Karen Read trial: Hung jury ends case as prosecutors vow to retry it
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
- We have full analysis of the mistrial in the Karen Read case, looking at what we learned from the court proceedings and what's to come.
Follow NBC10 Boston on...
Instagram: nbc10boston
TikTok: tiktok.com/@nbc10boston
Facebook: NBC10Boston
X: NBC10Boston
![Eminem - The Death of Slim Shady [Album Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X0HIrS6kUYI/mqdefault.jpg)
they should get another judge, prosecutor and send it to another town where the McThugs have no standing.
Shes CLEARLY NOT GUILTY. The 10% who still insist shes guilty are starving their pea brains of oxygen
Bootlickers are simp minded. Only believe the tyrannical pigs.
10-2 for CONVICTION
The jurors deliberated longer than Proctor spent "investigating" (16hrs) to find out what really happened to OJO..
Deeply held beliefs? moral convictions and principles? I thought it’s about evidence no?
Exactly what I was thinking
If I was a resident of Canton I would be furious for the waste of money and how the whole police department was stripped naked in this trial.
They need to clean house
The inverted video with the overwritten timestamps was it for me. Faked evidence.
The Lallyport video
Good for you, Oprah! Luckily, there were people on the jury who had the ability to listen and have logic and common sense.
What did mirroring the car do to "benefit" the Prosecution?? Why would they do that? I can guarantee NO ONE can answer that. People are so gullible and will believe whatever the defense tells them to believe. It's unbelievable
@@juliec2999go lick boots.
Bev has been exhausted through the whole trial 😅
Auntie Bev needs to retire…she showed us all that she doesn’t enjoy her job.
The judge was of the opinion that Karen Read is Guilty.
Oww judge canolies
Yes I'm tired judge canolies
We love u jc
We will keep funding Karen, so bring it! You're corruption, all of you is showing! Bev picked the floor person for a reason!
For sure, the judge needs to recuse herself!
Well, the super-confusing verdict-slip the jury instructions and the fact that the jury could have the testimony’s either in writing or have them read out didn’t help!! How could they ever have come to a verdict?!?! This case is so faulty but the jury system is also a big issue. This case really proves that!
Prosecutors need to be tried at this point !!!
Vote out this DA!
IF! A second trial happens, the defense will and should not allow , the prosecutor to call the State Police as so-called experts in Medical, Technical or Accident reconstruction
Why is that? That actually helped strengthen the defense's case.
True I see it both ways they weren't supposed to testify on medical but they were so pathetic and so ridiculous in their theories that it definitely had to strengthen the defenses case @@JennyLouLou
The judge allowing that expert in just shows how incompetent she is as a judge.
The defense can’t decide who the prosecutor calls as a witness. They can object but it’s the judge who decides. And. The witness you are talking about did not do the prosecutor any favors….
@@josefinasoderholm6488 yes you are correct, still the defense should strongly object!! The prosecutor called in too many witnesses, allowed the State Police to give so called in expert testimony, in fields beyond their education, mudding the real experts. It was a confusing mess.
Have you all seen the town meeting June 25? I was SHOCKED!
It was sad & crazy! So many feel helpless in that town.
Won't release the jurors names... BET YOUR ASS, the McAlberts, CPD, and the MSP, knows everything about each juror
Did you hear there was a dead Turtle with a hole in its head hanging from TB’s parents house. Smells exactly like the McAlberts. ESP dirty Brain.
I can’t believe the witch hunt where people are free to slander entire families without evidence.
One trillion percent
Yaaaas!!!
I think they chose this small court so the McAlbert's could intimidate the jury.
I wonder now when the jury sees that it was the FBI saying that it didnt happen the way prosecution said, what they think now.
9:53 BS. The CW doesn’t actually believe she guilty. Cmon. They HAVE to MAKE her guilty to get the focus off of the true killers.
💤Everyone heard Experts Prove~ The man was sucker punched. The dog attacked him. They left his body out to freeze. Judge is guilty💤💤💤💰
Proctor: "Get the F*KK off my lawn"
Gosh what a level-headed guy.
He's a coward and made his wife call out the journalist. Coward pig.😂
FBI needs to step in!
They need to hold the next trial outside of Canton. The Alberts, apparently, are a very big deal in Canton according to online sources.
I think Michael Morrissey is arrogant enough, delusional enough, vindictive enough, and just evil enough to retry Karen Read even if the vote was 10-2 in favor of not guilty. (I hope it was lopsided like that, but I don't know yet.) I really could see him doing that. Just an awful office. It's so sad to witness because our society needs good moral ethical intelligent and conscientious prosecutors offices.
Its amazing how people can see the evidence so differently.. im concerned about her safety.
When is Proctor going on trial?
For what? Nasty texts?
How about planting evidence and leaking information?? And just being an asshole
@@jackieblue6116you're a room temperature IQ copsucker. Wise up.
This shows the weakness of the commonwealth case
No, it doesn't!
@@Fee212 Yes it does. You have a smooth brain.
@@Fee212 Yes it does, otherwise it would have been a unanimous guilty verdict!
Yes it does because they brought over 70 witnesses to the stand and could not get a guilty verdict. The End. @Fee212
@Fee212 you bootlickers are weak minded.
No sympathy for Trooper Proctor. If he had acted with integrity as a law enforcement officer - as his job demands he would not be in this situation. Sure, he’s sorry now. 🙄
The investigation was done with the "utmost integrity", remember?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Fck the police. They all don't care about us. Only the bareback the blue crew.
The police have got his blood on their hands
I have no clowns in this circus, but I am saddened by the mistrial. I expected it, though.
how many police on the jury next time?
Judge Bev is doing her best to protect the Albert family just like HER BROTHER DID. Corrupt police department and corrupt judge. Ruse up Canton and vote Canonne out!!
Are we ever going to find out what the breakdown of the mistrial was? Why is that some secret? I can tell you the breakdown in any mistrial . It's seems like that's all mysterious for some reason.
you can be sure it was 11 to 1 or in an extreme case 10 to 2
Oh wow, Proctor dropping F bombs are reporters. He seems like such a nice guy. 🙄
Well done, Canton Confidential! I have thoroughly enjoyed your coverage of this case and I'm glad you're sticking around for a few days. I'm going to miss you guys when all is said and done. If that ever happens. I cannot get over how it wasn't a slam dunk NOT guilty. The CW proved virtually nothing. 🤔
ugh, i had to mute the stream at the beggining, i can't stand the sound of Auntie Bev's voice, she's corrupted
Lally's voice is horrible. Just monotone. What if any....?
Again Sue O’Connell demonstrates she heads and shoulders above with her intelligent and considered reporting. Sue’s truly honest approach and informed approach to reporting is something both Law&Crime and CourtTV could learn a hell of a lot from!
The Canton Confidential team are head and shoulders above their peers on this story to date.
I couldn't agree more
RIP Officer O'Keefe 💔 🙏
Whats up with Karen Read not hugging her mom......hmmmmm
she hugged her mom same time she hugged her dad . her left arm around dad and right arm around mom
maybe the dog licked her taillight and that's how the Pig DNA got on his arm? LOL
Lead investigator Proctor relieved of duty and transferred out of DA's investigation office today. Disciplinary hearing Scheduled 😅 in other words he's on paid leave until they decide what to do with him.
They did that with COP, that SHOWED UP IN UNMARKED CARS, LIKE THE GESTAPO, AT MY HOME!!
I GOT HIM ON VIDEO,
ALL GOES BACK TO COPS COVERING UP FOR MY ABUSIVE EX, A COP!! YEAH, THEY COVER UP AS GROUP! I STARTED RECORDING THEM!! ALL OVER USA! MINE IS IN TEXAS, VERY CORRUPT!
The movie is close
They won't find peace because she never hit John....
The Albert family did....🤬
Slander. You have no evidence. And they were not on trial. Shame.
Absolutely I agree 💯
@@jackieblue6116they weren't on Triel because they framed Karen they're corrupt. Getting rid of the dog got rid of there phones deleted tex messages
@@mariagutierrez4721 Quite the opposite. Karen’s defense team is trying to frame innocent people and their children. Disgusting. John never went in the house! The gps data proves it. Her car hit “something “ like her father said while she backed up at 24 miles per hour - all in evidence. Not to mention what her niece heard her say and emts, firemen and on and on.
@@jackieblue6116 Have you asked yourself why the FBI has been looking into this case and other appearances of corruption in the CW?
They were willing to spend a pretty penny on the last two expert witnesses the defense called. They're of the opinion that these witnesses are highly credible.
⚖STOP CORRUPTION!!!⚖⚖
💞💞FREE KAREN READ💞💞
JUSTICE FOR OFFICER JOHN O'KEEFE
💞💞🙏🙏⚖⚖ From South Africa
The CW lost by not getting a win, KR won by not getting a win!!!
Any Karen Read teams wants to know what was the outcome!
Letters were replicated from the instructions judge read to jury. Exact same words used
Blame the judge for the mistrial. The OKeefe family simply needs to ask for the feds to investigate if they want the truth.
Just grab 12 new jurors and have them watch the trial. No?
Yes starting July 22
@@RatTerminator7/22 is just a pre-trial hearing. This case won't reach a jury trial for a long time, at least a year but probably longer.
@JennyLouLou I know but its still a New trial
😂😂😂
Seems like judicial process is overdue for updating as technology has changed things drastically. But rewatching the trial might be overstepping a bit.
Haha judge bias Bev, as much as you helped lollypop, and didn’t allow most evidence to come in, case looks totally good on you, Boston, corrupt,
SO IS BEXAR COUNTY TX COURTS! I AM VICTIM OF DOMESTIC COP ABUSE! THEY COVER UP FOR EACH OTHER AND SO DO COURTS!
This is a waste of our taxpayer money
From an old, retired criminal defense attorney/ State & Federal prosecutor/ Magistrate/ law school prof (JD, SJD, PhD)
District Attorneys USUALLY say they'll re-try cases like this, puff out their chests, talk tough, and posture like big boys and girls.
BUT. THIS Case never should've been prosecuted in the first place. It's irretrievably flawed and corrupted.
Within a few weeks, I expect, we'll start seeing people who were in the house, or with the state police, maybe prosecutors, and possibly judges ending up in Federal lockup.
The small Federal investigation by the FBI for police and prosecutorial misconduct has grown exponentially into major RICO Case.
It seems my recent use of "McAlbert Crime Family" and "McAlbert Mafia" were on point.
Any way you slice it, this Case -- against Karen Read, anyway -- WILL NOT result in a guilty verdict. Re-trying HER would be a bigger train wreck than this one.
IF John O'Keefe's killer(s) are tried again, Karen Read won't be the Defendant.
I SUSPECT that one of the people who was in the Albert house that night has already run to the FBI, cut a deal and ratted- out everything. He KNOWS the "McAlbert Mafia" will make HIM their Fall Guy once they're arrested.
That's what I see coming.
We know John went inside and descended stairs based on his Apple Health data on his cell. Karen saw him walk to the door, and all witnesses saw Karen alone in the car, and John's body wasn't on the lawn. Lucky Lauchran drove by at 2:30 and 3:30, and there was no body on the lawn. At 3:30, a light colored Ford Edge (Colin's car) was parked at the spot where John's body would later be found.
Independent biomechanical engineers proved it was scientifically impossible for John's body to have ended up where it was found due to being struck by Karen's car, and the damage to the car wasn't caused from hitting John.
Proof beyond "reasonable" doubt only applies when jurors aren't UNREASONABLE! For an effective jury panel, most people lack the requisite emotional intelligence to be fair & the ability to give someone grace in times of trauma or grief. They don't realize that people all respond differently when experiencing trauma, or that "not crying during the trial" isn't an indication of guilt.
The lunatics who hear factual, credible, common sense evidence that the car didn't strike a person - and John's injuries weren't caused by a car - from the best independent experts in the nation used by the DOJ & NHL...and _still_ refuse to accept their testimony as true - are serving on juries & putting innocent people in prison ALL over...ALL the time.
So, _why_ is this our chosen justice system? Any of us could be imprisoned for something we didn't do because of those people. There are countless examples of this happening to people who were later exonerated upon further investigation. We cannot stand for this. I don't want these people on my jury if I'm ever falsely accused of a crime! I don't want my freedom taken because of a few people's blind faith in law enforcement or critique of my facial expressions.
Why do we put such an important decision in the hands of a jury with NO prerequisite IQ, education, life experience, or proven open-mindedness? Why wouldn't potential jurors have to pass a thorough screening interview, mental health assessment, psychological evaluation, or emotional intelligence screening? We all agree that our current system is wrought with human error & bias, yet we've done nothing to correct it in over 200 years!
Without enacting a more rigorous jury screening process, here's how we could improve the process to ensure defendants receive the benefit of the doubt while preventing wrongful convictions:
A "guilty" verdict must be unanimous. A 10-2 or 11-1 "not guilty" verdict is an acquittal. That way, 1 or 2 "unreasonable" people won't cause a mistrial!
Respecting everyone else opinions, I’m happy for KR too!!!💙
You don’t respect the Okeefes opinions if you’re happy for Karen.
@@jackieblue6116 your opinion is yours mines is mine. think what you want!
@@Whitsid_357-x3 I like the way you think.
@@jazamaraz8029 thank you!
@@jackieblue6116ok bootlicker. Is your husband a cop and beat you for not doing the dishes?😂😂😂😂
People who was leading this case only hve them selfs to blame they done poor job bye not investigated thiis case in the proper way
Even the CW itself has doubts, they just put Proctor on administrative leave.
They're already undermining the retrial, if it ever gets that far.
REHOME Prosecutor Lally !
THEY FORGET, FEDS GOING AFTER PROCTOR IS GOING TO CHANGE EVERYTHING, NOT GUILTY...👩⚖️👩⚖️👩⚖️👩⚖️👩⚖️
She fooled all of you!
🎉Karen Not Guilty 🎉
Awesome! A retrial so we can all hear what Michael Proctor said and did. Stupid.
Now that Proctor has been fired, I really wonder if this embarrassing DA is really going to try this again. They lucked out that even one juror believed their silly case.
@Richard.Atkinson He was just fired?
@@vincedidiana5781 Not fired. "Relieved from duty and transferred out of the detective unit of the Norfolk County DA." I.e. he's riding a desk and collecting a paycheck. For now.
I was wondering the same thing are they really going to use the investigation of a disgraced officer who was just relieved of his duties pending a disciplinary hearing 😂😂 c’mon that’s just ridiculous if I livid in Canton I’d be furious if they waste more taxpayers money on another trial
@@stephanieperri7747 Great point!
😮😮🎉@@SapphireandFadedJeans
Zero chance they retrial the trial
Well hate to break it to you .. they are re trying lol
They are
it's another nothingburger from lallyburger
Yup, interview the most unhinged obsessed KARENS😂🤡👌🏻
This coverage is insanely biased. Crazy to see!
Lawr enforcement
Ya two jurors think guilty the other 10 are guilty she’s guilty
Huh? You make no sense.
No! I heard from a juror cousin that they were almost split in half! She worded it differently, so she could have even meant split in half.
Ret4rd. You make zero sense.
Where did my blm money go ?
Why would they seek additional information after they ask for the cert report and she said you have everything you're going to get she shut that down right there so there was no need for them to ask any further questions.... the deliberations I feel like we're over right then and there because that was it
I would have found her guilty for the smirking alone.
and a killer goes free😕
Yep. The McAlberts walk away, for now. Only the FBI investigation can bring them to justice
It'll be interesting what the FBI and DOJ do. Time will tell.
The killers have been free but not for long
GUILTY MURDER 2🤬
😅😅😅😅😅😅
OK copsucker. Your brain is clouded with boot polish. 😂
The defences job is to create reasonable doubt clearly they didn’t do their Job as well as they thought they did .
It was a crime of passion. Re-try her and send her to prison for the rest of her life...
😂 wipe the boot paste off your chin. It’s embarrassing
Stunad
Your copsucking brain. Will not let you think any clearer. Please seek therapy and meds.😂
Think again this isn’t a win ! This is a big loose !!!
Your brain is a bit loose 🫠
Not quite...a loss would have been a loss.
Its only a loss for the tax payers
Loose? Haha.
You have a screw “loose” or is it “lose?” 🤔
And the okeeefe people will be there this time
Karen Read is Guilty!!!!!
Huh?
cope and seethe
I hope Karen Read realizes she wasn't acquitted. Put the liquor away Karen.
@@RobertP-kk5ou It is a victory!
To the woman who said this could be any one of us. No, it couldn’t unless you get drunk, and in a rage hit your bf and leave him to freeze to death.
Now what could be any of us is what has happened to the Alberts. Do you realize that evidence shows that John never entered that house and it would have had to take 4 seconds for him to fly into the house, be beaten and fly back out to where he was found? On grass with his phone. That’s what the evidence shows.
Thank goodness there were at least some people on the Jury that had BRAINS, common sense, and the ability to use cognitive thinking skills. OBVIOUSLY Karen hit him. The whole blaming of the family and friends who all went home and to bed after they supposedly tossed a cops body out on their lawn, is so moronic I can't even believe people bought that. And blaming the DOG!!?? Omg!! 😂😂 And next time two men "play fight" in a bar....that clearly shows they're probably ready to murder someone 😂 You can't get a more ridiculous narrative. Karen had a broken tail light and her broken light was laying around his body!! His DNA was on the back of her car!! She sped BACKWARDS according to the car computer!! She was wasted and DRIVING! They fought and there's a huge gap in time from when she left johns house and before she showed up to the friends house! She obviously went to the Albert house to look for him first...and SAW HIM, which was why she was in hysterics when she got to Jens house (she also TOLD someone she found him at 5am). Her over the top screaming and panic DOES NOT MAKE SENSE if she didnt know she hit him!! Its common sense!
Can ANYONE explain why karen would assume he was DEAD just because he didn't come home after a HUGE fight where he was drinking and supposedly walked into a party?? No one thinks that way! He didn't have a car to get home! Anyone would assume he passed out at his friend's house! But SHE screams about him being dead and they have to go "look for him?" Why would they have to go look for him if she saw him go in the house? If she saw him go into the house, why not bang on their door and scream, "what did you do to my boyfriend!!??" She never mentioned to ANYONE that he went in the house because she knew he didn't! And she was screaming about hitting him because she KNEW she sped backwards towards him, then curved off....probably thinking she missed him (unfortunately the right side of her SUV hit him!). She knows she hit him. His family isn't stupid, they know she hit him too.... which is why it's so sad for THEM. And no cop is going to plant a bunch of evidence on someone who is innocent so they can help the "real" cop killers get away with it. I suppose it was just pure "luck" that she broke her tail light and started yelling about hitting him? Ridiculous. Cops aren't going to risk going to prison for illegally planting evidence on someone when there's no evidence that the people they are supposedly "covering up a crime for" did anything wrong!?? That makes NO sense. What's the point?
These people outside rooting for Karen, are absolutely nuts.. grow up, .all of you. John is looking down and shaking his head at you guys. The despicables
The CW failed to convince all the jurors. They brought the case. It's on them.
Shut the buck up, copsucker. You're lacking cognitive thinking skills😂
The prosecution will be able to finetune its presentation and, hopefully, they will get a murder conviction.
She’s soo guilty !!
Jen McCabe is that you???
How? The jury could not figure that out. Keep on copsucking the government. 😂
The judge made this case worse for the jurors.