No it's horrible. All props for the playing part, but just no. The melodica version sounds like a shitty arcade version of the original Jupiter, because half of what makes it Jupiter is the orchestration.
It's funny, even in this version the movement at 1:30 makes me tear up. In high school Every time we warmed up in band before a show/ concert/ Marching half time, we played that movement. It's such an amazing composition. Holst is amazing.
so much yes!!!! but I kind of want to hear the fourth movement. if you can make me cry, I was going to say that I'll subscribe, but I've already done that...
I think I just about died at 1:56 where he does pretend hand vibrato as if he was playing a heartrending cello solo. It's a melodica; that makes absolutely no difference! 😂 A+ to you guys for tackling such a challenging piece of music and then proceeding to goof off the whole time! 😆
At 0:42 I started conducting with my hand out of habit, like I always do when I listen to the Planets, then I realized they were doing it too! Absolutely outstanding.
My father had a radio show in the 1960s in New York City about classical music and Holst's 'Jupiter' was the theme music. Having grown up with Jupiter, I think I get most of the nuance of it. I think your duo has captured practically every nuance of it known to me. Thanks.
The rhythmic tension is so excellent! There's nothing I don't love about this. I have played this several times from the cello section and I just adore hearing how you manage some of the orchestration with what I'm assuming is tonguing on the melodica. And I'm adding another 5000 points for the Tchaik 6 project.
I once went to a symphony where at the very end of the performance but before the room erutped into a roaring applause someone shouted, "Holy Crap!!!". This performance was even more impressive than that! When the video ended, those were the same two words that came from me as there was nothing else I could say! Amazing job guys. Simply amazing!
Damn! Fabulous! I was smiling and nodding my head through the whole thing. I have listening to every version of Jupiter I can find weather it be orchestra, sax ensemble, percussion ensemble, piano, guitars and you guys are up there. I love what you did. Nice touch in the chorale section changing instruments. I'm going to listen to it again right now.
Your guys' energy for classical music reminds me of my own passion- my friend and I can whistle all of Dvorak 9 and many other pieces together... it's so great to see you guys play. Would love to hear more of Holst's planets-- I just love your arrangements!!
@@timflatus when I sing other words to Thaxted (I vow to thee, my country” not being usual in a Catholic parish in Florida), that octave drop from the original tune is jarring. Poor Holst, his biggest tune mangled for hymnody. Does Elgar have only one Big Tune in Pomp and Circumstance 1, or does the one in 4 also count?
I have just subrscribed to your channel, I am blown away by what you can do with melodicas. Utterly flawless and so enjoyable, some really complex pieces too, perfectly executed.
Very well done, I enjoyed this greatly! But if you really want to knock my socks off... do a rendition of Mars, The Bringer of War by Holst. Then I will be incredibly impressed! Very good stuff nonetheless, all the finest gents!
How I see them: NASA and ESA sitting together in an office meeting and instead of agreeing on making another space project, both of them pulled up their instruments and played this
The fact that these two dudes literally converted one of the best orchestra pieces ever into something played by two melodicas is just amazing.
No it's horrible. All props for the playing part, but just no. The melodica version sounds like a shitty arcade version of the original Jupiter, because half of what makes it Jupiter is the orchestration.
@@shostakovichistheshit7322 The point is to make it comical and upbeat while maintaining the essence of the piece
@@shostakovichistheshit7322 It was originally written for two pianos.
@@shostakovichistheshit7322 You are saying that the orchestrated version is the original, but the original was actually written for two pianos.
Shostakovich is the shit its good but whatever you say buddy
This is more of a salute to Holst than a travesty.
I love it!!!
1:56 trying to vibrato a keyboard
Not trying, doing.
@@Kjango2002 he means how violinists do that motion on the string for a vibrato, even though it doesnt make a difference on a melodica.
It feels like it makes a difference when you’re playing it
I do the same thing
It's funny, even in this version the movement at 1:30 makes me tear up. In high school Every time we warmed up in band before a show/ concert/ Marching half time, we played that movement. It's such an amazing composition. Holst is amazing.
me too
I had to hold back tears during rehearsal and our spring concert
which was this past Thursday actually :3
Fastest sub of my life.
Fancy seeing you here Oxford Weatherman
25th like!
100th like
Same here 🙌🏼
If you guys find a way to do tchaikovsky 6 on melodica, i will give you guys 5000 good boy points
oh my god yes
Of course we're talking about the 3rd movement... right?
so much yes!!!! but I kind of want to hear the fourth movement. if you can make me cry, I was going to say that I'll subscribe, but I've already done that...
Oh my god please do!!
Tchaik 4...4th movement.
I'm telling you. Holst earned himself a special place in heaven when he wrote Jupiter.
I think I just about died at 1:56 where he does pretend hand vibrato as if he was playing a heartrending cello solo. It's a melodica; that makes absolutely no difference! 😂 A+ to you guys for tackling such a challenging piece of music and then proceeding to goof off the whole time! 😆
At 0:42 I started conducting with my hand out of habit, like I always do when I listen to the Planets, then I realized they were doing it too! Absolutely outstanding.
鍵盤ハーモニカだけでここまで再現されるとは…ホルストさんも思いもしなかっただろうw感動しました！！この世界観にとても惹かれます。
ぽmぽmプリnnn〝 いつだったかリコーダーでやらされたわ…
ぽmぽmプリnnn〝 関係ないけど右の人のシャツが好き。
My father had a radio show in the 1960s in New York City about classical music and Holst's 'Jupiter' was the theme music. Having grown up with Jupiter, I think I get most of the nuance of it. I think your duo has captured practically every nuance of it known to me. Thanks.
INCREDIBLE. It´s just perfect. Congratulations.
Gustav holst is my favourite classical compositor. The St Paul suite is incredibly beautiful.
Same tho personally I prefer first suite in Eb.
@@hannahreid1549 suit in Eb was the first piece of heard from Holst. It's my absolute favorite!
I like Hammersmith
Ode to death is pretty neat!
1. I'm not crying you are
And
2. Where did you get that Holst shirt? 👀
i need that shirt
zazzle.co.uk sell it.
thanks a lot
You're welcome, it is a bit pricey though. Plus you can't tell if the shirt is a quality silk screen or crappy plasticky transfer print.
I got the shirt too lmao. Gotta show some love for holst
i love that holst shirt so much
Thank you - There were like 50 or 60 people that bought that design this September. Just search 'Holst" on Zazzle.
my very good friend Kipp(tumor) made that shirt!
Some Indonesian pirate is selling it on ebay now.
The rhythmic tension is so excellent! There's nothing I don't love about this. I have played this several times from the cello section and I just adore hearing how you manage some of the orchestration with what I'm assuming is tonguing on the melodica. And I'm adding another 5000 points for the Tchaik 6 project.
I miss you guys
This is what i want to be played at my funeral when they lift my body in to space with several drones
And now for Stravinsky's "Rite of Spring" :))
adam28xx they've already done it...
ruclips.net/video/vIq543Q10UM/видео.html
adam28xx they already did. Almost a year ago
My assumption is they were referring to the next song in the playlist.
adam28xx pfft i read this the day that came out
肺活量はもちろんだけど地味にppでの細かいタンギングが凄い！
This is too beautiful. *sheds a tear*
A piece that is notorious for being written for an absolutely massive orchestra-
Also, two melodicas and a piano...
I once went to a symphony where at the very end of the performance but before the room erutped into a roaring applause someone shouted, "Holy Crap!!!". This performance was even more impressive than that! When the video ended, those were the same two words that came from me as there was nothing else I could say! Amazing job guys. Simply amazing!
Gentlemen, you do not disappoint.
This is much more than it looks....it can't even imagine what goes on to prep for these videos!!!
Great job guys!
Guys, that is awesome. Thats my favourite piece of classical music.
You can hear how it inspired both Williams and Zimmer directly
Fantastic! “Jupiter” is my favorite Holst planet especially the “hymn” portion beginning @1:30. You guys are truly melodious.
playing this piece is so hard esp at the beginning I felt that and I am vividly impressed by these melodicas
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH OH MAH GLOB .... please do Blue shades
Didn't expect to find you here Mr. Hogan, but at the same time I'm not that surprised
10th like!
amazing song
amazing play
amazing T-shirt
Damn! Fabulous! I was smiling and nodding my head through the whole thing. I have listening to every version of Jupiter I can find weather it be orchestra, sax ensemble, percussion ensemble, piano, guitars and you guys are up there. I love what you did. Nice touch in the chorale section changing instruments. I'm going to listen to it again right now.
My favorite!!! By the way, the melodica totally makes it sound like a sea shanty at 0:43.
It reminds me of a medieval drinking party
It's my favorite too
Amazing! Remember it was originally written by Holst for two pianos - and then turned into an orchestral piece.
Bravo!
Twenty seconds in, and consider me subscribed.
Mephostopheles IS THAT DANNY
Kawaii Potato _"Totally!"_
Same here!
Correct!
You needed 20 sec? 5 is anouht! Love it!
Your guys' energy for classical music reminds me of my own passion- my friend and I can whistle all of Dvorak 9 and many other pieces together... it's so great to see you guys play.
Would love to hear more of Holst's planets--
I just love your arrangements!!
That was the most talent I have ever seen used to play one instrument and multiple parts in my life. Bravo
They manage to make the "I vow to thee" segment sound good with THAT instrument.
Damn, talk about musical geniuses.
The tune is actually called "Thaxted". The hymn was a later adaptation that Holst was not so proud of for various reasons
@@timflatus when I sing other words to Thaxted (I vow to thee, my country” not being usual in a Catholic parish in Florida), that octave drop from the original tune is jarring.
Poor Holst, his biggest tune mangled for hymnody.
Does Elgar have only one Big Tune in Pomp and Circumstance 1, or does the one in 4 also count?
@@markiangooley #4 also counts. I've always been one for listening to the whole album, not just the singles
This deserves to be in everyone's recommended
Wow loved that vibrato 1:56
Yo this is one of my FAVORITE pieces I loooovvvvveeee this
you mean favorite movement
Besides being incredible musicians, the arrangements that these gentlemen make are Outstanding!
小学校の時､音楽会でした事思い出しました!!!楽しかったなぁって当時の事がこんなにハッキリ思い出されるなんて！凄い力を持った演奏…🙇💓💓
めっちゃ上手いのにおもしろい！！
You guys are seriously amazing. Thanks for playing everynote right in your arrangements, my ocd appreciates it
This is an incredible performance both in sound and picture.
This was amazing. Loved the facial expressions
These two are amazing !!!!Such original ideas to play like this with the facial expressions too!!!brilliant and original!!
I have just subrscribed to your channel, I am blown away by what you can do with melodicas. Utterly flawless and so enjoyable, some really complex pieces too, perfectly executed.
This video is a gem, these guys are awesome and the music is woaaaaah
You guys are fantastic!! I subscribed within 30 seconds. Love the addition of piano in the slow section. Excellent musicianship.
I've heard a lot of interpretations of this piece and this one was by far the best.
Oh my God, when it got to the Ballad part, I quite LITERALLY swooned. MAJOR SWOONAGE.
Awesome! It's comical and heartfelt all at once.
marvelous sense of timing!
Wow, I was thoroughly entertained. Thanks for a great performance! Loved it!
I'm laughing hysterically, because this is SO DAMN GOOD
Very well done, I enjoyed this greatly!
But if you really want to knock my socks off... do a rendition of Mars, The Bringer of War by Holst. Then I will be incredibly impressed! Very good stuff nonetheless, all the finest gents!
I literally just thought the same!
Hi, I'm here from the future of today to let you now they have done it! Check their channel!
Bruh they did it yesterday, time to say bye to them socks
puritania11 tbh Mars would probs be easier than this this is more impressive that melodica mars
Facial expressions are so fantastic!
I absolutely love holsts jupiter, and this is a great cover
Wow. This was fantastic thank you so much!!!! Your musicianship is out of this world!
What really makes this work is that it's clear you guys absolutely love what you're doing.
I got 36 seconds in and subscribed. Truly beautiful.
Those are some trumpeter chops if i've ever seen them haha good work guys, hella impressed.
すごいです！！！！！！！
木星は最初の部分が一番好きです！
so wholesome and well played!! I love
This is actually very soothing. The chorale is lovely!
How I see them:
NASA and ESA sitting together in an office meeting and instead of agreeing on making another space project, both of them pulled up their instruments and played this
最高すぎる。
素晴らしい音楽をありがとう！！😍
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH!!! One of my most favorite pieces!! You guys killed it!!
Fantastic. Like all good covers, it changes the way you listen to songs you love.
ピアニカって凄ぇ…
This gave me goosebumps. I am otherwise speechless. Just absolutely amazing!!!!
定期的に見たくなる笑
a true gift from the cosmos
This is pretty much my favorite piece ever and y'all nailed it
You guys are a blast! And obviously well-trained musicians!
maybe the most enthusiastic rendition of Thaxted I've ever heard and I'm not joking
Omg Bluey's episode in space
This is the weirdest thing.
Thank you RUclips recommended and you two beautiful musicians
This is actually my favourite piece of music ever. Thank you.
thetoobnoob venus the bringer of peace👌🏽
정말 놀라워요~~ 어느것 하나 실망시키지 않는군요! 👍
⚘⚘⚘
미쳤엌ㅋㅋㅋ 멜로디언으로 오케 소릴ㄹ 내네;;; 대단합니다 엄지척 드리고 가요...... 와 너무 신기해ㅠㅠㅠㅠ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 오케소리가 나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅠ ㅠ 👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍
looool i CANNOT believe you guys did this! I love this score (movement?). STELLAR JOB ;) Keep up the great work!
YOU DO ALL MY FAVORITE CLASSICAL SONGS THANK YOU SO MUCH
I've seen 19 seconds of this. now I'm subbed. this is the most wonderful thing I've ever seen.
This is perfect for me to know how this song was composed and organized. Thank you!!
Well, that's it. I'm done with the internet, because I will never see anything that can top this.
Firiel how about the original?
both of your T-shirts are awesome!
Can't say I want to buy your album or anything, but ... gotta appreciate the sincere artistry and talent on display here.
I don't know why this was on my recommended list but you guys just found another subscriber!
I love this piece so much.
What a wonderful reduction of Jupiter! Especially Thaxted; I do miss the sections you cut off for time, but it was still PERFECT.
Even on melodica this is still supremely enjoyable to listen to 😂
Masterfully player and arranged! Brilliant job guys
Fantastic! Amazing! Classy! (and thanks for the tee shirt ad) :)
Where do I find friends who will do this kind of stuff with me?
First become the kind of person someone would enjoy doing this with.
#tooreal
On a Facebook musician social group or instrument interest group!
@@SomeFreakingCactus Oof
Music school. That’s where.
Holy hell, I just stumbled on this and you guys are amazing.
I DIDN'T REALIZE THERE WAS A WHOLE CHANNEL FOR THIS AFTER THE RITE OF SPRING HOLY ♡w♡
This is so well done it hurts. Excellent work.
Well I was looking for the London Symphony Orchestra, but... this made my day instead.