@@Laxrocks571 don't talk like that, please, the game was apparently unfair on her, it happens sometimes, I've been the weakest player on my group so I know how hard this can be. Also, it's magic, things don't always work as they should in magic
@@Laxrocks571 I'd love to see how you play her pre-built deck (made by someone else) with those other guys stealing eachother's turns and getting maximum ramp/value out while you draw none of you own. How do you play against people who take 2 extra turns BEFORE the turn cycle ends (effectively cancelling out her mana curve and giving them 2 turns worth of plays while she just watches and waits for a card to ramp/board-wipe), WHILST stealing your lands and creatures? In no universe was she bad, the lads just drew and got way too much value.
I just hope that the CZ guys paid for the travel expenses for their guests to come out and film. Imagine if MTGNerdGirl paid for travel and lodging (assuming she doesn't live in the area), only to get to do almost nothing in the game.
@@Kronical69420 What's wrong with token decks? I've got a couple that produce an army as big as it is strong by turn 4 or 5. I'm popular in my playgroup for mainly running token decks that go ham in different ways
We want a less domineering set of decks or for Nerdgirl to bring a more domineering deck. Also Mindslaver and extra turn cards should be OUTTA it. Extra turns aren't that bad but we saw them abused. Mindslaver is garbage. And I like Amaz as a person, but he's not used to commander. Commander is LEAGUES less competitive than Limited. Tell him to tone the Scamazing and the overvaluing down whenever he plays (or just don't build such overvalued decks; he's a regular top 8 in competition, maybe overvaluing comes too easy)
In his defense the team up against him was pure overkill, and they let Yarok get out of control. Some very poor threat evaluation once Josh was handled.
@@cloudyskiesnow Alchemy, It is the scientific technique of understanding the structure of matter, decomposing it, and then reconstructing it. If performed skillfully, it is even possible to create gold out of lead. However, as it is a science, there are some natural principles in place. Only one thing can be created from something else of a certain mass. This is the Principle of Equivalent Exchange.
Michael Lebovitz if it makes you feel better a few days ago I played Unexpected Results at instant speed for free, pulled Rupture, sacrificed voracious hydra with 16 +1/+1 counters. Mono blue Control player casts Insidious will, other two players both Repeated Reverberation my Rupture. Killing me like 4 times over. This all happened because I convoluted a lotus petal T2 and Negated a different players sol ring T3...
That is very true. The majority of the high cost comes from those very old dual lands and fetch lands, not to mention, expensive instants like force of will or mana drain.
So I had never heard of nerd girl before this, but I liked that she kept her chin up despite getting a real bad beat. I was impressed by her sportsmanship, she just gained a fan. Plz have her back to play for real
@@ThunderfallFilms sometimes when you look around the table and look at the players themselves, they have their hand at angles you can see and it just happens sometimes. I have never seen a game of casual commander where someone has seen someone’s hand by accident or on purpose and actually done something with it. I wouldn’t go so far to call it cheating
@@godfather3916 she glances several times from his face to his hand. That would be at least game loss material in a tourney. I get it’s a casual game but you shouldn’t be obvious about looking at another player’s hand.
Shane ya need to calm down. The minute someone mentions a girl should come back on the show you dig through the archives for a a half assed claim about cheating? Get a life
@@FairchildTom I was calm? I was just pointing out she cheated. Generally that’s not a good thing for somebody to do, especially so blatantly on camera.
Too true. Tryna play a grumgully counters matter deck and my friend spends about 15 minutes on his turn with his Ur dragon deck and kills everyone in one turn. My board state was 3 mountains and 2 forests and Grum. 8 turns in.
in a twist of mind controls, incredible resurrections, time warpings, absurd expenditures of mana, and some birdwatching thrown in there too! coming to your nearest cinema.
Seemed like Globetrotting to quote the Commander VS guys. I originally thought Amaz's commander was weaker than Muldrotha. Now I'm not so sure. Certainly a reason to play no-ETB decks with Hushwing Gryff, Tocatli Honor Guard, and Torpor Orb.
Same! She basically couldn't play anything because of mana drought it suuuuucked! It's one thing to lose because of your own fuck ups. It's another thing to lose when you can't EVEN fuck up, because you can't cast anything!
Sophaurus Well she definitely should get a chance to redeem herself. Even if she doesn't win, it would be great to see her doing stuff, and impacting the game in a big way. I personally would loved to have seen what her deck could actually do.🤷🏾♂️
The decks a mess and (IMO) barely has any Kykar synergy, it's part super friends, part anthem tribal, part storm with no artifact ramp. With a budget like that there is no reason not to run mana rocks and talismans. I just think it was a really bad deck.
Yeah, using Decimate only on Josh's stuff was clearly a wrong move. I don't get why he didn't at least target Tatyova and Guardian Project, instead of letting Amaz draw so much cards. Especially when he planned to keep the lock on Josh anyway. If you intend to use a player as a weapon, why weaken him so much?
If you pay attention, Jimmy is a true red mage. Sometimes he tunnel visions one target a bit too hard. Not trying to be mean Jimmy much love from a huge fan but it is detrimental to your overall success sometimes I feel. On the flipside of that it can happen to anyone, especially when a game is this bonkers. Amaz's deck was also pretty sneaky at times with the value it gave him because it would do a lot of small things that gave enormous rewards seemingly out of nowhere. I have a Yarok deck myself and I can tell you it quietly goes insane sometimes.
I really feel like Jimmy needs to rewatch this episode and learn from his mistakes. Amaz had the most amazing turn after josh did but jimmy decided to slaver lock josh? Possibly the only person that could have stopped Amaz. And seriously, bring MTGNerdgirl back for another episode where she can actually play magic.
Abhrajit Dhar some decks are like that, have you seen moldrotha? What about yarok, all amaz did was have etb lands creatures and effects, look at jimmy, who’s commander literally needs a set up, and had amaz not had an explosive start, he would have run away with the game.
@@twoneraps3352 A lot of people feel that way because some of these games are just *too* convenient on the answers and responses. Sure they're really good at Magic and deck building but we've all had games that were so obviously lopsided and you just hit a pocket of land or missed your drops. Iirc, that never happens in Game Knights. Maybe they play a few games and choose the best one, I'm not really sure. But the staged criticism they receive is from there always being an answer to a game ending play, or the next turn being just as explosive to not let one person get too powerful.
Tam Chu yeah idk why people think it is staged. They actually did a behind the scenes episode and it can be staged but they only re do things to make it look better on camera and such. Everything that happens is real.
In today's episode of Game Knights, Josh plays as Amaz who plays as Josh, meanwhile Jimmy also plays as Josh, then destroys his own life total and exiles his own deck. Oh, and MTGNerdGirl blows up a Necropotence.
Jesus man, that game was crazy oppressive. I feel like if it wasn’t on camera Josh and MtgNerdGirl would have scooped long ago and gone onto other games.
@@Jester4580 I wouldn't say they bullied her specifically. It was more like three superheroes, -villains or -saiyans fighting each other, while a normal human gets caught in the crossfire.
@@malmasterson3890 I don't think so, when this episode came out I was so excited cause I'm an avid fan of amaz and he's definitely all about having fun.
We want a less domineering set of decks or for Nerdgirl to bring a more domineering deck. Also Mindslaver and extra turn cards should be OUTTA it. Extra turns aren't that bad but we saw them abused. Mindslaver is garbage. And I like Amaz as a person, but he's not used to commander. Commander is LEAGUES less competitive than Limited. Tell him to tone the Scamazing and the overvaluing down if whenever he plays (or just don't build such overvalued decks; he's a regular top 8 in competition, maybe overvaluing comes too easy)
@@Camp77777 Which poses the question: Did anyone here actually discuss what kind of powerlevel they were going for this game or did they just build like it's the wild west?
@@UlfMTG Depends on what kind of deck u are playing with Kykar. She didn't get to paly much because her deck was significantly weaker and because her opening hand had no ramp or aanything really good.
@@SystemLost good point. especially since she had to travel and I think they have said before making a game knights takes two days or more for the guests. That's valuable time she could have been streaming or doing anything besides getting steamrolled in this game. IDK why Jimmy/Josh or someone like Ashlen/Murph (to make it more fair) don't review all 4 decks beforehand to make sure no one is seriously at a disadvantage.
@@GM-rs2fv you can check her deck list the only one that seems way out of speck was joshes. The other two are balanced the issue was that the other two decks could leverage joshes deck to advantage themselves plus Josh rushing at the beginning also means that the value decks could build freely
Jimmy: *Destroys Josh's board* Jimmy: "I can use Josh as a weapon against the other player(s)" Bruh. He could have 2v1d Amos bc NerdGirl was so far behind, god that was so sad to watch.
Josh : Crazy early snowball Jimmy : Mindslave Lock Amaz : 500 iq mystic confluence MTG NG : 2 1/1 birds One of these is my spirit animal and it's not like the others.
First, shout out to MTGNerdGirl for being a good sport, especially for her first Commander game. Would have loved to see what her deck was capable of. Second, Amaz was a monster this game. It was insane. Well done! I will say while it was still fun to watch the episode, I feel like this episode illustrates what Josh and Jimmy always talk about regarding the deck power level and how that can affect one’s ability to literally play the game. Seemed like deck power scale was all over the place. I could see how it would get frustrating in a normal playgroup. But at least it made for a unique episode of Game Knights! Thanks again for the episode!
not at all, josh didn't just lose turns, he was actively sabotaged during those turns, not to mention that jimmy's obsession with sabotaging josh on his own turn blinded him to the play that could have saved him that turn.
To me the big mistake was not "using" JLK to disrupt Amaz board state in every possible way and just simply sabotaging Josh. Amaz at that stage in the game was clearly a HUGE threat.
Indeed, I remember thinking at that point of the video that I would seriously consider taking control of Amaz's turn instead. Unfortunately, Jimmy absolutely destroyed Josh, fueled Amaz some more (Ryhstic Studies) and utterly disrupted any sort of power balance there was in the game.
Jimmy: I'll steal your turn Josh: I'll play two more turns! AMaz: I'll anihilate the entire board Nerdgirl: I'll create a bunch of 1/1 birds COOL match. Maybe a little bit unbalanced
@@kal-el-fornia2479 The deck didn't seem terrible to me. It's just that she was playing Boros Signet on turn 7 instead of turn 2. She cast her commander on turn 4 unprotected, with 3 other commanders already on the board. The chance she untaps with it are basically nil but it's probably her only option. For all we know she's got a bunch of haymakers like Cyclonic Rift and Insurrection and stuff to turn the game around once she's pumping mana out of her commander but when your turn 4 play is a 3/3 flier and your opponent responds by casting Plague Wind and Blatant Thievery in the same turn you just aren't winning that game.
@@OMGclueless Her decklist is online, and no insurrection, but she did have cyclonic rift. Overall, I thought her decklist was straight bad. She was running the OG lands, but the build was not that great. She ran only 6 mana rocks compared to 11 planeswalkers. Planeswalkers that didnt really have too much synergy with her commander tbh. It was a bad deck, but what made it worse was how nasty and ruthless the rest of the table was. Hopefully she gets redemption in a future episode.
You can see the decklist is very bad. Lots of big value spells without ramp (with ramp it would be just like the other decks, not competitive, not really strong, but fine is most tables with splashy cards). Kykar is by far the most monstrous general of the four, but you gotta play your storm, and storm is hard, i guess... So you get your storm guy and make a token deck... with 11 planeswalkers... War Ral wihout his combo, even if it would fit perfectly in Kykar... tokens?, 13 freaking creatures... with 12 instants, not one counterspell... and there you go...
He had white sources, they were just trilands, etc. however, there are no trilands that produce colorless mana (unless you count the painlands) and so he needed to put at least 2 wastes in for hardcasting kozilek.
Juan Duarte Mindslaver sucks enough without it happening repeatedly... It's the kind of thing I would have loved as a brand new player, but now that I have been playing for this long, it's like, actually let people play magic. Control decks are fine, but in a friendly game, no jerk cards for jerks. 😂 I love Mel Li
Amaz has big rat bastard energy in this. Waiting silently for Jimmy and Nerdgirl to deal with Josh threat and capitalizing on it while doing jack shit.
I always found Amaz's humour to be annoying when he's streaming, because it just seemed ACTUALLY bitchy/smug with no-one to bounce off, but it just clicks a lot better when he's with people because you realise it isn't serious with it at all. Edit: 48:08 is the perfect example. While streaming, he'd usually just end on the "useless, so he's just a plastic sword", coming across as condescending and bitchy. However, because they can react, he then burst into laughter and you realise it isn't serious at all.
Extra turns can be used: 1)to chain them infinitely, winning on the spot; 2)to ramp and get extra upkeeps/draws/combat steps to close out games Mindslaver can be used: 1)repeatedly on all your opponents, probably (but not 100%) winning on the spot; 2)to spend opponent's resources against other opponents (which defies the point, as it can be done for 0 mana at instant speed via politicking); 3)to be the biggest asshole you can be to a single person you've grown to dislike 4)to get a brief taste of what it's like to play a good deck
there SERIOUSLY needs to be a round 2 of this episode. This wasn't even a match, it was a slaughter. 2 players didn't even get to play the game! rematch people... rematch rematch rematch rematch rematch!!!
Really only nerdgirl didn't get to play. Josh played plenty and took extra turns before he got his turns taken over. Nerdgirl didn't build her deck with enough ramp or card draw .
@@WrathOfEnd Just because she didn't draw into it, doesn't mean she didnt add enough, just means she got real unlucky. Happens to every magic player. Feels bad though and they definitely need a rematch, but one without Amoz in it. Don't want to see that disrespectful douche anywhere near that table again...
@@high1223 Blowing up/taking lands really isn't disrespectful man. Especially when he tutored for them. Or are you referring to something from outside the game?
@@brandog5363 His general attitude of "Oh, I'm already winning, so might as well just grind you into the dirt before finishing you off" is what was disrespectful. Also, everyone knows that you need to be a special kind of asshole to play land hate (outside of that one card you need to deal with maze of ith or dark depths). Mel Li said it best: "What kind of a person doesn't let you use your lands!?"
@@chrisfrommell7767 Pfft, try winning on turn 2 by casting t1 Ad nauseam into a t2 manual storm turn. I've won on t1 before with the same deck, but that game was my favorite of them all.
I know he hates the idea of it, but I would've scooped out of the game when its apparently that I'd keep getting mind slaver'd. If I'm not participating, even if just minimally, then there's no point in playing
I would just pray for the sweet release of death if I was in Josh's position. On the other hand, if the other players were rude enough to drag out the game while continually taking my turns, then I would be rude back and scoop out of spite
So, I've been watching all episodes, one after the other, for the past couple of weeks. First of all you guys are a drug. No, seriously, this format is more addicting than caffeine. I wasn't even a commander player, that's why I discovered you this late... But I'm starting to play the format thanks to you. Thank you for the amazing hard work you've put in it, seeing all the shows in sequence you can clearly tell an incredible progression: amazing job. Love it, take your time, much is needed as we know, but please keep on do it! In the meantime I'll go donate because I can't think of anybody whom deserve better my support. Cheers from Italy
That Decimate ignoring Rhystic Study AND Guardian Project is going to give me nightmares. Also: Jimmy: so everybody, we have to work together as a team to break Josh's unfair lock Everybody: ok Jimmy: tnx, I can finally drop my own unfair lock The famous "Mindslaver self-defense", as per George Orwell
You can really tell jimmy took it to heart when amaz said josh was the stronger player, amaz was clearly ahead of everyone else, yet all his aggro was still towards josh lol
I actually think that's exactly what they're doing. Obviously it's not fun to play against stuff like this but why else would they put those cards in other than to prove a point.
To be fair, isochron sceptor/ dramatic reversal, lots of mana rocks tutor for the land that tutors for artefacts, play a lot of tutors to find dramatic reversal, infinite mana, pst combo (Without the paradox engine now because the rules committee likes to up the price of engine alternatives but has only impacted some less powerful cedh decks like captain sissay) and bobs your uncle.
I mean, he clearly removed Expropriate from his deck, otherwise there's no way he wouldn't have put that on top instead of Aminatou's Augury, right? At least there's some attempt.
This kind of stuff makes Jimmy probably my favourite player on Game Knights. He's always there for a nice, truly unexpectable turn, that won't necessarily be good but definitely surprise everyone
@@Riboflav1n how? There are non basic lands that enter play tapped unless you deal 2 damage to yourself, and produce 2 mana types. Oh, and they share the 2 types that the basic lands that produce those manas would (the shock land that produces red and blue mana for instance is a mountain and an island.)
Especially NerdGirl, must be extremely frustrating to not draw any of your ramp and then even get some mana stuff stolen/blown up when you are on the show for the first time. I think that her deck (and the commander) is probably on the weaker side compared to the other stuff but she could still have done quite a lot I think.
@@danielvelasquez5319 I think this is one of the episodes filmed post Jimmy's movie shoot. he even claims it took him a month or more to get back into the swing.
This was easily the most disgusting match I’ve seen on the show. I mean, three of the decks were capable of locking the game, and the fourth was screwed to begin with. My Timmy heart is bleeding, but my Johnny at lease respects it.
@Kilgor4 what was bad? they are always playing to win, it's just that 2 deck out of 4 are 8-9 on the command zone scale one was a 7 and the other we don't know she did nothing. But that was a really good game, it's the one with the most interaction i've seen on this channel.
@Kilgor4 too be honest almost all episode someone do nothing but the other three did someting great. i agree commentary was worst than the other episode but it was the game with the most powerfull deck. I'm just happy to see deck that are 7-8 on this show.
Lol no it's only a death sentence if you list doesn't even try to make up for it with artifacts. She was running like 4 ramps to signet's a sol ring and a command sphere. She should really have been running the talismans as well plus no tithe nor was she running any blue counters red rituals while feel bad for her looking at her deck list it's clear that she had no idea what her build around was which is why she was running 11 planes walker 6 of which did very little for her
"Always attack the strongest player", attacks Josh. Jimmy: "What?????? I'm insulted!" Josh: "Always has the board state / combos that makes everyone go 3 vs 1 on" That's why, Jimmy. lol.
@@voltcorp That's fair. The deck already has a loop with Living Death/Greenwarden of Murasa, runs Spore Frog and Strip Mine, I figured I don't need to make it even more unfun. Especially since I already pilot a Niv-Mizzet deck that's quite a few steps ahead of what the other players in my group are doing. I want to have decks that can battle with the cEDH player who sneak into the pods at my LGS, but at the same time I don't want the group I usually play with (my son's friends) to hate it when I join them.
this episode auto played today 3/16/2022 after another a video I was watching so I let it run. What a brutal game! golos and Yarok, mindslaver, extra turn spells, decree of silence…it’s like someone made three pubstompers based edhrec salt scores and ambushed nerdgirl under the pretense of some “fun” kitchen table commander. Nerdgirl was a champ for putting up with these jokers :)
Josh: "It really sucks that I'm not getting to play Magic."
NerdGirl: "Am I a joke to you?"
I mean... at least she still had her turns
@@danilooliveira6580 Sort of. Up until every land she played got stolen.
Put that on a t-shirt and sell it. Yeah feel bads
more like, NerdGirl: Hold my beer
30 mins in it was her turn 6 she had 5 lands
That was nice of you guys to invite Nerdgirl to watch y'all play magic
no one told her it was St Patricks Day
That was BRUTAL
I honestly felt really bad for her. Lol.
It was nice for Josh to come watch too lol. I found this episode extremely hilarious to watch.
Although I feel for her I have bad luck with mana ramp in general
I like MTGNerdGirl's turn, it was easy to follow and comprehend what was going on.
Wait, She had a turn?
Wait she played in this ep?
She was actually terrible i hope this is a joke lol
@@Laxrocks571 don't talk like that, please, the game was apparently unfair on her, it happens sometimes, I've been the weakest player on my group so I know how hard this can be. Also, it's magic, things don't always work as they should in magic
@@Laxrocks571 I'd love to see how you play her pre-built deck (made by someone else) with those other guys stealing eachother's turns and getting maximum ramp/value out while you draw none of you own. How do you play against people who take 2 extra turns BEFORE the turn cycle ends (effectively cancelling out her mana curve and giving them 2 turns worth of plays while she just watches and waits for a card to ramp/board-wipe), WHILST stealing your lands and creatures? In no universe was she bad, the lads just drew and got way too much value.
I'm 99% sure what Amaz did there to NerdGirl is considered a war crime in most of the world.
This mana drain on signet was pure disrespect. XD
Beyond foul
Notice you never see Amaz again on game nights lol
@@moedark4390 also nerdgirl
So, Josh learned what it is like to play against Josh.
It felt weird to see so many likes but no comment but i also dont know what to say because you said it all....so hi :)
Josh is the goat tho
I just hope that the CZ guys paid for the travel expenses for their guests to come out and film. Imagine if MTGNerdGirl paid for travel and lodging (assuming she doesn't live in the area), only to get to do almost nothing in the game.
They pay for it
that's so evil and so true.. the like count proves everything.. There was 666 likes when I sent this
“I’m gonna go wide and catch people off guard” -MTG Nerd Girl’s famous last words
I actually died when she played murmuring mystic and Amaz says "Thats pretty good"
I haven't even watched the video yet, but I'm looking forward to seeing what you're talking about, lol
Soon as she said it was a token deck, I think we all knew.
@@Kronical69420 What's wrong with token decks? I've got a couple that produce an army as big as it is strong by turn 4 or 5. I'm popular in my playgroup for mainly running token decks that go ham in different ways
@@pkphantom but a token deck with no doubling season?
Jimmy: Josh is the enemy
Amaz: you played yourself Jimmy
Josh: you played yourself Jimmy
Nerdgirl: Im glad to be here
This is the best take on the episode.
@@Totescolin its so true I think Josh start was scary but his threat assessment was way off as they destroyed his game leaving Amaz to win that game.
This is good but nerdgirl should be : I’m glad to be here( dies as signet is mana drained)
@@buttergod42 Omg Yes lol that was such a mean play by that Amaz made.
We want a less domineering set of decks or for Nerdgirl to bring a more domineering deck.
Also Mindslaver and extra turn cards should be OUTTA it. Extra turns aren't that bad but we saw them abused. Mindslaver is garbage.
And I like Amaz as a person, but he's not used to commander. Commander is LEAGUES less competitive than Limited. Tell him to tone the Scamazing and the overvaluing down whenever he plays
(or just don't build such overvalued decks;
he's a regular top 8 in competition, maybe overvaluing comes too easy)
Amaz:its evil to play extra turns
Also amaz: play agent of treachery to steal lands
Facts AND Acidic slime to destroy lands
And also take an extra turn
turn 2: josh and jimmy playing lands each worth more than my whole commander decks.
Lol
SAME SAME SAME SAME SAME
and both of their turn threes...
My most expensive card is a masters doubling season. so same
Sadly, my most expensive is a scalding tarn I opened
Should definitely be an extra turns episodes with these decks so we can see nerd girl actually play
Seemed like an extra turns game to me!
@@randym5824 I see what you did there.
yes please
Yea, but she needs playable cards, not garbage like draw 4 for 5 mana or a Murmuring mystic
@@petrzitnik9494 It seems like they were on different power levels, maybe they didn't communicate well enough.
Josh: “I’ll take your turn.”
Jimmy “I’ll take your turn.”
Amoz: “I’ll take your turn.”
Nerdgirl: “Do I even get a turn?!”
Turns are for closers
I want to see you in my pants now!!!
Jimmy: I’ll take your turn Josh, and i’ll swing a 1/1 at ur 1/5 nerdgirl
Turns are for casters only
More like nerd girl: I’ll pass the turn
Capitalist Josh: My Turn
Communist Jimmy: *Our* Turn
lol!
That might be one of the best analogies to highlight the corruption of communism.
@@jamessaibot5681 they say on a platform owned by Google.
Hahaha!
Soviet anthem intensifies
Josh: Takes 2 extra turns
Also Josh: WHY CANT I PLAY MAGIC
In his defense the team up against him was pure overkill, and they let Yarok get out of control. Some very poor threat evaluation once Josh was handled.
He took two extra turns, then was forced to give them back later.
@@cloudyskiesnow Alchemy, It is the scientific technique of understanding the structure of matter, decomposing it, and then reconstructing it. If performed skillfully, it is even possible to create gold out of lead. However, as it is a science, there are some natural principles in place. Only one thing can be created from something else of a certain mass. This is the Principle of Equivalent Exchange.
Yeah, he played two extra turns then didnt get other two, so it's perfectly balanced
He took 2 extra turns, his opponents decided to have him lose 5 to 6 turns and shoot him in the spine while they were at it
That was the single most disrespectful Mana Drain I've ever been witness to.
Michael Lebovitz if it makes you feel better a few days ago I played Unexpected Results at instant speed for free, pulled Rupture, sacrificed voracious hydra with 16 +1/+1 counters. Mono blue Control player casts Insidious will, other two players both Repeated Reverberation my Rupture. Killing me like 4 times over.
This all happened because I convoluted a lotus petal T2 and Negated a different players sol ring T3...
That was the single most disrespectful finish to a game I had seen in general. He just took too many "just to make sure steps"
@@CR-kr9cs you definitely deserved it after negating a sol ring. have some class.
@@nicholas8739 Waaaahh! iT mAdE mE uPsEt. hOw DaRe hE WiN tOo mUcH!
Personally, I see it more as a pointless Mana Drain. It wasn't a big spell and he was gonna kill her next turn away
I'd like to see a special episode of Game Knights where any player who was on the show before but, never got off the ground, could be invited.
I want this episode to be C_edh so badly.
Actually they can kinda do it on extra turns.Jimmy played gishath there which didnt preform very well on ixalan episode
Its just Jimmy playing four decks
So we can add Jimmy's rackdos deck?
*Casually looks up prices of cool decks from the video*
*quietly goes to the commanders quarters channel*
You can safely subtract about 800-900 dollars for of duel lands and fetches which they are all running. Nice to have but far from needed
@@mark1A100 that's very true. Thanks for the insight :)
That is very true. The majority of the high cost comes from those very old dual lands and fetch lands, not to mention, expensive instants like force of will or mana drain.
@@Mach9330 bayou costs 200$... Bruh.
@Carlos Acevedo I know, it's still overpriced
Jimmy at 20:38: this is the most oppressive thing I've seen on GK
Jimmy at 33:42: hold my mindslaver
The game was really good though.
This is so me
It was like battle of the titans
So I had never heard of nerd girl before this, but I liked that she kept her chin up despite getting a real bad beat. I was impressed by her sportsmanship, she just gained a fan. Plz have her back to play for real
Completely agree! She was a great sport!
@@ThunderfallFilms sometimes when you look around the table and look at the players themselves, they have their hand at angles you can see and it just happens sometimes. I have never seen a game of casual commander where someone has seen someone’s hand by accident or on purpose and actually done something with it. I wouldn’t go so far to call it cheating
@@godfather3916 she glances several times from his face to his hand. That would be at least game loss material in a tourney. I get it’s a casual game but you shouldn’t be obvious about looking at another player’s hand.
Shane ya need to calm down. The minute someone mentions a girl should come back on the show you dig through the archives for a a half assed claim about cheating? Get a life
@@FairchildTom I was calm? I was just pointing out she cheated. Generally that’s not a good thing for somebody to do, especially so blatantly on camera.
*attacks josh*
"I heard you should hit the best player "
Jimmy: "WHAT HOW"
Also Jimmy: *uses necropotence 25 times in one go*
We've all been in nerdgirls position she has my condolences
Too true. Tryna play a grumgully counters matter deck and my friend spends about 15 minutes on his turn with his Ur dragon deck and kills everyone in one turn. My board state was 3 mountains and 2 forests and Grum. 8 turns in.
Three planeswalkers rend spacetime in massive epic powerplays...
Some birds are there too.
They weren't even there, they were illusions
in a twist of mind controls, incredible resurrections, time warpings, absurd expenditures of mana, and some birdwatching thrown in there too! coming to your nearest cinema.
a reenactment of the brothers war thats this game
Seeing Amaz mana drain NerdGirl's boros signet was the saddest thing I've ever seen
Yarry well, if she had teferis protection. Lock out all options
Seemed like Globetrotting to quote the Commander VS guys. I originally thought Amaz's commander was weaker than Muldrotha. Now I'm not so sure. Certainly a reason to play no-ETB decks with Hushwing Gryff, Tocatli Honor Guard, and Torpor Orb.
@@shayneweyker an upgraded version of Panharmonicon on legs VS a weaker version of Yawgmoth's Will. I'll pick the Panharmonicon on legs.
If you compare Amaz's behavior to another competitive player Melissa - they are totally different.
Once you get down to 1v1, the goal is to end the game ASAP. If that means mana draining a signet, that’s what you do. I know I’ve done it
MTG Nerd Girl needs a redemption invite back. Anything less is unacceptable.
Dude, for real, I know there were nice plays in this episode, but I felt bad all along because she basically couldn't play.
Its really her own fault. She even said she had cards but didnt want to play them because she wanted to wait. Then it was too late.
Same! She basically couldn't play anything because of mana drought it suuuuucked! It's one thing to lose because of your own fuck ups. It's another thing to lose when you can't EVEN fuck up, because you can't cast anything!
@@gordonross3270 but what she probably meant by that is that the cards wouldn't do much without the Commander out. So it was the right play.
I thought the same thing
Bro Jimmy is literally an anime character with the 25 life necropotence plays
Tbf the power of friendship put in work against Josh's board XD
And that anime betrayal from amaz🤣🤣
I highly enjoyed the cameo from MTGNerdGirl, i hope can see her features as a player in the future of Game Knights!
Sophaurus Well she definitely should get a chance to redeem herself. Even if she doesn't win, it would be great to see her doing stuff, and impacting the game in a big way. I personally would loved to have seen what her deck could actually do.🤷🏾♂️
Wait who? I thought it was only Josh, Jimmy and Amaz
Yes true, she got along well with Jimmy too. She was also friendly
Bring MTG Nerd Girl back, she never even got to play, and her deck looks cool!
ubermenschen01 yeah but damn expensive. Look at the lands. The snapcast mage, probably worth 1k
@@Tuturial464 she was the only one that didn't play OG dual lands so...I'd say the other three mana bases were much more expensive
FloppyTaco 6969 her mana base needed more ramp, talisman could have been nice. Maybe a few counterspells would have saved her.
ubermenschen01 Fr tho
The decks a mess and (IMO) barely has any Kykar synergy, it's part super friends, part anthem tribal, part storm with no artifact ramp. With a budget like that there is no reason not to run mana rocks and talismans. I just think it was a really bad deck.
*Amaz draws 16 cards, gains 16 life from landfall triggers*
Jimmy “screw youuuuu Josh!!”
Worst play of the game
Yeah, using Decimate only on Josh's stuff was clearly a wrong move. I don't get why he didn't at least target Tatyova and Guardian Project, instead of letting Amaz draw so much cards. Especially when he planned to keep the lock on Josh anyway. If you intend to use a player as a weapon, why weaken him so much?
If you pay attention, Jimmy is a true red mage. Sometimes he tunnel visions one target a bit too hard. Not trying to be mean Jimmy much love from a huge fan but it is detrimental to your overall success sometimes I feel. On the flipside of that it can happen to anyone, especially when a game is this bonkers. Amaz's deck was also pretty sneaky at times with the value it gave him because it would do a lot of small things that gave enormous rewards seemingly out of nowhere. I have a Yarok deck myself and I can tell you it quietly goes insane sometimes.
I really feel like Jimmy needs to rewatch this episode and learn from his mistakes. Amaz had the most amazing turn after josh did but jimmy decided to slaver lock josh? Possibly the only person that could have stopped Amaz.
And seriously, bring MTGNerdgirl back for another episode where she can actually play magic.
She really doesn't deserve it she made a deck waaay too reliant on her commander
Abhrajit Dhar some decks are like that, have you seen moldrotha? What about yarok, all amaz did was have etb lands creatures and effects, look at jimmy, who’s commander literally needs a set up, and had amaz not had an explosive start, he would have run away with the game.
Well ofc bc they make intentional missplays for the episodes to be more fun to watch its kinda like wwe for magic
Agreed or he could have used josh to focus on amaz 🤦♂️ biggggg misplay
@@abhrajitdhar4628 dont you have to be a virgin somewhere else?
A prime example to show Game Knights are not staged. NerdGirl’s mana screw was so real.
She didn't even get Mana screwed that badly. The other three just ramped like craaaaaazy.
who said it was staged
@@twoneraps3352 A lot of people feel that way because some of these games are just *too* convenient on the answers and responses. Sure they're really good at Magic and deck building but we've all had games that were so obviously lopsided and you just hit a pocket of land or missed your drops. Iirc, that never happens in Game Knights. Maybe they play a few games and choose the best one, I'm not really sure.
But the staged criticism they receive is from there always being an answer to a game ending play, or the next turn being just as explosive to not let one person get too powerful.
@@Joshbobjovi oh I see
Tam Chu yeah idk why people think it is staged. They actually did a behind the scenes episode and it can be staged but they only re do things to make it look better on camera and such. Everything that happens is real.
In today's episode of Game Knights, Josh plays as Amaz who plays as Josh, meanwhile Jimmy also plays as Josh, then destroys his own life total and exiles his own deck. Oh, and MTGNerdGirl blows up a Necropotence.
Solus lmao
Yup, pretty accurate
And exiles an avacyn
SPOILER
oh my god
Jesus man, that game was crazy oppressive. I feel like if it wasn’t on camera Josh and MtgNerdGirl would have scooped long ago and gone onto other games.
Josh couldn't concede. He never had control of his turns at sorcery speed for the last four turns. XD
@@coltsfan354 It's his just deserts for his constant use of Vedalken Orery.
That's why you run green lol
@@coltsfan354 You can concede at any point, not just sorcery speed
@@katherinetraxler1462 House rule on Game Knights is that you can only concede at sorcery speed.
Man you can just see Josh slowly lose his mind as he sits there and watches his world burn down around him
Nerd Girl was such a God sport here. She was smiling up until the very end.
Right? And to think recording the game probably took like 4+ hours. She cast like three cards. I feel for her.
I would rather have someone who id playing
Bring NerdGirl back, she didnt even get to play.
BMUFFINSPINZ agreed
They actually bullied that poor girl. This is probably the worst I have ever felt watching a magic video
Can't just play your commander on curve and lose to one boardwipe tho . . like what
@@Jester4580 I wouldn't say they bullied her specifically. It was more like three superheroes, -villains or -saiyans fighting each other, while a normal human gets caught in the crossfire.
Actually they kind of left her alone until the end.
27:00 "To be fair, YOU having your commander is annoying" I laughed so much! That was very called for.
Agreed. Best moment of the episode.
Amaz: So this is my first commander game ever...
And hopefully last
jurgen maybe not really but he was kind of overpowering. Mtgnerdgirl was very nice to jimmy tho. Also vice versa
You can tell considering his resume and his results that he came to win.
@@malmasterson3890 I don't think so, when this episode came out I was so excited cause I'm an avid fan of amaz and he's definitely all about having fun.
@@Camexagon Really? My apologies then, I'm not all that familiar with the pro circuit and its players.
Interesting choice to do an episode with only three players
Bit weird that they let amaz goldfish for two turns after he had won already.
You spelled two players incorrectly
@@helderboymh That bugged me even more then the power difference in decks
More like 2 players with mind slaver
We want a less domineering set of decks or for Nerdgirl to bring a more domineering deck.
Also Mindslaver and extra turn cards should be OUTTA it. Extra turns aren't that bad but we saw them abused. Mindslaver is garbage.
And I like Amaz as a person, but he's not used to commander. Commander is LEAGUES less competitive than Limited. Tell him to tone the Scamazing and the overvaluing down if whenever he plays
(or just don't build such overvalued decks;
he's a regular top 8 in competition, maybe overvaluing comes too easy)
everyone summoning their decks using a blood sacrifice and entering the darkest pits of hell to use its power
nerd girl: bird wizard! wooo
God I hope that's a loading ready run reference
@@r4diocr4b it is lmao
Damn, I feel bad for MTG Nerdgirl. I hate games where one player doesn't get to do their thing.
Everything she had need her commander. Everyone also ramped super hard, she got left behind... she got yamcha'd
Her decks too weak
Usually prompts an immediate replay in my pods. I’ve been Nerdgirl before and it’s just a no fun game.
@@Camp77777 Which poses the question: Did anyone here actually discuss what kind of powerlevel they were going for this game or did they just build like it's the wild west?
@@elijahdavila3684 yep like they said in their deck building video. NG had a 4 against two 8s and a 9
Josh: "My Commander is Golos, Tireless Pilgrim."
Me: "I'll take things that didn't age well for $200."
That's was the most ruthless, bloodbath of a commander match I've seen on Game Knights!
And I loved it
Yup. A great many things that makes EDH unfun... but yet all those things arent banned but Paradox Engine is.. so very fucking weird.
MTGnerdgirl: yay my land is back!
Amaz: what about no.
i cried lol
I wish we got to see mtgNerdGirl actually play.
Yeah... I hope she comes back a second time.
what happened? did she just not draw any lands? shouldn't a kykar deck be full of cheap cantrip spells?
Nah she didn't draw any lands/ramp
@@UlfMTG Depends on what kind of deck u are playing with Kykar. She didn't get to paly much because her deck was significantly weaker and because her opening hand had no ramp or aanything really good.
I agree! It sucks that she was mana screwed the majority of the game, and I wanted to see how her deck played out, too.
This game really allows me to visualize why Golos is currently banned
39:23 "This is my life now"
Have MTGNerdGirl back! Seeing her board state made me feels bad man.
Someone needs to zoom in crop and make that face a meme.
That was a waste of her time honestly. She didnt have one ounce of fun that game. If she did, she hid it from her face the entire time.
@@SystemLost good point. especially since she had to travel and I think they have said before making a game knights takes two days or more for the guests. That's valuable time she could have been streaming or doing anything besides getting steamrolled in this game.
IDK why Jimmy/Josh or someone like Ashlen/Murph (to make it more fair) don't review all 4 decks beforehand to make sure no one is seriously at a disadvantage.
@@GM-rs2fv i dont think the deck was inferieur, it'sjust bad luck. She didn't draw ramp and missed land drops. So it's sad, bur it happens.
@@GM-rs2fv you can check her deck list the only one that seems way out of speck was joshes. The other two are balanced the issue was that the other two decks could leverage joshes deck to advantage themselves plus Josh rushing at the beginning also means that the value decks could build freely
Bring back MTGNerdGirl, I felt sorry for her not really being able to do anything.
Maaaaaaaaaan, mtgNerdGirl should get an invite back. This episode was kinda sad for her. Oh, when she gets back, invite Day9 along! He's really fun!
I would love to see Sean on again!
I definitely agree. This must've been a really miserable game for her.
After this episode I would be surprised if she accepted it. I know I wouldn't
Josh: playing a five color deck
Also josh: playing wastes
Also Also Josh: Plays no basic plains.
He probably put kozilek in or something
Matthew Wilson yeah he did say he had a bunch of hatemakers and eldrazi definitely do that
They showed that Jimmy made him discard a Kozilek when he had taken over his turn.
@@Wolfen5207 even so he had other lands to produce great, the wastes were unnecessary
Jimmy when all hope is lost: "how did we get here?"
Me, watching in disgust: "YOU did this Jimmy. You doomed everyone."
Iirc Jimmy has done something like this quite a few times. Makes you wonder if he's doing it intentionally.
Sometimes I wonder if he actually thinks before he acts. To many times he has thrown a game by having tunnel vision.
Darian Hair I think he plays that way - he stated many times that he is a red player, more impulsive
Filip Horvath I know a lot of red players that don’t constantly throw the game
FloppyTaco 6969 It’s more that he’s a player that embodies the traits of the color red than a player who plays red decks (though he does that too).
NerdGirl: “everyone’s playing good fair magic”
Josh: “Hold my beer”
Andrew Chugg
Jimmy: Hold my Mindslaver
@@GM-rs2fv Amaz: Okay, I think I will.
Feels like every game Josh brings some broken combo with literally any commander (even though he usually picks the most powerful one available)
Josh: I love not playing magic
Nerd girl: hold my beer
😄 👍
😂🍺
MTGNerdGirl I honestly thought that even if you had the worst game you had the best attitude towards everything
Jimmy: *Destroys Josh's board*
Jimmy: "I can use Josh as a weapon against the other player(s)"
Bruh. He could have 2v1d Amos bc NerdGirl was so far behind, god that was so sad to watch.
Josh : Crazy early snowball
Jimmy : Mindslave Lock
Amaz : 500 iq mystic confluence
MTG NG : 2 1/1 birds
One of these is my spirit animal and it's not like the others.
I think ur hot 🥵
@@evanstark4823 you're weird lol
First, shout out to MTGNerdGirl for being a good sport, especially for her first Commander game. Would have loved to see what her deck was capable of.
Second, Amaz was a monster this game. It was insane. Well done!
I will say while it was still fun to watch the episode, I feel like this episode illustrates what Josh and Jimmy always talk about regarding the deck power level and how that can affect one’s ability to literally play the game. Seemed like deck power scale was all over the place. I could see how it would get frustrating in a normal playgroup. But at least it made for a unique episode of Game Knights!
Thanks again for the episode!
Josh took two extra turns and lost two turns. It’s an even exchange.
How ironic josh’s deck won the game. Well look at the prices go up
A soul for a soul
Perfectly balanced, as all things should be.
not at all, josh didn't just lose turns, he was actively sabotaged during those turns, not to mention that jimmy's obsession with sabotaging josh on his own turn blinded him to the play that could have saved him that turn.
No he made them wait two turns
They made him wait 6 and discard his hand and all his non land cards
The most evil thing that happend in this episode was Mana-draining NerdGirl's Signet. I felt so bad for her.
To me the big mistake was not "using" JLK to disrupt Amaz board state in every possible way and just simply sabotaging Josh. Amaz at that stage in the game was clearly a HUGE threat.
Agreed, it would have saved everyone a lot of trouble by doing so.
yeah absolutely if you have one player on a lock, it doesn't matter if you move him forward.
Indeed, I remember thinking at that point of the video that I would seriously consider taking control of Amaz's turn instead. Unfortunately, Jimmy absolutely destroyed Josh, fueled Amaz some more (Ryhstic Studies) and utterly disrupted any sort of power balance there was in the game.
exactly, Jimmy should have Mind Slaved him instead of Josh.
I disagree. I think mind slaving josh was fine. However he should have pointed most of if not all of josh's resources at amaz
Josh complaining that he didnt get to play magic.
Nerdgirl: ...
Zaylo to be fair, she got to take her turns and didn’t get Mindslaved...
It hits different when someone else prevents you from playing.
@@TheSilverSynchro they got the same number of turn played lol. that's what happen when you start taking extra turn, turn 6
@Kilgor4 Josh is hamming it up for the camera. He's not actually that self-unaware.
@@TheSilverSynchro But then again Josh took two extra turns at the beginning. Meaning Nerdgirl is the only one with the normal amount of turns.
Jimmy: I'll steal your turn
Josh: I'll play two more turns!
AMaz: I'll anihilate the entire board
Nerdgirl: I'll create a bunch of 1/1 birds
COOL match. Maybe a little bit unbalanced
I'll create two 1/1 birds*
@@TheShockingShane I'm surprised that useless deck even managed to do that.
@@kal-el-fornia2479 The deck didn't seem terrible to me. It's just that she was playing Boros Signet on turn 7 instead of turn 2. She cast her commander on turn 4 unprotected, with 3 other commanders already on the board. The chance she untaps with it are basically nil but it's probably her only option. For all we know she's got a bunch of haymakers like Cyclonic Rift and Insurrection and stuff to turn the game around once she's pumping mana out of her commander but when your turn 4 play is a 3/3 flier and your opponent responds by casting Plague Wind and Blatant Thievery in the same turn you just aren't winning that game.
@@OMGclueless Her decklist is online, and no insurrection, but she did have cyclonic rift. Overall, I thought her decklist was straight bad. She was running the OG lands, but the build was not that great. She ran only 6 mana rocks compared to 11 planeswalkers. Planeswalkers that didnt really have too much synergy with her commander tbh.
It was a bad deck, but what made it worse was how nasty and ruthless the rest of the table was. Hopefully she gets redemption in a future episode.
You can see the decklist is very bad. Lots of big value spells without ramp (with ramp it would be just like the other decks, not competitive, not really strong, but fine is most tables with splashy cards). Kykar is by far the most monstrous general of the four, but you gotta play your storm, and storm is hard, i guess... So you get your storm guy and make a token deck... with 11 planeswalkers... War Ral wihout his combo, even if it would fit perfectly in Kykar... tokens?, 13 freaking creatures... with 12 instants, not one counterspell... and there you go...
So josh didn’t put plains in his deck but he put wastes in
Me: *facepalms*
yeah honestly
He prioritized his kozolek over white
Zack Mabben yeah I thought about that about 2 weeks after commenting that
He had white sources, they were just trilands, etc. however, there are no trilands that produce colorless mana (unless you count the painlands) and so he needed to put at least 2 wastes in for hardcasting kozilek.
@@techoutsider5631 so he needed 2 searchable wastes to hardcast one card but not even a single searchable plains for his commanders ability
That was a pretty nice game of 1v1 Commander.
it was 1v1? Looked like Solitaire to me...with three people watching.
Yeah Amaz kinda took all the fun. ☹️
Wasn’t even fun to watch.
@@purplesnowshark6544 scamaz you mean
MTG Commander singleplayer mode.
Lol you could tell on Josh's face that he wanted to choke someone out.
Juan Duarte Mindslaver sucks enough without it happening repeatedly... It's the kind of thing I would have loved as a brand new player, but now that I have been playing for this long, it's like, actually let people play magic. Control decks are fine, but in a friendly game, no jerk cards for jerks. 😂 I love Mel Li
Karma got you nasty Josh.😂
Play 2 extra turns on turn 5
Gets 2 turns to see someone else play his deck
To be fair the two turns that he lost were way more damning than the two he took
@@redtreeman7814 yeaaaah cause they gleefully torched all his resources
Amaz has big rat bastard energy in this. Waiting silently for Jimmy and Nerdgirl to deal with Josh threat and capitalizing on it while doing jack shit.
SCAMAZED
Amaz: I've heard a saying that you always attack the strongest player first.
Jimmy: Yes.
Amaz: So Josh.
Jimmy: OH, I AM INSULTED!
dead 🤣🤣🤣
he knew he was the strongest before josh even did anything lol
dude can tell the future
I have to use this strategy to make people happy when I attack them instead of angry
"Math is for blockers"
I always found Amaz's humour to be annoying when he's streaming, because it just seemed ACTUALLY bitchy/smug with no-one to bounce off, but it just clicks a lot better when he's with people because you realise it isn't serious with it at all.
Edit: 48:08 is the perfect example. While streaming, he'd usually just end on the "useless, so he's just a plastic sword", coming across as condescending and bitchy. However, because they can react, he then burst into laughter and you realise it isn't serious at all.
Man, that game was DIRTY. And I really think that MTGNerdGirl needs to be invited back. She was awesome and she really didn't get to do anything!
Would you even come back if you were her? I wouldnt. Absolutely revolting what happened in those final moments
Josh: * plays two extra turn spells back-to-back *
Also Josh: Man, being Mind Slavered feels really bad.
Yea sucks
😂😂😂🤣😂😂
Extra turns can be used:
1)to chain them infinitely, winning on the spot;
2)to ramp and get extra upkeeps/draws/combat steps to close out games
Mindslaver can be used:
1)repeatedly on all your opponents, probably (but not 100%) winning on the spot;
2)to spend opponent's resources against other opponents (which defies the point, as it can be done for 0 mana at instant speed via politicking);
3)to be the biggest asshole you can be to a single person you've grown to dislike
4)to get a brief taste of what it's like to play a good deck
josh: I don't really have graveyard recursion
josh 10 minutes earlier: I cast rise of the dark realms
I want to like but it's at 69, rules are rules, If I see it above 69 I shall return a reward 1 like and 1 cookie.
@@Fallout3AtWar you may return.
He didn't have that recursion when he said he doesn't have the recursion.
Hope Nerd Girl comes back because she really had a bad time on this episode...
They all had bad times except Amaz
@@MathCraftpro4life123 Eh, Jimmy and Josh both had there, (albeit brief) moments in the sun.
Should have played green
there SERIOUSLY needs to be a round 2 of this episode. This wasn't even a match, it was a slaughter. 2 players didn't even get to play the game! rematch people... rematch rematch rematch rematch rematch!!!
Really only nerdgirl didn't get to play. Josh played plenty and took extra turns before he got his turns taken over. Nerdgirl didn't build her deck with enough ramp or card draw .
@@WrathOfEnd Just because she didn't draw into it, doesn't mean she didnt add enough, just means she got real unlucky. Happens to every magic player. Feels bad though and they definitely need a rematch, but one without Amoz in it. Don't want to see that disrespectful douche anywhere near that table again...
David Futral why disrespectful?
@@high1223 Blowing up/taking lands really isn't disrespectful man. Especially when he tutored for them. Or are you referring to something from outside the game?
@@brandog5363 His general attitude of "Oh, I'm already winning, so might as well just grind you into the dirt before finishing you off" is what was disrespectful. Also, everyone knows that you need to be a special kind of asshole to play land hate (outside of that one card you need to deal with maze of ith or dark depths).
Mel Li said it best: "What kind of a person doesn't let you use your lands!?"
I was excited for a new episode, but there was really only one and a half players who played this game
That's just how the game goes sometimes. It was entertaining to watch all the combos and synergies
truth. when the decks highlighted also cost an absurd amount of $$ it's really hard to accept Commander as a "casual" format. :/.
To be honest, Josh played all the turns he should have played.
I know that is how some games go. I personally have won on turn 6, but these seem like extremely powerful decks.(For the decks that did stuff)
@@chrisfrommell7767 Pfft, try winning on turn 2 by casting t1 Ad nauseam into a t2 manual storm turn.
I've won on t1 before with the same deck, but that game was my favorite of them all.
Oh, we've all been there, MTGNerdGirl. You exhibited excellent sportsmanship. Great game!
Jimmy: “I’m gonna pay 25 life”
*he’s been watching too much cedh hasn’t he*
He paid that life and still managed to last a WHILE!
No amount of cEDH is enough cEDH!
Nah, mehn, it’s just his inner red player kicking in
I thought that was sarcasm when he said that
Lol
He scratches his face, he draws two cards. Sounds like an Un-set activated trigger.
Target player scratches your face: Draw a card
@@TabooX1984 can't have target in an activation cost. sry but i had to :D
@@nesssel 👍 😀
Props to Josh for not flipping the table
You could tell he was using all his self control to avoid it
I know he hates the idea of it, but I would've scooped out of the game when its apparently that I'd keep getting mind slaver'd. If I'm not participating, even if just minimally, then there's no point in playing
I would just pray for the sweet release of death if I was in Josh's position. On the other hand, if the other players were rude enough to drag out the game while continually taking my turns, then I would be rude back and scoop out of spite
in real life this game wouldn't have lasted this long. Everyone would have scooped as soon as Amaz got the mindslaver.
josh? he even played extra turns, the props should go to Nerdgirl
So, I've been watching all episodes, one after the other, for the past couple of weeks. First of all you guys are a drug. No, seriously, this format is more addicting than caffeine. I wasn't even a commander player, that's why I discovered you this late... But I'm starting to play the format thanks to you. Thank you for the amazing hard work you've put in it, seeing all the shows in sequence you can clearly tell an incredible progression: amazing job. Love it, take your time, much is needed as we know, but please keep on do it! In the meantime I'll go donate because I can't think of anybody whom deserve better my support. Cheers from Italy
I don't even play MtG. but I got hooked. lmao.
How are you so relatable, hey from Italy also
That Decimate ignoring Rhystic Study AND Guardian Project is going to give me nightmares. Also:
Jimmy: so everybody, we have to work together as a team to break Josh's unfair lock
Everybody: ok
Jimmy: tnx, I can finally drop my own unfair lock
The famous "Mindslaver self-defense", as per George Orwell
Юлиан Мацкевич +1 Napoleon
Josh; “This is fun, I’m playing Magic.”
NerdGirl; “-.-“
You can really tell jimmy took it to heart when amaz said josh was the stronger player, amaz was clearly ahead of everyone else, yet all his aggro was still towards josh lol
Amaz(and Josh) is exactly the sort of player ProZD had satirized before.
I play groinpuncher
Was Jimmy purposefully playing all of the cards from the "Cards You Shouldn't Play" episode and that article? If so, that's kind of funny.
Nah, just Sorin and Mindslaver. It would have been pretty funny though.
I actually think that's exactly what they're doing. Obviously it's not fun to play against stuff like this but why else would they put those cards in other than to prove a point.
Can we please get shirts with Jimmy's face on them with the text "I'm going to pay 25 life."
Josh: Urza is too powerful
Also josh: I’m taking 3 extra turns and bringing all cards back
To be fair, isochron sceptor/ dramatic reversal, lots of mana rocks tutor for the land that tutors for artefacts, play a lot of tutors to find dramatic reversal, infinite mana, pst combo (Without the paradox engine now because the rules committee likes to up the price of engine alternatives but has only impacted some less powerful cedh decks like captain sissay) and bobs your uncle.
I mean, he clearly removed Expropriate from his deck, otherwise there's no way he wouldn't have put that on top instead of Aminatou's Augury, right? At least there's some attempt.
Jimmy's power move of 25 Cards though...
This kind of stuff makes Jimmy probably my favourite player on Game Knights. He's always there for a nice, truly unexpectable turn, that won't necessarily be good but definitely surprise everyone
Would love to see Day9 Back on here, Sean is such a happy little treasure.
Day9 and Cassius
@@MetalOnyxWolf Day9 and Danny Trejo!
Day9 and Jacob Holloway
I'd love to see him play commander and not those basic starter decks
My dream guest would be Brandon Sanderson but I'm assuming he's too busy writing at every waking moment with how fast he puts out books.
Jimmy: Plays Krosan Verge.
Me: Oh Jimmy must be playing a budget version of his deck.
Jimmy: Fetches for Bayou
Me: Huh
krosan verge is not a budget it is the strongest tutor land in the entire game of magic by far
@@dragullongblackfang8073 it's the fact that he used a budget fetch for the expensive dual land... it's the irony
Yeah no Krosan verge is a worse fetch land than evolving wilds
@@Riboflav1n how? There are non basic lands that enter play tapped unless you deal 2 damage to yourself, and produce 2 mana types. Oh, and they share the 2 types that the basic lands that produce those manas would (the shock land that produces red and blue mana for instance is a mountain and an island.)
@@dragullongblackfang8073 "Budget" referrs to the cards _monetary_ cost.
Good god, you guys must have the patience of saints. I was getting salty and I wasn't even at the table.
Same here.
Yep
Absolutely.
Right?! 😬
Especially NerdGirl, must be extremely frustrating to not draw any of your ramp and then even get some mana stuff stolen/blown up when you are on the show for the first time. I think that her deck (and the commander) is probably on the weaker side compared to the other stuff but she could still have done quite a lot I think.
“Scratch his face, draw two cards. Talk to someone, draw four cards”
-Josh- 😂😂😂
Just woke up. Sees Command zone video. Not disappointed.
Edit: #JusticeForNerdGirl
"#JusticeForNerdGirl" made me laugh so hard
Man i feel like Jimmy gave that game to amaz why destroy smothering tithe why not hit the leyline or the project.
Daniel Velasquez or rhystic
Its because jimmy sucks at magic
Tunnel vision too
Lol like Jimmy bro did you not listen to your own threat assessment video you guys made
@@danielvelasquez5319 I think this is one of the episodes filmed post Jimmy's movie shoot. he even claims it took him a month or more to get back into the swing.
This was easily the most disgusting match I’ve seen on the show. I mean, three of the decks were capable of locking the game, and the fourth was screwed to begin with. My Timmy heart is bleeding, but my Johnny at lease respects it.
Well, a theft oriented deck vs 2 goodstuff decks (and someone who is watching xD), guess who will win
I mean she wasn't really screwed, I don't think she missed any land drops, the other 3 just had insane ramp. FeelsBadMan.
Funny thing is whole was curse right from start
@Kilgor4 what was bad? they are always playing to win, it's just that 2 deck out of 4 are 8-9 on the command zone scale one was a 7 and the other we don't know she did nothing. But that was a really good game, it's the one with the most interaction i've seen on this channel.
@Kilgor4 too be honest almost all episode someone do nothing but the other three did someting great. i agree commentary was worst than the other episode but it was the game with the most powerfull deck. I'm just happy to see deck that are 7-8 on this show.
Josh: Zeus
Jim: Hades
Amaz: Poseidon
Mtgnerdgirl: Human
F
I agree with some of the other comments.
NERDGIRL NEEDS REDEMPTION 😈
I'm hoping they filmed an Extra Turns after this game since it seems like this game went really quickly.
Why??? Cause she's a woman???
@@trafalgarlaw5837 nigga what did u watch she barely played
Jimmy should have done stuff to Amaz's board with Josh's turn.
Should've taken amaz's turn he had way more advantage an josh didn't even control golos. Complete misjudgement in who the real threat was
@@FilthyWeeb27 So Jimmy doing Jimmy?
If he was planning on Slave locking Josh, he shouldn’t be sabotaging joshes board. As his army now fights for Jimmy. Exactly what I was thinking
Thank you, this video taught me that being the only Commander without green in a pod full of green mana is *a death sentence* .
Lol no it's only a death sentence if you list doesn't even try to make up for it with artifacts.
She was running like 4 ramps to signet's a sol ring and a command sphere. She should really have been running the talismans as well plus no tithe nor was she running any blue counters red rituals while feel bad for her looking at her deck list it's clear that she had no idea what her build around was which is why she was running 11 planes walker 6 of which did very little for her
"Always attack the strongest player", attacks Josh.
Jimmy: "What?????? I'm insulted!"
Josh: "Always has the board state / combos that makes everyone go 3 vs 1 on"
That's why, Jimmy. lol.
I have a Muldrotha deck that I have been meaning to add Mindslaver to, but I think I might actually pass.
mindslaver is actually soft banned on my group because of the feelbads
@@voltcorp That's fair. The deck already has a loop with Living Death/Greenwarden of Murasa, runs Spore Frog and Strip Mine, I figured I don't need to make it even more unfun. Especially since I already pilot a Niv-Mizzet deck that's quite a few steps ahead of what the other players in my group are doing. I want to have decks that can battle with the cEDH player who sneak into the pods at my LGS, but at the same time I don't want the group I usually play with (my son's friends) to hate it when I join them.
You're a good person
John Barrie This is what hero’s do. I too am a humble man
LOL mindslaver costs 6 to cast and 4. Theres a good reason why it nevers sees play in cedh.
Boros Signet?
Mana Drain
The bleakest timeline
Welcome to crux of fate.deck
So, aparently, Smothering Tithe is the new vedalken Orrery of Game Knights
this episode auto played today 3/16/2022 after another a video I was watching so I let it run. What a brutal game! golos and Yarok, mindslaver, extra turn spells, decree of silence…it’s like someone made three pubstompers based edhrec salt scores and ambushed nerdgirl under the pretense of some “fun” kitchen table commander. Nerdgirl was a champ for putting up with these jokers :)