"Neck" Comparison Study - HBCU Marching Bands

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 781

  • @michaeligbinoba2894
    @michaeligbinoba2894 5 лет назад +57

    Bethune plays in a whole different key, and does it well. That's an automatic win to me😁🔥

    • @uanonymous1090
      @uanonymous1090 4 года назад +1

      I am a huge Alabama fan but no one does it like LSU's band. They slayyyyyyy "Neck"! ruclips.net/video/mJFJHcH3dTQ/видео.html

    • @THEMIGHTYPANTHERS97
      @THEMIGHTYPANTHERS97 3 года назад +2

      @@uanonymous1090 they’re alright with neck

    • @uanonymous1090
      @uanonymous1090 3 года назад

      @@THEMIGHTYPANTHERS97 They dont do it like LSU and I am a Alabama fan. LSU's Trumpets and Tubas are more technically sound and precise. BCUs usually just blast their notes and are loud. There is a huge difference in the quality of sound between the two. Just because you are loud doesn't make you good. Bethune cant compare to LSU's band period!

    • @gardnerbc
      @gardnerbc 3 года назад +6

      the video doesn't do justice for Bethune... and trust me I LOVE my show bands.. but Bethune just does magic with Neck.. to hear them live, in-person... it's beyond words.

    • @MrKingpin1205
      @MrKingpin1205 3 года назад +5

      @@uanonymous1090 I know a few bands that play Neck better than LSU

  • @TheBiscuitKing96
    @TheBiscuitKing96 10 лет назад +57

    The cymbals for Florida A&M were going ham

  • @regiseleby97
    @regiseleby97 11 лет назад +10

    Bethune-Cookman Univ, best played.
    FAMU, best hyped while playing.
    JSU, best power.
    WHOEVER that was at the end credits, BEST ALL AROUND!!!!!

  • @CVernonC
    @CVernonC 12 лет назад +23

    Talking out the side of your neck, is a trademark for all HBCU bands. I marched at Livingstone College in the early 1990's and it's amazing how everyone comments on how these bigger bands can rock this song, but dont sleep on them smaller bands. They will wax you right off your own field. We were known as "The little band with the big band sound."

    • @bubz3t136
      @bubz3t136 Год назад

      What does the song title mean anyway?

  • @IamUrDreamgyrl
    @IamUrDreamgyrl 3 года назад +18

    I love how each school has added their own regional touches. It is a classic regardless of version, but I will always prefer the GoGo infused versions of the DMV.

    • @JeffCorryMusic
      @JeffCorryMusic 2 года назад

      Yeah especially the version Howard does since they’re from DC, the birthplace of Go-go.

  • @tkman122
    @tkman122 12 лет назад +16

    SU and JSU are definitely known for blastin nearly all songs they play

  • @odesseyhaynes7015
    @odesseyhaynes7015 11 лет назад +17

    FAMU won me over with that cymbal line! I wish I could have seen this when I was playing cymbals in high school!

  • @shammgodfaejikarimbahir8801
    @shammgodfaejikarimbahir8801 8 лет назад +17

    famu represented properly as always.... but I love all my hbcu's different renditions & flavors.. peace & love yall.

  • @KANKhaos1911
    @KANKhaos1911 12 лет назад +11

    SCSU has the most original and by the far the best rendition of Neck... in my opinion!

  • @finisher3x
    @finisher3x 10 лет назад +42

    Watching all of these bands play a high speed version of "Neck", makes me appreciate the super slow, almost "Chopped and Screwed" version of "Neck" that the Aristocrat of Bands ( Tennessee State ) play.

  • @FlawfulandBrown
    @FlawfulandBrown 12 лет назад +10

    -Norfolk State's version is the best ! The way they played it wanted you to get up & party & enjoy it with them...

  • @deacongaines6558
    @deacongaines6558 4 года назад +27

    TNSTATE AOB has the most unique/incomparable/original "Neck" versions, idk how we missed the lineup!

    • @deacongaines6558
      @deacongaines6558 2 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/hGdOSJ-7h_s/видео.html

    • @atoyshabassene6273
      @atoyshabassene6273 8 месяцев назад

      Exactly. I prefer what TSU plays. Marched only 95 and 96 so but I am biased LOL

  • @darrenmorrow9539
    @darrenmorrow9539 10 лет назад +44

    SCSU got the cleanest bass line of this song hands down. But the best version of the song is the one being played while rolling the credits.... IJS

    • @sxyalpha1906
      @sxyalpha1906 4 года назад +1

      Agree completely and I'm an SU Jaguar Alum. When I listed to SC State (my home state btw), I was like, wow. But whoever's is doing it in the credits takes the cake.

    • @MrJkinnebrew1
      @MrJkinnebrew1 4 года назад +1

      Lol yo y'all both lying to yourselves. TSU(TENN ST.) Started this chant back in the 80's when cameos song talking out the side of ya neck first came out and has been a staple in EVERY HBCU band that is around now. Check it out for yourselves. Just type in Tenn St Neck and listen to the superiority of the sounds... If FAMU band members can give them they praise and props then everyone gotta follow suit. I'm a Tenn St fan for life...but the FAMU band is just better, but not when it comes to this song.

    • @isaiahbangura4421
      @isaiahbangura4421 3 года назад

      @@sxyalpha1906 It's from Drumline Live

    • @shedrickhorton5628
      @shedrickhorton5628 3 года назад

      As usual Texas Southern has tge best version but Overall they all have good pieces except the last band. NSU What da hell kind of train wreck was that I expect better. Remember more is not necessarily better! GQ chapter 🤟🏾

    • @shedrickhorton5628
      @shedrickhorton5628 3 года назад

      they were doing to much it takes from the original version

  • @amandalee1716
    @amandalee1716 9 лет назад +6

    I'm in marching band and I love when we play this song! We all just start jamming out and dancing, it's just such a fun time!

  • @dontravisallen7011
    @dontravisallen7011 10 лет назад +22

    BCU & FAMU in one division then u got JSU & SU in the other... but that's my opinion :-)

  • @trellcorleone
    @trellcorleone 10 лет назад +21

    Jackson clearly sounds the best but didn't have the better arrangement! SCSU and BCU HAD THE BWST ARRANGEMENTS!

  • @KingNateCMB
    @KingNateCMB 11 лет назад +17

    TSU's version is dope. but on this ASU, FAMU, BCU

  • @Supaman1911
    @Supaman1911 10 лет назад +7

    I normally do not have a comment on band videos, but I had to throw in my two cents. Tennessee State University's Aristocrat of Bands version is by far the most original arrangement of "Neck" and should have been on the list. I just heard the same sped-up version of a Cameo classic. Slow it down so we can hear you!!!! #BIGBLUERISING
    TSU Aristocrat of Bands playing Neck - 2013 Gateway Classic

  • @blkplaya9891
    @blkplaya9891 12 лет назад +9

    SCSU, BCU & NSU, these 3 Meac bands have the best and most distinctive versions of NECK in my opinion.

  • @BrandoBossProduKKtions
    @BrandoBossProduKKtions 9 лет назад +44

    Whoever that is playing during the credits shoulda been in this video. 😂😂😂💯💯💯

    • @handyec
      @handyec 7 лет назад +6

      That was "Drumline Live" in the credits. Not a college band.

    • @zacharymckinnon6832
      @zacharymckinnon6832 4 года назад

      Logan Hal Leonard used the audio from Drumline live

  • @jordanhaleymcwilliams6920
    @jordanhaleymcwilliams6920 11 лет назад +21

    JSU, SU, and ASU

  • @MzcexciBadgurl
    @MzcexciBadgurl 10 лет назад +18

    BCU Hands down

  • @JaDaBeautiful7
    @JaDaBeautiful7 5 лет назад +5

    This was really good!!!! Lol 😂 the excerpt from the credits clearly was the best one!!! But for the sake of the film I’m gonna say I enjoyed SU and JSU then BCU🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾 SU comes in sooo solid, JSU just a powerhouse, and BCU got sooo much class!!!

  • @chuckbug05
    @chuckbug05 12 лет назад +3

    They are all pretty good. To me the winner goes to BCU. The Tubas made the difference for sure.

  • @esh8973
    @esh8973 7 лет назад +3

    Real talk while at Norfolk State, I thought we was the only ones that actually played it

  • @brittbrattism
    @brittbrattism 12 лет назад +6

    SCSU's Neck is the best so far!!! The chords and the tubas are AMAZING!!!!

  • @Savesme2
    @Savesme2 11 лет назад +3

    We are musically talented, instrumentally creative and have sound of no other. Thats why we are on top of the Marching Band World. There are no holes in our music and we play together. Our band does not try to blast you out of the stadium. We are consistent on the field, on the stage and in the class room!!! Take notes and when we are on the field during halftime thats class time for you. Bethune-Cookman Marching Wildcats!!!

  • @BMEZY
    @BMEZY 12 лет назад +3

    when it comes down to arrangement, perfect ratio between balance, precision/accuracy, and power (from top to bottom..you have to have a solid tuba line) then I have to give it to BCU

  • @teamdraco
    @teamdraco 11 лет назад +8

    SCSU Marching 101 on point as always!!! Kept it funky!!!

  • @thetraylors3609
    @thetraylors3609 10 лет назад +10

    how could you not have ga
    ambling in this when neck is damn near the school song

  • @Hismusicianship
    @Hismusicianship 12 лет назад +3

    Although I am a Marching 101 Alumni,From a musical professional's view point, I have to take my hat off to BCU. Although SU has the power behind theirs, BCU is just that balance between arrangement, power, and cleanliness. You may now bring on the negative comments.

  • @milesstone3264
    @milesstone3264 9 лет назад +15

    Grambling's Neck sounds a bit better.

  • @MsIGotDatWork
    @MsIGotDatWork 11 лет назад +6

    JSU rocked that thang out. I give it to BC for having a different version and it jammed

  • @JUST2SUAVE
    @JUST2SUAVE 8 лет назад +8

    Southern University got the best Neck Arrangement in the world

  • @unclebrother6244
    @unclebrother6244 Год назад +2

    Shout out to one of the greatest funk bands of all time, Cameo, for creating this legendary tune!

  • @trequawngreen1373
    @trequawngreen1373 10 лет назад +10

    I like southern's and the one at the end

  • @terrancecannon7048
    @terrancecannon7048 11 лет назад +9

    I played in TSU's Ocean of Soul in the 80's and will challenge anybody to find an early version of Neck than the halftime show TSU vs JSU 1984 when the song first came out. TSU is still playing the original version we played and has played it every year since. Count it 29 years and going. Also 1984 Ocean was the first to play Tribute to Bob Marley. Not bragging just the facts.

    • @afkripper747
      @afkripper747 2 года назад +1

      i march for the ocean now! can confirm we play neck the same way 👍🏾

    • @msramona247
      @msramona247 Год назад

      Oh yes Big Brother T! We’ll challenge ANYBODY who’s says different. TXSU arranged and played Neck FIRST when Cameo first put it out in 1984. #Ocean🌊 #NeverDuplicated

  • @djuancoleon
    @djuancoleon 10 лет назад +12

    Alabama A&M plays it the best period

    • @JasonT1875
      @JasonT1875 9 лет назад

      Correct ✌ that Tuba breakdown is something !

  • @lenardkeeling8869
    @lenardkeeling8869 12 лет назад +3

    UAPB has a nice rendition of this as well, nice vid thumbs up

  • @PricelessAmbitionTV
    @PricelessAmbitionTV 9 лет назад +20

    Who's playing the credits ? Cause that's the best of all

    • @TheQuincyT118
      @TheQuincyT118 7 лет назад

      Nene J Vlogs that's a jwpepper arrangement

    • @handyec
      @handyec 7 лет назад +3

      That was "Drumline Live" in the credits. Not a college band.

    • @ILLmfnMILL
      @ILLmfnMILL 6 лет назад

      Stra8 UP!!!!

  • @cherokeegotti4903
    @cherokeegotti4903 7 лет назад +4

    SU all day. Hands down. Even though famu has a very similar composition of the song. But the sheer size of famu gives them a powerful sound. But su is smaller and packs a bigger punch

  • @cedricmorrow7519
    @cedricmorrow7519 9 лет назад +12

    Like Bethune Cookman version the best

  • @Ajtori93
    @Ajtori93 10 лет назад +8

    JSU sounds the best,then maybe TxSu or SU!The band at the end turned it into a gospel praise song,lol.I thought them lil boys caught the ghost,lol!

  • @chiefprimate
    @chiefprimate 12 лет назад +2

    I played Tuba @ Morgan and I was not feeling Bethune but FAM was nuts with it the cymbal line SHEESH!!!

  • @drhall3
    @drhall3 12 лет назад +2

    Never heard UAPB, but I love the way Tennessee State plays it. We play UAPB for homecoming this year so I'll have to check them out. All of the bands sound good though.

  • @blackmiami3286
    @blackmiami3286 6 лет назад

    This a nice video.. I wish we had this arrangement out.. back in the early 90's..

  • @Nit2winit4me
    @Nit2winit4me 9 лет назад +14

    I'm sorry ya'll but FAMU's Marching 100 in my opinion took it to a whole new level, when they started singing in harmony! ...and that funky bass line remix! Yes Suh!!!

    • @olankidd1324
      @olankidd1324 9 лет назад +2

      Marching 100 ALL Day!

    • @iyounh954
      @iyounh954 9 лет назад +3

      im sorry calvin, this guy letson puts lsu name in the hat and they're not involved in the comparison nor FSU im just agitating him because i don't like lsu, but them Southern University boyz tops the neck comparison playa !!

    • @Nit2winit4me
      @Nit2winit4me 9 лет назад

      No sir! 100 all day everyday!!

    • @cherokeegotti4903
      @cherokeegotti4903 7 лет назад

      iyounh954 all day without fail

  • @sugabeariadt
    @sugabeariadt 2 года назад +1

    Cookman hands down got this one on lock. That swing it way better. The tubas crank hard too. Got forget the band singing in 3 part harmony as well. Another level. Shout to all the HBCUs though.

  • @carlaboatwright9168
    @carlaboatwright9168 11 лет назад +2

    Bama State...good tempo---would be flawless with SCSU's tuba part...parts have nice features...love the call and answer part with the trumpets...NICE!

  • @ssanto_s7363
    @ssanto_s7363 10 лет назад +7

    SCSU has the best version of Neck

    • @MrMelloCountry
      @MrMelloCountry 7 лет назад

      RaSantos I'd say the most original version. Their's is definitely unique.

  • @Redonus83
    @Redonus83 9 лет назад +23

    Sorry nothing beats the original "Human Jukebox" Sssssss U

    • @reggieb5324
      @reggieb5324 4 года назад +1

      I refused to go there because the Sousas played WAY too many high notes 😭

    • @Redonus83
      @Redonus83 4 года назад

      @@reggieb5324 yeah them some lung burners 😂😂

    • @reggieb5324
      @reggieb5324 4 года назад +1

      #NoFilter I wonder if I’ll be eligible after I get out.. I mean I’m only 22 lol

    • @Redonus83
      @Redonus83 4 года назад

      @@reggieb5324 lol should be

  • @Deltravar1
    @Deltravar1 12 лет назад +4

    NORFOLK STATE has the best hands down. The other bands were good too... just my opinion.

  • @mikepostley8645
    @mikepostley8645 7 лет назад +1

    the boom edges out su in this video.
    but I must admit uapb is the best I've ever heard play it.
    Love the boom!

  • @rdot980
    @rdot980 10 лет назад +21

    Who were those 3 kids in Southern's band that looked like they were in time out. lol.

  • @funkfixx
    @funkfixx 9 лет назад

    As most people here choose sides on whose band is better, I see this video as getting into the spirit of football. Being in the stands watching the game and listening to the band belt out their music. To hear NECK is to be at a game, love it!!!

  • @BMAN94
    @BMAN94  12 лет назад +1

    I placed it in the credits, but if you didn't catch it the last arrangement of "Neck" is played by Drumline Live arranged by Raymond James Rolle II

  • @NKLnDime
    @NKLnDime 12 лет назад +3

    I like Bethune and Famu versions best. The one during credits tops them all.

  • @teezyfitness6530
    @teezyfitness6530 11 лет назад +3

    Come On Now; We ALL Know Who Got The BEST Neck! SU Human Jukebox! But I Liked SCSU! They Murdered It! Love The Arrangements.

  • @jasminenicoleculliver2122
    @jasminenicoleculliver2122 10 лет назад +13

    I liked South Carolina State.

  • @ChillKenny
    @ChillKenny 8 лет назад +9

    It's between SCSU OR BCU

  • @dark12ain
    @dark12ain 11 лет назад +27

    Were is UAPB now they clearly have the best neck point blank period

  • @kharywright
    @kharywright 11 лет назад +3

    1. south carolina state
    2. jackson state
    3. bethune cookman
    4. norfolk state
    5. florida a&m
    6. texas southern
    7. southern university

  • @BCCHSMD
    @BCCHSMD 11 лет назад +5

    1.JSU
    2.BCU
    3.SU
    4.TXSU
    5.Famu
    6.SCSU
    7.NSU
    8.ASU

  • @troydariusrogers6543
    @troydariusrogers6543 11 лет назад +2

    SU all the way but the end credit song is from the drumline music pack for bands there version of Neck

  • @BrandoBossProduKKtions
    @BrandoBossProduKKtions 9 лет назад +9

    FAMU Southern BCU & JSU

  • @caseygreen5505
    @caseygreen5505 10 лет назад +7

    texas southern has the original neck played in 1984

    • @dawolf373
      @dawolf373 6 лет назад +2

      casey green, No way Green, Grambling is the original, Grambling World Famed Band was the first, it was the tube section that started it. As the tubes played Neck bass line other brass sections got in on the party. One weekend later World Famed played Neck over and over during the game against Texas Southern. Neck was nothing but drums and brass.

    • @kennethhansberry9042
      @kennethhansberry9042 5 лет назад

      @@dawolf373 you know your history!

    • @archangelmichvel2701
      @archangelmichvel2701 5 лет назад

      Da Wolf I’m a Texas Southern fan and even I know the World Famed Grambling are the originals

    • @georgefoley928
      @georgefoley928 4 года назад

      Boy yawl want to be above TSU so bad when it comes to this, damn at least give them that. TSU is the original band that started playing Neck! Show me a video of GSU playing neck in the 80’s untill than TSU is the original Neck slayers PERIOD

  • @scrizzle7
    @scrizzle7 12 лет назад +1

    The best version by far is when the credits are rolling. That shit is rocking!

  • @honeyflash1
    @honeyflash1 10 лет назад +10

    I love Bethune Cookman

  • @darinfrazier38
    @darinfrazier38 4 месяца назад

    Neck will never get old. Coming from someone that was class of 2005 Camden Fairview High

  • @MrEricbcarwell
    @MrEricbcarwell 12 лет назад +3

    Jackson smashing this song!!!! the arrangement...so so, but delivery on 100

  • @David_Duby
    @David_Duby 10 лет назад +3

    SU the best and for those who don't know the band at the end credits is from the video game BCFX

    • @travisjames7332
      @travisjames7332 10 лет назад +2

      That's Grambling playin a different arrangement on the end credits. A UAPB version at that. Not Grambling's original version

    • @drequynnrod5077
      @drequynnrod5077 9 лет назад

      gsu BTW that game is based on GRAMBLING and doug Williams gsu has over three neck arrangements

  • @Cediepee
    @Cediepee 11 лет назад +3

    NSU all day long!!! Behold the GREEN and GOLD

  • @unisol06
    @unisol06 12 лет назад +1

    Howard has a great arrangement for this song too, Very smooth

  • @brandonharris8883
    @brandonharris8883 2 года назад +1

    The Spartan Legion forever! Behold The Green and Gold! 🙌🏾

  • @krankup1175
    @krankup1175 10 лет назад +7

    The best one was played during the credits

    • @handyec
      @handyec 7 лет назад

      That was "Drumline Live" in the credits. Not a college band.

  • @allenthesingerinstgram
    @allenthesingerinstgram 5 лет назад +1

    My family went to south Carolina State And graduated from there. Come on man marching 101

  • @darinfrazier38
    @darinfrazier38 3 года назад +2

    Where is UAPB?????

  • @PurpleLionRs
    @PurpleLionRs 12 лет назад +2

    No UAPB?

  • @jalisarwilliams
    @jalisarwilliams 12 лет назад +1

    Who is playing during the credits?! That version of NECK is EVERYTHING!!!!

  • @jartarviez
    @jartarviez 11 лет назад +3

    I skimmed through this, but I'm pretty sure GSU wasn't on this....and it's one of the best versions hands down

  • @trellcorleone
    @trellcorleone 10 лет назад

    Central State Version is dope too!! The not featured, but they sounded great at the Chicago football classic last year!

  • @mckinley33
    @mckinley33 10 лет назад +7

    Southern killed it!! #Swca

  • @nauticaboy25
    @nauticaboy25 10 лет назад +3

    Tennessee State has the best Neck Arrangement

  • @msngrr
    @msngrr 11 лет назад

    just to think that my dad and mom went there...im in my high school band right now...cant wait to go to TSU!

  • @peytonfitzgerald1436
    @peytonfitzgerald1436 8 лет назад +11

    Southern Univeristy all day!!! Go Jags!!! #1 always

  • @tbyrddagreat
    @tbyrddagreat 12 лет назад +2

    UAPB neck should be in this discussion !!!

  • @Kpop0223
    @Kpop0223 12 лет назад +1

    FAMU is always clean and technically pretty sounding lol. And Southern sounded niiiice.

  • @cmansax06
    @cmansax06 11 лет назад +1

    The "Neck" arrangement during the ending credits is FUNKY tho...Kudos to the arranger...

  • @cavetteb
    @cavetteb 12 лет назад +1

    Hell... The best version was the audio playing during the damn credits! YEESH!

  • @stanewill
    @stanewill 9 лет назад +4

    Behold The Green and Gold!!!! The Marching Spartan Legion version is the best!!!!!!!

    • @keeloneptune727
      @keeloneptune727 5 лет назад

      It waS straight trash don’t nobody ever check got north folk 🤣

  • @divasinmotiondancecompany1005
    @divasinmotiondancecompany1005 8 лет назад +10

    Txsu hands down

  • @Shreveport_P
    @Shreveport_P 6 лет назад +2

    This compilation is and will be incomplete until The World Famed (Grambling State University) is in it! #GSUBESTNECK

  • @tyronecarter2625
    @tyronecarter2625 10 лет назад +14

    The best one I've hears was UAPB

  • @keeloneptune727
    @keeloneptune727 5 лет назад +2

    Bethune Cookman has the best version of neck no other HBCU band can compare to the marching wildcats

  • @MrDrummermatic
    @MrDrummermatic 11 лет назад

    that end credit arrangement to neck was the best one to me

  • @CigaraStCistar
    @CigaraStCistar 2 года назад +2

    Texas Southern -Musical NECK luv it, nice go go minuscule vibe ♡
    SCSU101 - Chant 1st, Flowing Funky & Nice Changes, Lush each section, Tubas Shine ♡
    Alabama - Musical, Changes, Distinct 'Talking out side of ya neck', Drums&Tubas Shine ♡
    FAMU 100 -Crisp on full sound, Tubas, Piccolos, Cymbals Shine, Total sound Funk N Swing ♡
    Southern -Jumped right in lol, Loud, a bit incohesive N disjointed, distinct on 'Talking part' ♡
    Bethune - Came in like a dj kept reverbing ♡ Def GO-GO Nice, Tubas N Drums, Issa VYBE ♡
    Jackson -Loud, Screamers no control, drowning others out, a bit disjointed arrgmnt potential ♡
    Norfolk -A bit fast, woosah, tried Go Go flow, should have slowed it, potential in arrangement ♡
    But um ending credits.... That's it for that Go Go flow N Big band sound...
    Love to all... HBCU.... BEBE Flautist age 7... Now 51 ♡
    Keep playing N flowing in your Purpose ♡
    When music hits you, you feel Noooooooo pain. 💋❤

    • @CigaraStCistar
      @CigaraStCistar 2 года назад +1

      Ending credits WHO IS THAT? ❤❤❤❤👐

  • @CEEthoughts
    @CEEthoughts 11 лет назад

    I loved the version at the ending credits as well, and didn't see a response to the questions as to who it was. I looked closely at the credits again....its the audio of Drumline Live's version of Neck...

  • @brlion66
    @brlion66 11 лет назад +1

    you should do a "HAY" Comparison video

  • @kharywright
    @kharywright 11 лет назад +1

    South Carolina State University Marching 101 has the best neck hands down!!!

  • @BlackhawkMediaATL
    @BlackhawkMediaATL 10 лет назад +6

    JSU hands down!