the low frequency noise is from the speaker, which is designed to let the people that walks around to notice the car when it in slow speed and it's much more obvious from the outside of the car, because the electric vehicle is too quite and too dangerous if they have not noise.. actually most of the EV vehicles have the same setting, like Tesla, you will find low frequency noise when you drive in slow speed.. but the noise varies from brands and models, just like different ring tones of different phones.😂
all evs especially in black colour with dark windows in winter autumn months or very grey cloudy days and after dusk ( HARDER to see) . SCHOOL KIDS , and pedestrians on their way to work in the morning wearing head phones or glued to their screen on their phone BEWARE when crossing roads and especially at junctions.
Other car makers from what I've heard is already in big trouble. Chinese car makers dont just stop here. They will keep on improving and flooding the market.
A very good review. There are things that you touch on that I have not seen anyone else doing. I get so much from this review that I will actually consider buying one. Thanks, Bobby!
To solve the humming issue, another solution is to mask the speaker in the bonnet, I did it with my Atto 3, it’s reduced the humming sound tremendously, been driving it for the last 6 months without any complain
Humming noise is a safety feature in the car. It is activated when speed is 30km n below. Its for people who to hear n note that a car is approaching as EV engine is very quiet. Not for driver to hear.... Why remove it ss it would prevent accidents
There's a lot of videos showing how simple it is to unplug the speaker.... it takes about 20 seconds. In Australia, there is no law that requires the low-speed sound.
this hymming sound is actually a feature in Atto 3, its called Engine Sound Simulator. you can change the sound setting to another type of sound in settings of car. its annoying but if you play some music instead you can barely hear it, especailly if you also open window..
That humming noise is intentionally generated by a small device under the engine hood. That is to warn people around there is a car approaching at low speed, since EV is so quiet. That is for safety purpose. Some people unplug the device, but it is not recommended. In many countries, this warning system is mandatory.
door handles , air vents ,and guitar string pocket door walls are a little to toy land style for me . Can you imagine yer young kids getting bored and playing about with the side pocket strings everytime you drive along , no kidding it will drive you nuts
At the 34th minute you rightly pointed out the problem which I detected before coming across your video, I thought it was my atto 3 problem but seems like a standard deviation on all the atto 3. The driver dashboard screen on the steering wheel base is indeed slightly slanted to the left. Not upright at 90 degrees.
This vehicle already launched in India before here the noise warning for other road users to realize something approaching them, it's already discussed by many car reviewers there
Hello Bobby, thanks for the review, I hv test drive the Atto 3 a month ago, and I think the humming sound during slow speed can be solved almost immediately by turning on the audio play/ radio and it will cover or soften the noisy that annoyed you isn't it?
Btw I tested the Atto 3 again last weekend as they came to Ipoh Parade for promotion. So, I posted your question/issue to the salesman, and he said the sound can be adjusted or turned off. But I didn't try it. Hope what he said is correct.
Another solid & comprehensive down to earth review. Bobby, wow you gave such high score for this Atto3 even better than the Germans which cost double the price! BYD is the EV to go for at this price range. p/s As for the irritating "humming engine sound", I read that some owners in Australia disabled it by disconecting the wire!
i'm considering a new SUV for family oriented car. Mazda CX-5, BYD Atto 3, Honda HR-V , Proton X70, which would you recommend from your personal POV in city drive and daily commute ?
Hi Bobby)) So its only one button (switch) to sport, just one click) Second standard/high is the level of brake recuperation, nothing to do with sport)
Hi, I'm on my way to own ATTO3 but I realizes that they used China brand tyre A21 batman. IYO, would you change to another reliable trusted tyre brand like Michelin/ Continental?
hey Bobby you thought the signal is on your left too ? I did that when I had my test drive too… it might be too much of continental touch and feel that mistakenly illusionalize it’s something like German car 👀
Bobby, what do you think about Mazda CX5 vs BYD ATTO 3? I’m considering either 1. Already got 1 Vios now, planning to get another SUV for family use, and travel work to home like that
The pedestrian warning system, there's a visible connector in the front part of the car, you can just unplug it and no more noise and no error message.
Yes it is. But they should look at how European car makers make nice sounds that doesn't annoy. The sounds emitted cannot be too homogenous or single tone.
This car should be at 100k to 120k price point to make sense.. at 150k there are so many better choice petrol car and Malaysian petrol price is not a factor to choose a 150k electric car.
Can you review the BYD's ADAS system? I heard their ADAS on lane keeping assist is terrible on their models from China reviewers, and I'm unsure whether this has been fixed. If it is a problem, it is such a deal breaker for EV choices, since BYD and Tesla is the choice to go to for under 200K. Tesla's shitty Tesla Vision is scary and chased me out of it.
It is true that Atto 3 can charge with 3 pin plug from home socket and no need to install the AC home charger? If yes then it will be very practical to charge in my office or home
Hi Bobby, Everyone is talking about the cornering of this car is very bad. I am going to get mine around end of March. Do you have any suggestions how I can reduce the body roll and increase the grip. Now what I can think of is to change to Continental UC6, I think UC7 doesn't have the 17inch size.
I don't think you should be modding this car in any way because it is so comfortable. You wanna enjoy handling and driving go buy a used proton iriz :)
Mmmm, it's actually for safety purpose. The car skips and body roll is too obvious. Some owner said the body roll happens even when they are driving around 60kmj around corner. The Batman Atlas tyre doesn't have the grip especially during raining time.
@@eddvangtc2944 Well Bobby just proved to us that with this tyre full throttling in sport mode on a damp morning asphalt can already send this car crazy haha
bro "If you include the company’s plug-in hybrid electric vehicles, it already overtook Tesla in 2022, and its sales of fully electric vehicles soared to around 911,000 last year from 321,000 in 2021." So technically BYD did not overtake tesla in EV sales.
Other EV car try to make the driving experience more different than ICE car with super acceleration... while BYD try to make an EV car drive like a ice car 😆😅.
I know how not to get that annoying voice assistant pop up whenever you say BYD. So just change your pronunciation of BYD. Instead of saying B-Y-D simply say BY-D which will sound as bye-D.
Dude try to use Chinese flagship mobile brands like oppo , honor , OnePlus or Xiaomi u will never regret... Samsung to me just rubbish overpriced products
EV cars should sell below 50k...forget it when it is selling above 100k and i still need to be at mercy of tnb, need to charge frequently, not enough place to charge, high maintenance parts etc...
@@realmlee8803 If they sell below 50k, it's no point for them to invest EV in Malaysia. However, i understood where you're coming from. As long for Msia to have petrol subsidy, there is no reason to get EV unless you just want a second car as a fun car. Other countries are different because their petrol price is high, so they have valid reason to get EV but not all willing to do so due to charging infrastructure. Msia, need to get used to hybrid 1st before their mindset can change to EV.
@@jcsenhamster315 agree with you bro and thks for yr inputs... I foresee the ev car price will come down once they have economy of scale... Perodua would come out their Axia EV version in future... Just a matter of time. Is always the same, new technology will be selling very high price and will come down few yrs later... The EV buyer now can show off bcox they are the early adopters. But i prefer to wait when EV cars have fast charging battery... Concept similar to our phone battery.
the low frequency noise is from the speaker, which is designed to let the people that walks around to notice the car when it in slow speed and it's much more obvious from the outside of the car, because the electric vehicle is too quite and too dangerous if they have not noise.. actually most of the EV vehicles have the same setting, like Tesla, you will find low frequency noise when you drive in slow speed.. but the noise varies from brands and models, just like different ring tones of different phones.😂
all evs especially in black colour with dark windows in winter autumn months or very grey cloudy days and after dusk ( HARDER to see) . SCHOOL KIDS , and pedestrians on their way to work in the morning wearing head phones or glued to their screen on their phone BEWARE when crossing roads and especially at junctions.
Pedestrian warning system. On the Atto it operates only from 1-28kmh.
drove an atto3 since jan 2023. truly a great suv ev. japanese and european ev and ice cars are in big trouble if they don’t keep up.
Other car makers from what I've heard is already in big trouble. Chinese car makers dont just stop here. They will keep on improving and flooding the market.
A very good review. There are things that you touch on that I have not seen anyone else doing. I get so much from this review that I will actually consider buying one. Thanks, Bobby!
To solve the humming issue, another solution is to mask the speaker in the bonnet, I did it with my Atto 3, it’s reduced the humming sound tremendously, been driving it for the last 6 months without any complain
Humming noise is a safety feature in the car. It is activated when speed is 30km n below. Its for people who to hear n note that a car is approaching as EV engine is very quiet. Not for driver to hear.... Why remove it ss it would prevent accidents
@@taiyeunleung6798 it’s not totally masked, still can hear some soft humming sound but not too intrusive
There's a lot of videos showing how simple it is to unplug the speaker.... it takes about 20 seconds. In Australia, there is no law that requires the low-speed sound.
LOL... love love love the acceleration portion of the video :p You look so gleefully happy
this hymming sound is actually a feature in Atto 3,
its called Engine Sound Simulator.
you can change the sound setting to another type of sound in settings of car.
its annoying but if you play some music instead you can barely hear it, especailly if you also open window..
Thanks for this. Fantastic induction to the systems 👍👍👍
bobby... the only car reviewer I will learn much more about refinement after watching your video :D haha.
Great review!
Really like your review from a genuine user. Thanks a lot.
That humming noise is intentionally generated by a small device under the engine hood. That is to warn people around there is a car approaching at low speed, since EV is so quiet. That is for safety purpose. Some people unplug the device, but it is not recommended. In many countries, this warning system is mandatory.
door handles , air vents ,and guitar string pocket door walls are a little to toy land style for me . Can you imagine yer young kids getting bored and playing about with the side pocket strings everytime you drive along , no kidding it will drive you nuts
Worth for the price.
Just change the Atlas tyre to have more quieter drive.
Superb explanation 👍
I love this car too. Test drove it in 1 utama couple of weeks ago. Sure wish i could afford it.
I saw this car near kelana jaya. Very nice look futuristic.
At the 34th minute you rightly pointed out the problem which I detected before coming across your video, I thought it was my atto 3 problem but seems like a standard deviation on all the atto 3. The driver dashboard screen on the steering wheel base is indeed slightly slanted to the left. Not upright at 90 degrees.
You can simply unplug the exterior speaker that creates the humming sound. Not saying you should, but you can.
The humming speaker is the round one(both side) or the square one? And where is the visible connector and what is look like(colour)?
Differences in gaps on tyre is to cancel the road noise made by tyre, to make it quieter
Nice review. Does it have a proximity sensor on the sides? If you get too close to an object, does it warn you?
BYD is the future.. hope for their success
This vehicle already launched in India before here the noise warning for other road users to realize something approaching them, it's already discussed by many car reviewers there
Yeah, many EVs have these noise generating devices to warn pedestrians, but this BYD's is rather constant and irks me after a while
Hello Bobby, thanks for the review, I hv test drive the Atto 3 a month ago, and I think the humming sound during slow speed can be solved almost immediately by turning on the audio play/ radio and it will cover or soften the noisy that annoyed you isn't it?
lol
Btw I tested the Atto 3 again last weekend as they came to Ipoh Parade for promotion. So, I posted your question/issue to the salesman, and he said the sound can be adjusted or turned off. But I didn't try it. Hope what he said is correct.
@@my987TVmy Anyway is just a speaker. If don't like it can just put a sock over it in the hood
actually where were you intended driving to at this very day while doing this review?
Another solid & comprehensive down to earth review. Bobby, wow you gave such high score for this Atto3 even better than the Germans which cost double the price! BYD is the EV to go for at this price range.
p/s As for the irritating "humming engine sound", I read that some owners in Australia disabled it by disconecting the wire!
Wii you test drive smart #1 when introduce to the M'sia market?
i'm considering a new SUV for family oriented car.
Mazda CX-5, BYD Atto 3, Honda HR-V , Proton X70, which would you recommend from your personal POV in city drive and daily commute ?
@Bobby Ang, what do you think to the han?
Hi Bobby)) So its only one button (switch) to sport, just one click)
Second standard/high is the level of brake recuperation, nothing to do with sport)
When are you going to review the new Honda HRV turbo 2023 ?
Hi, I'm on my way to own ATTO3 but I realizes that they used China brand tyre A21 batman. IYO, would you change to another reliable trusted tyre brand like Michelin/ Continental?
Would have loved to get Auto dimming exterior rear view mirror...
hey Bobby you thought the signal is on your left too ? I did that when I had my test drive too… it might be too much of continental touch and feel that mistakenly illusionalize it’s something like German car 👀
i like how this review is honest straightaway... the humming sound was what i noticed the first time driving it
That's why many car makers banned me :(
@@BobbyAngmalaysia You do you Bobby! 🫡
34:18 yes, i also realised the instrument display and the steering wheel is not aligned on mine. 🙄
You can turn off the byd voice thing in the settings. I think it is essential.
Aircond vent looked very retro.
Does any one know how to increase height of Led Headlights?any hack...(the settings on the screen is not enough ..its too low )
Bobby, what do you think about Mazda CX5 vs BYD ATTO 3? I’m considering either 1. Already got 1 Vios now, planning to get another SUV for family use, and travel work to home like that
if Atto3 is at 120k and below you can consider.. but at 150k better go for cx5
@@wensiangfong why said so? Can tell me more?
city drive better go EV
Atto because its a EV. All your friends will treat u dinner to test drive it
I test drive d. But looking at the warranty detail i become worry with so limited part with limited years of warranty
The pedestrian warning system, there's a visible connector in the front part of the car, you can just unplug it and no more noise and no error message.
That is for the safety of the pedestrian, don’t do these silly stuff
I just hope that the pedestrian whom the sensor fails to warn the driver is not a loved one of yours. Some suggestions are just plain stupid.
How to get sued in case of pedestrian accidents
@@jackeytam7700 this is not Europe, pedestrian have no rights here
@@azlanmahmud Try that. And see what happens. I bet my last Sen you don't know the law.
BYD ATTO 3 👍👏💪🇸🇬
Okay that low hum is driving me nuts.
Maybe there's a way or shop in future can change the humming sound to other sound...btw I love this byd than the good cat
The humming sound at low speed could be a safety feature from the speaker in front of the car to alert pedestrian.
Yes it is. But they should look at how European car makers make nice sounds that doesn't annoy. The sounds emitted cannot be too homogenous or single tone.
great review, BYD is not even close.
tesla has that noise too, when driving backwards.
The humming should be for outside, so pedestrian can hear car coming.
The speaker is mounted outside, but the sound will still enter into the interior
it be interesting to see how an electric car deals with KL peak hour traffic jam on a Hot day
As per dude at shop here, it stays on until 30 KMPH.
This car should be at 100k to 120k price point to make sense.. at 150k there are so many better choice petrol car and Malaysian petrol price is not a factor to choose a 150k electric car.
Compare apple to apple.
Byd ev doesn’t sell more than Tesla. BYD sells ice car which is factored into the sales number
Can you review the BYD's ADAS system? I heard their ADAS on lane keeping assist is terrible on their models from China reviewers, and I'm unsure whether this has been fixed. If it is a problem, it is such a deal breaker for EV choices, since BYD and Tesla is the choice to go to for under 200K. Tesla's shitty Tesla Vision is scary and chased me out of it.
It is true that Atto 3 can charge with 3 pin plug from home socket and no need to install the AC home charger? If yes then it will be very practical to charge in my office or home
Yes but v v slow
Charges at 1.5 kw. It’s ok for topping up overnight. Not so much for a full charge.
@@dermotbalaam5358 I get just over 3kW plugged into a 230volt wall socket.
i charge with 3 point overnight
fast charge should be used while travelling only
三个选项(H，L，S)是电力回收
Hi Bobby, how’s this car’s interior built quality compared to Mazda?
Slightly better overall but Mazda styling is more mature and beautiful while this one is all over the place
Ev good.
High = high regenerative braking.
Hi Bobby,
Everyone is talking about the cornering of this car is very bad. I am going to get mine around end of March. Do you have any suggestions how I can reduce the body roll and increase the grip. Now what I can think of is to change to Continental UC6, I think UC7 doesn't have the 17inch size.
UC is not a high end contiental tyre model. SC is.
I don't think you should be modding this car in any way because it is so comfortable. You wanna enjoy handling and driving go buy a used proton iriz :)
Mmmm, it's actually for safety purpose. The car skips and body roll is too obvious. Some owner said the body roll happens even when they are driving around 60kmj around corner. The Batman Atlas tyre doesn't have the grip especially during raining time.
@@eddvangtc2944 Well Bobby just proved to us that with this tyre full throttling in sport mode on a damp morning asphalt can already send this car crazy haha
EVs have low centre of gravity in general due to the position of the battery, I believe body rolls wouldn't be a very big problem.
They need a nicer design logo
able to slightly hear the humming sound at low speeds during your drive..
Drives me crazy
@@BobbyAngmalaysia just disconnet a wire under the bonnet and the humming is gone
actually it have 2 mode, try the music mode instead of the annoying humming sound
@@nanxingluo4902 which wire ah?
21:37 Regen mode
human ears must be different. i cannot barely notice the humming sound.
btw, that P button initiates auto parking.
bro "If you include the company’s plug-in hybrid electric vehicles, it already overtook Tesla in 2022, and its sales of fully electric vehicles soared to around 911,000 last year from 321,000 in 2021."
So technically BYD did not overtake tesla in EV sales.
26:55 because of this one car, you're generalizing the characteristics of Chinese, Japanese and German carmakers.
i think its the battery
yeah heard it, hummingg
15:45 almost drives into truck while messing with screen...
🤚= access card
慢速提示声是每个Ev生产商必要遵守欧盟推出最基本条件之一(因EV行使过于安静，所以发出嗡嗡嗡提示周围人小心
FFS turn the radio up
Other EV car try to make the driving experience more different than ICE car with super acceleration... while BYD try to make an EV car drive like a ice car 😆😅.
BYD definately looks much better than Tesla IMHO. Definitely will consider BYD if I were to look for EVs.
I know how not to get that annoying voice assistant pop up whenever you say BYD. So just change your pronunciation of BYD. Instead of saying B-Y-D simply say BY-D which will sound as bye-D.
Dude try to use Chinese flagship mobile brands like oppo , honor , OnePlus or Xiaomi u will never regret... Samsung to me just rubbish overpriced products
EV cars should sell below 50k...forget it when it is selling above 100k and i still need to be at mercy of tnb,
need to charge frequently, not enough place to charge, high maintenance parts etc...
Below rm50k? You think Malaysia ringgit big ah? Lol
@@BobbyAngmalaysia hahahhahha... soonest or later with smaller car models... This is call market skimming pricing.
@@realmlee8803 If they sell below 50k, it's no point for them to invest EV in Malaysia. However, i understood where you're coming from. As long for Msia to have petrol subsidy, there is no reason to get EV unless you just want a second car as a fun car. Other countries are different because their petrol price is high, so they have valid reason to get EV but not all willing to do so due to charging infrastructure. Msia, need to get used to hybrid 1st before their mindset can change to EV.
@@jcsenhamster315 agree with you bro and thks for yr inputs... I foresee the ev car price will come down once they have economy of scale... Perodua would come out their Axia EV version in future... Just a matter of time. Is always the same, new technology will be selling very high price and will come down few yrs later... The EV buyer now can show off bcox they are the early adopters. But i prefer to wait when EV cars have fast charging battery... Concept similar to our phone battery.
@@realmlee8803 no way below 50k if Axia prices has any indication. Even ICE cars are getting
Interior looks very cheap. Definately wont age well
Have you test driven yet?
@@wongcw08 what does test driving it got to do with that ugly cheap looking interior? From the video can tell that the interior won't age well
@@wongcw08 Ignore him, just a keyboard warrior
From what I heard, the interior looks much more premium in real life than on videos, maybe you should check out yourself.
Just like when someone see your face on the street and say: hey, by looking at your face, you seem stupid..lmao
Still a vehicle for the wealthy lah.