she was asked if it constituted bullying or harassment. something can be bad or against other policies without constituting bullying or harassment. the whole outrage about this hearing is ridiculous nonsense. the media has failed
Excuse me the presidents aren’t the problem the problem is 2% thinking they have supremacy over 98%. This has happened in history once before and it didn’t end well.
Academicians like these presidents live in a world divorced from reality. This is what happens when core values are not instilled in people from an early age.....everything becomes "contextualized", contingent and obscure. Only presumably educated people like them could be this foolish.
I'm not a proponent of hate in any form, but in the US we must adhere to the right of free speech, the Jewish, Palestinian conflict would be better served if less opinions and more factual evidences of the orgins of the conflict were presented.
Yeah anyone who doesn't blindly follow the Christian narrative of causing the end times via the formation of Israel by force is clearly disgusting.. much faith in god trying to force a prophecy to happen! Better blindly support Israel's atrocities!
@@aetherwizard3218 I don't understand how a war with no clear good guys and bad guys that happens thousands of kilometers away can suddenly allow you to call for a genocide in your elite university in the richest and safest country in the world. Maybe you hate jews and you feel relief to have this occasion to gain to right to finally express it?
What they can do is Walk the Walk and not just Talk the Talk. Hate is Hate and calling for genocide is not a fine line it is clear and distinguishable. These are private universities and can and should control hate speech. I bet if the hate was against another group they just might be a little more proactive.
@@jacalynstaten5607 miss Jacalyn is correct, but there has been too much pounding on those who are being charged because of what they think… It is an unbelievable and disgusting direction liberalism is heading.
What does it tell you that this Congresswoman is yelling at the top of her lungs about a theoretical, non existent "Jewish genocide" but could care less about the ACTUAL Genocide taking place in Palestine where thousands of innocent children are being slaughtered on a daily basis? Where is the outrage for that?
why exactly should people from private institutions be "removed"? What kind of Orwellian nightmare world do you want to live in? Just move to Russia instead please.
They should also ask the principals of NYU and Columbia U to testify and everybody will be even more jaw dropping to hear their responses. What an insane world.
I think congress should be spending our tax dollars on bigger issues, not policies at private or public universities, which r simply young ppl using their free speech at protests. It’s bad enough our tax dollars r being spent to fund what Israel’s doing which will put American lives at risk. I’m not talking about ppl who r protesting, who have no means to carry out any large serious attack on Jews or Palestinians in the US, but rather putting our soldiers at risk and will put Americans at risk of foreign terrorist attacks on US soil. U need to get ur priorities in order, as does congress!
@@janedoe3915Young people using free speech?😂😂 Calling for killing of Jews?😂. Is calling for killing of black people of transgender people also people protesting and using free speech? University has to provide a safe place free of harassment and bullying for students of all backgrounds I thought.
@@janedoe3915 You do realize that these universities are subsidized by tax payer dollars right? If they are being used for political indoctrination (which they are), we have every right to have them questioned especially if they are promoting hatred. It's called democracy.
@@ELARTEDELAMOTO Sure I do. Your god gave it to me when he gave me the ability to choose to do good or to do bad. If people don't have the right or ability to determine right from wrong, how could you possibly hold them accountable for being bad? Either individuals have that right, or your god is responsible for ever sin and evil deed ever committed by his creation, in which case it's not a god, it's a monster.
@@CowneloAlvaroid You have no idea what you're talking about...have you ever been to Israel...do you know any Jewish believing people...didn't think so.
At the same time, these professors preach about "microagressions" and the need for "safe spaces" with binkies and blankets and hot chocolate for their pampered, woke students.
Exactly. I mean the "moral clarity" which Congressperson Stefanik expressed seems to be rather foggy when it came to the insurrection of Jan. 6th. In that case, she will obfuscate and retreat into moral ambiguity.
Such as caring about the enormous massacre and racist vengeance unleashed in Gaza and the continued indiscriminate mistreatment and killing of Palestinians in the West Bank. Or the smearing of those defending the Palestinian people with an unlimited use of logical fallacies meant to silence anyone critical of the State of Israel. Let's hope The Hague has more moral and intellectual integrity than those in our government who curry favor with the pro-Israel lobby.
Holy moly,,, I gotta start looking for an exit strategy. This is the leadership of the highest level of education in our country? It definitely shows the contrast of educated vs common sense.
You think they're bad? Wait until the far right takes over in 2025. Then it won't just be about "common sense", but whether you still can LIVE FREELY in this country.
Presidents of so called premier colleges should not “get caught up in” in the moment. They are hired to make quality decisions not half assed determinations based on their own prejudiced ideas. There’s no walking it back they’re nailed and there’s no other result other than they needed to be fired. Anyone who continues to give money to these damaged schools are no better than they are.
Yeah, even if their personal beliefs were the opposite the right answer to give here was a no-brainer. There's no excuse for their waffling either from a moral or a business standpoint.
It is time to make our education institutions a place for education not for pushing particular ideologies. I wonder if the question of the Congresswoman was about death threats to any of the woke protected categories whether they would answer as they did.
Our “elite” colleges have been promoting the woke/inclusive/progressive agenda for years by staying away from what a college is supposed to be doing - educate future leaders, protect free speech and maintain the meritocracy. All three, and many more in other institutes, should either resign or let go.
Well I was going to comment but you just stated my exact thoughts. You know who gets discriminated the most, in this country...the law abiding, tax paying, loyal, hard working citizens of this country. I'm a recent retired combat veteran and I am tired of today's generations being indoctrinated and not educated... for their future and the future of their family.
And, please start teaching students what free speech is, as they currently believe free speech means you can say ANYTHING under the guise of it is free speech.
Seriously, do y ou understand what is woke, whatever that Trumpy hoo ha world is? It's a sign of shortened intellectual development to be wallowiing in "woke". It's a flag of conspiracy, again meaning nothing but a great fit to people who have very limited viewpoints on a liberal arts education. Same for progressive education. It's beyond uptight and facing backwards to think progressive is a negative. The entire engineering department is based on progressive education. The world's turn to internet and electronics is progressive. But I am guessing you are talking about progressive being non-Christian. And that, too, is dramatically incorrect. Martin Luthor was a progressive. It didn't stop there. The idea of fear feels palpable in the post. May I suggest new words and new concepts, not those from the hoo ha wing of the Republican Party.
You're not seeing the game that's being played as they did... First you ask if calling for genocide is bullying. And after they say yes with no context, you hit them with "wHat AboUT fROm tHe RiVeR tO ThE sea?!?!?!?!!!?!“
0:48 "[Calling for the genocide of Jews] is a context dependant decision." Genocide is context dependent? In what context is genocide permissable? According to ChatGPT, "Genocide universally carries a negative connotation due to its association with the intentional and systematic destruction of a specific ethnic, religious, or national group. There is no context where genocide is considered positive or acceptable." Thank you ChatGPT. You have more morality than a university president. That doesn't change my opinion that AI will end mankind, which isn't saying much for Magill.
Oh no ... Please don't use Black People as a point to prove your narrative. To add validity to your narrative you implement the continuous struggles another group of people. That's not very becoming.
I hate universities that have become political police. Forcing others to adopt your opinion under duress makes you as repugnant as the people you criticize. In today's society, just saying you aren't pro-Israel will probably considered violent hate speech. thats why it's too subjective. Ps, this is coming from someone who cares about neither side before you try to smear me as an anti-Semite.
They receive millions of donations from Qatar (the same one that sponsors HAMAS) Any reform must include forbidding Islamic influence on U.S. universities.
Hamas supporters have long operated in the United States. Internal Hamas documents and FBI wiretaps introduced as evidence in various federal criminal cases clearly show the existence of a nationwide Hamas network engaged in fundraising, lobbying, education and propaganda dissemination dating back to the 1980s. • The network formalized its existence in 1988, when it created the Palestine Committee in the US. The Committee’s goals included “increasing the financial and the moral support for Hamas,” “fighting surrendering solutions,” and publicizing “the savagery of the Jews.”
The congress women missed the chance to ask if calling for the genocide of trans or bipoc people violated the code of conduct. If they gave the same answer the students would revolt.
I can’t believe Jewish people should be afraid in America, it’s a shame. No one should live in fear. Jewish people have been persecuted enough in history. You would think Americans would know to treat people with compassion and respect. Glad alumni are pulling their endowments.
@@williamstevenson3049 Free Jewish people, they were attacked. Jewish people are Gods people. You better get your life right Jesus Christ comes back there are no take backs or forgiveness. Prayers for you.
I don't know what you wanna call "antisemitism", but seeing videos of Oct 7 massacre and barbarism that Hamas uploaded to their website themselves and then denying anything like that happened! Taking down kidnapped victims with the excuse that it's not real and it's all propaganda and joining Muslims all around the world -who's Muslim countries wouldn't allow Palestinian refugees because they know their history in countries they were welcomed to before - to protest against Israel by chanting "from the river to the sea Palestine will be free" and didn't face any backlash were definitely not only antisemitism which was even heartbreaking and infuriating to people like me who are neither Jewish/Israeli/Even religious anymore nor have anyone related to that religion or country because that was just inhumane. So of course you can state your opinion about antisemitism, but those universities not only allowed all that to happen in their campuses, they even encouraged it and turned a blind eye on Jewish/Israeli students getting hate. Maybe the backlash could be over so much these people already did and their testimony was the last nail in the coffin. My terrorist regime is helping Hamas or maybe even organized the attack on Israel but the fact that me and many Iranians are supporting Israel is the fact that we've been exposed to so much propaganda, we can see it from a mile away. Their women got raped and UN women didn't even care enough to condemn them. As someone living under oppression that goes back forty five years, I'd say the world turned antisemitic. Not just these people.
This behavior on university campuses is weird and puzzling. For a while now universities, which are supposed to be places of learning and exchanging of ideas through critical thinking and debates, it seems have been anything but that. I remember not too long ago when there were "safe rooms" with toys or stuffed animals--something like that, for students who were 'triggered' by ideas obviously too painful for discussion. I thought then, and now--that is creepy! Put your big boy and big girl pants on and get a grip. There are two sides to this horrific war and, no easy answers. Wouldn't it be great if students convened some sort of group-think throughout universities, to try to bring real discussion and possible solutions to this problem. Practice for future real-world leadership. The leaders of these institutions should not tolerate one-sided thinking and "safe rooms" on a university campus. Imho.
On the other hand maybe you better stand up and loudly support Israel no matter what they do for the 2 minute hate. otherwise you'll have to go before congress to answer for your crime of not supporting Israel.
@@aetherwizard3218not really i could care less on Israel or Ukraine. Americans military should be protecting our southern border with artillery as the are supposed to do
@@2103038335 well for one due to a lack of any actual quotes being stated about such genocide I'm lead to believe they're conflating genocide from slogans of Palestinians demanding their stolen land back.. as has been done several times lately.
I'm Cameroonian and am so glad that we have real problems to deal with and not poking our noses in others' business 😂😂😂. It's bizarre what America has become. Univiersities are supposed to be places of free speech and thought
@@scottholder4431is so partisan blue no matter who, he overlooks a race of people being erased from the face of this planet. Think about that!!! Blue no matter who’s life
Seems like YOU don’t know the definition of genocide. Many of the ceasefire protesters are Jewish themselves. Nobody is calling for a genocide of Jews, I personally would not support that and have not seen it in person or in any of the platforms. What people are calling for, however, if Palestinian freedom, a ceasefire and an end to genocide and atrocities being committed against Palestinians.
Did these University presidents not toe the Zionist line? Did they dare insult our Israeli overlords? How dare they! Their punishment should be 10 recitations of the "I have a dreidel" song while wearing a kippah and contemplating the mysteries our benevolent and merciful ruler Benjamin Netanyahu. /s
If a group of protesters said these things about the LGBT community or ethnic people, they would kick them out of that school, but for some reason it’s okay to say that about all Jewish people.
@@RiclmnoppIf it is in general, it is free speech. If it is aimed at a particular person, it is a threat. Why didn't Stefanik talk about the Israelis murdering Palestinians. That goes way beyond speech. Israel actually committing genocide.
Google this if you don't believe me. Another Muslim organization announced the other day that it would be committing another genocide in Armenia because it's a Christian country and they were inspired by hamas to do so... For those of you who don't know the Muslim Empire of Turkey committed the first Is Armenian genocide and I know that all of a sudden there's going to be a bunch of democrats who have no idea what I'm talking about at all even though the current democratic administration "fought really hard" to have the armenian genocide recognized as a genocide... Watch them all forget though, like that never happened 😂😂😂
The recent war in the middle east showed clearly that we as the USA are divided nation. Thank to our officials who brought us and pushed us to this extend !!!!
These university presidents cast the good professional women in a bad light. We work so hard to do things smart and do things right, and these women come along and can only suggest that calling for genocide might be bad depending on the context.
These three women being questioned should not be in their positions. When you can't differentiate between right and wrong YOU ARE NOT CAPABLE as a human being.
No one including Congress men or women have the right to delegate public opinion as to how people should or should not think let alone taking heads of education institutions and pressuring them “under the guise of semitism or antisemitism “ free thinking independent institutions of higher education should create free thinking individuals Government officials shaping thinking is not only against our bill of rights but outright unAmerican and dangerous! We should weedout and vote out government officials that act this way
How is this about protecting free speech when if a student makes a derogatory comment about someone's weight or if a student gets someone's pronouns wrong that is considered violent and abusive behavior subject to disaplinary action including expulsion and screaming at and calling for genocide of the Jewish students acceptable behavior
Because when a student makes a derogatory comment about someone's weight, that's just one student. But when students scream for genocide of you-know-who, that's hundreds or thousands, and they have many millions behind them.
Not answering a question in the way you like isn't the same as not answering.. As we all know it's highly illegal not to support the atrocities of Israel in the in US..
For the people crying about free speech, universities have a code of conduct an ethics policy. You can say what you want without being arrested, but the schools can kick you out for breaking their policies.
When the free speech incite violent actions, that goes beyond free speech! The hateful chanting makes Jewish students and Jewish folks in U.S. feel unsafe. Have anybody chants geocide to Palestinian?! no! No one should chant geocide to any groups!
Can someone please explain to me why there’s four women on the panel but they only keep mentioning three schools who is the fourth white woman and who is the fourth school because there’s four people sitting up there but you’re only mentioning three😵💫
Most of the students protesting, and students of these "elite" schools interviewed couldn't even show where Isreal is on a map. Probably have no idea Isreal was created after WWII by the United nations! Goes to show when you erase history you only hurt the future.
Antisemitism has no place among us., neither has Islamophobia., or any other hatred. We need to distinguish between free speech and hate speech .... Just saying.
Back in the days political, religion views were a private matter everyone has worked out their difference privately. Today, is social war of folks not respecting boundaries dividing humanity with social war views.
People have gone mad on both sides of the political spectrum. I live in Europe and this is terrifying because I know in 5/10 years we will be in the state the USA are today. The last people who lived the 20th century's wonders (communism, fascism, world wars, genocides...) in their flesh are dying of old age and it looks like we're preparing to start it all over again. With more people and a lot more technology.
How about if our politicians stop taking AIPAC money, and start focusing on calling out wrong actions by the government of any country that looks, smells or sounds apartheid, genocidal, or in any other way opposed to international law.
@@BeBoppin2000 This is the whole point. Go look at the millions of dollars given to politicians by AIPAC just to keep their mouths wired shut about the actions of Israel.
Israel has a right to defend itself. However, they have ignored 26 UN resolutions with only the US vetoing for a two state solution. When Britian gave up the land back in 1948, it was agreed upon to create one Israeli and one Muslim state? Israel has been building on the disputed land and there's barely any left for another state.
The perceived problems of the influence of Islamic regimes (Iran, Qatar, Turkey..) and dictatorships(Russia, China..) on the UN include: Human Rights Concerns: Some Islamic regimes and dictatorships have been criticized for human rights abuses, and their influence may hinder the UN's ability to address such issues objectively. Selective Focus on Issues: The influence of certain regimes might lead to a selective focus on issues that align with their interests, potentially neglecting other critical global matters. Biased Resolutions: There is concern that the influence of specific regimes may lead to biased resolutions, favoring their perspectives and unfairly targeting certain nations or groups. Suppression of Dissent: Regimes with authoritarian tendencies may use their influence to suppress dissenting voices within the UN, limiting open discourse and the exchange of diverse opinions. Obstruction of Peace Efforts: The interests of certain regimes might obstruct or complicate UN-led peace efforts, particularly in regions where these regimes have strategic interests. Failure to Address Terrorism: Some Islamic regimes accused of supporting or harboring terrorist groups may escape adequate scrutiny, hindering the UN's ability to effectively address global terrorism. Undermining Democratic Values: Dictatorships may undermine the promotion of democratic values within the UN, potentially impeding efforts to strengthen democratic governance globally. Misuse of UN Resources: There are concerns that regimes with significant influence may misuse UN resources or manipulate the organization for their own political agendas. Lack of Accountability: The influence of certain regimes may contribute to a lack of accountability, with inadequate consequences for actions that violate international norms and laws. Polarization and Division: The influence of specific regimes may contribute to increased polarization and division within the UN, making it challenging to build consensus on critical issues. But it does not bother you, as long as they continue focusing on anti-Israel resolutions, does it
When the students graduate and get employed the employer demand excellence the president of these colleges should be held to the highest standards in this country basic human rights laws are being violated because of their inability to act with authority
Hate speech is protected speech. They have the right to say hateful things without being arrested, however they don’t have freedom from consequences. The universities have a code of conduct and ethics policy, which they broke though.
A better idea than denying money to universities when their students express offensive opinions is for the leaders of those universities to confront their students and have an on honest debate with them about the necessary limits of free speech.
@@bryanmachin3738 In reality there is no law against hate speech as it's only a policy in organizations. Hate speech and threats are totally two different issues.
*@user-pd6bo7es1n* "Hate" is a powerful word for that, in my opinion.. But I'm very disappointed in both parties myself, for sure. Because they just care about their own agenda and selfishly cover for each other.
IT FUNNY THAT THE GRANDSTANDING ON CAPITOL HILL IS AS CRAZY AS THE CRAZY WAY THAT LAWS THAT RESITICT THEM FROM STOPING PROTESTING, THIS MAKE NO SENSE 🤔
The Second Gentleman calling out anyone for their morality is rich. Why hasn’t he called out his wife for her complete lack of morality? I agree with him that these University presidents are immoral and should be punished but it’s just hilarious that he is the one who called it out.
Who was the fourth President on the panel? I don’t think I saw one question or answer for her. I don’t even know what university they’re president of, because I never saw heraddressed. Please help annihilate my ignorance. Thank you!
@@irinakushner4791 That Congresswoman is an election denier. If she can't tell the truth about who won the 2020 election, then I could care less how "brilliant" she is. That people in power keep lying about the election is an even bigger disgrace than anything anyone said at Penn.
as a former computer programmer, this is an automated and directed hit-job. Finally, I read the Una-bomber manifesto, written by a Harvard alumni and it fits and addresses some the basic issues being raised, especially deal with Diversity, equality and inclusion. Because the author fell off the beaten path, does not mean that his arguments can be readily dismissed - hell, you got to giv e the devil(evil), his due.
"Semite" 1 a : a member of any of a number of peoples of ancient southwestern Asia including the Akkadians, Phoenicians, Hebrews, and Arabs b : a descendant of these peoples 2 : a member of a modern people speaking a Semitic language (from Merriam-Webster) The people of Middle Eastern ancestry in Gaza are also "Semites".
![GUILTY GEAR -STRIVE- Season Pass 4 Playable Character #1 [Queen Dizzy] Trailer](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nXDsAgYXXv4/mqdefault.jpg)
When the donor's stop donating to the colleges, you'll see some changes made and not before.
Yes, rich Jews give a lot of money to colleges. Meanwhile, the rich Jews are probably fine with Israel committing genocide against the Palestinians.
Exactly
EVERYTHING is always about money!
UNLESS... the donors are leftwing progressists.
💯%
Shocker....take away $$$ and can't apologize fast enough!
Wow. She didnt just state policy. It was the smugness on her face when she said it.
she was asked if it constituted bullying or harassment. something can be bad or against other policies without constituting bullying or harassment. the whole outrage about this hearing is ridiculous nonsense. the media has failed
This is an example of one of the main reasons why our nation is at odds within itself…. These presidents are lost in space.
it is just another problem with the abuse of the 1st amendment that has been brought to light in the Trump trials.
Excuse me the presidents aren’t the problem the problem is 2% thinking they have supremacy over 98%. This has happened in history once before and it didn’t end well.
Indoctrinated communist, in my opinion.
Academicians like these presidents live in a world divorced from reality. This is what happens when core values are not instilled in people from an early age.....everything becomes "contextualized", contingent and obscure. Only presumably educated people like them could be this foolish.
I'm not a proponent of hate in any form, but in the US we must adhere to the right of free speech, the Jewish, Palestinian conflict would be better served if less opinions and more factual evidences of the orgins of the conflict were presented.
I am so very glad that I have never had anything to do with any of these institutions. They are absolutely disgusting IMO.
Yeah anyone who doesn't blindly follow the Christian narrative of causing the end times via the formation of Israel by force is clearly disgusting.. much faith in god trying to force a prophecy to happen! Better blindly support Israel's atrocities!
IF you pay taxes, YOU are to blame, Ketin. YOU need to apologize to the spooks
An apology isn’t enough. Step down!
Yeah that congress lady should really step down.. what a joke that you have to go before congress for not supporting the atrocities of Israel.
@@aetherwizard3218do your research!
@@aligned4good Yeah I have that's the issue. Both sides are wrong.
@@aetherwizard3218 I don't understand how a war with no clear good guys and bad guys that happens thousands of kilometers away can suddenly allow you to call for a genocide in your elite university in the richest and safest country in the world. Maybe you hate jews and you feel relief to have this occasion to gain to right to finally express it?
What they can do is Walk the Walk and not just Talk the Talk. Hate is Hate and calling for genocide is not a fine line it is clear and distinguishable. These are private universities and can and should control hate speech. I bet if the hate was against another group they just might be a little more proactive.
No, it is free speech.
@@diffenedclearly you didn’t go to class the semester free speech was taught. You cannot just say whatever you want.
@@jacalynstaten5607 miss Jacalyn is correct, but there has been too much pounding on those who are being charged because of what they think… It is an unbelievable and disgusting direction liberalism is heading.
What does it tell you that this Congresswoman is yelling at the top of her lungs about a theoretical, non existent "Jewish genocide" but could care less about the ACTUAL Genocide taking place in Palestine where thousands of innocent children are being slaughtered on a daily basis? Where is the outrage for that?
@@jacalynstaten5607I think that’s their point
All three college Presidents of MIT, Harvard and UPenn need to be removed and held accountable for their sick behavior.
why exactly should people from private institutions be "removed"? What kind of Orwellian nightmare world do you want to live in? Just move to Russia instead please.
@@proudhabesha7963 it is amazing how many people here want a fascist state where speech is controlled.
They should also ask the principals of NYU and Columbia U to testify and everybody will be even more jaw dropping to hear their responses. What an insane world.
I think congress should be spending our tax dollars on bigger issues, not policies at private or public universities, which r simply young ppl using their free speech at protests. It’s bad enough our tax dollars r being spent to fund what Israel’s doing which will put American lives at risk. I’m not talking about ppl who r protesting, who have no means to carry out any large serious attack on Jews or Palestinians in the US, but rather putting our soldiers at risk and will put Americans at risk of foreign terrorist attacks on US soil. U need to get ur priorities in order, as does congress!
@@janedoe3915Young people using free speech?😂😂 Calling for killing of Jews?😂. Is calling for killing of black people of transgender people also people protesting and using free speech? University has to provide a safe place free of harassment and bullying for students of all backgrounds I thought.
@@janedoe3915 You do realize that these universities are subsidized by tax payer dollars right? If they are being used for political indoctrination (which they are), we have every right to have them questioned especially if they are promoting hatred. It's called democracy.
Brown doesn't even know what a woman is... so yeah... the elite have gone nutz. Tiberius Caligula nutz ..
Are we so far gone as a society that people can't differentiate between right and wrong? Very alarming.....
We civilized people can! Problem is hate, power and greed fuels Israel
Only God can tell what is good and what is wrong. No I, nor you have that right.
@@ELARTEDELAMOTO Sure I do. Your god gave it to me when he gave me the ability to choose to do good or to do bad. If people don't have the right or ability to determine right from wrong, how could you possibly hold them accountable for being bad? Either individuals have that right, or your god is responsible for ever sin and evil deed ever committed by his creation, in which case it's not a god, it's a monster.
@@ELARTEDELAMOTOwhich god? There are many of these fictional characters so I am trying to figure out which one you were brainwashed to worship.
@@CowneloAlvaroid You have no idea what you're talking about...have you ever been to Israel...do you know any Jewish believing people...didn't think so.
Ms Gill's condescending smirk when answering was just sickening.
At the same time, these professors preach about "microagressions" and the need for "safe spaces" with binkies and blankets and hot chocolate for their pampered, woke students.
NOW Imagine if congress CARED this MUCH about literally any other issue facing Americans
Exactly. I mean the "moral clarity" which Congressperson Stefanik expressed seems to be rather foggy when it came to the insurrection of Jan. 6th. In that case, she will obfuscate and retreat into moral ambiguity.
The take over of Ivy colleges and higher learning institutions by foreign groups and pro terrorist professors is a real issue.
@mujin70 there was no insurrection lmao. stop with that blatant lie already.
Wow! Truly unapologetic racism. Good job.
Such as caring about the enormous massacre and racist vengeance unleashed in Gaza and the continued indiscriminate mistreatment and killing of Palestinians in the West Bank. Or the smearing of those defending the Palestinian people with an unlimited use of logical fallacies meant to silence anyone critical of the State of Israel. Let's hope The Hague has more moral and intellectual integrity than those in our government who curry favor with the pro-Israel lobby.
Holy moly,,, I gotta start looking for an exit strategy. This is the leadership of the highest level of education in our country? It definitely shows the contrast of educated vs common sense.
Media is your threat, and to your freedom of speech.
You think they're bad? Wait until the far right takes over in 2025. Then it won't just be about "common sense", but whether you still can LIVE FREELY in this country.
Yes.
Get out.
Fast.
Presidents of so called premier colleges should not “get caught up in” in the moment. They are hired to make quality decisions not half assed determinations based on their own prejudiced ideas. There’s no walking it back they’re nailed and there’s no other result other than they needed to be fired. Anyone who continues to give money to these damaged schools are no better than they are.
The problem is they don't know what is right unless someone pays them for it.
Yeah, even if their personal beliefs were the opposite the right answer to give here was a no-brainer. There's no excuse for their waffling either from a moral or a business standpoint.
They receive millions of donations from Qatar (the same one that sponsors HAMAS)
It is time to make our education institutions a place for education not for pushing particular ideologies. I wonder if the question of the Congresswoman was about death threats to any of the woke protected categories whether they would answer as they did.
Y’all are really saying you want your agenda in colleges and universities instead of no agenda
Excellent point.
what do you mean.. blind support for the atrocities of Israel is woke..
😊😊
What are the "woke protected categories"?
Our “elite” colleges have been promoting the woke/inclusive/progressive agenda for years by staying away from what a college is supposed to be doing - educate future leaders, protect free speech and maintain the meritocracy. All three, and many more in other institutes, should either resign or let go.
You forgot critical thinking.
Well I was going to comment but you just stated my exact thoughts. You know who gets discriminated the most, in this country...the law abiding, tax paying, loyal, hard working citizens of this country. I'm a recent retired combat veteran and I am tired of today's generations being indoctrinated and not educated... for their future and the future of their family.
Amen
And, please start teaching students what free speech is, as they currently believe free speech means you can say ANYTHING under the guise of it is free speech.
Seriously, do y ou understand what is woke, whatever that Trumpy hoo ha world is? It's a sign of shortened intellectual development to be wallowiing in "woke". It's a flag of conspiracy, again meaning nothing but a great fit to people who have very limited viewpoints on a liberal arts education. Same for progressive education. It's beyond uptight and facing backwards to think progressive is a negative. The entire engineering department is based on progressive education. The world's turn to internet and electronics is progressive. But I am guessing you are talking about progressive being non-Christian. And that, too, is dramatically incorrect. Martin Luthor was a progressive. It didn't stop there. The idea of fear feels palpable in the post. May I suggest new words and new concepts, not those from the hoo ha wing of the Republican Party.
They All need to Resign! Those campuses have been out of line for quite some time!
No they donr
no.. they don't..
if you can't denounce the what was being asked of you then you shouldn't be in a position of leadership
Sadly, it's leadership in the age of PR. This is not just these presidents but everyone. Plausible deniability is the name of the game.
They couldn't denounce it...........because there is no context. Please try learning elementary logic before posting.
You're not seeing the game that's being played as they did...
First you ask if calling for genocide is bullying. And after they say yes with no context, you hit them with "wHat AboUT fROm tHe RiVeR tO ThE sea?!?!?!?!!!?!“
All Lives Matter?
@@mujin70 If they soundly denounced it, the headlines would read, " College Presidents Against Free Speech"
These people should NOT be in any position of authority in a learning environment. Not even for preschoolers.
Why?
@@kimaaa8370 Because they are trying to defend free speech, but right wingers hate free speech unless they are doing the speaking
It's a private institution.. What you're talking about is called fascism? Take that crap on back to Italy.
@@aetherwizard3218 there are a lot of intellectually challenged people making comments here
@@aetherwizard3218 they like freedom of speech only when they are speaking
get them out of school
Wow! CBS has recognized and acknowledged antisemitism! A miracle!
It's Hanukah;)
Indeed, a cease-woke! 😂😂😂
That's only because they're losing control and now it's impossible to deny it.
cbs is wrong here. listen to the clip again the question was answered correctly
0:48 "[Calling for the genocide of Jews] is a context dependant decision." Genocide is context dependent? In what context is genocide permissable? According to ChatGPT, "Genocide universally carries a negative connotation due to its association with the intentional and systematic destruction of a specific ethnic, religious, or national group. There is no context where genocide is considered positive or acceptable." Thank you ChatGPT. You have more morality than a university president. That doesn't change my opinion that AI will end mankind, which isn't saying much for Magill.
Take your students out of these schools and STOP DONATING to them!!!!!!!
This comment acting like college age adults should be "taken out of school" as if by their parents shows the mind set of these NPCs..
@@aetherwizard3218 if I’m paying for my “adult” KIDS college you bet it’s my decision where I spend MY MONEY, honey !!!
They receive millions of donations from Qatar (the same one that sponsors HAMAS).
@@marina12345678911000 just another good reason for parents that are paying $$$$$ to take their kids out of these schools !!!
Please watch the hearings and replace Jewish with Black and then pretend everyone of those presidents wouldn’t be fired immediately after the hearings
Oh no ... Please don't use Black People as a point to prove your narrative. To add validity to your narrative you implement the continuous struggles another group of people. That's not very becoming.
😂 the "Blacks" have it all! 🤡
Their code of conduct is "dont lose our funding" . Beyond that, they have no standard.
Fire all 3 of these immoral women.
I hate universities that have become political police. Forcing others to adopt your opinion under duress makes you as repugnant as the people you criticize. In today's society, just saying you aren't pro-Israel will probably considered violent hate speech. thats why it's too subjective. Ps, this is coming from someone who cares about neither side before you try to smear me as an anti-Semite.
Reform must start right now on these universities.
they're private institutions..
They receive millions of donations from Qatar (the same one that sponsors HAMAS)
Any reform must include forbidding Islamic influence on U.S. universities.
@@marina12345678911000 that's called fascism.. You can't both do that and live in a free society.
@@aetherwizard3218boycott!!!
Amazing to see how powerful the lobbyists behave...Jimmy Carter said it best...
Your comment in not as empowering as you think. Carter was one of the worst Presidents ever. Look it up.
Just as people have Freedom Of Speech, People also have freedom to choose who they donate their money to.
remember to see who rules over you it is usually who you are NOT allowed to criticize
Hamas supporters have long operated in the United States. Internal Hamas documents and FBI
wiretaps introduced as evidence in various federal criminal cases clearly show the existence of
a nationwide Hamas network engaged in fundraising, lobbying, education and propaganda
dissemination dating back to the 1980s.
• The network formalized its existence in 1988, when it created the Palestine Committee in the
US. The Committee’s goals included “increasing the financial and the moral support for Hamas,”
“fighting surrendering solutions,” and publicizing “the savagery of the Jews.”
We are not allowed to criticise Palestine or Islam.
🏆💯🥇
So they're ruled by climate change, LGBTQEIEIOs, palis, Che Guevara, and Karl Marx?
So saying that colleges should condemn any call for genocide is dancing to rich Jews' tune? Wow. If you own a dog or house plant, please give it away.
Defund the college
The congress women missed the chance to ask if calling for the genocide of trans or bipoc people violated the code of conduct. If they gave the same answer the students would revolt.
Favortism based on race, gender, sexuality, religion, ethnicity, imposed or proclaimed group identity---gee, that doesn't cause any problems, does it?
No room for all this in the country MY KINFOLK DIED FOR !!!
I can’t believe Jewish people should be afraid in America, it’s a shame. No one should live in fear. Jewish people have been persecuted enough in history. You would think Americans would know to treat people with compassion and respect. Glad alumni are pulling their endowments.
You’re the kettle calling the pot black. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@@williamstevenson3049 Free Jewish people, they were attacked. Jewish people are Gods people. You better get your life right Jesus Christ comes back there are no take backs or forgiveness. Prayers for you.
@@elizabethrose3667 Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Everyone who is against Israel’s actions isn’t anti semitic. By calling everyone an anti semite you’re helping the actual anti semites
Respect
?????
L. Nice try tho
That's where you're wrong. If you disagree with jews and zionists, you are anti-semitic. No getting around it.
I don't know what you wanna call "antisemitism", but seeing videos of Oct 7 massacre and barbarism that Hamas uploaded to their website themselves and then denying anything like that happened! Taking down kidnapped victims with the excuse that it's not real and it's all propaganda and joining Muslims all around the world -who's Muslim countries wouldn't allow Palestinian refugees because they know their history in countries they were welcomed to before - to protest against Israel by chanting "from the river to the sea Palestine will be free" and didn't face any backlash were definitely not only antisemitism which was even heartbreaking and infuriating to people like me who are neither Jewish/Israeli/Even religious anymore nor have anyone related to that religion or country because that was just inhumane. So of course you can state your opinion about antisemitism, but those universities not only allowed all that to happen in their campuses, they even encouraged it and turned a blind eye on Jewish/Israeli students getting hate. Maybe the backlash could be over so much these people already did and their testimony was the last nail in the coffin.
My terrorist regime is helping Hamas or maybe even organized the attack on Israel but the fact that me and many Iranians are supporting Israel is the fact that we've been exposed to so much propaganda, we can see it from a mile away. Their women got raped and UN women didn't even care enough to condemn them. As someone living under oppression that goes back forty five years, I'd say the world turned antisemitic. Not just these people.
This behavior on university campuses is weird and puzzling. For a while now universities, which are supposed to be places of learning and exchanging of ideas through critical thinking and debates, it seems have been anything but that. I remember not too long ago when there were "safe rooms" with toys or stuffed animals--something like that, for students who were 'triggered' by ideas obviously too painful for discussion. I thought then, and now--that is creepy!
Put your big boy and big girl pants on and get a grip. There are two sides to this horrific war and, no easy answers. Wouldn't it be great if students convened some sort of group-think throughout universities, to try to bring real discussion and possible solutions to this problem. Practice for future real-world leadership.
The leaders of these institutions should not tolerate one-sided thinking and "safe rooms" on a university campus. Imho.
On the other hand maybe you better stand up and loudly support Israel no matter what they do for the 2 minute hate. otherwise you'll have to go before congress to answer for your crime of not supporting Israel.
That's a bit of an overstatement, but I'm sure you already know that. Have a nice weekend. @@aetherwizard3218
@@aetherwizard3218not really i could care less on Israel or Ukraine. Americans military should be protecting our southern border with artillery as the are supposed to do
@@aetherwizard3218 In what world does advocating for Palestinians require genocidal statements to be tolerated on campus? Are you ok?
@@2103038335 well for one due to a lack of any actual quotes being stated about such genocide I'm lead to believe they're conflating genocide from slogans of Palestinians demanding their stolen land back.. as has been done several times lately.
What they need to do is just pull government funding from them. They charge astronomical amounts of money so they should be just fine.
They receive millions of donations from Qatar (the same one that sponsors HAMAS).
She needs to be fired
Get them out of office that a place to educate these young people for the world.
Respected institutions? NOT!
I'm Cameroonian and am so glad that we have real problems to deal with and not poking our noses in others' business 😂😂😂. It's bizarre what America has become. Univiersities are supposed to be places of free speech and thought
elite universities are places for rich kids to shout slogans at each other
and we are supposed to take them seriously.
They are......until republicans come along.
@@scottholder4431genocide of a people goes beyond free speech. Da
It is not OK to voice genocide!
@@scottholder4431is so partisan blue no matter who, he overlooks a race of people being erased from the face of this planet. Think about that!!! Blue no matter who’s life
Maybe they didn't know the definition of the word genocide.
3141, Israeli government sure knows the definition and they can't commit it fast enough, apparently
Seems like YOU don’t know the definition of genocide. Many of the ceasefire protesters are Jewish themselves. Nobody is calling for a genocide of Jews, I personally would not support that and have not seen it in person or in any of the platforms. What people are calling for, however, if Palestinian freedom, a ceasefire and an end to genocide and atrocities being committed against Palestinians.
Did these University presidents not toe the Zionist line? Did they dare insult our Israeli overlords? How dare they!
Their punishment should be 10 recitations of the "I have a dreidel" song while wearing a kippah and contemplating the mysteries our benevolent and merciful ruler Benjamin Netanyahu.
/s
If a group of protesters said these things about the LGBT community or ethnic people, they would kick them out of that school, but for some reason it’s okay to say that about all Jewish people.
You don't understand context. LMAO!
@@scottholder4431 calling or chanting for the genocide of ANY group of people is wrong and against the universities code of content and ethics policy.
@@Riclmnopp Try again. You don't understand context. LMAO!
@@Riclmnopp Get smarter.
@@RiclmnoppIf it is in general, it is free speech. If it is aimed at a particular person, it is a threat. Why didn't Stefanik talk about the Israelis murdering Palestinians. That goes way beyond speech. Israel actually committing genocide.
People with a permanent pout stuck on there face
Should you worry about them ? Children that have this expression get what ever they want !
Google this if you don't believe me. Another Muslim organization announced the other day that it would be committing another genocide in Armenia because it's a Christian country and they were inspired by hamas to do so... For those of you who don't know the Muslim Empire of Turkey committed the first Is Armenian genocide and I know that all of a sudden there's going to be a bunch of democrats who have no idea what I'm talking about at all even though the current democratic administration "fought really hard" to have the armenian genocide recognized as a genocide... Watch them all forget though, like that never happened 😂😂😂
The recent war in the middle east showed clearly that we as the USA are divided nation. Thank to our officials who brought us and pushed us to this extend !!!!
Also blame the cable news media. They just compete for those ratings. They should all be programed on pay-per- view.
They still mad at not having a date for prom.
Words have consequences, including theirs.
The whole talk about anti-Muslim behavior gets me. If it's occurring, it's happening much, much, much less than the hate being hurled at Jews.
These university presidents cast the good professional women in a bad light. We work so hard to do things smart and do things right, and these women come along and can only suggest that calling for genocide might be bad depending on the context.
These three women being questioned should not be in their positions. When you can't differentiate between right and wrong YOU ARE NOT CAPABLE as a human being.
affirmative action hires?😂
wonder if gender was a factor ? I'm at a loss to explain their behaviour.
she "apologized" but still didn't make it clear. so either she doesn't care or she is racist.
No one including Congress men or women have the right to delegate public opinion as to how people should or should not think let alone taking heads of education institutions and pressuring them “under the guise of semitism or antisemitism “ free thinking independent institutions of higher education should create free thinking individuals
Government officials shaping thinking is not only against our bill of rights but outright unAmerican and dangerous! We should weedout and vote out government officials that act this way
Remove all funding
How is this about protecting free speech when if a student makes a derogatory comment about someone's weight or if a student gets someone's pronouns wrong that is considered violent and abusive behavior subject to disaplinary action including expulsion and screaming at and calling for genocide of the Jewish students acceptable behavior
Because when a student makes a derogatory comment about someone's weight, that's just one student. But when students scream for genocide of you-know-who, that's hundreds or thousands, and they have many millions behind them.
Not answering a question in the way you like isn't the same as not answering.. As we all know it's highly illegal not to support the atrocities of Israel in the in US..
For the people crying about free speech, universities have a code of conduct an ethics policy. You can say what you want without being arrested, but the schools can kick you out for breaking their policies.
When the free speech incite violent actions, that goes beyond free speech! The hateful chanting makes Jewish students and Jewish folks in U.S. feel unsafe. Have anybody chants geocide to Palestinian?! no! No one should chant geocide to any groups!
Yet their "code of conduct" says calling for genocide is okay?
This 3 women should resign. Shame on them.
an apology after embedding it worldwide is futile. shame on all of them. disgusting.
shame on everyone who blindly supports the atrocities of Israel.
Can someone please explain to me why there’s four women on the panel but they only keep mentioning three schools who is the fourth white woman and who is the fourth school because there’s four people sitting up there but you’re only mentioning three😵💫
I want to hear from these students their perspective and not just the ones that are allegedly targeted but just the students get their scoop
Politicians aren't that thoughtful in carrying out their jobs.
Most of the students protesting, and students of these "elite" schools interviewed couldn't even show where Isreal is on a map. Probably have no idea Isreal was created after WWII by the United nations!
Goes to show when you erase history you only hurt the future.
There is ONE thing that is common between all of them...and i can see clear as day as to why those places are going thru this...
Wow! 3 WOMEN reporting on 3 WOMAN University presidents being grilled by a sharp Congress WOMAN
Antisemitism has no place among us., neither has Islamophobia., or any other hatred.
We need to distinguish between free speech and hate speech .... Just saying.
“Anti-Muslim harassment?” WTF is that? Bahaha!
Back in the days political, religion views were a private matter everyone has worked out their difference privately. Today, is social war of folks not respecting boundaries dividing humanity with social war views.
No you better stand up and loudly support Israel no matter what atrocities they commit if you don't want to stand out for the 2 minute hate!
People have gone mad on both sides of the political spectrum. I live in Europe and this is terrifying because I know in 5/10 years we will be in the state the USA are today. The last people who lived the 20th century's wonders (communism, fascism, world wars, genocides...) in their flesh are dying of old age and it looks like we're preparing to start it all over again. With more people and a lot more technology.
The professors are right. Stefanik didn't provide context.....on purpose.
How about if our politicians stop taking AIPAC money, and start focusing on calling out wrong actions by the government of any country that looks, smells or sounds apartheid, genocidal, or in any other way opposed to international law.
Nice dodge of the whole point.
@@BeBoppin2000 This is the whole point. Go look at the millions of dollars given to politicians by AIPAC just to keep their mouths wired shut about the actions of Israel.
@@BeBoppin2000 No, I think he is right on the money.
You want some cheese with that whine?
How about our politicians stop giving money to Iran, Qatar, Hezbollah, Hamas and these universities?
So basically almost all Muslim countries and Russia, China and Venezuela.
They thought if they stuck together and answered as one they could hold onto their cushy jobs!
They probably will!
Fire those woke Presidents
Used to be respected universities..no more
The apologies were hollow
Control the universities, control the culture.
When people can not answer yes to a plain question because of their political party that is as good as saying yes.
Israel has a right to defend itself. However, they have ignored 26 UN resolutions with only the US vetoing for a two state solution. When Britian gave up the land back in 1948, it was agreed upon to create one Israeli and one Muslim state? Israel has been building on the disputed land and there's barely any left for another state.
The perceived problems of the influence of Islamic regimes (Iran, Qatar, Turkey..) and dictatorships(Russia, China..) on the UN include:
Human Rights Concerns:
Some Islamic regimes and dictatorships have been criticized for human rights abuses, and their influence may hinder the UN's ability to address such issues objectively.
Selective Focus on Issues:
The influence of certain regimes might lead to a selective focus on issues that align with their interests, potentially neglecting other critical global matters.
Biased Resolutions:
There is concern that the influence of specific regimes may lead to biased resolutions, favoring their perspectives and unfairly targeting certain nations or groups.
Suppression of Dissent:
Regimes with authoritarian tendencies may use their influence to suppress dissenting voices within the UN, limiting open discourse and the exchange of diverse opinions.
Obstruction of Peace Efforts:
The interests of certain regimes might obstruct or complicate UN-led peace efforts, particularly in regions where these regimes have strategic interests.
Failure to Address Terrorism:
Some Islamic regimes accused of supporting or harboring terrorist groups may escape adequate scrutiny, hindering the UN's ability to effectively address global terrorism.
Undermining Democratic Values:
Dictatorships may undermine the promotion of democratic values within the UN, potentially impeding efforts to strengthen democratic governance globally.
Misuse of UN Resources:
There are concerns that regimes with significant influence may misuse UN resources or manipulate the organization for their own political agendas.
Lack of Accountability:
The influence of certain regimes may contribute to a lack of accountability, with inadequate consequences for actions that violate international norms and laws.
Polarization and Division:
The influence of specific regimes may contribute to increased polarization and division within the UN, making it challenging to build consensus on critical issues.
But it does not bother you, as long as they continue focusing on anti-Israel resolutions, does it
When the students graduate and get employed the employer demand excellence the president of these colleges should be held to the highest standards in this country basic human rights laws are being violated because of their inability to act with authority
You do mean their refusal to act on their authority
antisemitism SHOULD NOT be tolerated
antizionism IS NOT antisemitism
#DefundDemocrats
ARREST THEM!!! HATE SPEACH IS ""ILLEGAL"" & AGAINST THE LAW!!!
Hate speech is protected speech. They have the right to say hateful things without being arrested, however they don’t have freedom from consequences. The universities have a code of conduct and ethics policy, which they broke though.
AMERICA SHAME ON YOU
A better idea than denying money to universities when their students express offensive opinions is for the leaders of those universities to confront their students and have an on honest debate with them about the necessary limits of free speech.
Hate is free speech and no one in American can tell me who I can and cannot hate.
@@jamesm568 You'd think that. But in reality it doesn't work out that way.
See the 1919 Supreme Court decision "Debs v United States" for an example.
@@bryanmachin3738 In reality there is no law against hate speech as it's only a policy in organizations. Hate speech and threats are totally two different issues.
I hate both parties.
*@user-pd6bo7es1n* "Hate" is a powerful word for that, in my opinion.. But I'm very disappointed in both parties myself, for sure. Because they just care about their own agenda and selfishly cover for each other.
IT FUNNY THAT THE GRANDSTANDING ON CAPITOL HILL IS AS CRAZY AS THE CRAZY WAY THAT LAWS THAT RESITICT THEM FROM STOPING PROTESTING, THIS MAKE NO SENSE 🤔
Luv how talking heads say "still" with surprise. Slatted journalism at its best.
End all government research funding and federal student loan guarantees for these Woke institutions and let them then say whatever they want.
Follow the money….Katar
All wokies. All sinister.
GOOD this needs to End!
They have clarity. Their view is clearly antisemitic.
at this anti semitic just means NOT woke.
The Second Gentleman calling out anyone for their morality is rich. Why hasn’t he called out his wife for her complete lack of morality?
I agree with him that these University presidents are immoral and should be punished but it’s just hilarious that he is the one who called it out.
punished for what? not blindly supporting the atrocities of Israel? Not punishing "wrong" think on their campus?
@@aetherwizard3218 for turning once respected institutions into far left indoctrination camps that are so horrible people won’t hire their graduates.
These campuses are clearly not healthy or safe environments for young people. There is also scary similarities to behavior in 1940's Germany.
Who was the fourth President on the panel? I don’t think I saw one question or answer for her. I don’t even know what university they’re president of, because I never saw heraddressed. Please help annihilate my ignorance. Thank you!
I can't stand that Congresswoman, but still! Penn's president gave a REALLY BAD ANSWER to that question.
I cannot stand all of those 3 ,but Congress woman was brilliant and right
@@irinakushner4791 That Congresswoman is an election denier. If she can't tell the truth about who won the 2020 election, then I could care less how "brilliant" she is. That people in power keep lying about the election is an even bigger disgrace than anything anyone said at Penn.
Thank goodness Harris husband criticized them and in doing so gave the media the a okay to criticize the three school presidents.
as a former computer programmer, this is an automated and directed hit-job. Finally, I read the Una-bomber manifesto, written by a Harvard alumni and it fits and addresses some the basic issues being raised, especially deal with Diversity, equality and inclusion. Because the author fell off the beaten path, does not mean that his arguments can be readily dismissed - hell, you got to giv e the devil(evil), his due.
Immediately stop ALL Government funding to all these Universities.
Good to know where NoT to send our children
"Semite"
1
a
: a member of any of a number of peoples of ancient southwestern Asia including the Akkadians, Phoenicians, Hebrews, and Arabs
b
: a descendant of these peoples
2
: a member of a modern people speaking a Semitic language (from Merriam-Webster)
The people of Middle Eastern ancestry in Gaza are also "Semites".
Anti-semitism specifically refers to Jews. I'm fact, it was coined be a Jew hater.
@@BeBoppin2000 Some of us are against all forms of racism.