I am so glad to see that even someone who knows as much as you, and with all your tools and experience, gets frustrated from time to time trying to figure it out. So, here's to you!
Why are you glad someone is getting frustrated? lol misery loves company. I always end up doing everything three times to get it right, & then I realize I did the wrong thing after all.
After finding everything ok with my transfer case. i was going to open up the rear diff for diagnosing the shuddering in my 4wd. Well, after seeing this video, i guess i d rather leave it alone.
There's always a certain 'family' feel to ETCG's videos. The familiarity of his style makes us feel as though we're coming home to an old friend - a rare gift indeed. That's all before you get into the tuition, which is still - by a clear country mile - the best on RUclips. Long live ETCG!
@@ericthecarguy where are you finding that pinion bearing preload should be 20-25 in lbs. All I’m finding is that it should be 14-17lbs. I’m chasing the same problem you had in my 05 Silverado. I think that I’m going to contact my gear distributor and see what they say.
@@tonyburts7998 this sound is the same thing my 09 Silverado is making. Makes me wonder if the shop I’m waiting for an appointment to take it too, is going to figure out the problem. Odd things always happens to me 😔, just hope it doesn’t cost me a fortune. I’m a disabled mom 58 yrs old, but was married to a mechanic for many years. So I always look for help, he’s now passed away. So I have no help, why I’m here
@@tonyburts7998 I read in my manual for my Ford that the target preload should change depending on if you're trying to re-use bearings and crush sleeves. lower values for re-use.
Yep, I just went through this. I paid an "expert" to install a new to me used diff in my diff housing so he could check backlash, etc. It was noisy. Then I took it back to him a second time and he said it wasn't my diff making the noise, it was the transmission. I paid to have my transmission replaced with another (used) transmission. It still made noise. I spent quite a bit of time researching the issues myself, purchased all new bearing for the diff and assembled it all myself this time. It's quiet now!
How was the bearing replacement? Setting backlash has always kept me from messing with my ring & pinion on my Jeeps, but I don't have nor do I want to spend $1k on a shop replacing this.
@@harvestblades bearing replacement was fairly easy. For the backlash, I pulled the diff myself and just handed it to a transmission shop to do the backlash, then I reassembled.
I've had a very similar issue with my rear diff after swapping it out for an ATB one. It's loud at 70mph driving along a flat road, quiet when accelerating, decelerating or going up a hill. If it's under heavy load it's quiet. This video has confirmed my suspicion that I'm likely to leave it alone!
I can't begin to tell you how much I've struggled with the same thing. Especially with pinion depth, damaging the inner bearing while taking it off to re-shim. I appreciate your videos.
Eric, I've been watching you for over a decade now. I am absolutely blown away with patient you are. You have a gift my friend. Wow! We can all learn from you in so many ways other than just auto mechanics.
This is one of the best vids I’ve seen on auto repair. You’re skills and tool set are beyond the average home mechanic. This is no shade tree project. I understood everything you described so accurately, and have been at the end of a job to find out that wasn’t the fix. I would have lived with the noise after the first tear down. Outstanding job. I’m a subscriber now. Thank you.
From my training working in a bearing shop, it is a bad idea to replace a cone but not the cups in a tapered roller bearing. The races can have microscopic pits or grooves that will cause the rollers to hammer and degrade the bearing at a significantly faster rate than a new cup and cone. Glad you got that sorted out, Eric!!
Great to know you figured out the problem. That's one less thing on your mind to worry about and that's one more things that we learn! Thanks for your effort.
That moment when you want to walk away and you realize...."this thing ain't going to beat me that easy". Then you take a moment and decide "it's getting fixed, regardless if "it" knows that or not. Love this setup of videos. Strongly encourage more like this!
Here a little tip for ya, when you're doing axel bearings, don't soak them in gear oil and install them. I probably sound nuts, but use assembly lube. Reason being is because, if you soak them in gear oil, nine times out of ten by the time you get it back together. All the gear oil is gonna be ran off and when you go to drive it you're gonna be running the bearings dry. I've burnt up I don't even know how many bearings like that because of that reason. I started using assembly lube and I haven't had a issue since.
From my experience majority of acceleration and deceleration noise is ring and pinion. Usually on worn out gear sets or improperly installed gear sets. Couple thou. Makes all the difference sometimes. Bearing noise is usually constant.. if you ever hear a mechanic say they don’t ever make mistakes they’re full of shit. We all do, great video
I ruined a pinion bearing after a clutch dump as it was only noisy on acceleration, replaced it and it's still silent years later. Carrier bearings will give you constant rumbling though
I have been watching Eric's videos for a number of years. I enjoy his videos because he is thorough, careful, and offers good advice. The way he shoots his videos and talks is very good. Kind of a comforting way of speaking is what he does. I used to be an auto mechanic from the tail end of the 70s and through the 80s and 90s before I hung it up. Eric has good methods on how he does his repairs. He is a good mechanic. He has been very helpful during the years when I used fix my kids cars. Oh the things kids can do to their cars! Good job Eric.
If your carrier dropped out it probably was not preloaded properly resulting in too much pinion backlash under load which would cause noisy gears. Those two big holes on each side of housing are for a carrier spread tool to remove carrier assembly. You spread the housing with your dial indicator very carefully to not over spread. This is what preloades this style of diff. Use a long bar after carrier is installed to pry on carrier with dial gauge set to get zero end play and then add proper amount of side shims to get carrier side bearings preloaded.
Hi Eric, I'm from France and I have exactly the same problem on my 1998 Chevy Tahoe. Your video was very helpful and permits to me to gain a lot of time. Nearby 2 years ago I've rebuilt my rear diff I've changed all the bearings, my mesures were very accurate, and my pattern was very nice. But since 6 monthes I've the same noise on my rear end. As you, I Thought that is was comming from pinion bearings, and it has to be my first step to check where does it comes from, I thougt too that it could came from the gears themselves... and that is it! Thanks for all!
I know this is very old but I have this exact problem right now. I have a lot more faith in doing this myself and actually fixing the problem and not just throwing money at a mechanic. Very much appreciate this video and all of your videos.
Great video Eric, though no matter what gear lube you use, even with perfect gear tooth pattern, pinion bearing preload, carrier bearing preload and gear backlash there will always be a slight gear wine on deceleration. It’s normal...... Now that your differential is broken in, readjust your backlash to within the Factory or Gear Manufacturers 0.005” - 0.009” spec and try getting it within the preferred spec which is likely 0.006” - 0.008”. Personally, anything gear backlash between the tight 0.005” and midway point of 0.007” on a GM 10 bolt is good and you’ll still have slight gear wine on deceleration!!! Run it for 500 miles then change your gear lube to remove any wear deposits and go from there with fresh quality 80W-90 or 85W-140 (viscosity is dependent on the temperatures you drive in) synthetic gear lube with LSD additive (4oz is common) if you have a Limited-Slip Differential. I think Eric has just proven that you never mismatch new bearings with old bearing races is not a good idea. Plus, if your gear teeth have any chips, it may cause noise even if everything setup correctly. Also all differentials have a lube oil change interval like other oil change intervals your vehicle needs as maintenance.
I agree. He should run his truck for a few hundred miles, drain the old oil, and readjust tolerances. It's sad that he will have to drain the synthetic oil. However, he'll be happier in the long run. Sorry, Eric. Easy one for you.
@@jeffkelley3419 You really think it was necessary like he did, when he was trying to figure out what was wrong, to dump the new oil when it was brand new and in a broken in assembly and all he did was test drive it?
Hey Eric, I appreciate how open you are and with your experience that you are not afraid to be honest when having an issue or troubles. Something I wasn't sure if you checked but I had this exact same issue with a Silverado. Done plenty of rear ends before never had an issue however one Silverado I did kicked my butt. I had that thing out a million times it felt like. Long story short my preload on the carrier was the issue. I think that may have been your issue too because you mentioned you ended up using the factory shims in the Richmond set up. Long story short I did what you originally did and measured my old preload and stacked shims to obtain the same. Turns out a little bit of fluid/dust between the shims gave me a false reading of more preload. What I ended up doing was cleaning the shims in acetone and measured then separately. I wrote down the measurements and played them out. Than I added off of those figures vs stacking and than seeing how thick they were. I did it each time I took it down until I got the right combo to get the gear lash I wanted. That solves my issue. My theory is my preload was a little loose and that ultimately would cause the ring gear to move away from the pinion on decel which caused the exact same noise. I've never had to go to that detail/trouble before with any other build since. Makes me think the Chevy 8.5/8.6 are just sensitive. I could be wrong but that's my theory. Anyways how is your dad's truck doing? Been a while since we've seen an update on that.
I’m on your side about prior setups. Seemed reasonable. Two years ago I rebuilt my diff with the identical Richmond set, and it’s behaved well. Hope the same with yours..
Had the same noise in me colorado. Though after some digging, seeing this video and remembering repairs I've done to the pinion seal, I have come to the conclusion of water damage to either the gears or pinion bearings as water had been getting into my diff via the diff breather and blowing out the seal. I hope it's just the bearing anyway. I learned more in the video than I have in weeks researching shit I dont understand because of all the bullshit everyone else talks about to sound smart. Cheers mate
Did replacing the bearings and seals solve the problem? I just did all my bearings and seals and I still have this noise the wear pattern is fine and I’m not sure if it’s gears ( backlash and depth being wrong ) or if it’s just noisy from factory
I use the Yukon "super carrier shim kit" and "crush sleeve eliminator" whenever I can on gear installs. You can dial that backlash in where you want. (yes I prefer the tight end of the spec) And no more finger crossing while setting pinion preload.
My Dana 60 calls for 250 on the pinion nut. I had the same experience 10 years ago with Richmond gears, on a semi-floating Dana 60. Seeing those pinion bearings cut leaves me with the impression that the torque specs were off, and it break in the ring and pinion to a whine/houl. By the time you replaced the bearings again, it already existed. Replacing the bearings was necessary, but double check that torque spec. And my videos aren't monetized, so when I say Chinese mil spec is junk, that's exactly what I mean. Japan, Germany, or old stock U.S.A. is all we can hope for, for good mil spec bearing race kits. Good video, guy!
I had the same issue after going from 3.08 to 3.73 with the same diff but in a Tahoe. It was ultimately better after replacing all the bearings a couple times and setting it all to spec but never solved. I traded it off...
Eric, I think your problem might be in the excessive backlash. Every time I built a rear end I’d always shoot to get the backlash within the manufacture specs.. Typically if you could hit the within the specs. you were on the money. Great video as always, thank you sir from Oklahoma 🤠
Yes you are correct , always install new races that come with the bearing and always put a new crush sleeve in never reuse it, i also look at the outside of the pinion races as the diff housing wears and the races will spin or move in the housing .
I have been watching you for so long I learned a lot. A craftsman like you just shows how easy it is to do what you do. If a person really wants to learn a Trade. I have learned a lot. I took an ASE test and passed it for Brake and Suspension Certification. Keep on doing what you do. Thanks
Eric, I have this annoying noise coming from my passenger seat of my 2015 Chevy Silverado, but I have found out that is goes away when I leave my wife at home. Can you help? :)
Well, if you absolutely can't convince your wife not to ride along, duct tape can work wonders. Disclaimer: I take no responsibility for what your wife does do you after you apply the duct tape.
Many a year ago I worked for Ford in their powertrain NVH group and axle whine was a inexact science even on new axles. Visteon (our axle supplier) had an expensive machine called a veritach that would measure the transmissibility error (TE), which is the rotational discrepancy between the pinion and carrier. Even that machine wasn't perfect at predicting axle whine. Axle whine can be a system problem, meaning that the engagement can set off a natural frequency in the axle. Everything from component materials to weight to suspension bushings can affect its severity and manifestation. We used everything from torsional dampers in the driveshafts to "moose balls", which was a tuned damper bolted to the rear end, to improve the noise. Glad you got it fixed; great video 👍
Good video and I love the content! As a guy who does a lot of diffs though, let me say this. 4 thou on the pinion depth is not something I would call "close enough" and move on. And the paint pattern you show at the end confirms. It's close, but I probably would have made a shim adjustment to get that closer. Same with backlash, 11 isn't really what I would call "close enough to 5-9" and leave alone. A few thousandths seems like a silly small amount to be bothered by, but in differential setup it really does make a difference. Regardless, glad to see you got the problem fixed!
I appreciate all of his hard work and time spent , and shared his journey with us . Even though it was a little noisy , it probably would have been ok . I thought the same thing from the very beginning, ring gear end play excessive . In hindsight I guess that even if ya have to take your thicker shim to a machine shop and have it ground to get the clearance at the bottom of spec ,,, it's the right thing to do. If that was a High performance car , it would have scattered the gear ! Thanks Eric
Thanks for this video. I have the same noise with my Mustang as I hear in the beginning of this video, and the same issue of it increasing with deceleration. Was contemplating doing it myself until I watched all the tools and knowledge required. Am so proud of you for your persistence and payoff, you're so inspiring and easy to learn from. I love your axle cam! 😄 Thanks for enlightening my evening and at the very least giving me the assurance, that, yes, that noise is in the differential.
The mechanics shanty. What’s That Noise in My Differential? What’s That Noise in My Differential? What’s That Noise in My Differential? Early in the morning!
@@hornetkeeperh Wife says come to bed, it's midnight, Wife says come to bed, it's midnight, Wife says come to bed, it's midnight, Early in the morning!
Work for a truck manufacturer in Sweden and I assembled the differential and now I work as an operator manufacturing the pinions and gear. Point of contact is very important but what will make that sound is the chipped tooth without a doubt. When we test the gears in a sound machine just a small strand of hair at the edges can make it sound very bad. I figured it out though and installed new pinion and gear so everything was fine after that 👍🏻
Going thru a 2001 Silverado rear end right now. It is the open rear end and the smaller bevel gears both had most of the teeth breaking off the outer edge. Your video was a big help in what to look for and what to expect. Thanks
"Differential fluid is one of my favorite smells" until you said "Not" I was just stunned. I mean putrid rotting skunk sprayed onions would probably be more pleasant than that stuff. Ick.
Some GM AcDelco fluid smells like Grapes... Yes really, its scented. You can still pick up a little whiff of the normal gear oil smell under the grape smell though.
Nice work getting to the bottom of that one. Based on an experience I had 20 years ago, I would've sworn it was pinion nut torque that was the issue. I had an '86 Grand Marquis (exactly like the one I own now, only dark blue instead of light blue) that I changed the pinion seal on. After the job, on the test drive, I got an awful howl on decel. I ended up just having to turn the nut another 1/8th of a turn tighter, and the noise was 100% gone. Of course, this was with well worn-in ring and pinion gears - 230k miles at that time. I swapped the carrier in my '07 Silverado last year after a routine spill-and-fill turned up a bunch of metal stuck to the magnet inside. Closer inspection revealed that nearly all the teeth on my side gears were shed right off! 97k miles - they sure don't build stuff like they used to! I bought this truck spankin' new, and I haven't the slightest idea when this happened, or when it started - the diff was completely silent in all modes of operation, and never gave me a hint of any trouble. I installed an OX air locker, and set the preload pretty tight at .004" - the very bottom of the spec. I have a nearly imperceptible howl at light throttle settings that goes away upon the slightest loading in each direction, accel, or decel. Running Amsoil Severe Gear 75w-110, since I haul cars every so often. It's not something I'm going to chase, because I think it's due to moving the mating of the ring and pinion out of the already established wear pattern. Only a ring and pinion swap would cure it completely. Recently I had a '95 Volvo 940 wagon come in the shop with rear end shudder that would happen only when on the brakes, and just before a stop. On the lift, the whole housing would violently shake! I can't for the life of me figure out what is causing this! I pulled an axle - bearings and races look perfect. Had the cover off, and everything looks good there. All the support arms have good bushings in them, so there's no strange pinion angles happening. I would think if this were a bearing issue, we'd hear noise - it's silent, until just before the vehicle stops. The problem is exacerbated using the parking brake. Starting to wonder if maybe I have overlooked a bad rear u-joint? Differentials are amazing pieces of engineering! I would have never attempted my own install of that Ox Locker had I not seen your Fairmont and the truck vids. I just had to see someone else do it first, and that gave me the confidence to go for it. THANKS Eric!! 👍🍻 And you and the family have a great Independence Day.
My friend is having the same issue on his '90 Mercedes E300. I'm glad you are so thorough, because the diff rebuild video and this one will help him out a lot. Thanks, Eric
I will never disassemble or work on a differential. Having said that, I couldn’t wait to watch you do it and I couldn’t stop until I saw it all the way through to the end! I like what one of the other commentators said about you having a familiar family friend charm! That’s a very apt description of your style.
Didn’t get to the end but this is extremely common with certain manufacturers of gear sets. Richmond gears tend to whine ALOT due to how they are cut. Motive gears are much quieter.
Just watching this & the noise is exactly the same we used to have with some straight cut gears in the 70's -80's. It was the gear teeth bottoming out in the opposite gear. slightly relieving the tips of the gears & undercutting the oposite groove always worked. Utter pain to do though.
"Okay Eric we'll send you a new set. Thanks, bye!...Hey Frank! You still got that pinion set that you dropped off the truck? I got someone who'll take it!"
Eric: The suggestion to use synthetic oil I didn't agree with. The manufacturer used hypoid gear oil & it didn't make noise & doesn't in millions of differentials.. If synthetic oil had cured the noise, I would still be scratching my head when they buried me ! Great video, & as always, I learned something. Thanks Eric
I had a rear end that sounded like you were banging on the frame with a hammer every rotation it made. I didn't take it apart to see what was wrong I just replaced it with a junkyard one.
I appreciate your video and the honesty of your presentation. I like the detail and efforts to make sure we can see the important aspects. My grandfather would say to me there may not be enough time to do the job right the first time but always time to do the job over.
4 года назад+14
When you said differential fluid was your favorite smell i was thinking you were some maniac lol. Good thing it was a joke. That stuff is ronchy, and then when the diff goes out, ah man that swamp water smell is just torture.
Tell me, I changed my clutch in my FTW diesel and y trenny was bad so i bought a new (used) one from a car that have sat for almost 10 years. I got the trenny checked and it was just fine but the guy that I was checking the trenny with said that by the smell and color of the fluid it may only had 1 fluid change (in 23 years). BOY that smell was hard hitting.
I reckon that Castrol Limited Slip 90 gear oil actually smells good. Other brands I've tried have been the total opposite. Real nasty like rotting mucus or something.
I did that with a rear wheel bearing on a front wheel drive Horizon, I reused the old outer race with the new bearing. The result was it kept loosening up for about a year due to accelerated wearing, then it settled down and was good for the rest of the car life. So I concurr, change the whole bearing and do not reuse the old race.
I have the same noise in the rear of a Dodge truck. I had a mechanic disassemble and inspect it because I had plans for a motor swap. The noise was slightly different after it was reassembled with synthetic oil. It has about 6000 miles and still has not changed. The motor swap was completed about 4500 miles ago. It had a 4.7 and now sports a 6.4 Hemi. Sounds like I need a different gear set as well from your video. I had suspected the pinion bearings same as you. Anyway, well done sir.
20:36 every lip on "inside" portion of those teeth is raised, as if someone had smashed it with a hammer (absurd comparison). Note how the cut marks travel up, so that wasn't a factory thing, this was something that was raised in use...could it be ...that there's an angle of contact issue here, like a defective case or defective ring gear seat? Because that would cause excessive noise. These gears are extremely finicky and demand very precise angles of contact both in the ring's plane and the pinion gear's. The way i see that gear, it's almost as if the contact was done only on the inside (towards the bearing), with rotation upsetting metal, raising those lips on each of the teeth. This would also explain the chips. You're essentially asking an elephant to walk on ballet shoes. You can clearly see the difference between the new and old gear.
The old gear was like that out of the box, see the previous videos linked in the description. I wish I had smoothed out those chips before installation as that might have solved the problem from the get go. As for measurements, as you can see in the video I was pretty much bang on since the beginning with the exception of backlash. Note that the backlash was the same on both gear sets though. Still, I learned a great deal during this struggle and now I have a new tool that I can use on the next set of gears. So much of what I do is sharing my experiences with this stuff so that viewers know what to look for when they go to do this work. In a way, my experience is their experience. Some people see that as me not knowing what I'm doing, but in truth, I show my failings so that others don't have to suffer the same fate. Thanks for your comment.
@@ericthecarguy I still believe the new set was fabricated better. The teeth weren't so sharp. The old one looked like it was designed for a jet turbine, but that metal is probably titanium or something similar. I'm more comfortable with the new set. And, hey, it's not my truck. : \
I never tire of your videos. When I seen this Chevy getting some attention I just had to tune in. I've had my 1988 Cheyanne reworked with 4.56 gears in the back. I'm running 35 12.50 RL 15 tires. Since I didn't replace the front gears placing it in four wheel drive is useless. My issue is trying to find out the original gears that came in this model truck. I had written Monster Transmission since I had purchased a new transfer case from them, but I guess folks are still not getting back to work yet to answer my question.
Replaced my diff after watching your original video and had the same noise The gear set is currently Richmond excel but if I end up swapping the gear set again I’m just taking it to the shop to have it done because I’ve had it with the rear end project Thanks for your informational videos and updates though your knowledge is definitely appreciated
As soon as I heard that noise I knew right away. Gears. Only because in the Mustang world we’ve been dealing with Motive brand gears always being whiney just like that on coast. Which is why I don’t buy Motive. Glad you got it sorted. Rear end wind bugs me like nails on a chalkboard.
I actually noticed in your first video series that you installed the carrier bearings flush with the stub, instead of tight against the shoulder. As when you pushed them on, you didn't use anything to push the bearings past flush. I would think this would potentially leave a few thousandsth of gap between the bearing and the shoulder that it is suppose to rest on. That would also explain why when you tried to use the same shims that was origninally in it, they were too tight. Just wondering if this had anything to do with it?
the high backlash clearance puts more load on the ends of the teeths on the pinion bearing, hence why the chipping and noise. Tooth pattern was spot on but it was riding too much on the ends of the teeths on pinion.
Excellent video Eric. The take-away for me was whether or not it's worth tracking down and solving such a noise given the cost of finding it and curing it. Mostly I'd say not. I had a vehicle with a noisy diff that ran well with the noise (it did get louder over the years) for nearly 100,000 miles. Passengers would say 'what is that noise - do you have a bearing on the way out?' and I found that regular oil changes kept my mind happy even though I knew the diff was in need of work. Of course, if the vehicle was going to be raced or used to haul heavy loads I would have been anxious but otherwise; no. Nevertheless a great video albeit an expensive fix in terms of time and money.
I heard a clunk sound today during a turn. Sounded like it was from driver side. Differential has fluid on outside. Whole thing needs attention I know. Your video is excellent. I like that you saw it through to the end Two thumbs up!!!
Hi, now I am Leery about changing my Diff. My truck is a one wheel diff. I purchased a Tru-Track diff for it. I have all the equip to do it, but this video makes me rethink what I am doing!!
Just allow yourself plenty of time to work and be patient. If you can, track down one of those pinion depth gauges as it takes a lot of the guesswork out. That said, if you're only changing the differential, you really won't have to worry about the pinion at all. You just swap the ring gear onto your new diff. Good luck.
It may be that there is something more Eric's new and old subscribers could learn from this. I know I did. This seems like a straight-forward operation with the right tools and a little patience.
I just did my first set of ring and pinion gears in my 84 GMC Sierra classic 1500. It had 2.73 gears in it originally so that's what I put back in it. I bought a set from O'Reilly Auto Parts made by Motive Gear and installed new pinion bearings and races... I checked everything several times and all my specs were good... took it for a test drive and heard that exact same noise that's in your video. Immediately came home, put it back on jack stands and check everything again... put new fluid back in it and I still have the same noise... I really hope my noise is caused by the same thing.
I have known guys to rely on the gear pattern past for ever. It’s how we were tough in college back in the day. I agree with those who have been saying your way of presenting and persisting in showing how to solve a particular problem is second to none. Thanks Eric.
Really helpful. I have the 1999 LS 4X4 full size pickup and I have to diagnose the issue with my rear differential, however. I won't have to do any of the rear-end stuff this will be the pinion gear and ujoints. This video was very helpful. Thanks a lot..
At first I couldn't figure out what the noise or problem was, but then you finally got it sorted out, only then could I tell the difference in the noise.
Great video. I've got the same noise and believed it was my gear set. Installed motive racing gears and were noisy, then swapped for Yukon gears which i heard were better. Started with way less noise but still had some, 6 months later I feel it's the same noise level as the motives. Sad that I have OCD and can't not notice it every day...
I talked to a very knowledgeable older drag racer when I built my 10 bolt and he told me to set the backlash on the tight side for street and loose for racing. My first install was with a motive gear set. Made bad noises. Switched to nitro gear with no more noise
Depends on stick/transbrake vs stalled auto and a bunch of other stuff. Depends on the intended usage. High shock load then 12 seconds of running needs different specs than highway heat building.. Gear composition as well setup. Just like an engine, horses for courses.
I've seen a few of your videos and have been impressed. I also have had this exact complaint and noticed the finish of the wear pattern on the gears. Like you said, not a durability issue but still not a happy customer. I'm sure the added cost of new gears was a big issue at the time of the original bearing repair.
Eric, you need a lower range torque dial gauge and have to measure carrier bearing preload either by case spread or cumulative rotational torque of the pinion.
Im not a mechanic and i dont have an issue with my differential, BUT, i watched the whole thing, twice! lol Very good ,informative video. You sir were made for this . Thanks
We have the same problem with 2 of our old machines that take change gears. You have one gear that's just worn different and even if the meshing looks perfect, they will make a loud noise but it has never hurt any of gear sets.
I think you installed it better than most. Not a stretch to think you got a iffy gear set. Good video especially for those who wonder how all that works back there as most folks never even swap the oil. 😬.
I especially enjoy these episodes with your dads truck because I also have a GMT400, BUT the body on his truck is SO much nicer than mine. If I remember it started out in Chicago as a delivery truck, salt on the roads...
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
the fix was right in front of you the entire time.. more volume on that radio!!
Lol
@@louiswhetsell1144 thanks for your input.....
until one day... and with luck the wrong day...
Bro wth 🤣
🤘
I am so glad to see that even someone who knows as much as you, and with all your tools and experience, gets frustrated from time to time trying to figure it out. So, here's to you!
Anyone who says they don't is likely stretching the truth.
Why are you glad someone is getting frustrated? lol misery loves company. I always end up doing everything three times to get it right, & then I realize I did the wrong thing after all.
After finding everything ok with my transfer case. i was going to open up the rear diff for diagnosing the shuddering in my 4wd. Well, after seeing this video, i guess i d rather leave it alone.
@@Salmon_Rush_Die Knowing that even Eric gets frustrated helps me feel one tiny bit less stupid, after I stop cursing.
There's always a certain 'family' feel to ETCG's videos. The familiarity of his style makes us feel as though we're coming home to an old friend - a rare gift indeed. That's all before you get into the tuition, which is still - by a clear country mile - the best on RUclips. Long live ETCG!
Thank you!
It feels like we’re hanging out at his shop
@@ericthecarguy where are you finding that pinion bearing preload should be 20-25 in lbs. All I’m finding is that it should be 14-17lbs. I’m chasing the same problem you had in my 05 Silverado. I think that I’m going to contact my gear distributor and see what they say.
@@tonyburts7998 this sound is the same thing my 09 Silverado is making. Makes me wonder if the shop I’m waiting for an appointment to take it too, is going to figure out the problem. Odd things always happens to me 😔, just hope it doesn’t cost me a fortune. I’m a disabled mom 58 yrs old, but was married to a mechanic for many years. So I always look for help, he’s now passed away. So I have no help, why I’m here
@@tonyburts7998 I read in my manual for my Ford that the target preload should change depending on if you're trying to re-use bearings and crush sleeves. lower values for re-use.
Yep, I just went through this. I paid an "expert" to install a new to me used diff in my diff housing so he could check backlash, etc. It was noisy. Then I took it back to him a second time and he said it wasn't my diff making the noise, it was the transmission. I paid to have my transmission replaced with another (used) transmission. It still made noise. I spent quite a bit of time researching the issues myself, purchased all new bearing for the diff and assembled it all myself this time. It's quiet now!
Ugh pretty sure I'm in the same situation, guy told me it was the trans but I'm like 90% sure it isn't but at the time I didn't know.
A mechanics stethoscope can save you a lotta money plus warn you of upcoming failures!
How was the bearing replacement? Setting backlash has always kept me from messing with my ring & pinion on my Jeeps, but I don't have nor do I want to spend $1k on a shop replacing this.
@@harvestblades bearing replacement was fairly easy. For the backlash, I pulled the diff myself and just handed it to a transmission shop to do the backlash, then I reassembled.
I've had a very similar issue with my rear diff after swapping it out for an ATB one.
It's loud at 70mph driving along a flat road, quiet when accelerating, decelerating or going up a hill. If it's under heavy load it's quiet.
This video has confirmed my suspicion that I'm likely to leave it alone!
I can't begin to tell you how much I've struggled with the same thing. Especially with pinion depth, damaging the inner bearing while taking it off to re-shim. I appreciate your videos.
Eric, I've been watching you for over a decade now. I am absolutely blown away with patient you are. You have a gift my friend. Wow! We can all learn from you in so many ways other than just auto mechanics.
Meh, it's all in the editing. Thanks for watching!
This is one of the best vids I’ve seen on auto repair. You’re skills and tool set are beyond the average home mechanic. This is no shade tree project. I understood everything you described so accurately, and have been at the end of a job to find out that wasn’t the fix. I would have lived with the noise after the first tear down. Outstanding job. I’m a subscriber now. Thank you.
From my training working in a bearing shop, it is a bad idea to replace a cone but not the cups in a tapered roller bearing. The races can have microscopic pits or grooves that will cause the rollers to hammer and degrade the bearing at a significantly faster rate than a new cup and cone. Glad you got that sorted out, Eric!!
Great to know you figured out the problem. That's one less thing on your mind to worry about and that's one more things that we learn! Thanks for your effort.
That moment when you want to walk away and you realize...."this thing ain't going to beat me that easy". Then you take a moment and decide "it's getting fixed, regardless if "it" knows that or not.
Love this setup of videos. Strongly encourage more like this!
Thank you! Glad you like them.
Here a little tip for ya, when you're doing axel bearings, don't soak them in gear oil and install them. I probably sound nuts, but use assembly lube. Reason being is because, if you soak them in gear oil, nine times out of ten by the time you get it back together. All the gear oil is gonna be ran off and when you go to drive it you're gonna be running the bearings dry. I've burnt up I don't even know how many bearings like that because of that reason. I started using assembly lube and I haven't had a issue since.
From my experience majority of acceleration and deceleration noise is ring and pinion. Usually on worn out gear sets or improperly installed gear sets. Couple thou. Makes all the difference sometimes. Bearing noise is usually constant.. if you ever hear a mechanic say they don’t ever make mistakes they’re full of shit. We all do, great video
My 96 SS Impala is making d same noise think it's d same problem he's having??
Maybe the mechanic didn't make a mistake but his parents did?
I was curious about the torque spec not being right. It wasnt just a little òff, it was quite a bit under. Jus' sayin...
I ruined a pinion bearing after a clutch dump as it was only noisy on acceleration, replaced it and it's still silent years later. Carrier bearings will give you constant rumbling though
@@mikebaz7843replaced what exactly? Im having noise between 20-50mph, and as i slow down
I have been watching Eric's videos for a number of years. I enjoy his videos because he is thorough, careful, and offers good advice. The way he shoots his videos and talks is very good. Kind of a comforting way of speaking is what he does. I used to be an auto mechanic from the tail end of the 70s and through the 80s and 90s before I hung it up. Eric has good methods on how he does his repairs. He is a good mechanic. He has been very helpful during the years when I used fix my kids cars. Oh the things kids can do to their cars! Good job Eric.
If your carrier dropped out it probably was not preloaded properly resulting in too much pinion backlash under load which would cause noisy gears. Those two big holes on each side of housing are for a carrier spread tool to remove carrier assembly. You spread the housing with your dial indicator very carefully to not over spread. This is what preloades this style of diff. Use a long bar after carrier is installed to pry on carrier with dial gauge set to get zero end play and then add proper amount of side shims to get carrier side bearings preloaded.
Hi Eric, I'm from France and I have exactly the same problem on my 1998 Chevy Tahoe.
Your video was very helpful and permits to me to gain a lot of time.
Nearby 2 years ago I've rebuilt my rear diff I've changed all the bearings, my mesures were very accurate, and my pattern was very nice.
But since 6 monthes I've the same noise on my rear end. As you, I Thought that is was comming from pinion bearings, and it has to be my first step to check where does it comes from, I thougt too that it could came from the gears themselves... and that is it!
Thanks for all!
I hope this video was helpful? God bless you Eric! You really solve much doubt about differential...
I know this is very old but I have this exact problem right now. I have a lot more faith in doing this myself and actually fixing the problem and not just throwing money at a mechanic. Very much appreciate this video and all of your videos.
Great video Eric, though no matter what gear lube you use, even with perfect gear tooth pattern, pinion bearing preload, carrier bearing preload and gear backlash there will always be a slight gear wine on deceleration. It’s normal......
Now that your differential is broken in, readjust your backlash to within the Factory or Gear Manufacturers 0.005” - 0.009” spec and try getting it within the preferred spec which is likely 0.006” - 0.008”.
Personally, anything gear backlash between the tight 0.005” and midway point of 0.007” on a GM 10 bolt is good and you’ll still have slight gear wine on deceleration!!!
Run it for 500 miles then change your gear lube to remove any wear deposits and go from there with fresh quality 80W-90 or 85W-140 (viscosity is dependent on the temperatures you drive in) synthetic gear lube with LSD additive (4oz is common) if you have a Limited-Slip Differential.
I think Eric has just proven that you never mismatch new bearings with old bearing races is not a good idea. Plus, if your gear teeth have any chips, it may cause noise even if everything setup correctly. Also all differentials have a lube oil change interval like other oil change intervals your vehicle needs as maintenance.
I agree. He should run his truck for a few hundred miles, drain the old oil, and readjust tolerances. It's sad that he will have to drain the synthetic oil. However, he'll be happier in the long run. Sorry, Eric. Easy one for you.
@@jeffkelley3419 You really think it was necessary like he did, when he was trying to figure out what was wrong, to dump the new oil when it was brand new and in a broken in assembly and all he did was test drive it?
Both of the gears had chips in them. Spinning at thousands of rpm, out of balance parts are likely to "sing". Thats what ive been taught.
Hey Eric,
I appreciate how open you are and with your experience that you are not afraid to be honest when having an issue or troubles. Something I wasn't sure if you checked but I had this exact same issue with a Silverado. Done plenty of rear ends before never had an issue however one Silverado I did kicked my butt. I had that thing out a million times it felt like. Long story short my preload on the carrier was the issue. I think that may have been your issue too because you mentioned you ended up using the factory shims in the Richmond set up. Long story short I did what you originally did and measured my old preload and stacked shims to obtain the same. Turns out a little bit of fluid/dust between the shims gave me a false reading of more preload. What I ended up doing was cleaning the shims in acetone and measured then separately. I wrote down the measurements and played them out. Than I added off of those figures vs stacking and than seeing how thick they were. I did it each time I took it down until I got the right combo to get the gear lash I wanted. That solves my issue. My theory is my preload was a little loose and that ultimately would cause the ring gear to move away from the pinion on decel which caused the exact same noise. I've never had to go to that detail/trouble before with any other build since. Makes me think the Chevy 8.5/8.6 are just sensitive. I could be wrong but that's my theory.
Anyways how is your dad's truck doing? Been a while since we've seen an update on that.
I’m on your side about prior setups. Seemed reasonable. Two years ago I rebuilt my diff with the identical Richmond set, and it’s behaved well. Hope the same with yours..
Had the same noise in me colorado. Though after some digging, seeing this video and remembering repairs I've done to the pinion seal, I have come to the conclusion of water damage to either the gears or pinion bearings as water had been getting into my diff via the diff breather and blowing out the seal.
I hope it's just the bearing anyway.
I learned more in the video than I have in weeks researching shit I dont understand because of all the bullshit everyone else talks about to sound smart.
Cheers mate
Did replacing the bearings and seals solve the problem? I just did all my bearings and seals and I still have this noise the wear pattern is fine and I’m not sure if it’s gears ( backlash and depth being wrong ) or if it’s just noisy from factory
@@ThatKZ900LTD it did. My pinion bearings was rooted. Haven't had am issue since now.
I use the Yukon "super carrier shim kit" and "crush sleeve eliminator" whenever I can on gear installs. You can dial that backlash in where you want. (yes I prefer the tight end of the spec) And no more finger crossing while setting pinion preload.
My Dana 60 calls for 250 on the pinion nut. I had the same experience 10 years ago with Richmond gears, on a semi-floating Dana 60. Seeing those pinion bearings cut leaves me with the impression that the torque specs were off, and it break in the ring and pinion to a whine/houl. By the time you replaced the bearings again, it already existed. Replacing the bearings was necessary, but double check that torque spec. And my videos aren't monetized, so when I say Chinese mil spec is junk, that's exactly what I mean. Japan, Germany, or old stock U.S.A. is all we can hope for, for good mil spec bearing race kits. Good video, guy!
I had the same issue after going from 3.08 to 3.73 with the same diff but in a Tahoe. It was ultimately better after replacing all the bearings a couple times and setting it all to spec but never solved. I traded it off...
Sorry to hear it. I hope you have a better truck, now.
@Nick J What was I suppose to do with it?... Keep it forever? NO. I traded it to a GM dealer who has the capability to correctly solve the issue.
Great video man. I respect a man that can reveal hurdles of troubleshooting and not be prideful.
Wish I had this video as an introduction when I tried my first dif rebuild. Well done Eric.
I have a Ram 1500 and it has this same noise. It just started noticing it. I'm glad I came across this video.
Eric, I think your problem might be in the excessive backlash. Every time I built a rear end I’d always shoot to get the backlash within the manufacture specs.. Typically if you could hit the within the specs. you were on the money. Great video as always, thank you sir from Oklahoma 🤠
Eric theres a trick i used on a noisy rear diff. Couple small tubes of graphite powder. It helped. The reason is it fills in any slight imperfections.
Very informative as always! I've never been confident setting up rear and this is why haha
Yes you are correct , always install new races that come with the bearing and always put a new crush sleeve in never reuse it, i also look at the outside of the pinion races as the diff housing wears and the races will spin or move in the housing .
I didn't like how that old pinion gear looked at all. You just got a better quality gear set the second time around.
YES, WAS NOT HIS MECHANICAL SKILLS IT WAS THE BAD PART.
I have been watching you for so long I learned a lot. A craftsman like you just shows how easy it is to do what you do. If a person really wants to learn a Trade.
I have learned a lot. I took an ASE test and passed it for Brake and Suspension Certification. Keep on doing what you do. Thanks
Thank you, and congratulations on passing your ASE test!
Eric, I have this annoying noise coming from my passenger seat of my 2015 Chevy Silverado, but I have found out that is goes away when I leave my wife at home. Can you help? :)
Well, if you absolutely can't convince your wife not to ride along, duct tape can work wonders. Disclaimer: I take no responsibility for what your wife does do you after you apply the duct tape.
Divorce
I try try ty
@@russlehman2070 duck tape fixes everything
Dont have this issue on mine. Made damn sure of that!
Many a year ago I worked for Ford in their powertrain NVH group and axle whine was a inexact science even on new axles. Visteon (our axle supplier) had an expensive machine called a veritach that would measure the transmissibility error (TE), which is the rotational discrepancy between the pinion and carrier. Even that machine wasn't perfect at predicting axle whine. Axle whine can be a system problem, meaning that the engagement can set off a natural frequency in the axle. Everything from component materials to weight to suspension bushings can affect its severity and manifestation. We used everything from torsional dampers in the driveshafts to "moose balls", which was a tuned damper bolted to the rear end, to improve the noise. Glad you got it fixed; great video 👍
Fascinating. Thanks for that info.
Good video and I love the content!
As a guy who does a lot of diffs though, let me say this. 4 thou on the pinion depth is not something I would call "close enough" and move on. And the paint pattern you show at the end confirms. It's close, but I probably would have made a shim adjustment to get that closer. Same with backlash, 11 isn't really what I would call "close enough to 5-9" and leave alone. A few thousandths seems like a silly small amount to be bothered by, but in differential setup it really does make a difference.
Regardless, glad to see you got the problem fixed!
I appreciate all of his hard work and time spent , and shared his journey with us . Even though it was a little noisy , it probably would have been ok . I thought the same thing from the very beginning, ring gear end play excessive . In hindsight I guess that even if ya have to take your thicker shim to a machine shop and have it ground to get the clearance at the bottom of spec ,,, it's the right thing to do. If that was a High performance car , it would have scattered the gear ! Thanks Eric
Thanks for this video. I have the same noise with my Mustang as I hear in the beginning of this video, and the same issue of it increasing with deceleration. Was contemplating doing it myself until I watched all the tools and knowledge required. Am so proud of you for your persistence and payoff, you're so inspiring and easy to learn from. I love your axle cam! 😄 Thanks for enlightening my evening and at the very least giving me the assurance, that, yes, that noise is in the differential.
The mechanics shanty.
What’s That Noise in My Differential?
What’s That Noise in My Differential?
What’s That Noise in My Differential? Early in the morning!
Wife comes in, says I smell of oil
Wife comes in, says I smell of oil
Wife comes in, says I smell of oil, Early in the Mornin
@@hornetkeeperh Wife says come to bed, it's midnight,
Wife says come to bed, it's midnight,
Wife says come to bed, it's midnight,
Early in the morning!
Are you sure that clamp is tight
Sure I'm sure that clamp is tight
I'll swab that coolant up just right early in the morning!
That's tenacity
Work for a truck manufacturer in Sweden and I assembled the differential and now I work as an operator manufacturing the pinions and gear. Point of contact is very important but what will make that sound is the chipped tooth without a doubt. When we test the gears in a sound machine just a small strand of hair at the edges can make it sound very bad. I figured it out though and installed new pinion and gear so everything was fine after that 👍🏻
* u figured
Eric: I am closing this chapter for now.
Also Eric: *with disassembled differential* this is where I am now.😂
Take a break, get some food, get some rest, and start fresh tomorrow. Good luck!
@@ericthecarguy How about go around the shop and pick- up the tools and parts ?
Going thru a 2001 Silverado rear end right now. It is the open rear end and the smaller bevel gears both had most of the teeth breaking off the outer edge. Your video was a big help in what to look for and what to expect. Thanks
"Differential fluid is one of my favorite smells" until you said "Not" I was just stunned. I mean putrid rotting skunk sprayed onions would probably be more pleasant than that stuff. Ick.
Some GM AcDelco fluid smells like Grapes... Yes really, its scented. You can still pick up a little whiff of the normal gear oil smell under the grape smell though.
Need that smell to warn you the Pinon seal leaks and throws differential oil on the muffler!
Nice work getting to the bottom of that one. Based on an experience I had 20 years ago, I would've sworn it was pinion nut torque that was the issue. I had an '86 Grand Marquis (exactly like the one I own now, only dark blue instead of light blue) that I changed the pinion seal on. After the job, on the test drive, I got an awful howl on decel. I ended up just having to turn the nut another 1/8th of a turn tighter, and the noise was 100% gone. Of course, this was with well worn-in ring and pinion gears - 230k miles at that time.
I swapped the carrier in my '07 Silverado last year after a routine spill-and-fill turned up a bunch of metal stuck to the magnet inside. Closer inspection revealed that nearly all the teeth on my side gears were shed right off! 97k miles - they sure don't build stuff like they used to! I bought this truck spankin' new, and I haven't the slightest idea when this happened, or when it started - the diff was completely silent in all modes of operation, and never gave me a hint of any trouble. I installed an OX air locker, and set the preload pretty tight at .004" - the very bottom of the spec. I have a nearly imperceptible howl at light throttle settings that goes away upon the slightest loading in each direction, accel, or decel. Running Amsoil Severe Gear 75w-110, since I haul cars every so often. It's not something I'm going to chase, because I think it's due to moving the mating of the ring and pinion out of the already established wear pattern. Only a ring and pinion swap would cure it completely.
Recently I had a '95 Volvo 940 wagon come in the shop with rear end shudder that would happen only when on the brakes, and just before a stop. On the lift, the whole housing would violently shake! I can't for the life of me figure out what is causing this! I pulled an axle - bearings and races look perfect. Had the cover off, and everything looks good there. All the support arms have good bushings in them, so there's no strange pinion angles happening. I would think if this were a bearing issue, we'd hear noise - it's silent, until just before the vehicle stops. The problem is exacerbated using the parking brake. Starting to wonder if maybe I have overlooked a bad rear u-joint?
Differentials are amazing pieces of engineering! I would have never attempted my own install of that Ox Locker had I not seen your Fairmont and the truck vids. I just had to see someone else do it first, and that gave me the confidence to go for it. THANKS Eric!! 👍🍻 And you and the family have a great Independence Day.
wow you would go nuts with my diff. yours is quit compared to mine
My friend is having the same issue on his '90 Mercedes E300. I'm glad you are so thorough, because the diff rebuild video and this one will help him out a lot. Thanks, Eric
If you can, find one of those pinion depth tools. Extremely helpful. Linked in the description.
Pinion had summer teeth, made ol' girl talk with a lisp
I will never disassemble or work on a differential. Having said that, I couldn’t wait to watch you do it and I couldn’t stop until I saw it all the way through to the end! I like what one of the other commentators said about you having a familiar family friend charm! That’s a very apt description of your style.
Thank you!
This gives me an idea for a collaborative series "Eric consults with Eric" on head scratchers. ETCG and South Main.
Didn’t get to the end but this is extremely common with certain manufacturers of gear sets. Richmond gears tend to whine ALOT due to how they are cut. Motive gears are much quieter.
I always thought eric the car guy was eric from south main auto. Lmao
my old '86 C10 got the same noise but i know is my 34 years old set of gear that make it this! thx for sharing this is very helpful!
Haha, just discovered this dude has his shop 7 miles from my house. Passed it the other day. Small world. Im in Reading lol
Wow.. I never knew that. I live a few exits up from his shop just off 275. Never knew he was in Cincinnati
Lucky bass
Just watching this & the noise is exactly the same we used to have with some straight cut gears in the 70's -80's. It was the gear teeth bottoming out in the opposite gear. slightly relieving the tips of the gears & undercutting the oposite groove always worked. Utter pain to do though.
So clean under there!!👌
Well you definitely did what you could do to the best of your ability. I’m inspired by the dedication you gave to fixing it. Kudos to you!
"Okay Eric we'll send you a new set. Thanks, bye!...Hey Frank! You still got that pinion set that you dropped off the truck? I got someone who'll take it!"
Hil-larious!
Funny, I had a similar thought but kept it to myself.
ROFLMAO!!!
Eric: The suggestion to use synthetic oil I didn't agree with. The manufacturer used hypoid gear oil & it didn't make noise & doesn't in millions of differentials.. If synthetic oil had cured the noise, I would still be scratching my head when they buried me ! Great video, & as always, I learned something. Thanks Eric
I had a rear end that sounded like you were banging on the frame with a hammer every rotation it made. I didn't take it apart to see what was wrong I just replaced it with a junkyard one.
Great man,great display of patience and not giving up, you are blessed with a great gift and knowledge,and it is trait to share knowledge
"Well that was easy enough" said no car mechanic ever except ERICTHECARGUY
'bout right!
I appreciate your video and the honesty of your presentation. I like the detail and efforts to make sure we can see the important aspects. My grandfather would say to me there may not be enough time to do the job right the first time but always time to do the job over.
When you said differential fluid was your favorite smell i was thinking you were some maniac lol. Good thing it was a joke. That stuff is ronchy, and then when the diff goes out, ah man that swamp water smell is just torture.
Tell me, I changed my clutch in my FTW diesel and y trenny was bad so i bought a new (used) one from a car that have sat for almost 10 years. I got the trenny checked and it was just fine but the guy that I was checking the trenny with said that by the smell and color of the fluid it may only had 1 fluid change (in 23 years). BOY that smell was hard hitting.
@@eaglefeather Wha'dya expect from dead dinosaurs and manure?
@@jeffkelley3419 gas smells better xD
I reckon that Castrol Limited Slip 90 gear oil actually smells good. Other brands I've tried have been the total opposite. Real nasty like rotting mucus or something.
I did that with a rear wheel bearing on a front wheel drive Horizon, I reused the old outer race with the new bearing. The result was it kept loosening up for about a year due to accelerated wearing, then it settled down and was good for the rest of the car life. So I concurr, change the whole bearing and do not reuse the old race.
My guess would be on the edges of the chipped pinion gear, that must make some local vibration resulting in the sound.
A case where maybe you shouldn't let the chips fall where they may. : o
They don’t touch the ring gear.
I have the same noise in the rear of a Dodge truck. I had a mechanic disassemble and inspect it because I had plans for a motor swap. The noise was slightly different after it was reassembled with synthetic oil. It has about 6000 miles and still has not changed. The motor swap was completed about 4500 miles ago. It had a 4.7 and now sports a 6.4 Hemi. Sounds like I need a different gear set as well from your video. I had suspected the pinion bearings same as you. Anyway, well done sir.
20:36 every lip on "inside" portion of those teeth is raised, as if someone had smashed it with a hammer (absurd comparison). Note how the cut marks travel up, so that wasn't a factory thing, this was something that was raised in use...could it be ...that there's an angle of contact issue here, like a defective case or defective ring gear seat? Because that would cause excessive noise. These gears are extremely finicky and demand very precise angles of contact both in the ring's plane and the pinion gear's.
The way i see that gear, it's almost as if the contact was done only on the inside (towards the bearing), with rotation upsetting metal, raising those lips on each of the teeth. This would also explain the chips. You're essentially asking an elephant to walk on ballet shoes.
You can clearly see the difference between the new and old gear.
The old gear was like that out of the box, see the previous videos linked in the description. I wish I had smoothed out those chips before installation as that might have solved the problem from the get go. As for measurements, as you can see in the video I was pretty much bang on since the beginning with the exception of backlash. Note that the backlash was the same on both gear sets though. Still, I learned a great deal during this struggle and now I have a new tool that I can use on the next set of gears.
So much of what I do is sharing my experiences with this stuff so that viewers know what to look for when they go to do this work. In a way, my experience is their experience. Some people see that as me not knowing what I'm doing, but in truth, I show my failings so that others don't have to suffer the same fate.
Thanks for your comment.
@@ericthecarguy I still believe the new set was fabricated better. The teeth weren't so sharp. The old one looked like it was designed for a jet turbine, but that metal is probably titanium or something similar. I'm more comfortable with the new set. And, hey, it's not my truck. : \
@@jeffkelley3419 Night and Day difference in the manufacturing quality of those 2 sets.
I never tire of your videos. When I seen this Chevy getting some attention I just had to tune in. I've had my 1988 Cheyanne reworked with 4.56 gears in the back. I'm running 35 12.50 RL 15 tires. Since I didn't replace the front gears placing it in four wheel drive is useless. My issue is trying to find out the original gears that came in this model truck. I had written Monster Transmission since I had purchased a new transfer case from them, but I guess folks are still not getting back to work yet to answer my question.
deceleration is often to much tolerance / tooth pattern, im also thinking gearset mismatch. You likely got a badly machined gearset.
What about acceleration only? I've seen that yal have mentioned deceleration in particular twice now
Replaced my diff after watching your original video and had the same noise
The gear set is currently Richmond excel but if I end up swapping the gear set again I’m just taking it to the shop to have it done because I’ve had it with the rear end project
Thanks for your informational videos and updates though your knowledge is definitely appreciated
Learned a bunch. Thank you!
As soon as I heard that noise I knew right away. Gears. Only because in the Mustang world we’ve been dealing with Motive brand gears always being whiney just like that on coast. Which is why I don’t buy Motive. Glad you got it sorted. Rear end wind bugs me like nails on a chalkboard.
I actually noticed in your first video series that you installed the carrier bearings flush with the stub, instead of tight against the shoulder. As when you pushed them on, you didn't use anything to push the bearings past flush. I would think this would potentially leave a few thousandsth of gap between the bearing and the shoulder that it is suppose to rest on. That would also explain why when you tried to use the same shims that was origninally in it, they were too tight. Just wondering if this had anything to do with it?
I appreciate you posting these videos where things haven't gone quite right. Thanks Eric!
Same dilemma with my significant other. Years have i tried to solve it. I came to the conclusion years ago there will always be a little whining ◑﹏◐
Try given it a good wack with ball peen hammer..if the wineing continues use larger hammer and more force..it will stop
the high backlash clearance puts more load on the ends of the teeths on the pinion bearing, hence why the chipping and noise. Tooth pattern was spot on but it was riding too much on the ends of the teeths on pinion.
Excellent video Eric. The take-away for me was whether or not it's worth tracking down and solving such a noise given the cost of finding it and curing it. Mostly I'd say not. I had a vehicle with a noisy diff that ran well with the noise (it did get louder over the years) for nearly 100,000 miles. Passengers would say 'what is that noise - do you have a bearing on the way out?' and I found that regular oil changes kept my mind happy even though I knew the diff was in need of work. Of course, if the vehicle was going to be raced or used to haul heavy loads I would have been anxious but otherwise; no. Nevertheless a great video albeit an expensive fix in terms of time and money.
It really is about picking your battles isn't it?
@@ericthecarguy Yes, definitely! :-)
I heard a clunk sound today during a turn. Sounded like it was from driver side. Differential has fluid on outside. Whole thing needs attention I know. Your video is excellent. I like that you saw it through to the end Two thumbs up!!!
yep, I just been there in april, same "dancing with a wolf" noise auuuuuuuuuuuuuu :)
Hi, now I am Leery about changing my Diff. My truck is a one wheel diff. I purchased a Tru-Track diff for it. I have all the equip to do it, but this video makes me rethink what I am doing!!
Just allow yourself plenty of time to work and be patient. If you can, track down one of those pinion depth gauges as it takes a lot of the guesswork out. That said, if you're only changing the differential, you really won't have to worry about the pinion at all. You just swap the ring gear onto your new diff. Good luck.
Seems like that pinion gear all nicked and mating poorly to the ring gear.
Would've lived with it on an old truck, doing this 3 times no way.
It may be that there is something more Eric's new and old subscribers could learn from this. I know I did. This seems like a straight-forward operation with the right tools and a little patience.
I just did my first set of ring and pinion gears in my 84 GMC Sierra classic 1500. It had 2.73 gears in it originally so that's what I put back in it. I bought a set from O'Reilly Auto Parts made by Motive Gear and installed new pinion bearings and races... I checked everything several times and all my specs were good... took it for a test drive and heard that exact same noise that's in your video. Immediately came home, put it back on jack stands and check everything again... put new fluid back in it and I still have the same noise... I really hope my noise is caused by the same thing.
Why did the alcoholic chase the car down the street?
Because there was a wine in the diff.
So frustrating, all that work and then it's still making a whining noise. Good you fixed it in the end.
Hey where's my digital cake it's my birthday 🎂😁
I do that on my ETCG1 channel not here. ruclips.net/user/ETCG1
Happy Birthday!
I had his channels mixed up too. His budget is bigger over on his ETCG1 channel, so that's where he can afford the cakes.
Happy birthday your face
I have known guys to rely on the gear pattern past for ever. It’s how we were tough in college back in the day. I agree with those who have been saying your way of presenting and persisting in showing how to solve a particular problem is second to none. Thanks Eric.
I admire your tenacity and technical skills. Always a learning experience watching your videos. Thank you very much.
Really helpful. I have the 1999 LS 4X4 full size pickup and I have to diagnose the issue with my rear differential, however. I won't have to do any of the rear-end stuff this will be the pinion gear and ujoints. This video was very helpful. Thanks a lot..
Thanks again and your attempts at objectively! New tools, new measurements, oil, parts, and installation, etc.
At first I couldn't figure out what the noise or problem was, but then you finally got it sorted out, only then could I tell the difference in the noise.
Great video. I've got the same noise and believed it was my gear set. Installed motive racing gears and were noisy, then swapped for Yukon gears which i heard were better. Started with way less noise but still had some, 6 months later I feel it's the same noise level as the motives. Sad that I have OCD and can't not notice it every day...
8:20 Yes it is, my personal opinion.
Lovely to see the truck, very nice build. Good quality content.
Thank you!
I talked to a very knowledgeable older drag racer when I built my 10 bolt and he told me to set the backlash on the tight side for street and loose for racing. My first install was with a motive gear set. Made bad noises. Switched to nitro gear with no more noise
Depends on stick/transbrake vs stalled auto and a bunch of other stuff. Depends on the intended usage. High shock load then 12 seconds of running needs different specs than highway heat building.. Gear composition as well setup. Just like an engine, horses for courses.
I've seen a few of your videos and have been impressed. I also have had this exact complaint and noticed the finish of the wear pattern on the gears. Like you said, not a durability issue but still not a happy customer. I'm sure the added cost of new gears was a big issue at the time of the original bearing repair.
Eric, you need a lower range torque dial gauge and have to measure carrier bearing preload either by case spread or cumulative rotational torque of the pinion.
Thanks for the videos, brother. Even though most don't pertain to my vehicles, they're informative and enjoyable.
Thank you for watching!
Im not a mechanic and i dont have an issue with my differential, BUT, i watched the whole thing, twice! lol
Very good ,informative video.
You sir were made for this .
Thanks
We have the same problem with 2 of our old machines that take change gears. You have one gear that's just worn different and even if the meshing looks perfect, they will make a loud noise but it has never hurt any of gear sets.
Eric, I do most, if not all, of my own car work but this video is just another remind that I never want to do a ring and pinion.
I think you installed it better than most. Not a stretch to think you got a iffy gear set. Good video especially for those who wonder how all that works back there as most folks never even swap the oil. 😬.
The technical quality of yor videos has become so good. Excellent lighting, sound + editing. Thanks for sharing.
I especially enjoy these episodes with your dads truck because I also have a GMT400, BUT the body on his truck is SO much nicer than mine. If I remember it started out in Chicago as a delivery truck, salt on the roads...