11:16 Good theory but if you look at Talisa's letter as she starts rolling it up, you can see the ink through the paper. Her letter had at least 5 lines written, also seemed to be a larger piece of paper compared to the slip of paper with 3 lines that Arya found. I think Roose was the spy who wrote the letter.
I don’t think he was implying they are the same letter, I think he’s trying to make a point about the letter that spies send, as in she’s holding a letter, and there’s a similar letter on the table.
i only read the books after the series started, and didn't fall for them, so i'm not a good source. the alt-shift-x guy has done some theory videos. would be interesting to see whether any of them were backed up by enough series footage for an essay.
A bit of trivia: The actress who played Talisa nee-Maegyr is Oona Chaplin, the Granddaughter of Charlie Chaplin. Not important to the story line but thought I would mention her. PS: I didn't think she was a spy.
Yes OBVIOUSLY, but he didn’t say that was the same letter, he is making a point as she holds that letter and then shows the letter on Tywin’s table to imply that it’s related.
You made me look up "Eideteker." That's the greatest compliment by far. Thank you. I'm trying to dig more theories, whether true or not, for new videos. I've read about Jaime knowing the Red Wedding beforehand, but it's too unlikely. If you have any new ideas or recommendations, please share.
Nah bruh, if she was a spy she wouldn't have died at that point cuz she woulda had insight of them being butchered and she would have either been spared or said something that gave us a hint that she knew more than she lead on.. something like "but you said Id be spared". Definitely NOT a spy.
I always thought it was odd that some random woman from Volantis would show up in Oxcross post battle so conveniently. And the minute she mentioned that the Maester will have everything she needs at the Crag, it’s just like 🤨 wait a minute. 🚩🚩 ROBB HELLO 🚩🚩 🚩🚩PAY ATTENTION 🚩🚩 🚩🚩SHE’S NOT SUPPOSED TO KNOW THAT 🚩🚩
here's another possible parallel, "westerosi customs are a bit foreign to me" was the SAME thing Margaery said to Joffrey when she was playing him
11:16 Good theory but if you look at Talisa's letter as she starts rolling it up, you can see the ink through the paper. Her letter had at least 5 lines written, also seemed to be a larger piece of paper compared to the slip of paper with 3 lines that Arya found. I think Roose was the spy who wrote the letter.
I don’t think he was implying they are the same letter, I think he’s trying to make a point about the letter that spies send, as in she’s holding a letter, and there’s a similar letter on the table.
thanks for all that background, i never thought about that with arya, what an amazing thought.
If you have any new or old theories I'd like to examine, please share. Thanks.
i only read the books after the series started, and didn't fall for them, so i'm not a good source. the alt-shift-x guy has done some theory videos. would be interesting to see whether any of them were backed up by enough series footage for an essay.
Great vid! She was definitely a spy! Yeah, she died at the wedding, but that could have just been Tywin tying up loose ends. Karma!
She wasn't a spy
She 1000% wasn't a spy
A bit of trivia: The actress who played Talisa nee-Maegyr is Oona Chaplin, the Granddaughter of Charlie Chaplin.
Not important to the story line but thought I would mention her. PS: I didn't think she was a spy.
It is obviously not the same letter, so no, I highly doubt she was a spy.
Yes OBVIOUSLY, but he didn’t say that was the same letter, he is making a point as she holds that letter and then shows the letter on Tywin’s table to imply that it’s related.
Damn!
You nailed it again!
You must be close to GRRM, huh?
Or you're an Eideteker!
You made me look up "Eideteker." That's the greatest compliment by far. Thank you.
I'm trying to dig more theories, whether true or not, for new videos. I've read about Jaime knowing the Red Wedding beforehand, but it's too unlikely. If you have any new ideas or recommendations, please share.
Nah bruh, if she was a spy she wouldn't have died at that point cuz she woulda had insight of them being butchered and she would have either been spared or said something that gave us a hint that she knew more than she lead on.. something like "but you said Id be spared". Definitely NOT a spy.
a spy only brings information and recieves none back.
You must not know Tywin
Def IS a spy. Like they’d care about sacrificing her to kill Robb, that was a huge power move.
you're late to the party.
The Lannister Honeypot video was posted a while ago.
🤨
I feel like she may have been a spy but I also think their love was real.
I always thought it was odd that some random woman from Volantis would show up in Oxcross post battle so conveniently.
And the minute she mentioned that the Maester will have everything she needs at the Crag, it’s just like 🤨 wait a minute.
🚩🚩 ROBB HELLO 🚩🚩
🚩🚩PAY ATTENTION 🚩🚩
🚩🚩SHE’S NOT SUPPOSED TO KNOW THAT 🚩🚩