An indian hates pakistanis not because they are patriotic . Because one sided wars, cross border terrorism are the main instrument of pak . Heinous 26/11 and 9/11 . Poverty and corruption is a challenge to developing nation globally . We have fisherman dispute with bangladesh and srilanka too but solved by respective govt easily. The respective govt shall have the responsibility to empower their citizens. Mere a 6 minute documentary will not provide you insight, how humanity is suffering globally .
@@AbhishekKumar-gz9hq You indian gentleman , can u provide any evidence that how many pakistani fishermen were released by India in 2019 ? But I can provide you evidence from Indian media that Pakistan has released hundred's of Indian fishermen in 2019 and also released the man who had a fantastic cup of tea in Pakistan, also don't forget Kulbhooshan Jadhav, who is still in custody of Pakistan and his own statement that he was promoting terrorism in Pakistan. However, the tea was fantastic.
Doesn't matter if they are Indian or Pakistani, they are innocent hard-working people. Governments of both countries should do something for these people.
Your wrong.The world is dying. Its not like the 90s anymore, food is very scarce. As a leader you cant let your team just get fucked. With time you will learn.
On the one hand, I understand why countries make the consequences so severe for illegally crossing a border. On the other hand, it's unfair to these fishermen that they can be jailed and have their boat confiscated because they accidentally crossed over an unmarked line. Either both governments should create a chain of anchored buoys well out into the ocean along their mutual border, or fishermen who routinely operate in those waters should be given GPS devices that sound an alarm if the boat begins to drift too close to the border line.
Yes they are trying, Government of Indian is trying to destroy Pakistan Economically and Government of Pakistan is trying to annihilate India by terrorism.
@@superkirby14 Funny how I comment in every single Bodybuilding and strong man channel and you're the first in years to notice that on a fucking video about Indian fisherman in the middle of nowhere
Key takeaway: Pakistan and India arrest these people as political bargaining chips. Imagine being a poor fishermen who spends years in jails so that your neighboring country can you use you as a tool for negotiations
If you don't know about history of south asian region then first go through it . A sovereign democratic nation has the responsibility to secure it's border first. Where terrorist used fisherman boat and attacked 26/11. So the govt and authorities doesn't know by face Who is terrorist or a fisherman.
@- king-hypothetically speaking, if someone sexually assaulted your mother, it doesn't mean that you would go and assault his or her mother and daughter or son
This is so sad. Look at these poor old parents all looking for their children. The governments need to realize that these poor fishermen mean no harm and just turn them around when they do cross the border
@@smh6234 the only person who seams in any way zealous is you it’s crazy how ironic your statement is blame resides with both governments and people who think as you do
@@smh6234 What is wrong with you? It's the fault of both governments. It is not just India or just Pakistan. Both are to blame. It is about the poor people who are suffering.
@@smh6234 despite hindu , Muslims, cristian, we all humans in common, all the religion and rituals come from us, if you bron in Hindu family you are Hindu, if muslim you Muslim, right think you are not Muslim you are labeled as muslim, We live for some years and all needed to pass, why hates within ourselves in that short period, we are not alone, think if no humans around you who would you talk, cry, love, care and anger we all the network of 7.9billion people, please don't speard hates
Both sides says nobody want to cross by purpose they just don’t know and who will cross if they got their son with them , I hope the best for these people and I feel bad .
Except for the people who do cross and commit heinous acts of violance, cant build asecurity system vulnerable tp good guys and Tough against bad guys bro
@@rohandalvi6476 coming from someone with a juridique background no party should suffer consequences solly for crossing a border. On the worst case they should be detained and deported to home country not jailed for fifteen years away from their family
or you know something much more likely to happen......................a pandemic to drop their numbers back to caveman times levels........................
In 2008 Terrorists came by boat as fisherman, and they have massacred hundreds of people in mumbai, So then now, any intrusion is taken seriously. Not fault of fisherman, but their pakistani government who can't stop terrorist activities, and their people suffer due to this.
You did forgot to mention , that for the 2008 attacks , Pakistani militants came to the Indian city of Mumbai by Sea route , posing just as innocent fishermen when they hijacked an Indian fishing vessel and the landed in Mumbai . So after that Indian Navy and the Coast guard with the state police of Maharashtra , Gujrat took up great efforts to watch borders and check for any illegal Pakistani fishing vessels , as a result we see more people arrested from year 2009 and then on. The diplomatic situation makes it very hard for Pakistan to get its citizens back, however there are also a lot of Indian fishermen lodged in their jails on charges of trespassing to spying.
same problem everywhere ... in US they have problem with space for houmless people ..... living at sidewalks and every city wants to kick them out ... the problem is they have to be somewhere
Because you and your Indian people and government are zealous in your hatred against Muslims. Bihari Muslims getting beaten up, hijabs getting snatched off heads, and this.
The only people terrorised are the people of kashmire that ur corrupted police and military kill everyday. As a muslim we wont rest untill we free our bretherns from the aparthid rule of modis regime But still it hurts seeing innocent poor peoples from both side suffer like this. No one wether hindu or muslim should suffer from their governments political idiocy
@@evanmedi6144 I didn't know I had my own police department...."ur corrupt police". Btw there will be no peace as long as attitudes like yours prevail.
The poor old lady at the end has a such heart breaking life story who keeps on searching for her children. Typically messed up unstable country politicians create drama and hardships for their own citizens.
Poor mother doesnt know her children may be smuggling. Educate their children so that they don't end up like that poor mother.! That's what happens in a developing countries after 45 years of liberation. How does a Islamic state allow that 🤔🤨 who's to blame mother ? Religion ?
If I am not wrong Ansar Burney Trust in Pakistan was helping to secure the release of these fishermen on both sides of the border especially in Pakistan, this is so cruel. I really hope and pray that the poor woman get her sons back.
All My grandparents are from Lahore, Quetta Baloch and Kandhar -Akhand Bharat. Love to Sindhis. hope Sindh gets liberated soon. Punjab will take some time.
The Pakistani president Imran Khan offered to have talks with in at the UN a few months ago and India leader Moldy said no. Moldy doesn't care about Indians he's willing to have millions sent to there deaths over Kashmir, my uncle was arrested when he went to report in India on Kashmir for his own blog they took all his equipment and destroyed it then they took picture of his passport and told him if he's a spy sent from England tell him or they'd kill him which he denied, they locked him in a small coffin sized room where he couldn't sit down let alone move for 15 hours (he knew it was cause every hour he'd hear the bell ether in or near the jail) where they would bang on the metal door and keep shouting jaldi ut salah and wouldn't offer him water or any food and later was escorted to the airport and told never to return or they'll follow through on killing him if he comes back they also kept his 2 phones, watch, laptop, tape recorder and mp4.
It's really sad... Just sad. The world is cruel ! But there are still honest and humble People out there. Hope this can come to an end, they are just trying to feed their families. Sending out Prayers to them 🙏🏽
I am from India but i am not in favour of arrest of innocent from both sides. This kind of diplomacy is not going to lead both the countries nowhere. Show mercy to poor and innocent.
Seeing this reminds me of how small my sufferings are. Anticipating an amicable solution on both sides of border to end this hostility against poor,like this old lady. May god be with her and give her strength
@@VijayKumar-hx3pi Vivek might be insensitive but there is a valid question here. Why bring more kids into the world when you don't have the means to provide for them? They are condemned to a life of destitute.
@@V1Pin Wow, you have some serious anger issues. I asked because I have seen first hand the horrific lives some of these children live and was hoping for civil dialogues . It wasn't intended to trigger you. Please get some help.
It is unfortunate that they are caught in the crossfire, but for the western countries I would say, what would you do if you were right adjacent to the terrorist states, they over react to these minor skirmishes, while they rain fire over Asia
PM modi making laws such as CAA and NRC rather than dealing with such social and economic problems. This issue is just one other than the hidden realities of India. Moreover I'm really curious why no Indian news channel cover such alarming issues. There are way more important agendas than Swami Om or Deepak Kalal that many indians face, especially the minorities and the oppressed poor. I personally want to thank Vice news for spreading awareness about the unspoken folks of the world. Thanks for considering people as human beings rather than Pakistanis or Indians.
Imagine if Britain didn’t go to these countries, you would be blaming the french or Dutch or Portuguese lol Can’t blame Britain forever! Their own people have been running these places for a long time now.
The suffering of these poor people are painful to watch But as an Indian i would like to give rationale of Indian Government to persecute these mostly innocent people November 26 2008 ... City of Mumbai was attacked by 10 heavily armed terrorist who came on a fishing boat to shores of India and killed over 160 people....This shocked the nation’s conscience and people demanded action. Now what we perceive as innocent fisherman, security forces see as security threats. Their poverty can be used to entice them to do any gruesome act for money as they are too thinking about their family. Thus Indian Coastguard remain at vigil and spare no body. Furthermore the bargain angle shown in video where each country imprisons fisherman from enemy nation as bargain is also a major part of the reason for their suffering.
@@subhxsish Hafiz Saeed admitted nothing, India has no balls to admit it did itself in order to destroy peace and trade with Pakistan. India always does shit like that.. nothing new
How can ordinary citizens of India and Pakistan help these fisherman from both sides? Would giving them an ID Card that can be verified electronically by the authorities help?
Literally this video is so painful. 😭😭 Seeing a mother pointing out to the see and saying they use to come back but they didn't return one Day. I really hurts When she was showing Empty House's of their son's.😢😢
@@thevageek1021 Facts and objective perspective leads to a common conclusion. But yes India could be more gracious to these simple commoners. I may need more information but isn't Pakistan run but a dictator?
And India ventures into Pakistani waters to kidnap Pakistani fisherman. So clearly, more Indians are trying to come into Pakistan. So the problem is India not Pakistan, which has to protect its borders.
This both nations has a leader with complete senses, body parts and well working brain and yet they continue to clash for something that can be worked on peacefully
Yup, no matter who she is, she's a mother of a child. Yes, kasab and his filthy pigs came from the same route, but protecting international borders shouldn't come down to this.
Also If you look at it, Ajmal kasab and his men got in through one of the fisherman’s boats. We can’t just blame them. Everybody is suffering. Sad to see that such fishermen are victims.
Vice, Pakistan catches thrice the number of fishermen from Indian side. Show that story too. Many family are devastated because of the same reasons in my neighborhood of porbandar.
They said pak captures twice more than Indians does theirs, but as usual, they won't show it. Either way, this is not a game of who is committing more atrocities. The way we treat each other's civilians is deeply troubling. These people are mere humans, they are not poisoned with religious extremism yet, but these economic pressure might one day push them to be a potential recruit. We should be stopping this.
Education and family planning is so important..... The man is alone working as fisherman but he has feed 10 kids and also his wife..... Why have so many kids if you don't have the means to take care of them..... Lack of education and also the mentality is to blame.
You seem to be an educated person so why don't we start in our country India first before telling others what to do. So quick to point out the faults in others but ignoring ours.
@@nikhilthomas5491 Not only Pakistan its the problem of the entire subcontinent but Bangladesh and India have made efforts in this regard, while also Bangladesh has got some success in controlling their population.... don't you think so? All i mean to say is irrespective of religion ,ethnicity or country having to many kids while you are in poverty doesn't help rather makes the condition worst and puts immense pressure on the government and natural resources a like that's why the need to educate them.
I can imagine the argument that both the Pakistani & Indian police would make for their cruel treatment of the other country's fishermen: that it's the only way to deter illegal border crossings. But that clearly isn't working, cause both Indian & Pakistani fishermen are still being caught and their families are deprived of a source of income all the same, so Islamabad & New Delhi (as well as the governments of Sindh & Gujarat) have to come an agreement - or at least a temporary arrangement - over the border, right? Also: The intro from 0:00 & 0:44 is golden.
They mention the fact that Pakistan does it twice as much as India. However its almost impossible to tell where the border is if your in a ship that drifts while your fishing. It is a messed up situation that needs to be stopped.
A normal person would say that the fishermen of Pakistan should not be affected. But, I would like to remind people that the Mumbai attacks, where hundreds of people were slaughtered, the terrorists came through fishing boats. Moral: There is always two sides to a story. Although I agree innocent fishermen should not be harmed but after the terrorist attacks the coast guards became more harsh.
The cruelty from one human to another is horrific. This is not what God intended for anyone to go through. We all want the same things in life. To have and provide for our families. World wide the problem is the same, corruption of the governments.
This can be avoided by using better fishing practices to avoid overfishing on either side (preventing the need to cross over looking for fish on the other side), providing proper tech to fishermen on both sides to prevent accidentally crossing over and by setting up a joint mechanism that fastracks these cases and returns fishermen and equipment!
When terrorist attack happened on mumbai, terrorists were able to sneek in Indian borders pretending to be fisherman. So india has no option rather than to arrest these people whether or not they are terrorists.
After the terrorist attack on Mumbai India had to step up it's maritime security. Often terrorist use fishing boats to get in India. I know it's gone too far but it all started for a reason which no one is talking about. And about the jail sentence, they are never kept that long India and Pakistan regularly trade off innocents.
They should make a proper demarcated sea border and ensure that the fishermen have proper access to the maps so that they accidentally don't cross borders.
That poor lady broke my heart. Hope she finds some comfort.
Same here, felt her pain
Lauren Rose All of it should break your heart because they are all human beings, regardless of which side they belong to.
An indian hates pakistanis not because they are patriotic .
Because one sided wars, cross border terrorism are the main instrument of pak . Heinous 26/11 and 9/11 .
Poverty and corruption is a challenge to developing nation globally .
We have fisherman dispute with bangladesh and srilanka too but solved by respective govt easily.
The respective govt shall have the responsibility to empower their citizens. Mere a 6 minute documentary will not provide you insight, how humanity is suffering globally .
@@AbhishekKumar-gz9hq You indian gentleman , can u provide any evidence that how many pakistani fishermen were released by India in 2019 ? But I can provide you evidence from Indian media that Pakistan has released hundred's of Indian fishermen in 2019 and also released the man who had a fantastic cup of tea in Pakistan, also don't forget Kulbhooshan Jadhav, who is still in custody of Pakistan and his own statement that he was promoting terrorism in Pakistan. However, the tea was fantastic.
@@soomroabidskp fishermen can be released but not drug dealers and terrorists..... After all mumbai attack terrorists came as fisherman......
Doesn't matter if they are Indian or Pakistani, they are innocent hard-working people. Governments of both countries should do something for these people.
Your wrong.The world is dying.
Its not like the 90s anymore, food is very scarce. As a leader you cant let your team just get fucked.
With time you will learn.
On the one hand, I understand why countries make the consequences so severe for illegally crossing a border. On the other hand, it's unfair to these fishermen that they can be jailed and have their boat confiscated because they accidentally crossed over an unmarked line. Either both governments should create a chain of anchored buoys well out into the ocean along their mutual border, or fishermen who routinely operate in those waters should be given GPS devices that sound an alarm if the boat begins to drift too close to the border line.
India has tried multiple times to provide food and housing to everyone at the border, however Pakistan keeps funding Jaish E Mohammed.
@@robertcarson3116 wtf, you're holding innocent fishermen responsible for terrorists.
Yes they are trying, Government of Indian is trying to destroy Pakistan Economically and Government of Pakistan is trying to annihilate India by terrorism.
As always
Poor people are the ones that suffer the most!
Justice Warrior kai greene getting ready to smash a grapefruit as ur profile pic 😂
@@superkirby14
Hahahahahahahaha
G4P baby
Gotta pay the juice bills
@@superkirby14
Funny how I comment in every single Bodybuilding and strong man channel and you're the first in years to notice that on a fucking video about Indian fisherman in the middle of nowhere
And?
Too bad
So true 😔 💔 may god bless them when judgment day comes
Key takeaway: Pakistan and India arrest these people as political bargaining chips. Imagine being a poor fishermen who spends years in jails so that your neighboring country can you use you as a tool for negotiations
If you don't know about history of south asian region then first go through it .
A sovereign democratic nation has the responsibility to secure it's border first.
Where terrorist used fisherman boat and attacked 26/11. So the govt and authorities doesn't know by face Who is terrorist or a fisherman.
@@AbhishekKumar-gz9hq that was inside job
*India
Go look up how Indians abusing Sri Lankans marital border
@- king-hypothetically speaking, if someone sexually assaulted your mother, it doesn't mean that you would go and assault his or her mother and daughter or son
Always poor people suffer :(
yes
Last time India didn't pay much attention on it's maritime borders, 150 innocent people were killed in Mumbai.
Shubham Patil so lets just keep falsely imprisoning poor fishermen?
So just detain fishermen... Coz maritime security key Naam pey kuch toh dikhana padega...
Chutiya lodu... Intelligence.. Coast gaurd.. Navy.. Hilarahe they sab. Or wait they were busy detaining fishermen
Uncle Ruckus They are being illegally abducted by both sides even when they haven’t crossed any lines.
@@basilshibu5673 yeah coz Pakistanis came in a fishing boat that night, so....
India don't want 2008 again
PAIN is the only word sufficient to define this world.
Are you depressed or just emo
@@ethanmcfarland8240 none. Just tired of watching all this shit go down.
This is so sad. Look at these poor old parents all looking for their children. The governments need to realize that these poor fishermen mean no harm and just turn them around when they do cross the border
The government's? This is only India. Why are you and your people so zealous in your hatred against Muslims?
@@smh6234 the only person who seams in any way zealous is you it’s crazy how ironic your statement is blame resides with both governments and people who think as you do
@@smh6234 What is wrong with you? It's the fault of both governments. It is not just India or just Pakistan. Both are to blame. It is about the poor people who are suffering.
@@smh6234 despite hindu , Muslims, cristian, we all humans in common,
all the religion and rituals come from us,
if you bron in Hindu family you are Hindu, if muslim you Muslim, right
think you are not Muslim you are labeled as muslim,
We live for some years and all needed to pass, why
hates within ourselves in that short period,
we are not alone, think if no humans around you
who would you talk, cry, love, care and anger
we all the network of 7.9billion people, please don't speard hates
Both sides says nobody want to cross by purpose they just don’t know and who will cross if they got their son with them , I hope the best for these people and I feel bad .
Search 26/11 who caused it??
Except for the people who do cross and commit heinous acts of violance, cant build asecurity system vulnerable tp good guys and Tough against bad guys bro
@@rohandalvi6476 coming from someone with a juridique background no party should suffer consequences solly for crossing a border. On the worst case they should be detained and deported to home country not jailed for fifteen years away from their family
These folks have been in turmoil since forever...may Peace come to all of the conflicted...
or you know something much more likely to happen......................a pandemic to drop their numbers back to caveman times levels........................
@@nikadavise-br9lx clown smh
In 2008 Terrorists came by boat as fisherman, and they have massacred hundreds of people in mumbai, So then now, any intrusion is taken seriously. Not fault of fisherman, but their pakistani government who can't stop terrorist activities, and their people suffer due to this.
You did forgot to mention , that for the 2008 attacks , Pakistani militants came to the Indian city of Mumbai by Sea route , posing just as innocent fishermen when they hijacked an Indian fishing vessel and the landed in Mumbai . So after that Indian Navy and the Coast guard with the state police of Maharashtra , Gujrat took up great efforts to watch borders and check for any illegal Pakistani fishing vessels , as a result we see more people arrested from year 2009 and then on.
The diplomatic situation makes it very hard for Pakistan to get its citizens back, however there are also a lot of Indian fishermen lodged in their jails on charges of trespassing to spying.
imagine oppressing group of peopld because of an undefined imaginary line..
It's imaginary, but it's pretty well defined.
@@Arun-MM except for the parts where it isnt
Heartbreaking.
Why make poor people suffer? This is terrible politics
same problem everywhere ... in US they have problem with space for houmless people ..... living at sidewalks and every city wants to kick them out ... the problem is they have to be somewhere
These people are mentally ill.
You don't understand politics
This is trend around the globe. Poor people are biggest assets of any government.
Because you and your Indian people and government are zealous in your hatred against Muslims. Bihari Muslims getting beaten up, hijabs getting snatched off heads, and this.
Both side of suffering because of this ,This has to end
Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Turkey would rather pay and fund terrorism rather than doing a good deed and help free these people.
Am speechless!
The only people terrorised are the people of kashmire that ur corrupted police and military kill everyday. As a muslim we wont rest untill we free our bretherns from the aparthid rule of modis regime
But still it hurts seeing innocent poor peoples from both side suffer like this. No one wether hindu or muslim should suffer from their governments political idiocy
@@evanmedi6144 I didn't know I had my own police department...."ur corrupt police". Btw there will be no peace as long as attitudes like yours prevail.
@@mikebob4195 I think you missed his point
Everything aside but why showing only one side of coin.
This is not real journalism
The poor old lady at the end has a such heart breaking life story who keeps on searching for her children. Typically messed up unstable country politicians create drama and hardships for their own citizens.
Poor mother doesnt know her children may be smuggling. Educate their children so that they don't end up like that poor mother.! That's what happens in a developing countries after 45 years of liberation.
How does a Islamic state allow that 🤔🤨 who's to blame mother ? Religion ?
If I am not wrong Ansar Burney Trust in Pakistan was helping to secure the release of these fishermen on both sides of the border especially in Pakistan, this is so cruel. I really hope and pray that the poor woman get her sons back.
1:42 , 4:29 *Sindhi* 🙏
Ye log to meri bhasha bol rahe hai bhai 🙏🙏
Adaa malik rehem kare tvhaa te ae tvhaa ji jijal amaa te b 🇮🇳
U r from Pakistan ??
@@rohitrajput6043
Na.
Me bharatiya hu.
Mere dadaji akhand bharat sindh se the
@ it was fake unity by british
@@psltalpur9989 like ur own comment and bark some more
All My grandparents are from Lahore, Quetta Baloch and Kandhar -Akhand Bharat. Love to Sindhis. hope Sindh gets liberated soon. Punjab will take some time.
The Pakistani president Imran Khan offered to have talks with in at the UN a few months ago and India leader Moldy said no.
Moldy doesn't care about Indians he's willing to have millions sent to there deaths over Kashmir, my uncle was arrested when he went to report in India on Kashmir for his own blog they took all his equipment and destroyed it then they took picture of his passport and told him if he's a spy sent from England tell him or they'd kill him which he denied, they locked him in a small coffin sized room where he couldn't sit down let alone move for 15 hours (he knew it was cause every hour he'd hear the bell ether in or near the jail) where they would bang on the metal door and keep shouting jaldi ut salah and wouldn't offer him water or any food and later was escorted to the airport and told never to return or they'll follow through on killing him if he comes back they also kept his 2 phones, watch, laptop, tape recorder and mp4.
It's really sad... Just sad. The world is cruel ! But there are still honest and humble People out there. Hope this can come to an end, they are just trying to feed their families. Sending out Prayers to them 🙏🏽
I am from India but i am not in favour of arrest of innocent from both sides. This kind of diplomacy is not going to lead both the countries nowhere. Show mercy to poor and innocent.
Seeing this reminds me of how small my sufferings are. Anticipating an amicable solution on both sides of border to end this hostility against poor,like this old lady. May god be with her and give her strength
Count the number of children this man have 4:15
Dont be an insensitive idiot bro. Its heart breaking to see such cases
@@VijayKumar-hx3pi Vivek might be insensitive but there is a valid question here. Why bring more kids into the world when you don't have the means to provide for them? They are condemned to a life of destitute.
@@V1Pin Wow, you have some serious anger issues. I asked because I have seen first hand the horrific lives some of these children live and was hoping for civil dialogues . It wasn't intended to trigger you. Please get some help.
I feel like crying 😢 after watching the last part
You should feel like crying after watching both parts.
It is unfortunate that they are caught in the crossfire, but for the western countries I would say, what would you do if you were right adjacent to the terrorist states, they over react to these minor skirmishes, while they rain fire over Asia
@VICE So glad you're spreading the awareness, and being the Voice of these poor needy ppl.❤❤❤
Pakistan doesn't care lol 😂
Last month Pakistan released lots of fishermen they spent only three days in Pakistan but when india arrests Pakistani they jailed them for years.
Because the last time India took maritime borders lightly 26/11 happened
@@subhxsish Teri gand
And he has 7 kids....with that meagre income
Its sad but unavoidable after 26/11
@@congojander9743 The hate you have had after that attack is how indians have felt for years. Very hypocritical for you to not understand that.
PM modi making laws such as CAA and NRC rather than dealing with such social and economic problems. This issue is just one other than the hidden realities of India.
Moreover I'm really curious why no Indian news channel cover such alarming issues. There are way more important agendas than Swami Om or Deepak Kalal that many indians face, especially the minorities and the oppressed poor.
I personally want to thank Vice news for spreading awareness about the unspoken folks of the world. Thanks for considering people as human beings rather than Pakistanis or Indians.
no mention of 26/11 attackers who came via sea.
Why would one even mention it? What's the context?
@@nambin4895 the terrorists came by the Arabian sea by boats into mumbai
Can't even earn his own livelihood properly, and has 7children (one more on the way) with a wife half his age . Wow
@Murtaza Well their neighbors like India ,Nepal, Sri Lanka has fertility rates half of that of Pakistan.
Supporting Pakistan from Canada 🇨🇦
Why?
The root of the rot came from British Empire !
And now Britain got there payback. by having everyone from every where Into there country.
cobra kai you clearly don’t live in Britain
@@antiantiderivative lol ok mate..
Imagine if Britain didn’t go to these countries, you would be blaming the french or Dutch or Portuguese lol
Can’t blame Britain forever! Their own people have been running these places for a long time now.
@@weechill333 it should be wonderful if we can change the history with hypothesis .......!
The suffering of these poor people are painful to watch
But as an Indian i would like to give rationale of Indian Government to persecute these mostly innocent people
November 26 2008 ... City of Mumbai was attacked by 10 heavily armed terrorist who came on a fishing boat to shores of India and killed over 160 people....This shocked the nation’s conscience and people demanded action.
Now what we perceive as innocent fisherman, security forces see as security threats. Their poverty can be used to entice them to do any gruesome act for money as they are too thinking about their family. Thus Indian Coastguard remain at vigil and spare no body.
Furthermore the bargain angle shown in video where each country imprisons fisherman from enemy nation as bargain is also a major part of the reason for their suffering.
Remember how the 26/11 terrorists reached Mumbai?
Right 🙏🙏😂😂😂
*What I can't fathom is why the country wants to spend money detaining them and dealing with them. Political pawns seems like a priceless business*
What about attacks like 26/11 done by terrorists who came from fisherman boats and left 110 dead
India or pakistan please release innocent fishermens from both sides
Don't forget 26/11
Terrorist used water way to attack bombay
@@Danial0152 poor soul
Get well soon 😂😂
@@Danial0152 Modi wasn't in Power then. Nawaz Sharif has admitted that Kasab was a Pakistani. Hafiz Saeed has admitted that he planned the attacks.
@@subhxsish Hafiz Saeed admitted nothing, India has no balls to admit it did itself in order to destroy peace and trade with Pakistan. India always does shit like that.. nothing new
How can ordinary citizens of India and Pakistan help these fisherman from both sides? Would giving them an ID Card that can be verified electronically by the authorities help?
Literally this video is so painful. 😭😭 Seeing a mother pointing out to the see and saying they use to come back but they didn't return one Day. I really hurts When she was showing Empty House's of their son's.😢😢
Yes it hurts when she doesn't know her son's smuggle.
This has to end, at once...
They need to stop Pakistan once and for all.
Wish it was that easy
@@hwfq34fajw9foiffawdiufhuaiwfhw I'm sure it can be debated but historically and current events close the door on India being at fault.
@@thevageek1021 Facts and objective perspective leads to a common conclusion. But yes India could be more gracious to these simple commoners. I may need more information but isn't Pakistan run but a dictator?
@@hwfq34fajw9foiffawdiufhuaiwfhw tf u mean porkistan is the organiser of global terrorism
Pakistan catches twice as India so make documentary from Indian perspectives
And India ventures into Pakistani waters to kidnap Pakistani fisherman. So clearly, more Indians are trying to come into Pakistan. So the problem is India not Pakistan, which has to protect its borders.
@@andrewbackop3308lol you don't jackshit about geography of India and Pakistan.
@@rohithonmane
@@andrewbackop3308 Any sources besides the biased view of the fisherman.
impossible, no freedom of press in India.
How india is supposed to differentiate between smuggling boats and fishing boats .....
15-20 years for catching fish? Just unbelievably cruel. This is seriously injustice!
Old mother burst my eyes. Someone please help dat poor mom
These communities are still facing the burnt of partition even after more than 70 years. Pathetic.
poor lady broke my heart.
How many kids does he have lol
Bhai mai to bolta hun....zilla ghosit kr dena chahiye uske ghar ko🤣
This both nations has a leader with complete senses, body parts and well working brain and yet they continue to clash for something that can be worked on peacefully
It hurts. It just hurts.
Yup, no matter who she is, she's a mother of a child. Yes, kasab and his filthy pigs came from the same route, but protecting international borders shouldn't come down to this.
There should be Joint ministries from both sides to address these issues, and lessen social suffering.
A widdy wot wot 😳 made of steel & great hard working people 🙏
So sad............
15-20 years? Completely insane.
Also If you look at it, Ajmal kasab and his men got in through one of the fisherman’s boats. We can’t just blame them. Everybody is suffering. Sad to see that such fishermen are victims.
Why didnt they show Indian side ?
They said 3 words that of India side. That is "Pakistan detains twuse number of fishermans'
Christ, someone end this horrible conflict before these countries have a nuclear war.
the mother with the 8 sons really fucking bummed my day man..i pray she gets to see them again
If this video doesn't provoke your consciousness, I don't what will.
Vice, Pakistan catches thrice the number of fishermen from Indian side. Show that story too.
Many family are devastated because of the same reasons in my neighborhood of porbandar.
They said pak captures twice more than Indians does theirs, but as usual, they won't show it.
Either way, this is not a game of who is committing more atrocities. The way we treat each other's civilians is deeply troubling. These people are mere humans, they are not poisoned with religious extremism yet, but these economic pressure might one day push them to be a potential recruit. We should be stopping this.
There are far more of them.
And they have dried their waters of fish.
Watch Vox's video on how even srilanka is sick of them stealing their fish.
One world, one people. Can we learn to live as one...
It's harder than you think.
Apparently.
But where is the Indo-Pakistani comments war I’ve come to know and love ?
Life is so so hard in both the country.
This is too bad :(
Free these fishermen!
Very sad
Humanity above nationalism..
Peter Wang nationalism is bs.
Except in America that will lead the world out of darkness again.
Education and family planning is so important..... The man is alone working as fisherman but he has feed 10 kids and also his wife..... Why have so many kids if you don't have the means to take care of them..... Lack of education and also the mentality is to blame.
You seem to be an educated person so why don't we start in our country India first before telling others what to do. So quick to point out the faults in others but ignoring ours.
@@nikhilthomas5491
Not only Pakistan its the problem of the entire subcontinent but Bangladesh and India have made efforts in this regard, while also Bangladesh has got some success in controlling their population.... don't you think so?
All i mean to say is irrespective of religion ,ethnicity or country having to many kids while you are in poverty doesn't help rather makes the condition worst and puts immense pressure on the government and natural resources a like that's why the need to educate them.
I can imagine the argument that both the Pakistani & Indian police would make for their cruel treatment of the other country's fishermen: that it's the only way to deter illegal border crossings. But that clearly isn't working, cause both Indian & Pakistani fishermen are still being caught and their families are deprived of a source of income all the same, so Islamabad & New Delhi (as well as the governments of Sindh & Gujarat) have to come an agreement - or at least a temporary arrangement - over the border, right?
Also: The intro from 0:00 & 0:44 is golden.
Indian fishermen interview? And the water boundary is marked by United Nations CLOS . this time bad reporting by vice
They mention the fact that Pakistan does it twice as much as India. However its almost impossible to tell where the border is if your in a ship that drifts while your fishing. It is a messed up situation that needs to be stopped.
Vice has gone , nothing like it used to be and certainly cant be trusted
A normal person would say that the fishermen of Pakistan should not be affected.
But, I would like to remind people that the Mumbai attacks, where hundreds of people were slaughtered, the terrorists came through fishing boats.
Moral:
There is always two sides to a story. Although I agree innocent fishermen should not be harmed but after the terrorist attacks the coast guards became more harsh.
It breaks my heart 😭😭😭
Vice atleast donate that man some condoms.... His burden would be reduced and prevented....
im still struggling to understand why countries are allow to claim ownership of something that is literally a lack of that country
Let show only one side
An eye opening video
The cruelty from one human to another is horrific. This is not what God intended for anyone to go through. We all want the same things in life. To have and provide for our families. World wide the problem is the same, corruption of the governments.
Fisherman came from Karachi & bombed Bombay.. How to bifurcate whos the real fisherman
This is so painful to watch. Both governments should be ashamed for their own actions. Where is the love?
Well, that wasn't heart-breaking at all. #$%^!
I feel sorry for fishermen and their families on both the sides
This is so sad
Tragic, i hope for them, i hope for them 🙏
Hurts my mind...
I can’t understand that this is how we sit watch other souls hurt..
Mindless , heartless...
@@Exodus26.13Pi oh wow nationalism what a surprise THOSE ARE REAL FUCKING PEOPLE UNLIKE THAT LINE
very sad. Jail someone for years for just trying to feed their family? How about a warning or a small fine? Major changes needed!
So just a question...could they not get a map and just sail north or south, respectively, away from the border?
I dont need to see the subtitles to understand what they are saying because Hindi and Urdu is almost the same language.
Vice is not only for Indians and Pakistanis to see.
And this is happening in the south of India. Most South Indians don’t know Hindi
Solution: AKHAND BHARAT
This can be avoided by using better fishing practices to avoid overfishing on either side (preventing the need to cross over looking for fish on the other side), providing proper tech to fishermen on both sides to prevent accidentally crossing over and by setting up a joint mechanism that fastracks these cases and returns fishermen and equipment!
When terrorist attack happened on mumbai, terrorists were able to sneek in Indian borders pretending to be fisherman. So india has no option rather than to arrest these people whether or not they are terrorists.
We INDIANS never forgot 26/11
In that attack our kids, women, soilder, died
So don't use them for your propaganda
How many kids this guy have
After the terrorist attack on Mumbai India had to step up it's maritime security. Often terrorist use fishing boats to get in India. I know it's gone too far but it all started for a reason which no one is talking about.
And about the jail sentence, they are never kept that long India and Pakistan regularly trade off innocents.
They should make a proper demarcated sea border and ensure that the fishermen have proper access to the maps so that they accidentally don't cross borders.
Once Pakistan said 10 militants to India throw ocean