I have a 2008 ford focus all i use are motercraft filters. Original engine and transmission i just hit 495k miles. I do an oil change every 5k miles with motercraft oil. So ill stick to the motercraft.
Thanks, Pete and Mckenzie. The Donaldson is well built and clean. The Motorcraft was just sloppy. I agree with Mckenzie. A bigger filter offers more filter media. God knows that V 10 has plenty of oil to filter. Over the years, I know guys who find larger filters that fit their applications. Ironically, they usually found a larger Motorcraft that would fit their Dodge or Chevy engine.
I agree with you, Donaldson. It has more threads because how heavy/big it is. I would have gone with Motorcraft, but that glue is hideous. I hear a lot of complaints with glue coming off. & seeing it in the oil. 👍
In the "bigger is better" contest, the Donaldson definitely would be the choice. The one question mark is the bypass setting - if the Donaldson is in the same range as the Motorcraft, you definitely get much more from the Donaldson except for excess glue which the Motorcraft wins. Plus the Donaldson has my preference of a coil spring and a thicker can(n)ister.
If there's something I can take from these videos where an aftermarket is compared to an OEM, it's that in most cases with many applications, OEM filter is never a bad choice, but there's several aftermarket filters that offer better for less.
There are many instances where a larger filter can be substituted, I will always go for the biggest one possible as more capacity is always better - the donaldson filters look pretty solid, I’ve never seen them before
The only reason I use a large version of a filter is for Oil capacity. My car uses the same filter that a Lawn tractor uses, but with 4X the oil. Due to that, instead of a FL910 I use the FL1A or equivalent by Purolator. Cost is exactly the same. I also like the larger filter for lower restriction and higher flow rate with the same micron rating.
So nice of McKenzi! Another great comparison! Donaldson has so much more filter media. Definitely would pick Donaldson! “Bigger is Better” in this case. Thanks for sharing this video with us! A Great Weekend to You and Your Viewers! 👍😊
They changed the number of "points" or flats on the end of the can on the 820s a couple years ago and the old cap wrench won't fit the newer ones, probably when Mann + Hummel took over.
A lot of folks never knew that Ford/Motorcraft oil and air filters for Ford 6.0 diesels are actually Donaldson made in Germany 🇩🇪 as well. 😏🤷♂️👍🏻. Donaldson are for heavy duty and off road use because of all the dirt they hold to reduce field service intervals.
Great video Whip, Donaldson ftw and it's not even close. I use bigger filters on everything and have never had an issue. Lately all the motocrap filters have had tons of excess glue. Donaldson makes great filters mainly for diesel applications.
The donaldson by far is the better choice ! The only thing i would question is the micron rating ! My other question is what the heck happened to motorcraft filters ? i remember them being alot more cleaner !
A larger oil filter will offer more dirt holding capacity because it was designed to filter a larger volume of oil. Unless the owner plans on yearly / extended oil changes for 20,000 miles or more, then there is little to no benefit in using it over the smaller one. Great video!
@@GT-mn3bx I agree I would NEVER go 20 k. But many people are buying into the annual hype and are going 20k on some of the high end synthetic oil like mobil 1, amsoil etc.
I think the Donaldson is a better made filter. If there is a benefit to that much larger size, double pretty much, should have lower internal resistance to flow because of more area of media and more holes for the oil to flow, which to me means the oil pump is working a little less trying to push oil thru the filter, then the engine. Probably could go 2 oil changes at least on the Donaldson filter.
IMO bigger is not better. Depends on the application. Put your thumb over a garden hose you increase pressure without increasing volume. Too big of a filter can cause a significant drop in oil pressure. A person brought me a 2011 6.0 PPV Caprice that they were convinced the oil pump was dying. They changed the oil sending unit 3 times and couldn't get rid of the oil light. I took off the Napa filter and put the oem pinhead ac Delco on it problem fixed.
The big disadvantage of the Donaldson filter is that the center core has a straight/vertical seam instead of a spiral seam. Straight seams are more susceptible to splitting in extreme oil pressure situations. The American manufacturers that use steel cores use the spiral seam. We remember gm cars that had faulty oil pump pressure relief springs....
All that sloppy excess glue on the motorcraft immediately disqualifies it with me. Dammit, that drives me crazy. I'd use the Doanldson for sure. My only concern would be if the extra long case would hang too low and below the chassis line. if it does not, use it, if it does, you could get it caugh on something and that would be very very bad, and I would suggest finding another brand. I like those filtrons but you can't get them here. But if there is enough clearance, use it with confidence.
Love your videos! If we wanted to send you a filter to look at, what is the best way to contact you? I have an interesting situation with a filter that I just used only to "De-gunk" an engine with Motor Flush and there's a lot of sludge on the base plate, and I figure there's going to be some interesting stuff inside as well.
That Motorcraft filter sure has a lot of GLUE on it. As i stated on one of your previous videos, Mann and Hummel (purolator) has a problem with quality control in their manufacturing. Employees are not doing proper quality control checks and either people or computers are not applying the proper amount of glue to the product. Might be smart to go with the Donaldson filter, Morocraft is not cutting the mustard any more!
On this Particular Comparison I would use Donaldson over Motorcraft. Donaldson has more filter paper then Motorcraft and is bigger. Motorcraft Oil Filters can be a Hit or a Miss. Motorcraft oil filters do have filter paper to filter full synthetic and High Performance Engine oils like Royal Purple, Redline, Amsoil and Liqui Moli. But everything else inside is cheaply made. On 2015 to Present Ford Mustang GT the Ford Racing Filter is a Hit and Motorcraft Filter is a Miss.
Use what got him to 300,000+ miles, or go with something else. The 20k supertech is more consistent than motorcraft currently and has better filtration than the Donaldson.
Whip, can you do a comparison between the Motorcraft Fl 1995A and the Donaldson P550371 for the 7.3 Powerstroke? I use both of these and was curious how they compare. Thanks!
Whip you are ole so right. The Donaldson is the way to go. I do like the elongated holes and silicone anti drain back valve of tthe Motorcraft. The amount of threads in the base plate goes to the Donaldson. I love upper bypass valves, so that goes to the Motorcraft. Center tube goes to Donaldson for the use of numerous holes verses louvers of the Motorcraft. Filtering media goes to Donaldson because of the amount of filtering media used compared to the Motorcraft. The compression spring definitely goes to the Donaldson for the use of a coil spring over that crappy leaf spring of the Motorcraft. The Motorcraft has a very sloppy glue job compared to the clean Donaldson. The canister goes to Donaldson. The Donaldson is what I would use if it were my vehicle.
I wouldn't use an oversize in this application because the oversized filters are Heavy-Duty/Application Specific filters that are pretty expensive special order parts that don't seem to be all that efficient, I'd just stick with the standard size since they can be easily found at local department stores and parts stores easily and for as little as a few bucks if you want something better for that application I'd use a Fram FE2.
I've always thought Motorcraft made great filters. The last few you've opened up seem pretty sloppy. I think I would go with something else if I drove a Ford now.
Bit confused by these two filters. Is this Donaldson new old stock as the EEC ceased in 1993, became the EC then the EU in 2009. I can’t decipher the date, could be 2021 but sometimes the first number can be the year. The Motorcraft seems so sloppy could it be a Fake?
That MotorCraft filter is definitely a MotorCrap filter looking at the glue job & the thin can 💩🚽,all that extra glue the media looks like a used roll of toilet paper 🧻 with wipe on it ....definitely take the Donaldson over the MotorCrap filter
No excuse for sloppy glue on Motorcraft filters. Have watched RUclips videos of kids assembling oil filters in India that have similar looking glue everywhere.
I have a 2008 ford focus all i use are motercraft filters. Original engine and transmission i just hit 495k miles. I do an oil change every 5k miles with motercraft oil. So ill stick to the motercraft.
Wow, That's Great! Thanks for Sharing👍
When it comes to actually filtering oil, lab tests, it's hard to beat the Motorcraft filters.
Donaldson for the win.💪👍👍
Thanks, Dan👍
Nah, Motorcraft
► Thanks For Watching!
I try and make an oil filter inspection video every Friday on this RUclips Channel, Thank You! 👍
I have a new and used denso filter for teardown. Do you have po box I can send to please?
@@Sw-so4zj Send me an email and let me know what you have to, Poker4me007@gmail.com
Thanks, Pete and Mckenzie. The Donaldson is well built and clean. The Motorcraft was just sloppy. I agree with Mckenzie. A bigger filter offers more filter media. God knows that V 10 has plenty of oil to filter. Over the years, I know guys who find larger filters that fit their applications. Ironically, they usually found a larger Motorcraft that would fit their Dodge or Chevy engine.
You're Welcome Jonathan, and
Thanks👍
Unfortunately, especially lately, I think the Donaldsons are better made than the Motorcrafts.
I agree with you, Donaldson. It has more threads because how heavy/big it is. I would have gone with Motorcraft, but that glue is hideous. I hear a lot of complaints with glue coming off. & seeing it in the oil. 👍
Thanks, Rice👍
In the "bigger is better" contest, the Donaldson definitely would be the choice. The one question mark is the bypass setting - if the Donaldson is in the same range as the Motorcraft, you definitely get much more from the Donaldson except for excess glue which the Motorcraft wins. Plus the Donaldson has my preference of a coil spring and a thicker can(n)ister.
Thanks, Jeff👍
both brands are manufactured by Fluitek.
If there's something I can take from these videos where an aftermarket is compared to an OEM, it's that in most cases with many applications, OEM filter is never a bad choice, but there's several aftermarket filters that offer better for less.
Thanks, Doug👍
There are many instances where a larger filter can be substituted, I will always go for the biggest one possible as more capacity is always better - the donaldson filters look pretty solid, I’ve never seen them before
The only reason I use a large version of a filter is for Oil capacity. My car uses the same filter that a Lawn tractor uses, but with 4X the oil. Due to that, instead of a FL910 I use the FL1A or equivalent by Purolator. Cost is exactly the same. I also like the larger filter for lower restriction and higher flow rate with the same micron rating.
If it fits sure, the FL1A is almost an inch bigger in diameter than the FL910, and about 2 inches taller.
Thanks👍
So nice of McKenzi! Another great comparison! Donaldson has so much more filter media. Definitely would pick Donaldson! “Bigger is Better” in this case. Thanks for sharing this video with us! A Great Weekend to You and Your Viewers! 👍😊
Thanks, Ella
Have a Great Weekend Also👍
Thanks whip. Here supporting your great channel with full watch 👍
Thank you my freind👍
They changed the number of "points" or flats on the end of the can on the 820s a couple years ago and the old cap wrench won't fit the newer ones, probably when Mann + Hummel took over.
Well, Mann and Hummel own Purolator so who knows.
Thanks!
A lot of folks never knew that Ford/Motorcraft oil and air filters for Ford 6.0 diesels are actually Donaldson made in Germany 🇩🇪 as well. 😏🤷♂️👍🏻. Donaldson are for heavy duty and off road use because of all the dirt they hold to reduce field service intervals.
Thanks, Tom👍
I would use whatever size filter got him to 330,000 miles. Ford does recommend the silicone adbv for the Triton engines.
Thanks👍
Happy Friday My Friend Great Video WhipCity
Thanks Wrenching👍
Happy Friday and have a Great Weekend!
The Donaldson seems to be the better of the two. Again, as always, great review and sharing.😊. Take care. Merri 😊
Thanks Merri👍
Have a great weekend!
Great video Whip, Donaldson ftw and it's not even close. I use bigger filters on everything and have never had an issue. Lately all the motocrap filters have had tons of excess glue. Donaldson makes great filters mainly for diesel applications.
Thanks, Cody👍
Glad you liked the video😊
The donaldson by far is the better choice ! The only thing i would question is the micron rating ! My other question is what the heck happened to motorcraft filters ? i remember them being alot more cleaner !
Thanks, Scotty👍
A larger oil filter will offer more dirt holding capacity because it was designed to filter a larger volume of oil. Unless the owner plans on yearly / extended oil changes for 20,000 miles or more, then there is little to no benefit in using it over the smaller one. Great video!
Nobody in their right mind is going 20K. Blackstone Lab reports show most vehicles can go 7500+/- tops. Cleaner oil is better oil.
Thanks, Mike👍
@@GT-mn3bx I agree I would NEVER go 20 k. But many people are buying into the annual hype and are going 20k on some of the high end synthetic oil like mobil 1, amsoil etc.
Trump 2024
Thank you for your videos.
You're Welcome Jensen👍
Thanks!
Good video Pete
Thanks, John👍
Glad you liked it😊
He lives in my town!! I use motorcraft filters on my 04 superduty but seems like their quality went way down.
I think the Donaldson is a better made filter. If there is a benefit to that much larger size, double pretty much, should have lower internal resistance to flow because of more area of media and more holes for the oil to flow, which to me means the oil pump is working a little less trying to push oil thru the filter, then the engine. Probably could go 2 oil changes at least on the Donaldson filter.
Motorcraft quality has gone down the toilet.
IMO bigger is not better. Depends on the application. Put your thumb over a garden hose you increase pressure without increasing volume. Too big of a filter can cause a significant drop in oil pressure. A person brought me a 2011 6.0 PPV Caprice that they were convinced the oil pump was dying. They changed the oil sending unit 3 times and couldn't get rid of the oil light. I took off the Napa filter and put the oem pinhead ac Delco on it problem fixed.
The big disadvantage of the Donaldson filter is that the center core has a straight/vertical seam instead of a spiral seam. Straight seams are more susceptible to splitting in extreme oil pressure situations. The American manufacturers that use steel cores use the spiral seam. We remember gm cars that had faulty oil pump pressure relief springs....
Even though the Donaldson filter may not be more solid, the Donaldson filter has so much more area
Thanks Jim,
The Donaldson looks to be very solid to me, no less solid than the Motorcraft.
All that sloppy excess glue on the motorcraft immediately disqualifies it with me. Dammit, that drives me crazy. I'd use the Doanldson for sure. My only concern would be if the extra long case would hang too low and below the chassis line. if it does not, use it, if it does, you could get it caugh on something and that would be very very bad, and I would suggest finding another brand. I like those filtrons but you can't get them here. But if there is enough clearance, use it with confidence.
Thanks, Jim👍
The last couple of Motorcraft filters you've opened have been a mess. I won't be using Motorcraft filters in the future.
Hi Gary
I wouldn't use them either unless they start getting better.
Love your videos!
If we wanted to send you a filter to look at, what is the best way to contact you? I have an interesting situation with a filter that I just used only to "De-gunk" an engine with Motor Flush and there's a lot of sludge on the base plate, and I figure there's going to be some interesting stuff inside as well.
Sure, Thanks!
Just send me an email to, Poker4me007@gmail.com
That Motorcraft filter sure has a lot of GLUE on it. As i stated on one of your previous videos, Mann and Hummel (purolator) has a problem with quality control in their manufacturing. Employees are not doing proper quality control checks and either people or computers are not applying the proper amount of glue to the product. Might be smart to go with the Donaldson filter, Morocraft is not cutting the mustard any more!
Thanks, Dave👍
On this Particular Comparison I would use Donaldson over Motorcraft. Donaldson has more filter paper then Motorcraft and is bigger. Motorcraft Oil Filters can be a Hit or a Miss. Motorcraft oil filters do have filter paper to filter full synthetic and High Performance Engine oils like Royal Purple, Redline, Amsoil and Liqui Moli. But everything else inside is cheaply made. On 2015 to Present Ford Mustang GT the Ford Racing Filter is a Hit and Motorcraft Filter is a Miss.
Huh? All filters filter all oil types. Marketing jargon is nonsense.
Very informative 👍 full watch
Thanks, missy👍
Use what got him to 300,000+ miles, or go with something else. The 20k supertech is more consistent than motorcraft currently and has better filtration than the Donaldson.
If I remember correctly, I think he does use the Donalson.
Thanks👍
A lot of these European filters look like high quality.
I like Donaldson filter holds more oil and works all the time with more oil.
Donaldson 50 microns? Sloppy Motorcraft? I wouldn't use either one.
Thank You👍
Thank you Pete.
Whip, can you do a comparison between the Motorcraft Fl 1995A and the Donaldson P550371 for the 7.3 Powerstroke? I use both of these and was curious how they compare. Thanks!
It will be a while, but I'll put it on my to do list. Thanks!
Hey friend 😊
Thanks, Bo👍
Whip you are ole so right. The Donaldson is the way to go. I do like the elongated holes and silicone anti drain back valve of tthe Motorcraft. The amount of threads in the base plate goes to the Donaldson. I love upper bypass valves, so that goes to the Motorcraft. Center tube goes to Donaldson for the use of numerous holes verses louvers of the Motorcraft. Filtering media goes to Donaldson because of the amount of filtering media used compared to the Motorcraft. The compression spring definitely goes to the Donaldson for the use of a coil spring over that crappy leaf spring of the Motorcraft. The Motorcraft has a very sloppy glue job compared to the clean Donaldson. The canister goes to Donaldson. The Donaldson is what I would use if it were my vehicle.
Thank You👍
I wouldn't use an oversize in this application because the oversized filters are Heavy-Duty/Application Specific filters that are pretty expensive special order parts that don't seem to be all that efficient, I'd just stick with the standard size since they can be easily found at local department stores and parts stores easily and for as little as a few bucks if you want something better for that application I'd use a Fram FE2.
Thanks, brandon👍
I've always thought Motorcraft made great filters. The last few you've opened up seem pretty sloppy. I think I would go with something else if I drove a Ford now.
Thanks, Joseph👍
Bit confused by these two filters. Is this Donaldson new old stock as the EEC ceased in 1993, became the EC then the EU in 2009. I can’t decipher the date, could be 2021 but sometimes the first number can be the year. The Motorcraft seems so sloppy could it be a Fake?
That MotorCraft filter is definitely a MotorCrap filter looking at the glue job & the thin can 💩🚽,all that extra glue the media looks like a used roll of toilet paper 🧻 with wipe on it ....definitely take the Donaldson over the MotorCrap filter
Thanks, Mark👍
Jay the Florida pool pump motor repair guy. When Service Calls Longwood approved ! that was good info 2 see👨🔧good job !! WCW
Thanks, Jay👍
99% @ 40 microns(you said) or 95% @ 40 microns (on screen print) on the Donaldson. Which is correct?
Sorry about that it's 99% at 40 microns. Hit on the specifications shop.donaldson.com/store/en-us/product/P553315/20857#
No excuse for sloppy glue on Motorcraft filters. Have watched RUclips videos of kids assembling oil filters in India that have similar looking glue everywhere.
👍
Donaldson would flow a lot better..
I think so too.
Thanks👍
That Motorcraft is an embarrassment to any filter claiming O.E. quality.
The glue job on the Motorcraft looks like crap.
The best oil filter is Trump 2024
trump 2024 pounds of KFC grease
Nope. I'll stick with the Motorcraft filter.
Thank You👍
LoL