How this border transformed a subcontinent | India & Pakistan
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июн 2019
- The story of how a hastily-drawn line divided one people into two.
This season of Borders is presented by CuriosityStream. Watch thousands of documentaries for free for 31-days: www.curiositystream.com/Borders
Join the Video Lab to help us make more Vox Borders! bit.ly/video-lab
Follow the Vox Borders watch page: / voxborders
Follow Johnny on Instagram: / johnny.harris
Sign up for the Borders newsletter: www.vox.com/borders-email
With original music by Tom Fox: tfbeats.com/
The video conferencing session between the two schools was conducted between students of Gyan Mandir Public School (Delhi, India) and Adamjee Model School (Karachi, Pakistan). The session was coordinated by Ms Anju Anand and Ms Devika Mittal from Indian side and Mr Usama Palla and Ms Suraya Islam from Pakistan. We're grateful they let us drop by!
The British tasked Cyril Radcliffe with the job of drawing a line to separate Punjab and Bengal provinces from India into East and West Pakistan. Muslims and Hindus weren’t the only ones being separated from each other. Sikhs and people from other faiths were affected as well.
A Sikh pilgrimage was divided because of the new border, Punjabi people of all faiths were separated from each other, and a culture was ultimately divided.
This Vox Borders episode looks at how the Radcliffe line changed Punjab and how communities are affected now.
Watch all the episodes of Vox Borders: India here:
• Vox Borders: India
To learn more about the colonial history of the subcontinent, watch our explainer on the role of Great Britain in shaping the histories of India and Pakistan: • How the British failed...
For more on the present relationship between India and Pakistan, watch our explainer on the conflict in Kashmir here: • The conflict in Kashmi...
Vox Borders is an international documentary series by Emmy-nominated producer Johnny Harris exploring life at the edge of nations.
Start from the beginning. Watch all full episodes of Vox Borders on RUclips in one playlist:
• Here's where Borders i...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H
UPDATE: An border crossing known as the Kartarpur Corridor has opened between India and Pakistan, linking two of the holiest sites in Sikhism for the first time in more than 70 years. The 4.7 kilometres corridor connects the Gurdwara Darbar Sahib in Pakistan to the border with India.
This is truly amazing for all Sikhs.
I hope the new generation forgive the sins of both their fathers and move past it eventually leading their generation to a new horizon.
Although visa is required as well as a $20 fee per person per visit.
@@YuvrajDhingra so? maintenance and stuff. at least appreciate it
@@AmirAli-gv7kn well i do appreciate it.
Just correcting him as he said in the video that it would be VISA free.
A Turkish proverb fits in here,
''When the fish are fighting in their own pond, that is when you know the British were there''
We love our turk bro from pakistan. 🇵🇰♥️🇹🇷
Damn that's a nice quote...
👏That's hella'va proverb.
Yep.
@@THALASA The Turks are not from Turkey, they are from Turkmenistan.
Dhaka resident in 1946: I'm Indian.
Dhaka resident in 1947: I'm Pakistani
Dhaka resident in 1971: I'm Bangladeshi
😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Talk about being Bangladeshi
My Grandfather fought 3 of the fights
Dhaka resident in 2020 : I'm Assamese
@@reeshavgohain how
I am from West Bengal and the story was same here
Punjabis and Bengalis were suffered the most. This bought a tear to my eye
Don't forget about us Sindhis! We lost all our land and there is no "Sindh" in India anymore
@@nittyrustdoneharvardfaker630 Sindhis are definitely the ones that lost the most. At the time of independence we should have pushed to get certain districts of Sindh.
They even looted the word "loot" from your language, after looting everything, and killing every rebel, and enslaving the rest.
@@nittyrustdoneharvardfaker630 im sindhi in pakistan :)
@@vignesh1065 😭
My moms side of family was actually in India, Tripura. During partition they moved to east Pakistan which is now Bangladesh. Its been over 70 years but connection still remains. My grand father often sends fish(we are Bengali after all) over there to his friends. And his friend sends lots of to us fruits during summer.
My Grandfather had to leave his Zamindari in Mymensingh and settle in Calcutta in 1947. Till 1971 his former tenants who took over the land would still send him token bags of rice at every harvest. It stopped in 1971. We never found out what happened to them. My uncle stayed back in 1947. He had been a senior official in the British police and could not imagine anyone daring to attack him. He was killed in 1971.
My grandfather came from Syhlhet in present day Bangladesh to Darjeeling
beautiful!
I heard that there's a saying in Turkey. It goes like this,
"If in the same pond, two fish hate each other, rest assured the British were there."
It's a red Indian proverb in US
Im turkish and have never heard that
It's Iranian!
@Tmb1112 And there are problems everywhere- Israel-Palestine, India-Pakistan, Protestants and Catholics in Northern Ireland, to name a few.
Ironic, because the Turkish Ottoman EMPIRE left behind a legacy in the Balkans that are arguably the cause of religious & ethnic tensions today...
This dude probably took longer to make this video than that British lawyer did for making that border line.
Oh, that is obvious.
wizard680 it took 30 days to make border
Ahhh, the burn
Honestly I kind of feel bad for him, he gets the blame but really it was the British government's decision.
They said he was given what, a couple weeks to decide where to draw a dividing line between two entire new countries would be, given only census data and a little time to work.
It really should have been done over a couple years, with some temporary interim government elected from local communities would help make the decisions, with the future borders announced with months or years for everyone to move before the official division.
People needed to be in the highest of social and political circles to have been chosen for this job.
He probably had to do a lot of lobbying to get this job and would have made the assertion that he could do this job in a month ,even when he knew that he was not the right man for the job.
As a person of Indian descent ( my forefathers were brought here by the British as indentured labourers) it was very emotional for me seeing the schoolchildren of India & Pakistan interacting.
The colonial powers did untold harm to other countries and this world as a whole.
Trinidad & Tobago
West Indies.
it doesn't matter where you live as long u r living happily 🙏
Same as you - South African though
Same as you but surinam 🇮🇳🇸🇷🕉️
It was not colonial powers who demanded a seperate country. You know who did.
@@PotatoMan007 no it were the dutch british and french because they needed workers to work on the plantation
I have to share this story after watching this video.
A couple of weeks i my grandparents came to India after 3 years. Yesterday I was talking to my grandfather asking him everything about his past.
He told me he had to leave everything they owned and had to leave their town. Then I showed him Google Earth and searched his hometown. I showed him the street view and he was so happy when I told him that was were he had lived. I will remember his smile forever.
Strange how Britishers are taking years to finalize a Brexit deal but created two different countries in just months!
Niket Shukla no that’s because our government is useless and have a 6 week holiday in summer instead of sorting things out
@@Haybalemelonhead No only schools have 6 weeks off in the summer. All normal jobs resume
Zack E no the government has a recess in the summer, google it
Spot on!
:(
the problem that british made
1. Israel-palestine problem
2. Hongkong-china problem
3. Pakistan-india problem
how exactly did the British cause the Hong Kong problem
@@hugoherman3499 opium war, Qing dynasty ceded Hong Kong to British for 99 years
Much more than those three
You are absolutely right. Not just the British alone. Basically western powers created problems in all their ex-colonies. Besides the ones you have mentioned, Africa is a massive example.
@@Shadow_Dragon546 so they have went to war with a country and they have taken territory from them? Something that literally every empire have done?
My grandmother (nani) came from Pakistan to India due to partition, she used to tell us how back in their home in Pakistan they were sitting having tea and suddenly some Muslims came and threatened them to leave Pakistan, so they ran away without even taking a single piece of cloth with them...... her brothers and sisters all got divided while coming to India but fortunately they met after few years, all of them thought they died but they met and were so happy
@Akarsh2008The conflicts occured mostly in the border towns. All parties involved had it's fair share of skirmishes and mob violence in the border towns. It is also important to realise that our country is based on secularism, where as Pakistan was born based on the need for a Muslim state. In my state Kerala Hindus, Christians and Muslims co-exist peacefully.
@Akarsh2008 By saying we should have had complete muslim exchange, you have lost on secularism. Don't say that we can't do it. We can do it. But it requires trust from everyone and a willingness to acknowledge out mistakes.
@YourFuhrer1933 Both sides did bad things, you need to take that in.
@YourFuhrer1933 Because if you threatened the muslims there they'd have crushed you, as United Province was a Hindustani Muslim centre. You couldn't do such a thing in the first place.
@YourFuhrer1933 you write as if muslims werent forced out of hindu majority areas as well.
the fact that those kids are talking to each other with just innocence is just heartbreaking when you put into context what the leaders of both countries are doing. i hope the youth finds it in themselves to not give in to the hate!
youth supports hindu nationalism in india electorates says all
@@castlingcastle7970 seeeeeeetheeeeeeeeee
Indians: suffered
Pakistanis: suffered
Bangladeshis: suffered
Radcliffe : It was too hot out there in India
Ananya Pandey Struggle 😂
Fk Cyriel Radcliffe
😂😂😂😂😂
Mohmmad Jinnah: pakistan
Well , not whole Pakistani and bagladeshis.. Only minorities from those countries
British people learning history : "so we're the bad guys?"
Your forgetting the rest of the colonization gang. France, Spain, Portugal, and Britain.
@Gurnaj Virk Tbh we were mostly taught about WW1 and WW2 in history. Well that's what I remember anyway. This stuff needs to be on the curriculum.
Gurnaj Virk at school you learn about great power figures like the Tudors and also about moments the supposedly started the modern world of democracy (magna carta), then you go a bit into the industrial revolution and some of its effect of that before slipping into the world wars and the cold wars. At uni, you gain a more complex view of Britain’s role in the world and all I can say is that first year me was shocked that partition is hardly ever talked about and almost never taught in schools
Gurnaj Virk what so the British are the only people that conquered and killed people? We all know if India had had the technological prowess in the 1800’s then they would’ve colonised Europe. It is human nature to conquer your neighbours. In U.K. schools we are taught mostly about medieval Europe and the renaissance, not that we ‘civilised the world’. Although can you really argue against that? If it wasn’t for Britain there would be no industrial revolution. No railroads or factories
always has been🔫🚶♂
I’m not Indian, but it really pains my heart that people are separated simply out of haste and not proper negotiations. I can’t help but compare the Partition of India to the DMZ between North and South Korea following the Korean War, with many families being separated from each other for decades. I pray that, even if there is no reunification between India and Pakistan, people can visit each other’s “motherland” without any violence. Namaste and Salam to everyone in Hindustani (both India and Pakistan)🙏
Your comment is well-meaning. But it is not comparable with what happened in Korea. The creation of Pakistan was not something that was imposed by foreigners. It comes out of tensions between Muslims and Hindus that predate the British for centuries. The British Indian Muslims pushed for a Muslim state in the Indian continent.
@@ash9280 It was definitely imposed by foreigners. If the British wanted, India wudnt have been partitioned, but they had to act early, which they didn't, as they didn't care.
@@ash9280 The creation of 2 countries was to suit political interests of some people. I still don't see the need of a country based on religion in the subcontinent. If we divide the subcontinent on basis of language and religion, we would have a 100 countries in the Indian subcontinent.
@@phoenixbagri744completely political. Taking advantage of religious difference to advance politics. And the religious differences is to do with diet I blv. One eats one animal that other worships etc.. We are ok to go to moon but still hold such thoughts very seriously. Its difficult to explain this to people not raised in India.
@@phoenixbagri744bro the same thing is happening in South and North east of India
It would be awesome if you can add to the borders-india series with a couple episodes from the POV of Pakistan. It would dispel a lot of the misconceptions that people have of that place!
As someone who was born in pakistan, with grandparents from india, a sikh best friend and currently living in England, this series is pretty much perfect for me aha.
"the most bizzare lines drawn across a map"
Africa: I can relate.
Yeah haha, that immediately crossed my mind too
@@dankdungeon5104 Ireland (and especially Donegal): christ tell me about it
India Africa bhai bhai
Caucuses, Balkans, Central Asia and Middle East also deserve a shout out!
Kurds: We can relate too.
"Love knows no border "
Neither does Britain
daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaannnggg (insert meme of child saying "daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaannnnnnnnnnnnnnnngggggggggggggg").
Underrated comment
So deep
Well said
Im dead laughing.
Sikh and Bengali know the pain and other can only imagine. I have heard many stories from my grandmother. Really got emotional after watching this doc
Not only sikh but hindus of Pakistan also......
🙏 🤲 respect for you sir! Thankyou so much for uniting our thoughts. Never ever cried in a video before this. Hope someday we will break the borders and unite once again. Love from india 🇮🇳 ♥️
I was genuinely touched by the way in which Sikhs in that town meticulously cared for the Muslim graves. I can't think of a more powerful demonstration of respect.
Yes same as a Muslim I am truly thankful for their respect and I know that the people in my area would do the same because at the end of the day we’re all family 🇵🇰🇮🇳 i know that one day Pakistanis and Indians will unite once more after our governments stop being so anti India or anti Pakistan
@@SamSam-yt6xn As much as I want, it so looks out of the picture rn. Once it was just our plain patriotism and a sense of xenophobia on both ends. Now there's a lot of international involvement too plus populations on both ends need to realise what's best and not be convinced by a certain narrative set to them. US and China have also involved themselves in our issue now making it a more complex one
As a Muslim, that one act of humbleness shows that Sikhs are very kind people that are caring. We may not share the same beliefs, but we share common morals.
@@SSGJafri but sikhism is a false religion and the 10 gurus were liers.
Sikhs are the best - what tradition has men cover their hair and not women? True patriarchs there.
As a Korean, I can relate. A border drawn without the permission of the people. A border that separates families, a border that separates the same people.
Edit: When I said "same people", I don't mean the Indian and Pakistani people as a whole. I was referring to the few ethnic groups on the border who were divided.
And of course, instigation from politicians
@@HarkunwarSinghKochar Pakistan has religious freedom aswell, i literally ..
That seems like an amazing place btw, what part of korea you from?
Korea was unlawfully separated by the US thugs. It's a tragedy what happened to your country.
We get your pain too.
As an Indian...i can surely tell that all credit goes to British
I love this series.
Ok but that sikh committee still talking care of the Muslim shrines literally melted my heart, God bless them.
right
Credit goes to british
@@nextleveleveryday7535 yes, credit the British which made the previous community abandon the site in the first place.
Sikhs are good people and they're not rascists
All of them bless them.
As soon as I heard "British lawyer drew the borders" everything made sense
british: 😂let's separate sikhs into Pakistanis sikhs and indian sikhs by drawing a border.
its like if you bring a plumber to fix a chair but there blind
everything started to make sense
@25 years ago until the British partitioned
@25 years ago All people are wonderful, it is just a few bad apples that have selfish needs. I don't which people you are referring to as "mean" but again everything is for a reason and a reason for someone to backlash could be because they are being controlled by an external power such as UK did to Pakistan and India.
Dude this had me emotional. I'm missing those people more and more now
The best part of the video was the communication between Indian and Pakistani students
Let's be honest guys. The British draws terrible maps:
-India and Pakistan
-Israel and Palestine
- The whole Middle East
-Africa's
-etc.
Sang Pham it’s on purpose, the brits knew what they were doing.
Whow!
Just let those guys never negotiate borders.
They did it on purpose so that people will fight among themselves, otherwise these british colonies would go on for wars (world war 3) in future against British.
It’s not so much there bad it’s probably more they didn’t care ( sorry if I’m wrong)
" The sun never set on the British Empire, because even the god couldn't trust the English in the dark "
very perfect remark for britisheres
well now british have borise as leader so good luck to them 😁
@@worthit5064 As a British person I can say having Boris Johnson is terrible so far, so thanks for the luck lol 😅
@@naranciasorange579 hahahah i know , but you're not the one with the worst..........open twitter and see the Glory of Trump administration.😁
But he is absolutely right
Kartarpur is now opened for indian and feels happy that Sikh brother's and sister's will happily can visit their holy places
This was very emotional and I have absolutely no connection to that part of the world. Thank you, Johnny Harris, for being an amazing human being
indian partition: just get a guy to draw a line lol it's not so hard btw you have 4 months
brexit: *screams in british for 3 years*
subtitle [screaming continues]
tbh Brexit is being held up by another partition project that was supposed to prevent conflict
And it worked so well in Ireland that it caused two civil wars in 100 years.
Brexit manages to become even more exponentially ridiculous and hypocritical the more you learn.
🤹🏾🇵🇰 🇮🇳 🇧🇩 💂
Yeah that should do it, thnx for the soldiers bye.
🇨🇮 🇬🇧 🤽 🇪🇺
Britain: I want my independence! And I won't leave until you stop asking me all these hard questions I didn't prepare for!
Both Brexit and the Indian Partition have centuries of political history behind them. The basic principle is that no major change in governmental structures can ever be achieved in a way which satisfies everybody, and discussions on the best way to achieve the change will continually postpone the moment when an agreement is reached. The alternative is destroying the existing arrangements and leaving negotiations on the awkward details of the new arrangements until afterwards, when any compromise is better than total chaos.
Screams in British?.... Do you mean English?
Britain: Hobbies include drawing lines on maps
So underappreciated
Omg😂😂😂🤣
Palestine Israel i think also
😂👍👏
Britain let’s make random shapes on maps
This is one of the more incredible videos Vox has done, easily a top 5. When you realize how similar the cultures are, your heart just aches. The way Gandhi's heart probably ached when he saw it happening. What a mistake. You just want them to get along.
I'm afraid it's a little more nuanced than Vox makes it seem, Gandhi wasn't exactly an angel either.
Thank you for making this. May we both countries improve our relationship and share love and happiness. 🙏
There's an Indian north American proverb that says " if you saw two fish fight each other , certainly an English passed by "
Seems fitting
Jesus.... you mean native right?
@@LJ-fq6uw right
@@LJ-fq6uw Its complicated because Native American and American Indian are used interchangebly, made worse when even the Natives refer to themselves as 'Indians, Indian Reservations, etc'
@Bradley7 Johnson What? It's you Europeans lol stop blaming Muslims for your idiotic actions.
8yrs of studying History in School & never have I understood the partition of my country as clearly as here!
yes i agree with you the most
I never knew about that British Old Man did that in less than a month!!
Exactly me too.. I never understood the actual reason.. I mean who actually did it.
I agree
No hate but I think it’s because Muslims and Hindus weren’t getting along well and there were discriminatory acts on both sides that are still taking place today. We still have problems with each other but we need to solve the Kashmir problem democratically and become friendly neighbours
Such a great video! Not just the topic, but so well done aesthetically!
when i see the teacher doing the video call,
i got to tears.
that was deep, nearly 74 years gone by
our family was seperated.
Partition was the ugliest that happened to us Indians and Pakistani. And hatred from politicians has created a cloak of difference. But underneath the cloak lies similar identities, hearts and humans.
Love from India.
not by politician.
partition happen because of Islam
@@tarunchand3159 the only time when you should swear. Rather, _must_ swear. Politicians deserve only gaalis.
But at the end of the day, we are the ones who elect them to represent us, so aren't they a reflection of our inner selves after all?
@@bhavikbhatt8346 Partion happened because Mohammed Ali Jinnah thought Muslims would be looked down upon in a Hindu majority country
@@swadhinnayak4212 are they not?muslims are second class citizens in india
Swadhin Nayak please refer to the comments saying partition happened because of Islam. Muslims are not respected and don’t feel safe in India especially right now. If you don’t agree with please read other comments on this video made by Indians blaming muslims.
Some British dude: let's draw a line in a map, what could go wrong?
*Insert india-pakistan border, middle eastern border, Egypt-sudan border*
Edit : yes, i don't include Palestine-Israel border, but i do put middle eastern border, cause basically almost every middle eastern border happened cause brits. And Palestine and Israel also located in middle east. So yeah it technically count
Muhammad Iqbal Habibullah and don’t forget most borders in Africa!
Muhammad Iqbal Habibullah Oman UAE BORDER
Irish border
Don't forget the French!
To be fair he worked under pressure
Hindustan zindabad 🚩🕉️🕉️🕉️🚩
Truly amazing cinematography, so many emotions portrayed in 17 min video. 👏🏻
Shocked american: You can buy keychain of machine guns.
Rest of the world: Americans can buy actual machine guns.
in a supermarket!!!!!!!
he's shocked they dont sell the real thing
@@pablocalderon2342-n9s 😂😂😂😂😂
It's basically impossible to buy a machine gun in the US. You have to have an FFL and go through loads and loads of paperwork. It takes a lot of time and money because the guns are very expensive.
@@renjoh but what about shot-gun, pistols, rifles?
The kids from both sides communicating through Skype and talking about normal things without any hatred was so heartwarming.
You may watch AIB's video featuring conversations between Indian and Pakistanis on phones.
It's not us, it's the politicians.....
@muhammad ali right on! Good luck against south Africa!
@@IfIDont_NobodyWill
Yep
The only people who are against each other have Been told lies about their country which makes the other evil
@@IfIDont_NobodyWill
Yep
The only people who are against each other have Been told lies about their country which makes the other evil
Paneer ka pyaar desh nahi jaanta
This guy is amazing. His research in every video is phenomenal ❤
My grandmother's dad lived in Pakistan's side before partion...so at the time of partition he and one of his frnds took one blanket and left Pakistan(blanket bcuz there was no space on trains and had no time also to take any other thing, so took a blanket if they would have to sleep on roads). They boarded a train. Everywhere you can see where people in terror and dead bodies lying around. Muslims were killing all hindus on that train. It was evening and grandma's dad went to toilet, he listened people crying and screaming, he was terrified and waited in toilet. Nearly after an hour he came out and when he went to his coach he saw his frnd beheaded and many people dead and people who survived where crying. He explains that he couldn't understand anything and he felt like dying. He lost his frnd and reached Assam with dead bodies all around.
Partition was one of the most horrific events this land has ever seen
Thanks Britain
My grandfather born in India...❤
My father born in Pakistan...❤
I born in Bangladesh ❤
One place but 3 name..ha ha ha😍😍
So your grandfather was born in India and later it became East pakistan and then it became Bangladesh. Is that right.
@@captainnoodlez1718 I don't get it
@@robertomurri1278
British Raj in WW II and before (India)
East Pakistan before 1970's
Bangladesh after 1971
so you are a partition baby then or a real Asian baby then
Same with me. And now I am American.
A big respect to the sikhs taking care of muslim graves .
Being a hindu (though I don't believe in God). Sikhs are the most generous people.
SuBhaYU BiSwaS then your atheist that's the unique thing with religion so you should study them and the Bible is the most man made try it you will see
Agree . I almost cried on that clip , respect for them
@@SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi same
@@ApostateAbdul idc
Tears come when I think about this event. British gone but devides us in peices. 😞I love my real India , miss you India
Thanks for making this video to let know the world that how deep is this partition 🙏
The Sikhs taking care of the Muslim graves, with respect, with a great heart. Touching.
The kids skyping in India and Pakistan, give me hope.
Pakistan might have punished her... For this act.... They hate Hindus... Hating hindus is in their syllabus
Muslims should also take care of temples instead of vandalizing them
Yeah u will see complete opposite in Pakistan.where they demolish everything
Andrés Mauricio do muslims do the same to the sikhs grave.wonder why you not complementing them.afraid
Its nice to see people
Miss leaded by media
I live near a sikh temple
And we are supposed to take care of it
No matter what you say or think ✋
respect to all you Indians and pakistanis, us irish know your pain
WE PAKISTANI VERY HAPPY SO ITS NO PAIN ON OUR SIDE AND WE WILL GET KASHMIR TOO
@@umerzahid4377 Keep dreaming.
@@umerzahid4377 bhak chutiye
@@umerzahid4377 Try comparing POK and our Indian Kashmir.
Haha. Lol. We Indians only want destruction of UK. Hope to God that northern Ireland secedes from UK and joins republic of Ireland. Britain is responsible for 3-4th of world's major conflicts
you are a good and mindful youtuber, one of my fav ones.
Keep it up dude.
This was heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time.
respect for the teachers who are spreading love rather than hatred in both india and pakistan.
perfect example of how people can be brought closer with the help of technology.
Yes! This was my favorite part of the video. Teaching the kids to love and respect and realize they're all one and the same. We all are...
Very true. Lovely teachers n kids
AB186 Peace will not coexist in the region unless and until the ISI and the army is completely destroyed.
That made me tear up
Bangladesh sees the video
*Cries in the corner*
Are you from bangladesh
@@aditya2805 Yeah
@Shahrukh Shah pakistan did mass genocide on us...
@Shahrukh Shah google "Bangladesh genocide" and "Bangladesh war of independence"
It'd be weird if they don't cover Bangladesh in one of the next episodes. Just wait and see.
It feels like current Russia and Ukraine situation - we have shared history, culture, friends and families
But politicians tend to grow nationalism and anger among us and it's horrible(
I've visited India and people there are very kind and open
Stories where Sikhs caring Muslims graves and children' Skype calls - melted to heart
Completely wrong! Ukraine doesn't have shared history with Russia! Cuz occupation of Ukraine during centuries, countless tries to annihilate Ukrainian language, culture and self-identity and even genocide of Ukrainians back in 1932-1933 cannot be called as shared history. It would be better to say that Ukraine was Russian colony.
And even now Russians are doing second genocide of Ukrainians in last 90 years.
Only Russians are sick with imperial ideas see Ukraine and Ukrainians as a part of Russian empire. And you're the re and living evidence of my words.
@funny man kid named bayraktar tb2:
First of all, Ukrainians are not Russians. It's the Russians who always thought Ukraine is a part of Russia, but that's not true at all. Ukrainians speaks a whole separate language. Russians need to stop interfering in Ukraine
And if there was cultural similarity, then Bangladesh would still be a part of Pakistan, but you know one reason why the East Bengalis wanted to separate, because they had the brains to know that Urdu was NOT NOT WAS EVER their language.
@@nittyrustdoneharvardfaker630 ambos são da mesma etnia eslava e a Ucrânia falava russo em sua maioria, agora graças ao tirano do Putin os ucranianos não querem saber mais dos Russos.
Ukraine and Russia are both slavic and orthodox. India and pakistan and Bangladesh are neither same race, nor religion.
There's a story in my family of how my grandfather's father was a man of many countries. He hailed from Bangladesh lived in Pakistan for a while then settled near Bengal/Bihar. Ofcourse he really travelled within one nation then. Wish I could learn more
Glad this is back! You deserve a netflix series.
Ur right BRO
Agreed
Oh my lord yes! Please.
Johny did an amazing job for the time he has and the product is this pure distillate but there are also so many stories not told. So much more to see and experience that he could share in a more Netflix like format!
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO I can't watch netlfix in my country because it's too expensive
I know right?
Most world history can be covered in 4 words
"And then Europe happened"
And amazing stuff started happening because of them
And then the US happned
@@HN-kr1nf are you talking about Egyptian? Yeah that was bad
@@billmanning9172 no maybe there's a slim chance he's talking about the world, idk
@@HN-kr1nf slavs root of the word slave. The more you know ====*
Very Well Presented & Narrated by Johnny Harris. Kudos to your efforts Johnny. waiting for Many more to see.
This is just so heartbreaking to watch this. You've done an amazing job. But couldn't watch the whole video because I was continuously crying.
VOX BORDERS SERIOUSLY DESERVES WAY MORE ATTENTION.... SO GLAD ITS BACK GREAT WORK
🙄🙄🙄
75 likes Bhai RUclipsr ban Gaya
Pakistan: Kashmir is mine
India: no Kashmir is mine
China: hello there
Haha lol
general kenobi
Then india is great
@Teddy India controls 45% of Kashmir 35% is controlled by Pakistan and rest by China
@@himadrisharma9935 a man of culture.
Lovely work; I loved to learn about this. This is totally new for me. Thanks 🙏 muchas gracias
It is a good thing they are doing the show together, the bad thing is their celebration not based on their close culture of being in the sub continent, but to their respective nations.
Lesson learned: Never trust the British when your country is about to be independent
i have no words for how angry I am, they don't even own it. i don't even know, i have seen so many of them, just so many making fun of the patriotism, what do they actually expect? ha, not even ha.
just hear a fuvking partition story.
I just am so mad overall. acknowledge the trauma, share similarities, respect differences.
@@qsmimhmm1527 and the worst thing is when they draw the Borders they don't even know the map no matters what religion country we have one thing the same we are human love from Pakistan ❤️🇵🇰
@@Sammyfarel lots of love from indian subcontinent
@@Sai-hq4qo love you too brother i hope you and your family and loves one stay save love no matter what we are we are one that is human ❤️🇵🇰🇮🇳🇳🇵🇧🇩🇧🇹🇱🇰
How can someone with minimum sense trust those people whom they defeated to regain independence at last???????.
That clearly shows the level of common sense of those so-called leaders of India...
Actually, to speak the truth...I am talking about J. Nehru.
Atlast someone acknowledged the truth, British were in debt and couldn't afford India as it's colony.
Aur history book mein Gandhi ki Jay Jay Kar karte hai
And they were in debt because they tried socialism.
Fk no... there were many reasons...
The INA growing stronger was one the reasons...
@@zoephin6205 Did you forget about WW2? You know the war where the British went heavily into debt to fight the Germans?
Zoe Phin no they were in debt because of WW2. Same as most of Europe then
Those who are saying we are the same people (hindus and muslims) and lived peacefully before partition, are the biggest liars or dont know a thing about histroy
We are totally different people when it comes to our beliefs.
One is a religion from outside with set rules
and other is culture evolved in this land we called bharat
Thank you for this video from core of my ❤ Sometimes there are not enough words to say how Thankful we are for this video.
Thank you!
When I met you at India gate a few months ago... I never thought this is what you were making.
You made me cry...
You just made me cry...
Waiting for the next 4 episodes.
So, didn't you know who he was when you met him?
I'm Indian and wasn't aware of those Skype calls. This is so pure I love it.
@@trollrat2828 for real man.. Why can't just people appreciate each other with goodwill
@@trollrat2828 Sadly, some people have not learnt anything from the outcome we have seen of hated through partition. Who knows when humanity will actually exist.
But it was Jinnah who came with 2 nation theory. Don't blame just British Jinnah is equally responsible for partition
@@PoorPakistanisSurrenderwasFant exactly, I dont see how Muslims never wanna blame jinnah and the muslim league..
@@PoorPakistanisSurrenderwasFant actually ask historians it was savrakar then jinnah
better come out from that whatsapp facts
I thought I was watching Johnny Harris actual video didn’t even know this was vox 😂
I'm from North east India,Manipur, christian by birth....proud to be Indian....JAI HIND
"It is a politician who poisons people's minds."
Truer words were never spoken.
Not REALLY.😁😁Facts are bitter then this video👍👍😂
No. Evil is inside EVERYONE. Never forget that harsh fact of reality.
@@Neonvarun Privilege-seeking politicians in the half-century or so of reforms leading up to Independence were always a source of friction and discord (and were even partly responsible for tragedies like the 1943 Bengal famine, which Bengal's nationalist government refused to declare officially as a famine, because they needed to show that an independent Bengal could survive without help from India).
It's like claiming that Hindus and Muslims always lived in harmony before British.
British were able to put us against each other because we were already against each other.
If one is raised strong and pure no corruption of ones mind can be achieaved eh ..
I love this series! So happy it’s back!
Ikr?
?
Once in a while great stories like this come out, which gives me hope. Everything on the internet is always purposely depressing, trying to get us riled up and fight against each other. If we could all see past our created differences, the world would improve for the better
I'm very happy its back
Veritas Document Shows Google Encouraging Far Left Protest As 'Example'
When the school kids were singing their own nations national anthem... I legit cried...
Really goes to show how politicians use/divide us and humanity unites us...
Im from punjab ,exactly that city which was alloted to pakistan but now in india ,
I literally cried after watching this
I was overwhelmed so many times during the video... Especially when I saw the respect and honor that the Sikhs gave to masanian site. ♥️
Definitely Would have liked to see the other side do the same. But they just destroy the temples😂😂
Pakistanis are not like Hindus and Sikhs. ..They have damaged many Temples nd Gurdwara back there
That was really beautiful. One of those things that give you an ounce of hope for humanity.
I cried when the school bit started playing.
Can we just appreciate the video *quality* and *editing* being done here 🔥
He is always awesome
It's a company. Of course, it's gonna have production quality.
the magic of Vox
lets admit it, the ONLY REASON we watch VOX is this SERIES (Johnny) and OBSERVATORIES (joss Fong)
punjabis you are not alone you are joined by arabs in mesopotamia swahilis in east africa bengalis in east india and others
When lady teacher said- "before partition, we Pakistanis and Indians used to live together in the same place", it's just broke my heart, because of their foult (Britishers) we are now separated from each other.
Reckless mismanagement or i would say intentional mismanagement. There is no end Western hypocrisy.
Thanks for this video brother. We Indians are grateful to you for talking about this. 🙏
As a Pakistani I want everyone to know that I love my Indian neighbours - politics shouldn’t divide us.
As an Indian living in Canada, I can not thank you for the kind words. From a person who lives thousands of kilometers away from this conflict, it still has major reproductions. Love from an Indian to our Pakistan brothers.
Same Here Bro love from india
Absolutely right we are brothers god save us
Politicians are of devils breed.
Must ignore them.
Love from India!
Pakistanis are Indians with Islam as their religion, that's all.
Those students calling eachother, showing them their lunch, realizing we’re all the same people was so wholesome. Love from 🇧🇩
Hey dude! I just want to know what they teach you in school a d what people's opinions are on the 1971 war. In Pakistan it is considered a painful inevitability of sorts.
@@destruct0503 I didn't go to school here but pretty sure rounding up and killing 9 million people, mostly civilians, was not an inevitability. I have Pakistani friends whose parents lived in BD in 1971 and they were very ashamed of these actions.
Pakistan is son of india.... Its born from our land so be mindful of that son...... And also islam is religion of terrorist
@@darveshgupta8860 ok now you are just being arrogant... Not every Muslim IS a terrorist -_-
And Pakistan, India and Bangladesh are sons of The Indian Subcontinent (akhand bharat) .. that makes pakistan and bangladesh our brother..... And people like you are the reason of communal hatred between people... Grow up and stop getting manipulated by these politicians
@@darveshgupta8860 Not every muslim is a terrorist I am a muslim that offends me people like you are dead brain stereotypicial nobodys, and also pakistans are indians aren't dad and son there like siblings, I could say considering I am a pakistani.
one of the best video in youtube .thanks a lot
now a corridor has been opened between both the religeous site and as an indian sikh i will definitely visit kartarpur sahib someday... i really want to
The part where you showed the kids broke my heart. Just innocent souls bonding over food and cricket and a common language.
It looked as if Kids are wiser than war mongering adults.
@@GoodSoul-nh4xc agree 100%
Wah! That Wagah sequence brought back some memories 😅😁 Beautiful to see those school kids meeting each other and realising they have a lot in common 🇮🇳🇵🇰
BTW when will you come to Bangladesh
@@ShahTalks Not sure. It's on the list though. I need to return there!
@@KarlRock Hope you have a lovely time when visiting Bangladesh.
Jija Ji aap toh chaaye huwe hai har jagah
Karl Rock you should go to kashmir
Whenever international media cover this part of Subcontinental history they always focus on Punjab when Bengal also suffered as much as they did.
At 11:00 it shows that on Indian side people are taking care of a religious structure which is not even theirs...
For how many religious structures can we say that same thing is happening that side of the border....
Many Hindu sites in Pakistan are only damaged by constant flooding and earthquakes, not by the people. Please stop crying
mat kero bhai ye ahsaan.
Why does every sad story start with the Britishers drawing a line on the map
Jonny.... This how to your grandmother died,
You see...the British drew a line on the map....
They got too much land
Because white people like to colonize or exert influence on brown countries.
*India and Paskistan back then was British Raq so they were both Occupy by the british.*
@@gulerehan8625 actually because of that line many hundred thousand people died in the migration
Respect to the Indians who take care of the old mosque and gravestones
Zaid Ninja wonder if Muslims would do the same for Jewish graves🤔
MR. Right I know right because muslims have never killed anyone?
Uninstall Israelis pretty much bully a broke Palestine they don’t even have a military palestinians never kill anyone because they will always have an unfair trial
In Dubai, the government funds and protects a Synagogue for the small 3000 strong Jewish community in the country
Joking?
Thanks for this video this will help me in writing my paper, very well done and greatly shown
Thanku so much Johnny bro for this knowledge ❤ur such a great human.🙏🏻thank you sir❤
**People of different religions living in peace exist**
Britan: i'm about to end this country's whole career
@Farooq Tajammal search mauryan empire
They united and then divided again but it's also fault of politicians like of Muslim league that wanted separate country for themselves. Watch history of indian sub continent for better idea. If interested also watch 1947 Partition movie (Viceroy's House)
@@lightr2187 they didnt want the country for themselves. They knew that if they didnt get a separate state then the hindus would make up most of the government and then the muslims wouldnt get their basic rights. As the hindus would take revenge for the hundreds of years they were ruled by mughals. So a separate state was need for the security of muslims or else it would be like changing owners from the british to hindus.
*OP agrees with Brits as a white sexpat*
'Living in peace' is a stretch
incase any indian is reading this,,, love from pakistan☀️
Don't bother about the hate comment love from India too ❤️
@Phoenix Phoenix he have one phoenix and your profile pic have 2 minor difference
@Phoenix Phoenix Yes, I guess this is a very commonly used profile name 😂
Thank you same too you 💗.
Same from 🇧🇩. But I live in England.
I have been to Wagah Border and it is an experience! It's basically just a show of strength on both sides, and I wish that someday the stadium will be open. Free border crossings like the European Union. People able to easily cross into Pakistan and India