I'm sorry but I have no interest in watching this video explaining your reasons. I won't watch it because the most striking thing in your video posted here is a post with the call (LIP SYNC) . In my opinion this was a lack of professionalism from a person who claims to be a vocal coach.
После драки кулаками не машут, никому не нужно второе, не менее глупое и пустое по содержанию видео. Мы уже все поняли про Вас. Большая просьба, раскачивайте свой канал не за счёт Димаша и не делайте больше никаких реакций на его прекрасное творчество!
read my coment, thank you very much for show me your "evil troll side" like someone said on the last video. You lost a fan, a subscriber and someone who listened your song about war.
Predstava je završena. Istina je kao voda, uvek pronađe svoj put. Nikada Vas nisam pratila. Vaša "ljubav" prema Dimashu za mene je bila jeftina predstava. Toliko.
Buddy, I'd like to give you a piece of advice: please stop reacting to Dimash. Every reaction now has doubts or criticisms. Presentation with wei wei about the tone of Dimash's voice when they both sing in the same register. That sounded strange to you. Now a click bait with Lip Sync. Dimash doesn't have the autonomy to decide whether or not to sing live in programmes, which is a matter for the contractor. You as a music teacher should know that. So stop reacting to this singer. I don't see you sensationalising other singers by asking if they're singing lip sync. I really hope you'll stop analysing Dimash. Dimash doesn't need vocal teachers doubting his vocal abilities. He's been studying since he was five and has his own singing teachers and a whole team supporting and advising him in his career. Focus on your career as a singer and teacher. Let the Kazakh singer pursue their career without speculation - do you sing live or not?
I started listening to dimash only this year and he is really talented. I have great admiration for him as he is a person true to himself. I do not believe whatever nonsense this reactor says. I guess he has to find fault as he cant sing like dimash. Anyway as said he should stop reacting to dimash and now when i see his face i skip watching his reactions and any other who talks nonsense
I agree. It seems u r determined to "prove" Dimash lipsynchs, as u know this is a show in China, they do not allow that. I think it's time you cease and desist from reacting and find another type of work.
I have watched and supported every reaction you've done with Dimash for 2+ yrs now. I'm a big fan of yours also.....HOWEVER the biggest disappointment I have from this one is NOT whether its badly edited, whether its lip synched or playback. My biggest disappointment is you continuing for 14 minutes to prove and harp on the fact you believe it was. I'm never disappointed with the truth or someone's opinion..... but was it truly necessary to just hammer it to death. If you were wanting to get more viewings and "sell" the video I feel thats crappy way to do it 😢. If you didn't like it happening then just don't publish the video......let it go!! For us that greatly admire Dimash for what he is and does we see no reason to publicly bad mouth what we don't like (he's NOT perfect, nor do we all like everythinghe does). I was truly raised by "if you have nothing good to say, don't say anything at all"!!!! Now if you mentioned it once because you felt that was what was happening thats fine! But how about also something good about the arrangement, his Dombra playing, him switching up the song from old folk (rich baritone singing) to Jazz and his runs etc. Sorry have to say I was truly dissapointed in how you handled this one 😰💔
What Dimash does as a singer and as a composer is sooooo good that I don't even plan to spend a second of my life worrying about whether he sang live or not. Please keep singing, that's all I ask! I love this jazz funk version of the song. Bravo Dimash!! 💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
I normally really enjoy watching your reactions but this was totally unpleasant to watch. Not because you said that he lip synched. He most likely did for this show and I couldn't care less. But because you focussed 95% of the video on proving that he is lip synching which just gave off a super negative vibe through the whole vid. No comments on this wonderful song or his vocal abilities. There is so much cool stuff in this song to analyse as a vocal coach. The runs, the whistle notes, the belts, the switch from folk to jazz etc.. But you decided to be grumpy and only talk about him lip synching. He still sang the song (probably in a studio), so who cares? We know that he can sing that stuff live and there were reasons why he couldn't do it at this occasion. If I pay money to watch Dimash live then I would go to one of his concerts and not to a tv show that might force artists to sing playback. So let's not make a bigger deal out of this than it is. Sorry but for this video I can only give a thumbs down, since it was really not enjoyable.
Actually I agree with one of the above comments, that as this was done for a televised performance it could well have been recorded a few times and they just picked the best vocal track. We've seen a video with the audience reaction so we know he was definitely singing it.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Anyone who plays an instrument (like me, who plays keyboards) notices the technical quality of Dimash's arrangements: In the part where he harmonized the melody with a funk-jazz arrangement he could use the classic jazz-bebop scale (with the augmented fifth) but, based on the positions of his hands on the keyboard and the sound, we can see that he enhances the music using inverted chords, increases augmented fourths and sevenths and explores variations of the mixolydian mode, these are complex chords that demonstrate what an excellent vocalist, musician, instrumentalist and arranger Dimash is! written by @zemanoshtronz
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
I haven't bothered watching as I'm frankly sick of the whole lip syncing argument. Of course there's times when he has to lip sync but it depends on the event that he's working at and the circumstances surrounding it. Of the four performances in China, two were absolutely live, one was pre-recorded because they wanted pretty surroundings and I have no idea about this one but I enjoyed it anyway as he reinvented an old song. If anyone is questioning whether it's actually his voice, then that's ridiculous and just shows that people don't know what direction he's currently working in. He's already said that while he's been in the US he's focusing on jazz and blues and one of the first IG posts we got from him was with a vocal coach who is a renowned gospel specialist. It's not the first time we've heard him sing jazz and his early college years were focused on pop/jazz vocals.
Geen enkele andere zanger wordt zoveel op het rooster gelegd over lipsynchronisatie of autotune. Met onmiddellijke ingang abonnement weg en kijk zelf niet eens naar de reactie.
Димаш поет песню, написанную сотню лет назад и он поет ее так, что она проникает в души сердца! Он одимашил эту старинную песню. Но H of The Stage этого даже не заметил! Фууу я разочарована. Очень неприятно обнаружить такую узость восприятия у человека. которого я уважала. Я отписываюсь. Прощайте
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Я просто не понимаю, зачем было делать такую реакцию🤷.. Вы сказали о людях... итак, вы заплатили сами за этот концерт и вас обманули? Нет... это была телепередача, я не уверена, что там была вообще публика, но если и была, думаю они были в курсе, тем более что, наверное, все выступления артистов были записаны заранее. А еще покажите мне, где было написано, что это живое выступление? Димаш это где-то написал? Организаторы шоу? Нет. Так что считайте что это клип и просто наслаждайтесь этой уникальной композицией. с меня отписка...
Дело было в студии, были зрители, было интервью Димаша на проекте "Красота и гармония". Был волшебный дуэт Димаша и Ланг Ланга. Фрагмент фортепианного концерта композитора Синь Синхая. "Песнь лодочника Желтой Реки". Затем сольное выступление.
Gosh… I don’t generally leave comments, but this time I’ll make an exception, no matter if this comment will be read or not. I am very surprised and disappointed by your reaction this time. I didn’t see that coming. I was happy to enjoy a new reaction and then … the infamous lip syncing controversy again. Geeez … I am okay when reactors mention lip syncing when they see it. I don’t necessarily want to “defend” singers at all cost, no matter how much I can love them, and I will stand by the fact that, as a reactor, if you want to say something, you are free to say it as long as it is said with respect. And I’m personally totally okay with the fact that if you think that Dimash - or an another singer - is lip syncing in a performance, you can say it. But why making an entire video talking about just that topic only ? Other good reactors had mention lip syncing once or twice and after, they move on … They don’t just talk about that specifically throughout their videos. Plus, this was a TV Show, not a concert, so why bother that much ? They where so many other things to talk about Dimash’s performance, and yet, you only talked about the lip syncing. Why didn’t you talked at least a little bit about the instrumental for exemple ? Or about Dimash’s voice and/or techniques ? The Jazz part ? Lip syncing or not, there is still things to analyze, right …? I’m sorry but listening to you only focusing so hard about proving that Dimash is lip syncing- and for almost 15 min straight - was certainly not pleasant … :/ That makes me sad to see that you couldn’t enjoy that beautiful song …
Well said, there were 50 performers in this show, if he seriously thinks that a show of this magnitude would not have required many takes, many hours of editing and some unfortunate mistakes in the process then he's an idiot. Even Lang Langs performance was completely out of sync. I'm seriously doubting this guy's claim to be a vocal coach if he isn't aware of what goes on in a TV recording. They'll record and clip and finally add the best audio track. It's show business and it's not always down to the performer as what happens, especially in a show of this magnitude which would have been heavily controlled by the Chinese government.
❗Haven't watched this but here's what I DO know. My sister and I grew up in Kazakhstan, she and several of my friends went to school with him, our parents are friends and he's been battling this accusation as long as I can remember. Moscow has one arena and one other venue (the Kremlin) that require prior recording, the largest arena does not, his biggest success there and THAT'S the only time he's ever acquiesced and it under duress, in his performing career in live performance. Frankly, I'm tired of his waving his mic across his mouth while singing live to prove to his critics he's not lip syncing. That's not a mic "technique ". Period end of sentence.
Beneath him? WADR, it is beneath you to believe that Dimash should refuse to participate in cultural events/productions if he is required to lip sync. I feel sorry for you that you have resorted to this kind of reaction. So what if he lip synced himself!! And to plaster this in red across your photo? C'mon he deserves better from you. You are not required to be respectful, sadly. He is required to abide by the rules of the venue.
Until now I have always held back on this topic of lip syncing because I see this fuss as completely unnecessary. But now I have to say that this discussion is starting to get on my nerves. Are you really serious about starting a topic with this unnecessary comparison, whether live or not? If, as you state, one REALLY and TRULY appreciates and believes in an artist for their exceptional achievement, then this discussion on this topic should be beneath YOUR dignity! It's so easy to convince yourself 100% of Dimash's skills...go to one of his concerts! And then you can ask yourself whether this topic should even have a place in a Dimash reaction video!
You're being naïve and it's detestable! You could say you hated TV that forced performers to lip sync and leave it at that. But the whole video is on this subject. You took us for fools. Nothing about so many other aspects of this new song with a "first" for Dimash with this bold and creative musical style. Even if you hate giving reactions to television performances, be an adult and refrain from criticizing the artist on this point of detail because it is so common in this industry. And you call yourself a professional!
I really hated seeing the word "FAKE" next to Dimash. Even if you're right, he sang the song, and no one else. We know that he is capable of doing live performances, in fact he does live concerts of 3 hours and more. Out of respect for him, if you say you love him, you shouldn't have put that ugly title, making it evident as if it were a crime. It's your channel and you can do whatever you want, but I really didn't like that you did it.
What's your problem? This is easy peasy stuff for Dimash. He's mostly in chest voice; he's known for not showing strain even when he belts or soars into his coleratur soprano at times. He hates lipsyncing and only succumbs to it under constraining circumstances. But I sincerely doubt he would pretend to sing and play this new/jazzed up premiere of Dudarai. China's rules on live performing are known to be strict. This was in Macau though, so I reserve my right to apologise. But even after listening to Dimash on so many occasions, you clearly don't seem to know him at all, despite your 'expertise.' Your observations do not convince me, and allow me to state the obvious: he is by far the most accomplished and conscientious vocalist and performer of our times.
Lol, fake? That is a bold statement. Not being performed live does not make it fake. Still his vocals, him playing those instruments, AND his arrangement that rewrote completely a folk song. It's a TV show, there are other lipsynced performances in his channel, all in tv shows. If the production of this show decided that performances had to be pre-recorded and there were an audience in that studio, nobody was tricked, everybody knew what the rules were. Dimash is amazing, as always.
Yes “fake” means fraud. As a lawyer I would suggest you not use that word. As you noted, Dimash did not say this was a “live” performance. Notwithstanding, you went on for 14 minutes calling him out as being a fake! “Fake” is also used in the title of your reaction. And several have already commented that they know he is a fake; always has been a fake, etc. etc. so lots of damages could be on the way.
I don’t get how everyone will listen to a MV and say nothing but identify a lip synch in this kind of performance. If this was a MV, would you still complain? Please answer this question because I don’t understand! Look at Across Endless Dimensions MV. Any complaints? He should have released this as a MV and you would not have complained, right?
Ой, зачем вы делаете вид, будто не знаете, что формат выступления на официальных тв каналах певец, Димаш это или другой - не определяет? Вы врёте или притворяетесь? С других выступлений есть фанкамы, и они немного отличаются от официальной версии - но это формат тв шоу. Разве это сольный концерт Димаша? Всё помнят историю, когда на тв концерте в Москве Димаш пел Know в версии вокализа, и есть фанкамы. Но в тв версии поставили без его ведома вариант этой песни со словами. Так как автор слов - совладелец тв канала. И нашлись такие же, как вы, странные люди, которые набросились на Димаша с обвинениями и увидели несинхронное движение губ. Это неудивительно. Удивительно, что вы такой же притворщик и врун
@@liudadears2869 я теперь уверена, что он отработал заказ. Это деньги, а не жаба. Не может вокалист или преподаватель вокала не знать особенности организации тв шоу. Он врет и плохой актёр, видно что врет. Ну что же, пойду почищу подписки - я на него подписана с двух других каналов. И заодно других сомнительных реакционеров уберу. В этом печально другое - почти все они, значит, неискренни и за донат польют грязью любого. Скучно
Isso é absolutamente normal em programas de TV e em nenhum lugar diz que é uma apresentação ao vivo. Pode ter sido, mas mal editado, isso também acontece. Ao vivo ou não, Dimash é sempre excepcional e suas performances são surreais. Diferente de tudo que já ouvimos ou estamos acostumados a ouvir. Quanto ao reacionário, há detalhes muito mais significativos nesta atuação aos quais ele deveria prestar atenção e valorizar! Qual cantor nunca cantou com limpsync? Todos os grandes cantores cantaram e ainda cantam! Mas aqui a intenção é menosprezar o talento do Dimash! E não permitiremos isso! Porque Dimash não precisa mais provar nada a ninguém. Ele é e continuará a ser a maior voz de todos os tempos! Aliás, não só voz, pois é um artista completo em todos os aspectos musicais e artísticos! Goste ou não!
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
I don't understand why it even matters? He still sang it, it's not FAKE. Why are you focused on that and not the song, which is amazing? Ugh, YOU are disappointing.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
@@jooliveirabrasil5672 I can only hope that he loses many followers over this. I don't understand how anyone can claim to love Dimash and then turn an entire (non)reaction video of an amazing song into a rant on lip syncing. It's sickening. 😡
Your worst reaction so far. "Lip-sync, lip-sync...", that's the only thing you were saying over and over. Fake reaction, I would say. Yes, singers do lip-sync on tv shows!! What a surprise!!! 🤦🏻♀️
This performance was from his time in China and was recorded and released for Chinese tv. I have no doubt it was pre-recorded. It's done all the time. But why call it FAKE?
Похоже внимание Димаша на него плохо подействовало. Конечно же это отписка однозначно. Не потому что правду сказал, а потому что так рьяно это сделал, как будто только и ждал момента, когда сможет втоптать его в грязь. Все знаменитые певцы используют фонограмму. Ни один не поет все свои песни всегда вживую. Мы знаем возможности Димаша, он не обязан каждый раз доказывать нам свои голосовые возможности. Я хочу, чтобы он берег свой голос, чтобы мог нас радовать своими песнями долгие годы, а не доказывать всем свои возможности и рисковать своим голосом. Ваши потуги были более чем напрасны. Очень жаль. Разочарована.
Я давно разочарована. С тех пор, как настойчиво делал упор на том, что «Ок» было подражанием стилю Б.Айлиш. Не потому, что отказываю ему в выражении мнения, а оттого, что делает это с желанием добиться внимания к своей особе и явно с недобрыми намерениями. Если он думает, что открывает нам, невежественным, америку, то очень ошибается. Большинству диарс и без него всегда известно, в каком режиме поет артист. (заглянула сюда только чтобы почитать комменты под таким хайповым заголовком))). видео на стопе, просмотров не собираюсь ему добавлять.)
Неужели самое главное в этом выступлении не потрясающее соединение разных музыкальных стилей и жанров? Самое главное, что это запись?! Вы меня разочаровали. Не думала, что вы так поверхностно судите
@@natali.tomilova. так нигде и не написано было, что это живое. чего же так возмущаться.. взял выступление для тв канала, так и написано в названии, а потом обидился что неживое, типа его обманули.. и ещё 15 минут только про это и говорил... и ничего про саму композицию.. обидно.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Dears, I just want to ask you to please spend more time on our favorite artist’s channel, than on reactor’s channels. Dimash deserves our views, not the reactors. It’s sad to see when his videos get less views than combined reactions to them. The haters are always very happy to point the number of views out. Let’s support him TOGETHER! Thank you dears! ✌️ PS: I personally stopped watching reactions a long time ago. All of the reactors (with very few exceptions) go through the same path with Dimash reactions, this one seems to be at the end of his.
Absolutely and totally agree with you dear Elena..Is what i say and write from years but unfortunately many people is crazy and obsessed with the reactions and doesn't understand that who follow the youtubers and their reactions about Dimash doesn't support Dimash and his work at all but support only the youtubers and their channels..I don't follow the reactions, i only control if the youtubers respect Dimash and his work with the necessary link in description of the original video and or the link of the Dimash's channel..The Boss King Angel Dimash Forever
Why do you think his Chinese fans who always on scenes recording him and know exactly when he lipsync or not never pay attention to this issue? Because it's normal for them. In China showbiz culture, some tv program need artists singing live while some need the artists prerecord their singing so they can retake how many scenes they want. If you're on weibo where his complete activities are recorded by his chinese fans on daily basis since 2017, then you know his live performances are far greater in number compared to just a few of his prerecorded performances.
Вас волнует только одно: живое пение или нет? Даже если предположить, что это фонограмма, иногда это бывает требованием телевизионной программы, всё равно для записи пел сам Димаш, а не кто-то другой. Я уверена, что он и в живую так споёт, может даже лучше. А исполнение было на высшем уровне! Вы меня разочаровали
Щось дуже часто він почав звертати увагу на такі речі то автотюн то фонограма.,він же знає що для ТВ передач навіть в Китаї використовують запис!Мене реакціонер теж розчарував!
Entiendo que lo comentes, en cuanto lo vi lo noté, es muy obvio, pero no le restes valor a todo el tema por ese detalle. Tú más que nadie debes saber que ciertos programas, por temas técnicos y de producción, dificultan cantar en directo. Es un temazo, cante en directo o no. Estamos tan acostumbrados a ver sus directos que nos ofende si no lo es, no es justo para él. No creo que haya sido decisión suya el no cantarlo en vivo, Dimash no le tiene miedo al directo, lo sabemos de sobra. La canción es una maravilla.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Такое чувство что его волновала не сама песня ,а в чем то уличить Димаша, очень жаль скозит неприкрытая завесть эту песню Димаш пел тысячи раз и для него не проблема сметь еще раз , очень неприятный реакционер завистник
I have not watched this "professional" analysis and I will not watch it! But I can't say I'm surprised. I saw it coming the moment H posted his previous blog "I autotuned Dimash" or something. However, it was done with respect and knowledge. I even congratulated him on his work. And here's the thing - bloggers aren't that creative in their responses and there always comes a time when they can't say anything new or interesting. Those who respect themselves and their work simply stop reacting and wait for new content where they will feel confident, more interesting and original. Others, like H in his last video, will continue to make a pittance from Dimash simply by turning the other way and joining the blogger crowd trying to discredit Di in every possible way, thus relying on hate to attract new viewers and subscribers, and monetize the video. If H was sincere in his love and respect for Dimash, he would have watched the entire concert and seen that there was a lot of conversation with event guests in a studio, a lot of documentary footage and singers singing from different locations. Yes, the concert was pre-recorded, after which the various parts were edited more or less seamlessly. What viewers saw was a finished product and not a live broadcast. And yes, I'm unsubscribing too!
I feel his envy/jealousy from his very first reaction videos about Dimash, he just pretended to praise him in purpose of getting more views, now he exposed himself as a hater, so im not even surprised at all!
Dimash has been singing this song for many years in a row, we have heard it in different versions and live too, but the blogger is not a professional, so he does not know that the format of large-scale events provides for the performance of artists for studio recording. This is not Dimash's choice, but the demand of the show organizers. And Dimash is a brilliant musician, singer, composer, arranger.
Этот блогер как раз очень хорошо знает о форматах мероприятий. Либо его давнее восхищение Димашем сменилось на искреннюю ненависть, либо у него есть определённая цель, возможно деньги
И дальше что? Мне лично пофиг, есть ли синхронизация, потому что я понимаю, это принудительно. Ты это понимаешь тоже. Так зачем всё это?Моё уважение к Димашу, не уменьшилось ни на грош.
Why are you looking for lip singing? Did you want to watch this performance only for it? Audience loves him in any case. We admire him and his art. You talked only lip singing or not. Dimash sang this song in studio or at concert it's not important. You didn't even say anything about the song and his change ganres. I disappointed in you.
Denkst wirklich, dass es noch jemanden interessiert, ob e live oder synchronisiert ist? Man konnte aus dieser Reaktion was Interessanteres mache. Du bist immer langweiliger. Schade. Ich konnte nicht zu Ende mir anzuhören.
Korrekt! Ich habe ihn live gesehen und gehört und da war garninix gefakt, es war unglaublich toll und ich hoffe das ich ihn noch mal live sehen kann!!!
In the end of the day - who cares? For me personally , what was most interesting in this video was that Dimash seems to be venturing into a new direction, developing a new singing style. You completely missed the point, concentrating on the negativity
If we agree that due to being TV they made him lip syncing, why focus on that only. He sang it when was recorded right, we know and you know what he is capable off right, so why making a big deal about it. Every artist once in a while have to do it. What about if for some reason his vocals were not at a 100% that day for sickness or something else but still he needed to perform? We as listeners have to be more understandable, specifically the reactors that are singers like you…he is human. Very disappointed with this reaction only because you could have mentioned the lipsinc but you didn’t have to make it only about that…but yes, you say you know him🤦♀️
Making your personal expectations more important than the song and the artist is very disappointing. Dimash sings to entertain. He has said so himself in several interviews. We all know he prefers to sing live. Many arguments between him and Russian TV on this subject have been quoted over the years. He doesn’t look any happier doing this show than we might be seeing him forced to do it this way, probably contractually so. But you never once mention his ability to sing good old jazz. Or the actual beauty of this Kazakh folk song. You’ve selfishly made your satisfaction as a technician more important than the artist. I have always in the past enjoyed your educated reactions, but not this time.
I loved the song, I love Dimash, live or not, I always support you, Not for once do dubbing I would NEVER ACCUSE Dimash in front of thousands of followers, I preferred to preserve the magic that music gives us. Greetings and it is with respect, but you must accept that this was very unpleasant.
Dimash is loved and hated like any other person, and here is a talent that you can't hide... and summing up for myself the result of your today's "work", I want to leave here a quote by Stas Yankovsky "If someone appears ready to move mountains, others will surely follow him, ready to wring his neck."
I really don’t think this was lip-synched. But it was out of synch. Every camera had a different delay and the sound was badly out of sync. Especially in the beginning you can see him move first the whole time and then you hear the sound. If it was lip synched it would match up most of the time. I really don’t care if a show is lip syched. I just don’t believe it would be done so visibly. There have been some reactors claiming something is lip-synched when it wasn’t. (As seen on fancams) Plus there is post production and editing that sometimes make it seem fake. But someone has to explain to me how he would be able to sing runs and hold these ridiculously long notes to a playback track and match his movements perfectly. That would be even more incredible than him singing these ridiculous notes live. Because we all know he can sing them live. Perfectly. I believe it is lip synced, when Dimash tells us it is. Otherwise I‘m sceptical. (It‘s not impossible, but you couldn’t tell from an edited video)
Primero que todo saludos desde Perú... Creo que primero debemos quitarnos la mentalidad de que Dimash debe hacer todo todo en vivo, no es asi para el ni para el otro 99.9% de los cantantes... Eso de andar reaccionando a el poniendo como tema "Dimash has lip sync" deja mucho que desear porque pareciera que lo hicieran como para desmeritar su trabajo... Yo no veo a los reactores reaccionar a cada cancion o video de cada artista cuando saca alguna cancion nueva diciendo que ese artista ha hecho lip sync cuando el 99% hace lipsync en las presentaciones para tv o en ciertas situaciones.. Dimash no se escapa a eso señores, el mas del 95% de sus canciones las canta en directo, otras canta partes de la canción en directo y otras partes de la misma cancion pregrabadas y otras veces hace lipsync eso es normal... Nada de eso le quita merito a lo excepcional que el es tanto como cantante y como persona... El ha cantado todas sus canciones en directo muchas veces asi que el no le debe demostrar que canta como un angel a nadie; eso es un hecho....Quienes hemos visto y estado en sus conciertos sabemos cuales canta en vivo y cual una que otra hace lipsync en ciertas partes.. Que no es malo porque el canta mas de 25 canciones en cada concierto y si conocemos las canciones de Dimash mas del 90% de sus canciones tiene que emplear entre 4 y 5 octavas de su rango vocal para poder cantarlas y cantar 20 canciones haciendo fa sostenido 5 o mi6 todo el tiempo eso dañaria sus cuerdas vocales para siempre.... El es un ser humano y debe cuidarse.. Por eso debemos dejar de idealizarlo como un ser que canta el 100% en directo porque seria inhumano poder hacerlo ademas de decir que en muchas presentaciones de TV no permiten cantar en directo... En china hay una ley que prohibe cantar ocn lipsync pero es solo para artistas locales y bajo ciertas circunstancias.
судя по видео Димаш выступал для аудитории с живым голосом. а нам на картинку поставили заранее записанную версию или отредактированную. но все равно я насладилась выступлением. можно считать это видео как музыкальный клип
Dimash plays piano since he was 5 years old. He is also a composer of his own songs. You have never been in a concert 10 feet away from him. This is his voice and he is singing. CCTV only air a program where not only Dimash participated.
Eu não entendi o objetivo desse vídeo, é apenas para provar que a apresentação não é ao vivo 🤔 mas quem disse que era ao vivo, e o que importa isso.😔☺️🇧🇷
Dimash has no control over what television shows do to his performances during post production. The reason there is a discrepancy between his voice and the video is because they record his rehearsals to get the "perfect" sound without the audience screaming his name. Dimash prefers to sing live, however, in situations when his personal sound engineer, who has run all of his live performances for many years and knows exactly what to do is replaced with the show's own crew, adjustments must be made. This sound engineer may have never even heard Dimash sing prior to the rehearsal and his vocal dynamics, playing two separate instruments and using two different microphones may have created technical difficulties requiring Dimash to lip sync. Dimash is terrible at lip synching because he likes to go off in the moment rather than be constrained within a recording. You will find several instances during televised performances where the camera pulls away from him or switches to another camera to view the audience. Sometimes during post production they will hear audience noises or something they don't want televised so they replace those parts with clips they recorded during rehearsal. In those moments Dimash's mouth will not be in sync with the audio so they won't show him singing during those sections. Because of this there have been people who claim Dimash doesn't sing live. They will even pull up clips from two separate performances and show how they sound identical thus "proving" he's just lip synching. Those people don't understand that the audience is hearing a 100% live vocal performance and it's only those watching it on television who hear the edited version. This is one of the reasons I prefer fan cam videos. Personally, I think his raw vocals are much more beautiful and powerful than his post production sound. You also hear the ambient sounds and actually feel the energy radiating from the audience. Everything is more personal and real. I highly recommend you check some of these out.❤
This finally answers so many questions. Thank you! 🙏🏻😊❤️ So this was LIVE for the audience in the room! And a Frankenstein-edit of different audio and video from multiple live-performances for the TV-audience. (rehearsals are basically live…) Explains the different rates of delay between different cameras. Did I get this right?
I watch a lot of TV show as I am 68 years old, most of TV show are not live, even in America, or Russia and many others, but without TV show, how are we going to see many famous artist? we know Dimash can sing and sing it so well that I could not one day without listen to his music, I enjoy his music more then he sings live or not, it is HIM sings the song, OK?
The rare times he does a full song live is sounds VERY different from his miraculous studio recordings. All the reactors gush at how he transitions from low to high or vice versa or how he can start new lines without breathing, well easy, because it's not live. In a studio recording you simply juxtapose difficult parts back to back and wow, how impressive!
Dimash is showing us how much he has been working in LA and shows us a new style -jazz. He created and produced a new style to his native folklore song that was appreciated and admired. Except for you. Dimash is above all that that you are saying here. You are really fixated on trying to make us see your point aren’t you. You have not succeeded.
I am glad you're the only negative reactor. All other music teachers, producers and knowledgeable reactors were very positive. it's about his singing a jazzy style and it's sung very good. We don't want to have all those negative boohah. We listen to his singing.
На самом деле, это песня о грустной драме двух влюблённых и Димаш хотел в начале песни передать настроение двух влюблённых и поэтому у него серьёзное лицо, даже задумчивое. Зачем Димашу усилители, у него от рождения сильный тембр голоса.
@@beaschneider7758 ja ich war auch in Düsselsdorf..ich musste nicht so weit reisen..wohne ca 30 min entfernt 😀ich möchte ihn sooo gerne wieder hören und sehen..Hongkong ist leider zu weit😉😅😅
NO HE IS NOT LIP SYNCHING. I cannot tell you how annoying this constant claim. Its simply not true. Go listen to one of his live 3 hour concerts! Hes works tireously to maintain his vocal health as well as expand and grow. Anybody who knows Dimash understands how and why he does things. Whats important to him. I would by pass this exploitive headline to get views except there are people who dont know whats going on and will believe this nonesense. Because it doesnt matter if he did in this performance. He can and will sing it live in concert. Its negstive and speculative and unnecessary. I refuse to watch this tripe.
В Китае тоже исмользуют фонограму для ТВ передач и случаев ,когда нельзя сделать живое вьІступление!Ничего страшного здесь нет!Димаш не обязан петь всегда и везде вживую,! Реакционер разочаровал!
Yahu anladık,bu işleri anlıyorsun...Ama sonuçta canlı ya da değil,bunu söyleyen Dimash.Hem de muhteşem bir şekilde söyleyen.Şarkının aranjmanındaki sürpriz,harika jaz riflerini de mi takdir edemezdin...Tüm videoda "no,no" deyip durdun...
OK, no one anywhere is claiming this is a LIVE performance. Fans who follow his activities reported Dimash flying in to a precorded session for this particular tv show which was edited for best quality for the final airing results. Many artists including the famous concert pianist Lang Lang prerecorded their performances for this tv show. The audio editors very obviously did not do a perfect job of syncing Lang Langs fingers to the music. Lang Lang was obviously playing the piano and we all know he is an extremely accomplished pianist but the audio sync job was not perfect. So, same with Dimash's performance. The camera work always requires several takes. The final result is a compilation of the various takes from different angles. The audio is a live recording at the time of filming but as there are several takes, the composition can be taken from different audio recordings depending on the visual cuts in editing. You can consider these types of Chinese tv shows as presenting music video type artistic edits shot for aesthetics. In contrast to a live concert. You will find the performance duet with Tan Wei Wei singing A Thousand Miles A Common Dream as the same type of music video. Not a live performance. But unlike you, everyone knows this and appreciates the artistic presentation for what it is. It is gorgeous and worth watching and listening to their lovely voices.
Check the fan cams rehearsal before this shooting … so strange that you so concentrated on the lip sync as if you do not believe that Dimash can sing like this…
Too bad you couldn’t enjoy the song. I thought it was a lot of fun. 🌸 I’m sorry, but I felt I had to unsubscribe when I saw you called this a FAKE performance. It may be lip syncing but it’s still his voice. Saying this is a fake seems extreme and you putting that in the title seems unfair to him.
I unsubscribe from this blogger for an unprofessional approach. You need to understand the formats of events, and know where the soundtrack is necessary and where it is unacceptable.
Para mi es genial...pero lo que detaco de Dimash en esta cansion en particular es su lado como compositor....es genial el cambio musical que realizó..y vi otras presentaciones donde hubo cambios geniales por ejemplo Daybreak es un concierto en China y mi Swan cantada en Badtau....es un musico genial....
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Well, it was an important gig for Dimash. CCTV1 is the prime channel of Chinese state TVs and they don't like things to go wrong so they have the artists lip sync. Is that any worse than a music video? I enjoyed it.
Zaista nije bitno sto nije uzivo.....ali on to pjeva,nevjerojatan vocal na ovoj planeti❤....treba se zapitati sto svaka tv kuca zeli od pjevaca,dali da se pjeva uzivo ili blayback....uvijek je uglavnom playback....to bi vi trebali znati....no mene svaki put odusevi,jer boljeg vocala nikada nisam cula od njega....Dimash❤❤❤❤
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
So disappointing because you reacted just to say lip sync. You can say whatever you want, but you did not even notice what he did to the song because your sole focus was whether or not he was lip-synching.
Exactly 😂 he was the only reactor of this performance by Dimash who focused the entire reaction whether it was sang live or pre-recorded haha. He was not able to notice the fantastic new arrangement made by Dimash for this very old song.
Этот реакционер хотел раскритиковать Димаша, но у него ничего не вышло и все удивлены потому что у Димаша очень образованые Деарс и даже в музыке. Молодцы деарс.вот такая она настоящая любовь к Димашу и его творчеству.Браво деарс!
I didn't like that you only focused on whether it's alive or not. The song is very good and the arrangement is very innovative. I respect your opinion but this time I didn't really like your vision. You give more food to the many #haters that Dimash has and to ensure that it is "Fake" just like what you put in your title, by the way, it made me very sad to see that on your channel. I've been following you for a long time and respect you, but this time, I didn't see you as very objective.
Hi, I usually watch all your videos on Dimash and know how you appreciate him. But I won't watch this one because honestly I don't care. We all know that sometimes, he has to lip sync, especially during TV shows. But what we also know is how he viscerally loves singing: he always performs live when he can. And we also know that he is able to sing everything live. The talent of Dimash is stratospheric, unique and unmatched. Personally I only need to know that he continues delivering extraordinary performances with his heart and his soul, as he always does. I really hope that one day, you will have the opportunity to attend one of his concert: you will immediately understand how vain is this question 😉. I hope that you will continue to react to his performances because your analyses are always very interesting and what really matters is the sharing of our love and our admiration for him.
I think a lot of people still care. I would care if I paid good money and somebody was just opening their mouth and giving me a prerecorded song. I can listen to that in my room, but that's not live. Of course, he doesn't do it often, but here it was the whole song and I would feel so robbed if I saw this in person. Still love him, but live is live, lip syncing is not, and this is a channel where we talk about vocals and all things music, so I won't sit here and pretend nothing is happening because that would make me fake-er than this performance
@@sofialight9258 that's not true, at least not for all shows. The law is only for specific shows like live concerts etc. So lip synching isn't 100% forbidden in China.
Bueno, yo soy Dear y me doy cuenta cuando Di hace playback, y eso no importa, sabemos su capacidad vocal y su capacidad de tocar y cantar sin ningún problema, aquí sí es sincronizacion de labios, y?,eso no me importa, igual es mucho más que esos cantante que solo viven del playback, el hace eso en muy pocas ocasiones, te recomiendo ver su última actuación en China cantando Battle of memories, aquí su canto es totalmente en vivo, y es tan formidable
Be careful with your comments. You gave an additional bonus to those who accuse Dimash of not singing himself at all. and his voice is artificial. I think with this video alone you have caused harm that Dimash’s envious people could not do over many years. Dimash will never break through to world fame. And with a drop of tar you spoiled the barrel of honey Будьте осторожны со своими комментариями. Вы дали дополнительный бонус тем, кто обвиняет Димаша в том, что он совсем не поет. И голос у него искусственный. Я думаю, что одним этим видео вы нанесли вред, который завистники Димаша не могли причинить на протяжении многих лет. Димаш никогда не прорвется к мировой славе. И каплей дегтя вы испортили бочку меда.
Tus ultimos videos acerca de dimash son diferentes...lo criticas. Por que has cambiado..es extraño. No creo que sea envidia, hay algo mas. En fin. No has descuberto America. Se sabe que no fue en vivo, pero lo novedoso es el arreglo musical que hizo de esta cancion. No solo es cantante tambien es musico. Y le quedo maravillosa.
Why be disappointed--it's a great collaboration to put out a song on TV for everyone's enjoyment. I have no doubts he could sing this live, so what's the problem? The set was great with the lights and roses, the song and his runs were so amazingly creative--it was a total pleasure for me. In fact I listen to it every morning to get me up and going! I think you were right about what you said it's not live but like you also said, they didn't say it was live. Probably collaborated long distance, IMHO.
Perché c'è disappunto? In alcuni video Dimash è incollato e riripreso. Così gira il mondo. Per il resto- Lui è indiscusso genio di vocalità, talentuoso, dotato, super allenato con grandi sacrifici, un giovane di buona educazione, dedicato a famiglia, allo studio, alle sue passioni. Ad avere ragazzi come Lui!
Que pena este señor que hace un video tratando de minimizar el talento del mejor cantante del mundo, la voz mas bella de todos los tiempos, el mejor vocalista de la historia de la musica, una leyenda viviente, que desde ya sera parte de la historia de la musica. La bellisima voz de Dimash es una bendicion de Dios al mundo en medio de este caos, no importa ya lo que puedas llegar a decir de el, mas alla de todo, nos espera la voz mas bella del mundo. Gracias Dimash ❤
And then you said, I'm sorry this is not Dimash singing. But it IS Dimash singing, whether it's lipsynced or not!! I have to agree with others about the clickbait thing. And I did not hear those auto-tune artifacts you were talking about. You used to love Dimash, not sure what happened....
I love your content, and I know you're aware of the different reasons artists may lipsync, so I'm confused why you're only now talking about potential lipsyncing. Theres videos that are much more obvious to me when it comes to lipsyncing, such as the Slavic Bazaar SOS performance that was clearly lipsynced to a studio performance (with very noticable autotune unfortunately). A lot of his premieres are lipsynced and he has to lipsync on a lot of televised shows and events. Its just part of the job in modern music. Dimash is not unique for it. He's not a bad person for it either (I'm sure you agree) and all artists do it. Its especially important for Dimash as he wants to preserve his voice, so he lipsyncs a lot so he doesn't lose his voice on harder songs. His live performances are jaw dropping too (SOS at Singer which was absolutely live, as were his other singer performances). His concerts are also mostly live, with SOS always live, and if you watch a lot of his concerts you'll realise hes getting better live too.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Aún esperas que Dimash venga y te de una actuación en vivo?? Lo ha hecho miles de veces !! Y por esta actuación lo crucificas?? Tu lo dijiste que en las televisoras los obligan entonces porque la decepción?? Quien piensas que grabó la canción??? Acaso otro artista?? No!! Fue Dimash el la grabó y si pudiera te la cantaba a ti solo en vivo estoy segura. Me voy !!!!
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
My response to your comments: ruclips.net/video/r9wfQVdQMVc/видео.html
I'm sorry but I have no interest in watching this video explaining your reasons. I won't watch it because the most striking thing in your video posted here is a post with the call (LIP SYNC) . In my opinion this was a lack of professionalism from a person who claims to be a vocal coach.
@@ricdeioI agree with you
После драки кулаками не машут, никому не нужно второе, не менее глупое и пустое по содержанию видео. Мы уже все поняли про Вас. Большая просьба, раскачивайте свой канал не за счёт Димаша и не делайте больше никаких реакций на его прекрасное творчество!
read my coment, thank you very much for show me your "evil troll side" like someone said on the last video. You lost a fan, a subscriber and someone who listened your song about war.
Predstava je završena.
Istina je kao voda, uvek pronađe svoj put.
Nikada Vas nisam pratila. Vaša "ljubav" prema Dimashu za mene je bila jeftina predstava.
Toliko.
Buddy, I'd like to give you a piece of advice: please stop reacting to Dimash. Every reaction now has doubts or criticisms. Presentation with wei wei about the tone of Dimash's voice when they both sing in the same register. That sounded strange to you. Now a click bait with Lip Sync. Dimash doesn't have the autonomy to decide whether or not to sing live in programmes, which is a matter for the contractor. You as a music teacher should know that. So stop reacting to this singer. I don't see you sensationalising other singers by asking if they're singing lip sync.
I really hope you'll stop analysing Dimash. Dimash doesn't need vocal teachers doubting his vocal abilities. He's been studying since he was five and has his own singing teachers and a whole team supporting and advising him in his career. Focus on your career as a singer and teacher. Let the Kazakh singer pursue their career without speculation - do you sing live or not?
I started listening to dimash only this year and he is really talented. I have great admiration for him as he is a person true to himself. I do not believe whatever nonsense this reactor says. I guess he has to find fault as he cant sing like dimash. Anyway as said he should stop reacting to dimash and now when i see his face i skip watching his reactions and any other who talks nonsense
I agree. It seems u r determined to "prove" Dimash lipsynchs, as u know this is a show in China, they do not allow that.
I think it's time you cease and desist from reacting and find another type of work.
@@bya165this reactor just can't sing like dimash that why he say dimash lipsynchs 😂😂😂
I have watched and supported every reaction you've done with Dimash for 2+ yrs now. I'm a big fan of yours also.....HOWEVER the biggest disappointment I have from this one is NOT whether its badly edited, whether its lip synched or playback. My biggest disappointment is you continuing for 14 minutes to prove and harp on the fact you believe it was. I'm never disappointed with the truth or someone's opinion..... but was it truly necessary to just hammer it to death. If you were wanting to get more viewings and "sell" the video I feel thats crappy way to do it 😢. If you didn't like it happening then just don't publish the video......let it go!! For us that greatly admire Dimash for what he is and does we see no reason to publicly bad mouth what we don't like (he's NOT perfect, nor do we all like everythinghe does). I was truly raised by "if you have nothing good to say, don't say anything at all"!!!!
Now if you mentioned it once because you felt that was what was happening thats fine! But how about also something good about the arrangement, his Dombra playing, him switching up the song from old folk (rich baritone singing) to Jazz and his runs etc.
Sorry have to say I was truly dissapointed in how you handled this one 😰💔
💯
💯
Ive unsubscribed as a result.
Very well said.
AMEN
What Dimash does as a singer and as a composer is sooooo good that I don't even plan to spend a second of my life worrying about whether he sang live or not. Please keep singing, that's all I ask!
I love this jazz funk version of the song. Bravo Dimash!! 💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
I normally really enjoy watching your reactions but this was totally unpleasant to watch. Not because you said that he lip synched. He most likely did for this show and I couldn't care less. But because you focussed 95% of the video on proving that he is lip synching which just gave off a super negative vibe through the whole vid. No comments on this wonderful song or his vocal abilities. There is so much cool stuff in this song to analyse as a vocal coach. The runs, the whistle notes, the belts, the switch from folk to jazz etc.. But you decided to be grumpy and only talk about him lip synching. He still sang the song (probably in a studio), so who cares? We know that he can sing that stuff live and there were reasons why he couldn't do it at this occasion. If I pay money to watch Dimash live then I would go to one of his concerts and not to a tv show that might force artists to sing playback. So let's not make a bigger deal out of this than it is.
Sorry but for this video I can only give a thumbs down, since it was really not enjoyable.
Thank you! I am sure it’s a sentiment shared by many.
also... noone said it is LIVE so why he is trying to prove it is LIVE or not?
Actually I agree with one of the above comments, that as this was done for a televised performance it could well have been recorded a few times and they just picked the best vocal track. We've seen a video with the audience reaction so we know he was definitely singing it.
@@debbiemorgan859 as 99% of such events in any TV in every country. this was not concert
Well he always criticized Dimash’s voice I don’t know maybe it’s for more views and comments??
Lip sync or not it doesent matter, he sings and he is amazing as always.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
@@jooliveirabrasil5672 nice try bot;) how much he paid for this comment?)
Anyone who plays an instrument (like me, who plays keyboards) notices the technical quality of Dimash's arrangements: In the part where he harmonized the melody with a funk-jazz arrangement he could use the classic jazz-bebop scale (with the augmented fifth) but, based on the positions of his hands on the keyboard and the sound, we can see that he enhances the music using inverted chords, increases augmented fourths and sevenths and explores variations of the mixolydian mode, these are complex chords that demonstrate what an excellent vocalist, musician, instrumentalist and arranger Dimash is! written by
@zemanoshtronz
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
@@jooliveirabrasil5672 I agree
I haven't bothered watching as I'm frankly sick of the whole lip syncing argument. Of course there's times when he has to lip sync but it depends on the event that he's working at and the circumstances surrounding it. Of the four performances in China, two were absolutely live, one was pre-recorded because they wanted pretty surroundings and I have no idea about this one but I enjoyed it anyway as he reinvented an old song.
If anyone is questioning whether it's actually his voice, then that's ridiculous and just shows that people don't know what direction he's currently working in. He's already said that while he's been in the US he's focusing on jazz and blues and one of the first IG posts we got from him was with a vocal coach who is a renowned gospel specialist. It's not the first time we've heard him sing jazz and his early college years were focused on pop/jazz vocals.
Destes 4 eventos, quais foram ao vivo?
Join Hands and Battle of Memories
@@debbiemorgan859 Obrigada
Geen enkele andere zanger wordt zoveel op het rooster gelegd over lipsynchronisatie of autotune.
Met onmiddellijke ingang abonnement weg en kijk zelf niet eens naar de reactie.
I didn't bother watching either, as the headlines were so cheap and disgusting from someone who has gained subscriptions from Dears for years.
Димаш поет песню, написанную сотню лет назад и он поет ее так, что она проникает в души сердца! Он одимашил эту старинную песню. Но H of The Stage этого даже не заметил! Фууу я разочарована. Очень неприятно обнаружить такую узость восприятия у человека. которого я уважала. Я отписываюсь. Прощайте
, it is just envy
, it is just envy
Estou com você... mais uma inscrição cancelada
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
@@vered3179 Вы правы! Давно за ним это подозревала...Но так явно он никогда себя не проявлял...Низко...!
Ну надо же катастрофа! Разочаровался учитель! Сенсация! Димаш лучшийй!
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
We don’t care if it wasn’t live we just enjoyed. We know what Dimash is capable to do.
Я просто не понимаю, зачем было делать такую реакцию🤷.. Вы сказали о людях... итак, вы заплатили сами за этот концерт и вас обманули? Нет... это была телепередача, я не уверена, что там была вообще публика, но если и была, думаю они были в курсе, тем более что, наверное, все выступления артистов были записаны заранее. А еще покажите мне, где было написано, что это живое выступление? Димаш это где-то написал? Организаторы шоу? Нет. Так что считайте что это клип и просто наслаждайтесь этой уникальной композицией. с меня отписка...
Дело было в студии, были зрители, было интервью Димаша на проекте "Красота и гармония". Был волшебный дуэт Димаша и Ланг Ланга. Фрагмент фортепианного концерта композитора Синь Синхая. "Песнь лодочника Желтой Реки". Затем сольное выступление.
👍👏👏👏
Dimash is able to bring an ancient Kasakha folk song into the present. With touches of jazz and funk he transformed it into something great!!!
3 лайка❤❤❤😅
💯
Что с Вами случилось? Нет искренности в Ваших словах. А жаль. Когда то говорили от души. А сейчас Вам не верю.
Gosh… I don’t generally leave comments, but this time I’ll make an exception, no matter if this comment will be read or not.
I am very surprised and disappointed by your reaction this time. I didn’t see that coming. I was happy to enjoy a new reaction and then … the infamous lip syncing controversy again. Geeez … I am okay when reactors mention lip syncing when they see it. I don’t necessarily want to “defend” singers at all cost, no matter how much I can love them, and I will stand by the fact that, as a reactor, if you want to say something, you are free to say it as long as it is said with respect. And I’m personally totally okay with the fact that if you think that Dimash - or an another singer - is lip syncing in a performance, you can say it. But why making an entire video talking about just that topic only ? Other good reactors had mention lip syncing once or twice and after, they move on … They don’t just talk about that specifically throughout their videos. Plus, this was a TV Show, not a concert, so why bother that much ? They where so many other things to talk about Dimash’s performance, and yet, you only talked about the lip syncing. Why didn’t you talked at least a little bit about the instrumental for exemple ? Or about Dimash’s voice and/or techniques ? The Jazz part ? Lip syncing or not, there is still things to analyze, right …? I’m sorry but listening to you only focusing so hard about proving that Dimash is lip syncing- and for almost 15 min straight - was certainly not pleasant … :/ That makes me sad to see that you couldn’t enjoy that beautiful song …
Well said, there were 50 performers in this show, if he seriously thinks that a show of this magnitude would not have required many takes, many hours of editing and some unfortunate mistakes in the process then he's an idiot. Even Lang Langs performance was completely out of sync. I'm seriously doubting this guy's claim to be a vocal coach if he isn't aware of what goes on in a TV recording. They'll record and clip and finally add the best audio track. It's show business and it's not always down to the performer as what happens, especially in a show of this magnitude which would have been heavily controlled by the Chinese government.
❗Haven't watched this but here's what I DO know. My sister and I grew up in Kazakhstan, she and several of my friends went to school with him, our parents are friends and he's been battling this accusation as long as I can remember. Moscow has one arena and one other venue (the Kremlin) that require prior recording, the largest arena does not, his biggest success there and THAT'S the only time he's ever acquiesced and it under duress, in his performing career in live performance. Frankly, I'm tired of his waving his mic across his mouth while singing live to prove to his critics he's not lip syncing. That's not a mic "technique ". Period end of sentence.
Beneath him? WADR, it is beneath you to believe that Dimash should refuse to participate in cultural events/productions if he is required to lip sync. I feel sorry for you that you have resorted to this kind of reaction. So what if he lip synced himself!! And to plaster this in red across your photo? C'mon he deserves better from you. You are not required to be respectful, sadly. He is required to abide by the rules of the venue.
Until now I have always held back on this topic of lip syncing because I see this fuss as completely unnecessary. But now I have to say that this discussion is starting to get on my nerves. Are you really serious about starting a topic with this unnecessary comparison, whether live or not? If, as you state, one REALLY and TRULY appreciates and believes in an artist for their exceptional achievement, then this discussion on this topic should be beneath YOUR dignity! It's so easy to convince yourself 100% of Dimash's skills...go to one of his concerts! And then you can ask yourself whether this topic should even have a place in a Dimash reaction video!
You're being naïve and it's detestable! You could say you hated TV that forced performers to lip sync and leave it at that. But the whole video is on this subject. You took us for fools. Nothing about so many other aspects of this new song with a "first" for Dimash with this bold and creative musical style. Even if you hate giving reactions to television performances, be an adult and refrain from criticizing the artist on this point of detail because it is so common in this industry. And you call yourself a professional!
I really hated seeing the word "FAKE" next to Dimash. Even if you're right, he sang the song, and no one else. We know that he is capable of doing live performances, in fact he does live concerts of 3 hours and more. Out of respect for him, if you say you love him, you shouldn't have put that ugly title, making it evident as if it were a crime. It's your channel and you can do whatever you want, but I really didn't like that you did it.
100%
Agree
Yes!!
Yes
What's your problem? This is easy peasy stuff for Dimash. He's mostly in chest voice; he's known for not showing strain even when he belts or soars into his coleratur soprano at times. He hates lipsyncing and only succumbs to it under constraining circumstances. But I sincerely doubt he would pretend to sing and play this new/jazzed up premiere of Dudarai. China's rules on live performing are known to be strict. This was in Macau though, so I reserve my right to apologise. But even after listening to Dimash on so many occasions, you clearly don't seem to know him at all, despite your 'expertise.' Your observations do not convince me, and allow me to state the obvious: he is by far the most accomplished and conscientious vocalist and performer of our times.
Lol, fake? That is a bold statement. Not being performed live does not make it fake. Still his vocals, him playing those instruments, AND his arrangement that rewrote completely a folk song.
It's a TV show, there are other lipsynced performances in his channel, all in tv shows. If the production of this show decided that performances had to be pre-recorded and there were an audience in that studio, nobody was tricked, everybody knew what the rules were.
Dimash is amazing, as always.
Yes “fake” means fraud. As a lawyer I would suggest you not use that word. As you noted, Dimash did not say this was a “live” performance. Notwithstanding, you went on for 14 minutes calling him out as being a fake! “Fake” is also used in the title of your reaction. And several have already commented that they know he is a fake; always has been a fake, etc. etc. so lots of damages could be on the way.
I don’t get how everyone will listen to a MV and say nothing but identify a lip synch in this kind of performance. If this was a MV, would you still complain? Please answer this question because I don’t understand! Look at Across Endless Dimensions MV. Any complaints? He should have released this as a MV and you would not have complained, right?
Fake ?What do you mean?Dimash-fake?So, somebody else is singing?😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ой, зачем вы делаете вид, будто не знаете, что формат выступления на официальных тв каналах певец, Димаш это или другой - не определяет? Вы врёте или притворяетесь?
С других выступлений есть фанкамы, и они немного отличаются от официальной версии - но это формат тв шоу.
Разве это сольный концерт Димаша?
Всё помнят историю, когда на тв концерте в Москве Димаш пел Know в версии вокализа, и есть фанкамы. Но в тв версии поставили без его ведома вариант этой песни со словами. Так как автор слов - совладелец тв канала. И нашлись такие же, как вы, странные люди, которые набросились на Димаша с обвинениями и увидели несинхронное движение губ. Это неудивительно. Удивительно, что вы такой же притворщик и врун
Жаба его начала душить вдруг,раньше он так себя не вел!
@@liudadears2869 я теперь уверена, что он отработал заказ. Это деньги, а не жаба. Не может вокалист или преподаватель вокала не знать особенности организации тв шоу. Он врет и плохой актёр, видно что врет. Ну что же, пойду почищу подписки - я на него подписана с двух других каналов. И заодно других сомнительных реакционеров уберу.
В этом печально другое - почти все они, значит, неискренни и за донат польют грязью любого.
Скучно
Isso é absolutamente normal em programas de TV e em nenhum lugar diz que é uma apresentação ao vivo. Pode ter sido, mas mal editado, isso também acontece. Ao vivo ou não, Dimash é sempre excepcional e suas performances são surreais. Diferente de tudo que já ouvimos ou estamos acostumados a ouvir. Quanto ao reacionário, há detalhes muito mais significativos nesta atuação aos quais ele deveria prestar atenção e valorizar! Qual cantor nunca cantou com limpsync? Todos os grandes cantores cantaram e ainda cantam! Mas aqui a intenção é menosprezar o talento do Dimash! E não permitiremos isso! Porque Dimash não precisa mais provar nada a ninguém. Ele é e continuará a ser a maior voz de todos os tempos! Aliás, não só voz, pois é um artista completo em todos os aspectos musicais e artísticos! Goste ou não!
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
I don't understand why it even matters? He still sang it, it's not FAKE. Why are you focused on that and not the song, which is amazing? Ugh, YOU are disappointing.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
@@jooliveirabrasil5672 I can only hope that he loses many followers over this. I don't understand how anyone can claim to love Dimash and then turn an entire (non)reaction video of an amazing song into a rant on lip syncing. It's sickening. 😡
SORRY, WHAT DO YOU WANT TO PROVE BY THIS REACTION? DIMASH IS DIMASH !
Your worst reaction so far. "Lip-sync, lip-sync...", that's the only thing you were saying over and over. Fake reaction, I would say. Yes, singers do lip-sync on tv shows!! What a surprise!!! 🤦🏻♀️
This performance was from his time in China and was recorded and released for Chinese tv. I have no doubt it was pre-recorded. It's done all the time. But why call it FAKE?
Похоже внимание Димаша на него плохо подействовало. Конечно же это отписка однозначно. Не потому что правду сказал, а потому что так рьяно это сделал, как будто только и ждал момента, когда сможет втоптать его в грязь. Все знаменитые певцы используют фонограмму. Ни один не поет все свои песни всегда вживую. Мы знаем возможности Димаша, он не обязан каждый раз доказывать нам свои голосовые возможности. Я хочу, чтобы он берег свой голос, чтобы мог нас радовать своими песнями долгие годы, а не доказывать всем свои возможности и рисковать своим голосом. Ваши потуги были более чем напрасны. Очень жаль. Разочарована.
Я давно разочарована. С тех пор, как настойчиво делал упор на том, что «Ок» было подражанием стилю Б.Айлиш. Не потому, что отказываю ему в выражении мнения, а оттого, что делает это с желанием добиться внимания к своей особе и явно с недобрыми намерениями. Если он думает, что открывает нам, невежественным, америку, то очень ошибается. Большинству диарс и без него всегда известно, в каком режиме поет артист.
(заглянула сюда только чтобы почитать комменты под таким хайповым заголовком))). видео на стопе, просмотров не собираюсь ему добавлять.)
So what if it is not live. He sang it at some point. It is his voice. So what are you complaining about?
"he is too calm for this singing" what?
Неужели самое главное в этом выступлении не потрясающее соединение разных музыкальных стилей и жанров? Самое главное, что это запись?! Вы меня разочаровали. Не думала, что вы так поверхностно судите
Это для нас "и что", а они сознательно ищут живые выступления
@@natali.tomilova. так нигде и не написано было, что это живое. чего же так возмущаться.. взял выступление для тв канала, так и написано в названии, а потом обидился что неживое, типа его обманули.. и ещё 15 минут только про это и говорил... и ничего про саму композицию.. обидно.
@@Irina_Savenkova👍👏👏👏
@@Irina_Savenkova 👍🏻👏👏👏👏👏👏🇧🇷
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Dears, I just want to ask you to please spend more time on our favorite artist’s channel, than on reactor’s channels. Dimash deserves our views, not the reactors. It’s sad to see when his videos get less views than combined reactions to them. The haters are always very happy to point the number of views out. Let’s support him TOGETHER! Thank you dears! ✌️
PS: I personally stopped watching reactions a long time ago. All of the reactors (with very few exceptions) go through the same path with Dimash reactions, this one seems to be at the end of his.
❤
💯❤️
Absolutely and totally agree with you dear Elena..Is what i say and write from years but unfortunately many people is crazy and obsessed with the reactions and doesn't understand that who follow the youtubers and their reactions about Dimash doesn't support Dimash and his work at all but support only the youtubers and their channels..I don't follow the reactions, i only control if the youtubers respect Dimash and his work with the necessary link in description of the original video and or the link of the Dimash's channel..The Boss King Angel Dimash Forever
yes!!!!
Dimash ❤❤❤
Why do you think his Chinese fans who always on scenes recording him and know exactly when he lipsync or not never pay attention to this issue? Because it's normal for them. In China showbiz culture, some tv program need artists singing live while some need the artists prerecord their singing so they can retake how many scenes they want.
If you're on weibo where his complete activities are recorded by his chinese fans on daily basis since 2017, then you know his live performances are far greater in number compared to just a few of his prerecorded performances.
Вас волнует только одно: живое пение или нет? Даже если предположить, что это фонограмма, иногда это бывает требованием телевизионной программы, всё равно для записи пел сам Димаш, а не кто-то другой. Я уверена, что он и в живую так споёт, может даже лучше. А исполнение было на высшем уровне! Вы меня разочаровали
Exacto. Quién fue la IA la que grabó la canción en el estudio de grabación?. 😂😂😂😂
Щось дуже часто він почав звертати увагу на такі речі то автотюн то фонограма.,він же знає що для ТВ передач навіть в Китаї використовують запис!Мене реакціонер теж розчарував!
да он всегда ищет к чему бы придраться, то ли зависть его мучает, то ли ещё что😡
@@ЛюдмилаЛебедева-щ1с зависть его мучает
@@ЛюдмилаЛебедева-щ1с , it is just envy
Entiendo que lo comentes, en cuanto lo vi lo noté, es muy obvio, pero no le restes valor a todo el tema por ese detalle. Tú más que nadie debes saber que ciertos programas, por temas técnicos y de producción, dificultan cantar en directo. Es un temazo, cante en directo o no. Estamos tan acostumbrados a ver sus directos que nos ofende si no lo es, no es justo para él. No creo que haya sido decisión suya el no cantarlo en vivo, Dimash no le tiene miedo al directo, lo sabemos de sobra. La canción es una maravilla.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Такое чувство что его волновала не сама песня ,а в чем то уличить Димаша, очень жаль скозит неприкрытая завесть эту песню Димаш пел тысячи раз и для него не проблема сметь еще раз , очень неприятный реакционер завистник
I have not watched this "professional" analysis and I will not watch it! But I can't say I'm surprised. I saw it coming the moment H posted his previous blog "I autotuned Dimash" or something. However, it was done with respect and knowledge. I even congratulated him on his work. And here's the thing - bloggers aren't that creative in their responses and there always comes a time when they can't say anything new or interesting. Those who respect themselves and their work simply stop reacting and wait for new content where they will feel confident, more interesting and original. Others, like H in his last video, will continue to make a pittance from Dimash simply by turning the other way and joining the blogger crowd trying to discredit Di in every possible way, thus relying on hate to attract new viewers and subscribers, and monetize the video. If H was sincere in his love and respect for Dimash, he would have watched the entire concert and seen that there was a lot of conversation with event guests in a studio, a lot of documentary footage and singers singing from different locations. Yes, the concert was pre-recorded, after which the various parts were edited more or less seamlessly. What viewers saw was a finished product and not a live broadcast. And yes, I'm unsubscribing too!
I feel his envy/jealousy from his very first reaction videos about Dimash, he just pretended to praise him in purpose of getting more views, now he exposed himself as a hater, so im not even surprised at all!
Hey, maybe the reactor has no expertise in analyzing jazz/funk/swing, so he had to change the subject. 😋
I have unsubscibed too. There are far too many reactors to subscribe too.
Dimash has been singing this song for many years in a row, we have heard it in different versions and live too, but the blogger is not a professional, so he does not know that the format of large-scale events provides for the performance of artists for studio recording. This is not Dimash's choice, but the demand of the show organizers. And Dimash is a brilliant musician, singer, composer, arranger.
Этот блогер как раз очень хорошо знает о форматах мероприятий. Либо его давнее восхищение Димашем сменилось на искреннюю ненависть, либо у него есть определённая цель, возможно деньги
Sir, you have just exposed yourself as who you really are with this "reaction" video. What is really fake is your statement "I love Dimash".
Это точно. Сказал так в попытке избежать ответного негатива...
И дальше что? Мне лично пофиг, есть ли синхронизация, потому что я понимаю, это принудительно. Ты это понимаешь тоже. Так зачем всё это?Моё уважение к Димашу, не уменьшилось ни на грош.
You were not able to see the beauty of the song and the interpretation. What a pity!
It's not about Dimash. Something happened in H's life. He stopped seeing beauty. What happened to you, H?
Why are you looking for lip singing? Did you want to watch this performance only for it? Audience loves him in any case. We admire him and his art. You talked only lip singing or not. Dimash sang this song in studio or at concert it's not important. You didn't even say anything about the song and his change ganres. I disappointed in you.
Denkst wirklich, dass es noch jemanden interessiert, ob e live oder synchronisiert ist? Man konnte aus dieser Reaktion was Interessanteres mache. Du bist immer langweiliger. Schade. Ich konnte nicht zu Ende mir anzuhören.
100%.. Personally, I can't understand what's the big deal.
Korrekt! Ich habe ihn live gesehen und gehört und da war garninix gefakt, es war unglaublich toll und ich hoffe das ich ihn noch mal live sehen kann!!!
In the end of the day - who cares? For me personally , what was most interesting in this video was that Dimash seems to be venturing into a new direction, developing a new singing style. You completely missed the point, concentrating on the negativity
If we agree that due to being TV they made him lip syncing, why focus on that only. He sang it when was recorded right, we know and you know what he is capable off right, so why making a big deal about it. Every artist once in a while have to do it. What about if for some reason his vocals were not at a 100% that day for sickness or something else but still he needed to perform? We as listeners have to be more understandable, specifically the reactors that are singers like you…he is human. Very disappointed with this reaction only because you could have mentioned the lipsinc but you didn’t have to make it only about that…but yes, you say you know him🤦♀️
Surprised.... DID NOT expect an analysis of lip sync..... expected a reaction to DIMASH!!!😢😢😢
Making your personal expectations more important than the song and the artist is very disappointing. Dimash sings to entertain. He has said so himself in several interviews. We all know he prefers to sing live. Many arguments between him and Russian TV on this subject have been quoted over the years. He doesn’t look any happier doing this show than we might be seeing him forced to do it this way, probably contractually so. But you never once mention his ability to sing good old jazz. Or the actual beauty of this Kazakh folk song. You’ve selfishly made your satisfaction as a technician more important than the artist. I have always in the past enjoyed your educated reactions, but not this time.
I agree! So disapointed!
I loved the song, I love Dimash, live or not, I always support you, Not for once do dubbing I would NEVER ACCUSE Dimash in front of thousands of followers, I preferred to preserve the magic that music gives us. Greetings and it is with respect, but you must accept that this was very unpleasant.
Whats with this obssession with lip syncing ! If you have listened to Dimash before, this is obviously his voice. So disappointing.
Dimash is loved and hated like any other person, and here is a talent that you can't hide... and summing up for myself the result of your today's "work", I want to leave here a quote by Stas Yankovsky "If someone appears ready to move mountains, others will surely follow him, ready to wring his neck."
I really don’t think this was lip-synched. But it was out of synch.
Every camera had a different delay and the sound was badly out of sync. Especially in the beginning you can see him move first the whole time and then you hear the sound. If it was lip synched it would match up most of the time.
I really don’t care if a show is lip syched. I just don’t believe it would be done so visibly. There have been some reactors claiming something is lip-synched when it wasn’t. (As seen on fancams)
Plus there is post production and editing that sometimes make it seem fake. But someone has to explain to me how he would be able to sing runs and hold these ridiculously long notes to a playback track and match his movements perfectly. That would be even more incredible than him singing these ridiculous notes live. Because we all know he can sing them live. Perfectly.
I believe it is lip synced, when Dimash tells us it is. Otherwise I‘m sceptical. (It‘s not impossible, but you couldn’t tell from an edited video)
Primero que todo saludos desde Perú... Creo que primero debemos quitarnos la mentalidad de que Dimash debe hacer todo todo en vivo, no es asi para el ni para el otro 99.9% de los cantantes... Eso de andar reaccionando a el poniendo como tema "Dimash has lip sync" deja mucho que desear porque pareciera que lo hicieran como para desmeritar su trabajo... Yo no veo a los reactores reaccionar a cada cancion o video de cada artista cuando saca alguna cancion nueva diciendo que ese artista ha hecho lip sync cuando el 99% hace lipsync en las presentaciones para tv o en ciertas situaciones.. Dimash no se escapa a eso señores, el mas del 95% de sus canciones las canta en directo, otras canta partes de la canción en directo y otras partes de la misma cancion pregrabadas y otras veces hace lipsync eso es normal... Nada de eso le quita merito a lo excepcional que el es tanto como cantante y como persona... El ha cantado todas sus canciones en directo muchas veces asi que el no le debe demostrar que canta como un angel a nadie; eso es un hecho....Quienes hemos visto y estado en sus conciertos sabemos cuales canta en vivo y cual una que otra hace lipsync en ciertas partes.. Que no es malo porque el canta mas de 25 canciones en cada concierto y si conocemos las canciones de Dimash mas del 90% de sus canciones tiene que emplear entre 4 y 5 octavas de su rango vocal para poder cantarlas y cantar 20 canciones haciendo fa sostenido 5 o mi6 todo el tiempo eso dañaria sus cuerdas vocales para siempre.... El es un ser humano y debe cuidarse.. Por eso debemos dejar de idealizarlo como un ser que canta el 100% en directo porque seria inhumano poder hacerlo ademas de decir que en muchas presentaciones de TV no permiten cantar en directo... En china hay una ley que prohibe cantar ocn lipsync pero es solo para artistas locales y bajo ciertas circunstancias.
👏👏👏👍
судя по видео Димаш выступал для аудитории с живым голосом. а нам на картинку поставили заранее записанную версию или отредактированную. но все равно я насладилась выступлением.
можно считать это видео как музыкальный клип
они могли записать несколько дублей и выбрать лучшие кадры и звук, потом свести
@@olichkaBelDear Exactly! I am surprised that a person in the musical industry wouldn’t know or think of this.
Да, видно же, что это не Димаш покт под фонограмму, а картинка отстает от голоса
Dimash plays piano since he was 5 years old. He is also a composer of his own songs. You have never been in a concert 10 feet away from him. This is his voice and he is singing. CCTV only air a program where not only Dimash participated.
Does it really matters, he lips sinking or not? We all know about Dimash abilities.
вы все время ищите какие то недостатки! Не нравится, проходите мимо! Какая то реакция неискренняя, жаль!
Да ты ненавидишь Димаша и завидуешь ему.....☹
Eu não entendi o objetivo desse vídeo, é apenas para provar que a apresentação não é ao vivo 🤔 mas quem disse que era ao vivo, e o que importa isso.😔☺️🇧🇷
Yes…disappointed that you spent your time being negative about alignment of video. This is an amazing performance. His vocals are incredible!
Пригласили специально в Китай, чтоб Димаш спел под фонограмму? ЧУШЬ.
Dimash has no control over what television shows do to his performances during post production. The reason there is a discrepancy between his voice and the video is because they record his rehearsals to get the "perfect" sound without the audience screaming his name. Dimash prefers to sing live, however, in situations when his personal sound engineer, who has run all of his live performances for many years and knows exactly what to do is replaced with the show's own crew, adjustments must be made. This sound engineer may have never even heard Dimash sing prior to the rehearsal and his vocal dynamics, playing two separate instruments and using two different microphones may have created technical difficulties requiring Dimash to lip sync. Dimash is terrible at lip synching because he likes to go off in the moment rather than be constrained within a recording. You will find several instances during televised performances where the camera pulls away from him or switches to another camera to view the audience. Sometimes during post production they will hear audience noises or something they don't want televised so they replace those parts with clips they recorded during rehearsal. In those moments Dimash's mouth will not be in sync with the audio so they won't show him singing during those sections. Because of this there have been people who claim Dimash doesn't sing live. They will even pull up clips from two separate performances and show how they sound identical thus "proving" he's just lip synching. Those people don't understand that the audience is hearing a 100% live vocal performance and it's only those watching it on television who hear the edited version. This is one of the reasons I prefer fan cam videos. Personally, I think his raw vocals are much more beautiful and powerful than his post production sound. You also hear the ambient sounds and actually feel the energy radiating from the audience. Everything is more personal and real. I highly recommend you check some of these out.❤
This finally answers so many questions. Thank you! 🙏🏻😊❤️
So this was LIVE for the audience in the room!
And a Frankenstein-edit of different audio and video from multiple live-performances for the TV-audience. (rehearsals are basically live…)
Explains the different rates of delay between different cameras.
Did I get this right?
As a professional in the music industry, he should know all this, imho! The title of the video is inexcusable.
I watch a lot of TV show as I am 68 years old, most of TV show are not live, even in America, or Russia and many others, but without TV show, how are we going to see many famous artist? we know Dimash can sing and sing it so well that I could not one day without listen to his music, I enjoy his music more then he sings live or not, it is HIM sings the song, OK?
The rare times he does a full song live is sounds VERY different from his miraculous studio recordings. All the reactors gush at how he transitions from low to high or vice versa or how he can start new lines without breathing, well easy, because it's not live. In a studio recording you simply juxtapose difficult parts back to back and wow, how impressive!
@@tallard666 What live appearances of Dimash have you been to? Just curious.
Dimash is showing us how much he has been working in LA and shows us a new style -jazz. He created and produced a new style to his native folklore song that was appreciated and admired. Except for you.
Dimash is above all that that you are saying here. You are really fixated on trying to make us see your point aren’t you. You have not succeeded.
I am glad you're the only negative reactor. All other music teachers, producers and knowledgeable reactors were very positive. it's about his singing a jazzy style and it's sung very good. We don't want to have all those negative boohah. We listen to his singing.
На самом деле, это песня о грустной драме двух влюблённых и Димаш хотел в начале песни передать настроение двух влюблённых и поэтому у него серьёзное лицо, даже задумчивое. Зачем Димашу усилители, у него от рождения сильный тембр голоса.
I dont care about your Talking about Dimash. I always Love him forever, He is the best singer in The World.
Does it really matter?????? Dimash ie the best singer of all times. Please, just enjoy it.
Völlig egal..wir wissen das Dimash alles live singen kann..❤
Richtig!!! Habe ihn live gesehen bzw. Gehört und es war einfach unglaublich 👌🥰 er faket garninix
@@beaschneider7758 Ich war auch auf seinem Konzert..unbeschreiblich..ich war im siebten Himmel😀
@@dqdreams8251 und die zeit ist so schnell vergangen, ich hätte ihm 10 Stunden zuhören können 🥰
@@dqdreams8251 warst du auch in Düsseldorf?
@@beaschneider7758 ja ich war auch in Düsselsdorf..ich musste nicht so weit reisen..wohne ca 30 min entfernt 😀ich möchte ihn sooo gerne wieder hören und sehen..Hongkong ist leider zu weit😉😅😅
Странно, этот блогер до сих пор не принёс извинений и название все ещё не изменено. Значит, он доволен произведённых впечатлением.
Do you really care about his apology now? The damage is done.
Vocal Coach? NO tu no eres vocal coach, tu lo que eres es un envidioso del extraordinario talento de DIMASH.
NO HE IS NOT LIP SYNCHING.
I cannot tell you how annoying this constant
claim. Its simply not true. Go listen to one of his live 3 hour concerts! Hes works tireously to maintain his vocal health as well as expand and grow.
Anybody who knows Dimash understands how and why he does things. Whats important to him.
I would by pass this
exploitive headline
to get views except there are people who dont know whats going on and will believe this nonesense. Because it doesnt matter if he did in this performance. He can and will sing it live in concert.
Its negstive and speculative and unnecessary. I refuse to watch this tripe.
В Китае поют только в живую. Это реакционер немного завистлив. Но Димаш король вокала и ничего не сделаешь.
В Китае тоже исмользуют фонограму для ТВ передач и случаев ,когда нельзя сделать живое вьІступление!Ничего страшного здесь нет!Димаш не обязан петь всегда и везде вживую,!
Реакционер разочаровал!
Yahu anladık,bu işleri anlıyorsun...Ama sonuçta canlı ya da değil,bunu söyleyen Dimash.Hem de muhteşem bir şekilde söyleyen.Şarkının aranjmanındaki sürpriz,harika jaz riflerini de mi takdir edemezdin...Tüm videoda "no,no" deyip durdun...
OK, no one anywhere is claiming this is a LIVE performance. Fans who follow his activities reported Dimash flying in to a precorded session for this particular tv show which was edited for best quality for the final airing results. Many artists including the famous concert pianist Lang Lang prerecorded their performances for this tv show. The audio editors very obviously did not do a perfect job of syncing Lang Langs fingers to the music. Lang Lang was obviously playing the piano and we all know he is an extremely accomplished pianist but the audio sync job was not perfect. So, same with Dimash's performance. The camera work always requires several takes. The final result is a compilation of the various takes from different angles. The audio is a live recording at the time of filming but as there are several takes, the composition can be taken from different audio recordings depending on the visual cuts in editing. You can consider these types of Chinese tv shows as presenting music video type artistic edits shot for aesthetics. In contrast to a live concert. You will find the performance duet with Tan Wei Wei singing A Thousand Miles A Common Dream as the same type of music video. Not a live performance. But unlike you, everyone knows this and appreciates the artistic presentation for what it is. It is gorgeous and worth watching and listening to their lovely voices.
Well said. Tq 👍
Totalmente de acuerdo contigo, lo has explicado perfectamente 👌🤗🌹
Beautifully said!
Beautifully said !
Perfectly said. Thank you 💗
Check the fan cams rehearsal before this shooting … so strange that you so concentrated on the lip sync as if you do not believe that Dimash can sing like this…
Too bad you couldn’t enjoy the song. I thought it was a lot of fun. 🌸
I’m sorry, but I felt I had to unsubscribe when I saw you called this a FAKE performance. It may be lip syncing but it’s still his voice. Saying this is a fake seems extreme and you putting that in the title seems unfair to him.
H of The Stage, it's very obvious your ”love” for Dimash. Clickbite with DIMASH FAKE PERFORMANCE. Who is faker?
I unsubscribe from this blogger for an unprofessional approach. You need to understand the formats of events, and know where the soundtrack is necessary and where it is unacceptable.
Para mi es genial...pero lo que detaco de Dimash en esta cansion en particular es su lado como compositor....es genial el cambio musical que realizó..y vi otras presentaciones donde hubo cambios geniales por ejemplo Daybreak es un concierto en China y mi Swan cantada en Badtau....es un musico genial....
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Well, it was an important gig for Dimash. CCTV1 is the prime channel of Chinese state TVs and they don't like things to go wrong so they have the artists lip sync. Is that any worse than a music video? I enjoyed it.
Zaista nije bitno sto nije uzivo.....ali on to pjeva,nevjerojatan vocal na ovoj planeti❤....treba se zapitati sto svaka tv kuca zeli od pjevaca,dali da se pjeva uzivo ili blayback....uvijek je uglavnom playback....to bi vi trebali znati....no mene svaki put odusevi,jer boljeg vocala nikada nisam cula od njega....Dimash❤❤❤❤
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
So disappointing because you reacted just to say lip sync. You can say whatever you want, but you did not even notice what he did to the song because your sole focus was whether or not he was lip-synching.
Exactly 😂 he was the only reactor of this performance by Dimash who focused the entire reaction whether it was sang live or pre-recorded haha. He was not able to notice the fantastic new arrangement made by Dimash for this very old song.
Этот реакционер хотел раскритиковать Димаша, но у него ничего не вышло и все удивлены потому что у Димаша очень образованые Деарс и даже в музыке. Молодцы деарс.вот такая она настоящая любовь к Димашу и его творчеству.Браво деарс!
I didn't like that you only focused on whether it's alive or not. The song is very good and the arrangement is very innovative. I respect your opinion but this time I didn't really like your vision. You give more food to the many #haters that Dimash has and to ensure that it is "Fake" just like what you put in your title, by the way, it made me very sad to see that on your channel. I've been following you for a long time and respect you, but this time, I didn't see you as very objective.
Hi, I usually watch all your videos on Dimash and know how you appreciate him. But I won't watch this one because honestly I don't care. We all know that sometimes, he has to lip sync, especially during TV shows. But what we also know is how he viscerally loves singing: he always performs live when he can. And we also know that he is able to sing everything live. The talent of Dimash is stratospheric, unique and unmatched. Personally I only need to know that he continues delivering extraordinary performances with his heart and his soul, as he always does. I really hope that one day, you will have the opportunity to attend one of his concert: you will immediately understand how vain is this question 😉. I hope that you will continue to react to his performances because your analyses are always very interesting and what really matters is the sharing of our love and our admiration for him.
I think a lot of people still care. I would care if I paid good money and somebody was just opening their mouth and giving me a prerecorded song. I can listen to that in my room, but that's not live. Of course, he doesn't do it often, but here it was the whole song and I would feel so robbed if I saw this in person. Still love him, but live is live, lip syncing is not, and this is a channel where we talk about vocals and all things music, so I won't sit here and pretend nothing is happening because that would make me fake-er than this performance
I don’t want to argue with you guys but in China they are very strict and lip sync is not allowed by law
@@sofialight9258 that's not true, at least not for all shows. The law is only for specific shows like live concerts etc. So lip synching isn't 100% forbidden in China.
Unconditional love allows us the opportunity to share our opinions and technical knowledge,, especially during a reaction video.. PEACE
@@sofialight9258actually that is not true. It applies to competitions and to amateur performers but not to professionals.
Пусть он думает, что хочет, но мы то знаем возможности Димаша! Отписаться что ли?
Да!
Конечно отписаться
Bueno, yo soy Dear y me doy cuenta cuando Di hace playback, y eso no importa, sabemos su capacidad vocal y su capacidad de tocar y cantar sin ningún problema, aquí sí es sincronizacion de labios, y?,eso no me importa, igual es mucho más que esos cantante que solo viven del playback, el hace eso en muy pocas ocasiones, te recomiendo ver su última actuación en China cantando Battle of memories, aquí su canto es totalmente en vivo, y es tan formidable
👏👏👏👏👍
Димаш исполнил эту песню на все 💯
В чем проблема я вас не поняла🤔🤦♀️
Be careful with your comments. You gave an additional bonus to those who accuse Dimash of not singing himself at all. and his voice is artificial. I think with this video alone you have caused harm that Dimash’s envious people could not do over many years. Dimash will never break through to world fame. And with a drop of tar you spoiled the barrel of honey
Будьте осторожны со своими комментариями. Вы дали дополнительный бонус тем, кто обвиняет Димаша в том, что он совсем не поет. И голос у него искусственный. Я думаю, что одним этим видео вы нанесли вред, который завистники Димаша не могли причинить на протяжении многих лет. Димаш никогда не прорвется к мировой славе. И каплей дегтя вы испортили бочку меда.
Tus ultimos videos acerca de dimash son diferentes...lo criticas. Por que has cambiado..es extraño. No creo que sea envidia, hay algo mas. En fin. No has descuberto America. Se sabe que no fue en vivo, pero lo novedoso es el arreglo musical que hizo de esta cancion. No solo es cantante tambien es musico. Y le quedo maravillosa.
Why be disappointed--it's a great collaboration to put out a song on TV for everyone's enjoyment. I have no doubts he could sing this live, so what's the problem? The set was great with the lights and roses, the song and his runs were so amazingly creative--it was a total pleasure for me. In fact I listen to it every morning to get me up and going! I think you were right about what you said it's not live but like you also said, they didn't say it was live. Probably collaborated long distance, IMHO.
Perché c'è disappunto? In alcuni video Dimash è incollato e riripreso. Così gira il mondo. Per il resto- Lui è indiscusso genio di vocalità, talentuoso, dotato, super allenato con grandi sacrifici, un giovane di buona educazione, dedicato a famiglia, allo studio, alle sue passioni. Ad avere ragazzi come Lui!
Que pena este señor que hace un video tratando de minimizar el talento del mejor cantante del mundo, la voz mas bella de todos los tiempos, el mejor vocalista de la historia de la musica, una leyenda viviente, que desde ya sera parte de la historia de la musica. La bellisima voz de Dimash es una bendicion de Dios al mundo en medio de este caos, no importa ya lo que puedas llegar a decir de el, mas alla de todo, nos espera la voz mas bella del mundo. Gracias Dimash ❤
And then you said, I'm sorry this is not Dimash singing. But it IS Dimash singing, whether it's lipsynced or not!! I have to agree with others about the clickbait thing. And I did not hear those auto-tune artifacts you were talking about. You used to love Dimash, not sure what happened....
I love your content, and I know you're aware of the different reasons artists may lipsync, so I'm confused why you're only now talking about potential lipsyncing. Theres videos that are much more obvious to me when it comes to lipsyncing, such as the Slavic Bazaar SOS performance that was clearly lipsynced to a studio performance (with very noticable autotune unfortunately). A lot of his premieres are lipsynced and he has to lipsync on a lot of televised shows and events. Its just part of the job in modern music. Dimash is not unique for it. He's not a bad person for it either (I'm sure you agree) and all artists do it. Its especially important for Dimash as he wants to preserve his voice, so he lipsyncs a lot so he doesn't lose his voice on harder songs. His live performances are jaw dropping too (SOS at Singer which was absolutely live, as were his other singer performances). His concerts are also mostly live, with SOS always live, and if you watch a lot of his concerts you'll realise hes getting better live too.
The miserable considerations of this reactor devalue Dimash's integrity and respect, which is why I no longer allow myself to follow his channel and I hope that all his fans do the same.
Aún esperas que Dimash venga y te de una actuación en vivo?? Lo ha hecho miles de veces !! Y por esta actuación lo crucificas?? Tu lo dijiste que en las televisoras los obligan entonces porque la decepción?? Quien piensas que grabó la canción??? Acaso otro artista?? No!! Fue Dimash el la grabó y si pudiera te la cantaba a ti solo en vivo estoy segura.
Me voy !!!!