"Was he happy or sad while singing?" That's such a good question. I think, as is the case with truly profound music from anywhere in the world (especially including Sufi singing), the answer is probably "yes," as someone who truly understands life knows that it is bittersweet by nature.
To me at least, the song is wistful and bittersweet. About something beautiful the singer is remembering, but can't go back to. What an excellent question
It's incredible to see people in other parts of the world reacting to things not from my part of the world, and seeing them be so grateful to have a chance to experience all of this. This is an experience in of itself.
@@xvcelo1570 Idk about Persian but Arabic while not having the letter "o" it does have a similar letter which is "و" and when it's combined with other letters & diacritics it can make the exact same sound
Hi, Mongolian here! Throat singing is mostly about praising of the eternal blue sky, water goddesses and the Altai mountains. So there is no heavy emotions involved expect for praising the nature. Mongols don’t have a god figure but pray to the eternal blue sky 🙂 I enjoy your channel and lived in West Bengal briefly.
@@Кира-в6й Oh so Tenger is not a personal god but the sky itself has some divinity if i understood correctly. In Turkish there is a meaning shift in word Tengri. We call it Gök Tengri, i think you call it Kokh Tenger. So apperantly it was meant to be like: Gök/Kokh = Blue Tengri/Tenger = Sky but meaning of the words have changed in modern Turkish so it became: Gök/Kokh = Sky Tengri/Tenger = God So that is why i got confused.
Hungarian here! Although we live in central europe, we originally came from an area neighboring Mongolia, and some of these words carried over into our language as well. As far as I understand, a central point in Tengri is that everything in our world is a reflection of the world of gods. Of course, special attention is always given to the blue sky: when you look down, the thing which serves as the reflection to the eternal blue skies (Tengri) is the sea itself. And thus, the hungarian word for sea became "tenger". Despite the fact that Hungarians travelled to the other end of the Eurasian continent and took up Christianity in the 10th century, this word survived, which I think is pretty amazing.
As a Mongolian person, I assure you he is proud singing his country side, steppes and its beautiful nature. Almost like he is imaging the images in his head. 🙃
Intersting that the man compared it to an animal roaring because an Arabic emissary described the singing of the Vikings as being like animals or dogs and some have interpreted this to mean the Vikings had throat singing
i'm am always touched by how lovely this group of people are. Mongolian throat singing is so touching it gets to the heart, I always thought it was just me but seeing their unanimous reaction, has led me to see that it is a soul connection type of thing. Much love and many blessings to your lovely tribal people! xoxo
I am generally a very cynical person, but: This. This is what the internet is supposed be for. People simply appreciating others' cultures. Thank you for this & greetings from Germany.
Greetings from Mongolia! I've just found this channel, watched every single video and instantly loved these beautiful tribal people. They're so genuine and passionate about new things. And I really love these passions. This traditional Mongolian art piece is called "Huumii or Hoomii" in Mongolian. Actually, there are very rare people professionalized this art and rest of the Mongolians usually do admire this piece of art. Throat singing usually contains positive meanings and express further good will to everyone. It is very ancient heritage that the most of urban people couldn't understand the lyrics word by word, because it is heavy accented. I was so grateful and happy to see them enjoying our traditional thing. I would be so glad to let them know that whole world is watching you beautiful people and even the far east region, Mongolian people do watch them as well.
Thank you, we are so thankful to the beautiful people of Mongolia like Mr Batzorigh to keep this tradition alive and share with the world. I hope you are enjoying our content. Thanks again for all the love and support 🤗❤️😊🌷
Such incredible perspective you are providing not only to these wonderful people, but to us westerners as well, this is the best use of internet, to show us all the difference and similarities! Also as a music teacher i continue to find more similarities than differences in the way we all feel rhythm and song, a language with no translation necessary. Keep it up!!
Look at the way he’s smiling at the music too. He clearly has a very artistic spirit. It’s a shame that he’s only getting to explore that for the first time as an older gentleman
I loved the way the split-screen effect showed everybody sat there slightly stunned/in awe of the singing except Muharam who was just grooving away at the top! Perhaps they could watch some opera or ballet for a future video?
Yes, I had to think of "Der Hölle Rache kocht in meinem Herzen" from the Mozart opera Die Zauberflöte (The magic flute) immediately Edit: "kocht" instead of "tobt"
I wish they had used a clip with Batzorig doing sygyt like in “Mongolian Throat Singing With My Daughter” Then we would see some eye popping reactions…and get to see his sweet daughter for the man who hoped for passing down the skill.
I think this mongolian music was an excellent choice. The older gentleman has an open mind and is sincerely interested. I admire him. When he said that the mongolian singer would be a good man to have a chat with and to have him as a friend, made me cry. This is beautiful and I agree. I appreciate that you don't always just introduce western things. Greetings and much love from Germany.
I absolutely love how open and appreciative they each are for every new experience. Such a wonderful group of people. Many blessings to all of them and all of the Trybals team.
I love listening to Mongolian, Tuvan, and Inuit throat singing! Inuit ts calms me like nothing else. Inuit throat singing at shepherds of good hope is a short video I have saved whenever an anxiety attack is coming on. I'm glad tech has made it easier for us to share our worlds with each other.
On my main channel, I prepare videos with subtitles in 3 different languages for folk music of different nations. You are also invited. :)) An example of one of the videos: ruclips.net/video/vRp9EVrV77I/видео.html
Awesome, Mongolian music has long been my favorite music, and Batzorig among them. The tribespeople were all very openminded and considerate and it was nice when the instrument he mentioned was shown to us so that we could compare. This is one of the better try channels. I would love to hear the stars of this channel making a little music, if they feel comfortable doing so. I hope the little child gets water to go with their snack.
The gorgeous woman in purple and her baby are both equally adorable! So great to see hard working women make their debut on open minded channels such as this. Thank you, and keep up the good work! 💕 (Also, the edit showing the (local?) instrument this singing resembled was very helpful! Many thanks.)
One of the things to listen for with throat singing is the sort of whistling noise going on above the main voice. It’s a human making two pitches at once.
Yes...our ancestor also contributes to Indian Subcontinent, from slave to powerful empire...even after that we adopt Persian culture If u wanna see how Turks and Indian mixed up, you can see Shroff family (Jackie and Tiger) becausr their ancestor having Uyghur Turk blood
hi, new subscriber here. this channel showed up in my feed several days ago & i'm glad it did. from now on, it's part of my therapy, recovering from depression. these people have such a fresh outlook on life that i have slowly lost. thank you for sharing~
Im Indonesian and Indonesians are very racially diverse.. some look like pakistani/indians in Aceh, sumatra, east java some look like Mongols in North Sulawesi/Borneo/west java, some look like Africans in Papua.. the guy probably meant Filipinos because Phillipines is closer to mainland China/Mongolia. But Indonesia, its quite a distance from Mongolia
At the heart all people are simple and loving. The society and many times We ourselves condition ourselves. I really liked the old man Abdul. He is very broad minded. Simplicity of the others is too, very charming.
I really wish the world would be filled with people like them. They are all simple, humble, spiritual and loving towards others. I would love to have them as my friends and neighbours.
I’m honestly really enjoying how intrigued and curious everyone of them are when they were listening to Batzorig. Abdul seems to be the most curious, since I’ve noticed he leans forward to listen intently. What a bunch of wholesome individuals. I wouldn’t consider myself the most social person, but I would love to share a meal with Abdul.
Throat singing has roots so old no one can find where and by what people it was first developed. It touches something in me I hadn't realized was looking for it.
HAGSHXKJSHZHFJKDJSGDHF HIM TRYING TO SING WITH IS SO ADORABLE 💗💗💗 DONT WORRY everyone sucks in the beginning, i never learned so if i were to attempt i'd sound like a dying goose 😂😂
i feel so pleased with this video and i LOVED the editing, they touched my heart with their comments, is so cool that you are showing them so nice stuff about our world, im so happy they have the oportunity to see the rest of us is this planet as we have the oportunity to be aware of the existence of this beautiful people in Pakistan, thank you for your work on the channel!
That one gentleman mentioned he had listened to Michael Jackson & that made me think I would love to see tribal people to react to MJ's "Earth Song" with a translation of his lyrics. I cry every time I see the video. It's such a good message & very powerful beautiful video.
What I love about these people is that they see stuff totally strange to them, and truely and openly appreciate it for what it is. It's such a different image of what we usually get to see of people from these countries.
I love these videos. I am actually crying from the beauty of cultures appreciating other cultures. They are so gracious with something so different. I wish that attitude was more prevalent here.
My love and respect for them! Love this channel and I wish it gets bigger and bigger with many subscribers around the world! 😊 greetings from Brazil, south America 🇧🇷
I absolutely love the drumming on the table. There's something very magical about the regional drum rhythms. Absolutely fascinating to learn the different names for the instruments. You are all such beautiful people , I send my love and respect to you all.
I am so happy you picked the mighty Batzroig to show them! He is a great treasure to the world and all who study Khoomei or any extended vocal techniques. He is a wonderful teacher. Wela'lin!
i am so happy to hear people from other countries are as happy as i was when i first heard him, i think he is teaching,not only grandkids but others as well,
i don't watch reaction videos much but this channel randomly appeared in my recommended and i watched every video immediately. seeing them try things they've never seen or heard of before, and maybe never thought even possible, is such a joy and i hope that trybals continues to grow so that they can experience so much more!
I think it would be fun to see how they react to Powwow Regalia dance contest and Drum Circles. The Indigenous peoples of Canada and the U.S. have very interesting cultures and gather to sing and dance and share their culture. These gatherings are called Pow Wow.
This was such a great reaction video! Thank your for sharing this. I really enjoyed seeing all these wonderful people again: relating it to things they've experienced, being so open minded and in awe of a totally different skill. And Muharam drumming on the table - I could listen to that all day!
All my time watching your channel I always thought your Ustads were musicians. I’m amazed to hear today that most of them have never played or performed. Amazing that they have such passion and understanding of music.
I love these videos so much because these people are always so effusive with their praise. No matter what it is they’re reacting to, they’re so honest and feel free to share their emotions and feelings. It’s so refreshing. Thanks for sharing again and again!
I love how this channel allows these lovelies to discover the western arts, unlike most that concentrate on snacks and sensationalism, this has real meat on the bone, congratz :)
I love watching different cultures appreciate and respect different cultures. This channel is awesome and i hope everyone involved has much prosperity!
Amazing! How not to love Batzorig? His music introduced me to throat singing and opened me to a whole new world, I'm glad they liked it, actually made me tear up a bit
I have never listened to Mongolian throat singing either so I really enjoyed hearing it to the first time via this video. I felt like I was reacting along with them. Love this video
Oh everyone knows MJ. I asked Mukhtiar he says I just know the name but don't know who he was though. I was surprised by his answer and he told me everyone knows that name even in very remote villages. Strange but true.
i really really like how open minded these people are... i tried to make some people i know listen to mongolian throat singing (and other kind of "ethnic" music like indonesian gamalan) and they just laugh AT the musicians call them stupid and mock them, just being judgmental like most western people are while these people that are exposed to less or have less access to different things are much more openminded and while they sometimes laugh it is not a mean spirited judgmental laugh AT the people but just a WOW surprised kind of laugh
I think sometimes people fall into subcultures and develop this group identity over the silliest things. "Oh, I'm a _listens to pop music_ person. I don't listen to _this."_ Cue lots of stupid, pointless meanness and bickering. Honestly, probably one of the biggest things I miss about my childhood is how blissfully unaware I was about toxic fandoms -- I could just like what I liked without feeling self-conscious about whatever "fandom" I was getting lumped in with, and I didn't feel like having different tastes from someone else was somehow putting them down. We just liked different things, and if they were going to be weird about it then that was their problem.
Another very fine production. Thank you to all involved. As with your recent Bob Ross videos, the cross-cultural appreciation is sincere and, frankly, quite moving.
I'm so touched by these videos. This one is so beautiful. And I wanna listen to Batzorig too! Also can't wait to watch them singing, must be beautiful.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE have them watch the band The Hu (song wolf totem, in particular, PLEASE) now that they’ve heard traditional Mongolian thirst singing. That might rock their worlds! Who knows? But, boy, I’d sure LOVE to see that video and I know I’m not alone!!! 💜💜💜 Much love from Ohio, USA
I really enjoyed the Mongolian throat singing. The sound very much reminded me of the didgeridoo. Can you find a recording of the didgeridoo for them to see and hear please?
I am surprised that you didn't show them songs from The Hu too. Wolf Totem is probably the most well known one. I like the remix of it too. Maybe you can show those too. 😎
" I have listened to people sing with sore throats" . haha she's the best!
I love that comment.
I'm just baffled how we both have pretty much the same profile pic and both ended up watching this video ..
Imposter!!!
Epic
That was literally my comment too
"Was he happy or sad while singing?"
That's such a good question. I think, as is the case with truly profound music from anywhere in the world (especially including Sufi singing), the answer is probably "yes," as someone who truly understands life knows that it is bittersweet by nature.
That's probably why I love bittersweet music
This is a really good comment, and I seriously mean that. Thank you!
The lyrics have a very spiritual meaning, its about praising the mountains and worshipping the sky.
To me at least, the song is wistful and bittersweet. About something beautiful the singer is remembering, but can't go back to. What an excellent question
He sang with his heart & soul. It is up to the audience to feel the emotions.
It's incredible to see people in other parts of the world reacting to things not from my part of the world, and seeing them be so grateful to have a chance to experience all of this. This is an experience in of itself.
I feel the same way. Greetings from Germany.
literally i am crying
Stellar I feel the same way. Watching these videos have made me grateful for things that I didn’t even notice before.
Thanks to the white man's technology. As usual.
Yes and i am experiencing your experience with these people experiencing new experiences on camera. What an experience!
"Have you ever heard of Mongolia?"
"No, I haven't"
"How about their other name.............. the Mughals?"
*panic*
mughal is literally means mongol since arab persian dont have letter o
Ah, the mughals...
Nice Indian empire
@@xvcelo1570 Idk about Persian but Arabic while not having the letter "o" it does have a similar letter which is "و" and when it's combined with other letters & diacritics it can make the exact same sound
@@xvcelo1570 and mughals were originally a turkic tribe
@@dihydrogenmonoxide7600 no
Hi, Mongolian here!
Throat singing is mostly about praising of the eternal blue sky, water goddesses and the Altai mountains. So there is no heavy emotions involved expect for praising the nature. Mongols don’t have a god figure but pray to the eternal blue sky 🙂
I enjoy your channel and lived in West Bengal briefly.
Thank you so much Kira for sharing ❤️
Well don't you believe in Tengri/Tenger?
@@hackermeteo tenger is the eternal blue sky. There’s no god figure but all religion is welcome in Mongolia.
@@Кира-в6й Oh so Tenger is not a personal god but the sky itself has some divinity if i understood correctly. In Turkish there is a meaning shift in word Tengri. We call it Gök Tengri, i think you call it Kokh Tenger. So apperantly it was meant to be like:
Gök/Kokh = Blue
Tengri/Tenger = Sky
but meaning of the words have changed in modern Turkish so it became:
Gök/Kokh = Sky
Tengri/Tenger = God
So that is why i got confused.
Hungarian here! Although we live in central europe, we originally came from an area neighboring Mongolia, and some of these words carried over into our language as well. As far as I understand, a central point in Tengri is that everything in our world is a reflection of the world of gods. Of course, special attention is always given to the blue sky: when you look down, the thing which serves as the reflection to the eternal blue skies (Tengri) is the sea itself. And thus, the hungarian word for sea became "tenger".
Despite the fact that Hungarians travelled to the other end of the Eurasian continent and took up Christianity in the 10th century, this word survived, which I think is pretty amazing.
As a Mongolian person, I assure you he is proud singing his country side, steppes and its beautiful nature. Almost like he is imaging the images in his head. 🙃
I know, he saw this video and was very happy 😊
Throat singing is an amazing art, truly amazing .
I have a CD from The Hu. I love them so much! Did this man sing on any of their songs?
Here in America we like the band the Hu and it's a form of rock .
Beautiful, stirring music.
From the painting, to singing, to instruments, they exude passion for life and excitement. I love how they immediately try something new, so cool.
Intersting that the man compared it to an animal roaring because an Arabic emissary described the singing of the Vikings as being like animals or dogs and some have interpreted this to mean the Vikings had throat singing
He didn't mean in any offensive way though.
@@TRYBALS ruclips.net/video/QRg_8NNPTD8/видео.html&ab_channel=Heilung ... Viking music with a lot of Views, maybe your friends would like it!
interesting!!
No but the Norse have singing styles that were similar without harmonizing dual tones
Hey, I didn't expect to find you here lol
i'm am always touched by how lovely this group of people are. Mongolian throat singing is so touching it gets to the heart, I always thought it was just me but seeing their unanimous reaction, has led me to see that it is a soul connection type of thing.
Much love and many blessings to your lovely tribal people! xoxo
Sme bro I seem Mongolian music not just a music but a deep meditation ..the hu, batsoric , hangai💓
Nirban Gogoi … For me as well
Sarah Tonen … The soul connection has more energy and is more powerful than anything ❤️
@21brothers21 ..really brother 🤘
Sarah….PS love your handle
The older guy is cool. I love the way he appreciates the beauty of skills he sees in different people. Such an amazing soul
Wise old man
Yep. He was moved profoundly by our Mongolian friend's gift.
He is very cool
I am generally a very cynical person, but: This. This is what the internet is supposed be for. People simply appreciating others' cultures. Thank you for this & greetings from Germany.
This is the good side of RUclips. If the website was burning down, this is the content worth running into the fire to save
Das stimmt. Die Leute ziehen nicht über die Musiker her, sie versuchen stattdessen Verständnis zu finden. Sehr nett und freundlich, alle dort.
if you are cynical that's due to the environment you are in... we're humans, we conform to what we set ourselves around
100% agree
And Germans have their ancient tribal songs I mean time of tribalism not times of judeo christianity.
Greetings from Mongolia! I've just found this channel, watched every single video and instantly loved these beautiful tribal people. They're so genuine and passionate about new things. And I really love these passions. This traditional Mongolian art piece is called "Huumii or Hoomii" in Mongolian. Actually, there are very rare people professionalized this art and rest of the Mongolians usually do admire this piece of art. Throat singing usually contains positive meanings and express further good will to everyone. It is very ancient heritage that the most of urban people couldn't understand the lyrics word by word, because it is heavy accented. I was so grateful and happy to see them enjoying our traditional thing. I would be so glad to let them know that whole world is watching you beautiful people and even the far east region, Mongolian people do watch them as well.
Thank you, we are so thankful to the beautiful people of Mongolia like Mr Batzorigh to keep this tradition alive and share with the world. I hope you are enjoying our content. Thanks again for all the love and support 🤗❤️😊🌷
Hi from Australia, mate! Thanks for the info, brother. I watch a lot of Mongolian content on RUclips. You have some really talented artists out there!
Such incredible perspective you are providing not only to these wonderful people, but to us westerners as well, this is the best use of internet, to show us all the difference and similarities! Also as a music teacher i continue to find more similarities than differences in the way we all feel rhythm and song, a language with no translation necessary. Keep it up!!
Very true!
So true bro. Greetings from Germany.
Music is the best
4:00 wow this guy was really impacted by Bob Ross haha That was a good episode, I liked seeing the reactors paint so well
Bob Ross legit changed that dude's life.
Look at the way he’s smiling at the music too. He clearly has a very artistic spirit. It’s a shame that he’s only getting to explore that for the first time as an older gentleman
These people are all pretty wholesome. I wish them all the best.
P. S. You're definitely getting better at the video editing. Well done.
Thank you 😊
Yes, the cutting in of the video clip showing the playing of the traditional Pakistani "chang" (Jew's harp) was excellent!
I loved the way the split-screen effect showed everybody sat there slightly stunned/in awe of the singing except Muharam who was just grooving away at the top! Perhaps they could watch some opera or ballet for a future video?
Yes, I had to think of "Der Hölle Rache kocht in meinem Herzen" from the Mozart opera Die Zauberflöte (The magic flute) immediately
Edit: "kocht" instead of "tobt"
I wish they had used a clip with Batzorig doing sygyt like in “Mongolian Throat Singing With My Daughter” Then we would see some eye popping reactions…and get to see his sweet daughter for the man who hoped for passing down the skill.
Loved seeing their fingers or hands move up in the air at the same time
love how so many of these folks started singing along. music touches something even deeper than the soul.
I think this mongolian music was an excellent choice. The older gentleman has an open mind and is sincerely interested. I admire him. When he said that the mongolian singer would be a good man to have a chat with and to have him as a friend, made me cry. This is beautiful and I agree. I appreciate that you don't always just introduce western things. Greetings and much love from Germany.
Right!?! I want to befriend and chat with both of them
Music is universal. It unites all people across all cultures. Thank you for sharing with us. Excellent video.
I absolutely love how open and appreciative they each are for every new experience. Such a wonderful group of people. Many blessings to all of them and all of the Trybals team.
I really want that one guy to hear some more Michael jackson!
I have something very special for that video. You'll have to wait but it'll be worth it! 😊
@@TRYBALS Hey, I'd like to see what they think about women singing like this, there are Turkic people that do it and Native Americans too
Anyone who likes BOTH Michael Jackson and Mongolian Throat Singing has a very wide appreciation for music. And he is a darn good drummer too!
I love listening to Mongolian, Tuvan, and Inuit throat singing! Inuit ts calms me like nothing else. Inuit throat singing at shepherds of good hope is a short video I have saved whenever an anxiety attack is coming on.
I'm glad tech has made it easier for us to share our worlds with each other.
Not to mention sardinian throat singing
Have you heard Shinanova?
The old man of the turban, what a great man. So gentle and really thankful by this music.
I love his attitude.
You should look into showing them tribal/folk musics from all over the world!!!
Kpop be dope!
Native American drum music is wild ride sometimes.
On my main channel, I prepare videos with subtitles in 3 different languages for folk music of different nations. You are also invited. :))
An example of one of the videos:
ruclips.net/video/vRp9EVrV77I/видео.html
Bluegrass is folk music from my home region (East Tennessee, U.S.A.)
I agree that I would like the whole channel to jsut be this. Cultural music from around the world
"His music is heavy and so is his voice, I am enjoying it"-me after a good metal song
Look up "The Hu" on RUclips.You won't be disappointed.
Awesome, Mongolian music has long been my favorite music, and Batzorig among them. The tribespeople were all very openminded and considerate and it was nice when the instrument he mentioned was shown to us so that we could compare. This is one of the better try channels. I would love to hear the stars of this channel making a little music, if they feel comfortable doing so. I hope the little child gets water to go with their snack.
Thank you 🙏🤗😊🌷❤️
This is so great! Showing them different forms of dance and instruments would be awesome! Ballet, Hakka, Pow wow. The possibilities are endless.
I do love to listen to throat singing, it is right up there with native american singing and the wind flute.
Yes, you are right. And the Sami/ Laplanders also use throat singing. Take a look: ruclips.net/video/tU-np8zS4HQ/видео.html
Gorgeous, isn't it?
@@JariDawnchild Yes, indeed, Mary. Very beautiful.
I'm glad you spliced in their jaw harp he compared the singing to. It's nice to get glimpses into their cultures as well
The gorgeous woman in purple and her baby are both equally adorable! So great to see hard working women make their debut on open minded channels such as this. Thank you, and keep up the good work! 💕
(Also, the edit showing the (local?) instrument this singing resembled was very helpful! Many thanks.)
Hey Olivia, thank you 🤗❤️😊
pretty cool, this is the first time I'm hearing this Mongolian kind of singing. He's really using his voice as another kind of instrument
One of the things to listen for with throat singing is the sort of whistling noise going on above the main voice. It’s a human making two pitches at once.
@@ogolthorp Yes, overtone singing. (Always practiced in other singing traditions).
What a great video. This has quickly become one of my favorite channels to just relax and enjoy at the end of the day. I'd love to hear Paarvati sing.
Thank you for such compliments. Yes, we'll encourage her to sing someday. While I'll get Abdul a Dambora 😊
Tribal karaoke session?
Me too! I wholeheartedly second that.
Please ask her if she would like to share a song with us!
The Mughals were descendants of the Mongols. Turks-mongol music is known in the Indian subcontinent.
Yes...our ancestor also contributes to Indian Subcontinent, from slave to powerful empire...even after that we adopt Persian culture
If u wanna see how Turks and Indian mixed up, you can see Shroff family (Jackie and Tiger) becausr their ancestor having Uyghur Turk blood
@@uyghurmalay4155 bullshit, his mother is from myanmar
@@laalgoli8217 Jackie's Mother side is Uyghur from Central Asia, and his father is Gujarati Hindu
@@uyghurmalay4155 You have no right and shame to speak of culture and and contributions for you did nothing.
@@mightoftradition5586fuck that, I'm still speaks it. And Yes, if no Turks involvment, no India as people know today
hi, new subscriber here. this channel showed up in my feed several days ago & i'm glad it did. from now on, it's part of my therapy, recovering from depression. these people have such a fresh outlook on life that i have slowly lost. thank you for sharing~
Thank you for honoring us with such compliments 🙏🤗❤️😊🌷 I pray to God for your recovery and know that we all are with you ❤️
God Bless and Keep You.
@@evermore4487 God bless you too Teri, stay safe 🌷
Batzorig is NOICE!! it is so Wonderful to share with the world. internet isn't all bad. BLESS!!
Batzorig makes some beautiful music im surprised this didnt show up as a suggestion earlier
I love this channel and I feel grateful we can get wisdom and insight from the Trybals
Mad props to the editing and production!! Loving this very much.
Thank you, producer, cameraman, editor, manager it's all me for now lol
@@TRYBALS Good job!
I can only imagine the time it takes to do these. He certainly has a talent for it!
Thank you Jenny, it's all worth it when I read such comments ❤️
I love how easily he was able to identify the racial relationship between Indonesians and Mongolians
The culturescape expands ever forth!
Throat singing is also a thing in the Inuit tribe in north America
Did not expect to see you here.
Im Indonesian and Indonesians are very racially diverse.. some look like pakistani/indians in Aceh, sumatra, east java some look like Mongols in North Sulawesi/Borneo/west java, some look like Africans in Papua.. the guy probably meant Filipinos because Phillipines is closer to mainland China/Mongolia. But Indonesia, its quite a distance from Mongolia
@@patriot4786 Mongolians has nothing commun with Indonesians 😂 apart they are both mongoloid. Mongolia is like 6thousands kilometers norther
At the heart all people are simple and loving. The society and many times We ourselves condition ourselves.
I really liked the old man Abdul. He is very broad minded. Simplicity of the others is too, very charming.
I honestly love these videos. There would be no other way to mix and show culture in this way. Absolutely amazing!
I really wish the world would be filled with people like them. They are all simple, humble, spiritual and loving towards others. I would love to have them as my friends and neighbours.
I’m honestly really enjoying how intrigued and curious everyone of them are when they were listening to Batzorig. Abdul seems to be the most curious, since I’ve noticed he leans forward to listen intently. What a bunch of wholesome individuals. I wouldn’t consider myself the most social person, but I would love to share a meal with Abdul.
What is the name of the man with the turban? He is great! Reminds me of my father. Looks like him, that is. And appreciates new things, as well.
Hey his name is Abdul Aziz, he belongs to a tribe of Rind Balochs. OMG can you send us a picture of your dad???
@@TRYBALS he looks so epic, that beard is 10/10
I would LOVE to hear their music and songs!! Thank you for bringing these beautiful people to us. They have become very special to me.
Wow throat singing is so relaxing.......and fucking awesome
Here is more throat singing, from the Sami people of Northern Scandinavia: ruclips.net/video/tU-np8zS4HQ/видео.html
Throat singing has roots so old no one can find where and by what people it was first developed. It touches something in me I hadn't realized was looking for it.
Keep up the lovely work! and you and the people seem like you are wonderful souls
Everytime one of them started singing along it was amazing. They have great singing voices themselves! 😊
Muharam, your rhythm while you were drumming on the table was amazing, had me wanting to dance.
Thank you for showing and being so respectful to my culture 💗💗💗
HAGSHXKJSHZHFJKDJSGDHF HIM TRYING TO SING WITH IS SO ADORABLE 💗💗💗 DONT WORRY everyone sucks in the beginning, i never learned so if i were to attempt i'd sound like a dying goose 😂😂
❤️❤️❤️🤗
@@ThirrinDiamond I took an hour workshop (which is too short to learn much) on throat singing. It is very difficult.
@@Catlily5 I'm too poor to travel to interesting places to learn it, and I want to. Do you know of any reputable online content toward that end?
@@JariDawnchild No, I took an hour class at a local Folk Festival. So unless you live in N.M. I can't recommend anything.
i feel so pleased with this video and i LOVED the editing, they touched my heart with their comments, is so cool that you are showing them so nice stuff about our world, im so happy they have the oportunity to see the rest of us is this planet as we have the oportunity to be aware of the existence of this beautiful people in Pakistan, thank you for your work on the channel!
Thank you so much for appreciating my efforts 🤗❤️😊🌷
I love watching their reactions. I wouldn't mind a little bit from them with what music they know.
This is my new favourite channel! I love these wonderful human beings thoughts and opinions.
🤗❤️🌷
That one gentleman mentioned he had listened to Michael Jackson & that made me think I would love to see tribal people to react to MJ's "Earth Song" with a translation of his lyrics. I cry every time I see the video. It's such a good message & very powerful beautiful video.
Watching this channel never ceases to bring me joy
What I love about these people is that they see stuff totally strange to them, and truely and openly appreciate it for what it is. It's such a different image of what we usually get to see of people from these countries.
I love these videos. I am actually crying from the beauty of cultures appreciating other cultures. They are so gracious with something so different.
I wish that attitude was more prevalent here.
My love and respect for them! Love this channel and I wish it gets bigger and bigger with many subscribers around the world! 😊 greetings from Brazil, south America 🇧🇷
I absolutely love the drumming on the table. There's something very magical about the regional drum rhythms. Absolutely fascinating to learn the different names for the instruments. You are all such beautiful people , I send my love and respect to you all.
Mongolian throat singing is an amazing art. In fact, Mongolia is a superb land. The land of blue sky. People are awesome. Love Mongolia ❤️
We should go visit there and meet Batzorig
“He makes me happy inside.” What they recognize as a ‘Dambura’ reminded me of a Croatian relative telling me of his native country’s ‘Tamburica’.
I am so happy you picked the mighty Batzroig to show them! He is a great treasure to the world and all who study Khoomei or any extended vocal techniques. He is a wonderful teacher. Wela'lin!
i am so happy to hear people from other countries are as happy as i was when i first heard him, i think he is teaching,not only grandkids but others as well,
Throat singing takes tons of practice. I love that, as usual, the old man figures out what it is before even seening/hearing it.
Guy's a genius.
i don't watch reaction videos much but this channel randomly appeared in my recommended and i watched every video immediately. seeing them try things they've never seen or heard of before, and maybe never thought even possible, is such a joy and i hope that trybals continues to grow so that they can experience so much more!
Thank you so much, your love and support would mean alot to us :)
I think it would be fun to see how they react to Powwow Regalia dance contest and Drum Circles. The Indigenous peoples of Canada and the U.S. have very interesting cultures and gather to sing and dance and share their culture. These gatherings are called Pow Wow.
This was such a great reaction video! Thank your for sharing this. I really enjoyed seeing all these wonderful people again: relating it to things they've experienced, being so open minded and in awe of a totally different skill. And Muharam drumming on the table - I could listen to that all day!
Muharam is such a natural at gaining skills and he doesn’t realize it! 🌞
Again, I send my appreciation for your work. Your videos make me laugh and they make me cry; they fill my heart.
I was curious to hear if they liked it or not. Awesome that they did and recognized the difficulty and beauty of throat singing. Awesome reactions!
This channel deserves more subscribers 👏🏻
I would like to see them react to more music genres
All my time watching your channel I always thought your Ustads were musicians. I’m amazed to hear today that most of them have never played or performed. Amazing that they have such passion and understanding of music.
They are all so adorable, so pure with their reactions
I love these videos so much because these people are always so effusive with their praise. No matter what it is they’re reacting to, they’re so honest and feel free to share their emotions and feelings. It’s so refreshing. Thanks for sharing again and again!
Thanks 🤗❤️😊🌷
I love how this channel allows these lovelies to discover the western arts, unlike most that concentrate on snacks and sensationalism, this has real meat on the bone, congratz :)
Glad you enjoy it!
Mongolia isn't western art... But other than that yes it's a very good channel
I love watching different cultures appreciate and respect different cultures. This channel is awesome and i hope everyone involved has much prosperity!
I'd love to see them react to some other types of overtone singing.
Amazing! How not to love Batzorig? His music introduced me to throat singing and opened me to a whole new world, I'm glad they liked it, actually made me tear up a bit
Batzorig Vaanchig does teach his young daughter to sing in some of his videos.
The drumming on the table sounded awesome!
I have never listened to Mongolian throat singing either so I really enjoyed hearing it to the first time via this video. I felt like I was reacting along with them. Love this video
Oh everyone knows MJ. I asked Mukhtiar he says I just know the name but don't know who he was though. I was surprised by his answer and he told me everyone knows that name even in very remote villages. Strange but true.
These reactions are very heartwarming sometimes. Wonderful!
i really really like how open minded these people are... i tried to make some people i know listen to mongolian throat singing (and other kind of "ethnic" music like indonesian gamalan) and they just laugh AT the musicians call them stupid and mock them, just being judgmental like most western people are while these people that are exposed to less or have less access to different things are much more openminded and while they sometimes laugh it is not a mean spirited judgmental laugh AT the people but just a WOW surprised kind of laugh
Who would make nasty comments?
You may or not like it but otherwise is ignorant of other peiple and cultures
Hope u make more inlightened friends
I tried getting my family listen to Chinese Bus Chenyu's music 'Nunchucks' and the Korean pop singer/dancers BlackPink... They're just not interested.
I think sometimes people fall into subcultures and develop this group identity over the silliest things. "Oh, I'm a _listens to pop music_ person. I don't listen to _this."_ Cue lots of stupid, pointless meanness and bickering.
Honestly, probably one of the biggest things I miss about my childhood is how blissfully unaware I was about toxic fandoms -- I could just like what I liked without feeling self-conscious about whatever "fandom" I was getting lumped in with, and I didn't feel like having different tastes from someone else was somehow putting them down. We just liked different things, and if they were going to be weird about it then that was their problem.
i love when they try singing along!! you can see and genuine and pure they are! so happy i found this channel💗
Not very often a group of people are unanimous in compliments..
Kudos to them too.
What I have found watching your videos is that we have so much more in common than we have that's different. This just fills me with hope
i love to hear this..... i wish they could talk more about similarities and show how us all are similar !
Another very fine production. Thank you to all involved. As with your recent Bob Ross videos, the cross-cultural appreciation is sincere and, frankly, quite moving.
I'm so touched by these videos. This one is so beautiful. And I wanna listen to Batzorig too! Also can't wait to watch them singing, must be beautiful.
The sore throat comment was so wholesome and hilarious
Bless them, they were all amazed and happy to hear such spiritual sounds .
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE have them watch the band The Hu (song wolf totem, in particular, PLEASE) now that they’ve heard traditional Mongolian thirst singing. That might rock their worlds! Who knows? But, boy, I’d sure LOVE to see that video and I know I’m not alone!!! 💜💜💜 Much love from Ohio, USA
Sure, will do that soon 😊
YES this is an awesome song
The Hu are excellent, I absolutely love them.
I don't know if they're ready for The Hu yet. Lol. Wolf Totem is awesome!
Namaste
I absolutely love everyone and all that they bring in all these videos! Just such beautiful people, minds, and spirits!
I really enjoyed the Mongolian throat singing. The sound very much reminded me of the didgeridoo. Can you find a recording of the didgeridoo for them to see and hear please?
"Because his beard is not full grown." Stroking his elegant wizardly whiskers for emphasis. 8:05
I am surprised that you didn't show them songs from The Hu too. Wolf Totem is probably the most well known one. I like the remix of it too.
Maybe you can show those too. 😎
I think they need an introduction to some rock and metal first for that. Just my opinion, feel free to correct me if I am wrong 😊
@@TRYBALS You’re not wrong. Why show them westernized versions? Well done for showing them the traditional music. Much more interesting in my opinion.
@@TRYBALS Yes, Metallica, Rage Against the Machine, and System of a Down
I am so blessed to have found this channel! What amazing, genuine people with full hearts! God bless all of them
You are so kind! God bless you too
My man busting out a raggaeton beat pretty well while saying "I don't know if this is good"