Charlotte might be spoilt but you can clearly see that she is enjoying the experience. She is working hard and she seems to be such a warm hearted, kind an honest person. I like her
Both of those men saw James was somehow suffering from a lack of a father figure wanted to guide him. They probably realize a strong male role model is very important for a boy. I don't necessarily mean a "dad" but any good man who can help a boy through a rough patch.
Siana shows such disrespect to those who have opened their home and life to her. For someone who touts education she shows ignorance of basic etiquette towards her hosts.
J Mack This is, after all, a reality show, same as Big Brother but with the Amish, and what would a reality show be without some discord. Get real! It’s Siana’s job! You have one girl majoring in music/theater. One girl who is a radio DJ, and one girl who is a professional singer who is trying to find herself and reconcile her religious beliefs along with two guys who admit they don’t want to work and a college student. This is not Britain’s best, this is a group of reality actors. Why are these modern Amish participating? They are witnessing. Why am I watching? Because I am so curious about this peaceful God-fearing family loving culture-the Amish.
I adore Charlotte. She’s got such a kind heart. She isn’t afraid to explore different beliefs. In fact, she seems to be looking for something spiritual to fill an empty place in her. I hope she succeeds.
I think most people are longing for something from birth to fill a part of themselves. It is either taught to them and they believe it, don't believe it and find something else, don't believe it and keep looking, either find it or keep looking forever until they either destroy themselves or time runs out.
@@wellIdiditagain again...... it seems to be in these comments about open mindedness need be balanced with how Charlotte describes herself. She is a bit insecure and seeking validation; either through her friends, make-up, shopping and clothing. Although you can identify an element of that search for security as being open minded....you will see at the end of the series that although very enthusiastic about the bible its nuance soon wore away......
I get the impression she did not know herself at all before the trip. She was more easily shaped to fit in with the families because her identity is not well formed before. Siana seems to know her own values and has worked hard to challenge stereotypes and subvert expectations before the trip, so she was much less fluid in her identity and she couldn't fit in as well.
Yeah, it's funny how the SJW girls likes to speak about politics and open mindedness in the introduction scenes, while Charlotte was speaking about shopping and how her mom did everything for her, and still Charlotte comes of many times more open minded when faced with challenges far from her usual life, while the others struggle a lot to decide what they feel or how they feel about every little aspect of this new environment rather than just suck it in and embrace it for what it is.
Being open minded doesn't mean you have to accept everything, especially if you feel strongly about something being wrong. If you're open minded to hear peoples opinions, you can still absoluteely say "that is wrong, I dont agree with that" "I dont agree with how they raise their dogs" or whatever it is.
I don't know. Someone who is truly open minded probably won't respond in that way. They will say something along the lines of ''that does not fit with my indoctrinated views. My views and your views are certainly different, so maybe the truth lies somewhere in between the two. I'll sleep on it tonight and see if anything has changed in the morning''. This is because an open minded person is always open to changing their views if needed, and won't cut off any chance of learning something new by saying ''that is wrong, I don't agree with that''.
Charlotte is beautiful even without makeup. Funny, that she lacks self confidence and believes that buying a bunch of clothes and makeup would improve her when she is just as beautiful wearing a shapeless dress and no makeup.. I hope she sees that eventually. Her inside seems as beautiful inside as outside. The other two girls could learn a few things from watching her.
i mean how can you say that the bible is wrong and the torah is the truth? did god tell you himself? and if you sayyou read the torah, then why have that attitude at all ? did your torah tell you to laugh and comment like to other religion?
I would have rather suggested her to read scientific text rather than this bible...she would have understood more about the world than by reading bible...such a loss
songbird377 I agree with you 100%.At first I thought she was going to be the one who is Miss Lawdy Daw.But she was the one who was very open minded towards the Amish families.She was also very respectful towards the rules put in place by the parents and elders in the community.She is a very lovely girl.
@@staceyjessogreen4629 it seems to be in these comments about open mindedness need be balanced with how Charlotte describes herself. She is a bit insecure and seeking validation; either through her friends, make-up, shopping and clothing. Although you can identify an element of that search for security as being open minded....you will see at the end of the series that although very enthusiastic about the bible its nuance soon wore away......
+Oliver8111 How do you know that? He never "outed" himself or stated he was gay. You are assuming he because he is sensitive and not necessarily conforming to societies stereotyped. Some men are sensitive and some women are not.
NarnianLady So, devices that use electricity are forbidden in that home, right? Anybody notice the very ornate electric lamps (several in dinning room) outdoor floodlighting and all the electrical appliances, and equipment, ie. tools?
Charlotte is such a doll. She is very respectable and kind. Her heart is pure and she goes through life with an open mind. I enjoy watching her take on any task with so much enthusiasm. My heart hurts for James and I am so glad some of these Amish men are taking him under their wing and showing them that love and care that he lacked growing up.
J H I think the problem with Siana is that for all that she pushes feminism, strength, individualism and education, she sadly fails to see these very characteristics in the Amish women. They are not relying on superficial things to express themselves but rather on genuine and honest character... things that actually mean something. The strength these women have is amazing and the support they give to each other is hardly seen in today's world. Its ok to question but one needs to respect at the same time in doing so which she is not. This was a wonderful adventure and learning experience and she very quickly chose to judge and frown upon it rather than to increase her own intellectual quest and take something valuable from it. Why go into this with a closed mind? The entire point of something like this is to be open and learn and to respectfully embrace other's lifestyles and expand your horizons. I feel of all the visitors, she took the least from this experience because of her own narrow mindedness and judgement and that is so sad.
I thought this same thing. She underestimates the strength and commitments these women make. Also I don't know if she is aware that b4 committing to the church they spend time in the 'real world'.
My best friend “amished over” and married an Amish man. It was a good choice because she wanted to be a wife and mother. She eventually divorced as her Amish husband was abusive. I respect her as the strongest woman I know. She chose her path in life. Married Amish, raised her 8 children, lived on a farm, left when the time was right and continues to be an inspiration.
I feel like she did it for content for her radio show and blogs. For someone who is apparently a freedom fighter she really does judge these women and make it seem like domestic work is *beneath her*.. but domestic work is necessary for nurturing and building strong families which make for good communities and so on and so forth. There is honor in domestic work. She should respect these women just as much as she would respect a feminist leader.
Siana actually thinks that if the Amish are just exposed to her way of life, they'll immediately want to run away from their farms. Without even realizing it, she just referred to the Amish as "crazy fundamental people" . Good grief. She's so arrogant and insufferable. No doubt when she grows up, she'll look back and cringe.
Veronica Beck i can see james becoming amish. It seems to me like he got the most out of this journey. from what i gather he had no father figure around and not such a good role model when it came to his mother.
totally agree. She appears so closed minded. In my opinion, if she does not open her mind to other peoples beiiefs and ways of life she will gett absolutly nowhere in her own life.
@@rapturecidal3756 I don't think it is right to say she is evil, but perhaps some of her priorities in life should be rearranged. Everyone is loved by the Lord.
I really like the amish culture !... i wish ti live like them . I am a romanian guy and today i discover that the amish people make lot of things for our poor families from Romania ! I Like them !! AND I CRIED A LITTLE, HONNESTLY !!
+Emanuel Rotaru Si eu am ramas surprinsa cand am auzit pomenit numele Romaniei. Surprinsa si cumva rusinata de faptul ca fix noi cei care traim in Romania nu ne ajutam semenii, dar o face comunitatea amish de pe alt continent...
It’s a shame that the youth of the world are so disconnected from the reality of what work goes into everything they eat. Growing up on a family farm and processing our own poultry and pork and gardening has taught me the value of every meal I have.
6 лет назад+27
I am a Non Religious person from India. Some of what the Amish think about religion doesn't make sense to me but the way the Amish are living and seeing so many people from their community get together and seeing them so happy in turn makes me feel very joyful and it brings me tears.
Charlotte is a doll. I love her openness, enthusiasm, and graciousness towards others. For someone who says her life is about herself, she is very thoughtful towards others.
I like Sienna. Sure, she is no doll, but much more mature than all the others. She knows who she is and stands up for her beliefs. I admire her inner strength.
@@tehta7 that is not kind. She is just as passionate as the amish. It is just not about the same things as them. She has a passion it is just not a direction that is often liked, understood, or accepted. It dose not make her a B**** or any other negative adjective. It makes her a passionate individual who stands for what she believes in.
@@KatherineSinahon I will admit I think her views could be expressed in a better way. However she is young and not the most adept at debating in the most tactful way. The amish woman who said that she is going to hell could be seen as an attack. It could have been said as our belief is that if you dont believe your soul will will be in jeopardy of going to hell. We will pray for you and hope that you will end up with a relationship with God be cause he love you. The way it was said on the show felt less like a sharing of belief and more of a damnation of her. In this case I can see how her debate will be more heated and less respectful. Not that it makes it right to argue but it dose not make either side a B****. Also this could be a debate which is not disrespectful at all it is a challenge of the mind and viewpoint. You and I are not seeing eye to eye but I wouldn't call you anything nasty or mean simply based on us not having the same viewpoint. You also have to remember that it is TV and the production team might have cut and paisted parts to make it seem like more drama filled than it was in live in person. Just please be mindful of calling names it could have a deeper impact than you know or intend.
Blue Malka I know right! I've seen several British reality shows and it's always the same! It seems like their parents have completely checked out from raising them...
We’re not all this bad! Just the spoilt ones xD I had chores at home, I was expected to help parents and grandparents, Ive worked from age 14, I now have a full time job and have since graduating university. Honestly, these shows purposely pick the spoilt and the small minded etc.
It's sad and hypocritical that Siana, in all her want for female strength and individuality, fails to see the strength of the women in these communities and how supportive they are of one another. Instead she is caught up in believing her individuality and expression comes from the superficial things in her life.
One part that has really touched me is the keeping of yourself pure before marriage so that you will have "no regrets". I was a teenager during the 70's sexual revolution and was very promiscuous. I suffered all the ills of illicit sexual relationships- stds, abortion, pregnancy out of wedlock, divorce after a ten year marriage, raising two children as a single parent to name a few! I am 63 yrs old now and even tho I have a relationship with Jesus, there is pain in my heart due to regrets. Regrets dim your ability to feel joy. I would say the amish way of protecting their young people is totally righteous and good. I am glad that God has given American society a witness of a righteous community and lifestyle that brings NO REGRETS. Praise be to Jesus!
Even though I haven't went through that many things as You mentioned I truly understand what You mean by: Regret dims your ability to feel joy. Unfortunately I experienced what does it mean... Even through I'm believer since 2013 I don't feel joy as I felt it before. And this what that Amish woman said is really true. That when we reach a decision that is according to God's will then He gives us peace in our heart. Otherwise we will feel fear if we make a decision that is not God's will...
I fell in love with Charlotte, she was so open minded about absolutely everything. the way she acted was exactly how all of them should had acted. Respected there way of living. Very beautiful girl. Its amazing how these people live (Amish) and I literally live about an hour away from the nearest Amish town. I should try checking it out.
I think as a practicing Christian who was intentionally in a spiritually searching frame of mind, she started off closer to the Amish than the others. She did not have as big of a divide to bridge.
@@trishoconnor2169 It was the dark headed white girl who was the practicing Christian not the blonde (Charlotte). She was just open and ready to listen.
I understand that the two girls have their own beliefs / opinions but sometimes they come off as rude. They should respect the families more because of how kind they are to them.
I was thinking about that too and still agree. The only thing I could think of (in way of reason, not explanation), is that the producers likely told them to voice their opinions and differences whenever possible (to help give context to the viewers). Not that it was set-up or meant to fan flames, I just think they may have encouraged the girls to explain how each thing was different than their own experience. And because of some understandable immaturity, the girls didn't always know how to vocalize that without seeming judgmental or ungrateful.
It was annoying how sienna would take it personally if someone disagreed with her. Not every disagreement is cause for an argument, especially when it comes to religion. Just agree to disagree
Well said. I was guilty of prejudging them, until I started researching them. Are they perfect, no, but who is. The older I get the more I realize the best thing to do is not judge others to begin with. I've been wrong more times than not. I know my response is late, but just started watching this series.
The woman was so kind and patient with Siana who can't seem to express a point of view politely. If this is what she learned at Cambridge, so much for higher education.
I want James to move in with the first family! Their interactions were so deep and pure intentioned. They truly have what each other need to have a great symbiotic relationship.
These people (the amish) have done so much for my family, and soooo many other countless Romanian families, in the time of communism, and nowadays too.
Not sure I understand where you are going with this. What I said, was that the amish helped people in Romania, sending food and clothes etc to those who needed these things during communism.
Charlote seems the most happiest about this she seems nice and does not fight about why Amish women do certain things like the other girls I like her and I hope she does find a good religion
Siana is such a close minded opinionated person and so into herself that its sad to see. From her standpoint, she thinks that she is self confidant and she plows into whatever she steps into with no real regard..These beautiful families are not living in a box, its the other way around..I believe that the Amish and the Mennonite families have more "freedoms" than most of us realize...
Don't we all live in a box? Some receive their brainwashing from religious dogmas, others from advertising/social media, peer pressure etc.. We are all born into a set of beliefs, circumstances, social dynamics and systems of oppression.
It's almost like Siena looks down on the Amish and their way of life! She seems to think she is above it all - she needs to wake up!!! She is very rude to the Amish that she's staying with! Disrespectful young lady!!
She is what is known as a baby in her faith...curious to the big new spiritual world, viewing with a freshness..which is normal...unfortunately trials Will come and we should all pray for her everyday to remain steadfast and encouraged...i got goosebumps when she said shes ready to accept...its beautiful!!!
Yes. I would like to see an update of this program, as well. Sienna seemed to be the only girl that was uncaring, disrespectful and self centered. But the others, I hope they're doing very well.
James has been seriously emotionally & socially crippled by his mother’s incarceration and the social service department in the UK. Sad he’s got a lot to learn about being responsible and integrity and Hard Work. Lots of anger there I think
I used to love working very hard until my muscles ached. When you finally got to bed you rested in a peaceful way. When you slept it was like a rock. Oh, to be young again! I miss it.
Tashie Barlow If you really want to live amish - you can do it. Some modern kind of amish. But the key is to study the bible and turn your face to god. You can get rid of alkohol, tabak, sweets, chips etc, useless luxury. You can do a lot of things for charity. But it is hard in this world. There is a reason, why the amish live beside the community of the modern world. The devil and temptation is out there. Everytime. everywhere. They are hiding in some kind of perspective, but we normal christian people are living face to face with temptation. That does not mean, that we can´t do it if we want to. There is a reason, why we are not born as amish. We have to find our own way.
Tashie Barlow Dear Friend. I gratulate you to your clean life. This is a real archivement in times like these and in a world like these. Maybe I can help you a little. The Amish were very close to the Mennonites, so to the Hutteries. They all are baptist churches more or less in the tradition of Martin Luther. They all focus intensly on the life and the work of Jesus. (Which is MOST important for every christian). It seems like you are right and there are no amish in Australia/New Zealand. But there are Mennonites and some other kinds of baptist churches. Here is one Link to the Mennonites: www.anabaptist.asn.au/ And here another link to other Baptist churches: www.baptist.org.nz/ Maybe, this is not exactly, what you look for but listen. The core of the amish is the faith in God, his Son Jesus and the holy Ghost. There is no miracle, no wonder hiding in the barn. Through their communities they have it a little easier in some kind, but generaly god wants us to change this world to a better place. So we have to take our place in this world. The bible says it in slightly different words but: "See I send you as sheep right among wolfes." Hiding from the wolfes is maybe a way to keep faith. But it is not the only way to do so. You asked for support. I suppose you will find those under the links I send you in this message. All good for you. I hope, that you will get any support of any kind you need.
So annoying that the dating part was cut off... Kinda feels intentional. It was the most interesting part. Can't find the source material anywhere else.
There are many lessons the Amish, Mennonites, and Hutterites can teach us about living in the world, living with each other, and adapting faith to life.
I am so impressed with the Amish men and women. They are sincere and living a wonderful life. This experience for these young people is very valuable as they see a family that is dedicated to each other and God is the head of their household. Sharing their personal relationship with God and living by biblical principles sends a life changing message. They will never be the same
seems that she hasn't really grown up as yet. having everything handed to her and being spoiled like that, she has no idea of what its really like to support herself or anything. I have my doubts for her :(
I'm willing to guess all of you are Christians who feel the presence of God, otherwise I don't know what the problem is. Is she supposed to lie about her feelings? Is she supposed to be comfortable with people telling her she'll go to hell? I mean, respect is important but that was really creepy, and it's not unique to the Amish, it's honestly harmful. I don't blame them for their attitude, they have their beliefs which they can't do a lot about, but if you're an honest person and you don't feel God in any way there's no other way to react to people like that, you just tell them how you feel and you let them tell you God disapproves and you'll go to hell, I've been through many that kind of conversation after I stepped away from Christianity.
@@ReddoFreddo I also stepped away from the faith, and came back. I am curious, what did you find out in The World that you thought was better than following Christ? Telling you that "if you don't do it this way, you'll go to hell" was certainly not the way to lead you back to Christ. However, there was clearly something, or things, that initially led you to question the Christian faith. Maybe some moral that was contrary to Christianity that you thought was better. I'm just curious what that was.
I am totally in love with this people. I heard about them just a few weeks ago and it is unbelievable. Especially the way the women consider their role in the family is breathtaking that I never expected such people exist in the Western world. I wish they would allow me to marry one of their daughters. I am looking for a girl who has been raised with those qualities that Amish women did. Respectfulness , taking care, loving, virginity, and being supportive.Those qualities are necessary for girls to marry in my culture and it’s hard to find such women nowadays cos they have already done everything when they’re teenagers. But if you find a girl who thinks that way, Wow! you will live an amazing life cos everyone is alright once women are there. I hope I will see the Amish once the Covid19 is over. Respect for all women who take care of their kids, husbands, and contribute to the wellbeing of the whole family and communities. Huge respect for the men too!
Amish people are such a wonderful folks. I went to see them on three different occasions in Nappannee, Indiana. Met extended family, they took us in (my friends and I)to their house, fed us and sang for us in the choir. Amazing people.
Charlotte, although her questions about fait, is the one who gas learnt the the most and fitted in well. That girl from Sierra Leone ought to go ho home, visit, and see how bad her country is , and other African nations are doing. Boy , does she need to grow up.
What a wonderful community! I would love to have Amish friends, and to have the opportunity to experience the Amish way of life! What a great documentary!
I still think these are a group of nice kids. Charlotte would likely be welcomed anywhere she goes. Siana is very intense, very hungry for knowledge, etc. I like her spirit very much; she's thoroughly modern and trying to understand this simple lifestyle.
So they're talking about finding faith and Siana has to butt in and draw attention to herself again although they were having a perfectly good discussion about faith.
What an eye-opening experience! Not into the Amish but into how well meaning parents have left their children selfish, clueless, and completely unprepared to live in the real world and support themselves through their own work. What a joke. I really pity them
I love the community way of life . .to go back to simple and beautiful life embracing God and each other. It works for them and my fave is Charlotte..totally love her inquisitive nature and positive outlook.
david sasina Exceptional education about living on a farm, the responsibilities. The teens were very gracious to accept such hard work. I loved the song at the end about the 14 year old. I truly admire Charlotte's search to find a relationship with God to fill that empty place in her heart. Again, God bless.
I'm so happy for Chalotte !!! she is so open minded.. I'm gonna continue and see If she will have a break down like the other two girls. the other girl had her say that women and man are equal, the other just now in the EP says she doesn't have a belief. I think each EP is going to show each British person struggles with the Amish life.
@@averyjones3853 Right? Total drama queen and seems to take nothing away from her experiences. The amish families are being so gracious to all the kids and seem to be so patient and understanding, yet she can't even muster the respect to spend time with the chickens or stop bitching for 5 minutes.
Charlotte is just so pleasant. I am thoroughly against Christianity, but I admire her open-mindedness and positive attitude so much. She almost inspires me. Best of luck to her in everything she does.
+TickleMeElmo55 I know, right? How is one "thoroughly AGAINST Christianity?" Is that an Atheist? A Satanist? Is she saying she is against organized religion or against simply being Christian?? Strange to start with such a narrow minded and negative comment and then to end with something so gracious and kind. I myself am THOROUGHLY against nazi's and people kicking puppies.
+Amanda Harding She's also not consistent in her logic. If she's "thoroughly against" it, Christianity, then she'd also be "thoroughly against" someone practicing/entering Christianity yet she says Charlotte inspires her.
It is just as the Amish women were saying. Charlotte had a true desire for God in her heart. Why would the other girls want to push her away from that? Even the one who was supposedly Christian herself?
they are polite,generous to their guests,hard workers,eat healthier food,warm people,trying to live within their believes,their children polite with kind hearts that what I watched in this vedio.
In the last episode Sienna was complaining about having to do the domestic work in the house, thinking it's beneath her. Now she gets to work outside the house in the family business and she's still complaining. I think she just likes to complain. Nasty woman.
Last episode Siana didnt want to be stuck in the house because she's a feminist... this episode she gets to work outside and she's too good for that too!
Keeping cows is a nightmare and so-oh hard job. This is why I keep bees. Bees smell fantastic, honey is delicious, bees wake up at dawn and stop working after a sunset while a beekeeper is busy to sleep or to relax. Inside the hive they are hanging on each other and sweating with wax. I never use any protection from bees and rarely get stung. Despite sometimes I am all hands inside the hive and pushing bees gently away to see what is with combs or removing combs with honey. My role is to manage them wisely and to rob excess of honey from them. Actually, it is a hobby. I have only 10 beehives. But enough to enjoy it. We keep birds too - chicken, geese, ducks. And we have about 10 hectare of farming land in Thailand. I like Amish people so much but I would not stop using electrical pumps, instruments, lights, as well as tractors, cars and motorcycles. Simple life is great but making life easier is not a sin. I am PhD in physics since 1983, BTW. Enjoyed science, made large number of publications too and do it on my own till now.
Inhuman she said! She believes ripping a viable baby from its mothers protective womb is a humane choice but protecting chickens from predators is inhumane.
In all seriousness that chicken house, for a slightly larger-scale one, was very good. It wasn't nearly as dirty or overcrowded as the mass-production ones. She doesn't know what she's talking about. That whole act was just one more way for her to look down ono how these people live and what they do.
A lot of people are commenting that they don't allow themselves to be on Video or photographed. Not completely true. It depends on if they're running under Old Order or New Order leaders/Bishops. The Bishops are the ones who make the rules. They just use the Ordernung as a guideline as to stay humble and not become infatuated with the sometimes disorderly Englischer world. to keep their families pure-hearted and minded 👏💜 💯 which i think is a beautiful thing. :)
I really like these Amish ppl! I already said it but they look at it like we are all equal. No one is better because what they wear or drive we are all human we are the same at the end of the day
I will pray for you Charlotte! You are a beautiful woman inside and outside. I love how you open yourself for more things than just faith. Like how you see your role in your family back home. I started believing in God when I was about 12, after being brought up agnostic. But I really found my faith when I went to Taizé for the first time. Meeting other young people from all over the world and the simplicity of the daily life and the prayers in the huge church (the services are called prayers, because there is no preaching, just beautiful singing, a Bible reading, a spoken prayer, intercession and a 5 minute very impressive silence), sitting on the ground with thousands of other young people, it really made me feel humple and it made me connect to God in my way. I can really recommend young people to spend a week on that beautiful hill there in France in summer. Doesn't matter if you believe or not or from which church or religion (even Muslims and Jews come, as well as atheists, because it's fun to connect with new people from all over the world and get into discussions in your reflection group and work together). The stay there just costs €56,- for a week for people from 1st world countries, so you just need to pay your travelling costs besides that. There are coach services for every European country, that keep the costs very low. And meeting others already starts on the coach. You can bring your own tent or sleep I a barrack. Price for both is the same. Anyone interested can go to www.taize.fr/en, or go to www.taize.fr and choose your own language for the website. For an impression of Taizé, watch this video: ruclips.net/video/7fg-C2OSsgE/видео.html In all 18 years I've been going to Taizé, I never met someone who regretted coming there. I lived in Taizé for a year, so I met a lot of people there over the years and made lifetime friendships. The best person I met there is my husband😊
Very eye opening and sad in many ways. If we in the "modern" industrialized world think we are providing a culture to protect and nourish our children we are sadly wrong. Childhood and the growing up years should be about simple but worthwhile life practices..., like learning various skills, how to focus and complete projects and tasks, being sincerely appreciative of what they have by being a part of the provision of it and introducing them consistently but gently to the concept of spirituality...the appreciation of mother natures wonders and the idea that there is a spiritual energy that is trusting and exists to guide our moral compass so the World doesn't overwhelm us. All that is near impossible in a superficial world, moving at high speed with developing minds and souls heavily introduced to complex topics, like feminism , politics, adult issues, pornography, sex, rap music anti-social lyrics. We have allowed an environment where 16 and 17 yr olds are set up to be acting and understanding life as a 30 year old..., without even an ounce of natural evolving maturity for the body and soul. The human brain is not completely developed until age 25!
''It's inhumane, really.'' Oh yes.. Keeping them indoors, in the safety of not being picked off by birds of prey and other chick-mass-genociding-predators is cruel.
those chickens are considered free range... you need to find "open pasture" to get chickens that run around outside. Best way to eat chicken is raise it yourself! from chick to table is as quick as 21 days
Charlotte might be spoilt but you can clearly see that she is enjoying the experience. She is working hard and she seems to be such a warm hearted, kind an honest person. I like her
what matters is not where you are coming from, but the direction you are heading
@Jay Reisnek source?
@Jay Reisnek And how do you know this? Link your source please.
@xx yes, Charlotte has seems to bloom with guidance ❤❤
Both of those men saw James was somehow suffering from a lack of a father figure wanted to guide him. They probably realize a strong male role model is very important for a boy. I don't necessarily mean a "dad" but any good man who can help a boy through a rough patch.
Determined Di At this point James dosent even realize how broken he is, how he lives without ever working is sad, work is part of a healthy life
I SINCERELY hope James finds a family...he breaks my heart..
My Grandfather was my strong father figure and means the world to me. He was a hard working Coal Miner who had a family of 6 and I ended up the 7 th.
Thats a fact. And vice versa.
@@daniel_lim_music ok daniel LIM. not all of us can be chinese american..
its funny how no matter what, someone will dislike your way of life and try to convince you that its not enough even though you are happy...
MissKitn C Was this directed at the religious or irreligious?
I had friends who were staying in abusive relationships and if I seen something unjust I would try hard to help like in female genital mutilation.
Indeed. I would rather be the "helpmeet", as they call it. I've been called a liar to my face
they are processing the radical change in culture.
That little secretary is adorable!! I think it's great that they give her real responsibility at such a young age
Siana shows such disrespect to those who have opened their home and life to her. For someone who touts education she shows ignorance of basic etiquette towards her hosts.
No, she doesn't. She disagrees, as do the Amish hosts, without being disagreeable. She has strong opinions, as do the hosts.
Winston Hobson There's a way to disagree with someone without being rude; and yes she's been very rude the whole show.
Hopefully, her experience living with the Amish will give her a new perspective and she’ll have more respect for their lifestyle.
J Mack This is, after all, a reality show, same as Big Brother but with the Amish, and what would a reality show be without some discord. Get real! It’s Siana’s job! You have one girl majoring in music/theater. One girl who is a radio DJ, and one girl who is a professional singer who is trying to find herself and reconcile her religious beliefs along with two guys who admit they don’t want to work and a college student. This is not Britain’s best, this is a group of reality actors. Why are these modern Amish participating? They are witnessing. Why am I watching? Because I am so curious about this peaceful God-fearing family loving culture-the Amish.
She comes across very entitled.
I adore Charlotte. She’s got such a kind heart. She isn’t afraid to explore different beliefs. In fact, she seems to be looking for something spiritual to fill an empty place in her. I hope she succeeds.
I think most people are longing for something from birth to fill a part of themselves. It is either taught to them and they believe it, don't believe it and find something else, don't believe it and keep looking, either find it or keep looking forever until they either destroy themselves or time runs out.
I honestly misjudged Charlotte i thought she would do the worst but she is doing the best
+radar luv yea
+radar luv that sounds awsome
Philip cancel I think Charlotte is the most understanding to other cultures.
@@wellIdiditagain again...... it seems to be in these comments about open mindedness need be balanced with how Charlotte describes herself. She is a bit insecure and seeking validation; either through her friends, make-up, shopping and clothing. Although you can identify an element of that search for security as being open minded....you will see at the end of the series that although very enthusiastic about the bible its nuance soon wore away......
I get the impression she did not know herself at all before the trip. She was more easily shaped to fit in with the families because her identity is not well formed before. Siana seems to know her own values and has worked hard to challenge stereotypes and subvert expectations before the trip, so she was much less fluid in her identity and she couldn't fit in as well.
How is it that it is always the ones who claim to be open minded, are the most closed minded when it comes to beliefs they do not share...?
Yeah, it's funny how the SJW girls likes to speak about politics and open mindedness in the introduction scenes, while Charlotte was speaking about shopping and how her mom did everything for her, and still Charlotte comes of many times more open minded when faced with challenges far from her usual life, while the others struggle a lot to decide what they feel or how they feel about every little aspect of this new environment rather than just suck it in and embrace it for what it is.
Don't expect them to start up space program any time soon.
Only if it fits their narrative
Being open minded doesn't mean you have to accept everything, especially if you feel strongly about something being wrong.
If you're open minded to hear peoples opinions, you can still absoluteely say "that is wrong, I dont agree with that" "I dont agree with how they raise their dogs" or whatever it is.
I don't know. Someone who is truly open minded probably won't respond in that way. They will say something along the lines of ''that does not fit with my indoctrinated views. My views and your views are certainly different, so maybe the truth lies somewhere in between the two. I'll sleep on it tonight and see if anything has changed in the morning''. This is because an open minded person is always open to changing their views if needed, and won't cut off any chance of learning something new by saying ''that is wrong, I don't agree with that''.
Charlotte is the star of this show. An extremely thoughtful, understanding and honest young lady.
@@APerson-sr9pj what
And James....I like most of the others...but Charlotte and James are really being changed by these lovely Amish
@@dotsyjmaher So true. Its awesome how God works. I think they all will take things back with them. There all good young adults.
Charlotte is beautiful even without makeup. Funny, that she lacks self confidence and believes that buying a bunch of clothes and makeup would improve her when she is just as beautiful wearing a shapeless dress and no makeup.. I hope she sees that eventually. Her inside seems as beautiful inside as outside. The other two girls could learn a few things from watching her.
+Leah R. She's still so very young. She's only finding out who she is. She's lucky to have met these people.
+Leah R. I think Charlotte is is really learning alot in this journey but the other 2 girls no learning for them
I know, I just love Charlotte's innocence. Beautiful! Humility and innocence are beautiful mates.
I believe that walls are falling down around the other girls' hearts too. Just not as dramatic as Charlotte's.
yea, she seems to have a good heart.
The hunger and thirst for God in Charlotte is so sweet and pure!!!!!
the god of the bible is fake you fool read the torah
@@amandaclaireon4065 how can you say that?
@@kitzy051590 lol by reading the torah 😂😂😂
i mean how can you say that the bible is wrong and the torah is the truth? did god tell you himself? and if you sayyou read the torah, then why have that attitude at all ? did your torah tell you to laugh and comment like to other religion?
I would have rather suggested her to read scientific text rather than this bible...she would have understood more about the world than by reading bible...such a loss
Charlotte is so sweet and open minded! She's my favorite on the show.
songbird377 I agree with you 100%.At first I thought she was going to be the one who is Miss Lawdy Daw.But she was the one who was very open minded towards the Amish families.She was also very respectful towards the rules put in place by the parents and elders in the community.She is a very lovely girl.
@@staceyjessogreen4629 it seems to be in these comments about open mindedness need be balanced with how Charlotte describes herself. She is a bit insecure and seeking validation; either through her friends, make-up, shopping and clothing. Although you can identify an element of that search for security as being open minded....you will see at the end of the series that although very enthusiastic about the bible its nuance soon wore away......
Why was James so surprised to give up his headphones - he already had stayed with two Amish families before that?!
Exactly!
+NarnianLady
cos he's gay
+Oliver8111 How do you know that? He never "outed" himself or stated he was gay. You are assuming he because he is sensitive and not necessarily conforming to societies stereotyped. Some men are sensitive and some women are not.
It was a joke. Chill the fuck out.
NarnianLady So, devices that use electricity are forbidden in that home, right? Anybody notice the very ornate electric lamps (several in dinning room) outdoor floodlighting and all the electrical appliances, and equipment, ie. tools?
Charlotte is such a doll. She is very respectable and kind. Her heart is pure and she goes through life with an open mind. I enjoy watching her take on any task with so much enthusiasm.
My heart hurts for James and I am so glad some of these Amish men are taking him under their wing and showing them that love and care that he lacked growing up.
J H I think the problem with Siana is that for all that she pushes feminism, strength, individualism and education, she sadly fails to see these very characteristics in the Amish women. They are not relying on superficial things to express themselves but rather on genuine and honest character... things that actually mean something. The strength these women have is amazing and the support they give to each other is hardly seen in today's world. Its ok to question but one needs to respect at the same time in doing so which she is not. This was a wonderful adventure and learning experience and she very quickly chose to judge and frown upon it rather than to increase her own intellectual quest and take something valuable from it.
Why go into this with a closed mind? The entire point of something like this is to be open and learn and to respectfully embrace other's lifestyles and expand your horizons. I feel of all the visitors, she took the least from this experience because of her own narrow mindedness and judgement and that is so sad.
I thought this same thing. She underestimates the strength and commitments these women make. Also I don't know if she is aware that b4 committing to the church they spend time in the 'real world'.
My best friend “amished over” and married an Amish man. It was a good choice because she wanted to be a wife and mother. She eventually divorced as her Amish husband was abusive. I respect her as the strongest woman I know. She chose her path in life. Married Amish, raised her 8 children, lived on a farm, left when the time was right and continues to be an inspiration.
Perfectly said! 👍🙌👏
I feel like she did it for content for her radio show and blogs. For someone who is apparently a freedom fighter she really does judge these women and make it seem like domestic work is *beneath her*.. but domestic work is necessary for nurturing and building strong families which make for good communities and so on and so forth. There is honor in domestic work.
She should respect these women just as much as she would respect a feminist leader.
I agree Siana is not into this. I would love to be able to have had a experience like this 💞
Charlotte learned to stop acting fake and showed others respect and grown from this.
You can do it Charlotte! God is there for you 24/7.
Siana actually thinks that if the Amish are just exposed to her way of life, they'll immediately want to run away from their farms. Without even realizing it, she just referred to the Amish as "crazy fundamental people" . Good grief. She's so arrogant and insufferable. No doubt when she grows up, she'll look back and cringe.
From all of this it sort looks like Charlotte might turn Amish
Veronica Beck i can see james becoming amish. It seems to me like he got the most out of this journey. from what i gather he had no father figure around and not such a good role model when it came to his mother.
totally agree. She appears so closed minded. In my opinion, if she does not open her mind to other peoples beiiefs and ways of life she will gett absolutly nowhere in her own life.
@@rapturecidal3756 I don't think it is right to say she is evil, but perhaps some of her priorities in life should be rearranged. Everyone is loved by the Lord.
Or James my heart breaks for him he seems to be looking for a place to belong because he has been alone for so long
They would welcome her as family.
I really like the amish culture !... i wish ti live like them . I am a romanian guy and today i discover that the amish people make lot of things for our poor families from Romania ! I Like them !! AND I CRIED A LITTLE, HONNESTLY !!
+Emanuel Rotaru God bless! :)
+Emanuel Rotaru Si eu am ramas surprinsa cand am auzit pomenit numele Romaniei. Surprinsa si cumva rusinata de faptul ca fix noi cei care traim in Romania nu ne ajutam semenii, dar o face comunitatea amish de pe alt continent...
@@shutzyjcdr si eu am ramas surprin:) imi amintesc de organizatia Amish de prim 1998 era prim Suceava chair ca ajuta familile sarace.
It’s a shame that the youth of the world are so disconnected from the reality of what work goes into everything they eat. Growing up on a family farm and processing our own poultry and pork and gardening has taught me the value of every meal I have.
I am a Non Religious person from India. Some of what the Amish think about religion doesn't make sense to me but the way the Amish are living and seeing so many people from their community get together and seeing them so happy in turn makes me feel very joyful and it brings me tears.
I wish sienna was a quarter of as accepting as you
Love ya Kartik! Not amish or particularly religious, but we need more community in the world. Hope you're doing well :)
If you read the Bible, you'd understand and it would make sense to you!💙
Charlotte is a doll. I love her openness, enthusiasm, and graciousness towards others. For someone who says her life is about herself, she is very thoughtful towards others.
I like Sienna. Sure, she is no doll, but much more mature than all the others. She knows who she is and stands up for her beliefs. I admire her inner strength.
@@indrahx5905 The loudest shouter isn't always the most mature.
Charlotte. The FATHER has drawn you UNTO him. I pray you have continued in your journey with the Most HIGH!
That girl Siena, she is negative about every single thing!
Ursula. M what did you expect, she’s a vegetarian & a feminist. Ungrateful B....h.
@@tehta7 that is not kind. She is just as passionate as the amish. It is just not about the same things as them. She has a passion it is just not a direction that is often liked, understood, or accepted. It dose not make her a B**** or any other negative adjective. It makes her a passionate individual who stands for what she believes in.
@@tenderapple1671 yeah she's passionate but she's definitely disrespectful :)
@@KatherineSinahon I will admit I think her views could be expressed in a better way. However she is young and not the most adept at debating in the most tactful way. The amish woman who said that she is going to hell could be seen as an attack. It could have been said as our belief is that if you dont believe your soul will will be in jeopardy of going to hell. We will pray for you and hope that you will end up with a relationship with God be cause he love you. The way it was said on the show felt less like a sharing of belief and more of a damnation of her. In this case I can see how her debate will be more heated and less respectful. Not that it makes it right to argue but it dose not make either side a B****. Also this could be a debate which is not disrespectful at all it is a challenge of the mind and viewpoint. You and I are not seeing eye to eye but I wouldn't call you anything nasty or mean simply based on us not having the same viewpoint. You also have to remember that it is TV and the production team might have cut and paisted parts to make it seem like more drama filled than it was in live in person. Just please be mindful of calling names it could have a deeper impact than you know or intend.
She did not have to be sooo rude,at every home..
I guess she was told to be herself...and I saw RUDE
I love how the amish seem to be humble and willing to listen and seem to place more value on relationships than on opinions.
I don't have chores,I have no responsiblities ,I don't have a job..... No wonder the UK is in shambles and crumbling.
Blue Malka I know right! I've seen several British reality shows and it's always the same! It seems like their parents have completely checked out from raising them...
Very sad..
We’re not all this bad! Just the spoilt ones xD
I had chores at home, I was expected to help parents and grandparents, Ive worked from age 14, I now have a full time job and have since graduating university.
Honestly, these shows purposely pick the spoilt and the small minded etc.
MrRaretunes most of the western world in general...
The west is destroying its self by making there youth do nothing so they learn nothing good. The devil finds work for idle hands
It's sad and hypocritical that Siana, in all her want for female strength and individuality, fails to see the strength of the women in these communities and how supportive they are of one another. Instead she is caught up in believing her individuality and expression comes from the superficial things in her life.
Whitney Davenport lazy & kinda stupid
One part that has really touched me is the keeping of yourself pure before marriage so that you will have "no regrets". I was a teenager during the 70's sexual revolution and was very promiscuous. I suffered all the ills of illicit sexual relationships- stds, abortion, pregnancy out of wedlock, divorce after a ten year marriage, raising two children as a single parent to name a few! I am 63 yrs old now and even tho I have a relationship with Jesus, there is pain in my heart due to regrets. Regrets dim your ability to feel joy. I would say the amish way of protecting their young people is totally righteous and good. I am glad that God has given American society a witness of a righteous community and lifestyle that brings NO REGRETS. Praise be to Jesus!
Even though I haven't went through that many things as You mentioned I truly understand what You mean by: Regret dims your ability to feel joy. Unfortunately I experienced what does it mean... Even through I'm believer since 2013 I don't feel joy as I felt it before.
And this what that Amish woman said is really true. That when we reach a decision that is according to God's will then He gives us peace in our heart. Otherwise we will feel fear if we make a decision that is not God's will...
I agree
Amen
I fell in love with Charlotte, she was so open minded about absolutely everything. the way she acted was exactly how all of them should had acted. Respected there way of living. Very beautiful girl. Its amazing how these people live (Amish) and I literally live about an hour away from the nearest Amish town. I should try checking it out.
I think as a practicing Christian who was intentionally in a spiritually searching frame of mind, she started off closer to the Amish than the others. She did not have as big of a divide to bridge.
@@trishoconnor2169 It was the dark headed white girl who was the practicing Christian not the blonde (Charlotte). She was just open and ready to listen.
I understand that the two girls have their own beliefs / opinions but sometimes they come off as rude. They should respect the families more because of how kind they are to them.
I was thinking about that too and still agree. The only thing I could think of (in way of reason, not explanation), is that the producers likely told them to voice their opinions and differences whenever possible (to help give context to the viewers). Not that it was set-up or meant to fan flames, I just think they may have encouraged the girls to explain how each thing was different than their own experience. And because of some understandable immaturity, the girls didn't always know how to vocalize that without seeming judgmental or ungrateful.
I agree, its okay to ask questions but how they ask seems argumentative almost. Probably because they are so young!
It was annoying how sienna would take it personally if someone disagreed with her. Not every disagreement is cause for an argument, especially when it comes to religion. Just agree to disagree
This made me realize how brain washed the modern society is and how stupid we must look in the view of others like the amish.
Well said. I was guilty of prejudging them, until I started researching them. Are they perfect, no, but who is. The older I get the more I realize the best thing to do is not judge others to begin with. I've been wrong more times than not. I know my response is late, but just started watching this series.
I agree Frank Logrim. If I were younger I would like to live with the Amish.
Dianna Marie wtf, you wouldn‘t
Frank Logrim very true. It’s humbling
@@sarahd4784 maybe she would. It becomes normal eventually
The woman was so kind and patient with Siana who can't seem to express a point of view politely. If this is what she learned at Cambridge, so much for higher education.
I want James to move in with the first family! Their interactions were so deep and pure intentioned. They truly have what each other need to have a great symbiotic relationship.
Moi aussi.
The first familiy, wow, both are ANGELS.
The music was awesome. It gave me chills... Watching Charlotte's journey is so special.
These people (the amish) have done so much for my family, and soooo many other countless Romanian families, in the time of communism, and nowadays too.
Trisha Popa In the name of Communism?... wtf
In the time of communism.
Trisha Popa
No i dont see any slavery of free people in the Amish...
Not sure I understand where you are going with this. What I said, was that the amish helped people in Romania, sending food and clothes etc to those who needed these things during communism.
Trisha Popa
Ok.. sorry i tought you were praising communism here. I didnt read it correctly. :)
Charlotte is ,lovely - I hope she is doing something good with her life.
I like Charlotte. I hope, that she will find a way to Jesus to fill her emptyness. The struggle is worth it!
Dieter Gerding I like Charlotte too she has a great attitude
Dieter Gerding I
Amen...
And so the other English youth too.
@@CrankyGrandma look
Charlote seems the most happiest about this she seems nice and does not fight about why Amish women do certain things like the other girls I like her and I hope she does find a good religion
Feel the same. And when i see that video i be so thankfull to live with my Lord Jesus.
Siana is such a close minded opinionated person and so into herself that its sad to see. From her standpoint, she thinks that she is self confidant and she plows into whatever she steps into with no real regard..These beautiful families are not living in a box, its the other way around..I believe that the Amish and the Mennonite families have more "freedoms" than most of us realize...
Don't we all live in a box? Some receive their brainwashing from religious dogmas, others from advertising/social media, peer pressure etc.. We are all born into a set of beliefs, circumstances, social dynamics and systems of oppression.
@@AnimaLibera:: Ok so what are we supposed to do , According to you ??...
When the little boy said “I can imagine” when talking to George 😢 so touching the way they raise their kids with so much compassion.
Charlotte is my favorite! May God bless her and may God help her find him.
It's almost like Siena looks down on the Amish and their way of life! She seems to think she is above it all - she needs to wake up!!! She is very rude to the Amish that she's staying with! Disrespectful young lady!!
Exactly like her saying she’s from Sierra Leone and instead of that humbling her to their simpler way of life it’s just a meaningless badge she wears
I really felt for the dairy farmer. It was surprising to hear even the Amish get touched by the plague that is drugs.
Her interest didn't come from no where. When God calls you, you start wanting to know. It's not an interest, it's a calling.
Natasha Defoe Exactly! God is calling her! And that is so exciting!
Amen.
Natasha Defoe Amen! Hallelujah!
Ditto... I love watching Charlottes hunger to fill a void she doesn’t understand- I’m loving this programme - I’d love to sample this life style.
She is what is known as a baby in her faith...curious to the big new spiritual world, viewing with a freshness..which is normal...unfortunately trials Will come and we should all pray for her everyday to remain steadfast and encouraged...i got goosebumps when she said shes ready to accept...its beautiful!!!
I wonder how Charlotte is doing now. I like her a lot!
Yes. I would like to see an update of this program, as well. Sienna seemed to be the only girl that was uncaring, disrespectful and self centered. But the others, I hope they're doing very well.
James is yearning for more stability and family orientation in his life it looks like he's going to break down from the lack of a loving family
Charlotte is the star of this show she's so humble and understanding
Beautiful homes built by Amish tradition. Well done.
James has been seriously emotionally & socially crippled by his mother’s incarceration and the social service department in the UK. Sad he’s got a lot to learn about being responsible and integrity and Hard Work. Lots of anger there I think
I used to love working very hard until my muscles ached. When you finally got to bed you rested in a peaceful way. When you slept it was like a rock. Oh, to be young again! I miss it.
Before all the arthritis seeps in!
I am so happy for Charlotte.I hope she finds God. She is doing amazing asking great questions and searching for something to full fill her life.
I would love to live amish! They're awesome!
Tashie Barlow If you really want to live amish - you can do it. Some modern kind of amish. But the key is to study the bible and turn your face to god. You can get rid of alkohol, tabak, sweets, chips etc, useless luxury. You can do a lot of things for charity. But it is hard in this world. There is a reason, why the amish live beside the community of the modern world. The devil and temptation is out there. Everytime. everywhere. They are hiding in some kind of perspective, but we normal christian people are living face to face with temptation. That does not mean, that we can´t do it if we want to. There is a reason, why we are not born as amish. We have to find our own way.
I live a pretty clean life, unfortunately there isn't any amish communities here in New Zealand for the support etc
Tashie Barlow Dear Friend. I gratulate you to your clean life. This is a real archivement in times like these and in a world like these. Maybe I can help you a little. The Amish were very close to the Mennonites, so to the Hutteries. They all are baptist churches more or less in the tradition of Martin Luther. They all focus intensly on the life and the work of Jesus. (Which is MOST important for every christian). It seems like you are right and there are no amish in Australia/New Zealand. But there are Mennonites and some other kinds of baptist churches. Here is one Link to the Mennonites: www.anabaptist.asn.au/
And here another link to other Baptist churches: www.baptist.org.nz/
Maybe, this is not exactly, what you look for but listen. The core of the amish is the faith in God, his Son Jesus and the holy Ghost. There is no miracle, no wonder hiding in the barn. Through their communities they have it a little easier in some kind, but generaly god wants us to change this world to a better place. So we have to take our place in this world. The bible says it in slightly different words but: "See I send you as sheep right among wolfes."
Hiding from the wolfes is maybe a way to keep faith. But it is not the only way to do so.
You asked for support. I suppose you will find those under the links I send you in this message. All good for you. I hope, that you will get any support of any kind you need.
lol you might have to wear more clothes though
Amish food is terrific also. Shoo Fly Pie 🥧 .....so good!
So annoying that the dating part was cut off... Kinda feels intentional. It was the most interesting part. Can't find the source material anywhere else.
Stain I think that this is because it is considered a private thing. Not so much that they were hiding anything :)
There are many lessons the Amish, Mennonites, and Hutterites can teach us about living in the world, living with each other, and adapting faith to life.
I am so impressed with the Amish men and women. They are sincere and living a wonderful life. This experience for these young people is very valuable as they see a family that is dedicated to each other and God is the head of their household. Sharing their personal relationship with God and living by biblical principles sends a life changing message. They will never be the same
Siena needed to realize these people have graciously opened their homes to her. Show some respect. Learn to filter what comes out of her mouth.
seems that she hasn't really grown up as yet. having everything handed to her and being spoiled like that, she has no idea of what its really like to support herself or anything. I have my doubts for her :(
she is a total mental case
I'm willing to guess all of you are Christians who feel the presence of God, otherwise I don't know what the problem is. Is she supposed to lie about her feelings? Is she supposed to be comfortable with people telling her she'll go to hell? I mean, respect is important but that was really creepy, and it's not unique to the Amish, it's honestly harmful. I don't blame them for their attitude, they have their beliefs which they can't do a lot about, but if you're an honest person and you don't feel God in any way there's no other way to react to people like that, you just tell them how you feel and you let them tell you God disapproves and you'll go to hell, I've been through many that kind of conversation after I stepped away from Christianity.
Alright she was pretty aggrevating on the chickens granted..
@@ReddoFreddo I also stepped away from the faith, and came back. I am curious, what did you find out in The World that you thought was better than following Christ?
Telling you that "if you don't do it this way, you'll go to hell" was certainly not the way to lead you back to Christ. However, there was clearly something, or things, that initially led you to question the Christian faith. Maybe some moral that was contrary to Christianity that you thought was better. I'm just curious what that was.
I am totally in love with this people. I heard about them just a few weeks ago and it is unbelievable. Especially the way the women consider their role in the family is breathtaking that I never expected such people exist in the Western world. I wish they would allow me to marry one of their daughters. I am looking for a girl who has been raised with those qualities that Amish women did. Respectfulness , taking care, loving, virginity, and being supportive.Those qualities are necessary for girls to marry in my culture and it’s hard to find such women nowadays cos they have already done everything when they’re teenagers. But if you find a girl who thinks that way, Wow! you will live an amazing life cos everyone is alright once women are there. I hope I will see the Amish once the Covid19 is over. Respect for all women who take care of their kids, husbands, and contribute to the wellbeing of the whole family and communities. Huge respect for the men too!
Amish people are such a wonderful folks. I went to see them on three different occasions in Nappannee, Indiana. Met extended family, they took us in (my friends and I)to their house, fed us and sang for us in the choir. Amazing people.
I wish to live a kind of life like the amish ..i always wanted to be close to the Lord, live my life for Him. Do my duties as a woman of God.
Charlotte, although her questions about fait, is the one who gas learnt the the most and fitted in well. That girl from Sierra Leone ought to go ho home, visit, and see how bad her country is , and other African nations are doing. Boy , does she need to grow up.
What a wonderful community! I would love to have Amish friends, and to have the opportunity to experience the Amish way of life! What a great documentary!
I still think these are a group of nice kids. Charlotte would likely be welcomed anywhere she goes. Siana is very intense, very hungry for knowledge, etc. I like her spirit very much; she's thoroughly modern and trying to understand this simple lifestyle.
You’re siana aren’t you
Siana has a mocking, rude spirit and is the least interested in gaining knowledge here.
Charlotte is a lovely young lady. I wish her great happiness on her spiritual journey.
as for siana...shes super rude
Thank goodness this man recognizes what a lost soul James is. Hopefully someone takes him under their wing! 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
That was cute this is your GPS your way to heaven 😊
the patience is beautiful..
So they're talking about finding faith and Siana has to butt in and draw attention to herself again although they were having a perfectly good discussion about faith.
Anna Dannyels she has that mean angry face. Yuk
She was just getting jealous because praise was being given to Charlotte and she feels like she deserves all the praise.
What an eye-opening experience! Not into the Amish but into how well meaning parents have left their children selfish, clueless, and completely unprepared to live in the real world and support themselves through their own work. What a joke. I really pity them
at 21 it completely skipped a scene
hi sir thank you for posting this video I am going to convert to the Amish life style
I love the community way of life . .to go back to simple and beautiful life embracing God and each other. It works for them and my fave is Charlotte..totally love her inquisitive nature and positive outlook.
david sasina Exceptional education about living on a farm, the responsibilities. The teens were very gracious to accept such hard work. I loved the song at the end about the 14 year old. I truly admire Charlotte's search to find a relationship with God to fill that empty place in her heart. Again, God bless.
AMEN these children would have never gave it a thought had they not come to this place! and experienced this truth of GODS words!!
david sasina Amen, brother.
I love when the Amish sing, very beautiful..Respect and kind regards from Denmark.
I really like the kind loving nature of the Amish ppl
I'm so happy for Chalotte !!! she is so open minded.. I'm gonna continue and see If she will have a break down like the other two girls. the other girl had her say that women and man are equal, the other just now in the EP says she doesn't have a belief. I think each EP is going to show each British person struggles with the Amish life.
The black girl is quite insufferable. Curious to see if see manages to get out of her arrogant bubble before the end of this series
Siena was very frustrating!
Oh no she's at it again😖👎🏿👎🏿
older lady needs to tell Siena get a life and go back to the spoiled life she came from! total Bee-otch! ruins the open-minded on this show...
@@josefukuichi7189 - Jose, I agree with you. It's ironic. People like Sierra are the least open-minded and the quickest to judge.
@@averyjones3853 Right? Total drama queen and seems to take nothing away from her experiences. The amish families are being so gracious to all the kids and seem to be so patient and understanding, yet she can't even muster the respect to spend time with the chickens or stop bitching for 5 minutes.
Charlotte is just so pleasant. I am thoroughly against Christianity, but I admire her open-mindedness and positive attitude so much. She almost inspires me. Best of luck to her in everything she does.
>>I am thoroughly against Christianity
That's some statement.
+TickleMeElmo55 I know, right? How is one "thoroughly AGAINST Christianity?" Is that an Atheist? A Satanist? Is she saying she is against organized religion or against simply being Christian?? Strange to start with such a narrow minded and negative comment and then to end with something so gracious and kind. I myself am THOROUGHLY against nazi's and people kicking puppies.
+Amanda Harding She's also not consistent in her logic. If she's "thoroughly against" it, Christianity, then she'd also be "thoroughly against" someone practicing/entering Christianity yet she says Charlotte inspires her.
+Malka Strauss I know, right?
Can I just ask what you're so thoroughly against when it comes to Christianity?
It is just as the Amish women were saying. Charlotte had a true desire for God in her heart. Why would the other girls want to push her away from that? Even the one who was supposedly Christian herself?
Satan is busy influencing people in different thoughts who are not doing or thinking of God's will.
The song they sang "How great Thou Art" is a NZ song. That's interesting.
they are polite,generous to their guests,hard workers,eat healthier food,warm people,trying to live within their believes,their children polite with kind hearts that what I watched in this vedio.
I have a humble background.... I go to school at Cambridge.... so lovely
In the last episode Sienna was complaining about having to do the domestic work in the house, thinking it's beneath her. Now she gets to work outside the house in the family business and she's still complaining.
I think she just likes to complain. Nasty woman.
none of them were thrilled
Shes an entitled complainer, probably a quota entrant for university too.
It’s those nasty chimply genes
It’s those nasty chimply genes
OOOOOOOOOOOOOO CHARLOTTE! WHOOO PRAISE GOD!! I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHERE SHE IS NOW THO
Last episode Siana didnt want to be stuck in the house because she's a feminist... this episode she gets to work outside and she's too good for that too!
"more than one person can be right......" the best lesson learned!!!!!!!
Keeping cows is a nightmare and so-oh hard job. This is why I keep bees. Bees smell fantastic, honey is delicious, bees wake up at dawn and stop working after a sunset while a beekeeper is busy to sleep or to relax. Inside the hive they are hanging on each other and sweating with wax. I never use any protection from bees and rarely get stung. Despite sometimes I am all hands inside the hive and pushing bees gently away to see what is with combs or removing combs with honey. My role is to manage them wisely and to rob excess of honey from them. Actually, it is a hobby. I have only 10 beehives. But enough to enjoy it. We keep birds too - chicken, geese, ducks. And we have about 10 hectare of farming land in Thailand. I like Amish people so much but I would not stop using electrical pumps, instruments, lights, as well as tractors, cars and motorcycles. Simple life is great but making life easier is not a sin. I am PhD in physics since 1983, BTW. Enjoyed science, made large number of publications too and do it on my own till now.
how amazing. its crazy how different all our lives are. 😁😚
I am on 3 of 6 and I so badly want to go live with these people! Id come today!!
Awesome YODELER beautiful
+Vicki Acquah / this is the best way to live / close to the earth with discipline.
THe lady has been so gracious even if Siana is disrespectful. Oh my, who taught her manners?
No complaints about the host dismissing James' family as "broken"? Is all of your criticism directed only at Siana for questioning things?
Inhuman she said! She believes ripping a viable baby from its mothers protective womb is a humane choice but protecting chickens from predators is inhumane.
In all seriousness that chicken house, for a slightly larger-scale one, was very good. It wasn't nearly as dirty or overcrowded as the mass-production ones. She doesn't know what she's talking about. That whole act was just one more way for her to look down ono how these people live and what they do.
A lot of people are commenting that they don't allow themselves to be on Video or photographed. Not completely true. It depends on if they're running under Old Order or New Order leaders/Bishops. The Bishops are the ones who make the rules. They just use the Ordernung as a guideline as to stay humble and not become infatuated with the sometimes disorderly Englischer world. to keep their families pure-hearted and minded 👏💜 💯 which i think is a beautiful thing. :)
I really like these Amish ppl! I already said it but they look at it like we are all equal. No one is better because what they wear or drive we are all human we are the same at the end of the day
Amish are epitome of good character.
I will pray for you Charlotte! You are a beautiful woman inside and outside. I love how you open yourself for more things than just faith. Like how you see your role in your family back home.
I started believing in God when I was about 12, after being brought up agnostic. But I really found my faith when I went to Taizé for the first time.
Meeting other young people from all over the world and the simplicity of the daily life and the prayers in the huge church (the services are called prayers, because there is no preaching, just beautiful singing, a Bible reading, a spoken prayer, intercession and a 5 minute very impressive silence), sitting on the ground with thousands of other young people, it really made me feel humple and it made me connect to God in my way.
I can really recommend young people to spend a week on that beautiful hill there in France in summer. Doesn't matter if you believe or not or from which church or religion (even Muslims and Jews come, as well as atheists, because it's fun to connect with new people from all over the world and get into discussions in your reflection group and work together).
The stay there just costs €56,- for a week for people from 1st world countries, so you just need to pay your travelling costs besides that. There are coach services for every European country, that keep the costs very low. And meeting others already starts on the coach. You can bring your own tent or sleep I a barrack. Price for both is the same.
Anyone interested can go to www.taize.fr/en, or go to www.taize.fr and choose your own language for the website. For an impression of Taizé, watch this video: ruclips.net/video/7fg-C2OSsgE/видео.html
In all 18 years I've been going to Taizé, I never met someone who regretted coming there. I lived in Taizé for a year, so I met a lot of people there over the years and made lifetime friendships. The best person I met there is my husband😊
Wow the Amish are extremely hard working,humble,and have strong faith and I admire them for that!
Very eye opening and sad in many ways. If we in the "modern" industrialized world think we are providing a culture to protect and nourish our children we are sadly wrong. Childhood and the growing up years should be about simple but worthwhile life practices..., like learning various skills, how to focus and complete projects and tasks, being sincerely appreciative of what they have by being a part of the provision of it and introducing them consistently but gently to the concept of spirituality...the appreciation of mother natures wonders and the idea that there is a spiritual energy that is trusting and exists to guide our moral compass so the World doesn't overwhelm us. All that is near impossible in a superficial world, moving at high speed with developing minds and souls heavily introduced to complex topics, like feminism , politics, adult issues, pornography, sex, rap music anti-social lyrics. We have allowed an environment where 16 and 17 yr olds are set up to be acting and understanding life as a 30 year old..., without even an ounce of natural evolving maturity for the body and soul. The human brain is not completely developed until age 25!
Wow were these kids lucky to get the opportunity to do this. These people are so interesting and infectiously positive.
''It's inhumane, really.''
Oh yes.. Keeping them indoors, in the safety of not being picked off by birds of prey and other chick-mass-genociding-predators is cruel.
Zaaambieez if you eat eggs or chicken, all chicken, even 'Free Range' are kept indoors. May want to research why. Remember the bird virus?
That barely made any sense.. Are you saying that chicken farms could sometimes develop an epidemic with their poultry?
I think she may have thought you were being serious instead of sarcastic.
those chickens are considered free range... you need to find "open pasture" to get chickens that run around outside. Best way to eat chicken is raise it yourself! from chick to table is as quick as 21 days
It is inhumane because they're going to be murdered