Reviving Scientific Education in Pakistan - A Roadmap | Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy | Replugged

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии •

  • @rajyadavrajiitian
    @rajyadavrajiitian 23 дня назад +16

    Pakistan shayad rahe na rahe... but history will remember a man called Parvez Hoodbhoy kept trying to save it through every chunk in his armour despite looking at a certain defeat ... a lot of inspiration to draw from you sir , lot of love and respect from India

  • @SS-hv7bo
    @SS-hv7bo 24 дня назад +28

    Shoutout to whoever writes on the blackboard. Really nicely done.

  • @RazM007
    @RazM007 24 дня назад +9

    For Pakistanis, don't know what you learnt or what you wanna to learn, we the Indians learnt a lot .
    Parvez sir, pls don't mind the empty chairs, they are filled with lots of Indian peoples who want to learn. Since we've learning mindset, we proved that how we take knowledge from everywhere and apply those education in our society.
    Thank you Parvez sir, pls continue all the way, even with the empty chairs 🙏🙏🙏🤘🤘🤞

  • @pappu33
    @pappu33 24 дня назад +15

    Thanks for your effort Dr. Hoodbhoy, we have dozens of tv stations now , none of them have any scientific programs.

  • @rameshrajs8140
    @rameshrajs8140 22 дня назад +4

    I appreciate Parvez ji for starting a paid training program for teachers 👍👌 now you are actually going to make a difference, All the best sir!

  • @shameemqureshi2774
    @shameemqureshi2774 23 дня назад +4

    Hats off to you Hoodbhoy Sahib for your humility, courage and perseverance.👏

  • @ravichavan7513
    @ravichavan7513 22 дня назад +4

    A very important initiative by Dr. Hoodbhoy and his team. Apart from education, the other social and religious issues discussed in the discourse carry much importance and need to address..
    May this noble initiative spread all over Pakistan..

  • @rahulkapur687
    @rahulkapur687 24 дня назад +51

    Khiyali pulao is the favorite dish of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan...unfortunately! If you seriously start working on overhauling your education system on a war footing, it'll take your country 30-40 years to show some positive results. 🇮🇳

  • @purushetty7458
    @purushetty7458 24 дня назад +14

    What a pity that only a handful of people are interested in what Dr. hoodbhoy has to offer. No wonder Pakistan is doing so well :)

  • @NasreenNasreenjargees
    @NasreenNasreenjargees 23 дня назад +3

    Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy you are great Sir you are point out the major issue in our education system very nice and i am greatful you and Your best exprence in Our education system analyse and resrch.

  • @anildubey9211
    @anildubey9211 23 дня назад +2

    Nice and essential discussion for the whole Indian subcontinent.

  • @Harpreet-t2h
    @Harpreet-t2h 24 дня назад +19

    Pakistaan has to meet it doomsday within a foreseeable time. None can save it. A state with no defined political framework and a state lost in economic malaise can never be addressed as a developing state. Its society is illiterate and poor that lives in depression. There's no scope of any hope in future. Nothing..!!!!

    • @gopalramanathan7062
      @gopalramanathan7062 24 дня назад +4

      In fact its dissolution could be its only hope for moksha.

  • @yjkbuddy
    @yjkbuddy 24 дня назад +25

    A country born in the name of religion will be always like that.. You have no other options...

  • @sadasatyamvada
    @sadasatyamvada 23 дня назад +5

    In India no Hindu student finds any conflict between religion and science. So they have no issues pursuing science freely. It appears to me that Muslims in Pakistan May find it conflicting to study science and keeping the faith

  • @ShoukatAli-y7k8c
    @ShoukatAli-y7k8c 23 дня назад +2

    Thank you for the wonderful talks.

  • @adrianadam8543
    @adrianadam8543 10 дней назад

    Hoodbhoy Saab, you are the only one preaching the true Islam in Pakistan, almost everyone else is a Takfeeri savage. Every single video you make is valuable, You give millions hope that Pakistan may be a civilized society one day.

  • @DrAahad-xo6ev
    @DrAahad-xo6ev 24 дня назад +3

    Very very real situation and true scenario widespread of our COUNTRY, Sindh,Pakistan.
    Policymakers only do papery work and formulate project designs and implementation and operated by gosts and gins.
    I am more than 100% agreed with story.

  • @PrasadHalebidu
    @PrasadHalebidu 10 дней назад

    Pervez Hoodbhoy nicely explained that the laws of Nature like gravity cannot be changed by Human Beings . He should have also explained the same laws of Nature (eg natural disasters, viruses..etc) does not discriminate against people who follow different religions, beliefs etc !

  • @KaberiMukherjee-cy5fo
    @KaberiMukherjee-cy5fo 23 дня назад +2

    Please ask Dr Parvez Hoodbhoy sir about chemistry. I eagerly waiting about his thoughts on chemistry.

  • @ajithubli4994
    @ajithubli4994 24 дня назад +5

    The Pakistan government is not interested in the science channel but the government is inviting Zakir Naik,who spoiled general Pakistanis further. Sad state of affairs....

  • @SouthindianNarendra
    @SouthindianNarendra 24 дня назад +3

    Hardly a few people in the room may also come for AC, forget the education boss look for safety and food in Pakistan

    • @vinsin328
      @vinsin328 24 дня назад

      Same situation is in India

  • @pradyumnanayak9844
    @pradyumnanayak9844 24 дня назад +4

    It's the time for Ghar Wapsi for all. Welcome Home 🏡.

  • @homosapienssapiens4848
    @homosapienssapiens4848 24 дня назад +9

    When students are in school teachers tells that you'll study this xyz topic in college and when we reach in college teachers tell that you must have studied this xyz concept in school itself. 😂

  • @shahabuddin3658
    @shahabuddin3658 23 дня назад +1

    Love you Dr Perveze

  • @Sam-sb8kg
    @Sam-sb8kg 21 день назад

    Wow program, bohat umda!!

  • @sudiptoganguli8968
    @sudiptoganguli8968 23 дня назад

    The legacy of the land...so many great persons, so much talent...possibilities...but...

  • @shameemqureshi2774
    @shameemqureshi2774 22 дня назад +2

    At the root of all the problems discussed is the societal fossilised mindset. This is particularly a Pakistan centred phenomenon, a thousand times worse than the an Islamic one. There are two main reasons: 1. Islamic fundamentalism, rather sectarian fundamentalism, was brutally used to create Pakistan thus giving Mullahs almost a veto power; 2. Post-independence, we got very weak leaders, including the Quaid, who failed to guide the nation to an enlightened path. Instead they followed an easy path of going by the mullah-led popular religious sentiments. Objective Resolution was the first major blow. This inward spiral is sinking us to unimaginable depths. If Maulana Moududi who preached against religious tolerance, population control, banking and land reforms, is our hero, what hope?😢

  • @VictimHood-qv1hx
    @VictimHood-qv1hx 24 дня назад +1

    Pervez Hoodbhoy should get noble prize in Indian history 😂

  • @subramayamrvr8774
    @subramayamrvr8774 24 дня назад +5

    If you bring religion into science how can logical thinking develop.

  • @abdulmalik5852
    @abdulmalik5852 24 дня назад +2

    Education should be in mother tongue

  • @asmanasim9394
    @asmanasim9394 24 дня назад +4

    We have to put emergency for education. 24/7 schools

  • @radaysham
    @radaysham 24 дня назад +4

    This is a short life.A long life awaits in heaven. No worries.

    • @mymind1615
      @mymind1615 24 дня назад

      This is the problem of Muslims today. Islam is more than a means of prayer. It is a way of life. If Allah didn't want you to work so hard in this WORLD then the almighty wouldn't have sent us here. We have a duty as Muslims. working hard doesn't just mean prayers, that is the basics of islam, we have to dive much deeper. We were sent down to be a dominant force in this world, rather, we are acting as slaves. our job is too develop ourselves as a nation and as an ummah. Muslims today think that we shouldn't strive to achieve something great just because this is a temporary world. That's the wrong understanding of Islam and the Quran. We should achieve brilliant things in this world but through the help of Allah and his guidelines. That's the whole point of this world and our test. Muslims honestly have just given up on striving to be the dominant force. We must do better than this. Whatever profession we are in; businessman, athlete, scientist, we need to use these means to help others. Not just sit and wait for death

  • @shahabuddin3658
    @shahabuddin3658 23 дня назад +1

    MashaAllah. Thanks The black hole team ❤
    Watched the whole session !!

  • @shankeswartripathi7983
    @shankeswartripathi7983 22 дня назад

    Dr.Saheb, it needs total transformation..it can not be addressed partially.if a society allentiate itself from gross concessness of humanity, it will meet with same fate which are you facing.after all we have to match with growing mind of the world.hope you will clear one layer of dust .

  • @taimoor722
    @taimoor722 24 дня назад +3

    To inspire a Muslim mind toward science, we should frame the natural world as a divine creation. Allah has given us permission to explore, understand, and use His creation, as He made it rational and comprehensible to our intellect. Just as our eyes are designed to perceive light, our minds are designed to grasp the rational nature of the world. The thirst for understanding is akin to the physical thirst for water, and solving problems gives our brain a natural satisfaction, as it strengthens neural connections-reflecting our purpose in using reason.
    Just as life is a blessing, so is the earth and its natural resources. Allah has subdued animals like horses and camels for human use, but this came through understanding and effort. Similarly, natural elements like clouds, rain, oil, and steel are blessings waiting to be harnessed. With perseverance and experimentation, they can be transformed into means of benefit. If Prophet Suleiman (AS) had control over the wind by Allah’s permission, then our efforts to gain control over natural forces through science and discovery are also part of Allah's blessings and wisdom. With the right effort and understanding, we are fulfilling our role as stewards of this world.

  • @ayeshakiranayeshakiran823
    @ayeshakiranayeshakiran823 24 дня назад +3

    Kindly share website address for teacher training program.

  • @mosaqureshi9891
    @mosaqureshi9891 24 дня назад +1

    Great work

  • @ajithubli4994
    @ajithubli4994 24 дня назад +2

    The day Pakistan differentiates between religion & state. Things will change forever.
    Please concentrate on primary, secondary & higher education.
    If done,the next generation, may be after 15 to 20 years, Pakistan will be an enlightened society.

    • @vinsin328
      @vinsin328 24 дня назад +1

      Same thing applies to India also.

    • @madmax-bu6wh
      @madmax-bu6wh 23 дня назад

      Not possible in islamic republics

  • @MohinKMoh_Kamran
    @MohinKMoh_Kamran 23 дня назад +1

    Please invite the top Doctor of the world, Dr Zakir Nalayak as a State Guest, and he will tell you this discussion in the video is unislamic and against the teaching of Allah.

  • @RaviRJoshi
    @RaviRJoshi 22 дня назад +1

    The quality of STEM education in India outside of cities in significantly below passing grade, as well.

  • @DanishAli-nz3ks
    @DanishAli-nz3ks 23 дня назад

    Being a police person from gilgit baltistan listening to your mind boggling ideas

  • @Elodie12313
    @Elodie12313 24 дня назад +6

    Bahi Zakir Nalayak ko bula lo...3M views aa jayenge 😂😂...
    Wo batyega Evolution, Genetics,Moon Batayenga Acc To Majhab...

  • @jameelhussain7614
    @jameelhussain7614 24 дня назад +2

    میں اس پر ڈیبیٹ کرنے کے لیے تیار ہوں۔ عوام الناس سائنس ہی کیا ہر قسم کی تعلیم سے دور ہو رہے ہیں

  • @ayeshakiranayeshakiran823
    @ayeshakiranayeshakiran823 24 дня назад +2

    Mention pre qualifications to join your teaching course

  • @dharmeshparikh7837
    @dharmeshparikh7837 24 дня назад +4

    Derivative of Sinx is Sinx/x 😂😂 seriously. It's been decade years since I passed 12th, but even I know that it's Cosx. No offense to any pakistani new students, but be careful if you are having such teachers after BSC & MSc passed out professors.

  • @DanishAli-nz3ks
    @DanishAli-nz3ks 23 дня назад

    ❤ u pervaz Sir

  • @Gabbargaamada
    @Gabbargaamada 24 дня назад +2

    We also have the same problem here. Adults calling themselves "bacha"

  • @maharajzutshi2416
    @maharajzutshi2416 22 дня назад +1

    Make Zakir Nayak permanent resident of Pakistan. He will bring you out of all worries😂

  • @chelladuraik8638
    @chelladuraik8638 20 дней назад

    Pakistan is an extension of Punjab and Kashmir. General public are very smart and how come the very basic commonsense reasoning are missing, that too in college level. Difficult to absorb.

  • @Happy.dose99
    @Happy.dose99 19 дней назад +1

    Bhai science aur masalman ...?? Kya mazàk h ,chapti dharti par hi khush rho

  • @UmaShanker-de9gw
    @UmaShanker-de9gw 22 дня назад

    Can undeestand only few likes for this talk

  • @darkmatter253
    @darkmatter253 22 дня назад +1

    This channel 94.5 k subscribers 😊 Jakir Naik ke ek video per million million views 😊 Jai Ho pakistan 🎉 for bright future 😂

  • @pradiptagaurangadas5647
    @pradiptagaurangadas5647 23 дня назад +1

    So many chairs are empty clearly depicts the miserable condition of scientific temper in Terroristan 🇵🇰 In India this type of shows are always more than houseful.

  • @AbbasJafri-y4u
    @AbbasJafri-y4u 19 дней назад

    I think that it is better if books are written in English but terminology and formulas are written in English

  • @ArunGupta-wj1xl
    @ArunGupta-wj1xl 23 дня назад +1

    The condition of Pakistan is so bad; to revive the nation it requires at least 60 years of scientific education and keep Islam at bay. Increasing expenses for education to 6-7% on GDP. India spends 6% of GDP on Education. every day a new University or college is coming out in some place in India is the result.

  • @manteshsharma9351
    @manteshsharma9351 21 день назад

    All my fellow citizens (Indians) here trying to boost their self-esteem seeing how stupid and inefficient Pakistani education system is, how unscientific their teachers are, must realise we ain't here to complete with Pakistan.
    We have a lot of flaws on our own. Our teachers ain't too great either. And please don't bring IITs everywhere. Not even 0.1% of Indian engineers are produced in IITs.
    Come here to learn not for a false ego massage. Develop your own scientific temper. Learn alternative ways to actually learn your respective subjects better. And appreciate the speakers this platform is trying to provide.
    We ain't at the heights most of us try to imply. Aspire to reach there instead of feeling you're there by looking down upon those whom you think are below you!

  • @prabhatsingh513
    @prabhatsingh513 24 дня назад +5

    🤣🤣🤣🤣oo bhai SIN X ka derivative nhi pta

  • @E_CommMicroblogs
    @E_CommMicroblogs 23 дня назад

    "A specie which donate proton called acid" ~Arhenius concept
    i asked my chemistry teacher how can atom donate proton?
    He simply removed one proton from the Nucleus of Sodium (Na).... then remove one electron and told us that's how Na regain their stability i.e 10 protons 10 electrons.
    Nowadays he is head of chemistry department hiring other teachers 😅

  • @vision78678
    @vision78678 22 дня назад +2

    جی ایچ کیو کے جاگنے تک کچھ ممکن نہیں ہے ۔۔کیونکہ نفاذ کے لیے قوت چاہیے جو صرف فوج کے پاس ہے

  • @ajaykumarpal3357
    @ajaykumarpal3357 24 дня назад +1

    Only a few in the classroom.

  • @djawalikar2006
    @djawalikar2006 23 дня назад

    @ Hoodbhoy sir perhaps you have forgotten to ask the ' teesra jinn' to make the people of Pakistan unlearn first. Unless you unlearn things first you can't initiate learning new things.

  • @AkbarAli-cr2yh
    @AkbarAli-cr2yh 23 дня назад +1

    الاهي يه تيري ساده بندي کڏهر جائين
    که سلطاني بهي عياري هئي درويشي بهي عياري

  • @ramanv.r3422
    @ramanv.r3422 21 день назад

    At 31:45 the lady made a profound statement. Students are not trained or encouraged to ask questions. I think the religion plays a role here. May be I am wrong.

  • @MrNirmalkumar4
    @MrNirmalkumar4 23 дня назад

    The solution to Pakistan’s problems is already drawn on the board. It is the Aladdin ka Chirag. All the Pakistani generals have to do is to rub it a few times and lo and behold, there will be a solution.

  • @zaynabismoilova5584
    @zaynabismoilova5584 24 дня назад +1

    👍👍👍👍

  • @ahsanjabbar
    @ahsanjabbar 24 дня назад +2

    why being so pessimistic
    be passionate instead
    life evolves and all roads lead to enlightment
    don't dwell on others being ignorant
    they will also arrive

  • @bharathfsf3686
    @bharathfsf3686 19 дней назад

    Reviving scientific education in Pakistan is easy. You just make them read Carl Sagan books.

  • @MrNirmalkumar4
    @MrNirmalkumar4 23 дня назад +1

    Why do Pakistanis need to know the science of non-believers when they are happy with their flat earth science?

  • @dhananjayvaidya2473
    @dhananjayvaidya2473 21 день назад

    When Zakir naik occupies an audience seat, then even with otherwise empty auditorium you may call yourself successful in this mission of yours.

  • @AIAgentgold
    @AIAgentgold 24 дня назад

  • @anilthapa5631
    @anilthapa5631 24 дня назад +1

    Reviving anything in pakistan is not possible 😢

  • @CaptainOWAIS
    @CaptainOWAIS 24 дня назад

    55:50 wonderfull amazing work

  • @Keyur-Suthar
    @Keyur-Suthar 11 дней назад

    at 32:45 - I am not mocking, A religion/society that does not allow you to question anything Imprints this nature on young minds to not question things, everything is done by almighty at the end. This would happen to any kid who is forced to believe in such foolish ideas no matter what God or religion.

  • @utubetruthteller
    @utubetruthteller 22 дня назад +1

    Islam and science dont go together

  • @podcastcliping
    @podcastcliping 23 дня назад

    Book festival in pakistan: less than 50 Book sold, but people purchaged more than 3000 plate biryani.
    Parvej sir doing well but state honored Dr Zakir naik, it is the bad luck for the people like Parvej sir

  • @MuhammadjavaidSaghir
    @MuhammadjavaidSaghir 22 дня назад

    A very good sitting, a very good projection of the Professor, a very sweet mental acrobat: rather, making fun of the country and countrymen! Sorry to say! The main problem is not the stratum of education, but the Driver ( the Leadership), though, no doubt, Leadership comes through education! But, if even the present fabric of education is materialized, it can be more than enough! But, the Driver is giving Jerks to the Bus( the nation) ! So, I consider the present meeting of the Professor an intellectual shallowness!

  • @musawerkhan1259
    @musawerkhan1259 24 дня назад +2

    Where is the real jin?

  • @unwanted0907
    @unwanted0907 24 дня назад +4

    You are just wasting time ..........

  • @SomnathDe-h7d
    @SomnathDe-h7d 24 дня назад +1

    Pl open a chapter in New Delhi with joint collaboration from someone eminent personality in India.

    • @yjkbuddy
      @yjkbuddy 24 дня назад

      In India we don't need something like this.. Our education and mindset is way forward than Pakistan

  • @umairkhalid6687
    @umairkhalid6687 24 дня назад +2

    PV = nRT
    I think you took n = 1 (if so, then you should have mentioned it) 😂😂😂

  • @sant.76
    @sant.76 18 дней назад

    Online education for science is not fully successful. In India specially for JEE entrance exam any kind of internet uses it completely detrimental.

  • @kashifmogheera
    @kashifmogheera 22 дня назад

    میں ایک سکول کا سائنس میتھ کا ٹیچر ہوں ۔ آپ خلاصہ مافیہ کے کردار پر بھی روشنی ڈالیے ۔ جو ہر سوال کو ذہن میں پیدا ہونے سے پہلے ہی اس کا جواب رٹوا کر مار دیتے ہیں۔

  • @philosopherInmaking
    @philosopherInmaking 24 дня назад +1

    Is it done this late 🙄

  • @jameelhussain7614
    @jameelhussain7614 24 дня назад +1

    جب تک طلبا کو انگریزی میں پڑھایا جائے گا ان کے اندر گہرائی پیدا نہیں ہو سکتی ۔ انگریزی پڑھائیں مگر انگریزی میڈیم سے بچائیں

  • @sridharkaushik9290
    @sridharkaushik9290 23 дня назад

    Hoodhboy is the only sane voice or perhaps one of the very few in Pakistan. He is swimming against a tide. Had Pakistan been interested in Science and modern education, the State would have invited a Tech guru like the CEO of Google or Microsoft to Pakistan and not Zakir Naik!

  • @jameelhussain7614
    @jameelhussain7614 24 дня назад

    ہماری اشرافیہ کو سمجھ نہیں آ رہا کہ انگریزی میڈیم عوام کو علوم کی گہرائی اور لذت سے دور رکھے ہوئے ہے

  • @satkrapp7697
    @satkrapp7697 23 дня назад

    They invite Dr.Zokar Nalayak as state guest & at the same time they talk about scientific education in Pakistan. What a comedy program this is! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @abdulmajidbadini5871
    @abdulmajidbadini5871 23 дня назад

    مذہبی مدارس میں بنیادی سائنس اور ہنرمندی کے علوم سکھائے جائے

  • @rebasingh258
    @rebasingh258 9 дней назад

    Sheikh Chilli key haseen sapney.
    Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy should come yo zindia and teach here. He will be appreciated. In Pakistan no one listens to him.

  • @harshbhartia5052
    @harshbhartia5052 23 дня назад

    the average age of PHD in india is 23 to 30.

  • @ahmedshaharyarejaz9886
    @ahmedshaharyarejaz9886 24 дня назад +1

    رائے کے اظہار کی آزادی اچھی بات ہے، لیکن آپ کے 90 فیصد کمنٹس سیکشن میں بھارتی پاکستانی عوام کا مذاق اڑاتے ہیں۔ یہ ممکنہ سامعین کو دور کرتا ہے۔ براہ کرم ایسے کمنٹس کو ڈیلیٹ کرنا شروع کر دیں تاکہ پاکستان میں آپ کے سامعین میں اضافہ ہو۔

  • @anujay81
    @anujay81 24 дня назад

    Poor attendance for this important topic.

  • @vinodpandey5735
    @vinodpandey5735 22 дня назад

    Zakir have more listeners than Dr.Hoodbouy.

  • @althea_is_smokin_hot
    @althea_is_smokin_hot 21 день назад

    Sir is still worrying about science education after 77 years.
    Start islamic science.

  • @rajaninambiar6444
    @rajaninambiar6444 22 дня назад

    Too little too late 😪

  • @alokagarwal3714
    @alokagarwal3714 20 дней назад

    Make more madarsas and teach earth is flat to revive your religion based science

  • @BijoyHossen-ic7ue
    @BijoyHossen-ic7ue 24 дня назад +2

    😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @abdulmajidbadini5871
    @abdulmajidbadini5871 23 дня назад

    میرا سوال یہ ھے کہ خدا سارے کائنات کا تخلیق کار ھے اور سارے علوم اسکے زیر ھیں تو اسکے اپنے پیغمبران کو مذہبی علوم کے علاوہ سائنسی علامات کی تبلیغ کرنے کو نہیں کہا گیا تاکہ کائنات کو تسخیر کریں

  • @chaisma
    @chaisma 21 день назад

    Ek hi simple jin h,,,,blasphemy law hta dijiye ,,sab kam automatic ho jayenge,,,,,

  • @Kumaar-n9p
    @Kumaar-n9p 22 дня назад

    Waha Zakir naik islamic university kholne ja raha hai pakistan me😂😂😂