Now India have no appetite for Pakistan antics .India is working very hard to progress despite its own problems . Pakistan is no longer in Indian radar. Why only non resident Pakistanis r talking of peace but rest of Pakistanis r yearning for ghazwa e Hind . There can be no peace until Pakistan shed its ideology .Which is impossible .
In a country of 20 crore people, 55 people are listening, you think you can make these Pakistani radicalized zombies human beings. It's like 'Hamaari koshish mein koi kami ho to batao'. Is level ki talks se society mein kuch nahi hone wala, is se jyada to jumme ki nammaz mein ek masjid mein log radicalize hone jaate hai. 😂😂
Pakistan ke log accept hi nahi karna chahte ki unki problem Islamic radicalization hai. Jab accept nahi karenge to sudhrenge kaise. Neta, Abhineta , army aur jyadatar public sab gazwae hind ke khwab dekhte hai. Hum Indians ko nahi chahiye aise nafratiyon se dosti.
Indians do not want any soft border with radicalised and hater of Hindus Pakistanis and now Bangladeshis also do same, rather carve New country which is really to deal with soft border.
U can't fool India. Krishna forgave Sisupal 100 times,then took action. India is just doing that now. So It's only Pakistan's responsibility to take initiatives. India has 50 crores of well educated aggrieved middle v class people, and the number is increasing. They dominate India
Don’t blame govts. Blame people. Lahoree chooran that we are same and we want peace and all trouble is by govt on both sides is absolutely untrue. Reality is we don’t want peace. When we don’t accept 26/11 and don’t accept massacre during partition, don’t accept that partition was unnatural and more Muslims in India, false narrative of Kashmir. How can one have Muslim population larger than Pakistan in India whim Pakistan claims been highly persecuted and want Kashmir because it is Muslim majority and still say people are nice only govt are bad. No actually we are bad and govt on both sides are nothing but reflection of us. Therefore don’t create drama. Cool down. For few years no terrorist attack in India. Allow Kashmiris to live in peace. Probably after few years things might be normal. Don’t say india should be secular and Pakistan Islamic nation.
Let us have peace with zero engagement. Just mind our own business. We wish you the best, but there is no appetite in India for Pakistan. 26/11 has changed many people like me forever. Never again.
Keep religion a strictly personal affair and deal with fellow human beings on a purely insaniyat basis. In other words, Keep religion inside your home and do not let public life be affected by it. Separate state and the religion. India has achieved that to a high level. Can Pakistan, a country created on the basis of a religion, achieve that to a necessary level? I have serious doubts about that. Thus, good relations between India and Pakistan, unfortunately, are a far cry. Having said that, humans' motivation level towards any idea, often is driven by the potential desirable outcomes. So, the work needs to be done to highlight the good outcomes and thereby nudge the naysayers towards peace and good relations. Let's keep the hope alive, no matter how hard it may seem.
Please question your establishment who has caused this situation. Expect Punjabi's and some North Indian Muslims nobody has interest in Pakistan. The popular sentiment in India is we are better off without Pakistan. We have no bomblasts nowadays which was common during Aman ka Asha days.
*South Asia has now become defunct!* It is now known as the Indian Sub-continent which is part of the larger Indo-Pacific region. *Pakistan is now part of the AfPak region!* It is a much better idea to have *soft borders between Pakistan & Afghanistan* for more people to people exchange with a common curriculum in Madrassas on both sides to foster a common Jihadi culture...
Sorry Beena we don't want to be friends with ideology who want to change the border, demographic, culture, religion of our. Please be Arab, turk, Persian, afgan whatever don't even look at us, aap logo ne kafi dukh aur dard diya hai hame aur de rha hai please hme chor de kuch aur kra aur apne logo aur desh ko banaya acha Protect hindu and other minorities of your country
There’s a strong understanding in India now that peace with Pakistan is not the solution but rather an alternative solution that is a quiet border between India and Pakistan would help both the countries to grow as resolving differences is impossible without a major concession from Pakistan to completely eradicate extremism terrorism and radicalism which is impossible for Pakistan to achieve
MY question is in last 70 years what pakistan is doing to make it's own society Liberal. Please make your own society Liberal and Atheist then preach south asia. 😊😊😊😊😊
Sorry disagree. Indians are not keen at any relationship with pakistan at this point of time. Come back after 5 years. Meanwhile focus on yourself and see if you can recover your country.
Sara dukh dard Kashmiri aur Palestinians k lite but chuppi bilkul about Uighurs, Yemenis, Libyans, African muslims killing by muslims..selective outrage is not outrage but politics
India experienced many bad experience in past whenever they show good gesture for example mumbai attack. This is why reluctant to give any easy visa. Also pakistani politicians or government officials instead talking about serious business talks start with kashmir which is irritating Indian. Also a thought moving here that pakistan current position whether it's financial or political not good so they want talk but what if things gets settled in future? Are they not start same kashmir song here and there? Pakistan has to show repeated good gesture towards India to win their trust. Without Pakistan support India doing well so don't expect immediate positive response from Indian side.
As a Sikh from Punjab i request u pls just stay away bcz we don't want any relationship with pakistan. U can become super power but pls stay away from us
So Dr ijah who used Hindu 🕉️ 🚩 rate of growth because some Indian have written some where and calling people troll because they called it out or questioned it will he narrate the words of Dr Br Ambedkar a Indian on Muslims and Islam 🐫 🕌? 🤔 🙄
at 59:00 .. the questioner shows concerns abt some chapters being dropped from Delhi University history books .. that is laughable especially when Pakistani history books have to be completely rewritten 🤣
By listening the entire debate I can say that only the viewpoint of the journalist was making some sense to some extend but most of the audience were so dumb , illetrate in their question even elder people as well ( I guess they have a strong prejudiced view about India ), that shows the level of education they have . it seems like they are living in their own universe.
I think Pakistan has wrong perception about India.....its not whole India were u will find anger towards Pakistan, its mostly in cow belt. South indian , Bengali and North east don't share same hatred towards pakistan and considering historical significance Punjabis dont hate pakistan either but still many security concerns that India have are genuine and historically also India didn't had good experience with Pakistan( I want Indo pak relations to improve) . Every time effort was made from our side something fishy is done by pak establishment in the past so some serious guarantees need to given to India if we desire any improvement in relations but only way forward in the region is peace and economic integration and we all should strive to end radicalization and promote rationality.....JAI HIND experience
People make leaders and not otherwise. Modi is Popular PM because people want him. Indian people are not sheep to blindly follow any leader blindly. Pakistan was formed on two nation theory. Has Pakistan rejected that theory. You have so many islamic countries around you, but you are desperate for relations with the people you rejected on basis of religion. You have set the hate narrative in 1947 and we are just obliging you. Keep hating us and blame us for your misery. This conversation will push more indians away. Good luck Beena, with your fraudulent moral high ground you are going nowhere. Bhutto's 1000 years war, Zia's bleeding India with a thousand cuts and Musharraf's eternal low intensity conflict has come ro fruition.
all hoax and emotionalism , india tried this dish called aman ki aasha for 60 50 years, your artist were all over bollywood, Indians gave them love from actors to singers , but what happened kargil backstabbing , parliament attack, akshardham attack ,mumbai attack , pathankot ,URi attack etc etc , so first improve your country and make some basic institutions which works , pakistan is a democracy but your chief holds the power , your society is full of hate towards india and particularly hindus , you fed hate towards hindus in your school curriculum, first change your society and stop this terrorism ,
Pak needs union; India does not. Any mininscule economic benefit to India is easil offset by risk of terror and mass scale one way migration. More a Tamasha rather than Asha.
Please improve the acoustic characteristics of the room. Alternatively educate the online viewers how to reduce the reverberations of "The Black Hole" snows on our TVs
my question to the moderator. Why did you ask her to talk in English. No doubt, people present in the hall can understand English but when you are spreading the message through social media, you should use the language which is understood by common people especially if you want to convince common man. Please think
France and England fought for centuries. Now they are part of European Union. Saudia and Syria are coming closer. So it is only the will of the leaders to sort out the differences. People of both countries are so eager to have good relations. A relationship like Canada and US can be easily established. both India and Pakistan can have good relations , far better than the US and Canada. It may take some time. But the leaders of both countries should start this process.
So-called intellectual of Pakistan 😂😂😂😂. Modi ji jinko 2 baar India ki public ne elect kiya n most posible 3rd time bhi PM honge unka comparison zia se. Very good n pls keep it up and IND mein religious extremism ki bhi baat kar rahe hain 😂 good joke
Neeyat toh achchi hai aap logon ki but concepts clear nahi hain ..you need to unlearn a lot before trying to understand India ...for the time being please mind your own business..we have a mountain to climb and our entire focus is on that ...
Please remain within your side of the border. Kripya apna kachra apne paas rakhein. Dhanyavaad.
By listening to the audience it clearly states that we do not want to take responsibility but just blame the other party 😢
Now India have no appetite for Pakistan antics .India is working very hard to progress despite its own problems .
Pakistan is no longer in Indian radar. Why only non resident Pakistanis r talking of peace but rest of Pakistanis r yearning for ghazwa e Hind . There can be no peace until Pakistan shed its ideology .Which is impossible .
In a country of 20 crore people, 55 people are listening, you think you can make these Pakistani radicalized zombies human beings.
It's like 'Hamaari koshish mein koi kami ho to batao'.
Is level ki talks se society mein kuch nahi hone wala, is se jyada to jumme ki nammaz mein ek masjid mein log radicalize hone jaate hai.
😂😂
Pakistan ke log accept hi nahi karna chahte ki unki problem Islamic radicalization hai.
Jab accept nahi karenge to sudhrenge kaise.
Neta, Abhineta , army aur jyadatar public sab gazwae hind ke khwab dekhte hai.
Hum Indians ko nahi chahiye aise nafratiyon se dosti.
Indians do not want any soft border with radicalised and hater of Hindus Pakistanis and now Bangladeshis also do same, rather carve New country which is really to deal with soft border.
It is high time India gave Bharat Ratna to Jinnah.....Even tho I am atheist, I thank god for Jinnah when I hear such tone deafness.......
U can't fool India. Krishna forgave Sisupal 100 times,then took action. India is just doing that now. So It's only Pakistan's responsibility to take initiatives. India has 50 crores of well educated aggrieved middle v class people, and the number is increasing. They dominate India
I am from India , black hole sunna accha lagta h , very informative content, but Pakistan or pakistaniyo ka kuch nhi ho sakta,
Don’t blame govts. Blame people. Lahoree chooran that we are same and we want peace and all trouble is by govt on both sides is absolutely untrue. Reality is we don’t want peace. When we don’t accept 26/11 and don’t accept massacre during partition, don’t accept that partition was unnatural and more Muslims in India, false narrative of Kashmir. How can one have Muslim population larger than Pakistan in India whim Pakistan claims been highly persecuted and want Kashmir because it is Muslim majority and still say people are nice only govt are bad. No actually we are bad and govt on both sides are nothing but reflection of us. Therefore don’t create drama. Cool down. For few years no terrorist attack in India. Allow Kashmiris to live in peace. Probably after few years things might be normal. Don’t say india should be secular and Pakistan Islamic nation.
Let us have peace with zero engagement. Just mind our own business. We wish you the best, but there is no appetite in India for Pakistan. 26/11 has changed many people like me forever. Never again.
Keep religion a strictly personal affair and deal with fellow human beings on a purely insaniyat basis. In other words, Keep religion inside your home and do not let public life be affected by it. Separate state and the religion. India has achieved that to a high level. Can Pakistan, a country created on the basis of a religion, achieve that to a necessary level? I have serious doubts about that. Thus, good relations between India and Pakistan, unfortunately, are a far cry.
Having said that, humans' motivation level towards any idea, often is driven by the potential desirable outcomes. So, the work needs to be done to highlight the good outcomes and thereby nudge the naysayers towards peace and good relations. Let's keep the hope alive, no matter how hard it may seem.
Historically, Islam is a Political Religion. It will never keep religion as a private affair.
Agreed 100%! What we lack is modern education with critical thinking that can open minds and unfortunately that has never been our priority!
Appreciation for your positive attitude.
Please question your establishment who has caused this situation. Expect Punjabi's and some North Indian Muslims nobody has interest in Pakistan. The popular sentiment in India is we are better off without Pakistan. We have no bomblasts nowadays which was common during Aman ka Asha days.
no soft border...stop this" maan na maan , mein tera mehmaan..." who wants to have any truck with people who are still living in 640 AD
No more Aman ki asha with Pakistan
*South Asia has now become defunct!*
It is now known as the Indian Sub-continent which is part of the larger Indo-Pacific region.
*Pakistan is now part of the AfPak region!*
It is a much better idea to have *soft borders between Pakistan & Afghanistan* for more people to people exchange with a common curriculum in Madrassas on both sides to foster a common Jihadi culture...
Sorry Beena we don't want to be friends with ideology who want to change the border, demographic, culture, religion of our. Please be Arab, turk, Persian, afgan whatever don't even look at us, aap logo ne kafi dukh aur dard diya hai hame aur de rha hai please hme chor de kuch aur kra aur apne logo aur desh ko banaya acha
Protect hindu and other minorities of your country
Can the speaker give an example where journalist are killed or kidnapped by government of india ?
There’s a strong understanding in India now that peace with Pakistan is not the solution but rather an alternative solution that is a quiet border between India and Pakistan would help both the countries to grow as resolving differences is impossible without a major concession from Pakistan to completely eradicate extremism terrorism and radicalism which is impossible for Pakistan to achieve
I think paxtanis should stop worrying about Indian politics, indian muslims, indian religiousity.
MY question is in last 70 years what pakistan is doing to make it's own society Liberal.
Please make your own society Liberal and Atheist then preach south asia. 😊😊😊😊😊
Sorry disagree. Indians are not keen at any relationship with pakistan at this point of time. Come back after 5 years. Meanwhile focus on yourself and see if you can recover your country.
Heterogeneity hasn't stopped Bangladesh and India from trading!
But in India atleast no hatreds is tought against any relegion like Pakistan.
The lady is very courageous, smartest Pakistani I have heard on you tube .
Sara dukh dard Kashmiri aur Palestinians k lite but chuppi bilkul about Uighurs, Yemenis, Libyans, African muslims killing by muslims..selective outrage is not outrage but politics
South Asia, o you mean Bharat! 😇
India experienced many bad experience in past whenever they show good gesture for example mumbai attack. This is why reluctant to give any easy visa. Also pakistani politicians or government officials instead talking about serious business talks start with kashmir which is irritating Indian. Also a thought moving here that pakistan current position whether it's financial or political not good so they want talk but what if things gets settled in future? Are they not start same kashmir song here and there? Pakistan has to show repeated good gesture towards India to win their trust. Without Pakistan support India doing well so don't expect immediate positive response from Indian side.
These people have their own agenda of business don't get emotional
Sorry but nothing will ever work till the time you've people preaching gazwa hind
As a Sikh from Punjab i request u pls just stay away bcz we don't want any relationship with pakistan. U can become super power but pls stay away from us
First concentrate on Morden education and madrasa reform. Nobody will open border for Pakistani.
So Dr ijah who used Hindu 🕉️ 🚩 rate of growth because some Indian have written some where and calling people troll because they called it out or questioned it will he narrate the words of Dr Br Ambedkar a Indian on Muslims and Islam 🐫 🕌? 🤔 🙄
at 59:00 .. the questioner shows concerns abt some chapters being dropped from Delhi University history books .. that is laughable especially when Pakistani history books have to be completely rewritten 🤣
Blackboard and chalk , one side conversation limited audience and infrastructure of the 80's and they want to preach peace and talk about India
Modi is same as Zia ul haq .. really? 🤷♂️
Good subject. Appreciated. from India.
Beena Sarwar is a great progressive thinker and has been working so long for peace.
First, Pakistan should declare itself as a Secular State. 🙏🏾
Ms Beena Sarwar is doing a great job…. It’s a very tough job but no matter what she must continue….. all the best wishes to her 👏❤️☮️🙏
Pakistani Comrade abh India main activism kareghe.😅😅😅
By listening the entire debate I can say that only the viewpoint of the journalist was making some sense to some extend but most of the audience were so dumb , illetrate in their question even elder people as well ( I guess they have a strong prejudiced view about India ), that shows the level of education they have . it seems like they are living in their own universe.
Focus on building your own country 😂
literally i am delighted to see lots of people witnessing this insightfull dialogue
Aman ki aasha gang don't come to India otherwise you will regret.
I dont find any hope ,but bade logo ki bade bade shock ,krte rho time pass
I think Pakistan has wrong perception about India.....its not whole India were u will find anger towards Pakistan, its mostly in cow belt. South indian , Bengali and North east don't share same hatred towards pakistan and considering historical significance Punjabis dont hate pakistan either but still many security concerns that India have are genuine and historically also India didn't had good experience with Pakistan( I want Indo pak relations to improve) . Every time effort was made from our side something fishy is done by pak establishment in the past so some serious guarantees need to given to India if we desire any improvement in relations but only way forward in the region is peace and economic integration and we all should strive to end radicalization and promote rationality.....JAI HIND
experience
AAPSE HAATH JORKER GUJARISH HAI BAN KARO YE "GOODY GOODY"TALK HAM INDIANS BAHUT THAK CHUKE HAIN,PAKION KE CHUTIYAPAY SE.
Who said that Muslims can't live with Hindus ,Sikhs and other Indians . Please first shed ur ideology,then think of people to people contact .
People make leaders and not otherwise. Modi is Popular PM because people want him. Indian people are not sheep to blindly follow any leader blindly. Pakistan was formed on two nation theory. Has Pakistan rejected that theory. You have so many islamic countries around you, but you are desperate for relations with the people you rejected on basis of religion. You have set the hate narrative in 1947 and we are just obliging you. Keep hating us and blame us for your misery. This conversation will push more indians away. Good luck Beena, with your fraudulent moral high ground you are going nowhere. Bhutto's 1000 years war, Zia's bleeding India with a thousand cuts and Musharraf's eternal low intensity conflict has come ro fruition.
Aap indian education k liye pareshan na ho hm ceo nikalte h jo world ko lead krte h aap k yahan k ceo puri duniya me fatt rhe h....
all hoax and emotionalism ,
india tried this dish called aman ki aasha for 60 50 years, your artist were all over bollywood, Indians gave them love from actors to singers ,
but what happened kargil backstabbing , parliament attack, akshardham attack ,mumbai attack , pathankot ,URi attack etc etc ,
so first improve your country and make some basic institutions which works , pakistan is a democracy but your chief holds the power , your society is full of hate towards india and particularly hindus , you fed hate towards hindus in your school curriculum,
first change your society and stop this terrorism ,
AAP AZAD HAI PICHEY RAH GAYE PAKISTANIO KO LEJANEY KE LIYE.
Pak needs union; India does not. Any mininscule economic benefit to India is easil offset by risk of terror and mass scale one way migration.
More a Tamasha rather than Asha.
❤
Please improve the acoustic characteristics of the room. Alternatively educate the online viewers how to reduce the reverberations of "The Black Hole" snows on our TVs
Thanks, but no thanks.
southasian lol
my question to the moderator. Why did you ask her to talk in English. No doubt, people present in the hall can understand English but when you are spreading the message through social media, you should use the language which is understood by common people especially if you want to convince common man. Please think
Waw! Such a good debate.
try having a soft border with afghanistan, iran & turkey. they are your real umma
I was born in Karachi but my parents migrated from UP, I would like to visit the land of my ancestors!
Looks like some comments just disappear into thin air of RUclips algorithm. 😂 Narrative engineering by RUclips unhindered.
"Aman ki Asha" v2
Aman ki aasha bullshit 🤮🤮
Sorry india doesn't Need beggars
France and England fought for centuries. Now they are part of European Union. Saudia and Syria are coming closer. So it is only the will of the leaders to sort out the differences. People of both countries are so eager to have good relations. A relationship like Canada and US can be easily established. both India and Pakistan can have good relations , far better than the US and Canada. It may take some time. But the leaders of both countries should start this process.
So-called intellectual of Pakistan 😂😂😂😂. Modi ji jinko 2 baar India ki public ne elect kiya n most posible 3rd time bhi PM honge unka comparison zia se. Very good n pls keep it up and IND mein religious extremism ki bhi baat kar rahe hain 😂 good joke
Phale ye bato government kon hai pakistan me
👋
Useless discussion
We r not interested in talking with u. Pl. Leave us indians alone
Neeyat toh achchi hai aap logon ki but concepts clear nahi hain ..you need to unlearn a lot before trying to understand India ...for the time being please mind your own business..we have a mountain to climb and our entire focus is on that ...
❤