She Was NOT READY For This Charlie Kirk TAKEDOWN!!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 июл 2024
- Get my shirts, tumblers, and more here: autumnwillowcreek.com
Join the Gibson Family to support: geni.us/ChannelMember
Subscribe on Rumble: rumble.com/c/DevinGibson
Enjoyed this video? Join my Locals community for exclusive content at devingibson.locals.com/support
All of my links: linktr.ee/devingibson
Buy Me A Coffee: geni.us/BuyACoffee
Patreon: geni.us/DevinPatreon
PayPal: geni.us/PayPalDevin
CHAPTERS
00:00 Intro
00:19 Charlie Kirk vs Woke Student
06:19 My Thoughts
12:52 Outro
Im a white girl who lost all scholarships to black students, lost a spot in a good school to a black student, i didnt have a father and i worked 3 jobs to pay bills since i was 12 and raised my little brother. Where's my white priviledge?
Amazing! a 12 yr old with 3 jobs! Nice. Illegal to have 1.
In your case it manifested as a sense of personal responsibility... go figure!
No, wait... figuring (math) is racist!🤬
There were three black students in my medical school class who clearly demonstrated they did not belong in that classroom. They received all sorts of extra help that was not available to the White students..
@@Ty-bz7zxJust passing through but the person said they were raising their siblings since 12 years old... Not that they were working at 12, I am sure you just misread.
I mean I'm not saying I agree with the OP completely but you are just wrong broham.
Obviously, your privilege is to have the government destroy the nuclear family.
She's not listening because she's trying to remember all the talking points that she is supposed to parrot.
Yepppp.
She is hearing voices in her head.
That's how communism operates
I'M BLACK....andI I agree with CHARLIE.."ALL LIVES MATTER".....
ME TOO ,I ALSO SEE IN BLACK AND WHITE
It NEVER matters what your skin color is. Everyone has the same opportunities than any other person. Period.
I’m a retired black woman. Born and raised in the south. Live and worked in multiple states. I have never felt afraid to go anywhere in the United States. I have competed for jobs and promotions, with male and female of same and different races. My knowledge and work ethics earned my successes.
Guess you’ve never been near a sundown town ⁉️
Im a white male, and when i was a kid, white people couldn't go in the black neighborhood unless they had a black friend escorting them. And learned that when hanging out with my black friends that if we went to another of his friends' house, the first thing he had to say was he's cool or you would get beat up. Then, when i got to high school my black friends stopped hanging out with me because i am white. Because the other black friends pressured them but guess who the only black kids that did hang out were only the mixed kids because they were shunned too.
@@talleneagle1974 ⁉️ and why do you think that it was like that?
Also what you experienced wasn’t an entire system or government against you‼️ Even today we have black people being killed in mass shouting at grocery stores and churches etc…. Still no protection is offered by the government but Asian and Gay hate crime bills have already been passed
Sure they did? The race card abd female did not help? It works real goid at the veterans hospitals
There are a few areas I’m afraid to go but it’s not because of white people
"Racism is when you might be in danger if you walk into a place where your race isn't welcome."
She just described being a white person in Harlem.
Or Oakland, south central LA, certain neighborhoods in Chicago and Detroit
Even at Rutgers in the early 70’s I was threatened with a beating for walking through a section of the dining hall that a certain minority claimed as “their turf” and off limits to whites.
There’s more sundown towns for whites then blks in today’s America
She described a white person in a lot of city's......
I wonder if these people even know what they are saying, what they are trying to say, and what they thought they wanted to say....
She needs to go back school.
Cannot answer a single question.
Scary thing is, she learned this nonsense in school… our education system needs a MAJOR rework
The problem is she was probably more wise before entering the university! 🫤... She is proof our universities have indoctrinated the young people!
She has to learn to think for herself. She’s trying to quote propaganda and it backfires because reality and logic will always prevail
My mom refused to send any of her four children to liberal colleges. 40 years ago, 🎉us kids did not understand her telling us that we will be brainwashed. I’m almost 60. Thanks Mama! PS my mom is NYC born n bred!
She did not answer a SINGLE question.....sit down child sit down. 🤦🏼♀️
she is so frustrating to listen to. Wasting her money...or our money, or her parents money, whoever put her there.
That’s right
Not only did she not answer questions but she barked all the dissemblance that comes from the democrats and their media fascists!!!!!!!! That is the point, we have to put them down in logic and wisdom to their fascist communist bs to then force them to try and debate the nothing that they have to finally have it acknowledged as the nothing policies that is killing their entirety of human killing idealism!!!!!!!
She is the perfect example of what the modern day school system has filled all of their heads with. That's what the system wants. a bunch of idiots that will just follow anything that they say. Keep them dumb and they won't question us.
Because she doesn’t know the answer and it’s sad to see so many dumb people on campus but doesn’t surprise me at all.
This woman is giving me a headache. DONT SEND YOUR KIDS TO COLLEGE OR THEY MAY WIND UP BRAINWASHED LIKE THIS POOR LADY,😢
She cares a lot!!!!
It starts far earlier than college. My elementary school age daughters are getting it from elementary school and social media. Fortunately for me, they tell me about what they're hearing and ask for my insight.
@@NattyGymBro
That’s great that they talk to you about what’s going on,?!
That is really awesome,?sounds like you’ve raised them right, i know it starts at home but there’s still that worry that some professor will get in their head.
I’m pretty sure she was already dumbed down long before she arrived on that college campus.
Devin....You are a light in a dark place....CHRIST IS KING!!!!!!!!
Devin you are so right. You have my respect! God Bless You!
I'm a black and i approve Charlie's message.
I don’t. It’s disrespectful for someone to be vocally against someone, but now because he sees the mercy is trendy he appropriates it. That’s like someone hating on someone’s chain they got on, but they take it off their so they can shine. It’s disrespectful and it shows he’s not original
@tsczhabybecause he’s presenting himself as someone who’s opposed to BLM and he’s wearing a shirt that says ALM. Do you know how stupid it look if I wore a BLM shirt, while he’s wearing that. If I wore a blm while debating he’d initially look silly because everyone would see what started first and he’s copying my style and yet he claims to be in opposition of my position black lives matter
@tsczhabyHe says foreigners are being put before Americans, if he believes that then he wouldn’t compromise his position because then he’d include foreigners in all lives matter. Just because you say something doesn’t mean it’s true in the real world. History and current events show that black lives don’t matter. Black people are trying to bring attention to that and people who say that are trying to rebut them. BLM doesn’t exclude anyone’s race, they’re just bringing attention to theirs. When Vanessa Guillen, a now deceased Hispanic veteran, went missing for over a month, BLM marched in solidarity with her family to find her. All lives matter and blue lives matter was nowhere to be found. That’s the other thing, it doesn’t take much effort for someone to say all lives matter. You can say all lives matter and not have to think the state of other peoples lives
@tsczhabywhat
When I see user in the user name I call cap 😂😂
She did not answer any questions he asked, she is all over the place with no facts or answers.
They always do that
She keeps saying "overpolicing" except what she means is "profiling", not overpolicing.
She kept going back to her bullshit, marxist blm talking points.
The dumbest are always the loudest and the most redundant. 🤡👍
That's what they all do
I've never gone through anything racial before until this year, as a Jewish woman, I always wore my star of David necklace for decades. But after what happened on Oct 7, I've been dealing with several people, mostly young adults that give me dirty looks, and comment and say things that are Anti-Semitic towards me. And it made me realize just how arrogant this new generation is.
The anti semitism going around now is sickening.
Great preaching brother. Keep it going
I was a single black woman raising 6 children the oldest was 12 and the youngest was around 3 months. Jesus blessed to raise them. I sold home and got a real estate license, worked also at JC Penney sold furniture. My oldest graduated from college with Computer Engineering degree and next graduated from West Texas A & M university, next one has her own business, next one owns a Ranch, the next one has several degrees, graduated from Airforce Academy, became Captain, graduating from N W Kellogg with a Master degree in Leadership and a Major in the SpaceForce. Next one is in college still. I'm giving my Lord Jesus all the glory. He helped me raise them. Their dad is with the Lord.
God bless your family and God bless you.
You are a very strong mother whose devotion is to the Lord; I, too, raised my 5 children with His help. Their father was in prison. I am a Native American. Three earned engineering degrees and two with masters diplomas. They all are working in their choosen fields. Hallelujah to the Almighty!
Hallelujah! To God be the glory!!
What a stunning testimony! GBU sister in Christ!
Sounds like you raised them perfectly. Glad they have a Mom like you!
Years ago I was told to hire four people for a department and three must be black. They did not like it when I said, How about I hire who is the most qualified for the job?
Great idea, I’d feel the same, hire who’s qualified!
Yep 👍
But thats racist, qualifications don't matter, race matters. Wait....race mattering is racist, dammit I just admitted I am racist by saying race is important.
Exactly. I don’t understand why this concept is hard to understand. Why would we not hire based on qualifications?
Aaaaand that's how we got Kamala Harris or AOC
The lack of a father in a Black household came about when the government started paying Black women who had a baby but only if there was no male in the house. Thank you LBJ
AMERICA FIRST AND ONLY
Liberal gaslighting is the actual issue she should be concerned about.
Well said
Amen damnbabygirl.
Totally agree.
She has been indoctrinated and is now one of the Gaslighters...
Based
🔥
She’s brainwashed
Nah! She's just dumb!
She even hates her own race
The MK Ultra is working
She's also stupid
Blm is the new kkk...
Some people will never be happy, their brains keep them oppressed in this beautiful country with so many opportunities.
AMEN TO THAT!
Exactly Devin I'm white Scottish & my mum passed away when I was 26 & my dad's done another never been there I've always wanted God & this past 2 yrs I've watched you pastor jennings & Sam shamoun & I bought a bible 1mth ago & I want to be baptised as I feel that for some strange reason I was overwhelmed by emotions couldn't stopped crying I'd been praying for a few mth but I spoke to god telling him I repent I love him & could he send me a sign he hears me&i felt warm & a weight lifted from my body that felt what I'd been needing for years & I truly belive he answered me ❤ amen
This is America’s future. I never thought we could ever become this stupid
You haven’t seen anything yet, just wait until they have kids.
Thank the school systems and propaganda news for these brainwashed people….it will get worse …sad
I am in my 50's and have seen this coming for a while now. We keep going down that slippery slop.
I'm black. I do not feel like there is a target on my back. Anytime I see law enforcement, I wave. I say hello. I am not afraid of them. Even before being redpilled, I would always just be respectful of my encounters with police. As I've wakened up over the years, I'm even more appreciative of them.
Your individual experience isn’t, representative of the black experience of dealing with law enforcement. According to the Marshall project police dogs were disproportionately black and a lot of these police dog bites are from nonviolent crimes or no crime at all. Do you think black people are treated the same as white people
@chrisallison9151 I never said my experience was the black experience. I'm just stating my experience. I don't think any race can say they have exact similar experiences to one another. I will say this, though, your experience will be similar in the sense that they are good versus bad depending on how you carry yourself.
Fuk police
@@chrisallison9151personally I think the black community does a bad job at raising their children. Rather than teaching them how to behave civilized towards people in authority, they tell them the police, white peoples and the entirety of America is out to kill them.
For the people who try to make an effort, their community tells them to “stop acting white”
Of course not everyone, but it certainly is a cultural issue that needs to be broken.
@@chrisallison9151 Why, because he is trying to be a responsible citizen?...Or is that responsible citizen bit anathema to your thinking? I wish that fella succeeds in everything he wants to achieve...or is that going against your logic. Why isn't he representative of the black experience? It would be all around him. You think he should be like the rest of them to get that experience and feel down trodden, I suppose you think that teaching 'blacks' that negative CRT which makes them more downtrodden, will make them improve their lives. Well it won't..not one iota, Chris. I'm white, but I'm with the unrepresented person you refer to. Or do you think he is a 'goody two shoes' because he 'woke up' to that bullcrap?
Do the crime, and do the time. Not all cops are bad either Chris.
Brother I agree with you 100 percent I divorced 20 years ago and it was 1 of the biggest, worst decisions of my life. My father wasn't in my life and I wasn't a Christian when I got married and divorce so yes I believe in serving God and being married..if I only knew then .God bless you my brother
When your young and stupid and have no experience of buying a house, working a real Job, ect...
Tell me you've been brainwashed without telling me you've brainwashed. I feel bad for these kids. They don't understand how the world works.
They dont understand sh1t.
Imagine her with a degree.
With her logic. Or lack of.
But they sure have memorized the talking points.
She doesn't have to say she's brainwashed...we can all tell!!
I am tired of these naive children
I love you so much my good brother in Christ. God is GOOD ALL the TIME!
Devin you are rock solid brother! Keep preaching the truth! God is good!💪🏻💪🏻🙏🏻💪🏻
That girls parents should be ashamed of her
If they know what she's doing, I'm sure they are.
Lol. This is embarrassing. She is lost in her own confusion. She has yet to give a reasonably intelligent answer to any questions posed to her. She is just rambling on.
I spent my early years, in Cleveland Heights. I has black friends in the neighborhood. In schools, In college, I went to AKRON UNIVERSITY, in AKRON, OHIO. I didn't experience any racism. I had roommates, of every color of the rainbow. I also experienced different Nationalities.
Remember when Oblamo said "Don't take a knife to a gun fight" she obviously didn't get the memo! She didn't even bring a knife.
She would make an amazing democrat politician. Can’t answer a question with relevance
nah, they at least can use words to try and confuse the issue. she is like arguing with a child that makes it so obvious she doesn't understand and repeating what she hears somewhere without any understanding of what she is saying.
Well, in her defense, there is most likely an "ONGOING INVESTIGATION" going on in Her Head! That's always their excuse when they don't want to answer a question. 😂
Somewhere a parent needs to be really embarrassed for what they have produced.
LMAO
I have several friends who sent their perfectly rational kids off to school and they returned just like this girl after one year at a “university.” The brainwashing is real.
God bless you and your family. God bless Texas
I can't wait to meet this great man next month in Seattle
He’s so much smarter than her and she doesn’t recognize it. Embarrassing!
What he is is truly excellent at repartie.
She’s sooooo ignorant it’s just sickening. And she probably got a degree in ignorance
Nah a degree in liberal arts or socialism.
@@keithheinz1724 😂😂right
All she did was to filibuster and present Red-Herring arguments!!
Gender studies
Pray for her.
Amen Devin!! God bless you brother.
During this conversation she succeeded at only one thing: proving how intelligent Charlie Kirk is.
This is the stuff she's fed in college. This is our future, ladies and gentlemen.
She made my head hurt! 😖
Mine too…. And my ears are bleeding…. Lol
She's already learned to filibuster!!
@@ZippedUpKitz 😱🤣
Oh yeah. Mine too.
She flares my fibromyalgia.
As a black woman it’s so offensive for someone who is not black to tell me my struggles 😭 had a conversation with an African who said “Black Americans work harder than whites, I have to work harder than Black Americans”. It’s all about perspective. I’m a hardworking, God fearing, and praying woman that lives on the south side of Chicago and I can assure you that I’m not oppressed. Yes I work hard because I haven’t had certain opportunities like those around me but it was based on circumstances. In high school (i went to a primarily black school) I had friends whose parents were so rich that they had three living rooms that all had their own Christmas trees!! I’m in music school and My Latina friend had rich parents who put her in private lessons and I didn’t have that so as a grown adult I have to work harder than her and it’s people who didn’t have what I have and they have to work harder than me. No matter where you fall on the spectrum you can’t get around working hard.
My mother was a young widow with 4 of us to raise. She busted her butt working at a sewing factory every day. She worked hard as hell to bring us up, and she did a great job. We never wanted for anything, and she had no one to help her out. She never brought men in and out of the house, and she was a beautiful young woman at the time and had plenty interested., if we were ever supposed to have any white privilege, then I never have experienced it in my life. Mama didn’t rely on the government to take care of us either.
It’s so nice to see that this woman hasn’t let education get in the way of her ignorance.
Perfect
😂😂😂
I love this comment. 😂😂😂
Worse. She’s probably been “educated” to believe this.
😂😂😂😂
Charlie Kirk asks a straightforward question but instead of answering him, the student's response for just about every question is, "So the issue is....". Her statistics are "There's about a million of them but I can't give you any specific examples, and I know that they exist because they do exist."
We are all privileged and that’s privileged to be children of our Heavenly Father!
These kids are so frigging brainwashed. My twelve year old daughter has more common sense.
She did NOT answer one question 🫨😵💫 SMH
She couldn’t because any answer she could have given would be wrong.
She dropped her brain a long time ago.
These kids are being taught what to think instead of how to think. A large number just end up like this girl, endlessly repeating random things they've been taught to say without any understanding.
That first girl this is what happens when you think you're ready for a debate because you think you are correct and it sounded good inside your head until you got to the microphone
Love the rant. Keep planting seeds. God bless you.
amen and amen... right on all glory to God Almighty and blessing to Jesus Christ our lord ... amen
Dear Lord, please lift the blinders. I'm so embarrassed for her and can feel the cringe of her "parents."
I’ve never seen such ignorance in my 60 years. I’m afraid for my grandchildren having to grow up in this mentality. The things my 17 yo comes home from school saying is jaw dropping. I have to sit her down and talk to her about reality. 😡
Thanks for talking to your grandchild... You have to show them to see a different way, because the schools aren't doing it nowadays.
She is blessed to have you in her life pushing back against the Marxist indoctrination.
She's studying & trying to get a Degree at UNLV in Card Dealing.
‘A broken wagon makes the most noise’. She’s living proof.
Wow she just spewed the same bs that they have been spouting for years now 🙄🙄 Truly Pathetic.
"Black woman married the government and divorced the men they were once with" ... damnnnnn he brought out the big guns
He nailed it/
It's very common sense, calm down. It's the bare minimum that needs to be discussed. If that throws you, you're going to faint when I tell you (sit down first) that the first slave owner in America was BLACK.
@@smilesandthetwistedmd7608 How had he come to America?
Most don't know their history because it's scrubbed. When I tell people to look up when the King of Spain exiled the jews, watching their head explode at the truth behind Columbus is quite a site to witness.
Literally everything is a lie.
@smilesandthetwistedmd7608
@@d.tr6176 His private jet... wth are you talking about goofy
My daughter is biracial Asian and white.
She had an excellent grade, her dad passed away when she was 7 and now she is in graduate school. Law.
She had so much BS to deal with.
I've was a single mother to 3 and busted my ass trying to take care of my children. Still poor and close to being homeless. Where's my white privilege. This girl did not know what she was talking about
Can you imagine, if nobody would steal, cheat, murder how our world would be
Man I'm glad I found you.. I have been in a emotional hole for months now, from a sudden death of a best friend and just feeling sorry for my self. love the content but most definitely appreciate the word with ur authentic delivery brother.. 😊
Just being in University in north America YOU ARE PRIVILAGED!!!!!! look around the world you have got it the best.. A student told me they were DEVASTATED about the homeless and every night at 2 or 3 in the morning they where playing video games on a 2000 $ computer??? Go back to class talk to me when you pay TAXES...
The struggle is real for her…jumping from topic to topic when she gets debunked
I can hardly believe the ignorance of people.
It’s not ignorance it’s antiwhiteism. Ignorance too, but her logic and thought process comes from the Antiwhite Narrative
Oh I can have a 29-year-old and 19 year old grandsons ,and they are stupidest fools
Their not ignorant! They All know what they are doing!
@@CoolPapaJMagik anti white?? Whites are the ones that has the burden to prove that the society it runs and dominate shall be completely free of racism and inequality. They 've demonstrated for so long to 've the capacity to not grant this. No, no such thing as anti white but a fare request for justice from white people, who are the dominant group and culture in this nation.
@@RBLACKPEARL7 well, if they’re not ignorant, then they’re fools
Charlie educates these college students in 10 minutes vs professors who teach them in 4 years. Go Charlie
I couldn’t said it better myself! You’re hitting the nail on the head every time! Good job you guys are awesome! I like how Charlie keeps his cool listening to all that blather. I can’t say it enough,good job!!!!!!!!
Someone never was told, "Wait until your dad gets home"... marrying the government keeps you in lower income rather than working hard and getting it on your own!!
When polled if police presence should be decreased in black neighborhoods, blacks overwhelmingly votes against it.
Which makes no sense because when something does happen, they don't want to talk to the cops and they didn't see anything. They want their neighborhoods to be safe but expect the cops to do everything instead of them helping the cops to help them.
How is more crime the result of over policing? If there is over policing there should be less crime. If she is referring to getting arrested after the commission of a crime it has nothing to do with the reason the crime was committed to start with. Since it took place as the initial act. She makes no sense.
At 17 my brother was driving down the road. A cop pulled him over, pulled him through his driver side window because he thought his orange soda was a beer.
She doesnt know what shes talking about at all.
I don't know why people only focus on black people all lives go through hardship doesn't matter what race your in
Honestly, it's ridiculous 🙄
Because they're really grifters.
I'm white, I was on the lunch card system in school, my parents got food stamps, I grew up working side by side with migrant workers my whole life, we're all in the same orchard, baby...
You speak very well, and make some really good points. Congratulations for you overcoming your challenges.
I'm white and grew up poor. No running water or phone. Took an old car to catch the bus to school. Summer time you bathed in the creek. Outhouse and wood stove. I've also been discriminated against because I'm smaller than most people. Stop being a victim and be a survivor. God Bless and protect us from the those who are decided. Amen.
Decided? 'Deluded', maybe?
@d.tr6176 I think that's what he meant. Just a typo. Thank you for clarification.
You too? We use to walk to school, 2 miles at least, through the woods every day for three years. Long enough the wildlife knew us on a first name basis! Not a joke, but funny at the same time.
And yet even from half a world away I can see you have heart.
I'm a black and I feel for you bruh.
Poor little girl is trying so hard to sound irrelevant.
Oh well, NEXT!?
Who else felt lethargic and dumb listening to that delusional Bruno Mars doppelganger?
WOW! Beautiful message, my man that was on point. America First..
It is derogatory to black people to say black people deserve something because of their skin color.
Boy she must have read the Liberal playbook because she hit All the talking points,All of them!
Oh no, there are MANY more. She didn't hit on gender ideology or climate alarmism.
Thank you Devin for your testimony! I touched my heart to hear the place you made for God in your life!
How do these student come up with an argument without the facts??? This is ridiculous ….
The age to be considered an "adult" needs to be over 30.
Children need more life experience to be an adult.
I understand why you say that, but I believe the opposite: parents should be teaching their kids to be responsible, accountable, how to reason and think logically, the way they used to, so they can grow up to be functioning, responsible, independent adults instead infantile, man & woman-babies.
She still believes she's right, hasn't changed her mind at all and she gets to go vote. I'm so glad the Elecroral College is in place. The Fact that everyone lost their mind when they found out that's how voting worked when Trump got elected iver Hillaty is exactly why it's in place.
She hasn’t changed her mind because she’s NOT LISTENING! She just thinks she’s right.
Wonderful. Keep preaching. Amen!
Charlie is correct. I retired from the Juvenile Detention field and most criminals don’t have strong father figures in their homes. I’ve had more trouble with the parents than the children.
She did a lot of talking but said absolutely nothing! She just echoed liberal talking points or changed the subject entirely to avoid answering the questions! When confronted, deflect, deflect, deflect!
I’m biracial and I approve Charlie’s message
How can you be biracial if we’re all from the same great great great great. .. …………………………. grandmother? Maybe you have a lighter or darker color skin that’s a shading issue. 😊
@@roberttrough6439 I say for sake of those who keep track or geographical locations. However I’m a new creature in Christ where there is no difference between Jew or Greek. The same Lord who is over all is rich unto ALL who call upon the name of the Lord. ❤️
@@MC-bp1dm Amen. We are all the same. Amen
You need to speak in a stadium! Amen!
Tremendous to see you witness this way. I have to say, I feel like this is something I needed.
Nobody is ready for a Charlie Kirk takedown....he is so good at it. If they didn't want to be taken down, they shouldn't come out with dumb questions and statements.
We need to get education back in the school system this is sad and embarrassing
IN-DOC-TRIN-ATED! I can personally point to TWO occasions when "equal opportunity" prevented me (a white person) from being hired for a position I was fully qualified for (I was already working as a contractor in the position). I was told that my present supervisor had to interview me because I had applied, but he couldn't hire me because the position was an "equal opportunity" position. A totally unqualified black college grad was eventually hired into that spot. He was so incompetent he got passed from one group to another for three years, because he could never perform the job he was hired to do. The irony here is: my direct supervisor at the time was himself black, and arguably one of the best managers I have ever worked under in my 45+ year career.
They are hypnotized. Impossible to talk to them. You need to interrupt their pattern.
Her kind of thinking and attitude hurts the people she claims she's saving.
Oh sooo true!
As a black American my heart ❤️ goes out to my white brothers & sisters for the clear discrimination against them & black Americans we have our rights & nobody is stopping black Americans from being successful black Americans need JESUS CHRIST like everybody else