Finn, you have to let yourself curate your audience. 87% is not THAT bad of a dislike ratio. I say start exclusively making content that you're actually interested in, and others who are interested in that will follow eventually. You just have to be patient. Most of your audience, who loves no matter what you put out, will stick around. The important thing is to let yourself be happy with what you're making. At the end of the day, it's YOUR channel. If you're burned out making material you don't want, then stop doing that! Anyone who doesn't understand that isn't worth your stress anyway. Selfish people will never be satisfied. If that doesn't work, make another channel where you upload stuff that you're actually interested in, and occasionally keep posting to this one. Whatever you want, buddy. Personally, I'm here for the ride, whatever your endeavor is.
Your 2nd channel is AMAZING. When you inject your humour and personality, it's absolute gold. And I pay extra attention when you start talking about new music.
@@Frederick0220 I found out that I'm watching and enjoying his livestream snippets more than the MBA - specially the 2000's decade stuff that bring me a lot of cringe memories of my youth lol
Finn if you're not going to pull back here are some ideas: - worst lyrics of popular songs - underrated musicians/songwriters - music in tv, movies, video games - a baddiecore explanation - disney songs that don't suck - past musicians that would be canceled by today standards - beef in the rock world - best songs to do things to (sex, skateboard, video games) - explain how different level of musicians make their money - a history of blue collar Punk (ex. Gaslight Anthem, hot water music, Social D, Menzingers)
I really liked your lifestories, life advice, and how to overcome addictions. Those stories were the most relatable and felt the most genuine. If you make more of those I would watch them all.
Finn, you are absolutely the only content creator covering music that has really ever held my attention and intrigue. You do quality stuff. I also think you do a great job of the yin and yang with the more fact based stuff on this channel, and the more fun off the wall stuff on your personal. With this channel in general maybe you can do the thing that some movie directors do: one for the studio, one for me. Keep it up and much love!
Never commented on your vids before, but you're not alone, dude. Content creation is a different form of a 9 to 5 job. The mental pressure to produce is real, and I feel you on every point you made. For what it's worth I didn't sense any of this from your vids. Your opinions always come across so polished and insightful; honestly, I can probably speak for the silent majority when I say they're why I watch your videos! Hoping to see more in the future bro. 👊
Make a Weekly series thats about discovering new music and showcasing it. That would be a phenomenal tool for your viewers, and hell, you'll find some great new music, too!
As someone who's been doing this for over 10 years (and definitely gotten the same kind of comments/panic attacks/etc) I totally get where you're coming from man. Try and remember to give yourself a pat on the back for how far you've come every once in a while. It's hard not to take it personally when its your whole being put into the content you make, you really care, and then something does poorly. But try not to let it get you down man. Love your content! Whatever you do I'm sure it'll be succesful. Personally, I love learning new stuff about the bands I love when you talk about them. And deep dives into the 90's 2000's are super nostalgic.
LOL I said the same thing when I first heard dubstep. It was half beats that one could headbang to Kinda makes sense since Skrillex was like the pioneer of that shit and he was a vocalist from a post hardcore band before he did dubstep
Finn. You are the Punk rock MBA. You are going thru what many artists go through everyday. Monetizing underground movements has always been difficult. This is why so many artists " sell out" The mainstream will always exist, and it is by nature historically close minded. Welcome to the club my friend. For the record, I like ya. 👍
I’m only speaking for myself here, but you’re the only creator where i watch every video of yours even if im not interested in the topic you’re talking about. I hope you find your way finn❤
Hes great and knows a lot on music for sure i dont agree with every take but i still like his vids and him as a person hes also very funny love his humor
Finn. I watch anything you send. You are so dang funny and I look forward to every time there is a notification for a new video. But, your family and self are number one with priorities. Thanks for all you do!
Yeah, after all the hours I put into fun little genre hoping Christmas music videos I did for years to all have less than 1000 views kills me. "Do what YOU like" only ever takes you so far.
I had more feelings for: " _if the message is 'no please keep doing what you're doing, that's what we want' then that's cool too_ " reminded me of being in a abusive relationship and believing i deserved it
Your opinions and personality are what always made me come back to the channel when I first found it. I didn’t always agree with your takes, but you always at least had a good rationale for them and presented them in an entertaining way I’ve always liked hearing you point out the influences of older bands on newer bands. For example, I hadn’t noticed how much a lot of modern metal seems to take from Linkin Park, but when you pointed it out it made a lot of sense. Maybe you could try doing a video series on pointing those similarities out to bridge the gap between nostalgia and new bands and maybe drive attention to newer music
Music teacher here. I was talking to my kids about the scene back in the early 2000s when I realized how they don't really have anything equivalent. They'll never know what it's like to do watch a friend's band at some dive that's probably a crack house by day. Not sure if that's helpful, but there ya go!
tbh i dont even really watch this channel, but i watch pretty much every upload on your Finn McKenty channel. even tho those vids have been largely tier lists as of late, theyre still always so much fun, your sense of humor and the way you talk about subjects you enjoy is fucking awesome. i really enjoy it a lot. i think a lot of your fans watch you mostly for your personality specifically!!
Sorry you're going through this Finn. My take is you need to make the vids you love and try monetize additionally elsewhere. The hours researching, scripting, filming, editing on something you don't totally enjoy... will eat away at your energy (for you, for fam, for other ideas). Appreciate you!
i second this as a person who, just like many others in the world, has to do a job he doesnt like that much just for the sake of providing to his family, but any time i have to put effort in it, especially mental effort, it just sucks because i'd be fighting with my mind so loud. Finn you clearly love to make videos, researching all of the stuff and putting yourself into it, it would be painful to do that for something you don't like... that is pretty sure brother. Hope you'll figure out and till that time i will keep watching and liking :D
Pretty much this. When your passion becomes your job, you end up depending on everything around it (in this case viewers for example) and start hating what you used to love, because you wrap it up with what you still do, which is not what you love at all. And cue the anxiety and existential dread. I can't imagine doing this publicly on top of that, where if you stay the same people will start whining that you're not original enough, and if you change you'll get the "it used to be better" comments. If you can afford it, I would recommend a very long break, figure out what else you could do to support your family that wouldn't destroy your well being, and come back, if you want to, on your own terms. Also you'd probably end up with less followers, but more in tune with the content you want to make.
A well respected musician gave a warning to my neighbour, a well respected local musician in his own right, as advice before recording "your relationship to your music will change drastically as soon as you _need_ something from it".
Finn, as a product of the 90’s and 00’s, your first couple years of videos almost single-handedly got me into so many incredible bands - everything from ADTR to Waterparks to BMTH. I was lured in by the “what killed the genre” series and stuck around because I got educated on everything I had missed in my college and adult years. I miss learning about new music from you and getting your take on what’s going on in the rock music space. Thank you for transparency. I’ve spent dozens of hours with you over the years but have never taken the time to tell you I appreciate you and think you’re amazing.
I love your content Finn and I respect your opinion. I had no idea you were going through this. Also, congrats on your sub count. When I subbed you were under 10k and thought man this guy is underrated.
Finn, the main reason I watch you is because I respect your opinion and insights of the music industry; especially from a marketing perspective. I dunno if this idea sounds interesting to you, but surely you have a lot of music creators in your audience (especially in Rock and Metal); maybe you could discuss what other artists are doing (in any genre) to gain attention and present it in a way where other artists could apply it to their music. I'm not saying you have to go full teacher mode, but maybe if your content had "applicable education", it could be appreciated no matter what genre you're talking about. Lastly, I recently learned that "negative" engagement is still "engagement", and I think the algorithm still rewards it. If you can afford to make what you wanna make for a short period of time, and endure the haters, maybe in the long run, the haters will leave and you'll be left with a more loyal and supportive audience. I'm with you!
Thanks for what you do, Finn. I like your channel a lot and peep it regularly. While I recognize that a fair share of the videos haven't necessarily been things that I'm specifically interested in, I still love the channel(s) and your style -- That means, *I like your personality, and the things you're interested in.* As such, *I'm a fan as long as you're enjoying yourself.* As it's 'a music channel', sharing music that you're enjoying and interested in (REGARDLESS of genre) will always be a draw for people like me, because I myself am always spending time checking out new (to me) artists and intentionally spending time in different genres... because I love music! Also, you're the Punk Rock MBA, it's pretty punk to do whatever the fuck you want, tbh. For you, that could mean not just sharing but discussing more of what you find interesting about whatever you're listening to or spending time with, whether that's a personal connection and/or technical/production point. This lets *_you_* be your channel a bit more, so maybe you don't feel so dry and soulless, because you can offer more of your thoughts and insights about things you're actively into, and [re]build your community around that. Those of us who enjoy you for your vibe will eat that up. You can maybe involve some content relating to shows that you're able to make it out to, what some scenes are like, industry interviews as possible (that don't just have to be band members themselves, but tech and production crews are cool too, IMO). Idk, I just like lots of good music bro, wherever we find it! I don't know if my suggestions translate well into meaningful content production, but regardless, I hope you can ease into content that you enjoy, and have a better community where you're BOTH enjoying the journey. 🖤🙏
Maybe a semi-regular video about new artists you've discovered or listening to atm? You're how I learned about people like Essenger, Bilmuri, and a handful of other artists. In fact you're among my main sources for discovering new music these days.
Hey Finn, firstly I think it's great that you're so open about all this. Burnout is real and having the pressure of supporting a young family is difficult. You're right, when there is livelihood at stake, you can't always follow your passion 100% of the time and a lot of people who aren't under pressure don't understand this. This sucks and you're not alone in this position. I tune into your videos because I like your style, not because of the topic, but maybe for the masses you can find a balance "one for you, one for them" kind of thing. As for topics, maybe some topics that would resonate with your audience would be: - how bands make money on tour and how it's different from the 90s/early 00s - deep-dive videos on 80s alternative bands that influenced 90s/00s bands - interesting takes on alternative music in different media (movies, video games, etc.) - how marketing shaped music in the 90s and how it's different today - submissions from viewers redesigning band logos and then rank them - interviews with music industry people I'm sorry to see you struggling. Your family is the most important thing, so do what you need to do, man. Thanks again for being yourself!
Fin, dude, you are an absolute inspiration. You have introduced me to so many new bands and songs that has provided endless joy in my life. God bless you brother! I love watching all your content.
I'm a very new subscriber, but basically the reason I subbed was actually for your opinions and actual experience in the punk/hardcore/metal scenes for basically all of the 2000s and 90s which as someone who wasn't around when a lot of these bands you talk about were big is pretty fascinating.
Just want to say that I'm incredibly grateful for you. You're a good man, a great father, and my favorite content creator of all time. You've always been a breath of fresh air for me.
Finn, one of my favorite things the channel (that you are doing less often) is your technical musical analysis for laymen. You are so good at picking apart what is similar/different between different styles of music, and contrasting how they use different tools for similar effect. I'd love to see "Finns guides to genre X". Also, with your channel growing like it is, I'm sure many viewers might not know enough about the technical side music to follow some of your analysis. Basics guides might also be a great thing to have, for example; what makes someone good at a particular instrument, song structure basics, what is groove vs. virtuosity, etc. etc. You have a gift for that sort of thing, and even after decades of being a massive music enthusiast you regularly change my perspective and understanding of the technical side of music. On a personal note, thanks for educating me on punk and hardcore. I was lucky enough to come of age in a place where I could go to shows of multiple generas of music most nights of the week, and I took full advantage. I made a habit of watching every kind of music in every scene I could get myself into. I was always more than happy to go to NY hardcore shows in the 90's because the shows were amazing (and cheep) even if the music rarely hit for me. Your knowledge and passion helped me understand and appreciative the shows I did get to. Thank you for making so many connections for me and giving me the context to more fully appreciate so much of the music I love, especially for music OUTSIDE of your focus on metal. I hope your feeling better and that the comments on this video help you find a little bit of direction.
Being a small business owner and a hobbyist is not easy. Especially when there comes a time when you realize that work and passions do have some sort of separation, even if you believe that what you do for work is your passion, it does not always remain that way. I would say, make a brand new channel that only supports the content that you personally enjoy doing and want to do. Keep the other channels, strictly for work. You can’t lose. It’s just a time sacrifice for your personal stuff, which sucks, but it’s the best way!
Or talking to millennials who are in the game about the music and lifestyle which you grew up with and then try to reach an audience from all types. (It could be said better but that's on the top of my head)
i've always loved your style Finn, and the more you put your personality into the videos, the more i liked em. i hate that the metrics just aren't there for it to make sense for you to do *your* thing *your* way, i really do get that 'worn down' feeling. but man, i wish it was different right there along side ya. much love Finn!
The stuff you've made sharing what you're excited about and/or believe is up and coming are my favorite videos. I've found new bands, genres of music and new perspectives on topics thanks to those videos.
I'm in my early 40's and thought that my musical exploration had pretty much come to a halt. Stuck in my ways hardcore, punk, and metalish dude. But you have had an influence on how I view music, the whole music industry, what music I listen to (new and older), and various things about life in general. You are passionate, interesting, humorous, and relatable. I originally stumbled onto to your channel expecting just the usual facts and incite on music and ended up getting a whole lot more. Especially on your personal channel, I'm laughing my ass off and having a great time. Thank you.
So grateful for this channel. My favorite videos are the ones you said are less popular - your takes on new genres, but also things related to your own history with hardcore punk (including you last video on it). I'd love to see more videos of you telling stories from your time in the DIY punk scene that elicit deeper life lessons and reflections that are more than just critiques of the limitations of the subculture too. Maybe a frame around a particular band, but bring in your personal stories.
Hey man, this is the only comment I’ve ever left on a video. Been watching for a couple of years now and enjoy both channels. As someone who’s in advertising also (digital marketing for ~10 years now), I would find it fascinating to understand more how and why bands are marketed the way they are. Learning a bit about why record companies have pushed certain bands and not others, and how personalities of band members influence those campaigns, seems really interesting. For your creative inspiration if time permits you should definitely get a third channel going on these other topics you want to generate a new audience for. I’m sure you’ve thought about this before but you sound like you are getting burned out and need a change. Maybe this video is the sign you’ve been looking for. Appreciate all that you’ve done in the past. It’s been very entertaining and insightful.
Your opinions and anecdotes are a big part of the reason I subscribed to begin with and now watch your second channel. I understand your dilemma. Some of my favorite topics you’ve discussed are the ones adjacent to music and focused on the scene’s culture. It would be fun to see videos relating your other specialties (business/marketing/branding) to millennials who grew up and want to start a music adjacent business or a band. Would seem to fit with the channel name. Regardless, looking forward to seeing what you create in the future 🤘
Discovered you by your “What killed slam” video and haven’t missed a video since! Would love more “what killed ___” stuff, it was always fun and had lots of opinions and personality thrown in which was awesome 👏
Fin, definitely a vulnerable moment . You may feel like you have plateaued when it comes to content creation. I think switching gears could benefit you . Think back to 90s nostalgia. What’s something that always caught the attention of the masses. Shows like “ making the band “ are due for a reboot. You could possibly ask local bands for submissions, share them on your channel, go to a live show and film it “ reality tv “ style . Interview the bands , share back stories and help them with what they may lack ? Branding opportunities, sound recordings or just using your audience to capture attention? Could be a useful tool to discover new underground music . Help you get the ideas flowing again . Be watching since 2018 and I’ve also noticed the episodes are missing that spark. You are going through the motions to make content because it’s your main income vs doing it because you just loved it . Much love from Pennsylvania 🤙🏻 keep your head up
This actually sounds like a great idea. Kind of back to your roots kind of thing, but with modern music. As a millennial I also don't really know anything about the "scene" nowadays ie. I'm old enough that what kids do and are interested in is foreign and scary to me. Some content about that could be very interesting if done right.
A video about mid tier bands that have been able to have a long career like Coheed, Hawthorne Heights, Bayside, Four Year Strong, The Dear Hunter, or New Found Glory for example could be super cool.
do a weekly or monthly video covering a specific tour that’s happening that same time. maybe get an interview with a band member about how tour is going
Love your stuff Finn, but as of late I have been having a lot more fun with your 2nd channel. The tier lists, the worst (or best of) a decade, and tournaments have been a constant go to for me when I need something to listen to while working. Sorry to hear you feel this channel has stagnated, always enjoyed your history of _____ vids even when I hadn’t heard anything by the band you were covering. You have introduced me to a lot of bands, and I’m here for whatever’s next on the channel. You got this and Hell Yeah Brother!
The podcasts/interviews on your other channel are pretty cool, I would love to see more of them. Furthermore, you perhaps could not only talk about music and scenes as the main topics - but rather movies, book, films, games etc., which are somewhat related to punk/metal/rock and how those have been influential?
seriously, i kinda stopped watching the videos on his main channel because i can actually tell his heart's not really in it and he often complains that he's remaking the same video over and over. but i watch his 2nd channel all the time because Finn's personality is entertaining and he's speaking freely off the cuff about personal topics inbetween "topical topics" since it's almost all cuts from his livestreams. it kinda makes me sad that he feels the need to sanitize himself from his main videos but i think that it hurts him shows he is a human being. Mr Beast (who i just dont watch i have no strong opinions about, his content doesnt interest me) gave a interview recently where he alluded to the fact that his videos were successful because he had eliminated as much of his own personality as possible from his vdeos. some people are built different though, Finn is snarky but i can tell he's a very sensitive person. i'm oversensitive and i often get acidic to hide that fact about me. i don't get that same vibe from Mr Jimmy, which makes him unrelatable to me.
I personally would enjoy more videos on hardcore and newer bands in that genre, and also on street punk and oi bands (which are seeing a huge resurgence), vs videos on metalcore and emo
There could be some mileage there, interspersing the content that isn't going to get the views in the short term so that it doesn't harm the channel, but maybe broadens who gets recommended to watch over the long term
@@InGrindWeCrust2010 only thing is Glenn Fricker posts his own viewers comments videos on Friday, so Finn might need to take Thurs or Sat. Although, I wonder how much audience overlap they actually have and whether it would matter; I might just be in the minority there
This is easily one of the best channel updates ever. It felt super honest and heartfelt. Love ya, man. You're one of the best creators out there. Since, we're on the topic - "How Country Became The New Rock n' Roll" (Koe Wetzel, Read Southall, Whiskey Myers, Austin Meade)
Its sad how hes a victim of audience capture. He turned a passion project into a his familys meal ticket which is precarious. Im a professional artist and this is the part of being famous, even at this level, that most people dont talk about.
I appreciate your opinions and content, Finn. I started watching your channel when I was getting cancer treatment and it was a good way to take my mind off things. I'm better now and know you'll feel better too.
I’ve actually been really into your other channel. I think the interaction between you and the chat is hilarious. I still enjoy your videos a lot. One of my favorite creators. I also love the dynamic of your haters being personally offended by your opinions and you playing into that.
I just want to say as a creative type person I love the way you express yourself and the way you talk so bluntly. It’s refreshing in world where everyone sugar coats everything. Please don’t change and I look forward to your future videos no matter what way you decide. Thank you
Some ideas: - you are (to my knowledge) the only creator who knows and talks about the “scene”. Your updated perspective on how you have overcome a lot of that stuff is truly inspirational and I think would help a lot of people. - reformed “emos” is your niche! A lot of 30 somethings who used to mosh and crowd surf now work corporate jobs and live simpler lives. However, that wild, aggressive part of them still exists somewhere. Maybe there’s a way you could tap into that?I find your matured but funny take on life so refreshing. Nostalgia vids and commentary are amazing from you.
I agree. I loved the video about “where emo kids are now” or whatever it was called. I’d love more about that kind of thing. Recognise the roots and nostalgia but being real about the fact we’re getting older and have boring adult shit to do lol. Like as a 37 year old woman who was into nu metal back in the day, I really wanna know what other nu metal era women are wearing these days. I definitely had a decade where I went normie but now I’m rediscovering my alt roots and wanting to bring that back into my style a bit. But so much of the content out there is 20-year-olds showing their e-girl aesthetic or just recreating the nu metal look copypasta. I wanna know what grown ass alt women are wearing as they live their real lives not just being cute for TikTok or whatever. It would be cool to collaborate with some female creators to talk a bit about what reformed emos wear in their 30s and 40s
Finn, your content has gotten me through the bulk of my PhD program these past few years. The long tireless hours in the lab, burning the candle at both ends, and just grinding away into the ground. Your videos have been in my headphones the whole way. Thanks man.
Sounds like you are suffering from "audience capture". Your subscriber base has a strong influence over what you create for them, as opposed to creating for yourself. This can be positive if your values align but clearly you seem frustrated by a lack of interest in the content you want to make. This is a cycle that can be broken if you choose to create the content you want, you will then be growing an audience for that. It may be difficult to make that transition but the outcome is a better alignment between yourself and your audience. Personally speaking, I've enjoyed your content that introduced me to new music more than the 90s/00s metal/alternative retrospects. I hope you can figure out which direction you want to take going forward :-)
I started writing the same comment as @xisumavoid, so moving here - audience capture is a suck, but also is (IMO) a part of the growing pains in being a micro-celebrity and doing large scale public work. The name of the channel is your aesthetic, not your chains. I'm very much your elder-millenial listens to nu-metal still pretty often and enjoys your deep dives into the history of bands I had forgotten I liked, but man, I do feel like I don't find so much new and interesting bands nowdays. Finding ways to take "hey you liked x, y, z - it's likely you'd like a, b, c - and here's what they've been doing which is new" is a super compelling watch in a world where algorithms are making most of your recommendations, and they can't be introspected or interrogated
I think a series about the unpopular musicians that inspired popular musicians, would be really entertaining and interesting. Plus fulfilling for the algorithm because a big artist would be in the name and thumbnail. "The Bands You May Not Know Who Inspired _____" , something like that. Love all your content Finn, no matter what you put out, I always am a viewer 🤘
First off I really appreciate you taking such a brave step to be mentally transparent and vulnerable. As far as your question about "what you should do" I think you first need to answer the question of what do you like then work backwards from there to try and make it something your audience is into. Im not a content creator but I do think that your true community are the people who are down for all the experiments you try because they're into this channel because of you not just the history. Fantano's channel is an interesting case study with this. He makes a lot of different type of videos(on two separate channels) not just reviews and his audience for the most part is along for the ride. Although most of it is music related which leads me to the other point. How to solve the "I want to make videos on other things im interested in" issue is to maybe make more channels for those topics. You have business/investment video ideas start a channel for that (call it PRMBA-GrowUp or something), wanna do something with movies or games make PRMBA-NowInColor or something. But you should only do these videos (and make these channels) if you have a lot to say about these topics not just to diversify the content.
Bro you really inspire me. Thank you for your years of knowledge and expertise. I would hate to see you go. Thank you for your coaching also and I plan to book another session when I hit 500 sub, about half way there now. I want to be just like you man. I wish I had creative ideas for you.
You're one of the most genuinely funny and interesting channel I've watched since 2020. I like your personnality, your honesty and you showed so much new music. Thanks Finn, keep it real as always!
Finn, make a third channel where you can do all of the business videos you want to do! Life “maxing” has been booming lately and you seem like you have things to say about this topic. I’d be interested to hear, even if it’s not on a third channel.
I discovered a lot of artists and bands thru this different videos that you used to make. Maybe on the second channel you do a weekly video telling what you’ve been listening to no matter what kind of music, and depending on the reactions you do a more elaborated video on the first channel
I wish I could say, create another channel for you to release those "less popular" videos/subject matter but I know that takes more time on your part. When I first came upon your channel during the pandemic, I viewed you and your opinion as someone who was incredibly level headed, facts driven, informative and OPEN MINDED, which is so freaking rare these days. What you do for music and so many artists is amazing. In the past, you would have been considered a gatekeeper of sorts, but I think you are the keymaster (Ghostbusters reference). You opened up my mind to so many new genres that I never knew about and shared new information on bands and artists that I've followed for years that I didn't know about. All I can say is that I appreciate your work, your opinion and the value you bring. I don't have any particular ideas to share because I've enjoyed the output so far, but maybe others will help you discover some new and interesting topics to cover. Good luck
I'd love to hear more stories of punk/hardcore shows that you went to back in the day, what you learned from those shows, how it helped inform your world view. You've made videos like that before and they've always been my fav. I also love hearing about the evolution of punk and hardcore. Who influenced the newer artists coming out, how did they influence those artists.
LOL -- replying to my own post. But that last thing could be really cool. That way, you could talk about new bands, your viewers could discover new bands, while at the same time talking about who influenced those bands. Truly informative, and it would fit into the name of your channel very well.
Been commenting for a couple of years now for him to make a video about terror celebrating 20 years as a band and how they never stopped and their legacy. Maybe one day... Still wish he would do more hc vids :,-(
you my friend, are a fresh air in rock/metal. I am a metalhead all my life.. but never one who only wears metal t-shirts etc.. i really like your alternative view of things. You say things just like they are.. and hardcore metalheads don't like change and don't like anything new other that the big 5 (ok i went too far :) ) Greetings from Greece !!
This is actually my first time commenting, but your videos are awesome. I get the uncertainty that comes with running out ideas for (good) videos, and how that can make you feel like there's an end to your channel looming on the horizon. Much respect for all you do, man, you're an incredibly hard worker and always have some very cool insights into music. I know you've exposed me to a lot of incredible bands!
My grandpa also had serious sleep issues related to stress. He was in Vietnam and part of his job was to crawl through the hidden network of Vietcong tunnels. Can’t imagine what he may have seen..
I mean I don't know dude hears a thought ,maybe instead of old millennial Bands you can Focus on More modern Bands see what happens. I think a lot of your audience would enjoy it either the history of or The impact of I don't know man I've always trusted your contact and even as I said in another comment bands and style of music I absolutely hate that you make videos on I still watch and enjoy
I like wolfsguitarden7’s idea. There are a number of videos where you talk about how a particular band had a surprising impact in only a short number of years or with a very limited discography (Nirvana and Refused are two videos that come to mind). What about some newer artists that are already making a huge impact on their genre (or even other genres) even for not having been around for long?
I'm into history with an emphasis on military/political topics. The stories from Vietnam are just mind blowing on both sides. There's a quote about jungle warfare that states that you aren't just at war with the enemy but the environment as well. Just absolutely crazy to think about. My respect goes out to everyone on both sides as ultimately neither side that participated had an option to not - people in suits most can't even name made those calls and set up that chess board.
I'm sorry you're struggling, but for what it's worth, you are one of my favorite RUclipsrs. I like your style/delivery because you remind me of a lot of my dude-friends. (That's a compliment lol.) I hope you keep making videos!
I personally always loved when you covered new music & new waves. While I do think the viewership will decrease temporarily, in the long term you will gain more subscribers as you'll never run out of ideas & completely avoid stagnation. it is important to be more current. Also to make the best of both worlds, you can sprinkle in some nostalgic videos in there & add more of your opinion & witty humor in those. It's a win win situation! Just playing the long game, instead of shorter lived success! Of course this is all just my opinion, I feel many others would agree. Keep your head up buddy! A lot of us really appreciate what you do. Also if you need a manager then tell your people to call my people lol Cheers!
@@SMJSmoK yeah I think Finn has don’t THPS videos and he just did one about doom so maybe that could be a direction he could take it. Idk just spitballing here
A video on the copycat "Grunge" bands cashing in on the post-Nirvana hype such as - Bush, Silverchair, Candlebox, Superheaven, Gin Blossoms, LifeHouse, Toadies, Deep Blue Something, etc... would be great!
I feel for you Finn. I would recommend that you make a video about de band Low. Why? Because their music is great (especially their last three albums, which I think due to the use of distorsion a metal fan might like).
Maybe a video series based on the years? Do 4 vids on like 1985, one on country, one on metal, one on rock, one on pop, and continue doing those to the present day exploring the evolution of the genres and how sounds and styles progressed, you can weave newer artists throughout it by highlighting artists influenced by those that came before (like how emo rapper sample a lot of that stuff or how even Halsey has sampled bands like Brand New) It might not do well exactly, but I'd also love some videos on how promotion has changed over the years from DIY posters to street teams, all the way through tiktok and you can talk about new artists that way too. Who is still using promotional tactics from 30 years ago and making them work? Maybe include media reviews? I'm talking about more books than films and documentaries. I just read From the Basement and found it mediocre overall, but I know there are other authors in the scene. Keith Buckley has a few books out, Geoff Rickley, Joe Trohman Last idea... (maybe risky?) Rebrand, you would know more about that than most of us for sure, but if I saw someone with the name ThePunkRockMBA and they made a video on jazz or country, I'd just assume they were shitting on the genres before I even turned it on. Maybe switch to TheMusicMBA? I think part of what made Fantano able to do what he does is that his name is inclusive to all music.
@@ThePunkRockMBA I think there's a way to do it. I follow crypto channels (i know i know) but like bitboy crypto rebranded their entire channel to discover crypto, name change and all. After Jason Tate got the rights back to absolute punk he switched it over to chorus because punk no longer represented the entirety of what he did. I have no doubt you can pull off the samd
@@ThePunkRockMBAI love the name. See my other comment but punk rock isn’t just music but about how you approach life and thinking for yourself. You taught me that!
Here’s an idea. Make a video about songs that became more iconic and famous because they were in films. Directors like Quentin Tarantino put some of the best soundtracks in his films, and those soundtracks became more iconic because they were submitted in perfectly in his film. You don’t have to like the directors, but the style of how music can change your perspective in a film is interesting. 🎬🎶🎵🗣️
I like this idea. There was the video about the relationship between pop punk and teen movies which was really cool. I’d love to see one about maybe how other genres have been featured in movies (like the resident evil movies and the matrix and that kind of genre movie) or just music in movies in general
Been here since 2019 bro, sucks you’re in this rut or whatever. I too suffer from panic attacks in the middle of the night , they’re fucking miserable wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemies. Keep ya head up brother, most of us are pulling for ya!!! The squeakiest wheel gets the oil. Fuck them haters bro it’s probably 1/100 that thinks that way! Take care bro!
Please more videos of 90s culture, specially MTV (Celebrity Death Match, Daria, Unplugged, Tom Green and his influence on comedy), Napster vs Music Industry, Walkman-Diskman-MP3PortablePlayer era, experience of renting or buying VHS-DVD vs Streaming culture… Big fan of your channel. You are my favourite RUclipsr. Don´t stop with the Nu Metal content!!!
This is just my one subscriber’s opinion but my favorite vids of urs are the ones that are further out of the traditional metal stuff (like trap metal and Hyperpop) those are the vids I always come back to and I’ve even shared with people. So I get the algorithm may favor other things but you’ll always have at least one view on those vids from me. Also as an autistic person with a creative type brain the way u come off has never been off putting to me at least
Honestly, I'm not as interested in metal/music commentary as I used to be. I always come back to your videos (particularly your second channel/twitch streams) because you've brought more of your personality and perspectives into it. I really enjoy hearing you talk about "lifey" things. You have a lot to say that I think is incredibly valuable, especially in this day and age. I appreciate your willingness to put yourself out there and share your views honestly, it's very refreshing.
The sad truth is every RUclipsr who struggles deals with this, but they are afraid to be completely honest with their fanbase because they know they can never win the fight. So I respect you for being completely honest.. 💙 this is why a lot of RUclipsrs have to create a character for themselves on RUclips to become funny or amusing. When in reality that’s not who they are in real life. And they struggle every week on what things they should say when they are in their RUclips character again. I can’t imagine how mentally that must strain you. 😫 The public people will always control the public figures as a puppet to play with and it’s so messed up. 😞
Finn, First off, I want to say that me and my wife watch your youtube and love it. Our tastes go from big band in the 1940's, oldies in 50 and 60's then goes to hardcore and metal. We like ( and appreciate) your views on music of today. I think its really hard for you to do videos on punk and metal. To be honest, the new metal bands are not that good and most punk is pop punk. Also, im sure that most of the people that are talking smack on here are about 12 or dont realize the time and effort it takes uou to take this on. Well in any case i wanted to let you know that there are people who respect and appreciate you.
You said you were going to read the comments. So I'm going to take advantage and give you my perspective. First of all, I'm from Argentina, and while I understand English, I'm not very good at writing it. This message is translated by Google, therefore, it may have some writing problems. 1- Difference between the two channels, the personal and Punk Rock MBA. Personally, I like the Punk Rock MBA channel better: the videos have more production and the content is better structured, characteristics that the videos on the other channel do not have. The name of the Channel, Punk Rock MBA, was the first thing that caught my attention, and I think where the first videos were directed. The objective was to analyze and structure the way in which bands operate or how, in business terms, they serve their target audience, and they achieve it. It seemed like an excellent idea to me. For music NERDS, who don't want short videos, but want information about the bands and a different perspective, and the best thing I had was your opinion, which I always validate. I think the idea of the Channel, referenced as MBA, is very good and interesting, it stood out among all the other content there is. Your informative videos are 10 or more minutes long, therefore, your target audience is over 30 years old, consequently, it seems to me that I should attack it. I like data and information. How the albums were recorded, who was the producer, what did he mean in certain songs, what mood existed at the time of recording the album, meaning of songs, etc. 2- Importance of your opinion. It always seemed fundamental to me, in every channel, that the author's opinion on the topic he deals with is what makes it particular and different. Your opinions make you think. 3- Content proposal. I find it interesting that you can recommend bands and give solid points as to why you think we should listen to them. Today music is a commodity, all the songs sound the same and there are so many artists, it is difficult to distinguish which ones are worth it. I believe that today, the only thing that can make a difference is going to see them play live or, in your case, having them recommend you... and not songs! Albums worth it. On the other hand, although - as you said - there in videos you make a summary of what Wikipedia says - for my part I did not know it - for me they are interesting and even more so when you add your opinion. You could also give your opinion about the festivals or concerts that are taking place. 4- Interviews. The interviews you did seem great to me! I always enjoyed them a lot. 5- Consultations on social networks. Propose topics for people to vote on and choose topics for you to make videos on. 6- I don't like. First and foremost, that you give so much importance to the haters. I understand that the number of views is important, but comments are useless when they are hateful. Focus on those who help you. I also don't like the videos when you are streaming, they don't entertain me. Hope this can help you!
Here is a bit of advice from someone who struggles with anxiety and PTSD (I hope it helps at least a little): make peace with the worst possible outcome of your situation. If you make peace with that, it allows you to do whatever that thing is more freely (ie make internet content). There is also Pascal's wager - if you keep making videos people will make negative comments. If you stop, people will find old videos and make negative comments. So, keep making new videos. Lastly, as the greatest emo band ever (Copeland) said - dont break your neck to keep your chin up.
it's so funny cuz im millennial. i grew up with all sorts of pop punk-ish artists or whatever (i guess like senses fail etc) and i discovered gothboiclique in 2015 (about a year before lil peep was even a thing or at least before anyone heard of him). it blew my mind. the sound was so amazing to me and so new and i had no idea what this kind of music was even called. it was like the team sesh or raider klan stuff i was listening to for 2 years previous except with emo-influenced clean vocals and it worked so well i couldn't believe it hasn't been done before. i drove the 4 hours to go to a show they had in LA around january the next year: only about 50 or 60 people were there but i was still so starstruck meeting horse head and cold hart. i instantly told horse head "i listen to your romantic EP every day"
First off you're super great. Your content kicks ass and your little one is adorable (new dad gang). Secondly it might be unrealistic as time is so finite especially with a little one at home... but can you maybe add an extra video a month? Like a passion video? Or add extra content that you love on top of what is effective for viewership etc? Regardless sending super good vibes Finn you're amazing and pay homage to art that has touched so many of us. I'd also say your older stuff had a lot of personal connection that gave you insights people can't find on Wikipedia. That was so cool for me. But I recognized there is a finite amount of experiences for you to draw of from your life. But keep it up dude I love all of it.
Hey Finn, I just want to say I hear you and can relate. Several years ago, I had to take a step back from my work as a music director due to panic attacks and even seizures caused by the constant stress and criticism. There were several points where I wanted to end my life. I think being under a public microscope is about as unnatural as it gets in the human experience. It got to a level for me where I had to back off, resign from my position, and restructure life. I make less money, I’m not an influencer, and my music isn’t blowing up. However, my wife and I have been together for 11 years, we have a house, we our needs met, we’re slowly taking things in a new direction, and we’re enjoying life much more than when I was under constant pressure with never-ending negative feedback loops. I am not saying you need to step back like I did, and I’m not even giving advice here. I am not as experienced as you, and I’m definitely not as business savvy. (I’m probably grouped in with the “creative people” who are typically assholes to you.) I just want to say, you’ve got your priorities straight, you’re smart, and you’ll figure this chapter out, just like you’ve done before. I’m an F-Tier Nobody/Baddiecore Wannabe, but honestly, I’m here for it because I’m not suffocating anymore. You got this, dude.
The magic of this channel was this funny older dude talking about music in general and giving advice, if people want Wikipedia shit, guys theres Rock Feed and Loudwire and a ton of other channels, thank you Tool, Deftones and SOAD fans as always for ruining the party for everybody....
Thank you to everyone who's supported me in any way! 🙏
I'll support you either way I love all your videos Finn!!! I love rock and metal but I also like rap, country,pop, EDM Etc. Keep doing you man.
Thank you for your videos because of you, I love $uicideboy$, sleep token and parkway drive. I can't wait to see what you make next
For the record I enjoy all your content. Even not as popular ones like trap metal… it’s what got me into city morgue for example
Finn, you have to let yourself curate your audience. 87% is not THAT bad of a dislike ratio.
I say start exclusively making content that you're actually interested in, and others who are interested in that will follow eventually. You just have to be patient. Most of your audience, who loves no matter what you put out, will stick around.
The important thing is to let yourself be happy with what you're making. At the end of the day, it's YOUR channel. If you're burned out making material you don't want, then stop doing that! Anyone who doesn't understand that isn't worth your stress anyway. Selfish people will never be satisfied.
If that doesn't work, make another channel where you upload stuff that you're actually interested in, and occasionally keep posting to this one. Whatever you want, buddy. Personally, I'm here for the ride, whatever your endeavor is.
Thank you for all your videos and content!
I have a hard time finding new music...a series on "if you liked this band in 2001, try this new band" would be fun
oo that's a great idea!
Holy crap I would love that. Post college I stopped following heavy music closely and feel so lost in the genre now!
Dude, that's a wicked idea! 🙂 have you tried asking ai ?? "what bands are similar to ... " is what i'd ask 🙂
Yeah, but also Spotify and the such do that. It would be cool to find smaller undiscovered bands though
I dig this concept.
Your 2nd channel is AMAZING. When you inject your humour and personality, it's absolute gold. And I pay extra attention when you start talking about new music.
Totally agree. His vid from a couple weeks ago about farting at the party at high school was hysterical! Watched the vid twice
@@Frederick0220 I found out that I'm watching and enjoying his livestream snippets more than the MBA - specially the 2000's decade stuff that bring me a lot of cringe memories of my youth lol
Agreed, I watch almost every video on that channel he’s hilarious and so personable
Finn if you're not going to pull back here are some ideas:
- worst lyrics of popular songs
- underrated musicians/songwriters
- music in tv, movies, video games
- a baddiecore explanation
- disney songs that don't suck
- past musicians that would be canceled by today standards
- beef in the rock world
- best songs to do things to (sex, skateboard, video games)
- explain how different level of musicians make their money
- a history of blue collar Punk (ex. Gaslight Anthem, hot water music, Social D, Menzingers)
GOAT
Outstanding suggestions
Solid 10 out of 10
dude these are stellar suggestions ✨️
beef in the rock world would be great
I really liked your lifestories, life advice, and how to overcome addictions. Those stories were the most relatable and felt the most genuine.
If you make more of those I would watch them all.
I agree I still go back and watch those a lot because they’ve helped me a lot
Yeah these videos are always great
Same
Agree!
Finn, you are absolutely the only content creator covering music that has really ever held my attention and intrigue. You do quality stuff. I also think you do a great job of the yin and yang with the more fact based stuff on this channel, and the more fun off the wall stuff on your personal. With this channel in general maybe you can do the thing that some movie directors do: one for the studio, one for me. Keep it up and much love!
Never commented on your vids before, but you're not alone, dude. Content creation is a different form of a 9 to 5 job. The mental pressure to produce is real, and I feel you on every point you made. For what it's worth I didn't sense any of this from your vids. Your opinions always come across so polished and insightful; honestly, I can probably speak for the silent majority when I say they're why I watch your videos! Hoping to see more in the future bro. 👊
Totally agree with this guy
I love your channel too! \m/
Make a Weekly series thats about discovering new music and showcasing it. That would be a phenomenal tool for your viewers, and hell, you'll find some great new music, too!
I was thinking the same thing. I've been introduced to a bunch of great music from this channel.
I like this
I’m replying to upvote this idea
Upvote.
This!
As someone who's been doing this for over 10 years (and definitely gotten the same kind of comments/panic attacks/etc) I totally get where you're coming from man. Try and remember to give yourself a pat on the back for how far you've come every once in a while. It's hard not to take it personally when its your whole being put into the content you make, you really care, and then something does poorly. But try not to let it get you down man. Love your content! Whatever you do I'm sure it'll be succesful. Personally, I love learning new stuff about the bands I love when you talk about them. And deep dives into the 90's 2000's are super nostalgic.
You said a long time ago you wanted to make a video about how dubstep took a lot of the head banging fans and it never came out.
Also every single Minecraft gameplay intro ever
LOL I said the same thing when I first heard dubstep. It was half beats that one could headbang to
Kinda makes sense since Skrillex was like the pioneer of that shit and he was a vocalist from a post hardcore band before he did dubstep
I lost many a metalcore bandmates to dubstep
Came here to comment this exact thing
Finn. You are the Punk rock MBA. You are going thru what many artists go through everyday. Monetizing underground movements has always been difficult. This is why so many artists " sell out" The mainstream will always exist, and it is by nature historically close minded. Welcome to the club my friend. For the record, I like ya. 👍
I’m only speaking for myself here, but you’re the only creator where i watch every video of yours even if im not interested in the topic you’re talking about. I hope you find your way finn❤
Same here! And I've been found myself more open to new music because I decided to watch videos about genres I had no interest/idea about.
Hes great and knows a lot on music for sure i dont agree with every take but i still like his vids and him as a person hes also very funny love his humor
Finn. I watch anything you send. You are so dang funny and I look forward to every time there is a notification for a new video. But, your family and self are number one with priorities. Thanks for all you do!
I second this
Same!
The history and breaking down of metal genres are my favorite things you ever did. I’d love more stuff like that.
When he said "Why would I put all this time and energy into making a video that nobody's going to watch?" I felt that
Yeah, after all the hours I put into fun little genre hoping Christmas music videos I did for years to all have less than 1000 views kills me.
"Do what YOU like" only ever takes you so far.
I had more feelings for: " _if the message is 'no please keep doing what you're doing, that's what we want' then that's cool too_ " reminded me of being in a abusive relationship and believing i deserved it
That line is basically my entire existence
Your opinions and personality are what always made me come back to the channel when I first found it. I didn’t always agree with your takes, but you always at least had a good rationale for them and presented them in an entertaining way
I’ve always liked hearing you point out the influences of older bands on newer bands. For example, I hadn’t noticed how much a lot of modern metal seems to take from Linkin Park, but when you pointed it out it made a lot of sense. Maybe you could try doing a video series on pointing those similarities out to bridge the gap between nostalgia and new bands and maybe drive attention to newer music
Music teacher here. I was talking to my kids about the scene back in the early 2000s when I realized how they don't really have anything equivalent. They'll never know what it's like to do watch a friend's band at some dive that's probably a crack house by day. Not sure if that's helpful, but there ya go!
tbh i dont even really watch this channel, but i watch pretty much every upload on your Finn McKenty channel. even tho those vids have been largely tier lists as of late, theyre still always so much fun, your sense of humor and the way you talk about subjects you enjoy is fucking awesome. i really enjoy it a lot. i think a lot of your fans watch you mostly for your personality specifically!!
i just made a longform comment before i scrolled and saw this one where i was saying the exact same thing and it's for the exact same reasons.
Haha its true I found myself watching more of his secondary Channel as well, cuz he's so funny, relatable & always gives good insight 😢
Sorry you're going through this Finn. My take is you need to make the vids you love and try monetize additionally elsewhere. The hours researching, scripting, filming, editing on something you don't totally enjoy... will eat away at your energy (for you, for fam, for other ideas). Appreciate you!
i second this as a person who, just like many others in the world, has to do a job he doesnt like that much just for the sake of providing to his family, but any time i have to put effort in it, especially mental effort, it just sucks because i'd be fighting with my mind so loud. Finn you clearly love to make videos, researching all of the stuff and putting yourself into it, it would be painful to do that for something you don't like... that is pretty sure brother. Hope you'll figure out and till that time i will keep watching and liking :D
Pretty much this. When your passion becomes your job, you end up depending on everything around it (in this case viewers for example) and start hating what you used to love, because you wrap it up with what you still do, which is not what you love at all. And cue the anxiety and existential dread. I can't imagine doing this publicly on top of that, where if you stay the same people will start whining that you're not original enough, and if you change you'll get the "it used to be better" comments. If you can afford it, I would recommend a very long break, figure out what else you could do to support your family that wouldn't destroy your well being, and come back, if you want to, on your own terms. Also you'd probably end up with less followers, but more in tune with the content you want to make.
A well respected musician gave a warning to my neighbour, a well respected local musician in his own right, as advice before recording "your relationship to your music will change drastically as soon as you _need_ something from it".
This!
@7:23 my first year as a police officer, this was me 2-3 nights a week. Much love man. Enjoy your videos.
Finn, as a product of the 90’s and 00’s, your first couple years of videos almost single-handedly got me into so many incredible bands - everything from ADTR to Waterparks to BMTH. I was lured in by the “what killed the genre” series and stuck around because I got educated on everything I had missed in my college and adult years. I miss learning about new music from you and getting your take on what’s going on in the rock music space.
Thank you for transparency. I’ve spent dozens of hours with you over the years but have never taken the time to tell you I appreciate you and think you’re amazing.
I second all of this
One of my favorite aspects of this channel is that you've shown me a whole bunch of music I would have missed out on
I love your content Finn and I respect your opinion. I had no idea you were going through this. Also, congrats on your sub count. When I subbed you were under 10k and thought man this guy is underrated.
Thank you!
We love you Finn! I watch and enjoy ALL of your videos and totally respect and value your opinions.
Finn, the main reason I watch you is because I respect your opinion and insights of the music industry; especially from a marketing perspective.
I dunno if this idea sounds interesting to you, but surely you have a lot of music creators in your audience (especially in Rock and Metal); maybe you could discuss what other artists are doing (in any genre) to gain attention and present it in a way where other artists could apply it to their music.
I'm not saying you have to go full teacher mode, but maybe if your content had "applicable education", it could be appreciated no matter what genre you're talking about.
Lastly, I recently learned that "negative" engagement is still "engagement", and I think the algorithm still rewards it. If you can afford to make what you wanna make for a short period of time, and endure the haters, maybe in the long run, the haters will leave and you'll be left with a more loyal and supportive audience.
I'm with you!
The algorithm definitely rewards negative engagement as well. So. If your truly hate something ...you say nothing and just keep it moving.
Thanks for what you do, Finn. I like your channel a lot and peep it regularly. While I recognize that a fair share of the videos haven't necessarily been things that I'm specifically interested in, I still love the channel(s) and your style -- That means, *I like your personality, and the things you're interested in.*
As such, *I'm a fan as long as you're enjoying yourself.* As it's 'a music channel', sharing music that you're enjoying and interested in (REGARDLESS of genre) will always be a draw for people like me, because I myself am always spending time checking out new (to me) artists and intentionally spending time in different genres... because I love music! Also, you're the Punk Rock MBA, it's pretty punk to do whatever the fuck you want, tbh.
For you, that could mean not just sharing but discussing more of what you find interesting about whatever you're listening to or spending time with, whether that's a personal connection and/or technical/production point. This lets *_you_* be your channel a bit more, so maybe you don't feel so dry and soulless, because you can offer more of your thoughts and insights about things you're actively into, and [re]build your community around that. Those of us who enjoy you for your vibe will eat that up. You can maybe involve some content relating to shows that you're able to make it out to, what some scenes are like, industry interviews as possible (that don't just have to be band members themselves, but tech and production crews are cool too, IMO). Idk, I just like lots of good music bro, wherever we find it!
I don't know if my suggestions translate well into meaningful content production, but regardless, I hope you can ease into content that you enjoy, and have a better community where you're BOTH enjoying the journey. 🖤🙏
Maybe a semi-regular video about new artists you've discovered or listening to atm? You're how I learned about people like Essenger, Bilmuri, and a handful of other artists. In fact you're among my main sources for discovering new music these days.
I commented something similar to this on the other video and Finn said he mostly listens to pop and country.
Hey Finn, firstly I think it's great that you're so open about all this. Burnout is real and having the pressure of supporting a young family is difficult. You're right, when there is livelihood at stake, you can't always follow your passion 100% of the time and a lot of people who aren't under pressure don't understand this. This sucks and you're not alone in this position.
I tune into your videos because I like your style, not because of the topic, but maybe for the masses you can find a balance "one for you, one for them" kind of thing. As for topics, maybe some topics that would resonate with your audience would be:
- how bands make money on tour and how it's different from the 90s/early 00s
- deep-dive videos on 80s alternative bands that influenced 90s/00s bands
- interesting takes on alternative music in different media (movies, video games, etc.)
- how marketing shaped music in the 90s and how it's different today
- submissions from viewers redesigning band logos and then rank them
- interviews with music industry people
I'm sorry to see you struggling. Your family is the most important thing, so do what you need to do, man. Thanks again for being yourself!
Fin, dude, you are an absolute inspiration. You have introduced me to so many new bands and songs that has provided endless joy in my life. God bless you brother! I love watching all your content.
I'm a very new subscriber, but basically the reason I subbed was actually for your opinions and actual experience in the punk/hardcore/metal scenes for basically all of the 2000s and 90s which as someone who wasn't around when a lot of these bands you talk about were big is pretty fascinating.
Nice gay flag
🍉🍉🍉🍉
@@Nonshillnotbeing anti genocide is gay 😢oh well guess im gay
Been here a while and also pro palestine - finn is reactionary and attracts a lot of reactionaries in the comments btw
@@toga4900 wow I didn't know genocide also includes combatants. balestine is learning what FAFO means.
Just want to say that I'm incredibly grateful for you. You're a good man, a great father, and my favorite content creator of all time. You've always been a breath of fresh air for me.
Finn, one of my favorite things the channel (that you are doing less often) is your technical musical analysis for laymen. You are so good at picking apart what is similar/different between different styles of music, and contrasting how they use different tools for similar effect. I'd love to see "Finns guides to genre X". Also, with your channel growing like it is, I'm sure many viewers might not know enough about the technical side music to follow some of your analysis.
Basics guides might also be a great thing to have, for example; what makes someone good at a particular instrument, song structure basics, what is groove vs. virtuosity, etc. etc. You have a gift for that sort of thing, and even after decades of being a massive music enthusiast you regularly change my perspective and understanding of the technical side of music.
On a personal note, thanks for educating me on punk and hardcore. I was lucky enough to come of age in a place where I could go to shows of multiple generas of music most nights of the week, and I took full advantage. I made a habit of watching every kind of music in every scene I could get myself into. I was always more than happy to go to NY hardcore shows in the 90's because the shows were amazing (and cheep) even if the music rarely hit for me. Your knowledge and passion helped me understand and appreciative the shows I did get to. Thank you for making so many connections for me and giving me the context to more fully appreciate so much of the music I love, especially for music OUTSIDE of your focus on metal.
I hope your feeling better and that the comments on this video help you find a little bit of direction.
Man, your a good, likeable effective communicator, keep doing what you do bro......
Wait you made a video on KPop?! The algorithm failed us. Going to watch that shit now bruh.
Same here, I haven't even seen it pop up. I bet the algorithm plays it safe.
Being a small business owner and a hobbyist is not easy. Especially when there comes a time when you realize that work and passions do have some sort of separation, even if you believe that what you do for work is your passion, it does not always remain that way.
I would say, make a brand new channel that only supports the content that you personally enjoy doing and want to do. Keep the other channels, strictly for work. You can’t lose. It’s just a time sacrifice for your personal stuff, which sucks, but it’s the best way!
The what killed series should come back, if there are any genres left to cover that is….
Would love to! Just not sure what's left to cover.
@@ThePunkRockMBA electronic music, underground, techno etc
?
@@ThePunkRockMBA electronic music, underground, techno etc
?
@@tylermahaoney8138 Seems redundant considering that's pretty much what this, and his other video is.
Or talking to millennials who are in the game about the music and lifestyle which you grew up with and then try to reach an audience from all types. (It could be said better but that's on the top of my head)
What a nice looking family, good for you man!
i've always loved your style Finn, and the more you put your personality into the videos, the more i liked em. i hate that the metrics just aren't there for it to make sense for you to do *your* thing *your* way, i really do get that 'worn down' feeling. but man, i wish it was different right there along side ya.
much love Finn!
The stuff you've made sharing what you're excited about and/or believe is up and coming are my favorite videos. I've found new bands, genres of music and new perspectives on topics thanks to those videos.
I'm in my early 40's and thought that my musical exploration had pretty much come to a halt. Stuck in my ways hardcore, punk, and metalish dude. But you have had an influence on how I view music, the whole music industry, what music I listen to (new and older), and various things about life in general. You are passionate, interesting, humorous, and relatable. I originally stumbled onto to your channel expecting just the usual facts and incite on music and ended up getting a whole lot more. Especially on your personal channel, I'm laughing my ass off and having a great time. Thank you.
So grateful for this channel. My favorite videos are the ones you said are less popular - your takes on new genres, but also things related to your own history with hardcore punk (including you last video on it). I'd love to see more videos of you telling stories from your time in the DIY punk scene that elicit deeper life lessons and reflections that are more than just critiques of the limitations of the subculture too. Maybe a frame around a particular band, but bring in your personal stories.
Hey man, this is the only comment I’ve ever left on a video. Been watching for a couple of years now and enjoy both channels.
As someone who’s in advertising also (digital marketing for ~10 years now), I would find it fascinating to understand more how and why bands are marketed the way they are. Learning a bit about why record companies have pushed certain bands and not others, and how personalities of band members influence those campaigns, seems really interesting.
For your creative inspiration if time permits you should definitely get a third channel going on these other topics you want to generate a new audience for. I’m sure you’ve thought about this before but you sound like you are getting burned out and need a change. Maybe this video is the sign you’ve been looking for.
Appreciate all that you’ve done in the past. It’s been very entertaining and insightful.
Your opinions and anecdotes are a big part of the reason I subscribed to begin with and now watch your second channel. I understand your dilemma.
Some of my favorite topics you’ve discussed are the ones adjacent to music and focused on the scene’s culture.
It would be fun to see videos relating your other specialties (business/marketing/branding) to millennials who grew up and want to start a music adjacent business or a band. Would seem to fit with the channel name.
Regardless, looking forward to seeing what you create in the future 🤘
Discovered you by your “What killed slam” video and haven’t missed a video since! Would love more “what killed ___” stuff, it was always fun and had lots of opinions and personality thrown in which was awesome 👏
Fin, definitely a vulnerable moment . You may feel like you have plateaued when it comes to content creation. I think switching gears could benefit you . Think back to 90s nostalgia. What’s something that always caught the attention of the masses. Shows like “ making the band “ are due for a reboot. You could possibly ask local bands for submissions, share them on your channel, go to a live show and film it “ reality tv “ style . Interview the bands , share back stories and help them with what they may lack ? Branding opportunities, sound recordings or just using your audience to capture attention?
Could be a useful tool to discover new underground music . Help you get the ideas flowing again .
Be watching since 2018 and I’ve also noticed the episodes are missing that spark. You are going through the motions to make content because it’s your main income vs doing it because you just loved it . Much love from Pennsylvania 🤙🏻 keep your head up
This actually sounds like a great idea. Kind of back to your roots kind of thing, but with modern music. As a millennial I also don't really know anything about the "scene" nowadays ie. I'm old enough that what kids do and are interested in is foreign and scary to me. Some content about that could be very interesting if done right.
A video about mid tier bands that have been able to have a long career like Coheed, Hawthorne Heights, Bayside, Four Year Strong, The Dear Hunter, or New Found Glory for example could be super cool.
I love that idea
He did a video about New Found Glory before but yeah. That'd be appealing to me too.
Four year strong are indeed mid
I’d love this too!
Yeah but that doesn’t make the maximum amount of money from each video so it’s literally impossible for him to do.
do a weekly or monthly video covering a specific tour that’s happening that same time. maybe get an interview with a band member about how tour is going
Love your stuff Finn, but as of late I have been having a lot more fun with your 2nd channel. The tier lists, the worst (or best of) a decade, and tournaments have been a constant go to for me when I need something to listen to while working. Sorry to hear you feel this channel has stagnated, always enjoyed your history of _____ vids even when I hadn’t heard anything by the band you were covering. You have introduced me to a lot of bands, and I’m here for whatever’s next on the channel. You got this and Hell Yeah Brother!
The podcasts/interviews on your other channel are pretty cool, I would love to see more of them. Furthermore, you perhaps could not only talk about music and scenes as the main topics - but rather movies, book, films, games etc., which are somewhat related to punk/metal/rock and how those have been influential?
seriously, i kinda stopped watching the videos on his main channel because i can actually tell his heart's not really in it and he often complains that he's remaking the same video over and over. but i watch his 2nd channel all the time because Finn's personality is entertaining and he's speaking freely off the cuff about personal topics inbetween "topical topics" since it's almost all cuts from his livestreams.
it kinda makes me sad that he feels the need to sanitize himself from his main videos but i think that it hurts him shows he is a human being. Mr Beast (who i just dont watch i have no strong opinions about, his content doesnt interest me) gave a interview recently where he alluded to the fact that his videos were successful because he had eliminated as much of his own personality as possible from his vdeos.
some people are built different though, Finn is snarky but i can tell he's a very sensitive person. i'm oversensitive and i often get acidic to hide that fact about me. i don't get that same vibe from Mr Jimmy, which makes him unrelatable to me.
I personally would enjoy more videos on hardcore and newer bands in that genre, and also on street punk and oi bands (which are seeing a huge resurgence), vs videos on metalcore and emo
Another amazing and very thoughtful video. I’ll always support you Finn no matter what you decide on doing.
How about Finn's Fun Friday? Post whatever You like. I'd definitely watch.
There could be some mileage there, interspersing the content that isn't going to get the views in the short term so that it doesn't harm the channel, but maybe broadens who gets recommended to watch over the long term
There’s always the lazy “viewers comments” that he could start doing on Fridays. He could use it to call out the hateful comments
@@slayabouts it works for Ronnie Radke, it can work for Finn too!
Good suggestion. I like Coffee with Carl (Murawski) and SWOLA with Ola, which is kind of the same deal. What's coming out and top-of-head stuff.
@@InGrindWeCrust2010 only thing is Glenn Fricker posts his own viewers comments videos on Friday, so Finn might need to take Thurs or Sat. Although, I wonder how much audience overlap they actually have and whether it would matter; I might just be in the minority there
You say you're not the creative type, but go on to explain the plight of creating very succinctly.
This is easily one of the best channel updates ever. It felt super honest and heartfelt. Love ya, man. You're one of the best creators out there.
Since, we're on the topic - "How Country Became The New Rock n' Roll" (Koe Wetzel, Read Southall, Whiskey Myers, Austin Meade)
Mate its amazing how real you are towards your content. Fair play. Don't force it. it will come. Legendary videos mate
Its sad how hes a victim of audience capture. He turned a passion project into a his familys meal ticket which is precarious. Im a professional artist and this is the part of being famous, even at this level, that most people dont talk about.
Innit tho mate, FM for life (hello fellow Brit or maybe Aussie?) 😂
I appreciate your opinions and content, Finn. I started watching your channel when I was getting cancer treatment and it was a good way to take my mind off things. I'm better now and know you'll feel better too.
Glad you are better now!
Love the channel! No recommendations except keep it up! gl
I’ve actually been really into your other channel. I think the interaction between you and the chat is hilarious. I still enjoy your videos a lot. One of my favorite creators. I also love the dynamic of your haters being personally offended by your opinions and you playing into that.
I just want to say as a creative type person I love the way you express yourself and the way you talk so bluntly. It’s refreshing in world where everyone sugar coats everything. Please don’t change and I look forward to your future videos no matter what way you decide. Thank you
Some ideas:
- you are (to my knowledge) the only creator who knows and talks about the “scene”. Your updated perspective on how you have overcome a lot of that stuff is truly inspirational and I think would help a lot of people.
- reformed “emos” is your niche! A lot of 30 somethings who used to mosh and crowd surf now work corporate jobs and live simpler lives. However, that wild, aggressive part of them still exists somewhere. Maybe there’s a way you could tap into that?I find your matured but funny take on life so refreshing. Nostalgia vids and commentary are amazing from you.
I agree. I loved the video about “where emo kids are now” or whatever it was called. I’d love more about that kind of thing. Recognise the roots and nostalgia but being real about the fact we’re getting older and have boring adult shit to do lol. Like as a 37 year old woman who was into nu metal back in the day, I really wanna know what other nu metal era women are wearing these days. I definitely had a decade where I went normie but now I’m rediscovering my alt roots and wanting to bring that back into my style a bit. But so much of the content out there is 20-year-olds showing their e-girl aesthetic or just recreating the nu metal look copypasta. I wanna know what grown ass alt women are wearing as they live their real lives not just being cute for TikTok or whatever. It would be cool to collaborate with some female creators to talk a bit about what reformed emos wear in their 30s and 40s
Finn, your content has gotten me through the bulk of my PhD program these past few years. The long tireless hours in the lab, burning the candle at both ends, and just grinding away into the ground. Your videos have been in my headphones the whole way. Thanks man.
Sounds like you are suffering from "audience capture". Your subscriber base has a strong influence over what you create for them, as opposed to creating for yourself. This can be positive if your values align but clearly you seem frustrated by a lack of interest in the content you want to make. This is a cycle that can be broken if you choose to create the content you want, you will then be growing an audience for that. It may be difficult to make that transition but the outcome is a better alignment between yourself and your audience. Personally speaking, I've enjoyed your content that introduced me to new music more than the 90s/00s metal/alternative retrospects. I hope you can figure out which direction you want to take going forward :-)
Channel name kinda locks me in tbh
I started writing the same comment as @xisumavoid, so moving here - audience capture is a suck, but also is (IMO) a part of the growing pains in being a micro-celebrity and doing large scale public work. The name of the channel is your aesthetic, not your chains.
I'm very much your elder-millenial listens to nu-metal still pretty often and enjoys your deep dives into the history of bands I had forgotten I liked, but man, I do feel like I don't find so much new and interesting bands nowdays. Finding ways to take "hey you liked x, y, z - it's likely you'd like a, b, c - and here's what they've been doing which is new" is a super compelling watch in a world where algorithms are making most of your recommendations, and they can't be introspected or interrogated
I think a series about the unpopular musicians that inspired popular musicians, would be really entertaining and interesting. Plus fulfilling for the algorithm because a big artist would be in the name and thumbnail. "The Bands You May Not Know Who Inspired _____" , something like that.
Love all your content Finn, no matter what you put out, I always am a viewer 🤘
I personally love everything you put out. Thanks for being who you are. I appreciate you!
First off I really appreciate you taking such a brave step to be mentally transparent and vulnerable.
As far as your question about "what you should do" I think you first need to answer the question of what do you like then work backwards from there to try and make it something your audience is into. Im not a content creator but I do think that your true community are the people who are down for all the experiments you try because they're into this channel because of you not just the history.
Fantano's channel is an interesting case study with this. He makes a lot of different type of videos(on two separate channels) not just reviews and his audience for the most part is along for the ride. Although most of it is music related which leads me to the other point.
How to solve the "I want to make videos on other things im interested in" issue is to maybe make more channels for those topics.
You have business/investment video ideas start a channel for that (call it PRMBA-GrowUp or something), wanna do something with movies or games make PRMBA-NowInColor or something.
But you should only do these videos (and make these channels) if you have a lot to say about these topics not just to diversify the content.
Bro you really inspire me. Thank you for your years of knowledge and expertise. I would hate to see you go. Thank you for your coaching also and I plan to book another session when I hit 500 sub, about half way there now. I want to be just like you man. I wish I had creative ideas for you.
You're one of the most genuinely funny and interesting channel I've watched since 2020. I like your personnality, your honesty and you showed so much new music. Thanks Finn, keep it real as always!
Finn, make a third channel where you can do all of the business videos you want to do! Life “maxing” has been booming lately and you seem like you have things to say about this topic. I’d be interested to hear, even if it’s not on a third channel.
I discovered a lot of artists and bands thru this different videos that you used to make. Maybe on the second channel you do a weekly video telling what you’ve been listening to no matter what kind of music, and depending on the reactions you do a more elaborated video on the first channel
Ive discovered some of my new favorite bands through you, Beartooth and Waterparks. Thank you for all you do
I wish I could say, create another channel for you to release those "less popular" videos/subject matter but I know that takes more time on your part. When I first came upon your channel during the pandemic, I viewed you and your opinion as someone who was incredibly level headed, facts driven, informative and OPEN MINDED, which is so freaking rare these days. What you do for music and so many artists is amazing. In the past, you would have been considered a gatekeeper of sorts, but I think you are the keymaster (Ghostbusters reference). You opened up my mind to so many new genres that I never knew about and shared new information on bands and artists that I've followed for years that I didn't know about. All I can say is that I appreciate your work, your opinion and the value you bring. I don't have any particular ideas to share because I've enjoyed the output so far, but maybe others will help you discover some new and interesting topics to cover. Good luck
I'd love to hear more stories of punk/hardcore shows that you went to back in the day, what you learned from those shows, how it helped inform your world view. You've made videos like that before and they've always been my fav.
I also love hearing about the evolution of punk and hardcore. Who influenced the newer artists coming out, how did they influence those artists.
LOL -- replying to my own post. But that last thing could be really cool. That way, you could talk about new bands, your viewers could discover new bands, while at the same time talking about who influenced those bands. Truly informative, and it would fit into the name of your channel very well.
Been commenting for a couple of years now for him to make a video about terror celebrating 20 years as a band and how they never stopped and their legacy. Maybe one day... Still wish he would do more hc vids :,-(
Fwiw your videos on trap metal and emo rap got me into rap and broadened by musical tastes a lot.
you my friend, are a fresh air in rock/metal. I am a metalhead all my life.. but never one who only wears metal t-shirts etc.. i really like your alternative view of things. You say things just like they are.. and hardcore metalheads don't like change and don't like anything new other that the big 5 (ok i went too far :) ) Greetings from Greece !!
What if you continue your "Bands that Could've been Bigger" series? Or even a series on up and coming new rock/metal bands?
I LOVED the trap metal video. I still listed to the Spotify Playlist
I loved that video, as well. I'm now a Scarlxrd and City Morgue fan because of it.
Can you do a link to this playlist?
@@devenscience8894 EXACTLY
This is actually my first time commenting, but your videos are awesome. I get the uncertainty that comes with running out ideas for (good) videos, and how that can make you feel like there's an end to your channel looming on the horizon. Much respect for all you do, man, you're an incredibly hard worker and always have some very cool insights into music. I know you've exposed me to a lot of incredible bands!
My grandpa also had serious sleep issues related to stress. He was in Vietnam and part of his job was to crawl through the hidden network of Vietcong tunnels. Can’t imagine what he may have seen..
My father in law is from vietnam and fought in the war for SEVEN YEARS… can you imagine?
I mean I don't know dude hears a thought ,maybe instead of old millennial Bands you can Focus on More modern Bands see what happens. I think a lot of your audience would enjoy it either the history of or The impact of I don't know man I've always trusted your contact and even as I said in another comment bands and style of music I absolutely hate that you make videos on I still watch and enjoy
I like wolfsguitarden7’s idea. There are a number of videos where you talk about how a particular band had a surprising impact in only a short number of years or with a very limited discography (Nirvana and Refused are two videos that come to mind). What about some newer artists that are already making a huge impact on their genre (or even other genres) even for not having been around for long?
@@ThePunkRockMBANew Wave of Old School Thrash Metal.
I'm into history with an emphasis on military/political topics. The stories from Vietnam are just mind blowing on both sides. There's a quote about jungle warfare that states that you aren't just at war with the enemy but the environment as well. Just absolutely crazy to think about. My respect goes out to everyone on both sides as ultimately neither side that participated had an option to not - people in suits most can't even name made those calls and set up that chess board.
I'm sorry you're struggling, but for what it's worth, you are one of my favorite RUclipsrs. I like your style/delivery because you remind me of a lot of my dude-friends. (That's a compliment lol.) I hope you keep making videos!
I personally always loved when you covered new music & new waves. While I do think the viewership will decrease temporarily, in the long term you will gain more subscribers as you'll never run out of ideas & completely avoid stagnation. it is important to be more current. Also to make the best of both worlds, you can sprinkle in some nostalgic videos in there & add more of your opinion & witty humor in those. It's a win win situation! Just playing the long game, instead of shorter lived success! Of course this is all just my opinion, I feel many others would agree. Keep your head up buddy! A lot of us really appreciate what you do. Also if you need a manager then tell your people to call my people lol Cheers!
You like video games you could explore that world a little
True. IMO a nice niche would be videogame soundtracks that have licensed rock/metal music - Tony Hawk, Dave Mirra, NFS Underground, Flatout 2 etc.
@@SMJSmoK yeah I think Finn has don’t THPS videos and he just did one about doom so maybe that could be a direction he could take it. Idk just spitballing here
A video on the copycat "Grunge" bands cashing in on the post-Nirvana hype such as - Bush, Silverchair, Candlebox, Superheaven, Gin Blossoms, LifeHouse, Toadies, Deep Blue Something, etc... would be great!
I feel for you Finn. I would recommend that you make a video about de band Low. Why? Because their music is great (especially their last three albums, which I think due to the use of distorsion a metal fan might like).
Maybe a video series based on the years? Do 4 vids on like 1985, one on country, one on metal, one on rock, one on pop, and continue doing those to the present day exploring the evolution of the genres and how sounds and styles progressed, you can weave newer artists throughout it by highlighting artists influenced by those that came before (like how emo rapper sample a lot of that stuff or how even Halsey has sampled bands like Brand New)
It might not do well exactly, but I'd also love some videos on how promotion has changed over the years from DIY posters to street teams, all the way through tiktok and you can talk about new artists that way too. Who is still using promotional tactics from 30 years ago and making them work?
Maybe include media reviews? I'm talking about more books than films and documentaries. I just read From the Basement and found it mediocre overall, but I know there are other authors in the scene. Keith Buckley has a few books out, Geoff Rickley, Joe Trohman
Last idea... (maybe risky?) Rebrand, you would know more about that than most of us for sure, but if I saw someone with the name ThePunkRockMBA and they made a video on jazz or country, I'd just assume they were shitting on the genres before I even turned it on. Maybe switch to TheMusicMBA? I think part of what made Fantano able to do what he does is that his name is inclusive to all music.
Yeah, the channel name definitely boxes me in. I would have chosen something different in hindsight but oh well, here we are.
@@ThePunkRockMBA I think there's a way to do it. I follow crypto channels (i know i know) but like bitboy crypto rebranded their entire channel to discover crypto, name change and all. After Jason Tate got the rights back to absolute punk he switched it over to chorus because punk no longer represented the entirety of what he did. I have no doubt you can pull off the samd
@@ThePunkRockMBA Wouldn´t it be punk if you´d do videos about other genres? What´s in a name?
@@ThePunkRockMBAI love the name. See my other comment but punk rock isn’t just music but about how you approach life and thinking for yourself. You taught me that!
Here’s an idea. Make a video about songs that became more iconic and famous because they were in films. Directors like Quentin Tarantino put some of the best soundtracks in his films, and those soundtracks became more iconic because they were submitted in perfectly in his film. You don’t have to like the directors, but the style of how music can change your perspective in a film is interesting. 🎬🎶🎵🗣️
I like this idea. There was the video about the relationship between pop punk and teen movies which was really cool. I’d love to see one about maybe how other genres have been featured in movies (like the resident evil movies and the matrix and that kind of genre movie) or just music in movies in general
Been here since 2019 bro, sucks you’re in this rut or whatever. I too suffer from panic attacks in the middle of the night , they’re fucking miserable wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemies. Keep ya head up brother, most of us are pulling for ya!!! The squeakiest wheel gets the oil. Fuck them haters bro it’s probably 1/100 that thinks that way! Take care bro!
Please more videos of 90s culture, specially MTV (Celebrity Death Match, Daria, Unplugged, Tom Green and his influence on comedy), Napster vs Music Industry, Walkman-Diskman-MP3PortablePlayer era, experience of renting or buying VHS-DVD vs Streaming culture… Big fan of your channel. You are my favourite RUclipsr. Don´t stop with the Nu Metal content!!!
This is just my one subscriber’s opinion but my favorite vids of urs are the ones that are further out of the traditional metal stuff (like trap metal and Hyperpop) those are the vids I always come back to and I’ve even shared with people. So I get the algorithm may favor other things but you’ll always have at least one view on those vids from me. Also as an autistic person with a creative type brain the way u come off has never been off putting to me at least
Thank you!
Honestly, I'm not as interested in metal/music commentary as I used to be. I always come back to your videos (particularly your second channel/twitch streams) because you've brought more of your personality and perspectives into it.
I really enjoy hearing you talk about "lifey" things. You have a lot to say that I think is incredibly valuable, especially in this day and age. I appreciate your willingness to put yourself out there and share your views honestly, it's very refreshing.
The sad truth is every RUclipsr who struggles deals with this, but they are afraid to be completely honest with their fanbase because they know they can never win the fight. So I respect you for being completely honest.. 💙
this is why a lot of RUclipsrs have to create a character for themselves on RUclips to become funny or amusing. When in reality that’s not who they are in real life. And they struggle every week on what things they should say when they are in their RUclips character again. I can’t imagine how mentally that must strain you. 😫
The public people will always control the public figures as a puppet to play with and it’s so messed up. 😞
Please be good news please be good news 🤞
Finn,
First off, I want to say that me and my wife watch your youtube and love it. Our tastes go from big band in the 1940's, oldies in 50 and 60's then goes to hardcore and metal. We like ( and appreciate) your views on music of today. I think its really hard for you to do videos on punk and metal. To be honest, the new metal bands are not that good and most punk is pop punk. Also, im sure that most of the people that are talking smack on here are about 12 or dont realize the time and effort it takes uou to take this on. Well in any case i wanted to let you know that there are people who respect and appreciate you.
You said you were going to read the comments. So I'm going to take advantage and give you my perspective.
First of all, I'm from Argentina, and while I understand English, I'm not very good at writing it. This message is translated by Google, therefore, it may have some writing problems.
1- Difference between the two channels, the personal and Punk Rock MBA.
Personally, I like the Punk Rock MBA channel better: the videos have more production and the content is better structured, characteristics that the videos on the other channel do not have.
The name of the Channel, Punk Rock MBA, was the first thing that caught my attention, and I think where the first videos were directed.
The objective was to analyze and structure the way in which bands operate or how, in business terms, they serve their target audience, and they achieve it. It seemed like an excellent idea to me. For music NERDS, who don't want short videos, but want information about the bands and a different perspective, and the best thing I had was your opinion, which I always validate.
I think the idea of the Channel, referenced as MBA, is very good and interesting, it stood out among all the other content there is.
Your informative videos are 10 or more minutes long, therefore, your target audience is over 30 years old, consequently, it seems to me that I should attack it.
I like data and information. How the albums were recorded, who was the producer, what did he mean in certain songs, what mood existed at the time of recording the album, meaning of songs, etc.
2- Importance of your opinion.
It always seemed fundamental to me, in every channel, that the author's opinion on the topic he deals with is what makes it particular and different. Your opinions make you think.
3- Content proposal.
I find it interesting that you can recommend bands and give solid points as to why you think we should listen to them.
Today music is a commodity, all the songs sound the same and there are so many artists, it is difficult to distinguish which ones are worth it. I believe that today, the only thing that can make a difference is going to see them play live or, in your case, having them recommend you... and not songs! Albums worth it.
On the other hand, although - as you said - there in videos you make a summary of what Wikipedia says - for my part I did not know it - for me they are interesting and even more so when you add your opinion.
You could also give your opinion about the festivals or concerts that are taking place.
4- Interviews.
The interviews you did seem great to me! I always enjoyed them a lot.
5- Consultations on social networks.
Propose topics for people to vote on and choose topics for you to make videos on.
6- I don't like.
First and foremost, that you give so much importance to the haters. I understand that the number of views is important, but comments are useless when they are hateful. Focus on those who help you.
I also don't like the videos when you are streaming, they don't entertain me.
Hope this can help you!
Bro, keep doing you. I've been subscribed for years now. I can say I like deep dives on bands, and maybe some interviews. 🤘🏿
Thanks!
Here is a bit of advice from someone who struggles with anxiety and PTSD (I hope it helps at least a little): make peace with the worst possible outcome of your situation. If you make peace with that, it allows you to do whatever that thing is more freely (ie make internet content). There is also Pascal's wager - if you keep making videos people will make negative comments. If you stop, people will find old videos and make negative comments. So, keep making new videos. Lastly, as the greatest emo band ever (Copeland) said - dont break your neck to keep your chin up.
it's so funny cuz im millennial. i grew up with all sorts of pop punk-ish artists or whatever (i guess like senses fail etc) and i discovered gothboiclique in 2015 (about a year before lil peep was even a thing or at least before anyone heard of him). it blew my mind. the sound was so amazing to me and so new and i had no idea what this kind of music was even called. it was like the team sesh or raider klan stuff i was listening to for 2 years previous except with emo-influenced clean vocals and it worked so well i couldn't believe it hasn't been done before. i drove the 4 hours to go to a show they had in LA around january the next year: only about 50 or 60 people were there but i was still so starstruck meeting horse head and cold hart. i instantly told horse head "i listen to your romantic EP every day"
First off you're super great. Your content kicks ass and your little one is adorable (new dad gang).
Secondly it might be unrealistic as time is so finite especially with a little one at home... but can you maybe add an extra video a month? Like a passion video? Or add extra content that you love on top of what is effective for viewership etc?
Regardless sending super good vibes Finn you're amazing and pay homage to art that has touched so many of us. I'd also say your older stuff had a lot of personal connection that gave you insights people can't find on Wikipedia. That was so cool for me. But I recognized there is a finite amount of experiences for you to draw of from your life. But keep it up dude I love all of it.
He quit
@@bbailey3055 he posted a week ago...
Ah yes. Social media = the toilet 🚽 bowl of the internet. The struggle is real
Retrospectives of different bands would be cool
That's what he does already, those are the wikipedia videos he spoke about, endlessly looking back is what becomes so tiresome.
@@LightsOnTrees I mean yeah but I meant like a deep dive into them, like everything he can find about the history of them
thats literally what he did all these years lol
@@DigitalBath306 my bad I didn’t watch him 5 years ago
Hey Finn, I just want to say I hear you and can relate. Several years ago, I had to take a step back from my work as a music director due to panic attacks and even seizures caused by the constant stress and criticism. There were several points where I wanted to end my life. I think being under a public microscope is about as unnatural as it gets in the human experience. It got to a level for me where I had to back off, resign from my position, and restructure life. I make less money, I’m not an influencer, and my music isn’t blowing up. However, my wife and I have been together for 11 years, we have a house, we our needs met, we’re slowly taking things in a new direction, and we’re enjoying life much more than when I was under constant pressure with never-ending negative feedback loops. I am not saying you need to step back like I did, and I’m not even giving advice here. I am not as experienced as you, and I’m definitely not as business savvy. (I’m probably grouped in with the “creative people” who are typically assholes to you.) I just want to say, you’ve got your priorities straight, you’re smart, and you’ll figure this chapter out, just like you’ve done before. I’m an F-Tier Nobody/Baddiecore Wannabe, but honestly, I’m here for it because I’m not suffocating anymore. You got this, dude.
The magic of this channel was this funny older dude talking about music in general and giving advice, if people want Wikipedia shit, guys theres Rock Feed and Loudwire and a ton of other channels, thank you Tool, Deftones and SOAD fans as always for ruining the party for everybody....