StarTalk Podcast: Cosmic Queries - Out There with Neil deGrasse Tyson
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- Neil deGrasse Tyson, co-host Harrison Greenbaum, and astrophysicist Janna Levin answer questions on the far away and the far out, including Andromeda's impending collision with the Milky Way, white holes, a holographic universe, and more. Prepare to get trippy!
Support us on Patreon: / startalkradio
Subscribe to StarTalk: ruclips.net/user/startalk...
Follow StarTalk:
Twitter: / startalkradio
Facebook: / startalk
Instagram: / startalkradio
About StarTalk:
Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up!
#StarTalk #NeildeGrasseTyson #Science 
Наука
![A Day To Remember: Feedback [OFFICIAL VIDEO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/iXVnysmQ4e0/mqdefault.jpg)
Man that lady is the type you wanna drop a bottle of wine with and just talk and talk listen even more. Amazing guest!!!!
That and I'd like to listen to her voice after a bottle of wine.
Yeah but then watch some anime and play videogames please
I feel the exact way.
It's the grace, elegance, beauty, feminine, intelligence vibes that emanates from her.
I love it!
@@michaelnafari2032 Let's be real here.
Yup, she is extremely smart.
More of this, make Janna a recurring co-host, and godspeed.
like her space travelor outfit. check out those boots. very down town. like irrational numbers at 27 min.
I love Janna, she has a way with words
Jean you have beautiful eyes
One of my favorite queries editions! Janna went into such technical detail that I had to get acclimated, first, but it just got SO INTERESTING! Can't wait to see her again! And, Harrison is one of the few comedians I've seen who (like Chuck Nice) can really hold his own in this room. I want to see him again! :-)
Janna is awesome! Love her on the podcast!!
Neil and Janna together make for a great science talk and convo!
Often the case when the educated impart their knowledge on the eager albeit ignorant.
Love listening to people who talk when they actually have something to say
I love you Janna Levin. Such a beautiful mind!
Neil is legitimately more of a comedian than the "comedian"
Actually that’s not entirely fair since the comedian is probably constrained as to interruptions whereas Neil is not since it’s his show.
Yup
Honestly Neil doesn't need a comedian's assistance to make the show pleasant.
In fact (yes I am going to go there...) the comedians he hosted so far are rrrrreally making it hard for me to watch/listen to the show as much as I want to!
Please +StarTalk change the format!
@@IbizanHound2 ikr. They just make stupid partisan political jokes which i don't entirely mind except that's all they are and they're no where close to funny
HIs intelligence and wit is well above any comedian.
Neil is such a perfect person to host a science podcast, not only does he know what he's talking about but his ability to carry and direct a conversation is amazing.
"We are prisoners of the present, forever trapped between a past we cannot access and a future we cannot see." T-Shirt please.
Actually the present and the future are one and the same. With every tick of the clock we are at once in the present and the future.
T shirt for Joseph's comment
@@hypolitej Only if you are glitching.
I was going through comments and the second he started saying that I started reading this comment
Joseph's comment brings this video full circle. At the beginning of the video, they're talking about how skimming the event horizon of a black hole you would see the entire lifetime (the future) of the universe. At the end of the video, they were talking about the finite universe where walking from one point in a straight line, you would eventually catch up to the light of your galaxy (the past) where you would see yourself as a child. It gives us a sliding scale of how far into the future or past we wish to travel, but in either direction, it's only visible to us and we're not partaking in it nor can we change it. Ergo, we really are the prisoner of our own time.
That is, if I understood this correctly :)
Don't forget to vote for StarTalk! We're in first... but not by much. wbby.co/vote-pod18
Update... we won!!!! Thank you all for your support!
Yes ofcourse
Why not
The guy in the green shirt may have triggered some social conservatives. Be wary
when are u back on NAT GEO ???
Done
50 minutes of Neil, Yay! I prefer my science with less political commentary regardless of who or what party is mentioned, the science is less polluted that way. Other than that this was an awesome episode!
@Dan Tayler Dan Tayler I actually don't like Trump and agree with the quips the comedian made, I just don't like seeing science polluted with politics. I would have said the same if he had commented on Clinton, or anyone else political in nature, instead. I didn't say anything about supporting or opposing abortion, libtards, or religion. Please do not include me in such behavior as it furthers the divide in this country
@@StonedRedneckMarine i know, same, it was tacky and cringe, so cringe and..hes kinda not funny..like at all, wtf??
Neil and Janna combo are best❤️
Would help if the "comedian" wasn't there spewing out political bias every few mins
other than that the show was great
@@whyf9902 yes, harrison was a bad addition to the show
loved Ms.Janna Levin freaking out even Tyson there! Wonderful !
A huge thank you to StarTalk for making this Cosmic Queries available. As like with Carolyn Porco, Richard Feynman, and Carl Sagan's talks, just to name a few, it is a joy to listen to Neil and to Janna talking about what is known about the universe as well as about the natural phenomena which fills it. 🌻
I love u Janna!! Love how you narrate on universe documentaries !!! I want to fly around the universe with you and have you talk to me about all the secrets and mysteries !!!!! Lol
Other than the comedian, this show is brilliant !
鄭明耀 he was good. Not Chuck good but he did alright
Agreed, I'm an Aussie and I want want to know what side he's on but he made sure I did 3 times.
He wasn't even funny, he should stick to magic tricks.
Omg I wonder what political affiliation that comedian has???
Stick to magic tricks buddy, you're not funny and you just lost half of your audience by being a bigot.
@@mussang1 They all made their political stance clearly! The comedian is quirky, not funny and might hang out at a different kind of bar than I would!
Saw Janna on a short FB-watch video and had to run over to RUclips to get more of this amazing mind. What would I give to have a coffee conversation with these two. More of this please! These are the type of questions we should be pondering about. ❤
Neil: why cant we have a 3D hologram in a 4D space?
*hits blunt*
More of this, make Janna a recurring co-host, and godspeed.
Why can't we be a 3D hologram of a 4D hologram in 5D space?
(my turn to hit)
The best joke of Harrison was saying he had a girlfriend :)
Lmao I know!! I showed my boyfriend how queeny he was then played the clip of him dating girls and we died laughing, that was his only funny joke ... If you're gonna pretend to be straight then pretend to love Trump that would be a good start lmao
@@kylelevi6975 he could have dated girls before coming out. Dr Tyson rips on Trump all the time.
so many rightards are offended in the comments, so the guy is doing his job!
27:42
@@atlasfeynman1039 thank you!
I have enjoyed them all and this has been the best CQ yet. Thank you
My only complaint with Neil is his tendency to interrupt the other person's thoughts and responses with jokes and more questions. She is a great guest.
👌👌👌
It's maddening.
Neil just can't shut up! We all like him, but he just stomps on everyone.
This is my complaint about virtually every Startalk podcast. I don't listen to any of StarTalk because of the comedians he brings on. Not sure why he does it, but I'm positive it's causing him to lose a lot of listeners.
@@ForOrAgainstUs I agree. I hate how they feel obligated to dumb down science. What the hell is the point of mixing comedy? Nobody finds the two a good mix. Science, or comedy. Together they just frustrate everyone with a brain. It's like porn and comedy. Some things just don't mix. And on top of that, Neil loves to talk so much he steps all over everyone. Neil would really be better just lecturing alone.
Liked, Voted, Quoted, Shared! Thanks for sharing this mind-blowing and fantastic show!
Love Her! Great to see her again! Thanks. Regular please.
You expand my reach of thought and of understanding of my place in the universe every episode.Thank you
My fav guest i can think of atm. Bring her on more Neil!!
Neil deGrasse Tyson said: "I tried to fully understand the holographic universe, and I only skimmed the surface of it..." That was hilarious, a great joke!!
It's funny that everything he says is bs and people believe it. 😂
@@realicepick1-vy2mg why? What's bs
@@Rizzatouille the globe, space, evolution, aliens, dinosaurs and the entire heliocentric model are all lies.
There's no proof of any of them, all fantasy based off putting it in our heads from birth, reinforcing it through fear and ridicule and then subliminally placing it everywhere.
All of the things they say are the opposite of what we call the scientific method which involves the use of observing, measuring verifying and repeating..
You cannot do any of this from black holes, gravity, dark matter, earth's alleged rotation and curvature.
It's all a system of belief. Or rather indoctrination.
@@realicepick1-vy2mg you laugh in the face of education don't you?
joshua wilson there’s always a few like this😂
Where is Chuck!!!
he is in every other video... mostly :P
pumpuppthevolume yeah but we need him always😬
I seriously wish Neil was my grandpa!!!!! Love u Neil!!!!!
I wish he was my friend ...
I wish he was my mom
I wish he was my 3rd cousin twice removed
@@ChiTownsFinest1225 LOL - I wish he was my cat
@@denniscat9395 lol cat works too
1:33 when the joke isn't funny so you just smile and laugh
What a fun talk!...as always...hanging on every word Janna and Neil say. All the best to Harrison too!
Janna is so awesome! Definitely Neil’s best guest.
She would be awesome hosting this show too
Xander Gucci we all love chuck better
Bravi! 👏🏻👏🏻
StarTalk for the (webbys) win!
Totally Voted! Best of Luck StarTalk!
Yay, new episodes!!! We love Star Talk in our house and we love you, Neil deGrasse Tyson!
Dang, this was a REALLY good one, too!
Thank you for having such a wonderful science guest. I didn’t feel like the comedian was as egregious as others-he did his best. I’d love to better understand the empty space that atoms mostly comprise. Just trying to visualize it is challenging. Basking in all this knowledge and inspired intelligence I’m hoping some of it will sink in. 😊
i love how neil just brushes over the comedians bias tasteless joke
I wish every time they will drop the comedians. The people interested in this are not interested in a failed comic butting in on conversation to talk about his cat hologram lunchbox.
That 2 super smart people having a conversation that just clicked, almost beyond what someone would think 2 people could be talking about what they are and to them its so organic and is easily to understand, even though it's so deep.
That was really great.I loved that one.It had alot of questions I would have asked and the answers were spot on to.Exellent guys!Thanks
Chuck actually tries to be a part of the conversation. It works. This guy is like that kid at the lunch table that tries way too hard to get everyone to like him.
Agreed. He’s far out of his intellectual league.
How a scientist asks another scientist on a date? "Wanna write a paper together?" 😂
There was great synergy in this group! Awesome work!
Thanks for the video of this episode!
Lovin' the Levin!
Just voted! Thank you for your work!
Thanks for voting!
This is one of my favorite podcasts - both "the lady" and the topic! Please do it again!
Thanks... My brain feels like jello listening to this
Agreed
Honestly, as a leaning Dem, I'm not a fan of all the 'jokes' about politics. I came here for astro-physics and to learn new things about science, not politics :x
We can't always get what we want 🤷♂️
@Toke Panda There is no way to talk without showcasing your personal political views... And thinking there is a way to do it its kind of naive, I must say.. You´re even doing it with your comment.
Agreed, I felt the same, that comedian was horrible and uncivilized.
@@mokeish So, you´re asking him to be more "politically correct" with his personal opinions..?? Are you really that kind of person? Really?? Criiinge...
Gabriel P you’re spamming the same dumb messages over and over again across the comments section. You’re quite the example of your political party...
Politics don’t belong in science. Science is not an opinion. Stop whining. Get a life.
Wait wait do all the podcast have video 2. How do i watch them all
So glad to find one without 50 add breaks
Very fun episode! Just want to note that Warpdrive and Wormholes require "Negative Energy Density", not negative mass. In fact, it doesn't even require negative energy. What is required is a means of reducing the density of matter, which is essentially an anti-gravity "inflation" field. Where, it is the matter which is inflated. When matter is inflated, the volume increases faster than the energy input, and the density goes down. Clocks run slow when accelerated because they are under compression. A clock in the inflation field is not compressed by the acceleration, therefore it does not run slow.
What a great chemistry you all have in this video! I really like it!! I want her back in more episodes!
Janna has been on the podcast a bunch of times!
@@StarTalk I'm going to check them up!
this was aired on the 15th february, 2019, so don't expect recent news about the black hole picture!
Averitai Valentin i was looking for comments on it. I can’t wait to hear
Please do more with Jenna!! She is an amazing guest and has a smooth voice too😅😁
We've done a few episodes with her on the podcast! www.startalkradio.net/?s=janna+levin
Refreshing to have Janna on StarTalk
We love having Janna on!
Your discussion about time and the holographic universe reminds me of Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse 5 and the idea of becoming unstuck in time.
Edit: And Neil makes a Kurt Vonnegut reference!
All the jokes that guy said we're pretty lame
I don't know why he kept mentioning the alt-right? Does he have a personal agenda or something.
@@balz.k3483 Yeah, 36:43 Like that... Man, I'm from Argentina, and don't care about world's politics. But dude, this is a pure scientific channel, don't put political shit in the middle of this amazing talk...
Witches are females, use the right pronoun.
Ye...get Bill Nye on here please
@@ruellerz Yea his sex junk is variable.
Great sound. Pls thank the sound guys and whoever helped the laughs.
Vote is done . Love this show so much also NDT💖💖
In 26:23 you say, that the square root of 2 doesn't exist in the real world, because that it is an irrational number. But if you make a square with the side lenghts of 1, the diagonal has the same length as the square root of 2. Isn't tne only reason that it is irrational because of the way that we count? Like that a third is 0.33333333333333333333333333... but if we would count in base 3, it would just be 0.1. And nature doesn't care how we count, so isn't it actually possible to have something with the length of the square root of 2 in nature?
Can you really make a square that is exactly one of anything on each side? I mean down to the atomic level? I don't think it's possible
@@stevemonkey6666 there's no reason to say that, that is specifically impossible, as this is just as likely as any other measurements for each side.
@@stevemonkey6666 No, but you can't make anything that precise. That still doesn't mean that they're imposdible to make, just that human technologies a incapable of doing it.
@@stevemonkey6666 one what exactly? meter? centimeter? these are all human inventions so
Pretty sure it's because pythagorean theorem and trying to square/root the number 1... it's just always 1... so the hypotenuse of a box with equal sides of 1 is also 1 and therefore is not a natural example of "the square root of 2."
I don't quite understand the predicament at all whether "root 2 exists in reality," because quite frankly, I haven't even seen any number 2's walking around anywhere in the real world either... if I do I will certainly try to square it up!
Around 8:45 did she say that black holes could be Schrodinger teleporters? The traveler both travels through the black hole and is smeared on the surface, thus sending an identical copy forth and disabling the original? Or is it more of an Einstein effect where the observer on the ground and the observer traveling through the black hole just aren't experiencing the same effect. Observers outside might "see" the traveler spaghettified, but if the traveler survives then the observers only saw an optical illusion of spaghettification?
Absolutely love listening to Janna.
These are some fantastic questions.... And to think, I want to take Physics for fun and I just finished taking intermediate college algebra and it was EXTREMELY HARD. But, I enjoyed it because, it was hard. Physics just sounds fun.
Thinking about this blows my mind. Thinking of how Earth is only a spec (not even) to Space. Scary
I hear you. Sometimes I think about myself at the furthest point away from Earth where I can see it as just a tiny spec and it's a bit daunting. Because, we here see it as so big in front of us. But Earth really isn't anything when it comes to space. If Earth were to explode tomorrow, space will be infinite no matter what. Puts it in perspective how much life doesn't really matter. Which that perspective helps when you get stressed out over something so small. Billions of years from now, you won't matter to Earth. And you definitely won't matter to Space.
I've got to agree with many comments that this very interesting discussion was somewhat spoilt by the chap on the right. He didn't have anything relevant to add. In fact his lame jokes were misplaced and distracting.
😐wtf is "spoilt"?
Is that like "garbitch"?
Great episode.. Janna is awesome! 👍👍👍
that Pauli exclusion principle about electrons and their information is genius idea, they need to write a paper on it :D
Infinite energy: Spiderman 2 with Dr. Otto Octavius
As far as I understand it, he wasn't intending to make infinite energy. It seemed like cold fusion to me, since tritium was his fuel of choice.
When are u back on NAT GEO ???
So cool! I really enjoy these.
I managed 11 minutes of this and realised how little of the conversation I understood. I think I'll watch Aliens again!
I'm sure the comedian dude is a nice guy, and I lean more toward his political bent, but I seriously don't want to hear about any political non sense in the astronomy cast. I love astronomy because it's separate from human bullshit, can we please keep it that way?
zelkuta EXACTLY. Away from the Humanistic NONSENSE
@zelkuta @john galt You people are SOOO dumb. If you believe there is a way of creating any piece of entertainment without showcasing your political views, or any way to even TALK without doing it, you´re more naive than a 3 year old... Send me a link to any video, to any movie or any interview, that you consider an example of someone talking without showing his personal political views. ANY video. Im daring you to do it.
Gabriel P ok well then let's start with not directly attacking others' political views then.... That is surely possible in your universe?
@@cypheir Again, you can´t make a movie, write a novel, or make a joke, without political undertones. You. Can´t. That´s just an illusion.
Gabriel P you’re an idiot :)
That guy is not a "comedian".
Nevermore Yeah, because he’s a magician
@@johnchesterfield9726 you have to have some trick to be that unfunny
Hold up did he say he had a girlfriend!? Science has proven today there is no god🤯
@@idontcare6662 soy boy or in the closet
Correct. He's a hack. Chuck Nice sucks, too.
I had to pause the video as soon as they alluded to the universe being inside of the event horizon of a black hole. It was too much of a mind blown
This comedian was so much better than any other one I've seen on the show, excluding Chuck. Chuck is the best fit for the show .
I miss Chuck!
You're a real man.
I'd donate to Patreon for "comedians" to stop coming on the show.
Be nice lol
Chuck is ok but this guy sucks. His right wing jokes are terrible and in poor taste
Yeah, he’s pretty awful.
@@mavfan1 no love lol
They're kind of destructive
this was fun! lot of interesting tangents in there :)
Wonderful. Thank you so much.
Man that woman is very well spoken and interesting to listen to. But that comedian really just detracts from the show. He has nothing to input on the actual discussions. He seems like a nice guy and maybe even a decent comedian but he doesn’t really belong on a show like this.
People like fun.
Have you never had a group of friends? 1 is smart. 1 is kinda serious. 1 is the funny one.
Balance of diversity is fun.
Some stuck up people who think the world should ALWAYS be nothing but boring information..not that the information ismboring, but the exchange of information being boring..sure, they will have a stickup their ass.
NDT actually enjoys sharing information to people whom are less informed, just as much as he likes exchanging with those whom know more. He's explained this many times.
This set up was basically a tailor made setup for him.
People (more sciency people) have made that observation/complaint since the beginning of the series. Having an "everyman" comedian on the panel is a way for less-sciency people to have a sympathetic representative there, to point out the weirdness or complexity and make the panel bring things to a layman's/public point of view or level of understanding.
The actual jokes may be more or less successful, but it keeps the atmosphere a little lighter and stretches the pace so the public audience isn't getting bombarded with stuff that's over their head too fast and/or too many times in a row. If you are already literate in the field at hand, this effort wasn't for your benefit, so it may seem like just a string of interruptions. That's what you get for being a science geek! :)
If you want the heavier versions of science & futurism discussions, check out "PBS Space Time" and "Isaac Arthur" channels, or for an in-between presentation level check out "Astronomy Cast" and "The Royal Institution" which are also public but assume a good attention span and focus to topic.
animist channel that’s a really fair assessment and I think you’re right. I may have been a bit too harsh, I guess just personally his jokes didn’t add much to my enjoyment, but I can understand why others may enjoy that sort of personality on a show like this.
Yeah plus the "it adds humor" argument is very weak as Neil is incredible with humor and can make much better jokes that are way more contextualized
He was horrible and pointlessly political with poor timing.
Today's fact: In South Korea there is an emergency number (113) to report spies.
Excellent video, thanks very much
this was a great show...I enjoyed the comedian guy and astrophysicist Janna Levin .
Enjoyable podcast overall but please keep politics at the door.
@The PeoplesAsshole100 So you want this talk to be more "politically correct"?? Are you really that kind of person?? REALLY..?? Grow some balls...
Gabriel P classic answer of an sjw who thinks science is an opinion, not a fact.
@@gabrielp9646 can it be just.....not political? It's been irrelevant each time it's brought up.
@@chuckfist Im an electrical engineer and a communications tech, buddy... And you´re a SJW too, just letting you know.
@@freeignition No, it can´t. There hasn´t been a single movie ever made, a single book ever written, a single talk or speech ever given, that hasn´t been political. That´s just wishful thinking, it doesn´t work like that... You can´t be "not political", you just can pretend you are.
What's the deal with ScienceTalk rehashing all the old Star Talk stuff, is that a legit channel?
I enjoy listening to these as podcasts on iHeart Radio as I go about my day.
Thanks for listening!
keep up the uploads!
Stopped everything to listen to Levin :)
Now that's a woman to change your major for. Carry on.
Why does the comedian keep bringing up politics every 5 mins??
Completely irrelevant and boring.
The Gay Comedian is boring.
@@shorin43 lol I thought he was gay until he said he's dated negative girls .
I agree
the interesting thing about our galaxies colliding is that there will be few, if any actual planetary/star collisions.
Janna is a freaking BOSS legend! love everything about her!
"I dated a girl or two with negative energy" uhuh sure you did.
Jeez, the comedian's political jokes were really forced and lame, this guy is not a good match for the show.
Cringe worthy 😬
@@911greg your name reminds me of that tragedy...
Well this isn't the first time he will be on and wont be the last. You dont like it dont watch plenty of us will though and not wine about it
@@thermalrain_yt9725 sorry, are people not allowed or permitted to have an opinion?
@@thermalrain_yt9725 What kind of wine? Merlot?
Hope one day have that type of confidence in my field as you guys have ❤️
She needs to come on more often pls!!
the comic relief is ruining the conversation, i never thought i'd say this but please get rid of the comedians
I agree. Or at least turn it down a bit. Sometimes it slows things down, and some other times it derails the conversation and interrupts thought
So were just a universe spinning within a black hole of another universe that's also spinning within even bigger black hole........my head hurts 🤣
And each of us have a hole behind
This just helps affirm my theory that information IS a form of energy.
Great humor and discussion.