My Trans Twitter Spat With J.K Rowling - Caolan Robertson
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июл 2024
- Buy gold and earn interest on it! monetary-metals.com/triggerno...
💥Join us on our Journey to 1 Million Subscribers💥
Caolan Robertson is a filmmaker and journalist who co-founded Byline TV and directed films such as ‘Betrayed: The Truth About Brexit’ and ‘Under Deadly Skies: Ukraine's Eastern Front’ (watch on Amazon: www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0CGYFFT89). He was very recently embroiled in a heavily-publicised fracas involving trans activist India Willoughby and JK Rowling.
Caolan on X/Twitter: / caolanrob
#politics #media #interview
SPONSOR: Shopify - sign up for a £1 per month trial at www.shopify.co.uk/trigger/
Join our exclusive TRIGGERnometry community on Locals! triggernometry.locals.com/
OR Support TRIGGERnometry Here:
Bitcoin: bc1qm6vvhduc6s3rvy8u76sllmrfpynfv94qw8p8d5
Music by: Music by: Xentric | info@xentricapc.com | www.xentricapc.com/ RUclips: @xentricapc
Buy Merch Here:
www.triggerpod.co.uk/shop/
Advertise on TRIGGERnometry:
marketing@triggerpod.co.uk
Join the Mailing List:
www.triggerpod.co.uk/#mailing...
Find TRIGGERnometry on Social Media:
/ triggerpod
/ triggerpod
/ triggerpod
About TRIGGERnometry:
Stand-up comedians Konstantin Kisin (@konstantinkisin) and Francis Foster (@francisjfoster) make sense of politics, economics, free speech, AI, drug policy and WW3 with the help of presidential advisors, renowned economists, award-winning journalists, controversial writers, leading scientists and notorious comedians.
00:00 Introduction
00:39 Why Caolan Platformed India
01:43 India’s Accusation of JK Rowling
03:16 JK Rowling’s Response
05:04 Caolan Insulting JK
06:27 Caolan's Apology and JK's Response
09:53 Taking a Break From Media
16:06 The Delusion of Pronouns
19:34 Sponsor Message: Monetary Metals
21:28 Politics Has Become Toxic
26:19 Shouldn’t We Just Be Polite?
30:19 Why Caolan Left Byline TV
35:01 The Left’s Double Standards
38:09 Who Is Propagating This?
40:46 Caolan’s Move to the Left
44:25 Sponsor Message: Shopify
46:38 Strengths & Pitfalls of the Right
50:12 We Need Investigative Journalism
58:09 The Power of Genuine Apology
1:00:30 What’s the One Thing We’re Not Talking About?
LOL LOL LOL This is brilliant! He thinks JK is "done with all this!" and has "had enough!" Listen mate...... JK is JUST getting started and we are ALL standing RIGHT BEHIND her.
Only in the Trans issue. Or have you forgotten that outside of that she is a rather unpleasant feminist…? 🤔
@@andrewmontague9682 examples? Genuine question.
JK behaviour reminds me of my manipulative mom, who was moderate all her life, and then derailed in her 60s.
JK is just a manipulative, excentric matriarch who finds pleasure in controlling the narrative.
She should spend that energy in writing books, where she actually can control the narrative, lmao
too right!
@@andrewmontague9682You mean outside of the trans issue she’s a philanthropist who donates extensively to research into neurological conditions like MS and Alzheimer’s? And of course you knew that her personal charity, Lumos, is dedicated to getting kids out of orphanages and into families. And that she has given away so much of her wealth that she lost her billionaire status. Right?
I wish people would stop using the term 'misgendered' for using the right pronouns. The person doing the misgendering is the person pretending to be the other sex.
Well said! It's another example of the hijacking of language (the most powerful of tools) to distort truth and reality
Or as Kathleen Stock puts it, "misgendering is really just accurately sexing".
You mean the right pronouns to you. I use pronouns on how I see someone, not on how you do
What about transsexuals who get the pronoun that’s opposite sex without asking though…? 🤡 If they get to ‘pick their pronoun’ anyone can!
@@KM-tx7mn🤦🏻♂️
He brings up Blaire White but Blaire doesn't claim to be a woman. Blaire claims to be a transwoman. Blaire knows there is a difference between women and transwomen and has even said transwomen are a category of men. Blaire and India are not the same in their beliefs or ways of thinking.
So you'll call Blaire she/her then, right?
@@erikawilson9954Yes I will respect the man that is named Blair white by calling that man she. That is a personal preference not something anyone has forced me to do. India is a man I call he. Because he demands I call him she.
@erikawilson9954 yep. Blaire isn't trying to force herself into women's spaces or sports. She's not trying to dominate women by forcing herself upon them, whether it be by accessing their spaces or controlling their words.
She's also aware that she is a transwoman, not a woman. She's respects women and their right to their own spaces, so I will respect her by addressing her how she desires.
There are actual trans people that exist like Blaire, and then there are misogynists and predators who are using trangenderism to gain access to women and their spaces. Blaire is the former. Others today are the latter, and people know them by their behavior and demands.
@@MamaMOB I personally agree with you. I'd like to think that most of the people watching this video felt that way, but I'm not sure they do. When I hear Konstantin pushing back so hard on Caolan for refusing to actively call India he/him, it feels weird. I've been trying to extend people the benefit of the doubt, but increasingly it feels like people who seem reasonable about these issues actually just find trans people disgusting and want them to go away, and don't actually want to compromise or figure out how we can all live together respectfully.
@@LadyAmalthea0615 I think what you say is totally reasonable. I'm very worried, though, about this trend of treating trans people as a block as misogynists, narccisists and predators because of a few cherry picked TikTok weirdos, when in reality I suspect most trans women are far closer to Blaire and just want to live their lives and present themselves the way they want.
Get JK Rowling on the show.
Yes! JKR is so much more intelligent and brave than this cowardly, little baby.
That's gonna happen, these guys are single handely saving the U.K.s opinion journalism. She's crazy if she doesn't.
I doubt if she would, somehow.
@@sueedwards9334 she might, these guys aren't retarded?
They couldn't get her behind the show. Or under it. With a shovel.
Nothing says Progressive like calling women the C word for holding opposing political views.
Nothing says progressive, like inserting identity politics to create a protected class rather than an equal one. Would a man be able to handle the insult better than a woman, in your eyes?
@@SWINDYPANTS90 would you call your mother that word? if not, not calling anyone elses mother it is probably a good plan. And ive worked on Scottish building sites, ive been called seven shades of the C word before ive had my breakfast every morning, so aye, they probably could handle it better in my eyes.
@@davekenny8774 It's not misogynistic to call a woman a c*nt. Some people simply are c*nts, including women.
@@SWINDYPANTS90 we aren't the same women are different and can't handle the freedom they said they wanted.
It isn't a """"view"""", this is a male. It's a fact. Views are for subjective opinions.
My daughter just returned home from the hospital for a severe bout of endometriosis, a debilitating female issue for which no one would wish for. Trans females are telling females that we can’t gatekeep menstruation. It’s completely unacceptable and out of hand. It shows how insane this ideology has become. The ER doctor said this issue that impacts approximately 10% of women of menstruation age. Funding is meanwhile filtered away from this debilitating female issue to people who feel like they are in the wrong body. Women and women’s issues are being swept under the rug for the sake of people’s feelings, and enough is enough.
You know that famous saying: "First they came for the.... and I did nothing. Then they came for me."
I'm sorry they're coming for you but most of my friends are already dead.
enough is enough
Lovely...EMPTY...words
The medical profession went right from totally ignoring women’s medical issues to now assigning those issues to men, while still ignoring them in women. It’s very affirming to treat a man for menstrual disorders. Meanwhile women who have actual vaginas and actual menstrual issues are called right wing for even mentioning the word women.
Females can't gate keep menstruation that speaks volumes to me. That's the most ludicrous statement I've ever heard. They are hurting females in so many ways but for research to be channelled into trans research instead of women's specific health issues is appalling
Endometriosis effects so many women I know. Research seems to be grossly underfunded. Hope your daughter will see that change soon.
No matter what India thinks, India has to get an annual prostate exam. Facts don’t care about one’s delusions.
😂😂😂
Yeah, her delusion includes that women can have penises and prostate, and men can have ovaries, uterus and vagina. We have doctors, real medical doctors in the United States, who refused to say pregnant. People are women. These are gynecologist obstetricians, who have been on the Senate floor being interviewed by our politicians, and cannot define what a woman is. When asked if only women can get pregnant right? The answer was no because trans men can also get pregnant. When asked if trans women are real women we have politicians who have answered yes. We have politicians fighting to allow biological males with intact penises the right to go into teenage girls, locker rooms and Andress with them in there and watch those girls and dress if any of the girls complain, they are called bigots and if they speak of trauma and fear over being sexually assaulted and or raped, they’re called bigots trans phobic. We have politicians refusing to protect women, AOC, Kamala Harris, Nancy Pelosi, Hillary Clinton, President Biden, our telling biological women that if they are afraid to get undressed in the locker room in front of a biological male, that they are deplorable, trans phobic, and they usually throw in white supremacist for some reason. They are fighting to take away title nine from girls and women’s sports so that biological men can compete against them, take their trophies, take their scholarships, take their place in a sport that they have devoted their entire lives, too. Our president and vice president are actively Trying to put women in danger.
I’ve heard President Biden, and vice president Harris preach about how they want to protect women’s “healthcare “ or the woman’s right to choose, and they go on about women and allowing women the freedom to make their choices with their bodies. Well, at the same time they’re giving a woman who’s been raped the right to have an abortion. They’re also forcing her to go in the locker room with her rapist and change while he watches her and everybody’s just OK with this.
Well not annual every 3 to 5 years and age the age of 50. But it’s important!!! Get you self check lads, especially if you’ve got family history of it.
And if his left arm starts tingling he's having a heart attack. For me, a woman, it would be indigestion.
@@mrfr87well he'll never have to have a vaginal exam so there's that. Women are supposed to have at least one of those every year or two.
Rowling is a heroine. She's willing to defend her rational views to the courts- and others' rights in solidarity. Full support.
more importantly she is an eye wateringly wealthy heroine which gives her bottomless resources to fight as long and hard as she cares to...very few other people could march through the courts so untroubled...which makes her an incredibly powerful advocate in this incredibly important issue...
This guy is a mentally ill con artist?
The fact that people are even arguing about the most basic laws of nature and biology just shows how degenerate this world has become. 😂😂😂😂
Who do you think is arguing about basic biology. You know that sex and gender are different, right? Or are you a buffoon commenting about something you know nothing about?
There's no argument at all !!! Its a case of the VAST majority who know that men are men and women are women, and then the other tiny minority of deluded halfwits.
Meanwhile globalists, behind the smokescreen, continue to drain the public tax coffers of the world into their own private bank accounts, while everyone argues about this BS.
Translation: the fact that people think about the topic with nuance instead of immediately accepting their intuition as absolute truth makes me feel weird, and instead of trying to genuinely understand opposing viewpoints, I'm just gonna assert that my position is a "law of biology" (despite the fact that most biologists disagree with me), and dismiss everybody who thinks differently to me as a degenerate (I'm rational, by the way)
@@walterkronkitesleftshoe6684Ah so the vast majority of people agree with you on the trans debate, do they? Do you have any statistics indicating that this is the case? Or are you just asserting it? I mean, even if 99.99999% of the world agreed with you, that wouldn't make your position correct. This is just a textbook appeal to popularity.
Holey Eternal Omnipresent Greetingz cuzinz 🌠👋😎👍
Imagine calling the cops because someone said something you didn't like.
Who is more likely to do that, men or wmn?
@@OrwellsHousecatfragile people who can't handle facts which come in all sexes
@@OrwellsHousecatTrans folks
@@dRoscoAZ trns men or trns wmn?
@@OrwellsHousecat both
1:10 Called him a man.
Yep, Rowling called HIM a man. Nice to see Caolan on board with accurate gendering.
Exactly 😂 I thought I was the only one who noticed.
@@EhthrI noticed too. I busted out laughing when I heard it. The subconscious mind is amazing.
Thought I was going mad there haha!
Hahahahaha 😂
You can paint stripes on a horse but it will never be a zebra.... You can call it a zebra, but it will always be a horse.
I am a woman. If someone repeatedly called me a man, I'd think they're a bit silly, I'd probably laugh at it at first, I might think the joke is a bit old and get annoyed after a while, but I'd never feel the need to report them to the police or make a big deal out of it. It wouldn't influence my life one bit, outside of thinking that person is ridiculous and probably not interacting with them much... Maybe it's because I don't need to prove my womanhood to anyone. If someone is a woman, this is simply a non-issue
Damn, mic drop!
You don’t have a man’s aggression, because you actually are a woman
As a female with a relatively deep voice I've been called sir over the phone since I was 12. It's never bothered me.
You have that resilience because your entire self-image doesn’t depend upon believing that you have convinced eight billion other people to see something other than what they actually see. It’s much healthier your way.
An excellent point Sir!
This guy is a snake
I don’t believe a word he says
It sounds like he’s been fired and is fishing for a new job and potentially a new audience
He is part of the vitriolic rainbow mafia and couldnt help acting like it when put under pressure.
I knew nothing about him so thought I would give him the benefit of the doubt.... then I searched his name in YT and wow. Ye this guy clearly will just say or do anything so any semblance of fame, its actually embarrassing:
ruclips.net/video/sukBuPx-n_0/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/V-bxdFZJ8og/видео.html
And his contract probably has a clause that says he can't work for a rival or same contacts for six months afterwards
@@OrwellsHousecat I think you’re probably spot on there. I don’t buy his “I’m logging off for 6 months because Twitter” speech.
exactly he's no more a journalist than I am a rocket scientist. He's just another woke lefty crying victim.
The headline was that JK could be arrested. That’s where he lacked journalistic integrity because she was never at risk of being arrested. He comes across as incredibly immature and wanting to be a victim. It’s pathetic. He knew what he was doing. And JK is not at breaking point. She’s on fire.
My thoughts exactly!
I suspect she’s almost hoping to be arrested so she can challenge the whole thing in court. She may realize that she’s the perfect person to do this as she has the resources to fight this to the highest levels.
She is a hero what we need is people with the power to stand up for us.
@@YegRonI have thought this myself too.
Well said...he elevated something that was nothing and put it on the map, at Rowling's expense.
Misgendered? No. He is a man and JK called him what he his. You can live in a fantasy all you want, I won't and you can't make me.
So good that Kellie-Jay Keen was able to educate the Trig team about pronouns!! She enabled them to open the eyes of this ignorant young man.
Who actually cares what this guy thinks?
Good question
🌠😎👍
You’re the one who clicked on the video, so…
Clicking yes, commenting yes, watching no. So..@@Noplayster13
Apparently millions of people as well as you since you are here. Cheers brother.
Well I am offended by India calling himself a woman, but no that doesn’t count, but oh how dare we offend India.
Maybe we could really offend 'her' by calling 'her' Pakistan?
As an Indian I’m offended she uses my country name
As a gay dude we need an alphabetic divorce, because being bound together in the same acronym makes it look like all the other letters are co-signing on what the T is doing.
I've 2 boys aged 12 & 9 - if either were gay it wouldn't change how I feel about them. Who they love is who they love - if either come and said they were a girl I'd be really worried. Not because I'm anti trans it's because my worry would be " are they really? " I can't help but think a lot of these kids are just gay kids been pushed into the trans bracket! Does this make sense?
Agree 100% #notmyalphabet
Exactly, lesbians & homosexuals need to exit the Alphabet people, they are bringing you down....😢
@@garymoore2810 Yes, this is very personal for my boyfriend. He wanted to be a girl throughout his childhood. This went away as he went through puberty. He’s very aware that if he had just been born 10 years later he wouldn’t have his penis right now
But that implies all gay people are a hivemind, when we're clearly not. I mean, does any straight person really see the LGBT acronym and thinks all gay people think the same thing about the "T"? I doubt it. Just like how we don't assume all straight people think the same thing about any issue. Let's get some perspective here!
It’s a rights issue….. Women’s rights versus entitled men wanting to usurp women’s rights.
It’s not “entitled men” .. it’s neomarxists pushing trans ideology. Dont put this on “men.” Men have nothing to do with this gender insanity, men want it to end asap.
This young man is so fast to divest, change sides, retreat, disengage and most of all avoid commitment and responsibility… so afraid, so very afraid.
I get that sense aswel
What do you base your observation on?
The modern man’s adopted feminine personality trait of always seeking acceptance and validation. Leading to a principled backbone of wet toilet paper.
@@itsmyytaccount8498 He's apologetic to both sides. He should be a politician, not a journalist.
As soon as he mentioned working for Tommy Robinson and creating intentionally inflammatory content on his behalf, I realised he’s a hypocrite who can’t handle being on the receiving end of what he gives.
Also, if he can switch sides between extremes so easily, he’s a weasel.
@@AaBb-id1dm He made malicious lies to try and destroy Rommy Tobinsons life (yet further) and destroy the company they worked for (Rebel News), thankfully Rommy Tobinson recorded evidence that proved that Caolin lied and so could defend himself and Rebel News. The guy is a nasty piece of work and cannot be trusted.!
"It was overwhelming, I've never been at the center of a culture debate..."
He experienced less than 1% of what Rowling deals with (and credit to him for acknowledging this). Regardless of whether you agree with her or not, the treatment of Rowling by trans rights activists has been absolutely deplorable, I completely understand her lashing out. Trans Rights Activists have acted like feral animals in regards to Rowling and anyone else who doesn't 100% support their views. They are not worth engaging with.
India is a level beyond pathetic to be calling the police for that. How self-absorbed can one be? I hope the police didn't entertain this idiocy.
Narcissism is quite a common trait in autogynephiles
Literally called India ‘him’ within the first few minutes then claims they’ve never misgendered.. this boy is confused..
If you don’t like what someone says, block them. If you don’t like a movie, don’t watch it. If you don’t like a company, don’t buy their products. None of this is a “crime”. Freedom of thought and speech is more important than you being offended. Right or left, none have the right to dictate how anyone should think or speak.
Preach 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Exactly. And that goes for TRAs as well as TERFs. Stop policing others language!
@@Accountdeactivated_1986 The creation of whole new acronyms such as the TERF's that you just used is literally playing their obnoxious game which has an end goal of Communism. Dictating, controlling and policing peoples speech is one of the ways to get to their goal, so unless you want to play into their hands, or are one of them then I strongly and politely suggest that you do not use ANY of their terminology such as TERF or TRA.!
Totally agree 💯
The problem is deeper than speech though.
The problem is that a small section of society with a mental health issue is bullying the rest of society into acting as if denying that men or women are biologically different is the treatment for them- insane.
India is a fella though.
A fella called Jonathon.
Google gender
@@joshuataylor3550 Google chromosomes
@@joshuataylor3550Google ‘human biology!
Yeah, he used to be a nice bloke, he's gone a bit off since he started pretending to be a bird.
KK’s body language is speaking volumes. He’s not buying the explanations.
The more he talks the worse he sounds, I think he’s a narcissist not paranoid. 6 months isn’t going to change anything 😂
"My birth certificate says I'm female"
Yeah, because you had it edited. What did it say when you were born? That's like referencing a book that you wrote.
It's madness that people can change their birth certificate. It's basically state sponsored fraud.
Allowing people to change their birth certificate is basically S-T-A-T-E S-P-O-N-S-O-R-E-D F-R-A-UD and needs to stop.
I've never understood why and how birth certificates can be altered.
@@herbertlongfellow7702because it would be considered transphobic to not let someone change it, no doubt.
At some point this was okayed by Parliament.
Just a reminder that this bloke and Gary Willoghby would gladly send you to jail for the rest of your life for "being mean"
✔️
And they get to decide what "being mean" is
Blaire white is not out of her tiny mind she says she is a trans woman the ladyboys say they arent women .
"I AM A WOMAN!!!!!!!" - Joffrey Willoughby
"Anyone who must inform your of what their gender actually is probably doesn't have the chromosomes to match" - Tywin Lannister, probably.
My daughter is 9. She has started going to the toilet alone (without her mother). I'm talking about public restrooms, like in service stations. I am relieved to know that she is not going to a toilet that she has to share with biological men. And 99% of all fathers and mothers will agree with me that a visit to the toilet must be safe for woman and especially for young girls. There is more than one side to this coin.
I think you can increase that to 100% father's and mothers.
@@jimhallinsn1023unless it’s James O’Brien. I’ve just watched of him him asking Kellie Jay Keen why she would have a problem if he was getting changed next to her in a changing room if there was a curtain between them 😱
I’m a man and I’d be a bit wary coz I find him a creep, he always looks so dirty
we were recently on a road trip and every time my 7yo girl had to go to the bathroom, I'm there with her, watching like a hawk, scanning all the ppl in the restroom! I'll protect her with my life and if I ever see a man in a womans bathroom especially while my daughter is in there, you bet your ass I'll make you leave right then and there. try me!
What do you mean? Men can now use pretty much any toilet that they like, because bullying from the trans lobby has made people afraid to kick them out of female-only spaces. Thus, I wouldn't be so sure that your daughter is safe in women-only toilets or changing rooms.
@@MMChoza I'm not transgender myself, but I've been homeless while suffering from undiagnosed coeliac disease. Among other things, this causes severe diarrhoea. At times I found my self at public toilets where the men's cubicles were full as well as the disabled or even not having the disabled facility. The only option then is either call out to the female toilets "is anyone in there" plead my case or find a female to check, then go in, or shit myself. Living in constant fear of this you don't stray far from a toilet, but you can't always depend on a vacant men's cubicle.
On another occasion I was crossing the parklands and found a convenient pair of toilet blocks set up for an adjacent visiting circus. I needed to go and as I approached I noticed what I thought was a woman go into the further block. I was a bit tipsy and assumed that the closer block must be the men's. The signage wasn't so obvious and I assumed (falsely) that I was going into the men's. Halfway through my deed the circus intermission began and the toilets got inundated with female voices. I waited for about another 20 minutes before it all went quite to escape.
Sometimes a guy in a ladies loo is just making an innocent mistake, or has an emergency to deal with. Just saying is all.
JK Rowling is nowhere near ‘done with this’
I would just like everybody to know that as a biological woman if anybody wants to call me a man I promise I won’t call the police. Anybody want to guess why?
because you’re not a totalitarian mentalist
@@emmabrooker166 or because you know the police wouldn't give a $%**£ , because you're just a woman.
Sex is immutable. There are two sexes. Allowing a man to say he is a woman should be a crime.
Fraud is a crime…. And this is pure fraud.
Don't be ridiculous.
Maybe not a crime but certainly delusional, out of touch with reality and should be mentally assessed by being held for a few days for psychiatric evaluation.
Nothing J K stated was false.
This guy is a mentally ill con artist?
There is a difference from callling a Black or Asian person a racist slur versus telling a Trans person what they really are.
If you wish to use a racist slur then so what!
Point one: What you say is true.
Point two: Even a slur should not have you literally arrested and facing prison time.
Anyone remember sticks and stones? No? Oh, well...
And yet when Whyte's are vilified that's not hate speech. So all racial slurs should be permitted.
IW probably doesn't see that as a difference because IW probably does think of N-word & P-words are 'true, but we've decided to pretend otherwise', hence IW says they're the same thing as IW's situation
Especially as it can easily be done accidentally
"I am a woman, I've been through everything that's required *list of things not required to be a woman*"
What about menstruation?
Or just being born female. That might help a whole lot more.
There are exactly zero steps to "become" a woman. You either are, or you are not.
Menopause
Does he have vaginal smear tests every 3-5 years?
Wait until you find out some women can be born with medical conditions that don't allow them to menstruate. According to your 'logic', they wouldn't be women either
Calling a trans person "them" is not being neutral in their eyes because you're making the decision not to bow to their will. This is the biggest problem I have with trans. They can't be happy unless everyone else goes out of their way for them. Well too bad. I'd say the same thing I tell my kids - you can't control what others say or do, so all you can do is become resilient so that they don't bother you. It's sad that this is a new lesson for grown adults. Calling the police on someone who "misgenders" you is almost as insane as anyone taking that seriously.
... especially when so called 'misgendering' is actually only stating a scientific factual truth...
He’s boring whoever he is. He speaks with an apathetic self victimized tone.
Yea, not sure if they skipped the part where they introduce themselves and explain who they are or if I just missed it. Am watching to see what my beloved (Hallowed be her name) JK Rowling's been up to!
What are you taking about?
1:09 This complete pillock literally did the thing he was admonishing J.K. Rowling for doing. What a CLINT.
This guy is a complete fool
He sounds like a baby.
He’s a product of his times… I give him credit for trying to do a good job, but his raising is too ingrained.
A fool has his uses for the leftist scumbag media.
@@spaceknight793 I think that is part of the problem now...giving them credit. I try to be charitable and kind, but I do wonder the harm it is doing with some people (especially in the participation trophy generation).
@@spaceknight793he’s flip flopped his politics for years depending on what he thinks will make him more money. JKR was right - he’s a grifter.
Caolan Robertson is a naive, ill informed individual who meddled in an issue he had no business interfering in. He’s demonstrably ill equipped to be doing anything too serious until he’s done more work on educating himself. He has no business starting anything new until he does this work.
The guest worked for Rebel News some years ago. He was nothing but trouble. Ezra finally paid him money to just go away.
Imagine getting so emotionally wrought on Twitter you call the cops😂😂
Guys, the WPATH files is a much more worthy subject of an interview than this.
Geneviene Gluck would be an interesting person to interview.
Journalists do background research and report BOTH sides of an issue, giving each equal weight and let their viewers draw conclusions from the evidence. This man is not a journalist as he failed to do background research and only presented one side of an argument, quite literally. He then had the temerity to jump in at the deep end and defend this behaviour on Twitter, still not understanding the full issue. And then further goes on to say that other media outlets aren't doing "real journalism". This just reads as lazy arrogance, to be honest.
Time to stop all this trans nonsense.
Within 20 seconds of this video Caolan misgendered India Willoughby (not that I care). We live in a bizarro world.
I know right! Just shows the pronouns thing is so hard to keep up even if you want to.
I have been trying to listen to the arguments...I haven't understood anything. Am I the only one?
What I have gleaned from this:
Some transperson claims to be a woman, a woman says that person isn't...the Scottish law says that if we suggest that a man isn't a woman it is hate crime...rapists say they are women and end up in women's prisons and this guy is trying to make a bit of cash.
Have I got it right?
He also saying that people on the internet are too crazy..nobody is honest and ...he needs a holiday
Now you're up to speed
@@sergiufort9984thank you. I thought as much. cheers
“I’d rather be rude than a fvcking liar.” Magdalen Berns
❤❤❤❤❤
Seems like this guy is extraordinarily naive and clearly very new to this debate. The truth has to be spoken, otherwise you become just the thin end of the wedge, leading to the big lie. It’s the hottest topic, because misogyny is endemic in our society. This man is VERY NAIVE!
All he's done is moan about being called out by JKR. He's not expressed any interest in or understanding of the actual issues that caused that to happen. Then he bangs on about what a great guy and journalist he thinks he is. It's all surface bollocks. "Them" as a neutral term not taking sides - he hasn't grasped, or tried to grasp the actual issues.
Such a mixed-up pseudo-"conversation" with such a mixed-up guy is a waste of everyone's time.
Thanks in advance. Not gonna waste brain cells watching this interview. Cheers!
Maybe we should become even more aware of who and how the millions of views on tik tok are made.....Frustated nobodies who have unrestricted access to publicity.....against confirmed values like J K Rowling. Unortunately, Triggernometry have given them airtime 😢
Same@@highschoolhockeyminnesota
@@highschoolhockeyminnesota Yes, best to decide if a video is worth watching based on a random youtube comment. Hey at least you saved a few brain cells for something else - best of luck with it. I hope no-one suggests you don't bother.
Curious why you think this conversation is; not a real conversation nor useful to watch?
Sounds like you are trying to shut someone down for having a different viewpoint to you when you could instead just hit dislike and move on.
He wanted to be very respectful towards a trans person, but had no problem disrespecting Eastern Europeans.
Good for KK for holding his feet to the fire. By using "they," etc., you are taking a side - you are accepting the lie.
I was never a fan of her until all this shit started against her.
She is the very model of grace.
Peace.
secondeded
The conversation about Blair white looking like a pretty woman is exactly JK Rowling’s point. Women can be all different levels of ‘prettiness’ they are still 100% women.
Too many men are like "So long as s/he looks like something I can masterbate to -- I don't see the problem."
Blair White doesn't even look like a pretty woman once you remove the makeup and filters. I've had the unfortunate experience of witnessing video footage of his behind in a bikini. Definitely male.
Blair knows they're a man. You should hear him drop his feminie voice
Blair White is very clear that she's a biological male who presents as a woman, not a woman
Blair is a biological man
I took a spade from the store, I take it home and I cut sections off and manipulate the metal into forming it into a different shape. It looks like a digging fork, for anyone could tell and for all functional means it was a digging fork.
However, if I go back to the store, to the counter and the clerk scans the barcode it will still say "Spade".
Don't be afraid to call a spade a spade.
Well said!
“india was born a male but no longer identifies as such” ok? that doesnt stop him from being male though? i no longer identify as human and instead identify as a turtle. doesnt make me a turtle, and it doesnt make it hate crime to not admit me to a turtle hospital.
Is he going to admit that he referred to India Willoughby as 'HE' in his followup interview ? If not then he is not worth the bother of interviewing.
He called a man a man? Oh the heavens
I mean in one of his first sentences here "J K Rowling called him a man"....... Freud would say this guy knows what the truth is.
He did it again at the start of this interview. 'called HIM a man'.
No. Denies it even though during the first few minutes of this interview he’s referred to India as “him”.
How about using India and NO pronouns
He seems entirely disingenuous in his explanation. He didn't know about the toxicity of the trans debate? As a journo?? And then talks about how people fall into chasing click's but doesn't seem to include himself in that category although that's clearly what he did with his interview with that bloke India
He definitely said he was chasing clicks, were you even listening?
Claiming calling JK a c* isn't misogyny is priceless. Especially for the reason he called her that! Sounds like he doesn't understand what words mean.
At least this guy was honest about his own shortcomings. Taking on JK Rowling was obviously a stupid thing to do because she's a formidable character and intellectually in a different league. As even the Scottish government found out after implementing their ridiculous and unworkable Hate Crime law. It has many similarities to Jordan Peterson's confrontation due to Canada's C-16 bill.
I have no idea who this guy is, but I love how he embarrasses himself.
Themself*😂
He's a gay.
@@natangurfinkelITself*
Itself*@@natangurfinkel
He used to be Tommy Robinson's camera man. Not a nice guy.
Old Willyboy will be absolutely pissed at being referred to as "them". 😂
What surprised me is how ill informed this guy is on so much.
Does anyone else care that India’s name is geographical appropriation?
This guy is a mess
Basically, he's a "professional troll".
This little boy now knows how women feel when they call men out when they ask men to stay out of women's places, and when they refuse to be compelled to call men women.
Love how he "mansplains" what he believes JKR is feeling..
Does having a certificate also give you a uterus? Does it take away your prostate gland? Does it give you ovaries? NO? Not a woman.
No, that’s not any advice I’ve ever heard. The advice I’ve heard is, “Don’t apologize to people when you’ve done nothing wrong, and NEVER apologize to a a mob high on vicarious outrage that only cares about trampling you.”
Yeah, ABSOLUTELY apologize to an individual when you’ve wronged them and you know it. Nobody said otherwise.
I think that this is a debate between Women and Narcissists. Not many women can enter this space as a debater. Rowling has to defend herself but she is actually doing a Woman’s fight, not simply a personal fight.
I think you are exactly right about this.
Caolan proved he has got an extremely short fuse. He shouldn't be a journalist. Not made for the job.
Gheeeeey!
The ‘I haven’t done any research’ gave it away too
He lost his journalistic integrity the moment he used the pronoun THEM. He comes across as both immature and manipulative to me. He either knew he was stirring the pot or he has the IQ of a pot.
It can say he was born at hogwarts on his birth certificate and he identifies as a sorting hat, but he’s still a man.
This was like watching them interviewing the work experience boy. Who is he?
I’m guessing he is more successful and has had more high profile employment than you did by his age mate! Just a guess!
@@bonnieboyz the interview is literally about him calling JKR a slur on twitter , it was very school yard
Haha. Yeah thas hilarious.
💯💯🎯
@@bonnieboyzthis is a guy who put himself into debt to buy expensive hotel rooms etc to post on social media. Hes desperate for fame and its sad he has been platformed here.
He starting to look embarrassed,,,,, being schooled by konstantin , he has no idea of the ramifications of just being kind 🤦♀️
I don't think he has much of an idea about anything. he seems to think he us incredibly clever, witty with some personal insight that no-one else has. He also has no idea about personal responsibility or accountability.
What a creepy little fool as ably demonstrated by his language , power to JK !
I also thought he called India “him”, but I now gather he said “them”… However, he clearly misgendered her, because her pronouns are not “they”, “them”, but “she”, “her”.
Why did he say “them”? Because he does not actually believe that India is a “her”.
His claim to neutrality is false, the neutral pronoun is “one”.
Caught bang to rights.
Please look up the neutral pronoun in English: "it."
Do students get taught about history anymore, particularly World War 2? If they did, they would exercise caution about regarding someone who has a different opinion as non-human and therefore given freedom to treat them badly. it is the same as words like "needs to be reeducated" and new hate speech laws, that require people to snitch on each other to police. It all sends shivers down my spine, because I do remember the history I was taught in school regarding Nazi Germany. I also think the ice-berg analogy regarding the trans debate is very clever. Often people who oppose it, oppose it because they have done a lot of research and are talking about the whole ice-berg (e.g. trans-surgery, or puberty blockers and hormones for children who are too young to make huge life changing decisions, trans-men in women's prisons, women's sports being taken over by trans, etc), when people who are "for it" are just thinking about pronouns and being rude.
Your guest makes the typical British mistake of valuing "niceness" and "politeness" over valuing truthfulness and honesty, which is having tragic consequences on British society, and Western societies in general.
The world needs JK Rowling to put an end to all this nonsense discussion. Content creators are feeding into nonsensical and moronic appetite of people.Magnifying this issue for content and for views is not journalism.
Is he really this naïve?. He needs to go away and mature.
This guy doesn't know when to quit. Definitely not to be trusted.
It’s the continuous desperation for validation for me.
Someone doing a u turn from harassing people in the street with Tommy Robinson to being an activist for the left, strikes me as being a grifter.
I support JK Rolling.
dforsberg99:
(Rowling)😊📖🌹🇬🇧
If I hear the word “misgendered” one more time, my head is going to explode 🤯
Wear a helmet so nobody else has to clean up your mess.
FF and KK are handing him his ass by trying to show, teach, tell, instruct, prod, push, guide, provoke this equivocating young person. I hope it works. Time will tell.
He went straight to calling JKR a horrible name... what a charmer
You do realise that JK Rowling is left wing .
How can she be left wing if she lives in reality?
@laganas2008 she was always a far left feminist. Tried to rewrite her characters to appease the rainbow mob. Then when she took a stance they turned on her.
@@SWINDYPANTS90 That's what cry bullies do. They have no loyalty.
Yep the irony of it.
@@SWINDYPANTS90 and what's wrong with champagne socialist , to much empathy for ya ?.
Having a piece of paper does not make anyone a man or a woman.
I stand with JKR, like every other sane person. Caolan isn't independent- he can't even think for himself. It has nothing to do with the 'left' or 'right' or social media.
Three biological men having a conversation about two biological men having a conversation.
😹
Males*
@@joshuataylor3550 Adult human males, or "men" for short.
1:10 you literally called him a him whilst complaining about somebody else doing the same, then a few minutes later get mad and deny doing this on another occasion after being accused of such.
Objective reality is a powerful thing, you can fight it, but there will be slip ups.
It's fine to make mistakes, doing it deliberately after being told how someone prefers to be identified is the issue.
@@joshuataylor3550 aww boo hoo! The truth hurts . Accept it
"To learn who rules over you, simply look to those you cannot criticize."
-Voltaire
Good on JK Rowlings, Riley Gaines and all the women standing up women.
While its admirable to seek forgiveness for your mistakes the cynic in me thinks this guy has seen which way the wind is blowing and is backpedalling.
I think he got a call from the kind of lawyer Rowling can afford.
Caolan just posted that he had a lovely night out with Peter Tachell.
Does Coalan realise that Peter Tachell has openly defended pedophilia by saying that not all sexual interactions between adults and children should be criminal?
That's the point with these people. He's well aware
You have also had nights out with people who have said and done terrible things; unless you don’t interact with others at all.
That’s not what Tachell defended though you’re lying….
@@Noplayster13stop the deflection focus on the truth and evidence hun
PT is a raving NONCE Caolan is merely prey! 😆
Scrapping the barrel here guys
Mixed feelings on this guest. It doesn't make sense to say that he was to the right, then veered to the left because he didn't like how the people he worked with produced content for clicks. What an idiotic reason to change one's political opinion or worldview. I loved how KK replied something like "no, I don't know, can you elaborate?" Or "can you give examples?" when the guest said something vague formulated as if it went without saying. At one point, when KK said that recognising a basic truth is not a matter of opinion, he admitted that his interviewers were much well versed on the topic than he was. He seems a bit shallow, not very mature, but well intentioned. In need of mentoring perhaps.