Hey guys! So this is a different video than normal, and this was really more of an experiment than anything. Let me know if you like it or not. If not, then I won't do it again, but if so, then I'll continue this new series. Thanks for watching and enjoy! -Morgan
I want to say 2 and 2 halves, Lupin never liked to pick on snape, and he was likely not trying to support his friends but also not hurt Snape so he's half. Not because he's a poor duelist, but because he was holding back.
@@toothless3835Yeah Remus wasl literally the best person ever. He was talented, just and reallyy cared for everyone. It hurts that Remus had to die when people like Lucious still live...
@vedjoshi260 Kinnaird think your project who you think remus was. Remus found the bullying funny even If he was not the person to initiate it even 15 years later he was unremosfull. He was a coward who didn't tell Dumbledore that sirius was An anemigus as it would be admitting he broke Dumbledores trust by circumventing the protections dumbledore put in place to keep students and the peoples of Hogsmeade safe. He abandoned Tonks and only returned due to harry. He also abandoned Harry
That’s true, I think the reason they did this was so people knew for sure that it was Voldemort who was talking to Snape. The movies also made this mistake in Deathly Hallows part 2 during the princes tale. When they show Voldemort killing Lily and James he has the full “snake look” that he gets in the Goblet of Fire
@@comicalcosmonaut959 Yeah, pretty much the same as he looked in Chamber of secrets, but paler and red eyes like you said. He didn't look serpent-like until after his "resurrection" in Goblet of Fire. That is the first time he is mentioned with the slit eyes, flesh stretched over bones, and lack of nose, as far as I can remember
One quick point: Slughorn once said that he wanted the”whole batch” when referring to the Black family, implying that Sirius was the only one who didn’t get invited/accepted invitation to the Slug Club.
Always good to see another one of us around here. A las barricadas~ Y'know, is it just me, or is there a surprising amount of us around the place that you just... Stumble across from time to time, online? Especially since, of course, only some of us actually have icons by which we can be easily identified...
I really miss Alan Rickman 😔. You will for ever live in our heart and for all the great memories that you gave as Severus Snape. Rest in peace the half blood prince.
The director, Justin Zagri, is a professional director not only a HP fan. So are the actors. Especially the guy playing Snape. I found out this little gem 4 years ago and at once loved it!
This series actually has a sequel called "The Great Wizarding War." it's an audio drama and does a much better job at making James likeable. I really really recommend checking it out!
I gotta be honest I love the fact that James acts the way he does, he’s had a few drinks with his friends, wants to blow off steam, and I’ve always considered him more of a neutral character than a hero. Sure he has hero characteristics, but I find it really easy to believe that he wanted to bully snape one more time before he wouldn’t ever see him again
@@eternallucifer7709 The only people who've told us that are Remus and Sirius, and I don't think its a stretch to say they were leaving out some details to make James look better
@@TheJoeschmoe777and their words were never debunked by neither the books nor Rowling. On that scene, she used Sirius and Lupin to explain the kind of character James was. It's Rowling speaking through her characters, a very common practice in fiction
@@eternallucifer7709 Yes but you also have to consider their own personalities before taking their words at face value. Sirius was already known to have whitewashed a lot of James' faults in what he told to Harry (something Harry himself noted) and Remus in that same scene dismissed James behavior on the basis that he was 15. So, I don't think it's a stretch that if something like this happened, when tensions were running high and drinking was involved, that they wouldn't include it in their dialogue with Harry. Nothing in this film is a huge stretch of the imagination.
@@TheJoeschmoe777 in that scene Sirius and Lupin openly mocked James and admitted to their own fault. We are even told that Lupin voiced his dislike towards their bullying. You would be more convincing if that scene wasn't showing the exact opposite of unbias. "Remus in that same scene dismissed James behavior on the basis that he was 15" I often wonder if people don't know the difference between justification and explanation. Justification- saying why something is alright (what you are saying Lupin was doing) Explanation- saying why, even though something is not good, there are reasons behind it and the person who acted is not a demon (what Lupin is actually doing) Lupin is not dismissing James's beahvior, he is saying that James' behavior in those circumstances was not his full real self. "something Harry himself noted" Harry was not James. He did not have his life, or his personality and he didn't live in the same context as James. Harry's argument was that he was 15 and did not go around bullying other people. Yet he was friends with people whom he later on says were like his father and his friends when they were teenagers, and most definitely were like that when they were 15. "Nothing in this film is a huge stretch of the imagination." You are pretty much saying it's okay to call this headcanon canon.
I think Snape is actually ranked as the third best duelist in the series (Voldemort and Dumbledore being the only ones above him) and it makes sense when you think about it and ESPECIALLY as shown in this film. Snape, whether he was the one to start or not, was likely ganged up on a lot by the Marauders (tho I imagine Lupin only getting involved when things had already escalated too far and would just try to Snape from maiming/killing his friends).
I agree with your opinions but I see the ending with Lilly more as tragedy for snape he was soo close too Lilly forgiveness but his stubbornness held him back and if he never saw Lilly again....
Well maybe he (Snape) was dreaming that part. Maybe he dreamt all those scenes between him and the Marauders. The only thing he didn’t dream was him sitting in the bar and meeting voldemort. Or maybe he got a blackout because he was so drunk. And so he almost hoped that he had a fight with James and his friends and that Lily forgave him. Then Voldemort being Voldemort took this occasion to talk to a drunk broken Snape. It all makes sense now!
That is actually a good explanation. I thought it out of character for post graduation James to act like that, but alcohol and fear can do that to you.
I really want to see that one abs Sisters of House Black. Other good ones are The Greater Good and the Omen Files. Omen files takes place in Southern California. It's a whole American wizarding story in 2013, fifteen years after the defeat of Voldemort.
I personally think that if Lily really did hug Snape againg and said those words, he wouldn't become a deadeater afterwards. He loved her so much that he wouldn't let that go to a waist
I think the idea is that he was never a loyal death eater. Atleast in the universe of this fan film. It’s also a theory that a lot of people hold. That he joined with the intention of turning spy and didn’t get an opportunity until dumbledore approached him. Though personally I don’t think that’s that valid.
The catching of the rock was a call back to James being a seeker (though in the book he was a chaser I think but movie showed him a seeker so it makes sense I guess)
Well to be fair Snape was going to kill James. Sure James bullied him throughout their Hogwarts years but James never took it as far as murder. Not to mention he saved Snape from Remus when he was in his Werewolf form
@@soo1579 um, snape wasn't even trying to tho. If he wanted to kill james he prolly would have done it ages ago... He just wanted james to shut up from what I saw initially. It was after he tried to use fiendfyre, Snape was pushed to this extent.
Slug horn said ‘I got his brother when he came along but I would have liked the set’ referring to regulas and Sirius so I think yes Regulas was in the slug club.- if I remember the quote correctly
Slughorn was head of Slytherin. He got Regulus, but wanted Sirius as well. But Sirius was sorted into Gryffindor. That’s what it’s referring, not the slug club. Hope that helps!
I actually feel it makes more sense for James to still be immature. That’s the vibe I’ve always had of him and Sirius and Lupin’s perspectives are eschewed when they talk to Harry about him. James was their friend and their perspective is still biased no matter what bad tea they told him. So when they tell Harry he “grew out of it” is still vague and leaves out a lot of details. And if you listen to the radio drama, he does mature a lot more over the course of it so that makes up for it all. On that note, please react to it! It follows up on this film
But it doesn't mean he didn't actually grow out of it or that they lied. We're told James only continued to hex Snape in 7th year because Snape was also cursing him. Otherwise, he stopped hexing people just for fun. But this film shows him go after Snape unprovoked after they left school. Even if it's possible, it's still showing a worst possibility that isn't necessarily canon. It earned James so much of hate for something he only did in a fanfilm. Their radio show doesn't make up for it because a lot more people watched this but not the radio series.
James used to be a bully. But in year 7, he stopped bullying and hexing just for fun. And I have read somewhere that Snape was the one provoking and persuading James for a fight
That's because he made another Horcrux, Nagini while being brought back to life by Barty Crouch Jr. and Wormtail, by killing Bertha Jorkins, so he got red eyes from making his final Horcrux. And in the book he had red eyes after making 4 horcruxes.
But he was already really freaky looking before his fall. The kid he meets on Halloween when he's going after the Potters thinks he has a mask on at first and then runs away scared, and that was in 1981. By Harry's account, we know he was already starting to look freaky in the late 50s when he was asking Dumbledore for a teaching post.
Just saw the thumbnail 4 this about 5 seconds ago. making this comment before watching it. i never would have thought movie flame would review this!!! i am nerding out here!!!!
2:18 yes slughorn mentioned that regulus was on of his best student and he had a picture of him and said that he wanted the whole set of the black family but he didn't get Sirius in the half blood prince book.
I found this fanfilm carved deep in my mind, I watched it like 20 times (not kidding) cause it's having his own fascinating soul. The music is incredible done and it got dark and nostalgic tones that are very familiar with the image I have for Snape. I would really love to see a tv series about it with those actors, they are just perfect for the roles. I appreciated a lot Potter in this dark mood, cause it's really how I imagine him, and Snape fighting and winning against four people it's something that makes sense, if you consider he's using dark magic. I love everything about this, and the quality it's just spot on. I'm really sad they didn't just made another movie, talking about the beginning of the war, still from Snape's pov
Haha , ive watched it many times too!! It seems great! Sad they didnt make another movie , but they did continue this story in the audio-only- episoides on yt , as well as spotify ,i found the story absolutely brilliant 🔥, they did have a few plot holes ... its worth checking out !
Still one of my favourite fan-films of all time. Just don't ask me how many times I watched the film (and the cast's reaction to the film which is also on RUclips)
Theyve even continued the story as a series - The great wizarding war , in the form of audio-only- episoides on yt as well as spotify... the story is amazing!
I liked this review. I don't necessarily feel it was out of character for James to be bullying. He was out on his last hurrah with his buds, it's only natural to fall into old patterns.
7:08 - 7:11 When I first heard this in the movie especially as a woman, I was like, "thank you, Snape! We are not prizes to be won!". It is so interesting that she ended up marrying James when in this particular moment, Snape was being far, far more respectful to her than James.
To be fair, this film is fan fiction. The canon reality of these characters is separate from their portrayal here. That's not to say that these characters don't share characteristics with their canon counterparts; they're very much like them but presented in a different narrative and written with some liberties taken regarding the books. James is not an aggressive bully at this point and Snape is presented in a far less damning light than in the books. I consider this a sort of separate reality from the canon, to be honest. Also , it's an enjoyable film imo.
@@kingdaymon6433 Snape became a Death Eater but still loved Lily. Also, he betrayed Voldemort, even before his downfall at the end of the first Wizarding War
That's why James runs at Severus, to get his wand back. Plus he's upset Severus just beat him because now he would have to stay away from Lily, if was to keep
Man, Wow. Going into this I had no idea what to expect, like, maybe I'll get some cool ideas that my imagination can play around with. but, wow! Looks like I'm going to have to watch these fan films.
Pettigrews wand-work is very rat like, I like that touch alot. Also that scene with Snape and voldermort had a very sith-like feeling to it. Very palpatine esque by voldermort.
I think this fan film is amazing the actors and the special effects were incredible especially the magic the people who made the film got all of the characters right and I love how powerful Snape was all and all this was a very good film.🐀🐕🐺🐍
Well keep in mind Snape is the one telling the story so he's probably depicatating James as more of an a$$hole than he actually was. Plus James is intoxicated and it's graduation day and they have a lot of fear from Voldemort and they're friends dying, so it's probably why he started a fight w/Snape, cause he's drunk and fear from Voldemort and for his friends made him take it out on Snape. Edit: Forgot to mention James's parents would've just died from Dragon Pox as they died very soon after James and Lily were married, which they are here, when it shows Lily's ring.
I really liked ur reaction to the fam film! there is another fam film, which is actually one of my personal favs " Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch" by Muggle Flix.
James: about to literally die Sirius: under the crusiatus curse Lupin: literally bleeding out Pettegrew: he a runner he a track star Snape and lily: hugging
This fan video has been a favorite of mine for a long time. I really liked your professional review of it. In regards to James' character, I've always thought that he improved from generally pranking and hexing, but still made an exception for Snape. I loved Morgana (Mick) Ignis' performance as Snape.
Here’s a list of some other good HP fan films: The Greater Good Mischief Managed Le Maitre de la Mort (The Master of Death) Sisters of House Black Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch Son of the Moon Voldemort: Origins of the Heir Also kind of interesting, the Lily Evans Fan Film Series
Love this series I think IDEA: Maybe you should watch the whole fan film and make one with the entire one and then make another on but just cut out some parts for people who don’t want to watch the entire thing (if thay makes sense) again love this series!
Some of my recommendations for fan films: Neville Longbottom and the black witch Sisters of House Black Or that one about the tale of the three brothers: ruclips.net/video/dPKpDo_kGVI/видео.html 😊😁
this is my favourite fan film and i love how you gave your opinion on it and i loved the video! there is a follow up podcast to this film and it is just as incredible as the film if not better. just thought i’d let you know. happy pottering!!💖
This is awesome! Also, when Lily says "I hope to see you again" the next time they see each other, is when Snape visits their house right after she dies. But isn't Voldemort not supposed to have the pale, snake face yet?
i like it it's sooo close to the story n the detail to the overall story was a nice touch. voldemortes appearance was better here i think it was closer to the snakelike appearance he ended up with
Voldemort talking to Snape reminds me of the scene when Grindelwald tells Credence he's "betrayed" by dumbledore. Same whisper, same ambience music. Love it.
To think James wasn't a bully is wrong. This portrait of James is really spot on. "You're just like your father. Arrogant. Weak." None of the marauders could beat Snape one on one. James ran his mouth and couldn't back it up without his friends. Hence the arrogant and weak statement. Loved this fan film. I would love to see this era covered in a movie.
Review the fanfilm Voldemort Origins, talks about him and heirs to the other Hogwarts founders. The apparition here is like The Flash. There r fanfilms of Percy Jackson, only saw 1 of Percy’s claiming.
Also, a little detail that I LOVED in this film is how right after the fiendfyre spell you can see each of the marauders friendship or personalities on HOW they apparate. For starters, Peter just doesn't at all because, as he said, he is still not used to the feeling of it and is probably scared to try it on his own. Remus, apparated by himself within shot of where James and Sirius en up. BUT you can literally see, how in sync Sirius and James are because they apparate RIGHT next to each other, while Remus is a bit further appart. Obviusly all of them are in sync because they apparate in the same place without even talking about it; that's how close they are. But, within that, you can SEE how James and Sirius are evidently the closest. And I love how they SHOW you all of this without the need for a single word; as a key rule in filmmaking is to SHOW instead of just TELL.
Ok this is really cool. I honestly think it would be fun to see a Marauders movie. I know they have touched base of it at times in the books. Seeing this makes me think of a movie about this would help expand the HP franchise. It would be fun to even see Sirius, James, and Peter becoming animagus do be with Lupin and all that would be fun to see. Make a sequel to it following them through the first war and all. What do you think Morgan? Would you like something like that to add on to the HP franchise?!
I would love to watch a video where you can share your favourite/(least favourite) things in Harry Potter. For instance characters, teachers, school subjects, houses, threads, quotes, scenes, relationships, background stories, items, horcruxes etc.
Hey guys! So this is a different video than normal, and this was really more of an experiment than anything. Let me know if you like it or not. If not, then I won't do it again, but if so, then I'll continue this new series. Thanks for watching and enjoy!
-Morgan
Hi
Hi
Love it
Please do a video reviewing both Avatar Kyoshi books
Haven’t watched it but let’s be honest... yes
Thanks, friend!
:O you made an amazing movie dude. good job
Are subtitles there yet, in the new one...?
I loved everything about your film. Wish to see some more projects in the future.
Hello Broad Strokes
this is my favourite fan film tbh i really like it!
“Like-“
“-snape”
“Exactly”
“No I mean he’s right there”
Best line in the film
Lol
yup
4 actually
I agree
Personally I like:
"Are you serious?"
"No, you're Sirius!"
12:43 if lily didnt come then James last words would have been "Severus, please" the same last words as Dumbledore
Stolen comment
human ik lol
anddd also the muggle studies teacher that died at the death eaters' meating
@@liilacev1072 Oh yeah!
@@eleenasaha3334 I agree that would be cool But not if James died mabey just crucio
“Are you serious?” “No, you’re Sirius” lmao
"Like I'm a Leo" "No silly, I'm a Leo, YOU'RE a Percy"
@@Drowningindisappointment in blood of Olympus I swear I laughed so hard
Aye fandom jokes :-)
@@Drowningindisappointment I laughed so hard at that!!! 😂 🤣🤣🤣
Fandom jokes are probably my favorite jokes!!!
Damn Snape sure can handle 2 wizards!
*Remus joins in*
Even 3 wizards!
*Pettegrew joins in*
Damn boi, 3 and half!
I want to say 2 and 2 halves, Lupin never liked to pick on snape, and he was likely not trying to support his friends but also not hurt Snape so he's half. Not because he's a poor duelist, but because he was holding back.
@@toothless3835Yeah Remus wasl literally the best person ever. He was talented, just and reallyy cared for everyone. It hurts that Remus had to die when people like Lucious still live...
@vedjoshi260 Kinnaird think your project who you think remus was.
Remus found the bullying funny even If he was not the person to initiate it even 15 years later he was unremosfull.
He was a coward who didn't tell Dumbledore that sirius was An anemigus as it would be admitting he broke Dumbledores trust by circumventing the protections dumbledore put in place to keep students and the peoples of Hogsmeade safe. He abandoned Tonks and only returned due to harry. He also abandoned Harry
3 and half 😂😂😂
Other criticism is that Voldemort didn't look like that at that point in the timeline; he still had some of his younger looks.
That’s true, I think the reason they did this was so people knew for sure that it was Voldemort who was talking to Snape. The movies also made this mistake in Deathly Hallows part 2 during the princes tale. When they show Voldemort killing Lily and James he has the full “snake look” that he gets in the Goblet of Fire
Yea he was still Tom Riddle just with paler skin and red eyes.
@@comicalcosmonaut959 Yeah, pretty much the same as he looked in Chamber of secrets, but paler and red eyes like you said. He didn't look serpent-like until after his "resurrection" in Goblet of Fire. That is the first time he is mentioned with the slit eyes, flesh stretched over bones, and lack of nose, as far as I can remember
I was thinking that as I was watching it
@@xHTxRaptorF22 isn’t it mentioned in the HBP book that he was no longer the handsome Tom Riddle
One quick point: Slughorn once said that he wanted the”whole batch” when referring to the Black family, implying that Sirius was the only one who didn’t get invited/accepted invitation to the Slug Club.
He meant the whole batch in Slytherin, I don't think he meant the slug club but maybe you are right.
Always good to see another one of us around here. A las barricadas~
Y'know, is it just me, or is there a surprising amount of us around the place that you just... Stumble across from time to time, online? Especially since, of course, only some of us actually have icons by which we can be easily identified...
No he meant Sirius was the only one not in slytherin
There was a picture on his wall of the slughorn and the club and regulus was like on the second row I think
He said "I would have liked the pair"; when referring to Regulas being part of the slug club... I think
I really miss Alan Rickman 😔. You will for ever live in our heart and for all the great memories that you gave as Severus Snape. Rest in peace the half blood prince.
This comment should get more likes 😩😩😩
@@josieisthecoolest Thank y😌u so much for your support. N🙂 worries. Popularity isn't an indication of quantity.
IKR this has to have more likes ur right
He spread his wings just like absulum(Alice in wonderland)
The director, Justin Zagri, is a professional director not only a HP fan. So are the actors. Especially the guy playing Snape.
I found out this little gem 4 years ago and at once loved it!
The guy who played Remus looks exactly like him
He doesn't even kinda look like him
@@ssstarmann i thought i was the only one who thought so 💀
@@someonefromearth5231 lol
i don't think he does, but his acting was very good, i especially appreciated his movements in fight scenes, they look exactly in character for Lupin
I think you mean the guy who played remus acts exactly like him.
Harry Potter puns can Slytherin to any conversation
Quit being a Gryffindork ->-
Oh dear...
HAHAH
Jeez i need to ravenCLAW my way out the hole of bad punz
Oh no...
This series actually has a sequel called "The Great Wizarding War." it's an audio drama and does a much better job at making James likeable. I really really recommend checking it out!
I agree
Agree
Yes plz watch “The Great Wizarding War” series!!!
I gotta be honest I love the fact that James acts the way he does, he’s had a few drinks with his friends, wants to blow off steam, and I’ve always considered him more of a neutral character than a hero. Sure he has hero characteristics, but I find it really easy to believe that he wanted to bully snape one more time before he wouldn’t ever see him again
Except he was stated to have grown out of those habbits long before he graduated. What happened in the video would never have happened in the story.
@@eternallucifer7709 The only people who've told us that are Remus and Sirius, and I don't think its a stretch to say they were leaving out some details to make James look better
@@TheJoeschmoe777and their words were never debunked by neither the books nor Rowling. On that scene, she used Sirius and Lupin to explain the kind of character James was. It's Rowling speaking through her characters, a very common practice in fiction
@@eternallucifer7709 Yes but you also have to consider their own personalities before taking their words at face value. Sirius was already known to have whitewashed a lot of James' faults in what he told to Harry (something Harry himself noted) and Remus in that same scene dismissed James behavior on the basis that he was 15. So, I don't think it's a stretch that if something like this happened, when tensions were running high and drinking was involved, that they wouldn't include it in their dialogue with Harry. Nothing in this film is a huge stretch of the imagination.
@@TheJoeschmoe777 in that scene Sirius and Lupin openly mocked James and admitted to their own fault. We are even told that Lupin voiced his dislike towards their bullying. You would be more convincing if that scene wasn't showing the exact opposite of unbias.
"Remus in that same scene dismissed James behavior on the basis that he was 15"
I often wonder if people don't know the difference between justification and explanation.
Justification- saying why something is alright (what you are saying Lupin was doing)
Explanation- saying why, even though something is not good, there are reasons behind it and the person who acted is not a demon (what Lupin is actually doing)
Lupin is not dismissing James's beahvior, he is saying that James' behavior in those circumstances was not his full real self.
"something Harry himself noted"
Harry was not James. He did not have his life, or his personality and he didn't live in the same context as James. Harry's argument was that he was 15 and did not go around bullying other people. Yet he was friends with people whom he later on says were like his father and his friends when they were teenagers, and most definitely were like that when they were 15.
"Nothing in this film is a huge stretch of the imagination."
You are pretty much saying it's okay to call this headcanon canon.
I think Snape is actually ranked as the third best duelist in the series (Voldemort and Dumbledore being the only ones above him) and it makes sense when you think about it and ESPECIALLY as shown in this film. Snape, whether he was the one to start or not, was likely ganged up on a lot by the Marauders (tho I imagine Lupin only getting involved when things had already escalated too far and would just try to Snape from maiming/killing his friends).
I think Bellatrix is stronger than Snape. Maybe Snape is the fourth or fifth best duelist.
But bellatrix was killed by molly
I agree with your opinions but I see the ending with Lilly more as tragedy for snape he was soo close too Lilly forgiveness but his stubbornness held him back and if he never saw Lilly again....
Well maybe he (Snape) was dreaming that part. Maybe he dreamt all those scenes between him and the Marauders. The only thing he didn’t dream was him sitting in the bar and meeting voldemort. Or maybe he got a blackout because he was so drunk. And so he almost hoped that he had a fight with James and his friends and that Lily forgave him. Then Voldemort being Voldemort took this occasion to talk to a drunk broken Snape. It all makes sense now!
@@jicheetfoeww No he wasn't dreaming, I'm pretty sure he was having a flashback and telling his story to voldemort.
@@jicheetfoeww you can imagine the conversation
Voldemort) So you 100% sure you wanna join me
Snape) Sure just pay me bar tAB
I think the reason James is starting it is a mix of him being drunk it being graduation day and fear of him joining voldermort
Probably yea
Yeah
That is actually a good explanation. I thought it out of character for post graduation James to act like that, but alcohol and fear can do that to you.
For hunger games fan films I’d recommend an underrated film called “THE 67TH ANNUAL HUNGER GAMES” Yes, in uppercase. It’s by Elizabeth Wolf.
And the one about Haymitch's Games.
Yeah that one was good
@@bessieburnet9816 what's it called?
@@bessieburnet9816 Yeah that one's amazing
@@Danny-wn1gn HUNGER GAMES: THE SECOND QUARTER QUELL
4:14 I love how James says to sirius "No, you're sirius" that just made me laugh lmao
Do any one has the link of the film the marauders Ara, all the dudes if you please
Notice that James says “Severus Please” Dumbledork said that in the movies when Snape is about to kill Voldemort
Dumbledore
Let us see your reaction to Voldemort: Origins of the Heir
He has already done an review on that video about 2 years ago
Also the Bellatrix film, the Longbottom prequel film
Can u do one on SIsters of the Black House?
I really want to see that one abs Sisters of House Black.
Other good ones are The Greater Good and the Omen Files. Omen files takes place in Southern California. It's a whole American wizarding story in 2013, fifteen years after the defeat of Voldemort.
@@josephwatson1931 Ooh I’m gonna watch those now
I personally think that if Lily really did hug Snape againg and said those words, he wouldn't become a deadeater afterwards. He loved her so much that he wouldn't let that go to a waist
I think the idea is that he was never a loyal death eater. Atleast in the universe of this fan film. It’s also a theory that a lot of people hold. That he joined with the intention of turning spy and didn’t get an opportunity until dumbledore approached him. Though personally I don’t think that’s that valid.
The character of Peter, Lupin, Snape and Sirius are done extremely well.
I just don’t like how James was done
Peter is done the best
Yes please!
This was James in Snape's eyes. We only have a few pages about James to go on, he probably was this mean to Snape until the end of school.
@@joeyshofner639 but we learn that he stopped bullying Snape and only when Snape tried attacking him
James is mach more agresiv and chaidlish
I low key enjoyed Snape being the lead. Yes the cast is amazing. Especially Peter and Remus
when Morgan said "Maybe some Hunger Games or Star Wars fan films too" my face lit up and I got this huuuuge grin on my face
You gotta react to A Very Potter Musical
And the sequel and the senior year
You are still here
react to the ticking noise XD
BTW I'm not a fan of the person in your account
I liked the Snape preformance, Always was interested in this period od his life
The catching of the rock was a call back to James being a seeker (though in the book he was a chaser I think but movie showed him a seeker so it makes sense I guess)
James was never a seeker. He was a chaser or keeper can't remember but the movie was wrong James' wasn't a seeker.
Even though he wasn’t a seeker, in the books he still had a habit of casually playing around with a golden snitch so I guess it’s a callback to that
@@hache4329 Yes, and Harry who is a seeker himself notices his excellent reflexes.
James and his friends: use fieldfare and attack snape against his will
snape: takes his revenge
lily: comes in at the one time snape has beaten them
Lol lily ruining everything
Also Snape: Massive plot armor 4v1 and director bias
Well to be fair Snape was going to kill James. Sure James bullied him throughout their Hogwarts years but James never took it as far as murder. Not to mention he saved Snape from Remus when he was in his Werewolf form
@@soo1579 um, snape wasn't even trying to tho. If he wanted to kill james he prolly would have done it ages ago... He just wanted james to shut up from what I saw initially. It was after he tried to use fiendfyre, Snape was pushed to this extent.
@@soo1579 at least that was my perspective
Slug horn said ‘I got his brother when he came along but I would have liked the set’ referring to regulas and Sirius so I think yes Regulas was in the slug club.- if I remember the quote correctly
Slughorn was head of Slytherin. He got Regulus, but wanted Sirius as well. But Sirius was sorted into Gryffindor. That’s what it’s referring, not the slug club. Hope that helps!
I actually feel it makes more sense for James to still be immature. That’s the vibe I’ve always had of him and Sirius and Lupin’s perspectives are eschewed when they talk to Harry about him. James was their friend and their perspective is still biased no matter what bad tea they told him. So when they tell Harry he “grew out of it” is still vague and leaves out a lot of details.
And if you listen to the radio drama, he does mature a lot more over the course of it so that makes up for it all. On that note, please react to it! It follows up on this film
But it doesn't mean he didn't actually grow out of it or that they lied. We're told James only continued to hex Snape in 7th year because Snape was also cursing him. Otherwise, he stopped hexing people just for fun. But this film shows him go after Snape unprovoked after they left school. Even if it's possible, it's still showing a worst possibility that isn't necessarily canon. It earned James so much of hate for something he only did in a fanfilm. Their radio show doesn't make up for it because a lot more people watched this but not the radio series.
@@Tasha9315 Right. This fanfilm alone gained James so much hate, so much that he did not deserve
James used to be a bully. But in year 7, he stopped bullying and hexing just for fun. And I have read somewhere that Snape was the one provoking and persuading James for a fight
@@hanantkm Exactly. Some claim the lied, but there's hard evidence they lied. Being James's bffs doesn't indefinitely proof they lied.
@@Tasha9315 Yes, I agree. But only very few Potterheads would agree with us, sadly
You should react to Sister Of The House Black by Kelsey Ellison, and Mischief Managed by (Idk whon it was by)
Yasss it was awesome I loved it okay but the bellatrix there was - craxy
Sisters of House Black by Kelsey Ellison is my favorite fan film, it was so good!
foregone films i think
I love how the FeindFyre took the form of their respective Animagus forms/ Patronuses alongside Lupin's werewolf
"He is scarrier here than in the movies"...that s so true XD
You should really watch The Sisters Of House Black. It’s really good
The big thing that was bugging me was that they had voldemort after his resurrection, he still had a human body but red eyes
That's because he made another Horcrux, Nagini while being brought back to life by Barty Crouch Jr. and Wormtail, by killing Bertha Jorkins, so he got red eyes from making his final Horcrux. And in the book he had red eyes after making 4 horcruxes.
But he was already really freaky looking before his fall. The kid he meets on Halloween when he's going after the Potters thinks he has a mask on at first and then runs away scared, and that was in 1981. By Harry's account, we know he was already starting to look freaky in the late 50s when he was asking Dumbledore for a teaching post.
Just saw the thumbnail 4 this about 5 seconds ago. making this comment before watching it. i never would have thought movie flame would review this!!! i am nerding out here!!!!
Cringe
“What the heck was that? That looks like jimmy neutron’s brain blast” 😂😂😂
LMAOOOO
The aperating was so good and then there was what ever the heck that was 🤣
2:18 yes slughorn mentioned that regulus was on of his best student and he had a picture of him and said that he wanted the whole set of the black family but he didn't get Sirius in the half blood prince book.
I found this fanfilm carved deep in my mind, I watched it like 20 times (not kidding) cause it's having his own fascinating soul. The music is incredible done and it got dark and nostalgic tones that are very familiar with the image I have for Snape. I would really love to see a tv series about it with those actors, they are just perfect for the roles. I appreciated a lot Potter in this dark mood, cause it's really how I imagine him, and Snape fighting and winning against four people it's something that makes sense, if you consider he's using dark magic.
I love everything about this, and the quality it's just spot on.
I'm really sad they didn't just made another movie, talking about the beginning of the war, still from Snape's pov
Haha , ive watched it many times too!! It seems great!
Sad they didnt make another movie , but they did continue this story in the audio-only- episoides on yt , as well as spotify ,i found the story absolutely brilliant 🔥, they did have a few plot holes ... its worth checking out !
You should react to Voldemort: Origins of the heir
A very good film. I think these fans were Russian
He already did
Still one of my favourite fan-films of all time. Just don't ask me how many times I watched the film (and the cast's reaction to the film which is also on RUclips)
Yessss absolutely next-level production from Broad Strokes 😌😌
Theyve even continued the story as a series - The great wizarding war , in the form of audio-only- episoides on yt as well as spotify... the story is amazing!
Can you react to Neville longbottom and the black witch.....it’s another Harry Potter fan film it’s really great!
Yep
I recommend Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch
I'm also looking to make my own fan film soon hopefully!
I liked this review. I don't necessarily feel it was out of character for James to be bullying. He was out on his last hurrah with his buds, it's only natural to fall into old patterns.
hi i recommed reacting to "sisters of house black"
@Cookie RavenPuff yes me too!
YES.
Ya that one was amazing
Same
Thank you
Man this vid is better than the actual fanfiction. Amazing vid Morgan, keep going!
Honestly, I’m so addicted to your content, you explain everything so well and the videos are always super well done. Love the content
7:08 - 7:11 When I first heard this in the movie especially as a woman, I was like, "thank you, Snape! We are not prizes to be won!".
It is so interesting that she ended up marrying James when in this particular moment, Snape was being far, far more respectful to her than James.
Snape hated everyone with her blood status and became a death eater. I think that's more disrespectful than wanting to fight for her affection
To be fair, this film is fan fiction. The canon reality of these characters is separate from their portrayal here. That's not to say that these characters don't share characteristics with their canon counterparts; they're very much like them but presented in a different narrative and written with some liberties taken regarding the books. James is not an aggressive bully at this point and Snape is presented in a far less damning light than in the books. I consider this a sort of separate reality from the canon, to be honest. Also , it's an enjoyable film imo.
This is not canon so you cant consider that it happened in the hp universe
@@kingdaymon6433 Snape became a Death Eater but still loved Lily. Also, he betrayed Voldemort, even before his downfall at the end of the first Wizarding War
@@_Cragon_ and he still bullied students as a grown up
Voldemort looks really different but I liked it. Peter Petigrew looks really like how Rowling described him as. Please make more videos like this
i ain’t first
i ain’t last
i can’t think of a third rhyme.
thanks for 2 likes.
But I love the Harry Potter cast ???
@@becca3445 yes
Here's one:
You're not first
You're not last
But most importantly...
*Nobody asked.*
Credits to: someone else.
And now from the past.
James: So okay i got a wand in my hand, a object that has extreme power.
*Runs against Snape and gets hit by a spell*
snape disarmed him btw
That's why James runs at Severus, to get his wand back. Plus he's upset Severus just beat him because now he would have to stay away from Lily, if was to keep
his part of the bargain he wanted Severus to agree to.
Haven’t even watched it yet but I already know it’s gonna be 🔥🔥like every other video !!
Snape is a King and one of my favourite characters along with Neville Longbottom. This made me excited and sad at the same time. I want more!
I Personally feel the actors give a great Performance. So I give this Short Film 9 of 10.
On their channel they have a whole series called “The great wizarding war”. You should watch it!
I agree
Its audio formatted theres no video to it :)
You just gave me so much nostalgia holy lord
Peter: well I guess we know who the big cheese is here. 😂
Man, Wow.
Going into this I had no idea what to expect, like, maybe I'll get some cool ideas that my imagination can play around with. but, wow!
Looks like I'm going to have to watch these fan films.
Wish they would've shown more fight scenes with Snape in the movies especially after seeing him take on three and a half wizards here lol
Movie Flam: Damn! He going to space! 😂😭😭 I was crying 😂
4:13
“Are you serious?“
“No, you’re Sirius”
Pettigrews wand-work is very rat like, I like that touch alot. Also that scene with Snape and voldermort had a very sith-like feeling to it. Very palpatine esque by voldermort.
Sirius - I hate you James
James - Are you serius?
Sirius - Yes I am Sirius
😂 James got confused and broke their friendship
I highly suggest watching Sisters of House Black
I have seen snape and the marauders like 9-10 months ago and it was amazing to see it again thanks for uploading it
When snape was yelling and then exploded it reminded me so much of something that would be in Percy Jackson
eiiii another fellow Ravenclaw
I reminded me of a fanfic with the idea of a curse called Blood rage.
I think this fan film is amazing the actors and the special effects were incredible especially the magic the people who made the film got all of the characters right and I love how powerful Snape was all and all this was a very good film.🐀🐕🐺🐍
I also don't like how James starts it and goes at it
Well keep in mind Snape is the one telling the story so he's probably depicatating James as more of an a$$hole than he actually was. Plus James is intoxicated and it's graduation day and they have a lot of fear from Voldemort and they're friends dying, so it's probably why he started a fight w/Snape, cause he's drunk and fear from Voldemort and for his friends made him take it out on Snape. Edit: Forgot to mention James's parents would've just died from Dragon Pox as they died very soon after James and Lily were married, which they are here, when it shows Lily's ring.
Not really. James was ALWAYS the one at starting things.
@@sweetcupcake5235 yea that’s true
@@Alt-yg5ng no when he got with lily he matured in his last year and stoped that
@@Connor-ml1zd he matured but he didn't change much towards Snape when lily wasn't around
Do a video on the history of the sacred 28: explain the intermarriages and where the families are today
When all four are fighting peter doesn't cast the spells as fast
I really liked ur reaction to the fam film! there is another fam film, which is actually one of my personal favs " Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch" by Muggle Flix.
Let us see your reaction to Voldemort: Origins of the Heir.
He’s already done that one before, he should try le maitre de le Morte
I still am not happy with James's appearence because in canon, he has BLACK and MESSY hair while here, he is perfectly groomed and has brown (?) hair
Ikr
James: about to literally die
Sirius: under the crusiatus curse
Lupin: literally bleeding out
Pettegrew: he a runner he a track star
Snape and lily: hugging
This fan video has been a favorite of mine for a long time. I really liked your professional review of it. In regards to James' character, I've always thought that he improved from generally pranking and hexing, but still made an exception for Snape. I loved Morgana (Mick) Ignis' performance as Snape.
You need to watch Voldemort: Origins of the Heir!
he has in 2018
Here’s a list of some other good HP fan films:
The Greater Good
Mischief Managed
Le Maitre de la Mort (The Master of Death)
Sisters of House Black
Neville Longbottom and the Black Witch
Son of the Moon
Voldemort: Origins of the Heir
Also kind of interesting, the Lily Evans Fan Film Series
I bloody loved this short film, absolutely insane for an amateur film
This fan film was really interesting!! Thanks Morgan for starting this new set of videos!
James catching the rock might be a nod to his seeker skills
İn books he is a chaser
@@lunaticlunar9731 yeah, it’d have to strictly be a movie reference lol
@@isaacsoto7965 eh its possible
can we all just collectively agree that this is canon
Yes
Love this series I think IDEA: Maybe you should watch the whole fan film and make one with the entire one and then make another on but just cut out some parts for people who don’t want to watch the entire thing (if thay makes sense) again love this series!
Some of my recommendations for fan films:
Neville Longbottom and the black witch
Sisters of House Black
Or that one about the tale of the three brothers:
ruclips.net/video/dPKpDo_kGVI/видео.html
😊😁
Percival brothers
this is my favourite fan film and i love how you gave your opinion on it and i loved the video! there is a follow up podcast to this film and it is just as incredible as the film if not better. just thought i’d let you know. happy pottering!!💖
'Are you serious?'
**'No you're Sirius'**
😂😂😂
This is awesome! Also, when Lily says "I hope to see you again" the next time they see each other, is when Snape visits their house right after she dies. But isn't Voldemort not supposed to have the pale, snake face yet?
im late af but voldemort should look snake-ish because all of the horcrux making like harry notices in the half blood prince watching the memories
@@edvardhellstrom6872 true, true, but he shouldn't look like how he looks in the deathly hallows.
@@mbrady5652 No because he's only made 4 horcruxes
@@dhanvi2612 true
Book-Snape never went to the Potter's house. Only Movie-Snape did. :)
i like it it's sooo close to the story n the detail to the overall story was a nice touch. voldemortes appearance was better here i think it was closer to the snakelike appearance he ended up with
You should do these for Percy Jackson
Voldemort talking to Snape reminds me of the scene when Grindelwald tells Credence he's "betrayed" by dumbledore. Same whisper, same ambience music. Love it.
Well not quite the same ambience music but the same feel to it.
To think James wasn't a bully is wrong. This portrait of James is really spot on. "You're just like your father. Arrogant. Weak." None of the marauders could beat Snape one on one. James ran his mouth and couldn't back it up without his friends. Hence the arrogant and weak statement. Loved this fan film. I would love to see this era covered in a movie.
Except this is fanmade, in canon Snape couldn't beat Wormtail 😂
I don't watch fan films but most of them are pretty good
Review the fanfilm Voldemort Origins, talks about him and heirs to the other Hogwarts founders. The apparition here is like The Flash.
There r fanfilms of Percy Jackson, only saw 1 of Percy’s claiming.
He did that already
You must react to Grindelwald vs Dumbledore.
It's my favorite
Also, a little detail that I LOVED in this film is how right after the fiendfyre spell you can see each of the marauders friendship or personalities on HOW they apparate. For starters, Peter just doesn't at all because, as he said, he is still not used to the feeling of it and is probably scared to try it on his own. Remus, apparated by himself within shot of where James and Sirius en up. BUT you can literally see, how in sync Sirius and James are because they apparate RIGHT next to each other, while Remus is a bit further appart. Obviusly all of them are in sync because they apparate in the same place without even talking about it; that's how close they are. But, within that, you can SEE how James and Sirius are evidently the closest. And I love how they SHOW you all of this without the need for a single word; as a key rule in filmmaking is to SHOW instead of just TELL.
Ok this is really cool. I honestly think it would be fun to see a Marauders movie. I know they have touched base of it at times in the books. Seeing this makes me think of a movie about this would help expand the HP franchise. It would be fun to even see Sirius, James, and Peter becoming animagus do be with Lupin and all that would be fun to see. Make a sequel to it following them through the first war and all. What do you think Morgan? Would you like something like that to add on to the HP franchise?!
My favourite line:
Damn he going to space
There is a fan film called Sister of House black its really good
I like how Lily came in because it looks like she was in Angel and that’s probably foreshadowing too.
I would love to watch a video where you can share your favourite/(least favourite) things in Harry Potter. For instance characters, teachers, school subjects, houses, threads, quotes, scenes, relationships, background stories, items, horcruxes etc.
*7:52** He was a seeker in the quidditch team.*