He did succeed he just had trouble at home and then went back. He thought of the western world as inferior rainy and disgusting and wouldn’t want to control it anyway.
My wife grew up in rural Appalachia and has pointed out to me that most folk music has a lot of the same core sounds no matter where in the world it comes from.
Most cultures have a tradition of using a base tone and adding harmonies to it. I believe it's due to early simple instruments like skin or water drums, flutes, didgeridoos and single/double string instruments which only allowed a small range in the same key. So naturally, people started to add layers to those same tones/keys. This developed into instruments and techniques like overtone/throat singing, double flutes, bagpipes, more strings with a base tone like Hurdy Gurdys, so many other string instruments I don't know the names of or how they play the fiddle and folk guitar. There are only so many possibilities on the pentatonic scale, so music tends to sound similar.
Norwegian Black Metal also has a lot of throat singing,- except it hasn't yet developed into overtones. Perhaps it's too young of a genre to have learned/discovered overtones,- because they haven't been present yet.
@@TravelinChina In a way it has been done , A Bluegrass ballad, "Wayfaring Stranger" was done in 2014 by Bennett Konesni and the Altai Band when they toured the USA. Sung in both English and Mongolian, using traditional Mongolian instruments and only a guitar with Konesni. Bluegrass greats, Bill Monroe and Ralph Stanley had early hits with the song, especially Monroe, and it's been covered by other Country singers later on. You can see Altai's and Konesni's video on RUclips. I've been trying to cut and paste the video's info, but it's not working, I'm doing something wrong, but if you type in Wayfaring Stranger with Mongolian band Altai and Bennett Konesni, you should easily find it. I think you will enjoy it. BTW great video of Anda Union, and great job throat singing !!
@@TravelinChina I saw someone do this exactly on one of those talent shows and it was godawful. It didn't mix well at all. I love throat singing too, it sounds fantastic. But mixing those genres, just something about it absolutely did not work. If someone else has given it a go and done it well I have no idea, but the bit I have seen gave me little hope they mix well.
I figured out how to do this after being a heavy smoker for 3 years lol. Totally on accident, I didn't know what that low/rumble sounds was until I stumbled on a throat singing video a year ago.
Beepboop Boopbeep Well it’s bad for your lungs! Why do you really want to stay in he hospital? Please don’t, you’ll regret it! And if you can’t stop smoking go look for someone to help you out! It’s sooo bad for your lungs you’ll die quicker
I love the sounds of the Mongolian music. Normally, I sing in a Classical Chamber Choir, but due to the Corona Crisis, we haven't met, and now, I am totally going to burst out in some (attempted) throat singng at our next rehearsal! =D My conductor will be utterly shocked, haha!
Actually I learned myself how to create this sound just for fun at a young age. It was until when I was a lot older when I discovered that this was actually an ancient singing technique used primarily by the Mongols. Now I am trying to do the throat whistle as well. That technique is just SO difficult...
This is amazing!!!! I love the sounds of their voices, the instruments, the rhythm, everything! This video made me discover Mongolian throat singing and it gave me shivers from start to end! 😍
He's a great teacher. He says to tighten your chest, and that was key for me. Sit up, back straight, and think about tightening and pushing the sternum forward. Then, just.... bah like a sheep and if you put enough force into it, it'll sound great. I did cough up a storm though, but that's expected.
As someone that was curious how it's done for the past few years then seeing this, I feel like the best way I've seen it described: you know that voice you used as a child to try to convince your parents you were sick so you didn't have to go to school? That part of your throat.
Mongolian technique wants so many time to learn well. You can sing easily but you have to make practise and make it well. I'm 1 year old throat singer and I'm practising everyday.
Admittedly, I wasn't expecting to run across this video, but the interest in Tuvan throat singing brought me here. So here I am, and my goodness that band is really good!
@@TravelinChina You are very talented phonetically person: I hear it stretch from your Chinese pronunciation! So if you pronounce Chinese good like this, you also could pronounce well enough Russian (it's phonetically close, but people doesn't able to confess it- but fact that China's people can pronounce Russian very good, almost without any heavy accent). Cause of you phonetical talent I am not surprised that you was able to catch that throat sound examples 😊
Alvar Cyrodiil If you can find it, there’s a recording of Jackie Chan and Ani DiFranco singing “Unforgettable.” It’s on an album called When Pigs Fly: Songs You Never Thought You'd Hear. That’s my personal favorite odd couple.
I used to play around with the sounds coming from my throat when I was little! It was fun to feel like vibrations through my throat and head. The sounds they make take such skill and practice!!
Im iranian and i wanna learn this so bad i guess it takes a long time to learn throat singing update: i finally did it. I can throat sing now! I do it everywhere!
I managed to do it the other day. I’ve been trying for a while, I managed to get the third tone, albeit short. Very proud of this accomplishment though - never thought I’d be able to do it, this video has been very interesting, thank you for posting.
Well I was trying to follow the video... my family came in the room with crosses and holy water thinking I was posessed... I think I wasnt doing it right
I don’t think I’d ever be able to throat sing like that. He must have developed his vocal cords and proper breathing techniques at an early age. I’ve tried so many times I end up almost throwing up and coughing lots cause my throat it just not used to these sounds or even have the muscles trained properly.
This is so wierd watching this because I'm a 67 yr old lady & as a small child I used to sing like this I can still do it & i can't tell anyone why I was able to do this as a 5 yr old. I used to practise in our garden shed because my mother couldnt stand it she said I sounded like a bad tempered troll! I used to blow bubbles from my mouth holding them between my lips then open my mouth as I did the throat singing, moving my mouth around so the sounds would change. I'm even better at it now as my voice has deepened over the yrs. My grandparents were Scandinavian & my great great grandmama was Basque so maybe I held an ancestor memory of throat singing! It's great to do & makes yr mouth & lips tingle.
At 3:02 When he randomly swiched from Xhoomei to Kragyraa it really puts a beginner off. He Shows him the Approach to Xhoomei, where you begin with the Sheep sound. But then he instantly Switched to Kargyraa, which needs a approach where you make the Throat-Clearing sound... Of couse the poor beginner didn't get it... My students don't struggle like him when I teach Kargyraa or Xhoomei...
Can't believe this was 3 years ago? Just catching up on some of your older vlogs. It's great seeing how much diversity there is in China. It nothing like what's being reported here in the U.K. Anyway, was funny watching you and hearing him sing! Lol
@@otgonratnayake2133 No way?! So they used it without permission or paying royalties? Gosh. How naughty. I loved it when I heard it at 13 years of age.I had no idea it was Mongol, and only recognised it in the Enigma as Mongolian, because l recently got into Mongolian music through watching a Netflix series with the Khan Dynasty called 'Christopher Columbus.' (With which has sadly not been continued. )
Maybe I"m mistaken, but seems like a similar skills set to beat boxing, just a different execution. I wonder if any beat boxing experts have tried this.
Yeah all beatboxers know how to do it. Its called throat bass...its similar to throat singing but its deeper. And if you check out vibration bass, its out of this world !!!
6:00 Ordos drinking song "When the milk wine is in the bottle Just like small sheep in the pen When you drink the milk wine It is just like a tiger out of the pen We toast everything goes well for me and you".
Hey! It’s true that you did not quite get the trick but your attempt was far from bad! I home those mean comments didn’t get to you. I started a month ago, and it took me a whole day to figure out how to tighten my throat the right way! Then weeks to not get sore from practicing, he he! If you or anyone reading this wanna pick it up, here is the way it was taught to me. The style you hear in the video is a combination of two movements. The first is like when you’re trying to push a heavy door, with the “heave ho” moan that presses your chest cavity. The second is a forced wheeze, as in a fake laugh. Try combining the two and you might find your sound! If you need demonstration, check out the course on Skillshare. You’re welcome ;)
Imagine if Genghis Khan succeeded his mission conquering most parts of the world. We'd all be learning this at school now.
He did succeed he just had trouble at home and then went back. He thought of the western world as inferior rainy and disgusting and wouldn’t want to control it anyway.
Nelson Thayer there was no western world
@@Votol78 Europe was the Western World back then. It still is today
Lol he actually did succeed
Andrew the west has always been a thing 😂😂
My wife grew up in rural Appalachia and has pointed out to me that most folk music has a lot of the same core sounds no matter where in the world it comes from.
Most cultures have a tradition of using a base tone and adding harmonies to it. I believe it's due to early simple instruments like skin or water drums, flutes, didgeridoos and single/double string instruments which only allowed a small range in the same key. So naturally, people started to add layers to those same tones/keys. This developed into instruments and techniques like overtone/throat singing, double flutes, bagpipes, more strings with a base tone like Hurdy Gurdys, so many other string instruments I don't know the names of or how they play the fiddle and folk guitar. There are only so many possibilities on the pentatonic scale, so music tends to sound similar.
Norwegian Black Metal also has a lot of throat singing,- except it hasn't yet developed into overtones.
Perhaps it's too young of a genre to have learned/discovered overtones,- because they haven't been present yet.
Music is a very universal thing isn't it?
Open fifths
音乐才能把人类团结在一起。政治理念做不到。
No way. You met with Anda Union! They're a very famous band in Inner Mongolia!
Lovely people too!
Oof I accidentally read that as 'Soviet Union' my bad
@@HephaestusAki You definitely didn't.
@@Rayven_420 whatever asshat
@@HephaestusAki , Of course, you resort to insulting. Because you're just SOOOO hurt.
Dude put these guys with the american hillbillies in the mountains the music combanation would be gang
Bluegrass and ethnic Mongolian music would make for a great crossover genre.
@@TravelinChina In a way it has been done , A Bluegrass ballad, "Wayfaring Stranger" was done in 2014 by Bennett Konesni and the Altai Band when they toured the USA. Sung in both English and Mongolian, using traditional Mongolian instruments and only a guitar with Konesni. Bluegrass greats, Bill Monroe and Ralph Stanley had early hits with the song, especially Monroe, and it's been covered by other Country singers later on. You can see Altai's and Konesni's video on RUclips. I've been trying to cut and paste the video's info, but it's not working, I'm doing something wrong, but if you type in Wayfaring Stranger with Mongolian band Altai and Bennett Konesni, you should easily find it. I think you will enjoy it. BTW great video of Anda Union, and great job throat singing !!
I’d play my banjo with these folk any day!
@@TravelinChina I saw someone do this exactly on one of those talent shows and it was godawful. It didn't mix well at all. I love throat singing too, it sounds fantastic. But mixing those genres, just something about it absolutely did not work. If someone else has given it a go and done it well I have no idea, but the bit I have seen gave me little hope they mix well.
The China Traveller ruclips.net/video/E5oHBMo1pQk/видео.html
“Learn Throat Singing in 2 Minutes” by watching this 8 minute, 29 second video in which a guy can’t throat sing even after an hour of instruction.
You're welcome
@@TravelinChina 🤣🤣
When you are looking at throat singing videos and randomly find a reply from a guntuber. I was going to comment with almost the exact same thing.
@@freedoomed You're welcome!
@@TravelinChina Did you even read my reply? i was thanking TangnBang
I love a melodic metal band called The Hu. They're Mongolian and use throat singing it sounds amazing.
yuve yuve yu ma boiii
HU!
Huhuhuhuhu
I found them A few weeks ago, since then I'm stuck with their awesome music
Check out Tengger Cavalry you guys! Its like the Hu, but quite a bit heavier
I figured out how to do this after being a heavy smoker for 3 years lol. Totally on accident, I didn't know what that low/rumble sounds was until I stumbled on a throat singing video a year ago.
I've smoked for years now still haven't figured out
James H Don’t smoke! It’s bad for your mental health!
No shit sherlock
yooo, some tips?
Beepboop Boopbeep Well it’s bad for your lungs! Why do you really want to stay in he hospital? Please don’t, you’ll regret it! And if you can’t stop smoking go look for someone to help you out! It’s sooo bad for your lungs you’ll die quicker
'Learn in two minutes?' One hour later ... !
One year later... Erm... Yeah... Sorry...
30 mins later before i learn it
@@TravelinChina one year later? That's a heck of a splice in footage!
Me trying to do a presentation: *don't get too nervous*
Also me: 1:51
Why did I laugh at that poor man 😂
AK45GUY hahahahaha me too
Read it exactly when he sung, had me dying
This was hilarious
😂
I find myself on horseback in my mind. Riding across the wind swept plains. Great freedom in the sound.
That’s just schizophrenia
I've imagined something like this... Riding a horse , vaste plains, and in the background the Altai mountains....
I love the sounds of the Mongolian music. Normally, I sing in a Classical Chamber Choir, but due to the Corona Crisis, we haven't met, and now, I am totally going to burst out in some (attempted) throat singng at our next rehearsal! =D My conductor will be utterly shocked, haha!
Good luck
@@TravelinChina Thank you so much! It turns out that it comes fairly easy to me already! =D
сайна байна бидний нэг бол.
Actually I learned myself how to create this sound just for fun at a young age. It was until when I was a lot older when I discovered that this was actually an ancient singing technique used primarily by the Mongols. Now I am trying to do the throat whistle as well. That technique is just SO difficult...
This is amazing!!!! I love the sounds of their voices, the instruments, the rhythm, everything! This video made me discover Mongolian throat singing and it gave me shivers from start to end! 😍
Glad you liked it.
He's a great teacher. He says to tighten your chest, and that was key for me. Sit up, back straight, and think about tightening and pushing the sternum forward. Then, just.... bah like a sheep and if you put enough force into it, it'll sound great. I did cough up a storm though, but that's expected.
謝謝你~司徒建國，幫我們錄製了一段非常特殊好聽的蒙古樂隊演奏的蒙古音樂，都是一些平常看不到的特殊蒙古樂器演奏的，非常具有民族風情風味好好聽呢。
I just love that look he gives at 3:58.
PogU
He's like oh shit, he did it. I gave birth to an apprentice
that was literally PogU
As someone that was curious how it's done for the past few years then seeing this, I feel like the best way I've seen it described: you know that voice you used as a child to try to convince your parents you were sick so you didn't have to go to school? That part of your throat.
1:50 When you meet your neighbour at the bar whilst high on shrooms, LSD and battery acid.
Knugen av Swärje hahahahaha
Den var bra
I'm so glad you sat through all those looks to learn this so I could take 10x as long and mess it up without anyone having to hear how bad it sounds
No one:
Me at 3am: 2:50
My neighbours must be so proud of me
It’s 3.58 am here
Me at 2 am in my parents bathroom: 3:05
2.41 here
"learn throat singing in 2 minutes" "One Hour later..."
Mongolian technique wants so many time to learn well. You can sing easily but you have to make practise and make it well. I'm 1 year old throat singer and I'm practising everyday.
So you’re telling me I’ve been knowing how to Mongolian throat sing my whole life and I didn’t even know
Can we talk about the multi-tasking of the guy playing the drums, I could literally never
Wow, I really got it in under 2 Minutes :D the trick with the sheep did it for me!
Sebastian me too XD didn't really take it seriously but tried the sheep, went lower and suddenly there you go 😂
@@cafekkoXoX got it after 30 seconds but it tickles by throat and start coughing lol
cafekkoXoX yeah, it’s like magic. I guess the sheep is blessed.
Orient Prospect ALL HAIL THE SHEEP GOD!!!!
So jealous i am. Fuck, I've done it for a few days, couldn't get a high pitch going
Best wishes for Inner Mongolia from Turkey
Tittle: learn Mongolia throat singing in one minute Actually: one hour
title* a tittle is the dit above an i
安达组合，我的天呀，我这几天一直在听安达，没想到今天无意间点开司徒的视频，就看到安达了，这是命运吗！！！
这是大数据的推送😂
Admittedly, I wasn't expecting to run across this video, but the interest in Tuvan throat singing brought me here. So here I am, and my goodness that band is really good!
Wow, the singer who taught you is really amazing...!!!
Agreed!
@@TravelinChina perhaps you're still in contact with him? Does he speak english? I really wish to take a lesson!
@@TravelinChina You are very talented phonetically person: I hear it stretch from your Chinese pronunciation! So if you pronounce Chinese good like this, you also could pronounce well enough Russian (it's phonetically close, but people doesn't able to confess it- but fact that China's people can pronounce Russian very good, almost without any heavy accent). Cause of you phonetical talent I am not surprised that you was able to catch that throat sound examples 😊
They'd put one hell of a spin on Western cowboy music.
i would listen to that
There’s this. ruclips.net/video/aoR23_308Q4/видео.html
@@drkaufman With Willie Nelson!!!
the strangest crossover ever!
Alvar Cyrodiil If you can find it, there’s a recording of Jackie Chan and Ani DiFranco singing “Unforgettable.” It’s on an album called When Pigs Fly: Songs You Never Thought You'd Hear. That’s my personal favorite odd couple.
I used to play around with the sounds coming from my throat when I was little! It was fun to feel like vibrations through my throat and head. The sounds they make take such skill and practice!!
I love Moorin Khuur voice. I love Mongolians. I'm from Turkey.
Im iranian and i wanna learn this so bad i guess it takes a long time to learn throat singing update: i finally did it. I can throat sing now! I do it everywhere!
Can you give me some tips bro? I couldn't figure it out
@@TjoaWeiHan yea same
Can you give us some tips?
I managed to do it the other day. I’ve been trying for a while, I managed to get the third tone, albeit short. Very proud of this accomplishment though - never thought I’d be able to do it, this video has been very interesting, thank you for posting.
1:50
Absolute *GOLDEN* performance by Mr. Bill Gates.
Actually his name is BiliGate
Zinnia Lorant-Pryor r/woooosh (late)
4:12 I was thinking. OMG he’s a beast
3:50 "If I choked your neck it would sound right." XD
Probably the best tutorial I've seen so far
This actually helped me to be able to throat sing.
Well I was trying to follow the video... my family came in the room with crosses and holy water thinking I was posessed... I think I wasnt doing it right
I don’t think I’d ever be able to throat sing like that. He must have developed his vocal cords and proper breathing techniques at an early age. I’ve tried so many times I end up almost throwing up and coughing lots cause my throat it just not used to these sounds or even have the muscles trained properly.
Same 😨
who else was trying it and GOT EXCITED WHEN THEY ACTUALLY DID IT!!!?
5:33 Reminds me of the secret tunnel song from avatar
Wow, the vibration from the music is amazing!!!
Imagine playing a game and finding this guys out ......
Love mongolians. Five minutes in with a mongol and you're already like anda.
I totally just messed up my throat trying to do this ahahaha
Absolutely beautiful
Title "Learn Mongolian throat singing in 2 min"
In video * tries to learn...*" 1 hour later" xd
1:50 WOW what a talent very beautiful🧡🧡🧡❤💛💚💙💜🤎
It helps if you start really really quiet and low under your throat and slowly add more and more power.
Proud of you guys
mongolian throat singing is just vibing on another level
很喜欢 呼麦，这个真的很好啊 把不同地方有灵魂的文化传播出去，跨越国界
That was 💥AWESOME!!💥💥💥💜
I absolutely love that band at the end. I could listen to that all day. 💜👍🎉🎉🎉💥
Mongols and Turks is brother
This is so wierd watching this because I'm a 67 yr old lady & as a small child I used to sing like this
I can still do it & i can't tell anyone why I was able to do this as a 5 yr old. I used to practise in our garden shed because my mother couldnt stand it she said I sounded like a bad tempered troll! I used to blow bubbles from my mouth holding them between my lips then open my mouth as I did the throat singing, moving my mouth around so the sounds would change. I'm even better at it now as my voice has deepened over the yrs.
My grandparents were Scandinavian & my great great grandmama was Basque so maybe I held an ancestor memory of throat singing! It's great to do & makes yr mouth & lips tingle.
At 3:02 When he randomly swiched from Xhoomei to Kragyraa it really puts a beginner off. He Shows him the Approach to Xhoomei, where you begin with the Sheep sound. But then he instantly Switched to Kargyraa, which needs a approach where you make the Throat-Clearing sound... Of couse the poor beginner didn't get it... My students don't struggle like him when I teach Kargyraa or Xhoomei...
Can't believe this was 3 years ago? Just catching up on some of your older vlogs. It's great seeing how much diversity there is in China. It nothing like what's being reported here in the U.K. Anyway, was funny watching you and hearing him sing! Lol
I saw this video last november to learn throat sing, after ofter videos and texts i can do the 3 styles, it's near a year ago time flies
So Awesome😍
When its midnight and youre in a hotel full of people you work with and all you want to do is try this.. :I
These guys need to start a historically accurate ancient Mongolian deathcore band.
the most beautiful video i've watched in a long time
Yeah, it’s 3 am and i’m watching mongolian throat singing.
As good a time as any
Im hooked on this kind of music, after watching Netflix Marco Polo. It's so relaxing. I also recognise it now on Enigmas albums!
Enigma used Mongolian long song called Alsiin gazriin zereglee, by singer Nergui. It is a case for stealing intellectual propert,
@@otgonratnayake2133 No way?! So they used it without permission or paying royalties? Gosh. How naughty. I loved it when I heard it at 13 years of age.I had no idea it was Mongol, and only recognised it in the Enigma as Mongolian, because l recently got into Mongolian music through watching a Netflix series with the Khan Dynasty called 'Christopher Columbus.' (With which has sadly not been continued. )
ME wondering how i got to this video on youtube...
Beautiful
Nobody:
That one friend group when you walk by them: 7:00
Манай буряад монгол дуушан Сэсэгмаа Бабудоржийн 😍😍😍
All this while in med school when I would wonder what speaking with an electrolarynx would sound like! And they do it without one! WOW
Interesting❣️ I got goosebumps when the bass started to play :'3
What a beautiful piece, thank you!
Thanks for watching
Awesome video very powerful energy
This is truly fascinating and unique
Amazing I love this truly beautiful creative music
1:55 mongolian Steven Seagal
Steven seagal has mongolian roots from Buryatia in Russia
Godless Animator no he is just a liar.
he has mongolian wife too.
How should it sound/look like to u if you're doing it right?
loved it!
Listening to that song gave me woodland vibes with a big fire and a hog on the spit and lot's of people around it drinking and singing.
thanks for this! It really helped me grasp the technique.
also fun fact, metal singers also use this technique
i want to try this but its 3:02am here 😂😂😂
How did Steven Seagal end up in the band?
Strangely beautifull.
First he was doing sub harmonics, kinda like throat bass in beatboxing which i can do, then he did overtones which im still trying to figure out
Maybe I"m mistaken, but seems like a similar skills set to beat boxing, just a different execution. I wonder if any beat boxing experts have tried this.
Yeah all beatboxers know how to do it.
Its called throat bass...its similar to throat singing but its deeper.
And if you check out vibration bass, its out of this world !!!
太牛逼，蒙古傳統音樂就是能鎮台！這應該是一首喝酒時的祝酒歌
6:00 Ordos drinking song
"When the milk wine is in the bottle
Just like small sheep in the pen
When you drink the milk wine
It is just like a tiger out of the pen
We toast everything goes well for me and you".
This is so beautiful.
can girls learn to do this too?? my band director and a friend can do this, but they’re guys with super deep voices. i’m discouraged :(
Some of the women in the band can do it. They're amazing.
That guy's matouqin looks and sounds like a square-shaped contrabass. 👀
1:51
This guy: 🗿
His voice:➡⬆⬇⬆⬇⬆⬇↗⬆⬇⬆⬇⬆↔↔⤴⤵⤴⤵⤴⤵⤴⤵↖↗↖↗↘↙↘↙⬇⬆⬇⬆⬇⬆⬇⬆⬇➡➡➡
Hey! It’s true that you did not quite get the trick but your attempt was far from bad!
I home those mean comments didn’t get to you. I started a month ago, and it took me a whole day to figure out how to tighten my throat the right way! Then weeks to not get sore from practicing, he he!
If you or anyone reading this wanna pick it up, here is the way it was taught to me.
The style you hear in the video is a combination of two movements.
The first is like when you’re trying to push a heavy door, with the “heave ho” moan that presses your chest cavity.
The second is a forced wheeze, as in a fake laugh.
Try combining the two and you might find your sound!
If you need demonstration, check out the course on Skillshare.
You’re welcome ;)
Thanks for the great comment
The tight chest thing actually worked. Voice now man
It did what it advertised. I am very impressed and my day is made! :D
Why is no one talking about the guy at 0:58 is called Billgate
It took him an hour to get water
Thank you so much for the hint with the sheep! Now I can finally sing undertones, too, after mastering several overtone-styles :).
3:57 the dude was like "yah that's it"