This Pro Trans Ad Is Dangerous
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июл 2024
- The government of the Australian state of Victoria put out an ad aimed at promoting trans acceptance. Unfortunately, it’s essentially telling women to prioritize the feelings of trans people over even their own physical safety. Let’s talk about it.
Join the Club: / amalaekpunobi
Watch or Listen on Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3Zq6iX6...
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Follow Me on Social Media:
Instagram: / theamalaekpunobi
TikTok: / amalaekpunobi
X: / amalaekpunobi
Facebook: / theamalaekpunobi
Join My Discord Server: / discord 
Развлечения
Telling a woman to ignore her gut instinct is a dangerous message.
Not in support of this ad in the slightest but not necessarily in support of that message of yours either. Imagine a lady has a knife on her person, riding the elevator with a stranger, perhaps a shy or quiet young man on his way out of his home to a job interview. He’s as peaceful as her yet oddly something in her “Gut instincts” is telling her to strike first, fight or flight are often gut reactions often in tandem with gut instincts, something about him is perhaps making her “Feel” unsafe but her gut reaction is almost always to strike first, fight first, rather than someone else’s flight first. In this it is fight. Telling anybody to always listen and sometimes not ignore their gut instincts and reactions is an equally dangerous message. How to reconcile this?
@@Artryomthat seems like a pretty improbable reaction.
No, it isn't.
@@ArtryomThis is farcical.You're equaiting someone getting out of the elevator with someone actively assaulting someone else
@@kristakhaos6321 Doesn’t matter as long as it is indeed possible. Often what your gut instincts tell you is improbable, doesn’t matter either.
So, they deserve to feel safe ... but not the biological women who are being told to let biological men enter their bathrooms and locker rooms.
Yes!.... the radical left is FULL of hypocrisy but being the narcissists they are, they'll never see it.
Exactly!
She was in the elevator with a man and she knew it. But didn’t know what that man would do. I’m outta here too.
Don’t you know that we apparently don’t matter AT ALL anymore, especially when it comes to women’s safety? 😭😪
@beverlyshane8433 Do you automatically jump off an elevator everytime a man gets on the elevator with you? I gotta tell ya, ive been alone on elevators with men and women. Everything has been fine so far. No assaults or murders.
The irony of saying trans people deserve to feel safe while showing an actual woman feeling unsafe and therefore exiting the elevator can't be overstated lol
Yes and males pretending to be women and straight outright assaulting women in sports.
Trans people are 4 times more likely to to be victims of violent crime.
Came to say precisely this. 🙃
It's how woke ideology works, pathetically
Exactly. Also, how is the trans person unsafe because the woman got out of the elevator? At no time was the trans person in an unsafe situation.
I don’t care if you’re black, white, gay, straight, trans, or anything else… if I’m in an enclosed space with ANYONE that I feel discomfort around, I’m leaving. Period. It’s not about you. It’s about how I’m feeling in the moment and I 100% have the right to see myself out.
That’s the way, on the individual, self-centered and selfish level, not based solely on this specific aspect otherwise the messaging becomes a bit icky. Ultimately, anyone holds the right to leave some place they don’t feel comfortable no matter the situation.
Shaming women as "not nice" for prioritizing our safety over men's feelings?
How progressive.
Don't lump those freaks in with actual men. It should be quite clear that is not what actually defines them.
All you have to do to figure this out is think. Women go through the world more cautiously than men for a reason. First, is our physical safety. Men are bigger, stronger, and have way more testosterone pumping through their bodies. Women are so much more likely to be physically violated that I doubt if there’s even a statistic for it. The other reason is the way we’re made by nature to be hyper vigilant for every kind of threat around us, because we’re the ones who will spend way more time protecting babies and children. Normal women are always on the lookout for any potential threat to themselves and their children. We look out for other people’s children, too. Sorry if you’re little feelings are hurt by us doing what we’re made to do.
@@KatieBelle777 maybe read the post you commented to again O:)
@@KatieBelle777 ..Pretty sure I was being sarcastic.
@@5pctLowBattery I know you were kind of kidding, but it’s obvious many people honestly (or dishonestly) think like this and talk this way. It’s ridiculous and that’s who needs to understand basic biological differences in the way men and women have to navigate the world. I take BS like this actual government advertising in Australia seriously. This is so out of control.
As a woman, I am not obligated to stay on an elevator or in a restroom with ANYONE.
As a human being you aren't obligated.
The upper class wants you to get graped.
Isn’t it wild how it went from allowing them in to you not being allowed to leave?
@@mollygrace3068 Yes, totally crazy. How dare they tell me I am supposed to just stay put and and smile through very uncomfortable situations rather than leave?
👍
That man in a dress stands there with his fist clenched, but an older woman who is a foot shorter than him is a threat to him. It's almost like men's feelings worth more than women's lives
You are delusional. You got some citations of times where trans people are killing women?
So… THIS is what they are talking about when they say trans people are “literally dying” from transphobia? Older women not wanting to share elevators with linebackers in dresses?
We used to have this thing called “stranger danger.” The premise was “if someone feels strange, they probably are. And it’s safer to leave their presence than stay in it and face possible danger.” - we used to teach kids to trust their gut and follow their instincts - now we tell women that they have to stay in uncomfortable situations in close quarters or they are bigots - and if their instincts tell them to flee, that’s violence towards the person they are fleeing 😑
If the woman felt unsafe, she did the right thing by leaving.
If a liberal feels "unsafe" around christians then does that justify them behaving as if christians are dangerous? If a white person feels "unsafe" around black people is the behavior appropriate? it's just inappropriate behavior. The comments on this video are very strange.
Both should feel safe, they're both by theirselves.
Let's imagine that instead of a transgender person walking into the elevator, it was a religious person and the other person left (saw a Bible or something). Would liberals have a problem with that? Or are only SOME people's feelings sacrosanct?
I thought it was funny, because if I saw a woman leave an elevator like THAT; I would think she just really needed to take a shit
@@Paducahrus Very few men fear women, most could kill us with one blow.
Many female Victorians have made written complaints about this. As a survivor of SA, someone else’s feelings does not trump my safety
Exactly! I'm not Australian, but I am a SA survivor too and screw someone else's feelings when it comes to the safety of myself, other women and children. If I see a man in the women toilets or locker rooms, I'll scream. I don't care what anyone says. Pronouns or self ID'ing be damned, you still have the physique of a man! You shouldn't be in there! I don't get why there are even women that accept this! We constantly have to be on guard as women, especially around men we don't personally know. (sometimes even around men we think we know) I'm not saying that all men have bad intentions, but we have no way of knowing which man does or doesn't. That makes it so dangerous. And there are plenty of predatory men using this self ID'ing stuff to their advantage. We have to keep fighting this. I fear that one day, the governments are going to force us to accept this, but we can't jeopardize the safety of women and children, no matter what.
According to your government, they do.
@@noktumwhatever753 hence the written complaints
That's what kills me. They pushed all thos safety stuff using people like you and then turn around and basic say nah, you have to feel unsafe. It's insane.
The thing is that technically if feelings mattered to these government people and whoever pushes for that stuff fr, they would listen to a majority that feels unsafe. There are more women than trans people, and many women do not like this. Heck even many trans people believe womens spaces matter. It's like they returned to an era where women were not allowed to have opinions and we are regressing. And they wouldnt even listen to trans people like Buck Angel who call that kind of stuff out.
When the bullies declare themselves victims so they can continue to bully women and children.
Bullies always do that it is a trope for a reason.
100%
@@LloydChristmas-vx2wh People are bullies. But not all people. Cis men are bullies. But not all cis men. Why are a minority of ‘biological men’ who live as women more likely to be bullies in your eyes?
Who’s the bully here? The people who are saying “be nice to trans people” or the people who are calling trans women “men” and thereby degrading them
DARVO baby
This ad is asking for special treatment, not fairness.
I really don’t like it when they pretend just not wanting to be around someone is considered making them (the trans person) “unsafe”
couldn't agree more!
God made two, yes, only two genders, a MAN and a WOMAN! Period!
@TheAmalaEkpunobi honestly I thought the one that came out of the elevator was the trans person lol
These people love to twist language to make words with severe implications apply to their minor inconveniences. They'd call this r@pe if they thought they could get away with it.
@@TheAmalaEkpunobiof course the women's team who has a trans women in it is ok with cheating they want to win so they want the advantage until it's them not having the man on their team
Pretty sure 4/4 people in general have been treated unfairly at some point.
These stats are absurd.
Yeah but they’re special
I'm completely confident that you are correct about that.
My teacher once ignored what I had to say in class once because my twin brother had already said it in another class period. I was treated unfairly as a twin. 2/2 twins are treated unfairly in their lifetime.
If we are being 100% honest they wqnt special treatment not equal treatment.
@@slenderslayer8203😂😂
Their ad literally showed the opposite of their claim…
1:30 How exactly is the transgender woman not safe? The actual woman let the guy have the entire elevator.
This is what baffles me. They claim that trans would be unsafe in Men’s spaces but then with the same breath say women shouldn’t feel unsafe with trans in their spaces. So you can claim men can be deemed potentially dangerous but women can’t have the same concerns about trans who are actually men in their spaces. make it make sense
Yesssss 100% I think about this all the time! Thank you for saying it
It all comes down to the idea that only t-persons are allowed to have feelings.
Because you don't get their "logic".
The moment you put on a skirt, you cease to be a man.
That's the argument.
If he wears a dress and make-up all potential danger exits his body and he becomes more helpless and weak than even a young teenage girl. So it makes sense he feels threatened if that young girl doesn't want to undress in front of him.
Reasoning with this insanity is pointless. The mad have clearly taken over the assylum.
One can clearly see that you don't accept the dogma "transwomen are women" (the moment they say so) and therefore you already qualify as a transphobe. Sadly I've heard exactly this phrase out of the mouth of the (apparently female) German minister for family, and youth, brushing away the concerns about socalled transwomen in female spaces provoked by their new self-ID law. The ideological stubbornness is appalling.
The ad is oxymoronic... how does the "transwoman" NOT feel safe after being left TOTALLY alone on an elevator by someone who is clearly uncomfortable around her? Would it not have been worse for the woman to have mocked, scorned or physically hurt him/her?
This person was left completely ALONE ON AN ELEVATOR.... HOW MUCH SAFER CAN ONE BE????
These men require constant validation and affirmation to keep the fantasy that they are women going. That's what they really want and what all this is really about.
But their feelings were hurt 😞 and we all know emotional harm is the same as physical harm in clown world.
Oh, I don't know, maybe knowing that people around you despise you enough to want to immediately leave might lead to a sense of being unwelcome, unwanted, dare I say, unsafe in the place you live?
@@SanguinaryBlade my husband is a 6 foot two man he’s very muscular and has a big beard. he has had multiple women not enter an elevator because he’s been on it. He has had multiple women cross the street because he’s been walking down it. It’s obvious they are uncomfortable and feel unsafe around him , and it does hurt his feelings, But That’s not his fault, that’s their problem and their right to move.
@@SanguinaryBladeWhat about absence is threatening? Wouldn’t YOU not want someone who disagrees with your lifestyle around you? Why does everyone only exist to validate you and if they don’t then their presence or absence is a threat?
The fact that these are literal MEN telling WOMEN that we basically need to shut up and smile.....isn't that....."misogynistic?" How is this not clicking?
The depressing thing is that the government department and the advertising agency responsible for the ad are run by women. Maybe it's a stealth GC campaign.
it’s people telling bigots to be less awful. stop pretending women are victims here
@aaaaaaaa9189 no one is being a bigot. A man in a women's space is uncomfortable. We are still allowed to be uncomfortable and state as much.
@@Chez1991 you’re calling trans women men. the only people who do that are either ignorant or bigoted. you’re obviously the latter
you’re allowed to be uncomfortable. just like we’re allowed to point out that your discomfort is nothing but prejudice and immature world views on your end
@@Chez1991Are men allowed to feel uncomfortable from a lady that is in their space, state as much, won’t be an issue, right?
Way to go Texas Supreme Court for upholding SB 14 and banning gender assignment surgeries and puberty blockers for children.
So they’re saying better to risk being assaulted than hurt feelings.
Yep. Pure insanity.
That’s Zionism for ya.
Yes, just like in the 19th century.
I use elevators in shopping centers when I have my dog with me. She is very mellow, doesn’t bark, but isn’t small.
Several times people were afraid and said they’d wait for the next one.
An elevator is an extremely tight space. I completely understand if people are afraid.
They don’t know my dog. They might have had bad experiences with other dogs.
It doesn’t reflect on me or my dog at all.
It says we should ignore our instincts. I’m not going to do that!
Who hasn’t been “treated unfairly” in their life?
I couldn't imagine having a young daughter right now and worrying about an adult male being in the restroom or locker room with her. I don't care about trans women using a female bathroom with me, but I'm an adult. But with a 12-year-old girl?? That's scary. I remember being 9 or 10 years old when adult males started becoming inappropriate with me. During my preteen/teen years, I had men leer at me, stick their tongues out at me, grope me, rub up against me, try to hug or kiss me, say sexually inappropriate comments, try to give me rides. It happened all the time. I know most trans women aren't out to harm children or females, but we don't know who's doing it to get into women's spaces. Trans people should feel safe, but not at the expense of biological women.
ALL of us at some time or other!
How many women are dead or raped because the perpetrator shamed them out of acting on their unease?
101 in the person with ill intent playbook
They were putting the truth in plain sight. Clearly, the woman in this ad who was afraid did what most would do--they fled the situation. The trans wasn't afraid, they were just merely offended.
It is also part of the thrill, for some trans.
As an SA survivor who struggles with ptsd, i will vacate any small, inescapable space if I'm stuck there with ANYONE who looks like they can overpower me. And i will not apologize for that discrimination. Feel free to judge me if you see me gripping onto my car keys for safety. I will never place anyone's feelings over my own need to feel safe. 🤷
As you should, wouldn’t it be great if we had a safer world with ☮️
I'm not an SA survivor, but I've experienced domestic abuse from my brother, Im right there with you, sweetheart.
If people walk away from you, you'll be more safe than ever!
They want praise 😂
@@haroldjohn2273 No, this all goes much further than that. They want to be worshiped. That's why they all try to live off of the internet and other peoples money.
@@noktumwhatever753 Do I avoid people who think they are "trans" or even believe that transitioning is possible? Of course I do. Always will. Let 'em try and do something about it.
@ConservativeGrouch I mostly just pity them. Imagine have such a weak sense of self that someone else can make you ignore reality and destroy your health and relationships in the pursuit of a lie?
@@noktumwhatever753 I would have some pity for the kids who were misled into this horror show. They didn't know any better and they trusted the adult monsters who prompted them. On the other hand, the adults who should have known better even without a medical background (which I have) and STILL opted for their own surgical mutilation: tough. They couldn't bother to do their homework, so they might as well accept the 24/7 living nightmare which resulted and stop whining to us about it.
As a man, I would feel very unsafe stepping into an elevator with another huge man pretending to be a woman. Why? Because he's not just a man in an elevator, he's chosen to be a caricature of a woman, which is extremely unusual - 100% of people I've ridden with in an elevator in my 65 years have been exactly what I have expected them to be: men dressed and acting like men, women dressed and acting like women. This scenario as described in the clip would by so bizarre according to my lived reality, I would feel incredibly uneasy. Why? Because I can't predict whether that is a passive pretence by a psychologically confused individual who thinks he's a woman, or a potentially aggressive pretence by a psychologically disturbed individual playing a sinister role. Most likely it's the former, but I can understand why isolated women, in a lift who deal with male aggression in many forms, would be uneasy or frightened.
💥💯💥
I don't care how they feel anymore. That's how weaponized victimhood works. It creates compassion fatigue.
Dear Trans Community:
Don't tell us we have to accept you for who you are when you couldn't even accept yourself for who you are.
@@dragerdet respect and kindness given as commands are counter to what those _COURTESIIES_ describe.
@@dragerdetwhat exactly constitutes respect? It's 2024 I have to make sure we diffine words the same.
@@dragerdet
Except it is literally impossible to “transition” to the opposite sex.
Bit tired of this copypasta. So unoriginal 🙄
@@dragerdet so don't talk to them. I like being left alone. So I'm fine with ignoring thier existence, because that's what I want.
How about this? What if her leaving the elevator ACTUALLY HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH THE PERSON ON THE ELEVATOR? Feeling sick? Had to use the bathroom? Forgot something at her desk? Etc
Nope. It just has to be bigotry, because EVERYTHING is about you, right?🙄
Looked like she farted and then panicked when she realises she wouldn't be alone in the elevator 😂
@@Pepperkekpoor thing trusted her fart
*Yes.* I used to have a low self-esteem that made me think that people were avoiding me most of the time and *NO,* life happens and no one is the center of anyone's life!
Plus, sometimes people would avoid me because I literally looked like death, so cranky and in a bad mood... you know, *other factors that compose a human being besides this identity stuff...*
My mother can't be on an elevator for long, she gets serve travel sickness so to combat that if she needs to use the elevator she will go up a few floors, stop and have some water, get back on and repeat. This woman could have had that.
Trans people are deeply narcissistic.
It really is all about them all the time
In the first ad the man in woman dress invaded the personal space of the woman after he gazed her, that's why a woman will left an elevator as quick as possible. There was enough space in the elevator, why didn't he gave her more space? It's a common behaviour in an elevator situation to try not to stand too close together, unless you have to because it's full. That sort of behavior make me angry, it's threatening, rude and disrespectful. Like the manspreading next to a woman in the public transportation. So the woman had to make space to get comfortable again.
Australia showed its true colours during covid. This doesn’t surprise me, but it’s still deeply unnerving. A woman’s greatest asset to her safety is her intuition. It is vital to be able to listen to that little voice telling you to get out of the lift, to decline the man offering to help with your groceries, to ignore that man asking for directions, etc. Most of the time, after women have been assaulted, they report that they “had a feeling” but ignored it because they wanted to be polite. Ignoring those feelings gets women killed. And there has recently been a murder spree against women in Australia. Never let anyone tell you to ignore that little voice. It could save your life.
As an Australian you literally have no clue what you are talking about...but go off.
Something that always infuriates me about the transdebate is that they are really saying that trans people are entitled to feel safe even if it makes other people unsafe. The feminist agenda has been building up men as the boogey man for ages and now when the men suddenly takes on a dress and proclaim they are women they are somehow "elite women" above the rest and deserve extra privileges, its really mind boggling
we live in a clown world
It's nuts. The """feminists""" straight-up believe (and demand that WE ALL believe) that, as long as he calls himself a "transwoman", the feelings of ONE SINGLE man, outweigh the feelings, and right to privacy, dignity, safety, fair sports, self-determinism, safe prisons etc, of THOUSANDS of (actual, evidence-based) women and girls.
There is literally NOT ONE SINGLE ISSUE, where the rights of women have clashed with the demands of (men who self-ID as) "transwomen", where the left has FAILED to prioritize that 0.5% of men, above all women and girls.
There is literally NOTHING more important than affirming the evidence-free fantasies of people who choose to ID as "trans", according to these people.
Just goes to prove that some of the more extreme "feminists" were not excatly wrong, hm?
Anything to discourage normal human reproduction (families).
I personally would not have left the elevator, but I would run naked for my life screaming if they came into my changing room - telling me to "accept their bulge". If it was a Trans person like Blair White (who has a penis, but actually passes as a woman & respects womens rights) I would not be bothered. Genuine trans women don't create discomfort to women.
Remember ladies, if someone makes you feel unsafe, especially someone far stronger than you, make sure you don’t hurt their feelings. That would be phobic.
Well, it IS phobic. By pure definition of the word, you’re fearful. The thing is, that fear is justifiable, and they’re telling us it’s not. Why…. Because all trans people MUST be wonderful people. And everyone who puts on a wig MUST be trans.
🙌
Well, as a man, I've gotten this reaction from women for less. I usually assume that person has some kind of trauma they are dealing with to make them hyper-vigilant, and I'm usually relieved that they left, rather than interacting, because I assume the latter would be worse.
😂😂😂😂
So you should destroy the feels of the other person. Yes, it's phobic
Notice how the guy on the bus didn't make way for an actual woman to sit. There are a few standing.
🤷♀️Most folks actually do differentiate Trans and Bio despite the claims “Oh ye, trans are the Same as bio.” a result of the Bio being part of the movement that pushed for zero chivalry or have adopted that as part of it through the public’s perception. He just didn’t want to and gave it to the trans.
Obviously the actual woman doesn’t feel safe so she does the logical thing and leaves and yet she is the “bad guy”? Absolutely not.
Anyone should hold the right to leave peacefully for any reason tbh. It’s a W for them.
She’s bigoted at worst
Story time.
Me. 6'3 270lbs male.
On elevator going up. Stops at a random floor. Door opens. Woman on the other side. About to get on. Sees me. Stops. Says "Oh, I'll take the next one."
HOW DARE SHE NOT MAKE ME FEEL SAFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I've had people do this with my tiny dog too lol, it's normal to be cautious, we have this instinct for a reason. They might have had bad experience with tiny dogs too, people that tell others to forsake their caution are very entitled or they're actually wolf in sheep's clothing.
I guess my service dog and I are in danger when people don't want to share an elevator all the time.
Women who avoid any and all men no matter how they're dressed or how they look are exhibiting weird behavior, we should at least be able to admit that. I mean who knows it's possible she's been assaulted before so that might explain how it could be reasonable. As a black man I can understand when people avoid me but I dont have to like it or accept that its always reasonable behavior
I think these comments comparing avoiding being with a person to avoiding being with an unknown animal are wild. People who have dogs typically dont have problems with being with dogs, it's those who dont spend time with dogs who mostly dont like it. We all work with people literally everyday though. Justifying picking and choosing who you'd ride on an elevator with based on characteristics the person cannot control is nuts to me.
@@oakinwol Hear hear.
@@oakinwolyou can say this because you’re a man. For women, it’s not just about feeling uncomfortable, it’s about the risks involved. And yea, we know the man in the elevator is most likely not dangerous or a threat to us, but he’s physically intimidating and we know that IF he was dangerous, we wouldn’t stand a chance.
Women should not be shamed for choosing not to take that chance.
Nothing is more dangerous than dismantling a woman's instincts and leaving her totally disarmed.
I’m Australian, Queenslander here 🤚
I stopped going to my gym at AnyTime Fitness because they got rid of our women’s toilets and made all toilets unisex. Then there was piss on the walls and seats, they stunk and it was unhygienic. This isn’t about diversity and inclusion. It’s a hygiene matter - is women need to sit down to do our business, we need to make contact with the seat most times. We have a menstrual cycle and would prefer a clean toilet to change tampons/pads without the bin lid being covered in male urine. Needless to say, I cancelled my membership.
We had three women toilets and three men’s. and a few showers that were free for all of course - what’s the problem? It made me so mad that all the women loyal to that gym will now have to sacrifice their hygiene for the 1%
I hope you told them why you was cancelling
Notice all the actual women on the bus who are standing in the background; the seated man feels no need to offer THEM a seat, but as soon as he sees a man in a DRESS, he suddenly remembers his manners.
Ooh good call!
My brother said he was trans. And I didn't mind giving him a chance until I asked him why he thought that. "Well it's easier to be a woman" damn near sl@pped him back to the 90s.
For a guy who never has to endure menstruation or menopause, I might agree these days.
As someone living through the 90s I will tell you , that he woukd have changed his mind immediately
I don't think you made her feel very safe.
@chesscomsupport8689 Actually, he did the right thing to do this. Also, you don't have a bother to tell this, ok. Even though it's he, not she.
I've often suspected that a significant driver of the "trans movement is males who can't "make it as males" in society, and either secretly hate women for that reason or want to be the object of male attention, and so do wish to displace women.
Some might truly choose to believe that women have an "easier life" than do men, and want to ride that perceived social gravy train they believe women get.
We see relatively few females wanting to transition to males. The majority is male to female, and social climate seems to play a role.
So less than 1% of the populations feelings are more important than the safety of 50% of the population 😅 oh Lordy
"The needs of the few outweigh the needs of the many". This is the exact opposite of logic as per Spock on Star Trek. So feelings are more important than logic I guess.
The percentages should not matter. Even if Trannies were 40% and Women 30% somehow. We decided decades ago that Women ought to have a human right to have spaces seperate from men. If men have some vain, egotistical need to delude themselves they have no right to violate other people's human rights.
@@ShawnHall Welcome to the 2020s.
@@ShawnHall This is MIRROR Universe Spock! DQ&F!
@@ShawnHall Logic? Did you forget we are talking about liberals?
Start calling liberals veritasphobic. Veritas is latin for truth.
10 in 10 people have been treated unfairly at some point in their life
There was about 39 seconds where we were telling women it was ok to trust their instincts, rather than be polite. Remember that? It was like a Tuesday… in 2017 or something. Glad we got it sorted out that that is actually not ok.
Biggest gaslighting operation in all of recorded history.
I am an Australian living in Australia, and this ad makes me sick to the stomach. How dare they endanger women this way by making them feel that they should stay in an uncomfortable place. I wish I had left an uncomfortable situation in the past... too late now... but things would have been a whole lot better for me if I hadn't ignored my 'feelings of foreboding'. This is DISGUSTING, DECADENT and IMMORAL.
How about a reverse ad about trams"women" making little girls unsafe in the changing/ bathrooms? I would be all for that ad!😂
An exercise in emotional manipulation, from a government.
they removed all the comments bc they called out this anti woman pro grape misogynistic bs
They can still see the downvotes, though 😂
@@septillion2501 good 🥰 fyck that stupid ad
I expected that.
That's why we need third party comment options. The only one I've found so far is Clamor, it's a browser extension. It's a bit too basic but it's something at least.
Rape*
If this doesn't fulfill the concept of "doublethink/doublespeak" from 1984 by George Orwell, I don't know what does.
If a big man dressed as a clown got into the elevator I would feel uncomfortable as well
The alphabet mafia needs to be reminded of how insignificant they really are. We need to normalize pushing back.
Men telling women they have more of a right to not feel uncomfortable when they wear makeup and a dress. Typical.
Predatory and misogynist behavior
It's basically mansplaining being a woman to women.
Women inviting these men and women into society with open arms then expecting men to help you clean up the mess you created after men warned you who would be the most vulnerable and are now having to argue the flawed logic they use to gaslight you into feeling guilty. Typical.
What makes you think these freaks are somehow our representatives?
I don't think so ma'am.
Women giving into their feelings to push votes to allow for such things to happen then blame men when they don't like the results. Typical.
So Me as a sexual assault suvivor who was assaulted as a child, and again as a young woman just has to shut up and let a man with his male parts, who is biologically bigger, strong than me come into the gym locker room while I undress, or shower, or into the ladies room I am in and just deal?!?
I was told at work when a male came into the ladies room and I walked out and complained (without receiving myself) was told to Hold it in or walk around the complex (which is large) to find another ladies room?
That is sickening. I'm so sorry about that
As an Aussie & a Victorian, I am EMBARRASSED by this garbage!
Most of the time it isn't even NEEDED!
Female-born people also deserve to feel safe.
As an Australian, this is embarrassing. We are following Americans gender ideological 😢
As an American it's doubly embarrassing, seeing this spread like a virus. And as a woman, it's downright maddening. This whole subject is just wrong on so many levels, and it's upsetting to be lumped in with these psychologically challenged individuals. 😢
Unfortunately their distorted ideology may turn them into targets. No one likes to be forced fed or backed into a corner. It never ends well.
As a Norwegian I’m embarrassed to find us rooting for this spread of the ideology - using both American states and Australia (alongside Brighton in UK et cetera) as good examples…in stead of taking a more sceptic stance like per example Sweden seem to be approaching.
Thank the governments, all of that is just bs. The whole thing is a government started ideology, not the people's! Most of my male friends and best ones were gay, bi, trans etc. those friends are also so anti-alphabet you would be surprised. Go to New Orleans and see.
We don't want this crap in the USA. It's the media. Same as there.
We've been crossing the street and locking the car doors for decades. It's called survival.
Green Dress it was safe. It became alone. Other lady became safe too. All is good.
I would argue that EVERYONE is treated unfairly at some point in their life. It’s not unique to any particular group or person.
Dear Trans people: I reject your reality.
@@kristalandrews1550 agree with your comment 💯%
I reject the word "trans" itself. It's not even a word, it's a suffix. And more importantly, you can never change your gender.
Delusion you mean
i used to struggle with paranoid delusions during manic phases before i detransitioned. it’s terrifying feeling like every eye around is on you, staring at you and judging you for being visibly different.
if you ascribe malicious motivations to strangers simply going about their business such as a woman leaving an elevator, a person averting their gaze, etc., and this prevents you from being able to feel safe in public, please see about talking to a professional. those kinds of agoraphobic and paranoid thoughts are not normal, and there is help available for you. god bless
There's a lot to what you said. When I was a teenager and far up into adulthood, I thought of myself as only really existing if someone saw. It sounds strange but as I worked through why I felt so poorly about myself, that's what it worked out to. I realized that if I were the only person in a room, to my mind nobody was there. I'm not saying I think this was the same for you or anything, but what you say about thinking people were looking at you and judging you all the time is akin to that. And what happens when there are two people on an elevator, both thinking the other is judging them without mercy? Well, each is thinking only of themselves. What a wall stands between them.
I wish I could say only in Victoria. Sadly it's contagious and spreading, our elites are insane in Australia.
IF I were to live in Australia, I would be very angry. As a woman who worked in childcare for 20 years, I had to either push prams or carry babies on public transport. MANY times, no one offers a seat. Why is a trans woman mode deserving of a seat than a pregnant woman or a woman carrying a baby?
Women were saying in mass they'd rather be alone with a BEAR than a man in the woods and that was received with enthusiastic approval but if a woman doesn't want to be alone in an elevator with a man in a dress than this organization says that's not okay. Wild.
That bear shit is stupid but I'd rather hear about that than this damn ad 😂
Woman here.... it is still stupid that women said they would rather be with a bear. I find saying that all men are dangerous is ridiculous. Most men are perfectly safe. If a woman is thinking all men they are around are dangerous then they need to rethink about who they hang around. Most men in my life I feel very safe around, including most trans women.
@filmjustice4172 The percentage of men who are safe is definitely much higher than the percentage of bears. Picking the bear is ridiculous unless they get a big, hairy gay guy instead of the animal.
@@filmjustice4172for real. And get a better judge of character. A friend of mine and I were talking about this nonsense (she’d rather be with the bear), and lo & behold, she’s been caught up with a handful of trash men.
Even those of us who generally don’t get perceived as a threat still feel a little frustrated with this culture of misandry.
@filmjustice4172 Oh, I agree 100%. I just thought it was ironic how the world seems to react to both of these ideas with such contradiction. And realistically yeah most trans women are safe too I think it's more the idea that if your alone with another person (literally anyone) and you feel unsafe then removing yourself from the situation doesn't make you a bigot it makes you reasonably cautious. Just funny how in one breath society says most men are dangerous, and then in the next, they say well, but if they wear makeup and a dress, then they're automatically safe.
I dont understand this getting feelings hurt=feeling unsafe.
It’s so blatantly disrespectful and dismissive of women’s feelings of safety! How is it that nowadays women aren’t allowed to feel safe anymore & are being emotionally blackmailed to ignore their instincts about their personal safety?
The dude on the train took a seat, while a bunch of women were standing.
Yeah but those were women, not people
@@laurazepam8382 good one mate!👍
🤷♀️They wanted?
I just stopped at an unfamiliar corner store for a couple drinks. Guy behind the counter wasn't rude but wasn't friendly either. Theres a million things it could be, he's sick, just got bad news, had a long day.. a trans person who uses that as their entire identity would walk away from that exact situation feeling like its because they're trans when in probably has nothing to do with you. Its like they demand good vibes and validation from everyone, its bizarre. If people are not overly nice it doesn't mean they are rude or throwing hate your way, they are just living lol
No logic at all! We have been teaching WOMEN for decades to remove themselves from situations they don’t feel safe in! Those Trans Ads is putting women in a dangerous place!!!!
I don’t care if he has a dress on with a wig !!!! He is still a man with an advantage and an upper hand in any situation
No one persons rights are greater than anyone elses. Once you infringe on someone elses rights/safety....its unacceptable.
My FEELINGS of safety far outweigh that trans persons HURT feelings. Especially as there HAVE been women harmed by men pretending to be women, yet the trans person in this case is completely physically safe from ME.
As a woman I do not give a penny for their feel8ngs. As a german with the new laws installed , I decided to confront any man in a female space with ridiculing him. Being 1.80 m I am willing to take the risk
"We're glad you're on the team!"
What was unsaid: "...because you could singlehandedly wipe out the opposition! We will never lose again!"
And we’re glad we’re not going to be tackled by you!
“We’re glad you’re not on the other team!”
I want to see their smiling friendly faces when he follows them into the changeroom.
That was my first thought too. "We got a ringer!"
I suggest watching "Gender-A Wider Lens" on RUclips or listening to their podcast. A lot of great videos about this trans epidemic and what it's doing. People need to be informed of what's happening. It's definitely eye-opening.
The one in the green literally glared at the other one as “he” got in the lift. The Vic govt is awful
i'm _not_ obligated to humour a delusion. i live in reality and acknowledge what is real.
What I still don't understand is why are all examples of "transgender people" in sports only of men wanting to be part of the female team and never vice versa? It's such a strange, unexplained phenomenon...
Some women try, 99.99999% of them fail terribly.
1 boxer who fights in the lightweight division. She met a middling boxer and lost. Opponents after him will be stronger, so I think she finally hit the obvious wall. Her name is Patricia/Patricio.
There's also that Chris Mosier(?) one from years back. Qualified for the Olympics for speedwalking or something in that vein, but I think they never actually competed once there.
That girl who transitioned that "beat" Liam in the "He's not cheating match" following his NCAA win, tried out for the mens swim team and went from a top female swimmer to can't even hope to come last. She retired after.
It's not that they don't exist. They're just incredibly unsuccessful.
I mentioned this in another channel. Apparently there are examples. I’d bet that they’re larger framed women to begin with. I have female cousins who are over 6’ and built like amazons. With enough training they might be able to compete in certain areas but they are definitely outliers.
Its because nobody tells them they cant join (and we all know why). And its not like theyre breaking records or anything either, so they might just do sports and exist like a lot of other male athletes who only the most fanatic of fans may know about.
The reason they gave this example in the video is because men get denied to participate in female sports (and we all know why). The government perceives that as an act of unjust discrimination rather than actually justified.
Sane people deserve to feel safe.
More so than godless freaks.
they don’t want to feel "safe" they want to be in control, they want the whole world to cater to them, it doesn’t matter if the woman feels unsafe all it matters is for the trans person to feel comfortable, thats not equality that’s wanting special privileges.
Young girls and women have felt uncomfortable around certain biological males since the dawn of time!!!! Get used to it if you want to be a trans woman!
I'm genuinely scared for our future. It's not fair that I have to share my spaces, spaces where I'm meant to feel safe, with deceptive men who think womanhood is a costume.
what could be safer than having an elevator all to yourself.
Having your autogynephilic cravings for the reification of your delusions justified, I guess.
😂😂😂
You might get introspective, wonder if you've made an almighty boo-boo, and decide to detransition? Whoo! That kind of thinking is unsafe!
Maybe she's scared of the lift ghost 👻
And that alone shows and proves he'll never be a woman.
The guy on the bus didn’t offer the seat to the numerous women already standing up around him. 🤦🏼♀️ but .. hell with them, right?
I noticed the same thing!!
He didn't offer a seat at all. He just moved his bag which shouldn't have been on a seat at all in a crowded tram.
The real women can wait for the trans even if pregnant birthing female.
@@pollyparrot9447 wow. Ok. The point remains the same.
He's handsome and gay
I would to know this, what happened to the expression, WHAT HAPPENS BEHIND CLOSED DOORS IS NOBODY'S BUSINESS?
What I have gathered is that a lot of people want "special treatment"...not rights. Because after all, we all have the same rights. It's never about that. It needs to stop!
As a woman Idc whose feelings I'm gonna hurt as long as I am safe.
total BS
Women in womens sport
End of story
Aussie government 🤮🤮🤮
I suppose I’m a transphobe since I would feel uncomfortable with someone who dresses like a woman but is obviously a man. I have no problem with a person dressing how they choose, but I would still feel uncomfortable. Can’t help my feelings
It’s the uncanny valley feeling. You know it’s not real and is mimicking us unnaturally 😭
I refuse to play with them in their "fantasy".
If dudes wanna wear dresses and makeup, I'm so down. That's a vibe. But it does not make you a woman. You're still a dude.
Same here. I wouldn’t care if a man wore a croptop, but if they say they’re a woman, that’s where I draw the line.
@@aweebwhoexists64I can't draw that line, I am barely 5.4 ft tall. I don't want them to get mad.
Damn really the dude gave up his seat to that guy while many have been standing around?? So unreal.
Considering how many men in dresses are suddenly assaulting women, it's no wonder the woman chose to leave the elevator. She probably didn't feel safe with him.
I work at a hospital, in pharmacy. On some floors, when I deliver meds to the med rooms, I have to pass by a nurse's station. Most of the time, it would save me a few steps to walk behind the nurse's station. If there are only female nurse's present, I walk around it, because it is THEIR safe space. I will only ever walk behind it if there is a male nurse present, or if I am accompanied by a female from pharmacy. It's ingrained in my conscious and subconscious mind. I don't feel like I'm particularly threatening, but I feel like a little effort on my part goes a long way toward trust.
I think anybody with a brain recognizes women are rightfully on guard against anything that throws a threatening signal, even if unintentionally so.
Remember those are men with hurt feelings.
When I was younger, I shared hostel rooms with gay guys I met on tour who were easy going and got on well with my female friend and me. None of these guys ever assumed they could share, they threw it out there and we were happy to share, because we were genuinely comfortable with it and added an extra layer of safety, as gay men are still men and their presence doesn’t hurt. The point was, it was our choice, no one expected us to automatically give these guys carte blanche.
Men with hurt feelings = Can never be justified
Women with hurt feelings = Justified
🤔🤔 I took from that thought experiment in the beginning. Seems to be agreed with, how to seal in the hole of inequality in regards to that?
@@Catmom-gl5ntExpectations, perhaps is a better way to fight this. Though, that specific anecdotal doesn’t precisely fit what was being fought against, perhaps neither gender should expect the other to make a decision considering the other’s feelings? 🤔
That trans soccer player is only dangerous to the other team. “Get them Roberta!”
Wonder how far I would get if I “decided” I wanted to identify as rich. Credit card companies should just give me a card with no limit & not expect me to pay the bill or it would be discriminating towards me!!!! Hmmm, wonder how far I would get?!?
Rejected maybe but unsafe? Hardly.
Sidenote, when the Washington monument was finished with the elevator. A man was not allowed to enter the elevator alone with a woman for her protection. Those were the standards at the time.
I’m from Melbourne, Australia and hadn’t seen this yet. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
So there are all those people standing up in the Bus ad, but the seat is only cleared when a new person gets on lol
Holy crap, thats gold! 😂😂😂
How he got excited about moving his stuff appeared to me like he was saving the seat for his boyfriend.
Seems to me like the woman who got out of the elevator may have been the one who felt unsafe. Not sure how the other person felt "unsafe" being left in the elevator alone, unless they're frightened of elevators.
Having your feelings hurt is dangerous apparently.
How would he know his feelings are hurt? He doesn't even know his own sex lol
The main thing for me is that all of these scenarios are VASTLY different.
Being in a closed and confined space without anyone else around and sharing it with the opposite gender does NOT equate to giving up a seat for someone in a PUBLIC environment.
Also, that trans girl, i assume, going on the elevator gave the woman a look of DISGUST! THEY LITERALLY MADE AN ASSUMPTION FIRST!!
You are very brave for telling the TRUTH! Keep up the good work!!!
I'm so tired of these "victims"
If i'm in a elevator and a bath salts junkie enters that same space, i'm out! and no, i won't consider their "feelings"
So same thing goes with this, if a woman is uncomfortable with being in the same small space as a large man in a dress, she should get out if she don't feel safe.
As a Victorian, I don’t endorse this
As a Canadian the only offence I took was Victoria being called a State and not a Province. I really don’t give a shit about sex outside of sports.
@@markwalker4485 Why? They are literally called States in Australia. Unless you are trying to say Australian States have become subjugated territories?
Yeah, our government is insane. A lot of people don't know, but it's literally illegal to """mis-gender""" (ie, to CORRECTLY gender, with proper, sex-correct pronouns) in Victoria; It's bizarrely classed as "domestic violence".
Therapists are also legally constrained to an "affirmation-only" approach, to anyone claiming to be "trans".
I've never been an activist, but I'll sign up with just about ANY group, opposing these insane laws.
The fact I could potentially be jailed, for acknowledging THE OBJECTIVE, EVIDENCE-BASED TRUTH of someone's sex, is both ridiculous, and terrifying.
@@markwalker4485 It has nothing to do with Canada... there's states and territories in Australia.
@@distortedsoul27 ok I guess I’m wrong. To my knowledge all the old Commonwealth only had Provinces and Territories. Even in old Colonial Africa there are no States that I know of. This I do know because my second house is in Africa.