It's been about 15 years or so since I saw these first few episodes of the New Voyages. They still stand up and may be even better than I remembered them. They are of course, by far better than any corporate "Trek" made in the last 20 or so years. Stories right out of and up there with TOS, loving production and amazing cameos (behind and in front of the camera). Great to see again!
Not only does this give Sulu the episode that he's always deserved but this is one of the best Star Trek episodes ever made. I love how it manages to capture the energy and wonderful vibe that The Original Series had that was lost in the sequential series. And because of the fact that this was made in modern age makes it all that more incredible.
I 100% agree with you. I grew up with ST:TOS, and this episode had me locked into that energy you're talking about. Written so well, distilled essence of the show I grew up loving. This easily translates through the production values of this fan production, and I'm filled with gratitude toward everyone involved.
incredible use of the original actors in this series. My husband died in October and I cannot tell you how trite "I am sorry for your loss" got to be sounding from people. When Kirk said it, it was SO sincere I felt he said it to me.
May I ask a question of you? I don't wish to pry nor cause offense. However, a friend of mine is going to lose is wife in the not too distant future. I, too, have always found the, "I'm sorry for your lose" to be so trite and so, well, frankly unhelpful. So, my question is this: Is there some better phrase? Is there some better way to show empathy without it sounding so artificial? Again, I don't wish to pry. So if you'd rather not answer, I understand.
@@SlimThrull actually the best "response" was from an Irish friend who does not mince words, she simply said "that's bloody awful". While I wouldn't recommend that a sincere "I am so sorry" followed by silence and PRESENCE is the most sincere. Leave out the "for your loss". The person knows why you are sorry. Just being physically present and letting the grieving person talk, cry, or just sit in silent companionship are the absolute BEST responses. If you are "hugging" friends, give that person a hug. but beware, that physical contact may also set them off. (as I type this, I am crying). The crying never really goes away 3 years later. It only takes a second and I am right back in the hospital room on the last day again. also not abandoning your friend after a period of time. People had warned me to take any help clearning out, etc right away because people will move on with their lives and forget about you. The problem is one is so paralyzed that by the time one is ready to physically clear out things, no one is around. It is excruciating. I am living in another country without a support group, but I have a job, so I stay. Let the grieving person set the pace. Don't ask, SAY what you will do. "I am coming Monday to take you to lunch", etc. "I am coming over to sit with you". Just be present in the griever's life. Thank you so much for asking.
When my husband passed away,I used a book website to;’ease the pain’.It helped me!But,time has been a great healer,too!Now,I know,now that I didn’t want to get married,anymore.So,I never have to go through that loss,again!
This honestly might be George Takei's finest performance. It's impressive that a team of fans were responsible for giving him the platform to tell this story instead of the actual studio that owns it. Once again. Further proof that the fans care more about star trek than paramount ever did.
@@James.G.Ireland These fan films are self-funded. We who made these episodes used our own money. Considering we made this ep for under $100K? It's a great ep, considering Trek costs $6-$8million per ep
Don't know why I hadn't heard about these episodes years ago, but am thankful that I have found them. This episode is as memorable as the best of any other Star Trek episodes - George Takei is excellent, writing is strong, and I expect more successes from the actress who plays Alana.
Aye aye Captians; this episode truly was a masterpiece. Very touching and moving; reminded me of the ST:TNG episode with Picard's life in a moment. I've had a dream like that - very frustrating when you awaken. Well done.
Excellent Star Trek episode, George Tekai deserves a spin-off series of his own as Captain of the Excelsior. Such a touching story, with Demora Sulu and her baby at the end, it was full of emotion and passion, you guys did an awesome job. I bet there wasn't a dry eye in the house.
I agree if Demora Sulu was Captain Sulu's Daughter then Elena Sulu would be Demora's Sister even in both mainstream cannon and beta cannon weather it would be in mainstream trek or any fan trek film involving Captain Sulu's Excelsior
George Takei as Lt. Sulu and Christina Moses who plays "Alana" deliver an incredibly memorable scene at the climax of this story. This is at the heart of what makes the franchise great, which is the storytelling and the examination of our humanity.
Saw this the first time and I am blown away. So great! Really where Star Trek has never gone before. Great actors, great script, great music. Love it as much as my most beloved original series episodes.
Just wow. I am just blown away. Far and above one of the greatest Star Trek episodes ever written. A little rough in the beginning, but for a fan film to be able to drag the viewers in on such an emotional level is just amazing! I'm just stunned!
I’ve watched this episode multiple times, and I must say that this is one of my favorite Star Trek episodes ever. Seriously. Amazing story with amazing performances by the actors
I'm a fan of all things Star Trek, and I must say Star Trek: New Voyages--and Star Trek Continues--contains the best productions not only of TOS, but any Trek out there. You can never go better than fans making Star Trek, because they know what fellow fans want. Bravo to James and everyone at NV for their awesomeness.
Wow! I was blown away by this episode! Soooo freaking good! The writers are great! Thank you so much! I actually started to cry when Spock was giving Sulu his memories back.
I'm late to the party, but I watched this years ago and it made me cry at the end. James Cawley I love your portrayal of Kirk. You capture his essence quite well and I wish you would have kept portraying him. You are an excellent actor, or I wouldn't have been moved as much as I was at the end. I love that you got George. When people ask me what my five favorite episodes of TOS are I include this one. I've been an original Trekker since 1966 and you have given us a fantastic 4th season. Thank you and God bless!
All these memories flooding back. The romulans, the anomaly, caveman sulu. It’s. Been almost 3 years since I’ve watched these, and they still bring joy to me.
This surpassed my expectations for a fan film. A great story and wonderful performance by George Takei. The ending actually made me burst into tears! Well done.
This is I think my absolute favorite Star Trek episode of any series or movie. The cast was wonderful with Jeffrey Quinn exceptional as Spock and my favorite along with Nimoy. And Christina Moses as Alana was incredible! Everyone involved made this one of the best of all Star Trek episodes.
This was easily the most touching and heartbreaking episode I have ever seen. This is fan fiction and Star Trek at its greatest; a story of raw emotion. This was so beautiful I literally nearly cried
I had tears and I am still wiping them away as I just viewed the episode. this is what Star Trek is all about, they really caught the vision that it was supposed to have. not all the flash in the pan but a real homage to the original. I wish George would stop being mad at William Shatner. It wasn't his fault and if the roles were reversed I don't think he would have acted any different. It wasn't his fault that George didn't get more airtime. that was the decision of the people in charge. I hazard a guess that Shatner would not have been so petty if the roles were reversed to be honest. George did a great job here but he needs to let it go once and for all.
I've been to places and known people who have lost children from many causes.I think the last scene brought some sense of closure for the Sulu Character. Given his exprience in the alternate Universe, "Grandpa" is going to SPOIL that baby!
I am so pleased that comments are turned on for this episode. The fact fact that fans could put together something of this caliber and quality is mind blowing. Absolutely amazing!! Even vic mignogna who plays Kirk (no easy task considering who you are compared to) is exceptional. From the attention to detail to the special effect to the music...just incredible. Well done!!
@@skyhorseprice6591 There's a legend floating around out there that says that Elvis Presley was considered for the role of Captain Kirk. It is, of course, not at all true, but...Mr. Cawley gives us a glimpse of what might have been if it were.
All of the accolades that this presentation has received were genuinely well earned. Well produced, well written, and in the spirit of the franchise of old. To say that I liked it would be the understatement of the year. Thanks to all who worked on this. I was entertained, moved, and more.
My heart hurts so much. On another note, I can't imagine the joy George had doing this or the complex feelings about the fate of his character. Beautiful acting from all the Sulus. :)
I can say Mr Takei was very happy to be there and doing his job.. as everyone was, and I can send a belated THANK YOU to everyone who stuck by Trek back in the day As he said it was us who kept it going all these years.
Just "WOW". That was REALLY Well done! The entire production had the look and feel down perfectly! On top of that,the story was touching and had great flow from beginning to end, the acting was perfectly executed too!
This story made me tear up. It had the flavor of Star Trek TOS with the realistic drama, acting, directing and story line of an Academy Award level presentation. I do hope this team will do another video with George Takei. He still has it.
I also enjoyed this episode as well!It has the “old school’Star Trek episodes,here!The actress who played;Alana was great,but,I wasn’t sure if she would’ve been a character that I would’ve liked at first.But,I think,she was 👌 okay.After all,Captain Kirk had a love 💕 interest of the week!He certainly did on the original show of the 1960”s!
Its amazing how much this much this episode has hit me. Well done. Very well done. The actress playing Sulu's daughter did a great job. She has a great future in front of her.
Love seeing George in his classic role, and this episode was genuinely emotional. I have wonder if a certain Mr. Shatner could ever be talked into performing in New Voyages.
Absolutely incredible! Wonderful story telling an frankly this is 10 times better quality than main line StarTrek while preserving the feel of the original series! I love it!
Too bad the cast here isn't as diverse as the original series. The original series' bridge: Men, women, Asian, Vulcan, African Woman, European origin...and the rest of the cast...Kahn (South Asian), Kirk's tribunal: African American man, South Asian Man, A Woman, and on and on. The original series hosted hollywood's first inter-racial kiss! All in 1965 and the entire world was represented in the original Star Trek series, all races, living and working together. What a tremendous ground-breaking achievement for the original series!
This is, for me, amongst the best and the most intelligent Star Trek. On a par with the best of the Viacom episodes, so well-funded. You have created something that moves me and provoked my thoughts and feelings. The acting was so well done. Thank you for this.........
This particular episode has won several awards including the TV-Guide best sci-fi webisode and was nominated for a Hugo award against Dr. Who and Battlestar Gallactica.
As I pointed out to the director's son, not long ago, this episode had all the hallmarks of a production directed by Gerd Oswald ... just like the Old Series episode he directed, which also had a Shakespearean ambiance, a sad outcome for the leading lady, and a broken heart by Kirk at the end. I always considered most of the Old Series episodes as hokey; but that one stood out from the rest and showed what the series could have been ... as does yours.
My goodness this was a very special episode, a touch of old school with modern approach, however a soft story of love & wisdom, a fantastic storyline involved, this will go places boldly go where no story has gone, 'WELL DONE THANK YOU a serious fan!!!👍
I'm a long-time "Trekkie". I pride myself in being a macho "He Man".I've seen a lot of episodes but this one, broke me down to my bare and fundamental essence. it disassembled my atoms to the very core of their being, literally and rebuilt them back, from the ground up.The epitome of a true tear-jerker!🤧
George Takei - what a class a class act (on an off screen). And so was Grace Lee Whitney. Not forgetting Walter Konig, Tim Russ, Gary Graham and a few others from ST TV shows. They've all given up their time for free to give me/us/everyone the closest thing to TOS we're ever going to get now that so many of the originals have passed on. And it's all getting better and better, thanks to the dedication of people like James Cawley and Vic Mignogna and all the different cast and crew-members. Way to go guys. Live long and prosper.
Sulu was the most underused character on TOS, he never got a single good character episode! Finally. This is what both the actor and the fictional character deserved.
The only fitting thing i like about this epp is its connection between TOS and TMP eras involving Sulu as both Helmsman of the Enterprise and captain of the Excelsior.
The character of Sulu was to be featured in the Gamesters of Triskelion, but George Takei's role in The Green Beret Movie with John Wayne did not finish filming on time. It would have been Sulu, instead of Chekov opposite Jane Ross as Tamoon, which when I saw the original episode (as a pre-teen) I thought Jane Ross's portrayal of Tamoon was by a male actor in drag because of her deep voice. It would have been an inside joke if that was the case had George Takei co-starred in that episode.
I was lucky enough to talk with Mr Takei in 2013 when he appeared as narrator with the Nashville Symphony. George was in the green room with us for about 45 min after dress rehearsal. He spoke with fondness about his whole experience with Phase II and the rare opportunity to have a character expanding role so far removed from his original work. He appreciated too the chance to work with the “emerging talent” (his words) of Christina Moses, assuring us that we’d know her for more work soon. Right as usual, George. She has 30 IMDB credits today.
This episode makes me cry every damn time I watch it. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, and it doesn't get anymore Star Trek then that right there. The gut wrenching, soul crushing sacrifices the few endure so the many can survive, it's like the wrath of khan only with more tears. This is my favorite episode from the entire fan series and it is worthy to be Star Trek, and i would hope that even Gene Roddenberry would have been proud of this, rest his soul. Thank you for telling this story.
8 years after this was put online, this is still a powerful story the is head and shoulders above what the studios have been producing. I would have paid to see this in theatres and quite satisfied I had done so, thank you for all of your efforts. Kudos to the entire cast for a job very well done!
That was outstanding! Really hit with the feels in that last part, getting Demora to name her daughter after the sister she never knew. Paramount need to take that and make that story part of Sulu's legacy so to speak in SNW or something. These episodes are above and beyond, fantastic, really enjoying them.
THANK YOU! we really enjoyed the entire show, loved everything from seeing Mr.George Takei again to the original details and how well the story was done! i didn't know how much i missed the original until we found this, we will absolutely continue to be fans for a long long time.
Best Star Trek episode ever. George Takei plays the part of Hikaru Sulu excellently as always. The reference to "The Tempest" goes deep on the poetic level.
Man for being a fan-film, this is by far the most moving episode of any Star Trek series, official and non-official. George Takei was amazing in this. I totally geeked out during the this whole episode. Thank you for keeping the TOS era alive with new and amazing stories.
Absolutely brilliant episode and I love seeing George Takei back as Sulu. It was also one of the saddest episodes I have seen, up there with City on the edge of Forever. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I almost forgot about startreknewvoyages... the cure to the modern middle finger being given to a lot of us who loved Star Trek since we were children. Thank God this channel found me again.
Every time I look at this, it touches my heart. Christiana Moses, you did an exactly job...in fact everyone was on par. This was one of the best show in the entire franchise.
What a great episode. Perfect TOS caliber storyline, and easily the most heartbreaking sci fi I've seen since the Farscape episode 'Look at the Princess.'
I agree, been trying to get my Trek pals to watch it. They nailed it. It's real Trek all the way. And the Kirk guy James Crawley built a Star Trek original set in Ticonderoga NY. Incredible.
@@Lee-Darin I was actually up there not long ago. I play in a band and I had a gig across the street from the set in Ticonderoga. And the great part of it? I was standing right next to James Crawley at Stewart's right down the road. LOL. I turned to him and I said "hey, aren't you that Star Trek guy?"
I was skeptical about whether or not this would be good, but I must admit that I truly did enjoy this. Great story that captures the spirit of the original series.
I recently discovered these episodes while on Covid 19 lockdown in 2020. It is amazing what was accomplished here with a shoe string budget and what was probably a hell of a lot of work by this series creators, crew and actors. What an achievement. Thank you.
"What is the point?" This series, and this episode in particular, has brought a lot of happiness to those involved in making and watching it. It was not that expensive to make and paid for by those making it. This series IS both highly creative and imaginative. If you do not like it, there are plenty of other videos on RUclips. I suggest you direct your comments at the tons of stupid shows on TV.
I don't know if you still read this stuff & the comment was 7 years ago, but don't let the trolls bring you down. You have something like a 95% Like thingy going on. I'm way old, and a fan of stuff like "The Prisoner" "Star Trek" "Outer Limits" "I Spy" "Hill Street Blues" (I just love Name Dropping) and you knocked it out of the park with this episode, ripping the hide off the ball in the process!
@@jacksonmiller8309 Those who have created NOTHING in their lives sneer at those who have made something. I thought it was an amazingly good episode. Way better than the latest official series.
This is a fan made movie? So good! At first feel so strange to see different actors, but soon drew by the plot. MaCoy has a few shots really look like real MaCoy. The young Sulu is so impressive in the last 5 mins. Jim & Spot are good of course. This brings back all the memory and feel of the TOS!
Simply THE BEST Star Trek episode ever produced. George Takei was wonderful, as always. And the young actors / actresses were wonderful. Heart breaking yet beautiful.
I know there are few Star Trek shows out there, but adding the original cast is amazing. This show and the actors were excellent. This episode was great, This was fitting for Sulu. Long live Star Trek.
An amazing production on so many levels. Sulu always has been a warrior and he so grew into this part and the lady who played his played his daughter really got into the part and was quite remarkable. Mccawley made a great Captain Kirk and hair color is such a simply thing.
I've been a Star Trek fan ever since the show first started. Mid 60's. These shows are great! Thanks all of you for making these! I'm proud of each and every one of you!
Yes, Majel and Rodd Roddenberry as well as many others involved in producing the original Star Trek approved and assisted us with this project. Just have a look at the credits at the end.
Yes, this episode was nominated for the Hugo Award "Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form" in 2008. The Dr. Who episode "Blink" came in first place for that award.
I've been a Trekkie from day one of the premiere of the original series. i absolutely love James Cawley playing Captain Kirk....as far as I am concerned he done a good job in portraying him....Kirk is, like all the other of the original actors, a very hard one to follow....I love this ST New Voyages series as well as the other one with ST Continues....I am and will always be your friend and fan to the Star Trek legacy. For me this is the hope for our future, if only the whole world would put aside their differences and work together....it could be a Heaven on our Earth, and possibly....a future for exploration of our solar system.....but not in it's present condition. God bless all who have made and contributed to this endeavor of continuing a saga of hope for us.....without out it, we are but lost to nothing more than existence without insight or imagination. Hope is what helps build our futures. HIGH 5 to all who made this and other Star Treks possible. Love you all.....HIGH 5
Oh my This was amazing. The production quality is impressive for a fan funded thing. The acting, though imperfect, does a great job of capturing the spirit of TOS And the story was classic. Really stuck true to the "greek morality play... but in space" concept. I think Roddenberry would be proud. A shame that the big companies these days can't look beyond the dollar signs to see this 😔
This episode would be one of my favorites, but it left me with a " real " sense of loss. The writers were very clever in their craft! Bravo for pulling me into the story like the gravitational phenomenon that you created. This is the fourth time I viewed this and managed to shed tears. Bravo to all!
I just started watching New Voyages/Phase II a few days ago & I love how with each episode they are steadily improving. This one had the emotional depth of many of the original series/next generation episodes. It made you laugh ("shouldn't you send me candy & flowers first") and cry, with the very touching scenes near the end when Sulu's daughter knew her life could not continue. Awesome job guys! Very much looking forward to watching the 2-part episode tomorrow & all future installments.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
It's been about 15 years or so since I saw these first few episodes of the New Voyages. They still stand up and may be even better than I remembered them. They are of course, by far better than any corporate "Trek" made in the last 20 or so years.
Stories right out of and up there with TOS, loving production and amazing cameos (behind and in front of the camera). Great to see again!
Not only does this give Sulu the episode that he's always deserved but this is one of the best Star Trek episodes ever made. I love how it manages to capture the energy and wonderful vibe that The Original Series had that was lost in the sequential series. And because of the fact that this was made in modern age makes it all that more incredible.
Oh please
I 100% agree with you. I grew up with ST:TOS, and this episode had me locked into that energy you're talking about. Written so well, distilled essence of the show I grew up loving. This easily translates through the production values of this fan production, and I'm filled with gratitude toward everyone involved.
Yes it impressed me too which is not easily done.
I agree. Also, the actor who plays Kirk looks like the son of Carl Sagan, which is awesome!😎
Wow this is magnificent
This story was fitting for Sulu , beautifully written & well carried by all the cast members 🖖🙂
Glad he got a REAL wife in this episode.
Yes,I agree!Mr.Sulu finally got a family in this episode,which meant…..he finally retired,right?
Damn enjoyable episode I must say
😂@@ghostl1124
incredible use of the original actors in this series. My husband died in October and I cannot tell you how trite "I am sorry for your loss" got to be sounding from people. When Kirk said it, it was SO sincere I felt he said it to me.
Thank you for sharing that.
I am also sorry for your loss...
May I ask a question of you? I don't wish to pry nor cause offense. However, a friend of mine is going to lose is wife in the not too distant future. I, too, have always found the, "I'm sorry for your lose" to be so trite and so, well, frankly unhelpful. So, my question is this: Is there some better phrase? Is there some better way to show empathy without it sounding so artificial?
Again, I don't wish to pry. So if you'd rather not answer, I understand.
@@charlesnolan7602 🤣 case in point........
@@SlimThrull actually the best "response" was from an Irish friend who does not mince words, she simply said "that's bloody awful". While I wouldn't recommend that a sincere "I am so sorry" followed by silence and PRESENCE is the most sincere. Leave out the "for your loss". The person knows why you are sorry. Just being physically present and letting the grieving person talk, cry, or just sit in silent companionship are the absolute BEST responses. If you are "hugging" friends, give that person a hug. but beware, that physical contact may also set them off. (as I type this, I am crying). The crying never really goes away 3 years later. It only takes a second and I am right back in the hospital room on the last day again. also not abandoning your friend after a period of time. People had warned me to take any help clearning out, etc right away because people will move on with their lives and forget about you. The problem is one is so paralyzed that by the time one is ready to physically clear out things, no one is around. It is excruciating. I am living in another country without a support group, but I have a job, so I stay. Let the grieving person set the pace. Don't ask, SAY what you will do. "I am coming Monday to take you to lunch", etc. "I am coming over to sit with you". Just be present in the griever's life. Thank you so much for asking.
When my husband passed away,I used a book website to;’ease the pain’.It helped me!But,time has been a great healer,too!Now,I know,now that I didn’t want to get married,anymore.So,I never have to go through that loss,again!
This honestly might be George Takei's finest performance. It's impressive that a team of fans were responsible for giving him the platform to tell this story instead of the actual studio that owns it. Once again. Further proof that the fans care more about star trek than paramount ever did.
Fans always will.
This is awful
@@James.G.Ireland These fan films are self-funded. We who made these episodes used our own money. Considering we made this ep for under $100K? It's a great ep, considering Trek costs $6-$8million per ep
@@James.G.Ireland you must be fun at parties.
@dennis hotston
I just started watching these episodes for the first time and enjoying them. Thank you.
No TOS episode ever brought tears to my eyes before. Superb writing and acting. Thank you.
Get it together man. ST Continues is and will always be the best fan-made series. Takei's insane politics kept him out of it.
@@PaulStallion It's possible to enjoy both series, some people worked on both.
@@PaulStalliondude. Come on, man.
The only Star Trek episode that brought tears 😭 to my eyes,was;The Empath.This was;awhile ago,now!
Sometimes over the years I come back to this episode and watch it. It is wonderful. Christina Moses and George Takei are wonderful.
Fantastic film. First time a fan made star trek has brought tears to my eyes. Wish there were more episodes. Thank you.
Don't know why I hadn't heard about these episodes years ago, but am thankful that I have found them. This episode is as memorable as the best of any other Star Trek episodes - George Takei is excellent, writing is strong, and I expect more successes from the actress who plays Alana.
WOW! I'm 63 & have never cried about a Star Trek episode. This was truly beautiful.
I agree this was a great story
GOT ME TOO
Here too. Just now.
Aye aye Captians; this episode truly was a masterpiece.
Very touching and moving; reminded me of the ST:TNG episode with Picard's life in a moment.
I've had a dream like that - very frustrating when you awaken. Well done.
yes 64!! great episode...I miss the stories....
Excellent Star Trek episode, George Tekai deserves a spin-off series of his own as Captain of the Excelsior. Such a touching story, with Demora Sulu and her baby at the end, it was full of emotion and passion, you guys did an awesome job. I bet there wasn't a dry eye in the house.
I agree if Demora Sulu was Captain Sulu's Daughter then Elena Sulu would be Demora's Sister even in both mainstream cannon and beta cannon weather it would be in mainstream trek or any fan trek film involving Captain Sulu's Excelsior
Such a heartbreaking story... but my most sincere appreciation to everyone who produced this episode.
George Takei as Lt. Sulu and Christina Moses who plays "Alana" deliver an incredibly memorable scene at the climax of this story. This is at the heart of what makes the franchise great, which is the storytelling and the examination of our humanity.
Saw this the first time and I am blown away. So great! Really where Star Trek has never gone before. Great actors, great script, great music. Love it as much as my most beloved original series episodes.
Just wow. I am just blown away. Far and above one of the greatest Star Trek episodes ever written. A little rough in the beginning, but for a fan film to be able to drag the viewers in on such an emotional level is just amazing! I'm just stunned!
I was hooked after 15 minutes
Nahhhhhhh
@@salvagemonster3612 Wow, you're a laugh a minute aren't you.
I’ve watched this episode multiple times, and I must say that this is one of my favorite Star Trek episodes ever. Seriously. Amazing story with amazing performances by the actors
I'm a fan of all things Star Trek, and I must say Star Trek: New Voyages--and Star Trek Continues--contains the best productions not only of TOS, but any Trek out there. You can never go better than fans making Star Trek, because they know what fellow fans want. Bravo to James and everyone at NV for their awesomeness.
Well done! A tear jerking episode with great acting and special effects. Takei was fantastic, as always. Loved this!
One of the best Star Trek movies ever. The young man playing young Sulu did an academy award-winning performance at the end!!!!
I have watched this one before tear jerker ending
Wow! I was blown away by this episode! Soooo freaking good! The writers are great! Thank you so much!
I actually started to cry when Spock was giving Sulu his memories back.
Outstanding episode! This is what Star Trek fans wanted and still WANT!
I certainly wasn't expecting anything that well written, performed, directed and produced. Well done, thank you.
I'm late to the party, but I watched this years ago and it made me cry at the end. James Cawley I love your portrayal of Kirk. You capture his essence quite well and I wish you would have kept portraying him. You are an excellent actor, or I wouldn't have been moved as much as I was at the end. I love that you got George. When people ask me what my five favorite episodes of TOS are I include this one. I've been an original Trekker since 1966 and you have given us a fantastic 4th season. Thank you and God bless!
All these memories flooding back. The romulans, the anomaly, caveman sulu.
It’s. Been almost 3 years since I’ve watched these, and they still bring joy to me.
'caveman sulu' LOL
@@duckling4393 What? It's the best interpretation I could come up with.
This surpassed my expectations for a fan film. A great story and wonderful performance by George Takei. The ending actually made me burst into tears! Well done.
This is I think my absolute favorite Star Trek episode of any series or movie. The cast was wonderful with Jeffrey Quinn exceptional as Spock and my favorite along with Nimoy.
And Christina Moses as Alana was incredible! Everyone involved made this one of the best of all Star Trek episodes.
Excellent 👍👍
This was easily the most touching and heartbreaking episode I have ever seen. This is fan fiction and Star Trek at its greatest; a story of raw emotion. This was so beautiful I literally nearly cried
I had tears and I am still wiping them away as I just viewed the episode. this is what Star Trek is all about, they really caught the vision that it was supposed to have. not all the flash in the pan but a real homage to the original. I wish George would stop being mad at William Shatner. It wasn't his fault and if the roles were reversed I don't think he would have acted any different. It wasn't his fault that George didn't get more airtime. that was the decision of the people in charge. I hazard a guess that Shatner would not have been so petty if the roles were reversed to be honest. George did a great job here but he needs to let it go once and for all.
i did cry, male 61ex special forces
@@lorcis1 I'm 59. Just a great production. I wish they would catch the vision again.
I've been to places and known people who have lost children from many causes.I think the last scene brought some sense of closure for the Sulu Character. Given his exprience in the alternate Universe, "Grandpa" is going to SPOIL that baby!
@@kusnezoff8705 I WANT AXANAR!
I am so pleased that comments are turned on for this episode. The fact fact that fans could put together something of this caliber and quality is mind blowing. Absolutely amazing!! Even vic mignogna who plays Kirk (no easy task considering who you are compared to) is exceptional. From the attention to detail to the special effect to the music...just incredible. Well done!!
I agree, just beautiful! I cried through this episode. I was flabbergasted.
@@lindawilkerson5900 I would have to say everyone did.
That isn't Vic. He played Kirk in Star Trek Continues.
The actor who plays Kirk in this series is James Cawley.
@@skyhorseprice6591 There's a legend floating around out there that says that Elvis Presley was considered for the role of Captain Kirk. It is, of course, not at all true, but...Mr. Cawley gives us a glimpse of what might have been if it were.
Wow- that was Amazing! George Takei is incredible in this! Fantastic sir, hats off!
all the above.kudos all around.a real treat.
@@busterbiloxi3833 Look
@@busterbiloxi3833 in
9
I shed tears on this episode, it was amazing!
The actor's reminded me of the original cast so much, I was transported back.
Thank you.
All of the accolades that this presentation has received were genuinely well earned. Well produced, well written, and in the spirit of the franchise of old. To say that I liked it would be the understatement of the year. Thanks to all who worked on this. I was entertained, moved, and more.
This is objectivly both the best written, and performed Sulu centreic episode of all of Star Trek
My heart hurts so much.
On another note, I can't imagine the joy George had doing this or the complex feelings about the fate of his character. Beautiful acting from all the Sulus. :)
I can say Mr Takei was very happy to be there and doing his job.. as everyone was, and I can send a belated THANK YOU to everyone who stuck by Trek back in the day As he said it was us who kept it going all these years.
Just "WOW".
That was REALLY Well done! The entire production had the look and feel down perfectly! On top of that,the story was touching and had great flow from beginning to end, the acting was perfectly executed too!
Yes, even though Spock and McCoy were a little different, they did well overall.
Congrats to everyone involved.
This story made me tear up. It had the flavor of Star Trek TOS with the realistic drama, acting, directing and story line of an Academy Award level presentation. I do hope this team will do another video with George Takei. He still has it.
It got me as well :)
I also enjoyed this episode as well!It has the “old school’Star Trek episodes,here!The actress who played;Alana was great,but,I wasn’t sure if she would’ve been a character that I would’ve liked at first.But,I think,she was 👌 okay.After all,Captain Kirk had a love 💕 interest of the week!He certainly did on the original show of the 1960”s!
Its amazing how much this much this episode has hit me. Well done. Very well done. The actress playing Sulu's daughter did a great job. She has a great future in front of her.
A great storyline and episode.
A salute to the crew who made this.
Sulu... 🖖 George Takei
One of the best Star Trek episodes ever made. This is the Star Trek we have missed, the new stuff blows. Please keep them coming.
Love seeing George in his classic role, and this episode was genuinely emotional. I have wonder if a certain Mr. Shatner could ever be talked into performing in New Voyages.
It would be nice since he's sat in that exact Captain's Chair at this set.
@@Lee-Darin
Very cool.
In another new generation episode,Mr.Cawley played;Elvis Presley,as Captain 👩✈️ Kirk was in;’a crazy 😜 house.”It was in the episode;”Mindbender.”
Absolutely incredible! Wonderful story telling an frankly this is 10 times better quality than main line StarTrek while preserving the feel of the original series!
I love it!
You must have seen a different episode to the one I have just seen.
Perhaps because I was blown away with the intensity and just awesomeness of it!
Too bad the cast here isn't as diverse as the original series. The original series' bridge: Men, women, Asian, Vulcan, African Woman, European origin...and the rest of the cast...Kahn (South Asian), Kirk's tribunal: African American man, South Asian Man, A Woman, and on and on. The original series hosted hollywood's first inter-racial kiss! All in 1965 and the entire world was represented in the original Star Trek series, all races, living and working together. What a tremendous ground-breaking achievement for the original series!
@@lawrenceallen8096
They're fans of the show making something they're passionate about! Just give them a break for christ sake. So annoying.
@@jaymac7203 Ah, well, its just that I get annoyed when people who are standing on other's shoulders decided to piss on how those are standing on.
I can't thank you enough for this labor of love. The "Enterprise" and her original crew is what started it all. Bravo! LLAP ❤️
This is, for me, amongst the best and the most intelligent Star Trek. On a par with the best of the Viacom episodes, so well-funded. You have created something that moves me and provoked my thoughts and feelings. The acting was so well done. Thank you for this.........
The return at the ending put a MASSIVE smile on my face. Wow.
This particular episode has won several awards including the TV-Guide best sci-fi webisode and was nominated for a Hugo award against Dr. Who and Battlestar Gallactica.
Simply because it's GREAT!
Well-deserved!!!!
As I pointed out to the director's son, not long ago, this episode had all the hallmarks of a production directed by Gerd Oswald ... just like the Old Series episode he directed, which also had a Shakespearean ambiance, a sad outcome for the leading lady, and a broken heart by Kirk at the end. I always considered most of the Old Series episodes as hokey; but that one stood out from the rest and showed what the series could have been ... as does yours.
I can´t understand why this series are not filmed in at least 1080p. 720p is blurry.
@@DihelsonMendonca It was uploaded 9 years ago. 720p was maximum of youtube that time.
This was beautifully done and will be a fan favorite for years to come. Thank you all for this !!
My goodness this was a very special episode, a touch of old school with modern approach, however a soft story of love & wisdom, a fantastic storyline involved, this will go places boldly go where no story has gone, 'WELL DONE THANK YOU a serious fan!!!👍
I'm a long-time
"Trekkie". I pride myself in being a macho "He Man".I've seen a lot of episodes but this one, broke me down to my bare and fundamental essence. it disassembled my atoms to the very core of their being, literally and rebuilt them back, from the ground up.The epitome of a true tear-jerker!🤧
George Takei - what a class a class act (on an off screen).
And so was Grace Lee Whitney.
Not forgetting Walter Konig, Tim Russ, Gary Graham and a few others from ST TV shows.
They've all given up their time for free to give me/us/everyone the closest thing to TOS we're ever going to get now that so many of the originals have passed on.
And it's all getting better and better, thanks to the dedication of people like James Cawley and Vic Mignogna and all the different cast and crew-members.
Way to go guys. Live long and prosper.
awesomeness....
Sulu was the most underused character on TOS, he never got a single good character episode! Finally. This is what both the actor and the fictional character deserved.
The only fitting thing i like about this epp is its connection between TOS and TMP eras involving Sulu as both Helmsman of the Enterprise and captain of the Excelsior.
The character of Sulu was to be featured in the Gamesters of Triskelion, but George Takei's role in The Green Beret Movie with John Wayne did not finish filming on time. It would have been Sulu, instead of Chekov opposite Jane Ross as Tamoon, which when I saw the original episode (as a pre-teen) I thought Jane Ross's portrayal of Tamoon was by a male actor in drag because of her deep voice. It would have been an inside joke if that was the case had George Takei co-starred in that episode.
I was lucky enough to talk with Mr Takei in 2013 when he appeared as narrator with the Nashville Symphony. George was in the green room with us for about 45 min after dress rehearsal. He spoke with fondness about his whole experience with Phase II and the rare opportunity to have a character expanding role so far removed from his original work. He appreciated too the chance to work with the “emerging talent” (his words) of Christina Moses, assuring us that we’d know her for more work soon. Right as usual, George. She has 30 IMDB credits today.
A Heart rendering story of love and sacrifice. Truly one of the best, bringing out the entire gamut of human / alien emotions. Well done!
Christina Moses absolutely knocked it out of the park. What an impressive actor -- holy crap!
This episode makes me cry every damn time I watch it. The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, and it doesn't get anymore Star Trek then that right there. The gut wrenching, soul crushing sacrifices the few endure so the many can survive, it's like the wrath of khan only with more tears. This is my favorite episode from the entire fan series and it is worthy to be Star Trek, and i would hope that even Gene Roddenberry would have been proud of this, rest his soul. Thank you for telling this story.
Gotta say, impressive! Good writing. great acting, and... Sulu the Barbarian! Possibly one of the best episodes of the entire franchise.
8 years after this was put online, this is still a powerful story the is head and shoulders above what the studios have been producing. I would have paid to see this in theatres and quite satisfied I had done so, thank you for all of your efforts. Kudos to the entire cast for a job very well done!
That was outstanding! Really hit with the feels in that last part, getting Demora to name her daughter after the sister she never knew. Paramount need to take that and make that story part of Sulu's legacy so to speak in SNW or something. These episodes are above and beyond, fantastic, really enjoying them.
THANK YOU! we really enjoyed the entire show, loved everything from seeing Mr.George Takei again to the original details and how well the story was done! i didn't know how much i missed the original until we found this, we will absolutely continue to be fans for a long long time.
+Dan Ibsen Exactly! i agree.
Best Star Trek episode ever. George Takei plays the part of Hikaru Sulu excellently as always. The reference to "The Tempest" goes deep on the poetic level.
Man for being a fan-film, this is by far the most moving episode of any Star Trek series, official and non-official. George Takei was amazing in this. I totally geeked out during the this whole episode. Thank you for keeping the TOS era alive with new and amazing stories.
I would say even if so a close 2nd is The Visitor (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)
Absolutely brilliant episode and I love seeing George Takei back as Sulu. It was also one of the saddest episodes I have seen, up there with City on the edge of Forever. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Cant get enough of it. I hav been watching this episode over and over.
It is... Star Trek at its finest!
I almost forgot about startreknewvoyages... the cure to the modern middle finger being given to a lot of us who loved Star Trek since we were children. Thank God this channel found me again.
I am 59, these new adventures, really bring the tears....
This is the best of all the star trek episodes!!! Great story Great acting!
Every time I look at this, it touches my heart. Christiana Moses, you did an exactly job...in fact everyone was on par. This was one of the best show in the entire franchise.
This is one of the finest star treks I’ve seen. And I’ve seen most of them. Sulu is brilliant!
What a great episode. Perfect TOS caliber storyline, and easily the most heartbreaking sci fi I've seen since the Farscape episode 'Look at the Princess.'
I agree, been trying to get my Trek pals to watch it. They nailed it. It's real Trek all the way. And the Kirk guy James Crawley built a Star Trek original set in Ticonderoga NY. Incredible.
Yes!
@@johnnyclifford9423 you can go see it in person. And sit in the Captain's Chair
@@Lee-Darin I was actually up there not long ago. I play in a band and I had a gig across the street from the set in Ticonderoga. And the great part of it? I was standing right next to James Crawley at Stewart's right down the road. LOL. I turned to him and I said "hey, aren't you that Star Trek guy?"
@@johnnyclifford9423 I'd love to meet him one day. William Shatner has been there a few times.
must say I am duly impressed. never knew these even existed . without millions of dollars behind them and still be able to produce quality programs
I was skeptical about whether or not this would be good, but I must admit that I truly did enjoy this. Great story that captures the spirit of the original series.
Are you kidding??? I mean any self respecting fan would have vomited 2 minutes into this abortion !
@@michaellepore105 Eh... Maybe it's just nostalgia getting to me.
@@seoulmandan You were right the 1st time, Dan. Ignore Lepore's foolish criticism.
I recently discovered these episodes while on Covid 19 lockdown in 2020. It is amazing what was accomplished here with a shoe string budget and what was probably a hell of a lot of work by this series creators, crew and actors. What an achievement. Thank you.
This was one of the best episodes of Star trek I've ever seen. It brought tears to my eyes. Awesome job.
POWERFUL STORY! I'm loving STNV! Every episode thus far has been a winner! Thank you all for your great efforts!
I'm so glad George takei was able to make this episode. It was very poignant and moving.
This is award material. Best written episode of any show. I cried so hard watching this.
"What is the point?" This series, and this episode in particular, has brought a lot of happiness to those involved in making and watching it. It was not that expensive to make and paid for by those making it. This series IS both highly creative and imaginative. If you do not like it, there are plenty of other videos on RUclips.
I suggest you direct your comments at the tons of stupid shows on TV.
Great work. Screw 'em.
I don't know if you still read this stuff & the comment was 7 years ago, but don't let the trolls bring you down. You have something like a 95% Like thingy going on. I'm way old, and a fan of stuff like "The Prisoner" "Star Trek" "Outer Limits" "I Spy" "Hill Street Blues" (I just love Name Dropping) and you knocked it out of the park with this episode, ripping the hide off the ball in the process!
@@jacksonmiller8309 Those who have created NOTHING in their lives sneer at those who have made something. I thought it was an amazingly good episode. Way better than the latest official series.
Oh but to be a part of this... I thought I'd seen/owned all thing trek. Can't wait to see this asap Hell yes
@@jacksonmiller8309 Show us your trek or shut the fuck up!
This is a fan made movie? So good! At first feel so strange to see different actors, but soon drew by the plot. MaCoy has a few shots really look like real MaCoy. The young Sulu is so impressive in the last 5 mins. Jim & Spot are good of course. This brings back all the memory and feel of the TOS!
Simply THE BEST Star Trek episode ever produced. George Takei was wonderful, as always. And the young actors / actresses were wonderful. Heart breaking yet beautiful.
I know there are few Star Trek shows out there, but adding the original cast is amazing. This show and the actors were excellent. This episode was great, This was fitting for Sulu. Long live Star Trek.
really impressed with young Sulu's acting at the end when he breaks down
I am so glad that I found these episodes before I kick the bucket they did a good job on them
RIP Grace Lee Whitney.
So sadly missed Yeoman Rand.
I hurried home back in the 60's to see the first episode. from that point I was s follower. This is great!
What a phenomenal story! Star Trek at its finest!
This is a great performance by George Takei. The writing and production quality are superb also. Keep up the good work. You deserve all the kudos!
An amazing production on so many levels. Sulu always has been a warrior and he so grew into this part and the lady who played his played his daughter really got into the part and was quite remarkable. Mccawley made a great Captain Kirk and hair color is such a simply thing.
I've been a Star Trek fan ever since the show first started. Mid 60's. These shows are great! Thanks all of you for making these! I'm proud of each and every one of you!
Well done, I was very moved . It reminded me of why I loved the old series so much. I would really like to see more from the guys behind this, thanks.
Wonderfully done. This is the second time I have watched this episode in a while. It brought me to tears at the end .. you guys are the best. Godspeed
Star Trek Continues
ruclips.net/p/PLhvh2eq-XLgqNxH6npvQxGxLCUHy90IpZ
Yes, Majel and Rodd Roddenberry as well as many others involved in producing the original Star Trek approved and assisted us with this project. Just have a look at the credits at the end.
Amazing, life long fan, never thought anyone would do the original justice, that episode was so touching. Well done folks, and thanks
Yes, this episode was nominated for the Hugo Award "Best Dramatic Presentation, Short Form" in 2008. The Dr. Who episode "Blink" came in first place for that award.
I've been a Trekkie from day one of the premiere of the original series. i absolutely love James Cawley playing Captain Kirk....as far as I am concerned he done a good job in portraying him....Kirk is, like all the other of the original actors, a very hard one to follow....I love this ST New Voyages series as well as the other one with ST Continues....I am and will always be your friend and fan to the Star Trek legacy. For me this is the hope for our future, if only the whole world would put aside their differences and work together....it could be a Heaven on our Earth, and possibly....a future for exploration of our solar system.....but not in it's present condition.
God bless all who have made and contributed to this endeavor of continuing a saga of hope for us.....without out it, we are but lost to nothing more than existence without insight or imagination. Hope is what helps build our futures. HIGH 5 to all who made this and other Star Treks possible. Love you all.....HIGH 5
Oh my
This was amazing. The production quality is impressive for a fan funded thing. The acting, though imperfect, does a great job of capturing the spirit of TOS
And the story was classic. Really stuck true to the "greek morality play... but in space" concept.
I think Roddenberry would be proud. A shame that the big companies these days can't look beyond the dollar signs to see this 😔
Christina Moses and George Takei were outstanding in this! Wow!
This was excellent. So good it left me in tears ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Awesome! George Takei is a great addition to the Star Trek New Voyages! Very touching!
" Alana" Christian Moses, is a gem.
Absolutely!!!!!.......
isn't she though?!
And yummilicious
This episode would be one of my favorites, but it left me with a " real " sense of loss. The writers were very clever in their craft! Bravo for pulling me into the story like the gravitational phenomenon that you created. This is the fourth time I viewed this and managed to shed tears. Bravo to all!
Outstanding, A+++, a fantastic story and kudos to everyone for creating such an epic episode of Star Trek.
This series reminds me that a person properly motivated and working with a great team can do just about anything.
I just started watching New Voyages/Phase II a few days ago & I love how with each episode they are steadily improving.
This one had the emotional depth of many of the original series/next generation episodes. It made you laugh ("shouldn't you send me candy & flowers first") and cry, with the very touching scenes near the end when Sulu's daughter knew her life could not continue.
Awesome job guys! Very much looking forward to watching the 2-part episode tomorrow & all future installments.