Never get tired of this performance. It is so dramatic, its progression spot on. The final minutes so intense. The strings make the whole thing sound fuller. The heavy guitar sounds so powerful. If you don't feel anything when listening to this performance, you are dead.
No band will ever match what these guys have been doing over and over and over; just think: match the notes on a 10 or even 22 minute song (Octavarium anyone?) with unbelievably complicated timing in a live concert??? These guys so deserve more recognition!
And the next downfall is even better, it describes the aftershock of the grief of 9/11 and the monster that has been created with such an event. You really can feel terror and the need to build up an ever stronger spirit to beat this monster.
@@RaatoHamse I thjink John Petrucci actually writes most of the lyrics for DT songs I belive, but regardless IMO they are very appropriate. Almost like it's from the point of view of satirically insulting the "martyrdom" of the terrorists is how I've viewed it.
An absolute masterpiece. Brings so many emiotions together at one song. Also brings tears to my eyes when seeing those terrible images of the Twin-towers... Once again, just one epic masterpiece!
Esto es una obra maestra... Sinceramente esa canción se sale del rango ingenioso de todas las composiciones ke he escuchado en mi vida... Es algo más... Esa Canción No se puede encasillar en lo ke es "normal". Parece hecha solo para los oidos de los dioses
I remember when I was little I liked this song so much I had the lyrics printed out and hung on the dresser next to my bed. It was weird because I didn't know what they were singing about.
Is it ironic that, the song is about the attack to New York, there were three New Yorkers in the band at the time, but a canadian wrote the lyrics? Still, it was really appropiate to play in NY, with a full orchestra.
Keren abizzz .... Ingat Masa Sma ... Ingat Masa lalu .. The Dream theater .. Mr Jhon PetrucciLegend guitarist from Another planet .. Indonesian Waiting 4 you .. Keep on ... Bravo TDT
What a haunting account of what so many of us either personally witnessed or watched on our televisions on September 11, 2001 and the months to follow. I hope none of us forget the events of that day. May all those lost rest in peace...
Até agora me perguntando o que são essas viradas do Portnoy! Animal é pouco! E justo numa com orquestra e carregada de sentimento. Dream Theater: alguém aí me avisa quando nascer banda melhor...
For some reason, whenever I see James singing and he goes for the higher notes, his tongue is moving like he was Jabba the Hut, or maybe that's just me. No disrespect to him by the way, just wanted to point that out lol.
yeah. And it sucks in many other places. He is pretty bad when trying to sing high during live. It's not an accident that many people think he's tone deaf when live.
LaBrie's live performances are very hit or miss. Unless he's performing with Ayreon, where his performances are always hit. But this entire concert is LaBrie at his best.
Never get tired of this performance. It is so dramatic, its progression spot on. The final minutes so intense. The strings make the whole thing sound fuller. The heavy guitar sounds so powerful. If you don't feel anything when listening to this performance, you are dead.
Fuck yea!!!! Omg so amazing and so much put into it.
Truth be told, I felt nothing but Sorrow, Anger, and Disgust...
But like a man, I ironically decided to keep it to myself~
Mike Portnoy.
100% agreed
The beast of performance
No band will ever match what these guys have been doing over and over and over; just think: match the notes on a 10 or even 22 minute song (Octavarium anyone?) with unbelievably complicated timing in a live concert??? These guys so deserve more recognition!
Herman van Barneveld
They’re GOD
Sadly, VERY few people appreciate their music.
Love the part between 6:16 - 6:51. It's so "wooow!". Eargasm.
I think that section and the solo from Octavarium are the most powerful parts from the album. This is such an underrated song
+Muhammad Afiful Hashif The orchestra gaves such a special touch in this part
+Admirable Joe octavarium is an epic song but sacrificed sons is the most epic and powerful song on the album. just so beautifully melodic
And the next downfall is even better, it describes the aftershock of the grief of 9/11 and the monster that has been created with such an event. You really can feel terror and the need to build up an ever stronger spirit to beat this monster.
That's why i want Mike back
the 3 voices together so beautiful amazing masters
Yea
6:10 El solo de Petrucci es brutal..
This lineup, specifically at THIS time, was the most perfect fucking band to ever walk this earth
6:13 will never get tired of that part.. always gets me 👏🏼 best band ever
The way portnoy takes them out of the 15/8 section into the 6/8 and the accompanying melodies makes me tear up every now and then 😅
Words are useless to describe this epic song...
Cristian Halmagean LaBrie made awesome lyrics!!
@@RaatoHamse I thjink John Petrucci actually writes most of the lyrics for DT songs I belive, but regardless IMO they are very appropriate. Almost like it's from the point of view of satirically insulting the "martyrdom" of the terrorists is how I've viewed it.
Oh, I meant that LaBrie made lyrics for this song! :)
i agree
Proof that JP is the best guitarist on earth. I am baffled that anyone thinks otherwise
Ahhhhhhhh, I love those parts where MP and JP are singing also!!
me too
Ikr, i hope they start a band together again
6:14 and on is just fucking beautiful
Exactly. Most underrated DT song! That entire orchestral part is one of their best instrumental sections in my opinion.
Goosebumps everytime
Definitely in my Top 5 DT songs. This live DVD is incredible as well. Love the mix, the performances and of course, the lineup.
Just the best song of this album, even better than the title track, litteraly a hidden gem
No, but i agree about the best song.
2018 and still listening to this masterpiece
Franco Mazzeo 2019
2020
2021 :)
June 2021
November 2021 🤘
2020 Who still listening to this song?
Loove youuu Dreaam theater💓
Great band and still love!
Best song in the album! besides Octavarium !!
1:55 is where it gets real. Could rewind 100 times with that guitar with delayed attack
damn labrie still had the voice
virtuosismo en su maximo nivel,petrucci es un animal,la mejor banda de progresivo de todos los tiempos ;)
Easily, the best live performance ever of the best song ever, in the history of music itself. Unbelievable
You know something out of worldly incredible is happening when a classical music conductor is getting high on metal ....
9/11 2018. I think this song perfectly expresses what was seen and felt that day.
6:17 The face by the hypnotizing effect of John Petrucci
An absolute masterpiece. Brings so many emiotions together at one song. Also brings tears to my eyes when seeing those terrible images of the Twin-towers... Once again, just one epic masterpiece!
5:40 - the most badass solo by Petrucci!
one of the best live albums ever
The beauty of this song has made me cry many times.
Love how Portnoy strikes the Cymbals at 7:09 a delightful detail :)
It's so hard to cover jp's solo he is liked a guitar god
They all look really good & clear headed here... so focused! Such great writing & great performance!
~ Goddddd - So Beautiful!
RIP my mouse, keep clickin 6:16 !! T_T
You aren't alone.
F
Wonderful music, amazing lyrics, excquisite perfomance and unforgettable lives !
That's what Dream Theater offers to music civilazation .......
6:17 look at the face of the guy who has glasses :D That's what people always look like after Petrucci's solos.
Esto es una obra maestra... Sinceramente esa canción se sale del rango ingenioso de todas las composiciones ke he escuchado en mi vida... Es algo más... Esa Canción No se puede encasillar en lo ke es "normal". Parece hecha solo para los oidos de los dioses
I think it's safe to say, this song is both magnificent and tremendous.
My favorite JP look as far as beard/hair
Son y serán la mejor banda del maldito universo.
Dream theater once again making music out this existence
6:17 merinding gw bang.. g Ada lawan emg om petruci ini
I remember when I was little I liked this song so much I had the lyrics printed out and hung on the dresser next to my bed. It was weird because I didn't know what they were singing about.
it's about 9/11 tragedy
"Who'll be Coming home tonight" part
made me cried
6:16 On is probably the most beautiful/ badass thing ever.
God, I'm high
Buy me steak
mamesushi136 I'm a steak
Will mankind eat steak?
amish steak the og mishead lyrics video
This means so much more being in New York City.
I was thinking about that.
Is it ironic that, the song is about the attack to New York, there were three New Yorkers in the band at the time, but a canadian wrote the lyrics? Still, it was really appropiate to play in NY, with a full orchestra.
@@branlopgar wait, did James write this?
@@woodenhoe yep
"Words they preach I can't relate, if gods true love are acts of hate."
@telemachia1
possibly one of the most majestic songs i've ever heard!
Keren abizzz .... Ingat Masa Sma ... Ingat Masa lalu .. The Dream theater .. Mr Jhon PetrucciLegend guitarist from Another planet .. Indonesian Waiting 4 you .. Keep on ... Bravo TDT
My favorite album, my favorite song.... Awesome !!!!!!
Não Existe outra banda igual a essa pois eles sim são profissionais .........
Been a fan for almost 4 years but only recently getting into this song. The lyrics are so well written and performed!
Já ouvi umas 100 vezes e não me canso 🤘🤘🤘
What a haunting account of what so many of us either personally witnessed or watched on our televisions on September 11, 2001 and the months to follow. I hope none of us forget the events of that day. May all those lost rest in peace...
00:00-10:36 EPIC.MASTERPIECE
Is there anything more awesome than a kickass prog metal band with an orchestra?
The true Progressive Metal!!!!!!!!
uma das melhores performances do Dream Theater...
Até agora me perguntando o que são essas viradas do Portnoy! Animal é pouco! E justo numa com orquestra e carregada de sentimento.
Dream Theater: alguém aí me avisa quando nascer banda melhor...
I make it a point to listen to this every year on 9/11.
MP is so good at singing backing vocals.
I like how the orchestra just adds to how fucking amazing this already is
Saudade de quando era tudo lindo assim, tempos que não voltam mais. 😢❤
This is one of the rares times then everyone in DT was just PERFECT, this song has not even a note misplaced.
we always wanted to be like mike! no matter what isntrument we play. There's no words to describe what Mr MP mean and represent to music and to me
For some reason, whenever I see James singing and he goes for the higher notes, his tongue is moving like he was Jabba the Hut, or maybe that's just me. No disrespect to him by the way, just wanted to point that out lol.
Melhor do que a original do cd.
Ainda prefiro o cd, mas foi Espetacular mesmo!
People at DT gigs have the time of there live.. Its so great to see that, Best band
Look at Mike at 9:11 pointing to John to stand closer to the public during this segment of the song.
yeah .. 9:11
@MrMyungFan
i so agree!! And sooo much better than the album edition. Pure love!
Versão MUITO superior ao do álbum de estúdio.
Esse solo do Petrucci é de escorrer lágrimas dos olhos
We can't , we can't play better than this
Portnoy is still the best drummer on the planet.
Period
Yes.
what about sean reinhert
fumiya from galneryus is
Stephen Recchia agreed
Most tasteful I'd say. He nows what a song needs.
MIKE PORTNOY
The last 35 minutes of the Octavarium album are musical ecstasy...
Quem está ouvindo essa pérola ai em 2021?
10:20 portnoy throws the stick onto the orchestra
The unusual thing is that Portnoy didn't spit on the orchestra sometime during the show.
You know people give James so much criticism. But his performance here was flawless.
yeah. And it sucks in many other places. He is pretty bad when trying to sing high during live.
It's not an accident that many people think he's tone deaf when live.
@@gareginasatryan1579 it's both
LaBrie's live performances are very hit or miss. Unless he's performing with Ayreon, where his performances are always hit. But this entire concert is LaBrie at his best.
Miss this formation
INDRA RM Organization Bengkulu. INDONESIA.
7:38-7:42 james picking up a drum stick and yeeting it back to portnoy
7/8 rhythmic patterns at 4:40 and 7:38 ..... astonishing
I think it's 15/16
i love how Petrucci fails the note at 6:25 and still sound great maybe better than the original IMO
I do not think he failed to reach that note.
He might improvised to make the riff even better! ;)
Not a mistake, he did the same thing here ruclips.net/video/ebTwuR775NY/видео.html
sometimes I have a doubt that they are human. This song is flawless
Portnoy + Petrucci = PERFECTION!!!!!!!!!
Anyone else see Peyton manning in white shirt bottom left corner at 4:34?
Enorme banda mike excelente. No hay qye decir mas de esta banda
6:56 blonde girl were saying " wtf im playing "
Fuck this song is really powerful. One of my favorites of all time!
This song always gives me chills every time I listen to it
Goosebumps every time I hear it!
c'erano una volta i DREAM THEATER!!!...
Myung you beast!!! He's the man from Japan with a battle plan and a six string bass!!!
That bridge at 6:20 ish when the strings come back in make the hairs on my neck tingle every time!!!
I used to think the 9/11 shots were tasteless due to it being a New York show. Now? Not so much. It fits the feel of the song.
One earth one sky . Why we have the diffrent of each others . The song is so inspired
I simply love this song. Nothing else to add.
As always, the best 10 minutes and 36 seconds I've spent in a while. Why,why,why,why,why did I ever cut my hair and sell my drums?!!!
PETRUCCI!!
1:47 Dont cry my friend, Mike will return someday.
🙏👁️🙏
Almost a year too late, but he's back
That's sad, when I see Petrucci rocking the guitar like that I wanna hold my guitar more than ever
Love James's tongue from 1:13 to 1:53 !! But this song is just...epic.
What an epic journey this has been. Thanks DT.
Mike's still in the band and Petrucci says he's drumming is gonna kick ass in the upcoming album.