Mennonites, an ultra-conservative Christian community
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2023
- Similar to the Amish, the Mennonites, an ultra-conservative Christian community, vehemently reject the trappings of modern society, choosing instead to embrace a life frozen in the 19th century. The majority of Mennonites reside in self-sufficient colonies, deliberately isolating themselves to shield against the temptations of the contemporary world. Now, breaking from their tradition of seclusion, one such community has granted access to our cameras.
Upon entering the colony of Little Belize in South America, it becomes evident that time has come to a standstill. Residents traverse the area in horse-drawn carriages, conversing in Plattdeutsch, an ancient German dialect. However, even within this seemingly untouched enclave, external influences are making inroads. Wilhelm, the former community doctor, faced expulsion for possessing a mobile phone, reflecting concerns about the encroachment of the outside world. Fearing contamination, traditional members like Abram and his family embark on establishing a new, even more secluded colony in the jungles of Peru, striving to uphold their original doctrines.
We accompany them on their exodus, providing an unprecedented glimpse into the enigmatic world of the Mennonites as they navigate the delicate balance between preserving their traditions and confronting the inevitable influences of the changing times. 
Развлечения
My grandparents lived next to a Mennonite family. They were the sweetest people. We played with the kids when we visited. They loved basketball! They really help my grandparents with a lot of things. When grandpa passed they took care of grandma until she moved up north with us. Rare to have neighbors like that today.
Normal White people behavior
E le bambine?erano trattate alla pari dei maschi?
as a german i hardly understood a single word
Das wundert mich nicht, die sprechen noch das Deutsch aus dem Jahrhundert, in dem sie aus Deutschland geflohen sind. Sprache entwickelt sich schnell weiter!
@@rosapanther8466 Ich bin mir nichtmal sicher, ob das Deutsch ist.. Viele Mennoniten kamen auch aus Friesland, also den Niederlanden
Ja, den Gesichtern ( Franz zum Beispiel) sieht man den holländischen Einschlag voll an. Es ist sicher ein aus der Zeit gesprochenes Platt, gemischt mit entsprechendem Deutsch und Niederländisch.
@@waschte123 ich rede die selbe sprache, das ist platdeutsch was sie sprechen. Platdeutsche Menschen gibt es heut zu tag noch groszartig viel. Platdeutsch ist eigentlich meine Muttersprache. Hochdeutsch hab ich in die Schule gelernt in Chihuahua Mexico
Sie sprechen ein Dialekt vom mennonitischen Plattdeutsch, das sogennante Plautdietsch
The guy at 13.00 who says that the bible says that the only way to get into heaven is to reject modern things like TVs, Cars, the telephone and computer, made me laugh out loud. I didn’t know those things existed over 3000 years ago… 😂😂😂 brilliant
I have nothing against a conservative lifestyle but when you claim that's the way into heaven.. not true. A born again believer who follows Jesus is the only way into heaven 🙏
@@Diana-ue9tt go on waiting and praying for the rapture!
Also, what exactly is to be considered modern? They also could go back and live like humans lived 40.000 years ago, even without tools. Tools are modern things! :D
@@anonymer_anonymer haha this! Exactly.
😂 They're sectarians
Really enjoyed this but very conscious of the irony of the group moving to a remote location to stay away from modern civilisation and have a simpler life while taking 3 planes and being followed by a film crew 😂. They all seem so genuinely content, it’s beautiful to see
So long as they aren’t the ones operated, it’s allowed. It’s like the Amish.
😅
Jak by se jinak dostali na své vysněné místo? To měli jít pěšky jako Mojžíš z Egypta? A že dovolili aby je někdo filmoval to je jejich blahovůle - kdyby to nedovolili, neviděli bychom nic. A nejsou všichni spokojeni, špatně umíte číst obličeje......
I have the most respect for these people. I met a few in Kentucky around the bowling green area. It's difficult sometimes living in a world filled with temptation. Great episode thanks for sharing.
Agreed. And i'm a Oneness Apostolic Pentecostal.
@@LarzGustafsson now Pentecostal r taking over heir in Australia n its very sad how they brainwash the young n the old, my elderly neighbour gives 2/3rds of her pension every 2 weeks to heir Pentecostal n she basically has to which leaves her next to nothing to live of for the fornight, i think its disgusting.
This is child abuse
@@insynthesiswithinfiniteis2318 tHiS Is cHiLd AbUsE!!
@insynthesiswithinfiniteis2318 you leftist say about tolerance, shy don't tolernate this? in your logic every culture is bad
This is a great episode. I hope you do a follow up in time. I hope those going to seek out a new home are successful.
I'd be concerned about living so far from a hospital or medical care, especially when pregnant and having babies and kids. They can get sick and go downhill quickly without quick medical help.
That's the main thing that would concern me. I hope they at least know the basics of health care, and brought medicines with them.
They don't have many of the ailments that plague city people.
Average life expectancy in Amish communities is the same as the average American.
@@JaStvarnothe average Amish community isn't 4 hours away from the nearest civilization. These people have to rely on electric motors to even reach contact with a functioning civilization.
They don’t care if one or two are lost. When you have 14 others..
Abraham's optimism is so inspiring ❤
Thankyou so much for educating us all about this way of life and traditions, thankyou to the people and families who have opened there lives to help us understand your way of living ❤thank you
I am from Wisconsin. We have Amish communities here. They remind me of these Mennonites in a way. The Amish people here are great.
Very nice people and hard working. They have their ways and beliefs and I respect that.
في بداية الفيلم استغربتهم جدا لكن في النهاية احترمتهم وتعاطفت معهم
Yes all abhramic religion people should follow the lifestyle like them
Love this!!! Bob n Pups in Oregon
I see no slums, no starving children. Explain this to me, because there's something Im missing because 500km apart, you get different cities, bad looking and decaying.
Its a small community. They are poor but self sufficient. Its easier to have order in community like this, there is no specialisation and everyone can produce their own goods (so no starving children)
On the other hand you have only basic stuff.
So the choice is yours
Abuse is rampant because there is a huge lack of law enforcement around and there is no accountability or punishment for abusers
@@Thinminteaterwhere did you get this from?
Except women can't use birth control or abortions
@@Thinminteater US law enforcement (police) are the ones who abuse you
Го́споди помоги и благослови этих добрых людей.
I was raised in exactly the same way in a Mennonite family and I can assure you folks that it is not as sad as you think 🧐 😊and you can see it on their faces too they’re happy and full of joy 😊
We as kids had a lot of fun playing and working. Our whole families were very happy.
These people do complain a little bit but that’s just because you’re asking them. Once you’re gone they’ll be busy working away joyfully.
Can you tell us more about your story? 😊 did you leave this community? Did you get to study about more things?
I love to strip off my jewelry and makeup and dress in long dresses with sleeves when visiting to show utmost respect. These communities are very welcoming and the people are kind and loving. Respect is given and shown❤
You liked living in this community. But now you don't? Why? And have you been able to go to a public school? 🧐
You are using the internet. But the traditional mennonites don't? So if you like it so much living in the traditional community, why are you using the internet?
It's a cult.
Hab ja absolut nichts dagegen wenn Menschen sich aus freien stücken zu so einem Leben entscheiden, mir tun nur immer die Kinder leid, die zu diesem Leben gezwungen werden.
An extremely interesting documentary, I'd love to see an update.
Yes me too
Someone in the comments said that they got sued in Peru because of deforestation 😬
One Peru colony (not the one detailed in this video) are also being sued for impeding on indigenous land. The main guy from this video is also being sued for "Misuse of Agricultural Land". I knew he was an idiot when he picked up soil from a road and was like "Yup, this is perfect for crops"
I would love to see a follow up in a year to see how they are doing. As much as I couldn’t live like that, it was very interesting to watch … thank you.
I was curious too. Thanks to the internet you can at least learn what is going on with that community by searching for "Mennonites Peru Amazon".
They basically got sued in Peru because of deforestation😅
@@esmailalbertoghassemishuak1355 lol where u get ur infor its hard to find stuff about these people
@@esmailalbertoghassemishuak1355 Really?
@@esmailalbertoghassemishuak1355 Really? Are they still living there now?
This is a great episode. I hope you do a follow up in time.
Trochę obłudna społeczność,żadnej techniki i samochodu,ale traktor posiadają.
машини, це затратно, тим більше ремонт та інше
The Mennonites unfortunately are causing quite some damage in the Amazon by removing primary forest for their farmland. And there are many questions as to whether they were sold protected land that should never have been sold. The reality of what is going on there is not as rosy or simple as this film makes it look like. Which really is not what I wanted to learn.
This is in America?
@@germanshepherd6638 - Yes. Peru, South America.
Și vrei să spui că ei ar fi de vină pentru dezastrele din amazon? Bravo!!! Ai gasit problema!
@@allesandrogiovani8986 - No, but thank you for thinking so highly of me. ;)
Mind your own business city slicker
id like to see more of this family
Amazing hardworking people, so optimistic and kind❤ deep in my heart I wish to live life like they do
I have to give this man props, completely new experiences and having to process it all in 3 languages! For someone with so few years of schooling, this alone is so impressive. But to be such a strong and excited figure for his family of young children and his nervous wife is good to see. There’s a lot that can be discussed about this video, but I’m purely impressed by his ability to handle culture shock and lead his family through it with such grace and happiness (and again, in three languages!)
It may be worth mentioning that unlike the amish, relatively few mennonites still live this way. Most oft them are just as more or less open minded as other christians.
The mennonites I knew were allowed to drive cars and have modern utilities in their homes. I rode with a lady when I was a teen that had electricity in her home and drove me in her car there. They dressed similar to Amish but weren’t as strict with their home lives as they are. The Amish people in USA sound similar to the mennonites on this program. Does anyone know why the description is not referred to as Amish? The only reason I can think is it’s another country they live in so they are referred to differently depending on area of world they live in.
To nisu Amiši
They are Old Colony Mennonites.
The appear to be Old Order Mennonites. They are so similar to Amish I don’t know the differences between the two.
Die Amish und Mennoniten haben gemeinsame Wurzeln in der Täuferbewegung, unterscheiden sich jedoch erheblich in Bezug auf Lebensstil, Technologie, Kleidung, Gemeinschaftsstruktur und religiöse Praktiken. Während die Amish für ihre strikt traditionelle und technikferne Lebensweise bekannt sind, sind die Mennoniten vielfältiger und oft offener für moderne Einflüsse.
They sure do pick and choose what is “modern”. Also I would like to know how they found out about, and buy land in Peru without using technology 😜
👍👍👍🎯❗
yeah a lot of religious requirements are just determined to be "good enough". Like how in islam, followers should be only eating animals killed in a specific halal way but a lot of muslims don't bother with that since it's hard to find depending on where you live. The rule was made when mass animal farming didn't exist so you can rationalise it as doing the best you can. Probably the same with these mennonites
Outsiders simply cannot understand that these people have a completely different attitude to life and death. They are not afraid of death. If you really believe in an afterlife, how can you be afraid of death?... Conversely, if you are afraid of death, maybe you just don't believe in the afterlife?
Having 7 to 12 children for each married woman sounds horrible to me.
czyli masz szczęście że się urodziłeś... twoi rodzice mogli by pomyśleć że nie warto i że to jest okropne... brawo ty!
This is really kind of amazing. We have a mennonite community here in my german hometown too - but their life is far from anything comparable. Compared to the community in the video their life seems modern, almost average. To be honest, I have my problems with the idea of western people settling in the Amazon. Because this is the ancient way of colonization and the destruction of the Rain Forest is one of the greatest threats to native peoples and human kind as a whole, since this is the green lung of the world and so important with regards to climate aspects.
Absolutely right, that's what I thought too
It's true that white people have a penchant for homesteading, i.e. colonizing. But it's not the small communities of people like Mennonites that are devastating rainforests. It's mega corporations and corrupt governments.
Бог дасть кисень, Бог дасть житя, Бог дасть мир
Their companies do more destruction to their ancestral land than 300 Mennonites.
You really have problem when 30ish people settle down and live without any modern technology while you live surrounded all that technology produced by big companies that make million times more harm to the Earth than these guys will in a million years? If everyone were living like these guys the Earth will be a green paradise.
I think the people of Nedersachsen, Schleswig-Holstein, Hamburg and other northern German regions would disagree that Plattdüütsch is only spoken by these Mennonites.
Honestly though, I almost envy these people. They work hard and live simple lives, they're surrounded by their kin and they are kind. I bet they live happier lives than a lot of people in the modern world.
Wow get community May God bless them ....from Germany
قالها عالم مسلم يوما ما : لا يمكننا رفض الحضارة حتى ولو رغبنا في ذالك ولكن يمكننا تحطيم الأساطير التي تحيط بها
what myths surround civilization?
@@KoNitzThe7th أساطير مثل 1- انها مرادفة للسعادة حتما 2- انها تجعل الناس راقيين اخلاقيا ونبلاء لمجرد ان أدواتهم متطورة 3- انها خاصية إنسانية في كل جوانبها - الكثير من الحيوانات والطيور وهبها الخالق اجهزة تفوق ما توصل اليه البشر حتى الان 4-انها مثالية وبلا عيوب - لا يوجد تطور في جانب ما الا وهو على حساب جوانب إنسانية أخرى اكثر جوهرية ربما
@@selah920 truth
Evil 😡
I wonder if anybody can share how they deal with Autism or other special needs. I'm a teacher and it was odd to see a class that large where there didn't seem to be any special needs- are there fewer cases or are they just not in school?
I think I heard that they don't have much autism. Suggesting that it may come from a more modernized environment. A test showed autism is 8 times more prevalent in Americans than in Amish communities. That said, Mennonites are supposed to be more modernized than the Amish.
They don't eat processed foods and seed oils, which contribute significantly to behavioral problems, special needs, and autism.
Кстати, да, интересный вопрос 🤔 если есть дети с инвалидностью, то где они? Если они у них не рождаются, то это вообще очень интересно. Ведь они по сути все близкие более или менее родственники друг другу....
@@jackmiddleton2080 Of course they exist but you don't get them to see. They want to present the paradise: everybody is loving each other, everybody is happy and everything is good. Ill children likely get bred with violence to act normal without any respect for their needs. The number of mentally affected people of a society is heavily influenced by the openness to such problems. To think that autism doesn't exist there is like watching Nord Korean TV and thinking everybody is happy there.
@@runderdfrech3560 While that may be true, this study accounted for that. If I had to guess, Autism rates are being effected by something in the environment.
Нравится ли вам это? - Ну, мы больше ничего не знаем. Мы должны.
Они даже не смогли объяснить, зачем так надо делать. Ну, потому что так жили предки и поэтому они тоже должны, треш
@@user-fe8fk6xx8e а Богу это не надо. их наряды образца150-летней давности, их причёски прилизанные одинаковые, и их кривые гнилые зубы. если они думают, что этим служат и угождают Богу, и таким образом например проявляют смирение - они ошибаются.
😢😢😢😢😢забитые люди ,рабы какие то ,а заболеют ,что нет больниц ,лекарств где они рожают ,ужас и только
@@user-xm4ls9qi4s у них есть врач вне селения, отделён от общины вроде бы за наличие телефона. или за какой-то подобный ужасающий "грех". а рожают они дома, что там рожать - пуповину перерезала, перевязала, ничего сложного - делов-то ;-), процесс естественный, особенно если это 12-ый ребёнок. уже на автомате - раз-два, пошла дальше.
У меня один простой вопрос к тем ультраконсерватианым людям - как и чем они чистят зубы, или не чистят??!!
At about 13 minutes that’s not what the Bible states. That would be strictly their church doctrine.
There are a lot of versions of Bibles and each one is so convenient for the one who prints them and makes sure that these words do not deviate anywhere.
@@FtrollThat’s why everyone should look into Islam, there’s only one version, that hasn’t been altered since it was revealed by The Creator of the Universe (1400+ years ago).
He protects it for us so I invite everyone to accept Islam, Allah ydhina❤️❤️❤️❤️
Біблія й про це каже, гріхи спокуси жінки, в перекладі на сучасність це телефони це алеоголь це цигарки
@@heysoysalva5657але іслам був зформульований не богом а пророком
@@heysoysalva5657 Likewise, there are several currents of Islam, each one interprets the scriptures the way they want and each one shouts that his opinion is the most correct. Both of them manipulate the words of others for their own benefit. Nuno doesn’t believe in old texts, but develops his own thinking in his head.
I hope they do updated videos of the progress
An very interesting way of life i couldn't do it though
"They refuse all kinds of technology"... but who exactly determines what is modern and what is not? They use sunglasses, tools, industrially made clothing, washing machines, and dishwashers. Even the horse carriages they use were once modern innovations. I think it's very hypocritical that they pick and choose what's convenient for them.
1000% agree
When you know where tech comes from....
Because it's a cult.
Și nu este greșit să alegi tehnologia care nu te afectează din punct de vedere mental și spiritual.
Which is a complete lie as my grandparents were Mennonites.
Courageous, hard working and industrious people - the Mennonites! My late husband and I were befriended by a kind, generous and welcoming Mennonite family in Lewisburg, Pennsylvania, USA in 2014. 💜🙏🏻💜🙏🏻💜
А какому Богу они поклоняются??И что это за Бог,который держит народ,как рабов???Иисус,когда был на Земле,на сводьбе был,разговаривал с людьми других народов,и даже их лечил...кто придумал ,,эту жесть,,????
Дай Бог всего хорошего ❤, этим замечательным людям!!!
Сектанты не могут быть хорошими людьми. Мне жаль из детей, это варварство.
А вот мне интересно, как ты поняла, что они прекрасные? По часовому видеоролику? Была ли ты сама лично там? Знаешь что происходит внутри, за камерой?
Bunlar çılgın
Hz isa as bunlardan razı değil
@@pyromaniac1986 Люди которые вкалывают физическим трудом с утра до заката, в массе своей лучше тех кто бухает или шыряется и мозги выносит и работать не хочет, а жизнь в дебрях амазонки или в тайге она просто одинаково тяжелая, будешь баклуши бить будешь голодным
그들의 삶이옳다고 봅니다. 세상에 찌들어살다보면 나도 모르게 악한생각이 정상이라 생각될때가 많아요.
티비나 영화에서 보복이나 나도 모르게 남을 욕할때도 많고.. 행복한 그들에게 하나님은혜가 많길 바랍니다.
Погляньна них, їм не треба лікарня, в їхніх серцях немає гріха, лікара вигнали, він надіявся на лікарів але не на Бога, це дає нам розуміння того, що це ідеальні християни ❤
그렇습니다 그들은 더러움을 덜보고 덜 들으며 ,덜행합니다. 하나님은 보는거,듣는것을 조심하라 하십니다.@@netkamax50
다 저런 사람만 있으면 인류는 발전이 없죠 스마트폰 유튜브도 없어서 이런 영상도 못봄
we need a "5 years later"-episode ❤
Man, I need more than that. I want a five year series. I want to know how they handle real world problems. Disease sex pregnancy and death firstly. I can't imagine women giving birth and then there are complications. I want to know how they handle those that want more in life. It doesn't matter how far away you live, you know that there is another world out there. These thoughts may be suppressed or hidden but the desire will still burn in some.
Now a couple years later, how are the Mennonites doing in Peru? Can we get an update? Please!
Wie im mittelalter schlimm nicht viel bildung ,leider ..wissen ist macht ...nichts wissen macht klein
21:00 I’m curious how Abe heard about Peru and the soil/markets…
Maybe some info broker wormed his way into Abe's community as a mole and told him what he needed to know to move out.
I'm from PA. There were many in my area. I have high esteem and respect in how they love. They have a lot to show man kind
man, ikr.. tbh im smiling like 30-40 min watching it and also shed a happy tear a few times 😂😂 silly me
i'm in pa too, they're very respectful. I was on an amtrak the other day and a baby was crying in the seat across from me. A little mennonite boy (probably 6 years old) walked over from the front of the train and gave the baby his little toy owl. He did it with so much care, it made my day.
Foarte frumos Dumnezeu să vă binecuvânteze
This is fantastic
So much respect for these people.
I worked at the museum and they come in quite a few times. They have cell phones and credit cards.
Thanks for this .....can see they are integrating well in Uganda East Africa...
Always wondered a lot about the religion and their way of lifr
Great! I whish them all best. Long live to such a way of life!
I think it's sad. This is not a life. To many exciting things to do and see in the world. I also don't think this can be maintained indefinitely. Eventually this kind of lifestyle will dissappear.
What you mean by life? Watch youtube 8 hour a day, alcoholic, drug abuse, empty sad night life at the street? 😂
This people life like a true human.
@@kingconstantinusthesadisti133 You sure are judgemental, and presume everything about everyone else. A common element of extreme right wingers.
I agree
Però che tristezza che a tavola a cena non parlavano....avevano tutti la faccia triste veramente ,specialmente i giovani e le femmine....non c'è cosa più bella che parlare a tavola con la famiglia!!da quale parte della bibbia hanno preso questa regola?!la bibbia la conosco bene e non vi è questa regola....ho visto occhi tristi e un pranzo triste e non credo che Dio voglia questo.....😮
I would have a lot of questions:
How do you oppose modernity but use plastic and steel doorhandles?
How do you move to Peru without using the Internet to look it up?
Where was the german part in die first one minute? I didn't hear nothing 😂
Can we get an update on these families? This video wasn’t uploaded too long ago but it takes a while plan out a longish term trip with them especially if they are still in the amazon. Personally if they moved to the amazon jungle i think their dead.
I looked it up and they were accused of deforestation without permits by the local authorities. They might lose their land.
I feel bad for these people. What horrible indoctrination, but I would however like to live life simply. I wouldn’t mind living in a cottage in the middle of a forest with nothing but the bare minimum. ❤
but you cant
@Onewokewoman well they don't have skyrocketing rates of drug abuse, homelessness, suicide, mental illness, broken families, loneliness, and rage unlike the woke liberal nightmare that the rest of us are trapped in.
Of course you can
And? Why don't you go for it 🙄🙄🙄?
They do indonctrination too these days through media, what's the difference?
Какие "счастливые" лица у женщин 😂
Их счастье не твоё,подзаборное!
This seems like it was recorded a while ago. I hope they're still doing okay.
There are at least 3 copies of this documentary on yt. Why?
I think thats beautiful
"No foreign languages" - The bible is in German. And they speak English, too.
I am surprised to see all the good comments
I really appreciate to see it still available this life style.
A lotte of time it would be so so esyer to just live like them, work, nature, cumunity, happiness simple life
Thank you
I wish these people well....best wishes from scotland
i dated a german Mennonite girl, she skated, listened to music etc, completely normal girl, with a few hangups and daddy issues, a new generation, she did volunteer work and was very kind.
I think the Mennonites are more normal than the average American or European. (Romans 12:2)
The documentary is about a group of the Old Order Group
Now let’s get to the real real….. was it bomb bomb ???
you are so lucky
I think you are amazing !
The man was using technology in his engine shop. I thought they didn't use technology
Меня удивило количество пластика и потребностях в вещах "современных". Всю посуду можно изготовить из дерева, если такого нет - из глины. Матрасы из соломы или пуха/перьев. Самостоятельно делать ткани из крапивы, льна, хлопка и тд. Лекарства из трав и тд, а не таблетки из аптеки. Хоть они и живут по старым принципам, но как будто бы не правильно
как вы описали мало кто может жить, есть такие общины и в РФ и в Европе, но в основном все уже чем то современным да пользуются. Разве что какие то еще дикие племена на островах остались или где то в глубинах африканского континента
@@Tho_ra Зато такие как вы,в мракобесии преуспели!
This is so breathtaking, a way simplier life. Love it!
Yeah ... but still ... "iron rules" are just HELL ...
Они болеют. Это не сюрприз. Близкородственное скрещивание не идет на пользу здоровью, ни ментальному, ни физическому. Жаль, что в Библии это не описано подробно, как и множество других природных феноменов, которые сопровождают жизнь человеческого общества.
Біблія це не книга біології, це книга-дороговказ для життя
No they are rightly following Bible ,this all things is restricted in abhramic faith's
@@kmt55 It's not about incest in families, it's about the fact that they create marriages for centuries in the same group of people
@@MrYuricoach Mylisz się , to działa, działało i będzie działać
It actually does. Read it.
Die Untertitel in deutsch sind zum Teil mega witzig falsch übersetzt 😂
Forest... We don't need more people to deforest already eaten up jungle... 😢
The simplicity of the Mennonites' life amazes me! I would gladly live in a community with them.
Da uomo è semplice
I have respect for these people and their culture and way of life. They look very nice, calm, non-violent, modest. I wish all the best to them.
😢😢😢😢😢😢 мороженое редкость это говорит обо всем это несчастные дети не имеющие детства . Игрушки редкость ,мороженое недоступно .
Молится ,постится охереть ,значит не жить совсем
Главное работать как проклятые
Это очень страшное сообщество.
зато твои дети счастливы..на порносайтах и попивая пивасик!
главное что они заточены на жизнь в иллюзии
Это не сообщество, это секта. Не зря в царской России и в Советской стране секты были под запретом. И сектантов наказывали очень строго. Большевики говорили "Религия, опиум для народа" и были правы. Забитые, бесправные люди.
You don't need to be spoiled to be happy. One can have absolutely nothing and can still be happy.
Это одновременно пугает и завораживает... Я думаю, дело здесь не только в их религии. Есть многие, которые уезжают из городов и отказываются от многих благ, хотя не являются религиозными людьми. Мне кажется, это говорит о чём - то.
Never have I seen such happy and healthy AND well mannered children as the menonites I have met
😢😢😢а где вы увидели счастливых ? Забитые и несчастные
@@user-xm4ls9qi4s твоя счастье под забором..у них другое!
To each their own, everyone should be able to live the way they want
But what I don’t approve of is anyone being compelled to live this way way once they are old enough to make a decision, being shunned by their families for choosing a different life, etc
Who says we are doing right and they are not . If every people lives in their life style life will be good in this world.
какая то секта,жить по каким то канонам, кто их придумал,и кто решает как я хочу жить,жизнь одна
Тебе ли судить о секте,дитя сатаны!
Almost similar to the Amish🎉it is interesting enough to see how these people still enjoy real life🎉and real nature and are very content with all of that.🎉 I love it.😊 although i would miss the music😂
I think about when it was when my family first arrived in Amazon in the beggining of the last century.
My x husbond grew up in a cult like this ,not Christian but hindu cult,where women are not allowed to work and go out after 22 o clock i have never witness such madness in my life😂
if you call that madness, you have never witnessed madness at all.. 🤷🏻♂️
Too hard to listen... Isn't any law in united states to respect the right to education? Isn't any rights for these children? So sad. So scary.
In US maybe but they never lived there 😂 there is whole other world and US is just small part of that , but for sure you know that, because you have good education, right? They lived in Belize - Central America
First, they're not in the US. Secondly, they need to be judged by their standards, not ours.
Education of what? actually...? Is that whole think, called academic knowledge useful for anything worthy? If I can speak 4 languages, what can I really say? Sometimes nothing, and sometimes there is nobody, who wants to listen to me. Everyone is busy. That is our modern happy world looks like. No friends, no healthy food, no big families, no love...
They're being educated. Just not in the way YOU want.
@@cellospot If they have to be judged by their standards than judge North Korea by its standards too! Like universal values don't exist.
Hope good ol franz doesn't find out about dylan mulvaney
i wish there was an update
What are the main differences with the Amish? Someone knows some good stuff about it?
Most of the Amish don’t have hydro and don’t drive vehicles, and the men have beards. Most Mennonites have hydro, drive vehicles and taught against having beards. That pretty much sums it up.
The clothes and the doctrine are different.
I m from Lancaster it is a lot of amuses)
There are alot of Mennonites in the states of Chihuahua and Durango Mexico. Been there for year's. The Mennonites are some hard working people. They own alot of land and big factories they are really rich.
Also they make some good cheese! 🧀
I met those people once in Chihuahua with my boys.
Their cheese is so gooood. We always bring back menonite cheese from Durango to the US.
Remind me a novel written by Jean Christopher Grange
YOU CAN'T USE THE PHONE, BUT YOU CAN USE THE GRINDER!? THE SECT!
i really dont understand. god gave free will to do literally anything, and yet, they are arrogant enough to enact "gods will and wishes" on others? live your life how you please, but do not tell others how to behave. God will make the final judgement on your life, not your fellow man.
Бедные дети без будущего. Кстати, Анна Герман была из меннонитов. Но в СССР их все же наставили на путь истинный - образование и просвещение, а не вот это вот всё.
В России по всей видимости будут жить узбеки, таджики и чеченцы.
Христиан будет мало.
I visited an Amish community in Pennsylvania in 2018. I think though people of Amish try to keep away from the modern society, but with the modern society growing up, they will keep their tradition life style maybe more and more difficult.
What's the difference between Mennonites and the Amish??
I think it would be better for all of us to live this way. Greetings good people!
I'd prefer to live as they do.
Its boring. And false. The bible doesnt say You have to life like that.
Worst. They decline the word of Jesus that woman are equal in heaven and should be treated by men as He treated the Community. By giving them free choice and will.
@@nocomment6421 I think in your arrogance you think that if women aren't CEOs and whores then they must not have free will.
@@nocomment6421 Bro there are thousands of different sects and the teachings you practice now is only one of thousands.
Przepiękne są twarze tych małych dziewczynek! Pełne spokoju, zaciekawienia, niewinności. Jakże inne twarze otaczają mnie na codzień!
Wydaje mi się, że są szczęśliwsi od nas.
How is this even legal?
I feel so bad for those children. Not allowed an education because of fear of knowing anything.
Pretty much North Korean terrorist and rebels,
Why do you feel bad? They are probably happier and smarter than most other kids since they don't have access to garbage tiktok.
Knowing God is all that matters! What could be of more importance than eternity?!
@@gamer8300 Best comment on here! I agree!
@@gamer8300on god, as a 24 year old I only wish I got that instead of freedom on the internet at age 8
The Holy Bible does NOT say that to be accepted into heaven, we are not allowed to have any contact with modern things. Jesus Christ is the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the father except through him (John 14:6)
Also für mich nicht mal denkbar, so zu leben. Aber wenn sie so glücklich sind, was soll man dagegen einwenden. Was ist mit Menschen, die da ausbrechen? Werden sie dann auch verleugnet wie in anderen Sekten oder verletzt, bekämpft?