Is This New Cooling-Enhanced Back Cover Mod for the LEGION GO a Worthwhile Upgrade?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2025

Комментарии • 60

  • @TECHOSAUR
    @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад

    LINK AliExpress: s.click.aliexpress.com/e/_DEIKBnN
    LINK AMAZON US: amzn.to/4a2GCcI
    LINK AMAZON UK: amzn.to/3Qx8UVM
    LINK AMAZON DE: amzn.to/44zDvrx
    LINK AMAZON IT: amzn.to/3UNUfrQ
    LINK AMAZON FR: amzn.to/3y8q0Da
    LINK AMAZON ES: amzn.to/4b0CsDs
    If you are interested in buying it, please use those links as they're affiliated and I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
    LEGION GO Playlist: ruclips.net/p/PLg8ANjUNzqfN0uUCjfOQmFXCNulJuFIRr
    If you enjoy my content, PLease give it 👍, Subscribe, & Join the TECHOSAUR Community on Discord here : discord.gg/PXmJY6BP8b
    become a member: ruclips.net/channel/UC-jauq-kZ20FrlnCMkx2gSQjoin
    Pateron: www.patreon.com/TECHOSAUR

  • @meh78336
    @meh78336 6 месяцев назад +5

    I got the back cover and NVMe adapter, and its not bad but has one major shortcoming in my opinion and that is that the NVMe bay is not heatsink friendly to say the least, which given the fact that the LLG performs best with PCIe 4.0 x4 drives, and half decent ones run hot, it could do with a rework. I tried my spare Samsung 980 Pro with heat sink and I was expecting the cover not to fit and had some long thin screws to sort that, but it wont fit in the bay at all as its to wide.
    I ended up screwing it in to the raised back of the bay with some thermal pads underneath in the bay just to give it a level fitting. It now sits exposed but looks fine, and is on there rock solid. It has a nice performance boost as well compared to the original and 2TB upgraded one I had in there as it performs around 50+% faster and is very noticeable on some games like BG3 where the experience is smoother. it does heat up a fair bit and does get hot, but not hot enough to burn, more like holding a hot coffee cup type hot. Its not an ideal solution, but until a third party option comes along that lets me have it in a bay properly, its staying as is as the performance increase is worth it, plus its on there solid and nothing really is exposed as the drive is completely wrapped in the heatsink and the connector is covered. Its also got the advantage of being able to be actively cooled when being used docked as with a USB fan on it, it runs perfectly cool (I'm running the 3DMark storage test on it as I type this and its perfectly cool with the fan on it).
    I cut up an old 200mm fan dust filter and covered all the vents as well to complete the package, and while its not ideal, I am satisfied as its feeling like an upgrade to me.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад

      Thanks for sharing your experience.
      The 980 Pro runs a bit hot from what I know, given its high read/write speeds. It also depends on the controller type.

  • @Backstage_Politician
    @Backstage_Politician 4 месяца назад +3

    If I can suggest putting just a tiniest bit of thermal paste between the processor and the pad before you put the heat sink around the SSD, you'll have better heat dissipation. I know it sounds strange but if you try it, I know that you'll see different results.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  4 месяца назад

      Do you mean to put some thermal paste on top of the installed pad on the Z1 Extreme?

  • @Daburademo
    @Daburademo 8 месяцев назад +21

    This isn't surprising at all. More holes intakes or outakes doesn't means better airflow, it means less air moving per holes so the air is moving slower inside the device which is probably not a good thing. the size, position and number of holes was probably calculated in accordance with the fan's capacity. your are indeed disturbing the intended airflow and dissipation surfaces areas. The engineers probably know what they're doing, and if they've decided not to add more holes, it's probably for a good reason.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад +1

      The Legion Go has really good cooling for the APU. A single fan is able to cool it quite well. However, things aren't going so well for the SSD. I've constantly seen my mine showing critically high temperatures, especially when I install games. Of course, if you use a 2280 drive on this modded one, it's going to be super cool with a heatsink, but there are many users out there who prefer using the one that the Go comes with, a 2242, and using this mod cover with it's extra holes will worsen it for them

    • @hitchey1978
      @hitchey1978 4 месяца назад

      This. So much this. If this was supposed to improve things, then you might as well rip off any coolers off any CPU and open the case. Volumes of fresh air! Yayyyy oh you won’t last long

    • @hitchey1978
      @hitchey1978 4 месяца назад

      Best thing you can do is clean the fan every few months. They get choked

  • @valle5003
    @valle5003 7 месяцев назад +9

    Thank u so much for this. Was about to order this. Saved me money ❤

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  7 месяцев назад +2

      better wait for a well-engineered one that doesn't just have holes randomly, we need materials to have a heat transfer feature more than just holes

  • @francisa7997
    @francisa7997 3 месяца назад +1

    Maybe there will be an improvement if you try to blow air in the back area while using like a mini handheld or desk fan? The back cover design is good maybe we just need a smaller hexagonal hole to prevent big debris from entering.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  3 месяца назад

      I may try it, thanks for the idea. I don’t have anything against the cover itself, but I don’t like the 3D printed material. It’s ruining the nice look of the original Legion Go back cover. I think it's good only for the 2280 SSD installed in that middle slot, but you also need to apply dust mesh to reduce dust and even foreign objects (maybe small insects) from entering. I don’t want to sound grim, but it’s too open for anything to enter 😅

    • @max0r4axor
      @max0r4axor 3 месяца назад

      I used a nylon type screen mesh on the inside

  • @hotwebs
    @hotwebs 17 дней назад +1

    Hi I am using the similar backplate for my legion Go, however the temperature is lower than you full load max 60c+, i think that whether did you turn off the " link state power management", causing this high temperature to the SSD, cause i was turn this off and my SSD temperature was higher upto 80c ++. After that set it back to "Maximum Power Saving" then temperature reduce. I am using the original 2242 SSD without heatsink.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  14 дней назад

      But this might drop your SSD speed, wouldn't it?

  • @meh78336
    @meh78336 7 месяцев назад +2

    It looks like the back cover has thermal pads to connect to different parts of the Go, so it is used for cooling. That's probably why we haven't seen more official 3rd party mods like you get with the Steam deck, as they would need to replicate or have a substitute for that to not get overheating issues. My guess is a 2280 SSD with a heat sink would solve the SSD issue, but something else would be needed for the rest.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  7 месяцев назад +1

      Sure, if you are going to add a 2280 external SSD, this cover is the best option, but for any SSD that will go underneath it, it will be worse. I mean, the vents for the 2242 and 2230 are useless, plus it doesn't look very nice IMHO 😆
      I feel downgrade

  • @mo603
    @mo603 8 месяцев назад +1

    Informative as usual, thanks!

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад

      Thanks.
      I only got it because it’s important for others to know what they’re buying, especially since AliExpress stuff isn’t easily returnable. If you have a 2280 SSD with a heatsink, go for it as it has a hole for the adapter to go in externally, but for other size formats (2230, 2242), it would be terrible. Even I’m using a heatsink and the stock SSD for the Legion Go, which doesn’t have the highest read/write speed.
      If I use my 2230 WD Black SN770m, it will likely fry itself.
      Poking holes in the SSD area is definitely not enough; I’m not claiming to be a thermal engineer, but I believe that plastic isn’t thermally conductive like the metal used on the original. Even the thermal image shows how the original has heat spread over a wider area, while the PETG on the 3D mod cover used is just showing a very hot spot and the surrounding area is unaffected.

  • @atletasedentario2945
    @atletasedentario2945 2 месяца назад

    Solved an important issue, thank you

  • @mistersancho755
    @mistersancho755 7 месяцев назад +1

    Great video, and thank you for the heads up. 💯

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  7 месяцев назад

      Thanks for tuning in, more stuff for the GO!

  • @teachhimself
    @teachhimself 8 месяцев назад +1

    this is hella cool !!

  • @alex_vasconcelos
    @alex_vasconcelos Месяц назад +1

    Excelente vídeo. parabéns

  • @Zenithity
    @Zenithity 3 месяца назад +1

    Did you ever upload the 2280 video?

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  3 месяца назад

      Not yet, I hope to make it soon

  • @gutamihai3285
    @gutamihai3285 6 месяцев назад +1

    a mod with two fan 😊 or a heatsink on that free space

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад

      Will try! Thanks

    • @gutamihai3285
      @gutamihai3285 6 месяцев назад

      @@TECHOSAUR i make this right now, give me an email to send you a video

  • @IIPre
    @IIPre 5 месяцев назад

    did they remove the page? because those links lead to a error page

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  5 месяцев назад

      I can hardly find it on AliExpress, did u manage to find it ?

  • @zeinharis8467
    @zeinharis8467 6 месяцев назад

    Why don't you add a mesh first on the new backplate

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад

      to ensure that the mesh isn't decreasing the airflow, It's better to add mesh because holes are quite big but adding a mesh before testing may change the result

  • @cppctek
    @cppctek 8 месяцев назад +2

    You should re check before and after with nvme temps. Also really is designed for use with a 2280. I use a 2280 + a heatisnk. My max nvme temps are 40c and my average nvme temp while gaming is in the mid 30s. Also my cpu temps during all these test way lower also. Your numbers don’t align with mine so somethings off or your just not optimized as well as you could be

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад +6

      I didn't use a 2280, just the 2242 that comes with the Legion Go and a heatsink. Yes, it makes more sense if you use this mod with a 2280 drive, but with 2230 or 2242, it has worsened SSD temperatures much more than they're already on mine.
      For CPU & GPU, it improved by about 2-4 degrees.
      It has some downsides. First, the fan gets dusty much faster. A mesh filter is an option, but then it might reduce its cooling. We are back to square one, but cleaning frequently solves it.
      I think my results make sense. I repeated it three times. The original back cover has an internal metallic coating. I think it may transfer heat from the SSD hotspot more than a 3D printed plastic one.
      In your case, having a 2280 drive makes it a good mod, especially having a heatsink and all, but for 2230 and 2242 drives that go inside, it will get worse.
      Please check it to confirm this.
      I'll try it with a 2280 NVMe, sure it will be good. I also was interested in trying it with the 2242 that comes with the Legion Go, thinking I was improving it by having those extra air vents, but actually, it's not better at all.
      Our results don't align because we have different drive placements.

  • @cperl79
    @cperl79 7 месяцев назад +2

    Something is wrong with your SSD. I have the older revision of this back panel and my stock SSD tops out at 64c after downloading 125gb game using gigabyte Ethernet

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  7 месяцев назад

      Did u try crystal Disk mark ?

    • @cperl79
      @cperl79 7 месяцев назад

      Yes, that’s what I used

  • @warlockboyburns
    @warlockboyburns Месяц назад +1

    if you need this you probably have dust in your fan that needs cleaning out.

  • @MobileDecay
    @MobileDecay 8 месяцев назад +4

    That's what I thought. A waste of money and time. Lenovo spent a lot of time designing this thing. if it was just as easy as poking a million holes in the back they would've done that and moved on.

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад +2

      It's good if you have the 2280 SSD mounted along with a heatsink. I'll try it out later on. I got an SSD, especially for it, along with the adapter, but for anyone that is going to use a 2242 or 2230 NVMe, it's really going to worsen it. Those air holes aren't going to do any good.
      Plus, if you don't apply a dust filter on top, the fan will get way more dust and you will just need to clean it frequently. Maybe you noticed, but the fan gets dusty quite fast. I cleaned mine three times since I got it in November.
      I appreciate the work done on this mod, but if we want to address the internal SSD temperature, it would take more than just poking some holes like you said. The first thing is having some passive cooling, so you will need thermal engineering going on. I believe third-party companies like JSAUX and HandheldDIY could make it like they did for the Ally,it works well.

    • @4Mike167
      @4Mike167 6 месяцев назад +1

      he uses the backplate wrong...this backplate is not designed for original 2242 SSD but for 2280 SSD which should be put to the slot in the middle of the back plate in the back...this whole video is useless

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад

      But whoever made this cover has included some airflow holes for the internal SSD at the bottom, many would assume that more airflow generally may also improve internal SSD temperature, but it just worsens it.
      sure putting any SSD externally will be good. I'm just pointing out that this cover mod may be bad if u want to put ur SSD in its original position.

  • @shaolin95
    @shaolin95 6 месяцев назад

    This is not right. I got this and my temps easily improved

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад

      where did you install the SSD ?

  • @takeastepoutside
    @takeastepoutside 6 месяцев назад +1

    STAPM by design is a thermal target. You can’t compare temperature with STAPM applied. Move the SSD to the position the backplate is designed for, turn off STAPM, and rerun the tests. This is a hack job of a review lol

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  6 месяцев назад +1

      What do you mean by moving the SSD to the position the black plate is designed for?
      I am using the original Legion Go SSD 2240, not a 2280 drive.
      ur point about STAPM is definitely true, should re-do it

    • @4Mike167
      @4Mike167 6 месяцев назад

      @@TECHOSAUR you are ignorant desperate for content and attention and you just confirmed it with this comment...the backplate is DESIGNED for 2280 SSD in the middle of the backplate...the video is USELESS and only spread misinformation

    • @spikeyboy
      @spikeyboy 6 месяцев назад +1

      Use an adapter to move the SSD to the back plate.

  • @StuartEdgar-l5c
    @StuartEdgar-l5c 4 месяца назад +1

    why do people think they can improve on what cost millions to design! muppets

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  4 месяца назад +1

      I immediately went back to the original one. The appearance alone and build quality are significant downgrades

    • @turtle00-0
      @turtle00-0 4 месяца назад

      Same reason why cars with less electronic devices will outlive newer cars that's loaded with butt massage 3000.
      You can't make money if you make a near indestructible car or device or w.e
      Source: worked on navy planes. multi-million or billion dollars of research and you still end up with subpar design.

  • @ujingan9697
    @ujingan9697 28 дней назад +1

    Waste of time doing modify cover !! Ha ha , you think you are legion Engineer ?????😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

  • @prototype.studio
    @prototype.studio 8 месяцев назад

    differenze inutili. non ha senso comprare questa cover. grazie per iil test fratello

    • @TECHOSAUR
      @TECHOSAUR  8 месяцев назад

      Figurati, lo sto vedendo su Reddit e volevo testare dal punto di vista di qualcuno che usa il drive del Go originale. Onestamente, non credo che sia un buon aggiornamento a meno che tu non abbia un NVMe 2280 da montare, altrimenti potrebbe peggiorare le temperature del drive 2230, 2242 all'interno. Inoltre, la ventola raccoglierà più polvere dati i fori d'aria più grandi, quindi dovrai pulirla più spesso oppure installare un filtro antipolvere.
      La somma che più buchi non significa Wow, i materiali misti all'interno usati in quello originale possono condurre calore meglio del materiale di stampa 3D PETG.
      Se hai drive 2280, non è male anche la temperatura della CPU, GPU secondo poco 2-4 °C. Ma lo trovo esteticamente brutto rispetto all'originale, lol il Go sembra un giocattolo con questa cover 😄