Great video - I didn't see the Polar Pro when I bought the Neewer series. The one thing I like about the Neewer is they are variable and I can keep them on the DJI even when it is off. I saw some videos that the DJI filters must be taken off when powering the Osmo off.
There are soooo many ND filter choices. Both the Polar Pro and DJI filters need to be removed for the gimbal to return to a full closed position at shutdown. Glad you found the video helpful. Enjoy the Pocket 3 with your Neewer filters!
it's called a "variable" polariser with ND filter. (Because it has the rotating disc, and you can "dial" it in) but some people don't like variable polarizers because they can create a vignette (a darker border - sometimes as a blur or a shadow on the edges of the frame depending on the position of the polarizing dial)
in this case these ND's are not variable. that's why you need to choose 16, 32, 256 etc the adjustable polarizer on top of the ND is the variable.@@z352kdaf8324
Hello, it is a wonderful video, thanks to share it. I need ask a question please. I have Pocket 3 for a little time. I make only documentaries in sunny places and I want to use one filter only because I don't have free time to change it. I could use a VND filter, but it causes a slight loss of video quality, so I'm thinking to put one fixed ND/PL filter on my Pocket 3. I shoot only in 4K 50p in sunny days, with what a light transparent cloud. If I want to use a ND/PL filter with a 50-400 ISO range and Automatic Exposure, is it more useful to buy a ND16/PL or ND32/PL filter? I thank you.
First, thank you for watching and your comment. The ND 16 is 4 stops while the ND32 is 5 stops of light, they are very close. If I had to pick one, would buy the ND16 and see if that meets your needs or maybe buy both and return one. Sometimes it’s best to try both out in multiple shooting situations and take advantage of the return period for the one not chosen. Stay well and enjoy your Pocket 3!
Great comparison Mark thank you for doing this one. I was just looking at what ND kit to purchase. It looks like there was a bit more clarity in the image as well when you had the polar pro ND filters attached vs the DJI filters. I agree it seems polar pro is superior at least from your comparison to the alternative.
You can but the gimbal does not return to the full closed position - the ND is a little too thick. No damage will be caused to gimbal. Watch for my upcoming video on the Freewell “variable” ND filters that are real thin and will allow full closing. The P3 is perfect for travel journals! Enjoy.
Thanks for taking the time to compile this useful comparison. I currently own a variable ND set (6-9) and live in Greece where the sun is really bright. Now (April) I find that only 7 is adequate (meaning ND 128). Here's my problem and question: In some cases of clear blue sky, the variable ND creates an uneven sky surface. I mean it looks like one part of the sky is ok but the other half looks darker, as if there is a feathered wipe in the middle. I have heard that the PolarPro ND/PL have the same problem, while the non-PL PolarPro are ok. I think that I saw that when you turn the polarisation on, but I'm not sure. I'm torn between buying the non-PL and the "plain" ND filters that's why I would like to know. And a tip, if I may add: I found out that on mixed scenes with shadows and highlights using EV -1 (not -0,7) and variable ISO gives almost no burned highlights.
I haven’t noticed the uneven sky when using the ND with polarizer. Maybe I’m not looking close enough but I have found the polarizer really helps with sky color. Thanks for watching. Greece is a beautiful place which I hope to visit someday.
@@markexploringnewstuff Thanks for the fast reply! I might go for the plain NDs since I already trust their brand for my Sony big camera and GoPro. If this helps, I find the same strong sun in Italy too (in summer) so for the fixed setting of the Osmo Pocket 3, I think only 7 (ND 128) is adequate. 5 is certainly not enough anyway. Hoping you will use the pocket 3 in Greece soon.
I have a K&H ND4 and ND8 for my OP3. I probably need a higher ND. What do you think about the Variable ND filters out there compare to the single stop filters? I saw this video before I got the P3 but came back to it for your expert opinion.
I only have the single stop ND’s. The DJI set of 3 is 4/6/8 stop. Plus, I have the Polar Pro set of 3 (that also have a CP on each) at 3/5/7 stops - these translate to ND 8 thru ND 256. The variable ones I see on Amazon are 1-5 and 5-9 stops but I haven’t seen one with the CP feature. I mostly use Polar Pro Vivid Collection (3/5/7 stops) because the CP really helps with colors - these are ND 8, ND 32 and ND 128 and that range works for me so far.
I found the DJI and Polar Pro filters really compliment each other with DJI having a 16/64/256 while Polar Pro has 8/32/128. I use both just find the DJI are tougher to take off. Enjoy your Pocket 3 and thanks for watching!
You didn't mention if the polar pro can be put at the 15mm wid angle lens. I took a lot of time when u criticise it at the dji, so I was wondering why u don't mention it at the polar pro. And why should one stop less be more practical? I can't see that. I am very happy with my dji filters.
None of the ND filters can be put on top of the wide angle 15mm DJi lens, as the lens top is not magnetic. Both ND filter sets greatly improve the video quality in manual mode. Glad you are happy with your selection. Enjoy the Pocket 3!
I have heard (but not tested) that the Black Mist Filter ND will allow the gimbal to fully close. The DJI and Polar Pro need to be removed to have gimbal fully close. Thank you for watching.
With both these ND’s, I have seen other videos that show you can but the gimbal will not close to its normal position. They have indicated that gimbal is not damaged. Out of an abundance of caution, I always remove the ND before closing.
The Pocket 3 is able to shut down, but the gimbal will not fully reset to original closed position - this is will be the case with any external filter/lens being on at shutdown. From what I have heard this will cause no damage to the gimbal. In my practice, I always remove the filters before shutdown just be “safest”. Thanks for watching./
None of the filters will allow a full closed position if they are installed. This was an oversight on the part of DJI if they had just designed it with a couple more millimeters of space.
Not if you want the gimbal to close completely. Other videos have indicated that leaving on will not damage the gimbal, even though it won’t fully tuck in. I always remove to be safe.
idk why but i trust your word with my life. organic review thank you Mark!
I appreciate that!
Great video Mark! Have be looking for a video like! Thank you
Thanks so much for watching and your kind words. Enjoy!
Great video - I didn't see the Polar Pro when I bought the Neewer series. The one thing I like about the Neewer is they are variable and I can keep them on the DJI even when it is off. I saw some videos that the DJI filters must be taken off when powering the Osmo off.
There are soooo many ND filter choices. Both the Polar Pro and DJI filters need to be removed for the gimbal to return to a full closed position at shutdown. Glad you found the video helpful. Enjoy the Pocket 3 with your Neewer filters!
Very interesting video! I enjoyed seeing the side-by-side comparisons.
Thank you for your comment. Glad you found it helpful.
it's called a "variable" polariser with ND filter. (Because it has the rotating disc, and you can "dial" it in) but some people don't like variable polarizers because they can create a vignette (a darker border - sometimes as a blur or a shadow on the edges of the frame depending on the position of the polarizing dial)
Thanks for watching and commenting. I experienced no vignetting with the polarizer and the rotating disc made adding and removing much easier.
circular polarizer!!! nd's are variable.
in this case these ND's are not variable. that's why you need to choose 16, 32, 256 etc the adjustable polarizer on top of the ND is the variable.@@z352kdaf8324
Hello, it is a wonderful video, thanks to share it. I need ask a question please. I have Pocket 3 for a little time. I make only documentaries in sunny places and I want to use one filter only because I don't have free time to change it. I could use a VND filter, but it causes a slight loss of video quality, so I'm thinking to put one fixed ND/PL filter on my Pocket 3. I shoot only in 4K 50p in sunny days, with what a light transparent cloud. If I want to use a ND/PL filter with a 50-400 ISO range and Automatic Exposure, is it more useful to buy a ND16/PL or ND32/PL filter? I thank you.
First, thank you for watching and your comment. The ND 16 is 4 stops while the ND32 is 5 stops of light, they are very close. If I had to pick one, would buy the ND16 and see if that meets your needs or maybe buy both and return one. Sometimes it’s best to try both out in multiple shooting situations and take advantage of the return period for the one not chosen. Stay well and enjoy your Pocket 3!
Great comparison Mark thank you for doing this one. I was just looking at what ND kit to purchase. It looks like there was a bit more clarity in the image as well when you had the polar pro ND filters attached vs the DJI filters. I agree it seems polar pro is superior at least from your comparison to the alternative.
So glad you found this video useful. Enjoy your new ND’s.
Good job, Mark!
Thanks for watching and sharing your impression. Much appreciated.
Very helpful, thank you!
Glad to be of assistance. Thank you for watching. Be well.
Helpful video, thanks!
Glad it was helpful!
Really helpful, thank you. Do they feel secure?
Absolutely, they stick in place real well - strong magnetic hold. Getting them off is a chore! Thanks for watching and commenting.
Thanks Mark, good video. QUESTION: Can you turn the Pocket 3 off and on with the filter attached?
You can but the gimbal does not return to the full closed position - the ND is a little too thick. No damage will be caused to gimbal.
Watch for my upcoming video on the Freewell “variable” ND filters that are real thin and will allow full closing.
The P3 is perfect for travel journals! Enjoy.
Thanks for taking the time to compile this useful comparison. I currently own a variable ND set (6-9) and live in Greece where the sun is really bright. Now (April) I find that only 7 is adequate (meaning ND 128). Here's my problem and question: In some cases of clear blue sky, the variable ND creates an uneven sky surface. I mean it looks like one part of the sky is ok but the other half looks darker, as if there is a feathered wipe in the middle. I have heard that the PolarPro ND/PL have the same problem, while the non-PL PolarPro are ok. I think that I saw that when you turn the polarisation on, but I'm not sure. I'm torn between buying the non-PL and the "plain" ND filters that's why I would like to know. And a tip, if I may add: I found out that on mixed scenes with shadows and highlights using EV -1 (not -0,7) and variable ISO gives almost no burned highlights.
I haven’t noticed the uneven sky when using the ND with polarizer. Maybe I’m not looking close enough but I have found the polarizer really helps with sky color. Thanks for watching. Greece is a beautiful place which I hope to visit someday.
@@markexploringnewstuff Thanks for the fast reply! I might go for the plain NDs since I already trust their brand for my Sony big camera and GoPro. If this helps, I find the same strong sun in Italy too (in summer) so for the fixed setting of the Osmo Pocket 3, I think only 7 (ND 128) is adequate. 5 is certainly not enough anyway. Hoping you will use the pocket 3 in Greece soon.
I have a K&H ND4 and ND8 for my OP3. I probably need a higher ND. What do you think about the Variable ND filters out there compare to the single stop filters? I saw this video before I got the P3 but came back to it for your expert opinion.
I only have the single stop ND’s. The DJI set of 3 is 4/6/8 stop. Plus, I have the Polar Pro set of 3 (that also have a CP on each) at 3/5/7 stops - these translate to ND 8 thru ND 256. The variable ones I see on Amazon are 1-5 and 5-9 stops but I haven’t seen one with the CP feature.
I mostly use Polar Pro Vivid Collection (3/5/7 stops) because the CP really helps with colors - these are ND 8, ND 32 and ND 128 and that range works for me so far.
@@markexploringnewstuff thanks mark. I'm leaning toward the K&H variable ND. The ones I have fit close so the gimbal closes all the way.
@theoldvideoguy mine won’t allow the gimbal to fully close. We’re both learning. Stay well,
I find that ND16 is more practical, but Polar pro doesn't sell it. Does it?
I found the DJI and Polar Pro filters really compliment each other with DJI having a 16/64/256 while Polar Pro has 8/32/128. I use both just find the DJI are tougher to take off. Enjoy your Pocket 3 and thanks for watching!
You didn't mention if the polar pro can be put at the 15mm wid angle lens. I took a lot of time when u criticise it at the dji, so I was wondering why u don't mention it at the polar pro. And why should one stop less be more practical? I can't see that. I am very happy with my dji filters.
None of the ND filters can be put on top of the wide angle 15mm DJi lens, as the lens top is not magnetic. Both ND filter sets greatly improve the video quality in manual mode. Glad you are happy with your selection. Enjoy the Pocket 3!
Really enjoyed this. Thanks
Thanks so much!
Many THX , now I know what to get !
So glad to be able to help. Enjoy.
Are there any you can leave on it when you turn the camera off?
I have heard (but not tested) that the Black Mist Filter ND will allow the gimbal to fully close. The DJI and Polar Pro need to be removed to have gimbal fully close.
Thank you for watching.
Can you leave the filter on when shutting down the pocket 3?
With both these ND’s, I have seen other videos that show you can but the gimbal will not close to its normal position. They have indicated that gimbal is not damaged.
Out of an abundance of caution, I always remove the ND before closing.
thank you Mark!
My pleasure! Thanks for watching and taking time to comment.
Thanks for the video! Can you use the wide angle with the polar pro ND’s?
Nope! Neither DJI nor Polar Pro ND can go on top of (or behind) wide angle. That is a problem.
That camera is very tempting. Is that Miami?
Yes, a little R&R in Bal Harbour, FL. Great spot to try ND filters
@@markexploringnewstuff I’m originally from Miami
Live in MA so we enjoy escaping to warmth (and sun) in FL.
@@markexploringnewstuff I’m ready. Tuesday night is going to be 9° here in North Georgia.
That will be awful for all those Georgia peaches! Hopefully, warms up soon
Are the PolarPro filters slim enough to stay on the pocket 3 when it's turned off?
The Pocket 3 is able to shut down, but the gimbal will not fully reset to original closed position - this is will be the case with any external filter/lens being on at shutdown. From what I have heard this will cause no damage to the gimbal. In my practice, I always remove the filters before shutdown just be “safest”. Thanks for watching./
None of the filters will allow a full closed position if they are installed. This was an oversight on the part of DJI if they had just designed it with a couple more millimeters of space.
Interesting video, just got my pocket 3. Maybe if i got manual mode I'll do this thanks brother cool video subbed
After playing in auto, try manual mode, controlling the frame rate and ISO will make videos even better. Enjoy the Pocket 3! Thanks for commenting.
@@markexploringnewstuff thanks Mark I will do that brother cheers
I have the Dji nd filters and I’m really impressed with them,good video though buddy…
Great filters. Enjoy!
Can you leave the filter on when shutting down the pocket 3?
Not if you want the gimbal to close completely. Other videos have indicated that leaving on will not damage the gimbal, even though it won’t fully tuck in. I always remove to be safe.