu ni yo, pero yo creo que es tan sabio que está por encima de estas discusiones. Ultimo comentario que respondo o leo, porque no son capaces de distinguir una critica a un ser humano (extraordinario) a una ofensa. By,@@nydiasaavedrafaura1547
Dimash is not God, he is a man. And it’s difficult for him! It is difficult for him to break into modern show business. And you did him real harm with your video
I don’t have the time to read what’s going on but what’s wrong with lip synced? All singers do it sometimes… and some do it all the time! Like pop singers! And no body gets mad at it! Dimash is the best singer and doing this here and there doesn’t make him a bad singer! It’s ok! ❤
So, who am I to say for sure, but I do think this reactor is boldly addressing what others have only alluded to. Many have said "Please be polite" or something to that effect because if you read the comments it is the elephant in the room how some fans get their hackles up, like the fur on the back of a big cat, if they hear even a whisper of something they don't like. It's petty, it's rude, it's uncalled for and they should realize that Dimash himself is not like that. It is those people who harm his image by turning reactors off. Also, Dimash is human. Only God is God and to confuse that difference is to put a heavy burden on Dimash and is blasphemous of the Creator God.
This problem is reaching a boiling point. Those Dears need to reconsider what it truly means to be a Dear. His mannerisms and immense talent speak for the decent man he is and his giftedness. He is better off with the absence of lapdog fans going around spitting venom in his defense.
@@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o This reactor spewed his venom in the headlines he put on his reactions. Then he tried to fool us with other words, as if we didn't understand what he meant... He could mention that he didn't like the video. But he is very sneaky, like Brutus.
@@peggyuser-oq6xz7fg9o Amen!
The hate is stupid ! Love from Italy dear. ❤
Not stupid, we sow everything clean ;) and reason this section video ;) but too late
I won't get too involved in this conversation as I didn't watch the previous video. When I first came across Dimash about 2 years ago, I quickly learned from reading comments that it was not wise to question anything he did or suggest that perhaps he had sung in any way that was below perfection. I'm glad that this has been slowly changing. I think it's much better to be able to talk truthfully about his performances. I think we all know deep down inside that Dimash is a mere mortal and that like everyone else he makes mistakes and has off days and even has to (or dare I say it, chooses to) lip sync at times. I think the problem comes when people lip sync to songs that they didn't actually sing, or maybe to songs that have been "tweaked" to sound better than they originally were. And even people we love (and people we are in love with) have their flaws but we just love them anyway! All the best from 🇨🇦
The problem is this reactor’s obsession of lip-sinking and auto-tuning. Very professional! Where’s the beauty?!?
@@Elam888 ruclips.net/user/shortsQcxB0fLSd80
Feel free to critique his performances - he's his own worst critic - why can't you simply be appreciative of the most remarkable gift the world has seen in their lifetime?
К чему это видео????
I like your honesty bro as we all know dimash is extremely busy guy he performed this song after performing a lot of songs and performances in a big event in China.
Besides if you want to hear dudarai again
There is an older version of this song.
He is not interested in the song. He just want to put a label like FAKE on Dimash. That’s all.
He sings it with his sister, right? Beautiful performance.
Редакторы интервью с Димашем когда-то выбрали по каким-то своим критериям Вашу реакцию и этим самым прославили Вас в мире диарс. Это не значит, что Вы диар. А публикация последнего видео подтвердила этот факт. Вы льете воду на мельницу тех, кто по той или иной причине недолюбливает артиста. Даже если выступление с песней Дударай, которое, кстати, совершенно феноменально в музыкальном плане, Вам не понравилось, никто не принуждал Вас публиковать реакцию на него. Вы это сделали в желании хайпа, и опять за счет Димаша.
We are not stupid. But to make a whole reaction about it is more than hate, you want to harm him and we will never forget it.......
This is a perfect example of a huge over reaction. You are the hateful one.
Oh, stop it! He does not want to harm Dimash. He is simply interested in truth----something which you appear not to care about.
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz He is not interested in truth. He likes to throw muddy words like FAKE.
It’s funny and interesting that those who like to criticize and call Dimash fake like this reactor does cannot even sing himself and yet calls himself a vocal coach 😢😅😂😅😅😂. Bravo Dimash! Thank you for sharing your music to the world❤.
Sure I can't, neither can my students who without exception have all won first places in federal and world singing competitions :) Dimash is not fake, he's great, just he sometimes lip syncs, and lip syncing ih pretending to sing and play live. That's fake. They probably make him do that but still, doesn't make it less fake.
@@HofTheStagelip syncing or not it’s still Dimash singing, and he still sounds better than everyone else singing live lol 😂😅😂😅😂
@@HofTheStageIn fact, he wasn't pretending to be live. He didn't simulate anything. Pictures were released. Everyone who knew him knew he was recording, and not rehearsing on the pics the moment they saw him on TV in that same blue suit. After the show, he thanked Lang Lang for their long-distance cooperation and hoped to see each other soon. Either you knew this and chose not to mention it, or you didn't. Either way, fakery is on your side. Then why should I resent Dimash, if he is not faking anything? Why should I give you a slack for your "discovered fake"? Why should my unwillingness to accept the falsity of your reaction be called hatred?
Судя по всему данный товарищ не читает комменты на русском.🤦🏻♀️
Когда человек, чем бы он не занимался, профи в своей области, это значит, что он не только имеет высокий уровень навыков и знаний. Это ещё и понимание ЭТИКИ. Профессиональной этики. Когда ты не будешь публично обсуждать те или иные приемы коллеги, которые публике знать не обязательно. Тем более, что это особенности именно профессиональной, закулисной работы коллектива людей. Это неуважение к своим коллегам, нарушение этики музыканта и искусственное наращивание интереса к своему контенту.
Публика, 80-90 процентов которой составляют непрофессионалы неинтересно и неприятно узнавать о некоторых сторонах сцены.
данный господин концентрируется именно на этом, чем и не вызывает уважения.
Синхронизирует губы, не синхронизирует губы Димаш - это его личное дело! Это его собственные губы, его песня, его голос!
Тем более, он уважает правила организаторов шоу, с которыми он работает.
Не надо копать глубоко, чтоб не попасть под линию метро.
Надо наслаждаться процессом, а не взглядываться пристально синхронизированы ли губы.
И вполне ожидаемо, что видео не досмотрели многие, потому как подобные анализы предсказуемы и потому не интересны.
Автор настаивает на объективности, но ее то и не хватает. И как говорил американский поклонник Димаша - мы не молимся НА Димаша, мы молимся ЗА Димаша🇰🇿
I don' t care about your diploms. If your first video was bad this one was even worse.
Yes, and I've just leave a dislike to this vid
Я могу сказать собаки лают ,а караван идет
Не важно что ты думаешь все равно Димаш пел и будет петь ,а твой удел завидовать и критиковать от бесилия
👍👍👍
He is not criticizing from fury; he is criticizing from knowledge.
Правда? Он критикует из собственной гордыни и заносчивости. Какое здесь знание-он что-то сказал о музыке, особенностях исполнения? Нет, только о производстве. Что здесь такого, что не знают все? Пусть критикует тв канал.
Он себя дискредитировал как специалист, и это необратимо
@@Nadezhda-vn5lt Irreversible only in the mind of a bitter person who isn't capable of forgiveness----or even worse, isn't capable of acknowledging the truth.
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz переведите
Anyone who works in entertainment knows that often singers don't even have the choice about the mix.
A bad reaction…..by second time!…….
Clickbait tittle again 😃 HATE comments? Really? The different opinion and peoples thoughts is a HATE comments to you? I do not think so.
I doubt if Dimash could demand what he wanted to do considering the circumstances at that time. There were many performers for the show including the big names in China, and their performances were similarly situated. I think the rules imposed by the organizers on Dimash were likewise applied to the other performers. Langlang was not even spared. by the way, if you can find time, please watch the performance of Langlang on another occasion. He is a friend of Dimash. ruclips.net/video/cAOfUZUiZhM/видео.html
Eu posso dizer que assisti até o final do seu vídeo, até entendo o que você quis dizer, mas dedicar o vídeo inteiro nesse assunto de sincronização labial não foi muito legal, você até poderia citar, pois isso faz parte das apresentações da maioria dos cantores, mas há muito para se analisar na apresentação, como os arranjos , o estilo musical. Eu lamento 😔🇧🇷
I like most of your review but in this one I have to say you dissapoint me very badly.
Not because I like Dimash but more because how you react to it. If you think its lips sync, then it’s ok but leave it at that. You can still analyze the song itself. How he sang it because at the end of the day it still him that sang it even if it in studio. There still alot of delicate and mastery vocal skill that he presented. So basically There are alot of things that you can learn and share instead of being like a kid that got his candy robbed.
2nd, you make it sound like he always lips sync. Though it probably not intentional by you. So those things are what dissapoint me and probably alot of people. I hope you learn this lesson as we also learn from you.
I’m here not to have arguement or pointing fingers but to share what I honestly feel you can and should improve.
Your thumbnail said LIP-SYNC in big red letters, the title of the video was FAKE DIMASH...but is our fault because we didn't watch the full video? What about those who don't even know Dimash but saw your thumbnail? You made a huge mistake, it's ok, we are human, but just blaming the algorythm...the title and big letters were yours,you were the one who decided that that was the most important part of the performance. You wanted some clickbait, you got it. And I'm open, I know he lipsyncs, if you think that that performance wasn't good enough for a serious reaction, just don't do it. I've seen reactors saying that a performance was lipsync and then just proceed to talk about the song. Some coments were unfair to you I and said so to that people, but this video is not helping, instead of saying "ok, maybe the title wasn't good or I was so focus on the wrong thing" you are just insulting fans now? Double down...ok. 🤷🏻♀️
👏👏👏
very well said 👍
No somos hate somos dears del mejor cantante actual.
DisHonestComposer reacted to this video and the one where you called out lip synching. It's funny how some comments are saying the two of you belong together.
Keep in mind, Hrjove, that it has taken years to convince many of my fellow Dears that Dimash even EVER lip-synchs! As one commenter put it on the previous reaction video on which you are commenting: "Blinded by love." Virtually everything you say in this video is spot-on, in my opinion, and needs to be said. As someone who has spent considerable time in various aspects of the music industry, however, my only issue with what you say has to be with lip-synching in general. I fully understand the need for its use from time to time: the requirements of the venue, the fact that the artist is being "pushed too hard," (as you rightfully suggest, in my opinion), etc. If the artist wants to get paid, he or she may have to employ it occasionally. So your basic issue with that is not particularly appropriate when one recognizes the circumstances. Your suggestion, though, that Dimash is being asked to do more than is good for his voice is EXACTLY the right one, I believe, and that's the one that should be stressed. Expecting him to sing live every time on the kind of schedule he has been keeping is not good for him nor for his fans if they want to keep enjoying his talents for another decade or two or three. Dimash needs to slow down, and his team needs to step in to make that happen.
Hey nice to see your comment again.
Exactly and spot on, even Dimash has a right to rest and expecting him to sing always live isn't good as well! So H basically says faking is cheating and at the same time Dimash should stay away from those productions if he can't sing live. 😂 But forcing Dimash to sing always live is the same as working his voice to death😢.
Would any artist say no to big productions? Even Dimash needs to make money.
@@SoneaT Or instead of cheating maybe he should play 2 hour shows and not 3 or 4 hour showh but instead do them live? this would be more healthy for him and fair towards audience,
@@JolaHilja that's not cheating 🙄. ( is this really worth answering?) I was on countless concerts around the world. Even Big stars like Robby Williams, Bon Jovi, and almost all pop singers, lip syncing every 3rd to 4th song in a 1 hour to 2 hours at most performance . With long breaks in between and often there's an opening act.
And no if he wants to maintain his voice for years, he needs breaks in between his songs. And those aren't as easy peasy to sing as 1 octave songs. Singing is like running marathons and talking or screaming nonstop. So 2 hours without breaks is to long as well. Honestly his concerts are amazing, been to 3 all over Europe. I don't care lypsyncing no and then, bc those 3 hours are incredibly good and believe me, I can tell whenever it's playback or not 😉, even if it's only partly. But as your comment suggests, your not a real fan, have not one bit of music knowledge nor knows anything about music production. And if you think you can find an artist, who's only singing everything live, okay do it and be happy 😊.
Dimash Fans coming/ flying to concerts of Dimash from everywhere around the world. I met people from South Amerika, New Zealand, Korea and Canada. He knows this and wants to make us happy and not come so far for only one hour!
@@SoneaT I understand that you might not considering it cheating but for many people pretending that one is singing while they're just moving their lips to pre recorded track is cheating. Just that many people do that doesn't mean that we have to accept it.
@@SoneaT Also do you really don't know artists who don't use playback? Maybe you should expand your music taste.
you are not right
Hace mucho que sigo tu canal, definitivamente, estoy de acuerdo contigo. Me encanta qué hayas hecho esta reacción para quien quiera enterarse bien.
Saludos desde Gran Canaria España
POOR DIMASH...HE WORKED HARD WITH ALL HIS CRAFT JUST TO BE TREATED THIS WAY BY SOMEONE WHO BENEFITS IN HIS VIDEOS IN ALL...
Pood Dimash, can't believe how his fans are ruining his reputation by acting so poorly
@@HofTheStageIt seems that you do not even read or, maybe don’t understand, what people are trying to tell you. It’s a shame.
@@HofTheStage WOW coming from u...ruining reputation ? really ? coming from u ? LOL ur such a jk...anyway congratulations .. success ! ur getting more attention from DEARs by making this kind of videos ...CHEERS !
@@HofTheStage wow. Yes, fans wrote the tittle in HUGE RED letters -LIP-SYNC? and FAKE? Who is ruining his reputation here?
@@HofTheStageWow I lost my respect for you😢
Just raising this question is a haters trik. Why don't you leave him alone and not react on him at all. We all know that in some cases he can not sing live. We are not stupid. But to make a whole reaction about it is more than hate, you want to harm him and we will never forget it.......
I don' t think it's the case. I think that as he went on with his reaction, he was actually surprised that it may be a pre-recorded track what he was hearing, and that took him off. Maybe he did not know that there are a few of such performances on Dimash channel.
@@MsLucy4ever Sorry, but such an experienced vocal coach and reactor can't be that naive.
I agree
@@MsLucy4ever He did it to get all these comments so he can make more money and it worked!! the way is to ingore, no likes no subcribe
@@brendaguerin5423 Chillax.. This is a reaction video update.. The truth has been mentioned by other vocal coaches in the past.. I had my WTF moments with The Story of One Sky.. I hated seeing him holding a gun. I hated seeing him shoot another soldier, especially the scene at the end.. The young girl and killing Dimash. And Dimash wrote this mind-melting mini movie.. .
Then I watched the Yerevan performance.. Seeing him being frustrated with his performance broke me because, to me, he is like my son.. I am 61yo.. My autistic behaviours overdosed on all One Sky performances over the following few weeks.. I can hear the micromanaged x4 performances.. The slight differences in 3 performances makes me appreciate just how awesome One Sky is.. The vocalisations are magnificent,, but identical unlike the lyrics section
Сделал отвратительную реакцию, а потом удивляется комменариям, какой наивный или глупый. Пожалуйста, не делайте больше никаких реакций на Димаша. Раскачивайте свой канал за счет своего таланта "коуча"/певца или кто Вы там, а не вот этого всего. Набрали за счет Димаша подписчиков и просмотры, а теперь негатив из всех щелей льется. А сам, как невинная овечка удивляется, а что это меня такого великого люди хейтят. Типа, а причем тут я
Мне жаль разочароваться в Вас, я чувствую себя опустошенной! Но этим видео Вы подтвердили, что я не зря отписалась от Вас. Вы придумали глупые оправдания.
🤝 тоже отписалась,чувствую это видео специально вышло,это не просто разбор..вообще противно смотреть и слушать его
HIs "excuses" are totally appropriate.
If Dimash lipsynched it would be because he had no choice - you need to understand his culture to know that he is a perfectionist but you focused the entire video on lipsynching which is ludicrous - no one cares
Просто испугались хейта и страйков, отписки и выпустили это видео. А оно глупое, ненужное и в чем смысл этого видео- оправдания. Стало страшно за себя и свой канал, вот в чем правда.
Согласна с вами.
Жалкие оправдания!
Не хочется больше смотреть этого «коуча»
I did watch your reaction until the end. I did not say that he doesn’t lipsinc, we all know he has to sometimes, my point was if we know he has-to sometimes why not talk about the song, the composition or something else other than that he was lipsinging. I think you’re really missing the point to the majority of the comments. It was a non informative reaction and very negative and BTW, I’m not in love with this young artist, I’m 50 years old and can be his mom…I appreciate that you admitted, the reaction could have been a little more positive 😬…with that being said, I’ve watched all your Dimash reactions and can tell you know and sincerely like Dimash 👍
Unfortunately nowadays it is usually used on 99% of televisions in China, pre-recording in the studio is almost common...I don't care, the one who sings is Dimash and I understand the situation, it is also used in a couple of songs to rest the voice when you're singing for more than 3 hours and that... you don't need to make another video giving explanations. Dears, we know all this, we just like to see how the vocal coaches are interested in the song, my opinion. Greetings
PLEASE, STOP COMMENTING HERE, THAT'S WHAT THIS REACTOR NEEDS TO GAIN INTEREST OR MONEY ON RUclips. JUST GIVE A DISLIKE 👎, DON'T WATCH THE VIDEO, AND MOVE ON TO A WORTHIER REACTOR.
Both likes and dislikes, and also commenting promote channel and offers other people to watch it. JUST IGNORE. No likes, no dislikes, no commenting.
Gosh - you're so rude !!
Это видео ещё более омерзительно, чем полностью фейковое лживое предыдущее. Здесь этот коуч, тряся дипломами, не только обесценивает Димаша, но и всех зрителей, которые не разделяют его точку зрения. Странно, что находятся поддерживающие этого блогера в его хейте. Можно подумать, он не знает особенностей организации тв-программ и в Китае в частности. Зачем врать, что это не так? Или ты настолько дилетант? Отписка и жалоба
Here's my take on all this. You set out to react and critique this performance, most likely for views and likes. You didn't like it and made that quite clear with your words and how you came across to your viewers. They then got butt hurt because they didn't like what you said and how you said it.They then reacted and critiqued your reaction and left their reaction to your reaction in the comments. You then got butt hurt because they didn't like what you said and how they said it. Oh the irony 😆😆
Personally I watched both videos to the end. I myself felt that this particular performance from Dimash was substandard and no where near the almost flawless performances which I have watched previously. What a dilemma, can't have it both ways. Critique the audience that you rely on for your own thumbs ups at your peril 😁😁
I’ve seen your whole previous video named DIMASH FAKE PERFORMANCE. I saw his video before and Dimash wasn’t faking anything. I don’t believe in your ”expertise” anymore. He sang in there. I think the only fake one in this story is you, mister H. You haven’t convinced me neither this time of your benevolence. Expressing your anger in a video, I don’t think it’s very professional. Almost everybody felt your negativity, even beyond any words. Dimash didn’t enjoyed his performance?!? Really???😄 The problem with lip-sinqing is yours, dude. You’re obsessed with that! I think you loved Dimash before, but, in time, the envy conquered you. You cannot fool us. I don’t believe you, anymore. Sorry.
No, he did not sing live 🤷🏼♀️
Sin palabras , solo quitare mi suscripcion. Y ya bay bay
Mr. "H": You start very badly with the title of the video: "Responding to your hateful comments." It is very typical of the narcissist or conceited person. The comments of those who watch the videos are (should be) as respected as yours. Showing their diplomas and titles to justify their DISGUSTING video about Dudari is something that I do not accept as mitigating, on the contrary, it is another example of their arrogance. That 70% of those who visited the embarrassing video did not see it in its entirety does not excuse him in any way. It just reinforces the fact that you really bothered people and they stopped seeing you. I, at 73 years of age, had the patience to review it 3 times. IT IS NOT TRUE that you did not say anything against Dimash: you made several mentions of "the robotization" of some melismas and the insinuation of the use of Auto-tune in the recording. But, what is UNBEARABLE is his *permanent* gesticulation shaking his head and carrying all his ANGER on Dimash's back at the fact that CCTV1 does not allow ANY artist to perform live. You seem to ignore that your audience does not have the "DIPLOMAS" that you have and that the entire vent of your anger falls on Dimash and not on his "lecture on lip reading." Ah! and your "compassionate" concern for the future of Dimash's career is one more excuse for the disastrous work you did. Dimash and his father (producer) are mature enough to know what they should or should not do, and by the way, I think he has more technique than you can dream of, AND MORE DEGREES AND DIPLOMAS. Be happy and have good health!
I am a similar age and I can concur with most of what you said but I believe you are 100 percent off-base when you assume that Dimash and his father are "mature enough to know what they should or should not do." Dimash's international success came on at such a fast rate that I believe it made their heads spin. They were not prepared for this much so soon. That very truth is being expressed in Dimash's, "Omir," video which you apparently did not fully understand. (Don't be offended, many others didn't get it, either).
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz estás hablando de hace 6 años creo ya les ha dado tiempo de asimilarlo y encima 2 años de parón ( pandemia) para coger un poco de aire 😂 6 años!!
@@angeliareyes3111 There must be something wrong in the translation because I didn't refer to anything that happened six years ago.
@@GaryDouglas-lj5bz ah no ? La fama no le vino hace 6 años en China ? Según tú dónde fue ?
@@videospadron1950 el comentario no fue dirigido a ti... compruébalo
You do you. You have a right to say and express your opinion. Every artist fan has their right to say their opinion too, of course some are obnoxious and ridiculous. They may choose to watch your content based on their likings. I just a little surprised as you now mention about lip sync as if no singer has ever done it. Can be from the shows they are on, the requests and purpose of the shows. He sings live in the singer competition show in China and that proves his singing skills already though it is 6 years ago.
There are so many of his performances live and not live out there. Just pick one to watch and make sure you know it is live or not then contribute about singing lesson aspect rather spending 15 mins of the whole video just to prove Live or not. It’s weird
The thing is you have reacted with Dimash’s singing for the past 2 years so I don’t get it why you focused on too much on the last video about Live or not while other his performances that you have reacted are more clearly not live . 😯🤔
I believe you are correct in suggesting that Hrjove has reacted to other lip-synched Dimash performances without noticing (or at least not suggesting) that they were not live. That might be because Dimash is such a master lip-syncher that most viewers, even vocal coaches, don't always notice.
Has it ever occurred to you that many might be keeping quiet while it starts to bother them more & more, knowing that “fans” are going to react this way?
@@lolawants2008 Or the reactor has a personal problem with Dimash’s success, and he felt he need to put a lable like FAKE to ”get things right”. 😄
Пфффф вы себя еще больше закопали . Детский сад
Yo se muy bien cuando hace playback y cuando no pero...
Que seria de Dimash sin la tv rusa y china ?
Dimash es independiente y no puede hacer de cada cancion que estrena un MV. Se arruinaria!!! 😂
En las radios no suena en tv si se pone sensible con el playback y se niega a hacerlo me puede decir alguien donde lo vamos a ver cantar ? Siii he dicho VERLO porque nos encanta VERLO Donde va a estrenar sus composiciones ? De que vive para mantener su empresa ? Les recuerdo que si firma con discografica ya no lo veremos en crossover que es donde mas luce su voz y finalmente
De que actuaciones van a reaccionar los analistas vocales si no se molestan en buscar fancams de sus conciertos ? Me lo explican por favor ?
Your examples are stupid! Did you watch the TV version! Not a performance at a concert! Dimash could not disgrace himself, since this is a TV recording!
Твои примеры глупы! Ты смотрел телевизионную версию! А не выступление на концерте! Димаш не мог опозориться, так как это запись на ТВ!
I agree 100% with you. Stop selling playbackperformances as liveperformances. And in my opinion he should not lipsync songs at his own concerts. Just take a longer break if his voice needs rest. 💪
Los verdaderos fans de Dimash tenemos como mínimo un conocimiento básico en temas de como se manejan las canciones en tv y también de canto. Sabemos que cuando se lanza algún video canción ya se de cualquier artista, esta ya paso por una post producción, lo mas cercano que podemos tener de una actuación es de los fancams para darnos una idea si hay sincronización de labios (y aun así no al 100% de seguridad). En este video, obviamente ya paso por post producción y aun así se puede apreciar que varias partes no coincide la voz con el movimiento de labios, también podemos saberlo por el tipo de sonido tan limpio (en su voz). Una presentación en TV ya no depende del cantante de si cantar en vivo o no, si no de la casa productora. También comparto la opinión en que hay fragmentos en sus conciertos en vivo donde hace la sincronización de labios (sobre todo en las partes mas complejas). No olvidemos que en esa parte del continente no esta satanizado la sincronización de labios como lo hacemos en occidente. Gracias
Lip-synching should never be demonized. There is a very good reason for its use. This reactor's objection, though, seems to be with lip-synching in general but I think he understands it is being used because Dimash is being pushed too hard by his management---and I agree with him there.
@@gdouglas999 eso esta claro, no depende ya del artista de hacer o no hacer la sincronización de labios, es casi netamente decisión de la casa productora, y como bien lo recalcas, no hay que satanizar la SL, es parte de la industria y tiene sus razones
No podremos saber en realidad qué pasó, Lo que sí coincido es que en estos países no es tan mal visto el lipsinkin sino, Dimash No lo haría.
Синхронизирует губы... пишете как о какой то машине.. знатоки...плевать на ваше мнение
Saya tidak perlu nonton video Anda. Untuk apa? Apa tujuan Anda membuat video ini? Apakah Anda sudah membaca semua komentar di sini? Apakah Anda sudah menyadari apa yang terjadi? Silakan dipikir sendiri. Sebagai seorang reaktor seharusnya Anda berhati-hati dalam berbicara.
So let's see where it doesn't sync and analyze it. He has a lot of live concerts, so what are you talking about?
Your proposal that what happened during and after Ashlee Simpson’s television appearance could relate somehow to Dimash and his performances is absolutely ridiculous.
Another point is that the choices Dimash makes, in the end, are his own. Your comments about Dimash are quite patronizing.
Yes, yes, yes, thank you! I do believe, as you suggest, that his management IS pushing him too much. Dimash's voice is incredible, but it can only do what it does over time-----not day after day and night after night as it sometimes appears is the case, even if he is not in an arena. It seems as if every day I see him appearing before smaller crowds in smaller auditoriums expecting to be performing songs live---which sometimes they are, and sometimes they are lip-synched. That being said, I will take Dimash lip-synching anytime, anywhere over the likes of any other popular singer of the day.
Well said & I agree. Not happy with a lot of this promotional stuff, & I find it hard to believe it’s what he wants personally. Seems he lives under a lot of obligation I don’t think necessarily is for his benefit as an artist or the soul inside that artist. Edit- I don’t think he always needs to do huge events, it’s more like some of them are not worthy of him, expect him to perform his big songs yet don’t give him a proper set up to do it.
@@lolawants2008 I know some Dears don't like to hear it, but I've always felt that his daddy has way too much control over most aspects of his life. He is nearly 30 years old, and I believe he needs to cut the strings.
Take the time to listen to his interviews - ' I am my own man and no one makes my decisions for me". His TEAM is not pushing him, in fact just the opposite - Dimash is well aware that not all his fans have a community that has an arena of 150,000 seats so he is very gracious in performing at smaller venues
@@gracelatour3441 I have seen virtually EVERY interview that is on youtube. I know what he has said (at least I know what the translation indicates he has said). I also know his father is present at nearly every event in which he participates---even after seven years of world fame. It would be disingenuous to suggest that the father doesn't still have his hand in almost everything that Dimash is doing.
Isn't he managed by his family?
Вы придумали глупые оправдания.
Actually his "excuses" are perfect. There is no bigger Dimash fan in the world than I am, but I do recognize truth when I see it.
@@gdouglas999 we all know truth about prerecorded performances. But these clickbait tittles? "Dimash Fake". Or this -"your HATE comments". Really? This reactor done these videos only for the views. Putting that kind of tittle he knew what he is doing :) Don't you agree?
@@ausra4423 He has a quarter of a million subscribers! He clearly doesn't need what relatively few views and clicks he would get from doing two videos. He has been nothing but complimentary toward Dimash for years prior to this.
@@gdouglas999 so what is the point of this reaction? Tell everyone it's playback? We know that. Get angry at tv shows? So why not to write to them directly or write directly to his management? He said he love him, but this reaction gives only damage to Dimash. This reactor is feeding his haters. You are Dear and you know how many haters Dimash has. Would you do that to people you really love? Let's say to your children? I really really do not understand the purpose of that reaction and especially the tittle. If it is not for clickbait and the views, that is for what? Reactor could not to post this reaction, when he saw it is playback. But he choose to post. Why? Will this reaction change something in a good way in Dimash career? I do not think so.
@@ausra4423 I am not aware of any true "haters" of Dimash. Of course, there are many people who simply do not identify with what Dimash brings to us, but I have never sensed it was hatred. As for this reactor, he has always expressed respect and admiration for Dimash's voice and talent. I am not inclined to be angry about someone who has presented an honest reaction based on facts. That being said, I think he needs to reassess his negative attitude toward lip-synching in general because it is a technique which he should have understood by this time in his life and career that is sometimes used necessarily as a result of the circumstances in which a song is performed.
Fantástico mi amado Dimash 💖💗
Omg...not this subject again! But you already knew it was coming since it's not the first time. I just thought you did it on purpose for views or simply didn't care about the complaint... its your channel to do whatever...but whining about an artists loving fan base because they didnt respond well to the implied dissing is dumb. And i know you arent dumb...so this whole thing was planned, right? Please say yes...
He is just telling the truth guys. What's wrong with that? Is it a sin for telling that this performance is not live? Dimash is still great no matter what.
If you read the comments on the other clip you will see that all know already Dimash lip sync the performance no one tells otherwise, the thing is the reactor was so unpleasant to watch his reaction keep saying for 14 minutes lip syncing over and over again, he apologized for being angry that is good this is the matter
@@Somaso163I was angry at the TV station, never at Dimash
@@HofTheStage I know , I watched the whole clip, the only thing all the dears worried about is the headline ( lip sync) ( Fake) that’s it , you invited all the heaters who will not watch the clip only will take the advantage of your headline and spreading out everywhere ( where I already saw in many comments not on your page) , we know Dimash is human and do mistakes sometimes and not all of his works we like but it’s unfair to put in your clip headline like that , hopefully you get my point
@@HofTheStage I don’t believe that. That’s a fake statement. The energy never lies.
Знатоки синхронизации😂
Yes just unsubscribed from your channel. Sayonara...
Hi! I am a Dear and I love Dimash, but I know he lip syncs sometimes (he rarely does it, but I know he does, especially when he performs “The story of one sky” in his concerts). But I don’t believe he lip synced in this one, and I will tell you why I don’t believe so. If you watch the full cut of Dimash’s performance, not only the Dudarai song (he performed two songs during the TV show), you will see that there was a whole orchestra playing with him, but that orchestra wasn’t in evidence in his performance of Dudarai. In the first performance, he is standing and holding the mic, and the camera focuses on him very closely sometimes and we can see that he is singing (we can tell it by his neck movement). But even though he is singing live, his mouth and body movements don’t match the timing of song. The TV show wasn’t live streamed, it was prerecorded, and the big problem here was the postproduction. They did a poor job on editing the sound and matching the movements, it seamed to me as an amateur work and made me think that those people on the Chinese TV shows production are not good enough at editing the sound. I say that because it also happened in the song “Join hands” and in the song “Jasmine” he performed this year in the Chinese TV shows. When I first watched the official version of those performances I immediately thought: “Is he lip-syncing?” But then I searched for fancam recordings and I realized that he wasn’t lip syncing, but it was the bad editing by the postproduction. However, in this Dudarai performance, there wasn’t any fancam recording and we can’t properly see his neck in the official filming because it was either too far or his mic was blocking the view. That’s why I believe he did sang it live and I have no doubt he could reach those high note sitting by the piano, cause he can do it even crouching. If you want to watch the full cut of his performance, here is the link ruclips.net/video/aODly-9UGG0/видео.htmlsi=srV_D9XobhcdL80x I hope you have a nice day and I would love to see your reaction to Dimash’s performance of Autumn Strong in his Arnau concert in Kiev, if you haven’t reacted to it yet (I haven’t seen it in your channel). Here is the link ruclips.net/video/437IEsDIZfE/видео.htmlsi=tIcNYXgEeAh34bAo Thanks for your reactions!
Ohhh ahora leo un poco lo que paso del vídeo anterior….. y según lo que vi y leí creo que la molestia está en ponerlo como “FAKE”. Estoy de acuerdo con eso, porque para alguien que viene conociéndolo no le dará una buena imagen ese título y hasta lo pueden compartir en redes, eso no me pareció correcto y Justo de tu parte ( mas porque El es un excelente vocalista) Lo otro de que no cantó en vivo, Pues todos los hacen no? He ido a conciertos de pop ( cantantes de moda) y ellos dejan d encantar y la canción sigue😂. No pasa nada! Y ya lo sabemos. Pero creo que es la palabra fake que molestó, porque fake sería que alguien mas la cantó y el está fingiendo que es El, pero El la canto igual nada mas que en estudio. No es la mejor palabra que pudiste usar… eso es todo para mi! ❤
I know that you love Dimash and you support him always..its normal to happen this for all singers famous a lot or a little famous...even for singers in the size of Dimash....Dimash is amazing and he proved this always..think maybe he is sick or thats the rules of China tv....what ever happen he is a great singer we love him a lot and we appreciate your reactions ❤️ and i believe that if he do it live it will be more great because he have this unique way to do it more amazing and catchy.
Estoy totalmente de acuerdo contigo. Gracias por expresar lo que pienso. H of The Stage es casi un dear y lo ha demostrado ampliamente en el pasado. Espero que siga creciendo como dear