A Perfect Circle (Judith) Kel-n-Rich's First Reaction
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
- Watch and Listen to Kel-n-Rich's first reaction to A Perfect Circle's song Judith.
Please support our FREE channel!
Private message or contributions to: richgafter@gmail.com
MEN requesting Reactions… please use a hashtag plus the BAND NAME and SONG. Example: #PinkFloyd Comfortably Numb
For WOMEN requesting songs -
#MetalChickPick and List the BAND NAME AND SONG next to it please.
For YOUNG ADULTS watching with Metal Parents, Request:
#MetalDNA
For WALL OF SOUND songs to rock our epic world, use #SKADOOSH plus the BAND NAME and SONG NAME.
We will only ‘see’ your requests if you use a hashtag, so please do ! If no hashtag, we can’t search it easily and it will be LOST.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS 
Видеоклипы
![Eminem - Somebody Save Me (feat. Jelly Roll) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vwa0HenQMi4/mqdefault.jpg)
She had a stroke when Maynard was young. She was paralyzed in a wheelchair for approximately 10,000 days before she passed.
And according to Maynard's autobio his mother's congregation blamed her illness on not being a good enough Christian...
@@tdm-wo7omyeah and those are not real Christians.
God, I love this song. The anger, bitterness and raw emotion is just staggering.
Lol. The way you started that is jst great haha
@@sra5032 I thought the same thing...saying God is just *chef's kiss*.
I love the video for this song. One reason is that it was directed by God-like genius David Fincher. The other reason is that the moment when Paz puts her bass down, ties her hair up, and starts playing again is one of the sexiest things I have ever seen.
Need to check out the La Jolla show in the song Renholder. When she transitions from violin and comes in on the bass she is hot as fire.
She couldn't do the hair thing fast enough so they sped up that part of the video to make it work.
Oh man, you’re absolutely right... Fincher and Paz. And the song, of course!
First time i saw them live. The show opened with smoke coming out of the floor around her while she played the violin. Very nice
Agreed. Just watched this video for the first time in its entirety last week and hadn't seen Paz do the hair up move then finger lick to bass line before...it was so bad ass I had to watch it again when I showed my friend. Miss her in this band we need more Paz!!
Her brain aneurysm happened when Maynard was 11 yrs old, which he refers to in the Tool song Jimmy. Then the 10,000 days she spent paralyzed before death. And yes, this song was clearly coming from an angry place, but several years later when he made the 10,000 Days album, he showed that he let go of a lot of that anger and focuses on the positive effects she’s had on his life, praises her strength, etc.
I should clarify. He let’s go of much of the anger towards her, but still has frustration with the religious communities as a whole.
@@GoldTop57 if you listen carefully there is a lot of Christian theology on his lyrics specially Tool, He respects Christianity since it's his own mother's believes that help Maynard a lot trough years of pain specially after he got an eye opening of the rough reality of people, religions and society at a young age.
Pretty sure she had an aneurysm that paralyzed her and 10,000 Days signifies how long she lived while paralyzed.
Exactly.
Jimmy signifies that he was 11 when she had her aneurysm. It seem like If you were to list to Jimmy, Judith, 10,000 day and then Wings for Marie it would be the timeline of what happened to his mother.
Yup think that's right dude
yep when he was11
Maynards mother Judith I believe had an aneurysm when he was a teenager. 10,000 days is how long she suffered.. There's also a song on the same album called "Orestes" which is about him finally being able to let her go. It definitely tugs the heart. No matter how many times I listen to it still brings me to tears.
Not actually a teenager, only 11 as stated in the song Jimmy
@@iammine8117 I was about to say the same thing 😏
They need to do '3 libras' by A Perfect Circle next imo.
Anger is a very underestimated emotion.
It is my default emotion, for better.... or worse.
6:42 Love the synchronized deep breath!! LOL
She had a stroke when she was about 30 and lived aproximately 30 years or around 10,000 days. She had deep faith in god and never lost that and very clear in Wings for Marie but he hated god for the things he was seeing in his young childhood. She was paralized to a degree her life consisted of little.
Will G1986 no we don’t and why really didn’t say much about his believes but he mentions the Pockrus he of the church in many of his songs.
He explained that he didn't curse the real God, he cursed the idea of a god that extremist religious people created, he cursed the image of an old man judging you, he also explained what God means to him, which is love and light.
Siul Zenitram no, he criticizes God very much in this song.
ruclips.net/video/YU0BrwlWNTk/видео.html
In this video he explained what I said.
Well then both of us are right because as I said… He talks very poorly about God or the religious institution of God in the song and that’s what I had said and that he certainly does. It’s just like songs like schism, songs that are about the Pockrus he of the church in those kinds of institutions.Siul Zenitram
Gotta do Orestes next, always give me the goosebumps
The acoustic version with Billy Howerdel singing is great too.
This song gets to you so much so that at 6:41 you both take a deep breath and sigh together. I love Tool, I love APC, I love Puscifer and I just thought that was awesome.
I know this song can be uncomfortable for some people to hear due to the lyrics . Once you understand where the song comes from and why he curses God it's a very personal look into his mental state after experiencing a very traumatic event in his life . The anger is not held back and its honest and the anger is very real . Weither its misplaced is irrelevant. It's real and beautiful in it's own way that he could be so vulnerable with expressing his feelings .
This song is about his mom. When she got sick he wanted to help but she told him that she was in gods hands. She became paralyzed passed shortly after. So he wrote this song to say that his mother was a saint but god made her judith and made her suffer
Agreed. Not sure but I wouldn't be suprised if he wrote these lyrics long before Wings for Marie. But if you listen to them (Judith and Wings) back to back, you get a fuller sense of his feelings. There's definitely anger and resentment there, but also, there's an appreciation, admiration, and even awe, on his part when thinking about HER faith, whether he shares the same beliefs or not.
This is my first time watching your RUclips channel. You got my attention with this song.
I LOVE THIS SONG. His mom, Judith had suffered a cerebral aneurysm that left her in paralyzed in a wheelchair for 10,000 days before she inevitably died. He was born into a strong Southern Baptist family.
She was strong in her faith; even though she was wheelchair bound, she was still faithful to her Lord and Savior.
Absolutely brilliant song...
Truly amazing is the note that Maynard held in the song(approx. 7:18 in this video)... But, is this the edited version? on the album its the only song that Maynard actual curses the one set of lyrics.... Keep up the great reaction vids.... just watched the one you all did on the O'Keefes school .... 24 and 2.
Their FIRST!? Reactions! Oh my god. I’m jealous
#deftones ft Maynard - Passenger. I think you'll both dig it.
Sexiest song ever
That's a great song! When I first heard it, I had to listen to it again because I was like "Holy Shit!! Maynard!!"
That synchronized breathing at 6:42 was awesome lol
His mother, Judith, had a cerebral aneurysm when Maynard was 11, which left her paralyzed and basically a shell of what she used to be. She lived in this state for roughly 10,000 days or 29+ years before she died. This song was written I think 6-7 years before her death. There is some commentary from Maynard on what he was thinking about when he wrote this song. Link below:
ruclips.net/video/YU0BrwlWNTk/видео.html
My favorite APC song. Just amazing! Definitely could have been a Tool song. I hope they do a cover sometime! Too late now, but listening to this song without words for the first time vs. seeing the words will probably give very different reactions. Personally I didn't see the words for a long time and then we I saw them I completely understood Maynard's angst. You guys looked so bummed listening. If you didn't concentrate on the words you'd be diving into the amazing music, but the words have you quite stunned, and sad. His mother Judith Marie suffered from a paralyzing debility & was confined to a wheelchair for over 25 years, which is around 10,000 Days. You will find the next 2 songs Wings For Marie/10,000 Days to be quite different from Judith. Perhaps Progressive Rock in a nutshell. I believe Maynard's writing gave him a great release from the pain he felt towards his mother's fate, G*d rest her soul.
Yes, Wings for Marie/10,000 Days should be listened to ASAP. #TOOL #WINGSFORMARIA #10000DAYS #ASAP
Tearing up as I was watching, the pain and anger.
The Tool song Jimmy also is a major expression of Maynards youth. Very powerful song if you get the chance to listen to it. Love the channel guys!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️
You guys are in for a metal ride amigos🤘😜 you have many eager people to enlighten you. Fuck yeah rock on!
Thxs for doing this,this is one of the songs that i will react to.But there are more and I'll react when they show up.Keep it up.
"It's great to be Historians, but we do first reaction videos, and are married to each other" Haha
That's why I'm subscribed to the channel, you two are nothing more then who you are, great people. The key to everything is Authenticity.
Judith, MJKs mother had an Annieryism, was invalent for 10k days before her passing. The Tool song Jimmy is about moving from Ohio to Michigan with his dad after it happened (Jimmy is MJKs legal first name), Judith is about his mother's unwavering faith despite her grim overall outlook, finally Wings for Marie Part 1 and 2 by Tool is his goodbye to her. Performed during the 2006-2007 tour, MJK is on record saying he does have some regrets mourning so publicly, as a OGT fan, it's a safe bet that Wings will never be played live again, despite it being one of their most epic pieces of music to date. Most Tool fans it will make you cry every single time you listen to it. It's just one of the thousands of things that make them so incredibly special.
Once you guys see the entire Tool Discography as a whole, it's really gonna make you appreciate them that much more.
Opiate - Anger
Undertow - Working through Anger
Aenima - Pscyhedelic Prog aspect starts taking hold, the beginning of enlightenment, as the album ends with 3rd Eye.
Lateralus - To me represents the process of a Kundalini Awakening
10000 Days - Using the Enlightenment achieved to view the world for what it is.
New Album - Based on Descending as a preview, I'm guessing a possible album theme of our Souls journey leaving this Dimension.
There is a moment at 6:43 in the video when you can see you both take a huge deep breath under the huge weight of the emotions expressed in this song. It is heavy stuff and you could literally see it’s impact on you both at that moment.
caught that too. good catch
I wish you had watched the music video for this song. It would have amplified the mood of the song tenfold.
Another couple listening to amazing music. The world is finally changing for the great
I am new to your channel. The lyrics are something else to say the least. Thanks
You guys are awsome! Keepbdoing tool, puscifer, A Perfect Circle
Such a powerful song. Very deep and emotional. That long scream at the end. He does an even longer/better one with Tool in the song The Grudge.
#Karnivool
- All I know
- Nacash
- New day
- Goliath
- Simple boy
- lifelike
- We Are
Boy I have never seen the lyrical content of a song change the mood of a reaction video so quickly
She had an aneurysm when he was 11 years old and she was a single mother... so everyone understandably didn't know what to say so they would always instruct him and her to pray and to be thankful then the state ordered him out of his situation. I think a couple years after ..to go live with his father in Michigan.. and he did 10000 days is how long she lived after the aneurysm.
This is an amazing song. Maynard is a great vocalist. I’ve seen him live with Tool and it was an experience.
Revisted!
There's not one thing about this song that I don't 100% L.O.V.E. LOVE!!
One of my all time favs.
Goosebumps everytime i here judith, brilliant.
This song is about Maynard James Keenan's mother, Judith Marie. Judith
was paralyzed when Maynard was 11. She stayed paralyzed until she died
10,000 days later. She kept faith in God the whole time. Maynard had
quite the hard time accepting his mother's death, and her beliefs, which
often conflicted with Maynard's.
You guys will have to hire a secretary at this place 😂...I'll patiently wait for my birthday song...cheers
This album was one of my all time favorites when it first came out, then after my father had a stroke from brain cancer and slowly withered away in front of my eyes before passing away it brought on a whole new level of meaning and connection to me.
I lost my wife in July. She had suffered, physically and mentally, for many years. I am living day to day. Peace to both of us and my condolences.
@@willasacco9898 Thank you, stay strong.
@@Charlie1821 I will keep strong with you.
I found myself starring at Rich's shirt, It reminds me of Harry Potter.
Yes! Deathly Hallows!
Not gonna browse through comments to make sure I'm not repeating what someone else has alresdy said- Maynard's mom had a hemorrhagic stroke when he was 11 and lived, paralyzed, for the next 27 years (10,000 Days) until she passed. She never abandoned her faith and this song talks about that as kind of a heart-felt repudiation of Theodicy...
Whole album is a jewel, I love "Sleeping Beauty ", the flow of his voice,.I swear Maynard should do a rock opera, write it then sing it!, would love to see him do Rocky Horror, he would be so amazing. As I said this whole album, but 3 Libres, is a good example of his vocal range, beautiful album, simply beautiful..
10K days since she suffered a stroke until she died. She was paralysed during this time, and James Keenan was angry at her for accepting this reality. Yet why had her deity done this, if he was a malevolent being?
#muse
#knightsofcydonia
#liveatromeolympicstadium
Mind-blowing and epic live version of Knights of Cydonia by Muse.
yes I second this amazing song
or plug in baby olympicstadium
You guys are cool
Freethinkers Eternal.
I would also recommend Tool "Jimmy" before you do Wings 1&2, but at least you have some foundation with Judith. Also, if you want some idea of why Maynard was so angry, Prison Sex was about the abuse he suffered.
I try to leave songs for myself, for another point in time, and that is one of them. Thanks for the context.
My favorite perfect circle song
Cool couple, love that shirt BTW 🔥
10,000 days is roughly 27 years. The length of time Judith was incapacitated. The last 27 years of her life.
She was in a wheelchair for 10,000 days approximately, or 27 years, do To a stroke.She was alive when this Album dropped. She passed away before tools 10,000 days album.
Roughly, not approximate. People need to learn the definitions of words.
Joseph Burgess LOL. Thank you for your grammar lesson. You’ve been most helpful. He he
Fun fact: this song contained the only expletive on the entire album. Really shows how he's trying to make a point by making the only time he swears the line "Fuck your God." Really shows how serious this was to him.
#pinkfloyd great gig in the sky (pulse version)
Maynard was angry because his mother was full of faith, she never wavered and never thought of anything but what was actually happening. Maynard's Mother was a big believer in Christ and when she got really sick and her church mocked her, he took this in a very hostile way. He was so angry to why her god would punish her when she was so loyal and so obedient. This song goes so much deeper than just words.
The video for this is superb...like the but when paz does her hair in the breakdown...ahhh good times 😉
its my understand that 10000 days when divided by 365 comes out to around 27.3 years or so.........the amount of time she suffered with her illness until she got her *wings*
Maynard is definitely Worth listening
A rare good new rock song
take your time enjoy the music, a lot of people think Maynard James Keenan is being literal in this song but he is just questioning how his mother could stay loyal to the congregation of her church after her stroke when many of them stopped being her friends and even said she had to have sinned to been struck by a stroke
That is the truth. Jesus has abandoned us
To the dilettantes commenting otherwise, APC’s Orestes and Tool’s The Patient are not in any way, shape or form about Maynard’s mother. He didn’t even write the former (Billy Howerdel did years before APC even existed) and The Patient is about a female addict with whom Maynard was previously involved and then was reluctantly supporting.
Good stuff 😎👍. This song is basically MJK mad at his mother for staying a devout christian even after a stroke (or some medical issue) left her in a wheelchair.......the line in the song goes " praise the one left you broken down and paralyzed........he did it all for you".
That look on Kel’s face speaks volumes
Wikipedia: Keenan's mother suffered a paralyzing cerebral aneurysm in 1976, when Maynard was 11 (the inspiration for creative works such as Tool's songs "jimmy" and "Wings for Marie" as well as A Perfect Circle's "Judith"). She was very religious. those lines man "its not like you killed someone....it's not like you drove a hateful spear into his side". There are some great vocal techniques tooK the beautiful mix in "he did it all for youuuuuuu" the distortion at the end. this can be hard to listen to - even blasphemous i suppose. this was him processing his mom's illness, 10,000 days (27 years roughly) of suffering, and passing. a catharsis if you will. I'm not religious....but i hope she got her wings.
This band LOVES reaction videos and they react to people who react to their video hahaha #MyrathBeliever (it is a story made out of 3 music videos thus far : "believe" , then "Dance" and the last one "No holding back", there will be a fourth one).Its a Tunisian band ...its arabic metal
Thanks for doing , great f'n song!
The look on Kels face
it looked like Maynard broke Kel
im super excited!!! i feel a future video will be unleash the archers!!!!!
This is a powerful song with a message to his mom and would-be god
Maynard was angry that she still kept her faith in her religion alive, as he thought God was the one that caused her pain and suffering. Now you need to react to Wings For Marie and 10,000 Days (Wings Part 2).
Theres alot to unpack in this song, it's one of my favorites. It's not just about anger, hes pointing something out, something that Christians rarely allow themselves to contemplate. "Ur sunch an inspiration for the ways that I will never choose to be."
The Package #APerfectCircle
I loved that collective breath taken at 6:40, like you knew some heavy shit was coming.
If ever you listen to anything Maynard related, you can’t make a surface reaction and expected to understand or know what the song is truly about. I understand this is what reaction videos are about, but Maynards stuff (no matter what group he’s heading) is the exception. It’s crazy how even though this song has been out for along time, people still get the meaning wrong or rush to judgement. Search RUclips for “A Perfect Circle - Judith (Maynard commentary)”. He explains very clearly he was writing about the “ghouls” & hypocrisy in religion (his mothers church). He was not saying F@&k “God”, but “their god”. Their god who said that his mother must have been a sinner and not good and deserved what she was going through mentally - physically. Her church & friends would be kind and nice in front of her but disparage her behind her back. God = light & love, he loves all, but religion (or religious groups) take that and then preach conditions on that love and take it upon themselves to say who is worthy of it, who’s good, who’s bad. And even faced with all of that, his mothers faith was unwavering & true. THIS is what he was singing out and why he was no mad. ruclips.net/video/YU0BrwlWNTk/видео.html
11 is when we waved goodbye.
The video is awesome The story is tragic.
Hi guys🙋🏽♂️
I don't think there's another song (imo) that divides fans of hard rock more than "Judith" by MJ and his band A Perfect Circle. In its purest form it's an awesome hard hitting in your face hard rock song but it becomes so much more than that when we hear the lyrics. I know some ppl that refuse to listen to it because they consider it blasphemy and at the complete other end of the spectrum there's ppl who listen to it inspite of it being blasphemous. Then there's me, a person who listens to it because it does what any great song does....it draws its listeners in by painting a picture of exactly what the composer of the song was/is going through at a specific point in time...in this case what Maynard was going through emotionally over a 25+ year period of watching his beloved Mom suffer the consequences of something she had absolutely no control over. I can't think of another song that generates such emotion when ppl hear it for the first time.
Regards FB
🌴🌞🌴
That is a great one
#APerfectCircle - Gravity
One of my favorites from APC. I hope they do this.
@@zmarko they won't
God gave himself as a sacrifice, to himself, in order to save us from himself. He did it all for u.
She had a stroke & was an invalid/wheelchair bound for 10,000 days (29 years) before her death.
#SithuAye - Set Course For Andromeda!!!
I so understand this after watching his mom suffer a stroke and be bound to a wheelchair and never once question her faith i sadly was never strong enough praise Prometheus.
For the sake of all that's unholy! Maynards voice can just transport you. Please and ty for #APC Orestes phx
#nineinchnails wish
#ministry burning inside
The way MJK walks over to
Sing after sitting on the couch and preparing himself makes you brace for what holes got pent up inside. Like oh crap, he’s going to let loose here.
You forgot Jimmy. In the right order, Jimmy would be the first song of the "Maynards Mom Songs"... then Judith and then Wings & 10.000 days... hope you will get to Jimmy soon. It's the starting point, were he decides to deal with his pain and anger, what he has never done until then. By the way, take a look at the original video of Judith, it's awesome. Judith had a stroke and lived for about 10.000 days in a wheelchair, more or less paralized.
Today. Thanks
Yeah! Looking forward to it. Greets from Germany! @@Kel.N.RichReactions
Backacha @IB!!!!! Have a super night / sleep. Let’s do it again tomorrow… Even better and brighter. Rich
#clutch #modestmouse #moreTOOL
She had an aneurysm when he was 11. She lived for 10000 days as an invalid. His anger was directed at the church of which his mother was a congregation member. They would come tell his mother how strong in faith she was, but behind her back talk about her. He saw that as hypocrisy and he was talking to their God, not the God. It was directed at a certain congregation.
Legit, stay married, jam out, have a good time, wish ya'll nothing but the best. Robb from Ohio.
#aperfectcircle the package
Slipknot: Purity, Diluted, and Gently!
How come nobody knows about this great song of Maynard in A Perfect Circle. Is about 10 years old. ????
Tool wings for Marie part 1 and 2 10,000 days album guys 🙏 will blow you away!!
Such a sweet end to this video...
#Skynd - Jim Jones . That music video is really something else
10,000 days is the length of paralyses and living in a wheel chair until she died... watch that one next.
Maynard... he made such personal statements with APC